The British Empire and Commonwealth in the Caribbean and South Atlantic (see also the inset below).
Some interpretations of Britain’s imperial past have charged the ‘White British’ with using the Caribbean islands in general and Barbados in particular as a ‘dumping ground’ for Black slaves. In fact, the first settlers there were White Catholics, according to the Jesuit priest who met them in 1634, both Irish and English ‘recusants’, looking for somewhere to practice their faith freely, much like the puritan ‘refugees’ in New England. Sometimes called ‘Little England’, Barbados was settled in the 1620s, and quicly became prosperous due to the development of the sugar industry in the 1640s. Later, the British Commonwealth used the island as a place of penal exile for recalcitrant royalists and radicals. Oliver Cromwell first used it as an internment camp for prisoners taken during his battles in Ireland. In September 1649, reporting on his notorious storming of Drogheda (see below) to the Speaker of the English Parliament, he wrote of how …
When they submitted, their officers were knocked on the head; and every tenth man of the soldiers killed; and the rest were shipped off for the Barbadoes.
‘Warts and all’: Oliver Cromwell as Lord Protector, c. 1650
This wholesale transportation of some twelve thousand men gave rise to a new verb, ‘to barbadoes’. A letter of 1655 describes Cromwell as a terrible Protector … He dislikes shedding blood, but is very apt ‘to barbadoes’ an unruly man – has sent and sends us by hundreds to Barbadoes, so that we have made an active verb of it: ‘Barbadoes you’.
Meanwhile, the settlement of Jamestown in Virginia had continued to develop in the 1650s, attracting adventurers from England, but also political refugees, including both Royalists and Commonwealth soldiers, deported prisoners and indentured servants, together with many Puritan ‘dissenters’ of the kind who had settled in New England. Many of the prisoners and indentured servants were Irish, not to be confused with the ‘Scotch-Irish’ or Ulster Scots who were also settling as ‘voluntary’ emigrants, and their treatment was little better than the boatloads of Black slaves who were arriving further south at Charleston and in the Caribbean. In due course, these involuntary exiles, who became known as ‘redlegs’, were joined in Barbados by Scottish Highland rebels and, after the failure of the Duke of Monmouth’s Protestant rising in 1685, by West Country Englishmen.
Some of these luckless Barbadians became “poor Whites” after the abolition of slavery in the British Empire in 1833, and their descendants settled in a small, impoverished community in the parish of St Martin’s Bay, where they spoke a dialect of English which was indistinguishable from the Blacks known as ‘Bajan’ or Barbadian English. The influence of the Irish is also found on the island of Montserrat, known as “the emerald isle of the Caribbean”. The Irish migrated there to escape from religious persecution in Virginia and on neighbouring St Kitt’s. As early as 1643, an Irish priest, Father O’Hartegan, wrote of French and Irish being spoken on Montserrat, in addition to English. The island has Irish place names, including Glenmór, the ‘big valley’ at the centre of the island. The first ‘free’ Irish planters, the Rileys and the Sweeneys, were joined by involuntary exiles like those on Barbados. When the first Black slaves were transported there (below), some of the Irish took Black wives and mistresses, giving rise to a “Black Irish” community on the island.
Meanwhile, on Barbados, the settlement of slaves from West Africa to work on the sugar plantations (see below) made them dramatically more profitable. It was the first port of call for the slave ships and it was said that that the more ‘unruly’ slaves were shipped up the ‘claw’ of the West Indies, until they finally reached Jamaica. In any case, ‘Bajan’ creole is much closer to Standard English than Jamaican creole.
Sugar plantations on Barbados
Jamaica: ‘The Wickedest Place on Earth’?
Jamaica became an English possession almost by accident, yet in the eighteenth century it was to be Britain’s most valuable colony. Privateering had been its main source of income, but slowly, as resources were accumulated, a plantation economy based on slavery developed alongside a small-holding sector that produced food. The slave population, however, expanded far more rapidly than the white settlers in the late seventeenth century.
Jamaica in 1685
Jamaica was Britain’s first state-sponsored colonial venture. In 1654 Oliver Cromwell disparched a great fleet to ‘gain an interest’ in the Spanish Indies and, after a humiliating defeat at Hispaniola, its leaders turned on the thinly settled, and ill-defended island of Jamaica as a consolation prize. The ease of the initial seizure proved deceptive, however. Runaway Spanish slaves in the mountainous interior sustained years of guerrilla war with Spanish support which, together with disease, took a heavy toll on the army, in terms of both lives and morale. At the restoration of Charles II, peace was made with Spain, but the King decided to retain Jamaica and establish a civil government designed to encourage private investors and secure the island’s future. The island was ten times the combined size of the other English islands in the Caribbean and promised to provide a valuable extension to the sugar and slave system developed in Barbados. But the English inherited little from the Spanish, except what grew there naturally. Clearing the land and planting cash crops required time and and great capital investment which, despite Charles II’s hopes, were not forthcoming from outside investors. Although the first settlers were given patents for vast tracts of land, it was many years before the resources necessary to convert Jamaica into a thriving plantation economy were accumulated.
Colonial expansion to 1707: Large-scale emigration began and the sheer volume of settlers crossing the Atlantic proved crucial to the growth of empire.
The colonists exploited the island’s strategic location. Unlike the earlier successful English settlements, Jamaica was at the heart of the Spanish Indies, well placed for both slander and trade, with the additional advantage of a superb natural harbour protected by a long sand spit, at the end of which the English built the town of Port Royal. Privateering required little little capital and provided the funds needed to ensure the infant colony’s survival. In the long run, peaceful contraband trade (especially a slave re-export trade) which also got under way in the 1660s, proved more rewarding. Despite the Treaty of Madrid of 1670, which promised peace and friendship between England and Spain in the Indies, privateers continued to refit their ships and sell their prizes at Port Royal throughout the late seventeenth century. The town, home of Captain Henry Morgan and other famous adventurers and notorious for its rowdy, dissolute, high-spending social life, acquired the reputation of being ‘the wickedest city on earth’. When, in 1692, a dramatic earthquake plunged most of its buildings under water, many saw the disaster as well-deserved punishment from God.
A contemporary account of the earthquake, in Port Royal, Jamaica, viewed by many as divine retribution for the city’s wickedness. Much of Port Royal sank beneath the harbour.
As Port Royal prospered, the island merchants who profited from trade and plunder accumulated the capital to purchase a slave labour force (which increased from ten thousand in 1673 to forty-five thousand in 1703) and plant cash crops in the interior. Cocoa dominated in the 1660s, but was destroyed by blight in the 1670s and superseded by sugar. By 1684 the island had 246 sugar plantations (concentrated on alluvial plains in the south and east, with pockets of settlement along the rivers and coastal St Mary in the north) and sugar exports were approaching the level of those from Barbados. Although the size of plantations in Jamaica was to exceed that of those elsewhere in the English Caribbean, the island also maintained production of a wider range of minor staples than the smaller islands, including indigo, cotton, ginger and pimento (Jamaican pepper). It also had a small-holding sector geared to the internal exchange of food and cattle. The earthquake of 1692, the ensuing disease and the war with France in the 1690s, during which the island was invaded, took a heavy toll on the population, trade and prosperity. The population declined from nine to seven thousand between 1680 and 1700. The lost ground was regained in the eighteenth century, however.
The Roots of Caribbean English:
The British Empire in the eighteenth century.
The making of Black ‘pidgin’ English probably began even before the slave ships arrived on the west coast of Africa, and I have dealt with its development in the Caribbean and the Southern states of North America in earlier articles in this series. In Summary, as shown on the map below, the process began with the development of the ‘Atlantic Triangle’. The slave ships sailed from Bristol, later from Liverpool, with ‘trinkets’ made from various precious metals, together with cheap cotton goods. These were exchanged for cargoes of slaves who were taken to the Caribbean and the Southern states on the notorious ‘Middle Passage’. The ships then returned to the English ports with sugar and tobacco. It was in the terrible holds of the slave ships that the captured Africans began to use their pidgin English as a means of communication with each other and their white captors. When the slave ships arrived in West Africa, the slaves, from many different tribes, each with their own language, had to find a means of communication, and the African tradesmen needed to have a method of bargaining with the White slavers. In America, the first recorded use of pidgin comes from Cotton Mather who used the medical knowledge of the Africans in Boston to inoculate the local people against smallpox.
By the eighteenth century, Black ‘pidgin’ English was not only established on the plantations of the Southern states, but also along the North American coast as far as New York, Massachusetts and Nova Scotia. Here, it had an interesting impact on the vocabulary of the Northern states as slavery ended there. Boss is a typically American word, with enormous cultural overtones, and it came into the language via two routes, one distinctively ‘Black’ and the other just as distinctively ‘White’. In Black American English it is a ‘superlative’; a “boss chick” is a “fine girl”. This usage is also found in Surinam creole, Srana Tongo, as a result of the Dutch migration there after the loss of ‘New Amsterdam’, when it became ‘New York’. That adjectival use was added to by the noun form, as explained by the nineteenth-century American novelist, John Fennimore Cooper. He noted that the White domestic servants who wanted to avoid the ‘slave’ word “master” or “massa” still used by the Black servants after emancipation, would use “boss” as a less demeaning alternative.
Maritime Pidgin English, the lingua franca of sailors and merchant shipmen, was also well-established throughout the world, mirroring other forms of pidgin – French, Portuguese and Spanish. Words were often borrowed from one form of pigin to another, e.g. beaucoup, bonni-bon. The processes are controversial among linguists, and the arrows on the map below are only intended to indicate the general direction of language traffic accompanying the ocean-going trade.
In the Caribbean islands, the arrival of first the Whites, and then the hundreds of thousands of Black slaves caused an extraordinary transformation of the region’s social and linguistic geography, leading to the making of Caribbean creole. In retrospect, it is as though the Caribbean was a vast language laboratory. The tiny Carib and Arawak Indian population, once native to the region, speaking their own languages, and influencing Spanish with words like cannibal, were savagely obliterated. In their place, creolised forms of the invading European languages emerged. Into the fertile and sugar-rich islands came Whites and Blacks in unequal proportions, able to exploit their agricultural potential. From this meeting of European and African languages and pidgins emerged a Caribbean English which became a link in the chain making up the family of Black Englishes.
Am I not a Man and a Brother? Ending Slavery:
The opponents of slavery, led by Thomas Clarkson, the Quaker, and William Wilberforce, the evangelical Anglican Tory MP, supported by John Wesley, the Methodist preacher, formed their ‘Society for the Abolition of the Slave Trade’ in 1787. The former West Indian slave, Olandah Equiano (pictured above?), provided and published information about the barbarity of the Atlantic trade. These pictures and documents, which I have used in previous articles about slavery, exposed the cruelties of the plantation owners in Jamaica. Wilberforce, Clarkson and Equiano organised travelling exhibitions, displaying whips and chains, models of slave ships and the commodities used in the trade of humans. Instead of an image of the king, Clarkson’s famous print of a sardine-can slave ship and Josiah Wedgewood’s ‘mug’ print of a kneeling, exhorting slave were disseminated throughout Britain (below).
Fundamentally, the campaigners attacked the basic inhumanity of making people slaves, as both John Wesley and George Fox had done, but they also used economic arguments pointing out the pitfalls of colonial Atlantic trade. In 1776, the economist Adam Smith pointed out how expensive it was for Britain to maintain the North American and Caribbean colonies and their trade:
The expense of the ordinary peace establishment of the colonies amounted … to the expense of a very considerable naval force which was constantly kept up, in order to guard, from the smuggling vessels of other nations, the immense coast of North America, and that of our West Indian islands.
Of course, those who continued to trade in slaves from Britain stressed the advantages that the trade in slaves brought in the context of trade in West Indian produce more generally:
The most approved of the Commercial Interests of these Kingdoms have been of the opinion that our West India and African Trades are the most nationally beneficial of any we carry on. It is also allowed on all Hands that the Trade to Africa is the Branch which renders our American Colonies and Plantations so advantageous to Great Britain; that Traffic only affording our Planters a constant supply of Negro Servants for the Culture of their Lands in the Produce of Sugars, Tobacco, Rice, Rum, Cotton, Fustick, Pimento, and all our other Plantation Produce.
The House of Commons in the late eighteenth century.
These arguments, together with the well-organised campaign of the abolitionists, spearheaded by William Wilberforce in Parliament, led to it declaring the British slave trade illegal in 1807. But it took another twenty-six years of campaigning before slavery was abolished in the British Empire. Originally a ‘narrow’ Quaker concern, the abolitionist cause had, by then, swollen to a great evangelical campaign that crossed party and confessional lines. Those who found themselves in a receding minority by the 1830s had to, similarly, find support from people of far broader backgrounds than their own. Using their own ‘authentic’ evidence from the plantations, they argued that slavery benefited the ‘Negro’ slaves themselves. In October 1833, The Jamaica Monthly Magazine published the following condemnation of the abolitionists:
Deluded sons of Britain! Would that ye,
The proud, the omnipotent, the free,
Behold him seated at his ample meal,
With all his children seated at his knee!
As the cartoon below implies, it was also argued that the inevitable price of emancipation of the West Indian slaves, would be the enslavement in poverty of British workers:
Slavery and freedom! – British poverty and West Indian Slavery: A Cartoon from ‘The Looking Glass of 1832’
Although it had to contend with some crude working-class racism fuelled by this kind of propaganda, the abolitionist cause had strong support in Yorkshire and Lancashire, and it was at Oldham in 1832 that William Cobbett finally announced his conversion to it. The abolitionist George Thompson, who risked his life lecturing against slavery in the United States, claimed to have spoken to seven hundred thousand people in meetings in Liverpool alone. The abolitionists were prepared, if necessary, to organise a systematic boycott of West Indian sugar throughout the country which, given the enormous numbers involved in the campaigns since the Napoleonic wars, of commercially farmed sugar beet, might wellhave inflicted huge damage on West Indian slave owners. Hundreds of thousands of signatures were gathered on giant petitions, sewn into one enormously elongated sheet designed specifically for spectacular effect, and delivered to the floor of the House of Commons by supporting MPs, so weighty that it might take four or even eight members to carry them into the chamber. In the first three years of the 1830s, four thousand such petitions were brought to parliament. It has been suggested that as many as one in five adult males had signed an absolutist petition in 1787, 1814 or 1833.
‘Creeping Colonialism’ & the Decline of Transatlantic Trade:
The territory of the empire continued to grow gradually, though by the 1850s, the process of ‘creeping colonialism’ which Britain’s ‘old empire’ had been engaged in following the Napoleonic Wars, had not yet got very far. Most countries made perfectly satisfactory trading partners with little or no persuasion; the sea-lanes between them and Britain were amply secured by the general supremacy of the British Navy. Even so, Britain had acquired a considerable formal empire by the 1850s. It had little to do, however, with her contemporary needs and interests, having been inherited from a previous age when those interests were different. With slavery ended in 1833, the British West Indies had their origin in a now defunct system of Atlantic trade and a few long-forgotten naval victories. Canada, Australia and the Cape Colony had all, thus far at least, been ‘acquired’ with relatively little effort. British India had come into being through an earlier, economic manifestation of ‘creeping imperialism’. These were the largest units of the old empire. Despite the loss of the thirteen American colonies, it was not a negligible inheritance.
By the 1850s, however, a considerable revolution had taken place in Britain’s relations with her settlement colonies. The result now was that none of them was any longer ‘ruled’ by Britain in the conventional sense. They were dependent on Britain economically, as Argentina was, and militarily, But their political fortunes were in their own hands. If Britain could have relinquished her formal responsibilities in the Caribbean in the same way, it probably would have done so. Superficially, it might have appeared that this was already happening. Most West Indian islands had legislative assemblies modelled on the British parliament, lively and independent-minded, suggesting that the effective transfer of power there to European colonists had already taken place, or would do shortly. But appearances were deceptive. In the other colonies the recipients of responsible government, the white settlers, were clearly the dominant class within their own societies, economically as well as politically and militarily. Their increasing political autonomy as ‘dominions’ was backed by economic stability and, as necessary, military support. In the West Indies this was not the case. The sugar plantation industry on which the European settlers depended had been in decline for some years, unable to adapt itself to the new conditions of free labour and free trade forced upon it by the British Parliament in the 1830s and ’40s, though the decline had begun long before.
Slavery was finally ended in the Caribbean in 1838, and the liberated people now fully embraced carnival as their own. Their ‘Mas’ costumes were often based upon West African myths and were mostly scary rather than sexy. Surviving depictions show black revellers wearing whiteface and devil masks, or dressing as bats, skeletons, and midnight robbers. It was common for revellers to douse spectators with animal bladders filled with water. And, to the immense shock of the authorities, men and women dressed up as the opposite gender, wearing fake genitals or menstrual blood and doing provocative sexualised dances. The Caribbean is famed for its rich musical heritage, from calypso to reggae, but it wasn’t always so easy to play at carnival. After emancipation in 1838, authorities in Trinidad and Tobago tried to suppress carnival’s dangerous energy, and between the 1860s and 1890s banned the lighted torches, drums, and stick-fighting traditions that the people loved so much. Riots ensued.
After 1838, many planters simply abandoned their estates, or had them confiscated in lieu of of debts, returning ‘home’ to Britain or Ireland. A rival agriculture to the plantations sprang up, as ex-slaves set up as independent proprietors on vacant lands, so creating new communities outside the purview, and in continuous friction with, the old ruling classes who wanted their labour. The planters who remained to struggle on in the islands found their dominance there seriously threatened. Wealthy ‘men of colour’ were infiltrating their assemblies, and there was no way for the white planters to stop them short of abrogating their ancient constitutional ‘freedoms’ and ruling through a white oligarchy. So, if the Colonial Office had been bent on ‘responsible government’ for the West Indies, they could only have given it either to parliamentary assemblies of mixed race, or to oligarchies chosen on frankly racist lines. The former could not be entertained. Responsible government, said British parliamentarians, was only applicable to colonists of the English race. At best, a coloured parliament would be a very unpredictable polity; there was no precedent for it, and therefore no means of predicting how it might behave. The other alternative, however, would not be allowed either by ‘humanitarians’ in Britain or by the ‘good sense’ of the government. No such tyranny by a handful of incompetent bankrupts over an alienated population would be off its hands for very long. Very soon, it was thought in Whitehall, the white planters would be back asking for protection from an angry and rebellious population.
The settlers were themselves acutely aware of the weakness of their situation and it needed just a nudge in the 1860s for them to give up legislative independence for the cosy security of direct rule from Britain. In the longer term, and throughout the empire more generally, perhaps the chief effect of the ‘anti-imperialist’ sentiment on practical policy in the 1860s and ’70s was to inculcate a general feeling of resentment against those who had ‘forced’ Britain to take them over ‘against her will’. But occasionally, economic motivations won out, especially with colonies that had a permanent European population strong enough to contain by their own efforts the crises arising within their borders. There Britain could safely economise by delegating the defence of her interests to them. In New Zealand, that was the case, but in the West Indies and South Africa, it was not. Consequently, in those colonies, the imperial government had to intervene directly, and expensively, to defend its interests and, as a consequence, the frontiers of empire crept forward again. In the British West Indies, as the islands were now known, the resolution of the local ‘crisis’ was not a satisfactory one from the Colonial Office perspective. It was a crisis that had been brewing for some time and, like the other crises of that time, it was the result of European encroachment on non-European societies, but here it had taken place many years before and in another place, on the West coast of Africa.
A planter’s home
What was happening in the West Indies was that the system which had been originally devised for controlling the relations between the two racial groups there after the abolition of slavery was breaking down. Traditionally, the pattern was one of domination of white sugar planters over black labourers, but circumstances had conspired to undermine this pattern, and the ability of the Whites to control the situation. Political institutions devised for a slave economy proved deficient in an era of free labour; inadequate, that is, to preserve a satisfactory degree of white planter dominance. They were being infiltrated by men independent of the plantation economy, and hostile to the planters’ demands. Attempts to manipulate the constitutions of the islands to retain control in the hands of the planters came up against obstruction from the Colonial Office as well as the realities of the planters’ own circumstances as a dwindling bunch of men with little common ability to run their affairs responsibly and without either the financial or material resources to back up their pretensions. In 1853, twelve years before the crisis erupted, Earl Grey had predicted the outcome of planter ‘misrule’:
No one acquainted with the actual state of society in the West India islands … can doubt that, if they were left, unaided by us, to settle among themselves in whose hands power should be placed, a fearful war of colour would probably soon break out … and civilisation would be thrown back for centuries.
All this time, the situation on the ground was deteriorating in the largest of the islands, Jamaica, whose planters had been hardest hit of all by the general economic depression which had followed emancipation and free trade. The cause of the planters’ distress, they claimed, was was the availability on the island of vacant lands, where the ‘lazy’ blacks could settle and provide for themselves, thus releasing them from the need to work regularly on the plantations. On the other islands, the problem was solved, to som extent, by importing Asian labourers to work the plantations. In Jamaica, however, the planters tried to force the Blacks off the ‘vacant’ lands, which provoked riots. Missionaries, especially the Baptists, encouraged the Black settlers in their opposition to the planters. In the Legislative Assembly and in the countryside disaffection grew stronger, tinged with racial overtones. The planters’ order was breaking down.
In these conditions, the only solution was to surrender their powers to the Colonial Office, which was at least kindly disposed towards them and their method of production. It had recently replied to a petition from a group of poor blacks on the island by castigating their ‘sloth’ and telling them to return to the plantations to work for wages. The planters preferred to entrust their fate to Whitehall rather than have it decided by militant Blacks, of whom they were terrified: mindful of the horrors of the Indian Mutiny and of recent events in neighbouring Haiti, they were only too eager to attribute the same bloody intentions to their own ‘Black Rebellion’ when it came, in 1865. Like the Indian Mutiny (or ‘War of Independence’), the Jamaica Rebellion was brutally suppressed, in a manner which caused a storm in English public opinion. Shortly afterwards, the Jamaican assembly voted to relinquish its own powers, and the island’s government was taken over by the Crown. Over the next few years, all the other West Indian territories were which were not already Crown Colonies followed suit, except for Barbados. For the planting community, as for the Colonial Office, there was no other solution consistent with the preservation of the ‘white man’s law and order’ or Grey’s ‘civilisation’.
In the 1860s and ’70s, Britain’s transatlantic trade was becoming less important. The West Indies were stagnant; Latin America and the United States were both taking a smaller proportion of British exports than in the 1840s and ’50s. But over this comparitively short period these changes were marginal: with one or two exceptions, Britain’s best customers in 1857 were still her best customers in 1875. More important than changes in the direction of British trade was its sheer quantitative increase. The 1860s saw the culmination of the period of Britain’s most exhuberant industrial and commercial growth, when the plant nurtured by the industrial revolution and and then liberated by free trade in the 1840s came to flower and filled out into the world. Still unchallenged by effective competition until the last few years of the twenty-year period, way ahead of the rest of the world in its technology and industrial organisation, Britain’s new cheap products found markets almost everywhere, and her demands for food and raw materials eager suppliers. New markets were pioneered and old markets exploited more intensively.
The ‘family’ of the Empire at the end of the nineteenth century.
Protectionism & Progress – The Era of the Wars:
Protectionism as a consistent fiscal policy was almost as unthinkable in the 1890s as it had been in the 1860s; for most sectors of industry it was not yet necessary. The economy was a little sickly, but not chronically ill. There was no reason why Britain should not continue to hold its own in the more competitive conitions of the later nineteenth century, just as it had done in mid-century. This was the generally accepted view in the 1890s, and it left no room for a radical departure from free trade policy. It did, however, leave room for little departures. For while the British economy was fundamentally sound enough not to require special surgery, it might not be so strong as to be able to look on unconcerned while foreigners, by means which might be regarded as illicit, deliberately set out to cripple it. When foreign bounties on beet sugar made the West Indies’ case for retaliation almost unanswerable, and urgent, the British government at last relented in 1902 and threatened to impose countervailing duties if the bounties were not lifted. This worked, but it was as near as Britain got in this period to a retaliatory tariffs. But foreign sugar subsidies, while they might hurt the West Indies, also meant cheap sugar for the British housewife, and at someone else’s expense. Retalitory tariffs would mean higher prices, which was electoral suicide, as proved in 1906. So Britain persisted in playing by the old rules, even though almost every one of its rivals abjured them.
The sugar islands of the West Indies got Ł860,000 in grants between 1897 and 1905, and one or two big loans in addition. But most of this was to save them from ruin, and went to settle debts. Only about a third of it was used for anything more constructive, like agricultural research, roads and shipping. What Joseph Chamberlain, as Colonial Secretary, managed to squeeze out of a reluctant cabinet and Treasury hardly measured up to his own ambitions; but enough was done by way of state-sponsored colonial development to make a difference. The West Indies were saved from economic collapse until the cause of their distress, foreign bounties on beet sugar, had been eradicated by international agreement in 1903. They were allowed to continue the limping decline which the economic facts of life had decreed for them, with even the wretched crutch that Chamberlain had given them, of protection for their sugar exports against foreign bounties, taken from them in the 1908 because it was only ‘prolonging their dying agony’; and if they did not die, it was no thanks to the British government.
Trinidadian soldiers in 1919
The First World War made the Empire more valuable to Britain, both as a source of fighting men and of necessary imports. In all about two and a half million colonials fought for Britain, with thousands more serving as non-combatants. Economically, the Empire’s contribution was crucial and especially significant were the material goods they they supplied. Many of Britain’s resources, raw materials vital for war production, lay in its colonies, and still more lay in the wider world market which it was part of the colonies’ purpose to defend. Britain’s war economy gobbled up imports during the years of fighting, at a rate which in peacetime would have been considered disastrous to her balance of trade. The West Indies played their part in this, almost quadrupling their exports to Britain from an annual average value of six million pounds in the years 1910-14 to twenty-three million in 1915-20. Winston Churchill told the Commons after the war that …
… the commodities which they produced were in many cases vital to the maintenance of the industries, and particularly the war industries, of Britain and her Allies.
In the inter-war years, although it was fashionable in progressive circles to decry the Empire, from Britain’s material point of view it was far from being an anachronism. On the contrary, it was just only just beginning to pay the dividends its old champions had always expected from it, and handsomely. For the giant British-based industrial and commercial combines and cartels which the war and the depression, by weeding out their smaller, weaker competitors, had left in control of some of the empire’s most valuable assets, these dividends were especially high. In the West Indies, Tate and Lyle were major beneficiaries. To a large extent, British industry not only bought its raw materials from the colonies but it was directly involved there in their growth and production, which further cemented the bonds between British capitalism and the Empire. But the imperial system was not without its critics from both inside and outside. Imperialists, as well as Socialists and Liberals, were explicit in their views that the empire could not endure long into the twentieth century if it excluded countries from its self-governing upper echelon on the sole ground of colour. There was trouble in the African colonies after the war, as they had been before. But the organisation of discontent was, as yet, very embryonic, easily suppressed or disregarded locally, and it caused the British little trouble.
From ‘The New Pictorial Atlas of the World’ circa 1933.
The same was true elsewhere in the dependent empire. The West Indies had strikes and riots in the late 1930s which were less easily ‘tamed’ than expressions of discontent elsewhere, but no really effective political organisation emerged until after those riots. Provoked and stimulated by the riots, however, before the outbreak of the war there was a genuine resolution on the part of some politicians and colonial civil servants, to make something more of Britain’s professed aim of ‘trusteeship’ than it had made hitherto. Aside from the West Indies, most of the empire outside India and the middle east remained quiet to the end of the thirties, if not as ‘docile’ ad ‘tractable’ as Winston Churchill had painted it in 1921, then certainly quieter than it had been before that date. The colonies were still too valuable to Britain for it to want to give them up, or to loosen its control over them. But while, at the end of the Second World War, Churchill and other imperialists continued to congratulate themselves on ‘the soundness of our institutions’ as reflected in the empire’s loyalty, there were others who were working hard to improve their colonial institutions and by 1945 solid plans had been laid for a new colonial deal.
The North Atlantic Ocean showing the Commercial seaways, steamer routes, Air Mail routes and Pioneer Flights, circa 1933.
Independence, Migration & The New Commonwealth:
Culturally, the end of the war in Europe marked the origin of the steel bands that then made great use of the empty oil drums left behind by the military. But the ‘new’ rules from the 1890s curbing carnivals stuck, so Trinidadian people had to get creative. So-called tambou-bamboo bands instead invented a range of improvised tuned percussion instruments: bamboo tubes of varying lengths, gin bottles “played” with spoons, metal scrapers, and later biscuit tins, hubcaps, and brake blocks.
A Jamaican immigrant seeking work and lodgings in Birmingham in 1955.
By the 1950s, if Britain did not any longer have a credible world role, therefore, it still had worldwide economic interests. It continued to depend on the West Indies for sugar, for instance and increasingly for supplies of cheap labour as postwar reconstruction, declining birthrates and labour shortages resulted in the introduction of government schemes to encourage Commonwealth workers, paricularly from the West Indies, to seek employment in Britain. Jamaicans and Trinidadians were recruited directly by agents to fill vacancies in the British transport network and the newly created National Health Service. Patterns of chain migration developed in which pioneer migrants aided relatives and friends to settle. Despite this influx, however, the numbers of emigrants from Britain continued to be greater than those of ‘immigrants’. The 1948 Nationality Act reaffirmed the right of British citizenship to all Commonwealth citizens and colonial subjects and the importance of assigned to the Commonwealth in the 1950s prevented the imposition of immigration controls on New Commonwealth citizens. However, by the 1960s, Britain’s retreat from these ties in favour of European links heralded a policy of restriction, which gradually whittled away the right of New Commonwealth citizens to automatic British citizenship.
Britain’s disengagement from empire was not entirely voluntary. After World War II, Britain’s comparative international weakness required it to grant independence to territories in Asia that were rapidly becoming ungovernable. Further retreats were forced on successive governments by Britain’s inability to the contrary, the Commonwealth never allowed Britain to retain any real influence. For the West Indies, see the inset below.
Britain’s global political interests were not so very different than they had been in the previous decades, though its capacity to safeguard them may well have been. By October 1951, when Labour left office, nationalist demands in various countries were beginning to run on far ahead of Britain’s willingness to concede them. The next eight or nine years were the most difficult for the post-war empire, as nationalist demands became bolder and their methods more drastic, and as the Conservative government came to terms only very slowly and painfully with the full reality of the situation. They professed, at the very beginning of their term, an intention to continue the process towards ‘self-government within the Commonwealth’, and they put no great obstacles in the way of this process in those colonies, like the West Indies, where it was already too far advanced.
In the late 1950s, despite the outcomes of the Suez Crisis and all the other reverses through violent conflict, there was still a sizeable empire left for Britain to save, if it still had the willpower to do so. The progress towards independence of the larger colonies, such as the West Indies, could no longer be prevented, but they might be ‘guided’ towards a form of independence which suited Britain. With the coming into being of the ‘New Commonwealth’ from Britain’s former colonies, to add to the Dominions, and the strength which might still be drawn from it in terms of imperial preferences, there was still a secure framework for British world influence. In the 1960s, Britain was hustled and harried out of most of her old colonies, including the West Indian islands. The ‘Wind of Change’ blew steadily and irresistably across the Caribbean. Meanwhile, in Britain, the 1962 Immigration Act restricted the flow of New Commonwealth immigrants into Britain, but it had the opposite effect: fearful of losing the right of free entry, immigrants came to Britain in greater numbers. In the eighteen months before the restrictions were introduced, the volume of newcomers equalled the total for the previous five years. In August 1962 Jamaica, along with Trinidad and Tobago, became independent, followed by British Guiana (Guyana) in May 1966 and Barbados the following November. The next year, 1967, the Leeward Islands and Windward Islands joined the Commonwealth. Finally, the Bahamas gained their independence in July 1973, followed by Grenada the following February.
Eric Gairy, first Prime Minister of Grenada.
Grenada gained its independence as a sovereign state without breaking formal ties with the Commonwealth, under the leadership of Eric Gairy, who became the first Prime Minister of Grenada, with Queen Elizabeth as Head of State. In March 1979, the Marxist–LeninistNew Jewel Movement overthrew Gairy’s government in a popular bloodless coup d’état and established the People’s Revolutionary Government (PRG), headed by Maurice Bishop as Prime Minister. Bishop was later executed by military hardliners, prompting a U.S. invasion in October 1983. The invasion was heavily criticized by the governments of Britain, neighbouring Trinidad and Tobago, and Canada. It led to a famous, heated telephone conversation between British PM Margaret Thatcher and President Ronald Reagan, who was said to be unaware of the Queen’s status as the island’s Head of State. The US later stated that the invasion took place at the behest of the governments of Dominica and Barbados, involving troops from the Regional Security System based on Barbados, with the support of the Governor-General of Grenada. Apparently, Reagan was most concerned about the building of a ten-thousand-foot airstrip which involved Cuban construction workers and military personnel, and which might be used, at a tense period in the Cold War, to refuel Soviet airplanes supplying communist insurgents in Central America. US troop progress was rapid, and within four days the government of Hudson Austin had been removed, the Queen was restored as Head of State, and Grenada returned to the Commonwealth.
Later in the 1970s, independence followed for Bermuda, St Vincent, Dominica (1978); St Lucia (1979); Montserrat, the Virgin Islands, the Cayman, Turk and Caicos Islands, Antigua (1981); St Kitts and Nevis, and Anguilla (1983). Aside from the Dominions, which at that time included Canada, Australia and New Zealand, the colonies (apart from Rhodesia/ Zimbabwe and Hong Kong) were a scattering of the small islands all over the world which formed a total population of well under a million. Most of them had not been ruled directly, but only protected or subsidised. The island of Anguilla in the Caribbean, which was never a real colony but part of a British ‘Associated State’ with St Kitts and Nevis, caused a flurry in March 1969 when it wanted to break away from St Kitts, and – at its own request – was ‘occupied’ by a force of London policemen who were sent to protect it. On the map below, it can be seen that the British also had interests in central America, along the coasts which were controlled by pidgin English-speaking pirates form the seventeenth to the nineteenth centuries. In particular, the colony of British Honduras became the independent state of Belize in 1981.
Many Voices & Cultures – the Contemporary Caribbean:
The Caribbean as an oceanic region has the appearance of a certain geographical uniformity to the present day, but culturally and linguistically, it is, in reality, remarkably diverse. Each island has its own strong loyalties and traditions. Even the islands of the former British West Indies did not become a federation, either in political or linguistic terms. Cuba and the Dominican Republic are Spanish; Haiti is French; Trinidad is heavily influenced by Spanish, French creole and immigrant Indian traditions. The most English of the islands are Antigua, Jamaica and, above all, Barbados. These islands also provide good evidence for the the theory of separate language evolution because English is both a first and a national language. The spectacularly different form it took in each island was the legacy of the slave trade as already described.
By the twentieth century, Caribbean creole had developed far beyond its pidgin English roots, while maintaining a vigorous tradition separate from those of West Africa and the Southern United States. Of all the varieties of Caribbean English, Jamaican English (with the most speakers) attracted the most scholarly attention, beginning with F. G. Cassidy’s celebrated Jamaica Talk in 1953. With the development of Jamaican nationalism, E. K. Braithwaite, a celebrated Caribbean English poet and Professor of Caribbean Cultural and Social History of Social History at the University of the West Indies in the 1980s, spoke of Jamaican English as a ‘nation-language’:
The word ‘dialect’has so many perjorative overtones. You laugh at a “dialect”. It is broken English. “Nation-language” suggests the kind of authenticity which is now becoming part of our expression.
Other poets joined Braithwaite in talking of ‘the Jamaican language’. Jamaican linguists, however, insisted that the language was correctly termed ‘Jamaican creole’. It also continued to be called ‘the patois’ or ‘the dialect’ by ordinary speakers. Visitors to the island could detect that there were two basic levels of ‘native’ language, Standard English, as found in newspapers, books and journals, mildly influenced by Jamaican colloquialisms, and a spoken Jamaican English which was virtually unintelligible to outsiders. Journalists would use a spoken version of Standard English with a number of dialect words such as ‘nyam’ (eat) or ‘tacko’ (ugly) thrown into conversations. Until the 1970s, the ‘Jamaican language’ was a purely oral language of the streets and the home, but then, fuelled by cultural nationalism, reggae and ‘dub poetry’, a written standard began to emerge as an expression of Jamaican speech. Reggae has been described as the ‘heartbeat’ of Jamaica, and ‘dub poetry’ as ‘the baby of reggae’. It emerged in the early 1970s with poets such as Linton Kwesi Johnson and Mutabaruka, a Rastafarian. Johnson described dub poetry as:
… a new departure in Jamaican protest poetry. Here the spoken/ chanted word is the dominant mode. People’s speech and popular music are combined, and the Jamaican folk culture and the reggae tradition provide both sources of inspiration and frames of reference.
Above: the ‘dub poets’, Mutabaruka and Linton Kwesi Johnson, are part of a new generation who express Jamaican English in a written form far removed from Standard English.
The evolution of dub poetry can be traced in the work of Louise Bennett, who used a highly localised dialect of Jamaican form of English. In her own words, “Miss Lou”, as she was known, wrote poems in the free expression of the people … a manner of speaking unhampered by the rules of (Standard English) grammar. She writes out of the oral tradition of Jamaica and Black English, and is inspired by the spoken rhythms of the Bible, the Sankey and Moody hymnal, and the folksongs of Jamaica. Her poetry was at its best when she performed it, manipulating the full range of the language, playing on the nuances of meaning like a music-hall comedian. Her subjects are the life of Kingston – street scenes, public events, local sports and Jamaican politics. Here are some lines from her declaration of solidarity with ordinary Caribbean speech:
Meck me get it straight Mass Charlie
For me noh quite understan,
Yuh gwine kill all Englishdialect
Or jus Jamaica one?
When Louise Bennett’s poems were first published in a collection in 1966, Jamaica Labrish, a four-page glossary was included which included bockle for bottle, duppy for ghost, ninyam for food. At the time, ‘Miss Lou’ was an almost lone voice in her use of ‘nation language’. Twenty years later, she was at the centre of a vital tradition. Edward Braithwaite described the condition of Caribbean English at that time:
With the new generation, the people who are really using the nation language, the idea is not really to write it at all, but to have it recorded, and best of all, filmed. There you have a complete correlation between what the culture dictates, and what the media would like, and how you communicate it.
Braithwaite goes on to make the point that Caribbean English is refracted through many lenses, historical and local, providing an important model for the development of new Englishes around the world:
All Caribbean people partake in multiple cultures. They partake in the American culture. Some of us partake in the Latin American culture. Then there’s the European culture and the Caribbean culture.
Code-switching from a localised Caribbean English, whether ‘Bajan’, Jamaican, Trinidadian, etc, to Standard English was the upshot of this fusion. Barbadians, or ‘Bajans’ as they are sometimes still called, have a reputation for well-spoken respectability, and Bajan creole is much closer to Standard English than Jamaican creole. The Caribbean writer George Lamming is a Barbadian whose first novel, In the Castle of My Skin, has explored explores the subtle relations, roots and reasons for the similarity between Black and White Barbadian speech:
One of the curious things about Barbados is that given the same region … there is great proximity in accent, and intonation between Black and White … If I hear a voice next door … I would recognise that was a Barbadian speaking. I would not be too sure at first hearing whether that was a White Barbadian or a Black Barbadian. … There will certainly be an elementof Irish and Scots and English, greatly influenced of course by the African syntax and vocabulary which has been brought here. … You speak of people who are making a “bassa bassa” is a Twi word, but what it really means is a noise … Teachers would use that: “Don’t make any ‘bassa bassa’ in this classroom.”
At the end of the last century, Barbados itself, barely twenty-one miles long, was still almost wholly devoted, second only to tourism, to sugar production for its income. The plantation boundaries remained much as they always had been. To the north of the capital, Bridgetown, stretches a long plain on which there are many plantations dating back to the 1640s, fringed with hills and majestic royal palms. Much of the fertile ground was devoted to sugar cane, and some of the plantations were still owned by families who can trace their ancestry back to the first White settlement of the island. Their story, and that of the Black workers on their estates expresses much of the Barbadian experience and the development of the English language on the island over three and a half centuries. The older Black men, talking among themselves in the fields, use a Caribbean creole that is difficult for a Standard English speaker to follow. The white ‘bosses’ naturally use the same language, a ‘broken English’ which they refer to as ‘Bajan’, a creole which they recognise as being different from those spoken on other Caribbean islands like Trinidad and Jamaica where:
They’re speaking English but they’re putting different stresses … Bajans themselves don’t understand it although they’re not far away from that particular country. … I become more of a Bajan as soon as I’m talking to … people in the field … But when I’m sitting at a professional desk I’m slightly more English.
Standard English & Caribbean English – Whose Language?:
Standard English evolved slowly in the West Indies during the second half of the twentieth century, being dependent on newspapers, book dictionaries and broadcating authorities, whereas Caribbean ‘nation’ languages from the 1950s have been much more mobile, oral traditions continually searching for new forms of expression. One Caribbean writer whose work typified the transition into a written Caribbean English was ‘Mikey’ Smith, one of the dub poets who established an international reputation. As a young Jamaican drama student, Smith captured the imaginations of his generation in the late 1970s. His career was tragically cut short when he was stoned to death during Jamaica’s political violence. Michael Smith composed orally and made tape recordings. Only later did he transcribe his work, but he was followed by a group of poets who composed their work collaboratively, called Poets in Unity. They chose to write in the language of their own culture rather than in Standard English, and to disseminate it throughout the English-speaking world in performance, records, tapes and books. They were extremely alert to the idea that the language of their poetry might become the future standard language of the West Indians and give their society a distinct Caribbean identity that would not be overshadowed by British or American English. Edward Braithwaite made the point, in talking about English in Caribbean, that what was then commonly called ‘the Third World’ was acutely concerned, as a whole, with language. As he said, We regard words, word play, as an essential part of our personality.
In the 1950s, before the West Indies had had achieved their independence from Britain, the emphasis on Standard English was oppressive. Braithwaite recalled the experience of Jamaicans in the law courts:
The judge would expect the defendant to speak as best as he could in ‘the Queen’s English’. This would come out as broken English and the man would be hesitant and embarrassed. Now, with the acceptance of the nation language, the defendant comes in dressed as he is, and he speaks to the judge as himself, and is much more eloquent, and much more successful in his dealings with the court.
Bob Marley gave Jamaican English a special place in contemporary culture, symbolising the emergence of ‘New Englishes’.
The ‘Jamaican creole’ of Smith and the dub poets was closely related to the language of reggae star Bob Marley (above), having Rastafarian elements and dealing with themes of oppression, resistance and redemption. In the 1980s, Bob Marley was without doubt the most famous WestIndian in the world, invited as guest of honour to Independence Day celebrations and peace rallies. His music swept through Britain and the United States, influencing a generation of songwriters. His lyrics gave poignant expression to the Caribbean predicament: an imposed identity caught between an African one and an American one, with a European legacy. His worlwide success gave Jamaican creole a worlwide credibility. Braithwaite commented wryly that announcers on the radio are quite happy to move into nation language. In schools, the trend towards a Caribbean English was emphasised by the emergence of examinations devised and adjudicated not in London or Manchester but in Kingston or Bridgetown. One of the leading spokesmen for the recognition of the Jamaican creole was Hubert Devonish, a Guyanese academic. He wanted it given equal official status as English, maintaining that it was a very old language that the slaves brought from Africa to the Caribbean and had always been on a different ‘trajectory’ from English.
Devonish argued that although the African slaves picked up the vocabulary of English, they retained the grammatical structure of their African languages. No linguist, he claimed, could overlook the fact that all four of the Caribbean creoles – English, Dutch, French and Spanish – were remarkably similar in structure. He therefore argued that from both a historical and linguistic point of view, Jamaican creole was a separate language. Historically, he argued that English was the language of an élite, isolated from the mass of the Caribbean population. If the people of Jamaica were to participate fully in every aspect of their own society, the government should therefore recognise the creole as an official language, separate from English. There was, he said, …
… no reason why any élite group within Jamaican society should determine that only one language, that of the dominant European power, should be the official language.
The most effective way of getting Jamaican creole to be recognised by those in power, he suggested, was for it to be a medium of instruction in the education system. He argued that many people were denied proper access to this system because it operated only in English. He believed that the writing system of Jamaican creole should be introduced through a variety of board games, including Scrabble. Others took more of a middle path, arguing that Jamaica had a continuum of language, with creole at one end, incomprehensible to those not living in the society, and Standard English at the other, a medium in which many were never fully fluent. Mervyn Morris argued that the majority of Jamaicans could not be fully bilingual in their code-switching, operating “somewhere in the middle”. For Morris, Jamaicans had two co-existing needs, to “express things about the Jamaican experience” which could not be expressed in Standard English with the same force, and to use Standard English in order not to cut themselves off from “international communication”.
So, the international power of English has been the force which has arrested the full, separate development of the of Caribbean English. Within Caribbean culture, there is still a considerable resistance to the recognition of Caribbean English: a continuing debate about what is ‘correct’, and the absence of a standardised spelling system makes this debate almost irresolvable. Teachers have preferred to teach a Caribbean version of Standard English rather than a more self-conscious, nationalistic Caribbean English. Parents have also complained about their children “talking local” at school. This connects with the external pressures related to the growing demands for International English, which are similar to those experienced in other ‘developing’ economies. Despite the successes of the West Indian cricket team from the mid-seventies to the mid-nineties, the development of a collective Caribbean or West Indian political, linguistic and cultural identity has been slow to emerge, and has been resisted by the individual islands.
Today Caribbean creole has developed far beyond its pidgin English roots and the influence of Caribbean English is not confined to the Caribbean. Since the 1950s, there have been large, well established West Indian communities in Toronto, New York, London and Birmingham. I have written about the ‘final passage’, the ‘Windrush Generation’ and the British Caribbean communities in other articles on this site. Throughout what was the British Empire, and what is now the British Commonwealth, the independent traditions of Australia, Canada, New Zealand and, more recently, South Africa, have forged and breathed new life into the Englishes which were exported from Britain between two hundred and four hundred years ago. In South Africa over the last half century, it became the language of black consciousness and liberation. In the Caribbean, it has become the focus of new forms of anti-imperialism and nationalism which has served as a model of evolving bilingualism and multilingualism in ‘developing’ countries throughout Africa and Asia.
Sources:
Nuala Zahadieh et.al. (2001), Atlas of British & Irish History. London: Penguin.
Robert McCrum (1986), The Story of English. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
Bernard Porter (1986), A Short History of British Imperialism. London: Longman.
The English Language has always been the most significant battlegrounds of Anglo-American rivalry, a fascinating window on the tensions of the “special relationship”. Divided by a common language, each generation has made the enjoyable discovery that the ‘standard’ English of Britain is different from from the English of America, arguing or joking about it according to the mood and politics of the time. Antagonize and placate were both American neologisms which were hated by the Victorian British. By then, as members of a ‘multiracial’ society, the first Americans had also adopted words like wigwam, pretzel, spook, depot and canyon in borrowings from the Amerindians, Germans, Dutch, French, and Spanish. It was these additions that Samuel Johnson referred to in his famous complaint about the American dialect, a tract of corruption to which every language widely diffused must always be exposed. Like Johnson’s dictionary, Noah Webster’s 1828 American Dictionary of the English Language represents a landmark in the development of the dominant language spoken in the new ‘anglosphere’. It was Webster’s intention, as he put it, to introduce uniformity and accuracy of pronunciation into common schools. Webster’s dictionary was larger than Johnson’s by about a third, and contained much American usage. But a lifetime of effort, including a year spent in England, had mellowed him, and in the preface to his monument, he noted that the body of the language is the same as in England, and it is desirable to perpetuate that sameness. Despite its now honoured place in the history of American English, the 1828 dictionary sold only 2,500 copies and he was forced to mortgage his home to bring out a second edition. Despite this, he continued to be dogged by death until his death in his native Connecticut in 1843, his effort largely unrecognised and unapplauded.
Apart from the changes in spelling, it was the emphasis he gave to the pronunciation of each syllable in the distinctive pattern of American speech that was perhaps the most significant contribution attributed to Webster’s Dictionary. His insistence on a good articulation … giving every letter in a syllable its due proportion and sound … and in making such a distinction, between syllables, … that the ear shall without difficulty acknowledge their number, meant that Americans pronounced secretary as ‘sec-ret-ary’ rather than ‘secret’ry’ in British English. The precise extent of Webster’s influence on American speech rhythms remains controversial but no one disputes the remarkable uniformity of much American speech, particularly beyond the eastern seabord. Even in the East, there was nothing like the patchwork of local dialects and accents which continued to exist in Britain. Many nineteenth-century travellers to the United States also commented on the nasal quality and drawl of the American voice. The Victorian novelist, Captain Marryat, author of The Children of the New Forest, Mr Midshipman Easy and other children’s classics, travelled widely in the States, and noticed that:
The Americans dwell upon their words when they speak – a custom arising, I presume, from their cautious, calculating habits; and they have always more or less of a nasal twang.
Marryat also noted with obvious fascination another aspect of American speech, the ‘um’ and ‘hu’ as generally used as a sort of reply, which he found to be useful expressions and admits to having acquired a taste for them himself. But the hostility of most British visitors to American English undoubtedly bred a certain defensive arrogance among those who were not ashamed of “the American twang”. One traveller reported that he had found, …
… not an American, let him be Yankee or Southerner, from the banks of the Hudson or the Mississippi, but flatters himself that he speaks more correct English than we illiterate sons of the mother isle. …
Abraham Lincoln was born on 12 February 1809, in Kentucky, before leaving for the Midwestern state of Indiana.
Apart from the phrase unconditional surrender, first used by General Grant in 1862, the American Civil War itself had little immediate or lasting impact on the language of either Southerners or Yankees. What it did do, however, was to bring the economy and pioneering Mid-West into play for the first time in the history of the now divided country. Both Abraham Lincoln and Mark Twain were mid-Westerners. The direct simplicity of Lincoln’s ‘Gettysburg Address’ (19 November 1863), just two minutes of prose scribbled on the back of an envelope and barely audible to those in his audience, except those standing next to him, shows the new maturity and confidence of Webster’s American English:
Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent a new nation, conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal. Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceived and so dedicated, can long endure.
Lincoln is best known for his Emancipation Proclamation, issued on 1 January 1863, changing the character of the Civil War.
Then, on 16 December 1865, a story entitled John Smiley and his Jumping Frog was published by the New York Saturday Press. It was written by a young reporter from the West writing under the pen name of “Mark Twain”. This was the first of his stories which later formed the book Huckleberry Finn, which Ernest Hemingway later wrote was the best book we’ve had. All American writing comes from that. There was nothing before. There has been nothing as good since. Twain was able to render the American English vernacular in a way that was neither a parody nor a caricature but literature, based on the oral achievements epitomised by Lincoln’s speech at Gettysburg. Both Lincoln and Twain were brought up at the frontier; both were from the lively middle of the American continent and both shared its ethos and beliefs – democratic, individualistic, egalitarian. Lincoln believed in the American people; Twain wrote about them, using their common speech. T. S. Eliot placed him as one of those rare writers who have brought their language up to date. In Life on the Mississippi (1883) Twain himself described his career after the Civil War brought his initial occupation as a rive boat pilot to an abrupt end:
I had to seek another livelihood. So I became a silver-miner in Nevada; next, a newspaper reporter; next, a gold-miner in California; next, a reporter in San Francisco; next, a special correspondent in the Sandwich Islands; next a roving correspondent in Europe and the East; next, an instructional torch-bearer on the lecture platform; and, finally I became a scribbler of books, and an immovable fixture among the other rocks of New England.
That was written when Twain was forty-eight, looking back on an early life which epitomised the westward movements experienced by many Americans. Describing his experiences in the silver mines of Nevada, he remarked that …
… slang was the language of Nevada. It was hard to preach a sermon without it, and be understood. Such phrases as ‘You bet!’ ‘Oh, no, I reckon not!’ ‘No Irish need apply!’ and a hundred others, became so common as to fall from the lips of a speaker unconsciously …
In his work as a journalist he would have met pioneers from every part of the American frontier. As one reviewer of his first book, Innocents Abroad, noted, his work was characterised by the breadth and ruggedness and audacity of the West. Twain himself described the publication of the celebrated travelogue, an instant bestseller, as the Turning Point of My Life. And it was the last link in the chain of events that placed him among the many writers in English who, having struck gold and found a public, took to the lecture-circuit to talk about the travels abroad he had written about. He was perhaps the first writer in a distinctively American English to do so though, as a ‘humorist’, the English Language was essentially a playground, and his style was eclectic. Unlike his sober literary predecessors, ‘New Englanders’ like Emerson, Thoreau, Hawthorne and many others now forgotten, Twain had an enormously wide experience of American life as it was being lived by his contemporaries of all classes and occupations. His work therefore had an authenticity and originality which marked it out from that of his predecessors. The two novels for which he is best known and with which American literature came of age were The Adventures of Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn. The latter caused a scandal at its first appearance among the respectable reading public, celebrating as it did the rich variety of American society and its diverse speech. What is especially interesting about the book is the ‘Explanatory Note’ that precedes the first chapter in which he set out a complete prospectus for his use of dialect:
In this book a number of dialects are used, to wit: the Missouri Negro dialect, the extremist form of backwards Southwestern dialect, the ordinary “Pike County” dialect, and four modified varieties of this last. The shadings have not been done in a haphazard fashion or by guesswork, but painstakingly and with the trustworthy guidance and support of personal familiarity with these several forms of speech. I make this explanation for the reason that without it many readers would suppose that all these characters were trying to talk alike and not succeeding.
Mark Twain wrote about the West, but lived mainly in the East during his career as a writer, an increasingly urban and industrial world far removed from the open skies of the Mississippi. He was, in this sense, the writer who brought the newly-forged American language back from the frontier to the teeming cities of the East Coast. By a quirk of history, the only writer to touch Twain when it came to expressing the naturalness and vitality of American speech was already making a name for himself back East, and his name was Walt Whitman. He was an Easterner by birth on Long Island, raised in Brooklyn and rising through the ranks of the Brooklyn Eagle to become editor 1846. But two years later he went south to New Orleans, where he wrote Leaves of Grass in 1855, sending a copy to the great Ralph Waldo Emerson at his home in Concord, who at once recognised Whitman’s genius, describing it as the most extraordinary piece of wit and wisdom that America has yet contributed. His poetry continued to express the new voice of America, spanning thirty years from 1850 to 1880. He showed American writers and readers that it was not necessary to imitate English or European models. He encouraged those who came after to look and write about their own society in their own way. He celebrated the United States; he was intoxicated by it. He gave it a myth. “I hear America singing”, he wrote, and travelled extensively to hear its songs:
When Twain came east, Whitman went out west. When he died, in New Jersey, in 1892, he was recognised throughout America as a pioneer in language who had given his country its first uniquely American lyrical voice. He wrote, as a radical, that ‘the grand American expression’ was:
… the powerful language of resistance … it is the dialect of common sense. It is the speech of the proud and melancholy races and of all who aspire. It is the cosen tongue to express growth faith self-esteem freedom justice equality friendliness amplitude prudence decision and courage. It is the medium that shall well nigh express the inexpressible.
Meanwhile, in the Mid-West of the twenty years 1867-1887, with the opening of new railroads in Kansas, the cowboy was ‘king’, leaving behind a rich legacy of words and phrases to add to the one about McCoy. These formed a pidgin English for talking to the Plains Indians and to the many Mexican cowboys:
… rodeo, stampede, bronco, chaps, lassoo, mustang, lariat, pinto, poncho, ranch, cowhand, cowpuncher, cowpoke, bronco-buster, wrangler, range-rider, ranger, rustler; hot under the collar, bite the dust, ‘the real McCoy’.
These were just the latest in a long lexicon of new words and phrases which were added to English by the forging of a uniquely American language from the diverse dialects and accents of immigrants from the British Isles in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries and from the more recent European immigrants of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. I have previously written about the motivations for emigration and ‘concrete’ contributions of these immigrants to American society, so here I want to deal with the more abstract aspects of their linguistic and cultural identities within that society.
The Flight of the Irish – Newfoundland & American English:
The Irish first began leaving their homeland, voluntarily and involuntarily, in the sixteenth century. Their influence has been felt around the English-speaking world, from North America to Australia. The migrations and settlements of the Irish brought some Irish Gaelic words into worlwide currency. Newfoundland, distinctively Irish in character to the present day, was the first English-speaking colony in the New World.
Unlike the Welsh language in Pennsylvania, Irish was so completely and immediately assimilated into English language culture outside of Gaelic Ireland itself, that the specific Irish linguistic contribution to the narrative of that culture is difficult to detect. The one exception to this general ‘rule’ can, however, be found on the island of Newfoundland, whose inhabitants preserve a kind of Irish English that, until the end of the twentieth century at least, was almost indistinguishable from the real thing two-and-a-half thousand miles away across the North Atlantic. Newfoundland lies off the coast of Labrador at the mouth of the St Lawrence, commanding the sea lanes into Canada. In winter, it is shrouded in mist and menaced by ice. When the mist lifts, the landscape resembles the west coast of Ireland; similarly, the traditional industry is fishing and the more recent one is oil. A former colony and then dominion of the United Kingdom, Newfoundland gave up its independence in 1933, following significant economic distress caused by the Great Depression and the aftermath of Newfoundland’s participation in World War I. It became the tenth province to enter Confederation on 31 March 1949, as “Newfoundland”. On 6 December 2001, an amendment was made to the Constitution of Canada to change the province’s name to Newfoundland and Labrador.
The province is now Canada’s most linguistically homogeneous, with 97.0% of residents reporting English (Newfoundland English) as their mother tongue in the 2016 census. Historically, Newfoundland was also home to unique varieties of French and Irish, as well as the extinct Beothuk language. In Labrador, the indigenous languages Innu-aimun and Inuktitut are also spoken. Newfoundland was actually the first English-speaking colony in the ‘New World’, founded by Sir Humphrey Gilbert in 1588 for seasonal sea-fishing. Throughout the seventeenth century, a gradual migration of English shipowners gradually developed the community on the island. In a pattern repeated throughout North America and the Caribbean, most of their indentured servants were Irish, far outnumbering their masters. Quite quickly, therefore, the Hiberno-English of rural Ireland became the the socially dominant language of the capital, St John’s, which could today be mistaken for Waterford. This was, in part, because the Anglo-Irish and English landlords tended to be absentee, while the Irish stayed put. As well as the Irish descendents, who are based on the South Avalon Peninsula, there are a number of settlements descended from West Country fishermen with strong Dorset and Devonshire dialects, to the north of the island. The fur trade was dominated by Highland Scots, who have left traces of their speech behind. Among the Irish, however, there was very little mixing or ‘levelling’ with other nationalities or ethnic groups.
Unlike those who went to New England and rapidly integrated with the town life there, the Irish of Newfoundland returned to their village ways, living in communities of two to three hundred, as in much of Ireland in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Earning their living from the sea, there was no incentive for them to travel further than the nearest salt-fish factory, especially during harsh winters when they could be cut off for weeks at a time by blizzards. As a result, the English of Newfoundland and that of contemporary Waterford, Wexford, Kilkenny and Cork were remarkably similar at the end of the last century, particularly in patterns of pronunciation, stress, sense and traditional forms which are repeated continuously. The definitive Dictionary of Newfoundland English contains many Irish words, like ‘froster’ (a nail or cleat on a horse’s hoof to prevent slipping on the ice), ‘maneen’ (a boy who acts the part of a man) and ‘sulick’ (the liquid obtained from cooking meat or fish). One mildly self-mocking greeting used in Avalon Hiberno-Irish was, “welcome, my sweet fellow, would you be after having some tea?” Other translations from the Gaelic in Newfoundland, North American and international English include ‘shenanigens’, ‘smithereens’, ‘bother’ and ‘galore’.
Newfoundland English today is expressed in several accents and dialects found in the province of Newfoundland and Labrador. Most of these differ substantially from the English commonly spoken elsewhere in neighbouring Canada and North America. Many Newfoundland dialects are similar to the dialects of the West Country in England, while others resemble dialects of Ireland’s southeast. Still others blend elements of both, and there is also a Scottish influence on the dialects. While the Scots came in smaller numbers than the English and Irish, they had a large influence on Newfoundland society. Newfoundland was also the only place outside Europe to have its own distinct name in Irish: Talamh an Éisc, which means ‘land of the fish’. The Irish language is now extinct in Newfoundland. Scots Gaelic was also once spoken in the southwest of Newfoundland, following the settlement there, from the middle of the nineteenth century, of small numbers of Gaelic-speaking Scots from Cape Breton, Nova Scotia. A century and a half later, the language has not entirely disappeared, although it has no fluent speakers. Predominantly, however, Newfoundland remains simply the best-preserved of all the Irish communities scattered around the world, one which goes back to the migrations of the end of Elizabeth I’s reign, when not all the White migrants were voluntary travellers.
Like Christy Mahon in The Playboy of the Western World, the Irish had been looking hopefully towards America for centuries, and were among the first to emigrate to the ‘Thirteen Colonies’. The indentured Irish servant became such a familiar figure in the American South that by the end of the seventeenth century, three states – Maryland, Virginia and South Carolina – had passed laws restricting the immigration of Irish indentured servants. Statistically, the Irish accounted for a very significant part of the population, perhaps as many as four hundred thousand by 1790, second only to English nationals. By this time, the Irish in the New World had become a remarkably mixed society. During the nineteenth century, a staggering total of 4.7 million Irish people arrived in the United States fleeing the catastrophes at home. The idea of America permeated Irish society, so that villages on the west coast could still, in the late twentieth century, remember “the America Wake”, the lamentations attending the departures to the New World.
The main reason for the difficulty in identifying the effect of the English-speaking Irish arrivals on American English is that the two varieties had many characteristics in common, since both acquired their distinctive vocabularies and accents from the seventeenth-century English of the British Isles. Though the American variety had evolved further than the Irish, there were still important points of contact. Some details of American speech are almost certainly derived from Irish English, if not from Gaelic, mainly in grammar, syntax and pronunciation. Irish immigration led to the adoption of I seen for I saw, and the use of the modal verb shall rather than will. In Irish Gaelic, the Irish tended to use the definite article and say “She is in the school” rather than “She is in school”. Perhaps the most well-known Irish fragment in American speech is the Gaelic-inspired plural “yous”, still used by Irish American policemen in the NYPD.
By the middle of the nineteenth century, seventy-five per cent were able to read and write English, which supports the evidence for the decline of Irish Gaelic in Ireland itself. All the same, a number of ‘Irishisms’ made it across the Atlantic. Shenanigan, meaning “trickery” or “mischief” was first recorded in America in 1855, and comes from the Gaelic, sionnachaighim meaning “I play the fox, I play tricks” and smithereens comes from the County Mayo anglicisation of the Gaelic smidirin meaning ‘a small fragment’. The phrase “the whole shebang”, recorded in American English in 1879, is said to come from the Gaelic for ‘an illegal drinking establishment’ and ‘a temporary shelter or hovel’ and the word shanty from the Irish sean-tigh meaning ‘old house’. Etymology aside, the dictionary tells us that the word shantytown was first used in 1882 to refer to the shacks that were built alongside American railroads by Irish navvies working on the transcontinental railroad. In Boston, shanty Irish was a derogatory term for Irish families like the Kennedys, the first of whom, Patrick, arrived penniless in Boston in 1848 and earned his living as a cooper. Another perjorative, Paddy, dates back to at least 1748, and the paddy waggon meaning the police van, was coined in the 1920s also in Boston and other cities where there were many Irish policemen. The Irish had long had a reputation for being unruly and aggressive. To get one’s Irish up is an Americanism for ‘to get angry’. Traditionally, the Irish in America worked as labourers or servants or soldiers, and another colloquialism, biddy, meaning ‘a servant girl’ is thought to have come from the diminutive form of the Irish name, Bridget. One linguist has commented that…
from a sociological point of view it’s very interesting to speculate why Irishmen are so keen to derive ordinary English words from Irish.
The socio-political realities of the ‘Irish Question’ suggest that we are never likely to fathom Irish influence on American English. But we know that the high rates of literacy among the Irish meant that the better-educated Irish immigrants became clerks, priests or school-teachers. As in Britain, an important part of the American literary tradition is Irish. The writers F. Scott Fitzgerald and Eugene O’Neill were both of Irish descent, as were many diplomats and politicians, like Joseph Kennedy, father to Jack and Bobby. Much of the leadership of the labour unions and, of course, the Roman Catholic Church, was provided by the Irish. Charles Dickens, visiting New York in 1867, wrote that…
… the general corruption in respect of local funds appears to be stupendous… The Irish element is acquiring such enormous influence in New York City, that when I think of it, and see the the large Roman Catholic cathedral rising there, it seems unfair to stigmatise as ‘American’ other monstrous things that one also sees.
The slow integration of a distinct Irish English into American speech was matched by the great social crises which annhialated the Gaelic-speeching communities of the west of Ireland, the Gaeltacht. One million died in the terrible famine; millions more fled abroad. But almost more important in its effect on the native language was the fear of another catastrophe. Ever after, Irish parents encouraged their children to learn English and to leave in ever larger numbers for England, Australia and, above all, in the nineteenth and early twentieth century, the United States. The land was seen as cursed, and there was a tragic rejection of all things Irish. During the darkest moments of the Victorian age, the reality of everyday life in Ireland was so intolerable the Irish felt that only an escape into the Anglo-American way of life would solve their problems. In what has been called ‘the mass flight from the Irish language’ meant that by 1861, when the census was taken, less than two per cent of the Irish children between two and ten were monoglot Irish speakers. There were by then more Irish abroad than there were at home. The future for was an English-speaking one, and for many it was to lie overseas, at least for the next sixty years: in America, Britain and the wider Empire.
The Scottish Highlanders – Nova Scotia:
The Highland clearances of the eighteenth and nineteenth century stripped the ‘Highlands and Islands’ of their Gaelic-speaking population, leaving deserted farms and crofts to remind visitors like James Boswell and Samuel Johnson of what had been lost, during their tour of the Hebrides in the autumn of 1773. By the turn of the century, a rising population and the economic crisis had turned the Highlands into a society on the edge of catastrophe. For many, there was no choice but to leave, and even in Johnson’s day there was a steady flow of emigrants:
He that cannot live as he desires at home, listens to the tale of fortunate islands, and happy regions, where every man may have land of his own, and eat the product of his labour without a superior.
It is impossible to calculate how many Highlanders crossed the Atlantic after the Jacobite Uprising of 1745 in search of a better future, but there is no doubt that emigration to North America became a torrent. The Highland clearances left their mark on the character of the English spoken in parts of Canada and the United States. The story of Nova Scotia is typical. Heavy migration by crofters who had been forced off the land in Scotland changed the ethnic character of Nova Scotia quite suddenly. A 1767 census shows a total population of about thirteen thousand, a mixture of Acadians (French), Germans, Dutch, New Englanders, Irish and free Blacks. There were only 173 Scots before, in 1773, the ship Hector sailed from Greenock with two hundred Highland farmers. As the clearances in the Highlands quickened, thousands of Highland Scots followed. Their legendary hardiness was sorely tested by the dense forests, bitter winters and conflict with Indian tribes. But they prospered, and by 1851 some thirty-five thousand had made the difficult transatlantic journey and become a dominant force in the life of a colony that had earned its name, ‘New Scotland’, or Nova Scotia. The province still cherishes its Scottish roots and Highland traditions and Nova Scotian English still has the ‘lilt’ of the Highlands.
Driven from their lands, the Highlanders were forced to learn the language of their old ‘adversaries’ and, by a final irony, carried it to the four corners of the earth, from Sydney to Saskatchewan. The Highlanders came from the Gaelic-speaking Scotland of legend with its misty glens, skirling bagpipes and hunting tartans, but it is the other Scotland, the Scots-speaking Lowlands, who first became colonists in Ulster, who really had what Samuel Johnson called “the epidemick desire of wandering” and therefore made the greater impact on the common tongue of North America.
Ulster Scots & Appalachian English:
In the first decades of the seventeenth century, Presbyterian Lowland Scots set sail for Ulster, seeking the religious freedom they were denied at home. In total, some two hundred thousand Scots settled in Northern Ireland and, in turn, some two million of their descendants migrated to America during the next three centuries. Their initial migration occured at a point when the two ‘original’ Saxon languages of Britain, Scots and English, were diverging, so that the Scots took to Ulster a language that was very different from the English that was being imported from southern and midland England. In Ulster, the Scots outnumbered the English settlers by six to one, so their influence on language was dominant. About a hundred years after the first Ulster settlements, however, the conditions became more hostile. Rising rents, bad harvests and religious discrimination (from the Anglican Church and state) combined to send the Scots on the move again, this time to the new colonies of North America. By 1776, it has been calculated that almost half the population of Ulster had crossed the Atlantic, and that one in seven of the colonists was Ulster-Scots, or Scotch-Irish as they became known in North America.
The five emigrant ports – Belfast, Londonderry, Newry, Larne and Portrush – were busy with the Atlantic trade. Many of the poorest share croppers were willing to be transferred across the ocean as indentured servants, being offered for hire in the New World, as a class just above the African slaves. At first the Scotch-Irish headed for New England, especially to Boston, where they were not well received. They were encouraged to head south to Pennsylvania, with its economic opportunities and religious toleration. The state capital, Philadelphia, and its river, the Delaware, became the main entry point for most of the Ulster Scots. In 1760, Benjamin Franklin estimated that one-third of the City was British, one-third German and one-third Scots (including the Ulstermen). It was this last third who were to become, in the words of Theodore Roosevelt,
… the kernel of the distinctively and intensely American stock who were the pioneers of our people in their march westward.
At first, Philadelphia welcomed them for their frontier toughness, especially because Pennsylvanian politicians believed they would help to push back against the Indian tribes. James Logan, the state secretary, himself an Ulsterman, enthusiastically granted a chunk of land to establish the new American frontier town of Donegal. Logan soon regretted his original judgement, seeing his own ‘countrymen’ nothing but trouble:
A settlement of five families from the North of Ireland gives me more trouble than fifty of any other people.
In particular, he was infuriated by their “audacious and disorderly” tendency to claim squatters’ rights over “any spot of vacant land they fancied”. At odds with the largely ‘British’ élite in Philadelphia, they moved inland through ‘German territory’ and also came in contact with the Pennsylvanian Dutch, trading words with both groups. They settled there for a generation, and as their children grew up and went to school as young Americans, the distinctive dialects and accents of all three ethnic group became merged into one form of American speech. They shared folk songs, dance tunes and musical instruments and built German-style log cabins. Of course, this was a westward migration and a fusion of vocabulary which took place over the course of a century or more.
The Ulster Scots brought with them a rich oral culture: aphorisms, proverbs, superstitions, and an ability to turn a striking phrase – mad as a meat axe, dead as a hammer, so drunk he couldn’t hit the wall with a handful of beans, having an axe to grind, to sit on the fence, the whole hog. Their rhymes and songs came from the folklore of Scotland and Ireland. The tunes and the Scottish Lowland ballads of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries have been an important influence in the making of American country music. What became known as ‘Appalachian English’ therefore evolved from the ‘Scotch-Irish’ who became the western pioneers of the Thirteen States, pushing south and west through the Cumberland Gap (see the map below) and down the Ohio and Tennessee rivers, in search of of better land and prospects. Like the legendary Davy Crockett, ‘born on a mountain top in Tennessee’, with their long rifles and coon-skin hats, they acquired a ferocious reputation as frontiersmen.
Their descendants live in the hills of Appalachia, the home of ‘blue grass’ music, and further west in the Ozark Mountains. Always moving westwards, the Scotch-Irish accent was one of the first to cross the Mississippi and into Oklahoma and beyond. Today, the ‘country accents’ of Appalachia are found in the ‘sunbelt’, the south and the west as far as California. The talk of these hills is a mixture of Ulster Scots, English and German. Since their earliest settlements, this mixed speech has been described as ‘broad’, as distinct from the southern Irish ‘Brogue’. English words borrowed into Pennsylvanian German often reveal archaic forms which seem to have come from Ulster Scots: chaw (‘chew’) ingine (‘engine’)and picter (picture). The Reverend Jonathan Boucher, writing in the 1800s, claimed that it was one of the four distinctive ‘dialects’ remaining in the States:
… the Scotch-Irish, as it used to be called, in some of the back settlers of the Middle States.
Many examples of Ulster Scots usage have continued to the present day: flannel-cake, sook, sookie or sook cow, yous, who-all?, what-all?, cabin (the last dating from 1770 referring to the log cabins of Virginia, the design of which the Scotch-Irish borrowed from the German settlers). In Appalachian English, the word ‘there’ is pronounced tharr, ‘bear’ is barr and ‘hair’is herr. Colloquialism include the omission of the /g/ on the end of ‘ing’ participles, while continuing the use of the Middle English /a-/ before it, providing a-huntin’ and a-fishin’.
In due course, many of these usages became part of mainstream American English. Today, about twenty million people, some ten per cent of the American population claim Ulster Scots ancestry.
Canadian English:
When the Loyalists of Ontario fled north from New York and Pennsylvania in the 1780s, following the American War of Independence, they became responsible for the decisive shaping of Canadian English. Settled longer, the maritime provinces had a greater variety of Englishes and, of course, provinces which were French-speaking, like Quebec (see the map below). What is called General Canadian, a definition based on urban middle-class speech, not rural variants, has become the dominant form of English, a regional variant of North American English, one spanning the whole continent instead of occupying just one region. As observers have noted, …
… the most surprising thing about the English currently spoken in Canada is its homogeneity … It is certain that no Ontario Canadian, meeting another Canadian, can tell whether he comes from Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta, or British Columbia, or even Ontario, unless he asks.
Canadian English is usually defined by the ways in which it differs from what American or British observers consider their norm. American visitors at first think how British the Canadian vocabulary sounds (tap, braces, porridge instead of ‘faucet’, ‘suspenders’ and ‘oatmeal’), while the British think how ‘Americanized’ the Canadians have become (they hear gas, truck, and wrench for ‘petrol’, ‘lorry’ and ‘spanner’). The British have been making these rather prejudiced and politically-generated observations for a long time. One traveller in Upper Canada (now Ontario) in 1832 complained:
It is really melancholy to traverse the Province, and go into many of the common schools; you find a herd of children instructed by some anti-British adventurer, instilling into their young and tender minds sentiments hostile to the parent state … and American spelling-books, dictionaries and grammar, teaching them an anti-British dialect, and idiom, although living in the Province, and being subjects of the British Crown.
In fact, the linguistic differences are mainly in vocabulary and pronunciation. There is no distinctive Canadian grammar, and Canadian English uses elements of both British and American grammar, retaining more of the formality of Standard British English. Canadian spelling preserves some British forms, such as ‘colour’ and ‘theatre’. The inter-war Canadian ‘humorist’ Stephen Leacock once wrote:
In Canada we have enough to do keeping up with the two spoken languages without trying to invent slang, so we just go right ahead and use English for literature, Scotch for sermons and American for conversation.
It is primarily in pronunciation that Canadian English asserts its distinctiveness, and has done from the earliest settlements. It also reflects the continuing ‘schizophrenia’ of a people struggling for national identity against two strong influences. A Survey in the 1980s found that about three-quarters of Canadians said they use the American pronunciation of schedule, tomato and missile, while fifty-eight per cent use British pronunciation for progress and new. In the first half of the twentieth century, Canadians would have been content to have it thought that they sounded British or American, depending on where they lived. In 1936, Stephen Leacock wrote:
We used to be ashamed of our Canadian language, before the war, and try to correct it, and take on (British) English phrases and say… “Ah you thah?” instead of “Hello, Central”, “Oh! rather!” instead of “O-Hell-Yes”. But now since the Great War… made Canada a real nation, we just accept our language and are not ashamed of it. We say “yep!” when we mean “yep!” and we don’t try to make out it’s “yes”, which is a word we don’t use; and if we mean “four” we say so and don’t call it “faw”.
The snobbish affectation of British received pronunciation (or ‘King’s English’) sounds barely outlived Leacock. But the most obvious and distinctive feature of Canadian speech is probably its vowel sound, the dipthong /ou/ (so that ‘out’ rhymes with ‘boat’, so that a phrase like “out and about in a boat” becomes “oat and aboat in a boat”) There is a deeply held belief that this is the result of Scottish settlement, but the Scottish vowel /oo/ is completely different from the dipthong /ou/. Jack Chambers believed that it was an independent development in Canadian English:
The /ou/ in “house” and “about” begins with the vowel sound ‘hut’ and ‘but’, whereas the /ou/ in “houses” and “bough” begins with the vowel sound in ‘hot’ and ‘bought’. The difference in the two /ou/ sounds is systematic, and known to linguists in Canada as ‘Canadian Raising’. Because of it, Canadians have a different /ou/ sound in ‘house’ and ‘houses’, and in ‘lout’ and ‘loud’.
According to Chambers, there is a characteristic of pronunciation that can be traced to Pennsylvania: the merger of the two vowels in words like ‘cot’ and ‘caught’, ‘don’ and ‘dawn’, ‘offal’ and ‘awful’. When Canadians pronounce these word-pairs, with vowels not dipthongs, they sound identical. Chambers also demonstrated that, especially in the cities, the younger generation of Canadians was adopting American pronunciations, threatening a distinctive Canadian speech identity. The pattern of a people being pulled in two cultural directions is not just the result of recent influences. The differences between Canadian and American speech were also well known to be a source of humour in the nineteenth century. In the 1830s, the Nova Scotian writer Thomas Chandler Haliburton created a character Sam Slick, an itinerant Yankee clock pedlar, says, “they all know me here to be an American citizen by my talk”. Like other colonial varieties of English, Canadian English is the product of a language melting pot that resolved into a standard accent. The process was vividly described in the mid-nineteenth century by a settler in South Ontario:
Listening to the children at any school, composed of the children of Englishmen, Scotsmen, Americans and even Germans, it is impossible to detect any marked difference in their accent, or way of expressing themselves.
Canadian English owes its character to the people who settled there after the American Revolution, who called “Loyalists” by the British but “Tories” by the Americans. Like the wider culture, it is torn between the push-and-pull of the British and American models. In the nineteenth century, American English reflected the adventurousness, energy and experiences of the westward migrations, left Canadian English far behind.
‘Jive Talk’ – Black English, From South to North:
The half-century between the Civil War and the First World War saw the American Blacks catapulted from slavery to legal equality, then snapped back into a state almost as degrading as slavery. At the end of the Civil War, four million slaves were freed and an old English legal phrase, “civil rights” entered the American English lexicon. The avenging zeal of the Republican administrations of those years meant that by 1867 there were more Southern Blacks registered to vote than Whites, while Congress had twenty-four Black congressmen. All these gains were lost as White Southerners wore down the North. Once the last Federal troops were were withdrawn, the South hit back, passing ‘Jim Crow’ laws to abridge the rights of Blacks. The word segregation became part of the vocabulary of discrimination, as did uppity, a White Southern word for Blacks who did not know their place. In this way, language signified social and political reactionary change. The final blows to the freed Blacks came in the 1880s and 1890s when the Supreme Court attacked the Civil Rights Act as ‘unconstitutional’ and sanctioned segregated (“seperate but equal”) education.
Their new subjugation helped drive a great Black migration to the North. But most blacks did not migrate to the North until the 1920s. Of course, this was not ’emigration’, though many Blacks described it as such, because it involved a movement out of one type of ‘White State’ to another. It was, however, for many, a long-distance migration northwards (see the map above). Meanwhile, in the mid-1870s the various elements of Southern Black language and culture – double meanings, covert sexuality, African rhythms, liberation – came together in what was then the most vital centre of Black American culture, New Orleans. The name they gave to the new music was ‘jazz’, originally a word used by Blacks to mean ‘to speed up’. The specific etymology of the word has never been pinpointed, but most scholars believe that it is of West African origin.In that music, Blacks developed ‘ragtime’, ‘boogie woogie’, and ‘the blues’ as well as the ‘spiritual’; in dance, the ‘cakewalk’, the ‘jitterbug’ and the ‘jive’; in slang, the street ‘jive-talk’ of ‘cool’, ‘heavy’ and ‘doing your own thing’, the essential vocabulary of ‘letting your hair down’ and ‘having a good time’. By 1913, the words and the music had moved into the mainstream of American culture, with both Blacks and Whites using it to mean a particular type of ‘ragtime’ music with a syncopated rhythm. By the end of 1917, the year the “doughboys” sailed for Europe to fight the Kaiser, jazz music and jazz bands were the ‘talk of the town’ in New York, London and Paris.
After the war, as they moved to the northern cities like Chicago, Philadelphia and New York, Black language and culture began to have a major impact on White American speech and life, which began a massive appropriation of black words and styles. The speech of many American Blacks in the big cities has been described as “basically Down Home Talk”. Harlem in the 1920s underwent a cultural renaissance, symbolised by the work of the poet Langston Hughes and the flourishing there of a sophisticated Black middle class. The jazzmen brought with them their own Black English vocabulary. ‘Uptight’ is a famous, though controversial, example. It was originally associated with readiness, as in “I got my boots laced up tight, and am ready to go places.” Too much preparation, however, could kill the spontaneity needed for the greatest jazz performance, so a player who doesn’t improvise easily becomes ‘uptight’. Early Jazz was ‘hot’ (frenetic), but when this word was appropriated by the Whites, it was replaced by ‘cool’.
One of the greatest of the early jazzmen was the legendary Jelly Roll Morton. His real name was Ferdinand Le Menthe, but as leader of the Red Hot Peppers he became simply Morton, a milestone figure in the history of jazz. Upstaged in one performance by a Black comedian who introduced himself as “Sweet Papa Cream Puff. right out of the bakery shop”. Morton went one better and announced himself as “Sweet Papa Jelly Roll, with stove pipes in my hips and all the women in town dyin’ to turn my damper down”. Food words like ‘cookie’, ‘cake’, ‘pie’ and ‘angel-food cake’, all hidden expressions for sex, permeate Black English, but Morton’s was the ultimate sexual ‘braggadocio’. Few words in the Black English lexicon have more sexual evocation than ‘jelly roll’. In the African language Mandingo, jeli is a minstrel who gains popularity with women through skill with words and music. In the English creole of the Caribbean, ‘jelly’ refers to the meat of the coconut when it is still at a white, viscious stage, and in a form closely resembling semen. In English, ‘jelly’ and ‘jelly roll’ are both items of food. In Look Homeward, Angel by Thomas Wolfe, a novel published in 1929, the newsboy Eugene Gant, trying to collect his debts, has this conversation with a Black Customer who cannot pay:
” I’ll have somethin’ fo’ yuh, sho. I’se waitin’ fo’ a White gent’man now. He’s gonna gib me a dollar.” … “What’s – what’s he going to give you a dollar for?” “Jelly Roll”.
On the street, “jelly roll” had many associated meanings, from the respectable “lover” or “spouse” to the Harlem slang term for the vagina. In the twenties and thirties, Harlem was the pinnacle of Black city life and it was to Harlem that the jazzmen ultimately gravitated. Cab Calloway, Count Basie, Duke Ellington and Louis Armstrong all ended up there, playing in clubs like the Cotton Club and Leroy’s. In those inter-war decades, the Whites travelled ‘uptown’, as they put it, to see the shows. Or, as the Blacks put it, “came down from Sugar Hill” – the heights overlooking the west side of Harlem where all the ‘sugar’ (money) was. Albert Murray, whose syncopated autobiography, South To A Very Old Place, which celebrates both his youth and the roots of Black culture, has defined thirty-two meanings of the word ‘soul’. He also recalled his vivid memories of Harlem’s hey-day:
Leroy’s was at the corner of the 135th Street and Fifth Avenue. That was a very exclusive club and was mainly for uptown people. Only very special people who knew somebody very important in Harlem got a chance to go there. On the other hand, Edmond’s which was on Seventh Avenue near where Small’s is now, was a sort of mixed club. It was patronized by a number of downtown clientele.
The downtowners who came uptown would have been called ‘jazz babies’ or ‘flappers’ if they were women, and a ‘jazzbo’ or ‘sheik’ (after Rudolph Valentino’s starring role in the 1921 film, The Sheik) if they were men. The fascination of White “flappers” and “shieks” with Black music and lyrics carried much of the private code of the jazz players into the mainstream of American English and what we might call ‘Atlantic English’. The language of jazz players was known as ‘jive talk’ as defined here by Albert Murray, who was born in the South and ’emigrated’ to the North, where the money and the future were:
Jive talk was really the talk of the world of entertainment, and people whofrequented the world of entertainment, and people who imitated entertainers. It was called “hip talk” or “hip”, the language of hipsters … it reflected the jargon of music, of the stage, of the night clubs and of sports mainly.
The significance of ‘jive talk’ is probably best explained through the figure of Cab Calloway, one of the most popular jazzband leaders in Harlem during the heyday of the uptown nightclubs. He wasn’t a musician like Count Basie or Duke Ellington, but a front-man, an entertainer who sang “Jive talk is the lingo the jitterbugs use today” and used a kind of comic patter. Some of Cab Calloway’s phrases have passed into standard American English, like “All you hip to the jive … hip, hip, hip”, “I’m beat to my socks”, “it’s far out”, “it’s groovy”, and “a solid sender” which was a phrase meaning ‘an outstanding person’. When we list the words and phrases that have passed into the language, the importance of jive talk is inescapable. As jive talk caught on generally, the downtown clientele, the flappers and sheiks, who went to the Cotton Club would slip the neologisms into their conversation to show how smart and up to date they were. The journalists who reported the jazz scene would drop the same words and phrases into their columns for the same reason. Language moves fast when fashion drives it. Then, once the same entertainers and musicians began to get exposure on radio, their vocabulary reached an even larger audience.
With his instantly recognizable rich, gravelly voice, Louis Armstrong was also an influential singer and skillful improviser, bending the lyrics and melody of a song. He was also skilled at scat singing. His career spanned five decades, from the 1920s to the 1960s, and different eras in the history of jazz. His influence on jive talk, and the breadth of his audience, makes him one of the key figures in this part of the story of Black language and culture. Albert Murray remembered his use of phrases like “hip cats” and “daddy-o”, and commented on his contribution to the formation of an ‘American language’:
He was the veritable Prometheus of Jazz … the invention of it as a sort of national language was due to Louis. He was not the father of jive talk but he was the most important single individual in the development of jive talk from the world of entertainment into the mainstream of American speech.
New World, Old World – Divided by a ‘Common Tongue’?
At the turn of the century, Henry James, who was fascinated by the new European immigrants, for whom English was a second or third language, visited the Lower East Side. Reflecting on the impact of the new Americans on the language of which he was such a master, James observed that whatever we shall know it for … we shall not know it for English. For better or worse, though, this was the America – brash, prosperous, polyglot but united – that came to the aid of the ‘old World’ in the late spring of 1917. Woodrow Wilson was the most recent of a long line of presidents of ‘Scotch-Irish’ stock going back to Andrew ‘Stonewall’ Jackson. Having campaigned in 1916 for a second presidential term on the slogan He Kept us Out of War!, he finally made common cause with the British Empire and declared war on 6 April 1917. That same day, the songwriter George M. Cohan, having read the headlines in the newspaper, sat down and composed the number which accompanied the two million US troops, doughboys, to Europe:
Over there, over there,
Send the word, send the word, over there,
That the yanks are coming, the Yanks are coming
The drums rum-tumming everywhere …
For Britons and Americans alike, the war created a host of new words and phrases, many of which are still in everyday use: bombproof, barrage, camouflage, civvy, convoy, dud, red tape, sabotage, shell shock, tank, no-man’s-land, going over the top, high jump, in the pink, Tommy, trench foot, wastage, windy. There were also many shared colloquialisms and neologisms which remain specific to trench warfare, like ‘Archie’ for anti-aircraft fire, ‘Big Bertha’ for the large-calibre German cannon, ‘Boche’ and ‘Huns’ for the Germans, ‘bully beef’ for tinned corned beef, ‘Fritz’, ‘Jerry’ (GB, a nickname for the Pickelhaube, the German spiked-helmet, which the British troops compared to a chamber-pot) or ‘Heinie’ (US) for a German soldier, ‘hop the bags’ for ‘going over the top’, ‘pip-squeak’ for a type of German shell, poilu for a French soldier, ‘potato mashers’, for German hand grenades, ‘stuttering aunt’ for a German machine-gun. Also, more generally than ever before, speakers of British and American English could compare the differences in their vocabularies: ‘checkers’ versus ‘draughts’, ‘garbage’ v. ‘rubbish’, ‘kerosene’ v. ‘paraffin’, ‘lumber’ v. ‘timber’, ‘mail’ v. ‘post’, ‘pants’ v. ‘trousers’, ‘sidewalk’ v. ‘pavement’, ‘vacation’ v. ‘holiday’, ‘wrench’ v. ‘spanner’, ‘zero’ v. ‘nought’ or ‘ó’.
President Woodrow Wllso (right), with (left to right) PMs David Lloyd George (GB), Msr Orlando (Italy), Mns. Georges Clemenceau (Fr)
The entry of the United States into ‘World War One’ tipped the balance. It was over within eighteen months, before a single US plane was delivered to the front, and the ‘Spanish’ influenza epidemic in 1918 killed more US troops than those who died in combat. The war cost $208 Billion in total, and Britain had to borrow heavily from the USA. It was suggested, perhaps somewhat sarcastically, that this was one of the reasons America joined the war – to ensure its debt was paid. Announcing that “the world must be made safe for democracy”, Wilson then set sail for the Peace Conference in Paris, the first American President to visit Europe while still in office. The point was made. America was a world power; American English a world language.
In 1919, the American journalist H. A. Mencken published his book, The American Language. Mencken has been compared to G. B. Shaw in terms of his influence on that language. In the book, he set out what he claimed were the results of his inquiries into “the common tongue”. He stated that British English and American English were two separate languages on divergent paths. He was, like the first American revolutionaries, anxious to beat the drum for the language of which he was a master:
The American of today is much more honestly English, in any sense that Shakespeare would have understood, than the so-called Standard English of England. It still shows all the characteristics that marked the common tongue in the days of Elizabeth I, and it continues to resist stoutly the policing that ironed out Standard English in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.
His was an assertion not just of national pride but of an unjustified American superiority complex that paid no attention to other national varieties of English, or even to other forms of North American English which had emerged over the course of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. But within another generation, at the end of ‘World War Two’, these other English voices were demanding to be heard, together with a whole diversity of newer ones. For the time being, however, the dominant and unifying form of English was what we might call the trans-Atlantic language and culture of Harlem and Hollywood personified by Charlie Chaplin, albeit a silent star at this time, who in 1921 returned to both the West and the East End, ‘putting on the Ritz’ and eating stewed jellied eels:
Chaplin demonstrated how film comedy could provide a universal language, in the same way that jazz had done. Both came together in the thirties in ‘talkies’ and film musicals to sporn a whole, new cross-cultural experience. As Mencken himself commented in his 1919 book:
A living language is like a man suffering incessantly from small haemorrhages, and what it needs above all else is constant transactions of new blood from other tongues. The day the gates go up, that day it begins to die.
Source:
Robert McCrum, et. al. (1987), The Story of English. New York: Viking Penguin.
In 1870, seventy-two per cent of all British and Irish emigrants continued to see the United States as their preferred destination. After the Civil War, the American railroad companies began their huge task of driving a steel highway to the west. Where this permanent way pointed, the settlers followed. The railways also acquired huge areas of the United States, and had land to spare. They not only needed people as potential customers: they were prepared to dabble in real estate. The North Pacific alone sent eight hundred agents to Britain, and the Santa Fé set up the Anglo-American Agricultural Company with its headquarters in London. Another subsidiary, the American Land Company of London, had a hundred thousand acres in southwest Minnesota to dispose of. Likewise, the Land Colonization and Banking Company of London was the place to visit for those who wanted part of twenty thousand acres, with town sites and grain elevators, also in Minnesota. One firm opened a travel agency in London. It advertised “cheap and comfortable” passages to America, and was ready to advise anyone who wished to acquire a farm. In 1869, an outfit calling itself the American Emigrant Aid Society of London, went to the extent of organising a lottery, the first prize being a free passage to San Francisco. According to Josiah Strong, who published a book entitled Our Country in 1885, an intelligent man would go to the USA …
… with less inquiry as to his prospects in general and as to the particular place in which it may be best for him to settle than he would make if the contemplated removal were, say, from Kent to Yorkshire.
By the final decades of the twentieth century, the population of the British Isles had become far more mobile than it had generally been in the first half of the century. However, long-distance migration was no longer simply to be associated with overseas emigration, but took place within Britain itself, over distances as great if not greater than from Kent to Yorkshire or vice versa. Neither were movements of population in one direction only, from rural to urban areas, nor were the trends evenly distributed over all four nations of the British Isles. The decennial Census figures, combined with the Medical Officers’ returns reveal that whereas in the period 1851-81 Wales was losing considerably more of its population than England, this trend was more than reversed in 1881-1911. The reversal is most marked in the period 1901-1911. During these years, whilst England lost nineteen per ten thousand of its population, and Scotland fifty-seven, Wales was actually gaining population at a rate of forty-five per thousand. By 1911, not only had Wales kept the whole of her natural increase of her 1871 population of 1,412,000, but had added twenty thousand by net migration, whereas in the same period, England lost 1,355,000 by migration, and Scotland 619,000. But these national statistics conceal marked and diverse regional patterns.What makes this contrast even more striking is that much of the English migration, or emigration, took place from the old industrial towns of Northern England in the earlier decades, with London only overtaking them in the latter decade. It took place at the same time as South Wales was entering its most rapid phase of industrialisation, due to the demand for coal in the global economy. As the map of internal migration (below) shows, at the end of the century, those seeking to escape the poor wages in rural areas could find far better remuneration within those parts of urban Britain which depended on overseas trade, especially on exports. The newer industrial areas of …
The Atlantic Economy – Migration to & from South Wales:
In England, the relatively slow growth of the home consumer-based industries before the First World War caused a large part of both the urban and rural populations to emigrate overseas, or to the South Wales Coalfield. The phenomenal expansion of the steam coal export trade enabled industrial south Wales to act as a magnet to rural Wales so that the impact of emigration on the population of Wales as a whole was far less significant than for most European countries during the period 1881-1921. A study of the birth-place information in the censuses of 1851-1931 clearly demonstrates the ability of the coalfield to attract labour from all parts of Wales, while nearly all of the English immigrants came from the neighbouring counties in an era characterised by relatively short-distance, internal migration from rural to urban areas. In Wales, there were significant streams from distant Welsh counties such as Meirionydd, Caernarfon and Anglesey (Ynys Món). These were particularly important in the decade 1901-1911, as the supply from neighbouring counties was beginning to dry up. By contrast, in England at this time only suburban Middlesex was able to attract workers from more than a hundred miles. The majority of migrants similarly tended to travel relatively short distances within the UK as a whole, since the costs involved were considerable, especially for the impoverished. Within Wales, where apocryphal and linguistic evidence suggests that Welsh-speaking families and friends originally from north Wales played a major role in helping fellow migrants to move and settle in particular southern valley communities.
The returns of the US Bureau of the Census reveal that in 1850, just under thirty thousand of the inhabitants of the United States had been born in Wales, whereas forty years later the number had more than trebled to reach its peak at over a hundred thousand. But due to statistical anomalies, it is probable that the actual number of Welsh emigrants was higher than the US sources suggest. Nevertheless, the numbers of Welsh emigrants were dwarfed by those from Ireland, England, Scotland, and other European nations, especially Italy. In the era of mass European migration, in which thirty-five million crossed the Atlantic, the Welsh were, numerically at least, a drop in that ocean. Of course, Wales’ population was very small compared with most of these countries, barely two million in 1900, but its emigration rate as a percentage of that population was also low. Between 1881 and 1931 Wales lost to the United States, on average, less than seven per ten thousand, compared with fourteen for England, twenty-five for Scotland and eighty-nine for Ireland.
During the 1850s and ’60s, emigration from Wales to the United States entered a new phase, markedly different from the one which preceded it. Two major transformations took place. To begin with, there was was a noticeable growth in the size of the outflow. According to the official American immigration records, the number of Welsh emigrants increased after 1850, accelerated further after 1880 and thereafter remained steady, with slight variations, at around fifteen thousand per decade until 1930. Secondly, from the 1860s onwards, there was a decisive shift in the character of the emigration. Whereas the vast majority of the emigrants during the first half of the century had been leaving the rural areas of Wales, the larger movement of the second half of the nineteenth and the early twentieth centuries was predominantly one of industrial workers, mainly from the South Wales coalfield.
The reasons for the apparent reluctance to emigrate can be summarised by the term coined by Brinley Thomas, ‘the Atlantic Economy’, part of a much wider investigation from the late 1930s onwards of the relationship between migration and economic growth. Emigration and the export of capital from Britain boomed together at particular times and each wave of emigration was, in essence, a rural exodus, at least until the early twentieth century. When British investment in North America flourished, the domestic economy stagnated and surplus labour on the land tended to migrate to America. When investment at home was the dominant feature of the economy, the opposite occurred: internal movement to the industrial and urban areas became more marked and the number of emigrants fell. As already noted, throughout the period Britain as a whole lost population through migration, the bulk of it to the United States. These losses fluctuated, however, coinciding with long swings in international investment and in net emigration to America in the 1880s and in 1901-11. Wales diverged from this general pattern. The rate of loss through migration peaked in the 1860s and declined in the following decades. In the 1880s, when the absorptive power of the United States was at its peak and emigration from England, Ireland and Scotland was high, the rate from Wales remained low: During the first decade of the twentieth century, the contrast between the Wales’ migratory experience was even more marked. Whereas all the other countries showed large losses through emigration, the rate from Wales showed no change and it was unique in experiencing a significant population gain through immigration.
Thomas explained Wales’ unique migratory pattern by reference to the extent and nature of its phenomenal economic growth and its effect on the country’s surplus rural population. The whole of the Welsh industrial region, effectively the South Wales coalfield and its ports, was export-based and its fortunes fluctuated with those of the British export sector. Consequently, when the rest of the British Isles were experiencing high emigration, the Welsh export economy was booming as in the 1880s and 1901-11 and the growth was strong enough to retain the whole of the country’s natural increase and to attract significant immigration. The bulk of the Welsh rural outflow of the 1880s was retained within Wales, leading to further natural increase in the latter decade. Thomas therefore concludes that, without industrialisation, Wales might well have suffered the same fate as Ireland, if on a smaller scale, exporting its younger and more vigorous population to the United States and the British dominions. There was, therefore, no great Welsh ‘diaspora’ among the colonies, or ‘exodus’ to the United States; those who did emigrate were mainly skilled industrial workers, a complementary export of labour on a minor scale. They went ‘off to Philadelphia’, in the phrase coined by the title of a Jack Jones novel, induced by wages which were much higher than in Britain, even in the south Wales of 1911-21. But although their emigration may not have been massive in size, their patterns of settlement and the quality of their contribution to American life was seen as significant, both by contemporaries and in the context of American history. A further factor determining destination was that the United States provided opportunities for town-dwellers, unlike most of the colonies, including Canada. According to the superintendent of the American census in 1874,
… in respect of their industrial occupations, the foreigners among us may be divided as to those who are where they are because they are doing; and those who are doing what they are doing because they are where they are. In the former case, occupation has determined location; in the latter, location has determined occupations.
For the first two decades of the twentieth century, the dramatic growth of employment in the South Wales Coalfield was enough for the region to retain nearly the whole of the natural increase of Wales and to attract a considerable influx from other parts of Britain, most notably from the Severn-side counties of England. It was absorbing population at a rate second in the world only to the USA. In many ways, the south Wales valleys were developing as quickly as many towns in the northern and mid-western states of the USA or the the klondyke area of Canada. Although the rate of increase slowed between 1911 and 1921, South Wales still added thirteen per cent to its population, compared with eight per cent added by Durham and Northumberland and just four per cent added by the London Boroughs.
By maintaining a high rate of natural increase throughout the immediate post-war period, south Wales was able to survive the ‘culling’ of its young population in the decade which followed (see the figures and tables below). The movement out of south Wales began quietly during the 1926 coal stoppage, so that it has been estimated that, between 1920 and 1940, Wales lost 442,000 people by migration, a figure equivalent to seventeen per cent of its 1920 population, which disguised a far greater loss for particular coalfield communities (see the graphs below). From its beginning, this was mostly ‘chain migration’, organised on a familial and even institutional basis, and mostly on an entirely vountary basis. Some of the older migrants to the Midlands of England had previously been miners both in south Wales and Pennsylvania, and others had also begun their working lives in rural Wales.
Wales & America – Carbondale & Scranton as ‘mirrors’:
For may who left south Wales for the United States in the nineteenth century, the destination was perfectly clear. If you were a coal-miner, and fed up with wages and conditions at home, the chances were that you would take a boat to Philadelphia, and from there make for Carbondale in Pennsylvania.In 1827, the first immigrants arrived in Carbondale, which was, as its name implied, a centre for coal in general, and antracite in particular. They were expected to bring ‘English expertise’ to work on creating “Something like a methodological system”. Instead, they imported Welsh ‘know-how’ and quickly made a reputation for themselves as skilled colliers. When their wives joined them they too quickly established a local reputation as for making neat and comfortable homes. W. D. Jones (1983, ’87) has written of how the early development of a Welsh presence in Scranton, Pennsylvania, well illustrates some important characteristics of Welsh emigration to the USA as a whole.
To begin with, the crucial factor of Welsh industrial skill was symbolised by the achievements of John Davies. A native of Tredegar, he succeeded as an iron-manufacturer where Yankee enterprise had failed, and his expertise helped to ‘fire up’ Scranton, leading to the rapid development of the town. By 1844, the iron industry in Scranton had acquired an energetic recruiting officer in its mine foreman Evan Williams. His efforts resulted in a significant Welsh emigration to the area. An unofficial local census in the mid-1850s found eighty-one Welsh families, a total of 413 people, in Scranton, the majority of the adults males being employed in the iron works. Though the expertise of Welsh skilled workers was not the single most important factor in the development of the American iron and coal industries, by 1839, David Thomas, the pioneer of the anthracite industry in the USA, had already built his iron works at Catauseque Pa, and there was an important iron industry at Danville, run mainly by Welsh immigrants, using local iron-ore and anthracite. Throughout the rest of the century, Welsh skilled labour was very much sought after, and its availability helped to determine the character of both the Welsh immigration and the communities in which the immigrants settled.
In order to supply sufficient Welsh labour, networks were established that recruited both in the USA and Wales, often involving competitive bidding among rival companies. The recruitment of a Welsh foreman meant not only the acquisition of a skilled overseer, but also an effective focus for emigration of further skilled workers from Wales. The placement of Evan Williams as mine foreman of the Scranton iron works contributed greatly to the Welsh activity in the locality and provided a pattern for universal application in the mechanics of migration. Williams was the first in a long line of padroné through to Morgan Thomas, County Commissioner of Lackawanna Co. at the turn of the century, who was instrumental in the consolidation of the Welsh community in Scranton. As the use of the Italian word (from the Latin ‘patronus’ or ‘patron’ in English) suggests, he secured employment for newly-arrived Welsh immigrants. He was the man to write to before leaving for Scranton, or to see immediately on arrival in the town. He would provide the fresh immigrant with a job, and word would quickly get back to Wales about the high wages to be had in American industry, by means of letters home to friends and relatives. Through these informal ‘chain migration’ networks, the Welsh contingent in America grew and the Scranton was a typical epicentre of this. The City soon came to possess the heaviest concentration of Welsh people in the USA. The Welsh immigration streams were largely industrial in nature, and the number of farmers was low. After the Civil War and the coming of the railroads, some Welsh farmers did settle in already existing communities in Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota and Missouri, while others pushed even further westward into Nebraska, South Dakota, and, later, Oregon and Washington. Some of these earlier rural settlements were parly religious in character, but later emigrants, whether agricultural or industrial, were mainly motivated by economic practicalities.
Later commentators related the rapid growth of religious ’causes’ in Scranton as evidence of the piety of its Welsh settlers. Certainly, the Welsh Chapels in Scranton were important social institutions and much of the flourishing Welsh cultural life in the city centred on them. They also reflected the sporadic crises the Welsh community faced. The first Welsh cause, a Congregationalist one, was erected in 1849 by iron foundrymen in the Shanty Hill district of Scranton near the then rapidly expanding iron works. In the same area, a Baptist Church was built in 1851 and a Welsh Calvinistic Methodist one in 1853. By the 1860s, all three denominations had acquired new sites in West Scranton, following the movement of the Welsh element from around the iron works to the part of the city known as Hyde Park. This was situated on a small hill across the Lackawanna from the main bulk of Scranton, and became the Welsh section of the town. The district never became exclusively Welsh, its steep slope housing most of the representatives of most countries from which emigrants flocked to America. But, in many respects, it took on a the characteristics of a mini-Wales.
Attracted by the booming anthracite coal industry, Welsh miners flooded to Hyde Park from the 1850s to the 1870s, with the peak years being in the late sixties and early seventies. This coincided with the year of the greatest movement of Welsh people across the Atlantic in 1869. In the same year, a gas explosion at Avondale Colliery, ten miles from Scranton, killed 169 miners in the latest and most shocking of a long series of disasters. Two-thirds of those killed were estimated to be Welsh, most of them newly-arrived. The local Baptist Church in Edwardsville, Pennsylvania, lost all but three of its male members. Since the pattern of migration was for husbands to migrate first, to earn the money for their families to follow, it seems likely that that the disaster created more widows in Wales than in America. Indeed, some must actually have been on board ship crossing the Atlantic as the horrific news of Avondale became known, arriving in New York or Philadelphia as widows.
Hardly surprisingly, perhaps, adverse economic and social conditions in Wales instigated the emigration of many industrial workers, despite generally improving standards of living. Accomodation was often of a poor standard, mostly rented from colliery companies, and frequently overcrowded, with poor sanitation. Work was long, hard and dangerous, and there was continuous strife between owners and workers. It was also susceptible to slump, resulting in wage-cuts, unemployment, and a general sense of insecurity, with few opportunities for alternative employment to that in the primary industries of coal, iron, tin plate and slate. From the late 1850s to the 1870s, the Welsh iron industry was in a constant state of crisis during the transition to steel production. Despite the mass immigration into the region which began in the 1870s, the ‘Great Depression’ led to the emigration of many ironworkers, and in 1875-9, when wages fell drastically in the colliery districts, many colliers from the Rhondda, Aberdare and Rhymney Valleys moved to Pennsylvania.
The last clearly identifiable migration of workers, that of the tin-plate workers during the 1890s, was also occasioned by depression caused by the McKinley tariff which all but destroyed an industry which had supplied seventy-five per cent of American demand (exports fell by forty per cent in five years). Tin-platers from Llanelli and other towns moved to the States to seek work in the new mills established by the ‘protected’ American companies. Strikes and lock-outs also provided an impetus for emigration, as during the 1873 and 1875 lock-outs in Merthyr Tydfil. The Illustrated London News featured a picture of miners waiting at the railway station to begin their journey to America. Again, the net immigration figures disguise the specific industrial outflows which took place, particularly among skilled workers, who were so much in demand on the other side of the Atlantic that American companies sent agents to recruit them. When strikes led to ‘blacklisting’ by the colliery management, those victimised had little alternative but to emigrate and the passage of these ‘activists’ was often paid for out of the union’s funds.
In 1871, the strength of the Welsh miners in industrial relations in Scranton could be judged by the fact that some two hundred of them went on strike. Since the south of Ireland was lacking in factories, few Irish immigrants possessed the industrial skills of the Welsh or the Northern English, who were able to help themselves to the better-paid work. The Irish, relegated to the work of labourers, were envious of the Welsh in particular, and thirty of them decided to break the strike as ‘blacklegs’. Going to work one day with a militia escort, they were attacked by both the Welsh miners and their wives. Shots were firedby the soldiers, and two Welshmen were killed. Later, during a repeat episode of violent confrontation, three Irishmen were killed. A meeting of Irish mineworkers later condemned “the premeditated assassination of Irishmen” and resolved that there would be no more “unity and fraternity with Welshmen in the future”. Emigrants from the British Isles tended to form ‘clannish’ clusters in this way, taking their customs and traditions with them as a means of settling and creating a ‘home from home’. As Richard Garrett has put it, ‘the Pennsylvanian coal fields resounded to the the melodious thunder of Welsh choirs’ while Welsh women formed their ‘National Women’s Welsh-American Clubs’.
A section of the 1933 Atlas, showing Pennsylvania and New York State.
Although the peak of the Welsh miners’ migration to the Scranton anthracite coalfield was in the 1860’s and 1870’s, general levels of settlement in the city remained remarkably stable. The Welsh influx into the city continued into the 1920s, slowing considerably with the imposition of quotas on immigration from all parts of Europe and then coming to a full stop with the Wall Street Crash in 1929. This resulted in the relative collapse of the anthracite industry in Pennsylvania, plunging Scranton into a decline from which it never recovered in the following decades. Many of those who had used Scranton as their first port-of-call in the USA before going on elsewhere and numerous newspaper reports throughout the late nineteenth century indicated further migration West of many of city’s Welsh newcomers. In 1891 for example, fifty-seven Welsh miners left the locality for Indian Territory where new mines were being opened. However, W D Jones’ examination of city directories reveals that the overwhelming majority of those identifiably Welsh stayed in the city in this period.
There were Welsh ‘representatives’ in all wards of the city and notably in the clusters of satellite settlements surrounding it. But it was Hyde Park, which had merged with Scranton in 1866, which emerged as a distinctly Welsh area. In its heyday at the end of the nineteenth century, it could boast two blocks of Welsh stores and businesses. There was a West Side Bank, organised and run by Welshmen; three Welsh funeral homes, five Welsh churches, three of them Welsh-speaking and two English-speaking. There were also several Welsh doctors and lawyers, and Welsh postmen. Other facilities included one or two billiard rooms and, although puritan believers among the Welsh would hate to admit it, there were also predominantly Welsh bars and even a Welsh brothel, though Jones could not determine whether or not the ‘girls’ were Welsh. There were two Welsh newspapers, the Welsh language ‘Baner America’ from 1877 to 1890 and the English language ‘Druid’ from 1907 to 1915 when it moved to Pittsburgh. There were also many Welsh societies, including a St David’s Society, a Cambrian Society, and a Cymrodorion Society whose annual Eisteddfod was a major event on the Scranton calendar.
Beneath the veneer of respectability provided by these Welsh institutions flourished an alternative culture of foot races, riotous baseball and football matches and prize fights. Not all the Welsh migrants ascribed to the image imposed on them by a literary élite of the temperate, decent, orderly and pious Welshman. Reports in local newspapers reveal a fascinating world of drink, debauchery and lawlessness. This was long after Scranton’s early frontier years; scandals involving desertion, adultery, brawls, assaults and drunkenness were rife. In its early years, the Welsh community was Welsh-speaking, and in 1874 the West Side Bank printed a thousand advertising pamphlets in the Welsh language. But the forces of Americanism were too strong for the survival of the language. The first English-medium church seceded in 1882 and others followed soon after. At the turn of the century, many of the new immigrants from Wales were non-Welsh speaking. Judge H. M. Edwards, one of the most prominent Welshmen in Scranton, pleaded in vain in ‘the Druid’ for what he imagined as a “real, old-fashioned Eisteddfod”. He proposed that a fine of five cents be imposed for every English word used. As Jones comments, had the suggestion been adopted, many of the newcomers among the Welsh would have been either mute or broke on the day of the festival.
If in the early years, the Welsh community had been predominantly Welsh-speaking, it was also overwhelmingly a mining one. In the 1860s and ’70’s, the majority of Welsh workers were employed in the coal industry, not just as colliers but also in associated trades such as carpentry, and as general labourers. W. D. Jones’ study of the payrolls of Delaware, Lackawanna and the Western Railroad companies, the largest mine-owners, produced an endless list of miners bearing identifiably Welsh names. By 1900, the position was changing rapidly, with a significant decline in the numbers of Welsh miners. The 1900 Manuscript Census indicates that the children of the original settlers were now in commerce or the professions, becoming clerks, bank tellers and shop assistants. No doubt this was, in part, due to parental determination that their children should not go down the mines now that alternative employment were becoming increasingly available; by the turn of the century Scranton had grown out of its raw frontier youth and its economy had diversified greatly. As the City matured, so did the Welsh community, and it underwent occupational diversification with it. The local directories of the first decade of the twentieth century show a wide variety of occupations among the Welsh. As the ‘Coal complex’ became a greater factor in the second and third generations, just as in south Wales itself, the bonds that kept the Welsh community together in tough and adverse conditions, were loosening considerably.
The North-Eastern United States, showing the position of Pennsylvania
Although Welsh workers tended to congregate in the specific centres of their industries, their ‘colonisation’ of industrial America, and indeed the location of the Welsh presence in general at the time of its greatest strength, was ultimately even more confined. The 1900 Census recorded that, although the the Welsh had penetrated all states to some degree, over a third of them lived in one particular state, Pennsylvania, which contained twice as many as the combined total of the next most densely Welsh-populated states, New York and Ohio. Moreover, one in five of the Welsh stock in the USA were located in just three counties within Pennsylvania. Fifteen per cent were concentrated in the counties of Luzerne and Lackawanna in the North-East Pennsylvania coalfield, with their ‘capitals’ in Wilksbarre and Scranton. These forty thousand had decided to live and work in an area twice the size of the Rhondda Valley.
One of the most crucial factors in the shift in the mining labour force was the growing influx of Eastern European immigrants into the area and its concentration in the mining industry. Prepared like the Irish before them, to accept lower wages and riskier conditions, the Slavs, Hungarians and Italians gradually pushed the Welsh out of the mines altogether, or into roles as superintendents, foremen and mining inspectors. In any case, mining was becoming less of a skilled occupation in general, giving mine owners the opportunity to dispose of the Welsh, long distrusted for their clannishness, independence of mind and tendency to form unions. Efforts were made, organised by Welshmen, to block the importation of European immigrants into the mines, but it proved an unstoppable tide. The appearance of these more ‘alien’ newcomers form Central-Eastern Europe blurred the differences between the Welsh and those of Anglo-Saxon ‘stock’, and the Welsh were just as chauvinistic towards the new immigrants as other earlier settlers and ‘natives’.
As they closed ranks against the ‘invaders’, the Welsh became lingusitically and culturally more Anglo-American. But the more Americanised Welsh élite of Hyde Park could not aspire to enter the upper eschelons of Scranton high society, however hard they they tried; these were firmly reserved to the Scranton family and their acolytes. However, the Hyde Park élite continued to project an image of Wales as they saw it, one perpetuated in Eisteddfod essays, St David’s Day banquet speeches and articles in the Welsh-American press. But by 1911, the images of Wales they clung to were already out of date, a Wales far different from the reality of the industrial Wales which emerged during Edwardian times. By adhering to this idealisation of Victorian Wales, they ignored not only the temparament of the new Wales, but also the reality of American Wales as a whole. They functioned, according to W. D. Jones in a limbo existence, caught in a shadowy world that was neither American nor Welsh. The prospect of competition with other nationalities after the turn of the century may have lessened the appeal of America to Welsh skilled workers who by then were more secure in Wales itself than they had been in the late nineteenth century. America had, after all, finally arrived in south Wales, and Merthyr, in the words of a later migrant to England, who was born in the town before the First World War, was then the ‘El Dorado’. However, twenty years later the once-proud County Borough was bankrupt and in danger of losing its status as such (see the age-structure graph above). This time, although some twelve thousand Welsh people emigrated to the United States in the 1920s, they were negligible compared with those who crossed the border to live in the Midlands and South-East of England and to work in the American mass production factories.
The British Empire provided a focus for Celtic and Anglo-Saxon unity in North America as a whole. There was an intense and abiding loyalty to the so-called mother country. In 1887, when Queen Victoria celebrated her Jubilee, the churches were packed in thanksgiving. In 1909, the Imperial Order of Daughters of the British Empire was founded in New York. By 1916, it had sixty chapters throughout the the States. Northern Irish emigrants took the “Scarf” with them and formed ‘The Loyal Orange Institution’, which rapidly proliferated into 364 lodges and thirty thousand members, all of which turned out on 12 July to celebrate King William’s victory at the Battle of the Boyne. The Highlanders were quick to form the ‘Universal Order of Scottish Clans’ when Texas joined in. In Chicago, epatriate Shetland Islanders staged the ‘Up-Helly-A’ festival each year, in which a symbolic Viking longboat was burned. There were a number of Highland Regiments from outside Britain which fought in the World War, including several from North America. With the coming of the twentieth century, however, the British Empire was not simply a focus for loyalty, but was also overtaking the United States as the choice of destination. The governments of the dominions, including Canada, were helping directly in the recruitment and settlement of emigrants from the British Isles.
By and large, the emigrants from all parts of the British Isles were received with kindness and courtesy when they reached their destinations, though much depended on the state of the labour market. Labourers who were prepared to labour could nearly always expect a welcome. Skilled men who could fulfil a need were no less gratefully received, though in fewer numbers as modern mass-production industries developed. When, on the other hand, they presented a threat to put local craftsmen out of work by accepting lower wages, they became unpopular. In the United States, in the belief that North America rightfully belonged to people of ‘White Anglo-Saxon Protestant’ stock, there were spasmodic outbursts of opposition to newcomers from elsewhere. One politician who was particularly vocal among the opponents of immigration in America was Samuel Morse (the inventor of Morse Code), who denounced the flood of foreigners as a certain prescription for disaster. They were, he claimed, “rushing in to your ruin.” In 1891, there were riots in New York against this ‘peaceable invasion’, though the rioters themselves seem to have been uncertain about why they were protesting. When tempers had cooled, it was found that 141 soldiers were wounded by the mob and thirty-four civilians had been killed or wounded.
The “Huddled Masses” – Germans, Italians & Hungarians:
Most would probably have gone on to Liverpool and then crossed the Atlantic to New York.
At the beginning of the nineteenth century, most American families had come from the British Isles, Germany and Scandinavia, mainly as farmers or business people. But as factories were built and cities grew, people arrived from other European countries, looking to find work as skilled and unskilled labourers. Between 1840 and 1900, about five million people arrived from one country, Ireland. Another five million immigrants came from Italy, and millions more were from Russia, Poland, Hungary and other Eastern European countries, trying to find freedom as well as jobs. The United States became the immigrant society kept an ‘open door’ until 1924 and about twenty-seven million people arrived between 1880 and 1930. They were usually poor, if not destitute, had different religions, were often accompanied by young, unschooled children, and spoke very little English. From 1846, US regulations insisted that all ships entering New York harbour anchored off Staten Island for medical inspections. From 1892, this was moved to Ellis Island, within sight of the Statue of Liberty, erected as a gift from France on the approach to New York harbour in 1886, which, facing out into the Atlantic, welcomed the poor, tired immigrants with its famous inscription (see below). The Irish, Italians and Eastern Europeans usually stayed in the big cities of the East like New York, Boston or Chicago, and worked in the factories. Some ventured further to the Mid-West and settled as farmers, or became miners in Pennsylvania.
By the beginning of the twentieth century, New York was the undisputed first city of polyglot America. During the course of the nineteenth century, mainly due to its complex, changing geography and its excellent berthing facilities, the port of New York became the chief entry point for one of the greatest migrations in history. Decade by decade they came: the English farm workers escaping the cruelty of the New Poor Law in the 1830s, the Irish and Scots thrown off the land by absentee landlords or starving from the potato famines in the 1840s, the Germans, Italians and Hungarians leaving Europe after the failures of the 1848 revolutions, the northern English leaving their mill towns during the Cotton Famine of the 1860s and the Central European Jews fleeing the persecutions of the 1880s. Added to them were millions of skilled workers, like the Welsh miners, who were simply looking for improved conditions of work and a better standard of living, especially from the 1870s onwards, though many of these put into port at Philadelphia, as already described. Immigrant first came into popular usage as an American word, coined in 1789 to replace the word emigrant which was derived from the French emigré and had therefore been used in a double sense to describe those who had migrated under varying degrees of duress, whom we would now refer to as ‘refugees’. By the end of the nineteenth century, the economic ‘pull’ factors had become far more important in the Trans-Atlantic migration processes. This was certainly the case for most of those who arrived in New York and Philadelphia from the British Isles from the latter decades of the century. Humanitarian idealism was gradually replaced by the need for workforces to man the burgeoning American economy, making the USA the immigrant society par excellence. This was expressed in the famous lines of Emma Lazarus inscribed on the pedestal of the Statue of Liberty:
Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses, yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore,
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me:
I lift my lamp beside the golden door.
Emigrants depart for the USA, 1880. In spite of the political motives for emigration implied in this piece of US propaganda, most British people who left the British Isles were looking for better social and economic conditions. But a variety of European nationalities and ethicities, represented in the cartoon, were among those leaving Liverpool and elsewhere to escape autocracy and persecution, as well as looking for a better life.
By the 1880s, New York City had become an ethnic mosaic, especially in its foods: ‘liverwurst’ from Germany, ‘goulash’ from Hungary, ‘borscht’ from Russia, ‘lasagne’ from Italy, and ‘lox’ and ‘bagels’ from Central Europe. The impact of these huge ‘invasions’ was less than might have been expected because most immigrants were anxious to enlist in American society as rapidly as possible, following what became known later as the ‘melting pot’ principle. From the Gaelic-speaking Irish to the Yiddish-speaking Jews, they adopted English with enthusiasm, at least in public. At home, the older generation tended to cling to their mother tongue, and right through to the 1920s, many immigrant American families were fully bilingual into the next generation. Some only learnt their English when they went to school, so multi-lingual were the streets they were first ‘raised’ on. The film actor Tony Curtis was born Bernard Schwartz in 1925 in Manhattan, to Jewish Hungarian immigrants. His father was a tailor, working from home, and Bernard spoke only ‘Magyar’ until he went to school at the age of six. However, once at school, and especially in the playground, children were under fierce pressure to use the American standard, just as with the children from the Southern plantations. The schools were places where immigrant children were rapidly assimilated through the system and ‘Americanized’ by their playmates, and life was made intolerable for the child who used a foreign word rather than the appropriate American English term. Bernard and his brother grew up in poverty during the Depression, at one point being taken to an orphanage by their parents, who could not afford to feed them.
Although never living in Hungary, Curtis retained his Hungarian until the end of his life, no doubt able to use it with the numerous other Hollywood Hungarian exiles of this period, including the actor Béla Lugósi, who starred as ‘Count Dracula’ in the 1931 movie, the founderof Paramount Pictures Adolph Zukor, the founder of Twentieth Century Fox, William Fox, and the film directors and producers Michael Kurtiz, George Cukor, and Alexander Korda. On the wall of Adolph Zukor’s office at Paramount was an inscription: TO BE A HUNGARIAN IS NOT ENOUGH, though Adolph allegedly always added, “but it may help”. Another sign at the MGM Studios read, Just because you are Hungarian, doesn’t mean you are a genius.Although there were many Hungarian visitors, ‘hussars’ and writers in America from 1776 onwards, Hungarian immigration to the United States increased throughout the 1850s, following the Hungarian Revolutionary War of 1848-9. By the 1860s, an estimated four thousand of them lived in the States, though not all of them settling permanetly, gravitating to Ohio, New York, Pennsylvania and New Jersey. László Újházy came with Lajos Kossuth, the leader of the Revolution, in 1851, and founded a Hungarian settlement, New Buda, in Iowa. Throughout the last decades of the nineteenth century, American attention was drawn towards Hungary, especially due to the increased Hungarian immigration to the United States.
One of the new arrivals in this period who is perhaps typical of many of his fellow-countrymen who made the Atlantic crossing, was a Hungarian American entertainer who certainly fell into the category of ‘genius’. Probably the greatest escape artist of all time, Harry Houdini (1874–1926) was a Hungarian-born illusionist and stunt performer. As Erik Weisz, he was born in Budapest to a Jewish family. His parents were Rabbi Mayer Sámuel Weisz and Cecília Steiner. The Weisz family arrived in the United States in July 1878, on the SS Fresia. The family changed their name to the German spelling Weiss, and Erik became Ehrich. The family lived in Appleton, Wisconsin, where his father served as Rabbi of the Zion Reform Jewish Congregation. By this time, Ehrich was one of seven children.In June 1882, Rabbi Weisz became an American citizen, but losing his job at Zion later that year, he and his family moved to Milwaukee, where they fell into dire poverty. In 1887, Rabbi Weisz moved with Ehrich to New York City, where they lived in a boarding house on East 79th Street. He was joined by the rest of the family once he had found permanent housing. As a child, Ehrich Weisz took several jobs, making his public début as a 9-year-old trapeze artist, calling himself “Ehrich, the Prince of the Air”. He first attracted notice in vaudeville in New York and then as “Harry ‘Handcuff’ Houdini” on a tour of Europe, where he challenged police forces to keep him locked up. Brewers in Scranton, Pennsylvania and other cities challenged Houdini to escape from a barrel after they filled it with beer. Soon he extended his repertoire to include chains, ropes slung from skyscrapers, straitjackets under water, and having to escape from and hold his breath inside a sealed milk can with water in it. He died of peritonitis, secondary to a ruptured appendix, in October 1926 at Detroit’s Grace Hospital, aged 52. Houdini’s funeral was held on 4 November, in New York City, with more than two thousand mourners in attendance.
Although the exact figures are not available, it has been estimated that by 1910 more than 300,000 Hungarians lived in the USA. Many were former peasants, who settled in rural areas, but by 1914, a small number of Hungarian artisans, intellectuals and bankers lived in Cleveland, Chicago, and New York City. Many of these retained their language and cultural ties to their home country through churches, fraternal organisations and Hungarian-language newspapers. In 1902, the first-ever statue of Kossuth was erected in Cleveland. Another form of ‘memorial’, the Pulitzer Prizes, were first awarded in 1917, but they were founded by Joseph Pulitzer, who had set new precedents for his more critical style of news coverage after emigrating from Hungary to the US in 1864, in common with other Hungarians, to serve in the Civil War. He became a well-known publisher and, in 1892, he offered money to Columbia University in New York to set up the World’s first school of journalism, though the graduate school was only brought about two decades later, after his death. The prizes, now the most prestigious awards for journalism in the world, are awarded annually according to his wishes.
The outbreak of the First World War in 1914 effectively halted emigration from Britain and Europe. Between 1919 and 1921, although there was a post-war emigration boom in Britain, most of this was directed to the dominions, since it was comprised of ex-service people who were given government assistance. Then, despite the contributions of immigrants from southern, eastern and central Europe, famous or not, to the growth of the US economy and society, in May 1921, the US government decided to limit that flow under the ‘Emergency Quota Act’. Only three percent of each country’s existing numbers in the US as of 1910 were allowed to enter the country in future. Hungary’s quota under the Act was 5,747. This was a severe restriction on a country torn apart by war, revolutions and the border changes made by the Treaty of Trianon in 1920. There were relatively small but significant pockets of Hungarian urban workers and rural settlers across the Northern and mid-Western states. In 1910, there had been 1,214 Hungarian-born people in Scranton alone, out of a foreign-born population of over 35,000. The Immigration Act of 1924 further limited immigration from each country to two per cent of that country’s nationals in the United States in 1890. After 1 July, 1927 (later referred to 1929), the total number of immigrants from all countries to the United States was limited to 150,000 annually, with immigration quotas for each country based on their representation in the American population in 1920. Hungary’s quota under the new guidelines was just 869 people.
Due to the large number of Hungarians who had ‘immigrated’ to the USA before World War I, however, the Hungarian government sought and received permission to establish several consulates in the US in areas where there were significant Hungarian populations, to provide services to them without requiring them to go to Washington. The first of these opened in Pittsburgh in October 1922 (closed in 1926), followed in December by a Consulate General in New York and consulates in Chicago and Cleveland (which became Consulates General in 1935 and 1940, respectively). Many Hungarian immigrants also retained institutional links with each other and with Hungary through churches, clubs and other organisations, as shown in the picture above of the Mayor of Pittsburgh with members of the Hungarian Mothers’ and Garden Association in 1929. Cultural ties between the two countries strengthened even further during the inter-war years. Composer Béla Bartók, who was rooted in Central European folk music, toured the United States in 1927-28, and returned to live there in 1940, before both countries reluctantly declared war on each other. Eugene (Jenő) Ormándy, George Széll, and György Solti were three Hungarian conductors who escaped the years of dictatorship of the mid-century in Hungary to base themselves in the United States.
The Great Depression in the USA, which began with the ‘Wall Street Crash’ of October 1929, further restricted economic immigration, but from the mid-thirties onwards, there was a new influx or refugees from central Europe, especially of Jews who were increasingly victims of official anti-Semitism, especially in Germany and Hungary. The photographer Robert Capa was born Andre Friedman in Budapest, and was awarded the US Medal of Freedom for his powerful images of warfare against fascism, from the Spanish Civil War onwards. Edward Teller, the ‘father of the hydrogen bomb’, was a Hungarian physicist who fled the Nazis in 1935 and worked on the USA’s atomic bombs, becoming a leading member of the ‘Manhattan Project’ together with Léo Szilárd, who developed the first self-sustained nuclear fission reactor. While Szilárd supported American efforts to develop the atomic bomb, he later advocated the peaceful use of nuclear energy and opposed nuclear weapons. John von Neumann, an extraordinary mathematician and pioneer of digital computing and Eugene Wigner, a Nobel prize winning physicist, were two other Hungarian exiles who also participated in making the first atomic bomb.
Exiled Hungarian Nuclear Physicists.
Among the most distinctive and serious-minded of the new were the American Germans. It has been estimated that in the two centuries after 1776, a total of some seven million Germans migrated to the United States. Those who arrived after the 1848 revolutions were mainly middle class and most of those arriving after the American Civil War were working class. They went to live in ‘German’ cities like Cincinatti, Ohio, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and St Louis, Missouri. Like earlier British immigrants, they remembered the Old World in the New, so that in the USA today there are twelve Berlins, seven Germantowns; four Bismarcks; and five Fredericks. The Germans established themselves quickly: by 1860 there were twenty-eight daily German newspapers in fifteen cities. As the result of the establishment of this large, professionally successful, literate, alternative culture, American English acquired German words like ‘bummer’ (‘Bummler’; loafer), ‘check’ (‘Zeiche’, bill for drinks), ‘cookbook’ (‘Kochbuch’), ‘delicatessen’ (‘Delikatesse’; delicacies), ‘fresh’ (‘frech’; impertinent), ‘hoodlum’ (Bavarian word for ‘rowdy’), ‘kindergarten’, ‘nix’ (‘nichts’; nothing), ‘phooey’ (‘pfui’), ‘rifle’ (‘riffel’; groove), ‘scram!’ (Yiddish: ‘scrammen’), ‘spiel’ (‘spielen’; play), ‘yesman’ (‘Jasager’, yes-sayer). A further relection of the distinctive German contribution to American society is the direct translation of German into English: and how! (und wie), no way (keineswegs), can be (kann sein), will do (wird getan) let it be (lass es sein).
Between 1848 and 1871 the population of the Russian Empire grew by twenty million., more than a quarter, a rate that only Britain could match. Russia now had more than twice as many people as the German Empire, next in line. France and Austria-Hungary were equal third, with no gain on their 1848 figures because their territorial losses cancelled out their natural increases. The United Kingdom came close behind these two and in sixth place came the newly-united Kingdom of Italy. In 1867, the Emperor Franz Joseph, recognising that he needed to act to strengthen his Empire, decided to take the Hungarians into ‘partnership’. He gave them control over the Slavic populations of the ancient Kingdom. The Hapsburg Empire therefore became the ‘Dual Monarchy’, but with the Austrian Emperor still in overall control of both kingdoms. The Hungarian were every bit as repressive towards the minority nationalities as the Austrians. The polyglot state was now an anomoly at a time of aggressive nation-state formation.
Before the First World War, the Germans were a popular element in American society, renowned in the univesities for their science, their philosophy and their pedantry. But after the Lusitania was sunk in 1915 with the loss of twelve hundred lives, they became the Huns, the Bosche (from the French ca-boche for ‘blockhead’), and later, Jerries. This latter word was borrowed from British troops in the trenches – the English slang for a chamber-pot, “Jerry”, was applied to the Germans because their coal-scuttle helmets looked like chamber-pots. The rash of anti-German feeling was reflected in a changing of surnames and ‘borrowed’ terms. Sauerkraut became “liberty cabbage”, and frankfurters became “hot dogs”. Americans with the names Astor, Budweiser, Chrysler, Custer, Eisenhower, Frick, Heinz, Pershing, Rockefeller, Singer, Steinway, Studebaker or Westinghouse, were descendents of German immigrant families.
Europe’s population inreased by nearly fifty per cent in the period 1871-1910, faster than ever before or since. The biggest gains, both absolutely and proportionately, were registered by the biggest powers: Russia put on eighty million (an increase of 88%) and Germany twenty million (sixty per cent). Due to Ireland’s continuing losses, Britain managed only a forty per cent increase, which was still enough to take its overall population to overtake that of France for the first time. Austria-Hungary’s increase was 33%, but the proportion of Slavs was approaching fifty per cent, presenting the Empire with a broadening crisis of identity. But the ethnic Slavs in the Balkans were far from united in their identities, and were suspicious of Russian aggrandisement in eastern Europe.
The Italians, who first arrived somewhat later than the Germans, were given a lower social class and status as ‘southern Europeans’, who were nicknamed ‘dago’, a generic term of abuse for Iberians and Italians, or ‘wop’, for southern or ‘poor’ Italians, derived from the Neapolitan or southern Italian dialect word guappo, for a ‘dude’, a ‘dandy’ or ‘a worthless fellow’. It is said to have been first used by northern Italians to refer to Neapolitans. Italian immigrants would often call each other ‘wahppo’ (as it sounded to anglophone ears) in a jocular manner, especially when the elders among them referred to the younger and/or more recently-arrived immigrants, the point being that the Italians, at least on arrival, were mainly poor, often illiterate peasants from the south. Native-born American ‘bosses’ and fellow-workers took up the term as a derogatory one applied to all Italians. There is an apocryphal story that the immigration authorities on Ellis Island would tag the new immigrants with a label WOP (an acronym for without passport/ papers), implying that the Italian immigrants entered the USA as undocumented or illegal immigrants. The fact that the first known use of the slur was recorded in 1908 suggests that this is probably a false etymology, as immigration documents and passports were not required by US immigration officers until 1924.
The prejudice against Italian immigrants led to the case against Sacco and Vanzetti.
Between 1865 and 1920, as the age of the steamship brought cheap travel to more and more Europeans, more than five million Italians migrated to the United States, mainly to the great cities of the North-East. Soon, starting in New York, every city had its Little Italy. Unlike the Germans, the less-educated Italians made a more complete adoption of American English. As a result, the influence of Italian words is mainly limited to food words, now in common usage in international English. There were also some words associated with ‘the Mafia’, though many of these were added later, from the late 1930s onwards by Hollywood’s fascination with making “gangster” movies. Although many of these words and phrases are now associated with Italian accents, few of them originate in Italy or Little Italy. Their importance has more to do with the power of the media rather than that of the mafia itself, whose ‘fake’ vocabulary has had an influence on the language out of all proportion to its significance to the Italian American community. In so far as they existed in contemporary American usage, they were either, like ‘burying the hatchet’, well-established in the native lexicon, or, like ‘hoodlum’, imports from other languages. Apart from ‘padrone’, already mentined above, ‘capo’, short for ‘caporegime’ (a ‘captain’ in organised crime) is the only authentic Italian word associated with the mafia.
In August 1934, Al Capone was moved from a penitentiary to Alcatraz. For six years, Capone had been America’s greatest gangster. Brought to trial seven times, juries were afraid to convict him until 1931, when he had been given an eleven-year sentence for tax invasion.
The third main group of European exiles were the three million East and Central European Jews who landed between 1880 and 1910. At peak times, as many as fifteen thousand a day would arrive on Ellis Island, “the isle of tears”. Here the authorities checked the papers and the physical condition of the new arrivals, and then their material circumstances. Finally, each name was checked against the ship’s papers. This was when many new Americans acquired a new identity at the hand of ill-educated immigration officials. Names like Ouspenska would become Spansky; Nisnyevich would be shortened to Nissen and Ostazzinski would be transformed into O’Shaughnessy. If they hadn’t already changed their Slavic or German names to avoid persecution in Europe, many Jews would take the opportunity to change it on arrival, at least until the quota system of the 1920s introduced more formal requirements. Many of the East and Central European Jews ended up on the Lower East Side of New York City, working in the garment trade. Like the Germans, they formed a strong subculture within American society. In the 1890s, the Yiddish newspaper, the Jewish Daily Forward, had a circulation of a quarter of a million. Excluded from the more established avenues of advancement, many American Jews moved into the ‘media’ and entertainment businesses – newspapers, magazines, vaudeville, radio and films.
Ellis Island, New York, the gateway of opportunity.
The spread of Yinglish (Yiddish-English) into the mainstream of the language is partly the result of the preponderance of Jewish Americans in the media of the United States, performers as well as executives. As Leo Rosten, the ‘champion of Yinglish’ has remarked,The foothold established on the hospitable shore of English may be glimpsed if you can scan the entries beginning with ‘ch’, ‘k’, ‘sch’, ‘sh’, ‘y’. The collision of English and Yiddish has also given America such expressions as Get lost, Give a look, He knows from Nothing, If you’ll excuse the expression, I’m telling you, I need it like a hole in the head, Enjoy!, Smart he isn’t and I should worry. Many of these expressions emerged in the in the burlesque theatres of the late nineteenth century, a place where the new arrivals could send each other up. W. C. Fields, Groucho Marx, Jack Benny, Bert Lahr and George Burns all grew up in this environment.
The USA’s “Quota Acts” of 1921 and 1924 ruled that Asiatic immigrants should be excluded entirely; people of Latin, Slav or Celtic extraction might be admitted, though only in moderation. Anglo-Saxon immigration was also to be restricted, but Canadians, Britons and Germans were to receive larger allocations than the other groups. The message was clear. The Statue of Liberty no longer had a notice with the word “Welcome” on it. “Keep Out!” was the order of the day. So, from this day forward, for all but a few who decided to leave Britain or even what was now ‘the Irish Free State’, it was “Empire or bust!”
Black Migration & North American Music:
North American music began with the songs of Black slaves in their African work songs and religious songs, or ‘spirituals’ with a shape of ‘call and response’. When the slaves gained their freedom, they began to to tell their own stories in music called the ‘blues’, particularly in the area along the southern Mississippi. It had the same shape as the spiritual, where the guitar answers the solitary singer. At the beginning of the twentieth century, Black people moved from the South to the North to find work. The half-century between the Civil War and the First World War saw the American Blacks catapulted from slavery to legal equality, then snapped back into a state almost as degrading as slavery. At the end of the Civil War, four million slaves were freed and an old English legal phrase, “civil rights” entered the American English lexicon. Congress rapidly passed further legislation granting full citizenship and the guarantee of the rights to vote to the freed slaves.
Even after emancipation, many Blacks remained on the southern plantations for generations.
The avenging zeal of the Republican administrations of those immediate post-war years meant that by 1867 there were more Southern Blacks registered to vote than Whites, and Congress had twenty-four Black congressmen. All these gains were lost as White Southerners wore down the North. Once the last Federal troops were were withdrawn, the South hit back, passing ‘Jim Crow’ laws to abridge the rights of Blacks. The word segregation became part of the vocabulary of discrimination, as did uppity, a White Southern word for Blacks who did not know their place. In this way, language signified social and political reactionary change. The final blows to the freed Blacks came in the 1880s and 1890s when the Supreme Court attacked the Civil Rights Act as ‘unconstitutional’ and sanctioned segregated (“seperate but equal”) education. Decades of second-hand citizenship lay ahead for Southern Blacks.
Their new subjugation helped drive a great Black migration to the North. But most blacks did not migrate to the North until the 1920s. Meanwhile, in the mid-1870s the various elements of Southern Black language and culture – double meanings, covert sexuality, African rhythms, liberation – came together in what was then the most vital centre of Black American culture, New Orleans. The name they gave to the new music was ‘jazz’, and the musician Jelly Roll Morton claimed he was the first to play it in 1897, but nobody knows exactly when exactly it began. Certainly, by 1913, the word and the music had moved into the mainstream of American culture, with both Blacks and Whites using it to mean a particular type of ‘ragtime’ music with a syncopated rhythm. By the end of 1917, the year the “doughboys” sailed for Europe to fight the Kaiser, jazz music and jazz bands were the ‘talk of the town’ in New York, London and Paris.
The northward migration of the Black Americans is shown, in terms of general direction by the arrows from the former Confederate states (in blue).
After the First World War and the surge in manufacturing, there were even more potent economic reasons for the Blacks to leave the South and move to the northern cities like Chicago, Philadelphia, New York, and later to Detroit. The arrows on the map above are not intended to show precise migration patterns, but to convey the essence of the move from South to North. Later, there was also a significant Black migration to California. In the 1920s, Blacks living in large numbers in the cities were seen by most White Americans as stereotypical maids, cooks, waiters, porters and minstrels. This partly reflected the socio-economic reality, but it also showed in the influence of vaudeville, radio and the talkies. It was through the entertainment business that many Blacks fought their way out of the ghettos in the northern cities and out of the poverty-ridden South, like the New Orleans jazzmen, all the way up the Mississippi to Chicago and finally New York. The stereotype was by no means entirely accurate.
Harlem in the 1920s underwent a cultural renaissance, symbolised by the work of the poet Langston Hughes and the flourishing there of a sophisticated Black middle class. The downtowners who came uptown would have been called ‘jazz babies’ or ‘flappers’ if they were women, and a ‘jazzbo’ or ‘sheik’ (after Rudolph Valentino’s starring role in the 1921 film, The Sheik) if they were men. The language of jazz players was known as ‘jive talk’, as defined here by Albert Murray, who was born in the South and ’emigrated’ to the North, where the money and the future were:
… It’s derived from down home speech … It’s the Southern musician moving into the North which made the difference. Although normally people in the North show the great influence of Irish and Jewish people in their talk, the other great influence would be the speech of Southern musicians. …
At the centre of Harlem, the clubs and the bands, was the greatest Black musician of them all, Louis Armstrong. Armstrong was born and raised in New Orleans, becoming renowned for his charismatic stage presence and voice as well as his trumpet playing. Coming to prominence in the 1920s as an inventive trumpet and cornet player, Armstrong was a foundational influence in jazz, shifting the focus of the music from collective improvisation to solo performance. Around 1922, he followed his mentor, Joe “King” Oliver, to Chicago to play in the Creole Jazz Band. In Chicago, he spent time with other popular jazz musicians, reconnecting with his friend Bix Beiderbecke and spending time with Hoagy Carmichael and Lil Hardin. He earned a reputation at “cutting contests”, and relocated to New York in order to join Fletcher Henderson’s band. Jazz music became famous across the world after it was taken to Paris and London in the mid-twenties, as can be seen from the ‘picture post’ articles below. George and Ira Gershwin, the black songwriters and composers, wrote jazz songs like ‘Lady Be Good’ and ‘I Got Rhythm’ and made use of it in orchestral compositions like ‘Rhapsody in Blue’ and ‘An American in Paris’. A cast of African American singers staged their opera ‘Porgy and Bess’ in Budapest in 1935. American movies popularised jazz classics through music and dance and these films were distributed throughout the world by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Fox and Warner Brothers. Europe in particular was awash with American culture.
A Page from ‘These Tremendous Years’, a ‘Daily Express’ publication covering the years 1919-38.
The Blues singers took their music with them to Chicago and Detroit. Musicians like Muddy Waters, Willie Dixon, John Lee Hooker and Howlin’ Wolf were the first to use electric guitars. Bakerlite recordings of the blues became very popular in the 1920s and ’30s, when singers like Bessie Smith became famous. The other kind of American music started from the folk music of the Scottish, Irish and British people who settled in the Appalachian Mountains. ‘Country’ music began to be really popular in the 1920s, when Jimmie Rodgers and the Carter family made the first country records and the Grand Ole Opry radio show started in Nashville, Tennessee, which became the centre for this genre, just as Detroit became the centre for ‘Motown’ music, from the 1950s. Of course, Memphis, Tennessee became associated, in that era, with Rock ‘n’ Roll.
But it was Black sportsmen who did most to combat segregation in the thirties. Joe Lewis, the ‘Brown Bomber’ restored the world heavyweight boxing title to the USA in 1937, after it had been held by two Germans and an Italian for most of the decade. Lewis retired undefeated in 1949 after almost singlehandedly fading out the colour bar in American sport. In 1936 it was the turn of Berlin to host the Olymic Games and Hitler tried to turn the occasion into a Nordic spectacular of Aryan superiority and the will to win of the ‘Master Race’. It was therefore a great personal blow to him when most of the honours were carried off by the Americans, and a disproportionate number of them by Black athletes, especially by Jesse Owens (born 1913), the son of a share-cropper from Alabama in the south, whose father had been born into slavery.
Owens competed for Ohio State University, where he lived in a segregated dorm with other Black athletes. When they travelled away, they stayed in separate hotels from the White athletes, who were taken out for dinner while the Blacks ate in the hotels.
By the time he travelled to Berlin, he was already known as the fastest man in America, and was one of the first black athletes to run for the USA at the Olympics. When the time came for Hitler to meet the champions, the German leader didn’t speak to Owens or offer his hand because he didn’t want to be seen in newspaper photographs greeting a black athlete. But the discrimination against the Jewish athletes in the US team by its own coaches and administrators, as a sign of deference to Hitler, was also a sign that the ‘melting pot’ had not yet done its job. After the Olympics, Jesse visited many towns and cities throughout the USA to speak about the need to bring black and white American together through sport and to bring about an end to segregation.
Wave upon wave of new Americans were now flooding in from Ireland, Germany, Italy and, in the 1880s, from Central Europe. Many of them were also pushing westwards, pioneering the new frontier. Throughout the nineteenth century, the very notion and definition of the West kept changing. When Charles Dickens visited America, he went no father than St Louis, nine hundred miles short of the Rocky Mountains, announced that he had seen the West, and declared it to be a fraud. A generation later, Oscar Wilde lectured his way round America, drinking gold miners under the saloon tables of the ‘Wild West’. As the frontier moved, its language changed with each new environment. In the first half of the nineteenth century, the vast American continent offered so many obstacles to travel that the easiest way to the West was along the great, broad Mississippi, running from New Orleans to St Louis, then marking the boundary of ‘the West’. The Mississippi is 2,340 miles long and has 250 tributaries, including the Ohio and Missouri rivers. The river was a way of life which ferried settlers, farmers, and merchants; it prompted the development of the ‘steamboat’ or ‘paddlesteamer’. Together with its mighty tributaries, it was the cargo route for cotton, sugar, tobacco and slaves; it brought prosperity to scores of cities and towns, including Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Louisville, Kansas City, Minneapolis, St Louis, Memphis, Baton Rouge and, of course, New Orleans.
The Mid-Western states of the USA, as defined by the 1933 atlas.
In the Far West, the frontier was often hard to define. After the beaver trade in the Rocky Mountains collapsed, many of the trappers and ‘mountain men’ found new business as guides when ‘Oregon fever’ swept the Mississippi in the early 1840s. But that migration was nothing compared with what was to follow in 1848 with ‘Gold fever’, encouraging every adventurous ‘Yankee’ to head out to the Far West to the new “El Dorado”. But in the long history of the American frontier, the Gold Rush was something of a freak, a story of overnight riches that ran counter to the experiences of most pioneers. Those who came to settle the land and live on it, year by year, generation by generation, had to find a way of life less precarious than the fur trade and less solitary and dangerous than prospecting, a way of life that suited the peculiar climate and geography of the Far West. This was the way of the ‘cowboy’, a word that first appeared in print, in its present sense, in 1877, though its earlier British meaning of ‘a boy who tends cattle’ was first recorded a century and a half earlier.
The legend of the cowboys began ten years before the word appeared in print in American English, in the spring of 1867, when the as-yet-uncompleted transcontinental railroad ran a branch line to Abilene, Kansas. It was there that a twenty-nine-year-old livestock trader from Chicago named Joseph McCoy had an idea that put millions of dollars into his bank account and his name into the dictionaries. Having bought most of the town for $4,250, he set about bringing the cows from the high grasslands of Texas up to the new railhead to ship them back to feed the cities of the North and East. He advertised for cow-handlers to bring the the half-wild longhorns up the Chisholm Trail to his new railhead cattleyards. For this, he offered $40 a head, ten times the going rate. Apparently, a hundred days after McCoy first posted his offer, the first herds arrived from the South, two and three thousand at a time. McCoy had bragged that he wouéd deliver two hundred thousand cattle in the first decade of business. In the first four years alone he shipped more than two million back East. His performance matched his advertising: He was “the real McCoy”. Soon there were at least five thousand cowboys on the Chisholm Trail and for the next twenty years (until the drought of 1886-7), the ‘cowboy was king’, though the ‘cattle barons’ like McCoy were ultimately in control. In fact, there were very few cowboys, fewer than forty thousand at peak, and they rarely fought Indians or had gunfights with each other. At least a quarter of them were black or Mexican.
The Expanding Frontier
The new railroads opened up the prospect of cattle worth only two to three dollars a head in Texas being sold for twenty times as much in the cities of the East. All the cowboys had to do was to round up the cattle and drive them seven hundred miles to the railheads in the north.Between 1867 and 1887 they drove fifty-five million head of cattle to the towns of Abilene, Ellsworth and Dodge City, plus other railroad towns in Kansas and Missouri. From there the cows were sent to the abattoirs of Chicago in cattle wagons. Their work was hard and dangerous, though most days in the saddle were simply hot, dusty and long. The dangers of the trail, however, caught the popular imagination, as did the wild behaviour at the end of the trail when the cowboys spent their earnings like water in the saloon bars and dance halls of the cow towns. With all attention focused on his skill as a rider, his six-shooters, his hard-drinking and reckless gambling, the cowboy was soon glamorised in ‘Wild West’ shows and early Hollywood films. He became the first all-American hero. This process of immortalisation began with the drawings of Francis Remington, like the one below.
The cowboy era lasted little more than twenty years. As cattle ranchers fenced in more and more of the open range and as the railroads brought an increasing number of settlers to the area, the cowboy’s job became almost impossible in terms of being able to drive cattle through open country. The last of the big drives was in 1886 and it was not long before cattle trailing had dwindled away completely, and the railroad lands were sold to immigrant farmers. From 1862 to 1900 more than half a million farmers migrated to the West.
A Cattle Drive
Until the 1870’s the Great Plains were still largely unsettled. As the far West filled up, however, settlers were driven to consider cultivating the open grasslands of the ‘Great American Desert’. Daunting though the prospect was, the railroads made it possible to think of moving into this region. The journey there presented no problems and any special equipment and timber which might be needed to establish a farm in this dry, treeless area could now be brought in as required. It was in interests of the railway companies to encourage settlers to fill up the West’s empty spaces. Some companies, as a result of generous government grants, owned a great deal of unoccupied land which they now wished to sell. Every company wanted as much traffic as possible running along its lines. Railway companies began, therefore, to mount intensive advertising campaigns in which the mid-West was painted in very rosy colours. A circlar by the Burlington and Missouri River Railroad:
Ho for the West! Nebraska ahead! The truth will out! The best farming and stock-raising country in the world! The great central region, not too hot or too cold.
The facts about Western Iowa and Southern Nebraska are being slowly but surely discovered by all intelligent men. The large population now pouring into this region, consists of shrewd and well-intentioned farmers, who know what is good, and are taking advantage of the opportunities offered.
The crops of Southern Nebraskaare as fine as can be; a large wheat and barley crop has been harvested; corn is in splendid condition and all other crops are equally fine. The opportunities now offered to buy B. & M. R. R. lands on long credit, low interest twenty-per-cent rebate for improvements, low freights, and fares, free passes to those who buy, etc., etc., can never again be found.
The ‘Homesteaders’ as they were called, built their own homes using the logs delivered by train and the sods of earth they dug up in order to plant their crops. This was back-breaking work as the prairie grass was usually very deep-rooted. One family that moved onto this land was the Ingalls family, whose dughter, Laura Ingolls Wilder wrote the story of migration and settlement in Little House on the Prairie. The homesteads were often very isolated and life was tough, especially in winter, and lonely, though the railroad towns helped to bring people together. Before the end of the century, the Great Plains were settled, marking the end of an era for Americans. For the first time in their history there were no large tracts of land for them to move into. In that sense, The West was won.
A new Mid-Western City in the making.
It was won, however, at the expense of the Plains Indians, who were forced to exchange their hunting grounds for inadequate reservations allowed by the US government. Some went peaceably, while others had to be forcibly removed. For the Plains Indians, the building of the railroads across the plains marked the beginning of the end of their way of life. They also brought the men who virtually exterminated the animal around which that way of life revolved. In 1840, perhaps forty million buffalo roamed the Great Plains. By 1890 perhaps only a thousand remained. Many were killed by men employed by the railroad companies to supply their construction crews with meat. William Cody earned his nickname ‘Buffalo Bill’ by killing 4,280 buffalo in the space of eighteen months on behalf of the Kansas Pacific Railway Company. He was renowned for his skill at shooting from the saddle of a galloping horse. Many more buffalo were killed for sport and by professional hunters who sold the hides to tanneries in the East for $1 to $3 apiece.
Plains Indians hunting buffalo.
In 1876, Cody served as a scout to General George Custer just before the Battle of the Little Big Horn, and two weeks later he led the retalitory raid against the Cheyenne, killing and then scalping Chief Yellow Hand. Such was the stuff of legend at that time, of course, and Cody set about bringing the legend to a growing American and then, finally, a European audience. He formed the Wild West Show in 1883 and, as ‘Cowboy and Indian’ fever first swept the English-speaking world, he became the toast of fashionable society on both sides of the Atlantic. In 1887, Queen Victoria was persuaded by the Prince of Wales to attend his show and was reportedly much impressed by the dignity of the Indian Red Cloud who, had become part of the act, and commanded a royal performance for her Jubilee guests ten days later. Four European heads of state and the Prince of Wales were driven around the arena in the “Deadwood Stagecoach” and ambushed by Indians. The reality was that for almost thirty years the Plains Indians had resisted the white man. Tribe by tribe, however, they were defeated and confined to reservations. Chief Joseph of the Nez Perce tribe had surrendered in 1877, declaring:
I am tired of fighting. Our chiefs are killed. Looking Glass is dead. Theold men are all killed. It is the young men who say yes or no. He who led the young men is dead. It is cold and we have no blankets. The little children are freezing to death. My people, some of them, have run away to the hills, and have no blankets, no food; no one knows where they are, perhaps freezing to death. I want time to look for my children and see how many of them I can find. Maybe I shall find them among the dead. Hear me, my chiefs, I am tired; my heart is sick and sad. From where the sun now stands I will fight no more forever.
The last battle of the Indian Wars was fought in 1890. Fearing another uprising the US Army attacked the Sioux on the reservation. The Indians fled and were massacred in what is known as the ‘Battle of Wounded Knee’. The Indian Territory to the west of the Mississippi was the largest piece of land left to the Indians. Numerous tribes were settled there by the US government. As land grew scarce, white settlers looked greedily at this region and in 1889 the government declared the unoccupied central part of the Territory open to settlement. On 22 April, thousands of settlers lined up along the edge of this region. They had come on horseback, in wagons, on bicycles and even with wheelbarrows. When the bugles sounded at noon they raced in to stake their claim. Within twenty-four hours the whole area had been staked out. Other rushes followed, the biggest of them photographed below on 16 September 1893. In 1907, the Indian Territory became the State of Oklahoma.
A generation later, when long-rooted prairie grass had been removed by the ‘sodbusting’ settlers, and the topsoil had become exhausted by over-cultivation and blown away in dust storms, the ‘Okies’ were forced to ‘upsticks’ once more and go all the way West to pick fruit in California. By that time, the USA was no longer the nation of farmers Jefferson had hoped it would become. Already by the end of the nineteenth century, vast industries were developing in cities like Pittsburgh, Philadelphia and Chicago. Rather than continuing to go west, increasing numbers of Americans and new immigrants chose to live and work in these and other industrial centres. In 1860 only sixteen cities had populations of over fifty thousand. By 1890 this number had reached fifty-eight. The days were gone when the West was the only place to go for those who wanted to improve their lives. In reality, it never had been.
Migrating Militants & Managers in the Midlands of England:
In 1926, with many miners leaving the south Wales valleys during the six-month lock-out to find work in the new industry centres of the Midlands and South-East of England, the Pressed Steel Company of Detroit accepted the invitation from William Morris, the car magnate, to open a factory in Cowley, then just outside the City of Oxford. The purpose of the Works, as the name suggests, was the mass-production of steel bodies for Morris and other car assembly companies in England.Eight years later, on Friday 13 July 1934, almost every man in the press shop at the giant Works decided to walk out in protest over wage cuts and conditions. One of the key figures leading the unofficial strike was Tom Harris, a crane operator in the press shop. He had been born in Monmouthshire in the 1890s and, following some years working in the pits there, emigrated to Scranton, Pennsylvania in his early twenties. There he worked as a miner, and assisted John L. Lewis in building up the United Mine Workers (UMW). He then returned to South Wales in the mid-1920s, probably to the Maesteg District (covering the Llynfi, Ogmore and Garw valleys), where he became active in the South Wales Miners’ Federation (SWMF), the ‘Fed’, and became involved in the leadership of the General Strike locally. It was with this transatlantic experience of migration and trade union organisation that he arrived in Cowley at some point shortly before the strike in 1934.
The frontispiece collage to A J Chandler’s PhD thesis, showing various documents and pictures related to migration from South Wales to Oxford.
The strike was successful, leading to the establishment of a T&GWU branch, of which Harris became Chairman. He was also a ‘secret’ member of the Communist Party (CPGB) and became Vice-President of the Oxford Trades Council. In the space of four years, the T&GWU branch had grown in strength to up to three thousand members at the factory, representing ninety per cent of the unskilled workforce. Towards the end of 1938, however, Harris was ‘victimised’ by the American management for organising meetings at his place of work. The strike which followed did not succeed in getting him reinstated and, somewhat weary after his long career as a union organiser, Harris left the Pressed Steel to set himself up as a coal merchant. The membership of the branch declined sharply after what became known as the ‘Tom Harris episode’, demonstrating his importance as an organiser. Jack Thomas, the Regional Organiser for the T&GWU at the time (an experienced trade unionist from Swansea sent to Oxford by Ernest Bevin to gain control over the ‘militant’ branch), considered that…
It would be fair to say that in the centres of the country that had a strong trade union background, the young people got it from their fathers and the first thing they wanted to do was to join the union even if they had very little money.
In his work with the leaders of the branch, ‘back-to-work Jack’ (as he was known in the Works) got the impression from ‘most Welsh boys’ that their industrial and trade union background; the sense of heritage and solidarity, or ‘clannishness’ among them as immigrant workers, provided a powerful motivation to organisation at the Pressed Steel. By contrast, it was said by local investigators that workers in the Morris Motors’ Plant in Cowley were mostly natives of Oxford and lack therefore any trade union tradition; in Pressed Steel on the contrary the men are largely from other parts of the country…
Unemployment represented by blank towers, migration in black. LUI = Local Unemployment Index (Ministry of Labour).
The primacy of social and cultural factors among the largely immigrant workforce had been present in its early recruitment from former Garw Valley miners following the opening of the plant in 1926. Key figures in the management had played an important role in this before the arrival of Tom Harris. In particular, the foreman in the Trucking Department was a Welsh-American from Detroit, Tudor Brooks, who was als the bandmaster of Headington Silver Band. Brooks became good friends with a number of the Welsh workers who joined the band, including Dai Husk, who was on the Band’s Executive. Always on the look-out for new members of the band as well as being keen to recruit workers from industrial backgrounds for the tough, unskilled work at Pressed Steel, Brooks would tell Husk to ‘send the bugger up’ every time he ‘had a good man wanting a job’. Brooks and Husk were therefore responsible for the migration of large parts of the Garw and Maesteg Salvation Army Bands.
This process continued well into the 1930s, when the Oxford Welsh Male Voice Choir’s secretary was asked to write to the Pressed Steel’s manager, Otto Moeller, to ask if anything more could be done to secure a permanent job for Will Davies, the choir’s new conductor in 1936. When no prompt reply was received, it was then decided that Davies be taken to see Tudor Brooks,who had been responsible for finding positions for many Welsh immigrants at the plant. This worked, and Brooks received a letter of thanks from the choir, asking him to become an Honourary Vice-President. Besides choirs and brass bands, he was responsible for ‘transferring’ gymnastic groups and rugby teams. These experiences provides a further illustration of the primary role played by cultural institutions as well as trade union traditions in migration and settlement. In this sense, Tom Harris and Tudor Brooks, as experienced transatlantic migrants, were two sides of the same coin in this third migration experience.
Sources on Migration:
FromPapers in Modern Welsh History: The Journal of The Modern Wales Unit, 1, Cardiff, 1983:
W. D. Jones, ‘The Welsh Experience in Scranton, P. A.’
A. J. Chandler, ‘ “The Black Death on Wheels”; Unemployment and Migration – the Experience of Inter-War South Wales’.
Unpublished:
W. D. Jones (1987), ‘Wales in America: Scranton and the Welsh, c.1820-1920. University of Wales, Cardiff PhD thesis.
A. J. Chandler (1988), ‘The Re-making of a Working Class: Migration from the South Wales Coalfield to the New Industry Areas of the Midlands, c. 1920-1940’. University of Wales, Cardiff PhD thesis.
Published sources:
Richard Garrett (1973), The Search for Prosperity: Emigration from Britain, 1815-1930.
Robert McCrum, William Cran & Robert MacNeil (1987), The Story of English. New York: Penguin Books.
Marc J. Susser (2007), The United States & Hungary: Paths of Diplomacy, 1848-2006. Washington D. C. : US Department of State.
Stephen Constantine et. al. (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British & Irish History, London: Penguin Books.
While the King camped out at Raglan Castle at the beginning of July, to the north of the main ongoing conflict, Royalist troops under Lord Byron were attempting to hold their own at Chester, and in the south-west Lord Goring, continuing to command the King’s army there, was attempting to fight his way into Taunton. Fairfax lost no time in ensuring that royalist hopes of a military recovery were dashed. His first priorities were to relieve Taunton and defeat Goring. If, however, Charles could combine with Goring he would have an army of a superior size, though not of the same quality, as the army he had lost in the field at Naseby on 14th June. Taunton was held for Parliament by Colonel Robert Blake and Fairfax was ordered to march to his relief. But as Royalist garrisons at Bristol, Bath and Devizes blocked Fairfax’s most direct route from the Midlands, he advanced southwards using the south coast ports for re-provisioning. He drove his men hard; between Marlborough and Dorchester, they marched an average of seventeen miles per day over five consecutive days. By 3 July, the New Model was quartered at Dorchester, where it was met by leaders of the Clubmen of Dorset and Wiltshire, local people who had taken to arms to protect their homes. They asked for passes to carry petitions to both King and Parliament, calling for a cessation of hostilities and the handing over all the places in Dorset that were garrisoned by either side to the Clubmen themselves. Fairfax naturally refused their request, though with courtesy and reasoned argument. Their numbers made them formidable as a third force, but their attitude softened as they came to appreciate his genuine consideration for local interests and the growing contrast between his army’s respect for law and property and the habitual marauding of the western royalists.
Sir Thomas Fairfax, by John Hoskins: though it has been questioned whether the sitter really was ‘black Tom Fairfax’. Compare with the picture below.
By 4 July the New Model were nearing Crewkerne, prompting Goring to raise his siege of Taunton, falling back to the River Yeo between Yeovil and Langport. He then took up a forward position to the east of Bridgwater at Langport to await the advancing parliamentarian army. Goring garrisoned his position there, giving it a strategic position, controlling a bridge across the River Parrett. The royalist garrison at Langport was in an important strategic position, controlling the bridge across the River Parrett. On 6 July, Fairfax sent Colonel Montague, with two thousand musketeers to the aid of Major General Massey at Ilchester. Massey was in command of several regiments of horse and dragoons with which he followed a large part of Goring’s army, marching on Taunton once more. However, before Montague could reach them, Massey’s forces had already engaged and damaged Goring’s army. Fairfax then turned Goring’s line by capturing Yeovil. After that, Fairfax had no difficulty in making Goring give up the siege of Taunton, but experienced rather more in bringing him to battle on advantageous terms. The ranks of the of the New Model were thinned after Naseby, where many more had been wounded than killed, by the escort that he had had to provide that for the 4,500 royalist prisoners, and by the chronic drain of desertions. Massey and his Western Association forces, garrisoned in Gloucester, had brought his strength up to fourteen thousand.
Goring with about half that number was also expecting reinforcements, in his case from south Wales, and was avoiding battle until they arrived. On 10 July, The Royalists regrouped at Langport and Goring dispatched three brigades of cavalry south-westwards in the hope of convincing Fairfax that Taunton was under threat again so that he would split his forces, thereby reducing the numerical disparity between the armies. Fairfax dispatched 5,500 Horse in pursuit of George Porter, who was intercepted and defeated near Ilminster. Goring then began to withdraw in the direction of Bridgwater. To allow his baggage and artillery trains to cover the twelve miles to Bridgwater, he then prepared to fight a delaying action from high ground to the east of Langport. He had been able to select a strong defensive position there, and was much less heavily outnumbered than he had been a few days earlier. That morning the troops sent to assist Massey at Ilchester were recalled by Fairfax, but they didn’t join the main part of the New Model until the battle was over. Goring could only oppose roughly seven thousand men to Fairfax’s ten thousand. However, because it was a landscape of hedged and ditched fields, this was primarily a battle for musketeers and cavalry, with the New Model’s pikemen unable to play a significant role in the action.
Thomas Fairax, General of the Forces, by an unknown artist, c. 1648/9.
Goring’s position was fronted by a brook known as the Wagg Rhyne and by a good deal of marshy ground. The Langport-Somerton road crossed the brook at a ford before ascending the hill in the centre of the Royalist line. The road and the surrounding fields were bordered by hedges which Goring lined with musketeers, and sited two guns to cover the ford, with cavalry in support. It was a seemingly strong position and the nature of the ground offered Fairfax little alternative but to make a frontal attack along the road. But Fairfax attacked with boldness and skill, making good use of his artillery and co-ordinating the deployment of his cavalry and infantry with precision. After a Parliamentarian battery had silenced the Royalist guns, fifteen hundred musketeers were sent forward to clear the hedges surrounding the ford. Then, a detachment of parliamentarian cavalry advanced along the hedged lane on the Royalist position, defended by two cannon and by musketeers lining the hedgerows. As the Royalist infantry fell back, three troops of Cromwell’s Horse commanded by Major Bethell charged across the ford and up the slopes beyond. Success hung upon a cavalry charge which had to negotiate a line wide enough for only four troopers to ride abreast before they engaged the waiting royalist horse, and it was executed with proud courage by units which had ridden with Cromwell since before the New Model’s creation.
The first two ranks of Royalist horse broke before this charge but Goring’s remaining cavalry massed against Bethell and began to push him back. At this crucial moment three troops from Fairfax’s regiment struck Goring’s cavalry in its flank, supported by musketeers as the Parliamentarian foot began to arrive on the hill. By this time, Goring’s men could not match the spirit of Cromwell’s troopers. Goring’s cavalry broke and fled, pursued and attacked as they fled through the streets of Langport. His infantry regrouped for action but, without cavalry support, they had no option other than to surrender. Although only three hundred Royalists were killed, many more were captured or deserted. Cromwell reckoned that they lost two thousand killed or captured. Many others, scenting an unmitigated defeat, simply melted away. The New Model had destroyed the royalists’ last substantial field army. After garrisoning Bridgwater, Goring retreated into Devon with the remnants of the Western Army. The battlefield lies between Taunton and Somerton, approximately a thousand yards from the town of Langport on the road to Somerton.
Bridgwater to Sherborne:
By contrast with what had happened with the Earl of Manchester’s army following Marston Moor the previous year, Fairfax took every opportunity to capitalise upon his successes at Naseby and Langport. A pattern was established that was followed throughout the remainder of the year. Detachments of varying compositions were sent out to reduce lesser garrisons while the main body faced the major Royalist strongholds. The next target was the small but strongly fortified garrison at Bridgwater. The town was divided in two by the River Parrett, the lowest crossing of which gave it its strategic importance. The most heavily fortified part was on the west side of the river, which contained the Medieval castle with massive stone walls and a thirty-foot wide moat. The whole town was encompassed by a Medieval tidal ditch, which had been recut by the royalists. There were also stretches of surviving Medieval town wall, supplemented by new defences of earth and timber. There were said to have been forty guns mounted on these walls, but there are no traces of these defences remaining today. All that survives is a simple arch of the Water Gate to the castle in the West Quay.
Streeter’s contemporary drawing of the armies, showing the Parliamentarian lines, with Pickering’s and Montague’s regiments at the centre.
Bridgwater was well-supplied and manned, with eighteen hundred troops under the command of Colonel Edmund Windham. The King had been led to believe that Bridgwater was “a place impregnable”. Twelve days after their victory at Langport, Fairfax decided that he had to storm the town in order to consolidate his victory since he did not have the time for a protracted siege. Part of the New Model was on the west side of the river, while on the eastern side were, as at Naseby, Fairfax’s, Skippon’s, Pickering’s, Montague’s, Hardress Waller’s, Pride’s, Rainsborough’s and Hammond’s regiments. The attackers described what happened on 21 July:
… About two of the clock in the morning, the storm began accordingly on this side of the town (the Forces on the other side only alarming the enemy…). Our Forlorn hope was manfully led on by Lt. Colonel Hewson: and as valiantly; and as valiantly seconded by the General’s Regiment … and the Major-General’s …
John Hewson. An engraving by Van der Gucht, in the National Portrait Gallery, London.
The ditch was crossed on portable bridges and the works scaled against strong resistance. Once inside, Pickering’s regiment opened the drawbridge for the other regiments to enter and soon that part of the town on the eastern side of the river was taken:
There was not one officer of note slain, though many in person led on their men, and did gallantly, as Lt. Col. Jackson, Lt. Colonel to the General, and Col. Hewson of Col. Pickering’s regiment.
Six hundred royalists still maintained the defences on the west side of the river. Having cut the bridge, the governor set fire to the eastern part of the town with a bomardment of red hot shot, leaving no more than three or four houses standing. This desperate defensive action was followed on the 22nd by the storming of the western part of the town, prepared by intensive cannon fire. In the face of this bomardment the governor soon surrendered, rather than allow the rest of the town to be devastated by fire as he himself had ordered the eastern half to be. The parliamentarian troops were promised five shillings per man as a reward for the storming of the town, to be taken out of the sale of goods captured. However, when the troops had still not heard anything by the middle of August, it was reported that, ‘for want of pay’, the men of various regiments took ‘free quarter’ and ‘plunder’ at will.
Meanwhile, Cromwell was dispatched to deal with the Clubmen, who were now supporting the royalists and causing the parliamentarian army considerable trouble. They were numerous enough to hamper Fairfax’s operations. There were two distinct associations of them in the region. One of them, based on the chalk downs of Dorset and neighbouring Wiltshire had a markedly royalist bias. At the same time other parliamentarian forces were sent to besiege Bath, while Colonel Pickering was given the task of besieging another key royalist garrison, at Sherborne. On 27 July, Fairfax …
… sent a Brigade of horse and foot unto Sherborn under the command of that pious and deserving Commander, Colonel Pickering, to face the garrison, and to view the same; and if there were hopes to reduce it, to sit down before it, in order to a seige.
The garrison at Sherborne, under the command of Sir Lewis Dyve, was in the Medieval Castle. It was proving particularly troublesome as it was encouraging the activities of the Clubmen against the parliamentarian forces. Colonel Pickering’s brigade consisted of two thousand foot, supported by Colonel Whalley’s Regiment of horse. On 1 August, Fairfax arrived outside Sherborne to view the siege works and the castle. On the 2nd, he ordered a “close siege”, believing that it might be possible to quickly reduce the garrison. Most of the army was brought up to Sherborne and they proceeded to construct siegeworks around the castle. Dyve refused a second summons to surrender on 6th August, and preparation was made for an assault. Mines were dug and gun batteries were constructed. The twelve foot thick castle walls were unaffected by the army’s artillery until demi-cannon arrived, by which time the siegeworks were within ten yards of the walls. On the 10th, the besiegers reported:
… our great Guns began to batter the strong wall of the castle, between the two lesser Towers thereof, and had soone beaten down one of them, and before six of the clock that night, had made a breach in the wall, so as twelve abreast might enter.
The castle, which the Enemy had vaunted would continue and hold out a half yeares seige at least, was most valiantly stormed. Ingoldsby’s men had gained the corner tower of castle. Dyve then refused quarter and so the final assault was prepared. Under continued musket fire the defenders had to withdraw from the Great Court. Their position was becoming increasingly difficult and they were now running short of ammunition. By the 15th Dyve had no alternative but to surrender. In total, two hundred of the besieging force had been lost over the sixteen days. The castle was plundered and later slighted, although large parts of it still stand today, and it is possible to pick out the traces of the triangular bastions and banks of the Civil War period, set immediately outside the Medieval ditch.
While Fairfax was besieging Sherborne, the ‘cavalier’ Clubmen had been in touch with its defenders and had agreed to try to help force Fairfax to raise the siege. He frustrated their plan by surprising a meeting of their leaders at Shaftesbury and sending them to London as prisoners, whereupon two thousand or more of their associates assembled in arms upon Hambledon Hill nearby, demanding their release. Three times Cromwell sent a party of horse to command them to disperse, and each time his men were fired upon; some were taken prisoner and according to Cromwell ‘used most barbarously’. Two of their most pugnacious leaders were Anglican clergymen. In the end it took a minor cavalry action to break them up, and though fewer than a dozen were killed, many more were wounded and about three hundred captured. Cromwell held them in a church overnight, took their names, warned them that they would be hanged if they were caught again opposing the Parliament’s forces, and then let them go.
Shaftesbury to Bristol:
The other Clubmen association with which Fairfax dealt was drawn from the woodland and pastoral areas of Somerset and Gloucestershire. Research into the individual counties in the Civil War, especially by Underdown, has illustrated the importance of local issues in determining loyalties (see above). Gloucestershire was deeply divided during the Civil War, between royalists, parliamentarians and ‘clubmen’, local people who simply wanted nothing to do with the conflict and wanted to keep the fighting out of their towns and villages, if necessary by using a variety of ‘homemade’ arms themselves. Lacking great landed magnates to give leadership and with Gloucester firmly in parliamentary hands, the royalists proved ineffective. Gradually the better organised parliamentarians had been gaining control of the county, until in July 1643, when the King had seized Bristol and Gloucestershire had become the key theatre of the war.
Urged by his generals to exploit parliament’s disarray and advance on London, Charles instead turned aside to eliminate the last parliamentary garrison in the county, at Gloucester itself. Enthusiastically supported by the townsfolk, the garrison held out for six weeks until relieved by the Earl of Essex, possibly costing Charles the chance to end the war quickly. For the next two years, Gloucester remained a parliamentary enclave in royalist territory, a veritable ‘thorn in the side’ for Charles. The royalists failed to prevent the Gloucester garrison from raiding far and wide under its energetic commander Edward Massey; he slowly expanded the enclave until, after Naseby, royalist support in the county collapsed. In the clothing industries of the rural valleys of Gloucestershire and North Somerset, there was strong support for parliament and workers from these areas had quietly co-operated with Fairfax in the storming of Bridgwater.
The First Civil War in Scotland & England, 1639-47.
Bath had been taken soon after Bridgwater. These defeats made Charles and Rupert abandon their tentative plans for a new campaign in the West Country, with Bristol as their base. Their position in south Wales was endangered by a combined operation by Vice-Admiral Batten and Major-General Laugharne, who routed the local royalist forces at Colby Moor near Haverfordwest on 1 August. By the time of the successful assault on Sherborne Castle on the 14th, Charles, who had been in Cardiff, was already heading north, feeling the trap closing upon him. Leaving Rupert with what he thought was a sufficient force to defend Bristol, he set off with the idea of making a junction with Montrose. After his triumph at Auldern, Montrose had won another brilliant and bloody victory over Baillie and the Covenanters at Alford on 2 July, and was advancing upon Glasgow. When the two faced each other again , eleven miles from Glasgow at Kilsyth on 15 August, the committee of estates overruled Baillie’s plan of battle, and his army of six thousand was utterly routed; only a few hundred escaped with their lives. Montrose, with his own forces now grown to at least 4,400 foot and five hundred horse, entered Glasgow soon afterwards, and for a brief while he was master of Scotland.
Above: James Graham, First Marquis of Montrose, attributed to William Dobson, c.1640.
By then, Charles had got as far as Doncaster on his way to meet Montrose when he learnt that Leven and his army were on his tracks and only ten miles away. Leven had been besieging Hereford, but had broken off the operation to hunt larger prey. The Northern Association forces were also threatening Charles’ liitle army, so in search of safety he took it on a long and exhausting march by way of Newark and Huntingdon to Oxford and Worcester. By then his main concern, following the loss of the west country garrisons, was to save Bristol. Rupert had assured him that it could hold out for at least four months, which proved to be a serious error of judgement, one for which he was later made to pay dearly.
Prince Rupert of the Rhine, attributed to Gerrit van Honthorst.
Although other minor garrisons in the West Country were being cleared, Fairfax’s main objective was now Bristol, which he had had in his sights ever since Naseby. He overruled the more cautious spirits in his council of war who advised him first to clear out the far south-west, where Grenville, Goring and Hopton among others were still under arms, but he did think it important to reduce the nearest royalist garrisons in Dorset and Somerset, as we have seen. One reason for this was the need to deal with the local Clubmen, both the ‘hostile’ ones from Dorset and Wiltshire and the more ‘sympathetic’ ones from Gloucestershire and Somerset. When operations began against Bristol the Somerset Clubmen allowed Fairfax to recruit two thousand auxiliaries from their ranks. Gloucestershire contributed a further fifteen hundred and both counties readily raised more volunteers as the the siege progressed.
Above: A view of Bristol in the eighteenth century from Brandon Hill, site of one of the Civil War forts. The Parliamentarian troops’ breach of the Royalist defences was made at Lawford’s Gate, on the distant left of the picture.
The vanguard of the Parliamentary Army assembled around Bristol on the 22nd and 23rd August, when Fairax completed his investment of the City. Despite its formidable fortifications Fairfax did not intend to conduct a long siege. Yet the alternative of storming the city was a daunting one, and Rupert’s assurance to the king that he could hold out for four months shows that he expected no such exploit. Success depended on the newly developed courage of the infantry, having taken the outlying royalist garrison towns. Until a breach was made or a gate forced open, cavalry would be of little help. Sallies were made by the garrison over the following days against various regiments around the city. For foot soldiers, a pitched battle at push of pike was a severe enough test of morale, but to scale high walls under fire from cannon and muskets, and with defenders waiting to club or run through the assailants as they came over the top, must have been quite terrifying.
On the 29th the defenders attacked the parliamentarian quarters near Lawford’s Gate. It was then decided that the city should be stormed, because Fairfax was not confident that his army could maintain a long siege. By the time of the assault on Bristol the command of the General’s Brigade, comprising Fairfax’s, Montague’s, Pickering’s and Sir Hardress Waller’s regiments, had fallen to Colonel Montague. They were to attack on both sides of Lawford’s Gate, while other brigades attacked on the north and the west sides of the city. Montague’s and Rainsborough’s Brigades crossed the Avon at Keynsham to Stapleton where they quartered that night. Montague’s Brigade then secured the area between the rivers Frome and Avon, coming up to within musket-shot of Lawford’s Gate.
Above: The defences of Bristol in 1645 (after Gardiner)
On the morning of the 10th, a concerted attack was mounted. A new earthwork defence, with forts set along it, had been constructed outside the Medieval town walls. Fairfax sent his men in across these fortifications, even though the previous six days of bombardment had failed to make a breach in the walls. The soldiers carried faggots to fill in the ditch while some brought up ladders to scale the ramparts. The New Model foot that had fallen back before inferior numbers at Naseby fought heroically. Their task was made harder because at most points of attack their scaling ladders were too short to reach the tops of the walls. Priors’ Hill Fort, on the north side of the Frome, was captured but to the south of the Avon the attack faltered against much more substatial defences.
The decisive assault took place on the eastern side of the city. It was here that Montague’s Brigade stormed the defences on both sides of Lawford’s Gate, bothe to the river Avon, and the lesser river Froome. They forced their way in , and their numbers told in the end. Pickering himself entered gallantly, and with others gave the royal party that wound, which will hardly ever be healed. Fairfax had not far short of ten thousand men, including cavalry, backed by nearly five thousand Clubman auxiliaries. There was plague in the city, and sickness and desertion had left Rupert with at most two thousand regular troops and a thousand trained bands an auxiliaries to man a perimeter three to four miles long (although the Mayor of Bristol told Cromwell that Rupert had about a thousand horse and 2,500 foot, besides 1,200 or more trained bands and auxiliaries, but Rupert’s own narrative states that though his garrison was nominally 2,300 strong, he could never man the line with more than 1,500 regular soldiers, and that the trained band and auxiliaries were down to eight hundred).
Edward Montague, later Earl of Sandwich, in 1642, at the age of seventeen.A friend of John Pickering, he commanded an Eastern Association infantry regiment from the autumn of 1643, shortly before Pickering formed his regiment.
In his dispatch to the Speaker, Cromwell paid generous tribute to the gallantry of the soldiers which had secured this great victory. He described how:
Col. Montague and Col. Pickering, who stormed at Lawford’s Gate, where was a double work, well filled with men and cannons, presently entered; and with great resolution beat the Enemy from their works, and possessed their cannon. Their expedition was such that they forced the Enemy from their advantages, without any considerable loss to themselves. They laid down the bridges for the horse to enter; … Then our foot advanced to the Castle Street: whereunto were put a Hundred men; who made it good.
Oliver Cromwell, an unfinished minature by Samuel Cooper
He also testified that men of different religious professions had fought together as comrades, fired by the same spirit of faith and prayer, and he ended with an eloquent plea for that they and ‘the people of God all England over’ should enjoy liberty of conscience. With obvious reference to the sterile pursuit of religious uniformity thenin progress, he urged that the real unity was inward and spiritual, and from brethren, in things of the mind, we look for no compulsion but that of light and reason.
The Commons deleted the whole paragraph when they published his letter, as they had done with a similar plea in his Naseby dispatch, but his independent supporters had it printed separately and scattered in the streets. It probably received more public attention in the end because of the shabby attempt to suppress it.
Prince Rupert now requested a parley and Col. Pickering, with Montague and Rainsborough, was responsible for the negotiations with the royalists. The garrison surrendered on the following day. In all during the action Pickering’s and Montague’s captured twenty-two great guns and took many prisoners. For such a hazardous assault on one of the the major towns in the kingdom the losses were remarkably light. It was reported that in Col. Rainsborough’s and Col. Montague’s Brigade, not fortie men are lost, while in total the parliamentarian army suffered no more than two hundred killed. Apart from the earthwork remains on the fort on Brandon Hill, which now lie within a public park, nothing survives of the defences of Bristol. Of Lawford’s Gate, only the street name remains to show where the decisive breach was made.
No previous defeat so shocked and grieved the king as the surrender of Bristol. He saw it as a betrayal and immediately dismissed his nephew from the command of his army, rebuking him in a letter for ‘so mean an action’ and directing him to seek his subsistence overseas. This appears grossly unjust, even by contemporary absolutist standards. Rupert could fairly be faulted for misleading Charles about his power to hold on to Bristol for four months, but not for seeking terms when an immensely superior enemy had forced its way into a city beset with plague and had its defenders and citizens at its mercy. If he had cared nothing for civilian casualties or for the lives of his own men he might conceivably have withdrawn into the fort for a do-or-die stand, but his own officers judged this untenable in any case, and the only possible justification would have been that the King or Goring or both could have brought him swift and powerful relief. Bur Charles himself was in Raglan and in no position to assist him, and Goring was still in Exeter; Fairfax had intercepted from him saying that it would take him three weeks to get to Bristol.
Devizes to Winchester:
Montague was called to London and command of the brigade, which had fought together since Naseby, changed once more, passing to Col. John Pickering. Following the fall of Bristol the army was again divided and the clearance of the lesser royalist garrisons continued. Rainsborough was sent with a brigade to take Berkeley Castle, while Cromwell took Pickering’s brigade to take Devizes and Lacock House. Devizes town and castle had been fortified to command the county of Wiltshire and control traffic from London to the West. The governor, Sir Charles Lloyd, had a garrison of three to four hundred men. On 17 September, the town was quckly overrun forcing the garrison to retreat to the castle. Though much of the site was in ruins, the gatehouse was intact. Cromwell summoned the castle to surrender but was denied. Artillery was therefore brought up from Trowbridge and a battery of ten guns was set up in the market place, within pistol shot of the castle. The bombardment of both cannon and mortars began the next day and played on the castle all that day and night. One mortar shell even fell within the roofless keep, which was being used as a magazine, though it did not explode. This bombardment quickly persuaded the governor to discuss terms, and on the 23rd September the garrison surrendered.
Cromwell then left the brigade under Pickering’s command, and it was dispatched to Lacock House in Wiltshire. The garrison lay about twelve miles north of Devizes on the Chippenham road. It had been held at various times by either side, though the owners, the Talbots, were royalists and in the summer of 1645 Lacock was held for the King. The governor, Colonel Bovile, …
… considering that neither Bristol nor the Devizes were able to hold out against our force, did easily resolve that a Poore house was much less able; …. accordingly therefore upon the first Summons, he came to conditions to surrender …
Above: The Great Hall of Winchester Castle, showing (on the left) a fragment of the castle wall, in 1787.
The garrison duly marched out on 26 September. Two days later, the New Model brigade rejoined Cromwell, who was advancing on Winchester. The city, which still retained its Medieval defences, was well fortified. The garrison was based in the castle, which had been acquired as a home before the war by Sir William Waller, the early parliamentarian commaner. According to Hugh Peters, who walked around the the site after the surrender, the castle was heavily defended with six distinct works and a drawbridge … it was doubtless a very strong piece, very well victualled … as strong a place as any in England. Estimates of the strength of the garrison varied between five and seven hundred. On the 29th, in the face of unexpected resistance, the city was entered after the firing of a bridge or gate. The governor, Willam Ogle, the retreated with his troops into the castle. Cromwell wrote of these events:
I am come to Winchester on the Lord’s Day … with Colonel Pickering … After some dispute with the Governor, we entered the Town. I summoned the Castle, was denied, whereupon we fell to prepare our Batteries. …
Above: The Medieval West Gate of Winchester, viewed from inside the city, early in the last century. The castle was immediately to the left.
Within four days the gun batteries were ready, but soon after the barrage began a second sunmmons was refused. The next day there was a continual bombardment, with some two hundred shots being fired. This created a stormable breach, wide enough for the entry of thirty men abreast. However, during the night the royalist soldiers began to desert and the officers demanded a parley. As a result, on 5 October, Ogle surrendered. Only two or three of the parliamentarian forces were reported as lost during the siege. In fact, Cromwell probably gained more soldiers than he lost, as some of the royalist troops enlisted with the New Model Army. With Winchester taken, the whole of the ‘West’, or ‘Wessex’, was in parliamentary hands, though not yet the far south-west of Devon and Cornwall.
Further Royalist disasters followed fast. In Scotland, three days after Bristol fell, Montrose suffered a crushing and decisive defeat at Philiphaugh. David Leslie had a significant supremacy against him in cavalry and was reinforced by seasoned troops from Leven’s army in England. Their treatment of the Irish as sub-human was common to the English and the Scots, and in this case had the full blessing of the Scottish parliament. Montrose himself made his escape, but his hopes of doing the King further service were vitiated by the mutual emnity between the Huntly and the Gordons and himself. Not knowing of his Scottish champion’s defeat, Charles set off for Chester from Raglan on 18 September, hoping once more to join forces with Montrose. The city was under siege but open from the south, and he still had Langdale’s northern horse to screen him. But on 24 September, the day after the King’s arrival in Chester, the Northern Association Horse defeated Langdale and the garrison forces.
Above: Kin Charles I, a copy of John Hoskin’s minature, probably painted during Charles’ captivity at Hampton Court. Note the contrast between this care-worn face and the familiar, idealised pre-war portraits by Van Dyck.
Charles was forced to go on his travels again, with little more than a bodyguard, and he found refuge in Newark on 4 October. By then garrison after garrison had fallen to detachments of the New Model in the west; Devizes, Lacock and Berkeley Castle. Meanwhile, Rupert was so desperate to clear himself that he and Maurice skirmished their way to Newark, defying the King’s orders not to enter the city. Charles refused to see Rupert, but he obtained a hearing before members of the royal council of war, sitting as a court martial. They cleared him of any lack of courage or fidelity, but found him guilty of ‘indiscretion’ in surrendering Bristol prematurely.
The order for him to leave the country was not enforced, and eventually a sort of reconciliation was effected, so that Rupert ended the war in Oxford, though without a commission. The contrast between Charles’ severity towards his nephew and best commander and his indulgence towards Goring, whom he never reproached for failing to come to his aid when ordered to do so, makes sad reading.
(to be continued…)
Sources:
Glenn Foard (1994), Colonel John Pickering’s Regiment of Foot, 1644-1645. Whitstable: Pryor Publications.
John Haywood et.al. (eds)(2001), The Penguin Atlas of British and Irish History. London: Penguin Books.
Austin Woolrych (2004), Britain in Revolution, 1625-1660. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
”The Last of England’. A painting of emigrants by Ford Madox Brown. ‘The White Cliffs’ can be seen in the background.
The Pursuit of Poverty – Labouring Poor of the British Isles:
In 1828, a man of Minster in Kent, told a House of Commons committee formed to investigate the continuing conditions of poverty and destitution that:
The convicts on board the hulks are a great deal better off than our labouring poor, let the convict be ever so bad a man. The convicts come on shore to work; they they do not work so hard nor so many hours as the common labourers, and they live better.
In the nearby parish of Ash, there was a regular meeting every Thursday, where the paupers were put up for auction and their labour sold for a week. It often happened that there was no bidder, however. The penury endured in every part of the British Isles stifled almost every human characteristic except one: the ability to have children. Both Ireland and the Highlands of Scotland were overpopulated. England, perhaps, was not: but, to many of those living in the cities, growing industrial towns and London suburbs, it seemed to be. The expatriate Briton in Australia had free convict labour. In India, he enjoyed the services of ‘coolies’. If he lived in the southern United States, he employed slaves. Back in the old country, however, there was a home-grown product. Too many people earning too little money provided an endless source of recruitment. The so-called lower orders had never had it worse: the middle and upper classes had seldom had it better. To the starving and dispossessed of the Isles, especially the Irish, America beckoned. Seizing this slender straw of comfort, many set out on what was surely going to be the worst journey of their lives.
Poverty and destitution in Ireland and Scotland were even worse due to the potato crop failures of successive decades. When the potato crop was sufficient, the Irish peasant existed. When it failed, as it did, from time to time, he starved. In 1828, for example, Cork had a population of 117,000, of which no fewer than sixty thousand were paupers, and of this number a third did not possess so much as a straw bed. In 1822, during a potato famine, matters became so bad that aid had to be brought in from England – even though, according to a writer in the Dublin Evening Post,
… the alarming fever of 1822, and the famine which succeeded it, did not arise from want of means to buy that food, for we were in possession of a vast quantity … The English subscriptions saved a million people, I have little doubt, by enabling them to purchase it.
If a landlord ejected his tenants there were only roadside hovels to shelter in.
The authorities fumbled for a solution. In the late eighteenth century, the Agricultural Revolution had already reduced the farm labourer’s staple diet to bread and cheese, washed down with tea or beer. He seldom saw meat, but some were able to grow potatoes in their cottage gardens. Thomas Mathus (born 1766), a mathematically-minded parson, realised what was becoming uncomfortably evident: there were just too many people in the British Isles. In itself, he argued, this was bad enough, but its implications might have been less serious if the output of the farms had been keeping pace with the birth explosion. According to Malthus, this was not happening. As he put it: Population increases in a geometrical and subsistence only in arithmetical ratio.
In other words, people multiply at a much greater rate than food is produced. The outcome, unless former was controlled, would be starvation and misery. Part of Malthus’ solution was to discourage marriage and any other relationship which might result in childbirth. He also deemed it wise to encourage individuals and families to emigrate. He regarded the colonies as a receptacle for excess inhabitants, and had a formula to back up his ideas. There were also a number of schemes which were capable of translating his notions into practical terms. The collection of reliable statistical information was only begun with the first decennial census in 1801, but this was a barely reliable source for contemporaries and historians alike until 1841. There were no reliable government figures relating to unemployment until 1921.
In addition, historians still argue about the validity of making qualitative judgements on the basis of quantitative evidence and vice versa. Modern students of history are often surprised by the the length of time it took nineteenth-century government to act in response to general problems in the population, or by the the limted nature of the intervention made. Modern citizens of liberal-democratic welfare states automatically expect governments to legislate in response to such problems, and even to be pro-active in identifying them, but in the early nineteenth century, the role of government was simply to rule. For His Majesty’s government this meant managing the affairs of the monarchy, seeing to the defence of the realm, conducting foreign affairs, creating revenue by collecting taxes and enabling local officials to keep the peace. In other words, it was to provide the necessary stability for society to function as it always had done. This was underpinned by the all-pervading ‘laissez-faire’ philosophy of the Georgian period. The antipathy of successive governments and parliaments to state intervention is all too evident in contemporary sources, as are the roles of crusading individuals and extra-parliamentary campaigning groups in promoting the economic and social reforms of 1830 to 1870.
Overcrowded hovels and near-starvation diet were common-place for agricultural labourers in the 1820s and early 30s.
Gradually, however, the enormity of the problems caused by Britain’s rapid industrialisation were recognised and state intervention increased to meet these needs. It is important to remember the contemporary context in which these interventions were made. To intervene in order to maintain social stability was quite in keeping with traditional government responsibility, but there was still a hotly contested debate about collectivism versus individualism throughout the period. By 1830, the symptoms of industrialisation were too pressing to be ignored. Following the Great Reform Act of 1832, the British government was persuaded to implement the recommendations of the Poor Law Commission Report in 1834. This was a response to the complaints of those whose responsibity to deal with poverty was centuries old, a response which cost the Exchequer little and for which it has been monumentally criticised for what it did not do. It was finally jolted into action by the rising costs of the local poor rates, but the conclusions it drew were to the detriment of the poor:
It may be assumed that in the administration of relief, the public is warranted in imposing such conditions on the individual releved, as are conducive to the benefit either of the individual himself, or of the country at large, at whose expense he is to be relieved.
The first and most essential of all conditions, a principle which we find universally admitted, even by those whose practice is at variance with it; is that his situation on the whole shall be made really or apparently so eligible as the situation of the whole shall not be made really or apparently so eligible as the situation of the independent labourer of the lowest class. Throughout the evidence it is shown, that in proportion as the condition of any pauper is elevated above the condition of independent labourers, the condition of the independent class is depressed; their industry is impaired, their employment becomes unsteady, and its remuneration in wages is diminished. Such persons, therefore, are under the strongest inducements to quit the less eligible class of labourers and enter the more eligible class of paupers. The converse is the effect when the pauper class is placed in its proper position, below the condition of the independent labourer. Every penny bestowed, that tends to render the condition of the paupers more eligible than that of the independent labourer, is a bounty of indolence and vice. …
… We recommend, therefore, the appointment of a Central Board to control the administration of the Poor Laws; … To effect these purposes we recommend that the Central Board be empowered to cause any number of parishes which they may think convenient to be incorporated for the purpose of workhouse management, and for providing new workhouses where necessary …
The workhouse scene from Dickens’ Oliver Twist.
The passing an ‘Amendment’ to the Elizabethan Poor Law therefore ended ‘outdoor’ relief in individual parishes and transferred responsibility to ‘workhouses’ under the control of unions of parishes. These became dreaded and detestable institutions, run along the lines of prisons. Either a man accepted the puny wages offered by the self-righteous and well-fed farmers, or he committed himself to an establishment which, though it may have inspired some of the best of Dickens, had nothing else to commend it. The theory of ‘less eligibility’ which it was based on was that, if you made charity sufficiently unpleasant, nobody would want it. In Ireland, they did their very capable best to ensure that work workhouse conditions were even worse than those of the peasants’ hovels. One particularly vile aspect of the system was the splitting up of families. Writing in 1838, William Howlitt, author of Rural Life in England, wrote that:
… till the sound feeling of the nation shall have again disarmed them of this fearful authority, every poor man’s family is liable, on the occurrence of some stroke of destitution, to have their misfortune, bitter enough in itself, added the tenfold aggravation of being torn asunder and immured in the separate wards of a poverty prison.
The sexes were separated in workhouses.
The Report of the Royal Commission on the Poor Laws, and the Act which followed hard on its heels, contained weaknesses which severely limited their usefulness in dealing with poverty, or even with pauperism, in the second half of the nineteenth century. In the first place, the Royal Commission had concentrated too much of its attention upon a single problem, that of the able-bodied unemployed, particularly in rural areas, who it feared were being demoralised by ill-conceived grants of outdoor relief, as had happened in the Berkshire village of Speenhamland. It paid too little regard to the problems of those who were pauperised because of physical or mental ill-health, old age or loss of parents, although these probably constituted by far the largest proportion of those on relief. The important and complex problem of migration and settlement received only cursory treatment in the Report and was only modified in a few minor details by the Act, and the vital question of rating and the finance of of poor relief was dealt with in an entirely cavalier fashion.
No longer able to get outdoor relief, families had to go to the workhouses, where they would be clothed and fed. Children would also receive some schooling. In return, they would all have to work. However, the workhouse was more like a prison, and people dreaded being sent there.
Secondly, the reformers of 1834 focused their attention upon the problem of rural poverty, and produced the machinery to deal with it. The problem of the future was to be the far more difficult one of mass industrial unemployment and urban poverty. The poor law proved to be ill-adapted for dealing with poverty, and thus was increasingly ignored as a device for social reform. The oversimplified early nineteenth-century view of poverty was broken down into an investigation of its causes, and by changing attitudes towards it, a process which led to the introduction of new methods of treating poverty. The Old Poor Law, with its use of outdoor relief to assist the underpaid was, in essence, a device for dealing with the problem of surplus labour in the lagging rural sector of a rapidly expanding but still underdeveloped economy.
You could not throw surplus adults and children on to the scrap heap. The best idea, it was thought, was to send them overseas.
In their ‘methodology’, The Poor Law Commissioners of 1834 deliberately selected the facts so as to ‘impeach’ the existing administration. Not only did they fail in any way to take account of the special problem of structural unemployment in the countryside, but what evidence they did present consisted of little more than anecdotes. No attempt was made to take a census of the poor or to collate the information returned returned by the parishes. Instead, the Report contained an endless recital of ills from the mouths of squires, magistrates, overseers and clergymen. In this light, it was difficult for their reforming contemporaries to see the implementation of the new Poor Law as a blow for humanity, and they were cetainly ineffective in treating the roots of the problem and its mitigation. As the Georgian period came to an end and Britain entered the high-water mark of Victorian industrial production, migration, both internal and external, seemed to offer the solution to the problem of the surplus population.
Exodus? The Experience of Internal & External Migration:
Between 1821 and 1911, the total population of England, Wales, Scotland and Ireland grew from 20.9 million to 45.2 million. At the same time, the population of what have been described as ‘English-speaking neo-Europes’ also grew rapidly. These phenomena are connected: a significant proportion of the growing population of Great Britain emigrated, and these emigrants accounted over the century for a substantial part of the population growth of a number of states overseas. Emigration from the United Kingdom must not be detached from internal migration. Many Irish fled the famine in the 1840s to settle in the industrial west of Scotland, especially Clydeside, many Scots moved south into England, and many English people moved into the coalfield areas of South Wales. Whether they were migrating internally or emigrating, they were moving from a predominantly land-based ‘subsistence’ economy into an Atlantic and increasingly imperial economy based on industry, trade and commerce. Some emigrants sought to escape poverty, especially the rural Irish. But many more, especially the urban-dwelling English hoped for new and improved economic opportunities. Preferred destinations were the ‘Europeanised’ territories in North America, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand, where linguistic and cultural differences would be minimal and economic prospects attractive.
Internal migration in the British Isles: Those seeking to escape the poor wages and limited opportunities of rural regions could find far better conditions within urban Britain and its industrial regions.
Despite considerable emigration from all four countries of the British Isles, Wales was the only one of these home ‘nations’ to retain the whole of its natural increase as well as attracting major influxes from England in particular. As steam-ships replaced sailing ships and the railway revolution accelerated around the world, the coal from the valleys powered the growth of Britain’s global empire. The population of Scotland also grew, but less quickly than in England and Wales, from 2.1 to 4.8 million. Meanwhile, the population of Ireland rose 6.8 million in 1821 to peak of 8.2 million in 1841. Thereafter, it fell in every subsequent decade to 4.4 million in 1911, an overall decline of 35 per cent. This cannot be explained just by the dreadful mortality of the Great Famine, which caused a collapse in the Irish population in the 1840s; the different rates of emigration from the home countries was also a factor.
Nineteenth Century emigration from Brtain to British North America and the USA.
The overseas exodus was excessive as a proportion of the Irish-born population and substantial from Scotland, but also still significant from England. Only Wales increased its net in-migration rate. For some migrants, external migration was an alternative to, or an extension of internal movement. Official figures for emigration in the first half of the nineteenth century were not very reliable. Cabin-class passengers were rarely counted before 1863, and until 1853 no distinction was drawn between UK subjects and other nationals, and many European citizens travelled through Europe and across Britain en route to their overseas destinations. Nevertheless, a total tally of nearly seventeen million British and Irish emigrants is real enough.
Above: Some thought Roman Catholic priests in Ireland would oppose emigration because it would reduce their congregations. Instead, many encouraged their parishioners to go.
For people to move their homes overseas was a costly adventure. It was a fact of life that those most agreeable to emigrating would be those least able to afford the price. To suggest, for example, that a poverty-stricken Irishman could purchase a passage to America and still have enough in his pocket to pay for expenses at the other end, would be nonsensical. If people were to be encouraged to emigrate, the state would have to finance them. One plan, which struggled to find favour with Parliament in the early nineteenth century, suggested that funds for this purpose should be borrowed from the poor rate. In Scotland and Ireland, the landlords who wanted to clear their lands would be invited to contribute.
After four years the emigrant would be expected to repay the loan. Nobody was to be compelled to go, though Malthus insisted that anyone who refused should be denied poor relief. Others suggested that it would be better to use poor relief payments as an incentive to migration, however. In 1828, an MP named Wilmot Horton introduced a Bill to enable parishes to mortgage their poor rates for the purpose of providing for their able-bodied paupers, by colonization in the British colonies. The idea went further than merely providing passage money. Horton argued that they should be supplied with the capital goods to settle in the new lands: that, rather than become a burden on someone else’s purse, they should be able to create new and potentially affluent lives for themselves.
Horton’s bill was thrown out twice, before in 1832, the Minister for the Colonies, Viscount Goderich told the House of Lords that…
… he did not think that a necessity would rise for the Government going out of its way to afford pecuniary assistance to those persons disposed to emigrate, as the number of voluntary emigrants to the Canadas had considerably increased in the past year.
A Passage to The USA – Cobbett’s ‘Emigrant’s Guide’:
Emigration to the Empire certainly did continue throughout the 1830s, mainly as a means of escape from poverty, disappointment and frustration. Throughout these early years, the United States had come to be regarded as a sort of ‘Never, Never Land’ in this respect, where every street was paved with gold and where dreams came true. This was, of course, a good deal of rubbish, but the notion persisted well into the twentieth century. One of the people who furthered it was the controversial writer, William Cobbett. Despite his radical credentials, he was not thinking so much of the poor and destitute, as of the farmer and tradesmen, and his Emigrant’s Guide, which was published in 1829, was addressed to“The taxpayers of England”. Though he suggested that America was the best place for them, he also admitted that:
There is, in the transfer of our duty to a foreign land, something violently hostile to all our notions of fidelity: a man is so identified with his country, that he cannot, do what he will, wholly alienate himself from it.
It is hard to imagine that the starving labourer would have agreed with this, but in Cobbet’s opinion, the situation in England was sufficiently unbearable to bolster anyone’s will to violate “fidelity”. He wrote of the ‘deserving poor’ that hunger and rags, and filth, are now becometheir uniform and inevitable lot. For them, there was no hope. On the other hand,
… for the man who has some little money left; let him take a calm and impartial look at the state of things and let him say whether he sees any, even at the smallest, chance of escaping ruin, if he remain here.
He made a very compelling argument for moving home to the United States, dismissing Canada, because:
… the whole is wretchedly poor: heaps of rocks covered chiefly with fir trees. These countries are the ‘offal’ of North America; they are the head, the shins, the shanks and the hoofs of that part of the world; while the United States are the air-loins, the well-covered and well-lined ribs, and the suet. People who know of the matter frequently observe that the United States will ‘take’ our American colonies one of these days. This would be to act the wise part of a thief, who should come and steal a stone for the pleasure of carrying it about.
Although he had spent some time in New York and Long Island, Cobbett’s advice on how to get there was based on what seemed to him to be correct rather than the actual reality. Theoretically, there was everything to be said for travelling ‘steerage’, in the part of the ship above the rudder, where passengers travelled at the cheapest rate and by so doing, saved money for their expenses in America. While cabin class passengers paid between thirty-five and forty pounds, steerage passengers paid only eight pounds. On the other hand, he doesn’t seem to have realised just how bad conditions were in this section. For the mass of the people who were compelled to travel in this way, the voyage was a nightmare more frequently than not. For many, it meant death by disease.
Cobbett himself never suffered from seasickness and he had original and unscientific ideas. Women were more prone to the ailment than men and that servants, paying the penalty for belonging to an inferior class, were worst of all. He wrote that:
They will be more seasick than your wife and children… they will be a plague to you throughout the whole voyage.
Top: The travellers in steerage were responsible for bringing their own food on board. When it ran out, they bought fresh supplies from the Captain, often at outrageously inflated prices. Bottom: Emigrants at dinner. It was not enjoyed bx all the the travellers. Some were too ill, or had been too short of food to partake of it.
Cobbett argued that American ships were most likely to produce a quick and safe passage: largely on account of their more vigilant captains. In his opinion, which was not shared by the majority of emigrant passengers, they were rarely ill-tempered. Nevertheless he warned prospective passengers against ‘badgering’ him with silly questions, and to only speak to his crew in extreme necessity, since it interrupted their duties and they could rarely provide any useful information. The Emigrant’s Guide was merely one voice in a mounting pile of such literature. Though much of this was genuinely independent and sincere, some of the pamphlets put out by emigration agents were full of fake or fictional information, as were their advertisements. It was not uncommon for the hopeful traveller to be promised a passage in a ship ‘of the largest class’ , a ‘punctual departure’ and “every precaution … to promote the health and comfort of the passengers during the voyage.” When he arrived at the port of embarkation, however, he would find that he had bought his passage in a decrepit old vessel about half the size stated in the advertisement with filthy and inadequate steerage quarters and with a departure date often delayed by several days.
A deck scene in a typical emigrant ship. Passengers were advised not to waste the crew’s time by talking to them.
‘Confidence tricksters’ also got involved in fraudulant land settlement schemes in the new country. Farmers in Britain were sold what were said to be large and fertile tracts in California, but when they arrived they discovered that they had invested their life’s savings in a piece of desert. One trickster went so far as to invent towns in Texas, which he called Manchester, Brighton and Glasgow. Of course, none of them existed. The London Standard reported:
The emigrants who have already been induced to go out … declare they were deceived and that the country is unfitted for English settlers of the better class.
The Scots and Irish flight to British North America:
During the Napoleonic Wars, the local press in the Highlands took the view that people should be dissuaded from emigrating on the grounds that Highlanders would do better to fight in the wars rather than setting out on an opportunistic venture. In Ireland, some of the priests opposed it for fear that it would decimate their ‘flocks’ (though in many areas starvation was already doing that) and so did the shopkeepers, though few customers had much many to spend. Both the Scottish ‘crofters’ and the southern Irish peasants impressed the justices in the New World with their levels of motivation for hard work through owning their own farms. In this way, people were told who should go, and who should be left behind, where to go and how to get there.Those who advised them spoke from experience. They had been overseers and knew what it was arrive at a patch of virgin territory with nothing but an axe, a spade and a few days’ food. The grim voyage was a recent reality for them, and they understood how to overcome the dangers, discomforts and difficulties.
The newly-arrived emigrant in Canada often started their new lives by felling trees.
Canada was selected as the most promising destination for emigrants to British colonies, since it was the nearest one, and the passage was therefore cheaper. Unfortunately, however, Canada lacked the glamour of its neighbour. The United States was seen as an El Dorado: Canada, as Cobbett had suggested, was a place where you chopped trees and tried to come to terms with the generally unfriendly soil that was exposed by clearing. Nor had it the ready-made facilities of the USA where a coal miner, a cotton spinner or a factory hand could reasonably hope to find work. Up in Canada, it was literally a case of starting from the grass roots, and was therefore not a destination for those who lacked a pioneering spirit of endeavour and endurance. It was therefore difficult to persuade most ordinary people to go there. To most, south of the frontier was far more enticing.
Many Scottish emigrants went to Canada (originally known as British North America). They maintained their custom of observing the sabbath at home.
In 1815, an attempt had been made to re-direct to Canada a number of Scotsmen who were known to be planning to travel to the States. Each had been offered free travel, a parcel of land amounting to a hundred acres, and free food while he was preparing his farm. Since it was obviously possible that a number would accept the passage, and then travel south to the States, there had to be some safeguard that they would settle. Applicant had to satisfy the authorities about their characters, and each had to deposit twenty-six pounds (plus an additional two pounds for those who took their wives). If they remained in Canada for two years, the money was returned to them. Seven hundred and fifty took part in their first emigration. By the end of 1816, the number had reached 1,400, and then the scheme expired from lack of money and enthusiasm. After that, there were no more hand-outs except to a dribble of discharged soldiers.
Ireland had been described as “the wound in Britain’s side”. If anyone wanted something to worry about, he could always turn his mind to this ill-fed and unhappy community. Indeed, it seems strange that the country had to fight so hard and so long for Home Rule. Considering its record in the nineteenth century, one might have imagined that Britain would have only been too grateful to be rid of it. In 1823, poverty and over-population, as always, the twin nightmares in Ireland. To relieve both of them, an emigration scheme was devised for active and industrious men on a system which will best ensure their immediate comfort, their future prosperity. Peter Robinson, the brother of the Chief Justice of Upper Canada, was put in charge of it. The first party sailed from Cork for Quebec in the ship Hebe on 8 July of that year. When they arrived, every male emigrant between the ages of eighteen and forty-six was given a ‘location ticket’ for seventy acres of land, plus an assortment of essential farming implements and the guarantee of a free supply of food. If they worked well for ten years, each had the option to purchase a further thirty acres for the moderate sum of ten pounds. At first, opposition came from the Catholic priests, but a number of them then welcomed the scheme and encouraged their parishioners to take part in it.
The Hebe was followed by the transport ship Stokesby. All told, 568 went, of whom 182 were men, 143 women, 57 boys aged fourteen to eighteen, and 186 children under the age of fourteen. After they had been settled, at a total cost (including the crossing) of twelve and a half thousand pounds, Peter Robinson returned to Britain to work out a further scheme of this kind. With him, he took a number of letters from the settlers, including one from Michael Cronin to his mother:
We sailed from the cove of Cork on the 8th July and arrived in Quebec on the 1st September. We had a favourable voyage and as pleasant as ever was performed to this country and as good usage as any person could expect. Then from Quebec to Montreal we came in a steamboat, that is, as I am informed, 180miles. From Montreal, we came nine miles in wagons to a barracks called La Chingonly, and from thence to Prescott in boats, which is 130 miles. From Prescott we came to a place where we all encamped this month back. …It was on Thursday last that I made out my own farm, and as my own judgement I take it to be as good a farm as any the country. … Mr Robinson, our superintendent, is uncommonly humane and good to us all. He at first served us out bedding and blankets and all kinds of carpenters tools and farming utensils … Mr Robinson promises us a cow to the head of each family next spring … Since we came on shore, each man is served out in the day with 1lb. bread or flour and 1lb. beef or pork and each woman, boy and girl get the same.
Not every voyage from Ireland was as pleasant an experience as Michael Cronin’s. In 1834, the Montreal Advertiser reported:
We have frequently heard the character of emigrant ships from Ireland declared to be worse than that of those concerned in the slave trade of Africa.
However, one cannot help feeling that the expedition might have done better to have set off earlier in the year. With the Canadian winter approaching, the settlers obviously felt the cold. As one wrote to a friend who intended to follow him:
I press upon you the necessity of bringing with you plenty of clothes both for bed and body, for that is our greatest want in this country.
One of Robinson’s party also warned of the dangers of ‘drink’, suggesting that his brother should not to come to the country if he would not resolve to work better than he did at home. … If he would keep from the drink, he might do well. Rum was very cheap and a great many of our settlers like it too well, which may prove their ruin, for a drunkard will not do well here. One day, when the Irishmen had been enjoying too much rum, one of their number picked a quarrel with a party of older Scottish settlers, resulting in shots being fired and four men being convicted for riotous behaviour. They were each sentenced to two months’ imprisonment and fines of ten pounds. But accounts of the affair became hopelessly exaggerated. There was talk of a complete breakdown of law and order within the Irish settlement. It was reported that their neighbours had organised a petition against any further schemes. Robinson’s response was forthright:
… the disturbance was … by no means calculated to injure the character of the emigrants as settlers … no man can answer that quarrels may not occur – and that there may not be sundry broken heads. No doubt, their children, growing up in the habits of the country, will be more laborious.
All in all, the sheme was considered to be a success, and another was planned for 1825. Within a week of the new project’s announcement, over fifty applications had been received from heads of families, each of whom insisted that he could be ready to sail at an hour’s notice. To the authorities in Ireland, it brought renewed hope. As Wilmot Horton said, Employment is a certain cure for the disposition to riot so generally prevalent among the people of the South. Meanwhile, in Canada, the battle against nature continued. In 1824, the Canada Company had been founded, one of its objects was to create settlements on a large tract of country owned by the Crown. The Colonial Office, which moves throughout this period with a conspicuous lack of distinction, refused to release any funds for the the purpose. By 1827, after a great deal of argument, the company had been allowed to take over 1,100,000 acres on the shore of Lake Huron plus a further 829,430 acres of Crown lands. The territory was to be paid for over a period of sixteen years. Since the land bordering on the lake was entirely uncultivated, the company was allowed to spend one-third of the purchase money on such public works as bridges, roads, churches, schools, etc.
As the Canada Company found, the system of granting land in Canada was never simple. According to an Act of 1791, one-seventh of all the territory disposed of had to be reserved for the support of Protestant clergy. To make things more complicated, a further seventh was reserved for the Crown. Thus, before anything could be accomplished, two-sevenths of the acreage had to be put aside for the Establishment. It was just the kind of situation that many emigrants had fled England to escape. The land lay idle until 1854, when the clergy reserves were taken over by the municipal authorities. When the British Government was unable to deal with poverty on its own doorstep, it was, perhaps, not surprising that it showed such tardiness in dealing with land issues thousands of miles away on the other side the ocean.
The Victorian Age and the Coming of Steam Power:
Above: Launch of the SS Great Britain. Designed by one of the greatest engineers of the day, Isambard Kingdom Brunel, and launched at Bristol in 1843, the Great Britain was the first screw-driven boat iron ship to cross the Atlantic. It was a symbol of Victorian Britain’s commercial and technological might.
Initially, almost every port in Britain, especially those on the west coast, dispatched emigrants, sometimes in dangerously fragile vessels with insanitary conditions onboard. By mid-century, however, the development of steamships and government regulation speeded up the journey times, reduced costs, increased safety margins and led to the conentration of the emigration trade in certain large ports. Such improvements alone encouraged more traffic. Moreover, because of the greater size and capital expenditure required to operate modern vessels, the emigrant trade came to be regarded as the province of large companies like Cunard, White Star, Anchor and P&O, operating out of ports like Glasgow, Liverpool, Southampton and London. The Cunard Steam Ship Line was founded in 1840, with four steamers, each of 1,150 tons, and American competition in the shape of the Collins Line followed shortly afterwards. Steam, which had transformed factories and railways on land, was now making its mark on the ocean. Captains no longer had to wait for a favourable breeze: regular sailings became possible, and the time for the tranatlantic crossing was cut to between ten and fourteen days. But due the vast difference in cost, it took another three decades or more for this revolutionary form of power seriously impacted the emigrant trade, three decades in which the North Atlantic nightmare continued.
Regular and faster sailings started in 1840s with the first steamships.
The reign of Queen Victoria (1837-1901) was one of the most extraordinary periods of transformation in British history. At the beginning of the era, Britain was the sole mechanised industrial society of the world, embarking on a period of free trade that would help for a time to sustain its position. The British financial services sector had emerged, greatly helped by the globalising tendencies of new technology, by the scale of British overseas investment, and by the strength of shipping and commerce. In 1837, the British railway industry was still in its infancy, but by 1850 over 10,500 kilometres of railway had been constructed, completing an extensive network which sped up the internal transport links to the ports, making emigration easier from all parts of Britain.
As the Victorian ‘Age’ began, the British Empire not only continued to grow, develop and diversify, mainly through emigration, but it also evolved politically, at least in some territories. This was ‘sparked’ by a rebellion in Canada in 1837, where discontent arose both in the area consisting of the old French Province of Quebec and the settlement of the United Empire Loyalists in Upper Canada (see the sketch-maps below). This discontent arose because the provinces’ assemblies were overruled by the Governors and their officials, who were always Englishmen appointed by the Colonial Office in London. The national, ethnic and class differences between the Parliament of Lower Canada and the British officials increased the friction, while in Upper Canada a group of privileged families, termed the ‘Family Compact’ monopolised power. A further cause of discontent was the privileged position of the Anglican Church, with land set aside in each province for the clergy. This was resented in Lower Canada in particular, where the population consisted mainly of French Catholics. The rebellion in each province was easily suppressed, but the Whig Government determined to investigate the causes. Lord Durham was appointed as commissioner and, with the help of his secretaries, Gibbon Wakefield and Charles Buller, produced a report, published in 1839. This recommended the union of the two provinces and the introduction of representative self-government. This was the origin of ‘dominion status’, under which domestic affairs were left to local elected governments, while foreign relations remained the concern of Britain.
The Durham Report also looked forward to the unification of all the provinces of British North America and, as a stimulus to economic development and integration, it urged the construction of a transcontinental railway. The Canada Reunion Act of 1840 carried into effect the first provision of the Durham Report and united the two provinces under one Governor-general and one assembly, composed of equal representation from each province. The other recommendation was applied by Lord Elgin, Lord Durham’s son-in-law, who, as Governor-general, adopted the practice of choosing ministers from the party which had a majority in the Assembly. The maritme provinces also gained responsible self-government in the 1840s.
Meanwhile, the generally rising trend of the previous decades was lifted by a surge in emigration, especially from Ireland, in the 1840s, where the potato famine of the 1840s caused the death of more than a million people and further stimulated the mass emigration of Irish people across the Atlantic and elsewhere. Already by this time, those born in Britain and Ireland could be found in virtually all parts of the world. Overwhelmingly, emigrants were attracted to temperate regions, but some settled in the more environmentally challenging tropical territories of Asia and Africa. What is striking is that there was a gradual shift in destinations. Initially, most of those setting off voluntarily were bound for British North America (later Canada) or the USA, but as the century neared its end and the Empire grew, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand offered viable alternatives. Convention suggests that it was poverty that motivated early nineteenth-century migrants to move. In rural areas, population growth, fierce competition for land, low wages industrialisation and urbanisation did indeed push many to migrate. Other factors included the decision of some landowners, in the Gaelic-speaking Highlands and Islands, to clear their lands of crofters to make room for sheep. Disease, most notably the potato blight, which affected much of Ireland and parts of Scotland in the 1840s, was another important ‘push factor’, together with the resulting famine.
The middle years of the nineteenth century saw a big increase in the number of people leaving Britain to seek their fortunes overseas. This was no easy undertaking. The journey across the Atlantic was dangerous, extremely uncomfortable and very long. Compared with modern ocean going ships, the wooden sailing ships, in which most emigrants still travelled, were light and small. The majority of passengers travelled in the space between decks known as the ‘steerage’. When Charles Dickens made his tour of North America in 1842, he returned to England in a sailing ship. One hundred people were crowded together in what he called the “little world of poverty” of the steerage accommodation. Nearly all were returning from luckless attempts to conquer America, or at least to come to terms with it. Some has spent only three months there.
A number were going back defeated, in the very same ship that had taken them over there. Nearly all were in the terminal stages of poverty. Since their fares on this ship did not include food, a pitiful few were forced to live off the charity of the other steerage passengers. Dickens wrote of these ‘scavengers’:
If any class deserve to be protected by the Government, it is that class who are banished from their native land in search of the bare means of subsistence.
But these were the minority, perhaps the submerged tenth of unemployables. The majority of those who travelled to the United States in the first half of the nineteenth century found the country very much to their liking. They particularly liked the outlook which insisted that one should be “courteous, but never servile.” After traditionally touching their forelock so many times to a self-important English squire, it made a pleasant change. The USA’s advantage over Canada was that it catered for the emigrant town-dweller. One happy little success story is told in a letter written by an emigrant in New York State to his father in Kent, and quoted in Cobbett’s The Emigrant’s Guide:
Philip is apprentice to a tin-worker in the city; Henry is apprentice to a hatter, about thirty miles from New York; Joseph is gone with James to Albany; Josiah has got a place as hostler about seven miles from the city; I live … not more than five or six rods from Mr Selmes; they are great friends to us; we borrow anything that we want to use of them.
The witer was learning the trade of carpentry and appeared to be doing well for himself:
The labouring people live by the best of provisions; there is no such thing as a poor industrious man in New York; we live more on the best of everything here, because we have it so very cheap.
Another wrote to his children that …
… people are a great deal more friendly than they are, or can be, in England: because they have it not in their power as they have here; for we are all as one, and much more friendly.
The United States of America had been established, though the drive to the West had not yet begun: in the east, the trees had already been cleared away – there were industries, harvests and fine buildings. The cost of everything was far less than in England and for those who were not up to the the task of immigration, there were workhouses where a man could exist during winter before being shipped back to Britain in the spring, like those who accompanied Dickens on his return from the USA. Land was certainly not to be had for nothing, but a man could get a job, work for a few years and then purchase his plot outright, or rent it. Cobbett quoted an emigrant from Sussex, writing to his parents that he had a good house and garden, ninety rods of ground, and some fruit trees, for twenty-five dollars a year. Another of Cobbett’s ‘witnesses’, of a more devout turn of mind and phrase, observed:
We are in a land of plenty, and, above all, where we can hear the sound of the Gospel. The gentleman that we were working for has preaching in his own parlours, till he can build a chapel; it is begun not a quarter of a mile from where we live – and may poor sinners be brought to Christ; for here is many that is drinking in of sin, like the ox the water.
Emigrants arrived in New York, initially as their last resort from poverty, dispossession and the hungry. However, by mid-century many were more hopeful of making their fortune, also having more to lose to a variety of tricksters at the ports and further inland.
In New York, there was plenty of ‘drinking in of sin’, much of which was designed to rob the immigrant of his senses, followed by his savings. What seems to be certain, however, is that in the United States, an industrious, thrifty and sober immigrant could maintain his family in better style from three days’ work a week than he could by working six days a week in Britain. As everybody agreed, the two most important things were not to hang about in New York, and to get a job as quickly as possible. Some immigrants turned out to be woefully lacking in initiative. On one occasion, Cobbett was irritated by two passengers who had travelled in the same ship as him. One was a tailor: the other a collar-maker. A month after landing, both men called to see him at his lodgings on Long Island:
Perceiving them to be still as meanly dressed as they were upon going from the ship, I asked them what they had been doing. They said they had been doing nothing: I was surprised, and asked them whether people had left off wearing coats, and horses, harness. They said … they could not get as high wages as others got … I advised them to go by all means, and accept the terms offered by the masters; and told them that, at any rate, I had nothing to bestow upon men, who could, if they would … save 25s. 6d. a week.
By the mid-1840s, Britain may have been more prosperous than ever before, but Ireland, always poverty-stricken, was devastated by the ravages of the potato blight in 1845 and 1846. The disease, which crossed the Atlantic from the USA in 1845, reducing the staple food of the Irish to a black, rotting mush. Ireland was used to disasters of this kind, but this was unquestionably the worst. During the next two years, nearly seven hundred thousand people died, either from starvation or from disease brought on by the famine. Following this disaster many of those who survived were prompted to leave their country for good. About two million people left Ireland between 1845 and 1855. Some emigrated with state assistance. In 1846, 43,439 Irish men, women and children set off for Canada, and this figure increased to 109,680 in the following year. Many of them never arrived. According to one estimate, no fewer than 17,445 died on passage from fever following malnutrtion. The Home Secretary, Sir George Grey, had to tell Parliament that the Government had received accounts of the most deplorable sufferings endured by the emigrants. This was not due to callousness: it was simply that nobody had ever envisaged an exodus on so enormous a scale.
The Famine and the ‘Fever’ Ships of the 1840s:
The system broke down. Something like seven hundred vessels a year were leaving the English and Irish ports in a westerly direction. They were all crammed beyond capacity with starving emigrants, and it became impossible to find enough surgeons to go round. Many ships had to go without, and the already inadequate regulations had to be relaxed still more. The hygeine in steerage, never of a high standard, became atrocious. According to one eyewitness, …
No cleanliness was enforced, and the beds were never aired. The master during the whole voyage never entered the steerage, and would listen to no complaints; the dietary contracted for was, with some exceptions, normally supplied, though at irregular periods. … The case of this ship was not one of peculiar misconduct; on the contrary, I have received from very many emigrants well known to me, that this ship was better regulated and more comfortable than many that reached Canada.
The Leaving of Liverpool: Emigrants departing.
The Irish made up the bulk of the people leaving the British Isles during these years and the greater part of them decided to settle in the USA. Rather than leaving from Cork, as they had done in the 1820s and ’30s, by the 1840s, the first stage of the emigration journey of most Irish emigrants was the eastward journey across the Irish Sea to connect with the big steamers leaving Liverpool to cross the Atlantic to New York or Quebec.
Men, women and children were herded indiscriminately together in very cramped conditions. Most berths were less than two metres square and were intended for four people. Lieutenant Hodder, an emigration officer, explained the sleeping arrangements to a House of Commons Select Committee:
Q: The single men and women all sleep alongside of one another … ?
Hodder: Yes, there is no privacy whatever.
Q: But supposing an emigrant comes and finds that there is no room onboard the vessel, except in a berth holding four, one half of which is already occupied?
Hodder: He would have to go into that; his contract is, that he shall have eighteen inches space.
Q: And if that is occupied by a married couple, the emigrant, whether a single man or a single woman, would be put into that berth alongside the married couple?
Hodder: I do not see anything to prevent it.
The shipbrokers’ object was to cram as many passengers on board as humanly (or inhumanely) as possible.
Bad weather made conditions in the steerage far worse. In 1849 an ex-sailor called Herman Melville wrote a novel, Redburn, His First Voyage, in which an emigrant ship met stormy conditions in the Irish Sea:
That irresistable wrestler, seasickness, had overthrown the stoutest of their number, and the women and children were embracing and sobbing in all the agonies of the poor emigrants’ first storm at sea … How then, with the friendless emigrants, stowed away like bales of cotton, and packed like slaves in a slave ship; confined in a place that, during storm time, must be closed against both light and air; who can do no cooking, nor warm as much as a cup of water; for the drenching seas would instantly flood their fire in their exposed galley on deck? We had not been at sea one week, when to hold your head down the fore hatchway was like holding it down a suddenly-opened cesspool.
The Steerage: Conditions were abominably overcrowded, despite the Passenger Acts designed to improve them.
Seasickness was at the milder end of the sectrum of sickness and disease encountered onboard by emigrants. In 1847, the Brutus put out from Liverpool with 330 emigrants on board. On the ninth day of the voyage, a man in his early thirties, who had seemed to be perfectly fit, went down with cholera. He was given rough and ready treatment and, strangely enough, recovered. But, by this time, an elderly woman of sixty had become infected. She died ten hours after her first symptoms. More cases broke out and more deaths followed. On one day alone, there were twenty-four casualties, but the captain showed no intention of putting back to port. He held on until, at last, the crew became infected. This was too much: he went about and returned to the Mersey. By the time the ship dropped anchor in the river, there had been 117 cases: eighty-one had died and thirty-six were still on the danger list. In another vessel, when typhus broke out, a young Scotsman saw fifty-three corpses, including those of his mother and sister, thrown unceremoniously into the sea. He wrote afterwards:
One got used to it. It was nothing but splash, splash, splash, all day long – first one, then another. There was one Martin on board, I remember, with a wife and nine children … Well, first his wife died, and they threw her into the sea, and then he died, … and then the children, one after another, till only two were left alive. The eldest, a girl of about thirteen who had nursed them all, one after another, and seen them die – well, she died, and then there was only the little fellow left.
Emigrant ships of the mid-1840s became known as “fever ships”. Disease, mostly typhus, was rife on board
Contagious diseases spread like wildfire among the steerage passengers. The most common was ship fever, or typhus, from the Greek for ‘mist’ which describes the vague mental state of the patient. It was a disease transmitted by lice. In 1847, when more emigrants died at sea than in any other year during the nineteenth century, seven thousand passengers died of the fever before reaching America and many more died soon after disembarking. Terry Coleman, in Passage to America, gives a description of the disease:
Typhus is a disease of the blood vessels, the brain, and the skin.The onset is sudden. The symptoms are shivering, headache, congested face, bloodshot eyes, muscular twitchings, and a stupid stare, as if the sufferer were drunk. … The skin becomes dark, and sometimes the illness was called black fever. About the fifth day a rash comes out, and the delirium becomes a stupor. It is a disease greatly encouraged by starvation, dirt, and overcrowding.
Above: Grosse Isle in the St. Lawrence River, Canada where there was a quarantine station for emigrants
The ‘fever ships’ as they became known, arrived one by one in the St Lawrence, queuing to be allowed to complete their journey to Quebec. With the coming of the thousands of sick and famished Irishmen, the quarantine facilities on the small island of Grosse, originally created in 1832 to cope with an outbreak of cholera, were stretched beyond their limit. The ice on the St Lawrence had lasted until April in 1847, and it was not until 4 May that the quarantine station was opened for business. Its staff amounted to one steward, one orderly and one nurse. In the hospital, there was room for two hundred patients. The first fatality occurred on 15 May, when a little girl aged four died of typhus. By 28 May, there were 856 fever and dysentery cases on the island and a further 470 still onboard the ships. In addition, there were twenty-six more vessels and thirteen thousand passenger waiting in the river to be inspected. The Army provided eight marquees and 266 bell tents; but, owing to the risk of infection, no soldiers were allowed to erect them. In those tents that could be erected, the patients were dying by the dozens. They included some of the captains of the waiting ships. According to one witness, in one night, there were eleven deaths, while sixty more cases were admitted and three hundred others waiting to be admitted. There were 2,500 cases at the time with hundreds of others on the waiting ships.
Most of the casualties died of typhus, brought on board the ships by lice. If Grosse Isle was an inadequate reception status, the facilities for dispatching them from the the British and Irish ports were non-existent. If they had been washed and disinfected, it might have been a very different story. The situation among ‘the Irish poor’ on departure was summed up in a petition to the House of Lords, delivered with eighty-six signatures on the document, which read:
In times past the poor of this country had large gardens of potatoes, and as much conacre as supported them for nearly the whole year, and when they had no employment from the farmers they were working for themselves, and when they had no employment they had their own provisions; but now there are thousands and tens of thousands that have not a cabbage plant in the ground; so we hope that ye will be so charitable as to send us to America, and give us land according to our families and anything else ye will give us (and we we will do with the coarsest kind). We will repay the same, with the interest thereof, as the Government will direct.
But what they found was another form of hell. When the epidemic was over, a monument was erected on the site of Grosse Isle’s main cemetary. One side had the following word engraved on it:
In this secluded spot lie the mortal remains of the 5,424 persons who flying from Pestilence and Famine in Ireland in the year 1847 found in America but a Grave.
The Transformation of Britain & The British Abroad:
The British Isles contained a fat core of industrial prosperity and a periphery of poverty. The plight of the Irish was terrible, but that of the Highlanders was scarcely better. The blight which had stricken the Irish potato crop moved onto the Scottish Lowlands, where it inflicted damage estimated at fifty thousand pounds. By early September, it had reached the Orkneys. Since about half of Scotland lived on potatoes for nine months of the year, it was obvious that conditions were going to become very bad indeed. When Westminster was asked for help, the reaction was “let them eat oats”. But the Rosshire farmers had been making a handsome profit out of selling grain to the English and they were determined to go on doing so. They even asked for military protection to ensure that their convoys to England were not pillaged by starving peasants. The authorities, seemingly insensitive to the plight of the majority, provided it. By 1849, three thousand people in Western Ross were on relief, together with five thousand on Skye. Many families were living on hand-outs from emigrant relatives. The situation was not helped by the despatch of Irish reinforcements to quell the growing number of food riots.
The sad fact of the matter was that nobody wanted the Highland crofters any longer. The big landowners realised that sheep farmers paid two or three times as much rent as crofters, and they paid punctually. When there was a war, the Highlander was a fine warrior, and he was much in demand, but in peace-time, he cluttered up good grazing land, and was better off elsewhere. Already, during the first three years of the nineteenth century, ten thousand of them had left for Nova Scotia and Upper Canada, turned out of their homes by harsh ‘lairds’ keen to make a profit from sheep-farming. William Huskisson, Governer-General of British North America, had witnessed the arrival of the brig Jane, in 1826, with the observation:
I really do believe that there are not many instances of slave-traders from Africa to America exhibiting so disgusting a picture.
The vessels had grown larger than then; but, as the Irish emigration had also shown, there had been little or no improvement in the quality of accommodation onboard. Some of the Highlanders went to Ireland to obtain passages overseas, but many embarked at the small port of Ullapool in Western Ross, the highway to which became known as “Destitution Road.” When a Highlander agreed to sail, he deposited half his passage money. If he was unable to do this, he sold his property to the agent at the latter’s evaluation. He then went back home and waited until the passenger list was filled up and the broker was able to charter a vessel. This usually took several months during which time the agent took care of everything. He gave advice about how much food to take for the journey; he was even prepared to sell the necessary supplies. In selling a stone of potatoes, he could add significantly to his already substantial profits. Like most other emigrants in the early and mid-nineteenth century, the Highlander was steadily fleeced from the moment of his first encounter with the agent, until the time he reached his destination. It was all tremendously sad, since the Highlanders had known nothing else but their homes and the countryside around it. Many of them could not speak any English. Since the crews seldom spoke any Gaelic, communications were difficult. Less surprising, perhaps, in view of the near-starvation level of life at home, was the fact that many of the children had never seen a plate before, and few knew how to use knives, forks and spoons. As John Prebble wrote in The Highland Clearances, …
The Highlanders were like children, uninhibited in their feelings and wildly demonstrative in their grief. Men and Women wept without restraint. They flung themselves on the earth when they were leaving, clinging to it so fiercely that sailors had to prise them free and carry them bodily to the boats.
An elderly Highland couple weep as an emigrant ship departs with the younger members of their family.
As the business of stripping humanity from the Highlands continued only the old, the sick and the unwanted were left behind. Death could be relied upon to solve this problem of the remnant of overpopulation, and to clear the way for the sheep. The rest were wrenched from their holdings and turned loose upon the colonies. During one season alone, emigration went through the Hebrides like a scythe and removed two thousand people.
Theoretically, the emigrants’ boat tickets entitled them to more than their passage across the Atlantic. By law, they were entitled to ‘water and provisions’ from the ship’s master, together with ‘fires and suitable places for cooking’. The provisions included weekly measures of bread and ‘Navy biscuit’; wheaten flour, oatmeal, rice, sugar, molasses and tea. In practice, however, many captains did not fulfil their obligations and many emigrants complained about the quantity and the quality of the food they received. In 1850 William Mure, the British consul at New Orleans, reported that passengers from Liverpool were being issued with condemned bread. Three years later an article in The New York Times told of steerage passengers being given coffee made with water from the Atlantic. Nor was that all, as it was reported in a letter from William More in 1850, that the captain of the Bache McEver …
… conducted himself harshly and in a most improper manner to some of the female passengers. … having held out the inducement of better rations to two who were almost starving in the hope that they accede to his infamous designs.
On top of everything else, the journey was long. From Liverpool to New York, the crossing of over five thousand kilometres took six weeks. The regular ‘packets’ sailed weekly and the average time for the westward voyage was thirty-eight days; the return trip, taking advantage of the prevailing winds, was only twenty-five days. The departure times of the emigrant ships depended on the whims of the captains, the weather and the number of passages booked. They were much slower than the packets, and between forty and fifty days was by no means uncommon. One vessel, from Belfast with 139 passengers, took sixty-six days. The passengers exhausted their own stocks of food and had to buy supplies from the captain. He only had potatoes to supply, and by the time the ship docked, these too had run out, so that there was no food on board at all. But the record for the longest crossing in time probably belonged to a brig named The Lady Hood which set sail from Stornaway in 1841 with fourteen families (seventy-eight people). The weather conditions were so bad that she took seventy-eight hours to make the crossing. Again, the passengers were in a sorry state from malnutrition which was popularly considered to be one of the reasons why so many emigrants went down with disease. They did not get enough to eat and the condition was aggravated by seasickness. On some ships there were said to have been women who, literally, starved to death.
Very few emigrants had any choice about the vessel in which they sailed: they seldom had the opportunity to inspect the hell-ship which was to be their home for several weeks. The old sailing ships struggled on across the Atlantic. In 1847, over a hundred thousand emigrants sailed to either Canada or the USA, and 17,445 of them died of disease in transit. At the height of the Irish potato famine in 1847, one observer remarked that it would have been better, in his opinion, have been more humane to have deprived them at once of life. Scottish emigrants from the Highlands and Islands had no more choice in the matter of transportation than either the abducted Africans before them. Many of the departures from the Hebrides were extremely distasteful, but none worse than the sailing of the vessel Admiral in 1851. The villain of the piece was the laird, Colonel Gordon of Cluny, an avaricious landlord whose instructions were simple: the maximum number of people were to be removed from his domain in the shortest possible time. To speed matters up, the colonel had asked the ship to be sent to Loch Boisdale in South Uist. The inhabitants of the island were assembled on the beach, and some of them were were put on board by physical force. According to a contemporary report:
One stout Highlander, Angus Johnstone, resisted with such pith that they had to handcuff him before he could be mastered. One morning during the transporting season we were suddenly awakened by the screams of a young female who had been recaptured in an adjoining house, she having escaped after her first capture. We all rushed to the door, and saw the broken-hearted creature, with dishevelled hair and swollen face, dragged away by two constables and a ground-officer.
Emigrating was a major step. The costs, emotional wrench (and, until the age of the steam-ship in the late nineteenth century, the dangers) could be considerable. It took severe conditions at home or attractive opportunities overseas to motivate migrants.
Elsewhere, convicts were exported. In the Highlands, living and breathing was crime enough for human beings to be removed by force. Nor had it gone unnoticed that there was far less illness among the shiploads of German emigrants than among those from Britain. The Germans kept their vessels clean and when their passengers came ashore, they looked clean and healthy, and the children were ‘well-scrubbed’. Although ‘Britannia’ might very well have ruled the waves, in the emigrant trade, she presided over a sewer. The authorities took long enogh about it, but in 1848 they published a list of twenty-two regulations for preserving order and cleanliness. Three or four “trusties” were appointed to enforce these as well as to represent the passengers in any complaints they may wish to make to the captain.
Push and Pull Factors in Migration:
In spite of pressure on wages and poor living conditions, the compulsion of rural poverty became less critical as a ‘push’ factor by the second half of the century. Nevertheless, a significant drift from the rural areas of the British Isles continued, whether to growing industrial areas such as south Wales, the North East and North-West of England, Belfast, Clydeside and central Scotland, or to the overseas colonies and dominions. Some of the internal migrants became involved in what has become known by demographic historians as ‘step’ migration, from rural areas to temporary residence in towns and ports and then on to distant places overseas. The men were mainly quarrymen, agricultural workers and farmers; the women were usually farm workers or domestic servants. In the USA, Canada, Australia and New Zealand they cleared land for farming, opened up the mines (including the gold mines), helped build the railways, created towns and, of course, produced children. They played a lesser role in southern Africa, where native black labour was exploited instead. Most of these later nineteenth century migrants, certainly those from England and Wales, were born in towns and were general labourers, but others, including many women, had industrial or ‘service-sector’ skills, as artisans, builders, mechanics, engineers, textile workers and, increasingly, shopkeepers, clerks and professional people. They may have felt anxious about their economic and social prospects in the British Isles, they were also positively attracted by the greater opportunities that were emerging in the ‘neo-Europes’.
The first sight of land was usually a moment for celebration.
Most emigrants were young, male and single, but there was also a steady flow of single female emigrants for whom employment and indeed marriage prospects appeared better than at home. Many single Irish women had emigrated to the USA from the 1820s, but the proportion of women migrants in general increased as overseas settlements became more established. When married couples emigrated, the husband sometimes went ahead to ‘set up’ with his wife and children following later, sometimes a considerable time later. Migrants usually followed a process of ‘chain’ migration, responding to information about opportunities relayed to them in letters by family or friends already overseas, or in conversation with those who had been there and returned. For many, such sources determined not only whether to go, but also where and when. In the latter half of the century, they no longer settled on rural frontiers in large numbers, but increasingly in towns such as Pittsburgh, Toronto, Cape Town, Sydney and Wellington. Especially after the American Civil War and the resulting Lancashire ‘cotton famine’, booming economic conditions across the Atlantic prompted further surges in emigration. These surges foreshadowed the the more rapid industrialisation and urbanisation of the USA, Canada and the other British dominions around the turn of the century, prompting increased flows in those directions.
In Canada, and particularly in the province of Quebec (or ‘Lower Canada’), the rush of immigrants in the 1850s made the English-speaking settlers more numerous than the French-speakers. Ethnic conflict therefore recommenced, and the immediate solution to this was seen to be in the separation of the two provinces for local matters. The Governor-general realised that this crisis also afforded the opportunity to form a union among the provinces of British North America. His proposals led to the passing of the British North American Act of 1867. The terms of the Act were:
(1) The creation of the Dominion of Canada, consisting of the four provinces: Quebec, Ontario, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia;
(2) Each province retained its separate Parliament to deal with local affairs;
(3) One Union Parliament was created for the whole Dominion, with more power than the local parliaments.
(4) Provision for the expansion of the union. British Columbia joined in 1871 on condition that a transcontinental railway was constructed (this was the Canadian Pacific Railway, completed in 1885, leading to the forming of the ‘prairie’ provinces in the region from Ontario to the Rockies).
The increasing ease and relative affordability of transport also allowed many more emigrants to return to Great Britain. Some of those who came back had failed to make good, but for others return had always been part of their prospect. They had responded at particular moments to perceived economic and social opportunities overseas by emigration, and returned when they had achieved their objectives or when the balance of advantage swang back towards home. They were part of an early international workforce. The net balance between immigration and emigration was strongly outward throughout the period, but the inward movements of returnees underlines the rational calculations which underpinned migration decision-making.
The Opening of the Great Exhibition
In 1851, on the first of May, the Great Exhibition opened in London. This was a display of every possible kind from all over the world. It was housed in the Crystal Palace, a massive structure of iron and glass designed for the occasion by Joseph Paxton and built in Hyde Park in a mere seventeen weeks. The Exhibition was a spectacular success. Over six million people visted it during the six months it remained open. Queen Victoria, whose ‘consort’ Prince Albert had worked unceasingly on the project during the months of preparation, wrote: I never remember anything before that everyone was so pleased with, as is the case with the Exhibition. The exhibits provided a dazzling display of human skill and ingenuity. They also highlighted Britain’s position in the world as the leading industrial nation. No other country could match the range of goods and machines displayed by British exhibitors. Together with the exhibitors from the colonies, they occupied half the exhibition area. For home visitors this was all very reassuring and if the USA’s display did not fill the space allotted to it they could afford to smile, along with Punch magazine, which published the following ‘jibe’:
By packing up the American articles a little closer, by displaying Colt’s revolvers over the soap and piling up the Cincinnati pickles on top of the Virginian honey, we shall concentrate all the treasures of American art and manufacture into a very few square feet, and beds may be made up to accommodate several hundreds in the space claimed for, but not one quarter filled by, the products of United States industry.
This ‘hubris’ reflects the general mood optimism which pervaded the mid-century. Yet, even if reluctantly, the exhibition-goers were being made aware of the plight of the people of the Hebrides. Shortly after the Great Exhibition opened, a letter appeared in The Times from “the Widow of a Highlander.” She suggested that…
… a table and chair be placed in the Crystal Palace near the refreshment rooms, occupied by some lady, with a money box, to ask for the superfluous pence which thousands of who daily visit … would gladly give. … there are few who would not cast their mite to arrest the messenger of death, now busy among the families of Highlanders.
Exhibitions continued to be held, almost on an annual basis, throughout the country. Britain’s future seemed bright, as the Illustrated London News put it in reporting the opening of the Exhibition: … we may reasonably anticipate, if no war arise … to destroy the auspicious work that has begun, that the next twenty years will afford us triumphs still more substantial and more brilliant than those we already enjoy. Developments in foreign trade during the next twenty years certainly justified these hopes. During this period Britain exported cotton and woolen goods, iron and steel, machinery, hardware and coal at a greater rate than ever before. The world demand for these goods was increasing and Britain, due to the industrial revolution, was able to supply them. She had taken advantage of of her contacts with a large number of foreign markets, so that her share of world trade was far greater than that of any other country.
In September 1851, the Skye Emigration Society had been founded by the Sheriff-substitute of Skye. Presently, the name was changed to the Highlands and Islands Emigration Society. The object was to procure help for those who wished to emigrate, but had no means of doing so by affording information, encouragement and assistance to all to whom emigration would be a relief from want and misery. Applicants for help were told that everything would be done to help them: but that first, they should convert all their possessions into cash. In deserving cases, the society paid the deposit on the passage and provided a suitable outfit of clothes. Eventually, it became the Society for Assisting Emigration from the Highlands and Islands of Scotland, with its offices in St. Martin’s Lane in London. The Prince Consort became its Patron, and the Governor of the Bank of England and several nobles were among its Committee of Management. A deserving case was described as one where the applicant would be a burden to the British community in the mother country but a support to it when transferred to the colonies. Peculiarly, therefore, some applicants were nearly refused aid because they looked too robust and insufficiently destitute to be deserving. However, the Society’s secretary was reminded that ‘the mother country’ had pledged herself to send healthy people abroad, and not to offload her ‘debris of weaklings’.
‘Fleecing’ the Migrants – The Ports of Departure & Arrival:
An Irish emigrant arrives at the dockside in Liverpool
Once granted assistance with the passage, the emigrating family still had to contend with the perils, not just of the ocean crossing, but with the brutal disregard for humanity and the roughest standards of honesty in the ports on either side of it. New York was as bad as the warnings the emigrants were given by the Emigration Society of the nation to which they belonged, but Liverpool, the chief port of departure from Britain to North America was little better. By the mid-nineteenth centtury, Liverpool had overtaken Bristol as England’s second largest city and one of the most prosperous. Southampton had yet to come into its own as a transatlantic port: most of the westbound ships sailed from the Mersey. Although emigrant ships sailed from the home ports, many Irishmen preferred to use Liverpool as the point of departure. They believed that the passages were cheaper, and they were certainly more frequently. They had arrived in the Mersey half-starved and more often than not after a rough crossing over the Irish Sea. They were poorly-dressed, often ill, and in trepidation about the journey ahead.
For many emigrants, arriving at Liverpool was a bewildering, sometimes frightening experience
The centre of the port city was graced with some fine neo-classical architecture, but behind it were acres of slums: mean and dirty streets where rats swarmed. One building which, appropriately, had once been the headquarters of the slave trade, was now taken over by opportunists intent on making the utmost profit out of the urge to emigrate, especially by Irishmen. It was a warren of mean little offices, peopled by shipbrokers, merchants, agents and other sophisticated sharks. Waterloo Road, a grey scar running past the perimeter of the docks, was another of their strongholds, full of pubs, eating houses and provision merchants for passengers in transit. There were also crumbling boarding houses, mean little shops, and the hang-outs of criminal characters – the whole squalid set-up conceived with only one thing in mind – to rob men and women who were already poverty-stricken. This dock-side robbery was made easier by the brokers’ lists of sailing dates, which was usually pure fantasy, used as a means of keeping the emigrants hanging around in Liverpool waiting for days if not weeks for their ship to sail. Embarkation in the emigrant ships at Liverpool, pictured below, there was no real hurry, since they seldom sailed at the times scheduled.
The passage itself was, however, cheap enough, but there was a world of difference between the standard of the of the cabin accommodation, in the region of forty pounds and that of a steerage berth, at a tenth of the cost. As we have already noted, the brokers made their money by cramming the steerage space to capacity and beyond, reducing humanity to the status of a factory commodity, packing the emigrants on board.
Those who were determined to ‘fleece’ the emigrants ranged from wealthy shipowners and their agents at the top to the ‘shysters’ at the bottom, the most vicious of whom were ‘the runners’. Both New York and Liverpool were infested with them. The ‘runners’ were at the bottom of the social scale. If the brokers and the boarding housekeepers were the whoremasters, the runners were the pimps. They were essentially thugs, but with sufficient intelligence to pose as a cross between a porter and an information officer. He would carry the emigrants’ luggage, recommend accommodation in which to pass the days before the ship sailed and even suggest shops where they might buy provisions for the voyage. Provided they took his advice and paid meekly for his services, they had nothing to fear. If they refused his advances, they would probably be beaten up. The pestering escort would also take his cut from the lodging house-keeper, the shops, and sometimes from the broker himself.
The agent (pictured left and right): the arch-villain of the piece.
Of course, the runner overcharged for his service as a baggage attendant. The boarding houses he vigorously recommended were little more than overcrowded slums. One place, originally licensed for nineteen guests, but at the height of the emigration boom, it was not uncommon to find ninety-two sleeping there. In another instance, thirty-two people were crammed together on the stone floor of a cellar without any bedding. The sexes were not separated, one man being crammed into a cubbyhole for several nights with four women. At most boarding houses, the rate was fourpence a night, and this only included sleeping accommodation. The rate at the Union Hotel, on the other hand, was one shilling, but all meals were provided. Another enterprise had been started in a converted warehouse on the initiative of two Roman Catholic priests. Bedding, blankets and a fire for cooking were available, and the itinerant visitors could even take baths. Naturally, the runners frowned upon these new, more enlightened places and threatened their proprietors with assault. Many of the runners ran protection rates throughout the city. There were attempts by right-minded persons to protect the emigrants against these villains, but they were ineffective and it was not always easy to discern which organisation was on the right side of righteousness. For instance, the Liverpool Emigrants’ and Householders Protective Society sounds wholesome and worthy, but it was, in fact, a front for a concealed parcel of rogues.
A Liverpool lodging house for emigrants
If, by some oversight of the Liverpool runner, the wretched emigrant still had some money on him when he first became an immigrant, the New York runners did their best to deprive him of it. The moment an emigrant ship had undergone its medical inspection by the quarantine officials, they swarmed aboard, powerful, foul-mouthed, desperate men against whom only armed force would prevail. Often eight or nine boatloads were rowed out to a vessel in the ‘roads’. In many cases, the ships’ captains were on their payroll, and instances were reported in which these gentlemen received anything up to three hundred dollars for giving a particular gang the exclusive concession to rob their passengers. In 1829, William Cobbett wrote that the boarding houses in New York were kept without an exception, by persons of unquestionably good character. By the mid-century, however, many of these establishments had come down in the world, morally as well as materially. The runners, of course, took a cut from the proprietors, and at the lowest end of quality of accommodation, there was a lice-infested workhouse on Long Island in which one of the leading shareholders was a Liverpool racketeer.
On landing at New York, the runners would be happy to shift luggage, a ticket to the interior, or to recommend a boarding house – at a price.
Few emigrants remained in New York itself, and the journeys into the hinterland provided untold possibilities for profit-making, the source of which was the sale of tickets for the inland canal journey. On the boat, conditions were as bad as they had been on the emigrant ships. In his Passage to America, Terry Coleman quoted the evidence of a witness given before a committee appointed by the New York in 1847. According to this man, they were crowded like beasts into the canal boat, and are frequently compelled to pay their passage over again, or be thrown overboard by the captain. There must have been times when the unhappy emigrant wondered whether the hell into which he was entering was not worse than the one from which he had fled.
Triumph over Adversity – Survival, Security & Integration:
Every year brought a sorrowful crop of disasters. Between 1847 and 1851, forty-four of the 7,129 ships which sailed from the UK to North America were wrecked, and 1,043 were drowned. In at least one case, the crew abandoned ship and left the passengers to their fate. The fact that the master was charged with manslaughter was poor compensation for the 196 men, women and children who were drowned. Two hundred and forty-eight people perished in 1847 when the Exmouth was driven ashore on the coast of Islay in Scotland; and 176 died within sight of land when the White Diamond Line’s Ocean Monarch caught fire and sank in the Mersey estuary, only a few hours after leaving Liverpool. An eye-witness described the terrifying scene:
The flames were bursting with immense fury from the stern and centre of the vessel. So great was the heat in these parts that the passengers, men, women and children, crowded to the forepart of the vessel. In their maddened despair women jumped overboard; a few minutes more and the mainmast shared the same fate. There yet remained the foremast. As the fire was making its way to the forepart of the vessel, the passengers and crew, of course, crowded still further forward. To the jib-boom they clung in clusters as thick as they could pack – even one lying over another. At length the foremast went overboard, snapping the fastenings of the jib-boom, which, with its load of human beings, dropped into the water amidst the most heartrending screams both of those onboard and those who were falling into the water.
In 1852, the UK Parliament finally passed a Passenger Act which began to regulate the conditions for passengers onboard the ships, ordering that all single men were to be berthed in a separate part of the steerage from families and single women. Three years later, the Americans attempted to improve the conditions of immigrants afloat. The new legislation passed by Congress in 1855 stipulated that only one passenger could be carried for every two tons of ship, that every passenger must have at least sixteen feet of space, and that the decks must be separated by at least six feet. A hospital had to be provided: the berths had to be sufficiently wide, and not more than two people were allowed to occupy each. There were also regulations about such matters as adequate ventilation, the provision of sufficient food and an efficient cooking range. Captains who did not comply with these rules were liable to fines of up to a thousand dollars and could be sent to prison for a year. A fine of ten dollars was also levied for every death that occurred on a voyage. In the same year, there was also a new Passenger Act in Britain, which was even more demanding than the American regulations in terms of space and maximum numbers. Two years later, the fruits of this legislation were apparent. Out of those who sailed to Boston, numbering 16,467, only twenty-two died; and of the 4,939 who departed for Philadelphia, there were only eight deaths.
For the time being, it was the British who continued to ‘rule the waves’ and to be ‘the Carryers of the World’, and the carrying trade was one area where Britain remained supreme in 1870 and thereafter. Even in 1890 there was more shipping registered in Britain than in the rest of the world put together. The bulk of these ships were steam-driven but the switch from sailing ships to steamships had been a gradual process. One reason for this was that sailing ships became much faster with the development of the ‘clipper’ ships like The Cutty Sark, launched in 1869. These were first built in the 1840s by the Americans who, for a short while, until the outbreak of the Civil War in 1861, had succeeded in taking over from the British the bulk of the Anglo-American carrying trade. The progress of the steamship was also delayed by the fact that, until the development of more efficient engines from the 1860s, the ships used vast amounts of coal. Once this problem was solved, the days of the sailing ship were numbered.
If Malthus had seen emigration as a solution to the problem of overpopulation, and Wakefield conceived of it as the keystone of Empire-building, various British governments seem to have regarded it as a desperate remedy for use in periods of crisis. When thousands were starving, state-aided passages to the colonies were produced as a panacea. At other times, the emigrants had to pay for their own fares. In any case, the remedy was insufficient – and, it nearly always came too late. The tardiness was understandable. If it had been possible to foresee an emergency, the resources could have been mobilised ahead of it. Once it struck, a well-ordered fleet of ships would have been ready to dispatch the sufferers and, at the end of the voyage, people would have been well-primed and prepared to receive them. Unfortunately, natural disasters, such as potato blight, seldom gave sufficient warning of their advent.
Above: Agents of the American railroad companies addressed meeetings in England to persuade restless citizens to settle on their lands as well as to travel on their trains to their place of settlement.
British Governmental interest in emigration, such as it was, was mostly concerned with the colonies. The United States, however, was still the favourite target of the emigrants. Even during the American Civil War, when a sizeable number of US citizens migrated to Canada, this trend continued. In 1853, for instance, a total of 329,937 British subjects departed for overseas. Of this figure, 230,885 went to the US, while 34,522 sailed to Canada. Between 1861 and 1870, seventy-two per cent of all British and Irish emigrants went there. After the war, the American railroad companies began their huge task of driving a steel highway to the west. Where the permanent way pointed, the settlers followed, and in their acquisition of great swathes of the United State, the railways always had land to spare. They not only needed people as potential customers, but were also prepared to dabble in real estate. The North Pacific alone sent eight hundred agents to Britain, and the Santa Fé set up the Anglo-American Agricultural Company with its headquarters in London. In 1869, an outfit masquerading as the American Emigrant Aid Society of London, went to the extent of organising a lottery, with a first prize of a free passage to San Francisco. The more general inducements were much higher wages than in Britain, and the fact that, unlike most of the colonies, the United States provided opportunities for town-dwellers. According to the superintendent of the American census in 1874, …
… in respect of their industrial occupation, the foreigners among us may be divided as those who are where they are because they are because they are doing what they are doing; and those who are doing what they are doing because they are where they are. In the former case, occupation has determined location; in the latter, location has determined occupations.
For some, the destination was perfectly clear. If you were a miner, and fed up with the conditions at home, you would head for Carbondale in Pennsylvania. This, as its name implied, was a centre for coal and anthracite. Indeed, when the first immigrants arrived there in 1827, they were expected to bring British expertise to work on creating something like a methodical system. Welshmen in particular made a success in settling there, and Welsh women established a local reputation for creating their neat and comfortable homes. The Welsh miners imported their own brand of industrial relations to Scranton in 1871, when two hundred of them went on strike. Since so few of the Irish emigrants possessed industrial backgrounds and skills, they were usually relegated to the work of labourers. They envied the Welsh and the English, who had trades, and were therefore, quite naturally, helping themselves to the better-paid skilled work.
At Scranton, thirty Irishmen decided to ignore the stoppage. Going to work as ‘blacklegs’ one day, escorted byby a militia, they were attacked by a phalanx of angry Welsh pickets and their wives. Shots were fired by soldiers, and two Welshmen were killed. Later, the Welsh retaliated and three Irishmen were killed. A meeting of Irish mineworkers afterwards condemned this premeditated assassination of Irishmen, resolving that there would be no more unity and fraternity with Welshmen in the future. Thereafter, the Pennsylvanian coalfields resounded to the melodious thunder of Welsh choirs. There were also National Women’s Welsh-American Clubs.
One of the results of the Civil War (1861-65) was a ‘cotton famine’ in Lancashire. Acting on the assumption that if the raw material could not be exported there must be a thriving industry in the country where it was grown, a number of mill workers decided to cut their losses and look for opportunities at Fall River, Massachusetts. It was the easiest mill town to reach from New York, and the boat which sailed nightly between the two became renowned for its background music of Lancashire accents and dialects. In this way, emigrants from the British Isles tended to form clusters, re-establishing their national and regional traditions in the ‘New World’. Since the United States was almost a classless society, they had to adjust their outlooks to mix with people they would never have associated with in Britain. As one of the upper-class Lancastrians admitted:
They were no longer the same men. (In Lancashire), their employers seldom or never spoke to them, and the workmen were rather glad, as they feared the communication would lead to a reduction in wages …In Lancashire it never entered their heads to introduce me to their employers. But when I met them in America, they instantly proposed to introduce me to the mayor of the city … These men were still workmen, and they did introduce me to the mayor as “a friend of theirs” in an easy, confident manner, as one gentleman would speak to another.
By and large, the emigrants were received with kindness when they reached their destinations, though much depended on the state of the local labour market. Labourers were nearly always welcomed. Skilled men who could fulfil a need were no less gratefully received.
When, on the other hand, they presented a threat to local talent, and when it seemed like they might force local craftsmen out of work by accepting lower wages, they became unpopular. In the United States, the belief that North America rightfully belonged to the North Americans of first and second-generation settlers, led to sporadic outbursts of opposition to newcomers.
Britain in the World of 1783 – The Economic Advantages of Empire:
In the course of the eighteenth century, Britain became the most prosperous trading nation in the world. Her most serious commercial rival was France. At the beginning of the century both countries held possessions in North America, the West Indies and controlled trading posts in West Africa and India, seeing these as vital to their prosperity. A bitter struggle developed as each country sought to obtain supremacy in Atlantic trade, leading to the Seven Years’ War of 1756-63. When peace was made at Paris, France not only accepted the loss of Canada, but also abandoned its claims to the lands east and west of the Mississippi. With Spain now her only rival in the area, Britain was clearly the dominant power in North America. Twenty years later, however, she too had lost all her North American colonies.
The colonial possessions of Britain were valuable both as a source of raw materials and food which could not be grown in temperate latitudes and as a secure market for the sale of ‘home’ manufactured goods. The extension of colonial territory had three important results for British industry: Firstly, the overall volume and share of trade increased; Secondly, new inventions were stimulated in order to meet the enlarged demand; Thirdly, the increased demand for manufactured goods provided a strong motivation to introduce methods of mass production into home industries.
The predominant position of British shipping in the commerce of the world and the power of the Navy to protect it gave Britain ‘command of the seas’ and the means to carry her goods safely all over the world. For three centuries after the discovery of the Americas there had been competition among the nations of Western Europe for sea-power and colonial wealth. Britain had struggled successively against Portugal, Spain, Holland and France. By 1783, when the period of competition came to an end, she was supreme on the seas and on the point of becoming the leading colonial and commercial nation in the world. They had all come to regard the the colonies as spheres of trade monopoly, useful sources of tropical products and precious metals, and as distant places to be settled and exploited for the benefit of the mother countries within what has come to be described a ‘mercantilist’ system. This led to friction, not only with their rivals, but also with the colonies themselves, and afterwards to revolution. Britain’s American colonies had already declared their independence; the Spanish, Portuguese and Dutch colonies were also ripe for revolt.
Defeat in the American War of Independence in 1783 had been a painful experience for Britain. A prolonged period of peace was deemed essential to allow for economic recovery. The 1780s, however, saw the first real surge of economic growth of the Industrial Revolution and fears for the future of British trade with North America proved unfounded: recovery came much more quickly than had been expected.
The Transatlantic War, 1776-83
The American War of Independence had been a ‘salutory lesson’ for Britain, demonstrating the dangers of becoming isolated in Europe. Former enemies, such as France and Spain, were quick to seize the chance to avenge their recent defeats. Former allies and neutral states had nothing to gain from assisting Britain, but on the contrary, they knew that there were markets and colonial territories that might be won. Britain ended up fighting what was effectively a world war. Naval victories in European waters, the West Indies and India preserved Britain’s empire. For Britain, the foundations of a new empire had already been laid in 1783. The loss of the American colonies was a great blow, but Canada had remained a loyal part of the empire in the twenty years since the war with France, and after the war of 1783 the United Empire Loyalists left the revolting states and set up new homes on the shores of the great lakes and along the St Lawrence valley, thus developing Canada and consolidating British power there.
In addition, Britain still controlled much of the Caribbean. Certain West Indian islands were the most cherished of all British possessions, and in the days when Britain was self-sufficient in grain and meat, sugar, rum, tobacco and mahogany brought from the ‘Indies’ were the staple commodities of its overseas trade. A few coastal settlements which were important because of the slave trade were the only British possessions at the time, but it was from these seaboard holdings that Britain penetrated into the interior of the continent in the following century. The additions to the empire of India, Australia and New Zealand in the second half of the eighteenth century (although New Zealand was not formally ‘colonised’ until 1840) meant that in 1783 there was no habitable continent which did not provide Britain with unrivalled bases and openings for development. For almost a century, no foreign rival became formidable, and British traders and manufacturers were able to take advantage of their unique opportunities.
‘Wey Down Souf’ – Black Voices of America, 1783-1858:
By 1760 there were over a million and a half people living in the Thirteen colonies of North America, of which 230,000 were Africans, brought over the Atlantic to work as slaves in the tobacco, rice and cotton plantations of the southern states. In 1772, there were half a million slaves, half of them in Virginia and South Carolina. In the latter, Africans outnumbered Europeans by three to one. By the time the Civil War began, there were four million Blacks throughout the United States, still mainly in the South. The slaves were called ‘Negroes’ or ‘Blacks’ by their white owners, or later, euphemistically, as ‘servants’. As the nineteenth century unfolded, so-called “Nigger English”, later referred to as the “Negro dialect”, became widely recognised among both Blacks and Whites. Most of the slaves were illiterate, so they have left few written records of their own, but there is a neglected tradition of “Invisible Poets” from George Moses Horton, “the Coloured Bard of North Carolina” (born c. 1797) onwards. Among the Whites, the popular literature of the period made free (and often accurate) use of Black English, for example in Uncle Tom’s Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe (born 1811, Lichfield, Connecticut), and in the famous Uncle Remus Stories by Joel Chandler Harris (b 1848, Georgia). The entry of Black English into the mainstream of American life began with his ‘Brer Rabbit’ stories. But although he was born after the outbreak of the Civil War, Daniel Webster Davis’ poem ‘Wey Down South is considered the most authentic and typical of early Black English Literature:
O, de birds ar’ sweetly singin’,
‘Wey down Souf.
An’ de banjer is a-ringin’,
‘Wey down Souf;
An’ my heart it is a-sighin’,
Whil’ de moments am a-flyin’
Fur my hom’ I am a-cryin’,
‘Wey down Souf.
Webster provided a two-page glossary of the terms used in his poem, terms like:
Phar: fair
Ho’oped: helped
Huccum: how come?
Peckin: impose upon
Reggin’: reckon
Shore: sure as.
By way of comparison, here’s an extract from Harris’ Uncle Remus Stories:
One day after Brer Rabit fool ‘im wid dat calamus root, Brer Fox went tur wuk en got ‘im some tar, en mix it wid some tupentine, en fix up a contrapshun wat he call a Tar-Baby, en tuck dish yer Tar-Baby, en he sot’er in de big road, en den he lay off in de bushes fer te see wat de news wuz gwinter be.
Their author exemplifies the close relationship between plantation owners and slaves: his stories are creole tales from the plantations, but he himself was white which, as Mark Twain records, caused great disappointment among his fans: Undersized, red-haired and somehat freckled … it turned out wrote Twain, that he has never read aloud to people, and was too shy to venture the attempt now. Twain considered this a shame, because Mr Harris ought to be able to read the Negro dialect better than anybody else … in the matter of writing it he is the only master the country has produced. And Twain (born Samuel Langhorne Clemens (November 30, 1835)), a master of authentic American dialogue, knew what he was talking about. His ‘Nigger Jim’ was always afraid that he would be ‘sold down the river’, as the following extract shows:
Well, you see, it ‘uz dis way. Ole Missus -dat’s Miss Watson – she pecks me on me all de time, en treats me pooty rough, but she awluz said she wouldn’ sell me down to Orleans. But I noticed dey wuz a nigger trader roun’ de place considerable, lately, so I begin to git oneasy.
In his Introduction to Uncle Remus, Harris drew an interesting distinction between what he called the dialect of the cotton plantations and Sea Islands of the South Atlantic states. He himself paid tribute, in the style of the day, to the rich tradition he was attempting to preserve:
If the language of Uncle Remus fails to give vivid hunts of the really poetic imagination of the Negro; if it fails to embody the quaint and homely humor which was his most prominent characteristic. … then I have reproduced the form of the dialect merely, and not the essence.
The plantations of the deep South became the cradle of a new ingredient in American culture. The English of the slaves was having a decisive effect of their White Anglo-Saxon masters. Its influence was felt in the fields, where slave and overseer would mix, in the house, where master and mistress used Plantation Creole to communicate with their house-slaves, but above all, it was heard in the nursery. Up to the age of about six, the Black and White children grew up together, played together, and learned together. In these crucial years of development, White children were often outnumbered by Black slave children. Furthermore, as any reader of Southern literature knows, was done by Black house-slaves. As early as the mid-eighteenth century it had been reported that the better sort, in this country, paricularly, consign their children to the care of Negroes … As a result, their children grew up ‘bilingual’. On a tour of the United States, Charles Dickens noticed that it was the Southern white women whose speech was most influenced. A closer and better-informed set of observations come from the Journal of Residence on a Georgia Plantation in 1838-39, a fascinating social document kept by the famous British actress Fanny Kemble, after her marriage to a plantation owner. She recorded with some alarm that her daughter was beginning to pick up the local speech, described by Fanny as the thick Negro speech of the Southerners. She wrote that:
The children of the owners, brought up among them (the slaves), acquire their Negro mode of talking – slavish speech surely it is – and it is distinctly perceptible in the utterances of all Southerners, particularly of the women, whose avocations, taking them less from home, are less favourable to their throwing off this ignoble trick of pronunciation than the varied occupation and the more extended and promiscuous business relationsof men.
Southern boys from ‘good families’, in contrast, were usually sent away to White boarding schools, often in the Northern states. From the age of six or seven they were separated from Black talk and educated in racial hostility towards Blacks. The women remained on the plantations, rearing children, managing the servants and mixing with the hose slaves. The reasons for the acquisition of Black English characteristics in Southern speech were many but undoubtedly one of them among children was the natural tendency to imitate and mimic. Fanny Kemble wrote of four-year-old Sally that:
Apparently the Negro jargon has commended itself as euphonius to her infantile ears, and she is now treating me to the most ludicrous and accurate imitations of it every time she opens her mouth. Of course I shall not allow this to become a habit. This is the way the Southern ladies acquire the thick and inelegant pronunciation which distinguishes their utterances from the Northern snuffle, and I have no desire that Sally should adorn her mother tongue with either peculiarity.
In 1849, Sir Charles Lyell noticed how Black and White children on the plantations were being educated together. In his A Second Visit to the United States of North America, he wrote:
Unfortunately, the Whites … often learn from the Negros to speak broken English, and in spite of losing much time in unlearning ungrammatical phrases, well-educated persons retain some of them all their lives.
The mingling of Black and White American culture is illustrated by the story of Du Bose Heyward, the Charleston co-writer of Porgy and Bess (1934). A White southerner, Heyward was descended from one of the signatories of the Declaration of Independence. In 1915 he had published a novel based on the Black characters of his native town, which became a bestseller, Porgy. In 1926, George Gershwin was looking for a suitable subject for an American folk opera when a friend sent him a copy of Heyward’s book. However, it was already scheduled to be staged as a play, which happened the next year. Finally the way was clear and in 1934, Gershwin and Heyward spent the summer working together at a seaside cottage just outside Charleston, working on the lyrics for the opera. Gershwin immersed himself in the culture of the Gullah-speaking Blacks, especially their spirituals and songs. The opera he composed is therefore full of the sound of Black music, both in its rhythms and its Black English dialects:
Summertime an’ the livin’ is easy,
Fish are jumpin’ an’ the cotton is high.
Oh yo’ Daddy’s rich an yo’ Ma is goodlookin’
So hush little baby don’ yo’ cry.
Perhaps more controversially, Black English was also to sustain its place in maistream American society, both South and North, from the 1830s to today, through minstrel shows, vaudeville, music hall, radio and finally the movies.
The pervasive stereotype of Blacks among Whites was that Blacks had ‘rhythm’; a conviction that Whites had insisted on ever since slaves had danced “Jim Crow jigs” in the 1730s or performed the juba dance for the astonished plantation overseers. Minstrel shows emerged out of these traditions in the 1830s and 1840s, and after the ’emancipation’ a succession of musical styles and their lyrics had their origins on the plantations. Slaves’ lives were were restricted in many ways, but they were free to hold religious gatherings. Spirituals, Black Christian songs, began not only as acts of devotion, but also as coded messages of resistance amongst an oppressed people, as in Swing Low, Sweet Chariot:
I ain’t been to heaben but Ah been told,
Comin’ fuh to carry me home,
Dat de streets in heaben am paved wif gold,
Comin’ fuh to carry me home.
Steal away to Jesus was an invitation to a gathering of slaves; Judgement Day was the day of the slave uprising; Home, Canaan (the promised land) and Heaven were all veiled allusions to Africa. A spritual that talked of a fellow slave “a-gwine to Glory” was actually making a reference to one who had successfully boarded a repatriation ship bound for Africa. Nat Turner, a slave preacher, inspired by a vision of Blacks and Whites in battle, made the greatest use of hymns as covert propaganda. When his famous revolt was crushed in Courtland, Virginia, the place became known among Blacks as ‘Jerusalem’. Nat Turner became one of the first martyrs of Black liberation. After his execution, the Negro spiritual tended to lose its revolutionary associations and become a vehicle for Black Christian devotion and passive resistance. The subversive use of religious songs was just part of an understandably subversive attitude among speakers of Plantation English toward the language of their masters. There were other kinds of codes used on the plantation:
Sometimes while loading corn in the field, which demands loud singing, Josh would call to Alice, a girl he wanted to court on the adjoining plantation, “I’m so hungry want a piece of bread”; and her reply would be “I’se so hungry almost dead.” Then they would try to meet after dark in some secluded spot.
The tradition of employing double meanings in songs had been established and was to flourish in later forms of Black music, especially ‘rap’. Interestingly, the word ‘rap’ has meant ‘a rebuke’ or ‘blame’ in both Britain and America since the mid-eighteenth century. In American English, the word became part of the phrase, “to take the rap” meaning “to take the blame”, dating from the late nineteenth century. By the 1960s, ‘to rap’ was used by Blacks to criticise Whites and to demand Black civil rights. It was then adapted by Black protest poets before being adopted by streetwise White teenagers and finally ‘appropriated’ by commercial recording artists. It eventually lost its associations with angry protest and, by the 1980s became simply synonymous with up-beat conversational songs (‘talkin’ blues’).
Slavery itself continued to worry white Americans, both southern and northern, after the Revolutionary War. Thomas Jefferson had seen that when the slave states of the South and the free states of the North competed to join the Union, there would be trouble: This momentous question, like a firebell in the night, awakened and filled me with terror. I considered it at once as the knell of the Union. After Britain abolished the slave trade in 1807 and then ’emancipated’ its West Indian slaves, the United States had to decide whether or not they would do likewise. North and South were at odds. Abraham Lincoln expressed the greatest fear of all in a speech made at Edwardsville, Illinois, in 1858:
When you have succeeded in dehumanising the Negro, when you have put him down and made it impossible for him to be but as the beasts in the field … are you not quite sure that the demon you have roused will not turn and rend you?
Linguistically speaking, the effects of the Civil War and the ‘liberation’ of the slaves on the spread of Black English were comparatively slight in the short run. Most Southern Blacks stayed on or near the plantations, and not until the industrialisation of the North and the mass migration to the cities of the twentieth century did Black English enter its ‘modern’ phase. In the South, the original plantation creole continued to flourish and to influence the accent and vocabulary of White Southerners, which would almost certainly have been quite different without the influence of the Blacks.
The Campaign for Abolition of the Slave Trade in the British Empire, 1787-1807:
‘Am I not a Man and a Brother?’ read the inscription on the famous anti-slavery ceramic medallion produced by the Quaker industrialist Josiah Wedwood’s factory at Etruria in Staffordshire in 1787. The ‘new’ Nonconformist Churches – especially the Methodists and Unitarians – had preached the indissoluble bonds of obligation tying the more fortunate to those less so and they now took up the abolitionist cause with evangelical enthusiasm, using every means at their disposal: hymns, anthems, charismatic meetings, lectures, pamphlets and petitions to parliament, and not least, the powerful medium of images, designed by artists who included William Blake and J. M. W. Turner and printed on every available surface, even including drinking goblets. Each cause had its own particular story of infamy, repeated over and over as a rallying cry. The scandal of the slave ship Zong, when over a hundred sick Africans were thrown overboard so that the master could collect on insurance, was used time and time again to mobilise righteous indignation against the triangular trade – cheap manufactured goods from Britain to West Africa, that cargo exchanged for slaves to the West Indies who were replaced on the return leg by sugar and rum.
Above: A Negro Hung Alive by the Ribs to the Gallows, engraved by William Blake, 1793, from A Narrative of a Five Years’ Expedition Against the Revolted Negroes of Surinam (1806) by John Gabriel Stedman.
The fresh converts to the ranks of the abolitionists came from every layer of society in Britain – reform-minded aristocrats, country gentry, lawyers, physicians and ministers of religion, tradesmen – the same ‘broad church’ alliance of the righteous that had made the radical puritanism of a century and a half previously. But now it also included scientists and industrialists, often the next generation of a dynasty like the Darbys or the Wedgwoods, who felt the need to earn their inheritance, or even atone for it. They wanted to distinguish between their money and the profits made from the trade in Africans. Among the congregations of those indignant at the inhumanity of that trade, were those who brought whole new constituencies of educated women, both genteel and middle class, and even domestic servants who sat in the back pews of Dr Richard Price’s meeting house on Newington Green in London.
The Empire during the Napoleonic Wars, 1793-1815:
It was obvious that, in order for the anti-slavery campaign to succeed, parliament itself would first have to be reformed. Demands for reform of the British electoral system became more insistent and widespread from the late eighteenth century onwards. The growing and increasingly self-confident urban middle classes. Many of these ‘reformers’ and ‘radicals’ were inspired by a new religious enthusuiasm not eperienced since the middle decades of the seventeenth century, the period of the ‘Old Dissent’ of puritans from the established Church of England. The ‘Anglican’ Church remained rich in goods, but spiritually poor; the parish priests had become subservient to the squire, the local land-holder. In the rapidly growing towns which grew up around mines and mills, religious influences rarely reached the industrial workers. These conditions were transformed by the ‘New Dissent’ of John Wesley and theMethodists, who devoted themselves to bringing the the Gospel to the working-classes. They changed the spiritual lives of thousands of miners and mill-workers in the coalfields and textile factories of the North, the Midlands and South Wales. Disdained by the Church of England, they eventually broke away to form their own Methodist Church.
Those who remained in the Church, especially the clergy, who were inspired by Wesley’s work, were known as the Evangelicals, and they brought a new spirit into the Church itself. They also set out to improve social conditions among the poor. Prison-reform was advocated by John Howard (1726-1790), Sunday Schools were founded by Robert Raikes to enable the children of town-workers to read the Bible, and the slave trade was attacked by Wilberforce and Clarkson. There were also Unitarians, like Dr Richard Price, who were far more radical in their politics, as were many of the Quakers, providing continuity with the older forms of ‘nonconformity’. All these groups coalesced in the Anti-Slavery campaign in particular and the ‘Reform movement’ in general.
The debates centred on those arguing for a simple extension of the franchise and those who opposed any widening of the franchise as an invitation to ‘mob rule’ but who nevertheless accepted that limited reforms were needed to make government more responsive and effective. The Dissenters wanted more than to be ‘tolerated’ and allowed to worship according to their conscience, as the 1689 Act of Toleration had granted them. They wanted full civil liberties, including an equal franchise. Though they were forced to concede that there were occasions when the Tories could be moved to act on their urgent appeals, especially when the matter was moral rather than political, the the outbreak of revolution in France in 1789 did not warrant intervention, though the British government did not remain indifferent to it. While the revolution thrilled radicals and romantics like Richard Price, conservatives like Wilberforce watched in horror as the traditional order was overthrown. Fearing the spread of revolutionary politics to Britain, the government cracked down on radicalism and, in 1794, suspended ‘habeas corpus’.
Nonetheless, there remained great reluctance in Britain for any involvement in continental affairs. It was only when the French threatened the Netherlands in 1793 that Britain was prepared to enter a conflict that was to embroil the entire continent for more than two decades. Naval power had allowed Britain to dominate the world’s seas in the late eighteenth century. It rested on a sophisticated and well-financed administrative structure, and on a large fleet drawing on the manpower of the world’s leading merchant marine force (which was nonetheless always short of sailors). It also depended on qualities of seamanship and gunnery, a skilled and determined officer corps and the admirable leadership of its admirals. This was true not only of its command at sea, as demonsrated by Admiral Horatio Nelson, but also of the effective organisation of the Navy as an institution.
The Battle of the Nile: Napoleon’s ambitions to open a route to India,and challenge British power there, led to his invasion of Egypt in 1798.His plans were shattered when Nelson destroyed his fleet at Aboukir Bay, near the mouth of the Nile.
Britain was able to maintain not only the largest battle fleet in the world, but also the large number of smaller warships needed for blockade, convoying and amphibious operations. Naval power proved crucial in the wars against France through to 1815. The Royal Navy was able to secure a string of crushing victories at sea, keeping Britain free from the threat of invasion, as well as securing the sea lanes for its worldwide trade. After securing the routes into the Medterranean at Trafalgar in 1805, it was also able to support the land campaigns of Sir John Moore and the Duke of Wellington in the Peninsular War which led to Napoleon’s initial defeat on French empire soil at Toulouse in 1814. British gunners achieved consistently higher rates of fire than their French and Spanish opponents and this combined with Nelson’s innovative tactics and ability to inspire his captains to enable Britain to gain overall command of the seas. It was a time hungry for heroes, and hundreds of thousands turned out in London to pay their last respects to Nelson, a man who had supervised torture and hangings, as he was laid to rest beneath the dome of St Paul’s Cathedral. Though, as Simon Schama has pointed out,
… the vice-admiral was a dyed-in-the-wool reactionary, … he still belonged to the streets and taverns, to the ordinary seamen and dockers, and had got their blood up and pulse racing in a way none of the epauletted grand dukes could ever manage.
The same London crowds also also cheered the patrician Sir Francis Burdett, as well as an even more unlikely hero, the naval commander Thomas Cochrane, ane ex-privateer who had been jailed for stock-echange fraud. The pair were the new radical candidates for two Westminster seats, one of which had been held by Charles James Fox until his death in the previous year. Dissent, both political and religious, had not, in fact, gone away. In 1807, a huge petitioning campaign, driven by a Nonconformist multitude mobilised in chapels and meeting houses, had finally succeeded in making the slave trade illegal in the British Empire, though not in freeing the slaves in British plantation colonies of the West Indies. A year later Burdett and Cochrane swept away the official Whig candidates on a programme of patriotic revivalism. They wanted to return to what they saw as a ‘True Britain’, the ‘Free Britain’ that had been stolen by dukes and dandies. Their platform was one of annual parliaments, a secret ballot, and manhood suffrage. When this religious and patriotic revival won what they insisted were the ‘natural rights’ of Africans and Britons alike, they seemed unstoppable, but they had to wait for another twenty-five years to breach the stout defences of the establishment.
In a contemporary cartoon, Prime Minister William Pitt and Napoleo carve up the world in the form of a plum pudding.To many satirists, the imperial ambitions of both nations were obviously and entirely similar.
In the early nineteenth century, possible continental rivals were more concerned with wars and internal revolts than with economic progress. While European nations struggled for democracy or fought for freedom, Britain remained neutral, sold them arms, clothes and other manufactures, captured their overseas trade, and carried their goods. British people were free to move about and work where they wished, including overseas, to a degree unknown on the Continent, where feudal restrictions still fettered the peasantry to their landlords and made it difficult for factories to attract labour. In Britain, enclosure caused dispossessed agricultural workers to find employment in the towns and cities, where they provided a ready supply of cheap labour. The profits gained in the increased volume of trade provided an abundance of commercial capital, while the developing banking system provided increased facilities for borrowing money for use in industry and trade. The growth of the power and influence of trading companies, especially the East India Company, and the rapid rise of Liverpool as a port, and the continued but slower growth of Bristol, reflect the extent of the commercial expansion. As a result of the Union with England and Wales, Scottish merchants obtained free trade colonies, and Glasgow also became a great port.
In 1760, the population of Britain had been seven to eight million. By 1820, it had become fifteen million. Compared to the population of Britain in 2020, or even 1920, that may seem quite small, but the doubling of the population meant that there were twice as many mouths to be fed, and many more bodies to be clothed. In spite of the ingenuity of its inventors, Britain could not manufacture enough clothes in its mills and neither was there sufficient money with which to buy them. Both of these problems were being dealt with. For the time being, however, the cure seemed worse than the disease. In the world of farming, enclosure – the main feature of the Agricultural Revolution – had begun. The country was being carved up into patterns of neat, rectangular fields, each surrounded by a hedgerow. Acres of woodland were being cut down to clear a way for the plough, and a sensible system of crop rotation was being introduced. There seemed every reason to believe that a determined, even scientific, effort was being made to feed the etra mouths. The trouble was that, in this new agricultural landscape, there were few places for the peasants. Their smallholdings had no part in the grand design: they had to be erased from the idyllic rural picture. With so much surplus labour available, wages went lower and lower until they were barely enough to keep a family alive.
Nor were the cities doing much to help.The invention of the steam engine offered superb possibilities for transportation and pointed the war to both mass production and and mass unemployment at one and the same time. The steam jenny alone added steeply to the number out of work. Frameworkers, in particular, suddenly found themselves without jobs ad uncertain of where to go. What is more, the great concentrations of mills and workshops in the towns virtually put an end to the cottage industries, first hand-spinning and later handloom weaving.
The Wider Wars with France, 1793-1815
Britain’s economic base had changed since the American War of Independence. Worldwide exports of British manufactured goods replaced the the re-export of colonial products to Europe as the mainstay of of the economy. This meant that British trade, while it might be hurt by the loss of European markets, would not be crippled by wars on and around the European continent. Following the abolition of the slave trade in 1807, the staple commodities carried in the eighteenth century were no longer the chief cargoes. Iron, wheat, wool, minerals and other raw materials became more important. Britain grew prosperous by exporting her coal, manufactured goods, and machinery. It was also necessary to suppress slavery in the interior of Africa long after the abolition of the transatlantic trade in slaves. Despite the claims about Nelson’s own connections with slavery, the Royal Navy was particularly active in policing the African coast after 1807. Initially, British and American slavers, working together and trading up river, continued to conduct a lucrative trade, spreading the use of English as a lingua franca until the full abolition of slavery in the British Empire in 1833, as seen in the picture below:
In the wider war, detailed in the map below, naval strength enabled Britain to project its power worldwide and seize valuable colonial territories from France and others. But that power was not limitless. There were, for example, embarrassing failures in Argentina. Against the USA, a final defeat at New Orleans obscured considerable successes in raids on the American coastline.
Protest, Reform & Abolition, 1815-1838:
Victory in the Napoleonic Wars left Britain with the leading empire in the world. Within a century, this was to be enhanced both by subsequent expansion and by the collapse of the empire of a comparable size: the Spanish Empire in Latin America. By the end of the century, the concept of empire had become more central to Britain than it had to France or Germany, and Britain ruled a quarter of the world’s population and a fifth of its land surface. So much is clear, but what is less so is why this expansion occurred. Historians and political economists have referred to the term ‘imperialism’ as if it was simply a continuation of eighteenth-century ‘colonialism’, but imperial expansion occurred far more by accident than by design. There was neither a plan nor universal support for it. Britain emerged from the Napoleonic Wars with a foothold in all the continents, but the settlements were merely coastal strips and following the loss of the American colonies, British statesmen were not interested in acquiring colonies elsewhere, which were regarded as being expensive to protect and difficult to retain when fully developed. The British government showed little desire to take on the expensive responsibilities of fresh conquests. They looked forward to the time when all the colonies would become independent.
Supporters of free trade who were opposed to the ‘Corn Laws’ (see the map below) pointed out that the end of British colonial rule in the Thirteen American colonies had not harmed British trade. As long as the British were able to trade freely, and British traders and property protected, there seemed little need actually to conquer more territory. The Red River Colony was the last British venture in North America south of Canada and the first effort to settle on the open prairie in 1811, founded by the Earl of Selkirk for the benefit of dispossessed Highlanders.
However, as the century progressed, vast interior stretches were gradually mapped and settled, and British rule was greatly extended around the world. This was partly due to the great increase in the population of Britain. The industrial changes and the wars caused unemployment and widespread distress. The end of the Napoleonic Wars in 1815 made the situation even worse. About half a million ex-soldiers suddenly came on to the labour market; industry, which had enjoyed an artificial wartime boom, slid into a depression; and bad harvests from 1816 to 1818 caused the farmers to prune their labourers still further. These were ‘the Hard Times of Old England’ in the words of a popular ‘broadside’ song:
From the album, ‘All Around My Hat’ by Steeleye Span, 1974
The fifth verse goes on to refer to the “soldiers and sailors … just come from war” who had “come home to be starved, better stayed where they were”. ‘Surplus’ workers were willing to emigrate to new countries where it was easy to make a livelihood, and the government was prepared to assist them in this process. But it was the need to increase trade which was the chief motive behind the acquisition of new lands. As in the eighteenth century, financial interests in the City, whose investments around the globe might be threatened by local events, could exert influence over the government, arguing that their own interests and the national interest coincided.
Yet imperial expansion took place for many reasons, not all of them economic. There was also a strong sense of responsibility towards the so-called ‘backward races’. New territories were therefore opened up by missionary societies in their zeal to convert ‘the heathen’. Racialism became institutionalised throughout the empire. By the 1830s, the concept of ‘settlement colonies’, especially the ‘white dominions’ dominated by Europeans had become established, whereas colonies dominated by other ‘races’ were not considered ready for self-governance. It was firmly and widely believed that Britain had a civilising mission.
Four Views of reform, 1831. Whig, Tory, Liberal and Radical views of the reform debate. Their opinions range from the Tory, who feels that reform is tantamount to revolution, to the Radical, who threatens real revolution if reform is not forthcoming.
By the 1830s, the changing political circumstances finally pushed constitutional reform to the front of the parliamentary agenda. Popular pressure from the London Radical Association and the Birmingham Political Union was growing, while the death of the arch-conservative monarch, George IV in 1830 and the fall, the same year, of Wellington’s Tory government and its replacement with by the reformist Whig administration of Earl Grey, removed final obstacles to electoral reform. The 1832 Reform Act demonstrated both the extent of and the limitations of the contemporary debates on the nature of the constitution. Ideas of responsible citizenship were accepted, but concepts of natural, universal rights were rejected in favour of the status quo. The reform had to be etensive enough to to satisfy at least a significant proportion of public opinion, but was to be based on property and eisting franchises to appease the vested interests in parliament.
The political map of the West Riding of Yorkshire in the 1830s shows how idiosyncratic Britain’s political development was industrialisation made the area one of the most populous in England, yet it was represented by only eight MPs. The first Reform Act improved the situation, but not to everyone’s satisfaction, but not to everyone’s satisfaction, and great landowners retained significant influence.
The Act resulted in an increase in the number of electors of about forty-five per cent. In England and Wales, eighteen per cent of agult males now had the vote, but although in Scotland eighteen times as many voters existed after 1832, the proportion of the population who could vote was still lower than in England and Wales. Moreover, factory politics, the aspirations of radical dissenters, the hopes of the middle class and the political ambitions of the labouring classes all found a place in the politics of the West Riding of Yorkshire (above), one of those areas which had been most under-represented in parliament before the 1832 Act. However, the territorial influence of aristocratic landowners remained significant, demonstrating that a simple increase in the number of voters could not, of itself, necessarily challenge the power of the traditional governing élites.
The House of Commons, 1833
The first half of the nineteenth century was a particularly grim time for the British working classes: the growth of the factory system caused hardship not only for those who lived and worked in the new factory towns, but also for the many domestic workers who found work increasingly difficult to come by. The widespread unemployment caused by periodic slumps in foreign trade made things even worse, especially if bread prices happened to be high following a harvest failure. If working people were represented in Parliament, reformers argued, something would be done about the way they lived and worked. This idea was to be taken up by the Chartists in the later 1830s. Even after the Great Reform Act, five out of every six men in Britain were without the vote and the industrial areas were still under-represented in the House of Commons. In the meantime, however, Parliament did accept the need to regulate the factory system. An act of 1833 prohibited the employment of children under the age of nine, and those under thirteen were not allowed to work more than nine hours a day and were to have at least two hours of schooling a day. ‘Juveniles’, aged thirteeen to eighteen were not to work more than twelve hours. The law was to be enforced by factory inspectors.
Since the end of the French Wars in 1815, when four hundred thousand soldiers and sailors had been demobilised, too many men had been seeking work on the land. The results were unemployment and low wages for those who did find work. William Cobbett saw the conditions in which labourers in Leicestershire were living:
Look at these hovels, made of mud and straw; bits of glass, or of old cast-off windows, without frames or hinges frequently, but merely stuck in the mud wall. Enter them. and look at the bits of chairs or stools; the wretched boards tacked together to serve for a table; rhe floor of pebble, broken brick, and of the bare ground. …
Violence had erupted in 1830, directed mainly at the threshing machine which was increasing the number of farm labourers out of work during the winter months when threshing by hand was traditionally done. The disturbances started in Kent and quickly spread as far west as Dorset and as far north as Northamptonshire and Norfolk.An imaginery leader, ‘Captain Swing’ left ‘by order’ notes on the nearly four hundred machines that were destroyed. Against this background at home, those who attacked slavery in the West Indies were reminded by those who defended it, in popular cartoons like the one below, of the possible economic and social effects of abolition on poverty at ‘home’:
Above: Slavery and Freedom – British poverty and West Indian slavery. A cartoon from The Looking Glass (1832).
It was a matter of considerable pride to the British that their empire was the first to abolish slavery in 1833. It took place at a time when demand for slave-made products was increasing. Its destruction was seen as proof of Britain’s moral superiority, the result of the overwhelming force of moral argument; the final victory of the view that argued for a common human nature. That the compensation paid saved the owners of sugar plantations from ruination from foreign competition, and that, for the slaves, one form of bondage was replaced by another based on poverty, poor education and racial prejudice, passed unnoticed. Initially, a system of transitional ‘apprenticeship’ created a twilight world between continuing servitude and genuine freedom.
The Chartists sought to petition Parliament to accept the six points listed in ‘the People’s Charter’ which included universal manhood suffrage, secret ballots, equal constituencies and the payment of MPs. It was first published in May 1838. Its adoption by a crowd of 200,000 people at a meeting in Birmingham three months later marked the launching of the Chartist movement. Corn prices were still rising and fifty thousand workers in the Manchester area alone were either out of work or on short time by the middle of 1837. Some supporters, like the handloom weavers, were already starving before the collapse of foreign trade in 1837 led to mass unemployment in the manufacturing districts. In the north of England, support for Chartism was bound up with opposition to the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834, the effects of which will be dealt with in my next ‘chapter’ in this series.
Foreground: The ‘Drowning’ of Edward Colston, 2020
Above: Edward Colston’s statue towards Bristol harbour. Photograph from The Guardian Weekly, 12 June 2020, by Giulia Spadafora, Getty.
The heart-breaking, public and blatant murder of George Floyd by a white police officer in Minneapolis on 25 May 2020 has fuelled a storm of protests across the world. ‘Black Lives Matter’ protests have broken out across Britain and other European countries, where the reckoning has reopened questions about the legacies of empire, including the nature of the enslavement, brutalisation, and exploitation of African people. In many of these protests, statues in public squares have acted as focal points for public outrage. The most iconic moment in the British protests thus far has been the pulling down of the statue of Edward Colston in Bristol, a prominent slave-trader who died in 1721. To understand the true historical contexts of the Colston statue which was erected in 1895, 175 years after his death, we first need to consider what the City of Bristol was like when Colston was born into an established local merchant family there. Colston’s statue was erected in Bristol (most of his adult life had been spent in London) as a result not of a campaign from the ‘people of Bristol’, but rather because of the efforts of one businessman, James Arrowsmith. Fearing strikes and socialist agitation amongst the working poor in the 1890s, and anxious about the future of the British Empire at the time of the Boer Wars, he sought to proclaim the city’s imperial deeds through the commemoration of one of its seventeenth-century patrician class.
The Growth of Bristol & Atlantic Trade, 1580-1630:
In a petition of 25 May 1584, citizens of Bristol described their city as in an angle, between Somerset and Gloucestershire, and maynteyned onlie by the trade of merchandizes. It was mainly dependent, they said, upon the manufacture and export of coloured cloth, some of which was made in the city and some in Somerset. In addition, it served all the towns and creeks of the Severn valley as far upstream as Shrewsbury. The city was a great centre of trade where raw materials and foodstuffs from the whole of the West country were manufactured and exchanged for imported commodities, either luxuries like wine, fruit, sugar and spices or the goods used in its industries, such as dyestuffs, oil and iron.
Visitors found it an attractive city, the castle and the old town on high ground between the Avon and the Frome, surrounded inside its ring of water by a double line of walls within its towers and gates. Its buildings, both public and private, were fine and there were many beautiful churches. The streets were clean, as a raker was employed to keep them tidy and there was no dunghill in all the cittie, but all convaid under the ground. Camden, in his Brittania, explained that fear of fracturing these underground drains, or ‘gouts’, was the reason for the use of sleds rather than heavy carts within the town, but it was often said that this was to avoid shaking the wine in the cellars beneath. Possession of a good cellar must have been quite valuable as they were frequently leased to merchants for extra storage. By the sixteenth century, the water supply seems to have been quite good, with St. Edith’s well in the centre of the town and several conduits bringing water from the surrounding hills. The Council frequently employed a plumber to maintain these conduits, particularly the Quay pipe which supplied the ships in the harbour.
Inside the gates, the population was not divided into districts for each trade or social class, though there is no doubt that some streets were more fashionable than others. But throughout the city there was no absolute division; in Broad Street, the gardener lived next to the wax chandler, whose other neighbour was the skinner, while houses further along the road were occupied by tailors, weavers, a baker and a vintner. In some streets, tall houses belonging to merchants overshadowed small cottages interspersed with stables and open ground. Outside the walls to the north and west, around Broadmead and St. James’, a number of tanners and brewers used the water of the River Frome in their workshops. To the south-west, near the Cathedral, on the west bank of the Frome, in the parish of St. Augustine-the-less, were the homes of some gentry and Cathedral dignatories and also many sailors, lightermen and ships’ carpenters. It was generally a poorer area with a shifting population including, by the end of the century, immigrant Irish and other transient labourers.
On the south-eastern side of Bristol, in the great bend in the River Avon, the Port Wall enclosed the suburbs of Redcliffe and Temple. This was mainly an industrial area of smaller craftsmen, an important cloth-making and finishing area, where many of the houses had closes or yards with tentering racks and where dyers had their evil-smelling vats or ‘settings’ of woad. Many kinds of textile workers lived in this area, including glovers and saddlers, and a number of other craftsmen made metal goods, such as pewterers, wire drawers and cutlers. This proto-industrialisation was accelerated by the mining of lead in the Mendips and, later in the century, the import of considerable amounts of iron from South Wales. As the cloth industry declined or began to specialise more in dyeing and finishing, these ‘newer’ industries began to take its place, including bell-founding, pin-making, soap-making and sugar-refining. Rope-making and the manufacture of leather goods remained important.
The merchants formed the richest, though not the largest group. In the period 1532-1552, 428 ‘lads’ were apprenticed as merchants, or to the distributive trades, such as haberdashers, drapers and mercers. Of these, 111 paid subsidies in 1545, three-quarters of them paying on ten pounds or over. Nicholas Thorne, the richest, paid on three hundred pounds. The various textile workers seem to have been the most numerous group, taking 879 apprentices in the twenty-year period. The leather trades took 605 and their workers were much more prosperous than the textile workers, although the industry employed fewer of them. Of the 304 metal workers, only eight appeared in the subsidy rolls. It is clear from these figures that, although the merchants were a strong and wealthy group, yet the industrial workers were very numerous and the leaders of their guilds were substantial men, so that Bristol’s dependence on overseas trade did not in the sixteenth century, permit the merchants entirely to dominate the town to the exclusion of other interests as seems to have happened, for example, in Exeter. It was probably the increasing difficulties in trade during the latter decades of the century, including the war with France and Spain, combined with the problem of continual inflation, which caused the Bristol merchants to become more self-conscious as a group.
The grants of a monopoly of trade in various goods, of which there were a great many in the later years of Elizabeth’s reign, were very much hated by the other merchants, who evaded them whenever they could. A description of the provincial merchant as the straggler, shipping his Clothe and other commoditie in covert maner, hugger-mugger, and at obscure ports. Making false entries in the customs books, importing aliens’ goods and corrupting the Customs men were all clever pieces of London propaganda, but these accusations were not far from the truth. The men involved in ‘smuggling’ were not an obscure group of disreputable characters; they were the leading merchants in the City, very few of them not mentioned in the records of the Exchequer Court. They were Mayors and Aldermen, Masters of the Merchants’ Company and this was true throughout the sixteenth century but certainly, after 1570 when trade was uncertain, voyages to France and Spain were hazardous but necessary, and customs duties were very high. The Crown could not afford to offend these men as it relied on them, not only for the taxes that were paid but also for ships and men in time of war and for the unpaid administration, not only of the City but also of a considerable area of the local countryside, since many of them held country properties. By the end of the century, they had become alienated from the Crown by the pressure of wartime embargoes, high taxation and the monopolistic ‘selfishness’ of the Londoners. Only London and Norwich paid more in subsidy to the Crown and it is probable that while Bristol’s population was around ten thousand, while that of Norwich was over twelve thousand and that of London, then experiencing its own population ‘explosion’, was approaching sixty thousand.
Many of the Bristol merchants lived very comfortably. Their stone-built houses were three, four or even five storeys high, often with stables and courtyards backing onto another road or lane. Their inventories frequently showed more than a dozen rooms, often in two sections, one behind the other with a courtyard between and a covered gallery joining the two at first-floor level. The shop with its ‘beem of iron’ and weights, the counting-house, cupboards and table full of books and bills might be at the front of the ground floor; the kitchen and buttery, with their shining brass and pewter vessels, were at the back. Hall and parlour occupied the first floor with a deep bay window overlooking the street. Towards the end of the century, the rooms were often panelled and had huge ornate plaster fireplaces, a few of which still exist in Bristol, as well as in other ports. The several bedrooms, even those at the top of the house which were for apprentices and servants, were well provided with furniture and linen. Compared with this, the house of a craftsman would seem small and bare, but not necessarily squalid. When the house of a tiler was being repaired, six-foot oaken boards were used for the kitchen floor and there were several glaziers at work in the city so probably many houses had glass windows.
Most of these people were in some degree literate – merchants, their wives, craftsmen, town officials, even the official brokers of merchandise at the Back Hall, who were required to wrytt in a fair book, every bargayne and the names of the parties, the date, the price and the quantitie of all the merchandise and wares that shall pass through any of your handes. The later years of the century, however, were marked by increasing poverty and insecurity. Craftsmen, like masons and carpenters, were paid by the day, smiths and paviours and glaziers by the yard or foot of work done. There were no pension or insurance schemes, just the new ‘Poor Law’ providing a minimal level of ‘outdoor relief’, and the death of the ‘bread-winner’ could mean disaster for his family. Ships’ masters and mariners were paid perhaps eighteen to twenty-five shillings for the voyage to Spain or the Mediterranean, with the right to load some cargo for their own profit and ‘food’ and ‘clothes’ – of a kind – provided. In 1580, carpenters were paid one shilling a day, as were masons and plumbers, almost twice as much as in the 1530s. There seem to have always been poor labourers available to carry wheat to the granary, to stack timber, to help plant trees, to clean out ditches and to help mend the river banks. In the 1580s more homeless vagrants flocked to the city; poor women who sold nails or tile-pins, or rough tiles. In November and December 1587, the poor and homeless were sent to the House of Correction where they had food and shelter. In later years, bedding and sheets and coal were sent to the poor prisoners in Newgate in the cold weather.
In spite of the dangers, the Bristol merchants continued to trade in the Atlantic Islands and on the coasts of Barbary and Guinea. The Mediterranean coasts of France, Italy, North Africa and the Levant became a winter voyage where they ran the gauntlet of the Barbary pirates and the Spanish fleets, relying on their superior speed and firepower, and trading their fish, lead and cloth for fruit, dyestuffs, alum and spices. When, on Friday 29 July 1588, Howard and Drake had heard that the Spanish fleet was off the Lizard Point in Cornwall, they had some ninety ships; nineteen of the Queen’s ships and the rest armed merchantmen from the West Country ports including Bristol. Medina Sidonia, watching them emerge from Plymouth, wrote that these ships were very nimble and of such good steerage, as they did with them whatsoever they desired.
Following the defeat of the Armada, the war with Spain continued for another fifteen years, however, during which the Privy Council received innumerable complaints of loss of trade, bankruptcies and attacks on shipping. The Devon ports blamed the patents to search ships for prohibited goods and the dangers from pirates for the decrease in their trade and even Londoners grumbled at the increased cost of Bordeaux wine. English goods had become dear and of poor quality, so were difficult to market. An edict of 1591 forbade English merchants to deal in Spanish goods and the merchants seem to have tried to share what trade there was. A series of petitions from Bristol to Lord Burghley gave a graphic description of the plight …
… of diers, weavers and cloth workers here which did keepe one with another at least sixe or eight men at work (who) are now goers from dore to dore to begg their bread.
The Bristol merchants wished to be allowed to trade to Venice and Turkey which the London merchants had monopolised with not onelie the greatest parte of forrayn places of commerce, but the iron of Wales, the leadde of Mendipp and the calamyne stone being the commodities of these partes. The Privy Council had noted in October 1596 that Bristol claimed to have lost twelve thousand pounds ‘by sea’ in the last three years if the report of the petitioners for the cittie of Bristoll be true. Some seamen turned to privateering but it is doubtful that this was as profitable as normal trade as in 1597, the Lord Admiral agreed that the existing restraints on trade were to the great hinderaunce of Her Majesties Customs and the decay of the general state of the Citie, this hard time of dearth considered. In 1598, Lord Burghley considered the desirability of peace with Spain, listing the port towns which were ‘manifestly decayed’, which included Bristol. The merchants were therefore permitted to go ahead with their voyages, leaving bonds in the Customs House to return to within a month or six weeks. However, in 1600, the customs men in Bristol received instructions from Lord Buckhurst to forbid six ships preparing in Bristol from sailing to the Levant. When, in the same year, the owners of the Exchange began a suit in the Court of Requests, the City Fathers pleaded that Bristol was exceedinglie decayed and ympoverished through the longe restraynte of trade.
Against this economic background, by 1598, Bristol ships were making regular voyages not only to the Mediterranean ports but also to the Guinea Coast of Africa, the Atlantic Islands and North America. By 1605, the Bristol merchants felt strong enough to leave the London Company and petition for their own Charter which bore the names of over a hundred of them. It was many years before Bristol recovered fully from the effects of the war with Spain and those who had taken part in the action or suffered its consequences were long dead. One of the longer-term effects was the growth of the Atlantic trading system of which the Slave Trade and the institution of slavery in the Caribbean islands and North America formed an integral part. Perhaps ironically, given current controversies, Britain came late to the European Atlantic seabord’s imperial project. During the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, while Spain and Portugal founded great empires spanning America, Africa and Asia, Britain’s rulers watched from the sidelines. John Cabot, Martin Frobisher and others with English sponsorship, in search of a northwest passage to the Indies, played a part in mapping what became Canada and helped open up abundant new fishing grounds in Newfoundland and the North Atlantic; further south, raiders and traders such as John Hawkins, Walter Raleigh and Francis Drake attacked the rich Spanish Indies. Yet, on the death of Elizabeth I in 1603, Britain had no permanent settlements outside Europe.
Western Colonial Expansion to 1707
At the end of the sixteenth century, various pressures combined to arouse fresh interest in overseas expansion. War in Europe, as seen in the case of Bristol, disrupted the trade networks that supplied profitable Eastern goods, and English merchants took an increased interest in securing direct access to Asian markets. Colonies were established in the Americas, some in North America founded by those seeking to escape religious persecution. The West Indies gained most settlers, many of whom moved there hoping for quick wealth through raiding Spanish America. Others became involved in the highly profitable slave plantation economy that developed there and in parts of North America. Large-scale emigration began, and the sheer volume of settlers crossing the Atlantic proved crucial to the growth of the empire. In the late sixteenth century, the writer and exponent of exploration. Richard Hakluyt and others viewed an increasingly commercial Britain, in which land ownership was becoming more concentrated and agricultural production more geared to the market. This left many of the rising population landless and jobless: improvements in agriculture meant they were no longer needed on the land. It was argued that the surplus population should be sent to the abundant lands in America to produce valuable primary products for sale in England. These products would then be exchanged for goods manufactured in Britain, providing a new market for domestic industry, which was facing stagnation or declining demand in Europe. The trade would also employ large numbers of English ships and seamen and generate a spiralling improvement in national wealth, health and security.
The slave ships began crossing the Atlantic to the West Indies and to the ports of the plantation colonies at the beginning of the seventeenth century. It was clear that by the mid-eighteenth century Black pidgin English had been established across the plantations. It was also known, but not quite as fixed, wherever else in North America the slaves were brought, including Nova Scotia, New York and Massachusetts. At the same time, down in the islands of the Caribbean, the arrival of the first white settlers, followed by thousands of Black slaves caused an extraordinary transformation of the region’s social and linguistic geography: the making of Caribbean Creole. The tiny Carib and Arawak Indian populations, the original natives of the region, were savagely obliterated. In their place, creolised forms of the invading European languages have emerged. Into the fertile and sugar-rich islands came Whites and Blacks in unequal proportions to exploit their potential. From this merger of European and African tongues emerged a Caribbean English that makes up an important link in the family of Black Englishes. The most anglophone of the islands are Antigua, Jamaica and, most of all, Barbados, sometimes called ‘Little England’.
The two attempts of sir Walter Raleigh (in 1584 and 1587) to found a colony called ‘Virginia’ failed: permanent settlement began in 1606 when the London Company was formed. King James I may have published tracts against the filthy weed Nicotiana tabacum, but the first settlement the Virginia Company established to grow it still bore his name – Jamestown. Given the chance, the Jamestown settlers would have preferred to discover the gold and silver that had seemed to fall into the lap of the Spanish empire of the south. But there was no gold in the Chesapeake Bay and the settlers had to make do with their dependably prolific flop-leaved plant. The establishment of the tobacco trade in Virginia by the 1620s proved the feasibility of this ‘mercantilist’ project and unleashed a wave of emigration to New World territories. Many times, during the first half of the seventeenth century, the English tobacco colonies seemed close to obliteration: victims of disease, vicious wars with the Native Americans and their own profligate, unrealistic expectations. More than half the migrants were indentured servants who mortgaged their labour for a term of years in return for the payment of their passage. Though six thousand immigrants had moved to Virginia between 1607 and 1625, in the latter year a census found the population of the colony to be just 1,200. The climate, the insects and the unwelcome gifts they carried literally devoured the settlers. Of those who survived, most had moved to the West Indies, to the Leeward Islands (1623), especially St. Kitts, which they developed along the lines of the plantation colonies and where tobacco products could be combined with more predatory activities targeted against the Spanish empire. However, the tropical climate and the diseases it generated ensured a high mortality rate, as can be seen on the maps below, showing the difficulties of early settlers in these islands.
Above left: The Difficulties of Early Settlers/ Right: English, Spanish and French ‘Spheres’ in Early Colonial Period. .
Above: The Chesapeake Bay settlements in North America, 1607-1658.
The Establishment of the Slave Trade, 1620-1720:
Slavery was introduced into the English colony of Virginia when the first Africans were transported to Point Comfort in 1619 (pictured in the engraving above). Those who accepted Christianity became “Christian servants” with time-limited servitude, or even freed, but this mechanism for ending bondage was gradually shut down. As the tobacco habit became ingrained in European culture and Virginia leaf was established as the marker of quality, demand boomed, prices rose and the settlements in Lord Baltimore’s Maryland and in Virginia itself hung on, consolidated and pushed inland. Attracted by the possibility of owning hundreds of acres on their ‘manors’, the younger sons of English gentry and tradesmen arrived and established themselves as ‘tobacco barons’. Supplying the labour, alongside a limited number of African slaves, were ‘boys’ of a median age of sixteen, seldom over nineteen, in their tens of thousands, out from the tenements of London and Bristol, about seventy to eighty per cent of whom were ‘indentured’ to work for three to five years for room and board before being freed to claim a small plot of ‘promised land’, to hire out their labour or to set up shop. By the 1640s the output of tobacco from the southern plantation colonies (see the map above) had expanded to levels where, despite greatly increased consumption in Europe, supply exceeded demand, and prices collapsed. After these early misfortunes, tobacco cultivation began to bring prosperity to the colony of Virginia, based on the labour of West African slaves. The planters became a rich aristocracy.
In 1667, the Virginia Assembly passed a law that barred baptism as a means of conferring freedom. Africans who had been baptised before arriving in Virginia could be granted the status of indentured servants until 1682 when another law declared them to be slaves. In 1671, Virginia counted 6,000 white indentured servants among its 40,000 population but only 2,000 people of African descent, up to a third of whom in some counties were free. Whites and people of African descent in the lowest stratum of Virginian society shared common disadvantages and a common lifestyle, which included intermarriage until the Assembly made such unions punishable by banishment in 1691. Towards the end of the 17th century, English policy shifted in favour of retaining cheap labour rather than shipping it to the colonies, and the supply of indentured servants in Virginia began to dry up; by 1715, annual immigration was in the hundreds, compared with 1,500–2,000 in the 1680s. As tobacco planters put more land under cultivation, they made up the shortfall in labour with increasing numbers of slaves. The institution was rooted in racialism with the Virginia Slave Codes of 1705, and from around 1710 the growth in the slave population was fueled by natural increase.
A sugar plantation on Barbados
The introduction of sugar into Barbados the 1640s and the phenomenally high profits earned from it opened up the prospects of great wealth to those who could command a sufficient labour supply. The move towards a slave plantation system followed swiftly. Barbados had first been settled in 1624 and attracted many wealthy ‘cavaliers’ after the Civil War in England, who set up large sugar plantations on the island. The island owed its prosperity to this development in the 1640s and the settlement of slaves from the west coast of Africa to work on them: it was the first main port of call for the slave ships. It is said that the most unruly slaves from the least domesticated tribes were progressively shipped up the ‘claw’ of the West Indies until they finally reached Jamaica. In any case, the Barbadians, or ‘Bajans’, still have a reputation for well-spoken respectability, and Bajan creole is much closer to Standard English than Jamaican creole.
The transition to sugar production had begun in the 1680s when tobacco prices began to decline and then went into free-fall, bankrupting the smaller planters, brokers and processors. The shock was not enough to abort the Chesapeake experiment altogether, however. There were upwards of fifty thousand settlers in Maryland and Virginia, and they managed to find a more diversified range of crops to farm; indigo and wheat in particular. The colony would survive, and the tobacco market revived in the next century, but for the time being the bonanza was over. Meanwhile, the British sweet tooth had arrived with a vengeance in the national diet. Sugar had been widely known and consumed in medieval Europe, but its high price and exotic origin meant that it was considered either as a spice or a drug. The most common sweetener, conveniently produced close to home, was honey. But as the Portuguese shippers and growers of sugar cane moved further west, along the Tropic of Cancer, they searched for places with the ideal combination of heat and rain in which to cultivate it. Brazil, their own former colony, was one such place.
Sugar cane needed one other precondition if it was to pay off, and that was intensive, highly-concentrated applications of manpower. It could not be farmed and harvested in a single growing season since it took fourteen months to ripen. Once it had reached maturity, the cumbersome crop needed to be harvested quickly to prevent the sugar from going starchy. Once stripped and cut, the cane, in turn, had to be speedily taken to the ox-powered vertical crushing rollers before the sucrose concentration of the juice self-degraded. Every subsequent stage of production – boiling the juice, the arrest of the boiling process at the precise moment of optimum crystallisation, its partial refining in clay-stopped inverted cone moulds, the lengthy drying process – demanded the kind of strength, speed and stamina in tropical climatic conditions that indentured white Europeans or captive Amerindians were ill-equipped to provide. Both populations proved themselves hard to discipline, prone to drink and rebellious. They died like flies from the stew of water-borne diseases that simmered away in the humid conditions. What happened next has occupied the thoughts of historians, like Simon Schama, over decades:
So, where to turn for a labour supply that was strong, disease-resistant but obedient, like the cattle that turned the crushers? Where else, of course, but where the Portuguese were already making money from the commerce in ivory, gold and humans – West and Central Africa.
The Jesuits in Brazil condemned as the grossest blasphemy any equation between men and animals. Other, equally honourable Church fathers, wrote fortnightly to Philip II on the unspeakable, unchristian, evil of enslavement. But in 1630, there were probably over sixty thousand African slaves working in the estates of Brazil, by then under Spanish control, and the investment was paying off handsomely for all concerned except its traumatised, brutalised victims. English interlopers, since the reign of Elizabeth, competing with the Dutch, had been buying slaves on the coast of West Africa and selling them to Hispanic America. The English were aware that, even if it were highly volatile in the early stages of production, sugar was extremely stable in shipping and warehousing. It was also versatile and market-adaptable, yielding not just two qualities of sugar (raw and refined) but also molasses, treacle and rum. As a commodity in long-distance trade, it was impossible to beat.
The English made early attempts to grow sugar in Bermuda, but the tiny island off the coast of South Carolina was too dry, too cool and too remote. Barbados, on the other hand, seemed the answer to their prayers. Hanging out in the ocean, on the extreme windward edge of the Antilles, the annual rainfall averaged sixty inches a year, all the moisture the sugar cane needed, and its breezes could be harnessed to turn the sails of windmills to crush the cane. But the colonial product of choice in the 1620s was tobacco, and for a generation or so efforts were made to grow a crop on Barbados. Competing with Virginia and Maryland, however, was hard work. The island was covered with a dense copy of rainforest which took twenty years to clear for adequate growing space. Even then, the leaf never managed to achieve the quality of Virginia tobacco. There were also the same labour troubles that plagued the Chesapeake Bay plantations. In addition, neither the Irish indentured labourers nor the English apprentice boys could cope with the tropical heat and in 1649, the year the British Republic was established, there was a slave rebellion on Barbados, suppressed with characteristically ‘Cromwellian’ ruthlessness. The slave-sugar nexus seemed a better bet to the planters than the ongoing struggle with tobacco. With the help of the input of Dutch capital for milling equipment, the cane crop took off. As early as 1647, an owner of fifty acres reported that …
… provisions for the belly … at present is very scarce (since) men are so intent upon planting sugar that they had rather buy foode at very dear, rather than produce it by labour, soe infinite is the profitt of sugar workes.
Barbados itself, barely twenty-one miles long, and, besides tourism, it is still almost wholly devoted to sugar production. The plantation boundaries remain almost the same as they always have. To the north of the capital Bridgetown, there stretches a long plain on which there are many plantations dating back to the 1640s. Much of the fertile ground is devoted to growing sugar cane. One of the plantations, called ‘Dukes’, about ten miles from Bridgetown, appeared on the earliest map of Barbados, published in 1657 (see below), and is still worked today for sugar by a white family who can trace their ancestry back to the settlement of the island. As early as 1655, Barbados was shipping 7,787 tons of sugar back to England, and there were already twenty thousand slaves on the island against twenty-three thousand whites, well over half of whom were indentured servants. When Richard Ligon arrived two years later, the well-founded reputation of Barbados as a ‘gold mine’ had already been established and he wrote of how …
… as we passed along the shoar, the Plantations appeared to us one above the other like several stories in stately buildings which afforded us a large proportion of delight.
It was common knowledge that an up-front outlay of a thousand pounds, advanced by the Dutch, invested in two hundred acres, a windmill, a distillery to make rum and a hundred slaves would yield, within a few years, an annual income of two thousand pounds. The English gentry lived far better than they had done in England and were by far the richest men in the British American colonies. The Puritan Earl of Warwick had been among the most enthusiastic pioneers of settlement and slavery in the Caribbean in the 1620s. So Barbados soon filled up with shackled Africans while, under its white Assembly, it became a self-governing little Commonwealth, divided into parishes, each run by a ‘vestry’ and its manorial gentry, in their magisterial role, adjudicated the common law much as the did in Berkshire or Cheshire. But they also adjudicated the slave code, which declared the punishment for running away to be mutilation and the penalty for theft of any article worth more than a shilling, death. Wilfully killing a ‘negro’ might incur an inconvenient fine, but it was virtually impossible to prove it. And with Bridgetown and its other harbours made it easily defensible, the island was safe from the Spanish Catholic ‘scourge’.
It was Oliver Cromwell (right) who first sought the right to trade with Spanish America. In return for this privilege, he offered Spain help in its war against France. When Spain rejected this offer, the Protector attacked Spain and made an alliance with Mazarin. In 1654 Oliver Cromwell dispatched a great fleet to gain an interest in the Spanish Indies and, after a humiliating defeat at Hispaniola, the leaders turned on the thinly settled, and ill-defended, island of Jamaica as a consolation prize. Jamaica was captured and annexed by Penn and Venables in 1655 and during the war which followed, from 1656 to 1660, English seamen revived the Elizabethan ‘policy’ of raiding Spanish treasure ships. Admiral Blake carried out the first-ever blockade attempted by the British Navy in 1656 and 1657 when he blockaded the Spanish coast. The ease of the initial seizure proved deceptive, however, as runaway Spanish slaves in the mountainous interior sustained years of guerilla war with Spanish support which, together with disease, took a heavy toll on the army, in terms of both lives and morale.
At the Restoration, peace was made with Spain and it was widely expected that Charles II would return Cromwell’s prize. In the event, the king decided to retain Jamaica and established a civil government designed to encourage private investors and secure the island’s future. However, in Jamaica, the English inherited little from the Spanish. As one early settler remarked, …
… The Spaniard doth call it the garden of the Indies. But this I will say: the Gardeners have been verie bad for here is verie little more than that which groweth naturallie.
The struggle to turn a territory acquired through an adventure into a profitable colony is well illustrated by Jamaica, as Britain’s first state-sponsored colonial venture. The island was ten times the size of other ‘British’ islands in the Caribbean and promised to provide a valuable extension of the sugar and slave system developed in Barbados. Clearing the land and planting cash crops required time and great capital investment which, despite the king’s hopes, were not forthcoming from outsiders. Although the first settlers took out patents for vast tracts of land, it was many years before the resources necessary to convert Jamaica into a thriving plantation economy were accumulated. Meanwhile, the colonists exploited the island’s strategic location. Unlike the earlier successful English settlements, Jamaica was in the heart of the Spanish Indies, well placed for both plunder and trade, with the additional advantage of a superb natural harbour protected by a long sand spit, at the end of which the settlers built the town of Port Royal. However, the soldiers proved incompetent colonists, and the settlement was a failure until sugar-planting was introduced in the eighteenth century.
Jamaica in 1685
Meanwhile, privateering required little capital and provided the funds needed to ensure the infant colony’s survival. In the long run, peaceful contraband trade (especially a slave re-export trade), which also got underway in the 1660s, proved more important and more rewarding. Despite the treaty of Madrid in 1670, which promised peace and friendship between England and Spain in the Indies, privateers continued to refit their ships and sell their prizes at Port Royal throughout the late seventeenth century. The town, Henry Morgan and other famous adventurers, and notorious for its rowdy, dissolute, high-spending social life, acquired the reputation of being the wickedest city on earth. In 1692 a dramatic earthquake plunged most of its buildings underwater, beneath the harbour (see the contemporary newspaper below).
Many saw the disaster as well-deserved punishment from God. As Port Royal prospered, the island merchants who profited from trade and plunder accumulated the capital to purchase a slave labour force, which increased from ten thousand in 1673 to forty-five thousand in 1703, and planted cash crops in the interior. Cocoa dominated in the 1660s but was destroyed by blight in the 1670s and superseded by sugar. By 1684 the island had 246 sugar plantations (see the map below) and exports were approaching the level of those from Barbados. Although the size of the plantations on Jamaica was to exceed those of elsewhere in the anglophone Caribbean, the island also maintained production of a wider range of staples than the smaller islands (including indigo, cotton, ginger and pimento) and a small-holding sector geared to the internal exchange of food and cattle. The earthquake of 1692, the ensuing disease and the war of the 1690s, during which Jamaica was invaded by the French, took a heavy toll on the island’s population, trade and prosperity. The rapid progress made in the 1670s and ’80s was halted and even reversed, with the white settler population declining from around nine thousand to seven thousand between 1680 and 1700. The lost ground was regained in the eighteenth century, however, when Jamaica became the brightest jewel in Britain’s imperial crown. By the end of the century, while the slave population on Barbados numbered seventy thousand, that on Jamaica had swelled to four hundred thousand.
The restoration of the monarchy in England had only made things better for the slavers. Prince Rupert of the Rhine went slaving up the Gambia in West Africa and made a tidy profit on it. British colonial commerce in North America had taken two important new turns. The first was the formation of the Royal African Company by Charles II in 1663. This heralded wholehearted entry into the African slave trade, in which English ports dominated by the end of the eighteenth century. When Charles II became king, he was instrumental in founding the Company of Royal Adventurers Trading into Africa in 1660. Initially chartered with a thousand-year monopoly of trading rights in western Africa, it was re-chartered in 1663 as the Company of Royal Adventurers into Africa, becoming commonly known as ‘the Royal African Company’. In the same year, Lord Clarendon, Monck and other leading politicians obtained a charter from Charles II making them proprietors of the lands south of Virginia. The area was so large that two settlements were made, North Carolina and South Carolina. But the proprietors took little interest in them and few fresh settlers moved there, so the lands were offered to inhabitants of other colonies. North Carolina became a centre of piracy, but South Carolina developed into a more successful colony. It was there, to Charleston, a city that was known as the slave capital of the South, that many of the slaves were brought.
Those that survived the terrible ordeal of the Middle Passage would have been unloaded on Sullivan island, a swampy, low-lying strip of land opposite the man harbour of Charleston, a place that has been called the “Ellis Island for Blacks”, from where they would be sold off and shipped inland to the big plantations. But some remained, and still, on the sea islands of the South Carolina coast a kind of Black English creole known as ‘Gullah’, is preserved to this day. It is probably the closest form of Black American English to the original creole English of the New World and the pidgin English of the slave ships and is still spoken by a quarter of a million Blacks. Lying close to Charleston, they were near a slave port that ‘flourished’ well into the nineteenth century. They lived self-sufficient lives on these islands, growing their own crops in fertile soil and fishing for crabs and oysters out of the thousands of creeks and inlets. Constantly resupplied with new arrivals, they were also cut off from the mainland. Theirs was a self-contained language community whose speech patterns became partially ossified.
By the time the Royal African Company’s ships deposited their first human cargoes at Bridgetown there were already well over thirty thousand slaves on Barbados, twice as many blacks as whites on the island. By 1700 the number had risen to around fifty thousand. Barbados had become the forcing house of high-end, fast-profit, industrially organised slave capitalism. The patchwork landscape of relatively small farms, ten acres or so on average, worked by racially mixed gangs of indentured servants and slaves had gone forever. In its place were 350 large estates of more than two hundred acres and scores more of about a hundred acres, all of them worked almost exclusively with African slave labour. Quakers like George Fox visited Barbados, preached that all blacks, whites and tawnies were equally God’s creatures and asked the Quaker planters in America to preach the gospel to all Negroes and other servants if you be true Christians. He urged them to use the slaves gently and to free them after a period, though he stopped short of demanding abolition. The indefatigable old Puritan Richard Baxter, though, was more damning in 1673 when he chastised, …
How cursed a crime is it to equal men to beasts. Is this not your practice? Do you not buy them and use them merely as you do horses to labour for your commodity … Do you not see how you reproach and condemn yourselves while you vilify them all as savages?
In 1688, German Quaker settlers in Pennsylvania first urged the inconsistency of Quakerism and slavery and the ‘Quaker state’ showed the application of its principles in practice, against the general view that principles were best kept pure and spiritual, as the earliest Friends, including Fox, had advocated. When the German Friends in Pennsylvania went against Fox’s paternalistic attitude towards the slaves and questioned the whole moral basis of slavery, they began a shared witness which was the mainspring of Friends’ activity for nearly a hundred and fifty years in the British Empire and even longer in the North American mainland. The concern arose first in the American colonies, where the evil was most apparent, but slavery was increasingly censored in Britain too, as Baxter’s chastising demonstrates. From the early eighteenth century, Quakers on both sides of the Atlantic were actively involved in the movement against slavery. John Woolman, one of the most saintly of American Quakers, had been brought to a crisis of decision by being asked to write a bill of sale for a Negro woman. He wrote the bill but raised his objection to the principle, and from this grew his writing and preaching against slavery which was a keystone of the Quaker protest in America. Yet it was not until the second half of the eighteenth century that this protest led to a collective rejection of slavery by the Friends and other churches. Even then, when they were occasionally shamed into conceding the human cost they relied on, both the planters and the merchants at home who supplied them shrugged their shoulders and asked what a Negro would do with liberty. The bottom line, always, was money. Daniel Defoe, as usual, was shockingly blunt:
No African Trade, no Negroes; no Negroes, no sugars … no sugars … no Islands; no Islands, no Continent; no Continent, no Trade; that says farewell to all your American Trade, your West Indian Trade.
The second new development of the latter half of the seventeenth century was the provision of a lifeline for the struggling settlements of the North American mainland: although they did not find a profitable cash crop, they were now able to earn export credits by providing food, timber and shipping services to the plantations. These were used to pay for imported goods from English ports. Demand for sugar, more than tobacco, proved insatiable. As the production of sugar increased and the price fell, what had been a luxury available to a few became one that was available to all, albeit in small quantities. People began to use sugar in a greater variety of ways. From soon after its introduction in Barbados until the end of the eighteenth century, sugar accounted for over half the value of plantation imports. Sugar raised the stakes in the imperial project, with English merchants and their European rivals anxious to amass the profits and those in power keen to tap them, paying more careful attention to colonisation, which they had previously left to private enterprise. The English Navigation Act of 1651, directed above all at Dutch competitors, attempted to reserve the colonial carrying trade for English and colonial ships, excluding the Scots. This legislation was refined and improved after the Restoration, remaining in place until 1859. Resentment at their exclusion was a major factor in the Scots’ ill-fated attempt at settlement in Darien, a swampy region of the Panama isthmus in the 1690s, and in Scottish lobbying for Union with England and Wales in the years before the Act of 1707.
In the decades following the Restoration, England’s empire was consolidated and expanded. By 1700 England had settled seventeen colonies in America, with a narrow strip of continuous settlement along the coast of North America from Maine to South Carolina, together with six islands in the Caribbean, alongside France’s eight colonies and the three belonging to the Dutch. As territory expanded, the English population of America grew, increasing threefold between 1660 and 1700, reaching around 400,000, adding to the five million at home. By comparison, France with its ‘home’ population approaching twenty million in 1700, had a mere seventy thousand colonial subjects. Trade with Europe became less important as British involvement with the world beyond. By the beginning of the eighteenth century, trade with the plantations and India accounted for over thirty per cent of imports and fifteen per cent of exports. Britain had acquired a major share in Europe’s imperial growth, which was to come to full fruition by the end of the century. Nevertheless, in 1700 by far the greater part of Britain’s trade was still with Europe. This was not the case a hundred years later, by which time foreign trade had not simply grown, but had also completely changed direction.
Four hundred years ago, the ancestors of the black English-speakers of the southern American states and the Caribbean islands lived in the hinterland of what is now Sierra Leone, Nigeria, Ghana and the Ivory Coast, in West Africa. They would have spoken one of several hundred local languages, including Hausa, Wolof, Bulu, Bamoun, Temne, Akan and Twi. The first English they would have heard – and it has become the basis of Black English to this day – would have been from the sailors of the slave ships, many of whom started their journey from the old English trading ports like Liverpool and Bristol.
Bristol at the beginning of the eighteenth century
From the 1620s and for the next 150 years, Bristol was the apex of a trading triangle that was one of the most ruthless in the history of capitalism. British ships laden with cheap cotton goods, trinkets and Bibles sailed from Bristol and Liverpool for the west coast of Africa. They exchanged their cargo for a shipload of Black slaves who were then transported on the notorious ‘Middle Passage’, the second leg of the journey, to the sugar-bowl of the Caribbean.
Thomas Clarkson and other supporters of William Wilberforce’s campaign to abolish the slave trade prepared this diagram of a slave ship in 1789.
The master of the Royal African Company’s slave ship Hannibal, Thomas Phillips, who wrote an account of the typical voyage of the 1690s, described the degrading procedures imposed on the abductees when inspecting the shipment supplied by the African dealers at Ouidah: Searching for signs of the ‘yaws’ that discovers itself by almost the same symptoms … as clap does for us … our surgeon is forced to examine the privities of both men and women with the nicest scrutiny, which is great slavery but what can’t be omitted. Once purchased, the slave was branded on the breast or shoulder with the letter of the ship’s name, the place before being anointed with a little palm oil which caused but little pain, the mark being usually well in four or five days, appearing very plain and white. The loading process was repeatedly held up by captives so wilful and loth to leave their own country leaping out of the canoes, boats and from the deck of the ship and remaining underwater until drowned Once onboard there were further suicide attempts, especially since the slavers frequently prowled the coast looking for extra cargo: the Africans would jump overboard, even when shackled. Phillips wrote:
We have … seen divers of them eaten by the sharks, of which a prodigious number kept about the ships in this place … and I have been told will follow her to Barbadoes for the dead negroes that are thrown overboard in the passage. … I am certain in our voyage there we did not want the sight of some every day … we had about twelve negroes did wilfully drown themselves and others starv’d themselves to death for ’tis their belief that when they die they return home to their own country and friends.
‘The Atlantic Trade Triangle’ from a recent school text-book.
Other accounts register the ‘inconsiderateness’ of negroes who went ‘raving mad’, or mutilated themselves during the passage, or who had the audacity to refuse to eat, thereby jeopardising the value of the cargo. But what the slavers and their surgeons described as ‘melancholy’ was almost certainly the semi-catatonic state characterised by sunken eyes, swollen tongue and extreme torpor that is induced by extreme, potentially fatal, dehydration. Rather than the four pints of water required by the average man, he received only a pint every day for up to seventy days. If on this long journey, they lost just ten per cent of their body’s water content, they would certainly die. Between ten and twenty per cent of slaves on board died in this way and fluid loss from extreme perspiration was the primary cause of this. When the ships were out on the open ocean, the slaves were taken up on deck twice a day for air, water and soup. If the sea were too rough, however, they would be kept in the stifling heat of the cramped holds, shackled in pairs and given less space (according to the Royal African Company specifications) than for a European pauper’s coffin.
How then does the controversial legacy of EdwardColston fit into this tragic narrative?
1722 portrait of Edward Colston by George Vertue
The statue of Edward Colston in central Bristol
Colston (2 November 1636 – 11 October 1721) was a merchant, in Bristol and London, briefly a Tory Member of Parliament, and latterly a philanthropist. Born to a family of merchants that had lived in the city since the 1340s, he became a merchant, initially trading in wine, fruits and cloth, mainly in Spain, Portugal and other European ports. Colston was apprenticed to the Mercers’ Company for eight years and by 1672 was shipping goods from London. He built up a lucrative business, trading cloth, oil, wine, sherry and fruit with Spain, Portugal, Italy and North Africa. In 1680, Colston became a member of the Royal African Company, which had held the monopoly in England on trading along the west coast of Africa in gold, silver, ivory and slaves from 1663. He rose rapidly on to the board of the company and became deputy governor, the company’s most senior executive position, from 1689 to 1690; his association with the company ended in 1692. Both the length and the depth of Colston’s role in the Company have been exaggerated by David Olusoga, a Professor in ‘Public History’ at the University of Manchester and a ‘broadcaster’ who has claimed that Colston personally oversaw the transportation of Africans across the Atlantic and into slavery.
Above: John Locke
The company, founded by Charles II and his brother the Duke of York (later King James II), who was the governor of the company, together with London merchants, had many notable investors, including John Locke from 1671. In addition, while secretary to Shaftesbury, Locke participated in drafting the Fundamental Constitutions of Carolina, which established a feudal aristocracy and gave masters absolute power over their slaves. Of course, the English philosopher and physician was widely regarded as one of the most influential of Enlightenment thinkers, commonly known as the ‘Father of Liberalism’.
But some historians have noted that Locke, as a secretary to the Council of Trade and Plantations (1673–1674) and a member of the Board of Trade (1696–1700), was in fact, one of just half a dozen men who created and supervised both the colonies and their iniquitous systems of servitude. Though some claim that he later changed his stance on the slave trade, his opposition to aristocracy and slavery in his major writings have led to accusations of hypocrisy and racism, and/or of his caring only for the liberty of British capitalists. Another of these early colonialists and slave traders was the diarist Samuel Pepys.
During Colston’s involvement with the Royal African Company (1680 to 1692), it is estimated that the company transported around 84,000 African men, women and children, who had been traded as slaves in West Africa, to the Caribbean and the rest of the Americas, of whom 19,000 died on their journey. Due to the conditions on many of the vessels, the extended journeys also affected the ship’s crew mortality rates, which were often similar and sometimes greater than those of the slaves. The slaves were sold for cheap labour on tobacco, and, increasingly, sugar plantations, whose planters considered Africans would be more suited to the conditions than British workers, as the climate resembled the climate of their homeland in West Africa. Enslaved Africans were also much less expensive to maintain than indentured servants or paid wage labourers from Britain and Ireland. Colston’s parents had resettled in Bristol and in 1682 he made a loan to the Bristol Corporation, the following year becoming a member of the Society of Merchant Adventurers and a burgess of the City. In 1684 he inherited his brother’s mercantile business in Small Street and was a partner in a sugar refinery in St Peter’s Churchyard, shipping sugar produced by slaves from St Kitts. However, Colston was never resident in Bristol as an adult, carrying on his London business from Mortlake in Surrey until he retired in 1708.
The proportion of his wealth that came from his involvement in the slave trade and slave-produced sugar is unknown, and can only be the subject of conjecture unless further evidence is unearthed. As well as this income, he made money from his trade in the other commodities mentioned above, interest from money lending, and, most likely, from other careful financial dealings. Colston used his wealth to support and endow schools, hospitals, almshouses and churches in Bristol, London and elsewhere (see below).
The Dominance of the Slave Trade, 1720-1750:
Underpinned by the slave trade with West Africa, and reinforced by the commercial and maritime regulations embodied in the Navigation Acts, Britain’s Atlantic empire was of great importance to the domestic economy. Sugar, tobacco, coffee, rice and timber were supplied to Britain in steadily increasing quantities, and demand from expanding overseas population provided an important outlet for British manufactured products and re-exported goods derived from other parts of the world. By 1700, more and more of the British merchants’ dealings were with the colonies. Trade with the West Indies and North America increased at a spectacular rate. This brought prosperity to all the west coast ports of Glasgow, Whitehaven, Liverpool and Bristol, which were better placed than London and the East Anglian ports for the Atlantic trade. By the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, west-coast ports such as Bristol had benefited greatly from the expanding transatlantic trade in slaves, sugar and tobacco. Beginning with the laying out of Queen Square in 1699, Bristol far outgrew its medieval boundaries to become the second-largest city in Britain after London.
By the beginning of the eighteenth century, Bristol was a crowded port, teeming with vessels, all shipshape and Bristol fashion as the phrase goes and as can be seen from the contemporary picture above. Visiting Bristol today, the great merchants’ houses and Regency crescents are splendid reminders of the City’s former prosperity. However, the large tidal range of the River Avon was a disadvantage and, despite building a new merchant dock downriver in 1762, by 1800 Bristol had been overtaken by Liverpool as Britain’s second city.
Liverpool became an even more important trading centre, its population increasing from around six thousand in 1700 to over eighty thousand by the end of the century. Unlike Bristol, Liverpool had deep-water access for ships and had invested more heavily in new dock facilities. The famous Bristol ‘nails’ on which so much business was transacted (giving us cash on the nail) still stand, but there has never been a monument to the human cargo on which the riches were based. For a memorial to the City’s slaving past, we have to go to the village of Henbury. There, in the graveyard of St. Mary’s Church, is the 1720 tomb of one Scipio Africanus, a young slave who died in Bristol at the age of eighteen. The epitaph on the gravestone is a poignant memorial to the mingling of English and African culture:
I who was Born a Pagan and a Slave
Now sweetly Sleep a Christian in my Grave What tho my hue was dark my Saviour’s sight Shall change this darkness into radiant light.
Nothing further is known of Scipio Africanus, whose name is a witty classical allusion that suggested the gulf between Blacks and Whites. As his name and the inscription tell us, he, or his family, came from Africa and spoke an African language. In England, handsomely buried by an affectionate white ‘owner’, he would have spoken English, probably with the Bristolian accent of his master. The making of Black, or ‘pidgin’ English probably began even before the slave ships arrived on the west coast of Africa. The kind of English spoken on the ships at that time would have been highly idiosyncratic and even if the captain was English, many of his crew would have been foreign. The sailors, who would have worked on many ships for many masters, would almost certainly have been familiar with the Mediterranean sea-going lingua franca, Sabir, a language that evolved to cope with multi-ethnic crews. It dated from the time of the Crusades and survived into the nineteenth century, having strong Iberian roots. This may well explain why West African pidgin English contains words like pikaninny (derived from the Portuguese word for “small”) and savvy (from the French “savez-vous”). Of course, the Portuguese had already been trading in West Africa for two hundred years. The mixture of European languages from which the West Africans themselves formed a means of communication with the traders and intruders was described by one contemporary, who wrote of Sierra Leone that, …
Most of the Blacks about the bay speak either Portuguese or ‘lingua franca’ (‘Sabir’) which is a great convenience to the Europeans who come hither, and some understand a little English or Dutch.
As the eighteenth century progressed, the prosperity of the western ports was based increasingly on the slave trade. Slavers continued to set out laden with rum, trinkets and guns. At the West African trading posts which had grown up along what had become known as the ‘Slave Coast’, these goods were exchanged for Negro slaves provided by native rulers and suppliers. When the slave ships arrived in West Africa, the need for ‘pidgin’ occurred immediately. The slaves, from many different language backgrounds, had to communicate with each other and with their overseers. There is plenty of evidence to suggest that the slavers broke up the various tribes to minimise the risk of rebellions on board. Raiding parties were moving well north of the Niger and deep into western Sudan. A region already suffering from repeated plagues of locusts and droughts was now made even more insecure. In some of the worst-hit areas, it was not uncommon for desperate villagers to sell their children or even themselves. Those who survived the ‘middle passage’ were sold to plantation owners and set to work as house servants or in the fields. Meanwhile, the same ships, laden with sugar, rum and molasses, returned to their homeport, registering substantial profit for their merchant-owners.
In the century and a half of the slave trade, from the 1650s to 1807, between three and four million Africans were transported out of their homelands to the New World in British ships. Between nine and twelve million were abducted and sold as chattel property by the traders of all the European nations involved; it was the single largest mass abduction in human history. A million and a half of those transported to the Caribbean and the plantation colonies on the American continent died in transit. Of course, it was not only the white Europeans and Americans who were responsible for this enormous atrocity. It had been the Portuguese discovery of a thriving trans-Saharan slave trade, harvested and delivered by African warrior dealers, which had made the traffic possible in the first place. But the demand for slaves trans-shipped to the New World became so voracious in the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries that it created incentives for the raiders, usually native or Portuguese, to reach far beyond their traditional catchment areas, to make opportunistic descents on stricken and defenceless villages.
Above: A view Taken Near Bain on the West Coast of Guinea in Africa, engraved after Richard Westhall, c. 1789. A contemporary print illustrating a native slave raid on an African village.
As Captain William Smith wrote in A New Voyage to Guinea in 1744, by having some of every sort onboard, there will be no more Likelihood of their succeeding in a Plot, than of finishing the Tower of Babel. The captured Africans were brought to the coast in columns, loaded with heavy stones to prevent escape, and forced to march sometimes hundreds of miles to the sea. At the trading posts, they were penned into ‘trunks’ for inspection by buyers. Here, the death rate was one in five. Outside in the harbour, the slave captains waited to ferry their purchases on board. One of them, Captain Newton, who later became active in the anti-slavery movement, passed the time composing his famous hymn, How Sweet the Name of Jesus Sounds!
The transatlantic slave trade was qualitatively more inhuman than the norms of slavery prevailing in North and West Africa. Previously, such slaves had been attached to the households, courts and retinues of their owners. Never before, though, had masses of one particular African ethnic group been treated as forced labour, as mere units of production. By definition, slaves had always been seen as ‘property’, but now they were also ‘inventory’, as ‘nothing more than beasts of burden’ as Richard Baxter had put it. Perhaps the most shaming aspect of that dehumanisation was the adoption of a set of racial stereotypes claiming that black Africans were animal-like in their incapacity to feel pain or even emotion in the same manner experienced by white ‘Europeans’. By the time they had reached their first ‘selling point’ from the holding pens at trading posts like Cape Coast Castle, the abducted Africans had already endured a succession of traumas. Olaudah Equiano, the Ibo who wrote his memoirs in the mid-eighteenth century, had been well aware of the dangers of abduction as a child. When the adults of his village were away at work in the fields he would climb trees to sound the alarm when suspicious persons made an appearance. One day, nonetheless, he and his sister were taken. It was when separated that misery first took hold:
I was left in a state of distraction not to be described. I cried and grieved continually and for several days did not eat anything but what they forced in my mouth.
When he continued to refuse his gruel of horse beans and vegetables, he was flogged until he changed his mind. Though he was to see his sister again, it was a moment of false hope, for Equiano, like countless others, was deliberately uprooted from any kind of familiarity – country, customs, language, kin. When a ‘pidgin’ English, French or Portuguese became the common language on a slave ship, it evolved into a creole. The children of pidgin-speaking slaves who met on board a ship then developed it into a creole (from a Portuguese word for a slave born into a master’s household, a ‘house-slave’) which formed their native language. In these ways, the English creoles of Barbados, Jamaica and other English-speaking Caribbean islands developed, just as Haitian creole developed from the pidgin of the French slave trade. The roots of pidgin English are controversial among historical-linguists and etymologists, but few dispute that the idea of pidgin-like English expressions like ‘sicky-sicky’ and ‘workee’ were recognised from the middle of the sixteenth century, with both Marlowe and Shakespeare using forms of pidgin in their plays. By the beginning of the eighteenth century, the concept was sufficiently well-established for Daniel Defoe to put it in the mouth of ‘Man Friday’ in Robinson Crusoe without any explanation.
Olaudah Equiano was born in 1745 in the interior of what is now Nigeria. He was kidnapped by local raiders at the age of ten, taken to the coast and sold to white slave traders bound for the West Indies. After eleven years of slavery in the Caribbean and mainland America, he purchased his freedom and subsequently described his experiences of the slave trade and slavery in the middle decades of the eighteenth century, a book published in 1789; this was called The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano … the African. Here he describes how he felt when he was first taken on board the slave ship:
The first object which saluted my eyes when I arrived on the coast was the sea and a slave ship that was then riding at anchor and waiting for its cargo. These filled me with astonishment, which was soon converted into terror when I was carried on board. I was immediately handled and tossed up to see if I were sound by some of the crew, and I was now persuaded that I had gotten into a world of bad spirits and that they were going to kill me. Their complexions too differing so much from ours, their long hair and the language they spoke (which was very different from any I had ever heard) united to confirm me in this belief. … When I looked around the ship too and saw a large furnace of copper boiling and a multitude of black people of every description chained together, every one of their countenances expressing dejection and sorrow, I no longer doubted of my fate; and quite overpowered with horror and anguish, I fell motionless on the deck and fainted.
Onboard, the slaves were packed like animals. The ships then sailed across the Atlantic, many of the slaves dying on the journey. They could not sit upright or lie full length. Once a day, they were brought up for exercise and to the sailors a chance to “clean the pails”. When the weather was bad, they remained incarcerated. No place on earth, as one writer observed, concentrated so much misery as the hold of a slave ship. As the ship continued to sail the West African coast, one of the hottest and dampest regions of the world to pick up more cargo, and Equiano recalled how dangerous the climate below decks became:
The closeness of the place and the heat of the climate, added to the number in the ship, being so crowded that each had scarcely room to turn himself, almost suffocated us. This produced copious perspiration so that the air soon became unfit for respiration from a variety of loathsome smells and brought on a sickness among the slaves, of which many died, thus falling victims to the improvident avarice, as I may call, of their purchasers. This deplorable situation was again aggravated by the galling of the chains, now become insupportable; and the filth of necessary tubs into which the children often fell, and were almost suffocated. The shrieks of the women and groans of the dying rendered it a scene of horror almost inconceivable.
African slaves onboard ship – from a painting of about 1750
Equiano was describing a perfect environment for faecal contamination, in which both shigellosis or bacillary dysentery, the ‘red flux’ and, more ominously, amoebic dysentery, the ‘white flux’, could rage. Commonly chronicled by surgeons aboard the slavers, both triggered violent spasms of vomiting and diarrhoea, which would induce further fluid loss. No wonder that when he was taken below decks for the first time, even before the ship had set sail, Equiano received such a salutation in my nostrils as I had never experienced in my life. Amoebic dysentery, which had a longer incubation period, attacked the victim in mid-voyage and was the more serious of the two infections since it lasted for weeks rather than days, with its victims suffering around twenty evacuations a day. Fluid losses would have been massive, triggering rapid sodium depletion and the excretion of potassium, which in turn would have affected brain function. Under the circumstances, it is almost unbelievable that the mortality rate on slave ships was only around twelve to fifteen per cent, though it could be as high as twenty per cent for children, who were more vulnerable to acute dehydration than adults.
Above: Conditions on board the slave ships were very poor. Many slaves died on the Atlantic crossing, some of them thrown overboard when they became sick. When they finally got to the American colonies, the slaves were sold to the plantation and mine owners. They would be oiled to make them look healthier. Slaves had no rights and could not marry. Children were separated from their parents and often sold separately.
What happened to them next, if they survived to landfall, may have made the young slaves wish they had perished on board. When they reached the West Indies or the American colonies, the survivors were brought up on deck to be sold. Naked except for loincloths, they were paraded, poked and inspected all over again like livestock. Their purchasers examined them for defects, pinched their skin, and sometimes tasted their perspiration to see if their blood was pure. Their jaws were clamped open for the inspection of teeth. At Bridgetown in Barbados, Equiano described the prospective buyers on a signal given, such as the beat of a drum, rushing into the yard like bargain-hunters at a sale, sprinting towards the chained slaves and laying hands on them to secure their purchase. The most desirable job lots were young boys like Olaudah, between twelve and fifteen, for as David Stalker, a planter’s buyer on the island of Nevis, explained, …
… they are fully seasoned by eighteen and is full as handy as them that is born in the country, but them full-grownfellers think its hard work never being brought up to it … or are never good for anything.
Above: an eighteenth-century advertisement for a cargo of slaves to be sold in South Carolina.
If they were too ‘meagre’, Equiano wrote, they would be put in scales, weighed and sold a threepence or sixpence the pound like cabbages. Finally, the slave was branded again on the chest with a hot iron. They were then delivered, or sold on, to the owners of plantations. At least eighty per cent of the slave population worked, in some form or other, on the plantations for seventy to eighty hours per week. As a slave, Equiano appears to have been relatively fortunate with his masters, escaping the brutal treatment inflicted on many of his brethren:
It was very common in several of the islands, particularly in St Kitts, for the slaves to be branded with the initial letters of their master’s name, and a load of heavy iron hooks hung about their necks. Indeed on the most trifling occasions,they were loaded with chains, and often instruments of torture were added. The iron muzzle, thumbscrews, etc., are so well known as not to need a description and were sometimes applied for the slightest faults. I have seen a Negro beaten till some of his bones were broken for even letting a pot boil over.
Slaves planting sugar cane.
Now they truly belonged to ‘King Sugar’ and toiled to make him rich. He was no sparer of age or sex. At least eighty per cent of the slave population worked, in some form or other, on the plantation for seventy to eighty hours per week. About twenty per cent of those born there failed to survive beyond their second birthday, but if they did they had four or five years before they joined the ‘third’ work gang of the child labourers, gleaning, weeding, cutting grass and taking care of domestic animals. The ‘second gang’ comprised adolescents from twelve to nineteen, already out in the fields as well as tending to the animal population. The work of the second gang, around eleven hours from before dawn to after dusk, was so hard that many of the girls, in particular, died before they could graduate to the even more relentlessly back-breaking routine of the ‘great gang’ of adults. About sixty per cent of the total slave force of Barbados, Jamaica and Antigua worked in the ‘great’ or ‘first’ gang drilling holes for the new canes; cutting and stripping the the harvest during the frantic ‘crop time’ between January and May; bundling and hauling the cumbersome canes at a smart-enough pace not to compromise the quality of the sugar.
Above: A sugar plantation in Barbados
Looking on to see that the work was going quickly was the overseer, as often black as white, quick to use the whip should he see any laggards. Assignment in the mill or the boiling house was hardly an improvement. The vertical rollers that crushed the cane were notorious for taking hands with them since the cane had to be fed in manually, and hatchets were kept beside the mill to sever an arm before the entire body was pulled in. Slaves in the boiling houses worked in conditions of intense heat, dirt and exhaustion and were in constant danger of being scalded by the boiling syrup as it was poured from larger to smaller copper vats.
Above: Inside the boiling house on a sugar plantation.
By the time they left the slave ship, the Africans would have become familiar with quite a range of pidgin English, despite the conditions under which this new English emerged. There would have been every incentive for them to form a new speech community, the first step in the painful rebuilding of a shattered world. In this way, pidgin English, borrowed from the sailors, became the slave lingua franca. Resistance to their new conditions took many different forms other than violent insurrection. Among the socially traumatised slave community there were those who took it on themselves to preserve some sense of African tradition and cultural memory in a world that had been stripped of it. From the time they were put on board the slave ships, different language groups, regions and tribes had been deliberately mixed to pre-empt any kind of solidarity developing among them. But the memory of communal life and the need for retracing the scraps and shards of ancient traditions proved stronger than the institution of slavery itself. As Schama has it, …
… African culture, though pulverised by terror and hardship, was reduced not fine dust that could be blown away into the wind but to small, resistant grains that could be replanted, regrown, remade. And those new growths were tended by keepers of ancestral wisdom, keepers of the knowledge of religion … healing and music.
Because the tribal and language groups – Akan, Twi, Efik, Ewe (see the map of Africa above) – could not just be transposed to St Kitts, Antigua and Barbados, the healers, drummers, singers, weavers and carvers had to create new forms from many strands of material, some inherited, others discovered, all shared. These were hard-earned and retained possessions which were not in the gift of their masters. In fact, the reluctance of the Caribbean masters in the early years to Christianise the slaves, lest literacy and religion produce a sense of presumptuous brotherhood in Christ and lest the uses of literacy turn seditious, gave the Africans a generation or two to establish their own kind of syncretic culture, free from interference. When, finally, an effort was made to convert them, the missionary gospel was inevitably grafted on to cultural roots that had already sunk deep into the West Indian soil.
Since the 1980s, most American linguists have accepted that there was a continuum in the varieties of Black English which runs from the Krio of Sierra Leone to Caribbean Creole to the Gullah of the South Carolina coast to the modern Black English of the wider Unites States. The African element in the English spokenby the slaves on the plantations, known as ‘Plantation Creole’ was sustained well into the eighteenth century, since some African languages, Wolof in particular, were spoken quite widely in the southern states. At least one or two slaves on each plantation knew and were admired for knowing an African language. Slave advertisements indicate the presence of these Wolof-speakers. Others refer to the quality of the English spoken. Phrases like “speaks English though somewhat Negroish” and “speaks rather more proper than Negroes in general” occur regularly. Slavery was a part of everyday life. Many famous Americans, other than plantation owners like George Washington, had slaves, though they didn’t always refer to them as such. One of Benjamin Franklin’s sale notices advertised:
A likely Negro wench, about fifteen years old, … been in the country above a year and talks English.
Franklin himself attempted to record a version of Black English in writing his Information for those Who Would Remove to America, his respondent using an African word for ‘white man’, “Boccararra” from ‘bukra’. By the time he was caught up in the American Revolution, there were slave communities from Massachusetts to Georgia. The majority in the South were now speaking a wide range of English. The latest arrivals from Africa knew only pidgin English, but those who had been shipped from the West Indies and those who had been born on a plantation would speak Plantation Creole. If they were house slaves they would be able to speak “very proper English”. In the North, away from the influence of the plantations, and where the black populations were heavily outnumbered, the Blacks were rapidly assimilated lingustically than in the South.
Gradually, even in the ‘deep South’, the memory of their African languages faded. The children would switch to the language of the playground, Plantation Creole, even if her mother, a first generation slave, spoke to her in her native African tongue. But By the end of the eighteenth century, the linguistic situation among the Black slave communities on the plantations had excited enough literary comment for it to be clear to us today that Gullah was not an isolated exxample, but a forerunner of Black English. One British visitor who bought a slave named Richmond from a plantation in North Carolina noted that: “Many of the others also speak a mixed dialect between Guinea and the English.” By one route or another, therefore, words and phrases from various West African languages were retained and passed into spoken American English. There were also words and phrases which emerged from nearly 250 years of slavery itself. Phrases like ‘slave driver’ and ‘to sell down the river’ come from the plantations. The latter referred to a way of punishing a slave by selling him to a sugar-cane plantation on the Lower Mississippi where, as everyone knew, the conditions were far worse than on the Virginian tobacco plantations.
Rites of passage figured heavily in the retained and re-integrated culture, none more important than funerary rites. From the beginning of mass enslavement, the slaver captains noticed that Africans invariably treated death as liberation. To die in the Caribbean was to go home and, to the bewilderment of clergymen like the Reverend Griffith Hughes, in Jamaica in the 1730s burials were occasions for joyful outbreaks as well as solemnity. The bodies were laid out in fresh white cloths and were borne to the grave in a slow procession, the women walking in pairs and dressed in white, the West African colour of mourning, both women and men singing and howling in a ‘sorrowful manner’ according to one observer.
Once the body was interred, along with it went various provisions, in order to sustain him in his journey beyond those pleasant hills in their own country whither they say he is now going to live at rest. Once the grave was filled up the dirt, the mood of the moment changed to singing, clapping and dancing,using gourd rattles, drums and baffalo, many of the mourners desiring the corpse to acquaint their their … relations of their present condition … as he passeth through their country towards the pleasant mountains. Kissing the grave was the equivalent of sending a letter home with the dead acting as courier. Also deposited in the graves and recovered through the excavation of grave cemetteries on Barbados, were ornaments appropriate to a happy homecoming, often familiar objects in African jewellery such as cowrie shells and glass beads, amulets and charms which were lovingly fashioned. Having been dispossessed of virtually everything, not least their humanity, the slaves somehow managed to create works of art which they then gave to the dead so that they might arrive back home in dignity.
In 1732, the last of the British colonies in North America, Georgia, was founded. It was originally planned as a home for imprisoned debtors by a philanthropist, General Oglethorpe. Then, slaves were introduced to work on the rice fields, and the planters became rich. In 1619, there were only a handful of slaves in the North American colonies, but by 1772 there were half a million, half of them in Virginia and South Carolina. Slavery made its own traditions of speech and vocabulary, and the memory of both is still fundamental to Black American English. The trade involved much cruelty and was also highly profitable. Slaves were sold in the West Indies for roughly five times what they had ‘cost’ on the African coast. The journey may have been long (the triangular trip took between nine and twelve months) but from the merchants’ view, it was very worthwhile.
Successive eighteenth-century British governments took a great interest in foreign trade. They wanted Britain to become wealthier and therefore more powerful and its trading policies were designed to bring this about. The most important aim was to ensure that the goods leaving the country were worth more than the goods coming in, i.e. to create a favourable balance of trade. As a general rule, therefore, imports were discouraged by increasing import duties, while exports were encouraged by reducing export duties. Important home industries, such as the woollen cloth industry, were protected from foreign competition and encouraged to send their products overseas.
The government was also anxious that goods should be carried in British-owned ships. The Navigation Acts of 1651 and 1660, were designed to increase Britain’s share of the carrying trade. They were aimed principally against the Dutch who, as late as 1728, were described by Daniel Defoe as “the Carryers of the World”. The Acts stated that goods coming into Britain were to be carried either in British ships or in ships belonging to the country from where they came. The 1660 Act listed the goods to which this ruling applied. The list included many items from Europe, such as timber and naval stores from the Baltic, and important colonial products, such as sugar from the Caribbean and Virginian tobacco coming into Bristol, which became one of Britain’s main imports from the mid-seventeenth century, as the popularity of smoking developed (see the nineteenth-century label above). In the eyes of the government, Britain’s colonies had an important role to play in helping the mother country to prosper. They could supply Britain with raw materials she did not possess and could buy British-made goods. Many restrictions were placed on the colonies to ensure that they did not compete with the ‘home industries’ in woollen manufacture, not even by transporting and selling such goods from one colony to another. The Act proved difficult to enforce and woollen manufacturing continued in the American colonies.
In the course of the eighteenth century, Britain became the most prosperous trading nation in the world. Its most serious commercial rival was France. At the beginning of the century, both countries had empires in North America and the West Indies and controlled trading posts in West Africa and India. For both countries, these possessions were vital to their prosperity and a bitter struggle developed between them as each country sought to ruin the other’s trading position by attacking its rival’s colonies. This struggle reached its height during the Seven Years’ War (1756-63). Britain emerged victorious from this, leaving it in control of the most important European overseas empire, with a population of half a million in its Thirteen colonies. Yet, emerging from the war, there was a new awareness of empire in which the effective hegemony of North America was especially entrancing. Imperial civil servants and ministers enjoyed a brief period of uninhibited inventiveness in the early 1760s as they planned a new and rosy future for the transatlantic colonies. The West Indies, firmly entrenched in a more effectively policed mercantilist system, would maximise the benefits of a ‘flourishing’ slave trade, provide a steady flow of tropical products, and form a valuable base for commercial incursions into the Spanish Empire. In contrast to those that Simon Schama calls the grovelling hacks and epicene toadies who lived off the leavings of the oligarchs there had emerged, from the 1730s,
… the honest sort of the country, men who sweated for a living: ordinary country gentlemen, merchants, decent artisans, men of commerce – the ‘Heart Blood’ of the nation.It was these men whobelieved themselves tyrannised by the arbitrary powersof Walpole’s excise-men, and who looked to the promotion of blue-water empire to fulfil their partnership between trade and freedom. So when they spoke of liberty they meant, among other enterprises, the liberty to buy and sell slaves.
The kind of liberty they mouthed so freely was not for black Africans, whose welfare had definitely not been uppermost in the minds of those who had written ‘Magna Carta’ or ‘The Petition of Right’. It seldom occurred to those who spoke about the ’empire of liberty’ that its prosperity depended on the enslavement of hundreds of thousands of Africans since it would take another generation before ‘natural’ equality would join liberty in the radical canon. So while William Kent was erecting his memorial to the founding fathers of the free seventy-seven Akan-speaking Antiguan slaves, the leaders of an aborted rising which intended to seize the island on the anniversary of George II’s coronation in October 1736, were being publicly tortured and burnt alive. As Simon Schama has commented,
The irony that an empire so noisily advertised as an empire of free Britons should depend on the most brutal coercion of enslaved Africans is not just an academic paradox. It was the condition of the empire’s success, its original sin: a stain that no amount of righteous self-congratulation at its eventual abolition can altogether wash away.
By the middle of the eighteenth century, the mercantile ’empire of liberty’ was critically dependent for its fortune on the economic universe made from slavery. The sugar produced by three-quarters of a million slaves in the Caribbean had become the single most valuable import to Great Britain, and it would not be displaced from that rank until the 1820s. Huge fortunes had been made, which translated themselves into grandiose country estates and houses in Britain, or the kind of institutional bequest that, from the money of the Codringtons in Barbados and Antigua, created the great library of All Souls College, Oxford.
The profits from sugar are no longer considered by historians to have been a pre-condition of Britain’s industrial revolution, since the amounts available for reinvestment did not exceed anything like two per cent of the capital ploughed into purely industrial undertakings. But it’s indisputable that the sugar-tobacco slave economy had immensely important spin-off effects on Britain’s industrial enterprises after 1780. Much of the elegance of eighteenth-century Bristol was paid for by the sugar and tobacco trades, and therefore by the slave trade. The port of Liverpool, which in the 1740s sent three times as many triangular trade ships to Africa and the Caribbean as London, owed its expansion entirely to it. The great banking houses of Barclays and Lloyds were equally the creation of the Atlantic trade, and they were afterwards able to provide capital to the manufacturers of Britain. While Indian calicoes had once been among the exports shipped from Britain to Africa in exchange for slaves, the huge demand there for brilliant printed cottons was now supplied almost entirely by more cheaply produced British textiles. And the demand for the ancillary products of the sugar industry – molasses, rum and treacle – worked to tie together not just the West Indies and Britain but the continental American colonies and the wider Caribbean as well.
In the 1750s, the magnates who had made their fortunes in the West Indies – Christopher Codrington, Governor of the Leeward Islands, William Beckford, the Pinneys and the Lascelles – formed a powerful lobby in Westminster and the City of London and began to grumble about the difficulties it faced in preserving the sugar empire. The price of sugar was going down, it asserted, while the price of slaves was going up. Neither of these assertions was supported by any substantial evidence. Sugar prices had halved between 1713 and 1733, the lowest point, but it had recovered by the end of the 1740s. What did touch a raw nerve among Britain’s investors was the colonial rivalry offered by the French, especially in the Caribbean. They were right to worry, for although the French were comparative late-comers to the colonial theatre, at least in the boom sector of the West Indies, they more than compensated by the concentrated energy they brought to profit-making. By the 1740s, there were signs that the productivity of the French Caribbean sugar empire was beginning to outstrip that of the British. The French had their own slaver fleets built and fitted out at the dynamically growing port of Nantes at the mouth of the Loire; and they possessed their own locked-up sources of supply on the Gambia and in Senegal. The French plantations seem from the beginning to have been more productive than the British. They grew and shipped enough sugar to undercut prices in Europe, virtually taking that market away from the British. Also, the economy of the French West Indies was more diversified, exporting coffee, cotton and indigo. In St Dominique, on the western half of Spanish Hispaniola, they had an area bigger than any of the British islands.
The Demise of the Colonial Slave Trade: 1750-1780:
George Washington’s Mount Vernon Estate.
One of those who spoke freely of liberty, yet ‘acquired’ a large number of slaves was the future and first President of the United States. Between 1700 and 1750 the number of slaves in the colonies of Virginia had increased from 13,000 to 105,000, nearly eighty per cent of them born in Virginia. Agricultural land required labour to be productive, and in the 18th-century American south that meant slave labour. George Washington was born in 1732, the first child of his father Augustine’s second marriage. Augustine was a tobacco planter with some ten thousand acres of land and fifty slaves. On his death in 1743, he left his 2,500-acre Little Hunting Creek to George’s older half-brother Lawrence, who renamed it ‘Mount Vernon’. Washington inherited the 260-acre Ferry Farm and ten slaves. He leased Mount Vernon from Lawrence’s widow two years after his brother’s death in 1752 and inherited it in 1761. He was an aggressive land speculator, and by 1774 he had amassed some thirty-two thousand acres of land on the Ohio, on Virginia’s western frontier. At his death, he possessed over eighty thousand acres. In 1757, he began a programme of expansion at Mount Vernon that would ultimately result in an eight thousand-acre estate with five separate farms, on which he initially grew tobacco.
Above: George Washington, as Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army in 1775. He was faithfully accompanied by William Lee, throughout the Revolutionary War.On his death, Lee was the only of his slaves to be emancipated.
In Washington’s lifetime, slavery was deeply ingrained in the economic and social fabric of Virginia, where some forty per cent of the population and virtually all African Americans were enslaved. Washington inherited slaves from Lawrence, acquired more as part of the terms of leasing Mount Vernon, and inherited slaves again on the death of Lawrence’s widow in 1761. On his marriage in 1759 to Martha Dandridge Custis, Washington gained control of eighty-four ‘dower slaves’. They belonged to the Custis estate and were held in trust by Martha for the Custis heirs, and although Washington had no legal title to them, he managed them as his own property. Between 1752 and 1773, he purchased at least seventy-one slaves ‘of his own’ – men, women and children. He scaled back significantly his purchasing of slaves after the American Revolution, but continued to acquire them, mostly through natural increase and occasionally in settlement of debts. In 1786, he listed 216 slaves – 122 men and women and 88 children – making him one of the largest slaveholders in Fairfax County. Of that total, 103 belonged to Washington, the remainder being dower slaves. By the time of Washington’s death in 1799, the slave population at Mount Vernon had increased to 317, including 143 children. Of that total, he owned 124, leased forty and controlled 153 dower slaves.
Whether Britain should continue to sanction slavery and the slave trade was, of course, one of the great issues of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. Those in favour of slavery stressed the commercial advantages it brought, as they had from its beginning:
The most approved Judges of the Commercial Interests of these Kingdoms have been of the opinion that our West India and African Trades are the most nationally beneficial of any that we carry on. It also allowed on all Hands that the Trade to Africa is the Branch which renders our American Colonies and Plantations so advantageous in Great Britain; that Traffic only affording our Planters a constant supply of Negro Servants for the Culture of their Lands in the Produce of Sugars, Tobacco, Rice, Rum, Cotton, Fustick (yellow dye), Pimento (Jamaica Pepper) and all other Plantation Produce. …
But ‘Economists’ such as Adam Smith began to question the long-held assumption that the plantation colonies were essential to Britain’s continued prosperity. In his book, Wealth of Nations, (1776), Smith pointed out how expensive it was for Britain to defend the American colonies during the succession of colonial wars with France, Spain and the mainland colonies themselves:
The expense of the ordinary peace establishment of the coloniesamounted, before the commencement of the present disturbances (i.e. the American War of Independence), to the pay of twenty regiments of foot; … to the expense of a very considerable naval force which was constantly kept up,in order to guard, from the smuggling vessels of other nations, the immense coast of North America, and that of our West Indian islands. The whole expense of this peace establishment was a charge upon the revenue of Great Britain, and was, at the same time, the smallest part of what the dominion of the colonies has cost the mother-country. … We must add to it, in particular, the whole expense of the late war, and a great part of the war which preceded it.
In more specific economic terms, slavery as it was operated in the British Caribbean at this time was not, in any sense, a rational system. It did not mitigate the severity of labour conditions at least to the point where the planters could get full value from their investment, especially since deaths were never made up by births. Reproduction rates on the plantations were notoriously low, possibly ten to fifteen births per one thousand of the population, compared with perhaps twenty to thirty per thousand in Britain. But neither the balance of the sexes nor the way women were treated was likely to favour a home-grown slave population. Women were outnumbered by men almost two to one, and those who did become pregnant were not spared from work in the fields until they were virtually on the point of delivery. Those women were no more immune than anyone else from floggings administered by overseers if they lagged in the pace of their work. Poor nutrition, damp and vermin-infested huts, exposure to smallpox and yellow fever as well as diseases brought from Africa, like elephantiasis and ‘yaws’, further added to the toll of miscarriages and low fertility. . Yet it seems unlikely that the managers of the plantations were unduly troubled about ‘wastage’, at least until the third quarter of the eighteenth century when prices rose. For a while, it took at least forty pounds to raise a slave child to the point when child and mother could become productive, whereas a new slave could be bought from the traders for between fifteen and thirty pounds. No wonder then that, although 1.5 million slaves were imported into the British Caribbean during the eighteenth century, the population never rose above eight hundred thousand.
Jamaican slaves being punished in a house of correction
Violence, whether threatened or delivered, was what made the system work, and it fell with special savagery on African women. In one year, 1765, the estate manager of the Egypt plantation on Jamaica, Thomas Thistlewood, administered twenty-one floggings to thirteen women, each likely to have been no less than fifty lashes. Equiano wrote that it was common to make the slaves kneel down after such a flogging and thank their masters for it. Arguably, adult women endured the hardest lot of any section of the slave population, since so much was demanded of them – cooking, caring for infants, mending and washing clothes in addition to working in the fields. And they also had to endure the habitual sexual aggression of masters and overseers who assumed they could copulate with any woman they chose whenever and wherever the mood took them. Female field-hands, like the men, worked naked but for a loincloth, and must therefore have been especially vulnerable. Thomas Thistlewood recorded having intercourse a hundred times with his slave mistress, Phibbah, during one year. But in addition to her, he had twenty-three other slave women on fifty-five separate occasions in that same year. A small number of slaves of both sexes did manage to escape the toil of the fields, either as domestic servants in the plantation house or as artisans who had brought with them from Africa the specialised skills which were much needed on the plantation.They constituted a specialist artisan class among the slaves, freer to move around and to buy and sell materials needed in their crafts. The planters knew it was in their own interests to give the slaves some respite, and on Barbados, there were sixty holidays a year.
Above: Reconstruction of a sugar baron’s house on Barbados, c. 1750.
The Sunday markets in towns like English Harbour on Antigua or Bridgetown on Barbados was where the African world remade itself. Both women and men sold all manner of things they had made themselves, legitimately bought from villages or pilfered from the plantation house, if working there as domestics. Money might change hands, or beads and shells, the medium of exchange of West Africa. The markets and craftsmen’s shops created a class of slaves who were more literate and assertive than the field hands, with broader horizons. The planters and their managers sometimes showed their naivety in assuming that this class might act as a means of mediation between themselves and the mass of field hands, but the records of rebellions almost invariably featured ‘ringleaders’ from this ‘slave élite’. Even though there was little chance of any of these revolts actually overturning the slave system, especially on islands like Barbados where sheltering forests had been cleared to make way for cane, there was a steady drum-beat of rebellion which sometimes, as in Antigua in the 1720s and ’30s, and on Jamaica in mid-century, flared into ferocious violence. ‘Tacky’s Rebellion’ on Jamaica in 1760, cost the lives of nearly a hundred whites and four hundred blacks, with a further six hundred more exiled before it was finally put down with great difficulty.
Partly in order to justify their uses of violence, the planters, slavers and sugar magnates had increasingly had to add to their defence of slavery a ‘moral’ emphasis that the system benefited the Negro slaves themselves. Yet it was not until 1761 that London Yearly Meeting of the Society of Friends (Quakers) decided to disown Quakers involved in the slave trade. The latter half of the century saw the disentangling of American Friends from slavery. It also saw the building up of the abolitionist movement, which led to the Acts of Parliament forbidding slave trading by British subjects and ultimately to the the abolition of slavery in the British dominions which at the beginning of that decade still included the continental colonies. This was a ‘classical’ example of religious lobbying for social reform, which marked out the role of the Society among other active nonconformist groups, most notably the Wesleyan Methodists, over the next century and a half. Beginning with the consciences of individuals, then becoming a matter of conscience for the Society as a whole, it moved on to the conscience of the civilised world. The Quakers were the core of the movement, but they joined with all types of liberal and evangelical opinion. One in particular, Thomas Clarkson, came to know Quakers so well that, when the struggle was done, he wrote a Portraiture of Quakerism.
What was to become the ‘Rights of Man’ school was already visible in the writings of the early reform movement. Men such as Richard Price and Joseph Priestley were, by the standards of a later age, moderate enough. But they were challenging some of the most entrenched attitudes and commonplace ideas of their day and it needed very little to force apart their fragile alliance with backwoods gentry and provincial businessmen. In addition, that flourishing product of the Enlightenment mind – Utility – was already in sight. Jeremy Bentham and the philosophical radicals were yet to achieve a significant breakthrough in practical politics, but the flavour which they imparted or perhaps adopted was everywhere, as was the religious influence of evangelicalism. The most notorious target of this ‘new sensibility’ was, of course, the slave trade. The abolitionist campaign, led by Granville Sharp in the formative years of the 1770s, and by William Wilberforce in the 1780s, was to wait many years before success. But there were victories along the way. In the case of Somerset, 1772, a negro slave brought to London by a West Indian planter, was freed on the grounds that no law of England authorised so high an act of dominion as slavery. The historian Paul Langford has seen this both as a ‘tipping point’ in the anti-slavery campaign and a ‘turning point’ in the development of a moderate programme of political reform:
The publicity value of this decision was out of all proportion to its legal significance, but the interest which it aroused caught the essence of the late eighteenth-century mind, with its emphasis on human equality, religious redemption, and political conservatism. For Wilberforce and his friends were staunch defenders of the establishment in Church and State, and utterly uninterested in radical politics. In this, they expressed the serious-minded, Evangelical enthusiasm of the business classes of the new industrial England.
The opponents of slavery and the slave trade made much of the cruelties of the slave trader and the plantation owner. They also attacked the basic inhumanity of making a man a slave, as the Jesuits and the Quakers had done over previous centuries. John Wesley, in his Thoughts upon Slavery (1775) wrote that …
It cannot be that either War or contract, can give any man such property in another as he has in his sheep and oxen. Much less is it possible, that any child of a man should ever be born a slave. Liberty is the right of every human creature, as soon as he breathes the vital air. And no human law can deprive him of that right, which he derives from the law of nature.
In 1787, two years before Equiano published his book, William Wilberforce and other abolitionists formed the Society for the Abolition of the Slave Trade. Wesley wrote to Wilberforce, encouraging him in his glorious enterprise in opposing that execrable villainy (i.e. the slave trade)which is the scandal of religion, of England, and of human nature. Quoting Paul’s letter to the Romans, he assured him that, …
Unless God has raised you up for this very thing, you will be worn out by the opposition of men and devils; but if God be for you who can be against you? Are all of them stronger than God? Oh! Be not weary in well-doing. Go on in the name of God, and the power of His might, till even American slavery, the vilest that ever saw the sun, shall vanish away before it.
The well-organised anti-slavery campaign led to Parliament declaring the British slave trade illegal in 1807. But die-hard planters in Parliament resisted abolition, so that the campaigners had to wait until 1833 for the system of slavery to be abolished throughout the British Empire.
Two centuries later, and until very recently, Colston’s name permeated the city in such landmarks as Colston’s Almshouses, Colston Tower and Colston Hall, among many other school names, street names and placenames. He has also been remembered, particularly by some schools, charities and the Society of Merchant Venturers, on Colston Day (13 November), which celebrates the granting of a royal charter to the Society of Merchant Venturers in 1639, at a church service. A statue of him is on the exterior of Bristol Guildhall and a stained-glass window to his memory in the north transept of St Mary Redcliffe (1870). In April 2017, the charity that runs the Colston Hall, the Bristol Music Trust, announced that it would drop the name of Colston when it reopened after refurbishment in 2020. This happened in June of this year. There had been protests and petitions calling for a name change and some concert-goers and artists had boycotted the venue because of the Colston name. Following the decision, petitions to retain the name of Colston reached almost ten thousand signatures, though the charity confirmed that the name change would go ahead.
A statue, designed by John Cassidy, was erected in the centre of Bristol in 1895 to commemorate Colston’s philanthropy. Since at least the 1990s, campaigns have called for the removal of the statue, describing it as a disgraceful memorial considering Colston’s profiting from the slave trade. In 2018, with the involvement of the community, an official plaque was arranged for the statue to inform the public about more of Colston’s history. Conservative councillor Richard Eddy and the Society of Merchant Venturers (an organisation Colston belonged to) objected to the wording and were successful in, among other things, removing mention of Colston’s role as a Tory MP and selective nature of his philanthropy. They also disputed the exact number and ages of the thousands of children he trafficked. The plaque was rewritten with large involvement from the Society of Merchant Venturers, but the wording was then vetoed by incoming Bristol MayorMarvin Rees, who saw the Society having too much say in the process, instructing more parts of the community to be involved in producing the plaque. Frustrated by the failure of the City authorities to reach a compromise, and spurred on by the George Floyd protests instigated by ‘Black Lives Matter’, On 7 June 2020, the statue was toppled and thrown into Bristol Quay. While many disagreed with this action, few were sorry to see it go from the city centre where, arguably, it never belonged, regardless of the divergent views of Colston’s ‘legacy’.
One of the many murals of George Floyd which followed his death in Minneapolis
The following extract from a recent statement by The Decolonising Working Group Department of History, University of Exeter (and friends) is close to my own view of the toppling of the statue:
Over time societies find new heroes to honour, whose achievements and values more accurately reflect their own concerns and aspirations. And this is why, for all the voices that disagree with the removal of Colston, it is striking how few wish him to return. He was a man of his time, and one whose failures previous societies could overlook. Yet for all his wealth and his philanthropy – and knowing what we do of the current injustices he helped to create – we would not choose to celebrate him now.
I would also add that, in purely historical and contextual terms, Colston died at least forty years before there was a majority shift in contemporary attitudes to slavery. In his lifetime, he was one of many who actively participated in the slave trade and the institution of slavery, including many historical figures who, in other contexts, have been seen as liberals and ‘liberators’. Should their statues be toppled too, and their names be erased from urban landscapes across the world? Perhaps more careful and considered thought should be given to how we research, recall and remember our shared heritages. We may not choose to celebrate or commemorate these figures any longer, but should they simply be ‘expunged’ from history, or can we still learn something from learning about them and the markedly different Britain they lived in from the generally tolerant, multi-cultural one of today?
Sources:
George Taylor & J. A. Morris (c. 1939), A Sketch-Map History of Britain & Europe, 1485-1783. London: Harrap.
Jean Vanes (1988), Bristol at the time of the Spanish Armada. Bristol Branch of the Historical Association: The University of Bristol.
John Morrill, Asa Briggs, Joanna Bourke, et. al. (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British & Irish History. London: Penguin Books.
Martin Dickinson (1979), Britain, Europe and Beyond, 1700-1900. Basingstoke: Macmillan Education.
Robert McCrum, William Cran, Robert MacNeil (1987), The Story of English. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
Simon Schama (2001), A History of Britain: The British Wars, 1603-1776. London: BBC World.
Royalist strategy in the Spring of 1645 had been to thrust north through Worcester to Chester and then pick up reinforcements in the north, where there would still be plenty of sympathisers despite the disaster of Marston Moor in the previous year. Rupert and Maurice, the King’s nephews, cleared the way by victories at Ledbury and Chester, but Charles himself was slow to move. Meanwhile, Cromwell, who was enjoying his first independent command, was sent to the Midlands to upset any Royalist plans. He lost no time in showing his ability and determination, defeating the Earl of Northampton near Islip, compelling the surrender of Bletchington House, taking two hundred prisoners in battle at Bampton, and making an unsuccessful attack on Faringdon Castle. However, he could not prevent the King from leaving Oxford with an army numbering eleven thousand. Both armies now began manoevring for advantage. Fairfax came up from the west and threatened Oxford; Rupert countered by sacking Leicester. Charles, although aware that his army was large and well-balanced was not prepared to risk it in open battle against vastly superior numbers. He therefore moved to Daventry, where he deliberated about how to relieve Oxford.
General Sir Thomas Fairfax, commander of the Parliamentary Army in 1645.
Leicester’s agony had the expected effect of making the Committee of Safety in London abandon the folly of besieging Oxford. Parliament promptly accepted its recommendation that Fairfax should take the field against the King forthwith, and it soon freed him from constant direction from Westminster. It simply ordered him to follow the movements of the Royalist army and left the rest up to his judgement. Unaware of this, the King’s council of war overode Rupert and decided that the defence of Oxford must remain the main priority, the courtiers in the city, particularly the ladies, felt exposed. Added to this, Charles was not keen to engage the ‘Ironsides’ in the field with an army which was stretched by the need to garrison Leicester and beset by widespread looting, desertions and mutinies. He reckoned that he had barely four thousand foot and 3,500 horse left. Langdale’s northerners had riden off when they heard that the army was not going to move northwards and were only brought back with difficulty on 5 June, but there was still no sighting of Goring’s men or Gerrard’s Welsh levies.
In each other’s shadows:
Ordered to recover Leicester, Fairfax raised the siege of Oxford on 5 June and marched north. Three long marches took his army to a rendezvous near Newport Pagnell with the 2,500 men he had sent to support Leven, and by the 7th they were at Sherington, near Newport Pagnell. Meanwhile, the Royalist Army had camped near Daventry, where it remained immobile for nearly six days from 7 June onwards, mainly because 1,200 cavalry had been detached to escort vast quantities of cattle and sheep to Oxford, and they did not rejoin the army until the night of the 11th. Rupert cannot have approved this, because he knew from the 7th at the latest that Fairfax had raised the siege of Oxford. He wrote to his old friend Will Legge that there had been a plot among the civilian councillors to persuade Charles to return to Oxford, where they could reassert their control over him and counter the influence of the ‘soldiers’, meaning chiefly himself. Charles rejected the proposal, but it had already added to Rupert’s sense of insecurity. His own judgement was also questionable, however, for he shared the cavaliers’ facile contempt for the ‘New Noddle’, and he was poorly informed of its current strength. He was also quite unaware of its current proximity, whereas Fairfax had excellent intelligence of royalist movements from Sir Samuel Luke at the garrison at Newport Pagnell.
On 8 June, Fairfax held a crucial council of war. He put two questions to the council: how best to bring the King’s army to battle, and how to fill the vacant post of lieutenant-general of the horse. For that post he proposed Cromwell, and the assent was unanimous. He sent Colonel Robert Hammond to Westminster to request the appointment, to which the Commons immediately agreed. The Lords, whose concurrence was legally required to exempt Cromwell from the Self-Denying Ordinance, declined to give it, but the Commons’ assent was enough for Fairfax. Fairfax received equally strong support for seeking battle at the first opportunity, and on 11th he advanced his headquarters to Stony Stratford, only twenty-five miles from where the Royalist Army was entrenched in its impregnable position on Burough Hill near Daventry. Fairfax and his commander of foot, Skippon, had had much to do during the week before the impending battle, for many infantry recruits were recent arrivals and were not even armed when the army left the Oxford lines. A large consignment of muskets overtook them on the march, but there were still basic skills to be mastered. Fairfax began his final advance against the royal forces in foul weather on the 11th. His men slogged all day along muddy country lanes, avoiding the more frequented roads, and when they quartered at Wootton that night their approach was still unsuspected.
It was this stealthful strategy which gave Fairfax the initiative. By 12 June, the New Model had reached Kislingbury, eight miles east of Daventry (see ‘map 2’ above), and its cavalry patrols drove the Royalist outposts back towards the town. This was close enough to Charles to alert him to the impending danger, but the rain may have made Rupert’s scouts slack in patrolling, for he was still oblivious of the New Model’s proximity until late in the afternoon, when its ‘forlorn hope’ of forward cavalry surprised two of his outposts only two miles outside Daventry. The Royalist Army was dispersed and resting, its horses grazing, while the King was enjoying a hunt at Fawsley Park, several miles away from its nearest positions. Fairfax quartered his army around Kislingbury that night, and most of it must have slept in the wet fields. By nightfall, Rupert was at last aware that he had seriously underestimated the enemy’s numerical strength. He and the King had decided to retreat northward by way of Melton Mowbray to Belvoir Castle, where they could reinforce themselves from Newark and other Midland garrisons. Fairfax, not yet aware of this intended manoeuvre, stayed in the saddle until 4 a.m., riding round his regiments to check their preparedness against a nocturnal attack until he could make out the dim bulk of Burough Hill beyond Flore in the half-light. But the confusion caused by Fairfax’s sudden and unepexcted appearance did not force the Royalist Army to abandon its strong stand in arms on the hill above the town. Charles had no intention of being forced to fight at a disadvantage on ground not of his own choosing. All night, Fairfax could see their many little fires twinkling, but as the day dawned, so did the realisation that the ‘cavaliers’ were burning their huts before setting off ‘in retreat’.
At 5 a.m, back at the parliamentary camp, Fairfax’s scoutmaster brought him confirmation that the Royalists were indeed retreating. He had also intercepted a letter from Goring to Rupert, telling him that that he was not yet ready to join him from the west but urging him not to engage in battle without him. Buoyed by this news, and even more determined to draw the King into open battle, Fairfax called a war council at 6 a.m., and it was actually meeting when a cheer heralded Cromwell’s arrival. Cromwell had been in Ely, recruiting both horse and foot, and Fairfax sent for him at once on receiving the Commons’ approval of Cromwell’s appointment as Lieutenant-General, and of his plans to engage the King’s Army. Cromwell was the obvious military choice for this command, and it was a very popular appointment in the army. When he rode into the lines with seven hundred horse, early in the day, he was greeted ‘with a mighty shout’. To throw off a possible pursuit, the Royalists marched westwards for some miles towards Warwickshire, as if intending to retreat south-westward towards Oxford, before wheeling north-eastwards for their chosen quarters around Market Harborough, where the King planned to rendezvous with his troops from the Newark garrison. Fairfax lost little time in resuming his pursuit and his ‘complete’ New Model marched to Guilsborough, between Daventry and Market Harborough, about four miles south of Naseby and about eight miles from Harborough.
All through the 13th, a strong detachment of what was now Cromwell’s cavalry, under Henry Ireton and Thomas Harrison, had shadowed the Royalist Army’s movements, remaining hot on its heels, while the remainder of the New Model advanced on a parallel line with it at much closer quarters than Rupert was aware of. He had posted an advanced guard of about twenty horse at Naseby, seven miles from Market Harborough. That evening, Ireton’s scouts fell on them as they were taking supper and refreshments at the inn. Most were captured, but those playing quoits, possibly in a courtyard or separate room, were able to escape and carry the alarm to Harborough. Awakened with this alarming news, that night, Charles called a council of war with Rupert and the other councillors in the early hours of 14 June.
The great question at this was whether to offer open battle, and the answer wasn’t easy. The alternative proposals was to make speedily for Leicester, where the addition of its small garrison and the shelter of its defences would give about ten thousand men a better chance to hold off the fifteen thousand (but, for the most part, barely trained) men of the New Model. There were great risks either way. A retreat with Cromwell’s cavalry in hot pursuit could have led to a savage mauling, not least for the two hundred wagons in the royalist train. But it is very significant that Rupert advised against giving battle, while Digby and Ashburnham pressed for it, arguing that retreat would demoralise the king’s men, whereas they supposed Fairfax’s men to be discouraged by the sack of Leicester and the failure to take of Oxford. Even less realistically, they urged that Fairfax should be engaged before he could join forces with the Scots. In the end, the decision rested with the King, and he opted for open battle. So the decision was taken to stand and fight on the high ground two miles to the south of the town. Here there was a ridge of high ground covering the two miles from East Farndon to Great Oxendon, in modern co-ordinates from the B4036 to the A508 (see the map below).
The Royalists marched south on the morning of 14 June, and the two armies met at Naseby, just over the county boundary from Harborough, in Northants. It has been said that ‘the Royalist cause committed suicide at Naseby’, and it was a battle that the king should never have fought, but in fairness what has to be considered in making this distant judgement is what might have happened if the battle had been declined by Charles and Rupert. Even if the King could have got his army through to Leicester unscathed, he could not shelter there indefinitely, because Fairfax was intent on fighting and could in the long run muster more reinforcements than he. Now that Parliament had learnt how to deplo its superior resources and found commanders with the will to win, the tide of war had turned in its favour. And yet, if Goring had had obeyed orders and added his troops to the king’s, Naseby would have been fought on more equal terms, with even better if still fewer infantry and with a numerical advantage in cavalry. As Austin Woolrych has written,
If the untried New Model’s first battle had ended in defeat, who can be sure that it would have developed the the collective spirit that took it within a year to total victory?
As a result of the interception of his letter, Rupert did not know that Goring was still stuck in Somerset, and that the latter had advised against an immediate engagement in the assumption that his forces were well on the way. Had they waited in Leicester, Goring’s troops may have been able to make a difference in a subsequent battle, but by the time he arrived the Royalist Army could have been destroyed either on the road to Leicester, or in a siege of the City. However, in deciding to go into battle with the troops he had, Charles was going against the odds, but even then, the result was not a foregone conclusion, given the relative inexperience of the parliamentarian infantry.
Both armies were on the move from the early hours of 14 June and in position well before 8 a.m. Rupert deployed the Royal Army along the East Farndon-Oxendon ridge in a position to block any Parliamentarian advance towards Market Harborough. The New Model had concentrated on Naseby by 5 a.m. but Fairfax, unwilling to risk blundering into the royal army in the early morning mist, had halted to await firm news of the enemy’s movements. Fairfax and Cromwell went forward to reconnoitre the ground towards Clipston at about the same time that Rupert, disbelieving the report of his Scoutmaster-General that there were no Parliamentarian troops within four miles of the Royalist position, rode towards Naseby to find the enemy for himself. As Fairfax ranged on the ridge north of Naseby, he contemplated deploying one mile to the south of Clipston where his front would be protected by a stream and boggy ground, but Cromwell argued that Rupert would realize that that an attack in this direction could place his cavalry at a disadvantage, and would therefore refuse action or swing around the Parliamentarian flank onto firmer ground. Fairfax therefore agreed to fall back to the Naseby ridge, where Rupert’s cavalry would have to charge uphill to reach the Parliamentary line. He did not know yet whether the royalists would accept his challenge, but the appearance of their cavalry in force on another ridge four miles away reassured him. It was then that he realised that this was going to be a major battle, if not a decisive one.
Preliminary Manoeuvres:
Fairfax noted that the ground between Naseby and Clipston was marshy, so that if he could persuade Rupert to charge over it and up the ridge, this would be a good start to the day for him. Rupert, of course, had his eyes just as wide open as Fairfax and had during his reconnaisance had observed Fairfax and Cromwell withdraw towards Naseby with their escort. He ordered his army to veer to the right towards Dust Hill, on to the line of the Sibbertoft-Naseby road (see the map above). From there he hoped to to flank Fairfax’s position. Seeing this movement, Fairfax ordered the New Model to close to its left to meet it. By 9 a.m. the two armies were both marching westwards on a parallel course, shifting the battlefront one mile west of its original line. As they drew abreast of the open valley known as Broadmoor, they halted and deployed. The two armies drew up about a thousand yards apart, both near the crests of gentle rises, with the open expanses of Broadmoor between them. This area was now bounded by Dust Hill to the north, Red Hill to south, annd Sulby Hedges to the west.
Streeter’s contemporary line-drawing of the battle (see caption below).
The most recent, detailed and accurate analysis of the battle was written for the 350th anniversary of the battle by Glenn Foard (1995) in Naseby: The Decisive Campaign (Guildford), which is now much the fullest and best analysis of the battle, taking account of archaeological evidence. Excluding officers, Foard estimates that the king probably had just over nine thosand men, compared with something over fifteen thousand on the side of Parliament. The royalists were outnumbered mainly in infantry, though those they had were seasoned soldiers, a high proportion being hard-fighting Welshmen. In terms of cavalry, they had about five thousand against 6,600, but again, they had greater experience. Fairfax had approximately 13,500 New Model men in total, including a thousand dragoons.
The Parliamentarian infantry were deployed in two lines with a ‘forlorn hope’ of musketeers in front of the first and a reserve from Harley’s Regiment behind the second. From left to right the first line of foot consisted of Skippon’s, Hardress Waller’s, Pickering’s, Montague’s and Fairfax’s Regiments, and a second line of Hartley’s, Hammond’s and Rainsborough’s Regiments. Of these regiments, Pickering’s, Montague’s, Hardress Waller’s and Hartley’s (commanded by Lieutenant-Colonel Thomas Pride) were, almost certainly, still seriously under strength. Only Skippon’s own regiment is likely to have had anything near its full complement of men. Pickering’s also probably had more than its fair share of raw recruits, for in January 1645 it had been the weakest of all the Eastern Association regiments joining the New Model, with only 243 men. Moreover, although Ayloffe’s troops had been taken into the regiment, it is unlikely that, as a garrison force throughout 1644, they had been retrained for battle.
The parliamentarian cavalry were drawn up on either flank, Ireton commanding the left wing composed of eleven squadrons, and Cromwell’s slightly stronger right wing of 3,500 troopers in thirteen squadrons. The arrival of Colonel Rossiter’s Lincolnshire regiment, four hundred strong, soon after battle began may have swung the advantage even further towards Fairfax’s army. They deployed to the right rear of the first line and on the right of the third line. At the last moment, the parliamentary dragoons, under Colonel Okey, were ordered to line part of Sulby Hedges in advance of Ireton’s cavalry. From there, they were to have a major role to play against the right of the Royalist line. Fairfax’s artillery commanded by Lieutenant-General Hammond was positioned between the infantry regiments of the first and second lines with a total of eleven guns on the battlefield and three in the baggage park.
Across the moor the Royalist army numbered around nine thousand men, with approximately 4,500 cavalry and almost the same number of infantry. The foot, who had been commanded since Edgehill by the veteran 66-year-old Lord Astley, were deployed in three brigades under, from left to right, Sir George Lisle, Sir Henry Bard and Sir Bernard Astley. They were supported by the nine hundred troopers of Colonel Howard’s Horse and a reserve of 1,300 men formed by the King’s Lifeguard and Prince Rupert’s Regiment. The main body of the cavalry was deployed on the flanks with two thousand horse under Rupert on the right wing and sixteen hundred under Sir Marmaduke Langdale on the left. The royalist artillery comprised twelve cannon deployed in pairs between the regiments and two mortars. But there was very little primed artillery on the Royalist side, as most of it had been left in the army’s initial position. In addition, although the Royalist army was an experienced one with a high proportion of officers to men, it was seriously outnumbered.
Streeter’s plan gives us a contemporary picture, from an eye-witness, showing the two armies facing one another. At Naseby the greater resources available to Parliament, as well as superior discipline, proved decisive.
The battle front was now approximately a mile long. As the final stage of his deployment, Fairfax withdrew his line a hundred paces, so that most of his troops were then hidden behind the crest of the ridge. By 10 a.m., the two armies were in their new positions, having completed all their preliminary manoeuvres. Apart from broken ground to the right of the Parliamentarian position and some marshy ground on the left, the battlefield was favourable for cavalry and perhaps for this reason the outnumbered Royalists took the initiative. They began a general attack, advancing slowly across the half mile of moorland which separated them from the New Model. As they approached, Fairfax moved his line forward back over the crest of the ridge to confront them.
A Battle on Two Flanks:
The Royalist infantry began the battle well in the centre of the Parliamentarian front line, forcing their regiments back, concentrating their attack in support of Prince Rupert’s successful cavalry charge on the left flank and causing Ireton’s horse to veer to the right.
Woolrych’s map of the Field of Battle, showing physical features.
The charge at first seemed a typical one, aiming at the centre of Ireton’s position, but as Ireton’s men veered somewhat to the right, a flank attack of musket fire from Okey’s dragoons (hidden behind Sulby Hedges) slowed Rupert slightly, and both Ireton’s and Rupert’s squadrons halted for a few moments within a short distance of each other. For once, Rupert succeeded in keeping his cavalry in check so that Astley’s infantry were the first Royalist troops to engage the New Model’s. Ireton’s squadrons were already in confusion for while some of them advanced to meet the Royalist horse others stood fast. Rupert charged right into Ireton’s left, settling down to cut and thrust with sword. This was a tough, bloody engagement which the Royalists got the better of, forcing their way through. The first line of the New Model foot buckled and fell back in disorder. A Royalist eye-witness of the battle recorded:
…our forces advanced up the hill, the rebels only discharging five pieces at them, but over shot them, and so did their musquetiers. The foot on either side hardly saw each other until they were within the Carabine Shot, and so only made one Volley; ours falling in with Sword and butt end of the Musquet did notable Execution; so much as I saw their Colours fall, and their foot in great Disorder…
After a short time the regiments in the parliamentarian front line broke, as their diarist and cartographer Sprigge recounted:
The right hand of the foot, being the General’s Regiment, stood, not being much pressed upon: Almost all the rest of the Battail being overpressed, gave ground and went off in some disorder, falling behinde the Reserves.
Colonel John Pickering’s Regiment, was one of the regiments at the very centre of the parliamentarian infantry which took the main force of the combined royalist assault. Baille, a presbyterian, wrote that the Independent Collonels Pickering and Montague flee lyke men. Glenn Foard has contended that although the New Model Army had more infantry than the royalists, it is not clear whether, as enumerated above, in this initial assault the royalists were actually outnumbered. The royalists concentrated their attack against the infantry on parliament’s left and centre. Sprigge described how,
The Colonels and Officers, doing the duty of very gallant Men, in endeavouring to keep their men from disorder, and finding their attempts fruitless therein, fell into the Reserves with their Colours, choosing rather there to die, than leave the field.
Skippon was severely wounded, but he refused to leave the field. Despite the loss of one of his officers, Captain Tomkins, who was killed in this fight, Pickering was undoubtedly also one of those who chose to keep himself and his men with the body, choosing rather to die than leave the field. To his left the charge of the two princes, Rupert and Maurice, carried all before it, putting much of Ireton’s cavalry to rout. Ireton, promoted earlier that morning to commisary-general (second-in-command of the cavalry), was also wounded, and temporarily taken prisoner. When Rupert’s second line joined the melée, the Roundhead cavalry on the extreme left broke and were swept from the field. Rupert forced his way through Ireton’s line, and was then in a position to regroup. Instead, he decided to press on, but achieved little by doing so. The Royalists pursued Ireton’s troopers until they came upon the Parliamentarian baggage train to the west of Naseby. A vain attempt was made to overcome the baggage guard, and nearly an hour passed before Rupert was able to rally his troopers and lead them back to the battle.
Rupert was careful not to waste too much time, not wanting to be accused of another mistake like the one he had made at Edgehill, but his absence from the field at this time was disastrous for his side. In the centre the Royalist infantry had begun well and were forcing the Ironsides back. In attacking Ireton, Rupert, though pushing back the left wing, had left the right half and its commander intact. Ireton now used this part to attack Astley on the flank, as the latter’s magnificent foot stormed up the hill. Then Okey’s dragoons advanced in a cavalry charge. Meanwhile, Fairfax and Skippon had brought the reserve to the support of the Parliamentarian centre and its superior numbers began to tell against the Royalist pikes and muskets. The reserves held the royalist advance.
Thomas Fairfax and his subordinate Oliver Cromwell (right), rout the Royalists at the Battle of Naseby, 14 June 1645. A detail from the contemporary engraving of the Battle shown above..
The Ironside Lieutenant-General:
Everything now hung on what Cromwell’s veteran troopers could do on the right of parliament’s forces, where they had a distinct numerical advantage. His control of them saved the day for the New Model. He had calmly watched the advance of Langdale’s Northern Horse, finding their way over the broken ground at the foot of the hill. It was full of rabbit-warrens and bushes, and anyone caught there would be at a disadvantage. Cromwell launched a powerful, yet disciplined charge, smashing into Langdale’s cavalry, which had been slowed by this difficult terrain on the Royalist left. He needed only to use his leading regiments to wreak havoc in this area, but even these squadrons were impossible for him to recall when their task was done. In the rear, he still had uncommitted troops. He led his remaining squadrons in a spirited but controlled charge which broke the the outnumbered Royalist horse. They were completely victorious, but it was his control of them that saved the day for parliament. Detaching just enough of them to pursue Langdale’s fleeing horsemen, he kept the remainder intact and used them to turn the tide of battle on the rest of the field. This was the turning point of the battle.
As Astley’s Foot stormed their way up Red Hill Ridge, they were met with an unguarded attack from Ireton’s recovering ironsides, supported by a mounted charge from Okey’s dragoons, who had emerged, re-mounted, from behind Sulby Hedges. As Astley’s troops reached Skippon’s Foot, they not only met spirited resistance from the Parliamentary Infantry, but also received a terrible blow from Cromwell’s cavalry on their other flank.
The Ordnance Survey map of the battlefield, with positions of the two armies overlaid.
Having dealt with Langdale’s horse on the royalist left wing, Cromwell turned his cavalry against the royalist infantry. The remaining Parliamentarian cavalry – both Cromwell on the right and the dragoons on the left – charged the flanks of the royalist foot. Even the forward units, who had ridden down Langdale, returned to the fight, and the second and third lines went in completely fresh. The Royalist infantry were now boxed in on three sides, between two cavalry regiments and the crack infantry of the Parliamentary Army. This also gave the opportunity for the parliamentarian infantry regiments that had broken to be rallied and brought back into the action, ensuring the final destruction of the royalist infantry and deciding the outcome of the battle. It was too much even for Astley’s veterans who, abandoned by their own cavalry, were forced to surrender. The Parliamentary victory was complete and Rupert’s return to the battlefield could not retrieve the position. By the time he got back to to where the infantry battle had been raging, the day was all but lost. Cromwell had caught Astley’s gallant men without cavalry support, and Fairfax, who was never out of the thick of the fighting, had re-grouped his forces in a fresh order of battle.
Glenn Foard’s Plan of the battle of Naseby, 1645.
Rupert’s Return:
At this point Rupert came back to the field, but with his horses blown could do no more than be a spectator. The sight he saw was enough to sicken anyone, heroic though it was. Astley’s infantry, having fought their way up the ridge, having been attacked on three sides, were now being forced down again. They fought to the last, and were wiped out almost to a man, four thousand of them. Nearly a thousand were killed on the battlefield, with the others wounded or taken prisoner. Many of the cavalry fought it out to the end too, although it could not effect the result. The King himself was prevented to lead a desperate attempt to turn the tide, and less than three hours after battle had commenced he was in flight with whatever of his forces could get away. As the King and Prince Rupert left the field for their personal safety, Langdale’s cavalry fought on courageously, trying to cover the retreat of what was left of the Royalist Infantry. With the King and Rupert gone, those who could tried to leave the field. As on all battlefields the scenes of the heaviest fighting may be traced by names or by grave pits: ‘Red Hill Ridge’ and ‘Red Hill Farm’ need no explanation.
With eight or more hours to go before nightfall gave them cover, Charles’ fleeing cavalry were pursued with heavy slaughter to within sight of Leicester. Fewer than four thousand got away to safety. His infantry had no choice but surrender, and over 4,500 prisoners were on the march to London the next day. About five hundred more were too badly wounded to be moved far, and the total number of royalist dead, including those killed in flight or dying of wounds, probably came to at least on thousand. By contrast, the New Model probably lost no more than two hundred (some contemporary estimates put the losses at as between fifty and a hundred), including the wounded who did not recover. We can gain a better indication of the true impact of the battle on the regiments from those listed as seriously wounded. Forty-nine men from Pickering’s were listed, four of whom died of their wounds. The other regiments hard-pressed in the front line were Montague’s with thirty-nine seriously wounded, Hardress Waller’s with fourteen and Skippon’s with 140. The remaining infantry regiments suffered far lower numbers of casualties. The most pitiable casualties were the women who followed the Royal Army, many of whom were taken to be Irish, though they were probably the wives of Welsh soldiers. At least a hundred were slaughtered in the baggage train, while most of the rest had their faces slashed or noses slit to mark them as whores.
How decisive was Naseby?
Military historians broadly agree that Naseby was the most decisive battle of the war and that, arguably, Charles should never have fought it: He was outnumbered and was particularly short of cavalry. But it was, again, the indiscipline of Rupert’s own cavalry after its initial success, in moving off the field in the wrong direction, which sealed the fate of both the royalist cavalry and infantry left without cover on the field. The hard fact is that the Royalist officers undervalued their opponents and paid dearly for it. Besides losing his infantry, King Charles also lost his baggage train, his artillery, his private papers and, effectively, his throne, though it was to take another year for that to become evident. His papers included secret correspondence with the Queen which laid bare his hopes of bringing an army of Irish Catholics into England and of obtaining money and mercenaries from foreign princes, as well as his readiness to consider granting toleration to English papists. These letters, published as The King’s Cabinet Opened, created a sensation throughout the country and did him immense harm.
Naseby naturally gave a great boost to the New Model’s morale. Fairfax lost far more men through desertion than in battle, for many of his foot soldiers slipped off home with the booty they had scavenged from the royalist dead, wounded and prisoners. In the pursuit Cromwell had forbidden his troopers to dismount for plunder on pain of death, an unpopular order which seems to have been obeyed. In a memorable dispatch to the Speaker dictated late on the very day of the battle, he rightly praised Fairfax’s conduct in it but said nothing about his own. He gave all the glory to God, but did not forget the soldiery:
Honest men served you faithfully in this action. Sir, they are trusty; I beseech you in the name of God, not to discourage them. … He that ventures his life for the liberty of his country, I wish he trust God for the liberty of his conscience, and you for the liberty he fights for.
Cromwell’s portrait in 1652-53, by Samuel Cooper
The Commons, in ordering his dispatch to be printed, deleted this whole passage. Fortunately the Lords sanctioned its publication intact, so both versions appeared on the bookstalls. The Lords also assented to Cromwell’s appointment as lieutent-general, though only for three months, whereas the Commons voted to extend it indefinitely. Clearly, there were political battles to come, but for the time being it was the military one which was decisive. The day after the battle, as the thousands of royalist prisoners were escorted towards London, the New Model marched north where they joined Cromwell’s cavalry, who were already facing Leicester. On the 16th, Fairfax summoned the city to surrender, but the royalist governer refused. The next day gun batteries were raised and a breach was made in the defences of the Newark gate, where the royalists had stormed the city two weeks before. Soon after the barrage began Lord Hastings, the royalist commander, proposed surrender. Pickering, together with Rainsborough, was appointed as commissioner to treat with the governor over the articles of surrender. Negotiations went on throughout the night, but early on the 18th the garrison marched out, leaving its weapons. So, to add to his misfortunes, Charles’ garrison in Leicester was forced to surrender just three days after the battle.
Glenn Foard’s map of the campaign of 1645
Moving West:
Following a muster at Leicester on the samed day, the New Model advanced through Warwickshire and Gloucestershire, securing these Midland counties, and arrived in Wiltshire by the 3rd July. At Naseby, it had served notice that Parliament at last had an army which could win the war. If the King was was to avoid defeat he must concentrate his forces against the New Model and destroy it. Charles arrived at Hereford on 19 June, while his courtiers were soon engaged in diplomatic ‘damage limitation’ tactics. Within a week of the battle, Digby was writing that the consequences of this disaster will not have great extent, and Charles himself was putting a brave face on his terrible defeat. But on 23 June he wrote a letter to the fifteen-year-old Prince of Wales in terms which show that he was now, perhaps for the first time, contemplating the possibility that he would go on to lose the war. He solemnly commanded his son that should he, his father, ever be taken prisoner, not to yield to any conditions that were dishonourable, or derogatory to regal authority, even to save his father’s life.
In more sanguine moments, however, Charles was still hoping to rebuild an army as good as ever he had commanded. He was able to muster four thousand cavalry that had survived Naseby, but his three thousand infantry replacements were of indifferent quality, certainly compared with Astley’s seasoned soldiers he had lost on 14 June. They were mainly the Welsh levies he had failed to collect before Naseby. But he was also looking to Ireland for help, as he had been throughout the first half of 1645, whither he had dispatched of the Earl of Glamorgan by the end of June, to negotiate on his behalf for a ten-thousand-strong Irish Catholic army. It was this decision, more than any other, as revealed by the secret letters discovered in the baggage train, which sealed his ultimate fate as king.
(… to be continued).
Sources:
David Smurthwaite (1984), The Ordnance Survey Complete Guide to the Battlefields of Britain. Exeter: Webb & Bower.
Philip Warner (1976), Famous Battles of the Midlands. Glasgow: Fontana.
Austin Woolrych (2002), Britain in Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press.
Glenn Foard (1994), Colonel John Pickering’s Regiment of Foot, 1644-1645. Whitstable: Pryor Publications.