The Civil Wars and Local Communities in England, 1642-47: Documents, Debates and Case Studies from Somerset, Gloucestershire, Herefordshire and Wiltshire.

National, Regional & Local Narratives:

After the Battle of Edgehill, the king was beaten back from London, returning to Oxford. In the ‘Second’ Campaign of 1643, Charles planned a combined advance on London by his three armies. Each army was formed of local men unwilling to leave their districts until local Parliamentarian garrisons had suurendered. Hopton’s west country army wanted to seize Plymouth before advancing, while Charles himself besieged Gloucester in order to gain full control of the Severn valley and estuary. The resistance of these cities ruined Charles’s plan: During the winter both sides sought allies. The Somerset MP John Pym, one of the five whom Charles had tried to arrest, negotiated the Solemn League and Covenant with the Scots.

Local history has provided one of the most fruitful areas of study for historians researching the English Civil Wars in recent decades. Whereas earlier historians had tended to concentrate on presenting a chronological narrative of military events in the locality, more recent authors, stimulated by the wealth of source material available in County Record Offices, have continued to explore the relationship between national events and local society. A. M. Everitt, in his seminal 1969 book, The Local Community and the Great Rebellion, wrote that:

The allegiance of the the provincial gentry to the community of their native shire is one of the basic facts of English history in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Though the sense of national identity had been increasing since the early Tudors, so too had the sense of county identity, and the later was normally … the more powerful sentiment in 1640-60: … the growth of county administration, the development of county institutions, the expanding wealth of the local gentry, their increasing tendency to intermarriage, their growing interest in local history and legal custom, the rise of the county towns as social, cultural and administrative centres; these and many other elements entered into the rise of … the ‘country commonwealths’ of England.

… Despite the well-known fact that many gentry attended the universities and some of the wealthire families spent part of the year in London, the vast majority of the country gentry passed most of their lives within a few miles of their native manor-house, in a circle often as limited as that of their tenants and labourers. The brief years at the university and Inns of Court were no more than an interlude, principally designed to fit them out for their functions as justices, squires, and landlords in their own county …

In 1640, however, local attachments were, if anything, becoming deeper rather than more superficial. For this reason the Civil War was not simply a struggle between gallant Cavaliers and psalm-singing Roundheads … This does not mean that most English people were indifferent to the political problems of the time, but that their loyalties were polarised around different ideals. … a more urgent problem was the conflict between loyalty to the nation and loyalty to the county community. This division cut across the conventional division, like a geological fault. The unwillingness of most people to forgo the independence of their shire and admit that allegiance to the Kingdom as a whole must overide it was one of the reasons why the Civil War was so long drawn out. …

In a world with poor communications and no country newspapers … most people (were) chiefly concerned with the fortunes of their local community. It was not that they never heard any national news, but that they were not continuously preoccupied with it … There were other matters of more immediate concern, and most people lived too near the bone to spare much time for political speculation. … Every decision, every loyalty was shaped, not so much by the fiat of government, as by the whole network of local society: by all the pressures of personal influence, family connection, ancient amity, local pride, religious sentiment, economic necessity and a dozen other matters …

How much were ordinary people really affected by the events of the Great Rebellion? … In the Midlands, of course, country people could not fail at times to be conscious of the fighting, and for some of them – the people of Leicester, for instance, on a May evening in 1645 – it brought horror and tragedy. Yet it would be misleading to suppose that daily life was continuously disrupted by fighting, even in the Midlands. … There is, of course, no need to minimise the impact of the Civil War upon seventeenth-century England. Its consequences for provincial society were obviously far-reaching. But we also need to see the Rebellion as one of a succession of problems to which society at the time was particularly vulnerable. The recurrent problems of harvest failure, and the malnutrition and disease that often followed in its wake were, for most English people, more serious and more persistent than the tragic but temporary upheaval of the Civil War. … During the seventeenth century as a whole, every fourth harvest, on the average, fell seriously short of requirements, and in some decades several successive years showed a marked deficiency. Those who lived through the Civil War and Commonwealth period, for example, suffered no fewer than ten harvest failures within the space of fifteen or sixteen years, … This kind of situation affected every class in the country, and for hundreds of thousands of labourers, yeomen, craftsmen and traders it might well mean ruin. …

Their experiences might go some way to explain the latent intransigence of the provincial world which, in the last resort, was one of the principal factors in the failure of both Charles I and Cromwell. … a certain dumb obstinacy towards the world at large – and not least towards the strange doings of princes and protectors.

Bath, North-East Somerset, Gloucestershire and Wiltshire:

The following documents chiefly concern the city of Bath and the surrounding area of north-east Somerset, south Gloucestershire and Wiltshire. In 1642 Bath was a prosperous walled city of some two thousand people. It livelihood was based on a lucrative clothtrade and its fame as a health resort. From the outset of the first Civil War, the Community declared its vigorous support for parliament. But how far this was influenced by the loyalties of three prominant local ‘worthies’ – John Ashe, ‘the greatest clothier in the kingdom’; Alexander Popham, the city’s wealthy MP; and William Prynne, the nationally-famous pamphleteer, has been a matter of some debate among historians. Further, related questions have been: How great was the city’s real involvement in the war? How quickly did disillusionment set in? How seriously was everyday life disrupted by local hostilities, which included the battle of Lansdown and the siege by the New Model Army? How severe was the conflict between loyalty to the state and loyalty to the local community?

John Ashe wrote A Perfect Relation from the Committee of Sommersetshire in 1642, describing how the enthusiastic recruits to the Trained Bands from north-east Somerset arrived in Bath from Chewton Mendip. These included Popham’s Regiment, which had doubled in size with volunteers. Many of them had only swords, but were ‘put into order’, despite a lack of expert soldiers and officers. They then marched over the Mendip hills a distance of four miles, until they came within sight of Wells. By the evening, they were unable to obtain provisions, and so lay all that night upon the hill, fasting and in the cold, and spent the time in prayers and singing of Psalms. Popham, with his two ‘valiant’ brothers and Sir John Horner and son, …

… with many other young Gentlemen, Captaines and others lay all night upon fursbushes in their armes in the open fields amidst the camp, the old Knight often saying that his Furs-Bed was was the best he lay upon. It was very much to be admired that the Spirits and resolutions of so great a company, and men so tenderly bred could be kept to that night, as to indure so much hunger and cold. But such was the love and affections of all the country within eight and ten miles distance, that by the the next morning daylight they sent in such provisions of all sorts in waynes, carts and on horses, that this great company had sufficient and to spare, both for breakfast and for dinner, and would not take a penny for it, nay many did carry home againe their provisions, for want of Company to eat it.

Ashe’s narrative was reprinted in pamphlet form from a letter he wrote to the Speaker. In March 1643, the royalist newspaper, Mercurius Aulicus, reported the royalist Governor of Reading’s seizure of Ashe’s supplies for London:

Certaine news also came this day, that Sir Arthur Aston had seized on seven cart-loades, one waine-load and twenty-four horse-loades of broad fine cloth, amonting in the whole to 380 cloths, and that in many of the packs were found some ‘Belts’ and ‘Bandoleers’, and great store of ‘Match’, and a considerable summe of money. All of which were sent towards London from one Mr Ashe, the greatest ‘Clothier’ in the Kingdome, as it is conceived, but of so turbulent a spirit and so pernicious a practicer in the maintaining and fomenting of this Rebellion, that he stands excepted by His Majesty amongst some others, out of His Majesty’s generall pardon for the County of Sommerset.

The West in the First Civil War: The four Royalist victories in battle, together with the successful siege of Bristol extended their control of the West Country south of Gloucester, together with much of Wiltshire, Hampshire and Berkshire.

Clearly, there was no love lost between him and the royalists of Berkshire. The following summer, Royalist forces concentrated for a major assault on the Parliamentarian positions in the West Country. A contingent of three thousand foot, three hundred dragoons and five hundred horse under Lord Hopton was joined at Chard in Somerset on 4 June by a thousand foot and fifteen hundred horse under Prince Maurice and the Marquess of Hertford. These three were opposed by Sir William Waller, who controlled Bristol, Bath and Gloucester. He was a highly professional soldier, having learnt his trade in southern Europe. Now in his mid-forties, he was one of the most respected of the Parliamentarian generals. The Royalists decided that, despite his reputation, Waller could be and must be beaten. Hence their combined operation employing the victors of Stratton, from Cornwall, and an army from Oxford under the command of Prince Maurice. Hopton, the architect of the Stratton victory, had had no small difficulty in persuading his officers to march their men from Devonshire when Plymouth, Exeter, Barnstaple and Bideford were all in Roundhead hands, yet ripe for the taking.

Gentlemen & Generals – William Waller & Ralph Hopton:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006-3.jpg
Above: Sir Ralph Hopton, the King’s Lieutenant-General of the West, painted c. 1637. An early opponent of the excesses of the Court. Hopton still felt duty-bound to support the king against rebellion, and proved to be a highly professional field commander. He died in exile in Bruges in 1651.

The fact that, especially in the early years of the war, many of the generals on either side were so alike in their social and cultural personalities, indeed had often known each other well, either in parliament or in the country, and spoke the same kind of language of patriotic disinterest, must have weakened or at least tested their allegiance. Two generals who faced each other in the muderous little west country war, Sir William Waller and Sir Ralph Hopton, respectively from Gloucestershire and Somerset, and both professional soldiers, were virtually interchangeable, even in religion, where Hopton was just as much a sober Puritan as Waller, and had voted for the Grand Remonstrance. Both were in their mid-forties when the war began, and were close friends. It had only been when parliament had arrogated to itself power over the militia that Hopton had changed allegiance. Hopton was made a baronet in 1643 and became a close confidant of the king. Clarendon described him as a man…

… superior to any temptation, and abhorred enough of the license and the levities, with which he saw too many corrupted. He had a good understanding, a clear courage, an industry not to be tired, and a generosity that was not to be exhausted; a virtue that none of the rest had: but in debates concerning the war, was longer in resolving, and more apt to change his mind after he had resolved, than is agreeable to the office of a commander-in-chief; which rendered him rather fit for the second, rather than for the supreme command in an army.

As a key member of Charles I’s council of war, Hopton was, according to Clarendon, the only man ‘of whom nobody spoke ill, or laid anything to his charge’. During a brief lull in their campaign, Hopton had written to Waller asking for a meeting. Waller had to turn him down, but did so in terms that suggested just how deeply the distress of their broken friendship went:

To my noble friend, Sir Ralphe Hopton at Wells

Sir

The experience I have had of your worth, and the happiness I have enjoyed in your friendshipp, are wounding considerations to me when I looke upon this present distance between us. Certainly my affections to you are so unchangeable, that hostility itself cannot violate my friendshipp to your person, but I must be true to the cause wherein I serve. The old limitation ‘usque ad aras’ holds still, and where my conscience is interested all other obligations are swallowed upp. I should most gladly waite upon you, according to your desire, but that I looke upon you as you are ingaged in that party, beyond the possibility of a retreat and consequently uncapable of being wrought upon by any persuasions. And I know the conference could never be so close between us, but that it would take winde and retrieve a construction to my dishonour. That great God, who is the searcher of my heart, knowes with what a sad sence I go upon this service, and with what a perfect hatred I detest this warre without an enemy. But I look upon it as ‘Opus Domini’, and that is enough to silence all passion in mee. … We are both upon the stage, and must act those parts that are assigned to us in this Tragedy. Lett us do itt in a way of honour, and without personall animosities. Whatsoever the issue be, I shall never relinquish the dear title of…

Your most affectionated friend,

and faithfull servant

Wm Waller

Above: Sir William Waller, an etching published in 1643. Waller served with Hopton in the Thirty Years’ War and the two soldiers remained friends during the Civil Wars, despite being on opposing sides.

Three weeks after this letter was written, Hopton’s army met Waller’s in battle at Lansdown, near Bath. The combined Royalist army numbered seven thousand, of which just over half were infantry. Waller’s army of approximately equal numbers, though stronger in cavalry, was deployed near to the city. But the presence of three officers whose rank justified independent command raised the thorny question of who should actually control the operations of the Royalist army. The problem appears to have been solved by allowing Hertford to command in name, while Hopton commanded in the field and Maurice concentrated his attention on the Horse, and was given a free hand with its use. The Roundhead cavalry was more than equal in both quantity and quality, but its infantry was inferior in the latter. With Waller in so strong a position, however, the Royalist strategy of splitting his army and rolling them up in two phases was easier to plan than to execute. During June they were tidying up the position in Somerset by occupying Wells, Taunton and Bridgwater, and at the end of the month they occupied the Wiltshire woollen town of Bradford-on-Avon, just nine miles south-east of Bath. The city itself was the primary objective of the royalist assault, but to attack it from the south meant negotiating the Avon under Roundhead fire and it was therefore considered more expedient to approach from the east. To do so the Royalists moved in a north-westerly direction but when they reached Monkton Farleigh and Waller had given no sign of coming up on their flank they decided to push on to a better attacking position north of the city.

The Battle of Lansdown – A Contemporary Account:

In his History of the Rebellion, begun in 1646 but not published until 1702, Clarendon gave the following extremely vivid description of the Battle of Lansdown from the Royalist perspective. It begins with Hopton’s army at rest in Wells:

After … eight or ten days’ rest at Wells, the army generally expressing a cheerful impatience to meet with the enemy, of which, at that time, they had a greater contempt, than in reason they should have; the prince and marquis advanced to Frome, and thence to Bradford, within four miles of Bath. And now no day passed without action, and very sharp skirmishes; Sir William Waller having received from London a fresh regiment of five hundred horse, under the command of Sir Arthur Haselrig: which were so completely armed, that they were called by the other side the regiment of lobsters, because of their bright iron shells, with which they were covered, being perfect cuirassiers; and were the first seen so armed on either side, and the first that made any impression upon the king’s horse; who, being unarmed, were not able to bear a shock with them; besides that they were secure from hurts of the sword, which were almost the only weapons the other were furnished with.

The Battle of Lansdown, 1643

After some preliminary skirmishing in the area to the east of Bath, which were of the nature of light harassment, the Royalists marched another five miles, approaching Lansdown Hill, four miles to the north of Bath on 4 July. They were surprised to find Waller’s army firmly established on its summit, and temporarily withdrew to Marshfield where they camped that night. Waller’s presence was the result of his local knowledge, which had made him alert to their intentions well in advance of their approach from the east. Lansdown Hill was well known as a valuable strategic standpoint, and to prevent the Royalists from occupying it, he had marched out of Bath to occupy it himself. The armies were now just five miles apart, and there was inevitably some skirmishing between them. Very early on 5 July, Waller despatched a medium-sized force up to the Marshfield outposts to upset the Royalists as they were making their dispositions. This created considerable alarm and disorder, but Hopton soon had his men marching towards Bath, using tracks that would take them past Lansdown. As they approached the hill, they observed that the Roundheads were already strongly entrenched around it, with earthworks and wooden defences protecting their position, the whole area being screened by by flanking woods. Waller had constructed field fortifications on the northern end of the hill, thus strengthening the already formidable natural obstacle of a sharply falling hillside. Hopton and his officers decided this was neither the place nor the time to attack. They halted and skirmished, but after several clashes between the rival dragoons, the Royalists again drew off back to Marshfield, not prepared to commit military suicide. Clarendon’s account of the approaches of the two armies is as follows:

The contention was hitherto with parties; in which the successes were various, and almost with equal losses: for as Sir William Waller, upon the first advance from Wells, beat up a regiment of horse and dragoons of Sir James Hamilton’s, and dispersed them; so, within two days, the king’s forces beat a party of his from a pass near Bath, where the enemy lost two field pieces, and near an hundred men. But Sir William Waller had the advantage in his ground, having a good city, well furnished with provisions, to quarter his army together in; and so in his choice not to fight, but upon extraordinary advantage. Whereas the king’s forces must either disperse themselves, and so give the enemy advantage upon their quarters, or, keeping near together, lodge in the field, and endure great distress of provision; the country being so disaffected, that only force could bring in any supply or relief. Hereupon, … the marquis and Prince Maurice advanced their whole body to Marsfield, five miles beyond Bath towards Oxford, presuming that, by this means, they should draw the enemy from their place of advantage, his chief business being to hinder them from joining the with the king. And if they had been able to preserve that temper, and had neglected the enemy till he had quitted his advantages, it is probable that they might have fought upon as good terms as they desired; for Sir William Waller, … no sooner drew out his whole army to Lansdown, which looked towards Marsfield, but they suffered themselves to be engaged upon great disadvantage.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007-3.jpg
A harquebusier. or ‘trooper’. His equipment included a sword with a basket hilt to protect his hand, holsters for his pistols, a breastplate and lobster-tailed helmet with a faceguard, a sash worn around the waist to denote his ‘side’ (gold for parliamentarians; claret for royalists), top boots and rowel spurs, and leather gauntlets.

Waller then dispatched a thousand cavalry and dragoons to harry the retiring enemy flank and rear in the valley between Lansdown Hill and Freezing Hill. At first this went remarkably well for them, with the dragoons able to move up under cover of hedgerows and devastate the Royalist flanks; the Roundhead cavalry charged into the Royalist rear and drove into it so hard that they tangled with the unfortunate foot soldiers. Prince Maurice had introduced an interesting tactical disposition by stationing a section of foot among the cavalry. These were mainly the Cornishmen who had won the battle of Stratton and they began to give Waller’s cavalry a lot of trouble. As this great harassing sweep began to lose momentum and peter out, the Royalist cavalry began to put in two very sharp counter-attacks. Within the hour, the Royalists had driven their opponents back over Tog Hill to the base of Lansdown Hill, where they had stood despondently not so long before. It was 2 p.m., and Royalist morale was now at its peak, and the strong positions of Lansdown Hill somehow seemed less formidable than before. Hopton’s Cornish infantry, who had already killed a substantial number of Roundheads, clamoured to be allowed to make what appeared a suicidal assault on the main Parliamentarian position. They had tremendous faith in Hopton, who ordered flanking attacks by parties of musketeers while the main assault was delivered in the centre along the road which wound its way to the summit. The hill confronting the Cornish infantry was four miles long, and well wooded. The battle which took place that afternoon was a tribute to the amazing resolve of the Cornishmen. Whatever else happened, they ploughed on, supported by others, fighting alongside, but the steady rolling unrelaxed pressure which carried the day undoubtedly came from the tough Cornishmen. Clarendon gave the following account of their heroic assault on the hill-top:

It was upon the fifth of July when Sir William Waller, as soon as it was light, possessed himself of that hill; and after he had, upon the brow of the hill over the high way, raised breastworks with fagots and earth, and planted cannon there, he sent a strong party of horse towards Marsfield, which quickly alarmed the other army, and was shortly driven back to their body. … the king’s forces … when they had drawn into battalia, and found the enemy fixed on the top of the hill, they resolved not to attack upon so great disadvantage; and so retired again towards their old quarters: which Sir William Waller perceiving, sent his whole body of horse and dragoons down the hill, to charge the rear and flank; which they did thoroughly, the regiment of cuirassiers so amazing the horse they charged, that they totally routed them; and, standing firm and unshaken themselves, gave so great terror to the king’s horse, who had never before turned from an enemy, that no example of their officers, who did did their parts with invincible courage, could make them charge with the same confidence, and in the same manner they had usually done. However, in the end, after Sir Nicholas Slanning, with three hundred musketeers, had fallen upon and beaten their reserve of dragooners, Prince Maurice and the Earl of Carnarvon, rallying their horse, and winging them with the Cornish musketeers, charged the enemy’s horse again, and totally routed them; and in the same manner received two bodies more, and routed and chased them down the hill; where they stood in a place almost inaccessible.

Lansdown Hill lies four miles to the nort of Bath and can be reached from the A420 Chippenham to Bristol road. When approaching from Chippenham turn left on to a minor road 1,300 yards past the junction of the A420 and the A46. The road leads to Lansdown and as it ascends the summit of the hill the monument to Sir Bevil Grenville can be found on the left.

The Royalist cavalry were halted by a storm of fire poured down on them from above, but Sir Bevil Grenville’s Cornish pikemen struggled to the crest, where they held their ground in the face of Waller’s cavalry. They needed all the drive and resolve they could muster as they came up through the woods, meeting frontal musket fire, cross-fire and some heavy artillery, which the Roundheads had placed on top of the hill. They paid dearly for their success, but they made their enemy pay more, some regiments finding the fire so hot that they slipped away through the concealing woods. Some of the Royalist cavalry who were caught in plunging fire rode back to Oxford where they gave an account of the battle which indicated how wise they were to come away. They had of course been been badly handled and misused but it was not an excuse the Cornish infantrymen would have accepted. For had the cavalry stayed and stuck it out, they could have completed the victory when at last the pikemen and the musketeers had reached the last barricade. The Parliamentarian troops abandoned their field works and retreated to the protection of a stone wall which spanned four hundred yards of the summit. Hopton’s army captured Waller’s hilltop position, along with guns and prisoners but at savage cost to his troops and officers. Again, Clarendon provides us with his own vivid description of this final phase of the battle:

On the brow of the hill there were breast-works, on which were pretty bodies of small shot, and some cannon; on either flank grew a pretty thick wood towards the declining of the hill, in which strong parties of musketeers were placed; at the rear was a very fair plain, where the reserves of horse and foot stood ranged; yet the Cornish foot were so far from being appalled at this disadvantage, that they desired to fall on, and cried out, ‘that they might have leave to fetch off those cannon’. In the end, order was given to attempt the hill with horse and foot. Two strong parties of musketeers were sent into the woods, which flanked the the enemy; and the horse and other musketeers up the road way, which were charged by the enemy’s horse, and routed; then Sir Bevil Grenville advanced with a party of horse, on his right hand, that ground being best for them; and his musketeers on the left; himself leading up his pikes in the middle; and in the face of their cannon, and small-shot from the breast-works, gained the brow of the hill, having sustained two full charges of the enemy’s horse; but in the third charge his horse failing, and giving ground, he received, after other wounds, a blow to the head with a pole-axe, with which he fell, and many of his officers about him; yet the musketeers fired so fast upon the enemy’s horse, that they quitted their ground, and the two wings, who were sent to clear the woods, having done their work, and gained those parts of the hill; which they quickly did, and planted themselves on the ground they had won; … the enemy retiring … behind a stone wall upon the same level, and standing in reasonable good order. …

The costs of taking the hilltop to the royalist forces were immense. Of the two thousand who had ridden up the hill, only six hundred were left alive in the pyrrhic victory. Of the two hundred infantry who had died in the attack on the hilltop was Grenville, another friend of Waller’s, who was pole-axed at the summit. Hopton himself was badly slashed in the arm. There were still many Roundheads in force behind the stone wall, and neither side had the strength for a last clinching effort. Both armies were by now close to exhaustion, ammunition was short and a high proportion of Royalist officers had fallen in the assault. Both sides were anxious to maintain their position rather than undertake fresh attacks, so the fighting petered out in an exchange of musket fire. As darkness fell and neither side had the strength, ammunition or the will with which to renew the struggle, both commanders debated what to do next. If the Roundheads had counter-attacked, the exhausted Royalists might have tumbled down the hill and been utterly routed, but equally, had the Royalists put in a final assault at dawn, the route to Bath would have been open to them. As it happened, with the wisdom of an experienced campaigner rather than simply a battlefield commander, shortly after midnight Waller gave the order to withdraw to Bath, leaving lighted matches and bristling pikes on their last position as feints to cover his withdrawal. At dawn, finding their enemy gone, the Royalists retired to Marshfield. Clarendon’s description of the night on the hill-top is full of eye-witness detail, which must surely have come from the Royalist officers and soldiers themselves, perhaps from Hopton himself:

The king’s Horse were so shaken that of the two thousand which were upon the field in the morning, there were not above six hundred on the top of the hill. The enemy was exceedingly scattered too, and had no mind to venture on plain ground with those who had beaten them from the hill; so that, exchanging only some shot from their ordnance, they looked upon another until the night interposed. About twelve of the clock, it being very dark, the enemy made a show of moving towards the ground they had lost; but giving a smart volley of small-shot, and finding themselves answered with the like, they made no more noise: which, the prince observing, he sent a common soldier to hearken as near to the place where they were, as he could; who brought word, “that the enemy had left lighted matches in the wall behind which they had lain, and were drawn off the field”; which was true; so that, as soon as it was day, the king’s army found themselves possessed entirely of the field, and the dead, and all other ensigns of victory: Sir William Waller being marched to Bath, in so much disorder and apprehension, that he left great store of arms, and ten barrels of powder, behind him; which was a very seasonable supply to the other side, who had spent in that day’s service no less than fourscore barrels, and had not a safe proportion left.

It should have been a moment of tremendous triumph for the Royalists. Although Grenville had been killed, they had won the hill against almost impossible odds. But then, in the moment of elation, came an appalling setback. While Hopton was inspecting prisoners the next day, an ammunition wagon exploded, burning and temporarily blinding Hopton, so that he needed to be carried in a litter, knowing that at any time Waller’s troops, defeated but rested at Bath, might swoop down on his battered and bedraggled army. For a while, Hopton could neither speak, walk nor see and apparently dying, he was carried off the battlefield past his dismayed army. At this stage, it would have been limitless folly for him to press home his advantage against Bath. Reluctantly, but not slowly, the Royalists abandoned their hard-won position and set off back in the direction of Oxford. Behind them, on Cold Ashton, Tog Hill, Freezing Hill and on the slopes of Lansdown itself, there were several thousand men who would never fight again on that or any other. At the time, Lansdown was an inconclusive and costly battle, but it was eventually entered into the annals of Royalist victories, especially by Edward Hyde (Clarendon):

In this battle, on the king’s part, there were more officers and gentlemen of quality slain, than common men; and more hurt than slain. That which would have clouded any victory, and made the loss of others less spoken of, was the death of Sir Bevil Grenville. He was indeed an excellent person, whose activity, interest, and reputation, was the foundation of what had been done in Cornwall; and his temper and affections so public, that no accident which happened could make any impression in him; … In a word, a brighter courage, and a gentler disposition, were never married together to make the most cheerful and innocent conversation. Very many officers and persons of quality were hurt; as the lord Arundel of Wardour, shot in the thigh with a brace of pistol bullets; Sir Ralph Hopton, shot through the arm with a musket … and many others, hurt … with swords and pole-axes. But the morning added much to the melancholy of their victory, when the field was entirely their own. For Sir Ralph Hopton riding up and down the field to visit the hurt men, and to put the soldiers in order, and readiness for motion, sitting on his horse, with other officers and soldiers about him, near a waggon of ammunition, in which were eight barrels of powder; whether by treachery, or mere accident, is uncertain, the powder was blown up; and many, who stood nearest, killed; and many men were maimed; among whom Sir Ralph Hopton and sergent major Sheldon were miserably hurt.

Devizes & The Battle of Roundway Down:

A week later, on Roundway Down outside Devizes, Hopton’s army, despite its general being more or less unable to see or ride, again triumphed, this time overwhelmingly. Hopton had been insistent on being carried to councils of war, still refusing to leave his post while the royalist forces remained threatened by Waller’s still unbroken army. Hopton’s forces had taken up a defensive position at Devizes, just over the county border in Wiltshire. They were seriously short of ammunition and food supplies, and the council of war decided to send Hertford and Maurice and the remainder of their cavalry back to Oxford as fast as possible with an urgent plea for reinforcements. As the infantry followed them in the same direction, the Royalists felt frustrated and dejected. Apart from the blow of losing such inspiring leaders as Grenville and Hopton to death and injury respectively, they had other troubles as well; the people of the surrounding countryside seemed to be against them as they sought victuals. They had rested at Chippenham for two days and then moved on to Devizes, by which time Waller’s cavalry was harassing their rearguard. The Royalists were therefore glad to get into the town where they could collect their thoughts and decide on their next course of action. But Royalist morale plummeted further as for the next or two or three days, Waller tried to bombard Devizes Castle into submission, and he had drawn up his army at Roundway Down, three miles north of the town, but Hopton refused to take up the challenge and on 10 July they declined battle with the Parliamentarian army.

Instead, they prepared the town for a siege, withdrawing their artillery to Devizes Castle and erecting barricades across the approach roads. Hopton was now able to speak but not to walk and approved a plan by which his infantry and artillery would defend the town while the cavalry would break out in a bid to raise a relieving force from Oxford. Before the town was fully encircled the Royalist cavalry under the Marquess of Hertford and Prince Maurice succeeded in this, and after a night-ride of forty-four miles, Maurice and Hertford reached Oxford on 11 July to find that steps had already been taken to aid Hopton. On both the 9th and 10th, cavalry forces had been dispatched westwards as reinforcements, with the first under the Earl of Crawford also conveying an ammunition train. This was captured, however, and Crawford’s six hundred troopers scattered by Waller’s forces, but although shaken, the Royalist cavalry was able to rendezvous with Lord Wilmot and the rest of the relief force at Marlborough. As Devizes was being held with hastily constructed outer defences, and Prince Maurice having evaded Waller’s troops to reach Oxford, time was no longer on the side of the Parliamentarian besiegers, for the Royalists would soon be rushing reinforcements to help Hopton’s trapped army. Waller’s forces still outnumbered those of the Royalists, however, and as he redoubled his efforts to capture Devizes, he also sent in surrender terms. Hopton appeared to be considering them, but in fact, was waiting for the relief force he felt could not be far away. He was right, as Marlborough was only fourteen miles away. It was a force comprised entirely of cavalry, but also had two light guns.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 005-2.jpg

By the morning of 13 July, Lord Wilmot was approaching Devizes with eighteen hundred Horse from the king’s main army, but no infantry under his command. Between his cavalry and Hopton’s three thousand besieged infantry lay a Parliamentarian force of two thousand horse and 2,500 foot. They had kept Devizes under artillery fire for the previous twenty-four hours. Waller still held the initiative since he could turn on Wilmot’s cavalry and deal with them in a pitched battle, in which he would outnumber them, or he could draw them off with a portion of his army while he used the remainder to complete the capture of Devizes. He must not, of course, allow himself to be trapped between Wilmot’s horse and Hopton’s infantry, even though his forces still outnumbered the combined Royalist troops by over a thousand. What he could not have expected was that the Devizes ‘garrison’ would stand idly by, in spite of Hopton’s urgings, and let him annihilate Wilmot’s cavalry. Unaware of the fate in store for him, Wilmot continued along the old road from Marlborough to Devizes, which ran north of the present road and is the track which skirts to the south of Heddington today. This road was and is still today, crossed by another which runs south-west to Devizes, and the crossroads were right in the middle of Roundway Down where Waller had tried to tempt the entire Royalist army to battle just before they entered Devizes. It was, of course, a perfect place for a cavalry battle. To the north were Morgan’s Hill and King’s Play Hill, and to the south was Roundway Hill, then known as Bagdon Hill.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-9.jpg

Waller had withdrawn most of his army away from the siege of Devizes to meet Wilmot’s advance and he deployed his force in the shallow valley bounded in the north by King’s Play Hill and Morgan’s Hill and in the south by Roundway Hill. Hopton’s beleaguered army had observed Waller’s withdrawal and heard Wilmot’s signal guns, which were fired from Roughbridge Hill, but the council of war summoned to analyse these developments suspected a Parliamentarian trap and refused to march out of Devizes. Their shortages of ammunition, including ‘match’ (cord) for their musketeers also prevented their direct engagement in the battle. Hopton had ordered that all the bedcords in Devizes should be collected and boiled in resin; this ingenuity solved the ‘match’ problem but there was still a grave shortage of powder and ball. Hopton, still beset by his wounds, was unable to alter its opinion, so they did not join the battle until it was in its later stages. The scene was set for one of the most dramatic battles of the Civil Wars; a cavalry force tired by a long approach was about to attack an army of horse and foot which outnumbered it by nearly three-to-one. As Wilmot crossed the Wansdyke, a few miles from where the decisive battle of Ellandun had been fought over eight hundred years earlier, Waller’s army came into view over Roundway Hill. Wilmot had no doubt that Hopton’s army from Devizes would be coming up fast to catch Waller in the rearguard and calmly made his battle dispositions accordingly. Facing his left flank he could see a very formidable force, Sir Arthur Haselrig’s ‘Lobsters’, named after their close-fitting armour as cuirassiers, glinting in the sunlight.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006-4.jpg

Wilmot quickly realised that if they fought in isolation both Royalist forces would be outnumbered and that their only hope of victory would rest on a combined attack on the Parliamentarian army. Wilmot’s essential problem, however, was how to arrange for a concerted attack to strike the Parliamentarians at the same moment. The Royalist cavalry had brought two small cannon with them and Wilmot had decided to fire these as a signal to alert Hopton’s artillery that he was attacking. But a messenger sent to inform Hopton of the plan was captured and, in the event, despite Wilmot’s foresight, the two Royalist forces acted independently for the major part of the battle. Wilmot attacked, expecting Hopton’s infantry to come out of the town to support him. The Parliamentarian army had deployed in a conventional style with the infantry in the centre of the line and the cavalry on both flanks. Wilmot’s line consisted of his own brigade and that of Sir John Byron, with Crawford’s brigade in reserve. As Wilmot’s troopers advanced, Sir Arthur Haselrig, on the right of the Parliamentarian line, led his squadron to meet them. Wilmot, being a cavalryman, turned his attention to these wings and hit both simultaneously with vigorous charges. The visceral hand-to-hand combat which followed was described by Richard Atkyns, a cavalier who took part in the charge on Haselrig’s right wing, and fought with the general himself:

‘Twas my fortune in a direct line to charge their general of horse; he discharged his carbine first, and afterwards one of his pistols, before I came up to him; and missed with both; I then immediately struck into him and touched him before I discharged mine, and I am sure I hit him for he staggered and presently wheeled off from his party. Follow him I did and and discharged the other pistol at him; and I’m sure I hit his head for I touched it before I gave fire and it amazed him at that present but he was too well armed all over for a pistol bullet to do him any hurt, having a coat of mail over his arms and a headpiece musket proof. … I came up to him again and having a very awift horse stuck by him for a good while and tried him from the head to the saddle and could not penetrate him or do him any hurt; but in this attempt he cut my horse’s nose that you might put your finger in the wound and gave me such a blow on the inside of my arms amongst the veins that I could hardly hold my sword; he went on as before.

Sir Arthur Haselrig by Robert Walker

As the running fight continued, Atkyns was shot in the shoulder but not seriously wounded. During the ensuing melée of charge and counter-charge, Haselrig’s ‘Lobsters’ broke and fled. They were soon followed by Waller’s Brigade, furiously pursued by Byron’s troopers. In the course of the engagement, Waller’s cavalry had been so badly swung out of order that their only means of escape was to the west. As the majority of the beaten cavalry took flight in this direction, covering nearly a mile and a half, hoping to find a point to regroup, they suddenly realised that the gentle plain on which they galloping was a mere plateau and that they were now at its edge. To their horror, they found that the ground before them fell abruptly for three hundred feet in a treacherous slope. Unable to rein in, many of Waller’s troopers plunged downwards out of control crashing into the ‘Bloody Ditch’ at the foot of the slope. Down that deathtrap hill they rode, slithered and fell, and many of their pursuers with them. It was, indeed, a bloody ditch. Not since the battle of Ashdown in 871 had their been a scene like it, and even that was less dramatic. The unbelievable had happened: Waller’s invincible cavalry had been put to flight by a force of half their number, and at the end, it had not merely been beaten, but literally smashed to pieces.

The battlefield of Roundway Down lies to the north of Devizes between A342, A4 and A361. It can be approached along the secondary road to Roundway which leaves the A361 about a mile from the centre of Devizes, and King’s Play Hill provides a convenient vantage point.

This left the Roundhead infantry in the middle standing by inactive and unharmed apart from the occasional stray musket-ball finding a target in their ranks. They could not take part in the battle themselves since the wings were an indistinguishable fighting melée. They were mere spectators of the catastrophe which befell their cavalry, for with no opposing infantry to fight there was little they could do to support their cavalry. The musketeers could not intervene in the cavalry action for hear of hitting their own men, and as they disappeared from the field, the Parliamentarian infantry were left on a deserted battlefield to await events, having no conception of the disaster which had befallen their cavalry. They were not given long to speculate upon their fate, for the growing noise of battle had at last persuaded Hopton’s infantry to march out of Devizes, urged on by their wounded general. As they came out, they assumed that they would be saving Wilmot’s cavalry from too severe a defeat, or perhaps to change probable defeat into narrow victory. As they breasted the hill all they could see was the Roundhead infantry, still uncommitted. On its flanks, Wilmot’s cavalry had regrouped to deal with this last target. The isolated Roundheads had no hope at all. Assailed from the north by Wilmot’s victorious cavalry and from the south by three thousand fresh Cornish infantry, the Parliamentarian foot were soon overwhelmed and forced to surrender or flee. The total rout of Waller’s army must therefore be credited to Wilmot’s leadership and the tremendous courage of his cavalry, which included Byron’s and Maurice’s and the Earl of Crawford’s regiments as well as his own. The Royalists claimed to have inflicted six hundred casualties and taken eight hundred prisoners, a fitting end to a most extraordinary day.

Bath, Bristol & Gloucester; Sieges, Garrisons & Councils:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 017.jpg
.

The Royalists had certainly achieved their most decisive victory of the Civil Wars. Most of Waller’s forces that escaped death or capture quietly melted away, many to their homes, and he took the remnant first to Gloucester, then to Evesham, and finally back to London. To all intents and purposes, Waller’s army had ceased to exist. Wilmot returned to Oxford after his victory, but as he did so Rupert set out with a very substantial force to join the western army, which had already occupied Bath. Rupert’s objective was Bristol, however, and on 24 July he summoned the city to surrender. Nathaniel Fiennes, its governor, refused, though his garrison of fifteen hundred foot and three hundred horse was insufficient to man the three-mile circumference of its defences. Two days later, on 26 July, the walls of Bristol, thought to be impregnable, were stormed by Hopton’s Cornish army and the city, and Fiennes surrendered to Prince Rupert in the early evening. He had defended the city for as long as was reasonably possible against determined assailants and did not deserve to be court-martialled and sentenced to death, but Essex, to his honour, secured his reprieve. The loss of Bristol, however, was a very severe blow to the parliamentarians, as it was to Rupert and the Royalists three years later. It led to the reduction of the Parliamentary garrisons in Dorset, Devon and Somerset. Plymouth, Exeter, Lyme Regis and two or three other outposts remained in their hands, but almost the whole of the rest of the West to the south of Gloucester lay under the King’s control.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-3.jpg
Bristol in the mid-Seventeenth Century, showing the city walls

For a short time after the fall of Bristol towards the end of July, Gloucestershire was the key theatre of the war. Urged by his generals to exploit parliament’s disarray and advance on London, King Charles instead turned aside to eliminate the last parliamentary garrison at Gloucester. Charles appeared in person to summon Gloucester itself on 10 August, but the governor, Edward Massey defied him. Enthusiastically supported by its townsfolk, the garrison held out for six weeks, until it was relieved by the Earl of Essex. This also denied the king the chance to end the war quickly, as for the next two years, Gloucester remained a parliamentary enclave in royalist territory. The royalists failed to prevent the garrison from ‘raiding’ the county under its energetic commander, Edward Massey, who slowly extended the parliamentary enclave until almost the whole of the county was under parliamentarian control. But in 1643, as the summer wore on, Gloucester’s precarious resistance was the one bright spot in what for parliament was a very bleak picture. Study of the war in a single county helps illustrate the variety of national and local issues that determined loyalties. For example, the textile areas of north-east Somerset were more likely to be parliamentarian in sympathy.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-2-1.jpg

Three years after the Royalist victories at Lansdown and Roundway Down, in June 1646, villages near Bath were making claims to the parliamentary commissioners for the damage caused during the summer of 1643, and the costs to farmers and villagers for supplies and free quarter provided to the armies. The Bath Chamberlain’s Accounts from October 1643 to February 1646 make useful and reliable historical sources for assessing these real impacts of the war. At the end of this period, the local Council agreed that a peticion shall be preferred to the houses of Parliament for release of ffree quarter. In line with Everitt’s aguments about the importance of local communities in the war, the proloned military intrusion experienced by north-east Somerset, south Gloucestershire and Wiltshire brought considerable personal suffering to the civilian population. But the local sources also suggest that most aspects of everyday life in agriculture, religion, education, trade, routine maintenance, social and charitable activities, were not completely disrupted even during the Royalist occupation between 1643 and 1645, though the city councillors had clearly been unimpressed by the use of the city made by the occupiers. It is also clear that by February 1646 the people of Bath had become completely disillusioned with both sides in the war. Bath and its corporation were largely parliamentarian in political outlook. But the city fathers wrote to Sir John Harington of Kelston, to ‘beseeche’ him to advise his son…

… touching our cities distress at this present time, that he may in such wise get favour from the commander to spare further levies, as we hear the troops are coming onward for our city, and our houses are emptied of all useful furniture, and much broken and disfigured; our poore suffer for want of victuals, and rich we have none. God assist your love and friendship to us, and favour your good will herein. Your son hathe good interest in the army, and we doubt not will use his endeavours to succour and save his poore neighbours. Warrants are come to raise horse, but we have none left; Colonel Sandford doth promise his assistance, as much as he is able. We have now four hundred in the town and many more coming; God protect us from pillage. …

Captain Harington was able to assist the people of Bath by ordering his company to go into the city to prevent disorder which would often follow from the quarterings of troops. The company ‘behaved well’, as a letter from Robert Jones to Harington confirmed:

Major Hewlet got in the levies as commanded, in such manner as the rate observed all over the west. Many citizens had no monies ready, and were threatened with pillage. Eighteen horses were provided at the market house, and delivered up, as you desired; but the men required were excused on your desiring, nor was any seizure made, or plunder, except in liquors and bedding. The town-house was filled with troops that came from Marlborow in their march westward. … God preserve our Kingdom from these sad troubles much longer! …

The troops from Marlborough were less orderly, however, according to Jones:

Our meal was taken by the Marlborow troop, but they restored it again to many of the poorer sort. Our beds they occupied entirely, but no greater mischief has happened as yet … We have no divine service as yet … We have no divine service as yet; the Churches are full of the troops, furniture and bedding. Pardon my haste, as I have sent this by a poor man who may suffer if he is found out, and I dare not send a man on purpose on horseback, as the horse would be taken.

The historian John Wroughton, writing The Civil War in Bath and North Somerset in 1973, concluded that although the City Council was largely parliamentarian in its sympathies, and it continued to return puritan MPs like Popham, Ashe and Prynne to Westminster, it nevertheless contained an active group of royalists. The members of this group continued to sit side by side with the parliamentarians no matter which army was actually in control of the city. They were after all, close neighbours and friends, and all were just as concerned that the daily life of the city should not be be too greatly disrupted by the national crisis. They were mostly drawn from the wealthier class of traders, craftsmen and innkeepers who were interested in maintaining the flow of business … Although they begged to differ over national issues, they were equally anxious to work together on local matters of common concern. When the first war ended, there seemed to be even more reason for continuing this close relationship. Certainly the debates recorded in the Council Minute Books give no indication of any intention to remove the royalists from their midst, at least not until 27th September, 1647. On that day the Corporation decided quite suddenly by a majority of eighteen votes to ten that Sergent Hyde shall be removed from his place and a new Recorder chosen. The important office of Recorder had been held for several years by Robert Hyde, a member of the ‘notorious’ royalist family which Edward Hyde, later the Earl of Clarendon, was also a member of. During the war, Robert had served in person with Prince Rupert.

Even so, the Corporation’s action had been taken only after Parliament had passed an Ordinance on 9th September requesting the removal royalists from local government. Most of the local councillors were more than happy to forgive and forget – a fact vividly illustrated when, three weeks later, they agreed to quash their original decision and that there shall be no election for a new Recorder, but the Sergt. Hyde shall stand. The Commons, however, thought otherwise. On 4th October, they therefore passed a more precise and forceful Ordinance, which put irresistable pressure on local authorities:

Be it declared, ordered and ordained by the Lords and Commons in Parliament assembled that no person whatsoever that hath been in arms against the Parliament, or hath been or is sequestered, shall be elected, constituted Mayor, Alderman, Bailiff, Sheriff, Justice of the Peace Steward of any Court, Constable, or any other officer … And in case any such persons as aforesaid … the Lords and Commons do declare all such elections to be void and null.

Faced with this ultimatum, Bath Corporation had little choice. On 13th December, 1647 they agreed to expel the royalist group en bloc. All seven of them, including Robert Hyde, relinquished their places, four of them being present when the decision was taken. William Prynne was then elected as the new Recorder, gaining eighteen votes against the four received by the other candidate, John Harington. However, one of the excluded royalists, Robert Fisher, was reinstated in 1651 and shortly after the Restoration, he was joined by four others, including Robert Hyde, who returned to his former office. There is evidence both here and in the previous documents that support Everitt’s assertion of a conflict between loyalty to the nation and loyalty to the county community. However, at the Restoration, sequestered land throughout the kingdom reverted to its previous owners, and the most prominent parliamentarian landowners forfeited all their lands for their activities against the king. These included Alexander Popham, whose family held lands in Wiltshire.

Gloucestershire & Herefordshire – Counties Divided:

At the outbreak of the war, adjacent Gloucestershire was deeply divided. As in other parts of the country, religious persuasion played an important part in deciding allegiances. The Anglican Cotswolds and Catholic Forest of Dean naturally inclined towards the Crown, while the Puritan vales and valleys were strongholds of parliamentary support. That support was strongest in the City of Gloucester and the towns. Accounts from the port of Bristol of ‘rebel’ atrocities against Protestants in Ireland reinforced anti-Catholic prejudices to the benefit of the Parliamentary cause. Anti-royalist sentiment in in the north of the county was also fed by the king’s attempts in the 1630s to destroy the local tobacco-growing industry in order to protect the interests of planters in the colonies of Virginia. Though a majority of the county gentry supported the Crown, Gloucestershire had few great landowners; the county therefor lacked obvious leaders, and both sides were slow to organise for war. The parliamentary leaders eventually proved more able at this than the royalists, who allowed personal rivalries to interfere with their war effort. They failed to capitalise on their early advantages gained at and after the battles of Lansdown and Roundway Down, allowing the parliamentarians to recover from their reverses. A strong ‘third party’ of ‘clubmen’ also emerged, determined to have nothing to do with the fighting. The royalists in particular proved ineffective in meeting this threat, enabling the better organised parliamentarians to gain overall control of the county.

Gloucestershire in the Civil Wars.

Neighbouring Herefordshire had enjoyed peace since the Battle of Mortimer’s Cross during the Wars of the Roses in 1461, when Edward of York (later to be proclaimed Edward IV) defeated Owen Tudor. This county only became a fighting ground again in September 1642, the beginning of the first Civil War. Herefordshire, Wales and Shropshire were mainly Royalist, with Gloucester being the only Parliamentarian stronghold at the beginning of the conflict in Herefordshire’s neighbouring counties. Unlike a war against a foreign enemy, the Civil War pitched neighbours against neighbours – as for example, the Harleys against the Crofts in the north-west corner of Herefordshire; or even two branches of the same family – for instance, the Scudamores of Holme Lacy against the Scudamores of Kentchurch Court. In some cases the war split the family, as for example the Hopton family from Canon Frome, where one son fought for the Cavaliers while his brother fought for the Roundheads. In the largely conservative county, there there was a long tradition of loyalty to King and Church, the bishop and his priests had some influence over people’s opinions. Bishop George Coke (1636-46), whilst not an active supporter of Laud’s reactionary changes in the Church of England, still supported the King. The religious question of whether to retain or to abolish bishops was widely debated in Herefordshire. James Kyrle was keen on abolishing bishops, but none of his fellow JPs in Herefordshire would sign a petition. In response, two priests circulated a petition in support of bishops at the Hereford Quarter Sessions in January 1642, and all but James Kyrle and Edward Broughton signed. Viscount Scudamore is said to have been the first to sign.

But the most influential people in the county were members of the local gentry, many of whom were moderate in their political outlook. In fact one man, Sir John Kyrle of Much Marcle, changed sides three times. In a series of articles on Herefordshire in the civil wars, Toria Forsyth-Moser (2003) has pointed out how it is easier to judge from subsequent events how broad the support for the Royalist cause was in the county. According to Jaqueline Eales, there were many shades of commitment: The permanence of parliamentarian influence in Herefordshire after December 1645 raises questions about the real strength of royalist feeling in the county during the earlier stages of the war. Moderates from both sides were hoping for a compromise but gradually, as their positions became more entrenched, it was apparent that civil war was almost unavoidable. Even though there was some support for the Parliamentarian cause in the county, most of the landed gentry were Royalist in sentiment and, when it mattered most, supported the king. And, as it costs money to arm men and to fight a war, it was the support of the gentry which was to ultimately ensure the declaration of Herefordshire for the king. On 30 September 1642 the Parliamentarian commander the Earl of Stamford, with 1,000 foot soldiers and four troops of horse, arrived at the gates of Hereford. The pretext for this action was recorded in Parliamentary proceedings:

“Information was given to the House by letters, that 340 soldiers were come out of Herefordshire to his Excellency the Earl of Essex to serve the King and Parliament; and that the City of Hereford had sent to his Excellency stating their good affections to the Parliament, and their desire to be secured against the Cavaliers, whom they much feared would come thither, and there being a malignant party in the city, those that were well affected durst not shew their kindness as much as they would.”

It is not surprising therefore that the army which arrived to take Hereford received a mixed reception. The soldiers were kept waiting outside the city walls whilst a furious debate took place inside. Some councillors were all for holding out for Royalist reinforcements, but in the end, the Mayor was persuaded to open the gates. Nehemiah Wharton, a Parliamentarian officer, describes the take-over of the City of Hereford:

… the gates were shut against us, and for two houres we stood in dirt and water up to the middle legge, for the city were all malignants, save three, which were Roundheads, and the Marquesse of Harford had sent them word the day before that they should in no wise let us in, or if they did we would plunder their houses, murder their children, burne their Bibles, and utterly ruinate all, and promised he would relieve them himself with all speede; for which cause the citizens were resolved to oppose us unto the death, and having in the city three peeces or ordinance, charged them with neyles, stones, etc. and placed them against us …

But support for the Roundheads within the city walls was very much in the minority. Many citizens were in favour of defending and it seems they even loaded three pieces of ordinance (cannons or artillery pieces). The unwritten rule of war was that if a city held out and opted to defend, if then captured, the soldiers would be at liberty to plunder and destroy. Therefore, the decision as to whether or not to open the gates had to be taken quickly and much depended on how well fortified the city was and how long they thought they could hold out. The decision was made to open the gates and the Parliamentarians took over. They left a garrison of a regiment of foot soldiers and two troops of horse. The Royalists mounted several small-scale counter attacks, to no avail. The Earl of Stamford and his men, however unpopular, remained in charge until December. To supplement their meagre (and often outstanding) pay, the soldiers took to plundering the homes of known Royalists both in the city and in the surrounding countryside. Plundering and pilfering were common on both sides, but considered a perk for poorly paid and poorly fed soldiers. The logistics of supplying this unwanted garrison, in a town mainly hostile to it, took their toll, however, and in December the Parliamentarians decided to withdraw to Gloucester.

If Hereford surrendered easily the first time, it certainly did not overexert itself during the second Parliamentarian attack, led by Sir William Waller in April 1643. After the Parliamentarians left for the first time in December 1642, the Royalists tried to improve the fortifications of the city so that it would be better prepared to withstand a siege in the event of a return of the Roundheads, but again, the citizens were not very forthcoming in their support. Waller’s men attacked shortly after dawn on the 25th April. As part of this attack the Roundheads aimed a saker (a cannon, 3.5 inches (89mm) in diameter and 9 feet (2.77m) long) at Widemarsh Gate and fired shot weighing 6lbs (2.73kg). The first round breached the gate and decapitated an officer. Mr. Corbett, a chaplain in Waller’s army, described this incident:

To help forward the capture of the city, Massie [one of Waller’s staff officers] drew up two sakers in a straight line against Wide Marsh gate, not without extreme hazard of being shot from the walls, and himself gave fire, and the first cannon-shot entered the gate and took an officer’s head from his shoulders and slew some besides. More shot were made, each of which scoured the street and so alarmed the enemy that they presently sounded a parley which was entertained by Sir W. Waller.

Early in the afternoon, when the defenders saw how easily the gates were breached, they offered to enter into negotiations to surrender. Ironically, Waller was at this time under orders to join the siege of Reading and if there had been better resistance from the Royalists, he would have had to retreat. However, the Parliamentarians once again took the City of Hereford. The second surrender of Hereford was of little strategic importance in that it did not affect the outcome of the war in the long run, however, it had a demoralising effect on the Royalists. The Royalist high command in Oxford called for an investigation and put Sir Richard Cave, the governor of Hereford Castle who had escaped from Hereford, on trial. When Waller and his men moved on less than a fortnight later, the city fell into Royalist hands once again. As a result of their ignominious capitulation, however, the Royalist high command appointed Sir William Vavasour as governor of Hereford and Sir Henry Lingen as sheriff of Herefordshire. To boost morale, they launched an attack on Brampton Bryan Castle, the main Parliamentarian stronghold remaining in the county. The city of Hereford itself did not see serious action again until the siege by the Scottish Army in 1645. After the departure of Sir William Waller’s troops, the Royalists in Hereford had a period of two years to reassess and strengthen their position. During the early summer of 1644, the King commanded that Hereford should be fortified. As the Royalists had been having trouble recruiting men and gaining supplies, the King gave full authority to the governor of Hereford to impress men, seize all arms, billet and quarter soldiers as required and levy contributions. If people would not support the Royalist army voluntarily, they would be forced to do so.

County ‘Clubmen’ & the Battle of Ledbury, Spring 1645:

Naturally, such measures among the civilian population produced a backlash. By the early spring of 1645, a movement of popular unrest was arising in many areas of the south-west Midlands and the West Country that was having a significant effect on the conduct of the war. Prince Rupert was one of the first to encounter it. In March 1645 he was sent to relieve Chester, which was being seriously threatened by Bereton, reinforced by Leven’s dispatch of five thousand Scots under David Leslie. But Rupert was forced to fall back by a popular uprising in Herefordshire which threatened his rear. It was neither for parliament nor the king, but a spontaneous act of exasperated countrymen, who had formed an association to defend themselves against, as they saw it, lawless, plundering soldiers, whichever side they fought for. They were called ‘Clubmen’ because most of them were armed only with cudgels and farm implements, though some had firearms. Clubmen had first appeared in Shropshire in the previous December, and in March they rose in Worcestershire and Herefordshire. At this stage they were mostly yeomen and husbandmen, together with other small landowners and members of the lesser gentry. The Herefordshire men were particularly aggressive; an estimated fifteen thousand virtually laid siege to Hereford, firing on its royalist defenders and demanded the withdrawal of all but local troops from the county. Massey marched out of Gloucester to offer them support, but to his disgust they would have nothing to do with him. To have allied with him would have compromised their objectives, but their decision resulted in their being crushed by Rupert’s and Maurice’s combined forces, and the county was punished by Rupert’s quartering of his troops there and allowed them free reign. For the time being, the movement in the Marches was stamped out by force of arms, but further Clubmen risings followed throughout the West Country.

No fewer than four civil war battles were fought at Ledbury, a market town in Herefordshire, lying east of Hereford, and west of the Malvern Hills. Throughout the first war, it was a bastion of royalism. The most significant of these battles was before the Naseby campaign in April 1645 when Prince Rupert was on his way from Hereford to Shrewsbury with his army. When he reached Leominster, he heard that Colonel Massey, the Governor of Gloucester, had advanced to Ledbury with a considerable body of horse and foot. The Prince determined to surprise him there, and, having marched all night, reached Ledbury on the morning of 22nd April. Massey had barely time to raise a barricade of carts in Homend Street to check the advance of his impetuous adversary (Massey, in his account, wrote that eight of his scouts were intercepted by the Royalists). Here the attack was made by Lord Astley’s and Colonel Washington’s foot, and after desperate fighting the barricade was opened, and Lord Loughborough, at the head of the cavaliers, charged down the street and encountered the roundhead cavalry, led by Massey in person. Meanwhile another body of cavaliers passed along the back of Homend, and after an encounter in the church-yard, attested to by bullet marks still visible on the church walls and the presence of slugs and bullets lately extracted from the north door of that edifice, pushed forward across the grounds now forming Mr. Biddulph’s park, to cut off the enemy’s retreat towards Gloucester.

Prince Rupert

In the streets of Ledbury the combat raged fiercely; Prince Rupert and Colonel Massey, both of them conspicuous for unflinching courage, took part in the fray as though they were as irresponsible as their troopers, and each had his horse killed under him. But Massey knew his men were beaten, and in his account of the battle, he says, we made it good against them (the enemy) so long till my foot might retreat a secure way to Gloucester. Massey was driven out of the town and his army broken up; some retreated through Dymock, others by Redmarley, and Massey himself with eighty horse got away to Tewkesbury. The pursuit was entrusted to Colonel Thomas Sandys. In Prince Rupert’s account of the battle, he says, Massey was soundly beaten yesterday, his foot quite lost, and his horse beaten and pursued within six miles of Gloucester, and generously adds that he himself and some of his officers made a handsome retreat. Of the rebels, a hundred and twenty were killed, amongst them Major Backhouse and Captain Kyrle of Much Marcle. Very many were wounded,and near 400 taken prisoners, including 27 roundhead officers. Massey alleged Prince Rupert’s army to be 6,000 or 7,000 horse and foot, and that his own force was about 5,000 foot and 350 horse; but it is believed these numbers are over-stated. Prince Rupert allowed his weary soldiers to rest at Ledbury on the night following the battle, and then resumed his march to Ludlow.

Later that year, on 12 November, about sixty of Scudamore’s Horse (from Hereford) pushed out to Ledbury to prepare for a larger force, and were charged through the streets in ‘gallant style’ by parliamentarian troopers a quarter of their number under Major Hopton, who was returning from Leominster, and who subsequently dispersed a party of thirty Royalists in charge of about a hundred head of cattle, which they had plundered from drovers.

The Siege of Hereford, June 1645 – an Eye-witness Account:

A later portrait of Charles, made after the Battle of Naseby.

That the city of Hereford was still a Royalist stronghold in the summer cannot be doubted. King Charles chose Hereford as a safe haven after his troops were routed at the Battle of Naseby in June 1645 and stayed for two weeks. The king’s presence galvanised the governor into action and decrees were sent to all parishes with requests for men and arms. The Scots army under the leadership of Alexander Leslie, First Earl of Leven, had about 8,000 foot soldiers and 4,000 cavalry. By the time the army descended on Hereford on July 31st 1645, the men were hardened and experienced, yet perhaps also weary and certainly insufficiently supplied. Most contemporary descriptions omit an important part of most large armies, namely the hundreds of women and even children who travelled with the baggage train. These women would have nursed injured soldiers and cooked and washed for their menfolk. If the soldiers weren’t paid, then their own families would go hungry too. Committees were set up in areas the army had to pass through to feed and supply the army, but the Earl of Leven complained to Parliament that his soldiers were not sufficiently provided for in Herefordshire. He also commented on the terrible state of the roads:

 ” … the Army is not able to march above eight miles a day, though they begin to march at the Sun rising, and continue till ten at night … the county is unwilling to afford us anything, and the committees give us no assistance.”

The population of Hereford was about 4,500, and in addition to the regular inhabitants there were a number of Royalist gentlemen who had had to leave their own areas when these were occupied by the Roundheads. Altogether there would have been around 1,500 soldiers and armed townsmen defending the city. A series of letters passed between the leaders of the besieging army, who requested Hereford to surrender, and the governor of Hereford, Colonel Barnabas Scudamore, who rejected outright any suggestion of handing over the city to the Scottish army. The siege itself was fierce and all manner of military techniques and practices common to this period were applied. The walls were attacked with cannon, mines were laid, and at the same time the Royalists staged several sallies to wreak havoc with the besiegers. Breaches in the walls were instantly repaired by the courageous townspeople who worked under enemy fire. Sieges like this were even more demanding than battles. An excellent source regarding the siege from the defenders’ point of view is a letter written by Sir Barnabas Scudamore which was eventually published in the form of a pamphlet. Many pamphlets were published during the Civil War by both sides, as a means of propaganda and dissemination of information. In this letter to Lord Digby, Scudamore praised the efforts of the common soldiers and townspeople, both men and women:

My Lord,

A numerous and active army close besieging us hath rendred me, and those engaged with me … incapable of presenting your Lordship with an exact Relation thereof: …

On the 30th July, I sent out a party of twenty horse over Wye-bridge, who discovering their Forlone-hope of horse, charged them into their maine Body; and retreated in very little disorder, and with losse only of one trooper (taken prisoner), some of the Scots falling. Immediately after this, their whole body of Horse faced us, about ten of the clock in the morning within the reach of our cannon, and were welcomed with our mettall; good execution being done upon them, their Foot as yet undiscovered. About halfe an houre after, I caused a strong Party of Foot (seconded with Horse) to line the hedges, who galled them in their passage to the Fords, after whose handsome retreat, I began to ensafe the Ports, which I did that night. In the morning appeared their body of Foot, and we found ourselves surrounded. I injoyned the Bells silence, lest their ringing, which was an alarm to awaken our devotion, might chime them together to the execution of their malice. For the same reason, I stopt our clocks and hereby though I prevented their telling tales, to the advantage of the Enemy, I myselfe lost the punctuall observation of many particulars, …

Before they attempted anything against the towne, they invited us to a Surrendry, and this they did by a double Summons, one from Leven, directed to me; the other from the Committee of both Kingdoms (attending on the affaires of the Army) sent to the Mayor and the Corporation: … This not giving that satisfaction they desired, they began to approach upon the first of August, but very slowly and modestly; as yet intending more the security of their owne persons, then the ruine of ours: but all their Art could not protect them from our small and great shot which fell upon them. Besides this, our men galled them handsomly at their severall sallies, over Wyebridge, once beat them up to their maine guard, and at another demolisht one side of St Martin’s Steeple; which would have much annoyed us at the Bridge and Pallace; this was performed with the hurt only of two men, but with losse of great store of the Enemies’ men. … but upon our refusall to stoup … they were much incensed that they had been so long disappointed, and having all this while continued their line of communication, they raised their Batteries, commencing at Wyebridge, from whence they received the greatest dammage, but instead of revenging that losse upon us, they multiplied their owne, by death of their much lamented Major Generall Crafford, and others that fell with him. This provoked them to play hot upon the Gate for two days together, and battered it so much … that it was rendered uselesse, yet our men stopt it up with wooll-sacks and timber, and for our greater assurance of eluding their attempt, we brake an arch, and raised a very strong Worke behind it.

The Enemy frustrate of his hopes here, raiseth two severall Batteries, one at the Fryers, the other on the other side of the Wye River, and from both these, playes his Ordinance against the corner of the wall by Wye side, but we repaire and line our walls faster than than they can batter them, whereupon they desist. … About the 11th of August, we discover a Mine at Freingate, and imploy workmen to countermine them. When we had stopt the progresse of that Mine on one side of the Gate, they carried it on the other; which we also defeated by making a Sally-Port: and issuing forth did break it open and fire it. About the 13th, they raise Batteries round about the town, and make a bridge over Wye River. The 14th, Doctor Scudamore is sent by them to desire admittance for three Country Gentlemen, who pretended in their letters to import something of consequence to the good of the City and County, free leave of ingresse and egresse was allowed them, but being admitted, their suggestions were found to us so frivolous and impertinent, that they were dismd not without some disrelish… About the 16th, they discover the face of their of their Battery against Frein-gate, with five severall gun-ports, from hence they played foure cannon jointly at our walls, and made a breach, which was instantly made up; they doe the like on the other side with the like successe. The 17th, a notable Sally was made at St Owen’s Church with great execution, and divers prisoners taken with the losse only of one man, at which time little boyes strived, which was performed to some purpose, and so it was at the same Sally-port once before, though with a fewere number, and therefore with lesse execution. …

… from the 20 unto the 27, there was a great clme on all sides, we as willing to provide ourselves, and preserve our ammunition for a storme, as they could be industrious or malitious to bring it upon us: yet I cannot say that either side was Idle; for they ply’d their Mine at Saint Owen’s, and prepared it for scaling, we countermined, imploy’d our boyes day and night to steale out and fire their Works, securing their retreat under the protection of the Musquetiers upon the wall, and what our fire could not perfect, though it burnt farre, and suffocated some of their Miners, our water did, breaking in upon them and drowning that which the fire had not consumed, and this saved us the pains of pursuing a mine, which we had sunk on purpose to render theirs in that place ineffectuall.

The 29th, Leven (a merciful Generall) assayes the Towne againe by his last offer of honourable conditions to surrender, but he found us still unrelenting, the terror of his cannon making no impression at all upon our spirits, though the bullets discharged from them had done so much against our walls: this … drives their greatest spirits into a passionate resolution of storming. And to that purpose, August 31st and September 1, they prepare ladders, hurdles, and other accommodations for the advancing of their designe … and played very hot with their cannon upon Bysters gate, and the halfe moon next Saint Owen’s gate, intending the morrow after to fall on, presuming as they boasted, that after they had rung us this passing peale, they should presently force the Garrison to give up her Loyall Ghost, but the same night His Majesty advancing from Worcester, gave them a very hot alarum, and drawing a little nearer to us, like the Sunne to the Meridian, this Scottish mist beganne to disperse, and the next morning vanished out of sight. …

I should give your Lordship an accompt of the valor of our common souldiers and townesmen, that would hazard themselves at the making of breaches, to the astonishment of the Enemy, till their cannon played between their legges, and even the women (such was their gallantry) ventured where the musquet bullets did … what frequent alarums we gave them by fire-balls, lights upon our steeple, by dogs, cats, and outworne horses, having light matches tyed around them; and turned out upon their works, whereby we put the enemy in such distraction, that sometimes they charged one another. … that providence that brought these to us, at last drove our Enemies from us, after the destruction of four or five Mines, … the expence of three hundred Cannon shot, besides other Ammunition spent with muskets, the losse by their owne confession of twelve hundred, and as the Country sayes two thousand men, we in all not losing about twenty-one by all casualties whatsoever. Thus, craving your Lordship’s pardon for my prolixity, I take leave and rest,

Your Lordship’s most humble servant

BER. SCUDAMORE

Nevertheless, after withstanding the tremendous onslaught for nearly six weeks in 1645, the city would have been overrun, had the news not reached the Earl of Leven that the King’s troops were rushing to lift the siege of Hereford. The Scottish army broke camp and retreated to Gloucestershire. Hereford entertained the King and celebrated. Sir Barnabas Scudamore praised the city’s ‘officers, gentry, clergy, citizens and common souldiers’ who ‘behaved themselves all gallantly upon their duty, many eminently’, adding ‘to particularize each would be too great a trespasse’. But we can particularize at least one of these loyal defenders, ‘even’ one of the ‘gallant’ women he also referred to in his letter to Digby quoted above.

The Warrior Women of Herefordshire:

In a recent article, Lloyd Bowen has introduced us to Jane Merricke of Hereford. Although women did not have a formal role in the Civil War armies, recent research, including that of project member Professor Mark Stoyle, has highlighted the role of female camp followers as well as women who dressed as men and served in royalist and parliamentarian forces.  Moreover, there are several high profile cases of women participating in military encounters during the Civil Wars, perhaps the most famous being Brilliana Harley’s defence of Brampton Bryan in Herefordshire during the royalist siege. She was praised by one of her captains for her ‘masculine bravery’ in the face of the enemy. Most evidence of women in military contexts concerns high status figures like Harley who were left to defend the homestead while their husbands served elsewhere. Sir Robert was in London, without any way to reach home and her sons were Ned and Robert were in Waller’s army and, she hoped, safe. Most of the godly clergy and their families had long since fled, many to Gloucester, which was holding out against a royalist siege. Her friends’ abandoned houses had been gutted and vandalised, and the lands themselves forfeit to the king. Defending Brampton behind its fourteenth-century gatehouse were fifty musketeers, attempting to protect another fifty civilians, including her her family physician, her godly lady friends and her three youngest children. By late July 1643, seven hundred foot soldiers and horse troopers were camped around Brampton, building breastworks close to her garden from which they could fire cannonballs and musket shot at the house. There was nothing much that Brilliana could do except pray, wait and inspect her own defensive works.

The siege, when it began in earnest, went on for six and a half weeks, with daily bombardments, the defenders being reduced to using hand-mills to grind their grain into flour to make bread. The roof of the hall was smashed in, but despite the relentless regularity of the the fire few were killed, though Brilliana lost her cook, another servant and one of her woman friends. Apart from these losses, Brilliana was most upset by the perpetual enemy cursing coming from the breast works in our gardens and walks, where their rotten and poisoned language annoyed us more than their poisoned bullets. Throughout the siege Brilliana remained in regular contact with the besiegers, who themselves hoped for a negotiated end rather than having to storm the house, and she kept them talking as a ploy, while hoping for some relief from parliamentary troops. Eventually, in September, the royalists were called away to reinforce the siege of Gloucester, and left her still the mistress of Brampton Bryan. She set about levelling the earthworks and replanting her garden and orchards. She also badly needed to restock the estate with cattle and took tem from neighbours who had become enemies. The pious puritan lady herself became a plunderer. In October, she fell ill quite suddenly and died, to general shock and grief. Spurred on by Brilliana’s example, the defenders of Brampton Bryan continued to hold out against further attacks until April 1644, when they finally gave up the house to troops acting in the name of the governor of Hereford, Barnabas Scudamore, the viscount’s brother and author of the letter quoted above.

The Brilliana Harley story makes Jane Merricke’s petition all the more interesting as it shows participation in a Civil War siege by an obscure and relatively low status woman. Perhaps even more striking is the fact that Jane describes herself as the wife of Henry Merricke; there is no indication that he has died at the time the petition was composed and one would expect her to be described as ‘widow’ if this were the case. It seems that Jane was not content to be a demur wife who left engagement with the local authorities to the putative head of the household. Rather she devised her petition on her own initiative and with her own agenda. Jane Merricke’s petition was addressed to the mayor and justices of the city of Hereford. This was a wholly separate jurisdiction to the county of Herefordshire and made its own provision for poor relief. Merricke’s petition was presented to the authorities after the Restoration of Charles II in 1660, detailing her service in his father’s cause during the siege of the city. In her petition Jane Merricke described how, ‘when the Scotts beleaguered’ the city she had been ‘sorely wounded in severall parts of her bodie & limbs’. She was injured while ‘casting up worke for the defence of the … Cittie, which is not unknown to the whole Cittie’. It was clearly all hands to the pump as the royalists of Hereford scrambled to shore up their position against an impressive Scottish army. Female military support was not that unusual in the siege of a major urban centre, however. When the nearby city of Worcester was besieged in 1643, for example, it was reported that ‘the ordinary sort of women, out of every ward of the city, joined in companies, and with spades, shovels and mattocks’ went ‘in a warlike manner like soldiers’ to destroy parliament’s offensive works.

Jane Merricke’s petition had a colourful and compelling narrative underwriting her request for money. She maintained that when Charles I came to the city after its relief in September 1645, Merricke was brought before him at the marketplace. The king, ‘comiseratinge her sad mishap … out of his gracious favour then promised [her] … that shee should be cared for’. This paints a remarkable scene. It suggests that Merricke’s fortitude and bravery were particularly noteworthy and that she had been brought before the king as an example of Hereford’s resolute royalism. Perhaps this was why she noted that the ‘whole cittie & the inhabitants thereof’ knew of her actions. Charles’s gratefulness and generosity towards the city was particularly marked at this point as the royalists were struggling elsewhere in the country. On 4 September the king granted an augmentation to the city’s arms praising effusively the Herefordians’ ‘loyalltie, courage and undaunted resolution’ during the siege as they, ‘joineing with the garrison and doing the duty of souldiers then defended themselves and repell’d their fury and assaults’. Merricke seemed emblematic of such commitment and loyalty and, given the king’s buoyant mood, he may have promised Merricke she would be looked after.

Raising the siege of Hereford was one of a diminishing number of military bright spots for the royalists in 1645. The city finally fell to parliamentarian forces under Colonel John Birch on 18 December that year and the parliamentarian tide swept that over Hereford engulfed the rest of England and Wales in the following months. There was little prospect of Jane Merricke receiving any recompense until the restoration of monarchy in 1660. Even then, however, she claimed to have petitioned the authorities several times without success. Undeterred, she wrote another entreaty requesting consideration of ‘her sad condicon & her poore estate’. Merricke asked for an annual pension from the city elders to look after her and her children. An endorsement on her petition which now resides among the corporation’s papers at the Herefordshire Archives and Records Centre merely recorded that she was given twenty shillings from the moneys the city administered as a charitable bequest from one Mr Wood. It seems almost certain that this was a one-off gratuity rather than the annual pension she had requested. It is likely Merricke would have been disappointed with this meagre sum; it was hardly a generous return on a king’s promise. Jane Merricke’s determined pursuit of compensation means she is one of the few non-elite women involved in military service during the Civil Wars who can be identified by name. The reason others are not found in the archive of welfare petitions seems clear. The legislation which established both the parliamentarian and royalist compensatory systems envisaged a clear distinction between male combatants and female dependants. This was a rigorously patriarchal society and the systems of military welfare, particularly that of the royalist side, reflected this. Perhaps emboldened by a royal promise, Jane Merricke broke ranks to request her due as a female military veteran. She was, however, a singular case among the thousands of petitioners in post-Civil War England and Wales.

Conclusion – The Local World of the Civil Wars:

The ‘unearthing’ of cases like that of Jane Merricke is, nevertheless, a significant product of the focus on the local history of the civil war period begun by historians such as A.M. Everitt, Valerie Pearl, David Underdown, and Clive Holmes. Moreover, the application of statistical analysis to historical problems has enabled historians like David Underdown and Blair Worden to support their theories with ‘hard’ evidence. Long-held generalisations based on the ‘national’ British narrative have been seriously modified in the face of evidence produced by these local studies. At the same time, research into local documents, family papers, Council Minute Books, etc. has highlighted the the feelings, problems and needs of ordinary, largely anonymous people, whose world was far removed from those of King Charles I or even ‘King’ John Pym.

Sources:

Published:

John Hayward et.al. (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British & Irish History, London: Penguin Books.

John Wroughton (1980), Documents and Debates: Seventeenth Century Britain. Basingstoke: Macmillan Education Limited.

Austin Woolrych (2002), Britain in Revolution, 1625-1660. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Philip Warner (1976), Famous Battles of the Midlands. Glasgow: Fontana.

David Smurthwaite (1984), The Ordnance Survey Complete Guide to the Battlefields of Britain. Exeter: Webb & Bower (Publishers) Limited.

Simon Schama (2001), A History of Britain: The British Wars, 1603-1776. London: BBC Worldwide Ltd.

Internet:

http://texts.wishful-thinking.org.uk/LedburyGuide/CivilWar.html

https://htt.herefordshire.gov.uk/herefordshires-past/the-post-medieval-period/the-english-civil-war

https://www.civilwarpetitions.ac.uk/blog/a-female-combatant-jane-merricke-of-hereford/

The Three Kingdoms and The Third Civil War, Part Two – Scotland, 1650-52: Dunbar & Worcester

The Royalist General Tam Dalyell swore never to cut his beard until a Stuart was back on the throne again. Tam’s beard grew down to his girdle before this happened. He lived in the house pictured above, The Binns, Linlithgow, where the Dalyell family still live today. Visitors to the house can see the actual comb that Tam used to keep his long beard from tangling. A recently-deceased descendent and namesake became a Westminster MP and ‘Father of the House of Commons’. He was a fierce opponent of the reinstatement of the Scottish Parliament.

The Fate of the Earl of Montrose, April-May 1650:

At the beginning of the new decade, with Oliver Cromwell wintering in Ireland, together with a significant portion of the parliamentarian army, from the middle of January onwards the Rump became ever more fearful that the Scots were about to take up arms once more for the man they had proclaimed King Charles II. The Scottish Parliament was then sitting at Edinburgh, where it received a message from its emissary to the young Charles Stuart in Jersey. This told them that ‘the king would treat with their commissioners at Breda’, so that they immediately began preparing their instructions.The ‘young pretender’, as the Rump called him, had been in Jersey since the previous September, but in mid-February he sailed for France where he spent three weeks conferring with his mother at Beauvais before returning to Breda, where he would later treat with the Scottish parliament’s commissioners. That body was divided between two main ‘parties’; the representatives of the strict ‘Kirk party’, who were dubious about negotiating with him at all, the more flexible politicians led by Argyll, who saw the advantage of his ‘return’ to Scotland, at least as a figurehead. But Charles himself had recently commissioned his father’s champion and Argyll’s ‘enemy’, Montrose, to embark on the first stage of the enterprise to retake all three of the Stuart kingdoms. Not only did the Kirk party insist on the young king signing both the Scottish National Covenant and the Solemn League and Covenant, but Argyll also insisted that he should order Montrose to stand down and leave Scotland. The Earl (or Marquess) of Montrose, having left Scotland on Charles I’s orders in 1646, had returned in the service of Charles II by raising an army of mainly Danish, Swedish, Dutch and German mercenaries, no more than twelve hundred in total, and landing them on Orkney in the middle of March. There he found a letter waiting for him from from the king, written in January, directing him to go ahead with the campaign, despite Charles’ negotiations with the Covenanters, in order to help him wring concessions from the Kirk party.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 002-2-1.jpg

Accordingly, Montrose landed his small force on the mainland in mid-April, hoping to augment his army by recruiting from the Highland clans that had fought for his father before, but morale had been so sapped by defeat in the Second Civil War that very few joined. Also, as Clarendon recorded, the Marquess of Argyll was vigilant enough to observe the movements of the man he considered to be his foremost enemy. He received information about Montrose’s arrival in the Highlands, and of the smallness of the force which he had brought with him. The Scots’ parliament were alarmed by the news of Montrose’s landing and changed course to organising forces to send out to stop him before he could be reinforced by others. So he was left with the six hundred Dutch and German troops under ‘a company of good officers’. Although he chose advantageous ground on which to make his stand, he was defeated at Carbisdale on 27 April by vastly superior numbers under David Leslie. Montrose marched into a trap skilfully set for him by Archibald Strachan and the Covenanting cavalry. His common soldiers, being nearly all foreigners, responded to losing the first hundred of their number by throwing down their arms and some were drowned in trying to escape. Seeing that all was lost, Montrose threw away his ribbon and George cross (he was a knight of the garter) and exchanged his clothes with ‘a fellow of the country’. According to Clarendon, having gone two or three miles on foot, he hid in the house of a gentleman for the next two days, while the majority of the other officers were taken prisoner before the Marquess was himself captured a week after the battle. The foreign troops were transported back to their own countries. Montrose and the remaining prisoners were handed over to David Leslie, carrying them in triumph to Edinburgh. Whereas Leslie treated the Marquess ‘with great insolence’, Montrose behaved throughout with dignity,

… such as became a great man; his countenance serene and cheerful, as one that was superior to all those reproaches, which they had prepared the people to pour out upon him in all the places through which he was to pass. … When he came to one of the gates of Edinburgh, he was met by some of the magistrates, to whom he was delivered, and by them presently put in a new cart, purposely made, in which there was a high chair or bench, upon which he sat, that the people might have a full view of him, being bound with a chord drawn over his breast and shoulders, and fastened through holes made in the cart … the streets and windows being full of people to behold the triumph over a person whose name had made them tremble some few years before, and into whose hands the magistrates of that place had, upon their knees, delivered the keys of the city. In this manner he was carried to the common gaol, where he was received and treated as a common malefactor.

Presbyterian ministers then came to the gaol, obstensibly offering to intercede with the Kirk upon his repentance, and to pray with him. But, understanding that they meant to torment him with virulent condemnation, he desired them ‘to spare their pains, and to leave him to his devotions’. He told them that…

… he was so far from being troubled that his four limbs were to be hanged in four cities of the kingdom, that he heartily wished that he had flesh enough to be sent to every city in Christendom, as a testimony to the cause for which he suffered.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 003-1.jpg
Edward Hyde, Earl of Clarendon, who wrote the account of Montrose’s capture & execution.

The next day, 21 May, they executed every part of that barbarous sentence. He prayed ‘that they might not betray’ the young Charles Stuart as they had done his father. As a last ‘act of their tyranny’, the hangman then brought the book that had been published containing the details of his ‘heroic actions’, tied in a small chord which was placed around his neck. He ‘thanked them for it’ and said that he was pleased that it should be there; and was prouder of wearing it than he had been of the garter. He was publicly hanged and quartered, dying with a bravery that moved the onlookers, and five of his leading officers were executed over the course of the next month. Charles came to terms with the commissioners at Breda on 1 May, when he had not yet heard of Montrose’s defeat, but without gaining any guarantee of his safety. He wrote a public letter to the Earl on 3 May, ordering him to lay down his arms and leave Scotland, and a private one two days later, promising to protect his interests and hoping to employ him again soon. He then wrote to the Scottish parliament on the 8th, informing it that Montrose had been told to disband and asking that his forces should be allowed to leave Scotland unharmed, but the next day, still unaware of the defeat at Carbisdale, he wrote privately to Montrose again, telling him to remain in arms in case his treaty with the parliament should fall through.

Cromwell’s Return, the King’s Landing & Fairfax’s ‘Retreat’:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 012.jpg
Oliver Cromwell, by an unknown artist, c. 1650.

Cromwell landed at Bristol late in May, and parliament greeted his arrival with a grant of lands worth two thousand five hundred pounds a year, having already given him the use of St James’ House, the Cockpit and Spring Gardens. Many MPs, councillors, and officers came out to meet him at Windsor and many volleys were fired in his honour, but this company was nothing to the great crowds that gathered on Hounslow Heath to welcome him next day. Sir Thomas Fairfax was among those who greeted him, the mutual warmth and regard born of long comradeship in arms still undimmed, but Fairfax had had still stronger reasons for welcoming him home. Leading politicians were already persuaded that the safest way of countering the Scottish threat, and on 12th June Fairfax accepted command of it, with Cromwell as his lieutenant-general. But in Fairfax’s mind it was one thing to defend English territory and quite another to take the initiative in attacking an old ally, and when the Council of State formally voted on the 20th to invade Scotland, he decided to resign his commission. He took the view that England and Scotland were still mutually bound by the Solemn League and Covenant and though the Scottish ‘engagers’ had broken that bond by invading England in 1648, the Edinburgh parliament had subsequently disowned Hamilton’s ‘enterprise’.

Sir Thomas Fairfax

But Fairfax’s commitment to the Commonwealth had been in doubt since the trial of Charles I, when his wife (a Scottish presbyterian) had, ‘notoriously’, interrupted the proceedings to express his disaffection towards them. He himself had added to these doubts by refusing to formally take the Engagement and by not taking up his seat as an MP, to which he had been elected early in 1649. The House appointed a powerful committee which included Cromwell, in an attempt to overcome his scruples about carrying the war into Scotland, and it strove to to persuade him to accept the command. Fairfax reaffirmed his his ‘duty and affection’ to the parliamentarian cause, he resisted the committee’s arguments partly by pleading his ‘debilities both in body and mind’. According to his own memoirs, written after the Restoration, Charles II had tried in vain to tempt him with the earldom of Essex, ten thousand pounds a year in land, and whatever office he might choose, but Fairfax was not to take up the king’s cause until the Commonwealth was collapsing from within. Still only thirty-eight, he retired to Yorkshire to cultivate his garden.

Meanwhile, the king had set sail early in June in a warship provided by the Prince of Orange, the ‘young pretender’ eventually received an account of the details of Montrose’s defeat from the Scots’ parliamentary commissioners before he embarked from Holland. It contained no apology for the affront and indignity to himself by his servant’s execution, but included an assurance that the proceeding against the late marquis of Mountrose had been for his service. Even those at the exiled king’s court who had been most opposed to Argyll and his faction were nevertheless relieved that he had rid them of a far more dangerous enemy and they persuaded Charles that he might sooner take revenge on that people by temporarily complying with them, than by continuing to remain in exile and thereby facilitating their ‘absolute dominion’ in his Scottish kingdom and their tyranny over his faithful subjects there. It is clear that, to some extent, he publicly disowned the responsibility for Montrose’s efforts on his behalf after so strongly encouraging them. was thus persuaded to follow his ‘former resolution’ before he had been distracted in favour of the Irish option, and therefore embarked for Scotland. Before he was admitted to his father’s country of birth, Charles did sign both Covenants, recognised the supreme authority of the Kirk in spiritual, and of the parliament in secular matters, and agreed to disown Ormond and his Irish ‘rebels’ and their treaty if and when the parliament should require. His agreement with the Scots now formed the basis of what became known as the Treaty of Breda.

The Battles, Sieges and key places of the Civil Wars in Scotland

Charles only signed the final concessions shortly before his little flotilla, which had been hunted by the the English fleet, arrived in the Moray Forth on Midsummer’s Eve at the end of June 1650. Dismay at the terms he had agreed to was not confined to the old royalists such as Hyde, Hopton, Nicholas and Cottington, for his mother, who had been so keen on a Scottish alliance, and Rupert’s circle felt it too. Whether Charles, when he arrived in Edinburgh, observed Montrose’s severed head impaled on a spike in the Tolbooth is not recorded. He received a genuinely warm welcome from the common people of Scotland, but he was soon in bitter dispute with the parliament and the Kirk over the many old royalists he had brought with him as part of his household, and he was eventually forced to dismiss them. Charles was once more proclaimed King, this time in person, in July. The Scottish parliament had only just passed an act of levy for the recruiting of an army of over thirty-six thousand men, in addition to the few thousands that David Leslie already had under arms. It was a huge target for a small population, and one which was destined to be easily missed. But to the English Parliament it now seemed only a question of time before a Scottish army once again invaded England and it was decided that the New Model should immediately mount its own invasion of Scotland to pre-empt Charles. A significant proportion of the army was still serving in Ireland, and the demands of garrisoning England against Royalist risings meant that some new regiments had to be raised.

Cromwell’s Invasion of Scotland:

On 28 June, the day on which he received his formal commission to succeed Fairfax as Lord General, Cromwell marched north with five thousand horse and ten thousand foot, the vast majority of them veterans. His attacking force consisted of eight regiments apiece of cavalry and infantry. By the time it crossed the Tweed on 22 July, Leslie had raised his army to almost the same level, and Leslie was a far better general than Hamilton had been, probably the best that Cromwell had ever confronted. Though Leven, now about seventy, was still nominally commander-in-chief, Leslie was in actual control of operations. For all the English parliament’s superior resources, they were severely stretched across the three kingdoms. With Leslie’s forces increasing rapidly, a very testing time lay ahead for Cromwell, who pressed parliament to augment his own army to twenty-five thosand, but it was well into 1651 before it reached twenty thousand. The Scots were deployed in an exceptionally strong position between Edinburgh and Leith, and Leslie’s strategy was to leave Cromwell free to advance to it unopposed, having stripped the intervening territory of all provisions that his troops might need. This ‘scorched earth’ policy, coming on top of the impressment of all men of military age, inflicted great hardship on the Lowlanders and made them doubly hostile to the invaders; nor were they mollified by Cromwell’s repeated proclamations forbidding his men to lay hands on their persons or property.

In apalling weather conditions the New Model Retreated to Musselburgh and then to Dunbar, where it could be supplied by sea. But these were inadequate, and their transport from the shore was impeded by persistently wet weather. Nevertheless, Cromwell did his best to bring the Scots into open battle. After re-provisioning at Dunbar, Cromwell made contact with a Scottish army in excess of twenty thousand men under David Leslie on 29 July and he advanced upon Leslie’s lines. He bombarded Leith furiously, and even temporarily captured Arthur’s Seat, but after his wet and weary men had stood in battle order all night, he withdrew them to their camp at Musselborough. It was a fighting withdrawal, with the Scots harrying the rearguard and attacking the English army’s headquarters at Musselburgh. Their first night’s rest there was broken by a bold attack of fifteen troops of Leslie’s horse, which were beaten off only with some difficulty. Already, between four and five thousand of Cromwell’s troops were sick, and it was imperative that he bring about a battle before his army wasted away. While the Lord General’s army was shrinking, Leslie’s troops were being continually reinforced, so that they soon outnumbered Cromwell’s force by two to one.

Above: Cromwell’s Bible from the London Museum. It was bound in leather, with large metal clasps, and was well-used. Cromwell wrote his nameinside the cover. It was small enough to be carried on campaigns and into battle. We know that he read his bible every day, even in the battlefields. In Scotland, he disputed the interpretations of it held by the strict Presbyterian ministers who controlled both the politicians and the armies.

Cromwell’s attitude towards his Scottish adversaries was markedly different from the one he had shown to the Irish. The Scots’ lowlanders were fellow-protestants, if rather bigoted, and many of them had fought side-by-side with Cromwell’s own troopers at Marston Moor. But in Cromwell’s mind the two people’s had one thing in common: both were being driven to fight for a bad cause by their clergy. In a war of words with the kirkmen which had begun with the long manifesto in the name of his army when it first crossed the border, he published a famous address to the General Assembly of the Kirk from Musselborough on 3 August. He accused the ministers of claiming infallibility in interpreting the word of God, and teaching the people that the Covenant bound them to fight on their side in the present war. It was, of course, a highly partisan document, but it is expressive of his own convictions:

“Your own guilt is too much for you: bring not therefore upon yourselves the blood of innocent men, deceived with pretences of king and Covenant, from whose eyes you hide a better knowledge … Is it therefore infallibly agreeable to the Word of God, all that you say? I beseech you, in the bowels of Christ, think it possible you may be mistaken … There may be … a carnal confidence upon mistaken and misapplied concepts, which may be called spiritual drunkenness. There may be a Covenant made with death and hell.“

Smouldering with indignation, the kirkmen demanded of him, Would you have us to be sceptics in our religion? Their view, repeated again and again, was simply that Cromwell had signed the Covenant and was now breaking it. But Cromwell was not their only problem and his challenge to do battle on 29 July coincided with with an unofficial visit to the Scottish army by the king himself. Charles was joyously welcomed by both officers and men, so warmly indeed that the Kirk party were thoroughly dismayed. They feared that a war for God and the Covenant would degenerate into a secular war for the king, with a consequent dimunition in their own influence. They warned Charles that his continuing presence would discourage the godly and incur the wrath of God, who was jealous of any rivalry to his own glory. They put strong pressure on him to leave, which he reluctantly did on 2 August, and concluding that there were too many ‘malignants’ in Leslie’s camp, they persuaded the Committee of Estates to carry out a purge which rapidly removed about eighty officers and four thousand men. As well as reducing the army’s strength, this also damaged the morale of the Scottish army, roused the young king’s deep resentment and it widened the rift in the Covenanters’ ranks between the fanatical clergy-dominated wing and the moderate, aristocratic one led by Argyll.

The Battle of Dunbar, September 1650:

Above: A contemporary plan of the battle of Dunbar, 1650, showing on the right Cromwell’s camp by the town of Dunbar; in the centre lies Broxburn House where Cromwell planned his surprise night attack.
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-4.jpg

Throughout August Cromwell tried intermittently to bring Leslie to a decisive engagement, but he always failed. Leslie was also under pressure both from the politicians in Edinburgh and the Presbyterian chaplains in the army, but he steadfastly resisted them both. He reckoned that the toll that dysentery and camp fever were taking of the English army, combined with the problems of supplying it by sea, would force Cromwell back across the border before the winter set in. Although Cromwell had been reinforced, sickness and desertion had reduced his effective strength to about eleven thousand by the end of August, and despite the purge, Leslie still had at least twice as many in the field. Even so, the result of the purges was that the Scots’ army, although large, was an unwieldy and amateurish force compared with Cromwell’s seasoned New Model professionals. He therefore decided to advance in an attempt to turn the right flank of the Scots’ army, but Leslie was equal to this manoeuvre, so that the New Model was forced to return to Dunbar on 1 September, with the Scots harassing his rearguard. At Dunbar, Cromwell was able to take possession of the supplies that had been shipped from Berwick, but Leslie believed he had him cornered. The Scottish army then advanced and deployed on a strong position on Doon Hill, effectively also cutting off the land route back to Berwick at Cockburnspath for the parliamentarian troops. Cromwell would either have to evacuate his army by sea or fight his way out of encirclement. Equally, Leslie would have to attack if he was to prevent his prey slipping away on board the English fleet.

Above: The scene of the battlefield today, with Bass Rock and the Firth of Forth in distance.

The Scots’ deployment extended inland from the coast for over three thousand yards (2,740 metres) with the majority of their troops positioned on the forward slope of Doon Hill. On 2nd, Cromwell wrote to Haselrig, governor of Newcastle, warning him to muster all the troops he could against a possible defeat and a subsequent Scottish invasion:

We are here upon a an engagement very difficult. The enemy hath blocked up our way at the pass at Copperspath (Cockburnspath), through which we cannot get without almost a miracle. He lieth so much upon the hills that we know not how to come that way without great difficulty; and our lying here daily consumeth our men who fall sick beyond imagination.

But though defeat was a contingency against which it was his duty to provide, Cromwell’s mind was all on battle, and he never despaired of victory. Leslie, with his two to one superiority (slightly more than that in infantry, slightly less in cavalry), did not conceive that the English would attempt any more than to make their escape with as few losses as possible, and he felt confirmed in this expectation when Cromwell put five hundred of his sickest men on shipboard; he thought that the English were evacuating all their infantry. He came down fom Doon Hill on 2nd September and formed a battle-front about a mile long, mostly behind the shallow ravine of the Spott Burn, but stretching right across the Berwick road. He needed no persuading to give battle now and his move brought the English lines within range of his artillery, also giving his men some relief from the bitter winds and rain that swept Doon Hill. Cromwell led his senior officers on a mounted reconnaisance of the Scottish position late that afternoon, and after reconnoitring the Scots’ position later that evening, Cromwell and Lambert judged it vulnerable, and a council of war held on the night of 2nd-3rd September approved orders for an early assault the next morning. But whereas most of the Scots’ cavalry were allowed to unsaddle their horses and the musketeers to extinguish their matches, and many of their offices went off to houses or tents behind the lines for rest, the English regiments stayed at the ready, and Cromwell rode around them all night, checking their positions and giving them encouragement.

The battlefield at Dunbar lies just to the south of the town and can be approached via the A1 road, which cuts along the Lammermuir Hills as they run down to the coast.

Between five and six o’ clock, Lambert, with six regiments of horse, opened a the battle with an assault on the the Scots holding the pass at Cockburnspath and Monck, with three regiments of foot, charged the Scottish right, surprising them. Nevertheless, the Scots resisted fiercely, but despite a strong cavalry counter-attack, they cleared after an hour’s fighting. In the general engagement that followed, the infantry battle played at least as important a role as the early cavalry action. Attacking against such heavy odds, the English foot were at first repulsed, but they rallied and drove the Scots back at push of pike over a distance of of three quarters of a mile. When the Covenanters finally cracked and began to throw down their arms, Cromwell arrived with a reserve of horse and foot, which cut through the enemy right and began to roll up their line. They were, in his words, made by the Lord of Hosts as stubble to their swords. The centre and left of Leslie’s army then disintegrated in surrender or full flight and the Horse of the New Model set off in pursuit. As the sun rose over the sea, Cromwell shouted, “Now let God arise, and his enemies shall be shattered”. He had never fought a finer battle, though Lambert also derved the credit that Cromwell himself gave him. They had faced possible destruction together, but it was the Covenanting army that was all but destroyed. With three thousand Scots killed and over ten thousand captured, of Leslie’s army only about four thousand men, mainly cavalry, subsequently rallied to him. For Cromwell, Dunbar was a very special providencial action, and he was anxious that his masters at Westminster should see it as such, and be worthy of it, as he wrote to the Speaker the next day:

We that serve you beg of you not to own us, but God alone; we pray you own his people more and more, for they are the chariots and horsemen of Israel. Disown yourselves, but own your authority, and improve it to curb the proud and the insolent … relieve the oppressed, hear the groans of the poor prisoners in England, be pleased to reform the abuses of all profession; and if there be anyone that makes many poor to make a few rich, that suits not a Commonwealth.

The officer entrusted with the dispatch was Major White of the General’s own regiment of horse, who in 1647 had been expelled from the General Council for his extreme Leveller opinions and in 1649 had been employed to negotiate with the Oxfordshire mutineers. The House heard his account of the great victory with understandable enthusiasm and relief. It made some response to Cromwell’s pleas, for it quickly passed an act repealing all laws that penalised non-attendance at the parish church, providing that all nonconformists engaged in some other form of worship on the Lord’s Day. Edinburgh learned of the disaster at Dunbar from the fleeing horsemen who sought shelter within its walls, and it reacted with panic. Leven and Leslie withdrew what was left of their army to Stirling, which also became a refuge for the Committee of Estates and the city fathers and many burghers of Edinburgh, as well as its bellicose presbyters. Cromwell sent Lambert to secure the city while Cromwell took Leith, vital for the safe landing of supplies and reinforcements, which despite its strong walls and thirty-seven cannon offered no resistance. On arriving in Edinburgh himself, Cromwell again sought to persuade the Scottish people that his quarrel was not with him, promising them protection of their persons and property, and freedom of trade and movement. The Castle still held out against him, but its garrison posed no threat while it was cut off from reinforcements. He treated its governor, Sir Walter Dundas, with courtesy, and he also sent Colonel Whalley to invite its refugee ministers to preach in the city churches with free passage. Many of the fugitive burghers also returned and economic life in the capital soon returned to normal.

Above: The Dunbar Medal – the victory medal. It was the first military medal to be given both to officers and men in the army. On the medal is the portrait of Oliver Cromwell, the date of the battle and the inscription, which was the battle cry of Cromwell’s soldiers.

After a week in Edinburgh, Cromwell set out for Stirling to tackle Leslie and the remnants of his army there. He summoned the town to surrender on 18 September. Leslie had no more than five thousand men, including the garrison, but he refused and Cromwell prepared to storm the town. But at the last minute he changed his mind and by the 21st he had returned to Edinburgh. An assault could have cost many lives, and with so much already gained he did not want to subject his own troops to major losses. It would also have been a major problem for him to garrison Stirling, since it could not have been supplied by sea. But given the conciliatory gestures he had already made in the wake of Dunbar, Cromwell may well have decided not to use further force out of a genuine desire to win over most of Scotland by persuasion. The internal divisions had been opened much wider by the dramatic defeat at Dunbar, so much so that he may also have judged that a potentially lengthy and bloody siege so late in the campaigning year was unnecessary and could well prove counter-productive to his aims of pre-empting a Scottish invasion of England. Leslie’s authority as lieutenant-general was seriously diminished and he had been much criticised for the defeat of his army, so much that he had tried to resign. But the Committee of Estates would not accept his resignation, chiefly because there was no suitable replacement for him. Some influential officers, including Colonel Archibald Strachan and Gilbert Ker, blamed him so much for the Dunbar débacle that they refused to take orders from him.

Early in September, the Committee of Estates had accepted an offer from the counties between the Firth of Clyde and the Solway Firth, which had come together to form the Western Association to raise more than their quota of new levies on condition that their men would constitute a virtually independent army. Glasgow and the south-west were the heartlands of militant, hard-line Presbyterianism, and many there looked to this new army to prevent the strict Covenanting cause from being taken over by engager-royalists. The Committee sent Strachan and Ker to command the Western Association army, but by doing so they alienated the nobles and greater lairds of the region, who looked upon themselves as its natural commanders. The new army was therefore staffed mainly by minor gentry and men of ‘middling sort’, and won the enthusiastic support of many ministers of the kirk. In addition, following Dunbar, Presbyterian officers and men in Leslie’s army left to join it without orders. But this was not simpy a matter of regional religious and cultural concern.

Charles, Argyll and the Kirk Party:

Meanwhile, Charles had been ‘induced’ by the Scottish parliament to publish a humiliating declaration on 16 August as a condition of receiving Scottish armed support; among other things that were distasteful to him, he was made to revoke the the peace that he himself had instructed Ormond to conclude with the Irish Confederates in 1649, and to acknowledge the exceeding great sinfulness and unlawfulness of treating with the bloody Irish rebels. He also had to humble himself before God for his mother’s ‘idolatory’ and his father’s sin in opposing the Covenant. These concessions left him wretched, and he wrote to his Secretary Nicholas on 3 September, asking that through him the Prince of Orange should have a boat lying ready off the nearest Scottish shore, in case he should decide to throw up the whole adventure. By that time, however, the Scots were seriously at war for him. The kirk party, which included important laymen as well as the majority of ministers from across the country, reacted to the Dunbar defeat by asserting that the Lord had withdrawn his presence from them because they had put too much trust in a prince who was not sincerely repentant of his parents’ sins and was intent on worldly, not godly ends. In their view neither the purging of the army nor the king’s oaths and affirmations had gone far enough.

Charles II was over six feet tall (unusual at that time), very dark and nicknamed ‘Black Boy’. He landed in Scotland in June 1650, invaded England in August 1651 and was defeated at the Battle of Worcester on 3 September.

Charles himself must have had mixed feelings when he heard of Leslie’s defeat. On the one hand it gravely diminished the chances of his being restored to the English throne by a Scottish army, but on the other it gave him hope of loosening the grip of the kirk party had put on him. He was in Perth with Argyll, who was striving to extend his influence over Charles, who nevertheless disliked and distracted the man who had become his ‘companion’. At this stage, however, the two needed each other, and on 24 September Charles agreed to make Argyll a duke and knight of the garter. A few days later, the Committee of Estates banished twenty-four members of the king’s household and replaced them with hard-line Covenanters. For Charles, this was the last straw, and he entered into a conspiracy with his northern royalist supporters to raise all their friends and clansmen north of the Tay, with the aim of seizing Perth and Dundee and making a platform for a general royalist rising. But the day before the coup was due to begin he told the Duke of Buckingham of it, who was so worried that he in turn told Wilmot. They persuaded Charles that the scheme was hopelessly rash, and he gave orders to cancel it. But these were received too late, and the Committee of Estates found out about it. Charles fled from Perth without knowing where he was headed. Colonel Montgomery and a troop of Covenanter cavalry caught up with him, hiding in Glen Cova, and took him back to Perth. He had to make his submission to the Committee of Estates, but the more sensible kirkmen realised that if they provoked their country’s king too far they would raise questions about their claim to be the conscience of that country. After this, Charles was permitted to attend all the meetings of the Committee.

The zealots of the Kirk, especially those who dominated the territory of the Western Association, increasingly questioned whether the they should be fighting for a king whose commitment to the Covenant and the protestant religion in any form was highly questionable. Some of them began to wonder whether Cromwell did not, in faith, represent a better cause than that of the Stuart; indeed, Strachan and Ker made contact with Cromwell during October, and would probably have entered into negotiation with him if it had not been vetoed by the leading political Covenanters. Cromwell himself, with nine thousand men, paid a three-day visit to Glasgow in mid-October, probably in the hope of convincing its citizens of his good intentions, as much as to demonstrate his power, but he had little success. On his return to Edinburgh, however, an important Remonstrance was published, addressed to the Committee of Estates, in the name of the gentlemen, commanders and ministers attending the forces in the west. It was to further widen the rift in Scottish politics, giving its name to the Remonstrants. It castigated the Edinburgh government for not sufficiently purging malignants from their armies and for seeking to impose an unrepentant king on an unwilling England in order to grow rich on its spoils. The main support for this deeply divisive document came from the clergy, especially those of the west and south-west, and from the burghers of Glasgow. But Argyll and other nobles, who wanted to bring the king ‘to heel’ rather than alienate him further, denounced it when it came before the Committee of Estates and it was eventually withdrawn by the Remonstrants themselves after it was also rejected, albeit reluctantly, by the Committee of the Kirk.

But the Remonstrants spoke for few people outside their own home territory. Most Scottish people deeply resented the presence of an English army on Scottish soil, and were ready to rally behind their Stuart monarch in affirming a united national interest. By late autumn Cromwell’s forces were being harrassed by a rising guerilla movement in the whole territory between Edinburgh, Glasgow and the border, and he felt obliged to tackle the unreduced strongholds which were sheltering it. He himself moved against Borthwick Castle, one of the strongest and strategically most important. On the instructions of the Committee of Estates, Colonel Ker of the Western Association was ordered to relieve it. Ker refused, openly stating that his unwillingness to fight for the king, and on 22 November Borthwick had to surrender. Cromwell and Lambert then launched a two-pronged attack into Western Association territory, perhaps as much to explore its army’s willingness to resist as to force a battle. Ker came upon Lambert’s cavalry force camped near Hamilton, and grossly underestimating its strength attempted a night attack, for which Lambert was thoroughly prepared. Next morning, 1st December, the rout of Ker’s force was completed and he himself was captured. Strachan tried and failed to rally his fleeing men, then gave himself up to Lambert. The Western Association army ceased to exist after just two months in the field, since most of its soldiers who had not been killed or captured, simply went home. The New Model had consolidated its military dominance in southern Scotland.

The ‘action’ now switched to the Scottish parliament, reassembled in Perth during Edinburgh’s occupation and dominated once more by Argyll and his party. It recognised that it was no longer possible to raise an army with any chance of of restoring the king unless it could draw on all who were prepared to fight for him, including royalist-engagers. If the Kirk as a body opposed it, it would probably face the same fate as Hamilton’s army in 1648. So in mid-December, the Scotttish parliament put intense pressure on the Commission of the Kirk, shorn now of the extremist Remonstrants, to pass a set of ‘Public Resolutions’ which countenanced the enlisting of repentant former enemies of the Covenant to help defend the Scottish kingdom against the invading English ‘sectaries’. Parliament then promptly ordered the raising of twenty-five new regiments, and to the consternation of the strict Kirkmen their colonels not only included former engagers but also declared royalists who had taken part in the king’s ‘Start’ and were not at all repentant. This aroused a series of protests during late December and January, not only from the Remonstrants, but also from a wider range of presbyteries, though still mainly in the south-west. The majority of more moderate ministers, however, were patriots enough to accept that the struggle had become primarily a national one, and that strict religious objectives must yield priority for a time to the prime necessity of driving out the English.

Cromwell scored some notable successes in his campaign in his campaign against the bigotry of the Scottish Presbyterians. Two influential members of the Committee of Estates, Alexander Joffray and Alexander Brodie, became converts to Independency. Another who was shaken by doubts as to the worth of the king’s cause, and also the authoritarian claims of the Kirk, was Walter Dundas, governor of Edinburgh Castle. Cromwell could not tolerate a hostile garrison in the capital indefinitely, but an attempt to mine the castle had run up against solid rock. Cromwell summoned it on 12 December, and it took only a brief bombardment to make Dundas sue for terms. He surrendered on the 24th. By then, Charles was benefiting from the changes in the Scottish political scene. The order banning the English royalists from his entourage was rescinded, and those who had been laying low in Scotland since the summer rejoined him. On New Year’s Day 1651 he was at last crowned King of Scotland in the little church at Scone. Argyll, the most powerful man in Scotland, placed the crown upon his head (shown below). He had to subscribe the Covenants once more and declare them sacred, and he did so with a convincing show of zeal, foreseeing no doubt that whether he won or lost the war ahead, there was little chance that he would be forced to uphold them for long.

In the right background of this picture, Charles II is crowned by the Marquess of Argyll at Scone in 1651. On the left foreground the king is being prepared for battle, with ‘Scotland’ presenting a pistol, and Ireland adusting his armour. A ‘kirkman’ is looking on.

The war marked time during the first half of 1651. The Scots had a whole new army to raise, equip and train, but Cromwell found himself unable to take advantage of their weakness. Defying a typically hard Scottish winter, he set out early in February to reduce Fife, but he was driven back by weather ‘so tempestuous with wind, hail, snow and rain’ that his troops could hardly find their way. On the march back to Edinburgh he fell seriously ill, through a combination of different ailments, brought on by exposure. His health fluctuated through March, his recovery being slow. On 12 April, he wrote to his wife, beginning with his thankfulness for being increased in strength in my outward man, but ending it with the admission: Truly, I am not able as yet to write much. I am wearied. He had a relapse towards the end of the month, and the Council of State in London was so concerned that they sent his two physicians northwards and ordered him to return. He was too wrapped up in the affairs of Scotland to leave his post and on 9 June the two doctors were able to report that his health was restored.

The Campaigns of 1651 – From Inverkeithing to Worcester:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 011-2.jpg
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 011.jpg

The Scots were unable to take advantage of Cromwell’s incapitation due to their continuing political divisions. Their Perth parliament was prorogued by the Committee of Estates, which was dominated by the Kirk party, until 13 March. Then a newly-elected Committee of Estates, just as dominated by the Kirk party, kept it prorogued until 23 May. It is doubtful whether Leslie had as many as ten thousand men at Stirling at this time, and he was having great difficulty in provisioning them. A reinforced Cromwell would soon outnumber him comfortably. Finally, on 4 June, the Scottish parliament repealed the Act Of Classes, enabling those with a royalist past to be appointed as officers and commanders in the army. Cromwell took to the field at the end of June, intent on bringing Leslie to battle. First, however, he resumed his attempt to gain control of Fife, ‘the breadbasket of Scotland’, which he had had to abandon in February. He now made use of fifty flat-bottomed boats which he had had built, in order to transport four thousand men under Major General Overton across the Firth of Forth, with orders to secure and fortify the penninsula between there and the Firth of Tay. To distract attention from Overton’s operation, Cromwell marched against Leslie and took up battle stations opposite his defences, challenging him to come out and fight. When that failed to draw him out, Cromwell moved west to Glasgow and conducted forays into the territory in which the Scots were busy recruiting. This brought Leslie westwards to Kilsyth on 13 July, and focused his whole attention on Cromwell during during the next week, while the flatboats ferried the English forces over the Forth to North Queensferry.

Cromwell entrusted the operation to Lambert, now promoted to Lieutenant-General. When Leslie heard of it, belatedly, he sent Major-General Holborne with over four thousand men to oppose the move, but Lambert immediately forced a battle at Inverkeithing, only a mile or so from where he had just landed. After some preliminary skirmishing, the battle proper lasted for just a quarter of an hour, and for the Scots it was an utter rout. Their cavalry were put to flight and their infantry, mostly Highland clansmen, were cut down where they stood. About two thousand men were killed and fourteen hundred captured; only about a thousand got back to Stirling. Cromwell then brought his own forces back to Edinburgh and Leith, and then transported the greater part of them into Fife. He next marched not against Stirling, Leslie’s headquarters, but against Perth, the current seat of the Scottish government, far to the north-west. After Inverkeithing, Leslie’s demoralised men were deserting in droves, and Cromwell was deliberately leaving the way open for them to invade England. Now confident of complete military superiority, he was content to take the risk of fighting the decisive battle on English soil. Charles and Leslie realised that for them the risk was even greater. Argyll and Loudoun thought that invasion would be madness, but Charles feared that if he stayed in Scotland and suffered military defeat there, he would become the prisoner of The Kirk party once more. So he and his army set off southward from Sterling on 31 July, two days before Perth surrendered to Cromwell, on generous terms.

Charles and Leslie had little more than fourteen thousand men with them, when they took this audacious step of leaving Cromwell’s army in the field and marching south into England itself. They were so short of firearms that fifty or sixty archers had to make up the strength of each foot regiment. Nevertheless, they crossed the border in the first week of August 1651 in an attempt to raise a royalist rebellion, the main reason for Charles doing so being that once he had called his English supporters to arms, he could not, in all conscience, do anything else. The hope was that, once inside England, a nation of burning royalists would flock to his standard. But their response was all too disappointing, not that the entire country was so devoted to the new Commonwealth that rallying to Charles was under any circumstances unthinkable. It was rather that the armies of the republic were so obviously still formidable that it made no sense for anyone but the most blindly devoted royalist to hazard their safety by supporting so reckless a gamble. So the march down to Worcester was a lonely and exclusively Scottish business, and the Commonwealth’s local defences never showed any sign of cracking. Leslie led his army on long, rapid marches, in time to summon Carlisle on 6 August, but that well fortified city kept its gates shut against him. Scarcely any English came to him during his progress through Cumberland and Westmorland.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 002-3.jpg

One reason why the king received little support lay in the northerners’ detestation of the of Scotsmen, whose burdensome presence they had endured twice in the previous decade. To the Cumbrian countryfolk, they were alien, ill-disciplined plunderers. The gentry wanted better more than Charles could offer before they opened their estates to sequestration or confiscation for a third time. The reinstatement of a largely unknown and obviously opportunist king on the back of a Scottish army, with the Covenant and rigid Presbyterianism as part of the package was a prospect with little appeal. The Commonwealth also had an effective intelligence network to rely on. There had been a premature insurrection in Norfolk in December 1650 which was easily suppressed without a fight. The fiasco alerted the Council of State to a flimsy network of royalist conspirators over a much wider area of the country. The region of greatest danger lay in Lancashire and Cheshire, where the king’s supporters were directed by the Earl of Derby, then on the Isle of Man. But when one of them was captured, a string of arrests followed across and down the country. Derby did manage to muster fifteen hundred men in Lancashire and on Man to support the invasion, but before they could join it Colonel Robert Lilburne put them to rout at Wigan on 25 August, killing many and taking four hundred prisoners. The contingents of royalists who succeeded in joining the king’s army were numbered in scores rather than hundreds and the largest of them, sixty horse under Lord Talbot only arrived at Worcester. It is therefore seriously misleading to describe the campaigns of 1650-51 as the ‘Third Civil War’. This was essentially a war between Scots and royalists on one side and the English Commonwealth on the other, which was fought, with the notable exception of the Battle of Worcester, on Scottish soil.

Charles was intent on an advance by the western Pennine route into the Midlands, with London as his ultimate goal. After taking the surrender of Perth, Cromwell learnt that Charles had slipped past him and was marching rapidly down through England, trying to pick up reinforcements on the way. It was a critical moment for him. There was no army between the Scots and London, but Cromwell also learned that Charles was failing to gain recruits and that he was losing many Scots through desertion. Nonetheless, leaving Monck in charge of the five thousand troops he deemed necessary to keep Scotland quiet, Cromwell set off in pursuit, sending Lambert ahead with five regiments of Horse to join the troops of Colonel Rich and Major-General Harrison in the border country. He sent four thousand horse and dragoons to harrass the royal army’s eastern flank, and Lambert with a similar force to worry its rear. Both men moved swiftly; Harrison’s brigade was in Newcastle by 5 August, the day the Scots crossed the border, and Lambert’s were in Penrith on the 9th. Cromwell had to move more slowly with his main body of about ten thousand men, since most were infantry, but he rode somewhat ahead of them and reached the Tyne by the 12th. He did not have to worry about Yorkshire, for Fairfax came out of retirement to raise the county against the king. Meanwhile, Monck and his lieutenants had secured all of Scotland south of a line drawn through Perth, except for the isolated strongholds of Bass Rock and Dunfermline Castle.

Although Charles pushed steadily southwards, the north-western counties failed to rise in his support as he had hoped, and his army was being constantly harried by Lambert and Harrison. Cromwell had let the Scots go deep into the heart of England from which there would be no way back. On the way, the Scottish king summoned Shrewsbury, but its governor pointedly addressed his defiant reply to ‘the commander-in-chief of the Scottish army’. What had begun as a daring venture had become a steel trap closing fast on Charles Stuart. By the time he reached Worcester on 22 August, his dispirited and exhausted army was still being shadowed by Lambert’s reinforced troops shortly to be combined with another substantial parliamentarian army which had been moved north and west to join him. Since leaving Stirling, they had marched 330 miles in three weeks and a day. Charles had not wanted to stay in Worcester, but decided to pause his army there to allow for supporters to come down the Severn from Wales and other border areas which had previously stood by his father.

The Battle of Worcester, September 1651:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 003-2.jpg
The City of Worcester and the River Severn from the west bank in the early 1980s.

Charles also probably calculated that the city, with its fortifications and rivers as additional defences, was probably the safest place to await reinforcements, but again he was disappointed when only a few hundreds joined his cause. Ironically, the 22nd was nine years to the day after his father had his standard at Nottingham. Coincidentally, having taken the eastern route from Scotland, Cromwell marched into Nottingham on the very same day. With only 16,000 men, in the heart of largely hostile territory, the future did not look promising for Charles and Leslie. Lambert and Harrison made their rendezvous with Cromwell at Warwick on the 24th, and a few days later Cromwell halted his forced march at Evesham, just sixteen miles away, where he was reinforced by the trained bands of Essex and Suffolk. He was then able to muster some 31,000 Commonwealth troops in total faced a royalist-Scottish army of a little over half that number. On 28 August Lambert seized Upton Bridge, enabling the Parliamentarian troops to advance on both banks of the River Severn. Their combined forces continued to invest Worcester and Charles withdrew behind the River Teme. Cromwell was quite clear in his mind about what needed to be done, and he was determined to be quite ruthless in completely and finally destroying the royalist army. To accomplish this he must surround it and block every possible avenue of escape. He was strong enough to divide his army without either par being outnumbered if it had to fight on its own, butbut he knew he had to take Worcester’s defences seriously, for they had been strenuously improved during the twelve days that the royalist army had been there, and the rivers further complicated his plans.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 004.jpg
A great deal of the area of the battle is now obscured by subsequent building, as the OS map above shows, but a good view can still be gained from the Cathedral tower, from where Charles Stuart surveyed the battle. A visit to Powick Church is also worthwhile, for marks of musket balls can still be seen on its tower.

The subsequent battle took place in the fields north of Powick Bridge, in the bottom left corner of the map above. The Severn runs north-south through Worcester, but to the south of the city it is joined by the Teme. Cromwell planned to force a crossing of the Teme and to launch an attack on the city from the west, while a force under his own command attacked from the east. But Charles had stationed his army on the north bank of the Teme and had destroyed all the nearby bridges on both the Teme and the Severn. This put him at the apex of a triangle and, presumably, he was expecting to inflict heavy casualties on the parliamentarians who tried to cross the river to get at him. The Severn was swift-flowing, deep and forty yards across, and the Teme, although only ten feet wide, was also ten feet deep and fast-flowing. But Cromwell adapted his plan to accommodate a three-pronged attack. He spent several days collecting boats from up and down the river and, of course, they were there in abundance. Several of the largest of these were towed upstream to a point where they could be made into bridging pontoons. One of these was to be used to cross the Teme with eleven thousand men, the other to bridge the Severn below its junction with the Teme itself just to the west, thus maintaining communication between the two parliamentary forces. Their preparation took time, because the they needed to be piloted into place and then spanned with planks at just the right moment for the cavalry to ride across them. The third objective was Fort Royal, outside the east wall of the city, which formed the rear headquarters of the royalist position.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 009.jpg
Worcester, 1651, with Powick Bridge (bottom left) showing Fleetwood’s attack, and Red Hill (middle right), where Charles made his cavalry charge.

On 3 September, Charles Fleetwood led the southern Parliamentarian force, with some difficulty, across the Teme by the first pontoon and by the ford near the destroyed Powick Bridge. His men met considerable resistance from a royalist rearguard on the south bank where it fought a strong delaying action around Powick Church. The Lord General himself led his men across the bridge of boats over the Severn in the initial attack, timed to coincide with that of Fleetwood’s brigade over the Teme, upon the Scots’ position between the two rivers, and he was in the thick of the fighting. Miraculously, both ‘boatbridges’ seem to have held in place, though some of Fleetwood’s men appear to have swum across or forded higher up. Cromwell brought four regiments of horse and two of foot from the east bank of the Severn to Fleetwood’s support. All the regiments reached the meadows, and there, step by bloody step, they pushed the royalists back to St John’s. The Scots and their English ‘auxiliaries’ fought skilfully, as well as with the courage born of desperation, and Charles himself risked his life time and time again in encouraging them at the heart of the action. Charles seems to have continued to encourage his troops before ascending the cathedral tower to direct operations from that vantage point. Seeing Cromwell’s army in two sections, with no chance of joining up again quickly, and Cromwell himself pre-occupied with this action, Charles led an attack against the parliamentarian deployment on the east bank of the Severn. With every soldier he could collect at short notice, he delivered a tremendous blow on the troops Cromwell had not yet committed to battle, including the Cheshire and Essex militias. He swept all before him and reached the eminence known as Red Hill.

A mezzotint after original painting by Thomas Woodward, from the City of Worcester Museum, published in 1844.

With a less able opponent than Cromwell this counter-attack might have turned the battle, but Cromwell was not prepared to surrender the advantage he had gained in its first phase. Coming back across the bridge he hurled his troops into what he sensed was the key area of the fighting, and three hours of bitter combat followed. But then the royalist cavalry were broken by Cromwell’s regulars who had crossed the Severn first, although these contingents were supposed to come in on the second phase of the the attack. When Charles could no longer rally the Scottish cavalry to keep up their attack, the battle was decided. As darkness fell, the panic raced through the royalist ranks as what was left of the cavalry galloped off. Abandoned to their fate, the royalist infantry had no chance at all; many were taken prisoner, but most were killed before they surrendered. In some parts, however, the struggle went on well into the twilight with men still hacking at each other in the streets of the city. The battle was fully decided by 8 p.m., but the rounding-up of prisoners and the slaughter of fugitives went on until after midnight. By then, Charles had fled the field, but few others who managed to escape were able to reach safety. When they were counted the next day, the dead in and around the city numbered well over two thousand, and somewhere between six and seven thousand prisoners were taken. About three thousand cavalry escaped from the field, but many did not get home, because they had to evade the country folk all the way back to the border. Cromwell put the numbers of all the Commonwealth forces in the battle at under two hundred killed. The battle was a bloody catastrophe for the cavalier-Scottish troops, and a complete, devastating and final victory for the English Roundheads.

Cromwell’s Triumph & Charles’ Travels:

Cromwell returned to an even noisier London than had greeted his victorious Irish campaign. He was given a triumphal on 12 September, and the great cheering crowds that lined the streets testify to the very real popularity of his victory. Describing his conduct amid all the celebrations, Bulstrode Whitelocke wrote in his diary that:

He was affable and humble in his carriage, and in his discourses about the business of Scotland and of Worcester, he would seldom mention any thing of himself, but the gallantry of the officers and soldiers, and gave (as was due) all the glory of the action unto God.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 011-3.jpg

By contrast, Charles’ decisive defeat at Worcester on 3 September finished royalism as a military threat to the Commonwealth. The only royalist troops who got clean away were the king himself, Buckingham and Wilmot. The Scottish prisoners included the second Duke of Hamilton, who died of gangrene within a few days, Leslie and Lauderdale, who languished in prison until the Restoration, and Middleton, who escaped from the Tower. As for Charles’ own escape, the story of it became a legend, and it accreted a wealth of dubious detail, some of it contributed by Charles himself, who never tired of recounting it. Charles embarked on an extraordinary six-week flight from captivity, the bravest thing he would ever do. Disguised as a country yoeman, with his mane of black curls cropped short, his face darkened with nut juice to look more weather-beaten, and wearing a rough leather doublet, Charles outsmarted and outran his pursuers. Relying on a network of royalists in the West Country, many of them Catholics and therefore expert in concealment, Charles hid first in the Saffordshire woods around Boscobel House, the home of the Penderel brothers, to whom he was delivered by the Earl of Derby (before he himself was captured, court-martialled and subequently executed, despite Cromwell’s intervention on his behalf). Then, having failed to cross Severn in an attempt to get to Wales, Charles was first hidden in a hayloft and then walked in the rain back to Boscobel, where he slept exhausted in one of the great oaks in the park, while troopers searched the estate for him.

For royalist legend-makers it was a perfectly emblematic event and one which really happened: the young hope of the future safely cradled in the fatherly embrace of the ancient English tree from which countless English pubs have taken their name. There followed a ride across country disguised as ‘William Jackson’, the manservant of Jane Lane; failure to find a safe passage either from Bristol or Bridport in Dorset, where the quays and the taverns were crawling with Commonwealth soldiers about to be shipped to the Channel Islands; and then abortive wanderings along the south coast before finally finding a reliable ship, the Surprise, at Shoreham in Sussex. Although he was frequently recognised and had the (then) very large sum of a thousand pounds on his head, no-one betrayed him in the time between the battle and his sailing from Shoreham to Fécamp in mid-October. As Simon Schama has suggested, this was ‘astonishing’ considering his willingness to test the limits of his disguise by engaging in reckless banter about the rogue Charles Stuart. His near miraculous survival gave closetted ‘cavaliers’ an alternative narrative to develop in competition with, for them, the depressing record of ‘ironside’ invincibility. Charles’ escape, dependent as it was on so many helping hands, says something important about what Schama calls this very English revolution: that it lacked, perhaps providentially, those elements which made for the survival of republics – terror and paranoia. At the same time, it was becoming all too obvious that the Commonwealth was failing to to develop an independent republican culture to replace the banished monarchy.

Charles escapes with the remains of his army
Cromwell’s soldiers search for him near Boscobel House, Staffordshire. Charles hides in an oak tree, with Richard Penderel.
Disguised as a servant to Jane Lane, he travels to Bristol.
After many adventures, Charles reaches Shoreham, Sussex. A small ship smuggles him away to France.

These four pictures are taken from a contemporary ‘Broadside’ (news-sheet) which followed the adventures of Charles after the battle.

The ‘Settlement’ between England & Scotland:

Soon after he reached France the Duke of Orleans, the French king’s uncle, asked Charles if the rumour was true that he intended to return to Scotland. His response was that he would ‘rather have been hanged first’, and he never set in foot in his northern Kingdom again. His reaction was unkind to the thousands of Scots who had fought and died for him, but it is understandable, given his conflicts with the Kirk Party and the more extreme Presbyterian ministers. In due course, this was a vengeful attitude that would lead to the persecution of the Covenanters after his restoration to the crowns. But in 1651-2, there was soon nowhere in the kingdom to which he could have returned, given Monck’s impressive progress in the absence of Leslie’s army. Although there was still a large area of northern Scotland which was unaccounted for, the obstacles to tapping into the reserves of royalist sentiment in the Highlands were insurmountable. The magnates whom Charles had left in charge had either been captured or were in charge of areas which had no stomach for further fighting, like Gordon in his territory around Aberdeen. When Monck sent Okey with a body of cavalry to secure it, its council soon submitted. Its distinguished provost, Alexander Jaffray was one of Cromwell and Owen’s converts to Independency, and the Highland nobility remained at odds with the Lowland Covenanters. After Worcester, it was difficult to assemble any body or council that could speak as the government of Scotland and then to get such a body to speak with one voice. Of the uncaptured members of the Committee of Estates, Loudoun managed to bring together seven nobles, including Argyll, three lairds and three burgesses at Killin on 10 September, but the Clansmen would not attend or meet with them.

Argyll recognised the hopelessness of the situation and wrote to Monck on 15 October to propose peace negotiations. Huntly signed articles of surrender later in the month, while Monck and his subordinates encouraged the resumption of normal economic life in the Lowlands, including fishing, and most Scots welcomed this relief from the long rigours of war. The harvest had been poor, and the shortages of labour due to continual levies had created extensive shortages of food. The Rump had had no intention of annexing Scotland when it had sent Cromwell in 1650, but by the end of 1651 it had to do something to fill the political divisions created by the military, religious and political divisions there. After its rejoicings over Worcester, it gave a single reading to a bill asserting the right of England to Scotland, but the bill progressed no further. Instead of this, Scotland was to be incorporated int one commonwealth with England. Cromwell was largely resonsible for the change of policy, it is thought, opposing the many in England who favoured declaring a conquest, and making it one nation. A declaration outlining terms for a union of Scotland with England was prepared by the Council of State during early October, laid before parliament on the 23rd, and agreed to after two days’ debate, with minor amendments. It promised, in particular, that the Scots should have the same liberty of conscience in religion as the English had.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 003.jpg

The last royalist outposts in the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands surrendered before the end of the year. Scotland’s resistance had finally been broken by the beginning of 1652. The factional politics – Highland Catholics, Stuart loyalists, Covenanters and Republicans – left Scotland prey, eventually, to the Cromwellian forces. For the first time in their history, all of the British Isles were under the control of a single government. The process of attrition which had begun at Marston Moor and Naseby and continued at Preston and Dunbar was over. Stuart military power in Britain had been unequivocally crushed and nine years of outright, bloody civil war were finally at an end. In January 1652, the Rump dispatched eight commissioners to persuade the Scottish people and their parliament of the benefits of a union and to win their unforced assent to it. As might be expected, this faced a great deal of opposition, not only from those who prized Scottish independence, but also from remaining royalists and the clergy, who were against religious toleration. The English parliament could not ignore that a large part of the Scottish nation had recently been at war with them, and that resistance was still not over, but the process they set in motion was genuinely aimed at a real reconciliation between the two nations. However, F.D. Dow (1979) wrote that what in theory was to be a political merger … was in fact a take-over bid by the English, and that the period from January 1652 to April 1653 was one of the unremitting and successful efforts by the English to subordinate the Scots to their will. If this can be taken to be true, how far they ultimately succeeded can only be judged by the shape that the union eventually took.

Sources:

Philip Warner (1973), Famous Battles of the Midlands. London: Fontana/ Collins.

David Smurthwaite (1984), The Ordnance Survey Complete Guide to the Battlefields of Britain. Exeter: Webb & Bower.

Simon Schama (2001), The Story of Britain: The British Wars, 1603-1776. London: BBC Worldwide.

Austin Woolrych (2004), Britain in Revolution, 1625-1660. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

G. Huehns (ed.) (1955), Clarendon: Selections from ‘The History of the Rebellion and Civil Wars’. London: Oxford University Press.

The Three Kingdoms & The Third Civil War: Campaigns in Ireland; Drogheda & Wexford to Tipperary, 1649-1652.

The Stuart Court at the Hague, 1649-51:

The Trial and Execution of Charles I may have shocked the whole of Europe at first, but Edward Hyde, First Earl of Clarendon, wrote after the execution that…

The kings and princes of Christendom had their eyes fixed upon this woeful bloody spectacle; how they looked upon that issue of blood, at which their own seemed to be so prodigally poured out; with what consternation their hearts laboured to see the impious hands of the lowest and basest subjects bathing in the bowels and reeking blood of their sovereign; a brother king, the anointed of the Lord, dismembered as a malefactor … Alas! there was not a murmur amongst any of them at it; but, as if they had been all called upon in the language of the prophet Isaiah, … they made haste and and sent over, that they might get shares in the spoils of a murdered monarch.

Clarendon claimed that Cardinal Mazarin, the chief minister of the French crown, had long adored the conduct of Cromwell, and sought his friendship by a lower and viler application was suitable to the purple of a cardinal … admitted as a merchant to traffic in the purchase of the rich goods and jewels of the rifled crown. The King of Spain had, from the beginning of ‘the rebellion’, kept his court ambassador still residing in London, where the ambassador had had many audiences with parliament. Christina, Queen of Sweden, purchased the choice of all the King’s medals and jewels, and some valuable pictures. She received Cromwell’s ambassador with great joy and pomp, and made an alliance with him. The Archduke Leopold, governor of Flanders, disbursed a great sum of money for many of the best pictures in the monarch’s palaces, which were brought to Brussels, and from there taken into Germany. In this way, the neighbouring rulers assisted Cromwell to amass great sums of money, enabling him to prosecute and finish his wicked victory over what yet remained unconquered, and to extinguish monarchy. None of this wealth found its way to the exiled Stuart family, who now found themselves in the greatest necessities whichever a king was subjected to, despite the pretext and pretences that they were taking care of the royal treasures for their rightful owner. Clarendon claims that none of these ‘unlawful purchases’ were ever restored to Charles II, even following his own restoration.

Throughout 1649, Charles remained in the Hague. When he heard the horrifying news of his father’s death, he was at the court of his brother-in-law, William II of Orange at Breda. Though he had been kept informed of the desperate state his father was in, he was surprised by ‘the barbarous stroke’. The news was also received by all the common people of the Netherlands, according to Clarendon, with ‘consternation’ and the ‘States’ presented themselves to Charles, ‘to console with him’. The whole clergy also gave a lament and detestation of the actors, as unworthy of the name of Christians. But the powerful regent class of Holland and Zealand, who dominated the States-General, were dead set against involving the United Provinces in any further warfare. It was only months since the Peace of Westphalia had formally brought to an end the exhausting struggle that we call the Thirty Years’ War; their own war of independence had lasted with one short break for eighty years. Despite sinking under the burden of his grief, Charles summoned the members of his father’s council who were in exile with him to be sworn into his own privy council, before receiving a letter from the queen mother which advised him that he could not do better, than to repair into France as soon as was possible, and in the meantime, desired him not to swear any persons to be of his council, until she could speak with him. She may have felt that his councillors may prove unsympathetic to her following her husband’s death, or that she herself wanted to recommend those who would advise her son in these new, unfortunate circumstances.

Charles himself was reluctant to follow his mother’s advice to move to France, where he felt he had not been treated with courtesy to date, and was content to continue living with the prince of Orange, who provided him with everything he needed during his period of mourning. But he had no other means of support for his family, so that it was obvious that they would not be able to stay in the Hague for long. The exiled court hesitated as to what to do next, as the new king considered joining the Catholic rebels in Ireland but was also receiving invitations from the Scottish Presbyterians and the Marquess of Montrose. For Charles the great question was whether he should look first to the Irish or the Scots to help him back to his English throne. The Scots had been prompt to proclaim him King of Great Britain, but they made the actual exercise of his regal powers conditional on his giving satisfaction regarding religion and taking the oath of the Solemn League and Covenant. Ormond and his allies in Ireland had no such pre-conditions to impose.

James Butler, Earl of Ormond, by Van Egmont.

The constitutional royalists typified by Hyde and Hopton, however, were unhappy about entrusting his cause and theirs to the Covenanters, who had first risen in arms against Charles I, and had fought against him all through the first Civil War. As Anglicans, they also deplored the Scots’ requirement that the king should take the Covenant himself and enforce it on the English and Welsh people. They saw in the loyal protestant Ormond an ally after their own hearts, and they were ready not only to accept the concessions that he had made to Irish catholics but to extend at least some of them to the English ones in return for their active support. They would rather the king did not rely on any foreign military aid if he could avoid it, but if it should prove necessary they would prefer that it came from Spain rather than France, for they thoroughly distrusted the ‘Louvre’ party who attended the queen mother. The third group of royalists, ‘the swordsmen’, consisted mainly of Prince Rupert and the cavaliers who attached themselves to him. They were more adventurist, and tended to look in whatever direction seemed to offer most in the way of military advantage and their own profit.

Above: James Graham, Marquess of Montrose

Charles himself was eager to go to Ireland, and Montrose and several of the Scottish royalists advised him to do so. He remained at Breda until June, despite his mother’s urgent pleas that he should join her in St Germain. The Scottish parliament sent commissioners to treat with him there in March, hoping to negotiate terms to which he would commit himself in return for Scotland’s armed support, but they received little satisfaction, and went home empty-handed in June. His purpose was to keep the option open in case the Irish failed him, but the commissioners could not get him to dismiss Montrose, and he told them he was not prepared to impose their Covenant on England, Wales and Ireland without consulting their respective parliaments. Charles had been proclaimed king in several places in England, as well as in Ireland and Scotland, and if he could launch an invasion of Wales and England from southern Ireland, there seemed to be a good chance that the west country would come to his aid; its residual loyalty had not been put under the same pressures as had those of northern England in the Preston campaign the year before. There was considerable disaffection in London, where the Lord Mayor had been sent to the Tower for refusing to proclaim the abolition of the monarchy, and the Rump had had to resort to blatantly coercive methods to bring the City government to obedience. Relations between parliament and the army were less than cordial, given the soldiery’s widespread reluctance to fight in Ireland.

Meanwhile, on the continent, all the powers that counted had given the new king assurances of their goodwill, and none had recognised the Commonwealth; Spain was the first to do so, towards the end of 1650. In the Hague, Charles’ Chancellor did not think much of either the Scottish or Irish plan, so the courtiers had decided on a diplomatic mission to Madrid in 1650, but by 1651, this had proved a failure, though there were some redeeming moments for the English ambassadors. None of the other powers were prepared to fight for Charles, but if he could recover his kingdoms without depending on foreign arms, he would stand an even better chance of ‘enjoying his own again’ on a more permanent basis, rather than simply starting another civil war which might well result in defeat and widespread unpopularity.

The Rump, the Council of State and Cromwell:

The Rump was tentative in its moves towards a long-term settlement, but it showed a firm resolve against its enemies in arms. Soon after it was established, the Council of State had started to make serious plans for the reconquest of Ireland, proposing to send eight thousand foot, three thousand horse and twelve hundred dragoons to join the forces already there, and to maintain an army of 32,000 in England against any threat from Scotland or from insurrectionaries at home. On 15 March, Cromwell was named as commander-in-chief in Ireland, but it took him two weeks before he was ready to accept. On 23rd he made a long speech to his fellow-officers, who were urging him to accept the appointment, in which he declared:

I had had no serious thoughts on the business… (Yet) I think there is more cause of danger from disunion amongst ourselves than by anything from our enemies.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-5.jpg
Sir Thomas Fairfax

With the army clearly in a state of some considerable disunity, and with Fairfax increasingly out of his depth in the post-regicide political waters, he probably felt his presence was needed in parliament and the council, at least for a time. There were still powerful men among the Rumpers who were no friends of the army, who would be much happier to take decisions with Cromwell and Ireton a long way away. He probably also calculated that by delaying his acceptance he could exact firm assurances that forces would be constantly supplied, kept up to strength and regularly paid. When he did finally make his decision, there must have been many soldiers who felt their objections to service in Ireland to be mitigated by the knowledge that Cromwell was going to lead them. The choice of the regiments by lot did not prevent the mutinies developing, but it did remove any suspicion that the regiments would be chosen according to the political bias of the powerful men in parliament. Yet Cromwell also accepted the command as the servant rather than the master of the ‘Keepers of the Nation’s Liberties’, as the Rump now styled itself. Even as ‘Lord-Lieutenant’ Cromwell was still, in theory at least, subordinate to the commander-in-chief of the Commonwealth’s armies, Fairfax, until the latter resigned his commission on the eve of the Scottish War in 1650. All the issues of titles and offices which seemed to occupy many of his contemporaries, were for Cromwell beside the point. He told the Council of State:

I would not have the army now so much look at considerations that are personal, whether or no we shall go if such a Commander or such a Commander go and make that any part of our measure or foundation: but let us go if God go.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 004-2.jpg

He was clear in his own mind that, unless Ireland was subjugated, it would always remain the springboard for an invasion of Britain: perhaps in a pincer movement, with the other thrust coming from Scotland, where Charles II was king. So while the late summer and autumn of 1649 might have seemed like a time to sit back and settle the Commonwealth, for Cromwell there was still very much a wartime emergency. In addition to whatever prejudices he may have shared with his fellow English protestants towards Irish catholics, he was also fighting a war, as far as he was concerned, on behalf of a ‘Commonwealth’ and parliament which was the successor to the monarch of three kingdoms. Although both Scotland and Ireland had their own forms of government, they had been used in the past, and in the recent civil wars, to launch invasions of England and Wales. Ireland in particular was seen as the ‘back door’ to England throughout Tudor times. Before the end of May, the early signs of promise for the exiled king’s cause were fading. Those of his allies in England showed no signs of backing up their gestures with any serious plans for a rising, should he return, and after Thomas Scot was put in charge of intelligence on 1 July, the Commonwealth government was kept well informed of any royalist conspiracies. Few were reported, and after the defeat of the mutineers, the army was fully restored to discipline and good order and Cromwell was preparing to lead a now reliable force to Ireland.

What Cromwell does seem to have decided, both as Lieutenant-General and as a leading member of the Council of State, was that Ireland must be suppressed as swiftly, decisively and cheaply as possible. There were three reasons for this: first of all, the international situation, including the possibility of foreign intervention via Ireland to restore the monarchy; this demanded that the back door be swiftly slammed and bolted. Charles II arrived at Jersey in September en route for Ireland a few days after the massacre at Drogheda. He did not complete the journey, but remained there throughout the winter, with the Rump becoming increasingly anxious from mid-January, that the Scots were about to take up arms again. Secondly, the internal divisions in England called for quick successes without the imposition of heavy burdens on the taxpayer. The Irish expeditionary force and the navy were financed through the sale of church lands and rents from Crown lands, and vast sums had also been raised on the security of Irish lands, as wholesale confiscations had been envisaged from the from the start of the rebellion and wars in Ireland. Repayment at the expense of Irish landed proprietors did much to consolidate the support of moneyed men for the republican régime. Ireland was in every sense the first British colony. Thirdly, it is highly probable that many of those MPs who pressed the Irish command on an unwilling Cromwell did so in the hope of cutting him down to size, as the Earl of Essex had been under Elizabeth I, half a century earlier. If he had got bogged down in a long-drawn-out campaign in Ireland, control of the government in Westminster may well have passed to men hostile to him and Ireton. These time-related factors do not excuse his conduct of the campaign, but they do help to explain his ruthless determination to break Irish royalist resistance swiftly, finally and as cheaply as possible.

Cromwell accepted the command only on condition that it was ‘sufficiently provided’ for, and as a member of the parliamentary committee which persuaded the City of London to lend a hundred and twenty thousand pounds on the security of the sale of rents from Crown lands. As commander, he also knew that ‘out of sight means out of mind’. On 25 June, a newspaper reported a letter from Sir Charles Coote to Cromwell, complaining that his six regiments in Ireland had received only eight months pay in eight years. Within four days, the Commons had voted four hundred thosand pounds to provide for the army, and authorised a further loan of a hundred and fifty thousand. Cromwell lingered at Bristol from mid-July to mid-August when the hundred thousand pounds cash promised him actually arrived: he had assured his troops that they would not embark until it was at hand.

The Continuing ‘Rebellion’ in Ireland, 1647-49:

The situation in Ireland had continued to decline, though more slowly, but shortly before Cromwell landed in August, it took a sharp turn for the worse. After the serious defeats of the king’s supporters at Dungan’s Hill and Knockanauss, there was a fatal rift in the Confederation between the ‘Old English’ who adhered to Inchiquin and the clerical party which continued to take its orders from the papal nuncio, Rinuccini. This led to a hiatus in the fighting while the second civil war was being fought in northern England. The only clash of arms in Ireland itself was between the opposed factions of the Confederation. The royalist led by Inchiquin were allied to the moderate, pro-Ormond party and supported by what was left of the army of Leinster, which had been routed at Dungan’s Hill. Ranged against them were O’Neill’s army of Ulster. While Hamilton’s Scots were being defeated along the road from Preston, Inchiquin and most of the king’s other supporters were defending Leinster and Connaught against O’Neill. Thereafter, Charles I renewed his commission to Ormond and sent him back to Ireland late in September 1648, with instructions to reunite the Confederation. Ormond brought with him four thousand foot and one thousand horse, which were well received by Inchiquin, with whom he soon reached agreement. Riniccini’s supporters boycotted the recalled General Assembly of the Confederation, which made it easier for the other factions to come together, and the resultant articles of peace were published just as the king’s trial opened. Rinuccini did his best to frustrate these, since he no longer believed in a royalist victory and the ability of a British king to give catholics equal status in Ireland. Finding himself with no useful role in Ireland, having lost O’Neill’s support over his change in attitude to the Stuart cause, he sailed for Italy late in February, never to return.

A striking number of the main participants in the Irish wars had changed their allegiance at one time or another, more often on principle than through self-interest. Colonel Michael Jones, commander of the parliament’s forces and victor of Dungan’s Hill, had left his studies at Lincoln’s Inn at the start of first civil war to join the king’s army in Ireland. His Welsh father was Bishop of Killaloe and his brother was the Bishop of Clogher; but he himself was a strong protestant, with puritan leanings, and in 1643, outraged by the terms Ormond agreed with the king, he and his men went over to the side of parliament. He fought with distinction with its forces in Cheshire before being made governor of Dublin and commander in Leinster in 1647, and was soon to fight one of the crucial actions of the whole war in Ireland. Another of those who had changed their allegiance was General George Monck, who, when he had assumed his command of the parliamentarian forces in Ireland took a ‘negative oath’, not to assist the king, as well as the Solemn League and Covenant, and thenceforth remained unswervingly loyal to the parliamentarian cause until the Commonwealth collapsed. The commander appointed by the Scottish parliament over the Scottish forces in Ulster, Colonel Robert Munro, had sided with Hamilton and the Engagers and declared for the king, whereupon General Monck had him seized and shipped to England as a prisoner.

After the regicide, many of the Scottish officers took their lead from Edinburgh by refusing to serve under parliament’s banners. They had to be cashiered, and most of their men transferred their allegiance to Inchiquin. By the spring of 1649, the Confederation had also lost part of its army due to O’Neill’s march on Kilkenny which had made him the enemy of both Ormond and Inchiquin. His army of Ulster Irish was so short of ammunition that and provisions that it was beginning to disintegrate, and he had already tried to enter into negotiations with Michael Jones without success, and had sent an envoy to London to propose a deal whereby the Ulster Irish would have their estates restored and their religious freedoms assured, while he himself would be given a command in Fairfax’s army. At the same time, however, he was also exploring a rapprochement with Ormond. Monck himself had been starved of money and supplies, and controlled only patches of territory in Ulster, unable to defend Drogheda, which fell to Inchiquin in late June. In May, Monck had concluded a three months’ cessation of arms with O’Neill, each man giving undertakings which turned out to be insincere: Monck was buying time, preventing O’Neill from coming to terms with Ormond, which he eventually did, but only after the cessation expired.

The third parliamentary commander already in Ireland, Coote, was besieged in Londonderry by the Scottish royalists, and struck a similar deal with O’Neill, which saved the town from falling. Monck’s truce with O’Neill provided him with a defence against Inchiquin, who advanced in strength from Drogheda to Dundalk. Monck was forced to surrender to him, and most of his men promptly joined Inchiquin’s army. The terms of the surrender allowed him and other officers to return to Britain, and at Milford Haven on 4 August he had his first meeting with Cromwell, who was about to sail with his expeditionary force. Cromwell ordered him to London to explain to the Council of State his cessation with O’Neill and his failure to report it to his commander-in-chief for two and a half weeks. Monck was reprimanded at the bar of the House for entering into it, but with a gracious assurance that since he had believed it necessary to preserve parliament’s interest in Ireland he would not be required to return there. He loyally covered up the fact that Cromwell and the Council of State had known about the cessation, a loyalty which Cromwell did not forget later. As late as October 1649, in a letter to Parliament, Cromwell was stressing that the co-operation between O’Neill and Ormond should convince them that it is high time to take off their jealousy from those to whom they ought to exercise more charity. (Here, he was obviously referring to Monck.) The episode was to cement a mutual soldiers’ trust between Monck and Cromwell, in contrast with Monck’s well-grounded and ongoing mistrust towards the Rump, which Cromwell was already beginning to share.

By August the English expeditionary force was already ready to sail to Ireland, with Cromwell in command. The brutality of the reconquest of Ireland is not, in retrospect at least, one of the pleasanter aspects of his military career, and his conduct at Drogheda and Wexford cannot be whitewashed. But both the campaign itself and its aftermath must be brought into historical focus and seen in the perspective of Cromwell himself and his contemporaries, rather than through the distorted lense of posterity. Historians and biographers have attempted to do this over the last five decades, during which the popular mythology surrounding these events has remained a powerful propaganda tool. In the first place, though Cromwell must bear the responsibility for the conduct of the campaign, the policy was not his alone. It was that of the Rump parliament, and one that would prove popular with other factions of the English ruling class. Both parties in the Long Parliament from 1641-42 had supported the view that the native Catholic Irish should be subordinated to English rule: the dispute between them was only over command of the army which was to subdue them. Although Cromwell’s troops in Ireland must have contained many soldiers who had supported the Levellers just a few months before their arrival, they showed no disposition to fraternise with the native Irish.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007-2.jpg
Above: Map of Ireland in 1641, showing percentages of land owned by Catholics, by county.

To match the ex-royalists (including Jones) who were now fighting for the Commonwealth, Ormond’s chief lieutenant was the ex-parliamentarian Inchiquin, much strengthened by the Covenanting Scots who had previously fought for parliament under Munro. Late in May, Inchiquin reckoned that his total forces at nearly thirteen thousand, though for want of money to pay them all, he was struggling to hold them together. Against him, Michael Jones in Dublin was greatly outnumbered, and he too had dissatisfaction among his ranks. But in July the Council of State reinforced him with a little over two thousand men, which enabled him to hold firm until Cromwell, delayed by the mutinies, was ready to sail on 13 August. On 2 August, ten days before the expeditionary force sailed, Michael Jones won a crushing victory over Ormond’s forces at Rathmines, just south of Dublin. Misled by Cromwell’s choice of Milford Haven as his port of embarkation into thinking that the landing would be made in Munster, Ormond sent Inchiquin to counter it, while leading his own forces in an attempt to capture Dublin. With his refreshed ranks, Jones took the initiative and advanced against Ormond’s quarters at Rathmines, taking Ormond’s small army by surprise. In a skilfully conceived and executed attack, Jones broke Ormond’s forces, who fled. Ormond himself was almost captured, and he lost all his guns, wagons and treasure, amounting to four thousand pounds in gold. The armistice with O’Neill had done its job and could now be repudiated with impunity. A week later, Cromwell disermbarked his army near Dublin, unopposed.

Cromwell’s Expeditionary Campaign, Drogheda & Wexford:

Jones’ victory at Rathmines made the expeditionary forces task immensely easier, as Cromwell gratefully acknowledged. But there was some hard campaigning ahead, consisting of sieges rather than battles, and for these Cromwell had the artillery that his predecessors had lacked. His most troublesome enemies in the coming months were to be the weather and the Irish roads, together with the illnesses that afflicted armies in damp and boggy conditions. Among the many who were carried off by disease before the year was out were Michael Jones, who succumbed to fever on 6 December, and O’Neill, who died exactly a month earlier. O’Neill had made his peace with Ormond after Rathmines and agreed to serve as his commander in Ulster, but his broken health prevented him from bringing the swift military aid that was needed by the Confederation. Cromwell’s strategy was to reduce all the important towns on the eastern and southern shores before he carried his campaign into the hinterland. Cromwell made no secret of his contempt for the native Irish population, but he made it clear that he had no quarrel with its unarmed civilians. In fact, and in keeping with his practice in past campaigns in England, Cromwell went out of his way, publicly, to threaten retribution against any of his troops found assaulting the unarmed and unresisting population. His first action was to forbid any form of looting or pillage in a published declaration which also banned free quarter and promised that farmers who brought provisions to his forces would be paid in cash at the market rate. This order was quite new in Irish warfare, and could not have been enforced with an unpaid army. He was unable to go on paying his way for long after the turn of the year, but his initial policy won him considerable support in Leinster and Munster, especially when he had two of his men hanged expressly for violating the prohibition.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007-2.jpg
Above: The English Parliamentary Campaign in Ireland, 1649-52, showing major battles and sieges & The settlement of Ireland, 1652-57.
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007.jpg

The policy also had an immediate effect on Ormond’s protestant troops, many of whom deserted to the Parliamentarian army. Ormond wrote to Charles II that he feared Cromwell’s money more than his face. Before leaving England, Cromwell had secured the cooperation of Lord Broghill, son of the Earl of Cork and a former royalist, whose local influence brought many of the Irish protestant settlers over to the parliamentarian side. A fortnight after disembarking, Cromwell set out against Drogheda, where Ormond had chosen to take his stand, except that veteran English royalist, Sir Arthur Aston, was in command there, while Ormond remained at Tecroghan, thirty miles away. His justification for this distancing was that the morale of these troops was too low for him to trust them in the line of fire. Cromwell took six days to position his artillery before he summoned Drogheda to surrender on 10 September. In an attempt to obtain Aston’s peaceful surrender on that morning, Cromwell delivered a chilling ultimatum to him:

Sir, having brought the army belonging to the parliament of England before this place, to reduce it to obedience, to the end the effusion of blood may be prevented, I thought to summons you to deliver the same into my hands to their use. If this be refused you will have no cause to blame me. I expect your answer and rest, your servant, O. Cromwell.

In his summons, Cromwell warned the town’s defenders of the consequences of prolonging a hopeless resistance. Aston was outnumbered by nearly four to one, short of powder, and with Ormond ignoring his appeals for help, he nevertheless refused the summons contemptuously. The experience of the long-drawn-out siege of 1641-42 and the imposing walls of Drogheda made him believe that the town could hold out against the first shock of Cromwell’s assault, at least long enough for him to be relieved by Ormond’s troops. As it turned out, he was sadly deluded on both counts. By late afternoon the next day, 11 September, within a few hours of opening fire, the parliamentarian guns had breached the walls in two places, and Cromwell was able to send three foot regiments to storm the town. They came up against well prepared and stoutly defended entrenchments within the walls, and it took the parliamentarian infantry far longer to penetrate the breaches, from which they were ferociously beaten back by the royalist soldiery with some loss. Among the defenders was Edmund Verney, Ralph’s younger brother. He wrote of how the gaps were choked with wounded and dying. Accounts differ as to whether one assault or two were repulsed, but Cromwell and Colonel Hewson led a finally successful one on foot. It made enough ground to open a gate to the cavalry, but even then Aston and his men held out on the steep heights of Mill Mount from inside a flimsy stockade, while others retreated to the tower and steeple of the Protestant Church of St Peter.

Colonel John Hewson, regimental commander in the parliamentarian campaign in Ireland member of the Council of State.

What happened next was clearly an obscenity, yet Cromwell’s own account was, and still is, startlingly unapologetic and without any kind of euphamism. Infuriated by this ongoing resistance and, as he wrote himself, being in the heat of action, I forbade them to spare any that were in arms in the town, and, I think, that night they put to the sword about two thousand men. Out of approximately 3,100 soldiers there at least 2,800 were slain, most of them not in as they were frantically fighting the parliamentarian troops, but after they had stopped fighting and had either surrendered or disarmed. The refusal to give quarter to unresisting, defeated men was a calculated slaughter. At St Peter’s Church, Cromwell and Hewson had their soldiers burn the pews beneath the tower to smoke out the defenders who had taken refuge there, with the result that many of them fell to their deaths in flames along with the bells and masonry which came crashing down. The fanatical Baptist Daniel Axtell, Hewson’s Lieutenant-Colonel, was particularly active in this. Friars and priests were also killed, but there was no great slaughter of civilians, except for those who had taken up arms in support of the Irish soldiery. The total death toll was in excess of three thousand, compared with a hundred and fifty killed on the parliamentarian side. The murders were so inhuman that many among the lower ranking officers disobeyed their orders and some even went out of their way to to save their enemies. Virtually the whole garrison, and all the priests that were captured, were slaughtered. While all this was occurring, Ormond’s troops were nowhere in sight, though he had sent a small number of reinforcements to the garrison the day before.

Lieutent-Colonel Daniel Axtell.

Whatever degree of sincerity we may attach to Cromwell’s hint of compunction in his reports and letters to parliament, which I will discuss later, he made no bones about his intention to perpetrate a slaughter so ghastly that that it would dissuade other strongholds from making Aston’s mistake in refusing peaceful capitulation. Ormond himself admitted that Drogheda’s fate did indeed strike terror into the Irish countryside, and many of his surviving men deserted. When Cromwell moved against Wexford, his next major objective, its corporation and citizens were much divided as to whether to offer any resistance. Wexford was the home and base of many privateers, and much of its wealth derived from their plunder of English shipping: It had long been a thorn in the side of English traders. It was also a strongly catholic town and had been very much on the side of Rinuccini’s faction in the Confederacy. It had no garrison when Drogheda fell. Its newly-appointed governor, David Synnott, had been commissioned by Ormond to defend southern Ireland. With difficulty, Synnott persuaded the citizens of Wexford to resist Cromwell, on condition that Ormond furnished a competent garrison of exclusively catholic troops. Ormond agreed, so the city was by no means undefended when Cromwell summoned it on 2 October. Again, the town refused to surrender: Synnott made a show of negotiating terms, but Cromwell became exasperated when when he discovered that his real purpose was to spin out time while the Earl of Castlehaven brought in fifteen hundred reinforcements. Synnott’s procrastinations, under cover of which he sent an appeal to Ormond for further relief, caused Cromwell to break off negotiations, and on the 11th, exactly a month after they had done so at Drogheda, his siege guns opened a heavy bombardment.

Thereupon Synnott and the city magistrates proposed articles to surrender, but the terms they offered were so absurdly favourable to themselves that Cromwell justifiably described them as impudent. In return he offered quarter for their lives to the officers and soldiers, with leave to the latter to go home if they pledged themselves no more to fight against the English parliament. Civilian property would be respected, and the town spared from plunder. These were very generous terms in the circumstances, but they never reached Synnott, for just as they were being prepared, the commander of Wexford Castle surrendered it to the besiegers on his own initiative. After an eight days’ siege it was sacked. Cromwell’s guns had already breached the castle walls and the troops who took over the castle promptly turned its guns on the defenders manning the adjacent city walls, who quickly abandoned them. The besiegers then stormed them, and the garrison was soon in complete disarray. The parliamentarian troops were killing as many of the other side as they possibly could. Once again it’s no mitigation of the horror to realise that civilians were not among those slaughtered at Wexford. The most tragic and numerous civilian deaths occurred when there was a panicky rush for the boats moored at the quayside, as some of them tried to get over the estuary. In their haste they overloaded them, and at least one of them sank, causing nearly three hundred of them to drown. Other defending troops tried to make a stand in the marketplace, together with some armed citizens, where they were slaughtered indiscriminately. Priests and friars were again killed without mercy, though they may, understandably, have been armed. The whole action was over in an hour with a total of two thousand deaths, including those who drowned.

Since the inhabitants were either dead or fled, Cromwell reported, the town was available for English colonists to settle. The Rev. Hugh Peter wrote that, It is a fine spot for some godly congregation, where house and land wait for inhabitants and occupiers. Cromwell had assured parliament that he wished to avoid another bloodbath like that at Drogheda, and he himself was not in Wexford to give the orders when the firing began. It is questionable whether he was ever in a position to countermand the slaughter of the defenders, and whether he made any attempt to do so. In his report to parliament there are more intimations of compunction, yet it suggests that he saw Wexford’s agony, although unplanned by him, as a divine judgement:

And indeed it hath not without cause been deeply set upon our hearts, that we intending better to this place than so great a ruin, … yet God would not have it so; but, by an unexpected providence, in his righteous justice, brought a just judgement upon them, causing them to become a prey to the soldier, who in their piracies had made preys of so many families, and made with their blood to answer the cruelties which they had exercised upon the lives of divers poor protestants. … I could have wished for their own good, and the good of the garrison, they (the soldiers) had been more moderate.

This is absolutely authentic Cromwell, though it is not the testimony of a genocidal lunatic, but rather, as Schama has put it, the unwitting confession of a pig-headed, narrow-minded, Protestant bigot. At New Ross, the fate of Drogheda did indeed guarantee a bloodless surrender when Cromwell came before the walled town on 17 October, and as soon as he opened his bombardment its governor Sir Lucas Taaffe sued for terms of surrender. Many of the defending troops were English, and at least five hundred of them promptly enlisted under Cromwell. His own men were short of pay, however, and he felt obliged to issue a proclamation threatening severe punishment against any caught seizing plough horses and seed corn for ransom. Good discipline and good politics went together here, because the people of Leinster and Munster would rather support the parliamentarian forces than the remnants of the Confederation. Cork, which had many citizens of English origin, went over without bloodshed, and a succession of Munster towns also declared for the Commonwealth. Inchiquin’s army was in a state of dissolution by the time the campaigning season ended, and Rupert’s little fleet, which had been blockaded in Kinsale, was fortunate to get away to make for Lisbon, when a storm forced Robert Blake’s ships out to sea.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 016-1.jpg

The Second Stage of the War, 1649-50 – Waterford, Kilkenny & Clonmel:

By the end of October, Cromwell’s losses due to military action, sickness and the need to provide sentries for the captured garrisons had reduced his field army from fifteen to five thousand. Having reached the point from which so many British armies in Ireland had failed to recover, he was now relying on what Ormond referred to as the terror that those successes … had struck into the hearts of this people. It has been argued that it was only the terror that Cromwell’s name now aroused in the Catholic Irish which saved him from the fate of so many of his predecessors. This, together with the attractive power of his success for the protestant settlers, whom Broghill had imported in large numbers. The medical supplies and food which Cromwell had provided, far more plentifully than any previous British commander in Ireland. He continued to hurry, campaigning far later into the winter than normal, again emphasising on 26 October that: We could not satisfy our consciences to keep the field as we do, were it not that we hope to save blood by it … in prosecuting the enemy whiles the fear of God is upon them. When on 14 November he wrote to Parliament for money, clothes, shoes and stockings for his troops, he insisted that the extending your help in this way, at this time, is the most profitable means speedily to make Ireland no burden to England, but a profitable part of its Commonwealth.

The reconquest and colonisation of Ireland was viewed in London as a business operation, but the immediate need to garrison captured towns had drained Cromwell’s effective strength to only three thousand men, who were all too anxious to get into winter quarters. He reported to parliament on 25 November that ‘a considerable part’ of its army was ‘fitter for the hospital than the field.’ But he did not go into winter quarters for another three weeks, still pointing out that the Irish have so much of Ireland still in contribution as ministers to them a livelihood for the war, all the natives, almost to twenty, being friends to them but enemies to you. He argued that money must continue to be applied, the sea must be patrolled to prevent supplies and ammunition coming in from the continent. It was an early form of guerilla warfare, accompanied by frequent savagery, with the bulk of the population siding with the guerillas against the invaders. But Cromwell’s policy was proving successful. By mid-November Waterford was the only port on the east or south coasts still in royalist hands, and it was a prize worth taking, for it was always vying with Limerick to be seen as Ireland’s second city. Cromwell did not expect much resistance when he set out against it, for several inhabitants had let him know he would be welcome. But despite Waterford’s strong English connections, most of its population and all its garrison were staunchly catholic, none more so than its mayor and governor. This time, Ormond sent the defenders the help they needed, and when Michael Jones tried to storm Duncannon, covering the seaward approaches to Waterford, Colonel Edward Wogan threw his men back in serious disarray.

On 2 December, Cromwell abandoned the only siege that he ever undertook unsuccessfully, his troops marching away in the teeming rain. His own troops were not immune to hunger and sickness, which were the prevalent enemies of the winter of 1649-50. Cromwell himself became seriously ill as the attrition rate in his army rose to devastating levels. Even though he had issued draconian prohibitions forbidding his soldiers from wantonly looting from the local population, the orders were unenforceable. In all likelihood, several hundred thousand more died from those kinds of depredations, as well as from the epidemics of plague and dysentric fevers which swept through war-ravaged Ireland, than from the direct assault of parliamentarian soldiers. Yet Cromwell was soon heartened by the news that Dungarvan had surrendered to Broghill in the south and Carrickfergus to Coote in the north. Altogether the achievement of the four months since Rathmines had been impressive. Waterford and its estuary formed the only pocket of resistance along the whole coast from Derry round to Ireland’s southern tip, though the territory firmly under English control did not stretch far inland. Most of Cromwell’s sick soldiers would recover, and reinforcements were on the way. He continued to keep his troops in better discipline than Ormond’s unruly and generally unpaid forces, who made themselves so unpopular that Waterford and Limerick refused them winter quarters.

Meanwhile, the clericalist party that had followed Rinuccini became increasingly concerned over the tendency of the civil population to prefer co-operating with the Commonwealth’s forces rather than support the remnants of the Confederation. His policies of elevating the Church above the King had caused rifts not only between the Old English and the Old Irish but among the bishops themselves. In an attempt to repair the damage, the majority of the Irish catholic bishops met at Clonmacnoise during the first half of December 1649. From there they published a declaration proclaiming themselves united in the defence of their faith and their king, calling for an end to to dissension, and appealing to the people to support Ormond’s and the king’s cause loyally and generously. They warned against trusting Cromwell, who they claimed was planning to extirpate not only the catholic religion but the Irish people themselves, along with all their property. But the new Stuart king, or ‘Young Pretender’ as contemporary pamphlets called him, was still waiting in Jersey: it was not until February 1650 that he abandoned hope of Ireland and returned to the continent. Ormond still had more troops than Cromwell, but he had neither the money nor adequate supplies. Nor could his fortifications stand up against the powerful and mobile New Model artillery. Consequently, he lost influence with the native Irish, and the influence of the Ulstermen and the priesthood grew. More and more protestant settlers transferred their allegiance to the English Parliament, and Cromwell issued a Declaration which sharply distinguished between the Irish Catholics, and the protestant settlers.

Cromwell was greatly angered by the Irish bishops’ propaganda against him, and by virtue of his office as Lord-Lieutenant he published a very long counter-declaration. It has often been quoted to illustrate his bigotry against the Irish, and it does indeed display ignorance of their past and insensitivity towards their hopes for the future. But though he gave his authority to the document, it is unlikely that he himself composed all six thousand words of it, and large parts of it are quite unlike his authentic writings and utterances in style. They are couched in a bully-pulpit style of rhetoric which suggests a clerical hand, perhaps that of his trusted chaplain, John Owen. But the pages which seem most stamped with Cromwell’s own tone and thought are those which address the laity and challenge the bishops’ misrepresentations of the Commonwealth’s intentions towards them. Their gist was that England had no quarrel with the Irish people as such, but only with those in arms against her, and with the clergy who incited and supported them. The declaration hotly denied that the Council of State intended to massacre, banish and destroy the catholic inhabitants of Ireland. That, it said, had been the historic method of the Roman Catholic Church in dealing with those who rejected its authority, but a better might be found:

… to wit, the Word of God, which is able to convert… together with humanity, good life, equal and honest dealing with men of different opinion, which we desire to exercise towards this poor people, if you, by your wicked counsel, make them not incapable to receive it, by putting them into blood. … I shall not willingly take or suffer to be taken away the life of any man not in arms, but by the trial to which the people of this nation are subject by law, for offences against the same. … We come to break the power of a company of lawless rebels, who having cast off the authority of England, live as enemies to human society. … We come… to hold forth and maintain the lustre and glory of English liberty in a nation where we have an undoubted right to do it; – wherein the people of Ireland… may equally participate in all benefits, to use liberty and fortune equally with Englishmen, if they keep out of arms.

Cromwell’s army spent less than two months in winter quarters. The mild weather meant that most of his men made a good recovery from their various sicknesses, enabling him to take to the field before the end of January. He wrote again to the Speaker for money, since local levies could barely pay the cost of the garrisons. The only places of importance eastward of Connacht and the Shannon that still held out against him were Kilkenny, Clonmel, and Waterford, though a number of smaller strong points had to be reduced before he could tackle these major objectives. Except at Clonmel in County Tipperary, where Cromwell botched an attack, there was not a lot the remaining royalist and Irish armies could do to stop the relentless campaign of subjugation. Kilkenny, the old capital of the Confederation, proved a predictably hard nut to crack, though plague was raging in the city. It was in the heartland of Irish resistance and had a full circuit of medieval walls, an imposing castle and a large garrison, commanded by Ormand’s cousin Sir William Butler. Cromwell was in no hurry to attempt it, and he spent some weeks in reducing other minor strongholds in the vicinity, so as to isolate it.

For all or most of this time he must have been aware that parliament had voted on 8 January to order him to prepare himself to return to England as soon as possible, but he received no official intimation at that time, and he was most reluctant to leave Ireland until its reconquest was absolutely assured. He did not receive the Speaker’s letter formally summoning him home until 22 March, the day on which he appeared before Kilkenny. Together with Colonel Hewson, with forces from Dublin, he threatened the city with with a pincer movement, but Butler rejected his first summons. Two attempts to storm the walls were repulsed with considerable losses to the assailants, but after its gallant defence, Butler finally agreed honourable terms of surrender on the 27th. The townsfolk had to pay two thousand pounds to be spared being pillaged, but that did not save their churches from a good deal of vandalism by the angry protestant soldiers. Meanwhile, the catholic nobles met together in Ulster in March to appoint a commander to succeed O’Neill, their choice falling on the Bishop of Clogher, Heber MacMahon, an astute clerical politician but entirely lacking military experience. This thoroughly alienated Colonel Munro’s Ulster Scottish forces, who had been supporting Charles II since the regicide. Most of them now went over to the English parliament, though some threw in their lot with Ormond.

Cromwell was finally, officially, recalled by the Council of State in April 1650, but before he went he moved against Clonmel, where he received perhaps the worst rebuff of his military career from its governor, Major-General Hugh O’Neill. The latter was a resourceful soldier with a nerve of steel, and he managed to increase his garrison from about 1,300 to over 2,000 during the three weeks that Cromwell spent in forming his siege lines and planting his batteries. During that time his bold sallies inflicted considerable losses on the besiegers and when Cromwell’s heavy guns eventually opened up, the defenders built makeshift defences within the breach, so as to force the attacking troops to traverse a narrow line, ending in a deep ditch. So, when Cromwell sent his men in to storm the town on 16 May they marched into a cleverly set ambush, raked by guns firing chain-shot from behind the ditch and by musket-fire from the upper floors of the surrounding houses. He lost a thousand dead within an hour and another five hundred by the end of the day, by which time he had found that he was pushing his soldiers further than they were prepared to go. Around midnight, the town’s mayor sent to Cromwell to ask for terms, its defenders having run out of ammunition, and the Lord Lieutenant quickly granted favourable ones, but was then furious to find out that O’Neill and his men had slipped out of the town and through his lines under cover of darkness. Nevertheless, he honoured the terms he had offered to the townspeople. O’Neill paid for his deception when he got to Waterford, twenty-eight miles away, and found the city gates shut against him due to plague, so that his remnant of the army of Ulster was forced to break up.

Final Stages, 1650-52 – Ireton’s Death & Ormond’s Demise:

The protestant soldiers were, by mid-May, hurrying to submit, and on 18 May, Cromwell was in a position to return to England, eventually setting sail a week after taking Clonmel’s surrender, having appointed Ireton as his deputy in Ireland. But the country was still far from ‘pacified’: On 21 June, against his officers’ advice, MacMahon committed his army to battle against Coote’s superior forces at Scarrifholis, and it was utterly routed, with about three thousand soldiers killed. This was as bloody a business as Drogheda and Wexford, and a significant number of officers were executed after quarter had been given. MacMahon escaped but was captured next day and eventually hanged on Coote’s orders. Ireton secured the remaining garrisons of Leinster and Munster, including Waterford and Duncannon, during the summer, and only Limerick and the wilds of Connacht still offered resistance. Hugh O’Neill, by now probably Ireland’s best soldier, had persuaded the city to accept him as their commander of its garrison. Ireton was over-confident; he thought he could tackle Limerick and Athlone simultaneously, so he divided his forces. His conduct of his first independent campaign was indecisive, and by the time he concentrated his efforts on Limerick it was too late in the season for a prolonged siege. When he eventually began these operations in June 1651, he counted on starving it out and it was not until October that he at last prepared to storm it. In addition to the suffering imposed on the inhabitants by hunger and plague, his troops were guilty of some unnecessary acts of cruelty. The terms of surrender were harsh, especially towards the principal defenders, several of whom were executed. He finally gave way to his officers over O’Neill, who survived due to their admiration of him as a soldier. But, after five months of campaigning, Ireton himself succumbed to a chill which resulted in a high fever, cutting short his life on 26 November.

By that time, the king’s cause in Ireland was in terminal disarray, not least through the action of Charles II himself. The simmering feud between the catholic prelates and Ormond came to the boil when the bishops met at Jamestown in August 1650 and published a declaration that the catholics of Ireland could no longer accept him as their leader. They released the people from their obedience to him as Lord Lieutenant, called upon him to resign his authority and leave for France, and proposed in effect to take over political authority themselves until a General Assembly could be called and the Confederation revived. They prepared a formal excommunication of all Ormond’s supporters, but held it in suspension pending his reply. Predictably, he told their envoys that he had no intention of leaving and bade the bishops to stop wrangling and support the war. They then published their excommunication of him, not knowing that Charles II had just repudiated them. There was no more for Ormond to do in Ireland and Charles advised him to leave the country. With the grudging agreement of the bishops, he appointed Clarincard as his Lord Deputy, and in December sailed for France, not returning until the Restoration (see the picture below): With him went Inchiquin, Daniel O’Neill and the remaining Old English royalists.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 004-1.jpg

It is difficult to establish an end date to the Irish Rebellion, which had already lasted for nine years by the end of 1650. The ‘reconquest’ had been assured by the time Cromwell sailed home and after Coote took Galway in April 1651 virtually all the garrisons and forts in the country, of which there were over 350, were made subject to the English Commonwealth. In the meantime, Colonel Ludlow, with good reason for trepidation, had become temporary commander-in-chief of the parliamentarian army, remaining in post until 1652, when he was replaced by Charles Fleetwood. Although there was no realistic prospect of the royalist commanders mounting a campaign that could challenge the English forces in battle, they could still muster considerable numbers of soldiers on a local basis, even though an estimated thirty-four thousand Irishmen enlisted in continental armies during the 1650s. The remnants of the Irish armies in Leinster, Munster and Connacht made their formal surrenders between March and June 1652, but that did not spell an end to resistance. It took over thirty-three thousand English troops to man the garrisons in Ulster, Leinster and Munster, and mortality was so high among them that they needed to be constantly reinforced. The peace they were able to maintain was a precarious one. The parliamentarian troops eventually mopped up Irish resistance and under the Act of Settlement of 1652, which forcibly reunited it with England, Ireland went through a huge transfer of land: the gentry and nobility associated with the revolt were stripped of their estates in the east, centre and south, and transplanted to much smaller and less fertile lands in Connacht in the west.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-5.jpg

The English Parliament decided to solve ‘the Irish Problem’ by transplanting the majority of the Gaelic, Catholic Irish to Connacht; the remaining three-quarters of the country was to be granted to parliamentary veterans and other protestant settlers. Large numbers of dispossessed small landowners were living in the bogs and woods and mountains, and subsisting by armed raids. These ‘tories’, as they were called, drove off so many cattle that few were left to their rightful owners, and they made cultivation so hazardous that four-fifths of the fertile land lay fallow and uninhabited. As a result, whereas even in 1650 food prices were lower in Ireland than in England, by the end of 1651 bread was much dearer. Actual starvation became common over large areas, and a serious epidemic of plague followed in 1652. Sir William Petty estimated that the total population fell from a million and a half in 1641 to 850,000 in 1652, with the steepest decline coming towards the end of the period. Though the decline was therefore due only in part to the wars, some of the officers and men taken prisoner on Cromwell’s campaign, at Wexford for example, were treated as chattels of war and were shipped to Barbados, as ‘indentured servants’. The process of depopulation and impoverishment was compounded when garrison commanders responded to ‘tory’ raids and larger-scale military activity by laying waste the territory on which their tormentors subsisted. In the event, however, few veterans took up the land allotted to them, so that the settlement could not be implemented in full. Many of them sold their rights to officers and speculators, leading to the growth of a class of English landlords, and the Irish gentry were permanently crushed. The Catholic Irish remained on the land, but as the small-holding tenants of the Protestant landowners. It was poor consolation that Ireland gained representation in the English Parliament (by the 1653 Instrument of Government) and free trade with England.

Cromwell’s Legacy in Ireland:

However ambiguous the evidence, the legacy that Oliver Cromwell engendered in Ireland in the autumn of 1649 has been remembered as one of the most infamous atrocities in the entirety of the history of the British Isles, an enormity so monstrous that it has hampered the possibilities for Anglo-Irish co-existence ever since. Unquestionably, events of appalling cruelty took place at Drogheda and Wexford. But exactly what happened, and to whom, has been clouded with misunderstanding ever since. Only recently have Irish historians like Tom Reilly, a native of Drogheda, had the courage and scholarly integrity to get the story right. Getting it right, as Simon Schama has pointed out, is not in any sense exoneration or extenuation, but simply explanation. The first fact is that the vast majority were neither Catholic nor Gaelic, nor were any of them unarmed civilians, women or children, as Woolrych attests. This myth was created by Father Murphy’s ‘history’, published in 1883. Indeed, Cromwell had been sent by the Council of State not, primarily, to confront the Catholic confederates but the the royalist, largely Protestant army led by the Duke of Ormond, which had been fighting against, not alongside, the the rebels led by Owen Roe O’Neill. Secondly, Drogheda, from the beginning a staunchly loyalist Old English town, had in fact defied the siege of Phelim O’Neill’s insurgent army in 1641. As we have already noted, when Cromwell arrived in Ireland, there were no fewer than four distinct armies in Ireland: the Gaelic-Irish Confederation, dominated by O’Neill; the royalist army of Ormond; the Scots-Presbyterian army in Ulster under Munro and the parliamentarian forces commanded by the Welsh puritan Michael Jones. Although the negotiated truce between the royalists and the Catholic Irish had simplified the military quadrille, and as much as he hated Roman Catholicism and Spain, he also identified his primary and most formidable antagonist as the royalist army.

In his influential book of Essayes, Lord Montaigne had written nearly seventy years earlier, of:

… the custom we hold in wars, to punish, and that with death, those who wilfully opinionate themselves to defend a place which, by the rules of war, cannot be kept.

By these ‘rules of war’, which were generally accepted for another two hundred years, a garrison that refused a summons after its fortifications were breached was not entitled to quarter, but Cromwell had never hitherto conducted his English campaigns in such a spirit, not even at the siege of Basing House, and certainly not at the other West Country sieges of 1645-46, even when terms were not readily accepted. Nor would he have wanted to be judged by the low standards of the slaughter of civilians at Birmingham and Leicester by Rupert’s men. He had never been guilty of the slaughter of women and children and had consistently tried to spare unarmed civilians from the ravages of war. It was not, however, unprecedented in the appalling history of seventeenth-century warfare on the continent, and especially not in the Irish wars. The Scottish-Presbyterian General Monro had massacred three thousand at Island Magee, and after the battle of Knockanauss in 1647, Col. Michael Jones had had six hundred prisoners killed in cold blood, as well as hanging deserters on his own side, including his own nephew. Coote and Inchiquin had sometimes acted with comparable severity, and brutality towards both armed enemies and hapless civilians was not confined to one side. But Cromwell can hardly have been unaware that many of Drogheda’s defenders were English and protestant, even if he did not know that the town had actually been under siege by the catholic rebels at the time of the 1641 massacre which had occurred before the first civil war in England. That had been widely publicised in the contemporary propaganda print shown below.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 008.jpg

In common with many of his Puritan contemporaries, he believed these pornographic exaggerations of the atrocity propaganda by which most Englishmen got news of the rebellion: there were also graphic illustrations of impaled Presbyterian babies and mutilated patriarches in Ulster and Leinster. Irish catholics were held collectively responsible for this notorious massacre of protestant settlers. These illustrations had clearly made a lasting impression on Cromwell’s psyche, for In 1650, he wrote to justify the atrocities of the previous autumn to the Irish Catholic bishops, claiming that they had put the English to the most unheard-of and most barbarous massacre (without respect of sex and age) that ever the sun beheld. There’s little doubt that his credulous belief in the bestiality of the Irish hardened him against any suffering that might be inflicted on the native population as a result of the campaign. But this did not motivate him to commit genocide. Soldiers, not civilians, were the targets of his fury. Nevertheless, it is hard to stomach his pronouncement, made in his report to the Speaker of the Commons that the outcome of the siege was …

… a righteous judgement of God upon these barbarous wretches, who have imbrued their hands in so much innocent blood. … it will tend to prevent the effusion of blood for the future, which are the satisfactory grounds to such actions, which otherwise cannot but work remorse and regret.

One thing that Cromwell could not or would not understand was the depth of devotion that the majority of the Irish felt towards the catholic religion. He frankly declared that he would not permit the celebration of mass when he had the power to prevent it, but he failed to recognise that this would deprive most of the nation of the central rite of their faith; their devotion to it, he thought, was a superstition maintained by their priests. The general catholic population, he believed, were poor laity … ignorant of the grounds of the catholic religion. Many of them were not so much ‘catholic’ as ‘unconverted’ in his view. In secular matters, however, he does seem to have envisaged a kinder and more decent treatment of the mass of the Irish population than others in the Council of State, in a sincere belief that the bulk of it could be won over by it. He wrote to his friend, John Sadler, that in divers places where we are come, we find the people very greedy after the Word, and flocking to Christian meetings. Yet something further must be added about Cromwell’s attitude towards Irish Catholicism. The tolerance which is so a feature of his religious thought, of course, only applied to protestants, to those with the ‘root of the matter’ in them, to ‘God’s children’. In England, however, he was prepared to tolerate both Episcopalians and Catholics. In fact, Catholics were better off during the Protectorate than they had ever been under the Stuart kings. But in Ireland it was different, as he told the Governor of Ross:

For that which you mention concerning liberty of conscience … I meddle not with any man’s conscience. But if by liberty of conscience you mean a liberty to exercise the mass, I judge it best to use plain dealing, and let you know, where the Parliament of England have power, that will not be allowed of.

To his mind, then, private, individual belief was sacrosanct, but public practice or worship was quite another. In his declaration to the Irish Catholic priesthood of 1649, he told them that the mass had been illegal in Ireland for eighty years before the rebellion of 1641, and that he was determined to enforce this law, and to reduce things to their former state in this respect. Legally, he was right, but there had never been such a law-enforcing power in Ireland before the invasion of his army. Again, by way of explanation though not justification, it is important to refer to the political associations of Irish Catholicism, to the lead which the priesthood and the papacy had taken in the Irish Rebellion, to the contrasting political weakness of popery in England and its lack of effective foreign contacts, throughout the 1640s. Over the same decade, the utter failure of eighty years of proscription to uproot Irish Catholicism or to sever its links with Rome, became apparent. It was a political religion in a sense in which Catholicism in England had ceased to be, with the ‘Church of Rome’ seeking to control the laws of the land, and this formed Cromwell’s ‘justification’ for hanging priests and shooting officers, whereas other ranks and civilians were usually given quarter.

Cromwell had no particular relish for what he regarded as inevitable bloodshed. If he was merciless in his onslaught it was because he had been equally implacable in his prosecution of an unfinished second civil war and a threatened third one. He resolved to wage the war in Ireland with maximum ferocity, the better to shorten its duration. Whenever there was a chance of intimidating a defending stronghold into capitulation without loss of life, Cromwell did whatever he could to make that happen. At Drogheda, commanding the main road between Dublin and Ulster, he had believed there was just such a chance, since the royalist commander, the veteran Sir Arthur Aston, had been hopelessly outnumbered, not least in the heavy artillery which Cromwell could bring to bear on any attack in the form of huge siege mortars. The subsequent atrocity which was inflicted on the soldiers, few of whom were either Irish or Catholic, is surely sufficiently unforgivable to indict Cromwell, without any additional need to subscribe to the fiction that he deliberately or even passively extended the massacre to civilians. As Reilly has pointed out, the stories of women and children raped and mutilated are derived entirely from second-hand sources, virtually all of them either passionate royalists, like the antiquarian Anthony Wood, who published the stories during the Restoration ‘witch-hunts’ of republicans, or compilers of accounts writing centuries after the events. Wood’s brother Thomas was the source of many of the ‘juciest’ stories of Drogheda, including the one about Aston being beaten to death with his own wooden leg, and that of the mysterious martyred ‘virgin’ in her finest jewels and finery, who was stabbed in the ‘belly or fundament’ by marauding troopers.

Nevertheless, the savagery of the massacre at Drogheda was different from anything that had happened in the British civil wars to date, except perhaps to the royalist camp followers at Naseby. It recalled the worst horrors of the Thirty Years’ War on the continent. Cromwell, in his report on Drogheda to the Council of State, expressed the hope this business will save much effusion of blood. In a more considered report to the Speaker of the Commons, Cromwell again showed his anxiety lest Parliament should fail to keep him financially supplied:

I trust it will not be thought by any (that have not irreconcilable or malicious principles) unfit for me to move for a constant supply, which, in human probability as to outward means, is most likely to hasten and perfect this work. And indeed, if God please to finish it here as He hath done in England, the war is like to pay itself.

A week after Drogheda, the Council of State wrote to Cromwell instructing him to put all forfeited estates in Ireland up for let at the highest possible rent, and to use the proceeds to pay for his army. The war would not finance itself unless it was finished quickly, hence the ‘reason’ why Drogheda massacre was followed just a month later by another at Wexford. Cromwell’s actions and inactions at both Drogheda and Wexford can be legitimately judged, at least to some extent, according to the hints that he himself gave in his correspondence that his conscience was not entirely at ease about either. Of course, they were separate cases, and there was nothing remotely comparable with them in the subsequent actions which he fought in Ireland. In particular, his uncharacteristic conduct at Drogheda is a reminder of the corrosive effect that assumptions about the inherent inferiority of ‘race’ or creed, especially when stoked by persistent falsifying propaganda, can have even upon hearts and minds that are otherwise capable of nobility and toleration.

Miniature by Samuel Cooper, c. 1651.

The hatred and contempt which propertied Englishmen felt for the Irish is something which we may deplore but should not conceal. Even the poet Spenser, who knew Ireland well, the poet Milton, who believed passionately in liberty and human dignity, and the philosopher Bacon, all shared the the view that the Irish were culturally so inferior that their subordination was natural and necessary. Religious hostility reinforced such cultural prejudices and stereotypes. The strategic considerations already mentioned, reinforced by the anxieties which the ongoing civil wars continued to raise. As Christopher Hill (1974) concluded,

… a great number of civilised Englishmen of the propertied class in the seventeenth century spoke of Irishmen in tones not far removed from those which Nazis used about Slavs … the contempt rationalised a desire to exploit. … In these matters Cromwell was no better and no worse than the average Englishman of his time and class. Only a few intellectuals … seem to have been immune from this appalling attitude, and their ideological influence was slight, since it ran counter to to the extreme protestant assumptions which most of the radicals shared.

To Cromwell’s ‘racial contempt’ for the Irish, and his commercial-calculating attitude towards the the colonisation of Ireland, we must add a conscientious enthusiasm for conferring the benefits of ‘English civilisation’ on the natives, whether they liked it or not. His curious private letter of 31 December 1649 in which Oliver tried to persuade his friend John Sadler to accept the office of Chief Justice of Munster reveals something of this attitude:

We have a great opportunity to set up, until the Parliament shall otherwise determine, a way of doing justice amongst these poor people, which, for the uprightness and cheapness of it, may exceedingly gain upon them, who have been accustomed to as much injustice, tyranny and oppression from their landlords, the great men, and those that should have done them right as, I believe, any people in that which we call Christendom.

Sadler rejected the offer, which came with a ‘confidential’ promise of an allowance of a thousand pounds, more than ‘usually allowed’. The post was conferred instead on John Cook, the chief prosecuting lawyer at the trial of Charles I. Cromwell’s colonial attitude towards Ireland is also evident in the assurance he gave to Edmund Ludlow, Ireton’s successor as governor of Ireland, that the country was…

… a clean paper in that particular, and capable of being governed by such laws as should be found most agreeable to justice, which may be so impartially administered as to be a good precedent even to England itself; where they once perceive property preserved at an easy and cheap rate in Ireland they will never permit themselves to be so cheated and abused as they now are.

The quotation above provides a fascinating glimpse of what Cromwell thought was the republican ‘utopia’ of Ludlow and his friends. One of them, John Jones, hoped that ‘all men of estates’ would be banished, and the Irish ploughman and the labourer be admitted to the same immunities with the English. This would at least have been a postive if paternalistic policy for Ireland: better than what actually happened. On reflection, it was a misfortune that the Irish rebellion was launched shortly before British military power increased to a degree that left the Irish no chance of winning their independence, or at least an Irish parliament, firm titles for Irish landowners and a ‘de facto’ toleration of the Catholic faith as the religion of the vast majority of the Irish people. Once they were up against the undistracted military might of the English Commonwealth, ultimate defeat was only a matter of time. Yet the real curse of Ireland was not Cromwell but the conjunction of attitudes, largely shared by both the English and the Scots which went back to the time of Thomas Cromwell and John Knox; attitudes which assumed Ireland to be a dependent kingdom, looked upon her land as consisting of ‘four green fields’, open for colonisation, and equated ‘popery’ with idolatry. The ‘Act for the Settling Ireland’ of 1652, which set into motion the Rump parliament’s pre-meditated, wholesale confiscation of Irish lands, also rendering eighty thousand Irishmen officially subject to the death penalty, was passed at a time when Cromwell, far from dominating it, was seriously at odds with it.

Sources:

John Morrill (ed.), Sarah Barber et. al. (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British & Irish History. London: Penguin Books.

Glenn Foard (1994), Colonel John Pickering’s Regiment of Foot, 1644-45. Whitstable: Pryor Publications.

Austin Woolrych (2004), Britain in Revolution, 1625-1660. Oxford: OUP.

Simon Schama (2001), A History of Britain: The British Wars, 1603-1776. London: BBC Worldwide.

Christopher Hill (1974), God’s Englishman: Oliver Cromwell and the English Revolution. Harmondsworth: Penguin (Pelican) Books.

G. Huehns (ed.) (1955), Clarendon: Selections from ‘The History of the Rebellion and Civil Wars’. London: Oxford University Press.

(to be continued… )

Regicides, Rebels & Revolutionaries: November 1648 – October 1649; from Pride’s Purge to the Leveller Mutinies in England.

Ireton’s ‘Remonstrance’ – St Albans & the London Levellers:

When the Second Civil War ended, the frustrations and bitterness which had steadily been mounting against the king’s duplicity finally reached fever pitch. Many petitions were dispatched to London from various parts of the country demanding ‘impartial justice’ for all those involved in causing the recent bloodshed. The feeling was particularly strong in the army where Republicans and Levellers were extremely active. At some point in October 1648, Henry Ireton became fully convinced that the negotiations at Newport on the Isle of Wight with King Charles must be brought to an end, that the king must be brought to London to stand trial and that a new parliament must be elected. He prepared a new manifesto of these intentions which soon became known as The Remonstrance of the Army, for signature by its officers. It was considered at a meeting on the General Council of Officers, which had replaced the General Council of the Army of the Putney Debates the year before. This Council, which had no agitators or ‘rank and file’ soldiers, met at St Albans on 9th – 15th November to approve the first draft of the ‘Remonstrance’ for consideration by king and parliament. It was largely the work of Ireton, but Cromwell, still on duty with his regiment in Yorkshire, was duly informed of the decision. At this stage, however, there was no consensus in favour of forceful intervention, doubtless because Fairfax, recovered from illness and about to preside again, remained adamantly opposed to such a course of action. In fact, the Council voted to acquiesce in the Newport treaty, while also seeking to present the king and parliament with certain minimal conditions for his restoration.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-4.jpg

Ireton’s draft did not satisfy the London Levellers, however, since they were now seeking a broad alliance with their fellow civilian independents in the capital and radical MPs, as well as with the Army. Leading Levellers and Independents had been meeting in London at the ‘Nag’s Head’ tavern, and had agreed on 15th November to aim for a constituent assembly consisting of representatives of the army and well-wishers from every county. Its task would be to draft a new constitution in the form of a revised Agreement of the People, and they wanted to get it endorsed by the officers at St Albans, who had already received the outline of their proposals sympathetically. They were paricularly anxious that the army should dissolve the parliament before any constitutional agreement had been reached, so some of them sought an urgent meeting with Ireton and a few fellow-officers at Windsor. They had a tough negotiation, but they secured the amendment and expansion of the Remonstrance in some significant particulars. It now specifically commended the programme of reform in the Levellers’ petition of September, and desired that ‘matters of general settlement’, including annual or biennial parliaments, so reformed as to render the House of Commons, as near as may be, an equal representative of the whole people electing, should be legislated for by the present parliament, or by the Commons alone if need be, and to be further established by a general contract or agreement of the people, with their subscriptions thereunto. To frame such an agreement, Ireton and his visitors agreed that a committee should be set up consisting of four representatives apiece of the Levellers, the army, the London independents, and what he called the ‘honest party’ in parliament.

The ‘Peace Party’ & the ‘Honest Party’ at Westminster:

Meanwhile, at Newport, Charles conceded the key point that that all military forces should be controlled by parliament for at least twenty years. The Council of Officers were pre-empted by parliament, however, still dominated by Denzil Holles and the presbyterian ‘peace party’ which on the 15th had voted to re-open negotiations with the king, resolving that he shall be settled in a condition of honour, freedom and safety, agreeable to the laws of this land. This was exactly the same form of words that those who had risen for him in the spring and summer had declared as their aims. It was too much for most of the officers at St Albans, who met again on 18 November and quickly agreed to send the ‘Remonstrance’ to parliament. This final version of the Remonstrance was approved by the Council of Officers on 18 November and the following day this was presented to Faifax who, having failed to persuade the king to sign a version of the army’s Heads of the Proposals, was now more or less compelled to agree to it. This ferociously worded final draft of the ‘Remonstrance’ now demanded the trial of the king and the abolition of the monarchy. Two days later, it was laid before the Commons, to whom it was addressed, with a covering letter from Fairfax. He must have winced at the central demand, which was for exemplary justice … in capital punishment upon the principal author and some and some prime instruments of our late wars. It argued at length that the pledge in the Solemn League and Covenant to preserve the king’s person and authority had ceased to be binding. Fairfax’s letter did not propose the abolition of the monarchy, but stipulated that no king should henceforth be admitted except upon upon the election of the people’s representatives in parliament, and after subscribing the proposed Agreement of the People. The same subsciption was to be required of all other holders of public office.

The House reacted by postponing any consideration of the Remonstrance for a whole week, and turned instead to debating the latest unsatisfactory answers from the king. Having gained the king’s assurances over their future control of the army, however, parliament voted in favour of extending the Newport negotiations. By these two decisions, taken together, it took a long step towards sealing its own fate, as the council of officers responded by ordering a military occupation of Westminster and the City. None of this, by now, could have been much of a surprise to Charles who, although apparently impotent, was at last in control, if not of his ultimate destiny, then of his legacy. His worst moment became his best moment. He must have taken satisfaction from the knowledge that everything that would be done to him could only be done by making a nonsense of the principles for which parliament had claimed to go to war: the protection of the liberties of the subject. Charles himself could now claim that, all along, he and not parliament, had been the shield of his subjects, the defender of the people.

Cromwell’s Conscience and the Colonels:

Oéiver Cromwell, by Robert Walker, c. 1649

Cromwell’s continued absence in the north in early November could be easily explained, but from mid-month the reason for it became problematic. For the first fortnight after leaving Edinburgh he was busy dealing with the pockets of resistance and arranging garrisons in northern England, but by the end of October only Pontefract was holding on. Fairfax sent Rainborough, back in the army after the fleet had rejected his command, to take over command of the siege. But the royalist garrison got wind of his presence at Doncaster, and sent out a battalion of horse to capture him at his lodgings there. As he attempted to escape, his captors ran him through and killed him. Rainborough’s death roused a sense of of outrage throughout the army, and the regimental petitions that followed called for vengeance on his ‘murderers’. His body was brought back to London, and the Levellers mounted a great funeral procession for him, followed by many hundreds of mounted men; one estimate said three thousand. In these emotive circumstances it was appropriate for Cromwell to take over the siege fo a while, and Fairfax ordered him to do so. But he did not need to stay there for a whole month after Rainborough’s death, especially as Lambert’s detachment rejoined him before mid-November. He did not return south until Fairfax sent him a direct order to do so on the 28th. Even then he took a week to complete the journey. It’s likely that he still had doubts about Ireton’s efforts to commit the army to dissolving or purging parliament and putting the king on trial for his life. He would have been expected to take his seat in the Commons had he returned earlier, and may not have felt ready for that either.

We get a glimpse into his thinking and heart-searching ‘waiting upon the Lord’ in two letters to his cousin Colonel Robert Hammond, who was still acting as the king’s keeper as governor of the Isle of Wight and was known to have personal sympathy for his royal ‘guest’. These were written to his ‘dear Robin’ three weeks apart on 6th and 25th November, and they suggest that in trying to point where the path of conscience should lead Hammond, Cromwell indicated that he was wrestling with his own. In particular, he warned Hammond against letting his aversion to the Levellers lead him into ‘meddling with an accursed thing’. The first letter reveals that Vane and the other leading independents were concerned that his own agreement with Argyll amounted to ‘a compliance with presbytery’, and wished he had gone on to conquer Scotland. Cromwell wrote that while that might have been feasible, it would not have been ‘Christian’, and he had been commanded by parliament not to do it. For his own part, he had waited and prayed for the day to see union and right understanding between the godly people, who for him included Jews, Gentiles, Presbyterians, Independents, Anabaptists and all, as well as Scots and English. His second letter, written after the Council of Officers’ acceptance of the Remonstrance, shows Cromwell coming to terms with the necessity for the army to put a stop to the Newport treaty, this ruining hypocritical agreement, as he put it. ‘Robin’, he wrote, could neither expect any good to come from the king:

Good by this man, against whom the Lord hath witnessed? … seek to know the mind of God in all that chain of providence, … and then tell, whether there be not some glorious and high meaning in all this? … I dare be bold to say, it is not that the wicked should be exalted, that God should so appear as indeed he hath done.

Sir Thomas Fairfax, General of the Forces, by an unknown artist, c. 1650.

Cromwell believed that the army was a lawful power, called by God to oppose and fight against the king upon some stated grounds, and whether, as such it might not resist a corrupted parliament as well as a king. On the ‘Remonstrance’ he wrote that he wished that it had been held back until after the treaty was concluded, but he hoped for God’s blessing upon it. But before he received this letter Hammond was was under arrest. He had refused to place the king under closer arrest, as Fairfax had commanded, without direct orders from parliament, so on 21 November Fairfax summoned him to Windsor, where the general was now headquartered. Colonel Ewer was sent to escort him there. Two radical officers, Lieutenant-Colonel Ralph Cobbett and Captain John Merriman arrived on the isle soon after and put the king under heavy guard. They were acting under the orders of Ireton and his close associates, and at daybreak on 1 December they roused Charles and removed him to Hurst Castle on the mainland. At the same time, a sizeable part of the army was on the march to London. The Commons had made it clear that they were not going to give any time to the ‘Remonstrance’ until they had fully considered the King’s final answer to parliament’s propositions, and that was the last straw for Ireton. A public declaration by Fairfax and the General Council of Officers heralded the army’s advance, claiming that it was …

… necessitated to, and justified in, an appeal from this parliament, in the present constitution as it stands, unto the extraordinary judgement of God and good people.

Ireton’s ‘Coup’ & Pride’s ‘Purge’:

Henry Ireton, detail.

The General Council of Officers in the army still aimed at a settlement based on a regular succession of parliaments, and hoped that the present House of Commons would expel its ‘corrupt and apostacised members’ forthwith. If it did not do that, and few expected that it would, the army called upon its ‘upright’ members to withdraw, and undertook to recognise them as a provisional government until a new and reformed parliament was elected, which was to be arranged as soon as possible. Ireton was the moving force behind this declaration and the army’s consequent moves, and he clearly envisaged a forcible dissolution rather than a purge. But parliament remained defiant, though on 1 December they did not go as far as William Prynne, who urged them to cashier Fairfax and declare the army to be in rebellion. They totally rejected the ‘Remonstrance’ however, by 125 votes to 58, and ordered Fairfax not to bring his forces any nearer to London. That was a futile gesture, for by the time Fairfax received the Speaker’s letter, he had seven thousand men already drawn up for review in Hyde Park. Ireton and his fellow officers did listen, however, to the pleas of members friendly to the army, who urged them to purge parliament rather than dissolve it. Later the same day, parliament received the formal report by its recently returned commissioners on the king’s final answer to the propositions put to him at Newport. A thinned out House of Lords voted without a division that it provided a ground … to proceed upon for the settlement of the peace of the kingdom. The alliance made that summer between Saye, the royal independents and the army leaders was in ruins.

The Commons put off their response, being preoccupied with more immediate military matters. On the following day, a Saturday, the whole of Westminster from Whitehall to Ludgate was crammed with troops; the City itself was temporarily spared having to quarter them on condition that it immediately handed over forty thousand pounds of its assessment arrears. When the Commons sat again the following Monday, they argued for a record-breaking twenty-four hours as to how to respond both to the king’s answer and the military occupation. Their numbers shrank from 340 to 214 before they finally voted, on the morning of the 5th, on the same motion the Lords had passed, and they concurred that the king’s reply furnished them with ground for proceeding to a peace settlement. Speaker Lenthall warned them that they were voting for their own demise. He was right, as later that day Ireton and other officers met friendly MPs to persuade them to agree to a dissolution rather than sit on as ‘a mock parliament’. He failed, and a committee of three officers and three members was entrusted with deciding how a purge was to be conducted, who should be excluded and who arrested. Those to be excluded were those who the previous August had refused to declare the invading Scottish ‘Engager’ army to be made up of enemies and traitors, as well as those who had just voted in support of the king’s final answer.

So it was that by 7 a.m. on 6 December several regiments were posted in the precincts of the parliament-house, and Colonel Thomas Pride stood in the lobby with his guard, ready to execute the operation which has become associated with his name. The Council of Officers had ordered him to ‘purge’ the Long Parliament of those members who were obstructing the army in its desire to bring Charles I to trial. Altogether 186 members were ‘secluded’ or prevented from taking their seats in the Commons. A further forty-five were sent to prison. Out of a total of 471 MPs, only seventy-one continued into Westminster Hall on the path that would bring the king to trial and, ultimately, to the scaffold. By stopping members who had voted for the Newport Treaty from entering and arresting others, Pride was violating precisely the parliamentary independence that the war had been fought to preserve. The truncated ‘Rump’ Parliament that resulted was more of a mockery of the institution than anything the Stuarts had ever convened or dissolved. Effectively, the ‘purge’ was a military coup d’état, which only Oliver St John and Henry Vane the younger embraced with any enthusiasm. Fairfax seems to have given Ireton free rein and kept out of the business himself, but he must have known what was going on; his lodging was close by in Whitehall. When a committee of six MPs waited on him to explain the previous morning’s vote he kept them waiting for three hours, and then would give them no straight answer to their questions about what his army was up to. Since the motive force behind that revolution and its ultimate success lay so much in the army, it was somewhat strange that the attitude of its grandees remained so equivocal. Fairfax was genuinely convinced that the treaty of Newport was a potential disaster and must be stopped, but he was deeply unhappy about the consequential moves to put the king on trial.

After the miniature by Samuel Cooper, c. 1650-53.

Later in the day on the 6th, Cromwell arrived from his long journey south, declaring that he had not been acquainted with the purge beforehand, yet since it was done he was glad of it, and would endeavour to maintain it. It is inconceivable that Ireton had kept his father-in-law and immediate superior in the dark about his intentions, but Cromwell probably took care not to know enough to ‘incriminate’ him in the days’ events, also timing his arrival so as not to be visibly involved in them. Cromwell’s standpoint throughout December remained hard to penetrate, and historians continue to disagree about it. He had had no qualms about the termination of the Newport treaty, as his letters to Hammond reveal, and no longer needed any convincing that Charles was unfit to rule, but that did not necessarily justify persuing him to his death or abolishing the monarchy in Britain. If a way could be found of sparing his life, or if Charles could have been persuaded to abdicate in favour of his youngest son, the Duke of Gloucester, Cromwell would probably have welcomed it. He had, for a long time, seemed painfully aware of the transparent manipulations of legality going on around him, and was deeply troubled by the prospect of a trial. In December, even though he accepted the need for a trial, he still referred publicly to those who had ‘carried on a design’ to depose Charles as traitors. But at some part over the next few weeks he had decided that Providence was, after all, unmistakably demanding the punishment of the ‘man of blood’, the ‘author’ of the civil woes of Britain.

The army moved into the City on 8 December, since the corporation had failed to meet Fairfax’s deadline for the demanded payment to the army. Fairfax had no compunction about helping his unpaid troops to twenty-seven thousand which his officers found in Weavers’ Hall, banked there by the Committee for Advance of Money. The shrunken Commons spent the 8th as a day of fasting and humiliation, and then adjourned until the 12th, as the Lords had already done. Somehow during these hectic days of early December the committee which Ireton had conceded to the Levellers just before the ‘Remonstrance’ finally managed to meet and thrash out a new Agreement of the People. We don’t know how many of its sixteen members took part; though the chief negotiators were Lilburne, Ireton, Colonel Tichborne, and Henry Marten, the only MP who attended. By Lilburne’s own account he and Ireton argued keenly over the contents of the document, which was much longer than the original Agreement, but it was drafted in time to be presented to the General Council of Officers on 11 December. Lilburne claimed to have understood that its text was final, to be accepted or rejected as it stood, but to the Levellers’ disgust the Council of Officers examined it closely, debated it at intervals for five weeks, and modified it in significant respects.

In mid-December, with parliament clearly subordinate to the army, it was the Council of Officers which also decided the fate of the king. On 15 December, it resolved that he should be brought speedily to justice, and appointed a committee to consider how this should be done. Cromwell and Ireton were conspicuously missing from its membership, perhaps because they were just too busy behind the scenes, but perhaps also, at least in Cromwell’s case, because he was still more than a little uneasy about the enormity of what was being contemplated. The small number of MPs who still attended the House contained many who were more resentful of the Purge than keen to proceed against the king, and it was not until the 28th that they gave a first reading to an ordinance for the establishment of a High Court of Justice to try him. Nine days earlier they had driven out the few remaining seekers after accommodation by requiring members, as a condition of their continuing to sit, to make a formal declaration that they dissented from the vote on 5 December which had accepted the king’s answer as grounds for proceeding to a settlement.

The military watch on the on the entrance to the House had continued until the 12th December, by which time forty-five members had been imprisoned, though all but twenty were released by the 20th. A rather larger number were prevented from taking up their seats. Just how many members were excluded is not known, and estimates vary widely, but many members avoided his actions on the day by staying away, and many more expressed their outrage at the army’s violation by voluntarily absenting themselves, either permanently or for an extended period. The pre-purge strength of the House was 471, since eighteen were vacant and eighteen more were held by men who had already been long absent. Eventually, just over two hundred members would take their seats in the ‘Rump’, as the purged parliament came to be known, but at the time the army’s action alienated most of the parliamentary independents as well as all the presbyterians. It was a thin company that carried on the business of parliament during the dangerous weeks of the king’s trial and execution, and several times in December the House was short of a quorum. The number of members who attended at any time between 6 December and 5 February, or who signed the king’s death warrant, totalled only just over seventy, and Vane, St John and Haselrig were not among them. The attendance of the peers rarely reached double figures. The ‘high court’, packed and processed into compliance by Ireton, was more arbitrary than than any of the prerogative courts of the Long Parliament had abolished as the tools of despotism.

Contemporary and Historical Views of the Purge:

Predictably, Pride’s Purge was denounced by most of the Presbyterian clergy in London and acclaimed by many, though not all, of the Independents, including the numerous Baptists (above). The army’s champion, Hugh Peter, was especially rapturous. Before the end of the year, parliament received a spate of petitions and declarations, by one account over a hundred, from radical puritans and commonwealthmen in various counties and towns, praising the army, urging members to complete the work of reformation, and, in many cases, calling for stern justice upon the king. They represented the views of a minority, but an articulate, active and organised one. The majority who looked upon the proceedings against the king with horror were powerless to resist them, for they had spent whatever force they could command in the spring, summer and early autumn. A presbyterian City corporation might just have attempted resistance, despite the military occupation, but such a body now no longer existed. Just before the annual elections to the Common Council on 21 December, the Rump rushed through legislation disqualifying all who had sided with the king in the wars or signed the engagement of the previous June calling for a personal treaty with him. As a result, only the old common-councilmen were re-elected, and the corporation’s support for the revolution in progress was assured.

In December 1648, Hewson’s regiment was part of the force with which Fairfax occupied London, and its commanders remained instrumental in political events as they unfolded in the capital. Some historians have claimed that, in the crisis which followed the second civil war, leading to Pride’s Purge and the trial of the king, Ireton used rank-and-file petitioners to achieve his own political ends and that the grandees exploited and then cast aside the Levellers of whom there is no fear, as Cromwell put it. Some of the reforms recommended by the Levellers were adopted – a republic, abolition of the House of Lords – but none of the democratic content which alone, in the Leveller view, could have legitimated military intervention in politics. It was at this time that Henry Pinnell seems to have had a role in the republication of the Agreement in December 1648. William Clarke recorded much of the proceedings, which took place in the Palace of Whitehall, and they are of as much interest as the more famous Putney debates. They reveal that, far from simply acting as pawns of the grandees, the regiments remained actively engaged in determining the direction of the Revolution. At least seventy-three officers participated at one time or another, attendances of fifty being not uncommon. One of the documents published for consideration, and then for wider circulation, has been attributed to Henry Pinnell, the chaplain of Hewson’s regiment, the front page of which is shown below. While it proposed a radical refom of parliament, it also set ot the terms by which the monarch could continue to play a role in the English state, even at this late stage in the proceedings against the existing king.

001 (57)

Besides these proposals, the grandees themselves were not of one mind and spirit as to what needed to be done next. In particular, throughout much of December, Cromwell was at odds with his son-in-law, Ireton. According to Woolrych, Cromwell may have found parts of the new Agreement of the People too radical for him, and he held three meetings with the old middle group men, including Speaker Lenthall at the third of these, to discuss proposals for a more conservative settlement. It was not until the 20th January that the Common Council presented its amended Agreement of the People, in a fair parchment copy, to the Commons, but by then the eyes of the whole country were on the adjacent Westminster Hall, where the king’s trial opened that day. Christopher Hill and other historians have argued that Ireton conceded the drafting of a new ‘Agreement’ only in order to neutralise the Levellers while the army went ahead with enforcing the king’s prosecution, to which even Levellers like Lilburne and Pinnell were opposed. But the length and intensity of the Whitehall debates surely show that the Agreement was intended as a blueprint for a settlement, as Woolrych calls it, which was being taken very seriously, not least by Ireton himself, who was prepared to risk the wrath of his commander and father-in-law in order to see it through. He told parliament:

The ground of the late war between the King and Parliament was … whether he or you should exercise the supreme power over us. … so it’s vain to expect a settlement of peace amongst us until until that point be clearly and justly determined, that there can be no liberty in any nation where the law-giving power is not solely in the people or their representatives.

Is not all the controversy, whose slaves the poor shall be? asked a Leveller pamphlet, pointing to the need for a radical reform of the ‘establishment’ as a whole. But the experiment of democratic politics had been tried, in the most favourable possible forum, the Army, a cross-section of men of all orders of society; even there it had failed. The myth was, and is, that it failed not because the ideas were wrong but because the generals were too treacherous, the radicals too trusting, the mass of those whom they led too little impressed with the importance of the issues. Sin, in seventeenth-century parlance, was too powerful. But, as Hill also pointed out, ‘Sin’ is the reflection in the minds of men of the realities of this society. Both Ireton and the London independent pastors appear to have had a clearer and more realistic view of fallen ‘human society’, at least in mid-seventeenth century England and Wales. Only a ruthless ‘Godly republic’ could succeed in controlling such a society.

Westminster Hall, still much as it appeared in the mid-seventeenth century.

Revolutionaries & Republicans – who were they?:

The Revolution was no longer, if it ever had been, simply a question of Independents versus Presbyterians, either in parliament or in the City. So who were the revolutionaries now, apart from the army officers who had ordered the ‘purge’? In attempting to answer this question fifty years ago, David Underdown continued a trend away from an almost total emphasis on the social and economic aspects of the ‘English Revolution’. Interest in the political issues was partly revived by the use of statistical sources and the introduction of quantitative techniques. These studies, culminating in Underdown’s (1971), Pride’s Purge, have provided subsequent historians of the period with a detailed picture of the complexity of party groupings within the Commons. Blair Worden (1974) challenged the long-established theory that the Rump acted throughout 1648-53 in mere self-interest. Underdown examined the evidence about the 471 individual MPs who were sitting just prior to the purge, though this varied greatly in both quantity and quality. He divided them into five groups: the active revolutionaries who openly committed themselves to the revolution while it was in progress during December and January; the conformists, who avoided formal commitment at that time, but accepted the fait accompli in February, when they could no longer be incriminated in the execution of the king; the abstainers, who were not actually secluded, but showed their opposition by staying away from parliament, at least until the spring of 1649; those secluded by the purge, including the hard core of the Army’s enemies, who suffered imprisonment as well as seclusion. At the end of this process, Underdown enumerated the categories as follows:

Revolutionaries 71 (15%);

Conformists 83 (18%);

Abstainers 86 (18%);

Secluded 186 (40%);

Imprisoned 45 (9%)

Underdown interpreted these statistics as showing that the ‘revolution’ was not essentially about either politics or religion; or that it was essentially either a class struggle or a mere coup d’état by a crowd of backwoods outsiders trying to get in. They do suggest that it was a mixture of all these things. He went on to descibe a ‘typical’ member of these categories. Here he characterised the ‘typical revolutionary’ as …

… a married man in his mid-forties. He had probably inherited an estate, but was quite possibly a younger son. He had gone to one of the Inns of Court, most likely Gray’s Inn, and was less likely to have attended a university. He may possibly have come from the North-East of England. He had no previous parliamentary experience, entered the Long Parliament in a by-election after August 1645, and attached himself to the radical wing of the Independents; … in religion he probably, but not necessarily, turned to Independency. Of country gentry status, he came of a rather insecure family, and was probably not a rich man, having a pre-war income of less than five hundred pounds a year: if richer, he may well have been in serious debt. He was likely to have large financial claims against the State, and to recover some of these debts in the form of Church, royalist or Crown lands, in that order of preference. He may have been an office-holder, and if not was quite likely to become one after the revolution …

The Monarch’s Path to the Martyr’s Scaffold:

Even with the removal of the presbyterian ‘peace party’, the remnant, or ‘Rump’ were reluctant to pursue the path that they anticipated would bring the king to trial and end on the scaffold. Cromwell himself, who had already hesitated in his support for the Purge, was half-drawn to a scheme advanced by a group of peers, whereby Charles might even have remained king, with drastically reduced powers. One of their leaders, Denbigh made a final offer to Charles, but the king was unwilling to consider such terms, and rather than compromise his crown any further, he was now resigned to what he saw as his martyrdom. By the 26th December, the quest for a bloodless solution was over, and Cromwell seemed fully convinced that the king must pay the penalty for making war upon his people. During the debate on the first reading of the ordinance for a High Court of Justice, he told the House that if any man had pursued a design to put the king on trial and depose him he would be the greatest traitor in the world, but that since providence and necessity had cast it upon them he would pray God to bless their counsels, though he could as yet offer them no counsel himself. Despite their misgivings, the Commons voted to end negotiations with the king and passed the ordinance on 1st January, but next day the Lords unanimously threw it out and adjourned for a week. Attempting to cover the illegal and unconstitutional nature of their ‘revolutionary tribunal’, the Commons then resolved:

That the people are, under God, the original of all just power; that the Commons of England, in parliament assembled, being chosen by and representing the people, have the supreme power in this nation; that whatsoever is enacted or declared for law by the Commons … hath the force of law, and all the people of this nation are concluded thereby, although the consent and concurrence of king or House of Peers be not had thereunto.

The ordinance, as first drafted, intended the court to consist of 150 commissioners, presided over by the Chief Justices of the King’s Bench and Common Pleas and the Chief Baron of the Exchequer. But none of these, nor any judge in the central courts, was willing to act. Most lawyers refused to associate themselves with what was clearly an illegal court. So they chose the best man they could find, John Bradshaw, the Chief Justice of Chester, a convinced republican and a friend of John Milton. The special High Court was hand-picked, with a great deal of trouble given to include a cross-section of the English notability – landowners, army officers and MPs. Such was the unwillingness to serve that the number of commissioners had to be reduced to 135, though most of those nominated only agreed under extreme pressure. Of these, fifty-five, including most of the lawyers named and all six of the peers, never attended the trial. Average attendances at sessions never seldom amounted to more than seventy. Vane, Skippon and Brereton were among those who never appeared. Fairfax attended the initial meeting of the court, dealing with preliminary business on 8 January, when attendance was so poor that it had to be postponed until the 10th, and he never attended again. When his name was called at the top of the roll, it was answered by Lady Fairfax, sitting veiled in the public gallery: No, nor will he be here; he has more wit than to be here! Oliver St John also decided against making an appearance. Colonel Algernon Sidney withdrew after these initial meetings, declaring that the king could not be tried by any court, and that no king could be tried by this one. He later became a famous republican theorist. John Cook, a republican fanatic at the time, was appointed solicitor to the Commonwealth on 10 January so that he could lead the prosecution.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 002-1.jpg
The King’s Trial, January 1649.

Certain precautions had to be taken. The atmosphere of fear and tension was best illustrated by John Bradshaw, the presiding judge (pictured seated in the centre in the picture above), wearing a hat with a special metal lining ‘to ward off blows’ and protect him from shots from the public galleries, from which the prisoner was kept well away. On 19th January, Charles had been brought from Windsor, where he had been since 23rd December, to St James’ Palace, where he dined and lodged as ‘Charles Stuart’, without any of the service and courtesies due to a sovereign. It was as though he was already deposed, if not yet dead, but their were ‘certain formalities’ to go through. In Westminster Hall, the Stuart monarch was told by the prosecutor John Cook that he was being arraigned for his chief and prime responsibility for all the treasons, murders, ravages, burnings, spoils, desolations, damages, and mischiefs to this nation.

Charles’ attempted objections could not prevent Cook from reading out the rest of the lengthy charge which the lawyer had prepared with some difficulty and together with others. Its main burden was that Charles Stuart, having been entrusted with a limited power to govern according to the laws of the land, for the good of the people and the preservation of their rights, had pursued a wicked design to to arrogate to himself an unlimited and tyrannical power, in order to rule as he pleased. To that end he had traitorously and maliciously levied war against the present parliament, and the people therein represented. Moreover, he had compounded his guilt by deliberately causing the war to be renewed during the past year. Nothing was said about the ‘Engagement’ or the Scottish invasion, as he was on trial solely as the King of England. The Scottish parliament had been pressing that proceedings should be suspended until their country had been heard in the matter. But his dealings with the Irish rebels and his encouragement of an Irish invasion of England and Wales formed part of the charge at Westminster. When he heard himself condemned as a tyrant, traitor and murderer, a public and implacable enemy to the commonwealth of England, he laughed in the face of the judges. Asked to plead, he refused, demanding instead to know by …

… “what power I am called hither … I would know by what Authority, I mean, lawful; for there are many unlawful Authorities in the world, Theeves and Robbers by the highways … Remember I am your King, your lawful King, and what sins you bring upon your heads, and the Judgement of God upon this Land, think well upon it … before you go any further from one sin to a greater.”

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007-4.jpg
Charles I at his Trial, by 1649. Charles, clad in gold and black, wore the ‘uniform of monarchy’.

Denying the court its show trial, complete with witnesses, Charles, without his habitual stammer, reiterated his refusal to acknowledge the competency of its jurisdiction. Throughout the trial, he also refused to plead to the charge and to defend himself. When he reappeared on 22 January he was hoping to read the text of a written explanation of his reasons for refusing to plead, insisting that as king he could not be held accountable to any earthly judges and that nothing lawful could possibly be derived from a body that had removed one part of its indivisible lawmaking sovereignty. The only possible claim to such jurisdiction was through the revolutionary utterance, already made by the Rump Parliament when it had asserted on 4th January that the people are, under God, the source of all just power. Charles, not hesitating to expose the coercion behind this, protested that it was common knowledge that this parliament’s claim to represent the people was belied by the dentention and exclusion of many of its representatives. Here he was making the claim that he, and not the army or a fraudulant parliament, was the true guardian of the welfare and freedom of the people. That, of course, was what his most articulate and disinterested champion, Edward Hyde (later Lord Clarendon), had wanted him to say all along. However, the chiefs among his judges were not about to allow Charles to express these views out loud. He was silenced before getting very far into his statement and after much protest he was again removed from the court. The following day the same exchange ended when Bradshaw admonished Charles for seemingly not understanding that he was ‘before a Court of Justice’, to which Charles retorted: “I see I am before a power.”

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006-6.jpg
The trial of Charles I before a High Court of Justice established by the Rump. By refusing to plead, Charles played into the hands of the regicides, who were able to conclude his trial in a week and execute him three days later on 30 January 1649.

Time and again, on this and subsequent days, he challenged Bradshaw to by what authority the court sat, and when told that it was by the authority of the Commons of England, he poured justified scorn on the idea that the Lower House of parliament was a court of judicature or that a small fraction of it, first elected more than eight years previously, had any claim to speak for the commons of England in a broader sense. If he had recognised the court’s jurisdiction and been prepared to abdicate, he could still have saved his life, but by refusing to plead, he frustrated the one purpose of his accusors, since until he did so the thirty-three witnesses who had been assembled to testify to his responsibility for the two wars could not be heard publicly. The further price that he paid by not pleading was that he was not allowed to address the court himself; yet his regal dignity and self-control on all three appearances before it won him many sympathisers. For the remainder of the proceedings the court merely sat as a committee, before which the witnesses were eventually heard on the 24th, and their depositions were read out in a public session in the Painted Chamber the next day. Only forty-six commissioners attended this, but they resolved that they could now proceed to a death sentence. In the face of his bold defiance, it was a foregone conclusion, and Charles was brought before the court to hear it on the 27th. He pleaded eloquently to be heard before the full body of Lords and Commons, and in doing so he had the better of yet another exchange with Bradshaw, but all he won was a brief adjournment. In the course of this, Cromwell is reported to have used all his powers of angry rhetoric to bring round the waverers among the commissioners. But Lucy Hutchinson, the wife of Colonel Thomas Hutchinson, wrote about how this was used as an ‘excuse’ by some of the fifty-nine ‘regicide’ signatories of the king’s death warrant when they were later called to account themselves following the restoration:

In January 1648/49*, the court sat, the King was brought to his trial. … One thing was remarked in him by many of the court, that when the blood spilt in many of the battles where he was in his own person, and had caused it to be shed by his own command, was laid to his charge, he heard it with disdainful smiles, and looks and gestures which rather expressed sorrow that all the opposite party to him were not cut off, … The gentlemen that were appointed his judges, and divers others, saw in him a disposition so bent on the ruin of all that opposed him, and of all the righteous and just things they had contended for, that it was upon the consciences of many of them, that if they did not execute justice upon him, God would require at their hands all the blood and desolation which should ensure by their suffering him to escape, when God had brought him into their hands. Although the malice of the malignant party and their apostate brethren seemed to threaten them, yet they ought to cast themselves upon God, while they acted with a good conscience for him and for their country. Some of them afterwards, for excuse, belied themselves, and said they were under the awe of the army, and overpersuaded by Cromwell and the like: but it is certain that all men herein were left to their free liberty of acting, neither persuaded nor compelled … As for Mr Hutchinson, although he was very much confirmed in his judgment concerning the cause, yet herein being called to an extraordinary action, whereof many were of several minds, he addressed himself to God by prayer; … and finding no check, but a confirmation in his conscience that it was his duty to act as he did, he, upon serious debate, both privately and in his address to God, and in conferences with conscientious, upright, unbiased persons, proceeded to sign the sentence against the King … and therefore he cast himself on God’s protection.

(*According to the old calendar, in use until 1564, the year began on 1 April, and some ‘chroniclers’ continued to use this in the first half of the seventeenth century.)

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007-3.jpg
Above and below: The King’s death warrant with its fifty-nine sealed signatures.

On the resumption of the court session, the sentence was read out in open court, and all sixty-seven commissioners present rose to signify their assent to Bradshaw’s declaration that the judgement was that of the whole court, sentencing the former monarch to be ‘put to death, by the severing of his Head from his Body.’ Charles was brought back to hear his fate. When he asked to be heard once more, he was about to be denied the opportunity to do so, and when one of the commissioners, John Downes, protested that Charles ought to be allowed to speak, he drew from Cromwell the intimidating question, What ails thee? He scoffed and asked to speak for a final time, but was again denied on the grounds that he had refused to recognise the legitimacy of the court. He was taken away protesting, “I am not suffered to speak. Expect what Justice other people will have.” Only fifty-nine members of the court signed the death warrant, but all sixty-seven were later counted among the ‘regicides’ (two of the commissioners signed the warrant later who were not present when the sentence was read). Cromwell and Ireton were prominent among the signatories, together with a number of other colonels, including John Hewson; his signature can be seen on the warrant in the third column at the bottom (above).

The Views from the Scaffold – Witnesses & Historians:

Lieutenant-Colonel Daniel Axtell, second-in-command of Hewson’s Regiment, which remained obedient during the Leveller Risings in 1649. The regiment had been known as the most radical in the New Model Army, but under Hewson, Axtell and Major Carter it went on to become an important tool of suppression. It was involved in Pride’s Purge and Axtell himself commanded the guard at the king’s execution.

Three days later, on the cold morning of 30th January, Colonel Hewson’s second-in-command, Lieutenant-Colonel Daniel Axtell (pictured above) commanded the guard for the king’s execution, which took place on the black-draped platform outside the Banqueting House of St James’ Palace in Whitehall. Charles had passed up chance after chance of saving his life because he thought that to do so he would have to compromise the sacred prerogatives of his kingly office. Those who brought him to the scaffold were driven by a no less sincere conviction that they were doing justice upon a man whom God had witnessed for shedding the blood of thousands of his subjects in an evil cause. His final ordeal was cruelly prolonged, largely because the Rump belatedly realised, on that morning, that the death of a monarch had to be followed by a proclamation of the successor, so they had to rush through an act to make such a proclamation illegal. Perfectly composed and dressed in two shirts, lest shivering be mistaken for fear, he was at last able to make his speech, written on paper that he opened on the scaffold. Not many of the thousands present can have heard his last words from the platform, but he accepted his ‘unjust sentence’ as God’s punishment for his failings as a monarch. He denied that he had declared war on parliament, neither Lords nor Commons, or to encroach upon their privileges. He reaffirmed his central political beliefs, though not in the form of Edward Hyde’s thought-out theory of a constitutional monarchy so much as an expression of personal sorrow and anger of all that had occured since the ‘Grand Remonstrance’ of 1642. But rejected the charge that he was the enemy of the people; indeed, he claimed to be ‘the martyr of the people’:

“For the people … truly I desire their liberty and freedom as much as anybody whomsoever; but I must tell you their liberty and freedom consists in having of government, those laws by which their life and their goods may be most their own. It is not for having a share in government, sir, that is nothing pertaining to them. A subject and a sovereign are clear different things.”

Certainly, no one had ever accused Charles of pandering to the public. From beginning to end, through all the tactical twists and turns of his relatively short reign, he had remained utterly constant in his belief in the sanctity of his appointment. He concluded his oration with the words, “I go from a corruptible to an incorruptible Crown; where no disturbance can be, no disturbance in the world.”

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 005-5.jpg

Elizabeth I had wanted the execution of Mary Stuart, Charles’ grandmother, to be carried out in utmost secrecy, far away from public gaze. Cromwell and Ireton were convinced that as many people as possible should see Charles beheaded, both to dissuade any attempts at rescue and to do God’s work in the clear light of day, without shame or hesitation. Unlike his grandmother’s messy execution, Richard Brandon cut through his neck with a single blow. Cromwell had given notice that he would “cut his head off with the crown upon it”, but the ‘groan’ which went up from ‘the thousands present’ when the king’s head dropped into the bloody basket and was held up by Brandon, could not have been very reassuring for the grandees present. The person of the monarch had already proved to be separable from the institution. Simon Schama has claimed that, in his last days, Charles had managed, despite all attempts to gag him, to teach by actions as well as words that armed power could not remould the broken legitimacy of either the English state, nor the Scottish. But henceforth, it was not sufficient for any king of either state to to simply assert a ‘Divine Right’ to rule. It would only be when a monarch of both England, Scotland and Ireland ruled who recognised that the status of the Crown might be enhanced, not compromised, by partnership with the parliaments that the violent pendulum swings of all three kingdoms could find their equipoise. That issue was not finally resolved until the second, less bloody revolution of 1688-89 and the establishment of a ‘constitutional monarchy’ in England.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 008-3.jpg

Fifty years ago, the historian C V Wedgewood described the Trial and Execution of Charles I as one of the most startling – perhaps the most startling – event of English history. It astounded the whole of Europe in 1649, with some calling it the most horrible and detestable patricide ever committed by Christians. It was condemned almost everywhere. Only in some of the Swiss Protestant cantons does there seem to have been a sympathetic reception to the event as, in Cromwell’s words, ‘a cruel necessity’. Kings had been deposed before, and some killed. But this was the first time that a king had been arraigned under his title as King and in the name of his people. Three weeks before putting him on trial the House of Commons proclaimed that the people under God are the source of all just power. They went on to assert the rather less convincing proposition that the remnant of the Hose of Commons elected eight years previously truly represented the people. According to Wedgewood, the trial and execution were an attack on the mistique of the monarchy, an assertion that ithe monarch was no more than the highest officer of State, a steward appointed by and for the people, who was accountable to them. This was a new concept in 1649. It was the work of a dominant group of officers in the Parliamentary Army led by Lieutenant-General Oliver Cromwell and his son-in-law, Henry Ireton, seconded by Republicans like Colonel Edmund Ludlow and sectarians like Colonel Thomas Harrison. They acted in conjunction with Commonwealthmen in the Commons, of whom Henry Marten was the most significant.

Wedgewood pointed out how, inevitably, in any account of his trial the King appears in a more sympathetic light than his accusers and judges. But polically and in the long-term, the greater courage was theirs. Convinced, as Cromwell chose to record, that God had witnessed against the King and that he deserved death, they chose to defy convention; they did not engineer som hole-in-the-corner murder; they sought to demonstrate the guilt of the monarch in the traditional seat of English justice, Westminster Hall, before a full audience of his subjects, in a trial that was fully reported. As one of their supporters proudly predicted a few days after the king’s death, their actions would live and remain upon record to the perpetual honour of the English State, who took no dark and doubtful way, no indirect by-course, but went in the open and plain path of Justice, Reason, Law and Religion. John Milton praised the glory of the act: God has inspired the English to be the first of mankind who have not hesitated to judge and condemn their king.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006-2-2.jpg
The dignity and courage with which he met his death added greatly to Charles’ prestige.

Filling the Void – Commonwealth and Republic:

As we have seen, the months between October 1648 and January 1649 were crucial to the English Revolution. With the execution of Charles I, England was kingless. The Scots, however, declared their willingness to accept Prince Charles as their Charles II and as king of all Britain, on condition that he accepted the Solemn League and Covenant. But it was not until the end of June 1650 that Charles landed in Scotland and he was proclaimed king in July. In England, meanwhile, a series of radical acts followed: the Commons declared themselves the sovereign power, the monarchy and the House of Lords were abolished on 17 March 1649, and England was declared a Commonwealth in May, making its government that of a republic. An executive Council of State had been established to deal with day-to-day business of government which had previously been the province of the king’s ministers at court. The decision to establish it was taken on 7 February, immediately after the Rump had voted to abolish the monarchy. A powerful committee had been set up to define the council’s powers and propose the names of its initial members. The latter were to number forty-one, of whom thirty-one were MPs; the others included five peers, the three chief judges, an alderman to represent the City, and John Bradshaw, who had presided over the king’s trial. But only three of the peers, Denbigh, Pembroke and Salisbury, were willing to serve, and from the committee’s nominees, the House rejected Ireton and Harrison. This was a heavy slight to the army, whose only members on the council were Fairfax, Cromwell and Skippon. Since Fairfax was seldom seen and would eventually resign his command, and since Cromwell was to be absent in Ireland and Scotland for much of the next two years, the army was most unwisely under-represented.

The council was empowered to raise forces, conduct relations with foreign powers and their ambassadors, and imprison anyone who disobeyed its commands, but it was firmly subjected to whatever orders parliament gave it, and was appointed for one year only. Behind the Rump stood the army, to which it owed its power, and the army might not sustain it for long, since its first intention had been to dissolve the parliament rather than purge it. The army had seemingly committed itself to supporting a programme of radical reform, embodied in the revised Agreement of the People that it had presented to the Rump, a programme that would have transformed the constitution of parliament itself, regulated the frequency and duration of its sitting, brought large alterations to the law of the land, and changed the whole relationship between the church and the state. The army and its supporters hoped and expected that this caretaker régime, as they saw it, would soon make way for a reformed and reforming parliament, elected on a far broader franchise than ever in the past. Yet, as Worden (1974) commented in his analysis of its eventual dissolution in 1653, the Rump had never regarded itself as anything other than an interim government, and it had always acted on the assumption that it would eventually make way for a newly elected parliament. In all its resolutions from March 1649 onwards, it implicitly if not explicitly acknowledged that by postponing them it was compromising between the ideal and the necessary; elections were desirable, but they were not yet practicable. Worden has challenged the traditional view of the Rump among historians that it was ‘energetically radical’ in 1649, yet by 1653 it had become intolerably oligarchical, dilatory and corrupt. He has shown that:

Both the initial radicalism and the subsequent decadence of the régime have been exaggerated. The explanation of the Rump’s demise lay less in any change in its character, which had been largely determined in infancy, than in the changing requirements Cromwell made of it. Cromwell, the destroyer of the Commonwealth régime, had also, more than anyone else, been its architect. The Rump was his conservative solution to the problems of 1648-49.

In the Spring of 1649, the Levellers reached the the peak of their influence, through the share they had had taken in drafting the new ‘Agreement’. From the early months of 1649 onward there was a burgeoning of various groups outside parliament of even more radical than the Levellers; the Fifth Monarchists, who felt a divine call to set up a régime ruled exclusively by their fellow ‘saints’ in preparation for Christ’s prophesied kingdom on earth; the Diggers who called themselves ‘True Levellers’, and preached and practised the community of property. Of these groups only the Fifth Monarchists had any considerable following in the army, but there was an understandable fear in conservative hearts that with dissolution threatening the ancient constitution, the established church, and the known laws of the land, a dark and revolutionary future lay ahead. For the Fifth Monarchists and a multitude of other equally fervent sects, the emptiness left by the dethroned king was not a void at all but the antechamber to glory. Their preachers and prophets said so in the streets and to rapt congregations of appremtices and artisans. But the message resonated with special force in the army where sabres had been honed by the fire of sermons. With the Scottish Presbyterian régime having declared for Charles II as King of both Scotland and England, and Ireland still in the power of the Catholic confederacy, now reinforced by the royalist army of the Duke of Ormonde, the New Model Army could not afford to let its guard down.

Colonel John Hewson. An engraving by Van der Gucht. (The National Portrait Gallery, London). Hewson had not received a university education before the war, but was given an honourary MA by Oxford University in 1649 (the same year as Oliver Cromwell). He commanded his regiment in Ireland later in the year, and became governor of Dublin, member of the Council of State and an MP. Knighted by Cromwell, for whom he was a close ally at first, one of the king’s judges at his trial, he was described as an “arch-radical and religious zealot”, but was a fierce and outspoken opponent of the Leveller agitators in the Army.

So England remained an armed camp, an occupied country in all but name, where law might as easily be delivered on the point of a sword as in a magistrates’ court. The army’s officer corps, especially at the junior level, was younger, less traditionally educated, drawn from lower down the social scale and passionately Independent in religion. Since about seventy per cent of artisans – shoemakers like Hewson, weavers, coopers, tanners and others – were literate, the rank and file had a political awareness of its destiny and that of the country. For the most part, the Leveller leaders were at pains to distance themselves from any imputation of social egalitarianism. At the same time, Lilburne detested everything about the new régime. He had been against the trial and execution of the king, which he believed were violations of all the principles of equity encoded in the common law. The response of the Leveller leaders to a formal ban on political discussions within the army was a two-part pamphlet called England’s New Chains, which called into question any kind of obedience to a régime they condemned as illegitimate. On 28 March, Lilburne, Overton and Walwyn, together with Thomas Prince, were arrested and dragged before the new ‘Council of State’. According to Lilburne, both they and the councillors were treated to a fist-pounding eruption of rage from Oliver Cromwell:

“I tell you … you have no other way to deal with these men but to break them, or they will break you; yea, and bring all the guilt of the blood and treasure shed and spent in this kingdom upon your heads and shoulders, and frustrate and make void all that work that, with so many years’ industry, toil and pains, you have done, and so render you to all rational men in the world as the most comptemtible generation of silly, low-spirited men in the earth … I tell you again, you are necessitated to break them.”

Not surprisingly, then, the Levellers who refused to acknowledge the authority of the Council were packed off to the Tower. But then, a petitioning campaign for their release immediately broke out in London, mobilised by Leveller women. The most articulate and impassioned preacher-turned-Leveller was Katherine Chidley, who tried to make the Commonwealth understand the particular sufferings of their sex and institute poor relief for their assistance:

Considering that we have an equal share and interest with men in the Commonwealth and it cannot be laid waste (as it now is) and not we be the greatest and most helpless sufferers therein: and considering the poverty, misery and famine, like a mighty torrent is breaking in upon us … and we are not able to see our children hang upon us, and cry out for bread, and not have the where-withal to feed them, we had rather die than see that day.

The outrageous temerity of women giving voice to these grievances was profoundly shocking to mainstream Puritan culture, devoted as it was to the dominant Calvinist view of the hierarchy of the sexes in which the woman’s role was seen as that of the obedient, quietly devoted helpmate. When Elizabeth Lilburne and Katherine Chidley, at the head of mass demonstration of women, presumed to petition parliament for the release of the Leveller leaders, they met with a predictably chauvinistic response:

The matter you petition about is of a higher concernment than you understand, the House have an answerto your Husbands and therefore you are desired to go home and looke after your own businesse, and meddle with your huswifery.

But the Leveller women did not go home, and instead made sure that the Manifestation, published from the Tower under the names of all the imprisoned Levellers, was widely distributed in London. It was an explanation of why, after so much persecution, deprivation and frustration, they had no choice but to persevere, whatever further ordeals might come their way. In its determination and bleak pathos, the Manifestation was a vocational manifesto for ‘the revolutionary calling’, as Schama has called it. All the same, the four denied that they were impatient and over-violent in our motions for the Publick Good, hoping to achieve their ends through another ‘Agreement of the (Free) People’, which they proceeded to publish from their ’causelesse captivity’ on 1 May. The document was serious and practical in content, repeating many of their original proposals of 1647, but judged by what was thought politically acceptable, in the Commonwealth, this third Agreement was a non-starter. But this does not mean that the kind of assumptions and arguments made by the Levellers could be thought of as utopian, hence the determination to mark themselves as fundamentally different from the ‘Diggers’, who preached community of lands and goods.

The early years of the Commonwealth revealed its internal isolation. The means by which it came to power, its decision to create a Council of State and the slow pace of further reform also alienated many of its potential allies like the Levellers. Despite the minimal role he had played in the trial and execution of Charles I, Fairfax and the army supported the Council of State. But although he was originally listed as a commissioner in his trial, Fairfax had never approved of the king’s execution and was clearly disillusioned by what the revolution had achieved. He retired from his commission as general at the age of thirty-eight. Cromwell took over the command of the army and eventually usurped the power of the Council of State as Lord Protector. However, in the first half of 1649 he remained an MP and this initial period was at a time when everybody could still ask, What is the ideal way for the Commonwealth of England to be governed? A great variety of answers were offered to that question during the ‘interregnum’. It is worth reminding ourselves that, from a religious perspective, Cromwell remained an Independent throughout the interregnum, and held strong views about liberty of conscience which also continued to influence his political and constitutional outlook. The manner in which the composition of the Rump and its Council of State evolved goes a long way to explain why the early fears of radical change in political, legal and social institutions – far beyond the the abolition of the monarchy and the Lords – proved to be unfounded. Conservative spirits had been equally apprehensive about the influence of the army, and particularly about its leaders’ collaboration with Lilburne and the other Levellers in framing a new constitutional settlement.

Final Acts of the Revolution: ‘Diggers’ & Mutineers:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 002-2.jpg
Ploughing with Oxen

But though religious and political differences caused the civil wars, it was social and cultural differences that made the revolution. In addition to the powerful new classes of mechants and gentry, there were increasing numbers of craftsmen, small traders and tenant farmers who were in danger of eviction because the landowners wished to enclose their lands and farms for their own use. There was much to be done in restoring stability and prosperity to the countryside after the wars. As a region that had been at the centre of the fighting, Oxfordshire and Berkshire (see the map below) had much wasted land; landowners were heavily taxed, and in many cases their tenants had failed to pay their rents for some years. The Rump government provided an opportunity for petitions for redress. For example, the citizens of Oxford petitioned parliament for help to restore the damage done to the city during the siege and fire of 1644. Others rebuilt their estates in a different way. The Loder family, based around Kintbury and Harwell in Berkshire, were keen to experiment in the most modern farming and land-management techniques. They were at the forefront of those progressive landlords who sought agreement to enclose land and to manage and divert water-courses in order to improve the quality, productivity and profitability of their lands. The region remained strategically important, too, as it lay between London and the west coast ports from which troops were to embark for the continuing, unpopular war in Ireland. Signs of dissent, such as the mutinies at Banbury and Burford in 1649 over pay and unwillingness to fight in Ireland, remained a major concern for the Council of State in the Rump parliament.

Selling pamphlets

In religion, these new, ‘lesser’ gentry and yeoman classes tended to be Independent, and in the army they had won promotion to become officers and even generals by this time, though they were still more numerous among the ordinary soldiery. They still had no political power, although the war had brought them closer to it, and many of them made excellent agitators, demonstrators and pamphleteers. A man needed to own a substantial amount of property before he could vote in these times. The Levellers wanted the property qualification removed, but this was a view of democracy that did not gain acceptance for another two centuries in Britain. Ireton’s view, clearly expressed at the Putney debates with the Leveller agitators in the army in November 1647, had been: Liberty cannot be provided for in general sense if property be preserved. Those were circumstances in which revolutionary solutions might be well received; they must have existed in many more parts of the country. In ‘Banburyshire’, for example, there were pockets of religious enthusiasm among the largely puritan and parliamentarian area, which easily became a stronghold of opposition to the deeply unpopular Rump. Abingdon was also known as a centre of both relgious radicalism and civil unrest. In the early 1650s, both counties continued to be regarded as centres of both royalist and sectarian resistance to Cromwell’s Protectorate.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006-10.jpg

The national economic and political situation in the early months of 1649 was particularly explosive, with many in the capital also starving. Some Levellers and army radicals felt that they had been duped in the negotiations which led to the trial and execution of the king: the republic set up by the Independent Grandees had set up fell far short of the of the reformed democratic society they had hoped to see. They demanded the reappointment of Agitators and recall of the General Council of the army. It was out of the Levellers that the ‘True Levellers’ or ‘Diggers’ emerged in 1649. In April, they took over a patch of waste land near Cobham and established a ‘colony’ there which survived for a year in which it won much support in southern and central England, where similar ventures were established. Its leading pamphleteer, Gerrard Winstanley, from a Wigan mechant family, published a number of pamphlets, culminating in 1652 with a summary of his ideas in The Law of Freedom in a Platform, dedicated to Oliver Cromwell. It was on the day that Charles was sentenced that Winstanley published his pamphlet, The New Law of Righteousness. It was a time when almost anything seemed possible, a time at which ideas developed rapidly. The point was made by Winstanley’s title. For most conservatives, there could be no such ‘new law’: there was only a long-established and well-known one. Confidence in novel ideas was itself a new concept, and one which only radicals possessed.

We can see why Winstanley’s sudden insight struck him as a divine revelation. The generals’ coup d’état had not solved England’s social and economic problems. All over the country poor squatters and cottagers, the victims of enclosure and heavy taxation, were ready for desperate remedies. It was no coincidence that the Diggers’ standard was first set up in north Surrey (see the map below), close not only to the radical South Bank of the Thames but also was in an area in which there were large crown estates, parks and forests, and where there had been a great deal of enclosure and consequent hardship to the peasantry. Nearby was Windsor Great Forest, which squatters were illegally cultivating. Other areas from which we have evidence of Digger activity including Buckinghamshire and Northamptonshire, counties in which there had been much enclosure and which had been much enclosure and which had been the scene of considerable fighting and free-quarter in the civil war. In the parish of Wellingborough, Northants, 1,169 were receiving alms in 1650. The local magistrates had ordered a workhouse to be set up, but the ‘true’ Levellers, or Diggers, claimed that…

… as yet we see nothing is done, nor any man that goeth about it; we have spent all we have, our trading is decayed, our wives and children cry for bread, our lives are a burden to us, divers of us having five, six, seven, eight, nine in family, and we cannot get bread for one of them by our labour. Rich men’s hearts are hardened, they will not give us if we beg at their doors; if we steal, the law will end our lives. Divers of the poor are starved to death already, and it were better for us that are living to die by the sword than by the famine.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 003-7.jpg

The Digger movement appeared during a period of panic, when it was no means obvious that the radical threat had been overcome. On Sunday 1 April, a group of poor men assembled on St George’s Hill in the parish of Walton-on-Thames and began to dig the waste land there, sowing it with corn, parsnips, carrots and beans. The Diggers’ numbers soon rose to twenty or thirty. One observer noted, They invite all to come in and help them and promise them meat, drink and clothes … They give out, they will be four or five thousand within ten days … It is feared they have some design in hand. Local property-owners tried to drive them off (as desribed in one of their pamphlets above), before calling on the Council of State to intervene with military assistance. Thinking that great conflux of people may be a beginning whence things of greater and more dangerous consequence may grow, the Council of State alerted the Surrey J.P.s and General Fairfax. The latter sent a couple of troopers down to see what was happening. From the report which Captain Gladman sent in to Fairfax it is clear that he thought the Council was being unduly alarmist and Fairfax refused to take the incident seriously.

On 3rd April, two days after Winstanley and his comrades started digging on St George’s Hill, Peter Chamberlen suggested using the confiscated lands of crown, church and royalists, together with common and waste lands, for a public bank. If you provide not for the poor they will provide for themselves, he declared, and a continual anxiety during the civil wars had been that the necessitous people of the whole kingdom should set up for themselves, to the utter ruin of all the nobility and gentry. A third party of the poor was a continual nightmare for the men of property and their armies, for whom the ‘Clubmen’ of the south-west had been a major threat in 1645 and by Levellers in London and the Army in the years following the end of the first civil war. Pamphlets and petitions in 1647 and ’48 demanded common lands for the poor in which Winstanley had estimated that from half to two-thirds of England was not properly cultivated, and that one third of the country was barren waste. But if the poor were allowed to manure and cultivate the wastes and the commons, there was land enough to maintain ten times the existing population, so that begging and poverty could be abolished. This was the vision that he conceived some time between 16 October 1648 and 26 January 1649. Four days before the execution of King Charles, Winstanley solemny announced:

… when the Lord doth show unto me the place and manner, how he will have those of us that are called common people to manure and work upon the common lands, I will go forth and declare it in my action, to eat my bread with the sweat of brows, without either giving or taking hire, looking upon the land as freely mine as another’s … The spirit of the poor shall be drawn forth ere long, to act materially this law of righteousness.

On 20 April two of the principal Diggers, William Everard and Gerrard Winstanley, were brought before the Commander-in-Chief. They kept their hats on in Fairfax’s presence, the traditional symbolic refusal to recognise social superiority and political authority. Lilburne had made the same gesture in 1637, and it was later a point of principle by the Quakers. Fairfax, the Digger leaders said, was but their fellow-creature. Their intention, they told the general, was to cultivate the waste lands as a colony: they would ‘meddle only with what was common and untilled’. Any rights in the commons claimed by lords of manors, Winstanley later explained, had been cut off with the King’s head. They hoped that before long the poor everywhere would voluntarily surrender their estates and join in communal production. Fairfax thought Everard was “no better than a madman”, when he called himself a prophet “of the race of the Jews” and recalled stories of his visions. William Everard, probably the same man, had been an Agitator in the New Model Army, where he had promoted the Agreement of the People. He had been arrested for his participation in the mutiny at Ware in November 1647, and was alleged to been involved in the conspiracy to kill the King, together with Captain Bray and William Thompson. In December he was released from prison, but cashiered. In the early years of the Digger movement Everard rather than Winstanley seems to have been its spokesman. This would fit with the Digger William Everard, whom we know was dismissed from the army.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 004-6.jpg

After the Ware mutiny, William Everard had been a fellow-prisoner with his fellow-agitator Thompson, who had led some of the mutineers. This would seem to explain Everard’s disappearance from the Digger story and his reappearance at Bradfield, near Reading, at harvest-time, since if he had been in arms after leaving St George’s Hill, he would have have sought a safe refuge. Soldiers, tired of war, continued to read Lilburne, Overton and Walwyn. In April 1649, they mutinied in London over pay, and in response to moves to send them to ‘pacify’ Ireland. Throughout April, further mutinies broke out when soldiers who refused to serve in Ireland were demobilised without payment of arrears. One of these was in Colonel Whalley’s London-based regiment of horse when fifteen troopers publicly defied their Colonel’s personal orders to march. They were court-martialled, and six were sentenced to death. They made a humble submission, however, and Cromwell was for pardoning them, but Fairfax insisted that an example must be made of the one considered most responsible. On 27 April, Trooper Robert Lockyer was shot in St Paul’s Churchyard. Fairfax was not deterred by a menacing letter which appeared in print from Lilburne and Overton, accusing him of treason and murder, and threatening a popular rebellion if the sentence were carried out. Lockyer died bravely and defiantly, and his funeral two days later was a vast demonstration of popular support for the Leveller cause in London, with four thousand following his coffin. The mourners included large numbers of women, and they wore the green ribbons which had become the colour of the movement. Hundreds of soldiers also joined in the procession.

South-west view of Old St Paul’s, engraved by Wenceslaus Hollar, c. 1660.

In May more serious revolts broke out among troops in Oxfordshire, Wiltshire and Buckinghamshire, with rumours of civilian support from the old Clubman areas of the south-west. The Levellers in the Tower published a new, third edition of the Agreement of the People, to serve as a manifesto for what they hoped would become a general rising and expressing their ultimate end and full scope of all our desires and intentions for concerning the government of this nation, free from any pressure to make compromises. However, it was no more radical than the second version, and far less practcable. In mid-May, a serious mutiny broke out among some troops passing through the garrison stationed in the staunchly Puritan town of Banbury in north Oxfordshire (see the map below). Colonel Reynolds, half of whose new regiment had joined the mutiny, engaged the mutineers under Willian Thompson’s direction, and routed them near Banbury. Thompson got away, but died later that month in a shoot-out with his pursuers. What really broke the mutiny was the resolution with which Fairfax and Cromwell in person led a force of four thousand so far loyal troops against its focal area in Bristol. On 12 May, when they were marching through Hampshire, a shrewdly calculated declaration was published in Fairfax’s name, assuring the whole army that no one would be compelled to serve in Ireland against his wishes and that the mutineers’ grievances were being heeded. It claimed, with little justification, that the implementation of the Agreement was in hand, meaning of course the one presented to the Rump by the army. The declaration offered pardon to the mutinous regiments if they returned to obedience immediately, but if they did not they would be reduced by force. By this time the mutineers were becoming worried by their failure to mobilise more supporters, and their resistance began to crumble.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 005-3.jpg
Oxfordshire and Berkshire in the Civil Wars: These counties had seen fierce fighting during the First Civil War, and urgently needed to restore prosperity and stability. This was no easy matter, with royalist estates sequestered, or their owners paying heavy fines for opposing parliament. Nor was the continuing political controversy in 1649 of any help, with radicals in both counties, especially in the army garrisons, dissatisfied with the Rump Government, causing loyalties within the army to waver, especially when regiments were sent to embark for Ireland.

Two more regiments that had mutinied near Salisbury attempted to join the ‘Banburyshire’ rebels. They failed when, on 13 May, Cromwell and Fairfax marched a pursuit force fifty miles in a single day, catching the mutineers in the middle of the night on the edge of the Cotswolds (see the map above). Fairfax sent a delegation of to parley with representatives of the mutineers and appointed Major White, the former Leveller, to head it. White performed his duty faithfully, but the negotiations broke down. Cromwell and Fairfax then cornered the mutinous regiments in a skirmish at Burford on the night of 14/15 May. There was little fighting, however; 340 were taken prisoner and another six or seven hundred fled. Five were sentenced to be shot, the sentence ultimately being carried out on three of them. The other prisoners were not only released, but were given debentures for their arrears of pay. The next day, Cromwell received an honourary degree in law from Oxford University. Leveller statements continued to be published from Bristol before the heavy hand of the grandees came down again. There was little to connect the Leveller leaders in London directly with the mutiny, though contemporary news-sheets suggest that Everard had left the Digger colony at St George’s Hill by the end of April 1649 in order to join the Banburyshire mutiny. His brother, another fellow Agitator, Robert Everard, certainly was at Burford, and had taken part in the Putney Debates. He published several pamphlets between 1649 and 1652, defending adult baptism and denying original sin.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is cropped-image-3.png
Oliver Cromwell, by Samuel Cooper, c. 1650-53.

After the glorious rich providence of God to England – the ‘quashing of the Levellers at Burford – the grandees and the Council of State decided that there would be no further social revolution. It was almost inevitable that those who had done well out of the civil war should seek to consolidate their position. This, they came to recognise could best be achieved by compromise with their defeated enemies, even at the price of retaining or restoring much of the old order. The alternative of continuous revolution, or a further extension of democracy, was too frightening to contemplate for many of those now in power as well as for many moderate Levellers. The Revolution had begun with Oliver Cromwell leading fenmen in revolt against the Court’s drainage schemes; it effectively ended in the routing of the Leveller regiments at Burford, which was, incidentally, immediately followed by an act for draining the fens. By the autumn, it was clear that, whatever else was going to fill the space left by the monarchy, it was not going to be the visionary alternative Commonwealth of the Levellers. Bought off, bullied or imprisoned, their remaining leaders and agitators dispersed. The rank and file of the regiments were shipped off to Ireland where they could vent their fervour and frustrations on the rebels there. Hewson’s regiment was among these, chosen by lot, along with three other existing regiments and six new ones.

Sir Thomas Fairfax

After Burford, the Levellers rapidly lost coherence as a political movement and their organisation sank into terminal decline. The voices of some of them would be heard again at intervals in the 1650s, but they were never again serious contenders for power. Much of what they contended for was achieved, at least in part, by the end of the 1650s: regular parliaments at minimal intervals, a rational reappointment of seats, and a broad liberty of worship and belief. The Levellers were not the only champions of these objectives, but they took an early lead in asserting them. Between receiving the second version of the Agreement and confronting the Leveller mutiny, Fairfax was directed by the Council of State to deal with the small incident in Surrey caused by the emergence of the Diggers. Returning from putting down the grave events in Oxfordshire, however, Fairfax still refused to take the Digger ‘threat’ seriously. Visiting the colony at the end of May, and with Everard departed, he had an amicable exchange with Winstanley, during which the latter repeated his assurance that the Diggers had no intention of using force. Despite this, an action for trespass was brought by local landowners against the Diggers in the court at Kingston, where they were not allowed to plead unless they hired an attorney. When they refused to do this, they were condemned unheard. With no means with which to meet the fines, the Diggers had their goods distrained. An exciting tussle ensued over Winstanley’s cows, which changed hands many times and became symbols of resistance.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 017.jpg

The Diggers called themselves ‘True Levellers’, but their communitarian views were rejected by many Leveller leaders in London, including John Lilburne, though there was support for them in the countryside. However, the connection was emphasised by the publication of their manifesto, The True Leveller Standard Advanced (pictured above) by The Moderate, the Leveller newspaper. Signed by Winstanley and fourteen other Diggers, it had first appeared on 26 April, and in it Winstanley claimed that The old world … is running up like parchment in the fire, the powers of England and all the powers of the world. Some time in or before August 1649, the colony abandoned St George’s Hill and transferred to Cobham Heath, a mile or two away. This gave rise to further complaints against, and this time the council gave the army firm orders to suppress it. The squatters’ shacks were pulled down, their crops destroyed, and the men convicted of trespass and fined. By the winter of 1649-50, the Digger colony was in dire financial straits, but somehow the little colony survived quietly into the spring in 1650. Other Digger communities sprang up in various parts of the country, but they were equally short-lived, and the movement was never large. But in Gerrard Winstanley, the Diggers had a leader and publicist of genius. In the spring of 1649, when he published the first ‘True Leveller’ manifesto, he had become convinced that the prophesied kingdom of the saints was to be brought into being through Christ, the second Adam, working in the breast of every man and woman, and inspiring them to redeem the first Adam’s sin by renouncing lordship and property. Spiritual regeneration was to be attained through the sharing of the earth and its fruits.

Eikon Basilike (1649), by Charles I, frontispiece.

At least the various programmes of Levellers, Diggers, and even Fifth Monarchists were borne up by a stronger conviction than the few dragging steps which the Commonwealth’s actual government took towards shaping its constitutional future. Even Cromwell had voted against the act abolishing the House of Lords, and a substantial number of ‘Rumpers’ wanted to retain the Lords in a purely consultative role. What tipped the balance was a printed royalist declaration, proclaming Charles II as king and designating the House of Lords as the sole legitimate authority until he was able to exercise his regal powers in person. In response, the Commons passed the abolition bill rapidly, but in the Lords it only had a majority of fifteen in a House numbering seventy-three. The Rump was being made daily aware of the deep unpopularity of its rule in the country at large. One piece of evidence for this was the huge success of a pious forgery entitled Eikon Basilike (pictured above), a book which purported to record the late king’s meditations and devotional exercises during his final captivity. It was compiled and probably mainly written by John Gauden, the future Bishop of Worcester, and published ten days after Charles’ execution. As a tear-jerking portrayal of martyred innocence and piety, it had a very broad appeal; despite government attempts to suppress it, it was reprinted thirty times within 1649 and translated into several European languages. One hostile and exasperated reader was John Milton, who had had no quarrel with the monarchy when he had first taken up his pen against the bishops, but during the civil wars had found himself firmly aligned with the Independents and the New Model Army.

By 1649, Milton had become well known as a scholar, poet and polemicist in defence of the Rump, which had few enough supporters. Gratefully, it appointed him as Secretary for Foreign Tongues to the Council of State on a salary of two hundred pounds a year. Alongside his routine duties of translation and diplomatic writing, mainly in Latin, Milton earned this quite handsome salary by defending the Commonwealth in print, one of the council’s first requests being for a reply to the Leveller tract, England’s New Chains Discovered. He never wrote it, suggesting to some that he was sympathetic to the Leveller cause, but Woolrych believes that it was because he gave priority to writing an answer to Eikon Basilike in his 242-page Eikonoklastes, published in October 1649. Milton believed that the popularity of the Eikon revealed a fundamental weakness in the Commonwealth, that it was unlikely to win the hearts and minds of a people who had little idea of what a republic might look like by comparison with a very vivid and visceral monarchy. More than five months passed after Pride’s Purge before the Rump defined what kind of state it purported to govern. Even then, it did so in a one-sentence act declaring England to be a Commonwealth and Free State … governed by the representatives of the people in parliament … without any king or House of Lords.

Charles. Prince of Wales, future Charles II

The Rump became aware that the state of public opinion made it impossible for it to keep its promise to hold early general elections. It was also precluded from courting the popularity it lacked by reducing taxation, because the threats from Ireland and Scotland forced it to keep up large land forces, which would grow even larger when conquered territory had to be garrisoned. The Commonwealth had a total of about 47,000 men under arms in March 1649, many with large arrears of pay and living at free quarter. Furthermore, it had to continue to build ships, not only to counter Rupert’s small fleet and the much larger number of royalist privateers, but because it faced the hostility and colonial rivalry of the Dutch. ‘Charles II’ was the guest of his brother-in-law, William II of Orange, who was well disposed to assist him. The Rump’s hope to reduce the monthly assessment from ninety to sixty thousand pounds at the end of 1649 proved to be a forlorn one. So, when Fairfax, in the midst of the Leveller mutiny in May 1649, assured the army elections to a new parliament were high on the Rump’s agenda, he cannot have known how mistaken he was. But the pressure in the army for an early dissolution did cause the House to debate the matter. It set up a committee, over which Vane was given special responsibility, to consider both the apportionment of seats in future parliaments and the date by which the present one should dissolve itself. But amid the external threats to the Commonwealth, and the demoralising impact on it of its unpopularity at home, the prospect of putting its future in the hands of a volatile and potentially hostile electorate became ever less attractive. Nothing was heard from Vane’s committee, though the House did try in October to prod it into activity by ordering it to meet daily.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-1.jpg
Sir Arthur Haselrig, by Robert Walker.

As time went by, the suspicion grew that the Rumpers were clinging to their seats in order to retain their pecuniary privileges. Sir Arthur Haselrig was sometimes referred to as ‘the bishop’ because of the amount of diocesan land he bought in the see of Durham, and Colonel Philip Jones, who was born in Swansea’s High Street of very minor gentry stock, rose by questionable means to become a significant magnate in south Wales. He was by no means the only army officer to do well for himself through sequestration, as the map of Oxfordshire and Berkshire in the civil war (above) shows. Sequestered lands, like those of Sir Edward Hyde (below), who had joined Charles II in exile, were confiscated and sold off, or granted to prominent parliamentarians. Henry Marten gained lands at Eynsham to add to his estates between Shrivenham and Longworth, and the brothers John and William Lenthall increased their land holdings around Burford. Speaker Lenthall was alleged to have taken bribes, and so was his MP son, but the allegations were never substantiated. These circumstances offered great opportunities for speculators such as the former Leveller John Wildman who, as a lawyer used his knowledge of the land market and his connections with leading figures in government toaccumulate large land holdings in northwest Berkshire, as well as in other counties. One Rumper, and only one, was actually convicted for taking bribes, Lord Howard of Escrick. The fact that the House of Commons expelled him, disqualified him from public office, fined him ten thousand pounds and sent him to the Tower shows that it regarded corruption as a serious offence, from which rank gave no protection. Furthermore, looking at the Commonwealth as a whole, it was managed by its councillors, officials, military and naval officers with more probity than and a stronger sense of public service than the early Stuart monarchy had been, and that remained true right through the 1650s.

The charges levelled against the grandees, however, were of a far higher order, even though they continued to come from outside parliament. Despite his apparent detachment both from the mutineers and the Diggers, in August 1649 Lilburne published An Impeachment of High Treason against Oliver Cromwell and Henry Ireton. In October it was he himself who found himself on trial for treason at the Guildhall in the city of London. He played brilliantly to the gallery by insisting that the jury alone was empowered to issue a verdict as the judges were merely ‘cyphers’ of the people’s will. It duly acquitted him and Lilburne was freed without conditions, the other three in the Tower following on condition that they subscribed to the oath of engagement which was now required by the Commonwealth of all its citizens. All three of them did so, but Lilburne was not even asked. Lilburne took up various social causes and grievances before finally being banished for life in 1651. Returning to England from the Netherlands in 1653 he published again, was again imprisoned and eventually became a Quaker, like many other radical independents who turned what eventually, after much ‘quaking’ by Fox, Nayler and others, became a ‘quietist’ religion.

But by the autumn of 1649, and until Cromwell’s death a decade later, the military régime was secure. The English Revolution was effectively over, and Ireland had been ‘pacified’ by Cromwell, who had sailed there on 13 August with an army of two thousand (to be dealt with in my next chapter). For a short time, perhaps as little as two years, most ordinary people were freer from the authority of the established church and their social superiors than they had ever been before, or were for a long time to be again. We have a pretty full record of what they discussed. They speculated about the end of the world and the coming of the millennium; they contemplated the possibility that God might intend to save everybody, that something of God might be within each of us. They founded new sects to express these new ideas. Some considered the possibility that there might not be a creator God, only nature. They attacked the monopoly of knowledge within the privileged professions; divinity, law, medicine. They critised the existing educational structure, especially the universities, and proposed a vast expansion of educational opportunity to both sexes. They also questioned parts of the ‘protestant work ethic’. In the decade that followed, the eloquence and power of the simple artisans who took part in these discussions came across in print, especially from George Fox the Shepherd, John Bunyan the tinker and James Nayler the yeoman, all of whom I have written about on my previous website (www.chandlerozconsultants.wordpress.com).

Sources:

Austin Woolrych (2002), Britain in Revolution, 1625-1660. Oxford: OUP.

Simon Schama (2001), A History of Britain: The British Wars, 1603-1776. London: BBC Worldwide.

Sara Barber (et. al.) (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British & Irish History. London: Penguin Books.

Glenn Foard (1994), Colonel John Pickering’s Regiment of Foot, 1644-1645. Whitstable: Pryor Publications.

David Starsmere (1978), Diggers: The Story of a Commune. Glasgow: Blackie.

John Wroughton (1980), Documents and Debates: Seventeenth-Century Britain. Basingstoke: Macmillan.

Christopher Hill (ed.) (1973), Winstanley – The Law of Freedom and Other Writings. Harmondsworth: Pelican Books.

Christopher Hill (1975), The World Turned Upside Down: Radical Ideas During the English Revolution. Harmondsworth: Pelican Books.

David Smurthwaite (1984), The Ordnance Survey Complete Guide to the Battlefields of Britain. Exeter: Welsh & Bower.

Appendix:

75 Years on: Memories of the Blitz on Coventry, November 14-15 1940 and after.

AngloMagyarMedia's avatarAndrew James

This coming weekend, Coventry remembers the trauma it suffered on the night of 14-15 November 1940, when the Luftwaffe destroyed the Medieval centre of the city, including its old Cathedral in its ‘Moonlight Sonata’ raid of three major waves of aerial bombardment which gave a new word to both the German and English languages for this form of blanket bombing, Coventration.

My mother, then nine years old, Daphne Gulliver, had vivid memories of this night, but also the previous significant air-raids on Coventry, and the first use of the communal shelter at Walsgrave-on-Sowe school. The Anderson shelters that people had put up in their gardens by the summer of 1940 had become flooded so they had to go to the shelter at the school, which had been put there for the school children. However, as there were no day-time raids, it had not been used, and was still locked. The…

View original post 3,299 more words

The Putney Debates, the Second Civil War & the Newport Treaty: Oct 1647 – Oct 1648; Levellers, Engagers & Insurgents.

An ‘Outbreak of Democracy’?:

In his 1961 work on The Levellers and the English Revolution, H N Brailsford wrote that:

… there has been nothing like this spontaneous outbreak of democracy in any English or continental army before this year of 1647, nor was there anything like it thereafter till the Workers’ and Soldiers’ Councils met in 1917 in Russia.

The rank and file organised themselves from below, led by the yeoman cavalry regiments. Petitions were drafted, like the one from Colonel Hewson’s regiment, some of them dealing with political matters as well as military grievances. In the summer of 1647 the ‘Agitators’ had their own printer, a Leveller, John Harris; at the height of their influence his became an official army press. The army radicals also linked up with with their civilian counterparts. Petitions calling on the army to give a radical political lead also came in from London tradesmen as well as from the counties. The army had therefore advanced on London and entered upon a course of decisive political action, as already described in my previous ‘chapter’ in this series, and though it was now united under the command of Fairfax and Cromwell, the initiative for this action had come from the ‘rank and file’, including newly promoted or recruited officers who were in close contact with the London Levellers. The apprentices of London, under the influence of John Lilburne, who was still under arrest in the Tower, had also appointed ‘agitators’.

In the early autumn, the army commanders clearly signalled the limits to this radical ‘tide’ when Major Francis White, Agitator of Fairfax’s own regiment, had been expelled from the Army Council on 9 September for maintaining that there was now no visible authority in the kingdom but the power and force of the sword. This view was shared by others among the agitators and Colonel Rainborough, whom Gardiner described as the principal spokesman for this ‘third party’ among the officers, had also publicly expressed his anxiety about White being ‘kicked out’. White did not conclude, unlike the chaplain Hugh Peter, that any act of force was therefore justified. White set out his views at great length before Fairfax in 1647, repeated just over a year later. He held that all laws made since the Norman Conquest which were contrary to ‘equity’ should be abolished, and told Fairfax that his authority derived less from Parliament than from the ‘Solemn Engagements’ of the Army. The Levellers thought that the state had broken down in the course of the civil war; until it was legitimately refounded a state of nature existed in which the sword was the only remaining authority. But military force could justly only be used only to hand power back to the people.

This was the purpose of the Agreement of the People, the Levellers’ new ‘social contract’ refounding the state, which was submitted to the Army Council in October 1647. It was discussed by officers and men at Putney in the days after 28 October. But even as the debates got underway, the agitators had lost the initiative they had gained from March to August. Agitators of five cavalry regiments had been recalled by their constituents, under suspicion of being corrupted by their officers; they had been replaced by new representatives, and it was these new agitators who presented their new document to the Army Council. What we do not know from the available documents is what the expectations of the agitators were. At one time agreement seemed to have been reached on a general rendezvous at which they intended to have the Agreement accepted by the whole army. It had been amended to include a substantial extension of the franchise to all soldiers and to all others except servants and beggars. The current ‘state of nature’ was to be ended and the English commonwealth was to be restored as a democracy. For the senior officers, the debates in the army held at Putney in late October into early November took a very different course from that expected. Fairfax, Cromwell and Ireton had hoped that the General Council would reject the the accusations in The Case of the Army, reaffirm the basic unity of the army’s purpose, and get on with business of agreeing a set of terms that could be put to the king in its name.

In the event, what trooper Robert Everard, a new agent in Cromwell’s own regiment, brought to headquarters on the day before the General Council’s next meeting, however, was an entirely new document, approved that same day by by a meeting of the five regiments, together with other soldiers and some civilian Levellers, including Wildman, who was deputed to speak for it before the General Council. It seems to have been put together in order to steal the initiative for the Leveller’s broader aims before the army’s representative body. It seems to have been written by Wildman and William Walwyn. When Cromwell read it, he concluded that there were ‘new designs a-driving’ and that the General Council would have to thrash them out. Whereas The Case of the Army had set out a programme for action in the specific circumstances of early October, the Agreement of the People dealt in first principles, further widening the gap between its authors and the leaders of the army. The ‘Grandees’ – Fairfax, Cromwell and Ireton – were still seeking a settlement based on the ancient constitution and fundamental laws of England, albeit in radically modified form. These would have the binding consent of King, Lords and Commons.

The Levellers, by contrast, had come to regard the existing laws as very largely a legacy of ‘the Norman Yoke’, and now that the ‘freeborn’ English had defeated the last remnants of the Conquerors successors, they claimed that it was only the free people of England who could legitimate a new, valid constitution. The Agreement was their means to this end, offered as something altogether as something higher than a statute, which future parliaments could modify or repeal. It was intended to be a declaration of the principles on which future parliaments would be bound to operate. The people’s representatives in parliament would have full power without the consent of or concurrence of any other person or persons, to make laws, appoint offices of state and magistrates ‘of every degree’, declare war, make peace and to do everything that a sovereign people did not reserve to themselves. Their power was inferior only to theirs that choose them, but some rights were so ineradicably planted by ‘natural law’ that even their chosen representatives would be prevented from infringing them. Those affirmed in the Agreement included freedom of religion, immunity from conscription, and total equality before the law, regardless of birth, rank or tenure. Parliament itself should be reformed by reapportioning constituencies according to the number of inhabitants, not their contribution to taxation, as Ireton had suggested in the Heads of Proposals. However, the Agreement itself did not deal specifically with the Crown or the Lords. Woolrych has commented that It is a document as remarkable for its silences, which were doubtless deliberate, as for its prescriptions.

The fact that Cromwell, presiding (Fairfax being unwell again), caused the debates engendered by the Agreement to be recorded almost verbatim shows that he and Ireton were well aware of how much hung on their outcome. They were taken down by the aptly-named William Clarke, a Londoner of humble origin in his mid-twenties who had risen in the army secretariat and was now secretary to its General Council. He had mastered an early form of shorthand from which he later transcribed. At the General Council on 28 October, Sexby introduced the delegates from the new agents’ organisation: two soldiers, Robert Everard being one, and the civilian Levellers John Wildman and Maximilian Petty. He then told Cromwell and Ireton to to their faces that their credits and reputation hath been much blasted by their striving to please the king and their support of a parliament of rotten members. Very soon the fundamental difference of purpose between the army commanders and the Leveller group became apparent. The ‘grandees’ held themselves bound by their pledges to respect the authority of parliament and to seek a settlement with it or with a new parliament following the dissolution of the current one. On the other hand, the Levellers wanted the army to reoccupy London, dissolve parliament and inaugurate a new and revolutionary constitution, which could only be done by force. The prospect of the Agreement gaining enough subscriptions to give it democratic legitimacy if it was to be imposed by military dictatorship upon a nation yearning for peace and still devoted to its monarchy, were non-existent. It is little wonder then that the General Council was so divided. Many of those present, officers and soldiers alike, must have felt torn between the powerful attraction of high ideals on the one hand and a deep reluctance to divide the army on the other, in defiance of its senior commanders. Strong ties bound those who had fought together and who knew that they might have to do so again soon.

We lack evidence, however, about the sentiments of the rank and file, for the only soldiers recorded as having spoken during the three days of debate at Putney were Sexby, Allen, Lockyer, Everard and Jubbes. The last of these, recently promoted from Major to Lieutenant-Colonel in Hewson’s regiment on the death of its previous commander, Colonel John Pickering, was certainly committed to the Leveller’s political agenda along with at least three of the regiment’s captains. Earlier in the year, as political debate had intensified in the army throughout the summer and autumn, some in Hewson’s (formerly Pickering’s) regiment were clearly committed to the political agenda of the Levellers. In addition, there were at least two ordinary soldiers from the regiment, radical by reputation since its foundation in 1645, who were among the seventeen from nine regiments who had signed a letter on 21st June which went far beyond mere army grievances. But Jubbes was also interested in reconciling the Levellers with moderate Independents and even presbyterians, as he made clear in his brief contribution to the debates at Putney. His attitudes may have been tempered by his new commander, Colonel John Hewson (pictured below) who, though from a humble background himself, was soon to support Cromwell in moving against the Levellers in the army. Nevertheless, Jubbes remained critical of Cromwell and, disillusined with the course of the ‘revolution’ and its failure to bring ‘liberation’, he resigned his commission and left the army in April 1648, becoming a Fifth Monarchist. By that time, it was obvious that both he and the Levellers had lost the debate in the regiments and in the army as a whole. No doubt also disillusioned with the Leveller leader’s support for military dictatorship, Jubbes had also become a pacifist, like many others who were to form the early Quaker sect.

John Hewson. An engraving by Van der Gucht (National Gallery, London).

The Putney Debates & the Battle for the Army:

Although the Agreement was read to the General Council on the 28th, there was no debate on its contents on the first day. Cromwell and Ireton were doubtful as to whether the army should be considering such radical proposals at all. They argued that it was duty bound by its declarations made from June onwards, in which it had subjugated itself to the authority of parliament in exchange for the redress of its grievances, and that it also had a moral duty to to pursue the path of negotiation with both king and parliament on which it had already embarked. The Heads of the Proposals remained the basis for these, and they had not yet been fully and formerly considered by either party. For their part, the Leveller spokesmen contended that Parliament’s rotteness was manifest, that the king had forfeited any right to be further treated with, and that no engagements were binding if they stood in the way of the rights of the people; if the matters propounded in the Agreement were the people’s due, they stood self-justified. The outcome of the day’s debate was the appointment of a committee to sift the army’s declaration and itemise the commitments contained in them, so as to help help the General Council, in a special meeting in a few days’ time, to assess how far the Agreement‘s proposals were compatible with them. Cromwell’s attitude was conciliatory rather than confrontational; he assured the spokesmen for the Agreement that they would not find him and his fellow-officers wedded and glued to forms of government and readily acknowledged for his part that the foundation and supremacy is in the people, radically in them.

‘Leveller Country’: Places associated with the Leveller and the ‘True Leveller’ (‘Digger’) Movement in 1647-49.

The famous debate on the 29th, in which the Leveller spokesmen joined issue with Cromwell and Ireton over the very foundations of a free commonwealth, came about almost by accident. On the previous day, Lieutenant-Colonel Goffe made an urgent plea that they should meet first for prayer. He probably spoke for many when he said that God had not been with them in their debates so far. This did not please some of the less religious Leveller leaders like Wildman, who spoke extensively at Putney, almost as much as Ireton. But there was wide support for the proposal, and it was agreed that the next morning should be given to prayer, with the committee convening in the afternoon. There was a big attendance at the prayer meeting, and testimonies were heard. When the Levellers arrived in the early afternoon to confer with the committee, they found a large and potentially sympathetic audience and wanted to launch a general debate on the Agreement there and then. Cromwell understandably opposed this proposal, stating that he and the others present had already spent several hours together in seeking the Lord. But several other officers supported it, including Colonel Thomas Rainborough, whom Cromwell and Fairfax had already incensed over his appointment as vice-admiral in the Navy and their consequent reassignment of his New Model regiment to another officer. Although brave, sincere and a genuine radical, his motives at Putney were somewhat clouded by personal antagonisms. Nonetheless, the support he garnered at that moment meant that Cromwell and Ireton had to bow to pressure; the Agreement was duly read out in its entirety once more, and then debated clause by clause.

If Cromwell and Ireton had had time to think and reflect, they might have furthered their most immediate object, which was to preserve the army’s unity and discipline, by focusing on those parts of the Agreement which commanded general consensus in it, such as liberty of conscience, equality before the law and the superior authority of the people’s representatives. Instead, Ireton seized upon the proposal to equalise constituencies on the basis of population meant that every male inhabitant had a right to vote. This was what prompted Rainborough’s memorable affirmation that…

… the poorest he that is in England hath a life to live, as the greatest he; and therefore… that every man who is to live under a government ought first by his own consent to put himself under that government.

Henry Ireton

Against him, Ireton (above) took his stand on the constitution of parliament from time immemorial and on the principle that only they who had a permanent fixed interest in this kingdom, whether as freeholders or as freemen of corporations, the latter being mostly substantial traders. Liberty cannot be provided for in a general sense if property be preserved he asserted, and added I would have an eye to property. This led to a gladatorial contest with Rainborough; for at least half an hour no one else got a word in, and both made long speeches after that. Sexby and Wildman also contributed substantially, and there is no doubt that the Leveller case commanded more sympathy than Ireton’s. Sexby was passionately eloquent on behalf of his fellow-soldiers in challenging the claim that only those with a fixed estate should enjoy full political rights. Alluding to the already famous declaration of June that this was no mercenary army, he declared that if we had not a right to the kingdom, we were mere mercenary soldiers. He was echoing Rainborough, who had said he would fain know what the soldier hath fought for all this while. Rainborough went further than most of the Leveller leaders up to this point, by contending for unqualified manhood suffrage. The Levellers represented the interests of people of some modest economic independence, small traders and craftsmen, rather than those of the great mass of the poor. When some of the officers present, in dismay at the heat being generated by the long wrangle between Ireton and Rainborough, tried to steer discussion towards a compromise, such as denying the vote only to foreigners and to those too dependent to make a free choice, Petty responded positively; he was quite ready to consider excluding servants and apprentices who lived in their masters’ households, and men who subsisted by alms.

But just as the debate seemed set on a more constructive course, Rainborough tried to move that the army should be called to a rendezvous, and its line of action settled there. He doubtless had in mind the June rendezvous near Newmarket and the mass adoption of the Solemn Engagement, but whereas that event had served to unite the greater mass of the army, what he proposed would have further divided it. The record of the day’s debate breaks off before the end, but it seems that a straw poll was taken as to whether all but beggars and servants should have the vote, and (reportedly), only three were against. This did not, of course, amount to a general conversion to the Leveller programme as a whole, as if the vote had been on whether to march on London and impose the Agreement on parliament it would doubtless have gone very differently. To prepare for the next day, a new committee was established to seek compromises between the Heads of the Proposals and the Agreement. It comprised Cromwell, Ireton, both the Rainborough brothers, Chillenden, Sexby and Allen.

The Levellers, however, were rarely all of one mind, and Wildman was much less interested in compromise than in power, unlike John Lilburne, who was not ill-disposed towards the king. Wildman was already a republican by this time, and almost certainly wrote A Call to all the Soldiers of the Army by the People of England, which was in print and circulating among the regiments on 29 October, just as the great debate on the Agreement was happening. It denounced Cromwell and Ireton in virulent terms, accusing them of ‘leading the agitators by the nose’ in the General Council while they drove on the king’s design in parliament, and of claiming as they did so that they spoke for the whole army. It called upon the soldiery to withdraw their obedience from all officers who would not go with them along the path blazed by the Agreement, declaring …

… Ye have men amongst you as fit to govern as others to be removed: And with a word ye can create new officers. … truest lovers of the people ye can find to help you. … Establish a free parliament by expulsion of the usurpers.

This was an open incitement to mutiny, and it was not the only one in print and circulation. New agents were already appearing in other regiments beside the original five, and the men of Colonel Robert Lilburne’s regiment of foot, which Fairfax had ordered to Newcastle, was already defying their officers and holding unauthorised rendezvous.

On Sunday 31st, Colonel Rainborough took advantage of a break in proceedings in the debates to visit John Lilburne in the Tower. Rainborough professed great friendship towards the Leveller leader, though there is little evidence that he had met him previously. Nevertheless, he deplored the ‘foolish zeal’ which was driving some of the spokesmen at Putney to express evil intentions towards the king’s person, which he well knew the greatest part of the army abhorred to think of. Our information about this visit comes from The Tower of London Letter-Book of Sir Lewis Dyve. Earlier in the month Dyve had delivered Lilburne’s advice to the king that he should call a meeting with the Levellers in the army council and reassure them about his intentions. If he did so, Lilburne promised, he would have the army at his devotion within six weeks. But in that the Leveller leader was out of touch with the tide of ill-feeling towards the king that was rising in the army which made itself known in the special session of the General Council on Monday 1st. It probably owed something to Wildman’s influence over the new agents and his speeches at Putney, but it was also partly religious in origin. Lieutenant Colonel John Jubbes made a statement at the Putney debates on 1st November 1647, in which he called for political reforms extending well beyond the regiment’s grievances he had set down in a statement on 13th May. However, Jubbes’ position was a conciliatory one between the army independents and the Levellers, seeking even to bring ‘liberal presbyterians’ into an agreement.

Cromwell was presiding at Putney again as November began, and he began by inviting those present to speak of any divine prompting that they had received in answer to their prayers, and this was an unintended invitation to those, not just the Levellers, to express their beliefs that God had abandoned their cause because their leaders in parliament continued to sin against him by trafficking with the king. In particular, Captain Bishop gave powerful testimony that God’s answer to his prayers had been that they were all guilty of…

… compliance to preserve that man of blood, and those principles, which God from heaven by his many successes given hath manifestly declared against.

The King’s ‘Escape’ to Carisbrooke Castle:

This scriptural image of Charles as a ‘man of blood’ was to gain even more potency with the outbreak of the second Civil War leading to a justification of his trial before parliament and subsequent execution. But, at this point, such responses were just the opposite of what Cromwell wanted to hear, and he let himself get drawn into a long altercation with Goffe in particular as to how far they could expect God to pronounce on detailed political matters. He also allowed a long and increasingly ill-tempered three-sided exchange of views to develop between Ireton, Wildman and Rainborough, who differed so much in their principles that there was little chance of reconciling these views. Yet the General Council agreed to go on meeting daily until the proposals in front of it had been fully considered. But these sittings only generated more division, and the commanders became increasingly concerned about this. Charles had also given them fresh cause to be concerned about his intentions since he had given his word that he would not try to ‘escape’ from Hampton Court and, in return, he had been free to see whomever he pleased. However, on 30 October he withdrew his ‘parole’, resulting in a doubling of his guards. But it was impossible to foil a determined escape plan from the palace without making him a close prisoner within it, and that was politically unacceptable while he was still formally king and accorded royal honours.

What was more worrying, however, was the growing restlessness in the army. Leveller propaganda was making convertsand the new agents were claiming to have the support of sixteen regiments, including seven of foot. But not all the discontent was of their making since four hundred of Colonel Robert Lilburne’s mutinous foot soldiers were reported early in November to have declared for the king, and his was not the only regiment in which royalist sympathies rose to the surface. Probably more typical was a rising resentment against the agitators in perfectly loyal regiments due to the divisions they were causing and, in some cases, their overbearing attitude towards the ordinary soldiery. Whether such tensions were aroused by the original agitators or the new agents is not clear, but men who were not in direct touch with the proceedings at Putney may not have made the distinction. Fairfax was reliably reported to have received a petition from the majority of regiments, asking him to send their agitators back to them until he felt a need to summon them again, and undertaking to submit to him and his council of war according to the old and accustomed discipline of the army.

Oliver Cromwell by Robert Walker, circa 1649.

Within the General Council the generals’ hold on proceedings remained somewhat precarious. On 5 November, when Fairfax was well enough to preside again, and Cromwell had gone to the Commons, Rainborough secured the assent of the meeting to send a damaging letter to the Speaker alleging that the House had been induced to make further propositions to the king because it was told that the army wished it. The General Council declared that any such representation of the army’s desires was absolutely groundless. This was as good as to accuse Cromwell and Ireton of misrepresenting the army’s views to the House, so Ireton opposed the letter vehemently. When it was approved, he stormed out of the meeting, vowing not to return until it was recalled. The Levellers also went on pushing for another general rendezvous, and on the 6th, they pressed hard for a free debate on whether the king should be allowed to retain any powers. At the General Council’s next meeting two days later they seemed bent on confrontation over the franchise, and there was another protracted clash, but Fairfax and Cromwell had already decided that the General Council was being made a platform for those who sought to divide the army and take control of it, so that the long debate on the Agreement must be wound up.

The ‘grandees’ may also have had intelligence that the king was about to ‘bolt’, for it was during this weekend that Charles finally made up his mind to leave Hampton Court. So when the talks seemed to have run their course, Cromwell moved that since Fairfax intended to call the army to a rendezvous shortly, and because many distempers are reported to to be in the several regiments, the General Council should advise him to send the officer-representatives and the the agitators back to their regiments until he should see cause to summon them again. There is no record of any dissent, and Fairfax reported to the Speaker that the regimental representatives had unanimously offered to return the regiments and do all they could to restore discipline in them. To underline his support for his soldiers’ real interests, he accompanied their letter with a request to the Commons for the immediate disbursement of six weeks’ pay. When the full General Council met next day, it approved a letter to the Speaker, explaining that its previous one on the 5th was not intended to mean that the army was opposed to parliament’s sending any more propositions to the king. The generals were in control again, and it was announced on the same day that the promised rendezvous of the army was to be spread over three separate dates and places between 15th and 18th November.

The Leveller agents publicly denounced this as a base device to prevent the army from adopting their Agreement by general acclamation, and this was doubtless a consideration. But there were more compelling reasons for appointing three rendezvous, not least that Fairfax wanted to address each regiment in person, which could not be done in the course of one day. Moreover the regiments were now dispersed over a wide area, and to suddenly concentrated them in one place close to London would have not only set the political alarm bells ringing but caused much hardship to civilians. The Leveller agents, however, urged them in print to gather in a single rendezvous in defiance of orders. Nevertheless, the Agreement had been amended to include a substantial extension of the franchise, as proposed, to all soldiers and all others except servants and beggars. But Cromwell and Ireton made a perfectly-timed counter-attack. The old agitators repudiated the new programme; the generals reasserted their authority. On 8 November the agitators were sent back to their regiments, and the Army Council was adjourned for over a fortnight. The pattern established in June had now been dramatically reversed. Then the rank and file had held the initiative: the agitators had seized the king and the commanding officers had had to accept the situation at the general rendezvous at Newmarket as the only means of preserving the unity of the army. Now the rank and file were already divided and had lost the initiative, when the shattering news came that King Charles had escaped from army captivity.

On 11 November 1647 Charles had indeed escaped the custody of the New Model Army at Hampton Court. He had finally decided upon flight more than a week earlier, and he probably fixed the date on the 7th, before he had anything to fear from the army. Yet on the 9th he told Sir John Berkeley that he was in fear for his life, for he had received a letter that day warning him that eight or nine agitators had met the previous night and resolved to kill him. The writer, who signed himself ‘E.R.’, was almost certainly Lieutenant-Colonel Henry Lilburne, brother and second-in-command to Colonel Robert, but of a very different temper from either him or even his other brother John. Henry was shortly to declare for the king. There is some evidence of a shadowy plot among some of the Leveller agents to abduct the king, though not to assassinate him. Cromwell himself heard rumours of an attempt on the king’s person, and wrote at once to his cousin Colonel Whalley, who commanded the guards at Hampton Court to take special measures against this, for it would be accounted a most horrid act. But while it suited Charles to declare publicly that he fled because he feared for his life, he left a letter for Whalley, assuring him that this was not the case. His main reason, which he kept to himself, was to be free to negotiate with the Scottish commissioners without the surveillance of the army or parliament. When he set out from Hampton Court, he had no idea where he would head for, and neither did Cromwell, who had not yet given up hope of coming to terms with him, for only the day before his escape the Commons had put the finishing touches to a new set of peace propositions, based on the initiative of Cromwell’s independent allies.

The King had told the Scottish commissioners on the 9th that he was ready to make for Berwick, but he evidently changed his mind, and his companions Ashburnham and Berkeley gave him conflicting advice. In the end, he decided to decided to place his trust in Colonel Robert Hammond, another of Cromwell’s cousins, who had become increasingly unhappy about the army’s increasingly political role over the second half of 1647, and with Fairfax’s concurrence he had given up his regimental command in favour of what he hoped would be a quieter life as governor of the Isle of Wight. Hammond was utterly dumbfounded, therefore, when Berkeley and Ashburnham arrived at Carisbrooke Castle, his headquarters, and delivered the king into his hands. He immediately sent word to Cromwell, and despite his conflict of loyalties, he set a guard on his uninvited guest to prevent either kidnap or escape. Two days after his arrival he sent a request to parliament for a personal negotiation in London, on the basis of a three-year trial period for Presbyterianism, liberty of worship thereafter for all papists, and parliamentary control of the armed forces during his lifetime but not under his successors. That might have been a basis for a settlement eighteen months earlier, but he was now far less credible as a negotiator than he had been then.

This key locked the door to the king’s room at Carisbrooke Castle on the Isle of Wight. A laundry maid, Mary, smuggled letters in and out on the castle for the king. Charles sometimes used the secret code below for his letters.

Rendezvous & ‘Remonstrance’:

Meanwhile, on 15th, Fairfax held the first of the three scheduled rendezvous at Corkbush Field near Ware. He brought with him a new Remonstrance, issued in his name and that of his council of war, and prepared with the advice of a committee headed by Cromwell and Ireton but included several radical officers and agitators. It redefined the common objectives of the army, and it was hoped that by having it read to eat regiment, personally commended by Fairfax, and then subscribed by officers and men, unity and and discipline would be restored. But the Levellers had been busy preparing to use the occasion for their own purposes, and the generals must have feared that they would try to turn it into a general rendezvous and get the Agreement acclaimed instead of Fairfax’s Remonstrance. They soon found people distributing the former among the the troops and two former officers, Colonel William Eyre and Major Thomas Scott, haranguing them in support of it. The generals promptly had them arrested, but as soon as Fairfax appeared on the field he was confronted by a delegation headed by Rainborough, who presented him with the Agreement and a petition. Rainborough, no longer in the army, had no right to be there, and as a member of the House of Commons, he was also choosing openly to disregard its condemnation of the Agreement as destructive to the being of Parliaments, and to the fundamental government of the kingdom.

Seven regiments attended the first rendezvous at Corkbush Field near Ware by Fairfax’s commands; all greeted him with enthusiasm and readily subscribed his Remonstrance. Two others, Harrison’s and Lilburne’s, appeared on the field without orders and without their officers, except for Captain-Lieutenant Bray of Lilburne’s, the highest-ranked officer. He claimed that there was no visible authority in the Kingdom but the general … and the general was not infallible. Many of the men wore copies of the Agreement stuck in their hats, overwritten with the Leveller slogan, England’s freedom: soldiers’ rights! This was mutiny, but it swiftly collapsed. The defiant soldiers found themselves isolated, and they were met with uncompromising firmness. Officers of Fairfax’s staff rode in among them, snatching the papers and sea-green ribbons from their hats. Earlier in 1647 the Levellers had begun to mobilise mass petitions, often delivered by noisy crowds wearing the Leveller token of a sea-green ribbon in their hats. Cromwell was in no doubt at all that the Leveller agitations were undermining military discipline.

Robert Lilburne’s men, having marched twenty miles that day, arrived long after Harrison’s had been dealt with, and when a major tried to remonstrate with them they stoned and wounded him. Fairfax left them until he had reviewed the seven regiments present by his orders, but they must have heard the cheers that greeted his speeches throughout the day. Promises of arrears of pay were given, together with vague declarations about political reforms. Fairfax threatened to resign if these assurances were not accepted and if he did not receive a promise from each and every officer and soldier to obey his superiors in accordance with military discipline, and to abide by what the General Council determined with respect to public engagements. In return he pledged not only to fulfill all his duties as general, but also to further join with them in pressing for an early dissolution of parliament and the succession of future parliaments, elected by ‘equal representation’.

In the prevailing political circumstances nothing but surrender and submission was possible for the rebels. Encouraged by Bray and other agitators, there was a brief skirmish when Fairfax’s staff approached the two rebellious regiments, but when Cromwell and other officers drew their swords and charged at them, they soon fell into line and general discipline was swiftly asserted. Fairfax’s wisdom of holding separate rendezvous at which he could exploit his personal charisma to the full was now apparent after Ware. He had further successes at Ruislip Heath and Kingston in the following days, at which the regiments, two of which had been in a state of of incipient mutiny read the signs, toed the line and expressed a ready compliance and subjection. The Remonstrance was well calculated to restore the soldiers’ solidarity. It accused the new agents of acting, without any mandate from their regiments, as a ‘divided party’ from the General Council, under the direction of non-members of the army. This represented a resetting and a reafirmation of what the army had stood for in its pre-Agreement manifestoes of the previous June. All the regiments, including the lately mutinous ones, gave Fairfax the promises he demanded. This also marked a rejection, not of the basic principles of the Leveller movement, but of its recent tactics.

Considering how serious the threat of mutiny had been in the New Model at this point, its perpetrators were dealt with remarkably leniently, especially by the standards of early modern armies. On Corkbush Field, eight or nine ringleaders in Lilburne’s regiment were court-martialled on the spot and sentenced to death by firing squad, but Fairfax pardoned all but three, who were then allowed to draw lots for their lives. Only the one loser was shot, so that instead of the Agreement being read at the head of each regiment, Private Richard Arnold was shot at the head of his. The Levellers made made much of him as their first martyr. and when the eight others, including Bray, were taken into custody for future trial, the London Levellers campaigned and demonstrated vociferously for their release, leading to further arrests. In addition to those mentioned above, those arrested included William Everard, William Thompson, eleven in all. Their trials by court-martial were delayed, the last being held on 23 December, and when they proceeded, there was an unwillingness to judge harshly men who, however mistaken in their actions, had acted out of conviction. Only two were condemned to death, and both were reprieved. Both Colonel Rainborough and Major White made contrition before the General Council, the former eventually being allowed to resume his commission in the Navy, and the latter being retored to the Council. Even Bray was allowed to resume his regimental duties after making due submission.

So ended the Leveller attempt to capture control of the army, but not the movement’s wider role in the future of the kingdom. In retrospect, it is clear that the recall and replacement of the agitators of the five cavalry regiments, apparently done on John Lilburne’s advice, was going much faster than the majority of the rank and file were prepared to follow. They were principally concerned with wages and indemnity, and royalist sentiments were also widespread among them, even within regiments otherwise known for their radicalism. The declarations of the new agitators show them to be consistently on the defensive, for as Wildman himself wrote later: Did not many regiments at Ware cry out for the King and Sir Thomas? Consternation over the current wave of Leveller demonstrations and the anxiety about the king’s activities made parliament look more kindly on the army. Cromwell received the thanks of the Commons for restoring order on 19 November, though Fairfax was ordered to withdraw his headquarters to Windsor. The General Council met intermittently for the next six weeks, but it had lost its purpose, was dominated by the grandees and faded out at the beginning of the New Year.

Getting the pay the army needed took a little longer than the expressions of goodwill from parliament, but the City began to open its purse-strings when Colonel Hewson pointedly drew up his regiment in Hyde Park, and a firmly worded representation from Fairfax and the General Council, on 7 December, concerning the army’s financial and other material needs, got parliament moving towards meeting them. Under the threat of having troops billeted on citizens who were defaulting on their assessment payments, measures were taken to put an end to free quarter and enough money was found to pay off the men who had enlisted since 6 August. Most of those still in service were fully paid during the next six months; provision was made for maimed soldiers, widows and orphans, and apprentices were assured that their time in the army would count as part of their term of service. Parliament was not under the same pressure to attend the king’s latest overtures, for it was plain to the clear-sighted that if he had been seriously intent on negotiating he would have stayed at Hampton Court to hear parliament’s new proposals. The Independent-dominated House of Lords responded first, and they wanted some binding pledges from him before parliament wouéd treat further. They therefore framed four propositions, for the Commons to convert into bills, intending that he should first give them statutory force by his assent before being brought to London for a personal treaty.

The Four Bills & Presbyterian Parleys with the King:

The first of these propositions gave parliament full control over all land and sea forces for the next twenty years, and made the king’s disposal of them thereafter subject to parliamentary consent. The second annulled all oaths, declarations, proclamations, and judicial proceedings against parliament and its members and supporters since the start of the war. The third cancelled all peerages granted since May 1642, and ruled that no peers made from that time on should sit in parliament without the consent of both Houses. The fourth empowered the present parliament to adjourn to any place in England that it chose, for as long as it saw fit. Annexed to the Four Bills, as they came to be called, were a set of propositions, intended as parliament’s further terms for a treaty, which included the abolition of episcopacy, the banning of the Book of Common Prayer, and the penalisation of the king’s supporters in the war on the lines of the Propositions of Newcastle. The Commons approved the Lord’s proposals by a mere nine votes, but then stalled on converting them into bills. The Independents, who were still prepared to restore the king on strict conditions, were almost balanced by a combination of Presbyterians who would have him back on easier terms and the ‘commonwealthmen’ who did not want him back on any terms. Charles sent Berkeley to Windsor to ask the army to intervene on his behalf, but his envoy was given a cool reception. Fairfax told him that they were the parliament’s army, and would have to refer his proposals there. The Four Bills, when eventually enacted, were presented to Charles on Christmas Eve, and he was given four days in which to reply.

The King’s cane handle in Carisbrooke Castle Museum

Somewhat ironically, being shut up in Carisbrooke Castle provided Charles with a kind of political liberty, since he was still allowed to entertain offers for his endorsement from the lowest bidders. They included the Scots, not the zealous Covenanters, but a critical element of the Scottish nobles who feared that the formidable New Model Army which had neutered the English Parliament would target them next, and thereby subject Scotland to a bedlam of sects which was already being unloosed, in their eyes, in England. The Scots also knew that, in his troubles, Charles was already becoming more popular than ever been during the eleven years of personal rule and the first Civil War. Lauderdale, Loudoun and Lanark arrived at Carisbrooke soon after the votes in the Commons, somewhat suspicious of Charles because he had not gone to Berwick, as promised. But they were anxious that he should not make peace with the English Parliament in which Scotland had no say. So they came to the Isle of Wight and made him the best offer he had yet received: In return for a trial period of three years of Presbyterianism in England and his voluntary acceptance of the Covenant, the Scots agreed to help Charles regain control of his kingdoms. He certainly wrung easier terms from them by pretending that he was about to assent to the Four Bills.

The political front with and in Scotland had been relatively quiet throughout most of 1647, when much of the country had been in the grip of a prolonged and deadly visitation of the plague. But the last of the Irish and the MacDonalds who had fought with Montrose had been savagely crushed, and there was no further resistance from the royalist party under Huntly. No enemies of the Covenant remained undrer arms, therefore, so the political arena was dominated by the rival Covenanting factions headed by Argyll and Hamilton. Both wanted to see the king restored in all his kingdoms, but until the summer Argyll’s and the Kirk’s party had successfully maintained that he must take and impose the Covenant. From August onwards, however, the prospect that the king might come to terms with an independent-dominated English parliament backed by the hated New Model Army swung the balance towards Hamilton’s party, and so still more did the personal danger which Charles was perceived to be in from the dissenters in the army. For the Scots, he was their king as much as he was England’s, and the view prevailed that that it was better he should owe his restoration to Scotland, even if his commitment to Presbyterianism fell far short of what the Scots’ leaders wanted than that he should regain his thrones on the ungodly basis of religious liberty, or to be prevented from regaining them at all. That, at least, was how Lauderdale and Lanark felt, though Loudon was full of misgivings.

In the end, all three signed a secret agreement with Charles, known as the ‘Engagement’, on 26th December, under which (also seen as a means to end the civil war in Scotland), the Scots’ army, together with a newly-raised royalist army from the North of England, would, if necessary, impose the settlement by force. Despite the distrust he inspired, the three Scots’ visits were not controlled by their leaders at home. Charles was still their king, and Scotland was still England’s ally as long as he was also its king. At this point, there was no real indication that this was about to change. Charles did not give much away in the Engagement, however, and although he agreed to confirm the ‘Solemn League and Covenant’ by act of parliament in both kingdoms, he only agreed to confirm a Presbyterian establishment in the Church of England for an experimental three years. After that, there would be a debate among the ‘divines’ of the Westminster Assembly, reinforced by twenty additional members named by himself and any others sent by the Kirk. In the light of these deliberations, the permanent form of government of the Church of England would then be settled by King and Parliament. He also promised his assent to acts of parliament for the suppression of all Independents, Baptists and seperatists of every kind, and for the punishment of blasphemy, heresy and schism.

Charles condemned the actions of Fairfax’s army since its refusal to disband, and all the propositions that had been sent to him thereafter without the Scots’ consent. He promised to endeavour a complete union of the kingdoms, and in return the Scots promised to secure a personal treaty in London, upon propositions mutually agreed between England and Scotland. If this was refused by the English parliament, Scotland would declare his right to control the armed forces and the Great Seal, and to bestow offices and honours and to veto acts of parliament; and ultimately, in order to restore him to his just rights would send an army into England. But the Scots had no chance of raising an army that could engage that of Fairfax and Cromwell with any hope of success; they would have to count on powerful risings in their support, but they were hardly likely to win the hearts and minds of ‘freeborn’ Englishmen by dictating in advance the solutions to such problems as the control of the armed forces, the appointment of ministers and the royal veto, and by closing the door to liberty of conscience. As for Charles, his calling in of a Scottish army before he had explored fully the possibility of negotiating a peaceful restoration with the English parliament and army, was the most disastrous decision of his life. If he had been in Berwick, with a reasonable chance of escaping abroad if his champions were defeated, the gamble would have been less reckless, though he would still have lost his temporary popularity by plunging the two kingdoms into bloodshed again.

Over Christmas there were riotous demonstrations for king and church, for the old Anglican religion, almost amounting to insurrections, in Canterbury, Ipswich, and other towns, while in London Christmas decorations appeared defiantly in churches and other public places. Ejected clergymen resumed their pulpits and used the Prayer Book services, and royalist newspapers and pamphlets appeared freely on the bookstalls. But these were mostly symptoms of a widespread nostalgia for the old days of peace rather than of any general willingness to go to war again, and Charles failed to exploit this discontent by not displaying a more straightforward disposition towards a peace settlement. Next Charles attempted to escape by sea from his island ‘open prison’ but the wind was aginst him. As a result, his guards were redoubled and Vice-Admiral Rainborough, taking up his Naval commission on 1st January, was posted to guard the Solent. Charles lost the company of his friends Berkeley, Ashburton and Legge. In the Commons there was a move to impeach him on 3rd January, and to settle the kingdom without him. For most MPs that was a step too far, but it did pass a ‘Vote of No Address’, declaring that it would send no more overtures to the king and would receive none from the king. Anyone else caught attempting to treat with him would be charged with high treason. But in passing this, the ‘party of royal independents’ was seriously split, as was its alliance with the army high command, which had produced the most statesmanlike proposals for a lasting peace settlement.

The Outbreak of the Second Civil War:

The threat of the King once more in arms reunited the factious elements in the Parliamentarian camp and the New Model returned to duty. The hard-won peace was lost and the stage was now set for the second Civil War, but once again there were serious disagreements ongoing within the two Houses as to what parliament’s war aims would now be, and still wider differences between them and the army. With the Scots’ intentions uncertain, and the Irish rebels still undefeated, the army needed to close ranks. Moreover, the Levellers articulated only one strain of radical idealism in the English Revolution of the 1640s, whether in London, the counties or the army. Independent and sectarian congregations were growing rapidly in all three, and it was widely believed among them that the victory God had granted to his ‘saints’ in the recent war heralded the prophesied overthrow of the Antichrist, and that to seek its ‘fruits’ in the secular ideas of the Agreement was at the best to be distracted from Divine Truth and at the worst to succumb to blasphemy. To such believers, Leveller democracy was a dubious basis for a holy commonwealth. Just after Fairfax finished reviewing the army in November, the gathered churches of London had published a declaration which bore the names of some of the best known Independent and Baptist ministers, including Rainborough’s own pastor. A key passage in it alluded to the Levellers’ policies and their propogation in the army:

Since there is also much darkness remaining in the minds of men, as to make them call evil good, and good evil; and so much pride in their hearts as to make their own wills a law, not unto themselves only but unto others also; it cannot but be very prejudicial to to human society, and the promotion of the good of commonwealths, cities, armies or families, to admit of a party, or all to be equal in power. … the ranging of men into several and subordinate ranks and degrees is a thing necessary for the common good of men.

This may also have been the position of Hewson’s regimental chaplain, Henry Pinnell, who in December 1647 defended the Agitators to Cromwell’s face and in 1648 wrote A Word of Prophecy concerning The Parliament, Generall and the Army. Under Hewson’s command, the formally radical regiment remained loyal to the senior commanders, while others supported the Levellers. Unpopular though the military presence was due to its cost, neither parliament nor the army could be justly accused of keeping up larger forces than the circumstances warranted. During the early months of 1648 no fewer than twenty thousand soldiers had been disbanded with two months’ pay. The axe fell mainly on the provincial forces, especially those in Wales and the borders, many of whose officers had had been in sympathy with the attempted presbyterian counter-revolution of the previous summer. It looked as though they might join in a general mutiny against their disbandment, but firm measures by Fairfax stifled it. There were further mutinies in February, led by former agitators, but they were easily dealt with. On 22nd February 1648, following a soldier petition to Fairfax, Hewson expressed a view about the Levellers which was typical of the ‘grandees’:

We have had tryal enough of the Civil Courts; we can hang twenty before they will hang one.

The war itself was an incoherent affair. Charles and the Scots had hoped that his English and Welsh supporters would rise in arms simultaneously with a Scottish incursion, for they knew that their only real chance against the New Model ‘veterans’ lay in diverting and dividing it by co-ordinated insurrections in several parts of southern Britain. But the king was still a captive on the Isle of Wight, and had no real means of marshalling his followers nationwide. The Scots did not have an army in the field until July, long after the series of separate royalist risings in southern England and Wales had already been defeated. The garrisons of most defended towns and castles in England and Wales were discharged, and Colonel Lambert (pictured below) was now in charge of the remaining forces in northern England, following the disbandment of the Northern Association. The New Model itself was slimmed down to about twenty-four thousand men, losing nearly four thousand, less than parliament itself had recently legislated for. Divisions among the king’s erstwhile supporters in the Celtic kingdoms held up the construction of a significant force for his cause in the north.

In April 1648, having lost the debate within the regiment, as the Levellers had within the army as a whole, and as the Second Civil War approached, Major Jubbes laid down his sword and took up the pen. He was disillusioned with the course the revolution was taking, believing that Cromwell was diverting the cause of liberation, but he seems to have been equally saddened by Leveller support for mutinies in the army and violent revolution involving military dictatorship. The war had encouraged Major Jubbes’ pacifist views, and he came to see a real conflict between, in his words, the slavery of the sword and a Christian peace. Opposed to the war in Ireland and saddened by the suppression of the Levellers, Jubbes pressed for political change from outside the army. He became associated with a group of London radicals who were more moderate than the Levellers. His social radicalism was linked to millennarian ideas which he shared with the Fifth Monarchists. The first two political documents of the millennarian cause originated in Norwich, Jubbes’ home town, and addressed issues on which he had expressed his views within the army. Jubbes was replaced as Lieutenant Colonel by Daniel Axtell, with John Carter becoming Major.

Lieutenant-Colonel Daniel Axtell

During April and May 1648, the military situation facing Parliament gave considerable cause for concern. Revolts on behalf of the King had occurred in South Wales, Kent and Essex, and there had also been a mutiny in the Navy. From Essex, two thousand men had marched on Westminster on 4 May with a petition bearing ten times their number in names, calling for the king to be treated with and the army to be disbanded. In Kent, the spark which lit the powder keg was the sitting of a special commission at Canterbury on 10th and 11th May to try the Christmas rioters. More seriously, on the 16th, three thousand armed men from Surrey brought another petition to Westminster Hall. Fairfax still had two regiments in the capital to guard the parliament, and they were called in. The result was a violent encounter in which half a dozen petitioners were killed and many more were wounded. Fairfax was able to deal with these threats in turn and he was supported by a strong framework of Parliamentarian garrisons in north Wales, the north of England and the Midlands. Kent, Surrey and Essex were still in an explosive condition as Cromwell headed for south Wales.

Westminster Hall, still standing as part of the Palace of Westminster (Houses of Parliament) today.

Whilst Fairfax had had to delay his march northwards against the expected Scottish invasion in order to successfully drive the rebels back into their homes, the bolder spirits among them held a large gathering at Rochester on the 22nd, supported by many of the local gentry. They appointed a general rendezvous at Blackheath on the 30th, hoping to be joined there by equal numbers from Essex. They were encouraged when many of the warships around the eastern coasts declared for the king, many of the Kentish sailors also being disgusted by Rainborough’s appointment as Vice-Admiral. The crew of his flagship mutinied while he was ashore, preventing him and his family from coming aboard. Nine ships were defying parliament within days of the outbreak of the rebellion, and they were soon joined by others, enabling the Kentishmen to secure all the maritime castles with the exception of Dover. The insurgents lacked as yet an authorised military leader, and since the king was a captive it fell to the exiled court of the queen and the Prince of Wales to commission one. Their choice as commander of all the king’s forces in England was the Earl of Holland, a courtier who had changed sides twice but was still a favourite of Henrietta Maria. He appointed the veteran Earl of Norwich, Goring’s father, to command the Kentish forces. He was hardly the ideal man to reconcile the divergent aspirations of the seasoned cavaliers and of the majority who had risen primarily to reassert the rights and interests of their county community, but his leadership was accepted and he exercised it vigorously.

By the end of May, Norwich had about eleven thousand men under arms, and there was a great fear in London of a concerted atack from both north and south of the Thames. But Norwich’s troops were widely scattered, and Fairfax frustrated their planned rendezvous by occupying Blackheath himself. From there, he advanced with about four thousand men against Maidstone, where Norwich found himself dangerously outnumbered. While Cromwell supervised the campaign in Wales, Fairfax fought his way into Maidstone on 31st May in a tough fight before he dislodged the royalists, and then crossed to Essex to besiege Colchester, leaving Hewson’s regiment to ‘mop up’ the rest of Kent. Norwich tried to maintain his advance to Blackheath, but finding his road to London blocked, he ferried his remaining three thousand men across the Thames into Essex and set about raising that county. Colonel Hewson himself was commended for his valour and resolution when the regiment bore the brunt of the fighting at the storming of Maidstone. Fairfax wrote of the valour and resolution of Col. Hewson, whose Regiment had the hardest task, Major Carter being injured and Captain Price slain. Hewson and Axtell were voted a hundred and a hundred and fifty pounds respectively by parliament in recognition of this service. With Rich’s regiment, they suppressed the rising in Kent and recaptured the castles of Deal, Walmer and Sandown. But Rich’s regiment had reappointed its agitators, who petitioned for the Agreement once more: they were forcibly dispersed by their officers. By judicious manoeuvring the generals retained control before the Second Civil War broke out in earnest.

James Hamilton, Duke of Hamilton, after Van Dyck.

As the Engagement became better publicised during the Spring, hundreds of English royalists and reformadoes arrived in Scotland to offer their services. With their help, Berwick and Carlisle were occupied for the king on 28-29 April by Sir Marmaduke Langdale and Sir Philip Musgrave respectively. But it was not until 4 May, when the war had already begun in Wales, that the Scottish Parliament ordered the raising of an army of 27,750 foot and 2,760 horse. The Covenanting army was to be absorbed into it, but its commander David Leslie refused to serve for an uncovenanted king. Hamilton was then named as general. Meanwhile, Fairfax sent Colonel Horton with a small mixed force to Wales, to ensure that Laugharne’s troops disbanded according to orders, but Horton found most of them defiant; many wore papers in their hats reading ‘We long to see our king’. He engaged them at St Fagans near Llandaff on 8 May, the first clash of arms of the second war, beating them soundly; but it took larger forces to retake Pembroke Castle and subdue south Wales. Cromwell was already on the way to join him with three regiments of foot and two of horse. By this time there were clear signs that the Scots were raising an amy, and the northern royalists’ seizure of Berwick and Carlisle confirmed that an invasion was not far away. English counties petitioned parliament to readmit the king to a personal treaty, and although this was unrealistic, given the king’s obvious determination to regain what he had lost by force, the Commons did vote by 165 to 99 that they would not alter the fundamental government of the kingdom, by King, Lords and Commons, though they were already thinking of replacing Charles with his youngest son, the Duke of Gloucester. ‘That man of blood’, as Charles had first been named at Putney, had, in many eyes, foreited his right to rule by renewing warfare against his people, but they had not yet concluded that the monarchy should be abolished.

We also need to be wary of believing that the grandees and officers embarked on the second Civil War with the aim of putting the king on trial for his life. We do not know when Cromwell made up his mind that Charles was no longer fit to be king, but it was almost certainly not in the Spring of 1648. The republican soldier and MP, Edmund Ludlow, wrote an account of a conference that Cromwell held at his London residence between those called the grandees of the the House and Army, just before his Welsh campaign, in which Cromwell and his fellow-officers…

… kept themselves in the clouds, and would not declare their judgements either for a monarchical, aristocratical or democratical government; maintaining that any of them might be good in themselves, or for us, according as providence should direct us.

It would have been unlike Cromwell to presume to judge the intentions of providence until after the outcome of the war that lay ahead. One continuing difference was as to whether it was the army’s business to promote a just secular settlement of the kingdom and leave the matters of religion to the individual conscience, or whether its primary mission was to advance the interests of the people of God. The Levellers were among those who sought to prescribe a political role for it, and though Fairfax’s triumph at the three rendezvous in November had checked their influence, it had not erased it, as the events of Spring 1648 had revealed.

Theatres of War – Essex, Wales, Lancashire & Scotland:

Essex was the main theatre of war in June, but rebellion was threatened from so many quarters from mid-May that the generals’ forces were fully stretched, and it was well for parliament that, by the beginning of June, their loyalty was unassailable. In Bury St Edmunds there was a riot when some revellers tried to set up a maypole, after which some six hundred armed men took ver the town on 13th, shouting ‘For God and King Charles’. The trained bands dispersed them next day, but Colonel Whalley was sent in the next day to keep East Anglia quiet. Royalist meetings at nearby Rushbrooke Hall and Newmarket continued to arose anxiety, and there was another scare over a royalist plot to seize King’s Lynn. In June, there were reports of widespread disaffection in the Fens, the old parliamentarian heartlands, where the gentry had been dismayed by the rapid rise of radical independency, leading to them feeling equivocal if not outright hostile towards parliament. Royalism of an older kind was raising its head in Devon and Cornwall; Fairfax had sent Hardress Waller there, and he had to suppress rebellions there during June. The king’s supporters in Herefordshire were preparing to rise in support of the expected Scottish invasion, and some northern royalists under Langdale’s oders seized Pontefract Castle on 1st June. Cromwell sent some small detachments to to deal with disaffection in Shropshire, Cheshire and north Wales. However, lacking siege guns, Pembroke Castle held out against him until 11 July.

So when Fairfax set about reducing the County of Essex in June he had units of his army operating in six widely separated parts of England and Wales, and there was a serious danger of the conflagration spreading across East Anglia if he did not deal with it swiftly. The Essex rising got under way when some of the county militia were joined by Sir Charles Lucas commanding the royal forces in the county and Norwich, at Chelmsford with the Kentishmen. Together, they made for Colchester, the county town, where they set about organising its defences. Fairfax arrived before it on 12th June and summoned it to surrender the next day. When the defenders refused, he tried to storm it; but they withstood his assault through a fierce fight that lasted until midnight, with considerable losses on both sides. Fairfax’s troops were not overwhelming, so he faced a long siege; he had about nine thousand against four thousand defenders, but his troops also included local troops from Essex and Suffolk. The siege was conducted in unusual hardship and with harshness and mutual bitterness unlike any of the sieges in the first civil war. The experience of it on the parliamentarian side heightened the feeling that the king had wilfully renewed the bloodshed in the teeth of God’s judgement.

Above. The small round holes in the timbers of this house in Colchester were made by musket balls fired at the house by parliamentarian musketeers when they besieged the town in 1648.

Colchester was only fifty miles from London, and while Skippon could be counted on to hold the trained bands firm, the City government was downright unfriendly, the Lords were equivocal and the Commons were wavering. Early in June the the latter revoked their votes expelling the eleven impeached members, some of whom resumed their seats. The Tower and its garrison were back under presbyterian command, and on 19 June a train of wagons carrying munitions for the army through London was attacked and overturned by gangs of apprentices. Holland and the Duke of Buckingham were mustering the royalists of Surrey close to the capital, as part of an ambitious plan in which the warships which had gone over to the king were to sail up the Thames with the Prince of Wales and troops and munitions from France on board. But they were put to rout at Kingston on 5 July by a mixed force of Kentish levies and regulars, Buckingham’s son being killed and Holland taken prisoner. Holland was held captive at Warwick Castle, pending trial, but the Lords ordered, through their Speaker, Manchester, that he be handed over to their custody. Fairfax refused this command, which so incensed the peers that they actually entertained a motion to revoke his commission, though they did not pass it. In the span of the next week, three key events in the war occured in quick succession: the Scottish army crossed into England, the leaders of the insurrection in south Wales and the remaining royalists of the south-east were bottled up in Colchester.

On 8 July a Scottish army of six thousand infantry and three thousand cavalry, under the command of the Duke of Hamilton, crossed the border. Three days later Cromwell was able to switch his army from Wales to the north to support the 3,500 under John Lambert who had been charged with delaying the Scottish advance. This was a timely move, for although Lambert had been joined by 2,700 Lancashire troops under Ralph Assheton. Hamilton had also been joined by seven thousand more Scots and 3,500 men under Sir Marmaduke Langdale. Lambert evacuated Penrith on 14 July, falling back into Yorkshire in the expectation that the Scots would advance down the eastern side of the Pennine Hill chain. Hamilton, however, chose to advance down its western side through Cumbria and Lancashire, and Lambert lost touch with the enemy. Cromwell finally met up with him at Wetherby on 12 August before marching on to Preston, in the hope of cutting across the Scottish line of advance or of taking it in flank. Due to the heavy rain and the daily need to forage for supplies, Hamilton’s column of march became over-extended as the Scots pushed southwards. When Cromwell’s troops made contact with Langdale’s rearguard on 16 August, the Scottish infantry had barely reached Preston, while their horse were sixteen miles (26k) further south at Wigan, and their artillery was still far to the north.

Langdale warned Hamilton of the danger threatening the army’s eastern flank, but the Duke dismissed the Parliamentarian presence as a mere reconnaissance in force. On 17 August, Langdale’s Regiments stood to arms at dawn and fell back to within two miles of Preston. Sir Marmaduke posted his musketeers and pikemen in the enclosures on the west of Ribbleton Moor where the hedges and soft boggy ground made it difficult for the opposition to manoeuvre. It was not until 4 pm that the Parliamentarian regiments were finally deployed. When attacked the Royalists stood their ground well, and a fierce struggle ensued from hedge to hedge. As Langdale’s troops were gradually pushed clear of the enclosures, Cromwell’s Horse cut into the flanks and the withdrawal developed into a rout. While Langdale’s men fell or were captured, the Scottish foot continued southwards over Preston bridge, putting the Ribble between themselves and the persuing parliamentarians. Once Cromwell had cleared Preston of royalists his men stormed the bridge, driving in the defending Scottish brigades. The next bridge to fall was that crossing the Darwen, but by then it was entirely dark and fighting petered out.

The Battle of Preston painted by Charles Cattermole (1800-68). The original Walton Bridge, shown here, no longer stands and the new bridge is about fifty yards (46 metres) upstream. The Darwen Bridge has also been replaced although the present bridge stands almost exactly on the site of the old.

Hamilton’s army had escaped, though five thousand royalists had been killed or captured in the process. During the night the Scottish infantry attempted to link up with their cavalry which was now returning to Preston, but as the two bodies were moving towards each other on different roads, the first troops encountered by the cavaliers were Cromwell’s. After a running fight along the Standish road, the Scottish cavalry were at last reunited with their infantry on Wigan Moor. With his army disintegrating around him, Hamilton rode off with the horse leaving the foot to surrender at Warrington. The news of their victory hastened the surrender of Colchester, whose defenders were already preparing themselves for the inevitable. Fairfax had not tried to storm the town, though its decaying walls offered no such challenge as Bristol’s fortifications had done. Only three of his regiments were from the New Model; the others were recently recruited in Essex and Suffolk. He neither wanted nor needed to incur further casualties. Once all the other royalist movements south of the Trent had been suppressed, the Colchester garrison was isolated, and it posed no threat unless a Scottish army came to its relief. Fairfax’s persistence with the siege shows that he had strong confidence in Cromwell’s capacity to deal with Hamilton.

Sir Thomas Fairfax by John Hoskins.

The terms of surrender demanded by Fairfax at Colchester were hard, and reflect the change in the army’s attitude towards the royalist insurgents compared with the besieged garrisons of 1645-46. Both senior and junior regimental officers were granted quarter for their lives, but many of the men were sent to the West Indies as indentured servants. The townsfolk were made to pay a fine of eleven thousand pounds to prevent their city from being sacked. The fate of the commanders was decided by Fairfax’s council of war. As peers, Norwich, Capel and Hastings were sent to London to be judged by parliament, but Lucas, Lisle and Gascoigne were sentenced to military execution, though the latter was reprieved as a foreigner. Lucas and Lisle were shot the same evening. This was entirely within the rules of war as they stood, since not only had they refused the earlier summons, but both men had been made prisoners in the first war and had been released on their parole not to fight again, and Lucas was reported to the council of war as having himself ordered the slaughter of between twenty and forty men of a surrendered garrison. Hamilton, Holland and Capel were executed in front of Westminster Hall six months later, sentenced by an unconstitutional ‘High Court of Justice’ set up by the Rump Parliament. Norwich was also sentenced to death, but was reprieved by the Commons on the casting vote of the Speaker.

The immediate reaction at Westminster to the news of Cromwell’s victory at Preston was to repeal the ‘Vote of No Addresses’. Both Houses did this on 24 August, even before Colchester had surrendered and while men were still in arms for the king in Carlisle, Berwick, Pontefract and other northern fortresses, and while the Prince of Wales was still preparing to sail up the Thames. Cromwell may well have wondered why Charles was thought to be fitter to be treated with after all he had done to renew the warfare than he had been before it restarted, but for the time being he put his responsibilities as a soldier before those of a politician. In spite of his cavalry being so exceedingly battered as I never saw in my life and his infantry shattered… all to pieces, he sent Lambert off with 3,400 men in pursuit of Hamilton and led the rest of his forces in a vain attempt to cut off the retreat of Monro’s brigade into Scotland. The fragments of the Scottish army still at large in England were hunted down by Lambert and the local parliamentarian commanders, and Hamilton was captured at Uttoxeter on the 25th. Cromwell had to deal with nearly ten thousand prisoners as he carried the pursuit into Scotland. He also had to reduce Carlisle and Berwick, which were still being held in the name of the Scottish committee of estates. He had lost fewer than a hundred men killed, though many more were wounded, and together with Lambert, he had waged a brilliant campaign. On arriving in the borders, he judged the situation in Scotland to be so unsettled as to call for military intervention.

The Civil Wars in Scotland, showing siege and battle sites.

On hearing of Hamilton’s defeat, those regions who had been most hostile to the ‘Engagement’, especially Ayrshire and Clydesdale, rose in open revolt, and Galloway soon joined in. Loudoun and the other noblemen of Argyll’s party led the insurgents, in company with Leven and David Leslie, and Argyll himself was not long in joining them. Several thousand men were soon on the march towards Edinburgh, as what became known as the ‘Whiggamore Raid’ threatened to develop into a full-scale Scottish civil war. But the ‘Engagers’ had Monro’s brigade and some other straggling forces with which to shield themselves, and on 12 September they defeated the westerners at Linlithgow and then established themselves at Stirling. In mid-September, Argyll begged Cromwell not to cross the border until they invited him, promising that Berwick and Carlisle would promptly be surrendered. But in Cromwell’s view there were still too many Engagers still under arms for it to be safe to hold back, and he may have known that the pro-Stuart nobility in the north were arming to support them. The committee of estates was now badly split; Argyll’s ‘party’ sat in Edinburgh and on 4 October it renewed an act debarring all Engagers from from public office. That same day, Cromwell entered Edinburgh and eventually convinced Argyll’s committee that it needed English support, leaving some troops behind to help defend the capital. This task was entrusted to Lambert who, with two cavalry regiments and two companies of dragoons, remained there as unwelcome guests for a month.

The Treaty of Newport:

In England, meanwhile, the two major events of September were the opening of the promised negotiation between the king and fifteen commissioners of parliament in the town hall of Newport on the Isle of Wight, and the return of the Levellers to political activity after they had observed while the war lasted. In the summer of 1648 Henry Marten and Lt.-Col. William Eyres had raised a regiment of cavalry volunteers for the people’s freedom against all tyrants whatsoever. The rustics of Berkshire… the basest and vilest of men rushed to enlist, according to Brailsford. They hoped to level all sorts of people, even from the highest to the lowest. But once the second war was won, this private force was incorporated within the army and neutralised. More significant, beginning on 18th September, was the treaty of Newport, as it came to be known. It was scheduled to run for no more than forty days, but in its anxiety to come to terms parliament let it run well beyond its appointed limit. During his annihilation of the Stuart loyalist insurgents, Cromwell seems to have developed his own infuriated conviction that Charles had defied the judgement of Providence by his household’s call to arms in a second civil war, and that the monarchy may have to go. Whether he thought that Charles had to die, even at this point, was quite another matter. After all, there was little point with the Prince of Wales still at large and a whole collection of healthy Stuarts exiled in France and Holland as potential successors.

Charles I and James, Duke of York by Sir Peter Lely, c.1647.

It was when the the parliamentary Presbyterians realised that the trial of the king was now a distinct possibity that they hastened to pre-empt it by sending their deputation to Newport. But Charles continued to believe that he could continue to exploit the deep differences between between parliament and the army, that one or the other would need him to prevail. Periodically, he also lost himself in a reverie, meditating on his coming martyrdom, confident that his son would succeed him. So Charles was increasingly prepared, even eager, to deliver himself to his fate, convinced that his death would wipe clean his transgressions and follies, excite popular revulsion and guarantee the throne for his son. The English people are a sober people, however at present under some infatuation, he wrote to the Prince of Wales.

Charles, Prince of Wales, studio of Adriaen Hannerman, c. 1648-49. A rare portrait of the young prince during his early exile in the Low Countries.

He was sure that they would soon recover from this dangerous delirium. On the other side of the extensive negotiations, the presbyterians were relatively easy on the political terms, but pressed Charles I hard to accept the recently completed parliamentary religious settlement, while the independents Saye and Vane were stricter on the constitutional restraints but strove for the relative religious liberty envisaged in the ‘Heads of the Proposals’. But although Charles continued to play his old game of exploiting their divisions, he was weary of being a prisoner and aware of the danger to his life. As time went on he made larger concessions than he had before, as he admitted in a letter to a confidant on 9 October:

To deal freely with you, the great concession I made this day – the church, militia, and Ireland – was made merely in order to my escape, of which if I had not hope, I would not have done; … for my only hope is that now they believe I dare deny them nothing, as so be less careful of their guards.

The Frontispiece to the Elison Basilika (1649) of Charles I.

Ireton, Fairfax & the Levellers’ Return:

There were many aspects to the new negotiations that followed the second war. The moderate ‘Presbyterians’ in the English parliament still believed that compromise with the king was possible. The more radical ‘Independents’, including the Levellers, continued to press for sweeping changes not only to the political system, but to society at large. Believing that a judgement of God had been delivered on Charles, many of the independents in the Army sought justice and/or vengeance for the blood spilled in the wars. The Levellers were not yet finished as a threat to the ‘grandees’, though no longer a serious military one. Through the second civil war, the Moderate continued to voice the programme set out the year before in The Agreement of the People, as well as to point fingers at ‘backsliders’ and ‘adventurers’ in parliament. Astonishingly, some of the Leveller leaders even began to make contact with the king in the hopes of of persuading him to become a patron of their ‘household democracy’.

After Charles’s double defeat, Ireton grafted some of their principal demands – the abolition of the House of Lords and the monarchy, and annual parliaments – on to his own official proposals for republican government. They themselves opened their new campaign just before the start of the Newport treaty, with a comprehensive petition To The Commons of England in Parliament Assembled. It was more moderate in tone than most of their previous manifestos and it dwelt on the many things that the people had hoped for from the parliament’s victory but had yet to obtain. It reiterated most of the familiar objectives, but it was again silent on the contentious question of the franchise, and in wishing that the Commons had declared what the duty or business of the kingly office is, and what not, it seemed to envisage the continuance of the monarchy in some attenuated form. It repudiated the common charge of levelling by advocating a paramount and irreversible law against abolishing property, levelling men’s estates, or making all things common. In contrast with the extreme hostility with which they had received earlier Leveller addresses, the Commons thanked the petitioners for their care for the public good of the kingdom and promised to take their desires into early and serious consideration. Fairfax soon received letters in support of the petition from several outlying regiments, and from early October a wave of petitioning spread over the army.

The title page of an anti-radical tract. Moderates, horrified by the extremism engendered by the war, struggled to make their voices heard.

A great deal of responsibility fell upon Ireton during the autumn, because Fairfax was often uncertain as to how to act in the circumstances and Cromwell was in Scotland until 10 October, and then in the north of England until the end of November. Edmund Ludlow, who who had a footing in both army and parliament and saw what was going on from inside the House, tried hard to get the army to stop the Newport negotiations from proceeding. He rode down to headquarters early in September to warn Fairfax that the projected treaty was likely to betray the cause that they had fought for, indeed that those who pressed it were aiming to destroy the army altogether, and that the king would not would not feel himself bound by any promises that he made because he would regard them as made under duress. Fairfax acknowledged what Ludlow said to be true, but did not feel that he had the power to intervene. Ludlow took him to be irresolute, but it would be truer to say that he was torn between conflicting loyalties and duties. As always he felt obliged to his men, who, as usual when parliament was in a hostile mood, were being starved of their pay. But Fairfax was unwilling to show direct force towards parliament, and was deeply unsympathetic to the demand in parts of the army that the king should be brought to trial and the kingdom settled without him.

After failing to convince Fairfax, Ludlow talked with Ireton, who agreed that the army would have to intervene, but differed about the timing. He thought it would be better to wait until the king and parliament had come to terms, so that the army would gain more popular support when time came to act. At some point before the end of September, Ireton became so frustrated with Fairfax’s refusal to intervene that he tendered the resignation of his commission. But Fairfax would not accept it, and Ireton changed his mind about leaving the army, though he did withdraw from headquarters for a time to work out what should be done. He became fully convinced that that the army must take full control of the situation, terminating the negotiations at Newport, bringing the king to trial and securing fresh elections for an entirely new parliament.

(…to be continued… sources to be listed later)

Between Civil Wars: The Search for a Settlement, 1646-47 – Losing the Peace.

013
The First Civil War to 1647.

The Continuing Conflict across the British Isles:

The king’s surrender at Newark in the early summer of 1646, while effectively ending the first civil war, did little to clarify matters in Wales or Ireland. Harlech did not surrender until March 1647 and the royalist governor of Dublin surrendered the city to parliament in July. The Scots expanded their enclave in Ulster at the expense of both the Confederates and the royalists. But the Confederates continued to control most of the countryside and royalist garrisons most of the towns. The English Parliament had more pressing problems, however, in searching for and securing a settlement with the king which would satisfy all its own political factions, the New Model Army and Scottish army, still in the field, and, of course, Charles himself. For the time being, Ireland was left to its own devices, so that conflict continued into the autumn.

Diverse Ideas and Identities in Religion & Politics:

In mainland Britain, the political divergences within the parliamentarian ranks, and the gap between the war aims of English and Scots, resulted in their jointly presenting the king with harsher terms than he could reasonably have expected to submit to, while Charles was so dominated by his conviction that God would not let rebels prosper, and that to give up any of his regal powers would be a sin, that his mind was closed to to honourable terms even when (belatedly) they were offered to him. He never gave up the the hope of somehow renewing the war and winning it. Meanwhile, the main line of political division at Westminster continued to lie between the presbyterians and independents, but since the chief plank of the independents’ platform had been to fight the war to a successful conclusion, their ascendancy was much less secure after it was won. The New Model Army, their creation, was still their ally, but it was the principal cause of continuing high taxes, and a large reduction in its size became a popular policy. It was eagerly taken up by the presbyterians, for whom it, and in particularly Cromwell, were increasingly regarded as their enemies. The popularity they enjoyed, especially in the City, as the party which sought to cut military power and expenditure, was however somewhat offset by their determination to deny of religious liberty to episcopalians, independents and sectaries alike.

The political independents were also more interested in genuine political reform, which would render the king’s rule permanently more accountable to the people’s representatives, so long as ‘the people’ were not too democratically defined. It was also something of a paradox that while the presbyterians were more anxious to see the king restored and the ‘war machine’ dismantled as soon as possible, they made strict demands regarding religion, the control of the armed forces and the appointment of the essential officers of state that were more unacceptable to Charles than those which the independents were prepared to offer. For Charles, this was a chink in his enemies’ armour that he was not slow to probe. He also knew that the Scots distrusted the independents to such an extent that they had been prepared to consider going over to his side, but it is remarkable that after all the months of Montreuil’s mission he still did not know the terms on which they would be willing to fight for him when he put themselves into his hands. They were amazed and delighted to have acquired so strong a bargaining chip as his royal person, but having demanded and obtained his order for the surrender of Newark, they took him back to Newcastle with them, where they treated him with little ceremony. He was very plainly their prisoner, and unless he would agree to impose the Westminster Assembly’s version of Presbyterianism on the enire English nation, that was how he would remain. Enduring weeks of instruction in the ‘true faith’ and much pressure to convert to it, he began to regret his surrender, and sent a request to Westminster that he be allowed to come and negotiate with parliament in person.
But the MPs were steadily uncovering for themselves the extent of the king’s intrigues with the Scots, the Irish and the French, as they went on unhurriedly preparing their own peace terms. Argyll, leading the Scots, saw a danger that the Englsh parliament might come to an agreement that left him and the Scots out in the cold, and he hastened to London to try to prevent it. Parliament’s peace propositions were ready when he got there and, though they fell short of the Covenenters’ full objectives for uniformity of religion throughout Britain, he and the Scottish commissioners accepted them without alteration. Scottish fears of a separate English peace, and English suspicions of a deal between Charles and the Scots were allayed. There was no question of inviting the king to Westminster, and the Propositions of Newcastle, as they soon became known, were carried north to him by commissioners in mid-July. The Propositions were drawn up on the assumption that, as a prisoner, defeated in war, Charles had no choice but to bow to the victors’ demands. He was asked to sign and swear to the Solemn League and Covenant, and to promise to pass acts requiring all his subjects in all three kingdoms to do the same.
King Charles I: a copy by David des Granges of John Hoskin’s minature, which was probably painted during Charles’s captivity at Hampton Court in 1647.
The small pointed beard was known as a Van Dyck beard, named after the famous painter.
His care-worn face is in stark contrast to the somewhat idealised pre-war portraits by Van Dyck. Hoskin’s miniature is held in the National Portrait Gallery.
In secular matters, parliament was to have sole control of the armed forces for twenty years, and the right to resume it at any point at a later time when the two Houses should declare the safety of the kingdom to be concerned. In twenty years Charles would be sixty-six, an age to which no English king had lived since Edward I. As for the king’s supporters, a long list of both English and Scots were to be excluded from pardon altogether, more were to be banned from the court and public office, and all active royalists were to lose varying proportions of their estates, from two-thirds downwards, according to the degree of their ‘deliquency’. But the radical limitations of the historic royal prerogative went far further than was necessary to prevent Charles from doing further damage to his kingdoms, and the savage penalties and prescriptions proposed for the beaten royalists might have been calculated to perpetuate divisions in the nation rather than heal them. Charles was understandably angered by the propositions, but he was warned by his advisors that if he was intransigent he might be deposed, so his formal reply was to request more time to consider them, and for a safe conduct to London so that he could negotiate in person. At the time, that was not a serious possibility, but it was the first move in a long stalling exercise from which he had much to gain. At Westminster, all the presbyterians and nearly all the independents wanted him back on his throne, and by playing them off against each other he stood a fair chance of securing easier terms. As for the Scots, the strict Covenanters were demanding a price he could never agree to pay, but Hamilton led a party of nobles and lairds who were prepared to fight for him without forcing his conscience.
James Hamilton, Duke of Hamilton, after Van Dyck.
In Ireland, meanwhile, Ormond’s treaty had set up a Supreme Council, which was at odds with the clerical party. There were three parties within the Confederation at this stage. Those who sought peace with the king in return for access to public office, and de facto religious toleration were mostly laymen and included most of the Old English ascendancy, though no sharp lines can be drawn between the Old English and the Old Irish nobility and gentry. They were intent on maintaining the king’s rights to his Irish kingdom, even if he went down to defeat in England, though they expected reasonable concessions in return for their loyalty. Opposed to them were the clerical party which took its cue from Rinuccini, the papal nuncio, though not all the bishops were equally willing to follow his lead, and O’Neill was not the only prominent layman to support him; others of the Old Irish interest did likewise, not only in Ulster, and so did a few ultra-catholic Old English. This party sought the full restoration of the catholic church in Ireland and an independent Irish parliament. Between these extremes was a third party whose leading figure was Nicholas Plunkett, a lawyer and third son of Lord Killeen, an Old English Lord of the Pale. A devout catholic, in the interests of unity, he and his group sought to moderate the positions assumed by the two other parties, and they held the balance of power. At first Plunkett supported the Ormond treaty, but eventually he gave his full backing to Rinuccini, seeing the greatest threat to Ireland in a total victory for the English parliament.
James Butler, Earl of Ormond, by Van Egmont.
In September the members of the Supreme Council who had supported the Ormond treaty were imprisoned, and a new Supreme Council of sixteen, chosen by the snod, was set up with Rinuccini as president. O’Neill fully accepted its authority, and supported the nuncoi’s plans to conquer the whole of Ireland, beginning with Dublin, by military force. Faced with that threat, and with the likely rejection of the king’s authority over Ireland that lay behind it, Ormond’s positon became intolerable. It would have been even more so if he had been aware that Charles had written to Glamorgan on 20th July, offering virtually to pawn his Irish kingdom in return for a large sum of money, and talking of coming over and putting himself in Glamorgan’s and Rinuccini’s hands. Nor did Ormond know that Rinuccini was manoeuvring to get him replaced as Lord Lieutenant by Glamorgan, who swore an oath to Rinuccini on 28th September. What he did know was that Charles had publicly repudiated that Glamorgan had concluded on his behalf the previous year. Faced with an imminent attack on Dublin by O’Neill’s forces, it is entirely understandable that Ormond, as a protestant and the senior Irish servant of the crown, could not contemplate surrendering the city to a body of catholic rebels directed by an Italian servant of the pope, whose aims for Ireland clashed directly with the real interests of his royal master, as well as those of the Old English ascendancy that he represented.

Ormond therefore applied to the English parliament for help in defending Dublin, and it sent commissioners to negotiate with him. Before they arrived, however, the city came under siege by the Confederate forces early in November. It was late in the year for campaigning, so O’Neill took his own troops into winter quarters. The immediate threat to Dublin collapsed, and the parliamentary commissioners began a negotiation with Ormond on 14th November. But when he found them unwilling to allow the king to be a party to a peace treaty, he broke it off and they retired to Ulster. Rinuccini’s policy was not only bound to alienate a considerable part of the population of Ireland, but it was militarily unrealistic, because he grossly underestimated the power that England could bring to bear against his forces once its own civil war was over. For their part, the Scots offered Charles little better prospect of armed assistance. Argyll’s party continued to enjoy greater support than that of Hamilton among the lairds, nobles and burgesses, and it also had the Kirk behind it. Since Charles persistently refused to impose Presbyterianism on his English subjects, it continued to regard him as a bargaining chip for securing payment of England’s debts for the maintenance of a Scottish army in England, which were continuing to mount.

The King’s Prospects, the Army, Parliament & the City:

Charles came to see little prospect in his current situation beyond a possible change of gaolers, and from the early summer onward he began to plan an escape to France or Holland. To keep parliament interested in a possible negotiation, and to continue to play on its divisions, from September onwards he found ways of putting to it certain counter-proposals to those he had received in Newcastle. He would consider parting with control of the armed forces for ten years instead of of twenty, and he would confirm the Presbyterian Church of England, now being established by ordinance, for three years, after which an assembly of twenty Presbyterian divines, twenty Independents, and twenty more of his own choosing would work out a final settlement to the religious question. How seriously he intended these offers is questionable, for he was simultaneously appealing for to his wife and daughter Mary, William of Orange’s wife, to provide a means of escape and a safe haven of refuge. A Dutch ship waited for him in Newcastle harbour all through the late autumn, supposedly being cleaned, but he hesitated too long and when he did attempt a getaway on Christmas Day, it was bungled. His guards were then doubled and the seaward escape routed was patrolled by naval frigates.
Charles did not despair, however, as he had been receiving intelligence that large parts of England and Wales wanted so much to see him restored that they might be prepared to rise for him. It was not entirely a vain hope, though it would be more than a year before a mood of insurrection would come to fruition in certain key areas of the countries. The impetus behind this genuinely popular dissent was not any great resurgence of royalist sentiment, but rather a sense of nostalgia for ‘the old ways’ for which, in the people’s eyes, the monarchy stood symbolically. The ‘peace’ had brought no substantial relief from crippling taxation, and free quarter, the tyranny of county committees and the violence and plunder continually conducted by ill-paid, mutinous soldiers. The New Model’s discipline remained relatively intact, despite its pay being in considerable arrears, but Fairfax’s army accounted for less than half the men-at-arms throughout the countries, excluding the Scots. Between May and September 1646, there were mutinies in no fewer than twenty-two English counties and several Welsh ones, and it was usually the local populations who suffered most from these.

Hostility to the New Model Army remained strong in the City of London, which had long been a centre of Presbyterian puritanism, both religious and political, the latter becoming even stronger with the autumn elections to the Common Council. The corporation petitioned parliament for the disbandment of the New Model Army, complaining about the widespread disaffection within it towards the new church government, and of the usurpation of pulpits by preaching soldiers, infecting the people with ‘strange and dangerous errors’. The Lords welcomed the petition with ‘hearty thanks’ and had it printed; the Commons received it coldly. There had been an attempt by the ‘party’ of Essex and Holles to build up Massey’s western brigade into a self sufficient army, capable of counter-balancing the New Model, but in October parliament decided to disband Massey’s force and to keep the New Model intact for a further six months. While the king was still in Scottish hands and known to be angling for armed resistance from abroad, it was the only safe decision. It also showed that in such a crucial vote the independents could still command a Commons majority, parly because from August 1645 onwards a number of by-elections had been held which were conducted along ‘party’ lines. The net effect was to strengthen the power of the independents and to add substantially to their radical wing. Nearly 270 new members were elected to the House by the time of Pride’s Purge, the vast majority of them by the end of 1646. Among these ‘recruiters’, as they were called, were future republicans like Edmund Ludlow and Fifth Monarchists John Carew and Thomas Harrison. The majority of the forty-three MPs who ultimately signed the king’s death warrant.

By contrast, with the passing of Essex in September 1646, the aristocratic element in the parliamentary cause became more fragmented, and the House of Lords had a dimished role in national politics. Saye, Northumberland and Wharton still had a significant part to play, as leading independents, and Manchester remained a leading presbyterian, though with a diminshed interest in public life. But despite the strengthening of the independents, parliament was committed to the religious settlement that the Westminster Assembly was working out, and that it was slowly establishing in legislation, step by step. All puritans could at least agree on the abolition of the episcopacy, which was effected when the Lords finally passed the necessary ordinance on 9 October.
Oddly enough, in the context of the early modern British history of the relations between the two kingdoms, by the winter of 1646-7, it was England that wanted to be left alone, and parliament paid the Scots four hundred thousand pounds to go away, leaving the king behind. The Scottish commissioners then accepted, in September 1646, a down payment of half the agreed amount as the price of withdrawing Leven’s army. The Scottish parliament was given assurances from Westminster that no peace would be concluded without the consent of both kingdoms, and that meanwhile the form of government in England would not be changed. The transaction may have appeared unappealing, but the the Scots had gone to war for the Covenant, and in face of his persistent rejection of it they were entitled to say ‘no Covenant, no pikes and muskets’. In this way, Parliament secured the person of the king by paying off the Scots for their participation in the war, and opened direct negotiations with Charles for the restoration of his throne. The wielder of power within England, however, was not parliamemt but the army: a massive military machine which had never been seen before in Britain. When the fighting was more-or-less done, the men of this hungry, angry and poorly-paid army were perfectly prepared to mutiny, seize their officers, march to new quarters without permission and refuse to decamp. In the last years of the first Civil War, the New Model Army at least had also been socially transformed and with the officer corps drawn from the sections of society that were much broader and lower down the pecking order than anything thought possible before 1645. As Simon Schama has commented, … Something new had been unloosed on the English polity: a reading, debating soldiery with a burning desire to settle accounts with its parliamentary paymasters.
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 002-4.jpg

So the king passed into the hands of the English parliament’s commissioners at the end of 1646, and the last of Leven’s troops left England on 3 February 1647. While Parliament were debating what next to do with the royal person, an extremely important element in the army, led by Cromwell and Ireton, was becoming increasingly ‘hostile’ to the ‘Scottish’ Presbyterianism that was being imposed on England. Let the Scots have their ‘Kirk’ said the Independents, and let the godly English congregations elect their ministers according to their own understanding of faith and liturgy. In 1647, the army not only had the guns but also the idealogues, such as Ireton and Colonel Rainborough who ventured to argue that parliament was a ‘decayed’ body and that the army was a great deal more representative of the people than was the genteel body at Westminster.
067

Levellers and Agitators:

Rainborough provided an important link to a body of men who were soon to be known as ‘the Levellers’. They were at this time essentially a London-based movement comprised mainly of small traders, craftsmen and apprentices, though their leaders – John Lilburne, William Walwyn, Maximilian Petty and John Wildman – came of minor gentry stock. Richard Overton was of humbler origins, a Baptist who had been in exile before the war and had since been running an unlicensed printing-press. Lilburne, Overton and Walwyn had long been prolific pamphleteers, and the first two had been in the Tower since the summer of 1646 for attacking the peerage in print.There were already quite a few links between the Levellers and radical independents in the New Model. Lilburne had been a lieutenant-colonel of dragoons in pre-New Model days, and Overton’s brother, Robert, had recently been appointed colonel of foot. Edward Sexby, who soon became one of the most prominent army agitators, had visited Lilburne in the Tower. There is no evidence that the Levellers instigated the petitioning movement in the army, however, and every indication that it arose spontaneously in response to the soldiers’ grievances. The Levellers and the independents in the army may have been close in their beliefs in religious tolerance, but they had many differences in their ideas of a future social order, a became increasingly apparent during 1647 as the political debate progressed. Hewson’s regiment, formerly Pickering’s, experienced the conflict within its own ranks, as is apparent from a study of the various attitudes and actions of its senior officers.
The soldier’s petition was wholly concerned with parliament’s threatened treatment of them as soldiers, whereas the Leveller petition of March was a highly political document, provocatively addressed to the Commons as ‘the supreme authority of the nation’. Its first demand was that neither the king nor the Lords should have any veto over the what the people’s representatives decided, nor should the peers have any jurisdiction over commoners.It called for the repeal of all oaths and covenants that could lead to the persecution of law-abiding people for nonconformity in religion, and demanded that no one should be punished for preaching or publishing his religious opinions in a peaceable way, a clear condemnation of the Blasphemy Ordinance then in course of enactment. It further called for the abolition of tithes, desiring that henceforth, ‘all ministers may be paidonly by those who voluntarily choose them’. It also called for radical reform of the law, legal procedures and the prison system. It was the most radical programme yet put forward by the Levellers, a fact which was confirmed when parliament ordered that it be burnt by the common hangman from the gallows.
As the political debate intensified inside the army, some in Hewson’s regiment were clearly committed to the political agenda of the Levellers. Of the six authors of A Letter from the Army to all the honest Seamen of England (published on 21 June 1647), two were from the regiment. They were Captains Alexander Brayfield and John Carter; a third agitator had been a captain in the regiment, Azariah Husbands. Two ordinary soldiers were also among the seventeen signatories to the letter. But all this time the agitators were developing and refining their organisation. They had a kind of central council to concert policies and find printers for their pamphlets and petitions, acting in liaison with a number of junior officers. They played a large part in preparing many regiments’ statements of their grievances and desires for their next meeting with the parliamentary commissioners. Like the publications from Hewson’s regiment, some of the agitators pamplets were beginning to show signs of radical political attitudes, and the Levellers were not slow in trying to make use of their organisation as a means of politicising the army. But hostile contemporary allegations that the army was all ‘one Lilburne throughout’ and that the soldiers took his tracts as statute law were still widely off the mak at this stage. In all the surviving regimental ‘submissions’, only two or three show a distinctively Leveller ‘bias’, and they do so in only two or three articles.
As yet, there was still no trace of the outright republicanism that was to emerge in sections of the army late that autumn. At that level of debate, soldiers from Norfolk and Suffolk were heard to say that they had fought the king to bring him to London, and that this was what they were determined to do. This was not the only expression of goodwill towards the king which revealed that most of the common soldiers had no personal animosity towards him. Since nobody was seriously considering a peace without the king at that stage, it was not unnatural for some in the army to speculate on whether the captive monarch might not be a better line of approach to a settlement than the presbyterian politicians. The chaplain of Hewson’s regiment, Henry Pinnell, certainly thought so, and articulated this in a pamphlet he published. Instead, the presbyterian politicians reckoned that they could dispose of enough force to take on the New Model Army if need be, and decided to disband it immediately. They had twenty thousand trained bands in London and its surroundings, under safe presbyterian commanders and Poyntz’s northern army already detached from the New Model in preparation for service in Ireland.

Major Daniel Axtell
In May, the presbyterians in parliament tried to break the power base of the independents in the army, requiring the New Model regiments to disband or volunteer for the Irish campaign. Hewson’s regiment refused, as did many others, and it was Lieutenant-Colonel Jubbes, together with Major Axtell (above) and two other ‘agitators’ who prepared a statement, or petition, of the grievances of the regiment. On 24 May, Fairfax wrote from Bury St. Edmunds to every regiment, ordering that soldiers should stop acting independently of their officers, and in particular that that the agitators should hold no more central meetings. He was not obeyed, as is evident from the fact that the agitators were never more active than in late May and early June. On 25 May, the Commons approved orders for the disbandment of the entire New Model infantry between 1st and 15th June. Skippon protested in writing to the Speaker, and Fairfax was also riven between a deep reluctance to disobey parliament and the strong corporate loyalty he felt with his officers and men. The agitators were well supplied with intelligence from London, and young Cornet Joyce, another of their close collaborators, was already organising a cavalry force to abduct the king. Rainborough’s regiment set off without its colonel’s knowledge to secure the army’s train of artillery in Oxford, in case parliament should try to move it. Fairfax could not have known of this either, but he did receive a Humble Petition of the Soldiers of the Army, signed by the agitators of ten regiments of horse and six of foot, calling upon him to call a general rendezvous of the army, more than hinting that they would hold one anyway if he did not.
On 29 May Fairfax duly held an enlarged council of war of about a hundred officers at Bury St. Edmunds, and there the crucial decisions about the future conduct of the army were taken. After the parliament’s votes and the agitators’ petition had been read and considered, he had two questons put to each officer individually. The first was whether enough had been done to satisfy the men’s grievances for the propsed disbandment to be carried out without danger of disturbance. The answer was ‘no’ by eighty-six votes. Next they were asked if, in the light of the first vote, they favoured a general rendezvous, to which eighty-for voted affirmative, with only seven against, though a further nine left the meeting without committing themselves. Fairfax had now to decide whether to resign his generalship or to agree with the decisively expressed wishes of his army. Characteristically, he resorted to consultation, confident that this would bind his officers more closely to his preferred course of action. He ordered the general rendezvous, to be held near Newmarket on 4th and 5th June.

The Capture of the King & the Rendezvous at Newmarket:

At the beginning of June, before the New Model regiments marched to Newmarket, the quarrel over sovereignty turned literal when a detachment of Fairfax’s own soldiers, led by Cornet George Joyce, seized the king himself from Holmby House in Northamptonshire. Joyce and his force seem to have been acting under instructions from the central council of agitators, and he and they were almost certainly engaged with the men of Rainborough’s foot regiment, who had been directed from the same source in securing the artillery train in Oxford. While on that mission, Joyce received intelligence that orders were being received from Westminster to remove the king from Holmby. Fearing, as many of the army did, that Charles was being brough closer to Westminster by the presbyterians in order to strike a swift deal with him, Joyce resolved to prevent this. But it was a heavy responsibility for a young officer to carry, and he might need more help in achieving the obstruction, so he rode to London to consult Cromwell. That evening he obtained Cromwell’s approval to prevent the removal of the king, but it is doubtful that either man thought that this would involve abducting the king. Cromwell consistently denied that he had authorised, let alone instigated this. There can be no doubt about Fairfax’s shock and consternation when he learnt that the king was on his way to Newmarket; his first reaction was to have Joyce court-martialled, though when he came to appreciate the cornet’s motives he relented and promised him the captaincy of the first troop that became vacant.
After leaving Cromwell, Joyce sent orders to his troops to make their way to Holmby as fast as they could and himself set off on his seventy-mile ride there. He arrived there a few hours before them on 2nd June, to find the king away playing bowls at Althorp. When his men caught up with him late that evening, the garrison’s soldiers greeted them as comrades; Major-General Browne found himself powerless to resist, as did Charles himself. Joyce’s men were unanimous in deciding to move the king, to prevent his movement by ‘hostile’ forces. Joyce then talked his way past the parliamentary commissioners who were still in attendance at Holmby, but he entered the royal bedchamber at ten that night to warn Charles to be ready to depart early the next morning. Before they set out at six, the king asked where they were going. By his own account, Joyce suggested five destinations, including Oxford and Cambridge. Charles suggested Newmarket, as its air agreed with him, and Joyce concurred, further evidence that his abduction of the king was unpremeditated.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 004-2.jpg

It was coincidental and unbeknown to Charles that, even as they set off, most of the New Model was converging on Newmarket for a general rendezvous in defiance of parliament’s orders. Cromwell was also on his way there. Since the end of the war he had been putting his parliamentary duties first, striving to to counter the policies and practices of the presbyterians on the floor of the House. But as soon as it became known that the army was resisting parliament’s orders for disbandment there was talk of impeaching him, and if he had stayed until the seizure of the king became known he could not have been safe from arrest. Moreover, he must have felt that with the rendezvous in progress, his place was at his general’s side, and as a politician that the army was a necessary safeguard against a partisan and unsafe peace. He had had nothing to do with the army’s ‘revolt’, as his meeting with Joyce had revealed, but his best service as he saw it was to provide it with statesmanlike leadership, alongside Fairfax.
In the same week of the king’s capture by the army and its rendezvous on Kentford Heath, near Newmarket, parliamentary troops also hijacked the bullion intended for their disbandment. At the rendezvous, Fairfax agreed to the unprecedented establishment of a General Council of the New Model Army to consist both of officers and men elected from each regiment. With money, force and the king all in hand, the army began to demand the impeachment of Denzil Holles and ten other MPs who had resisted the redress of the army’s grievances, in particular their arrears of pay, indemnity for conduct during the war and adequate pensions, all genuinely matters of life and death for the battle-worn soldiery. The presbyterian politicians wanted to eliminate the army as an obstacle to to their own plans for reinstating the king, while the army sought only to to avert its own destruction, secure its soldier’s rights, and prevent a partisan peace that would betray much that it thought it had fought for. The army also wanted the kind of religious establishment dear to Cromwell, one that respected the independence of congregational preference rather than one that surrendered to Presbyterian enforcement. Neither side was seeking drastic political change; they differed not as to whether the king should be restored but to his regal authority but over the constitutional terms upon which he should be allowed to resume it.

The Constitutional Crisis & the Four Countries:

This constitutional crisis was in origin very much an English crisis, through its outcome would have profound implications for both Scotland and Ireland. The Scots watched it with acute concern, and its progress would determine whether Argyll and the strict Covenanters continued to dominate the political arena or whether the threat to the king would shift the initiative to the Hamiltons and their party, who were prepared to come to his rescue on less stringent terms. For the Irish, the new breach in England postponed the nemesis that awaited the Confederates, but they were powerless to affect its outcome, more powerless than they had appeared towards the end of 1646. The factions among the Irish themselves largely neutralised the threat posed by an Irish catholic rebellion until a radically changed English government was ready to deal with it.

Above: Land owned by catholics in Ireland in 1641.
The peace treaty which Ormond, as the king’s Lord Lieutenant, had concluded with the delegates of the of the Confederates’ Supreme Council in March 1646 had been vehemently opposed by O’Neill, the clerical party and Rinuccini, who had engineered the establishment of a new Supreme Council dominated by his own faction. But the treaty had not yet come before a General Assembly, and, under pressure from the royalists within the Confederation, Rinuccini agreed that one should be called for January 1647, expressly to consider it. It was rejected on 2nd February, by which time the rifts in the Confederation were threatening it with dissolution. On the one hand were those who remained loyal to the crown, even in defeat, provided they could practice their faith openly, have access to office and entitlement to property. On the other there were those who wanted a total Catholic state, prepared to bid for independence under the protection of a foreign Catholic power, perhaps with their own king, perhaps O’Neill.

Following the repudiation of his treaty, Ormond felt justified in applying for redress to Westminster. He offered to surrender his office of Lord Lieutenant to parliament, which now realised that it must take full responsibility for England’s interests in Ireland and sent over a force of two thousand men under Colonel Michael Jones. They landed in Dublin in June; Ormond handed over his command to Jones and signed a treaty with the parliamentary commissioners. By the terms of this, all protestants were to be secured in their estates, loyal catholics were to be favourably treated, and all noblemen, gentlemen and officers who wished to leave Ireland with him were free to do so. He sought an interview with the king at Hampton Court as soon as he arrived back in London, and recieved full royal approval for his conduct in Ireland. Nevertheless, his capitulation divided his Old English adherents, some of them joining the army of Leinster which set out again to lay siege to Dublin. But Colonel Jones stood in his way, holding a good position on Dungan’s Hill near Trim. The Confederates could not supply the Leinster men during a protracted campaign, so they attacked on 8th August. Jones’s men were no raw recruits, and only lately disbanded from the parliamentary army, so the Irish troops were utterly routed, leaving Leinster so vulnerable that O’Neill’s dreaded Ulstermen had to be brought in to help protect the province. This led to a further worsening of relations between the Old English moderates and the ultra-Catholic militants. A full-scale civil war had broken out between the protestants in the south and the Confederates, with the former, led by Murrough O’Brien, taking one castle after another throughout the summer.
So it can be seen that by June 1647, neither party had much to fear in the short term from enemies, real or potential, in any of the four nations or from overseas, especially after Michael Jones’s important victory at Dungan’s Hill. The Commons, however, were so alarmed by the army’s defiance and its seizure of the king that they sat all through the night of 3-4 June, while the regiments were converging on Kentford Heath, and at two in the morning they voted their Declaration of Dislike out of their Journal. Later in the day a Humble Representation of the Dissatisfactions of the Army was read to each regiment at the rendezvous, signed by most of their officers and men. Much of it was couched in the now familiar language of the agitators, voicing familiar grievances. It demonstrated the failure of the army’s opponents in parliament to drive a wedge between officers and men, or between horse and foot. Fairfax was determined to keep defiance to a minimum and to maintain military discipline. In an exhausting day, he addressed each regiment in turn, urging it to show moderation and to respect the civil authority. The cheers that greeted Fairfax everywhere showed what a hero he still was to his men and how much they appreciated his sympathy and support, but he was not really a political figure, and now that the army was assuming so political a role it would need a different talent from his to guide it along constructive courses.

The Army’s Demands articulated:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 014-1.jpg
Commissary-General Henry Ireton.
Much of the initiative in this field was assumed during the next two years by Cromwell’s son-in-law, Henry Ireton, the Commissary-General (pictured above). He was almost certainly the author of The Solemn Engagement of the Army, which was read to all the regiments on the second day of the rendezvous and assented to by them. It immediately gained the status of a covenant by the army. All its signatories engaged with each other, and with the parliament and kingdom, to disband cheerfully or to remain in service, as parliament should require, but only when they were given satisfaction for their stated grievances and when they received security that when disbanded neither they nor ‘other freeborn people of England’ would remain subject to oppression and injury through the countenance in power of men who had abused parliament in its past proceedings against the army. This was tantamount to a demand for a purge of the presbyterian leadership. The redress and security thus requested was expected to meet with the satisfaction of a startingly new body which came to be called the General Council of the Army, to include not only the senior commanders who normally attended the general council of war, but two officers and two ordinary soldiers from each regiment. This General Council was not to meet until mid-July, but until it was satisfied that the Solemn Engagement declaration that ‘we shall not willingly disband nor divide’, nor suffer ourselves to be disbanded or divided’ was fully accepted.

Colonel John Hewson
By June 1647, and since its formation, the New Model had lost thirty-three officers at or above company commander level to death in battle or by disease, another twenty-five who had resigned earlier in the Naseby campaign, so the turnover in senior officers amounted to fifty-seven per cent by the end of that month. The greater majority of those who died or departed were replaced by promoting men already within the army, very often of humbler origin, like John Hewson (pictured above) within Pickering’s regiment, which, following Pickering’s death, now became Hewson’s; he had been a humble cobbler before the war. Others of modest birth who rose to command in the New Model Army were Harrison, Pride, Okey, Goffe and Tomlinson, and they also achieved a new prominence in the politics of the army. The social level of the officer corps was thus lowered considerably, though around half of those in more senior ranks would probably still have styled themselves as gentlemen.

003 (40)

The remainder of the summer of 1647 saw a highly politicised army preparing to impose religious liberty at the point of the sword. As if that were not paradoxical enough, the men they hated, the parliamentary Presbyterians, were defending the right of the elected representatives of the nation to impose a Calvinist Church on England by virtue of of their votes. When, at the end of July, a vast and heavily armed demonstration forced both houses of parliament to support the Holles Presbyterian line, bloodshed seemed inevitable. MPs and peers on the losing side, including the Earl of Manchester, although himself a political presbyterian, escaped London to Fairfax’s camp. The Lord General began a slow advance on London from Newmarket in the second week of June, to the general consternation to those at Westminster and in the City. The guards were doubled and the portcullises were lowered. On 10 June Fairfax sent an assurance that the army sought ‘no alteration to the civil government’. He paused and set up camp at St. Albans, little more than twenty miles north of London. There he and his council approved a document called A Declaration from Sir Thomas Fairfax and the Army, which purported to be a vindication clearing the New Model from all the scandals that had been cast upon it. Through it, the army staked a claim to speak and act for the whole kingdom, proudly asserting that…
… we were not a mere mercenary army, hired to serve any arbitrary power of state, but called forth and conjured by the several declarations of parliament to the defence of our own and the people’s just rights and liberties.
The army made it clear that it had no desire to ‘overthrow the Presbytery’ or to set up Independency as a national religion; it asked only that those who dissented from the established forms should suffer no persecution or civil disabilities. The situation remained very tense through most of June, with the agitators continuing to hold their own unauthorised meetings, and a number of officers working hand in glove with them. They kept pressing for a march on London in order to enforce the impeachment of the eleven impeached MPs, which the House was resisting. Fairfax did advance his command post to Uxbridge, only fifteen miles from Westminster, and stationed some of his troops even closer, in defiance of an order frm the Commons not to bring the army within forty miles. In response, the Lord Mayor called the Trained Bands to arms, but most of the common citizens showed a sensible reluctance to engage in heroics against the veterans of Fairfax and Cromwell. On 15 June, both Houses voted to bring the king to Westminster, but this was an empty gesture since Charles was firmly in the army’s keeping and relatively content with his new captors who treated him with civility, allowing him to entertain his friends and receive the respects of the East Anglian gentry. After his long summer sojourn in Newmarket, he was moved in stages to Hampton Court. Meanwhile, Fairfax took pains to respond positively to parliament’s conciliatory gesture by withdrawing his headquarters back to Reading. It was there, on 16th July, that the first General Council of the army took place. But Cromwell and Ireton urged strongly against the use of force to free John Lilburne and the other Leveller prisoners, finally persuading the agitators to drop their pressure for an immediate march. In return, the General Council agreed to put their other main points before parliament, especially that concerning the restoration of the City’s old militia officers and the liberation of the Leveller prisoners.
On the second day of the debates at Reading Ireton read out the the the draft of a comprehensive scheme for the settlement of the kingdom which soon became known as its Heads of the Proposals. The hope of Ireton and the rest of the generals was that they could, when perfected, be put to both king and parliament as the desires of the whole army, and provide a way out of the impasse that had existed since the Propositions of Newcastle had been presented a year or more earlier. Until recently, Ireton has always been regarded as their author, and there is still little argument that in their conception and formulation they were essentially his work. But there is also evidence that they were put together in close consultation with a group of leading independents from both Houses including Saye, Wharton, Nothumberland, Vane, St John, and Saye’s son Nathaniel Fiennes. For about ten days before the Reading debates, messages had been passing between this group and Cromwell and Ireton, and from the end of June, Wharton was a parliamentary commissioner at army headquarters. This was not, therefore, an attempt by the army to promulgate peace over the heads of parliament, but a collaboration between leading independent parliamentarians and the army generals to stand together against the presbyterian ‘party’.

The King’s Last Chance:

In addition, the queen had sent over from France the exiled former royalist commander in Devon, Sir John Berkeley, with specific directions to promote an agreement between the great officers and the king. Berkeley reached Reading on 12th July and soon established a good rapport with Cromwell and Ireton, who were clear about their hopes for a peace that would be more acceptable to both the king and the kingdom than what had been offered so far. Berkeley soon gained the impression that the whole army, agitators included, were yearning to come to terms with Charles. The king himself, however, was delighted to play off the political Presbyterians against the Independents in the army, especially when it turned out that that the Army’s terms were a lot more palatable for him than the official ones currently on the table from parliament. The king, however, would not accept Berkeley’s reading of the situation, saying that he distrusted the chief officers because they had asked him for no personal favours as rewards, providing historians with clear evidence that he had never been serious about securing an agreement.
Nevertheless, the great difference between the scheme put forward by the independents and the army, and the Newcastle Proposals of the presbyterians was that while the latter were mainly preoccupied with the disposal of power, the Heads of the Proposals were much more concerned with genuine reform and with healing old emnities. For instance, they proposed that parliaments should be elected biennially and should sit for no more than 240 days during the two years. It was regard to religion, however, that Ireton’s preferred terms differed most refreshingly from those of parliament. The use of the Book of Common Prayer was to be permitted but not imposed, and there should be no penalties for not attending the parish church, or for attending other meetings for worship. Bishops could still be appointed, though without coercive power or jurisdiction. No one was to be forced to take the covenant. The whole parliamentary settlement of church government and worship was passed over in silence. Nothing so tolerant was to come before the two Houses again for more than another forty years in England and Wales.
The prospects looked good for a peace on terms that the king could in honour accept, and would have left Anglicans, Presbyterians, Independents and Separatists free to worship according to their consciences. The proposals were reported to parliament on 20th July and taken into debate immediately by the Lords, where the Saye-Northumberland group dominated the dozen or so peers still in attendance. On the same day the eleven impeached members, sensing that the game was up, requested and obtained the Commons’ leave to go into exile, and withdrew. Within the next two days, parliament restored control of City’s trained bands to the old Militia Committee, ordered the disbandment of the regiments it had detached from the New Model, and passed the desired declaration against the introduction of any foreign into the kingdom. This apparent surrender of the army, however, triggered a violent rection from those in London who saw it as their prime enemy, especially the City presbyterians and the ‘reformadoes’. Many of the latter had lost their military employment when the New Model was created, and not a few had fought for the king. On the 21st, large numbers of militiamen, reformadoes, apprentice watermen, and others gathered in Skinners’ Hall to sign a Solemn Engagement, pledging their utmost efforts to bring the king to Westminster, in order to restore him on their terms that he himself had offered.

Next evening two or three thousand reformadoes demonstrated in St James’ Field, clamouring for the City to join them in pressuring parliament to bring the king back to his capital. The Common Council was divided, but the Commons’ vote to reinstate the old City Militia Committee temporarily reunited it. It welcomed two mass petitions urging it not to yield control over its trained bands, and on the 26th it processed as a body to Westminster to present them to parliament. An angry crowd of citizens followed the City fathers, with apprentices noisily prominent, and it was bent on no mere peaceful demonstration. It forced its way into the Commons’ chamber, abusing and insulting the members until they not only confirmed the Lords’ votes but passed a resolution inviting the king to London. While under this intimidation they sent urgently to the Lord Mayor for some trained bands to protect them and restore order, but he ignored their request. Once free of the mob the Speakers of both Houses, with eight peers and fifty-seven MPs, left Westminster and took refuge with the army. The futility of this attempt at counter-revolution was soon exposed, because it met with virtually no response outside London, which itself quickly discovered that it had no defence.
In any case, London also had large numbers of Independents and Seperatists who took heart from the army’s championship of freedom of conscience, and while many apprentices, fired with civic patriotism, had rioted on 26th July, many others were drawn to Leveller movement and saw the army agitators as a means of promoting its aims. Moreover, London was home to many of the officers and men of the New Model, and the populous suburbs of Southwark and Tower Hamlets were resistant to to the City government’s attempts to extend its authority over them, and were ready to welcome the army as its liberator. Fairfax had authority as well as power on his side when he announced on the 28th that, at the request of both Speakers of Parliament and the fugitive peers and members the army would shortly march into the capital to restore it to its freedom.
The king wrote to Fairfax and Cromwell offering to treat on the basis of the Heads of the Proposals, which had been shown to him a few days earlier. Before he set off to Woburn, Cromwell authorised Ireton, Rainborough, Hammond and Rich to visit the king and bring him to agreement if they could. But Charles failed to appreciate that he was being offered a fleeting opportunity. If he had grasped it, by pledging himself there and then to accept the Heads of the Proposals, Fairfax would have escorted not only the Speakers and the independent parliamentarians back to London, but also the king himself. But Charles did not assent to the Proposals. Deeply disappointed, Cromwell and Ireton asked him urgently to write ‘a kind letter to the army’, giving it his blessing in restoring order to London and disowning the actions of the mob. When he eventually produced this, it was not very supportive and he delayed it until it was quite clear that resistance in the capital was collapsing; indeed, the City formally submitted before the letter appeared in print. In one crucial week he threw away not only his best chance of regaining the throne but the goodwill of a great part of the army.
Fairfax had already made it clear that if the city did not open its gates he would blow them open. But he did not hasten it, for he wanted no bloodshed. He drew up his forces on Hounslow Heath on 3rd August, a line stretching for a mile and a half, and escorted the two Speakers, fourteen peers and about a hundred MPs in a review of them. Not a shot was fired or a sword drawn when his regiments encircled the City next day, and when he escorted the returning to the Palace of Westminster on the 5th his men wore laurel leaves in their hats and the church bells pealed. The New Model Army was peacefully admitted. London, and therefore England, was now under military control. To complete the triumph, all twenty regiments paraded in Hyde Park on the 7th before marching to Cheapside with colours flying. They then moved through all the streets of the old City, where they were greeted enthusiastically. The people were impressed by their orderliness which was contrasted to the recent behaviour of the reformadoes. But the army still faced difficult relations with parliament and growing dissention in its own ranks. Saye and most of the other active peers were friendly, but although five of the eleven impeached MPs had gone into exile during August the co-operation of the Commons was much less certain. It took concerted pressure from Cromwell and Ireton to get it to deal with the disorder that had occured in and since the July tumults. In mid-August, Fairfax set up his headquarters at Kingston, so while the military presence remained close, apart from one regiment temporarily guarding the Tower he quartered his troops well outside the capital.
Sir Thomas Fairfax, by John Hoskins. It has been questioned whether the sitter really was ‘black Tom Fairfax’. Contrast this portrait with the later one from 1650 (below), painted after his ‘retirement’, which may also reveal the effects of the first two civil wars and the quest for peace on him.
But, from here, Fairfax was having difficulty in holding the army’s discordant elements together. At the only meeting of its General Council during August, at Kingston on the 18th, a carefully worded Remonstrance was approved, and was subsequently read at the head of each regiment. It declared that we shall rejoice as much as any to see the king brought back to his parliament … on such sound terms as may render the the kingdom safe, quiet and happy. It asked parliament to take the Heads of the Proposals into speedy consideration, and to exclude all the the members who had sat on during the recent absence of the Speakers, until they had expressly disavowed the votes that had been passed under pressure from the mob. The Lords immediately approved the Remonstrance, but the Commons ignored the main requests of the army. This incensed the growing number of agitators, who were clamouring with for the total expulsion of those members who had sat on in Lenthall’s absence. Since over a hundred MPs had done so on one day or another, that would probably have united the parliament and most of the public against the army and wrecked its leaders’ plans for a settlement.
Fairfax moved his headquarters to Putney early in September, and there he instituted regular weekly meetings of the General Council, on Thursdays in the parish church. The Heads of the Proposals were further debated in three consecutive sessions; that on the 9th specifically considered the rights of the king and his heirs. Fairfax’s own senior officer of foot, Major Francis White, a committed Leveller, spoke against restoring him on any such terms as those proposed, declaring that there was now no visible authority in the kingdom other than the power of the sword. He was promptly expelled from the Council, his commander publicly reaffirming that the army upheld the fundamental authority and government of the kingdom. During the autumn, the king himself encouraged by this dissention within the Parliamentary cause, further prevaricating and then re-opening negotiations with the Scots in November.

Levellers, Lords and Generals:

Meanwhile, the Levellers were stepping up their efforts to influence and infiltrate the agitators and the soldiery in general, and with the active support or sympathy of a number of officers, including some on the General Council, including the Rainborough brothers, Major William and Colonel Thomas. The army being so close to London, it recruited to vacancies in its ranks during the late summer and autumn, and a number of Levellers enlisted with the purpose of spreading the word in it. The Leveller leaders were thoroughly disillusioned by now with the present parliament, and bent on an altogether radical programme of reform than the Heads of the Proposals offered. John Lilburne bore a grudge against Cromwell for not securing his release from the Tower, but now that a sympathetic colonel was in charge, he was allowed to go about London by day almost as he pleased. He also blamed the independent leaders of the Lords, Saye and Wharton, for his imprisonment and viewed their close rapport with the army leaders with suspicion and resentment. Early in September he asked to see Cromwell, who readily visited him and urged him in as cordial way as he could to drop his attacks on parliament. If he would just be patient, Cromwell promised, he would receive satisfaction for the wrongs he had suffered and gain honourable employment in the army. Lilburne, however, would not promise to keep quiet, demanding instead a public vindication and reparations.

True to his word, soon after meeting Cromwell, ‘honest John’ wrote and published an open letter to the army in which he urged its soldiery to trust your your great officers at the general’s quarters no further than you can throw an ox. For by their cunning, he wrote, they had most unjustly stolen the power from your honest general, and your too flexible agitators. Ireton was the Levellers béte noire; they held him responsible for perverting Cromwell, claiming that he had, through the General Council, turned the army into a corporation independent of the state. During September and most of October the General Council strived to contain the discontent in the army’s ranks and to provide a forum for its material grievances, though from the news that leaked out from its debates it seems that the agitators were showing increasing opposition to the seniors officers’ dealings with the king. In the Commons on 22nd September, Marten and Colonel Rainsborough moved that no further addresses should be made to him, but Cromwell, Ireton, Vane, St John, and Nathaniel Fiennes strongly opposed them, and the motion was defeated by eighty-four votes to thirty-four. In practical terms, the army had more to lose than to gain by quarrelling with parliament, which in the course of September approved a new establishment for the home forces under Fairfax’s command. They were to total 26,400, which was an advance of over twenty thousand on what parliament had proposed only six months earlier. In October the soldiers even got an extra month’s pay. For all their professions, the Levellers were dubious friends to the army. When they came to publish their comprehensive plan for a democratic commonwealth it found no place for a standing army at all.
Lilburne and his associates were so disappointed with the performance of the existing agitators that towards the end of September they set about engineering the emergence of new ones. These appeared in five cavalry regiments, to which Fairfax’s horse should probably be added since Edward Sexby was its senior agitator. For more than a month they spread no further, and it is not clear whether they were actually elected by the men they claimed to represent. In some regiments they received some form of assent, but they did not displace the original agitators or gain a place on the General Council. They were commonly referred to as ‘the agents of the five regiments’ and they met regularly in London, daily in the early stages. They were essentially propagandists for the Leveller movement, organised mainly by John Wildman, a man of radical temperament and gentry background who had some knowledge of the law. They were probably acting already as a caucus before they sought any mandate from their fellow soldiers. Their publication of a paper entitled The Case of the Army Truly Stated threatened to give a revolutionary turn to national politics. It was signed by all five of them and presented to Fairfax by two of them on 18th October. Its main author was probably Wildman, with passages added by Sexby and the others. It repeated their earlier claim that, since the meeting at Newmarket in June, the the senior offices had been perverting the whole intention of the Solemn Engagement. The ‘London agents’ also claimed that the officers were proposing to restore the king’s veto, and were allowing his ‘evil counsellors’ free access to him, even though this had already been stopped some days earlier.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 012-1.jpg

Fairfax (pictured above, c. 1650, by an unknown artist), no doubt exasperated and exhausted by the Levellers and sensing the danger of the document produced by them, put it in front of the General Council on 21st October. The day before, Cromwell had delivered a very long speech in the Commons, totally disassociating himself and Fairfax from the the proposals in The Case of the Army and reaffirming their commitment to the historic monarchy and to the restoration of the king. The General Council gave the manifesto a cool reception, not relishing the allegations that they had been the generals’ ‘poodle’. The regular agitators of the five regiments for which it purported to speak repudiated it. Probably because of the presence of the signatures of Sexby, Lockyer and Allen on the document, the committee appointed to investigate its authorship took a softer line and sent these three to the agents’ meeting with a cordial invitation to send representatives to explain their positions to the next General Council.

Re-enter the Scots & the English take the ‘Road’ to Revolution:

But it was not a time for the army to weaken itself by internal dissension. In Scotland (see the map below), the convention of estates had just voted to keep its army in the field until at least March 1648, and Hamilton’s party was now in almost even balance with Argyll’s. Hamilton’s brother Lanark travelled south to see the king: they visited him at Hampton Court on 22nd October and raised his hopes of getting armed support from Scotland without having to accept the Covenant himself. Two days later, they even urged him to escape with them, then and there. He was not ready for that, but the option made him less responsive to any propositions that either the parliament or the army might have to offer. In the Commons, it was getting harder for Cromwell and the ‘royal’ independents to keep their peace process afloat in face of of the growing minority who already regarded Charles as unfit to treat with.

The Civil Wars in Scotland, showing battles 1642-1651
Such was the background to the most famous extra-parliamentary debates in British history, those held at Putney from late October into early November. With the first civil war over, but the question of its monarchy and constitution unresolved, Britain was entering a revolutionary phase in the winter of 1646-47.

(to be continued…)

Sources:

Austin Woolrych (2004), Britain in Revolution, 1625-1660. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Glenn Foard (1994), Colonel John Pickering’s Regiment of Foot, 1644-45. Whitstable: Pryor Publications.

Simon Schama (2001), A History of Britain: The British Wars, 1603-1776. London: BBC Worldwide.

375 Years Ago – The End of the First Civil War, October 1645 – March 1647: Sieges, Plagues & the Aftermath.

The War in the West of England – Winchester to Exeter:

After bombarding and taking Winchester at the beginning of October 1645 Cromwell’s troops moved on to lay siege to Basing House, a royalist stronghold and garrison in the north of Hampshire, a centre of heroic resistance. It had already proved a major obstacle to parliamentarian progress throughout the first war, withstanding two sieges, the second lasting three months. The ‘Castle’ was … the seat and mansion of the Marquisse of Winchester, a Catholic, who described it in his own account of the siege as standing…

… on a rising ground, having its forme circular, encompassed with a brick rampart lyned with earth, and a very deep trench, but dry. The loftie Gate-house with foure turrets looking northwards, on the right whereof without the compasse of the ditch, a goodly building containing two faire courts, before them is the Graunge, severed by a wall and common roade…
Visitors to the site today can appreciate the scale of the fortifications which existed in the mid-seventeenth century from the massive earthworks that still survive. Short stretches of the wall and a single turret of the far weaker outer defensive circuit still stand to almost their original height. In places they retain the crude musket loops from which the defenders could fire on the besieging troops. The outer gate is also partially intact, with the arms of the ancestral Paulet family displayed above (as shown in the picture). Due to the excavations in the early years of this century, there is both archaeological as well as documentary evidence for the seventeenth century castle and the sieges of 1644 and 1645. Until Fairfax arrived the house had stood invincible:
They that have seen and viewed it say that it was a piece made as strong and defensible as nature and art could imagine.
Several earlier sieges, both blockades and frontal assaults, had failed to reduce the stronghold. An alternative strategy was therefore decided upon, the employment of scientific siege engineering. Colonel Dalbier had begun the siege on 20th August, and having very carefully prepared his positions, started his bombardment in late September. This succeeded in making a major breach in the structure before Cromwell arrived with the heaviest of the siege pieces on 8th October. Forts and sconces were then raised by the besiegers completely enclosing the garrison. When the heavy cannon opened fire from newly dug positions on 12th October two further great breaches were made. The marquis refused Cromwell’s summons to surrender, so he had to storm it. Dalbier had already prepared siegeworks, which had approached almost to the foot of the royalist defences. Therefore, by 6.00 a.m. on the 14th, the assault began. Dalbier was on the north side of the House next to the Grange, Pickering’s Regiment were on his left, then Hartrop’s, Sir Hardress Waller’s and Montague’s. The royalists immediately abandoned the outer defences, estimates of the garrison’s strength ranging between three and eight hundred, compared with a parliamentarian force of perhaps seven thousand. The defenders were simply too few to man the extensive outer defences against such a massive offensive force. The defenders retreated into two houses, the massive Medieval stone keep called the Old House and the later mansion known as the New House.
Dalbier’s artillery had been directed against the New House. The cannon fire had created a massive breach in the walls, which can be seen in the contemporary engraving above. While Montague’s and Waller’s assaulted the strongest walls, where Cromwell’s artillery had also breached the defences, Pickering’s troops stormed the New House, passing through the house into the bailey that separated it from the Old House. A parliamentarian reported:
They in the Old House hung out some black ensigns of defiance, and set a fire on a bridge over which our men were to pass, disputing the passage at swords’ point, and the rest in the house threw out granadoes amongst our men, wherby many of them were killed.

Above: Plan of Basing House siege, 1645.

Once Pickering’s had taken the gatehouse to the Old House, the defenders summoned a perley, which our men would not hear, according to a letter sent the same day. It can hardly be doubted that Cromwell’s uncharacteristic harshness (at least at this point in the war), sprang partly from Basing’s notoriety as “a nest of idolatrous papists”. But although Cromwell and his officers may have been spurred on by the well-known ‘papist’ sympathies of the household within, it was at least partly the great wealth also known to be within which encouraged the ordinary soldiers in the assault. The artillery bombardment continued as the attack on the Old House proceeded. Within three quarters of an hour, at about 7.30 a.m., all resistance was broken. Cromwell’s forces suffered little loss, estimated at the time as no more than forty, whilst the royalists lost up to three hundred men. They fought almost to the last, and Cromwell let his men slaughter many of them, including six priests, before granting quarter to the majority. Since terms had been refused after the essential breaches had been made, the defenders were not entitled to quarter, and a case could be made for punishing desperate as an example, for the sake of saving soldiers’ lives and shortening the war.
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 004-1.jpg

Above: A View of the New House at Basing, by John Dunstal, circa 1652, showing the breaches through which Pickering’s probably stormed the House.

During the rest of the day, the ordinary soldiers proceeded to plunder the mansion, the wealth of which was supposed to be of greater value than any single garrison could be imagined. They would not only have considered this as just desserts for the day’s action, but also as part righteous remuneration for in lieu of pay not received from within the New Model Army. The sack of the house was comprehensive, and its inmates, including the ladies, were even stripped of their clothes by the soldiers. Amonst those taken prisoner were Hollar, the engraver, the Marquis of Winchester himself (heir of Mary Tudor’s Lord Treasurer who had built the mansion), and Inigo Jones, the famous architect and creator of the court masques, who got away wrapped only in a blanket to protect him from naked indignity. Paintings and books were taken to London to be burned in a great public bonfire, and whatever was left of the furniture or jewels found in the mansion was the soldiers’ to sell. During this period of plundering, the House was set on fire unintentionally. Cromwell’s troops put to the sword everyone they could find in the burning ruins, civilians as well as soldiers, women as well if they offered resistance. What was not destroyed by the fire was then demolished to stop Basing ever again being used as a royalist garrison.
Above: The Campaign of 1645.
While Cromwell was mopping up the royalist strongholds and garrisons in Hampshire and Wiltshire, Fairfax embarked on a reconquest of the far south-west. He took Tiverton after storming its castle on 19 October, but his campaign petered out becausean increasingly wet autumn made the roads impassable for his baggage train and artillery. There was a good deal of sickness in his cold and hungry army, and even he himself fell ill. He suffered from kidney stones, rheumatism and (as he wrote to his father), a benumbing coldness in my head and arms, especially on that side that I had any hurts. He had been wounded four times before becoming Lord General. Cromwell and his part of the army rejoined him in late October, having taken the surrender of Longford House on the way, clearing its garrison of a hundred men. The House belonged to the Earl of Coleraine, and was four miles from Salisbury. Known as Longford Castle today, it was a fortified house built in the 1590s.
John Hewson, in an engraving by Van der Gucht in the National Portrait Gallery, London.
Lieutenant Colonel Hewson (pictured above), second-in-command of Pickering’s regiment, and Major Kelsey were sent to treat with the governor, Lieutenant General Pell. In the face of superior forces, and with no hope of relief, Pell surrendered without a shot being fired. When six of the parliamentarian soldiers, deprived of their loot by the generous terms of the surrender, tried to rob Pell’s officers, they were court-martialled. Since they had done the same at Winchester, their sentence was severe: they were made to draw lots for their lives, the loser was hanged and the others were dispatched to the governor of Oxford to deal with as he thought fit. He ‘repaid the courtesy’ by setting them free. The contrast with the treatment of Basing House clearly demonstrated the value of surrendering. The house wasn’t slighted, but was later deserted and fell into ruins. It was sympathetically restored in the nineteent century, as shown in the picture above.
Almost the only substantial royalist garrison now left between London and Exeter was at Corfe Castle in Dorset. By 20th October, at the request of the Western Association, Fairfax sent troops to assist in the siege there, which had been begun by Colonel Bingham, the governor of Poole. The massive Medieval castle lay in a strong defensive position and was very well fortified. It could not be so easily reduced as many other strongholds had been in 1645. The besieging force set up gun batteries facing the castle. The earthworks of a Medieval siege castle, a quarter of a mile to the south west of the main castle, were reused for one of the parliamentarian gun batteries. This turned out to be a long siege: Corfe did not surrender, nor did it succumb to a quick assault. This was because, not being in a key strategic position, it did not warrant the troops and/ or artillery necessary for a major storming. Those forces were, instead, deployed around Exeter, a far more significant garrison. However, on 16th December, Fairfax did send further troops to Corfe, comprising one regiment of horse and two regiments of foot. The castle did not finally fall to Bingham until early March 1646. It was then comprehensively slighted by the parliamentarians, but the destruction was not total (the picture below showing the romanticism ruins of the castle in the early nineteenth century).
Above: An artist’s impression of the siege of Corfe Castle.
While the siege of Corfe continued, the reunited New Model Army spent the rest of 1645 in widely scattered winter quarters in Devon. It no longer had to contend with Goring, who had given up his fight for the west and took a ship for France in late November. Hopton, whom he had supplanted as commander-in-chief of the king’s western troops by his intrigues, now had the thankless task of taking over the demoralised remnants of the royalist army. The parliamentary soldiers were mostly quartered in villages around the City of Exeter, the army headquarters being at Ottery St. Mary, a small market town ten miles east of Exeter. Though his regiment was at the siege of Corfe, Colonel John Pickering himself was, by 12th November, at Ottery, involved once again in discussions with representatives of a royalist garrison. Together with Ireton and the Judge-Advocate, he was attempting to negotiate the surrender of Exeter.
Corfe Castle as it was in the early nineteenth century. The towers are ruined and tumbling into the ditch, just as they were left by the
parliamentarian forces who slighted the castle.

Northern England, the Scots and the Irish:

Meanwhile, at Newark Charles was having to bear not only bad news from all points, including West, but he also had troubles at court. They were partly of his own making, for he had dismissed Will Legge, the governor of Oxford, for no better reason than that he was a friend of Rupert, and Digby wanted him out of the way. He then did the same to Sir Richard Willys, the governor of Newark and commander of its large garrison. This led to a disgraceful scene in which Rupert, Maurice, Willys, Lord Gerrard, and a dozen more of their friends burst unbidden into the king’s presence and demanded an explanation. Willys may have remembered his treatment when he had betrayed the secrets of the Sealed Knot, the royalist spy network, years later. Such quarrels did nothing to improve Charles’s authority, but the passions simmered down, and on 5 November he returned to Oxford to face a cheerless winter. After cashiering Rupert he had appointed his archenemy Digby as Lieutenant-General of all his forces north of Trent, and then in mid-October sent with him fifteen hundred men, including what was left of Langdale’s northern horse, to try and make a junction with Montrose on the Scottish border.
James Graham, Marquess of Montrose. In 1638, Montrose had subscribed to the Covenant in opposition to Charles I’s arbitrary rule over Scotland, and for the next three years he fought with the Covenanter Army commanded by Alexander Leslie. But when the extremist Presbyterians gained influence, he became alienated and changed allegiance to the king. Leslie had surprised and bloodily defeated Montrose’s force of 1500 men at Philiphaugh. Montrose left Scotland on Charles’ orders in 1646, but returned in support of Charles II (of Scotland) in 1650. He was defeated at Carbisdale on 27 April and executed in Edinburgh.
In a rare and brief moment of co-operation in the king’s cause, Aboyne had lately joined Montrose with fifteen hundred foot and five hundred horse. Two days out of Newark, Digby surprised Poyntz’s northern army at Sherburne in Yorkshire and captured most of it, but in an ensuing cavalry action, a misunderstanding between him and Langdale turned victory into defeat, and they and their disorganised cavaliers fled all the way to Skipton Castle. From Skipton, they resumed their circuituous journey north, and though their forces took another beating from the Scottish forces based at Carlisle, they pressed on as far as Dumfries. The news that they received there concerning Montrose and the forces opposed to him was so discouraging that they returned to England hastily. Their few remaining troops melted away in the Cumbrian fells, and with a small band of officers they found a small boat in Ravenglass to take them to the Isle of Man. From there, Digby sailed to Ireland, where he busied himself with a plan to bring over the Prince of Wales in order to make the country a base for royalist resurgence.
Charles’ thoughts had also been turning increasingly towards Ireland. Charles’ envoy there, Edward Somerset, Earl of Glamorgan, a catholic, had begun to interpret his brief very liberally after the Naseby defeat. He did not, therefore, deal directly with the General Assembly in Kilkenny, but with the Confederate delegates who were treating with Ormond in Dublin. On 25 August, Glamorgan concluded an agreement with them whereby in return for an army of ten thousand Irishmen he conceded, on the king’s behalf, not only the repeal of the anti-catholic penal laws but also the reinstatement of public catholic worship in all the churches in Confederate-held territory and the sole jurisdiction of catholic priests over Irish catholics. But the agreement was to be kept secret until the Irish army was on English soil, and Glamorgan went beyond his instructions, and he was probably unsure as to how far his discretion stretched.

Glamorgan’s treaty never stood much chance of Being implemented, and it was doomed by the end of the year. In October, the pope sent the Archbishop of Fermo to Ireland as his nuncio. His overriding aims were to restore public catholic worship and the power of the cat church in Ireland. He called Glamorgan to Kilkenny for discussions, and reached an agreement with him on 20th December which added further concessions to those of the August treaty. The church was to regain most of its lands, catholic bishops were to sit in the Irish House of Lords, and the next Lord Lieutenant was to be a catholic. The Archbishop’s position had been further strengthened by two letters written by Charles in October to the pope and his cardinal secretary of state, expressing his full confidence in Glamorgan and promising to ratify any agreement that he made.
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 016-1.jpg

Unfortunately for Charles, the Archbishop of Tuam had been killed in a skirmish near Sligo and a copy of Glamorgan’s August treaty was found on him. It was sent to London and published on parliament’s orders; consequently, when Glamorgan returned to Dublin on 26 December, Ormond had him arrested and charged with treason. A month later, the king publicly disavowed Glamorgan’s treaty, and denied that the earl had had any authority to make concessions regarding religion, or to negotiate anything apart from the raising of forces, without Ormond’s ‘privity and directions’. That put paid to the possibility of raising forces in Ireland, but Ormond released Glamorgan under pressure from the Confederates. By then, the papal nuncio had lost interest in him, because Henrietta Maria had concluded a separate treaty with the pope on Charles’ behalf, through her envoy Sir Kenelm Digby, granting the Irish catholics even more than Glamorgan had promised.

The Siege of Exeter, the ‘Plague’ & the Death of Pickering:

During the first Civil War, there were probably more soldiers who died of disease than died on the battlefield, or of their wounds. The winter of 1645-6 at the siege of Exeter was no exception. Plague had been rife in and around Bristol at the time of its capture by pariamentarian forces, but those forces had apparently escaped infection. However, by early November the New Model Army was beset by a new outbreak of disease that was claiming many lives. Presumably the plague had been brought from Bristol, but had taken a month or more to take hold and spread in the army, possibly through Fairfax’s troops who had fallen ill before the siege of Tiverton in mid-October. The infantry reported sick in a number of places, but at Ottery St Mary, the army headquarters where many of them were quartered, between seven and nine soldiers were dying every day for several weeks, insomuch that it was not held safe for the headquarter to be continued there any longer. Many soldiers probably succumbed easily to illness because they were so poorly supplied. As the chaplain Hugh Peters reported from the army in October:

It is most certain that of twenty-one weeks the horse are twelve weeks behind, and the foot have likewise their proportion of sorrow through want of pay. I know three score in one company lying sick by eating of raw roots and green apples through want of money to buy proper food.
The officers lived in far greater comfort and had a much better diet, so one may expect they had greater resistance to illnesses. They were not, however, immune to the diseased that camp life engendered, so Colonel Pickering fell ill while at the army headquarters at Ottery. Like so many of the common soldiers, he did not recover, and on 24th November 1645, just before his fortieth birthday, …
… that pious, active Gentleman, that lived so much to God, and his Country, and divers other Officers, dyed of the New disease in that place; Six of the general’s own family were sick of it at one time, and throughout the foot regiments half the Souldiers. …
The victims of the ‘plague’ were not recorded in the parish register, and there is a claim that they were buried in a communal grave in Bury Meadow. John Pickering was given a funeral and a burial place appropriate to his rank. It must have taken some time for the news to reach his family in Northamptonshire, so the arrangements for the funeral were not made until more than two weeks of after John had died. On 10th December, Cromwell wrote from Tiverton to Colonel Ceely:
Its the desier of Sir Gilbert Pickeringe, that his deceased Brother, Col. Pickeringe should bee interred in your guarrison; and that to the end his funeral may bee solemnized with as much honour as his memorie calls for, you are desired to give all possible assistance therein: the particulars will be offered to you by his Major, Major Gubbs, with whom I desier you to concurr herein, and believe it. … Whereof rests assured your humble servant,
Oliver Cromwell.

In 1644 and 1645, including October, Colonel Ceely was in charge of the nearest parliamentarian garrison to Ottery St. Mary and and governor of Lyme Regis in Dorset. It lay fifteen miles to the east and had remained stauncly parliamentarian throughout the war. Unfortunately, the burial register for 1645 does not survive for the town, nor is there a monument Colonel John in the parish church. There can be little doubt that that Sir Gilbert’s wishes were carried out, and that his younger brother was buried at Lyme Regis with due ceremony in December 1645. The high esteem in which Pickering was held by many parliamentarians, both soldiers and MPs, can be seen in the various reports of his death in the newsheets of the time. The article in the Moderate Intelligencer was accompanied by an elegy:
Now that Bethel* and he are gone; For reward, garlands, or crowns for all their faithfull services, and valiant sections for their country, let England mourn them, lest the War outlive the Worthies: And it shall melt us into teares, to think, that these should not live to see the fruit of their service and share in the benefit upon earth, but the will of the Lord be done.

(*Major Bethell, one of the heroes of the Battle of Langport, had been killed at the siege of Bristol.)

Another newsheet, The Kingdom’s Scout, 2nd-9th December 1945, recorded:
The Souldiers are overwhelmed with grief, deare, gallant, Pickering is dead, the Champions, nor Oracles can cease to mourne since glorious Pickering is gone; the heaviest blow that England received this winter…
Pickering’s standing in the army cannot be overestimated, for Sprigge devoted a whole page to a poem on his death:
But whosoever would have me proceed in my story, must give me leave first to weep a while this sorrowfull verse, over deer Colonel Pickerings Hearse. …
Vain all our profer’d Ransoms are,
There’s no discharge in the Graves war;
Well they may shew; yet they cannot,
What a brave Captive death hath got
.
Colonel John Pickering, His Regiment of Foote – A Sealed Knot Regiment
The Pickering Coat of arms in the mid-seventeenth century.
In military terms, Pickering bequethed a regiment that would continue to have a significant impact on the events of the Civil Wars and the Interregnum. The success of Pickering’s regiment, now to become known as Hewson’s, including the advancement of its senior officers, was a clear reflection of the success of the Independents. As a close associate of Cromwell, Pickering had been in an ideal position to establish a regiment, in the teeth of Presbyterian opposition, that mirrored Cromwell’s own political and religious views. Of all the regiments in the New Model Army, it had been Pickering’s regiment alone which the presbyterians had wanted to be struck out en bloc. His deep religious conviction, in the eyes of enemies his fanatical Independency, was his strength in the first Civil War. His beliefs, shared with his troops, gave him and his regiment the deep commitment to succeed that was essential in winning such a war. Pickering’s close colleagues, Montague and Hardress Waller, saw great advancement under Cromwell. Edward Montague (pictured below) became a Councillor of State and then, following the Restoration, Admiral of the Fleet. Waller became a Major General, and two of the regiment’s senior officers, John Hewson and Daniel Axtell, were willing partners with Gilbert Pickering in the actions of the Commonwealth and Interregnum. As allies and supporters of Oliver Cromwell, right through to the installation of a military dictatorship, they remained close to the centre of power, and Axtell was executed as a regicide. Colonel John Pickering was typical of the puritan gentry behind the Cromwellian revolution, and his regiment provided the military power base which enabled the ‘Lord Protector’ to establish, albeit accidentally, the British Republic.
Above: Edward Montague, later Earl Of Sandwich, in 1642, at the age of seventeen. A friend of John Pickering, he had commanded an
Eastern Association regiment from the autumn of 1643. (We have no portrait of John Pickering, who was of a similar age when he died.)

Winter into Spring 1646 – Charles’ Surrender & Survival:

But first, in the winter and spring of 1645-6, there was still a civil war to be won decisively. On 5 December, King Charles proposed that parliament should send commissioners to discuss peace terms and asked for safe-conducts for commissioners of his own. These overtures were rightly seen by parliament as a bid to buy time, and were ignored. He met Montreuil on 2nd January and encouraged a plan for the Scottish army to join with the English presbyterians in fighting for him, with armed assistance from France. The Scottish commissioners in London were interested, but he would not pay their price; He was prepared to tolerate Presbyterianism, but not to make it the established religion of England. Henrietta Maria, who had persuaded Mazarin to send Montreuil, was impatient at such scruples, for she could see the little to choose between one form of heresy and another. In January, Charles was setting his hopes more on direct military aid from France, and was urging his wife to hasten the landing of five thousand troops at Hastings.
Ralph Hopton, 1st Baron Hopton - Wikipedia
Ralph Hopton, 1st Baron Hopton, the King’s Lieutenant-General of the West, painted c. 1637. An early opponent of the excesses of the Court, Hopton still felt duty-bound to support his king against rebellion, and proved to be a highly professional field commander. He died in exile in Bruges in 1651. Hopton served with William Waller during the Thirty Years War and the two soldiers remained friends during the Civil War, although they fought on opposing sides, though Waller retired from the ‘front line’ earlier. His son, Hardress Waller became an officer in the New Model Army.
But there was no help to be had now from outside the realm, and nothing to stave off defeat within it. Early in January, Fairfax set off on icy roads in Devon to clear the south-west, leaving enough troops to keep Exeter under siege. He took Dartmouth by assault on the 19th, then struck north-westwards to engage Hopton. The crucial action was the storming of Torrington on the night of 16th February, for the ensuing pursuit left Hopton with only the tattered remnants of an army. Hopton went on resisting against hopeless odds for as long as the Prince of Wales and his council remained in the south-west, but the king was now writing to his son repeatedly, urging him to escape overseas. Really in danger of capture, on 2 March, just as Fairfax was occupying Bodmin, Prince Charles sailed for the Scilly Isles. Soon afterwards, Fairfax invited Hopton to treat on honourable terms, and Hopton capitulated. On 12th March, the remainder of Hopton’s troops surrendered, and on the disbandment of the king’s army of the west, such as it still was, began on 20th March. The next day three thousand men who were left of the royalist main army under the command of Lord Astley, were utterly defeated and scattered at Stow-on-the-Wold. After that, only a few garrisons remained under arms for him, Exeter being the most important after Oxford and Newark. On 9 April, Fairfax took its surrender on generous terms, not only granting its defenders all the honours of war, but guaranteeing its cathedral and all its churches against defacement.
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 015-1.jpg

The chivalry with which Fairfax treated his enemies in their defeat and the discipline that he kept in the army helped to bring an end to resistance without pointless loss of life; so did the wide publicity given to the Glamorgan treaty and to the correspondence between the king and queen over military intervention by France. Damaging letters from Henrietta Maria (pictured below) were intercepted when a French sea captain put into Dartmouth, believing the port, recently captured by Fairfax, to still be in royalist hands. Once he was unopposed in the field, Fairfax set about preparing to besiege Oxford. Anxious at all costs to avoid capture, Charles slipped out of the city at 3 a.m. on 27 April, disguised as a servant, with only his friend Jack Ashburnham and his chaplain Michael Hudson for company. He had cut his hair, was wearing a false beard and was dressed without any of the trappings of a gentleman, much less those of a king.

His intentions are still something of a mystery, and he was probably not clear about them himself. He had told his council that he was going to London, that he had received an assurance that he would be well received at Westminster, but this may have been a feint on his part. He halted for three hours at Hillingdon, as if waiting for a message, and then rode on to Harrow, within sight of London’s towers. After a night at Wheathampstead, however, he turned north-eastward to Downham Market in Norfolk. He was heading towards the Scottish presbyterian army, which was besieging Newark and had its headquarters at Southwell. Montreuil was there, and Charles sent Hudson forward to seek his assurances that the Scots would support him. But since Montreuil had been negotiating with the Scots for over seven months, and Charles had been in personal contact with with him since early January, it is strange that there was such uncertainty about his reception. Moreover, the way that Charles awaited Hudson’s return so close to King’s Lynn suggests that he was keeping open the option of fleeing abroad, if the negotiations failed. For a while, the King continued to hide in Norfolk, hoping that he might yet escape by sea and join the queen in France. But the county was mainly in the control of parliament, and all the ports were being watched. His better chance lay with the Scots, even the Covenanters, for he knew that, Presbyterian though they were, their vision for the future assumed the continuing presence of a king of both Scotland and England. Exactly what sort of king was evidently open to dispute.

Hudson could not obtain the written assurance of Scottish armed support that Charles (pictured above) had urged Montreuil to procure for him. The Scots commissioners did, however, assent verbally to four engagements that Montreuil set down on paper. One of these was that they would not press the king to do anything against his conscience, and another was that if parliament refused to retore him to his rights and prerogatives they would declare for him. With those stipulations Charles had to be content, and he road into Southwell on 5th May, surrendering himself to the Scots army besieging Newark. From the moment he he put himself into the Scots’ hands he was treated as a prisoner, and he remained one for the rest of his life. They insisted that he should order Newark to surrender, and he did so. The surrender of Oxford followed, though only after lengthy negotiation. His remaining garrisons capitulated under assault, including Cardiff and Carlisle. But though the last royalist garrison in England to surrender did so in August 1646, the last to hold out in Wales was Harlech (below) which flew the royal standard until 13th March 1647, a full year after Hopton’s surrender in the west. By then, to all intents and purposes, the first Civil War was long since over, since the last of Leven’s army had left England on 3rd February, but the hauling down of the banner at Harlech was its last act. After that, the problems of the peace settlement could be tackled in earnest. But though the King himself was now a captive at Holmby House in Northants, his wife, eldest son and many of his supporters had escaped to Europe. The situation was one of armistice, a truce which might easily be broken.

Harlech Castle
Britain was deeply war-weary when the fighting ended, but the prospects of its finding relief in a generally acceptable peace settlement were heavily clouded. On the face of it, a settlement might not have been too difficult, since the war had not been a clash between irreconcilable ideologies, as on the continent. Both sides had professed to take up arms for much the same things: the rights and privileges of parliament the just powers and prerogatives of the monarch, the true protestant religion, the fundamental laws of the land, and the liberties of the subject. That went for the Scots too, though their conception of the true protestant religion was very different from that of most Englishmen. Charles had hoped to be able to exploit the differences between the Scots and the Westminster Parliament to the extent of gaining military support from the former. The cost of such support, however, was the adoption of Presbyterianism in England and to this, Charles would not at first agree. Just what the ‘new England’ and the ‘new Britain’ was supposed to look like, what the prize was for which so many had laid down their lives, remained unresolved. So many of the principles for which the parliament had gone to war for in 1642 had been made redundant by the transforming brutality of the conflict. The one thing that had not changed, shared by a majority in parliament, was that they needed some sort of king, chastened, emasculated, restrained and reformed, but a king none the less, as an indispensible element in the constitution.

The Aftermath & the Legacy of Loss in the War:

Between the last battle of the first civil war, at the end of March 1646, and the first military action in the second, just over two years elapsed in which the British peoples licked their wounds and counted the cost of civil strife. Their experience naturally coloured their quest for a peace settlement and, when that quest failed, their wrath against those whom they counted responsible for the renewal of war. The first civil war had had taken a heavy toll in human lives and livelihoods, leaving physical and mental scars on the survivors, and in the lasting material damage that it had inflicted. As the main theatres of war, the peoples of England and Wales had taken the heaviest casualties. Ireland’s agony still lay mainly in the future and, together with further significant battles in Scotland, needs to be considered in separate contexts on future anniversaries. Scottish casualties in England were not very heavy in the first Civil War, because Leven’s army did little serious fighting after the Battle of Marston Moor in 1644. They would be heavier when the Scots fought for the Stuart kings at Preston and Worcester in 1648 and 1651, which brought the estimated total of those killed to 6,120. In Scotland itself, Montrose’s campaigns were small in scale but took a severe toll in men killed – an estimated 2,400 of his men and as many as 12,300 Covenenters. In southern mainland Britain, it is very hard to quantify the scale of fatal casualties, because contemporary estmates often varied wildly and tended to exaggerate.
The Course of the First Civil War, 1642-46.
The tally of dead left on battlefields might be more or less accurately counted, but not the numbers of those who died later from their wounds, or who were cut down in pursuits. Major battles accounted for only fifteen per cent of of fatalities; more than three times as many died in skirmishes or other minor engagements, and sieges were responsible for nearly a quarter. Most of the rest are attributable to exploding powder-barrels, bursting pistols and fatal accidents with artillery and muskets. A painstaking recent estimate by Charles Carlton (1991, ’92) suggests that between 1642 and 1651, the total number of those who died by these various means amounted to over eighty-four thousand, over sixty-two thousand of whom perished in the first war. In the seventeenth century, however, war-related diseases, especially typhus and dysentry, together with the ravages of plague in besieged cities which allowed no escape, regularly took a heavier toll than actual combat, and probably carried off at least a hundred thousand. If these figures are anything like correct, they may mean that in proportion to the whole population of England and Wales, the civil wars carried off more dead than the First World War, and certainly many more than died in combat in World War Two.
Infantrymen suffered far higher casualties than cavalrymen, though it depended very much on whether they served in garrison or field armies. Those in the latter who survived the heavy slaughter in major battles, the gruelling marches with poor footwear and meagre rations, the epidemics of the camp and the nights in the open, often in wet clothes, were fortunate, though many lost limbs or bore other scars of war. Common soldiers who were wounded in the field were lucky if they received the services of a services of a surgeon, and if they did so there was no anaesthetic to relieve the agony of an amputation and no effective amputation and no effective antiseptics to stave off gangrene. Those who were made prisoners of war would expect to be plundered of any possessions and stripped of any clothes worth taking, and were liking to be crammed suffocatingly into churches and other buildings and half starved before further before further arrangements were made for them. Sometimes a triumphant enemy subjected them to collective public humiliation. The luckiest were exchanged, or set free under promise not to fight again; the unluckiest were sold as indentured servants to planters in Barbados and worked to death, though this happened mainly to those taken from 1648 to 1651. Many on both sides promptly enlisted in their captors’ army, for war had become a way of life to them; they knew no other trade, and peace must have brought them problems.
The experience of garrison troops varied very greatly, from relative comfort and idleness if they never came under attack from to sheer horror if they succumbed to a direct assault after a long siege. But with regard to sieges, one cannot draw a hard line between the experiences of soldiers and civilians, or indeed between those of men and women. All shared, if unequally, the blight of hunger and hardship and disease that a long siege imposed. Women often worked alongside men in building fortifications, putting out fires, taking their turn at guard duty, bringing food and drinkto the soldiers under fire, reloading their muskets, and even sniping with them at the besiegers. There were defences in which women took full command, notably the Countess of Derbyin Latholm House on the king’s side and Lady Brilliana Harley in Brampton Bryan Castle on the parliament’s. But the worst civilian suffering occurred in populous towns which withstood long sieges, for the attacking commanders seldom allowed women and children to leave since their departure would allow resistance to be prolonged. The squalor and stench when water was scarce can only be imagined, when people were unable to wash themselves or their clothes, when hunger made them too weak to bury their dead, and when sewage had no escape from a surrounding ditch or a sluggish mid-town river.
If the defending commander refused terms of surrender and the town was taken by storm and it was generally reckoned on both sides that the ordinary soldiery were entitled to take what they could by looting. Soldiers who had been through the extreme danger of assaulting manned fortifications were apt to engage in indiscriminate slaughter and wanton destruction, wrecking what they could not take with them and sell. Yet in comparison with the continental wars there was generally some restraint, and there seems to have been very little rape. England experienced nothing similar to the atrocities on the continent during the Thirty Years’ War in the 1630s and ’40s. Army discipline was improving due to the advent of the New Model Army: Before Fairfax (pictured below) stormed Bristol he promised his men two weeks’ pay in lieu of sack, and a grateful corporation was glad to help him find the money. The New Model’s discipline after Naseby and Fairfax’s willingness to grant honourable terms to garrisons in the West saved many lives and spared much property, shortening a war that might have been prolonged by desperate resistance.

The Lord General, Thomas Fairfax.
Material damage in England was generally greater in the towns than in the countryside, though the destruction of crops and orchards and timber caused hardship enough at the time. At least a hundred and fifty towns sustained significant destruction of property, though actual war damage was very unequally distributed, since in the first Civil War there was no serious military action east of a line drawn through King’s Lynn, Cambridge, London and Arundel. The Midlands and the Welsh borders were the worst affected areas, though parts of the Welsh interior and the West Country suffered considerably. Posterity has tended to focus on the ruination of churches and castles and mansions, but in terms of human suffering the destruction of ordinary dwellings took a far heavier toll. It has been reckoned that ten thousand houses were demolished or burnt down in towns and at least one thousand in villages, which would suggest that about one in ten inhabitants of provincial towns and villages was made homeless, many more in the main theatres of war.
It was not only in war-torn regions that people lost their homes, because many were deliberately demolished before an enemy came near. Few towns still had their medieval defences intact since they had not been needed after the ‘Wars of the Roses’ in the fifteenth century. Newer ‘Tudor’ towns had never had any. Where defensible walls survived, many buildings had gone up alongside them, providing cover for attacking troops and miners, or denied the defending artillery and musketeers the clear field of fire that they needed. Many suburban dwellings were pulled down when war broke out, sometimes by order of the corporation, but more often on the insistence of the local military commander. And in most defended towns existing fortifications needed to be extended or new ones created; bastions were built out of from old walls and sconces erected outside them. Usually this necessitated the demolition of houses and their re-erection elsewhere. Damage by direct military action took many forms. Bombardment was only one, and the slow rate of seventeenth-century cannon-fire and the limited effectiveness of solid shot fired at low velocity made it less destructive than modern artillery fire. Fires were a greater menace, especially where thatched roofs were the norm, and considerable use was made on red-hot shot to start them.
Even more effective, and more damaging to civilian morale, were the hollow iron grenades filled with gunpowder or quick-burning material that were fired over walls by large mortars with a high trajectory. But these were scarce and very expensive weapons; the New Model had only one mortar when it first took the field, though by the end of the war he was able to deploy six at sieges. Considering how combustible most houses were when timber, lath-and-plaster and thatch were the commonest building materials, serious firestorms were were surprisingly rare and most fires were less more or less successfully contained. Town corporations were well aware of the danger and made serious provision against it. In the most heavily war-damaged towns it might be thirty years or more before their stricken suburbs were fully rebuilt. Gloucester’s population had not recovered its pre-war level by the end of the century, and York’s was about the same in 1760 as it had been in 1640, but this was partly because the tide of economic expansion was passing these cities by. Elsewhere there was a great deal of reconstruction in the 1650s and 1660s, and most of the material ravages of war were repaired within a generation.

Some losses were of course irreperable, and the destruction wrought in some cathedrals, whether by military action as in Lichfield or bigoted iconoclasm as in Ely, was tragic. Churches in defended towns quite often suffered because their towers were manned by gunners and snipers, or because they became a last refuge for a desperate garrison. Not all were rebuilt, and one reason why some survive in ruins is that many towns had become overprovided for in churches by the 1640s. It is always worth checking whether the smashing of medieval glass and and statuary can really be blamed on Oliver Cromwell’s soldiers, as most of these assertions are only justified by folk memory. Iconoclasm, such as much of that at Ely, often turns out to have taken place in the Protestant Reformation of a century earlier, under the orders of Thomas Cromwell’s commissioners. Most of the deliberate iconoclastic acts of the civil war period were carried out on the authority of a parliamentary ordinance of August 1643, almost ten years before Cromwell became Lord Protector. It commanded the general demolition of altars and defacement of paintings and sculptures. In addition, all candlesticks were to be removed, and these were taken in payment for the services rendered. One of the parliamentary ‘visitors’ who executed this order, William Dowsing, destroyed more ecclesiastical treasures in the two counties of Cambridgeshire and Suffolk than all the soldiery on both sides in the entire period of the Civil Wars.
Dowsing had risen from obscurity from Laxfield in Suffolk and returned to it after a brief blaze of what he thought of as glory. He had immediately came forward as one prepared for the zeal of the Lord to undertake this task and was appointed Parliamentary Visitor by the General of the Eastern Association. After creating havoc in Cambridgeshire, Dowsing turned to his own county of Suffolk. Between January and October 1644 he toured Suffolk with a company of soldiers, smashing stained glass windows and defacing carved bench ends and fonts, breaking down crucifixes, tearing up brasses and obliterating inscriptions. In his disastrous rampage he visited 150 churches and carefully recorded his handiwork in a journal. At Clare, for example:
We broke down one thousand pictures superstitious. I broke down two hundred; three of God the Father and three of Christ and the Holy Lamb, and three of the Holy Ghost like a dove with wings; and the twelve apostles were carved in wood, on the top of the roof, which we gave order to take down; and twenty cherubims to be taken down; and the sun and moon in the east window, by the King’s arms to be taken down.
Some parishes, it is only fair to say, welcomed Dowsing and co-operated with him but others, such as Ufford, put up a show of resistance, locked the church and tried to keep the desecrators at bay. Many churchwardens, even if sympathetic to Dowsing, resented to having to pay the standard charge of 6s. 8d. for his visitation. The more general vandalism of some parliamentarian troops was also the product of preaching that encouraged them to believe that cathedrals, in particular, were centres of idolatry. They did considerable damage to a dozen of them, but parish churches suffered much less by them; of more than nine thousand in England and Wales, they are known to have despoiled fewer than thirty. It was one thing to purify religion of the popish vestments of prelates and relics; it was quite another to show a total disrespect for the things of God, as did soldiers who used churches for stables and fired their muskets at ancient windows and monuments for target practice.
To the north of Lostwitiel, Restormel Castle’, which was captured by Grenville… ( c. 1100 wooden defences were replaced by stone fortifications, c. 1200.) … in the Battle of Lostwithiel on 31 August 1644 was a major defeat for the Parliamentary forces in the West, caught between the King’s army from the east and Sir Richard Grenville’s forces from the West.
Castles and country houses suffered heavily during the wars, usually because they were garrisoned. Most castles underwent the greatest damage after the fighting ceased, when they were deliberately made indefensible. Some, like Banbury, Tickhill and Pontefract were in large part demolished, but more often they were ‘slighted’, which generally meant having their outer walls destroyed while their living quarters were left relatively intact. That was the fate of Kenilworth, Sudely, Dudley, Denbigh, Pembroke and Raglan, among others. From 1642, soldiers on both sides ransacked the houses of the gentry for arms and plate. A visit of one Eastern Association troop at Somerleyton House near Lowestoft cost Sir John Wentworth forty-four pounds in various appropriations and plus a hundred and sixty pounds of gold. Many country houses were also garrisoned. The more important defended towns were commonly surrounded by a ring of satellite garrisons, often in suitably sited mansions strengthened by defensive works, and if the central stronghold had to be abandoned the satellites were sometimes demolished so as to deny the enemy the use of them. Between a hundred and fifty and two hundred country houses are thought to have been destroyed, including gems like Sir Baptist Hick’s mansion in Chipping Campden. In the later stages of the Naseby campaign parliament made a conscious attempt to limit the damage. Countermanding a county committee’s instructions to burn a great hose in order to prevent it from being occupied and defended by royalists, the Committee of Both Kingdoms stated in April 1646 that it did not…
… think it fit that all houses whose situation or strength render them capable of being made garrisons should be pulled down. There would then be too many sad marks left of the calamity of this war.
There were sad marks enough, but many country houses were rebuilt as England entered its most glorious age of domestic architecture. The loss was not as great as in the case of medieval cathedrals and castles, nor was the resultant distress to be compared with that of the poor and homeless.

( … to be continued… part one of three. )

Sources:

Austin Woolrych (2002), Britain in Revolution, 1625-1660. Oxford: OUP.
Glenn Foard (1994),

Whitstable: Pryor Publications.

Four Hundred Years Ago: The Birth of a ‘New England’ – Trans-Atlantic Separatists & the Language of Dissent.

‘The Ship they called the Mayflower‘:

The 16th September 2020 marks the four hundredth anniversary of the departure of the ship, Mayflower, from Plymouth Sound in Devon, England. The ‘Pilgrim Fathers’ were drawn from the Puritan separatists who had set up illegal churches in Lincolnshire and other parts of East Anglia. Threatened with fines and/or imprisonment, some had fled to Holland, setting up churches in Amsterdam and Leyden, but then decided to reunite their English churches by setting up a religious ‘plantation’ or colony in America. The Mayflower left Delftshaven in July 1620, the saints being joined by prospective settlers from England at Southampton in August, where the Speedwell, the smaller accompanying ship, already leaking, had to be repaired. The two ships left Southampton on 5 August but had to put into Dartmouth in Devon for further repairs. On the second attempt, they sailed about 350 miles beyond Land’s End, before Speedwell again started taking on water. The ships returned to Dartmouth, and most of the separatists decided to go on to the New World on Mayflower alone, finally leaving Plymouth on 6 September. Of the 120 combined passengers, 102 were chosen to travel on the Mayflower with the supplies consolidated. Of these, about half had come by way of Leyden, and about 28 of the adults were members of the congregation. The reduced party finally sailed successfully on September 6 (old calendar)/September 16 (new), 1620.

A diagram of the Mayflower. It was in the first and second holds that the passengers lived, ate, and slept during the three-month voyage. In the twenty years that followed the voyage of the ship, some twenty thousand colonists from the British Isles settled in New England, as they called it, having crossed the Atlantic on ships of a similar size.

The Elizabethan puritans had wanted to reform the church from within, to make it more like Jean Calvin‘s church in Geneva, as part of a ‘Corpus Christianum’, a Christian state. They simply wanted to purify the national church from all the ceremonial remnants, vestiges and vestments of Roman Catholicism. They also questioned whether there was any biblical basis for the authority of bishops over the Church. Some wanted to replace them with a system of elders and synods, with stricter discipline. This became known as Presbyterianism. Elizabeth I resisted these changes and James I hated Presbyterians, threatening to ‘harry them out of the land.’ His problems with the English puritans were as nothing compared with what he had suffered from the ‘high’ Calvinists in his native Scotland. The leading role of the laity and James’ long minority had resulted in the establishment of a predominantly Presbyterian Kirk of Scotland, with no royal supremacy comparable to that which existed in Tudor England.

The high tide of Scottish Calvinism began to flow in 1574, when the famous scholar Andrew Melville returned from Geneva to assume the the headship of the University of Glasgow. He revived both Glasgow and St Andrews, but also fought to make the Kirk totally Presbyterian throughout the final decades of the sixteenth century and, perhaps most importantly, to make it independent of the Crown. Eventually, in 1606, Melville was summoned to London, where his invective against the Anglican forms of worship and, in particular, Archbishop Bancroft’s ‘Romish Rags’ so incenced the privy councillors that it committed him to the Tower, where he stayed for five years before being banished to France for the rest of his life. After this, James gradually restored both the crown and the bishops to considerable authority within the Kirk, but though, by 1621, he had forced it to accept the observance of the great Christian festivals and various other ‘Anglican’ practices, faced by open rebellion, he abandoned his plan to introduce a Scottish Prayer Book, based on the English Book of Common Prayer. To build on his success, it was important to avoid alienating the clergy, the nobles and the lairds all at the same time, giving them common cause to rebel. Where James had succeeded, however, Charles was to fail catastrophically.

In England, meanwhile, while many Calvinists compromised uneasily within the state Church, others eventually left of their own accord, more radical groups of ‘separatists’ growing up in parallel to the main puritan group. The separatists had first attracted the the attention of the authorities in the 1580s. They had formed their own independent congregation at Norwich in 1581, withdrawing completely from the Church, which they believed to be so polluted it could not be cleansed from within. However, in Elizabethan England it was illegal not to attend the national church and to form separate church congregations. The ‘sectaries’ or separatists, sometimes called ‘Brownists’ after one of their early leaders, incurred the heavy displeasure of church and state alike, though ‘mainstream’ puritans within the established church felt no need to consider leaving England, since they felt tolerably at home within the established church. But then an Act against Seditious Sectaries was passed, giving those who persisted in attending ‘conventicles’ the choice between death or banishment. In 1593 three of their pastors were executed for sedition.

Despite this, early in the seventeenth century, separatists set up further illegal churches in Scrooby and Gainsborough in Lincolnshire. The government of their chapel was based on a ‘covenant’, marking the beginning of the ‘Congregationalist’ movement. They were threatened with fines and imprisonments if they did not conform with the Church of England. Some of them, in 1608, fled to Holland to escape from persecution by the authorities, setting up churches in Amsterdam and later in Leyden. The Dutch were tolerant of religious nonconformity and allowed the English independents refugee status and freedom of worship. However, life in the Netherlands was far from easy for the exiles. They stayed briefly in Amsterdam and then moved to the city of Leyden where they remained for the next twelve years. Even so, they remained impoverished, most of them working in the depressed cloth trades. Others worked as printers, carpenters and tailors. Even children had to work all day, and had little time for education. Parents felt shut off and feared that their that their children would lose their language and identity as English people, so they decided to move again, this time to somewhere they could farm the land and maintain both their religious and cultural identities. In order to make a new start, both spiritually and materially, the groups in both England and Holland determined to cross the Atlantic and found a colony in the New World. It was from Leyden that one of these groups emigrated to New England, via Plymouth, in 1620. In July of that year they sailed in the Speedwell from Delftshaven to rendezvous with the English congregationalists in Southampton and Dartmouth before setting off for the New World.

The English General Baptists had their beginnings in 1608, when John Smyth, being convinced that no surviving church possessed the true ordinances, baptised first himself and then the rest of his congregation. But separatists remained few, and most of them went into exile, to Amsterdam and other Dutch cities, rather than face the harsh penalties that threatened them at home. The second-stage migration of the Mayflower ‘Pilgrims’ from Leyden was a response to the economic conditions in the Netherlands, and therefore different from the migrations with mixed motivations of the 1630s. The persecutions worsened after Charles I came to the throne and Laud became Archbishop of Canterbury, as the evidence below confirms.

By the time the ‘Pilgrim’ congregationalists left the Netherlands, other groups had already returned to England, led by Thomas Helwys, who had founded the first openly ‘Baptist’ church in London. Helwys’ group formed the first General or Arminian Baptist Congregation in England at Spitalfields in 1612. Arminianism was a rejection of Calvinist ideas of predestination and ‘God’s Elect’, and the belief that God’s grace is available to all. They practised believers’ baptism as a sign of this.  By 1638, there were also Calvinists in London who practised believers’ baptism, and these became known as ‘Particular Baptists‘. They had grown out of the first independent congregations in the capital, and their understanding of the church as a gathered community led to them professing that only the baptism of believers fitted such a view. Helwys’ group had been much influenced by the Dutch Mennonites, but both the General and Particular Baptist churches developed out of a conscientious search for the true pattern of the ‘apostolic church’ of the New Testament and the first century.

Seafarers, Strangers and Pilgrims:

The English congregational emigrants were not alone in deciding to leave either Holland and England to establish a farming village in the New World. Their intention, like many others, was to establish a farming village in the northern part of the Virginia Colony. At that time, Virginia effectively extended from Jamestown in the south to to the mouth of the Hudson River in the north, and the would-be emigrants planned to settle near where New York City is located today. The congregation purchased a small ship, the Speedwell, to transport them across the sea and to use for fishing and trading along the Atlantic shore.

The story of what was to become the first North American settlements by Europeans had begun in 1583 when Sir Humphrey Gilbert, under charter from Elizabeth I, claimed Newfoundland for England (my Hungarian readers may be interested in the fact that one of his fellow explorers was a Hungarian historian and poet István Parmenius of Buda). Most of the early settlers there were not English, however, but Gaelic-speaking fishermen and indentured servants from Ireland. To this day, Newfoundland English is a distinct variant of North American English. Heading South, Gilbert was then drowned in a storm with the famous last words, We are as neer to heaven by sea as by land. Sir Walter Raleigh took up the cause of founding a new colony, temporarily establishing the Cittie of Ralegh in Virginea, on today’s coast of North Carolina. The story of The Lost Colony, as it became known, and of Pocahontas, exemplifies the adventurous mariners of the Jacobean era but also shows how hazardous and difficult the settlement of the New World was. The first group began the colony of Jamestown in 1607, hoping to find gold there. But they had very little food, and many of them died during the first winter.

Raleigh, now out of favour with the Crown, continued to express his undying faith in an English empire overseas. With hindsight, the colonisation of the new huge land-mass of North America by English-speaking settlers seems inevitable and Ralegh’s boast to Sir Robert Cecil in 1602, that he would yet live to see it an English Nation might not seem so idle, had he been allowed to live on. However, at the time neither Raleigh nor the prospective settlers could envisage what they were taking on, let alone confront the harsh realities of the new frontier on the other side of the ocean. The hazards of extremes of climate and the difficulties of transforming wild country into good farming land were often underestimated by would-be ‘planters’. Many expeditions were destroyed by natives and even after James I came to the English throne in 1603, there was news that a colony of fifteen hundred settlers had been wiped out. But the Jamestown settlers stopped looking for gold and started growing tobacco instead, which they sold in Europe where smoking was becoming fashionable, and the colony survived. It then began to thrive when slaves were brought from Africa to expand the plantations, better able to withstand the sub-tropical climate. In the early seventeenth century, it was not just the British and Irish who came to live in North America: the French in Quebec and the Dutch in New York had also begun major settlements. In the meantime, raiding and trading, including slave-trading, was continuing to prove far more lucrative for the English ‘privateers’ and adventurers.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is the_leading_facts_of_american_history_1910_-_the_first_negro_slaves_brought_to_virginia.png
Dutch slave-traders in the early seventeenth century and their African human ‘cargo’

By contrast, the ‘pilgrims’, as they became known only after the War of Independence, were English patriots who thought of their new territory as New England. Although they were determined to maintain their independence from the state church in England, as ‘secularists’ they were loyal to the English Crown and received permission and funding from it to found a new colony in the New World. As already mentioned, they had originally intended to settle close to the Virginian colonists, but sailed off course and landed further north in what is now Cape Cod Bay, in the state of Massachusetts. On 21 December, they arrived at an abandoned Indian village where they settled, re-naming it Plymouth. Their allegiance was still very much to their mother country and they had no intention of founding a new nation. The territory is now called by the Amerindian name of Massachusetts, though it is still referred to as New England. The first use of the word pilgrims for the Mayflower passengers appeared in William Bradford’s Of Plimouth Plantation. As he finished recounting his group’s July 1620 departure from Leyden, he used the imagery of Hebrews 11: 13-16 about Old Testament “strangers and pilgrims” who had the opportunity to return to their old country but instead longed for a better, heavenly country:

So they lefte [that] goodly & pleasante citie, which had been ther resting place, nere 12 years; but they knew they were pilgrimes, & looked not much on these things; but lift up their eyes to ye heavens, their dearest cuntrie, and quieted their spirits.

Embarkation of the Pilgrims by Robert Weir a c...
Embarkation of the Pilgrims by Robert Weir a copy is also located in the, United States Capitol rotunda, Washington, DC (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

There is no record of the term Pilgrims being used to describe Plymouth’s founders for 150 years after Bradford wrote this passage, except when quoting him. The Mayflower’s story was retold by historians Nathaniel Morton (in 1669) and Cotton Mather (in 1702), and both paraphrased Bradford’s passage and used his word pilgrims. At Plymouth’s Forefathers’ Day observance in 1793, Rev. Chandler Robbins recited this passage. The Mayflower emigrants themselves and their contemporaries never referred to themselves as ‘pilgrims’, a word which was only popularised in ‘old’ England after the publication of Bunyan’s famous work from the 1680s. They may have used the word ‘saints’ and it may have been used by further settlers to distinguish between themselves and the ‘separatists’ or ‘dissenters’. Nor is there any evidence to suggest that they regarded themselves as ‘fathers’ or ‘founders’ of a new earthly ‘nation’, an action which would have seemed and been seen as treasonous at the time. Again, the scant contemporary evidence is drawn from Bradford’s later history of the Massachusetts colony, which confirms the strong sense of patriotism in one of the finest and earliest examples of prose written in America:

But may not and ought not the children of these fathers rightly say – Our Fathers were Englishmen which came over this great ocean, and were ready to perish in the wilderness, but they cried unto the Lord, and he heard their voice and looked on their adversities.

Colonial expansion in America & the Caribbean to 1707. Roanoke was England’s first colony in the Americas (1584-90). It failed, in part because of the war between England and Spain which made sailings by support expeditions impossible. The settlers were evacuated and resettled once, but when a relief ship arrived in 1590 it found no trace of them. A number of early settlements suffered similarly through inadequate supplies. Colonies were established along the North American coast, some by those seeking to escape religious persecution. Many who moved to the West Indies hoped for quick wealth through raiding Spanish America as privateers. Others became involved in the highly profitable slave plantation economy that also developed along the coast of North America. Large-scale emigration and the volume of settlers crossing the Atlantic led to the growth of empire.

Escaping Persecution & Looking for a True England:

In his address on BBC RADIO 4’s SUNDAY WORSHIP PROGRAMME, 13/09/2020 (available to listen to via the BBC web-site/ ‘BBC Sounds’), Stephen Tomkins has pointed out that it’s often said that the Mayflower pilgrims sailed to North America to escape religious persecution. It’s true that many members of their Separatist movement had suffered imprisonment and death in England for their faith. But after three of their leaders were executed in 1593, the Separatists took refuge in Leyden in the Netherlands, and there they enjoyed religious toleration for twenty-seven years before the Mayflower sailed. So, if they no longer needed to escape persecution, why did they take the dreadfully dangerous course of migrating to North America? They went because of a familiar Bible story from the book of Exodus:

Then Moses stretched out his hand over the sea. The Lord drove the sea back by a strong east wind all night, and turned the sea into dry land; and the waters were divided. The Israelites went into the sea on dry ground, the waters forming a wall for them on their right and on their left.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 012-1.jpg
Embarking the Mayflower in Plymouth, 16 September 1620. Getty Images, after a famous painting by Arthur Cope which illustrates the scene as a group of ‘Pilgrims’ are pushed offshore in a small boat, taking them to the ship.

In the book of Exodus, God’s people, the children of Israel, are slaves in Egypt. It’s the land of their birth, but a godless place of oppression, where they are subjected to cruelty and violence, by an unholy regime. So, in the story of the Exodus, God leads the Israelites out of Egypt, across the sea, to the promised land, where they will be free and prosper:

Then the Lord said to Moses, “Stretch out your hand over the sea, so that the water may come back upon the Egyptians, upon their chariots and chariot drivers.” So Moses stretched out his hand over the sea, and at dawn the sea returned to its normal depth. As the Egyptians fled before it, the Lord tossed the Egyptians into the sea. The waters returned and covered the chariots and the chariot drivers, the entire army of Pharaoh that had followed them into the sea; not one of them remained. But the Israelites walked on dry ground through the sea, the waters forming a wall for them on their right and on their left. Thus the Lord saved Israel that day from the Egyptians.

Map showing the orginal locations of the main group of Separatists in England & the Netherlands during the decades before their departure to the New World.

The Separatists believed that they were the people of God in their own day, just as the Israelites were in the Bible. They were suffering in the same way – England was the new Egypt. And so they believed that God was leading them out of that land of chains and blood, across the sea to freedom, in the Netherlands. The problem was that the Netherlands did not turn out to be much of a promised land. They enjoyed religious freedom there, but they lived in poverty, they suffered splits and scandals, life was hard, their numbers declined. What did these struggles mean? They looked again at the story of the Exodus and remembered that after God led Israel out of Egypt they had wandered for many years in the wilderness – a time of testing – before the Lord led them again, through the waters of the Jordan, finally, into the promised land. So the Separatists concluded that, following the same pattern, they too had another journey to make before they reached the place to which God was calling them.

The Puritans’ Tangled Motivations for Migration:

Many, perhaps most, of the Mayflower migrants were Puritan dissenters, or separatists, who would not conform with the liturgy and practices of the Church of England, and their story became the story of American English. Their motives were a tangle of idealistic, colonising, self-interested and religious ambitions. The Pilgrim Fathers went to escape, in the words of Andrew Marvell, the Prelate’s Rage. They were also escaping from a monarch of Great Britain who hated both Scottish Presbyterians and English Independents among his subjects, vowing to harry them out of the land. But neither of these groups declared themselves as opponents of monarchy, which they saw as the legitimate instrument of secular authority. This was twenty years before the civil wars broke out, first in Scotland, and then in England. But though they may well have believed in the ‘Divine Right’ of King James to be God’s annointed magistrate over secular, ‘temporal’ matters, they certainly did not accept the right of any monarch to rule over matters of religion and conscience. Their impulse to migrate was therefore, simultaneously, both profoundly conservative and revolutionary, in religious terms at least. They hoped to find an austere wilderness where they could establish an authentically English Christian community. They did not see themselves as abandoning their East Anglian identity, but rather purifying and transplanting it. They did not see themselves as creating a new country, America, but rather as recreating the old country, free from what they felt were the papist poisons prevalent in the national church.

At Southampton, the Leyden congregation on the Speedwell was joined by the other English congregations and the Mayflower. The two ships departed for England together, but twice had to return to port, first at Dartmouth and then Plymouth, because the Speedwell kept leaking due to having been re-fitted with too large a mast. Finally, the Mayflower left Plymouth alone on 16 September, with 102 passengers. When the Mayflower set sail, the largest group on board came from East Anglia, but they represented thirty different communities from all over England. These can still be seen in the place-names of New England… Boston, Bedford, Braintree, Cambridge, Lincoln and Yarmouth. By the middle of the seventeenth century, there were some already a quarter of a million colonists on the North-Eastern seaboard of North America, mainly from London and the eastern counties. 

"The Landing of the Pilgrims."(1877)...
“The Landing of the Pilgrims.”(1877) by Henry A. Bacon (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

The sixty-six days spent on board the Mayflower was far from comfortable, as the cross-section diagram above suggests. The ship was originally built as a cargo ship and under the deck the ceiling was so low that the adults, including the women, could not stand up straight. Due to the roughness of the crossing and the risk of fire, they were unable to cook. They had no livestock in any case, so food was very basic. Drinking water was unsafe, so everyone, including the children, drank ‘ale’ or ‘small beer’ as the chief means of hydration. Sanitation consisted of slop-buckets, and there was no running water for bathing. Many of the passengers suffered seasickness for much of the journey and sleeping facilities were either improvised bunks or hammocks. Each of the families brought only one chest for clothes, weapons and tools for cooking, building and gardening. There was one baby born on board; its parents named it ‘Oceanus’. During the voyage, one passenger, John Howland, fell overboard, but managed to save himself by catching hold of a rope he had been trailing in the water. He lived on to become an influential member of the Plymouth community. Mayflower arrived at what became known as Plymouth Harbour on 16 December, 1620. While they were building their houses, the group continued to live on board ship. Many of them fell ill in the winter, probably from scurvy, due to a continued lack of fresh fruit and vegetables, and from pneumonia, due to the wet, damp conditions. Two or three of them died each day until only fifty-two remained, the survivors of the first year. Of the nineteen women who had boarded, only five survived, though one further baby was born shortly after the landing, the first of a new generation on American soil.

After the Separatists settled in New England, many other Puritans followed, as many as twenty thousand of them over the next twenty years. One of Suffolk’s famous Puritan sons was John Winthrop, lord of the manor of Groton and a landowner descended from a long line of Lavenham clothiers, and a practising lawyer. His conscience would not allow him to enjoy the rural peace of his patrimonial estates. In June 1628 he he met with other of like mind in Cambridge and they resolved to get together a party of men and women prepared to follow the example of the ‘Pigrim Fathers’. Winthrop was elected their leader and, less than two years later, he led a fleet of emigrants out of Southampton. They founded Boston in 1630 and Winthrop became the first Governor of the colony of Massachusetts upon its founding. Many of these early settlers were determined to establish a new, purified version of the all-encompassing English state church which would be enforced on all citizens. Winthrop felt an affinity with the kind of international protestant interest that was embodied by the Elector Palatine and Elizabeth Stuart, the deposed ‘winter’ King and Queen of Bohemia. Abandoned by her brother in favour of his Hapsburg alliance, Elizabeth had received a letter from Viscount Dorchester in which he expressed his admiration for …

… our godly people, who, weary of this wicked land, are gone (man, woman and child) in great numbers to seek new worlds.

Another friend of hers, Sir Thomas Roe, also wrote to her of his intention to settle in the New World: … if there be an America, I can live. In the 1630s he called for an Anglo-Dutch alliance to invade the Spanish Indies. As Lord Protector, twenty years later, Cromwell mounted this ‘mighty war’ without a Dutch alliance. I return to its implications below, but it is worth noting here that the colonists of the Providence Island venture used slave labour in large quantities between 1629 and 1641, when it came to an end. (On this, Christopher Hill references a 1968 book by W D Jordan, White over Black: American Attitudes towards the Negro: Chapel Hill.)

Most Separatists, however, remained true to their vision. Their church in America, as it had been in England, was a voluntary community, a gathering for those who chose to worship together, a place of freedom. The ‘Great Migration’ to New England was certainly underway, coinciding almost exactly with Charles’ period of personal rule. Between 1629 and 1640 about sixty thousand men, women and children made the journey and, far more than in the case of Virginia and the other older colonies whole families wound up their affairs in England and sailed to Massachusetts together. By no means all of them emigrated for religious reasons, but the high proportion who did brave such a vast and perilous change of life for the sake of their faith, and the number of ordained ministers who sailed with them, are eloquent testimony that for a significant sector of the English population, the only religion permitted to them by law had become offensive to their consciences to a degree unprecedented before Charles’ reign. In contrast to the Mayflower emigrants, who were avowed separatists, many who sailed in the 1630s had always regarded themselves as members of the national church, and severed communion with it reluctantly. Many more were considering emigration as the only way of finding religious freedom, including Oliver Cromwell, when the change in Charles’ fortunes gave them fresh hope at home.

Cromwell may have been partly motivated to consider emigration by financial problems, some resulting from the crown’s impositions. In April 1631 he was fined ten pounds for refusing to purchase a knghthood. The ‘impoverished’ James I had debased knighthood by putting it up for to auction, and many gentlemen were reluctant to accept what had once been an honour in exchange for payment. This was one of the many fiscal devices, like Ship Money, which Charles I used to raise revenue in the absence of his annual grant from Parliament. He fined those who refused to pay up, and Cromwell appeared with six others from his neighbourhood appeared before royal commissioners, including the Earl of Manchester, for repeated refusal to pay; he was the last to submit to the fine, though he never paid for a knighthood. The sale of his Huntingdon property may also have been connected with this, and he himself had played an important part in the in Parliamentary elections in the borough, by his own participation in the 1628 Parliament and by his battle against the corporation over its new charter which had imposed a new oligarchy on the town. He had been defeated by the power of the royal government, symbolised for him by Sir Edward Montagu, the Earl of Manchester.

The Montagus had been his family’s great local rivals, buying out their family seat at Hinchingbrooke and succeeding to their political influence in the county. Effectively driven out of Huntingdonshire, Cromwell had continued from the rural obscurity of St Ives to interest himself in the maintenance of Dr Wells as a lecturer, entering for his purpose into correspondence with the London merchants who financed him. He was also related to many of the Virginia Company and Providence Island Company Adventurers, and there are contemporary apocryphal stories that he intended to emigrate to New England himself. It was this colony which from 1630 onwards was regarded as at least a temporary refuge by many religious and political ‘malcontents’. Like his fellow Cambridgeshire and Huntingdonshire gentry, he opposed Ship Money and favoured, at this point, the Scottish Presbyterian cause.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007-4.jpg

It was the emergence of William Laud as controller of ecclesiatical affairs, holding many bishoprics before becoming Archbishop of Canterbury in 1633, that precipitated the religious and constitutional crisis in England. He was determined to enforce conformity by every possible means – using paid informers, muzzling the press, prosecuting Puritan clergy in the courts. Laud’s treatment of the Puritan propagandist Alexander Leighton in 1630 had already appalled the nation. Convicted in Star Chamber, Leighton was fined ten thousand pounds, and was sentenced to have both nostrils slit, both ears cut off and his face branded, to be whipped, pilloried and then imprisoned for life. Many Suffolk Puritans took fright and, led by Dr Dalton of Woolverstone, planned their flight to America. They sought the advice of the Puritan patriarch, Samuel Ward, town preacher of Ipswich from 1603 to 1635.

Forthright yet wise, Ward was widely respected and his sermons at St Mary le Tower in the very centre of the city attracted large congregations. He was also a familiar figure in Cambridge and London pulpits and had even spent a few days in prison for lampooning Spanish dignitaries. In 1623, the King wrote personally to the Ipswich corporation asking for Ward’s suspension from office, a request that the city fathers declined. In 1633, he told Dalton’s group that there was no dishonour in the younger members fleeing persecution to set up a ‘holy commonwealth’ in the New World, but that those too old for such adventures should remain to resist their tormentors. Six hundred Suffolk men and women sailed from Ipswich and settled in a place in Massachusetts in a place they named after their home town. Two years later, Samuel Ward was finally dismissed from office and imprisoned. At length he fled to Holland, but returned to be buried in the churchyard at St Mary’s. As the years of political and religious crisis continued, the people of Suffolk were ruined by economic distress and royal taxation, no longer able to meet the unremitting demands made by the government. Little wonder, then, that so many of them continued to join their exiled relatives and friends in New England.

The Massachusetts Bay Company was not the only colonising venture with a religious complexion, for Viscount Saye and Sale, of Broughton Castle, near Banbury, and Lord Brooke of Warwick Castle, both strong puritans, founded the ‘Saybrook’ Company for the settlement of Conneticut; while the Providence Island Company, which aimed to establish a puritan colony in the Caribbean, became politically important at home because it kept so many future leaders of the Long Parliament in close touch in the years when the two houses at Westminster stood empty. The establishment of ‘New England’, however, was just one episode in what became a vast colonial enterprise that was not always about freedom and non-violence, indeed far from it. Nevertheless, those of us who value the freedom of religion and thought that exists today, and see it being denied to people in various parts of the world, have good reason to look back with gratitude to those dissidents who paid a steep price for it four hundred years ago. The story of the ‘Pilgrims’ also shows the futility in trying to draw a line between ‘refugees’ and ‘economic migrants’, between those whose motives for migration are connected with spiritual freedoms and those looking to find material security and wellbeing.

Getty Images, The Graphic News.

The historian Tom Holland has written that Christianity has two deeply subversive ideas at its heart: that all people are equal and that the weak are heroic. Those ideas flow from the ministry of Jesus walking the roads of Galilee teaching, healing, praying until the powers of his day denied his “freedom of religion” as on the cross he laid down his life for his friends, making possible the forgiveness and grace that we can know today. In response to that grace and alongside their vision of a new land, the Pilgrims determined to live out the values of their faith with the creation of a fairer society. While still aboard the ship they drew up the Mayflower Compact to form what they called their “civic body politic”, the arrangements for the sort of community they would become. This agreed to frame just laws as should be most meet and convenient for the general good of the colony int which we promise all due submission and obedience. It fits on a side of A4 and is perhaps their most significant legacy, setting in train an approach which came to influence the American Declaration of Independence and the UN Declaration of Human Rights. The author Kate Caffrey describes their achievement in these words:

The system of laws and management set up by the Pilgrims may not seem startlingly democratic today, but it was a great advance on anything seen before then. They made a plantation, and kept it going despite death, disease, terror, storm and tempest on the spot, exploitation and swindling from within and without. They dealt fairly with one another and with all they met. Steadfast endurance in trials, inspiring leadership, dauntless faith sustained them. They created one of the best-ordered and most successful colonies ever known.

Miles Standish with the Wampanoag chief, Massasoit.

The ‘Pilgrims’ were 102 determined people who were founding a community built on hard work and unselfishness. Their first winter was very severe; they relied on the supplies they had brought with them, building cabins. In the Spring, they sowed seeds supplied to them by the local Indians. When the ship returned to England, not one settler returned with it. Their inspirational leader, William Bradford, became Governer, and Captain Myles Standish, a gifted soldier, led the defence of the colony, though the Amerindians were mostly friendly. Despite the noble ideals of the separatists, however, the legacy of the Mayflower makes us confront an uncomfortable truth; that the freedom and aspirations of one group of people can come at a cost to another. The story of the Mayflower lays bare the complexity of human experience. Many subsequent colonisers, though not the original ‘pilgrims’, inflicted death and destruction on the indigenous peoples, taking land, bringing further disease and betraying the trust of those who had offered hospitality to the first arrivals. Their story is told here by Dr Kathryn Gray, Associate Professor in Early American Literature at the University of Plymouth:

When the Mayflower passengers set sail for North America in 1620, they took a patent, a legal document, which gave them authority to settle a parcel of land in North America. These political arrangements took no account of the Indigenous people already living in the region. By 1620, Indigenous coastal communities were aware of European arrivals and interventions: the Dutch were developing trade in the region; and printed accounts of Indigenous men taken captive from the shoreline and forcibly removed to Europe, were circulating in the early decades of the seventeenth century. For the Wampanoag, the tribe closest to the colonists, geographically and, later, diplomatically, the impact of European disease was beginning to take its toll. The place called Patuxet, a village devastated by disease just a few years before the Mayflower arrived, became the chosen site of the Plymouth Colony.

In Plymouth, Massachusetts today, their village has been carefully and authentically rebuilt. There was a great fence or stockade around the village and the saw pit was where the planks for building were cut. Below the village was the Meeting House with a fort above it with three small cannon. The Meeting House would be used every day for Bible readings and prayer meetings, and sermons preached on Sundays.

William Bradford, an early Governor of the colony, commented years later that ‘God cleared a space for us in the wilderness.’ This clearing came at a human cost; the providential errand had visible and unrelenting consequences for Indigenous people.The first settlers of the Plymouth colony relied on the Wampanoag for food, in the first instance; for translation, as they integrated in the region, economically and diplomatically; and for protection, through a Peace Treaty that, at least ostensibly, agreed to mutual protection. The arrival of many more settlers, and the emergence of many more colonial settlements in the New England area in the decades that followed, meant that relatively local conflicts, tensions and violence caused by settlement at Plymouth, soon developed into a crisis across the region. Conflicts called the Pequot War, of the 1630s, and King Philip’s War, of the 1670s, had devastating impacts on Indigenous people.

English: "The First Thanksgiving at Plymo...
“The First Thanksgiving at Plymouth” (1914) By Jennie A. Brownscombe (Photo credit: Wikipedia). See also the caption below the image below.

The East Anglians’ first year in the new settlement was very difficult. Most of them had come from towns in England or Holland, and had no idea of how to live in a wilderness. They were not skilled hunters as in England hunting was a sporting activity reserved to the aristocracy. Common people were fined, mutilated or transported to prison colonies for shooting game. Having arrived too late to seed crops, and finding that the seeds they had brought with them would not germinate in the new soil, half the colony died from disease, and might have perished altogether had they not received help and training from the native Wompanoag Indians.

The rock on which the settlers first set foot, Plymouth Rock, lies on the harbour shore near the site of the first houses in Leyden Street, now sheltered by a granite canopy. Above the rock rises the Coles Hill where the Pilgrims buried nearly half their number during that first severe winter. They sowed grain over the graves to conceal their misfortune from the Indians. In 1855, some human bones were discovered and these now have a place of honourabove the granite rock canopy. Burial Hill, formerly a defence work called Fort Hill, contains many graves of the early settlers and their descendents, the earliest stone being dated to 1681. Tablets mark the site of the old fort, which was also a place of worship and a watch tower; there is an obelisk memorial to Governor William Bradford. Pilgrim Hall is a large stone building with many relics of the first settlers. These include a portrait of Edward Winslow, one of the original Mayflower passengers, books, manuscripts, Governor Bradford’s Bible, copies of Eliot’s Bible, and Myles Standish’s sword. In 1889, a national monument was set up with a 13.7 metres’ high pedestal, with figures representing the ‘Pilgrims’ and others representing Morality, Education, Law and Freedom. Marble relief frescoes recall the traditional narrative of the first settlement.

Time to Reflect – Inter-cultural Connections:

The arrival of the Mayflower in North America four hundred years ago is a point of connection, not necessarily a beginning. It connects the religious experiences of the Separatists in England and Leyden, with England’s colonial ambitions in North America, and all of this connects with centuries of Indigenous history and culture that western traditions are only just beginning to understand. Over the centuries, the voices and perspectives of the colonists have dominated the ways in which this past constructs a narrative of national origins. At this moment of reflection, four hundred years later, and thanks to the work of numerous indigenous leaders, scholars, artists and curators, the significance of this point of connection is productively and permanently transformed, revealing the deep and complex entanglements of our shared histories.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 010-1.jpg

Perhaps the most fundamental aspect of this inter-cultural connection was a linguistic one. It was the English of East Anglia which was first to take hold in Massachusetts, the language of the rigorous Puritan mind. But to understand the momentous nature of the first English voyages to the New World, we have to appreciate the forlorn position of these weary travellers in a strange landscape without a single familiar reference point. We have to imagine a world in which all languages were foreign, all communications difficult, and even hazardous. One of the first surprises for the Plymouth settlers, was the appearance of Indians speaking “broken English”. William Bradford’s ‘History’ reports that:

… about 16th of March (1621), a certain Indian came boldly among them and spoke to them in broken English, which they could well understand but marvelled at … At length, they understood by discourse with him, that he was not of these parts, but belonged to the eastern parts where some English ships came in to fish, with whom he was acquainted and … amongst whom he had got his language.

In fact, the ‘Indian’ was one of a number of Wampanoag who formed a delegation, led by Massasoit, their military leader, who arrived at the ‘Plymouth’ settlement. Their purpose was to arrange an agreement with the settlers, who would be allowed to stay on Wompanoag territory in exchange for protection against a rival Indian group. Massasoit brought with him an ‘interpreter’ called Tisquantuman, who knew some English from his time in the captivity of pirates. ‘Squanto’, as he became known to the settlers, stayed with them and proved important to their survival. He and other Wampanoag taught the serttlers how to grow corn and showed them other crops that would grow well in the unfamiliar soil. He also taught them how to fish and dig for clams, and how to hunt game in the forests. By the ‘Fall’ of 1621, the settlers had learnt how to harvest bountiful crops of corn, barley, beans and pumpkins. Legend has it that they invited Massasoit to to a feast of ‘thanksgiving’ and that the Chief came with ninety others who brought turkeys and deer to roast. Until recently, school textbooks in the USA presented the legend as one in which the ‘Pilgrims’ cooked the the entire feast, offering it to the ‘less fortunate’ natives. Fortunately, this grotesque distortion and insult has now been removed from the popular narrative. Even among immigrant Americans, at one time, ‘Thanksgiving’ was seen as a relic of Puritan bigotry, but it is now regarded as part of the secular mainstream of American traditions, with a focus on giving thanks for all blessings on a day for family reunion.

In 1988, a Thanksgiving ceremony of a different kind took place at the Cathedral of St John the Divine in New York. More than four thousand people gathered there on Thanksgiving night. Among them were Native Americans representing tribes from all over the country, and descendants of the first immigrants. The ceremony was the first public acknowledgement of the Indians’ role in the first Thanksgiving. Wilma Mankiller, principal chief of the Cherokee nation, spoke the following words:

We celebrate Thanksgiving along with the rest of America, maybe in different ways and for different reasons. Despite everything that’s happened to us since we fed the Pilgrims, we still have our language, our culture, our distinct social system. Even in a nuclear age, we still have a tribal people.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006-3.jpg
This early map shows how the settlements grew. The placenames show the influence of East Anglia among the migrants. On the map, we can find Sudbury and Haveril (Suffolk), Plimouth and Weymouth (West Country), Bradford (Yorkshire), Cambridge and Dover.

Merchant trading ships plied their trade along the east coast of America between tiny English settlements like Jamestown, Plymouth and up to Newfoundland. The first Black slaves, who first arrived in the colonies the year before the Mayflower migrants also helped to spread varieties of ‘pidgin English’ among the Indian tribes. Apparently, the settlers possessed a genuine admiration for the Indians’ speech. William Penn, the founder of Pennsylvania, wrote:

I know not a language spoken in Europe, that hath words of more sweetness and greatness, in Accent and Emphasis than theirs.

Penn was a handsome man who had won fame as a soldier and had been a great favourite at Charles II’s Court, but he gave up his sword after becoming a Quaker. When he debated with the Presbyterian divine Richard Baxter at Rickmansworth in Hertfordshire, he would have worn a dark cloth jacket and breeches and a short crowned hat, the usual garb of Quaker men. Both Baxter and Penn respected one another, though they did not agree on many points, and both were courageous men who went about their work in contant danger of persecution. Penn eventually migrated to America where he founded the colony of Pennsylvania.

Quite quickly, American English became enriched by what the settlers called, somewhat disparagingly, “wigwam” words, like racoon, acorn, possum, skunk, squash, pow-wow, mugwump (meaning ‘great chief’, which the Massachusetts Bible used to translate ‘duke’ in Genesis xxxvi, 15). A number of metaphoric turns of phrase have obvious origins in Indian languages like fire-water, play possum, smoke the peace pipe, bury the hatchet, put on the warpaint, and go on the warpath.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 009-1.jpg

Holy Words & New Englishes:

The text of the 1611 ‘Authorised Version’ of the Bible owed much to earlier translations, especially that of Tyndale, but also to the scholarship of John Bois in ensuring the faithfulness of the overall text to the original Hebrew and Greek. He was born in 1560 and grew up East Anglia, reading the Hebrew Bible at the age of six, and becoming a classics scholar at St John’s College at fourteen. He passed through the examinations at record speed, and soon became a Fellow of the College. When this expired he was given a rectorship at Boxworth, an isolated hamlet a few miles north of Cambridge, on condition that he married the deceased rector’s daughter. This he did, moving into the Fens, but still rising at four o’clock to ride into Cambridge to teach, even reading a book while on horseback. Bois continued to live quietly in Boxworth, a man with a brilliant scholarly reputation. At the Hampton Court Conference in 1604, called by James I to discuss matters of religion, Dr John Reynolds of Oxford proposed a definitive translation of the Bible to ameliorate the developing friction between Anglicans and Puritans. The Rex Pacificus gladly assented to the idea of one uniforme translation, though he doubted whether he would see a Bible well translated in English.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 003-6.jpg

The ‘King James’ Bible (above) was published in the same year as Shakespeare produced his last play, The Tempest, in 1611. Both the play and the Bible are masterpieces, but there is one crucial difference between them. While the playwright used more words than ever, inventing new ones as he wrote, the King James Version employed a mere eight thousand words, God’s English for Everyman. The people for whom the new, simplified yet poetic text became a weapon saw themselves as God’s Englishmen and Englishwomen. Their heartland was East Anglia, including the birthplaces of John Bunyan and Oliver Cromwell.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 002-9.jpg

Nevertheless, the royal patronage of the ‘Authorised Version’ caused it to be disliked by the ‘Pilgrim Fathers’, who tended to continue to use the Genevan Bible, the marginal notes of which, in any case, better suited their Calvinist theology. One of the essentials of the separatist tradition was that the sermon should be followed by discussion. For them, worship was not a matter of passively hearing the Word preached by by a learned minister, but should be followed by participation by the congregation after a gifted member had opened up the discussion. John Robinson, pastor to the Leyden congregation in the Netherlands, wrote in The People’s Plea for the Exercise of Prophesie in 1618 that after public ministry the elders should exhort anyone who had a gift of speaking to the edification of hearers to make use of it. In the radicals’ mode of thought two strands were twisted together. One was the belief in the evolution of truth, continuous revelation. Robinson preached this doctrine in his farewell sermon to the emigrants in 1620, so it is fitting that the belief is often related to the settlement of the New World. In 1634, John Cotton included in the the order of public worship in the church of Boston prophesying by gifted members of of the congregation and discussion of questions addressed to the minister. John Goodwin wrote in 1642 that:

… if so great and considerable a part of the world as America is … was yet unknown to all the world besides for so many generations together: well may it be conceived, not only that some but many truths, yea and those of main concernment and importance, may yet be unknown.

Thomas Goodwin announced that… a new Indies of heavenly treasure … hath been found out! … Yet more … may be. Lord Brooke and the five Dissenting Brethren of the Westminster Assembly had already looked forward to a state of permanent reformation. John Saltmarsh, Walter Cradock and many others saw their own age, of as one of an outpouring of the spirit: they hoped that a thousand flowers would bloom. This was a great argument for religious toleration and liberty of conscience; better many errors of some kind suffered than one useful truth be obstructed or destroyed. Through revelation of new truths to believers, traditional Christianity could be adapted to the needs of a new age; the everlasting gospel within responded more easily and swiftly to the pressures of the environment than did traditions of the church or the literal text. History is a gradual progress towards total revelation of truth, as John Goodwin wrote.

Besides many of these very English radicals, about two-thirds of the early settlers of Massachusetts Bay came from the eastern and ‘home’ counties, from Lincolnshire in the north to Essex and in the south, from Suffolk and Norfolk in the East to Bedfordshire and Buckinghamshire in the west. Throughout the seventeenth century, the villages and towns of these counties supplied the New World with a ready and steady stream of immigrants, country people with country skills who were already well adapted for the hard life of the pioneer. The speech-features of East Anglia that were transplanted to the place the Pilgrim Fathers named New England are still to be heard in the rural parts of Norfolk and Suffolk. People there still say noo instead of new and don’t sound the r in words like bar, storm and yard, very different from the burr of western English counties from rural Oxfordshire and Worcestershire down to Dorset and Devon.

007
009

New England for Old – ‘Mirror’ Images of Early Colonialism:

In the 1630s the opposition group organised its activity around the Providence Island Company, a trading company of which John Pym was Treasurer and many of Cromwell’s cousins were also members. Providence Island lay just off the mainland of Spanish America, cutting the route for the silver galleons: its occupation would make sense only as part of an anti-Spanish policy like the one which Cromwell himself took up in the 1650s. The Western Design had a long pre-history, going back to Ralegh’s privately financed expeditions which got distracted by piracy. The merchants who sponsored the Pilgrim Fathers and the Massachusetts settlements of the 1630s may have also had long-term anti-Spanish designs; but no government support was forthcoming for their colonising efforts. One of the five Commissioners in charge of Cromwell’s expedition was Edward Winslow, the Pilgrim Father. The Providence Island Committee came as close as private enterprise could get to putting the policy into effect, by planting a colony right in the Spanish Main (see the map at the top). Cromwell’s Manifesto against Spain of 1656, dealt with below, referred specifically to the Providence Island venture.

In the period leading to the outbreak of the Civil Wars, the Providence Island group organised the opposition to Ship Money. The judgement against John Hampden of 1637 shocked the propertied classes. If Ship Money was was legal, then non-parliamentary government had come to stay. The situation was saved by the Scottish War, which made resistance possible and in 1638 sixty-one per cent of Ship Money remained unpaid. The Providence Island Group were in contact with the Scottish Covenanters, and in 1640 co-ordinated their actions with them. The Short Parliament which Charles was compelled to call in April 1640 insisted on peace with the Scots, which was concluded at Ripon in October 1640 on terms which forced the summoning of another Parliament which as ‘the Long Parliament’ was to sit for more than eleven years.

Charles I

During the Civil Wars of the 1640s, the majority of English people remained attached either to the liturgy and government of the pre-Caroline Church of England, or, as puritan separatists or ‘Independents’, to the congregational forms of church which had originated in London and East Anglia, and were then adopted in the Netherlands and transferred to New England. Puritan emigration to New England reached a peak in the 1630s: Oliver Cromwell had thought of going, but was elected to both the Short and Long Parliament to represent the borough of Cambridge, the Puritans’ stronghold. In his attack on the Huntingdon oligarchy, Cromwell made himself the spokesman and organiser of the commoners’ opposition. His own financial position was improving after he inherited property from his maternal grandfather in 1636. Oliver’s heriditary protestantism had been reinforced by his education at a very puritan college, Sidney Sussex in Cambridge, and by his own conversion, and by his reaction against Henrietta Maria’s Catholic circle at Charles’ court, which included members of the Montagu family, the Cromwells’ county rivals. It is therefore unsurprising that when in 1640 Charles finally decided to summon another Parliament, Cromwell was a candidate. He was invited to stand for the borough of Cambridge and the city avenged the loss of his Huntingdon seat. All talk of emigration was long forgotten, though Cromwell maintained his trading links with North America and the Caribbean. His friend of later years, Sir Henry Vane, actually went. But returning New Englanders were then to play a prominent part in the revolutionary movement of the 1640s. Cromwell was said to especially favour them within his regiment.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 014-1.jpg

Throughout the conflicts, the ‘Independents’ in Parliament and the Army, including Cromwell, rejected the imposition of a Presbyterian Covenant in alliance with the Scots. In 1644, at a crucial juncture in the internal conflict between the ‘political’ Presbyterians and Independents in Parliament, their ‘religious’ counterparts in the Westminster Assembly met to decide the form of government that the Church of England should have. Since episcopalians were not represented in the Assembly, the English divines were willing to endorse the essentials of the Presbyterian system. They were opposed in doing so by a small group of Independents who became known as the ‘Dissenting Brethren’. The five most prominent of them published An Apologetical Narration in order to distinguish their position from those of the Presbyterian on the one hand and the separatists or sectaries on the other. They were all men of learning, trained and ordained, who had gone into exile during the Laudian persecution and had ministered to their fellow exiles in Holland. There they had followed the ‘congregational way’, like their brethren in New England. But they failed in reaching a compromise with the Presbyterians in the Assembly and the episcopalian order was eventually restored in ‘Old England’.

Another ‘mirror’ needs to be held up in respect of Cromwell’s Irish policy, which should be seen as part of his general colonial policy. The native Irish were treated much as the original settlers of New England treated the Amerindians. Cromwell wrote to New England treated to try to persuade ‘godly people and ministers’ to move to Ireland. His own influence as Lord Protector was in the direction of moderating the policy of wholesale transplantation of Irish indentured labourers across the Atlantic. Only landowners were shifted: the mass of the Irish population was required as labourers and payers of rent. Ireland had been included within the scope of the 1651 Navigation Act, so that the same customs and excise were paid as in England. But of course it was the English settlers who benefited, as in New England: the native Irish and ‘papists’ were excluded from corporate towns. Ireland must not be over-taxed, Cromwell said, lest the English must needs run away for pure beggary and the Irish possess the country again.

In 1653, the continuing ‘mirror’ influence of ‘New England’ on the old homeland was again apparent during the interregnum, when the radicals in the ‘Barebones’ Parliament set out to codify all that it found good and just in the existing laws, harmonise these with the law of God, and prescribe propotionable punishments for specific offences. It invoked the example of Massachusetts, where such a written code had been promulgated ten years earlier, but England, with its age-old complexities of tenure and property rights, was not Massachusetts, and so the radical project failed, as did the Parliament, by 1655.

By the end of 1653, English foreign policy was conceived in in hard practical terms of national and commercial interest. Two lines of policy emerged. One, popular with the City of London and the Rump Parliament, aimed at annihilating Dutch mercantile rivalry, either by agreement if possible, by war if not. This would open up to English merchants the trade of India and the Far East. This policy inspired the Navigation Act and the First Dutch War, and completely abandoned religion as as a consideration in determining foreign policy. The alternative course of action, more popular with the Presbyterian gentry, would have been to force a way into the Spanish monopoly trading area between the Gulf of Mexico and the South American coast. It was a continuance of the Providence Island Company’s policy, and if successful would have given England bases in the sugar and tobacco islands of the West Indies and a strong position in the trade in African slaves to America. War against Spain had the added advantage that it could be justified as an anti-Catholic ‘crusade’. The anti-Dutch policy was preferred by the radicals in the Barebones Parliament, but Cromwell also saw it as being in the trading interests of the Commonwealth.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is cropped-image-3.png
The Lord Protector, warts and all, circa 1653.

In 1654, the ‘Lord Protector’ equipped and dispatched an expedition to co-operate with the New Englanders in the capture of the Dutch settlements on the mainland of North America. This plan was frustrated by the signing of peace, but the force then carried out Cromwell’s alternative instructions by capturing Nova Scotia. This might have provided a base for a second attempt at the colonisation of Canada, where Charles I had surrendered an earlier settlement in 1629, but Charles II gave Nova Scotia back to the French in 1668. Although in 1656 Cromwell was accused by the Baptist Captain Chillenden in selling English trade to the Dutch, the peace terms of 1654 were not unfavourable to the Commonwealth. Cromwell had told the Dutch Ambassadors in July 1653 that, if they agreed a peace, their two countries could overrule all others and control the markets and dictate the conditions. But he was equally determined, by the end of 1654, to oust the Dutch from the leadership of the protestant interest in Europe and North America. Having largely succeeded in this, he could then turn his attention to Spanish America.

Map of Colonial Jamaica

The ‘Western Design’ was Cromwell’s main contribution to the development of English colonial policy, and it is important to see it in the perspective of the cross-cultural contexts of international setlement. It had nothing in common with the raids of the Elizabethan sea-dogs: Cromwell’s ‘Design’ was a determined attempt to to occupy and settle permanently a stable base in the West Indies. Its commander was told that the design in general is to gain an interest in that part of the West Indies in the possession of the Spaniard. Englishmen would then settle there ‘from other parts’. Cromwell tried hard to persude the New Englanders or Irish protestant settlers to transfer to Jamaica. A simultaneous aim was to achieve ‘the mastery of all those seas’ in order to maintain the Navigation Act and to humble the Netherlands. Dutch ships were seized at Barbados and on the high seas. The ultimate objective was to open up South American trade, seizing Spanish silver fleets in the process, but the most important part of the scheme was government-sponsored settlement. Just as the Commonwealth of Great Britain had been followed by an offer to the Netherlands on similar terms as those between England and Scotland, so the conquest and settlement of Ireland was to be followed by the conquest and settlement of the West Indies. The two were connected by the transportation of Irish, Scots and English to the West Indies; an unsuccessful attempt was also made to get New Englanders to move to Jamaica. Of course, Black Africans did not have the right to decline, and soon thousands were being shipped from West Africa to Jamaica, Barbados and other Caribbean islands.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006-4.jpg

For the next hundred and fifty years, Jamaica became the centre of the slave trade, first supplying slaves for other West Indian islands, and then for the southern colonies of the American mainland. The eighteenth century prosperity of Bristol (below) and Liverpool was made possible by Jamaica and its trade in slaves: the original sin among the settlement of saints. There was continuity there too, for the colonists of Providence Island had employed Black slave labour in large quantities.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 013.jpg
Eighteenth-century Bristol

In 1652, the regicide Rev Hugh Peter had enthusiastically urged New Englanders to return to their mother country, as he himself had done in 1641. By 1654, however, he thought they should stay where they were, given England’s ‘great uncertainty and changes’. But by March 1658 the uncertainty was over, at least for him. ‘Truly upon all accounts’, he wrote, ‘I think New England best, if clothing and bread may be had.’ He failed to take his own advice, however, and, having remained in London, he was hung, drawn and quartered in October 1660.

Hugh Peters Sintzenich.jpg
Rev. Hugh Peter

The Meaning and Legacy of the Mayflower Migration:

Many places in England remain connected with the tradition and era of Protestant Dissent, the most atmospheric of which are the old Baptist and Congregationalist chapels and the Quaker meeting-houses. One in particular is especially commemorative of the first English colonists in North America, the one at Jordans in Buckinghamshire (below). It stands amongst orchards close to a barn said to be built from the timbers of the Mayflower. It was built towards the end of the era, in 1688, by William Penn, who lies in the graveyard outside. It is a simple building with transomed leaded windows, the interior singing with silence and peace, towards the end of more than half a century of religious warfare in England.

Governor Bradford and his migrating flock may not have been conscious of themselves as ‘pilgrims’ or ‘forefathers’, but they were conscious of their ‘forebears’, of those who had gone before, the people of Israel journeying to Canaan, the ‘strangers and pilgrims’ desiring a homeland and in the words of the Epistle to the Hebrews looking to Jesus the pioneer and perfecter of their faith who had prepared a better country, that is a heavenly one. The Christian journey still requires the courage of heart, independence of mind and piety of spirit of those who embark upon that journey, and who, in doing so, can still draw inspiration from those who set out from Britain’s shores four hundred years ago to become, providentially though unwittingly, the founders of a mighty nation.

Sources:

Austin Woolrych (2002), Britain in Revolution. Oxford: Oxford Univesity Press.

Robert McCrum, William Cran & Robert MacNeil (1987), The Story of English. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.

Nuala Zahadieh (2001) in The Penguin Atlas of British & Irish History. London: Penguin Books.

William Anderson & Clive Hicks (1983), Holy Places of the British Isles: A guide to the legendary and sacred sites. London: Ebury Press.

Christopher Hill (1970), God’s Englishman. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.

Christopher Hill (1975), The World Turned Upside Down. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.

 

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 220px-1920USstamp2centPilgrimTercentenaryLanding.jpg
1920 U.S. stamp celebrating the Pilgrim Tercentenary

Poverty, Progress & the Nonconformist Conscience in Britain, 1844-1914: London, Manchester & Birmingham.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 049-1.jpg
‘Under the Viaduct’ (1872) by Gustave Doré (1833-83). Over a hundred thousand people were displaced from their homes in London alone as a result of railway building, and many were crowded even closer in the centres of cities because they could not afford to travel to work on the railways that had effectively evicted them. The French artist Doré became a major artistic ‘institution’ in Britain through the wide circulation of engravings of his works and his illustrated editions of popular writings. His sombre images of squalor leave a profound, sulphurous impression.

The ‘Manchester School’ and the Industrial City:

By the 1840s, Manchester had become the symbol of a new form of social organisation, a ‘modern Athens’ to Benjamin Disraeli. But, in a sense, the City deserved the rough treatment it subsequently got from two notable foreign visitors, Alexis de Tocqueville and Friedrich Engels. In 1851, John Bright, the Quaker economist and politician spoke at the Free Trade Hall, extolling the virtues of ‘laissez-faire’, which he re-named ‘the Manchester Policy’. With its satellite towns of Stockport, Salford and Oldham, Manchester was the most impressive example of urban expansion up to the mid-century, and its dependence on factory industry and persistent identification with the ‘gospel’ of the market economy. It demanded attention as ‘the portent of a new age’ as Disraeli had suggested and, therefore, quite naturally, attracted the attention of social critics such as de Tocqueville and Engels. Writing in 1844, however, in his Condition of the Working Class in England, Friedrich Engels identified in Manchester the process of social and residential segregation that was typical of so many towns and cities in mid-Victorian Britain. But where Engels saw urban squalor as the result of the acts of an exploiting bourgeoisie, Tocqueville blamed it on the absence of a tradition of governmental intervention. He commented, in 1835, that the sight of its fine civic buildings with Corinthian columns in the city centre could not disguise the squalor which was found in its residential areas:

But who could describe the interiors of these quarters set apart, home of vice and poverty, which surround the huge palaces of industry and clasp them in the hideous folds? On ground below the level of the river and overshadowed on every side by immense workshops, stretches marshy land which widely spaced ditches can neither drain nor cleanse. Narrow, twisting roads lead down to it. They are lined with one-storey houses whose ill-fitting planks and broken windows show them up, even from a distance, as the last refuge a man might find between poverty and death. Nonetheless, the wretched people living in them can still inspire jealousy of their fellow beings. Below some of their miserable dwellings is a row of cellars to which a sunken corridor leads. Twelve to fifteen human beings are crowded pell-mell into each of these damp, repulsive holes. …

… The fetid, muddy waters, stained with a thousand colours by the factories they pass, of one of the streams I mentioned before, wander slowly round this refuge of poverty. … Look up and all around this place you see will see the huge palaces of industry. You will hear the noise of furnaces, the whistle of steam. These vast structures keep air and light out of the human habitations which they dominate; they envelop them in perpetual fog; here is the slave, there is the master; there is wealth of some, here is the poverty of most… From this filthy sewer pure gold flows. Here humanity strains its most complete development and its most brutish; here civilisation makes its miracles, and civilised man is turned back almost into a savage.

Manchester had, in fact, been given its first Corporation under the terms of the Municipal Reform Act in 1835, but all this did was to deprive local oligarchies of the rich pickings of old privileges. But it was only after the public health reforms of the 1840s that local government began to assume the shape fully established half a century later in Birmingham. Engels also identified the ‘Two Nations’ of Britain, as captured in Disraeli’s novel Sybil (1846), in which the poor were spatially distanced from an emerging middle class increasingly housed in a rural or suburban idyll of villas and private gardens. With their strengthening purchasing powers, the middle classes were able to move away from town centres to genteel suburbs with their domesticity and security. Engels quoted a local cleric, Canon Parkinson in support of his case for Manchester as a case study of the ‘two Britains’:

There is no town in the world where the distance between rich and poor is so great, or the barrier between them so difficult to be crossed. I once ventured to designate the town of Manchester the most ‘aristocratic’ town in England, and, in the sense in which the term was used, the expression is not hyperbolical. The separation between the different classes, and the consequent ignorance of each other’s habits and condition, are far more complete in this place than in any country of older nations of Europe, or the agricultural parts of our own kingdom. There is far less ‘personal’ communication between the master cotton spinner and his workmen, between the calico printer and his blue-handed boys, between the master tailor and his apprentices, than there is between the Duke of Wellington and the humblest labourer on his estate, or than there was between good old George the Third and the meanest errand-boy about the palace. I mention this not a matter of blame, but I state it simply as a fact.

Industrial Manchester in the late nineteenth century (Eastern section)

Manchester was never merely a factory town. In the 1770s, it had been unremarkable, if thriving textile manufacturing centre which had capitalised on its location adjacent to the Pennine slopes, with their ideal conditions for cotton-spinning and weaving. It had had a population of about twenty-five thousand. Thirty years later, it had almost tripled, and by the 1840s it had also become the commercial centre of the textile trade, and the factories were soon outnumbered by warehouses and salesrooms for finished cloth. The typical Manchester worker was not a factory worker, but a carter, porter, packer, or labourer. In fact, the social gulf which worried contemporaries was, by the mid-century, filled with clerks, shopkeepers and members of the emerging professions, alongside the ‘labour aristocracy’ of master cotton spinners, calico printers and tailors. Besides the further expansion of manufacturing, the growth of secondary and service industries led to the city’s waterways becoming clogged with both human and industrial waste from tanneries, abattoirs, foundries and dye-works.

As in London and other cities, in Manchester railway lines had isolated ghettos such as ‘Little Ireland’, which then became slums. Chimneys dominated the skylines and the city became shrouded in smoke, which blackened buildings and killed vegetation. Contaminated water supplies and the accumulation of waste in the streets and allies contributed to a life expectancy for working-class inhabitants of less than half that of the surrounding agricultural districts. As the old town crumbled under the weight of the increased population, new districts of working-class housing sprang up to the east and south, as shown in the graphic map above, engulfing existing residences and driving the middle classes out into the neighbouring villages which, by the new century, had become more fashionable suburbs.

The Segregation & Conditions of the Classes:

In the first half of the nineteenth century, very few houses were purpose-built for the British working classes. Instead, the existing housing stock was ‘made down’ (subdivided into many rooms) as the wealthy quit the increasingly hostile physical and moral environs of the city centre for houses some distance away. Alternatively, outhouses and courtyards were adapted and back-to-back housing was developed. The correlation between poverty and housing conditions were widely publicised through Edwin Chadwick’s Report on the Sanitary Conditions of the Labouring Classes (1842) after details of the causes of death began to be recorded in the Registrar General’s annual reports on births, marriages and deaths (from 1837 in England). The conditions in British cities contributed to the process of suburbanisation from about 1850, as the middle classes increasingly sought to distance themselves from the moral and physical degeneration identified with town centres. Infant mortality rates, a sensitive indicator of the relationship between poverty and death, show how, in the 1860s, this was closely associated with urban districts and, in London, with the central part of the city. Indeed, moving away from London to housing with more generous space significantly reduced infant mortality.

Infant mortality, 1861-70

The map above shows a fairly clear correlation between areas of intense industrialisation and high infant mortality. Rapid urban population growth caused intense pressure on existing housing. The entrepreneurial response, being free of any form of regulation, was to subdivide larger properties or construct cramped new housing for rent. Only slowly were steps taken to regulate the standards of housing built for the working classes. Speculative builders were more important in determining housing quality and the fluctuations in house-building itself, together with the zoning effect of mid-century railway developments. On the demand side, the stability of employment and the level of household incomes were crucial. In Leicester, for example, where female employment in the hosiery trade supplemented a male workforce mainly occupied in the boot and shoe industry and in engineering, steady household incomes contributed to a housing stock that on the eve of World War I was superior in quality and amenities to that of over a hundred other English towns and cities.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-3.jpg
A Sunderland slum, circa 1889. Squalor was all too often the fate of the industrial working class in Victorian times. In the later decades of the nineteenth century, local by-laws were used to regulate new housing, but clearing slums like the one shown here took longer.

Housing quality improved ultimately in the final quarter of the nineteenth century because of four linked developments; rising real wages, smaller family sizes, slum clearance and compulsory building by-laws. Together, these resulted in improved dietary, sanitary and environmental conditions. The ‘by-law’ terraced house became an almost universal English and Welsh working-class housing type, as the housing around central courtyards was opened up, cellar-dwelling banned, and back-to-back house-building suspended. The nature of twentieth-century housing was influenced by the block dwellings of the Peabody (London) and Guinness (London and Dublin) Trusts and by those of the newly formed London County Council in the 1890s, which were much criticised by their tenants. Company housing, though limited in quantity, did improve quality of life at Saltaire (Bradford), Port Sunlight (Cheshire), New Earswick (York) and Bournville (Birmingham), emphasising perspectives, with boulevards, curves and an explicitly English country cottage design, later associated with the concept of garden cities. Bournville was the estate created by George Cadbury, Quaker and chocolate manufacturer, for his factory workers.

The London Poor: ‘Snobs’, ‘Street Preachers’ & Social Surveyors:

The ascendancy of Disraeli and Gladstone in the politics of the 1870s and 1880s represented the emergence of the middle class as a major force in British politics. While the aristocracy maintained its grip on many of the leading organs of the state, including the ministries, and was to return to the prime ministership in the shape of the marquis of Salisbury and the Earl of Rosebery, but more middle-class businessmen, of whom Joseph Chamberlain is a pre-eminent example, and professionals now also aspired to political office. This mirrored the emergence of the middle class as a dominant class in British society, partially replacing the rural gentry. Britain’s built environment is full of the homes they made for themselves. The wealthier echelons of the middle class, whose fortunes were usually made in the industry and commerce of the towns, also set out to secure country estates in order to gentrify themselves, although this may have served to dilute their entrepreneurial spirit. These professional classes, including lawyers, doctors, academics and teachers, also grew tremendously during this period.

Charles Haddon Spurgeon (1834-1892) was a noted English Baptist minister who preached at the Metropolitan Tabernacle to a congregation of six thousand. Some two hundred million copies of his sermons have been distributed worldwide since his death.

As early as 1861, following the opening of the Metropolitan Tabernacle, Charles H. Spurgeon, the great Baptist preacher, warned against the atmosphere of snobbery which he perceived was increasingly prevalent among his flock:

There is growing up even in our Dissenting churches, an evil which I greatly deplore, a despising of the poor. I frequently hear, in conversation, such remarks as this: ‘It is of no use trying in such a place as this: you could never raise a self-supporting cause. There are none but poor living in this neighbourhood.’ … You know that in the city of London itself, there is now scarce a Dissenting place of worship. The reason for giving most of them up and moving them into the suburbs is that all the respectable people live out of town, and of course, they are the people to look after. They will not stop in London. They will go out and take villas in the suburbs where they may be maintained. ‘No doubt’, it is said, ‘the poor ought to be looked after: but we had better leave them to another order, an inferior order. The city missionaries will do for them; send them a few street preachers.’

Henry Mayhew, who in E. P. Thompson’s estimation, was incomparably the greatest social investigator in the mid-century, absorbed himself, in his monumental London Labour and the London Poor, (1851-62), less in the investigation of the casualties of industrialisation and more in the casualties of non-industrialisation, as the extract below shows. His subjects were the urban masses whose expansion did not directly result from the expansion of industry, and whose apparent social degeneracy alarmed other commentators.

The American socialist and writer, Jack London, referred to these urban masses, half a century later (see below), as unable to render efficient service to England in the world struggle for industrial supremacy. They were the product not of the organisation of industry but of the disorganisation of urban growth. Unlike Jack London, however, Mayhew was a sympathetic early ethnographer, who got his subjects to talk to him with a rare frankness and lack of inhibition. The individual components of the urban mass, whom some commentators treated at best as inanimate statistics or at worst as anonymous brutes, gained an identity as they talked to him. Mayhew came from the same ‘milieu’ as Dickens; he was a playwright and journalist. Occasionally the theatrical shows through, but this does not detract from his value in providing direct contact with the forgotten masses of Victorian London.

Some of the most compelling photographs of poverty to survive were taken for religious and charitable organisations concerned with saving and helping children. The photograph above is of a ‘Ragged School’ showing not only ragged clothes but thin rickety legs, bare feet and the hollow-eyed accusative stare of children robbed of childhood. If Dr Barnado was guilty on occasions of exaggerating the condition of hi ‘street Arabs while they were under the eye of his photographer, substantive pictures from the Church of England’s Children’s Society, the Methodist Mission and the Salvation Army confirm that the appearance of the children matches the descriptions left us by various contemporary social commentators.

In the 1840s, John Pounds, a crippled cobbler of Portsmouth, used to gather in his workshop little groups of the poorest boys he could find, teaching them to read while he continued with his repairs. Pounds’ work and that of the London City Mission, which started schools into which ‘children raggedly clothed are admitted’ were the originators of the evangelical mission which became known as the Ragged Schools’ Union. The mission was to rescue children who were the street Arabs and outcasts of the poorest working-class districts and provide them with education and recreation. It was into the London of Dickens’ Oliver Twist that they delved to find and rescue children from the worst effects of indescribable poverty and abandonment. Indeed, Dickens supported and wrote of the work of the Ragged Schools, a movement that also attracted Lord Shaftesbury and other reforming figures. Finding that their pupils were often ‘crying from hunger and falling off their seats through exhaustion’, the schools gave meals as often as possible. About the time that the photograph of ragged children with their teacher was taken, in 1890, the Camberwell Ragged School announced ‘bring a spoon’. Two hundred and fifty children sat at rows of long tables and were given a slice of bread and a basin of soup thickened with peas and barley, at the cost of a halfpenny. Though the purpose of the Ragged Schools was an education for ‘Church and Empire’, they also filled empty bellies and cared for those for whom society had no care.

Church v Chapel – Establishment Schools & Progress for the Poor:

Newlyn School, Cornwall, 1889: Even isolated fishing communities, such as Newlyn, experienced growth in educational provision, extended to girls as well as boys.

The chief providers of elementary education for most of the nineteenth century had been the voluntary bodies, especially the churches, from the 1830s receiving Treasury grants. Some among the middle classes supported universal education for philanthropic reasons, as a means of preventing crime and immorality, or as insurance against social unrest. Some Anglicans were alarmed at the growth of Catholicism and Nonconformity and saw an Anglican education system as a defence against this. There was opposition, however, from those, especially farmers, who feared that educating the working classes would lead to higher taxes and labour costs, if not the spread of radical political ideas. National differences in education and literacy were marked. Levels of literacy were comparatively low in many parts of rural Britain, where school attendance was also low, but especially high in Scotland and Ireland, where favourable attitudes to an educated population were supported by a network of parochial schools. They were also higher among girls than boys in some areas where they were educated at voluntary schools, for example in East Anglia. In Wales, the Nonconformist churches, and in Ireland, Catholics opposed state funding of education, fearing Anglican propaganda. The Welsh also feared that the established Church sought to extinguish the Welsh language through the provision of monolingual English schooling. This strategy would undermine the Sunday schools provided by the Nonconformist chapels, in which Welsh was the medium of instruction.

Nineteenth-Century educational provision and literacy.

Thirteen years before the first Education Act, when countless children toiled ten or twelve hours a day in a mill or a colliery, Jeremiah James Colman opened Carrow School for the children of his employees at his Stoke and Carrow mustard works in Norwich. He was the grandnephew of the founder of the company, a strong Nonconformist, philanthropist and Member of Parliament. The weekly payment for attendance at the school was a penny for one child, three halfpence for two and twopence for a third from the same family. The first school was over a carpenter’s shop and crammed in fifty-three pupils. In an opening statement, Colman announced:

… the school helps you to educate your children and to train up a set of men who will go into the world qualified for any duties they may be called upon to discharge.

With a workforce of three and a half thousand, Colman’s was, in effect, the local community and it was likely that their duties would be discharged in manufacturing mustard. The school began each morning with a hymn, a prayer and a Bible reading, but while a Colman education included diligent and careful teaching of the scriptures, it also included art and craft subjects in addition to ‘the three r’s’. Not only was Colman far-sighted in his attitude to education, but he was also a firm believer in women being given every opportunity for learning, and from the outset drawing and needlework were included in the subjects taught. Caroline Colman, Jeremiah’s wife, was the force in the direction and development of the school. The Colman’s were also committed to technical education, and in 1899 they claimed to be the first to introduce cookery, gardening, laundry work, beekeeping and ironwork into the curriculum. As the school grew, it moved and improved, adding a wide range of technical subjects, but never neglected art and culture.

At the time the photograph above was taken in the early 1900s, Caroline Colman was intensely concerned with the physical wellbeing of her pupils, urging mothers to ensure that their daughters wore warm dresses ‘as a caution against measles and other childish ailments’. Although the children have been carefully groomed and prepared for the class photograph, their general condition of wellbeing contrasts sharply with the ragged appearance and thin faces of the children in the London photographs. The reminiscences of former pupils were warm and grateful, happy and nostalgic if at times a little pious.

In successive Education Acts from 1870, governments took steps to fill the most obvious gaps in education provision and made it compulsory until the age of ten. Although standards of literacy had been relatively high before the Education Act of 1870, the emergence of compulsory elementary education under the legislation produced one of the best-educated and most literate populations in Europe. The 1870 act provided for basic literacy and numeracy, together with religious and moral education, though the curriculum was gradually widened. The so-called public schools were reformed and became a model for a new wave of independent schools as well as the grammar schools and high schools, sometimes built on ancient foundations, that emerged in every city and town.

University education had expanded slowly in the nineteenth century as it became clear that the ancient foundations could no longer meet the economic and intellectual demands of Victorian Britain. New colleges, soon to be elevated to the status of universities, were founded in all major industrial cities, offering a more accessible tertiary education to many. By the end of the century, universities had been established in all the major urban centres of England and Wales. In 1878 the University of London had become the first institution to to admit women students, and by 1900 women were attending all universities, although with some restrictions. The number of women receiving degrees was limited, and Oxford and Cambridge resisted awarding degrees until well into the twentieth century.

Cambridge in the 19th Century: During the Victorian period, the growth in the university’s provision was as marked there as it was in the new university towns. This, in turn, encouraged rapid population and urban growth, and the development of modern Cambridge.

Consumer Co-operation – A ‘Self-help’ Solution?:

Beatrice Webb, c1875.jpg
Beatrice Potter (later Webb) in 1875.

Beatrice Webb, née Potter, (1858-1943) was born into a Lancashire family who became integrated into the traditional administrative and professional class, and Beatrice found herself related to a good proportion of the academics, senior civil servants and leading lawyers of the capital. On the other hand, she still kept in contact with her Lancashire forebears who had not made the transition. Stimulated by the great Charles Booth, she embarked in 1884 on her own programme of social research into Co-operation and Nonconformity in Bacup, a town in the South Pennines of Lancashire, close to the border with Yorkshire. In a letter to her father, She wrote of her enquiries into the operations of the co-operative societies in the town, entirely owned and managed by working men:

I have spent the day in the chapels and schools. After dinner, a dissenting minister dropped in and I had a long talk with him: he is coming for a cigarette this evening after chapel. He told me that in all the chapels there was a growing desire among the congregation to have political and social subjects treated in the pulpit and that it was very difficult for a minister, now, to please. He also remarked that in the districts where co-operation amongst the workmen (in industrial enterprise) existed, they were a much more independent and free-thinking set.

There is an immense amount of co-operation in the whole of this district; the stores seem to succeed well, both as regards supplying the people with cheap articles and as savings banks paying good interest. Of course, I am just in the centre of the dissenting organisation; and as our host is the chapel keeper and entertains all the ministers who come here, I hear all about the internal management … each chapel is a self-governing community, regulating not only chapel matters but overlooking the private life of its members.

Working-class self-help or self-protection organisations grew rapidly in the nineteenth century. Friendly societies, trade unions and consumer cooperative societies, the most important of the predominantly working-class mutual assistance societies, are often presented as ‘self-help’ organisations; but they were as much about self-protection as self-advancement and much more about solidarity than individualism. Cooperatives, on the model of the Rochdale ‘Pioneers’ of 1844 (pictured below), were identified with consumers. Skilled workers led the way, as they were better able to pay subscriptions and use their literacy to organise beyond the workplace, and their jobs and conditions were often threatened by technological innovation in the mid-century. Many workers felt the need to make provisions to avoid the much-feared Poor Law; skilled workers sought to combine together to defend their livelihoods in an era of rapid technological development.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 001-5.jpg
The Rochdale Pioneers founded the first modern cooperative in Rochdale in 1844, with their first shop in Toad Lane. The Pioneers established the principles of consumer cooperation.

Forty years after the Rochdale Pioneers, the young social researcher Beatrice Webb, not yet a socialist, was clear about the ties which existed between the Nonconformist chapels in Bacup and the local cooperatives:

One cannot help feeling what an excellent thing these dissenting organisations have been for educating this class for self-government. I can’t help thinking, too, that one of the best preventives against the socialistic tendency of the coming democracy would lie in local government; which would force the respectable working man to consider political questions as they come up in local administration. … they are keen enough on any local question which comes within their own experiences and would bring plenty of shrewd sound sense to bear on the actual management of things… There is an immense amount of spare energy in this class, now that it is educated, which is by no means used up in their mechanical occupation. … It can be employed either in the practical solution of social and economic questions or in the purely intellectual exercise of political discussion about problems considered in the abstract. …

In living amongst mill-hands of East Lancashire … I was impressed with the depth and realism of their religious faith. … Even the social intercourse was based on religious sympathy and common religious sympathy and common religious effort. …

Cooperatives and trade unions.

As legal restraints were lifted in the 1870s, it became easier for trade unions to spread to ‘unskilled’ groups, such as the agricultural workers, led by the Methodist Joseph Arch, who founded the National Agricultural Labourers’ Union. The growth of waterfront and related unions in the great seaports helped to change the geography of the trade union movement, although their strength ebbed and flowed with the trade cycle. In 1891, on the crest of the cycle, officially recorded trade union membership had penetrated deepest in Northumberland, Durham, industrial Lancashire, Yorkshire and Derbyshire, and South Wales. It remained at a very low ebb across the Home Counties, southwest England, the rest of Wales and most of East Anglia, despite the rise in agricultural trade unions. The same geographical pattern applied to the development of consumer cooperatives. ‘Coops’ divided profits among their members and were based on the doctrines of the mill owner Robert Owen, whose great discovery that the key to a better society was unrestrained co-operation on the part of all members for every purpose of social life. They attempted to build virtuous alternative societies based on a fair distribution of the rewards of labour, whose superiority to corrupt competitive capitalism would gradually and ultimately prevail. To raise funds for these Owenite communities, shops were established, with the surpluses going towards the next stages of cooperative manufacturing and agriculture.

Dozens of such societies were founded, to begin with mainly in the industrial north of England. The extra spark was provided by Rochdale’s Equitable Pioneers in 1844 in deciding to divide up the profits from sales, in proportion to their spending at the store. This ‘dividend’ enabled working-class consumers to save while they spent, and its attractions provided the basis for a tremendous expansion of consumer cooperation, extending to housing, manufacturing and insurance, throughout the second half of the nineteenth century. By 1870, Yorkshire had 121 societies of varying sizes, and Lancashire 112, followed by Durham (twenty-eight), the Northamptonshire footwear district (twenty-one) Northumberland (eighteen) and Cheshire/ Derbyshire (seventeen). At this point, there were just six societies within a twelve-mile radius of London.

The story of the Radcliffe Co-op, whose shop is shown above, is not unique, but rather typifies the pioneering enterprise of the early co-operators. Founded in 1860, the Radcliffe co-operators looked to the established movement in Bury, Oldham and Ashton for inspiration and advice. The founding members would ‘cart it’ to the towns to attend the tea parties and lectures of other societies, the strongest contingent of workers coming from the Red Bank Mills. The ‘cut-lookers’, overlookers, winders and weavers, encouraged by the obvious success of these societies, soon took the decision to start a Cooperative store in Radcliffe, the first sovereign being subscribed at a pub in Black Lane. Their first meeting was held in August 1860, incurring an expense of eleven shillings and sixpence. By October, 181 workers had subscribed one shilling and sixpence each, enabling a flour bin to be made and a shop to be rented in Mount Sion Road for fourteen pounds a year. The stock was ordered, one sack of soda heading the list. After only a year, the first dividend was paid, two shillings in the pound to each member. The Radcliffe Co-op flourished, reading rooms, educational classes, Women’s Guild and political committee interwoven with the steady growth of baking, coal supply, housing, dairy produce, and a growing number of branches. Radcliffe existed as a separate Society for more than a century, finally merging with Bolton Co-operative in 1963.

Wherever traditions of self-help and trade union commitment coexisted with hard-working, thrifty Nonconformity, cooperation took root. These included Birmingham and the Midlands, which were also strongholds of radical religious Dissent which was becoming overtly political with the rise to municipal power of Liberal reformers like Joseph Chamberlain. Beatrice Webb commented on her conversations with him in her diary, in entries made during their four-year relationship which had begun in 1882 when he had become a minister in Gladstone’s second government:

The same quality of one-idea’d-ness is present in the Birmingham Radical set, earnestness and simplicity of motive being strikingly present. Political conviction takes the place here of religious faith. … Heine said some fifty years ago, “Talk to an Englishman on religion and he is fanatic; talk to him on politics and he is a man of the world.” It would seem to me from my slight experience of Bacup and Birmingham, that that part of the Englishman’s nature which has found gratification in religion is now drifting into political life. When I suggested this to Mr- Chamberlain he answered. “I quite agree with you, and I rejoice in it. I have always had a grudge against religion for absorbing the passion in man’s nature.” It is only natural then that, this being his view, he should find in the uncompromising belief of his own set a more sympathetic atmosphere wherein to recruit his forces to battle with powers of evil, than in the somewhat cynical… political opinions of London Society. (MS diary, 16 March 1884).

‘Slum Sisters’ & Child Labourers:

The photographs below of children queing for, and enjoying, farthing breakfasts, taken for the Salvation Army in the 1890s, are a reminder of the tens of thousands of children who went to school hungry. In addition to the meals provided by the Ragged Schools, breakfasts were provided by the the ‘slum sisters’ of the Salvation Army; a huge mug of hot, sweet tea and a ‘doorstep’ of bread in a ‘jam butty’ would be given in return for the smallest coin of the realm. It was not only the best meal of the day for many, but for some, the only meal.

Farthing Breakfast queue

The poor children, especially in East London, would otherwise have gone to school with empty stomachs. They might well have been given, on their return each evening, stale bread covered with dripping or a red herring with pickles. Skimmed milk and a pennyworth of brawn would commonly serve as the main meal for the children of the East End, and the less fortunate would scour the market places for rotten vegetables and fruit discarded as unsaleable by the ‘barrow boys’.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 005.jpg
Farthing breakfasts

As far as diet was concerned, the Medical Inspector of Schools for Lambeth, Dr Alfred Eichholz, testified to the interdepartmental Committee on Physical Deterioration in December 1903 that:

Want of food, irregularity and unsuitability of food, taken together are the determining cause of degeneracy in children. The breakfasts that these children get are nominally bread and tea if they get it at all. There is bread and margarine for lunch, and the dinner is normally nothing but what a copper can purchase at the local fried fish shops, where the most inferior kinds of fish such as skate are fried in unwholesome, reeking cottonseed oil. They frequently supplement this with rotten fruit, which they collect beneath barrows. … In these districts the only milk which any of the children know is tinned milk which does not possess the nutritive power of fresh milk … As regards meat, if they get it at all, it is for the most part once a week on Sundays and then very little and of the poor sort.

The photographs below, of London children in a school playground and a street, are memorials to the working-class children who went to school barefoot. They were taken for the Salvation Army and others in order to demonstrate aspects of poverty, though that does not detract from the help they give us in understanding the effects and extent of poverty in London at the height of imperial splendour at the turn of the century. Robert Sherhard’s description of the little milk carrier in Glasgow, a girl of ten, whose ‘feet felt and looked like pieces of frozen meat’ drives away any illusion of the romance of going without shoes in the British climate. Barefoot children were a phenomenon that remained in Britain until the outbreak of the Second World War. For fifty years before that clog clubs and boot clubs flourished as parents scrimped and scraped to see their children shod and even then waged a constant struggle to keep boots and shoes in repair. In wet and wintry weather, rain and snow squelched through holes stuffed with brown paper as children shuffled to school, their footwear too large or too small, cast-offs from brothers and sisters.

Even after 1880, when elementary schooling had been made compulsory, for thousands of poor children it came only after work, which was either casual help to local tradesmen or part-time work in factories and mills. Legally allowed to start work at eleven years of age, the children would clock on at five in the morning, working barefoot in the shattering noise and humid atmosphere of the mill before going exhausted to school in the afternoon. Health and education suffered but mill owners fought fiercely against depriving them of their cheap labour and it was not until the Education Act of 1918 that half-time work for children was legally ended. The report of the Inter-Departmental Committee on the Employment of Schoolchildren, in 1901, put the figure at three hundred thousand children in England and Wales combining school attendance with paid employment. But that fact by itself does not convey the devastating effect on the health and education of working-class children inadequately or badly fed, invariably badly dressed, totting up a sixteen-hour day of schoolwork and labour. Reports of children falling from their desks with exhaustion or fainting from hunger were common and it does not require more than a modicum of imagination to picture the condition of barefooted, raggedy-clothed children arriving at school in wet or wintry weather, having already put in a few hours work, often in the open air.

Looking closely at the photograph from the Fawcett album of schoolchildren in a playground, it is apparent that those with boots (or clogs) are scarcely better shod than those barefooted. School authorities were not unaware of the problem, and as early as 1879 the London School Board began to provide boots for the poorest children in order that they could attend school, only to find themselves attacked by the Charity Organisation Society who feared that other parents would keep their children at home in order to obtain boots. The problem of the poor in providing boots for their children was to remain a source of concern and debate until the outbreak of the Second World War.

Work for children was a necessity born of adult unemployment and underemployment, casual labour, trade recessions, seasonal occupations, and the payment of less than subsistence wages, not only in the sweated trades but by the employers in the major sections of British commerce, including clockwork, mining and agriculture. What of the work that the children undertook in their playtime? Helping the milkman from four-thirty in the morning till school time and again from five till nine; selling newspapers for sixty hours a week, lather boy for the barber from school-out till ten every night, delivering heavy groceries, paid a ‘thruppence for six hours’, these extra chores contributed to the family income and in some cases, where dad was out of work and the family large, was the family income, saving them from the final degradation of the workhouse.

The photograph above, of children outside a pie shop, was taken for the Salvation Army. It poses questions that suggested it was contrived. The children seem poor, even if the boy in knickerbockers is far better attired than his ‘mates’, but they all seem able to make a purchase from the shop. Perhaps the photographer staged the ‘event’ by rewarding his subjects. Nevertheless, the small sartorial details tell a story of hand-me-down clothes and a lack of footwear that was a common sight in cities at the turn of the century.

In November 1886, the Revd. Samuel Francis Collier was placed in charge of the new Methodist Central Hall, Manchester, built at the then prodigious cost of forty thousand pounds. Magnificent though the Hall was, the dynamic evangelist, with a social as well as a spiritual conscience, soon launched a programme of practical help for the poor, using the motto ‘Need not creed’ in his daring new ministry. Nobody in need was to be refused help, regardless of belief. In 1891, an old rag factory was established at Ancoats, salvaging the waste of the city, old bottles, jars, empty tins, cotton waste, pails and clothing all being sorted for re-use and sale, destitute men being given a good bed and three square meals a day for their labour. From that venture in social rehabilitation grew the most complete set of social service premises possessed by any church in Britain. By the early 1900s, a Men’s Home, Labour Yard, Women’s Refuge, a Maternity Hospital for unmarried mothers and a Labour Advice Bureau had all been developed together with educational clubs, prison visiting services and holiday funds. The picture below shows the boys in the Labour Yard of the Manchester and Salford Wesleyan Missions. Outcasts of industrial society, they were welcomed by Collier and provided with clothes, food, shelter and hope in exchange for ‘honest toil’.

Distant Dissenters & Social Justice:

Against this ‘backdrop’, the attitudes towards the poor of the more distant and ‘conservative’ Nonconformist leaders, were well illustrated from the pens of those who patronised them, those who preached to them and from those amongst the poor who discovered in the Nonconformist pulpit a means for calling their colleagues to self-realisation. It was significant that Andrew Mearns, William Booth and Charles Booth were all Nonconformists, but Dissenters were also prone to being accused of philanthropy divorced from a sense of social justice, and even of outright hypocrisy in their attitudes towards the poor. All too easily, as Briggs and Sellers (1973) noted, the phrase ‘the Nonconformist conscience’,

… could lapse into an unlovely onslaught from a determined, Puritanical middle-class sectarianism against the drink, gambling and thriftlessness of the classes below and above it to the ignoring of the deeper social problems which afflicted the nation.

This collage from the cover of the book by John Briggs and Ian Sellers on ‘Victorian Nonconformity’ was designed to illustrate different facets of Victorian Nonconformity. The figures are part of the Pugh Collection of Staffordshire figures at pressures on loan to the City Museum and Art Gallery, Stoke-on-Trent.

That is not to say that Nonconformity’s sympathies rested upon calculation alone. The growing call for the preaching of a ‘social gospel’ was, at least, the ‘child’ of a more positive definition of individualism, standing as a proper, practical and involved corrective to the implicit pietism of the tradition of conscientious separation. In his address published in the Congregational Year Book in 1885, Dr Joseph Parker envisaged a speech by one of ‘that suffering community’ of ‘ignorance, misfortunate, misery and shame’ who had spent a year observing the ‘Unions, Conferences, Assemblies and Convocations’ held among Nonconformist ‘leaders’:

‘We have had a full year among, and we cannot very well make out what you are driving at. We do not know most of the long words you use … We do not know what you are, or what you want to be at. From what we can make out you seem to know that we poor devils are going straight down to a place you call hell. … We read the inky papers which you call your “resolutions” but in them, there is no word for us that is likely to do us real good. They say nothing about our real misery; nothing about our long hours, our poor pay, our wretched lodgings.’

… our evangelism is in danger of devoting itself almost exclusively to what is known as ‘the masses’. I must protest against this contraction, on the ground that it is as unjust to Christianity, as it is blind to the evidence of facts. If the city missionary … is wanted anywhere, he is specially wanted where … conscience is lulled by charity which knows nothing of sacrifice, and where the political economy is made the scapegoat for oppression and robbery. … There is only one class worse than the class known as ‘outcast London’, and that class is composed of those who ‘have lived in pleasure on the earth and been wanton. The cry is ‘bitterer’ in many tones at the West End than at the East; … the thousand social falsehoods that mimic the airs of Piety … these seem to be distressed without alleviation and to constitute heathenism which Christ himself might view with despair.

Within the Nonconformist tradition, however, the individualistic emphasis upon personal conversion had always had to be held in tension with a corporate understanding of the church and its role in society: as the normative social philosophy of Victorian Britain changed from individualism to collectivism, so correspondingly this second emphasis, which for much of the century was neglected, came into new prominence. Social Science may well have been a middle-class preoccupation of the mid-century, but when linked with the kingdom of God theology of the Christian Socialists it provided an important link between the ‘Political Dissent’ of the 1830s and ’40s with the ‘Nonconformist Conscience’ or ‘social gospel’ of the ’80s and ’90s. The Baptist pastor, J. Clifford, was actively involved in campaigning against the ‘living in’ system, as the photograph above shows. ‘Dressed like dukes, treated like slaves as the slogan went, since shop assistants were expected to dress like aristocrats and to spend their lives in total subjection to their employers. Almost half a million were of them were compelled to ‘live in’ their employers’ premises in conditions that were appalling and institutional. The shopowners created a tyranny as harsh as the yearly bond system of the mine-owners or the feudal power of the squirearchy. Stores were open from morning to night for six days a week and working hours of eighty to ninety hours per week were common.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 006.jpg

The ‘living in’ system bound the shopworker to the shopowner as tightly as the tied cottage bound the labourer to the farm owner. Much of the accommodation was barrack-like with beds alive with fleas and walls crawling with bugs. Baths were rarely provided and hot water was almost as scarce. The rules of one Knightsbridge store forbade lights after 11 p.m., breaching of which resulted in instant dismissal. Sleeping out required permission and failure to comply with this also resulted in dismissal on the second offence. Assistants were also forbidden to marry without permission and communal living denied them the vote. On their one free day, they were expected to attend church. The photograph, taken in May 1901, shows thirteen shop assistants advertising a meeting against the system, with Dr Clifford as the chief speaker. The sandwich boards were hired from the Church Army; third in line is P. C. Hoffman, a pioneer of the Shop Assistants’ Union and a trade union official for forty years. In his Fabian Tract of 1897, Socialism and the Teachings of Christ, Clifford encapsulated the transition from individualist to collectivist thinking among many Nonconformists and Church organisations:

Collectivism, although it does not change human nature, yet takes away the occasion for many of the evils which now afflict society. It reduces the temptations of life in number and in strength. It means work for everyone and the elimination of the idle, and if the work should not be so exacting, responsible, and therefore not so educative for a few individuals, yet it will go far to answer Browning’s prayer:

O God, make no more giants,

Elevate the race.

… Individualism adds to the number of the indolent year by year; collectivism sets everybody alike to his share of work, and gives to him his share of the reward. … Collectivism affords a better environment for the teachings of Jesus concerning wealth and the ideals of labour and brotherhood. If man is … only ‘the expression of his environment’ … then it is an unspeakable gain to bring that environment into line with the teaching of Jesus Christ. In the Gospels, accumulated wealth appears as a grave peril to the spiritual life, a menace to the spiritual life, a menace to the purest aims and noblest ideals. Christ is entirely undazzled by its fascinations and sees in it a threat against the integrity and progress of his kingdom. ‘Lay not up for yourselves treasures on earth’. … Now, though Collectivism does not profess to extinguish vice and manufacture saints, it will abolish poverty, reduce the hungry to an imperceptible quantity, and systematically care for the aged poor and for the sick. It will carry forward much of the charitable work left to individual initiative … is not all that in harmony with the spirit and teaching of Him who bids us see Himself in the hungry and sick, the poor and the criminal?

… Collectivism fosters a more Christian conception of industry; one in which every man is a worker, and each worker does not toil for himself exclusively, but for the necessities, comforts and privileges he shares equally with all members of the community. … It is a new ideal of life and labour that is most urgently needed. England’s present ideal is a creation of hard individualism; and therefore is partial, hollow, unreal and disastrous. … Individualism fosters the caste feelings and caste divisions of society, creates the serfdom of one class and the indolence of another; makes a large body of submissive, silent, unmanly slaves undergoing grinding toil and continuous anxiety, and a smaller company suffering from debasing indolence and continual weariness. … No! the ideal we need and must have is in the unity of English life, in the recognition that man is complete in the State, at once a member of society and of the Government…

In terms of collective ‘self-help’, by 1899, 1,531 cooperative societies in Great Britain had over 1.6 million members, and in heartlands like ‘cotton Lancashire’, practically every household included a cooperator. London, the great seaports and even the popular resorts were catching up with the older industrial centres by this time, and the cooperative and trade union movements marched in step, though they rarely collaborated, except when there were strikes and marches of workers to London. As a more widely supported movement that drew in women as well as men, especially through its Women’s Guild, and pulled in whole families as consumers, Cooperation had an even bigger impact than the better-documented trade union movement, especially during the troughs of the trade cycle. The geographical bases of the two movements are best understood as products of the economic peaks and troughs, or as two sides of the same coin.

Investigating Poverty:

It was against this paradoxical economic, social and political background that poverty began to attract more attention once again primarily due to men and women of public conscience, notably the nonconformist shipowner Charles Booth and the Quaker chocolate manufacturer, Seebohm Rowntree, who began to investigate it, to quantify it and to reveal its extent in irrefutable detail for the first time. Thirty per cent of London’s population at the beginning of the 1890s fell on or below Booth’s poverty line and in certain parts of London the percentages were far higher, sixty-eight per cent in Southwark, for instance, and sixty-five in Greenwich. Rowntree’s figure for York in 1899 was hardly any lower so that cases of real want could no longer be characterised as unrepresentative. Nor, in many cases, could they be attributed to an unwillingness to work. So low or intermittent were earnings that many families had incomes below the level needed for the maintenance of ‘physical efficiency’. Rowntree spelt out in precise and detailed language for middle-class readers exactly what this meant:

A family … must never spend a penny on railway fare or omnibus. … They cannot save, nor can they join a sick club or Trade Union. … The children must have no pocket money. … Should a child fall ill, it must be attended by the parish doctor, should it die, it must be buried by the parish. Finally, the wage-earner must never be absent from his work for a single day.

In the York of 1899, nearly ten per cent of the total population, more than fifteen per cent of wage-earners, lived in ‘primary poverty’ below even this ‘line’, and these figures were believed to be not untypical of other provincial towns. These revelations of poverty by Booth and Rowntree came as a ‘disagreeable shock‘ for late Victorian society. According to J Burnett in his seminal (1977) work, A History of the Cost of Living, the period between 1830 and 1900 saw a doubling of the real earnings of the average worker. Britain’s productive resources had, at last, enabled its working classes to realize a standard of living that was unique in time and place. Because of this improvement and due to the continuous upgrading of labour from unskilled to semi-skilled occupations, there was little doubt that the working classes had gained as much as other classes during the period of late Victorian prosperity. It was against this ‘optimistic’ background that the findings of Booth and Rowntree stood out in stark contrast. By the standards of the most rigorous, scientific measures available at the time, a subsistence level defined by reference to the smallest amount of food necessary to support mere physical efficiency, they came to an almost precisely identical conclusion, namely that nearly 31% of the population of London and 28% of the population of York were existing in poverty, one in six babies died before reaching their first birthday, and one in five of the population would still ‘look forward to the indignity of a pauper’s funeral from the workhouse in which they would end their days‘.

It was, therefore, with hindsight, hardly a matter for surprise that just over a third of men who volunteered for military service between 1893 and 1908 (at the time of the Boer Wars) were rejected on medical grounds, and fears of national physical deterioration began to alarm the more conservative elements in the country and allied them with those whose consciences had been stirred by the social investigators’ ‘arithmetic of woe’. The plight of the poor was made worse to some extent by the fact that many more of them lived in towns. The urbanisation theme, frequently encountered in earlier chapters, now reaches its climax. In 1871, sixty-two per cent of the population of England and Wales was classed as urban; by 1911 it reached eighty per cent of a much larger total. A visiting American visiting London in 1909, drew some interesting internal contrasts together with international comparisons:

These beef-eating, port-drinking fellows in Piccadilly, exercised, scrubbed, groomed, they are well enough to be sure; but this other side of the shield is distressing to look at. Poor, stunted, bad-complexioned, shabbily dressed, ill-featured are these pork-eating, gin-drinking denizens of the East End. Crowds I have seen in America, in Mexico, and in most of the great cities of Europe … Nowhere is there such squalor, such pinching poverty, so many undersized, so many plainly and revoltingly diseased, so much human rottenness as here …

Jack London, already the author of a two-volume work about life in the Klondyke, had come to London in the summer of 1902, aged twenty-six, living in the dockland area for two months. He published his book chronicling the visit, The People of the Abyss, the following year. In it, he remarked that:

There is one beautiful sight in the East End, and only one, and it is the children dancing in the street when the organ-grinder goes his round.

The Wisconsin-born journalist, R. D. Blumenfeld had visited England even earlier, in the 1880s and kept a diary, which he eventually published in 1930. As editor of the Daily Express, he played an important role in the shaping of popular journalism in Britain. In his entry for December 1901, he gave a vivid portrayal of a night spent on the Embankment among the poor and homeless. ‘Charlie’ Chaplin was born in 1889 at Walworth and grew up in Lambeth and elsewhere south of the Thames. When his father’s death at thirty-one brought about the family’s ruin, they were forced into the Lambeth workhouse, where they had to separate. In his Autobiography, published in 1966, he recalled:

… the poignant sadness of that first visiting day: the shock of seeing Mother enter the visiting-room garbed in workhouse clothes. How forlorn and embarrassed she looked! In one week she had aged and grown thin, … but she smiled at our cropped heads and stroked them consolingly, telling us that we would soon all be together again. From her apron, she produced a bag of coconut candy which she had bought at the workhouse store with her earnings from crocheting lace cuffs for one of the nurses.

In 1921, Chaplin went ‘home’ to the East End, during a stay at the Ritz. His visit was recorded as one of the events of the year in the Daily Express’ publication, These Tremendous Years (1939):

In his Life and Labour of the London Poor, written in 1902-3, Charles Booth wrote of his encounter with a group of East End children as he stood in the lighted porch of a chapel which had the sound of Sankey’s hymns coming from inside. Going towards them, he suggested that they would be better off in bed at that time of the evening. One of the girls, scarcely more than eight years old, replied:

“Garn, we’re ahrt wiv ahr blokes … that’s my bloke”. “Yus”, said the other girl, and that’s mine” (they pointed to two boys about their own size). At this there was a general shout of laughter and then came the plaintive plea from the first child, “Give us a penny, will you, Guv’nor?!” Regular cockney Arabs these.

Retrospectively, and more ‘optimistically’, J. Burnett, in his 1977 book, A History of the Cost of Living, took a longer-term look at the period from 1790 to 1900, which saw a quantifiably absolute increase in the real earnings of the average worker of some two-and-a-half times, and probably a doubling within the period 1830 to 1900. According to Burnett:

Britain’s productive resources had, at last, enabled it to realise a standard of life that was unique in time and place. … Because of this improvement, and because of the continuous up-grading of labour from less-skilled to more skilled occupations, there can be little doubt that the worker had gained as much as other classes during the period of late Victorian prosperity.

There are qualitative sources in the social sphere to support the view that progress and prosperity were more the ‘orders of the day’ for most British people, and increasingly the conditions experienced by those workers who did not fall into the poorest tenth of the population. Yet for perhaps the majority of the working-class population, industrialisation had disrupted the traditional patterns of their social lives as much as their working lives. Of course, much of this disruption was for the betterment of individuals within society. While on the one hand there were new constraints, on the other new horizons were extended in other directions by technological advances and distances were being overcome. The range of consumer products was enlarged and cheapened, and social experiences were diversified. It is not necessary, when evaluating the qualitative evidence, to posit a pre-industrial ‘Golden Age’ of social harmony and higher living standards, though many in Victorian and Edwardian times, as well as more recently, have been eager to do so. The emergence of industrial society, it was claimed, did untold and irreparable damage to the traditional, spiritual values of society. Personal relationships took on a corporate, commercial and mercenary character; competition and rivalry replaced a society based on cooperation. In total, the effect was to produce an imbalance between man and nature, since man had become as mechanical in his responses as the machines he tended. Further apprehensions were expressed about the growing uniformity of society.

The Birmingham ‘Bible’ & Social Gospel:

Birmingham’s diverse industrial base made it a serious rival to Manchester as Britain’s second city in the later nineteenth century. The city gained a reputation for municipal enterprise for its public works, including one of the country’s most extensive urban tramway systems. Cheap and efficient public transport systems, based on horse-drawn omnibuses and trams, proved to be an effective way of dispersing the industrial working class from overcrowded and disease-ridden city-centre slums. From the Nonconformist point of view, however, R. W. Dale delivered a Lecture to the New Electors in which he addressed the citizens of Birmingham who had acquired the vote as a result of the 1867 Reform Act which enfranchised the majority of working-class men, but not its ‘slum-dwellers’:

You have a great practical concern in whatever measures are likely to make the criminal classes disappear, and I trust that such measures will have your hearty support. … There is another class from which we have almost as much to fear … one million persons receiving relief. … And in this million you have first the permanent paupers, and then a vast mass of people who are on the parish on and off again every few months, but who when they go off are sure to leave successors … We have hereditary paupers, as well as hereditary criminals, and I maintain that this is intolerable. … You will feel very distinctly the sharp pressure that comes upon the community for the support of the ‘armies of the homeless and unfed’, and will be the more eager to discover how the pauperism of the country can be effectively diminished.

In Birmingham, as Dale knew well, the city’s municipal administration was notably lax with regards to public works, and many urban dwellers lived in conditions of great poverty. Joseph Chamberlain made his career in Birmingham, first as a manufacturer of screws and then as a notable mayor of the city. He became involved in Liberal politics, influenced by the strong radical and liberal traditions among Birmingham shoemakers and the long tradition of social action in Chamberlain’s Unitarian church. Chamberlain He was a radical Liberal Party member and an opponent of the Elementary Education Act 1870 on the basis that it could result in subsidising Church of England schools with local ratepayers’ money. As a self-made businessman, he had never attended university and had contempt for the aristocracy.  In November 1873, the Liberal Party swept the municipal elections and Chamberlain was elected Mayor of Birmingham. The Conservatives had denounced his Radicalism and called him a “monopoliser and a dictator” whilst the Liberals had campaigned against their High Church Tory opponents with the slogan “The People above the Priests”. As Mayor, Chamberlain promoted many civic improvements, promising the city would be “parked, paved, assized, marketed, gas & watered and ‘improved'”. In February 1874, he wrote to Henry Allen, Editor of the Nonconformist Review, reflecting on the election results and the need for a campaign to further a closer union between nonconformists as such and the working classes.

The only chance of the Government lay in a declaration of policy calculated to arouse the hearty enthusiasm of the non-conformists and the working. Instead of this Gladstone issued the meanest manifesto that ever proceeded from a great Minister. … At the same time, the returns show that the present political position of the Dissenters is not satisfactory. They are very hazy as to the principles of the Education question, and have, in many cases, been carried over to the enemy by the ‘Bible’ cry.

In the latter assertion, it can be assumed that Chamberlain is referring to the provision of the 1870 act in respect of Religious Education, which placed Biblical knowledge at the centre of the curriculum, alongside numeracy and literacy. By ‘the enemy’, Chamberlain was referring to ‘the Anglican Establishment’, as he went on to explain:

Worse still, they have ceased to combine cordially with the working classes, without whose active assistance further advances in the direction of Religious Equality are impossible. But both in the case of the agricultural labourers, and in reference to the demands of the Trades Unions for the repeal of what I do not hesitate to stigmatize as class legislation of the worst kind, the Dissenters have largely held aloof, and their organs in the Press … have been unsympathetic and even hostile.

In his references to the agricultural workers and the trades unions, Chamberlain was no doubt referring to the National Agricultural Labourers’ Union, founded in Warwickshire in the early 1870s, led by the Wesleyan lay-preacher Joseph Arch and supported by thousands of Nonconformist workers who had faced wage cuts and evictions from local squires simply for joining the union, and whose children had been excluded from parish schools in some areas. The failure of some nonconformist church leaders to support their poorer members led Chamberlain to argue that:

Unless this is altered in the future such questions as Disestablishment and Disendowment will be indefinitely postponed, as the Artisan voter can see little difference between Caesar and Pompey, and looking like the whole affair is a mere squabble between Church and Chapel, will take no interest in the matter.

Chamberlain pointed out that the only districts in which Liberalism had come well out of the recent were the Midland Counties, where they gained one seat and the Northern Counties, where the balance was still in favour of the Liberals. There, he wrote, the local parties appealed directly to the mass of the working-class population, with the Dissenters aiding very largely with their purses and influence, and cordially recognising the justice of the labourers’ claims. Chamberlain contrasted the enduring support of the local Liberal Press in Birmingham and Newcastle, in particular, with …

… this narrowness on the part of many of the rank and file of Dissent, will be fatal to the success of our special aims unless we can induce and make a more generous recognition of the claims of the masses.

The ‘richest country’ in the world? Rising Standards of Living?:

Paradoxically, the changing composition of the ruling classes gave the emergent working classes the opportunity to fight for a share in the spoils of progress and power. Initially, working-class activity had taken the form of semi-legal organisations and actions, mainly aimed at restricting production and/or trade. But once the working classes had established more ‘mature’ craft-based trade unions, and economic and political organisations, the ruling classes were not slow to entangle them in their political intrigues. At the same time, despite the revelations of Booth and Rowntree that poverty was still alive and ‘well’ in the richest country in the world, there was an overall rise in living standards for the majority of British people over the Victorian and Edwardian periods. The growing urbanisation of the country which many people thought aggravated the problems of the poor also made it easier to deal with the worst social injustices. Towns provided an increasing range of free services, as local government expenditure almost doubled between 1900 and 1913. It was in towns that free school meals and school medical inspection began. Better medical attention was becoming available, too, in hospitals, which catered mainly for working-class patients.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 007-2.jpg
A football match at the Molineux Grounds in the 1890s, shortly after it was taken over by Wolverhampton Wanderers. The first match played by the Wolves on their new ground was a friendly against Aston Villa when on Monday, 2 September 1889, at 5.30 p.m., a crowd of just under four thousand watched them defeat the Villa 1-0. Five days later, the Wolves staged their first League game at Molineux, against Notts County. Wolves won 2-0. Despite the extensions to the embankments and terraces shown below, by 1905 the ground was falling behind those of near neighbours Birmingham, Aston Villa and West Bromwich Albion. It stayed that way until 1911 when a curved roof was built over the north end of the ground, nicknamed ‘the Cowshed’ because of the corrugated iron fencing that formed its walls.

Falling prices and rising working-class living standards in late Victorian times made hard-working, thrifty Nonconformity compatible with popular pleasures like football and the seaside, as more working people could afford to save and spend or save in order to spend, as cooperation became a mass movement. Workmen’s trains and, from the 1890s onwards, electric tramcars, together with cheap, second-hand bicycles, enabled many wage-earners to escape from the congested central areas of towns into the suburbs, leaving more room for those who still had to remain. Other innovations were the music halls, sporting events, excursion trains, silent films and, above all, new and more attractive public houses with their bright lives and vast expanses of plate glass and mirrors. Within these new ‘pubs’ there was a definite decline in heavy alcohol consumption, particularly in spirits, and, from 1900, in general drunkenness. This marked a clear break with the past but so, too, did the increase in cigarette smoking. Charles Booth wrote of these changes as he observed them in London:

There has been a great development and improvement upon the usual public-house sing-song as to the low character and bad influence of which there are no two opinions. The story of progress in this respect may be traced in many of the existing places which, from a bar parlour and a piano to an accompaniment on which friends “obliged with a song”, have passed through every stage to that of music hall … The audiences are youthful. They seek amusement and are easily pleased … The increase in the number, as well as size of halls, has been rapid. … The taste becomes a habit and new halls are opened every year…

More importantly, the same schools’ medical inspector who had found high levels of malnourishment in Lambeth, Dr Alfred Eicholz, reported in the next year, 1904, to the Committee on physical deterioration, that on his ‘special visits’ to West Ham, Manchester, Salford and Leeds that:

In the better districts of the towns there exist public elementary schools frequented by children not merely equal but often superior in physique and attainments to rural children. And these schools seem to be at least as numerous as schools of the lower type. … All evidence points to active improvement, bodily and mental, in the worst districts, so soon as they are exposed to better circumstances, even the weaker children recovering at a later age from the evil effects of infant life. Compulsory school attendance, the more rigorous scheduling of children of school age and the abolition of school fees in elementary schools have swept into the schools an annually increasing proportion of children during the last thirty years.

Dr Eicholz explained this difference between districts by commenting on the importance of elementary education in determining opportunities in relieving deprived areas:

Elementary education has contributed to the stratification of the large urban population into a distinct series of social levels. There is an upper class, well-to-do and well cared for, to whom our methods afford every chance of mental and physical improvement … At the other end of the scale, we find the aggregations of the slum population ill-nourished, poor, ignorant, badly housed, to a small extent only benefited by our methods of training ...

Housing problems – Overcrowding & Sanitation:

The first Town Planning Act had been passed in 1909, and the more progressive municipalities, stirred by its apparent opportunities, undertook local surveys. For example, in the spring of 1913, Birmingham City Council instituted an enquiry to ‘investigate the present housing conditions of the poor’. It found that, of the 175,000 dwellings in the city, fifty thousand, though occupied, were unfit for habitation; forty-two thousand had no separate water supply, no sinks or drains, and fifty-eight thousand had no separate water closet, the closets being communal and exposed in courts. These conditions were matched by any great English city, and in Scotland, living conditions were, if anything, even worse. But not only were the dwellings of a very large proportion of the working class dilapidated and unsanitary; they were also overcrowded. In 1911, over thirty per cent of the population was living under conditions of more than three persons per two rooms. In the same year, an average group of a hundred people was living as twenty-three family units. These were the two main social evils of the pre-1914 period; gross overcrowding and filthily squalid accommodation. But some of the overcrowding was also eased by the preference for smaller families which began to spread to certain sections of the working classes before the First World War. At the same time, however, the rates of natural increase continued to rise due to improvements in medical and maternity services, old age pensions began to be paid by the state at the beginning of 1909 and health and unemployment benefits were introduced in 1913.

The second major housing evil of pre-1914 days was tackled with far fewer measures. In 1911, it was not uncommon to find in many cities that as many as a third of dwellings were so obsolete and unsanitary that they were unfit for human habitation. Despite the introduction of ‘revolutionary’ standards for new housing in 1918, only about a third of a million of the millions of squalid dwellings that existed in 1911 had been demolished by 1939. The rest were still in occupation, and some four million people were living in dwellings built before the 1860s. Despite patching and ‘modernisation’, sanitary conditions remained primitive and amenities were rare. In the same year, Manchester’s Medical Officer for Health officially condemned over a third of the city’s housing as unfit for habitation. In Birmingham, after surveying the third of a million dwellings in the city, the City Engineer found that sixty-three thousand of them, almost twenty per cent, were so dilapidated and insanitary that they were due to be condemned immediately. Fifty-two thousand of these still had no separate WC and fourteen thousand had no separate water supply. Conditions were even worse on Tyneside, and in 1939, some of the Scottish slums matched and often plumbed the depths of 1911. A report of the Department of Health for Scotland described the 1939 conditions as follows:

Damp was present everywhere, the walls and ceilings of a large number of houses being literally soaking. Everywhere we noticed an almost total lack of sanitation, conveniences being few and for the most part out of repair, and even in some cases leaking downstairs and into the houses. Practically every property inspected was absolutely bug-ridden. The food itself will not keep owing to the damp and verminous conditions of the holes-in-the-walls in which it is kept. … We found lice, rats in great numbers, mice and cockroaches.

This was Spon Street in Coventry in 1957. The courtyard area was then considered a slum, but the street, containing many medieval half-timbered houses and shops, gathered from various of the city’s streets, is now a tourist attraction. Many of the city’s medieval ‘slums’ were destroyed in the Blitz of 1940, but many others were cleared in the late 1930s, like those from Butchers’ Row, pictured below (from the Coventry & Warwickshire Collection).

That these conditions still existed in some parts of the United Kingdom thirty years after they were first reported is evidence of how retarded progress in housing and welfare reform was in the inter-war period. For almost forty years, the pioneering work of Booth in London (1889) and Rowntree in York (1899) served as the brilliant but almost solitary guide to those who wished to realise, with precision, what was the exact extent of poverty in Britain, what its causes were, and what might be done to relieve it. In 1912, new material was provided by a team of researchers at the London School of Economics, who carried out a series of restricted but comparable studies into poverty in various small towns in the North-West and Midlands of England. Poverty was still endemic and alarmingly extensive in 1914, despite the positive efforts made to alleviate its effects by the extension of elementary education. It remained so for more than thirty years, primarily due to the poor nature of Britain’s housing stock.

Writing for the Fabian Society in 1945, Mark Abrams pointed out that, also by 1914, the first beneficiaries of free, compulsory education had grown up and produced their own families for whom full-time and everyday attendance at school until adolescence was accepted as normal; the schools had already started to participate in some of the traditional parental responsibilities such as feeding, medical care and job-selection. Abrams commented:

A citizen from our own day moving in that world of a few years before 1914 would have found in every context almost everything which has come to be regarded as distinctive of the culture of the inter-war years. He would have found civil servants administering schemes of old-age pensions, health and unemployment insurance, and minimum wages. … The visitor from today would have found, already fully established, the precarious and crowded ladder which enabled a handful of working-class children to enter secondary schools and enabled a fraction of these to proceed to universities. He would have seen a rapidly increasing number of junior technical schools training the clerks and technicians needed by modern business and industry.

… The visitor would have found – at least in the more prosperous parts of the country – public medicine and sanitation based firmly on the work of Pasteur and Lister, and yielding rapidly falling death rates. … In most areas he would have visited public, i.e. rate-supported, parks, libraries and swimming baths. On the public walls of lavatories … he could have read the advertisements for contraceptives manufactured by firms who claimed, in neo-Malthusian language and argument, hundreds of thousands of customers among the “respectable poor”. … For his further relaxation he could have joined a crowd of forty thousand on a Saturday afternoon and watched Wolverhampton Wanderers defeat Aston Villa or Jack Hobbs score a century… In the evening, … he could have gone to the cinema and seen Chaplin and Mary Pickford.

… In many households, the family budgets made provision for holidays at the seaside, and for payments to the building society; some were already grappling with the problems of the upkeep of the motor car. No middle-class home was complete without its bathroom … The houses were lit with electricity, and many were equipped with telephones and gramophones. The cooking was done on gas stoves, and the first dwellings were being equipped with refrigerators.

The ‘Pinch of Poverty’ & Passage to Canada:

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 011.jpg

The picture above is a classic encapsulation of northern working-class life captured by a press photographer covering an unidentified industrial dispute shortly before the war. Clogs, cobbles, and shawls are manifest in a street of narrow terraced houses dominated by factories and chimneys. The women and children wait, each with a jug, to collect soup from a communal kitchen, their only hot meal of the day. The ‘pinch of poverty’ was found pencilled on the back of the photograph, an apt caption applicable to the daily scene in a score of towns at a time when working people never did have butter for tea. In 1914, those who had passed their thirtieth birthday, and spent the formative years of their life in the intellectual atmosphere and physical environment of the revolutionary Edwardian decade. It was a revolution that still needed to be consolidated which, due to two world wars and a decade of economic depression and unemployment, could not be achieved for another thirty years and more. Nonetheless, it was a social, cultural and political revolution that had already produced distinctive patterns which set up trends in British life that were clearly visible throughout the inter-war years, and in the welfare policies of the 1940s.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is 010.jpg

In this photograph, fifty-two boys, each clutching a new sixpence, stand before their top-hatted benefactors at a boys’ emigration party given by the Lord Mayor of Manchester on 14 April 1910. ‘Culled’ from the poor law unions of Charlton and Salford, Strangeways gaol and charitable refuges, they passively await departure for their long sea voyage to Canada and their destiny as cheap labour for the farms around Ontario. While, for nearly forty years, some trade unions, like the agricultural workers’ union (NALU) had actively participated in family emigration schemes, reasoning that it would lessen the evils of unemployment, some municipalities backed it because it would lessen the burden of the ratepayers. The Mayor explained that the Manchester community benefited economically from emigration. The twelve pounds steerage passage was all that had to be paid for each boy compared with the cost of keeping them for several years.

Thomas Ackroyd, the Hon. Secretary of Refuges, pointed out that they recognised the importance of keeping healthy and honest children at home and preparing them for work in their own country. It was the ‘waifs and strays’, the very poor and sickly that would benefit by being rescued from degrading and dangerous surroundings, saved from a drunken and vicious future and at the same time save Britain from overcrowding. Contradicting himself somewhat, however, he also claimed that it would supply the colony with one of their greatest needs, healthy honest labour. No doubt many found kindly homes and grew in strength and maturity away from the mills of Lancashire, and the slums surrounding them. Some of them, as young as six, however, were bound to work in the fields, putting in a full day’s work for no wages, completely in the power of their new masters. The Lord Mayor exhorted the boys to be true Britons, true Christians, show your colonial brothers that Manchester boys will do honour to their native city. Looking at the apprehensive figure of the little lad on the extreme right of the front row, wearing a charitable overcoat a few sizes too large, we can only speculate as to the effect of those ‘stirring’ words from the spokesman of the Empire’s second city. They were words that continued to identify the amelioration of unemployment and poverty at home with the use of Britain’s Dominions to absorb, in the words of Malthus via Dickens, ‘the surplus population’.

Sources:

John Briggs & Ian Sellers (eds) (1973), Victorian Nonconformity. London: Edward Arnold.

John Gorman (1980), To Build Jerusalem: A Photographic Remembrance of British Working Class Life, 1875-1950. London: Scorpion Publications.

Asa Briggs (ed) (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British & Irish History. London: Penguin Books.