The recent confluence of several events, from Donald Trump’s announcement of the renaming of the US Department of Defence as the War Department to the Last Night of the Proms at the Royal Albert Hall, featuring the Kanneh-Mason family playing their favourite Welsh folk song, Ar Lán Y Mor (‘Along the Seashore’), also mine, prompted a reminiscence of a wartime poem by the Welsh language poet Waldo Williams. A native of Pembrokeshire, he wrote it in reference to the bombing attacks on Swansea. In my second year at the University of Wales, Bangor, I learnt his more famous poem Cofio (‘Remembering’) for the Welsh learners’ competition at the Inter-College Eisteddfod to be held in Aberystwyth in 1976. Unfortunately, a bad dose of the flu robbed me of my voice and kept me away from the event, but I continued to recite it from a poster with the poem on it, which adorned my various student rooms in Bangor, Cardiff, Swansea and Carmarthen over the next seven years. In 1978, I went on a ‘pilgrimage’ to St David’s along the Pembrokeshire coast path, completed in two stages, one along the southern coast, and the other from the north, from the Cardiganshire border, over the Preseli hills, where I found Pentre Ifan, pictured above, the Cromlech (ancient burial chamber) and the memorial stone to Waldo Williams (1904-72), pictured below. I camped on St. David’s Head, overlooking the sea, near the chapel dedicated to Non, David’s mother.
St David’s Cathedral, Pembrokeshire.
A few years later, I was inspired by Williams’ poetry and life story to become a teacher of Primary-age children in Llanelli. However, my limited Welsh convinced me that I should concentrate on teaching history and religious education in English secondary schools, and I moved to Lancashire in 1983. But I continued to be inspired by Williams, as well as by R.S. Thomas, whose work, written in English on the northern peninsula of Lleyn, also turned on the mystical theme of the brotherhood of man and the great Christian vision of the oneness of all mankind. Williams’ mastery of language gave an original force and freshness to his expression of ancient themes. In many ways, this demanded a comparison with Blake. Like him, Williams’ life was inextricably linked to his work. Imprisoned for his refusal, as a pacifist, to pay taxes for military purposes, he was nonetheless an intensely reserved and unassuming person.
The memorial stone to Waldo Williams on the Preseli Hills in North Pembrokeshire.
At the time I first read his poetry, I identified with it immediately, and still do, although my outward stance on these matters has changed somewhat with the complexities of the twenty-first-century conflicts, despite their ancient origins. His poetry was greatly loved by many Welsh-speakers, and, late in life, he received an Arts Council prize for it. His one volume of verse, Dail Pren, published in 1956, won him an enduring place in Welsh literature and made him an increasingly important influence on young Welsh poets from the seventies onwards, following his death in 1972. A selection of his poems was published in 1974, with translations into English. One of these was Y Tangnefeddwyr, quoted bilingually below:
Uwch yr eira, wybren ros,
Lle mae’r Abertawe’n fflam.
Cerddaf adref yn y nos,
Af dan gofio ‘nhad a ‘mam.
Gwyn eu byd tu hwnt i glyw,
Tangnefeddwyr, plant i Dduw.
Above the snow, a rose-red sky,
Where Swansea’s now aflame.
I walk home this night,
I walk home remembering father and mother,
Blessed are they, beyond all hearing,
Peacemakers, children of God.
…
The guardian-angel of poor homes
gave my father two proud pearls:
Man’s mission is to be a brother,
God’s wealth is the invisible world.
…
A good nation and a bad nation-
They taught that this was all fantasy,
But the light of Christ will bring
Freedom to all men who wish it.
Blessed are they, one day they will be heard,
Peacemakers, children of God.
And what tonight is their estate?
Tonight, when all their world’s in flames?
Truth still lives where my father is,
And mercy with my mother.
Blessed be the age that will listen to them,
Peacemakers, children of God.
Waldo Williams
Williams contrasts the simple faith of his parents with that of the rich and powerful who divide nations into ‘good’ and ‘bad’. For him, the role of Christian peacemakers is to bring the light of freedom to all people who strive for it. They do not covet peace ‘prizes’, or seek peace by preparing for war, through military might; they seek the paths of peace and mercy which lead to God’s invisible wealth. This child-like peace witness is one that I also learnt from my parents growing up, and later from brothers and sisters in Wales, Lancashire, the Midlands, the West Country, Northern Ireland and Hungary. We need to hear it again today, perhaps now more than ever.
Last Sunday, I was reminded of Waldo Williams’ poem when it was sung, set to music by Eric Jones, in a BBC Sunday Worship service from the historic Mynyddbach Chapel in North Swansea, home to the Calon Lán Centre, celebrating the seventy-fifth anniversary of the Morriston Orpheus Choir.
Glastonbury in Somerset has long been associated with the legendary Arthur and Guinevere, and it came to be identified as the Isle of Avalon (Ynys yr Afal in Welsh, ‘the Isle of the Apple’) to which Arthur was borne by three black-robed queens after his last battle with Mordred, according to the romantic literature of the late twelfth and thirteenth centuries. This association of Glastonbury with Arthur may have been why the last king of Wessex, Eadmund Ironside, was buried there, not at Winchester, in 1016, although there is no contemporary record to this effect. It later received a great boost in 1191 when a monk of the abbey, inspired by a vision, claimed to have discovered the coffin of the legendary king and queen. The coffin was said to have been inscribed with the words: Here lies the famous King Arthur, buried in the island of Avalon. When it was opened, it was found to contain the skeletons of the royal couple. The blonde tresses of Guinevere’s hair were said to be intact and still shining golden, though they crumbled to dust in the hand of the monk. This was clearly an invented story, not least because Arthur, the Welsh guerrilla leader, had not gained widespread fame by the early sixth century, when he was supposed to have lived and died. It was not until the middle of the twelfth century, with the writing of Geoffrey of Monmouth, based on the earlier Welsh ‘legendarium’ of ‘The Mabinogion‘ and the earlier ‘chronicles’ of Gildas and Nennius, that the mythological and literary figure of Arthur became ‘famous’.
The media historian, Dan Snow, has given a full summary and a dramatic reading of Gildas’s Ruin of Britain, written in the sixth century, chronicling the century before, in his recent ‘History Hit’ podcast on ‘The Real King Arthur’. Gildas identified an early Romano-British leader or chieftain as ‘Ambrosius Aurielanus’. Ambrosius is referred to as the victor of several battles against the Saxon invaders, including a final victory at ‘Badon Hill’. Gildas also refers to Arthur’s parents as wearing ‘the purple’, implying that they were wealthy Romans, perhaps even members of the imperial family. However, Gildas made no reference to Glastonbury as the place of his royal hero’s burial. Nor does Gildas ever refer to Ambrosius as ‘Arthur’. The use of that name in connection with the restoration of order in Britain had to wait until the chronicle of the Welsh monk Nennius, known as the Historia Brittonum. Nennius identified Ambrosius with Artorius, or Arthur, whom he introduces as a Dux Bellorum, a warlord. Like Gildas, he refers to several victorious battles fought by Arthur, the last of which was at Badon Hill (Mons Badonis).
Nevertheless, we have to wait until after the Norman Conquest, in 1136, for a more detailed account of Arthur’s deeds by another ‘Welsh’ monk, Geoffrey of Monmouth. He added the ancient Welsh stories of Arthur, some of them found in the Mabinogion, and others in the oral traditions of the broader legendarium . According to these stories, Arthur begins his campaigns against the Saxons from his base in Somerset, where he fought a gigantic battle with them. Before this, Geoffrey records Arthur as giving a rousing speech promising his soldiers absolution for their sins if they die ‘doing God’s work’. In this, Geoffrey seems to have been influenced by the crusading spirit of his age. Geoffrey describes Arthur as wearing a leather jerkin, ‘worthy of so great a king’, and putting on a golden helmet with a crest carved in the shape of a dragon. He also carries a circular shield called ‘Prydwen’, on which there is painted a likeness of the Virgin Mary. His sword was named ‘Caliban’, (in later literature ‘Excalibur’), which was forged on the Isle of Avalon.
The television historian, Michael Wood, in his series on Heroes and Myths, began his search for the magical sword, Excalibur, not on the Isle of Avalon, but on a canalside in an industrial suburb of Oxford, amid the ruins of a twelfth-century Abbey on another island, to the south of the city. It was there, in 1129, that Geoffrey created, or reshaped, the myth of Arthur, the once and future king. There, Geoffrey fashioned all the essential elements of the myth, including Excalibur. In the Bronze Age, from about a thousand BC, and on into the early medieval period, swords were cast in bronze in a stone mould, no doubt the origin of the sword in the stone element in Arthurian mythology.
The Seal of Henry II
According to Geoffrey of Monmouth, Arthur’s last resting place was the Isle of Avalon, which the Saxons later named Glastonbury. In the late twelfth century, the first Plantagenet king of England, Henry II, heir to an extensive European ‘Angevin’ empire, decided to prove that Arthur was dead and could never again provide a rallying cry for the rebellious Welsh. He ordered a ‘dig’ at Glastonbury, which discovered, at a depth of sixteen feet, the hollowed oak coffin supposedly containing the remains of Arthur and Guinevere, bearing an inscription in Latin declaring them to be the remains of the famous King Arthur and his queen.
Of course, Arthur only became ‘famous’ in the twelfth century, as a result of the legends about him. Given a fine new tomb in Glastonbury, Arthur became a huge new ‘draw’ for pilgrims. Henry II’s French wife, Eleanor of Aquitaine, hired courtly poets to write new tales about Arthur and Guinevere, and their knights, giving rise to the chivalric elements in the romantic literature, including the Round Table and the Holy Grail, the latter already connected to Glastonbury through the legends of Joseph of Arimathea. In turn, these stories renewed the spiritual values of the Glastonbury mythology.
It wasin Angevin Brittany and France that romantic writers made the tales of Arthur into a focus for these spiritual values of the ageof chivalry.To help them find this focus, they invented the purely mythological elements of the Grail and the Round Table. Thefirst was an invention of Chrétien de Troyes, and developed by the poets who followed him, a symbol of a virtue which can never be possessed, but for which the faithful must still strive, a symbol of the human ‘quest’ itself. At Winchester, thought to be Arthur’s Camelot in the Middle Ages, there is a Round Table, the ultimate symbol of equality among men of power. It was made for Edward I in 1290, after he’d conquered Wales and reburied the bones of Arthur and Guinevere in a marble tomb in Glastonbury. It was repainted by Henry Tudor (VIII) two hundred years later, in 1516, to impress the Holy Roman Emperor, Charles V, on a visit to Britain. Henry wanted to succeed the Habsburg monarch as emperor, so Arthur was repainted at the centre of the table with the King’s likeness.
So, Geoffrey of Monmouth’s prophecy had come true. The Tudors were a Welsh family, originally from Pembroke and Gwynedd, and had therefore restored the old monarchy of Britain. The myth of Arthur became a parable of Britain, a dream of what the country had been and of what it could become once more. Thomas Malory recorded these beliefs in his poem Morte d’Arthur. But when Henry fell out with the Pope and the emperor twenty years later over his divorce from Catherine of Aragon, he ordered the demolition of England’s European ‘Roman Catholic’ culture. Henry and his chancellor, Thomas Cromwell, dissolved and destroyed the monasteries, including that of Glastonbury. The supposed bones of Arthur and Guinevere were removed from their black marble tomb forever.
However, the Arthurian myth did not disappear. The British still needed their myths of identity and of state. In the nineteenth century, the Arthur story was revived once again with Pugin’s Gothic creation of the Houses of Parliament, and Queen Victoria and her Windsor successors traced their ancestry to Cymbeline and the ancient kings of Britain, whose lives had been chronicled by Geoffrey of Monmouth. As late as 1953, in preparing for the coronation of the young Queen Elizabeth II, the monarchy brushed off complaints from the Papacy about these claims. However, in any case, few of these tales had any foundation in authenticated historical events.
Dan Snow has argued that Arthur is the repeating national myth of the British. As it did in the twelfth century, it is a trope or legendarium that transcends the narrow confines of British, Welsh, Breton and English identities, both ancient and modern. Created by the geography of the Western Isles, the recurring island myth is one of how a leader emerges to fight against the invasion of massed continentalforces, sometimes winning, sometimes not, as seen in the battles against the Danish and Norman conquerors. So Arthur is Caradoc, Boudicca, Ambrosius, Cerdic, Alfred the Great, Eadmund Ironside, Elizabeth Tudor, Winston Churchill… These heroes all share characteristics which are particular to the British as island people. And Arthur is not dead but sleeping on the Isle of Avalon, Glastonbury, waiting to return. Metaphorically, that may also be true. The British island story is therefore not finished, and, in a chaotic and seemingly hopeless world, it may yet produce a heroic force of resistance to the tyrannical external forces threatening conquest and subjugation. In that sense, the Glastonbury myths represent a trope of British resistance to tyrannical power, one which is continually revived throughout the histories of the peoples of the islands.
South Somerset, Dorset and Devon. Source: Susan Hill (see below).
Long before its relatively recent appropriation as the site of a major music festival, Glastonbury in Somerset was intimately connected with the two linked legends of Joseph of Arimathea and King Arthur. Both were fully recorded in written form for the first time in the twelfth century, but they drew on oral traditions of much greater antiquity. According to the first of these, Joseph of Arimathea was sent by the Apostle Philip with a band of missionaries to Britain in AD 36. Joseph’s band was said to have brought the Christian faith with them, together with the communal cup used by Christ during the Last Supper.
Glastonbury Tor, Somerset. A natural mound carved with a spiral path of ascent around it, which some have said was a ritual path of initiation going back to the Bronze Age. Source: William Anderson and Clive Hicks (see below).
Landing in Cornwall (reportedly at St Just-in-Roseland), they travelled towards Glastonbury and first sojourned at a hill called Wearyall. There, as the legend states, Joseph, weary from his travel, stopped to rest, thrusting his hawthorn staff into the ground where it immediately took root and, in a short time, blossomed. It is known as the ‘Holy Thorn’. From ancient times, it has been referred to as a phenomenon of nature, being the only thorn tree in the world to bloom at Christmas time as well as in Spring. It endured through the centuries as a perpetual, living monument to the landing of the saintly, ‘lost disciples’ of Christ.
The Glastonbury Thorn in flower. This branch is on one of several trees descending from the original, cut down during the Interregnum, 1649-60, when it was cut down by a fanatical puritan, at a time when desecration of holy places by the bigoted was in operation.
The sacred phenomenon did not die. Its scion, already planted, lived to thrive and bloom as had the mother thorn tree, its snow-white blossoms spreading outwards like a beacon amid the winter gloom. Joseph settled on the present site of the abbey ruins of Glastonbury and built there the first Christian church in Britain, made of wattle and daub. This vetusta ecclesia, or ‘Ancient Church’, was said to have existed up to the great fire of 1184, when it was destroyed. In another version of the legend preserved amongst West Country miners, Joseph had been to Glastonbury before, with the young Jesus as his apprentice, who had built a simple shrine in honour of his mother. William Blake drew on the legend for his preface to his last poem, Milton, written in 1804, and which, a century later, became a popular national hymn, if not a second national anthem, set to Hubert Parry’s tune, Jerusalem:
And did those feet in ancient time
Walk upon England’s mountains green?
And was the holy Lamb of God
On England’s pleasant pastures seen?
And did the countenance divine
Shine forth upon our clouded hills?
And was Jerusalem builded here
Among those dark satanic mills?
Underneath the four verses which make up the hymn, Blake wrote ‘Would to God that all the Lord’s people were prophets’, and gave the biblical source from which the quotation comes: Numbers 11.29. But the imagery of the four verses is complex. Some of it is borrowed from the Bible, for instance, the chariots of fire, taken from 2 Kings 2: v. 11, but much is of Blake’s own invention. In suggesting that Jesus may have set foot in England, Blake was resurrecting the old legend which told of Christ’s visit as a young man with Joseph of Arimathea.
William Blake was born in London in 1757, but was familiar with the stories associated with Glastonbury and steeped in its ancient history. The story that found its way into his hymn told of Joseph as a metals merchant who took Jesus with him to Cornwall and the West Country in a time before England even existed, historically. There is also a verse from Blake’s long poem Jerusalem, which dates back to 1804, echoing the theme of the Lamb of God walking upon our meadows green. He expressed his heartfelt prayers for this, the Holiest Ground on Earth. In the poem, Jerusalem represents the ideal life of freedom and is a call to the values of social justice, which were to build a new Jerusalem in Britain following the First World War. In 1916, the Poet Laureate Robert Bridges included And did those feet in a patriotic anthology entitled The Spirit of Man.
In the traditions of Cornwall, Devon, Somerset, Wiltshire and Wales, there were longstanding claims that the teenage boy Jesus accompanied Joseph of Arimathea on a visit to Britain. According to the Talmud, Joseph was the younger brother of Mary’s father and therefore a great maternal uncle to Jesus. It is obvious from the synoptic gospels that Mary’s husband, also Joseph, the Carpenter of Nazareth, died when Jesus was young, possibly still a teenager, soon after his last appearance in the gospels on the family’s visit to the Temple in Jerusalem, when Jesus was about twelve. Under Jewish Law, such a circumstance automatically called for the next male kin of the husband to be appointed legal guardian to the family.
Ancient Historical tradition reports Jesus as a boy, frequently in the company of his great-uncle at the time of subsequent religious festivals in Judea, and that he made voyages to Britain in Joseph’s ships. Cornish traditions, in particular, abound with this testimony, and numerous ancient landmarks bear Hebrew names thought to record such visits. Although it is commonly taught that Jesus’s family was from humble origins, Joseph of Arimathea was both a property owner and a wealthy merchant at the time of Jesus’ ministry. However, when he later took up his own mission, he would have likely forsaken his material wealth.
Source: Dowley (see below).
The record shows that Joseph frequently journeyed to Gaul (known as ‘Galatia’ in Paul’s letters) to confer with the disciples there, particularly with the apostle Philip, who had arrived at Marseilles ahead of Joseph, together with ‘others’ among the early followers of ‘the Way’, men and women escaping persecution in Judea and Rome. There is a wealth of testimony asserting his commission in Gaul, all of which state that he received and consecrated Joseph, prior to his appointment as Apostle to Britain and his embarkation at Marseilles. Joseph himself is thought to have had a long association with the British through his tin mining interests in Cornwall and the West. The ancient port on the Mediterranean was the chief port of call for those transporting lead and tin from Britain. It is reputed to be the oldest city in France and its oldest seaport. Consequently, the comings and goings of Joseph’s ships would have kept them up to date with happenings throughout the Mediterranean world, including Gaul. Long before Joseph arrived on his mission to Britain, the scandal of the cross was well known to them and had caused grave concerns to the Druidic faith. That faith prepared the way for the spread of primitive Christianity in both Gaul and Britain.
Source: Dowley.
The emperors Augustus, Tiberius, Claudius and Diocletian made acceptance of both Druidism and Christianity a capital offence, punishable by death. The ancient ‘Cymry’ (Welsh) were bonded in the patriarchal faith even before they arrived in ‘Prydain’. Organised by Huw Gadarn, the faith took on the name of ‘Druid’, derived from the Celtic word for the oak tree. The prelates of the religion recognised the death of Jesus Christ as the fulfilment of their prophecy of vicarious atonement. The Roman persecutions bonded the older monotheistic faith to the new Judaistic religion of ‘the Way’.
‘The Way’, as the primitive Christian religion was known in its early centuries, found a natural haven in Gaul and its early apostolic missionaries, including Philip and Paul, found an even safer refuge in ‘the furthest reaches of the West’ of the known world, i.e. Prydain, from the Greek ‘Pretani’, or Britannia, in Latin, as it became following the Roman invasions. Up until the Claudian conquest (AD 43), the ‘British Isles’ were the only free territories in ‘southern’ Europe. Gaul had been subjected to the Roman Reich‘s persecution long before its Caesars turned their attention to the western offshore islands. It was the constant aid given to their Gaulish brethren by the Druidic warriors which eventually led to the successful conquest.
Source: Dowley (see below)
Julius Caesar’s expeditionary force of 55 BC, designed to punish Britons for thwarting his arms in Gaul, failed to establish a foothold in Britain beyond a trading post on the south coast, and it was not until the reign of Hadrian in AD 120 that Britannia was fully incorporated as a Roman dominion by a treaty through which the British ‘kings’ retained their ancestral lands, laws and rights, while accepting the nucleus of a Roman occupying legion for the defence of the ‘province’. Gaul, by contrast, was destined to become the continental crossroads of the empire.
Philip was referred to in the early Gallic church as the Apostle of Gaul, though it might be more correct to state that while he was in Gaul, he was accepted as the head of the Gallic Christian Church. The biblical and secular records show that he did not remain constantly in Gaul. Many of the early writers report that he was in Gaul in AD 65, the year in which he consecrated Joseph for the third time (the first was claimed to be in AD 36). The Epistle to the Galatians was addressed, as the ancient writers claimed, to the inhabitants of Gaul, and not to the small colony of Gauls in Asia Minor known at the time, at least to the early apostles, as ‘Galatia’. Rev. Lionel Smithett Lewis, an early twentieth-century Vicar of Glastonbury, considered the foremost church historian of his times, wrote of how Edouard de Bazelaire traced the movements of St. Paul in about AD 63 along the Aurelian Way from Rome to Arles in southern Gaul. Lewis also stated:
All this goes to prove that Gaul was known as Galatia, and their chronicling St. Paul’s and his companions’ journey does not in the least mean that they deny St Philip’s. … the Churches of Vienne and Mayence in Gaul claim Crescens as their founder. … Galatia in II Timothy iv: 10, means Gaul and not its colony in Galatia in Asia… St. Philip preached to the Gauls, and not to the Galatians in Asia.
Lewis, St. Joseph of Arimathea at Glastonbury,pp. 75-76.
The Judean Mission to Glastonbury:
Biblical tradition, supported by secular records, brought Philip to Gaul, from where he sent Joseph to Britain. The Norman chronicler, William of Malmesbury, quoting Freculphus, called Joseph Philip’s “dearest friend”, suggesting that they must have been in close association. However, Philip did not die in Gaul, but in Hierapolis, a city of Phrygia, where he was crucified at the advanced age of eighty-seven. Meanwhile, for Joseph, the way from Marseilles to Britannia lay up the Rhone Valley to Morlaix in Brittany and from there across the Channel to Cornwall. The route must have been well known to Joseph as one regularly taken by fellow traders, seeking ore. From Cornwall, an ancient road led to the lead mines of the Mendips, remains of which still exist, passing close to Glastonbury.
Glastonbury, South Somerset and Dorset.
To most people, Joseph of Arimathea is passingly remembered as the rich man who kindly offered his private sepulchre for the burial of Christ. Beyond that, we find references in the gospels to him as ‘Decurio’, a common term employed by the Romans to designate an official in charge of metal mines. It indicated that he held a prominent position in the Roman administration as a minister of mines. Tin was the chief metal for the making of alloys and was in great demand by the empire-building Romans. Many historians have claimed that Joseph’s wealth and influence were the result of his vast holdings in the ancient tin mines of Britain.
The bulk of the first century’s supplies of tin and lead were mined in Cornwall and Somerset. The tin was smelted into ingots and exported throughout the known ‘civilised’ world. Joseph was reported as owning one of the largest merchant shipping fleets of the time, traversing the world’s sea lanes in the transportation of the precious metal. In particular, the trade between Cornwall and Phoenicia was frequently referred to by classical writers and described at considerable length by Diodorus Siculus as well as by Julius Caesar.
The art of enamelling was identified with the Ancient Britons, just as was the production of tin. They were so skilled in this craft that relics in the British Museum and the Glastonbury Museum, such as the famous Glastonbury bowl, over two thousand years old, and the Desborough mirror, are as admirable as the day they were made. They are magnificent examples of “La Téne” art, as the Celtic design is named, their geometric beauty and excellence being beyond the ability of modern craftsmen to duplicate. The same can be said of the finds from the Sutton Hoo ship burial, emphasising the continuity of Celtic design into the enamelling of the post-Roman and early medieval periods, also on display at the British Museum. Roman testimony states that captive Britons taught the Romans the craft of enamelling. The Anglo-Saxon enamellers also learnt the craft from the Romano-British, among whom they settled in the sixth century. Modern ethnographers and historical linguists have charted the earlier Celtic migrations from their ancient homelands in eastern Europe to their final destinations in Gaul and Britain.
Proof of British superiority in the tin industry and its affluent worldwide trade was referred to by Herodotus as early as BC 450, when the islands were known as the Cassiterides, meaning The Tin Islands. This reference was followed by several others, each of which explained the paths of transportation from Britain overland and by sea to the various Mediterranean ports. The tin that garnished the Palace of Solomon in BC 1005 was mined and smelted into ingots in Cornwall and thence shipped by the Phoenicians to Palestine, where it supplied the adornment to his temple. The association of Joseph of Arimathea with the tin industry in Cornwall has been echoed down the centuries in fragments of poems and miners’ songs making reference to Joseph, such as ‘Joseph was a tin man’ and ‘Joseph was in the tin trade.’
Nevertheless, for a Jew to have held such a high rank of Nobilis Decurio in the Roman Empire was somewhat rare. We also know that he was a prominent member of the Sanhedrin, the Jewish Council in Judea that ruled over Roman Jewry. Everything known of him suggests that he was an affluent person of importance and influence within both the Jewish and Roman hierarchies. But his story is also an important chapter in the story of Britain, since he became known as the Apostle of Britain, establishing its first church at Glastonbury. From this base, Joseph is said to have frequently journeyed to Gaul, to Marseilles and Arles, to confer with the exiled disciples there, led by Philip. As George B. Jowett wrote in his 1961 book, The Drama of the Lost Disciples, from this apostolic connection grew the seeds of organised Christianity in ‘the West’:
Thus began the epochal drama that was to change imperial destiny and lead the peoples of the world to a better way of life. Yet, before this was to be fully achieved, millions were to wade their way through unbelievable tragedy, defying tyranny in its basest and most terrifying form, wholesale massacre and fiendish torture, suffering the brutalities of the Colisseum, the horrors of the fetid prison… and the dreadful scourging wars in which the British were to make the most colossal sacrifice in blood and life known to history.
Jowett (1961), p. 62.
The Colosseum in Rome, a place of martyrdom and torture for many early Christians. Source: Dowley (see below).
Arviragus appears in the first-century legends of early British kings as a British opponent of the Romans. Geoffrey of Monmouth described him as the king of the Silures of Britain, son of King Cymbeline (Cunobel), the brother of Guiderius and cousin of the legendary warrior-patriot, Caradoc (Caractacus). According to Geoffrey, Cymbeline gave up the helm of state to Guiderius, but when he refused to keep paying the tribute demanded by the Romans, Claudius, who had been raised to the empire, invaded the island. His commander-in-chief, named Levis Hamo in the Cymric tongue, which he had learnt, tricked Guiderius and the Britons into an attack on the Roman army, which was a pyrrhic victory, because Hamo then assassinated Guiderius.
Arviragus, pretending to be his brother, cheered on the British army and defeated the Romans in a further open battle. Hamo slipped away into the forest, and Claudius fled to his ships on the south coast. Arviragus was too quick for Hamo, who was unable to board the ships and was killed. Claudius attacked Caerperis (Porchester), casting down its walls and pursuing Arviragus to Winton, besieging the royal town. Arviragus sallied out to fight, but Claudius offered a truce, which the British king was persuaded to accept by his own courtiers. By this, Claudius gave his daughter in marriage to Arviragus, and the British king agreed that Britain would become a fiefdom of the empire, a province with Gloucester as its capital.
Several centuries after Joseph’s time, St Augustine confirmed the tradition of the wattle and daub altar in a letter to Gregory, Epistolae ad Gregoriam Papam, stating that the shrine still existed on the site. Consequently, we may believe that it was also there when Joseph and his twelve companions arrived in Glastonbury to establish their mission. With the chartered gift of land to the Josephian Mission, Arviragus promised his protection. In return, the cross, as the Christian symbol of Royal heraldry, was given to Arviragus by Joseph and the cross on the shield became the special symbol of the sovereigns of Britain centuries before its associations with the Crusades, England and St. George. Arviragus carried the banner of the Cross through the most bitterly fought battles between the Britons and the Romans. However, his fame was overshadowed by Caractacus, or Caradoc. Despite this, Arviragus was the most powerful representative of the royal house of the Silures and the most famous Christian warrior in Romano-British history.
Arviragus’s reception of St. Joseph suggests a previous acquaintance, and testimony from the Early Fathers from various branches of the Church shows that Glastonbury was an early Christian site. The Magna Glastonensis Tabula was a manuscript quoted by John of Glastonbury and William of Malmesbury. It records that Philip sent Joseph, his son, and ten other disciples, and ultimately that one hundred and sixty were sent to Britain in groups at various intervals by Philip to serve Joseph in his evangelistic mission. Arviragus’s grandson, King Lucius, succeeded him and was buried at Gloucester in AD 156. He renewed and enlarged the charter with the Glastonbury Christian mission, and early in his reign, he was baptised at Winchester by his uncle, Timotheus, who also proclaimed him ‘Defender of the Faith’. Geoffrey informs us that, even before King Lucius formally accepted Christianity, a ‘Papal’ legation had returned to Britain, …
… with a passing great company of others, by the teaching of whom the nation of the British was in a brief space established in the Christian faith.
Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Histories of the Kings of Britain, 1912 edn., Book IV, Chapter XX, p. 74.
The royal territories of the Silures were divided into two. Arviragus ruled over the southern part of what later became England, including Somerset, and Caradoc ruled over Cambria, the region which became (south) Wales. Each was king in his royal domain, but in time of war, they combined forces under a ‘Pendragon’ or Commander-in-Chief. When Caradoc was taken captive to Rome, Arviragus took over from him as Pendragon, conducting a war of resistance against the Empire for decades in Britain, as recorded by Tacitus, the Roman historian, in his Annals of the Conquest. (bk. 5, ch. 28). Another Roman writer, Juvenal, indicated how greatly the Romans feared Arviragus, and that no better news could be received at Rome than the fall of the Royal Christian Silurian. Such was the invincible spirit of the Silures that they formed a living wall around the sacred boundaries of Avalon in Arviragus’s domain. No Roman army ever pierced its perimeter, and Roman writers referred to it as ‘territory inaccessible to the Roman where Christ is taught’. Behind the living wall of warriors, Joseph and his companions were safe from persecution, free to teach and preach the Christian faith from its first planting on the Sacred Isle.
Geoffrey of Monmouth’s primary source for this official dating of the conversion of Britain to ‘Roman’ Christianity was the British monk, Gildas’s sixth-century book concerning the victories over the invading Saxons of Ambrosius Aurelianus (his name for Arthur), which Geoffrey chooses not to quote extensively. Nevertheless, a “Life” of Gildas was written by Caradoc of Llancarfan, a friend of Geoffrey of Monmouth and his Anglo-Norman patrons. This is an entirely fictional account intended to associate Gildas with Glastonbury Abbey and with King Arthur. Arthur kills Gildas’s brother Hueil, which causes enmity between them for a time. Hueil’s enmity with Arthur is also mentioned in the later Welsh prose tale Culhwch and Olwen, written around 1100. Gildas is best known for his polemic De Excidio et Conquestu Britanniae, written in c. 490, which recounts the sub-Roman history of Britain, and which is the only substantial source for the history of this period written by a near-contemporary Briton, although it is not intended to be an objective chronicle. At the beginning of Book V of his Histories, Geoffrey tells us more about the process of conversion:
Meanwhile, King Lucius the Glorious, when he saw how the worship of the true faith had been magnified in his kingdom, did rejoice with exceeding great joy, and converted the lands and revenues which formerly did belong unto the temples and idols unto a better use, did by grant allow them to be still held by the churches of the faithful. And for that it seemed to him he ought to show them yet greater honour, he did increase them with broader fields and fair dwelling-houses, and confirmed their liberties by privileges of all kinds.
Geoffrey of Monmouth, Histories(1912), p. 75.
From a historical perspective, the suggestion that the teenage Jesus visited Glastonbury with Joseph seems no more than a myth. Still, it seems entirely possible that Glastonbury received the first Christian Mission in Britain. William of Malmesbury, a twelfth-century monk from Malmesbury Abbey in Wiltshire and author of various authoritative chronicles, wrote, from his research in the library of Glastonbury Abbey, De Antiquitate Glastoniensis Ecclesiae, the primary Christian source about Glastonbury. He records a second-century foundation of Christianity in Britain, but cautiously entertains the possibility that when the Bishop of Rome’s emissaries arrived at Glastonbury, they discovered an already established church, a wattle-and-daub structure, set amongst a dozen huts or cells, later a great draw for pilgrims and known as the Old Church. At about the same time, other chroniclers began to build on Glastonbury’s earlier reputation as a sacred burial ground or kingdom of the Underworld.
The Arthurian Mythology:
An illustration accompanying the ninth-century Nennius’ Annals of Wales.
Geoffrey of Monmouth first mentioned Avalon as King Arthur’s burial site in his Historia Regum Britanniae:
Arthur himself, our renowned King, was mortally wounded and was carried off to the Isle of Avalon, so that his wounds might be attended to.
By the time Geoffrey was writing, the Cambro-Norman chronicler, Giraldus Cambriensis, had already identified ‘insula Avallonia’ with Glastonbury as Arthur’s resting place. With their wholly compatible codes, Christian and Arthurian mythologies were inseparable to begin with, but when the Arthurian stories obtained greater and more widespread popularity by the end of the twelfth century and became more important than the ethics they were supposed to represent, tensions arose. Robert de Boron’s thirteenth century romance, Joseph d’Aramathie cast Joseph, the rich disciple who obtained permission from Pilate to remove Christ’s body to his own tomb, as the earliest founder of Christianity in Britain. In the context of William of Malmesbury’s work, this was an acceptable idea to the monks at Glastonbury, but de Boron also had Joseph bring with him the Cup of the Last Supper in which he had caught the blood of the crucified Christ. This identified the Glastonbury Chalice as the Holy Grail and raised the standing of the great totem of Arthurian myth to the most exalted heights. When the word spread that the Grail had been found in a stony nook beneath the waters of the Chalice Well, the stream of pilgrims became a flood. It was then, in 1190-91, that, rather than tempering the rumours, the monks declared they had turned up the bodies of Arthur and Guenevere from sixteen foot underground.
Malory’s more romantic account in Le Morte D’Arthur came more than two centuries later, but he brilliantly formalised the relationship of the myth to the landscape:
Then Sir Bedevere took the king upon his back, and so went with him to that waterside, even fast by the bank, hoved a little barge with many fair ladies in it, and among them all was a queen, and they all had black hoods, and they all had black hoods, and they all wept and shrieked when they saw King Arthur.
‘Now put me into the barge,’ said the king.
And so he did softly; and there rerceived him three queens with great mourning; and so they set them down, and in one of their laps King Arthur laid his head. …
… And so then they rowed from the land and St Bedevere beheld all those ladies go from him.
Then Sir Bedevere cried, ‘Ah my lord Arthur, what shall become of me, now ye go from me and leave me here alone among mine enemies?’
‘Comfort thyself,’ said the king, ‘and do as well as thou mayest, for in me is no trust for to trust in; for I will into the vale of Avilon to heal me of my grevious wound: and if thou never hear more of me, pray for my soul… ‘
Malory leaves Sir Bedevere with the hermit ‘in a chapel beside Glastonbury’ with Arthur’s tomb ‘new graven … and so they lived in their prayers, and fastings, and great abstinence.’
In the 1580s, the intrepid Queen Elizabeth Tudor, direct descendant of Arviragus and Lucius, made the Reformation declaration, when challenging the authority of the combined forces of France, Spain and Rome, that Britain’s priority in the Christian Church stemmed not from Papal authority, but from the ancient oath of the British King Lucius. As her ancestors had done, she declared that only Christ was the Head of the Church, and ever since, on their coronation, the sovereigns of Great Britain (and sometimes Ireland) had taken this oath. In 1953, the Roman Church petitioned for this oath to be omitted from the coronation of Elizabeth II, but this was refused by ‘the establishment’ with the statement that the United Kingdom was the one true defender of the Christian cause in Britain, with Christ as its Head.
Joseph was said to have brought the Holy Grail with him to Glastonbury and to have buried it in an unknown place near his first settlement there, thus connecting it with the legend of King Arthur and his knights searching for it. It is thought to be marked by the site of the Chalice Well at the foot of the Tor. Glastonbury was therefore identified as the ancient Isle of Avalon, the island of apples (‘apple’ being ‘afal’ or ‘aval’ in Cymric) to which Arthur was borne in the legend following his last battle with Mordred. This association of Glastonbury with Arthur received a boost in 1191 when a monk at the abbey, inspired by a vision, claimed to have discovered the tomb of Arthur and Guenevere. The coffin bore on it the inscription:
‘Here lies the famous King Arthur buried in the Island of Avalon.’
When it was opened, it was found to contain the skeletons of the king and his consort. The still blonde tresses of Guenevere’s hair apparently crumbled in the hand of the monk. It is not surprising that Glastonbury should be associated with such powerful legends, located as it is on the Somerset Levels, much of which was under the Severn estuary until drained by Dutch engineers in the later seventeenth century. Dr John Dee, the Welsh mathematician and astrologer to Elizabeth I, developed the theory that the landscape was part of the immense depiction of the twelve signs of the zodiac formed by rising ground, streams, ancient roads and field boundaries. Long before the eighteenth century, when ditches, or rhynes, were dug, enclosing fields and organising better drainage. The area developed its own culture, the willows along the flowery edges of the rhynes supporting a thriving basket-making industry.
The extraordariness of Glastonbury Tor begins with its physical characteristics, its visibility for miles around, the smooth greeness and shape of the mound, which makes it suspiciously man-made, like a Norman ‘motte’, the narrow terraces that circle the summit which appear to form a convoluted maze with the ruin of St Michael’s Church at its core, and the quality of the spring that flows fom its flank down to the Chalice Well, crystal clear water trailing red as blood due to the iron ore in its course. In fact, the hill is composed of clays and limestones in horizontal strata that have gradually eroded. The phenomenon of red water is the oxidation of the naturally high iron content that occurs upon contact with air. But this does not challenge the mystical spirit of the place that has been impressive for thousands of years in a variety of cultures.
Originally surrounded by marsh and water, the four-hundred-foot Tor with Chalice Hill and the site of the abbey and town all formed a single island, Avalon, on the low, flat Somerset plain. Seen across ‘the Levels’ on a misty day or evening, they still give the appearance of insularity. The Levels stretch westwards towards Bridgwater Bay, being liable to flooding in winter from the Axe, Brue and Parrett rivers. It has been suggested that the Celtic Christian monks, known as Culdees, who first founded a settlement here were inspired to make this ancient holy place a hallowed site of the new faith. It has also suggested that the Tor itself, a strange cone now crowned by the tower of the medieval church of St Michael, was, from the Bronze Age or even earlier, a site of initiation, a three-dimensional maze traced by a spiral path around its mound.
Within a mile of the Sacred Isle of Avalon was another smaller island known as Ynys Wytren, or Glass Island, a name with a claim to be derived from the still, pure waters that once surrounded it when much of the ‘Somerset Levels’ were almost permanently under water. In Saxon times, the water receded in the Summer to reveal a ‘summer pasture’, giving the name ‘somer saete’ to the whole county. Excavations have also revealed that it was once a busy site for the glass industry, for which the ancient Britons were famous, alongside their enamelling and metalworking. Later, the Saxons named it Glastonbury, though the word ‘Glas’ in Welsh means ‘blue’, which may have been a reference to the incoming seawater from the Severn estuary. Today, the western boundary of the lowland area is known as ‘the Levels’ and the eastern flood plains as the Moors. Behind the clay banks of the Levels, tides rise many feet higher than the Moors, and even as late as 1607, after considerable engineering works first by the Romans and then throughout the Middle Ages, sea water could still come in as far as Glastonbury itself.
During Anglo-Saxon times, some of the ‘isles’ ceased to exist as the monks at Glastonbury Abbey drained much of the land around them, creating a muddy salt plain, though it is still, today, below sea level, and swampy in wet weather. Yet today, as pilgrims realise that they are standing in the centre of the twelve hallowed hides of land which the Silurian prince deeded to St. Joseph and his twelve companions, it is impossible for them not to feel moved by the beauty of the scene in what is still, for most of the year at least, the quiet little English town, encircled by verdant meadows, all part of the 1,920 acres of early Christendom. At the same time, it is difficult for them to fully comprehend that they are treading on the same holy ground where the early saints trod and communed together. There is good evidence to suggest that they may have included Aristobulus, a successor to Joseph as apostle to the Britons.
The magnificent ruins of Glastonbury Abbey are the remains of the beautiful church that was erected over the altar of the wattle-and-daub shrine, thatched with reeds from the wetlands below, as was the custom of the time. Wattle was the common building material of the ancient Britons, as well as the Saxons who followed them to the area, and they used it in the construction of their homes, halls, and churches. Therefore, Joseph and his fellow disciples did not employ unusual materials, but only those which were then of common order. A former Bishop of Bristol commented on excavations at nearby Godney Marsh, discovered by Arthur Bulleid in 1892 and excavated over the following fifteen years. Another was unearthed at Mere. Settlers were first drawn there in pre-Celtic times, and not just by the abundant stocks of fish and fowl. Ever since the discoveries, there has been speculation about the name ‘Glass Island’. Nature’s glass, quartz stone, was being used in Bronze Age tombs and as ceremonially significant pillars in stone circles, such as at Boscawen (Penrith) in Cornwall and places of ritual sacrifice.
The ‘Lake Village’ has been described as “the best preserved prehistoric village ever found in the United Kingdom”. The site covered an area of 400 feet (122 m) north to south by 300 feet (91 m) east to west. It was first constructed 250 B.C. by laying down timber and clay. Wooden houses and barns were then built on the clay base and occupied by up to two hundred people at any time until the village was abandoned around 50 B.C. Artefacts uncovered include wooden and metal objects, many of which are now on display at The Tribunal in Glastonbury High Street and in the Museum of Somerset in Taunton. Bishop Brown observed that:
Wattlework is a very perishable material, and of all things of the kind, the least likely is that we in the nineteenth century … discover at Glastonbury an almost endless amount of British wattle work. Yet this is exactly what happened. In the low ground, now occupying the place of the impenetrable marshes which gave the name of the Isle of Avalon to the higher ground, the eye of the local antiquary had long marked a mass of dome-shaped hillocks, some of them of a very considerable diameter, and about seventy in number, clustered together in what is now a large field, a mile and a quarter from Glastonbury. …
The hillocks proved to be the ramains of British houses burned by fire. They were set on ground made solid in the midst of waters, with causeways revetted with wattle work … all over. … The wattle when first uncovered is as good to all appearances as the day it was made. The houses of the Britons at Glastonbury … and their church were made of wattles.
Rev. G. F. Brown,The Church in These Islands before Augustine.
Soon after Joseph and his company had settled in Avalon, they began, painstakingly, to construct their wattle church. It was reported as being sixty feet in length and twenty-six feet wide, following the pattern of the Tabernacle in Jerusalem, still standing at the time of the Roman destruction of it in AD 70. St. Paulinus had the wattle church encased in local lead from the Mendips in AD 630 and, thus protected from dissolution, it remained intact until 1184, when the whole abbey was destroyed by fire. By then, the cross-shaped pattern of the wattle church at Glastonbury had become the model employed in the construction of all the early British churches built in Roman, Anglo-Saxon and early medieval times. But its first function was to provide sanctuary for the refugees from the persecution of the Sanhedrin and pagan Rome. Protected by the armed might of the Silures, the companions of the Apostle of Britain began to teach Christ crucified in the sunlit combes and vales of the Western islands of Britain.
Speculation that Glastonbury was a seat of the Old Religion (Druidism) or a sacred burial site was fuelled by legend. St Collen was an early Celtic Christian settler who built his cell at Glastonbury and upset the settled people there by denying that the Tor was the entrance to the Underworld, the domain of Gwyn ap Nudd. When the hermit was introduced to it, as the folk story went, a fine castle within the hill, he sprinkled holy water on it so that it disappeared. John Cowper Powys explained:
In the ethnic atmosphere about these two, as they stood there, quivered the immemorial Mystery of Glastonbury. Christians had one name for this Power, the ancient heathen inhabitants of this place had another, and a quite different one. Everyone who came to this spot seemed to draw something from it, attracted by a magnetism too powerful for anyone to resist, but as different people approached it changed its chemistry, though not its essence, by their own identity, so that upon none of them it had the same psychic effect. … Older than Christianity, older than the Druids, older than the gods of Norsemen or Romans, older than the gods of the neolithic men, this many-named Mystery had been handed down to subsequent generations…
John Cowper Powys, A Glastobury Romance.
Behind the church rose the great Tor, a Druidic centre for a Gorsedd, a High Circle of Worship, a hand-piled mound of earth with terraces that wind around the hill to its summit. On these eminences, the Druids had their astronomical observatories from which, like the sages of Persia, they studied the heavens and the movements of the stars and their relationships to ancient prophecies. The merging of the Celtic Druidic traditions with early Christianity had already become an accepted process, peacefully performed. Archaeological evidence has also demonstrated that there was no bitter opposition between the Druidic priests and the Christian apostles. Nowhere in the Celtic and Cymric records is there any mention of antagonism between the two faiths. The Archdruids recognised that the old order was fulfilled according to prophecy, and that with the advent of the Messiah, Christ, and his atonement, the new dispensation had arrived. In the light of the understanding reached between them and the Judean refugees, their common resistance to pagan Roman persecution bound the two religions together.
The Augustinian mission of AD 596, sent by the Roman prelate Gregory, later erroneously referred to as a ‘Pope’, was actually part of the first attempt to introduce Roman Christianity to Britain. Even the earliest Vatican historians referred to St. Joseph as the first Apostle of Britain and the first to introduce Christian teachings to the Islands. Subsequent popes have also substantiated this statement. St Paul was actually the first to deliver the Roman Christian message to Britain, at first through his appointed apostle, Aristobulus. St Joseph was not sent from Rome, but went directly from Palestine, via Marseilles, preceding both Aristobulus and possibly Paul himself by two decades. Theodore Martin, of Lovan, wrote at the beginning of the Reformation in continental Europe, that:
Three times the antiquity of the British Church was affirmed in ecclesiastical councils: 1. The Council of Pisa, AD 1417; 2. Council of Constance, AD 1419; 3. Council of Siena, AD 1423. It was said that the British Church took precedence over all other Churches, being founded by Joseph of Arimathea, immediately after the passion of Christ.
Disputoilis super Dignitatem Anglis it Gallioe in Councilio Constantino, AD 1517.
Alfred the Great’s erudite chief minister and chronicler, Bishop Ussher, also stated, without equivocation, in his Britannicarum Ecclesiarum Antiquitates that the British National Church was founded in AD 36, a hundred and sixty years before heathen Rome confessed Christianity. The founding of a British national church by the Josephan Mission led to rapid conversion throughout the Isles. In AD 48, Conor Macnessa, King of Ulster, sent his priests to Avalon to commit Christian precepts and teachings into law, naming them ‘the Celestial Judgments’.
The Roman Pauline Mission:
About twenty years after Joseph’s arrival, there was a second Christian mission, also established under the protection and sponsorship of the Royal Silurian House, and under the commission of St. Paul. By this time, the Romans in Britain had become the implacable foe of the British Christians and sought by every means at their command to exterminate the new movement at its source. At the same time, they held the British warriors in high esteem and believed their religion was the reason for their fearlessness in battle and disdain of death. Lucanus, writing in Pharsalia in A.D. 38, argued that this indifference of the Britons to death was due to their religious beliefs, and Pomponius Mela, writing three years later, described, with astonishment, the British warriors as extraordinarily brave, which he ascribed to their religious doctrine, based on the immortality of the soul.
After his contact with the royal family of the Silures in Rome, Paul declared in his statement, I turn henceforth to the Gentiles. The family were destined to become the first martyrs to suffer for the Gentile Church, and millions more were soon to follow their example. The underground cemeteries of Rome, the Catacombs, were packed with the tortured, murdered bodies of Christian men, women and children from this period, just as British soil was saturated with the blood of martyrs, eternal testimony to their steadfast faith. Believing that Christ had died for them, they were fearless in dying for Christ.
The Romans had not previously held any special animosity towards the British, though they always despised the Jews. This hatred was now intensified by the Claudian Edict, which accused them of being responsible for the rise of the new faith, finding its converts among the people of Judea. Seeking further to inflame the citizens against both through the slander that Christians and Jews alike practised human sacrifice in their religions. However, they knew better that the burnt offerings of both Judeans and Druids were animals, chiefly sheep, goats and doves. The Romans also spread the age-old blood libel that the Jews devoured Gentile babies.
Throughout the nine-year Claudian campaign, the Irish and Pictish records tell of an ever-flowing stream of delegates from the various kingdoms, journeying to Avalon to receive at first-hand instruction from the Arimathean Culdees. Had it not been for this movement, Paul would almost certainly have been seriously handicapped in carrying out his mission to the Gentiles. The long-established, inter-generational familial associations between the Britons and the Romans in commerce, culture and social affairs had made both peoples conversant with each other on common grounds. Latin was not adopted in British ecclesiastical liturgies until the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. Yet, from the first to the fourth century, it was as familiar to the Cymry as was Greek or Hebrew. Through the Arimathean and Pauline missions, the Silureans eventually conquered Rome for Christ.
The first-century basilica was thought to be the centre of the Christian mission in Rome, home of Pudens. Source: Jowett (see below).
Among the earliest British hostages in Rome was Llyr Llediaith, grandfather of Caradoc. He died shortly after he arrived in Rome, and his son, Brán, became the Archdruid Silurian monarch who abdicated in favour of his son, Caractacus, who had offered himself as a hostage to replace his father, Llyr, the King Lear of Shakespeare’s play. These characters, gathering at the ‘House of Apostles’ in Rome, were to play a major role in the continuing drama of the ‘lost’ disciples under the direction of the Apostle Paul. Even though the apostle had his residence in Rome provided for him by the Christian following, the Scriptures state that he only resided there for two years during his ten years in the city. The common inference is that St Paul arrived in the city in A.D. 58, though his arrival could have been two years earlier. St Jerome wrote that Paul arrived inRome in the second year of Nero, who succeeded Claudius as emperor.
In the year AD 58, the Pauline mission was ready to leave Rome to begin their work in Britain in the territorial section then known as Cambria, later Wales. Aristobulus was installed as the first Bishop of Llanulltid, with Brán remaining as Archdruid and High Priest of Siluria at Llandaff. In the Cymric language, Aristobulus was known as Arwistli-Hén and Arwystli-Senex in Roman-Latin. Unfortunately, the aged or ‘hén’ Aristobulus met a tragic end within a year of his return to Britain. The Pauline Mission had come directly from Rome, and the inveterate hatred of the British for all things Roman was unrelating. Brán wrote in his journals that they were hard pressed to induce the British to accept anyone or anything that came from the imperial city. It was only their love for the devout Brán and Eurgain of Old Sarum (Caer Salog; Salisbury), the Patroness of the Pauline mission among the Silures, that made them willing to receive the Roman Christian missionaries. Aristobulus was well respected among the Silures. He was a Greek Christian who had come to Britain from Jerusalem via Galicia, on the Atlantic coast in Northern Spain. He was also previously known to Joseph and the Avalon Mission.
On his missionary journeys in Britain, Aristobulus journeyed far beyond the territory of the Silures into the lands of the Ordovices, whose hatred for the Romans was even more bitter and certainly blacker than that of the Silures. The Roman missionary was also unknown to them, and they were justifiably suspicious that his appearance was yet another Roman trick and that he was really an imperial spy. According to Cardinal Alford’s Regia Fides, the Ordovices rose up and slew him in the year AD 58 or 59. He was martyred at what later became St Albans, following the Diocletian martyrdom of the saint of that name. Aristobulus, therefore, became the first Romano-British martyr and the only one to be martyred by the Celtic tribes. When the Ordovices were informed of the misunderstanding, they were remorseful. They erected a beautiful church on the site of his martyrdom.
Following the death of Aristobulus, the Princess Eurgain became the leader of the Pauline Mission. She was the first female convert in Britain and the first female Christian saint. She founded twelve colleges for Culdee initiates at Cor Eurgain. Ilid, ‘aman of Israel’, a Judean convert who had accompanied Bran and Aristobulus to Cambria, took charge of the mission until Paul arrived. He was a Judean convert from Rome and was shown to be a very capable, energetic leader. Financed by the royal Silurian family, a magnificent church and university were built, and many new schools were built throughout Cambria. The Iolo manuscript says of Ilid:
He afterwards went to Glastonbury, where he died and was buried, and Ina, King of that country, raised a large church over his grave.
King Ina’s church at Glastonbury Abbey, built in AD 700, was excavated in the 1950s. The loss of his aged friend, Aristobulus, was a great blow to Paul, who sent his salutations to his friends at Rome. The last epistle Paul sent out from prison was to his fellow apostle, Timothy, requesting him to deliver his (last) greetings or benedictions to the ones he loved dearest on earth, to his sister-in-law, Claudia, and her husband; his half-brother, Pudens; to their children and to his nieces and nephews, whom he had taught; the beloved Linus, whom he had consecrated and appointed First Bishop of Rome, Linus; to Eubulus, cousin of Claudia, and them which are of the household of Aristobulus. In only ten years, Paul had faithfully carried out his commission to go to the Gentiles. He had established the First Christian Church in Rome and undertaken a mission to Britain in collaboration with the Josephan Mission at Avalon and the members of the British royal Silurian family.
It is claimed that Paul landed at what is now a suburb of the great naval port of Portsmouth, from where ferries still arrive from Brittany and Northern Spain. It has been known over the centuries as ‘Paul’s Grove’. From there, he made his way into Cambria, to Bangor-on-Dee, where (it is claimed) he founded the famous abbey, destroyed in 613 by Aethelfrith of Northumbria after he defeated the Welsh armies at the Battle of Chester and slaughtered the monks. The doctrine and administration of the Abbey was known as Pauli Regula, ‘The Rule of Paul’. According to R. W. Morgan, author of St. Paul in Britain, the abbots all considered themselves as direct successors of Paul, although other records show it to have been founded by Dunod in the mid-sixth century. It’s doubtful that Paul stayed long enough in Britain to see the abbey completed, even as a simple construction. Certainly, it could not have been the monastery described by St Hilary and St Benedict as the ‘Mother of Monasteries’, and by Bede as having over two thousand resident monks.
A casual study of the life and works of St Paul, after his arrival in Rome, shows a ‘blank period’ of six years. Many scholars now believe that those years were spent in Gaul, and principally in Cambria. We know (from his letters) that he returned to Rome from there in AD 61, and that he was reinterned there, and that he also returned to Arles, in southern Gaul, where he was obliged to leave one of his sick companions from Rome. In Cambria, as in Gaul, the memory of Paul’s sojourn was almost entirely lost or became fabricated parts of later legend. The only enduring ‘traces’ of his visit are found in ‘Llundain’ or Londinum, where he is said to have preached from the summit of Ludgate Hill, the original site of the old St. Paul’s Cathedral. Arising from this legend, London has been referred to as the ‘Aereopagus’ of Britain, and the exact spot of his preaching may well be marked by the ancient St. Paul’s Cross. The emblem associated with him, the sword of martyrdom, was incorporated in the coat of arms of the City of London.
A common question often arises concerning the apostles’ ability to preach to the people in the various languages of Britain. Since it is unlikely that Paul could use a Cymric tongue for this, we may assume that he spoke in Latin, which was well-known among the educated Romano-British. However, we know that he wrote fluently, in Greek, the most widely comprehensible language of the first-century Mediterranean world. It was not until the time of Charlemagne that Latin became the language of church services. It was imposed by Pope Gregory I on much of Europe in AD 600, but the Celtic Church in Britain opposed this until the end of the seventh century. Bishop Ussher, chief advisor to Alfred the Great, writing in his Historia Dogmatica, claimed that:
No two causes contributed so much to the declension of Christianity… as the suppression by the Church of Rome of the vernacular scriptures, and her adoption of image worship.
Had it not been for the vigorous support of the Pauline Mission in Cambria by the Princess Eurgain and her relatives, his efforts might have failed completely. The success of his mission was undoubtedly due to its sponsorship. Following the martyrdom of Aristobulus, the Cambrian church renewed its close ties with Avalon. The common people their allegiance never deviated from Joseph or the Mother Church there, while they could not and did not accept leadership from Rome. However, Paul fulfilled his own mission, to go far hence unto the Gentiles, and the magnitude of his achievements is summed up by St. Clement, who followed Linus as Bishop of Rome at the end of the first century:
Paul,… having seven times worn chains, and being hunted and stoned, received the prize of such endurance. For he was the herald of the Gospel in the West as well as in the East, and enjoyed the illustrious reputation of the faith in teaching the whole world to be righteous.And after he had been in the extremity of the West, he suffered martyrdom before the sovereigns of mankind…
1 Clement 5: 6-7.
‘Extremity of the West’ was the term used by Romans to indicate Britain, though it was also used by Paul himself to refer to western Gaul, especially Galicia in northern Spain. In his History of the Apostles, Capellus wrote:
I know scarcely of one author from the time of the Fathers downward who does not maintain that St Paul, after his liberation, preached in every country of the West, in Europe, Britain included.
Theodoret, writing in the fourth century, claimed that St. Paul brought salvation to the Isles in the ocean, and Ventanius, the sixth-century Patriarch of Jerusalem, wrote very definitely and in detail of Paul’s visit to Britain, as did many other chroniclers of early church history.
In his recent, influential ‘biography’ of Paul, the New Testament scholar Tom Wright explained why he is now inclined to give more weight than he once did to the testimony of Clement, Bishop of Rome, quoted above. In referring to the farthest limits of the west, Clement could have been simply extrapolating from Romans 15, and Wright suggests that it would have suited his purpose to give the impression of Paul’s reach across the empire. But he also points out that Clement was a central figure in the Roman Church within a generation of Paul’s day, writing at most thirty years after the apostle’s death. It is far more likely that he had more solid and reliable traditions about Paul than we can invent without first-hand sources other than those in the New Testament. “The farthest reaches of the west” could, of course, have meant Spain, but it could also have meant Britain, especially after the Claudian Conquest of AD 43 and especially by AD 63, when Paul was reported to be visiting the ‘Galatian’ churches along the Aurelian Way.
Even if Paul were killed in AD 64, there were nearly two years, time enough for a visit to Spain, and even to Britain, especially if he followed the route from Marseilles to Brittany and then to Portsmouth. There was also regular traffic between Rome and Tarraco, the Catalan town of Tarragona, the capital of Hispania Tarraconensis, which since the time of Augustus had stretched right across the Iberian Peninsula to the Atlantic coast. Paul may have had an additional motivation for choosing this latter route, as the temple to Augustus had been replaced in Paul’s day with a dramatic complex for the imperial cult. This was clearly visible from several miles out to sea, and Paul may have been eager to announce Jesus as Lord and King in places where Caesar was claiming those titles. If Tarraco was still considered to be in the province at the end of the known world in AD 63, it would have been a natural target by the missionaries.
As Tom Wright has pointed out, all of Paul’s plans carried the word ‘perhaps’ about with them, so perhaps if he did make it to Spain, he could also have gone north-west to the oceanic islands. Wright asks, might we not have had the chance of a Pauline version of Blake’s famous poem, ‘Jerusalem’? It would, of course, have had to refer to ‘Cambria’s mountains green’! It may be that the comparatively easy convergence between Paul’s letters and the narrative of Acts has lulled scholars into thinking that we know more than we do about his last years. The second letter to Timothy implies some additional activity back in the East after an initial hearing in Rome. In his letter, Paul really does believe he is facing death at last:
I am already being poured out as a drink-offering; my departure time has arrived. I have fought the good fight; I have completed the course; I have kept the faith. What do I still have to look for? The crown of righteousness! The Lord, the righteous judge, will give it to me as my reward on that day – and not only to me, but to all who have loved his appearing.
2 Timothy 4: 6-8.
If Paul was back in Rome by the time of Nero’s persecution, facing additional hearings in difficult circumstances, two years would hardly have been enough for journeys both to the west and the east. But by AD 62, the persecution would have negated the need for any hearings or legal trappings. Paul could no longer shelter in house arrest from the terror behind his Roman citizenship. The emperor had laid the blame for the fire on the Christians as a group, and that was enough for Paul to be rounded up with all his fellow believers. Paul may have been away from the city in either the west or east, but returned to Rome in AD 64, to find that the public mood had changed so much that, citizen or not, appealing to Caesar or not, he was now straightforwardly on trial as a dangerous troublemaker. However, rather than the slow, agonising deaths, often following appalling tortures that Nero inflicted on the Jewish-Christian immigrants from the southern ghetto, he was summarily convicted and swiftly executed by beheading, as a citizen, with a sword.
Paul’s world view and theology was strongly motivated by his eschatology, which, as his letter to the Romans (chapter eight) shows, was shared by many of his readers and listeners. This was undoubtedly what added an urgency to his last missions. But the main point about the end of the world was that it could occur at any time, not that it had to occur within a specific time frame. The event that was to occur within a generation was not the end of the world itself, but, according to the Gospel writers, the fall of Jerusalem. By the time of Paul’s death, this was woven into the fabric of the early Christian faith. Jerusalem itself, and the Temple specifically, had always been seen as the place where heaven and earth met. Its destruction in AD70 was therefore a pivotal point in the development of Judeo-Christian thinking and theology.
Source: Dowley
If Paul had heard of this by living just a few years longer, he might have reflected, theologically, that the One God had already built his new Temple, his new microcosmos; the Jew-plus-Gentile church was the place where the divine spirit was already living in the midst of mankind, revealing his glory as a sign of what would happen one day throughout the whole world. Sooner or later, Paul must have thought, the new movement was bound to thrive. Of course, Paul would not expect all this to happen smoothly, without suffering and struggle. He would not have expected that the small and muddled communities would be transformed into a much larger body, covering the entire known world, without further terrible persecution. The new movement in which he led was not just the accidental by-product of energetic work, a historical opportunity, but the chief product of divine will and purpose. But just as Paul would not want to give a purely naturalistic, demythologised explanation, neither would he wish instead to ascribe the whole series of events to divine or angelic power without human agency.
Probably because the diasporic Jews after the Jewish War of AD 70 were unorganised and not militant, like the British guerrilla warriors, the Roman campaign of extermination against them was not so widespread or determined. They also had a longstanding imperial exemption from making tribute to the emperor, whereas Gentiles had no such exemption. Instead, as in Rome, they were forced into ghettoes throughout the imperial cities where they settled, where their defiance could not easily be observed. The Gauls and the British, however, were warrior nations skilled in the arts of warfare on land and at sea.
The Gauls had been largely subdued, but the British were still led by independent rulers and military commanders, all of whom were steeped in invincibility of spirit, which stemmed from their Christian faith, which decreed that all men should be free. The overwhelming rise of Christianity in the densely populated cities of Gaul and Britain was therefore viewed with consternation by the authorities in Rome. Britain had become the seedbed of missions like the one at Glastonbury, where an ever-flowing stream of preachers was tutored, trained, and ordained by the apostles and disciples, and then sent out as missionaries to distant territories and foreign lands.
The Persecutions of the Early Church:
The Romans declared that this mushrooming of missionary activity had to be stopped. To them, might alone was right, but from their past experience of British military resistance, they had good reason to respect and even fear it, inspired as it was by the zeal of Christ. Yet Rome had conquered the world, or so it claimed. That unity was a top-down uniformity in which diversity was welcomed as long as it didn’t threaten the absolute sovereignty of Caesar. That diversity was always seen in strictly hierarchical terms: men over women, free over slaves, Romans over everybody else. Rebels were to be ruthlessly suppressed, as were the Druids and Cambrian Christians in the Menai bloodbath staged by Suetonius Paulinus, and the Trinovantes in the Boadicean atrocities conducted under the malignant direction of Catus Decianus in AD 60 to 62.
The Pax Britannica, ‘the great peace’ which had descended over the Island, beginning with the Treaty of Agricola in AD 86, continued for a period of two hundred years. During that time, no mention of British-Roman conflict was recorded. Yet, as the Briton Calgacus remarked, they make a wilderness, and call it peace. The Claudian Edict to crush British resistance was founded on the mistaken belief that only violent persecution would terrorise the Britons into ultimate submission. Roman chroniclers were silent, leaping the two-hundred year gap as though nothing of significance had occured in the ‘pacified’ island of Britannia. They took up the record again in the year AD 287, to recite the usurpage of the Emperor’s crown by Carausius, the Admiral of the Roman fleet, who landed in northern Britain, marching to York, where he had himself proclaimed Emperor. Since the fall of London to Queen Boudicca (Boadicea) of the Iceni, the City of York had become a popular resort for the Romans. From the ancient British city, the age-old citadel of the Brigantes, first known as Caer Evroc, several Roman emperors had chosen to rule, deeming it a safer haven for that purpose than Rome. For centuries before them and Christ, it had been the centre of the enamelling craftsmen of the La Téne art.
But we should always listen to the silences in the official records, and by doing so, we discover from Geoffrey of Monmouth’s British sources that it was in AD 156 that, by the royal edict of King Lucius, proclaimed at Winchester, southern Britain became officially Christian for the first time. Carausius reigned as Emperor from York for seven years before his assassination and usurpation by his own minister, Allectus, in AD 294. The usurper reigned for two years before falling in battle against the forces of Constantius Chlorus, who then succeeded him and also ruled the Empire from York for the next ten years. With him began one of the most momentous chapters in early Christian history, beginning first in the city of Colchester, or Camulodunum, once capital of the Iceni under Boudicca, and the royal seat of King Coel, whose castle was at Lexdon, now a suburb of the modern city.
Source: Dowley
In AD 265, Coel had a daughter named Elén, who later became known as Empress Helen of the Cross. Raised in a Christian household, her natural talents were developed to a higher degree by the best scholars and administrators in the land. While her regal husband and son stood out eminently in the art of diplomacy, her capacity for political administration played a prominent part in their imperial destiny. The Christianising of the Roman Empire would undoubtedly have been delayed centuries but for her energy and devotional support. Roman history merely describes her in her role as Empress. No mention is made of her British ancestry and heritage, including her royal Romano-British predecessors, Princess Eurgain and Claudia Pudens. She was made to appear simply as a native of Rome, wife of a Roman and mother of an illustrious Roman son. Later, however, the Protestant reformer, Philip Melanchthon, sought to set the Roman record straight when he wrote in his Epistola that Helen was unquestionably a British Princess.
Even before Constantius defeated Allectus at York, he was recognised as Emperor of Britain, Spain and Gaul, the boundaries of which extended far across western and southern Europe, including Germany. He was proclaimed as Emperor of Rome at York and was the first to be recognised as monarch by the people of the four domains. Only he and his extraordinary son, Constantine the Great, were ever to attain imperial rule over the whole of the vast empire at its height. In the pre-Christian era, as Caer Evroc, York was one of the Druidic centres, continuing so at the time of the Josephan Mission until King Lucius established London, York and Caerleon on Usk as the three great Archbishoprics of Britain. Six years before he became Roman Emperor, in AD 290, Constantius renewed and enlarged the Archbishopric of York, making it the most outstanding royal and religious city in Britain. Later, Caerleon was replaced by Canterbury as the third archbishopric, with the latter then replacing London as the chief ecclesiastical seat ahead of York.
Before the ascent of Constantius to the throne of the Roman Empire, revolution and assassination had been disposing of one emperor after another. There was a confusing array of predatory Roman nobles who raised their armies, laying claim to the throne of the Caesars. The notorious Diocletian held the reins in Rome, and on his orders began what is often described as the worst persecution of Christians in the year AD 290. Besides the attacks on people, churches and scriptures, libraries, schools of learning and private homes were destroyed. The lions roared again in the Colosseum, the prisons were filled, and the streets ran with the blood of many martyrs. No Christian was spared, nor were their families, even babes-in-arms. This persecution was described as the tenth since the Claudian Edict of AD 42. Like previous emperors, Diocletian scapegoated the Christians for the series of disasters over the years that had decimated the Roman armies to such an extent that they were no longer able to defend their frontiers successfully, let alone conquer as before. Rome was on the decline, and her glory was fast fading. Diocletian sought to evade national disaster by ordering the extermination of the Christians, their churches, and other possessions.
This bestial cruelty lasted for eighteen years, and it flamed across Europe for several years before it struck Britain. Again, the Romans were frustrated by the incredible zeal of the martyrs who died with prayer on their lips, watching the common people being destroyed, showing the same disdain for death as had their Christian forbears. This infuriated Diocletian, so that he adopted ever more fiendish practices, in which he was later aided by Maximian, who became co-ruler with him over the continental empire. His ferocity and atrocities were claimed to be beyond description; he was blind with maniacal hatred of Christians.
The Diocletan savagery, which began in Britain in about 300 AD, showed how barbaric the imperial extermination of British independence and all that was Christian had become. On the orders of Maximian, co-ruler with Diocletian, the Christian Gaulish veterans, the finest warrior battalions in the Roman army, were slaughtered to a man in cold blood, such was his absolute hatred of Christianity. Meanwhile, the Emperor poured a huge army into Britain. But Constantius Chlorus had already been proclaimed Emperor at York, and the British kingdoms were more united. Previously, they had fought for years in deciding each conflict with the Romans, with victory swinging from one side to the other. Yet, within a year, Constantius had terminated the Diocletian persecution in Britain, driving the Romans back to the continent in AD 302. However, the Romans had succeeded in inflicting huge losses on the British armies, and had levelled churches, universities and libraries, besides sacking towns. The slaughter was terrific, and included a list of British martyrs that far exceeded the total by all the former persecutions combined. This was not so much the total from the field of battle, but in the slaughter of the priesthood and their defenceless flocks.
Following King Lucius’s death and the raising of Asclepiodotus, Duke of Cornwall, to be king, the persecution of the Emperor Diocletian resulted in the near blotting out of official Christianity across the whole island. Maximianus Herculius, chief of the Roman armies in Britain, reconquered the whole country, tore down the churches and burnt all copies of the sacred scriptures that could be found in the marketplaces. Priests were put to death, along with the faithful committed to their charge, …
… and thethronging fellowship of Christians did hasten to vie with one another which should first reach the kingdom of Heaven and delight thereof, as though it had been their abiding place.
Geoffrey’s Histories, p. 79.
Among those men and women martyred was Alban of Verulamium, his confessor and protector, Amphibalus, and Julius and Aaron of the City of Legions, Chester, who were torn limb from limb. The prelates killed included Socrates of York, Stephen of London and his successor, Nicholas of Penrhyn (Glasgow), and Melior of Carlisle. Gildas also estimated that the number of communicants killed was as many as ten thousand.
After Constantius had married Elén, she bore him a son whom she called Constantine. The Emperor and his Queen Empress began to restore the churches destroyed under Diocletian’s Edict. It was a titanic task into which the royal family poured their fortune. During these eleven years of restoration, Constantius died at York in AD 306 and was succeeded as King of Britain by his son, Constantine, with his mother acting as protector. For the next six years, the young Emperor remained in Britain, building many new churches and institutions of learning.
The Constantinian Conquest of Rome:
Having restored peace to his British kingdom, expelling the armies of Diocletian, Constantine prepared to cross the seas to the continent. During this time of the protectorate, Diocletian and Maximianian continued their destruction of Christian lives there. Meanwhile, many Roman refugees, fleeing Maxentius’s tyranny in Rome and other imperial cities across Gaul, began to arrive in York, where Constantine received them with honour. As their numbers grew, they stirred him up into hatred of the tyrant who had deprived them of their homes, estates, and families. They made speeches imploring him to act on their behalf:
“How long, O Constantine, wilt thou endure this our calamity and exile? Wherefore delayest thou to restore us to our native land? Thou art the only one of our blood strong enough to give us back that which we have lost and to drive Maxentius forth. For what prince is there who may be compared unto the King of Britain, whether it be in the valour of his hardy soldiers or the plenty of his gold and silver? We do adjure thee, give us back our possessions, our wives and children, by emprising an expedition to Rome with thine army and ourselves.”
Geoffrey of Monmouth, Histories, V, Chapter VII (1912 edn.)
Geoffrey wrote that, provoked by these words and others, Constantine massed a powerful army in Britain and went via Gaul (southern Germany today) to Rome, taking with him the three uncles of Helena. The two armies clashed on the banks of the Tiber, where the Romano-Britons won an overwhelming victory under his generalship. Maximian was completely routed, and the persecution was brought to an immediate end. After deposing Maximian and becoming emperor, he raised his uncles to the rank of Senators.
Officially acclaimed by the Senate and the citizens of Rome, he also became Emperor of Gaul and Spain by hereditary right. Including Britain, this was the greatest territorial dominion ruled over by one emperor. His first act as Emperor of Rome was to declare it Christian in religion, ending persecution within the Empire (c. 312).
Christ was depicted in association with the Sun god by Constantine. Source: Dowley.
So, just when it seemed as though Christianity on the Continent had been crushed by the Diocletian persecution, it was a Romano-British consul, Constantine, who, with an army of Christian British warriors, crossed the seas and smashed the imperial armies with a defeat so catastrophic that they never rose again. That Western victory ended the persecution of Christianity within the empire. The Roman Empire became nominally tolerant of Christianity under Constantine in c. 350 AD, but it was not until the later seventh century that Papal supremacy was recognised across Western Europe.
On the continent, the Empress Helen is also given credit for the founding of the first cathedral at Tréves (Trier), then the capital of Belgic Gaul. Due to this association, the city had closer contact with the early British monarchs than any other on the continent before the Norman Conquest. The practice of making church dedications to women, other than to Mary, the mother of Jesus, did not begin until the twelfth century. But the church of St Helen was erected to her glory several hundred years before that practice, when she was also proclaimed as a saint. After the death of her husband at York in AD 306, Helen continued to reign as Empress together with her son before she died in AD 336, aged seventy-one, in Constantinople.
Source: Dowley
Later in the fourth century, the Emperor Maximus Magnus (the legendary ‘Macsen Wledig’ of the Mabinogion, the eleven Old Welsh stories written down in circa 1300-25) overran the continental empire in AD 387 from Galicia with his British army before withdrawing into Gaul, where they settled in Brittany. According to Hewin’s Royal Saints of Britain…
…The Emperor Maximus Magnus or ‘Maxen Wledig’ was a Roman-Spaniard related to the Emperor Theodosius, and of the family of Constantine the Great, and British royal descent on his mother’s side. …
Although Macsen was Spanish-born (in Celtic-speaking Galicia), he served with Theodosius in the British wars and rose to high military command in Britain. In 383, he invaded Gaul to oust Gratian, the Roman emperor of that time, and after Gratian’s assassination and the flight of Valentinian, became master of Italy, but was himself put to death in 388 by Theodosius. The excursion of Elén’s brothers to Rome is historically inaccurate, but the story shows a strong, nostalgic interest in the old Roman grandeur, and the (exaggerated) contribution to it of British fighting men.
The Age of Christian Expansion:
Source: Dowley (ed.)
It was not until the beginning of the fifth century that native Christianity in the British Isles, having recovered sufficiently from the Roman persecutions, re-established itself to the extent that the Patriarch of Constantinople was able to remark:
The British Isles have received the virtue of the Word. Churches are there found and altars erected. … Though thou shouldst go to the ocean, to the British Isles, there thou shouldst hear all men everywhere discoursing matters out of Scriptures, with another voice indeed, but not another faith, with a different tongue, but the same judgment.
Chrysostom, Sermo De Utilitate, AD 402.
The renowned Cymric bard, Taliesin, writing in AD 500-540, one of post-Roman Britain’s greatest scholars and an archdruid, declared that though the gospel teaching was new to India and Asia, it had always, from the beginning, been known in Celtic Britain. He wrote:
Christ, the Word from the beginning, was from the first our teacher, and we never lost His teachings. Christianity was a new thing in Asia, but there never was a time when the Druids of Britain did not hold its Doctrines.
Söurce: Dowley
As we have seen, Christianity in Britain, in its first three centuries at least, was a flower planted and flourishing in the soil laid by the Druids. This could be seen in both the practice and the basic principles of the new religion. The Druidic economic law of the law of righteousness and distributive justice, based on the practice of tithing. The Druidic natural law was exactly the same as the Judao-Christian law of righteousness, enabling the merging of Druidic and Christian principles of faith. For its first millennium, this practice was so embedded in the minds of the faithful that it was normally carried on throughout the Golden Era of the church in Britain. The magnificent gifts of the British kings to the church were simply an enlargement of the tithe on their part. The Queen Empress Helen and her son, Constantine the Great, were probably the greatest contributors to the Roman-British church. For their subjects, the Harvest Festival or Thanksgiving was the time when they brought their gifts from the field to the church. Following the Golden Era, circa AD 600, the time of the conversions of the Anglo-Saxons, the tithe began to lose some of its original substance, a development which was intensified by the effect of the Viking raids and incursions of the eighth and ninth centuries. In 854, King Aethelwulf issued a Royal Charter which recognised the tithe as a national institution, representing:
“The tenth part of the land of the Kingdom to God’s praise and His eternal welfare.”
The deed was written at Winchester, and the Charter was placed on the Cathedral altar in the presence of Archbishop Swithun and the Witangamot (The Council of Aeldermen), where it was consecrated to the service of Christ. This effectively established the church as the national church of England. The apostolic claim of the Church of Rome is unsupported in historical terms. Peter was never addressed as Bishop of Rome by St Paul, any of the Apostles or the early Bishops of the Church. Neither did he make any claim to the title, that of Archbishop or Pope. Clement was the first to be named as Bishop of Rome. In the British succession, Gregory the Great, who sent Augustine to England, rejected the title of Pope, and it was only ascribed to him posthumously by various church chroniclers. Gregory simply claimed to be ‘first among equals’.
The earthly leader of the Roman Church in the fourth and fifth centuries was known as the Bishop of Rome. It was only in the year AD 610 that the title of Pope, meaning universal pontiff, was created by the Emperor Phocas because the Bishop of Constantinople had excommunicated him for having plotted the execution of his predecessor. Even then, the title was not universally recognised until the establishment of the Holy Roman Empire, under the leadership of the Emperor of Germany, Otto I. Although the bishops of the Kingdom of Northumbria accepted the Roman rites and calendar at the Synod of Whitby in 664, the Kingdom of England did not come into being until the reign of Eadgar in the second half of the tenth century, and the English Church was not fully subject to Rome until the Norman Conquest, a century later.
The Return to Glastonbury:
The View of the Tor from across the Levels, from along the drainage rhines. Source: Susan Hill (see below).
Returning to Glastonbury, many are still intrigued by the mystery of the original cup used at the Last Supper, which, according to some ancient records, was preserved. The answer may lie in the ancient British tradition, which associates the original cup with Joseph of Arimathea at Avalon. With the Edicts of Tiberius and Claudius making it a capital offence for anyone to embrace the teachings of The Way, and calling for the destruction of anything related to the Christian cause, the Apostles would have wished to place any sacred object where it could be kept safe. The ancient British tradition was that the sacred Cup was in Joseph’s possession when he first arrived at Avalon with the Judean refugees, and when the first persecution of Christians in Britain began after the Claudian conquest of AD 43. The tradition was that Joseph buried it secretly, though perhaps after consulting with a few other members of the group. If there is any merit in this persistent age-old tradition, the original Cup was buried on or near what is now known as Chalice Hill.
Source: Dowley.
Few of the widespread ruins brought about byHenry VIII’s Dissolution of the Monasteries of 1539produce such a pang as do those of Glastonbury, whether because the surviving parts of the Lady Chapel and St Joseph’s Chapel help us to realise what a great work of art was destroyed, or because the whole site is associated with the dreadful narrative of its brutal destruction, the martyrdom of its abbot and the expulsion of its monks. Excavations have revealed traces of the original Celtic monastic settlement, first documented in 658. Tradition maintains that St. Patrick, St. Brigid, and St. David all visited the monastery. Refounded by Æthelwulf of Wessex, the abbey began its great period in 940 under the energetic abbot Dunstan, later Archbishop of Canterbury. None of the Celtic or Anglo-Saxon remains are visible, though we know that Eadmund Ironside, the last King of Wessex, and last legitimate Saxon king of England, was buried there in 1016. What we see now, however, are the remains of the great church built after the fire of 1181, largely in the Transitional and Early English styles. There is the Abbot’s kitchen, and a descendant of Joseph’s original hawthorn, seeming to confirm the legend that it blooms at Christmastide.
The Chalice Well, a spring of great antiquity, had its modern cover design influenced by the Celtic revival. Source: Anderson & Hicks.
A typical pattern for pilgrims and visitors is to visit the abbey ruins first, then proceed to the Chalice Well, in the terraced garden at the foot of the Tor, before climbing up. The Well is lined with ancient stonework worked in a way which prompted the suggestion that it was built by Egyptian traders. From the earliest Christian times, the hill and the well have been known by the particular name they still bear, though the well is also often referred to as the Holy Well, like others surviving from Celtic Christian times (in Wales, there is a well-known site of pilgrimage in the town of Holywell). Reputedly, the waters of the well were used to baptise King Lucius and countless other notable early converts to the faith. The water flows out from springs on the hill to form the well, and it is supposed that this was where Joseph buried the Cup. This tradition was firmly believed for over a thousand years, and formed the basis for the thirteenth-century Arthurian tales of the search of the Knights of the Round Table for the Holy Grail. The many poems, songs and stories that have abounded from medieval to modern times were immortalised by Tennyson in the following verse:
‘The Cup, the cup itself from which our Lord
drank at the last sad supper with His own;
This from the blessed land of Amamat,
After the day of darkness, when the dead
went wandering over Moriah – the good Saint,
Arimathean Joseph, brought to Glastonbury.‘
Source: Dowley
A ‘grail’ in Old English is a serving dish, a ‘cruet’, more like a small jar (‘egg-cup size’) than a large ‘chalice’, and ancient records describe two of them being brought to Glastonbury and being buried with Joseph in a niche carved into his stone coffin. They contained the blood and sweat of Jesus, presumably collected by Joseph during the burial of Jesus, and were held in highest reverence by the Abbey throughout its existence. The Grail story was made famous by Chrétien de Troyes, and was also recorded in a thirteenth-century Shropshire legend and resurfaces with a Victorian antiquarian, Thomas Wright, who left clues as to the whereabouts of the Grail in the west window of a village church. In the base of one of the statues removed from the church, a small jar was discovered, which the British Museum decided was a first-century Roman scent jar.
As Tom Holland (in his popular book, The Rest is History, 2023) has pointed out, the support for Arthur’s actual existence is flimsy. ‘Y Gododdin’, an Old Welsh poem composed around AD 600, praises the feats of a Welsh-speaking, Roman-fort-bashing, Edinburgh-dwelling warlord, while admitting that ‘he was not Arthur’. However, this poem was written down in the ninth century, and the earliest surviving manuscript comes from the thirteenth century. Slightly more promisingly, Nennius, a ninth-century Welsh monk, gave a list of twelve battles supposedly won by Arthur, culminating in the Battle of Badon Hill (a hill outside Bath). However, Gildas, the sixth-century monk, mentioned the same battle against the Saxons, but didn’t associate it with Arthur. However, he could still have been a mythical figure, and while no one has proved his existence, neither has anyone comprehensively disproved it, thus ‘busting’ the myth by destroying the legend. Intriguingly, Arthur’s story also runs contrary to euhemerism, the way that mortal kings from the distant past often become elevated over time to the status of gods. Arthur, by contrast, is a folklore figure who has become attached to a specific historical narrative.
We know that the pagan Anglo-Saxons became dominant over the lowlands of the former province of Britannia, while the Romanised, Christian Welsh were pushed into the upland fringes. Arthur, therefore, became a Welsh folk hero, his status magnified by a prophecy that he would come again to reverse their humiliation. Arthur rapidly became a hero of all things to all kings. He provided a useful ‘template’ to the Normans and Angevins wanting to subdue the outlying regions of their empire. During the reign of Edward I (1272-1307), the conqueror of Wales as well as the hammer of the Scots, Arthur’s tomb was conveniently discovered in Glastonbury, evidence that he would not rise again, any more than would the Scots’ warrior-hero by the name of ‘Walleas’. By the time of the Tudors, the Arthurian myth had become an international brand, even after Henry VII’s elder son, Arthur, Prince of Wales, died in 1502, aged fifteen.
The story of the search for the Holy Grail by the Knights of the Round Table carries a double meaning, blending the narratives of Joseph of Arimathea and Arthur. It is generally believed that the ‘Quest for the Grail’ was for the cup of the Last Supper, which Joseph is claimed to have concealed on Chalice Hill. On the other hand, the word ‘Grail’ in Old English means ‘elements’, which some writers indicate meant the lost ‘cruets’ or ‘vials’. These were placed within Joseph’s sarcophagus of Joseph at his death and buried with him. The word ‘Grail’ was also employed to mean a container, a chalice or a cup, which might better indicate that the search of King Arthur’s knights was directed to find the Cup or Chalice used by Jesus in the Upper Room on the night before the crucifixion, and not the vials used for his burial. Mention of the Cup was naturally shrouded in secrecy following the record of its concealment at Glastonbury, but the cruets persist so strongly through the rituals of the early church, and their association with Joseph, that there is no doubt that they represent an important memorial of Josephan mission at Glastonbury.
A sixteenth-century poem, The Lyfe of Joseph of Arimathea, probably written by a monk from Glastonbury, began to tone down the stories about Joseph and the Grail. The poet does seek to confirm, however, that Joseph had brought Christianity to Britain:
Then hyther into britayne Ioseph did come,
And this was by kyng Averagus dayes;
So dyd Ioseph and also Iosephas his sonne,
With many one mo, as the old bloke says.
This kynge was hethen and lyved on fals layes,
And yet he gave to Ioseph av(i)lonye,
There Ioseph lyved with other hermyttes twelfe,
That were the chyfe of all the company,
But Ioseph was the chefe hym-selfe;
There led they an holy lyfe and gostely.
Quoted by Susan Hill.
Joseph had come with the blood of Jesus from the wound in Christ’s side, contained in the vials he concealed at Glastonbury; thys blode in two cruettes Joseph did take. Significantly, there was no mention of a Holy Grail in the form of a Chalice. If the stories had run away with themselves, this did nothing to diminish the power of the place to inspire its pilgrims, whatever their denomination. In John Cowper Powys’ story, A Glastonbury Romance, three local ‘worthies’ discuss the legacy of Glastonbury:
“Well, of course, to our old-fashioned Protestantancestors, Glastonbury must have reeked with what you call ‘superstition’ Three famous Saxon kings are buried here. … All the Holy Grail legends gather to a head here. The Druids played a great part here, and long before the Druids, there was a Lake Village… whose mounds you can still see in the fields. Ancient Britons who probably was… But I expect the deepest-rooted suspicion here, if you could compel Glastonbury Tor to speak, would turn out to be the religion of the people who lived before the Ancient Britons… At any rate, we have some excuse for being ‘superstitious’ in these parts. Don’t you think so, Miss Drew?”
“I think you are very kind, dear Vicar, to answer Mr Crow’s question at all,” said the old lady severely. “For myself, I would answer it rather differently. I would assure him that what he calls superstition, WE call the Only True Faith.”
Quoted by Susan Hill.
Ascending to the summit of the Tor, we come to the place of execution of Richard Whiting, the last abbot of Glastonbury, declared to be a traitor in 1539 by Henry VIII. There is a sense of being taken up above the world, above the intense blue colours of the Somerset levels. It seems mystically connected with the dedication of the church to the Archangel Michael, the vanquisher of evil. Another Arthurian site visible from the Tor is the hillfort of South Cadbury, traditionally said to be the site of King Arthur’s Camelot. He and the legends surrounding his knights and his court are seen through the screen of later medieval chivalric society. However, it was at Winchester that the Round Table was ‘discovered’, repainted and restored by Henry VIII, placing himself at the ‘top’ of it to impress Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor, whom he hoped to succeed.
The view across Somerset from South Cadbury hillfort. Source: Anderson & Hicks.
The Arthur of South Cadbury defeated the Saxons at the great battle of Mons Badonicus (Badon Hill, near Bath) in circa 494-516, possibly on the site of Liddington Castle in modern-day Wiltshire. The ‘real’ Arthur must have been far more provincial than the later hero, but he would seem to have led the resistance to the Anglo-Saxon advance and thereby helped to save Christian Romano-British culture from extinction. The Romano-British, holding a line stretching from Cornwall to Strathclyde from the fifth to the mid-sixth century, a period that became known as the Age of the Saints.
The real, authentic ‘Glastonbury’, then, is a La Téne period lake village site. The remains of the abbey, the Tor, and the Chalice Well, with their early Christian and Arthurian associations, place Glastonbury in prime position among the holy sites of Britain. Over centuries, it has provided a place of refuge and a source of spiritual refreshment to people of many different backgrounds and, therefore, a place that is synonymous with diversity, toleration and inclusiveness. It’s therefore a great shame that the so-called ‘Glastonbury Festival’ held on a field near the town in July every year, decided this year to allow one of its stages to be occupied by a group broadcasting (with the help of the BBC) ‘Jew-hate’ and encouraging violence. But then, as Holland notes, the monks of Glastonbury weren’t the last ‘company’ to discover that Arthur sells tickets. Part of the allure of the current Festival is that it takes place at a site which may have been linked to the Isle of Avalon, and still has the mud to prove it. Let’s hope that the true ‘Spirit of Glastonbury’ will return next year. After all, its essence is the story of Arthur, according to Malory, Rex quondam rexque futurus – ‘the once and future king’ who will return to restore peace and justice to his kingdom.
Sources:
George F. Jowett (1961), The Drama of the Lost Disciples. London: Covenant Publishing.
Tim Dowley (ed.) (1977), The History of Christianity. Berkhamsted: Lion Publishing.
William Anderson, Clive Hicks (1983), Holy Places of the British Isles: A Guide to the Legendary and Sacred Sites of the British Isles. London: Ebury Press.
Susan Hill (1994), The Spirit of Britain: An Illustrated Guide to Literary Britain. London: Headline Book Publishing (Hodder).
Tom Wright (2018), Paul: A Biography. London: SPCK.
Episode Six: End of Dynasty – Exit the Cerdicingas, Enter the Angevins:
Scene Sixty-four; October 1173 – The Battle of Fornham, Bury St Edmunds and the Revolt of 1173-74:
By the early 1170s, the king had already decided that, after his death, his dominions should be partitioned between his three eldest sons. Young Henry was to have Anjou, Normandy and England; Richard was to have Aquitaine, and Geoffrey was to have Brittany. However, in April 1173, a revolt began against King Henry’s efforts to find lands for his youngest legitimate son, Prince John. The Revolt occurred as a result, in part at least, of Henry II’s decision to offer three castles to John as part of an inheritance to secure his son’s marriage to the daughter of the Count of Maurienne. This undermined the claim of Henry the Young, the king’s eldest legitimate son, as the three castles chosen were on land that would have formed part of his inheritance. The fallout of this decision led to Henry’s three elder sons, Henry, Richard, and Geoffrey, withdrawing to the court of the French king and raising a rebellion against their father. Louis was Henry the Young’s father-in-law, and he encouraged the rebellion along with other nobles who would profit from a transfer of power to the would-be usurper. The brothers were also aided by their mother, Eleanor of Aquitaine, Henry II’s estranged wife, who joined the cause along with many others who had been horrified by the King’s possible complicity in the martyrdom of Archbishop Becket in 1170.
The rebellious sons and King Louis secured several allies and invaded Normandy, and the Scottish king invaded England. The invasions failed, and negotiations between the rebels and King Henry were started, but they did not result in peace until William the Lion agreed to a truce, which enabled Richard de Lucy and Humphrey de Bohun to hurry south to confront the invaders from Flanders.Robert de Beaumont (Blanchmains, ‘Whitehands’), third Earl of Leicester, had raised an army of three thousand Flemings against King Henry in support of his elder sons. After landing at Walton in Suffolk in late September and a failed attack on Dunwich, he marched his troops to Framlingham Castle, where Hugh Bigod welcomed them. After some inconclusive skirmishing, Robert decided to lead his men to his base at Leicester, but was prevented from doing so by royalist forces. His base came under attack from them, and needed reinforcement, but there was also some friction between de Beaumont and Bigod.
Mustering more troops and fortified by the sacking of Haughley Castle, they marched on to Bury. They were met at the village of Fornham All Saints by the King’s forces, soldiers who were bloodied and victorious over the Scots, led by Humphrey de Bohun, Lord High Constable, and Richard de Lucy, the Chief Justiciar. These forces also included three hundred mounted knights led by Roger Bigod, the son of the Earl of Norfolk, who, in opposition to his father, had remained loyal to the king. Along with those knights, the royal forces also had local levies and military retinues of the Earls of Gloucester, Arundel and Cornwall. They were also joined by the knights of the Abbot of Bury St Edmunds.
The battle was fought on 17th October 1173, the rebel forces of three thousand being led by Robert de Beaumont. They were caught fording the River Lark near the three neighbouring villages of Fornham St Genevieve, All Saints and St Martin, four miles north of Bury St Edmunds. The royalist barons intercepted Leicester’s army and brought out their forces in array against his troops. The Abbot’s forces were led by the banner of St Edmund the Martyr, carried by Roger Bigod. The Justiciar’s forces were already outside Bury St Edmunds, preventing Leicester’s further progress into England.The battle was sited in the valley of the River Lark near the church of St Genevieve, on the eastern side of the river. The Rebel Army, leaving Bury St Edmunds behind them, sought a river crossing, a causeway between the Fornham All Saints and Fornham St Genevieve. The King’s troops surprised Whitehands’ mercenaries, forcing them back to Fornham St Genevieve. Leicester, who reported that he could turn neither left nor right,
“saw the armed people approaching them … hauberks and helmets against the sun glinting,”
… and decided to accept battle. Many of the rebel troops were situated on marshy ground near the river, close by the church of St Genevieve. With his forces split, Leicester’s cavalry was captured, and his mercenaries were driven into nearby swamps, where the local peasants killed most of them. The river and the marshy ground accounted for many of the casualties, of whom…
“ …the greater part were killed, a certain number were drowned, a very few were taken away to undergo captivity… The prisoners of distinction were sent to the king in Normandy… but nearly the whole of the foot soldiers were killed, and many of the others were taken prisoner and put to death. … The prisoners of the low valley, King Henry disposed of according to his discretion. Many of the Flemings were killed, and many of the others taken prisoner (were) put to death.”
The battle itself was soon over, resulting in a decisive victory for the royalists. Probably over three thousand rebels were killed either in the battle or in the rout which followed along the banks of the River Lark. Thus, Whitehands’ entire force was either killed or taken prisoner, including Leicester himself and his wife, the Countess Petronilla de Grandmesnil, who had herself put on male armour. She was the great-granddaughter and heiress of Hugh de Grandmesnil, one of the proven companions of William the Conqueror, who fought at the Battle of Hastings. Jordan Fantsome, a chronicler, wrote that she fled the field, only to be found in a ditch. He credited her with dismissive remarks about the English who were fighting for the king:
“The English are great boasters, but poor fighters; they are better at quaffing great tankards and guzzling.”
She accompanied Earl Robert throughout his military campaign against the English troops under the command of the Earl of Arundel and Humphrey III de Bohun. During the final battle, Simon of Odell pulled her out of the ditch, where he claimed she was trying to drown herself, telling her:
“My lady, come away from this place, and abandon your design! War is all a question of losing and winning.”
She was reported as wearing male armour when captured, with a mail hauberk, a sword, and a shield. Earl Robert was also captured, and his holdings were confiscated. Countess Petronilla was released, but Leicester joined the other rebel leaders incarcerated at Falaise in Normandy, where he remained in captivity until 1177, when he was reinstated to his earldom and some of his lands were returned to him. He died in 1190 when returning from the crusades. Petronilla had married him in the mid-1150s and bore at least seven children, one of whom, Amice, was the mother of Simon de Montfort, the fifth Earl of Leicester.
The revolt did not end until 1174 with the capture of the King of Scots, William ‘the Lion’, at Alnwick in Cumbria. Henry II forced William to recognise his overlordship by the Treaty of Falaise (1174), and a century later, Edward I based his claim to interfere in Scottish affairs on this treaty. The Anglo-Scottish treaty was followed by the capitulation of Hugh Bigod and a general surrender at Northampton by the Earl of Derby and the remaining rebels, but the royalist victory at Fornham ended any serious threat to the security and stability of the realm.
Evidence of the Flemings’ brave final stand in St Genevieve’s church was found in the eighteenth century, when the bones of about forty of them were discovered lying head-to-head in a mound near the now ruined church. Its tower is fourteenth century, and so post-dates the battle. Despite many subsequent attempts to drain the land, the northern bank of the river shows extensive ponds and marshy stretches, indicating exactly the difficulties the fleeing Flemings would have faced.
Sixty-five, Canterbury, 1174 – The Advent of Gothic:
Despite his protestations of innocence concerning Becket’s murder, Henry made public penances. In 1174, he came to Canterbury to show his grief and to be lashed by bishops and monks present at Becket’s tomb. Later the same year, a great fire destroyed the choir of the cathedral, which had been built earlier in the century. The cathedral coffers were full enough from the offerings given to the shrine of St Thomas that the rebuilding of the choir could start almost immediately.
Canterbury Cathedral. The view westwards of the choir shows the high altar, and in the foreground, the opus alexandrinum mosaic work őn which the shrine of St Thomas stood.
The style of architecture chosen for the new choir at Canterbury, Gothic, was as important for the development of civilisation in Britain as the martyrdom of Becket was in its political and spiritual development. The style had made its first appearance in France at St-Denis, Chartres and Sens, where the first cathedral to be built wholly in the new style was begun in the 1130s. All the constructional elements – the ribbed vault, the pointed arch in the vault and the flying buttress, all of which were necessary for the development of the style, had been brought together in the high vaults in Durham, where the buttresses are nevertheless hidden by the aisle roofs.
Durham Cathedral: The interior of the nave, showing the alternation of round and shafted piers. The lozenge and chevron patterns on the round piers are both designs of great antiquity.
Durham: The Galilee or Lady Chapel of the cathedral, built in the Transitional style c. 1170, contains (right) the tomb of the Venerable Bede.
The Cistercians seized on the style for their later churches: For example, Kirkstall outside Leeds, containing many Gothic features from about 1150. The prestige of Canterbury as the primatial see of England and the shrine of a recent martyr ensured that the Gothic would, in the various stages of its development, be the style of church architecture for the next four hundred years in the British Isles, not just for great cathedrals and abbey churches, but also for the humbler parish churches.In the sculpture of the Gothic artists, there seemed to be a new visual presentation of the Christian idea of the worth of the individual soul. Stained-glass windows were made possible by the high vaulting and flying buttresses, employing sunlight and glass to depict Bible stories and the miracles of the saints, including St Thomas in one of the new windows in Canterbury Cathedral.
Canterbury: A miracle performed by St Thomas Becket is portrayed in one of the thirteenth-century stained-glass windows.
Scotland’s greatest surviving Gothic building was the cathedral of St Mungo in Glasgow. It was founded by David I in 1136 on the site of a cemetery that two hundred years earlier had been consecrated by St Ninian. The building was destroyed by fire and rebuilt in 1197. At St David’s in Wales, the interior of the nave was built under Bishop Leia between 1180 and 1198, and the building is an anthology of all the styles of all the styles from the Romanesque and Transitional to Tudor. The stone is a violet coloured sandstone quarried locally. Though built after the choir in Canterbury, it is still strongly Romanesque in style, but with pointed arches in the Gothic style. In the Middle Ages, two pilgrimages to St David’s were considered the equal of one to Rome.
Sixty-six: Chinon, July 1189; End of Reign – The Death and Legacy of Henry Plantagenet:
By the time of Becket’s martyrdom, the king had already decided that, after his death, his dominions should be partitioned between his three eldest sons. Young Henry was to have Anjou, Normandy and England; Richard was to have Aquitaine, and Geoffrey was to have Brittany. Later, in 1185, John was granted his father’s other major acquisition, Ireland. The death of young King Henry in 1183 and Geoffrey in 1186 should have eased Henry’s dynastic difficulties, but Richard was alarmed by his father’s obvious favouritism towards John. An alliance between Richard and King Philip II led to Henry’s defeat, and he died at Chinon in July 1189. Although his interest in rational reform has led to him being regarded as the founder of the English common law and a great, creative king, in his own eyes, these were matters of secondary importance. To him, personally, what mattered most were dynastic politics, and he died believing that in this, he had failed despite the successes of the previous thirty years.
But following his act of penance at the cathedral, Henry II ruled England for another fifteen years, long enough to see his embryonic legal system grow into a network of courts. Up and down the land, these new courts were to settle not just the usual disputes of blood and mayhem, but all manner of painful rows over inheritances, estates and property. Most importantly, Henry II revived and reorganised his grandfather’s Curia Regis and developed the justice system by sending itinerant justices around the country. These judges followed the laws which applied to the whole country instead of local customs, and so improved on the old methods of trying a case. They invited witnesses to help settle disputes, and tried criminals presented to them by local groups of men who were responsible for finding offenders. Justice in the King’s Court was better than that of the baron’s court or the shire court; the use of trial by jury was an improvement on the Saxon method of trial by ordeal or the Norman method of trial by battle. By the end of his reign, England was so well organised as a kingdom that even in the absence of Richard I (1189-99) on the Crusades, order was maintained.
The death of young King Henry, officially the next king of England, in 1183, and Geoffrey in 1186, should have eased Henry’s dynastic difficulties, but Richard, Coeur de Lion, the Lionheart, physically brave, chivalrous and brutally ambitious, was alarmed by his father’s obvious favouritism towards John. He was the youngest, vindictive, self-serving, but undoubtedly clever. Henry saw in him the only one capable of governing well. Eleanor pinned her hopes on Richard and encouraged an alliance between Richard and her husband’s bitterest enemy, the French King, Philip II, which led to Henry’s defeat in battle, and he died at Chinon in July 1189.Although Henry’s interest in rational reform has led to him being regarded as the founder of the English common law and a great, creative king, in his own eyes, these were matters of secondary importance. To him, personally, what mattered most were dynastic politics, and he died believing that in this, and through all the quarrels that beset his family, he had ultimately failed despite the successes of the first thirty years of his reign in England.
Henry II was certainly one of the outstanding rulers of the Middle Ages in Europe. He not only possessed vast lands in France, but he also pacified the principalities and marches of Wales, and drove mercenary soldiers from England, as well as pulling down the castles unlawfully built by over-mighty barons in Stephen’s reign. He also became lord of part of Ireland, which, in 1185, he granted to Prince John. He was determined to make the king’s power so strong that the barons could no longer disturb the peace of the land. By his system of scutage, he allowed the barons to give money instead of military service, a plan which enabled the king to hire soldiers on whom he could depend, and at the same time weakened the barons, who no longer trained so many knights. He also reorganised the Saxon fyrds and prevented the barons from becoming sheriffs in the counties in which they held their lands.
Epilogue I – The Green Tree and the Holy Rood:
The Green Tree of Edward the Confessor’s deathbed dream was seen by contemporary chroniclers as a prophetic vision of the kingdom traumatised by the Conquest. Its restoration should have come by the 1170s, but the tree had not been fully restored to its former self and much of it was barely recognisable, for a wholly new stock had been grafted onto the severed trunk. England’s aristocracy, its attitudes and its architecture had all been transformed by the coming of the Normans. The body of the tree, too, had been twisted into new forms. The laws of the kingdom, its language, its customs, and institutions were clearly not the same as they had been before. Even so, anyone looking at these new forms could see in a second that their origins were English. By the 1170s, English had clearly become the language spoken by all classes in England, whatever their ancestry. Intermarriage had blurred the lines of national identity. Yet it was still clear that the unfree peasants were English and that the upper echelons of the aristocracy who still held lands in Normandy were French.Butalthough the English landscape was studded with Norman castles, it was still a land of shires, hundreds, hides, and boroughs. The branches were new, but the roots remained ancient. The tree had survived the trauma by becoming a hybrid. Against all expectations, its sap was once again rising.
When Edward I invaded Scotland in 1297-98, he seized Agatha’s black cross, falsely claiming it as one of the English crown jewels and took it into England. Robert the Bruce so vehemently demanded its restoration that Queen Isabella yielded it up on the pacification during her regency in 1327. The following year, Edward III signed the Treaty of Northampton, recognising Robert Bruce as the King of an independent Scotland.But the symbols of the House of Wessex were to play one further role in the formation of the medieval kingdoms of England and Scotland. David I (1124-53) established Norman barons on both sides of the border and introduced Norman feudal customs to Scotland, besides building abbeys and castles. When the House of Dunkeld died out following the death of Alexander III (1249-86), Edward declared that he had the right to decide on the successor.
Edward ‘Longshanks’ (as he was known to the Scots) chose John Balliol, whom he expected to obey him as if he were an English baron. When Balliol refused this, Edward invaded and defeated him at Dunbar in 1296. He then dethroned Balliol and governed Scotland as if it were a vassal state of England. Under William Wallace, the Scots fought back, taking Stirling Castle in 1297. However, after his victory at Falkirk the following year, Edward seized on Ágota’s black cross, falsely claiming it as one of the English crown jewels, and took it into England.The Scots regained their independence in 1314 following the Battle of Bannockburn, and Robert the Bruce, their new leader, so vehemently demanded the restoration of the Black Cross that Queen Isabella yielded it up on the pacification during her regency in 1327. The following year, Edward III signed the Treaty of Northampton, recognising Robert Bruce as the King of an independent Scotland.
Rievaulx, North Yorkshire. A view from the north aisle of the thirteenth-century choir, looking towards the south transept.
According to Bishop Turgot, drawing on the Bollandists (vol. xxi, p. 335), the seventeenth-century Jesuit order that collected objects and information relating to the lives of the saints, the Black Cross was enclosed in a black case, whence it was called the Black Cross. The cross itself was of gold and set with large diamonds. Aelred of Riveaux described it as about an ell long (= a cubit, the combined length of the forearm from the ‘elbow’ to the middle finger-tip of the extended hand, the Scottish ‘ell’ being 37 ins or 94 cm),
‘… manufactured in pure gold, of most wonderful workmanship, and may be shut and opened like a chest. Inside is seen a portion of our Lord’s Cross (as has often been proved by convincing miracles), having a figure of our Saviour sculptured out of massive ivory, and marvellously adorned with gold. Queen Margaret had brought this with her to Scotland, and handed it down as an heirloom to her sons; and the youngest of them, David, when he became king, built a magnificent church for it near the city, called Holy-Rood.’
A section of Gisela’s black cross, brought to Britain by Ágota, wife of Edward the Exile and mother of St Margaret of Scotland.
All this was the result of David’s continued development of the Norman methods begun by his parents, together with those he had learnt at the court of Henry I of England and Matilda of Scotland. Besides the new monastic foundations, his appointment of Anglo-French bishops further strengthened Scotland’s independent links with the continent. Above all, the Norman military machine of knights and castles, the use of sheriffs and the expansion of trade served as the basis for the expansion of royal power and a strong Scottish economy in the thirteenth century.
St Margaret as depicted in the window of her chapel in Edinburgh Castle.
In the early modern period, lowland Scots tended to trace the origins of their culture to the marriage of Malcolm II to Margaret of Wessex. David left a Scotland which, though more ethnically diverse than England and Wales, was more united, with a series of able monarchs who continued to improve its administrative and military mechanisms. Following David’s example, they relied on the support of the Church in the formation of states, rather than on ethnic homogeneity. Though the authority of kings over much of their kingdom, especially Galloway, the Highlands and the Isles, was limited, the fertile central belt was under secure control.
Epilogue II: Romancing the British Monarchies – An Empire from the Pennines to the Pyrenees:
William I, William II, Henry I (bottom left) and Stephen (right) – the Norman dynasty; from a fourteenth-century manuscript.
The actual empire of Henry I had consisted mainly of England, Normandy, Wales and Brittany. The actual empire of Henry II extended, in a contemporary yet historic phrase, from the Pennines to the Pyrenees.When he came to the throne of England, adding the dominions held by Stephen, Normandy, Anjou and Aquitaine, it seemed that the dynastic dream could be accomplished within his reign. The dominant idea of the Plantagenet Henry II’s reign was to gradually extend the frontiers of the Anglo-Cymric-Norman-Breton empire until the descendants of the Conqueror of England would become the emperors of Christendom.It was the lack of cohesion between the various constituent parts of the empire which was the greatest peril to that dream. Lucy Allen Paton wrote in her 1911 introduction to Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Histories of the Kings of Britain,
If only Norman and Englishman, Welshman and Breton, could be induced to work together in the common interest of the Empire, there was no limit to the potentialities of its future greatness. The restoration of an Empire mightier and broader than that of Charlemagne, nay, even that of Augustus, was no impossibility, but a practical aim, towards the attainment of which all the resources known to the statecraft of the time should be directed.
… Geoffrey… was inspired by Henry… Henry, indeed, was no Augustus, and Geoffrey was far enough from being a Virgil, but in this respect the relations between the Roman emperor and the Mantuan poet were strictly analogous to those existing between the Norman king and the Welsh romancer.
To Sebastian Evans, as translator, Geoffrey’s book was an epic that failed, for it was to have been the national epic of an empire that failed. When, in the next generation, King John lost Normandy and most of France in the early years of the thirteenth century, the Angevin empire came to an abrupt end in western Europe. Arthur, the romantic creation of Geoffrey, who was set to have been the traditional hero of the Anglo-Norman-British nucleus of that western empire, became a detached national hero, a purely literary, mythological figure to the early modern British who had forgotten the short-lived empire that had created him.
For Lucy Allen-Paton as well, the Historia is not a chronicle or a history, but a romance based on early British histories, combining his historical, legendary and mythological material with interest and ingenuity. Geoffrey raised a national hero, Arthur of the Britons, already the centre of myth and legend, to the rank of an imperial monarch, substituting for early British stories and customs those of Anglo-Norman England. In doing so, he provided a model of knightly and kingly custom and practice and a dignified place in literature to popular national narrative, determining the form of the romantic chronicle for many centuries to come.
Glastonbury: The ruins of the thirteenth-century crossing of the abbey church, with, on the left, part of the nave.
Glastonbury in Somerset had long been associated with the legendary Arthur and Guinevere, and it came to be identified as the Isle of Avalon (Ynys yr Afal in Welsh, ‘the Isle of the Apple’) to which Arthur was borne by three black-robed queens after his last battle with Mordred. This association of Glastonbury with Arthur may have been why Eadmund Ironside was buried there, not at Winchester, in 1016.It later received a great boost in 1191 when a monk of the abbey, inspired by a vision, claimed to have discovered the coffin of the legendary king and queen. The coffin was said to have been inscribed with the words: Here lies the famous King Arthur, buried in the island of Avalon. When it was opened, it was found to contain the skeletons of the royal couple. The blonde tresses of Guinevere’s hair were said to be intact and still shining golden, though they crumbled to dust in the hand of the monk. This was clearly an invented story, not least because Arthur, the Welsh guerilla leader, had not gained widespread fame by the early sixth century, when he was supposed to have lived and died.
Glastonbury Tor, Somerset. A natural mound carved with a spiritual path of ascent around it, which some have said was a ritual path of initiation going back to the Bronze Age. On top of the mound is the fifteenth-century tower of St Michael’s Church.
Another ‘Arthurian’ site visible from the ‘Tor’ at Glastonbury is the hillfort of South Cadbury, traditionally associated with Arthur’s Camelot. It is an Iron Age fort reoccupied and fortified not only in the Brythonic period but also in later Anglo-Saxon times. The sites associated with the legendary Arthur range from Tintagel in Cornwall, an important Celtic monastery, to Arthur’s Seat in Edinburgh.Whatever we may make of such stories and associations, their attractiveness in the late twelfth century is testimony to the continuing popularity of the Arthurian literature and legendarium of the time. They derive from traditions and beliefs going far back into the pre-Christian era, seen through the screen of medieval chivalric society. The Arthur of South Cadbury, who defeated the advancing pagan Saxons at the great battle of Mons Badonicus sometime between 494 and 515, fought somewhere between Bath and Swindon, must, by nature of the topographical and archaeological evidence, have been more parochial and provincial in his outlook. Nevertheless, by the beginning of the Plantagenet period, he would seem to have become a figure symbolising the defence of Christian civilisation and the establishment of kingly rule based on justice and compassion.
South Cadbury, Somerset. A view showing a rampart of the Iron Age hillfort, a site containing a Celtic temple with ritual pits. Traditionally the site of Arthur’s Camelot, South Cadbury was refortified in late Roman times and at the start of the Dark Ages.
Despite these heroic allusions, however, the down-to-earth chronicler William of Newburgh,writing in about 1200, after the king died in 1189, noted of Henry II that he was unpopular with almost all men in his days. This may have had something to do with his infamous early conflict with the Church, but it may also have been because, although he was king for thirty-four years, he was also Duke of Normandy and Count of Anjou; he therefore spent only thirteen of them in England. He held more lands in France than its king, while England’s wealth enabled him to outshine the German emperor. Through marriage, inheritance, diplomacy, and occasionally war, Henry II built up a huge domain, and he extended his sovereignty to Scotland and Ireland, as well as to much of Wales.
The seal of Henry II as Duke of Normandy and Count of Aquitaine. The Angevins ruled their French lands not as kings of England but as vassals of the kings of France. Seals were attached to documents as evidence of authenticity.
His marriage to Eleanor of Aquitaine brought him control over most of southwest France. Combined with the Norman and Angevin inheritance, this made him the most powerful ruler in France, more so than his suzerain (feudal lord) for these French territories, Louis VII, king of France. In Britain, the Scottish frontier was settled in 1157, making Cumbria and Northumbria definitively part of England. Besides campaigning actively in Wales, making the whole of it a vassal state, Henry intervened in Ireland in 1171. Following a papal bull of 1155 from the English pope, Adrian IV, he established the new lordship of Ireland, based on Dublin, creating a large royal demesne for himself, which became known as ‘the Pale’. From this, he bound the Anglo-Norman barons and most of the native Irish kings to him.
Henry spent twenty-one years on the continent. For both him and Eleanor, England was a social and cultural backwater compared with the French parts of the Angevin dominion. The prosperous communities in the valleys of the Seine, Loire and Garonne river systems were centres of learning, art, architecture, poetry and music. Aquitaine and Anjou produced two essential commodities of medieval commerce: wine and salt. These could be exchanged for English cloth, and this trade must have brought great profit to Henry as the prince who ruled over both producers and consumers of these products. As duke of Normandy, duke of Aquitaine, and count of Anjou, Henry had inherited the claims of his predecessors to lordship over neighbouring territories. These claims led to the occupation of Brittany after 1166 and the installation of his son Geoffrey as duke. However, he failed to give his short-lived empire any institutional unity. It therefore collapsed under his sons, Richard and John. At the time of his death, in 1216, John had lost all of the Angevin lands on the continent except Gascony.
The population of north-western Europe had expanded to a point unsurpassed since the Celtic migrations of the fourth century BCE. The revival and spread of the Arthurian legends in the eleventh century, when legends, myths, and symbols from the Celtic and Romano-British past were revived and transfigured in the Renaissance of the ancient Bear God as Arthur, the Godly Christian prince, led to a growth in the self-confidence of Plantagenet England and Wales. The entire iconography of the House of Wessex, from the story of Offa’s bloodied sword to Agatha’s black cross and Edward’s Green Tree, is a forgotten thread, not just of a romantic royal chronicle, but of the British national narrative.
Whitby Abbey, North Yorkshire, at sunset.
Appendix – The Gesta Hungarorum and Central Europe in the Twelfth Century:
Across Europe, in the birthplace of the children of the House of Wessex, Hungary, the memory of the English exiles and their influence at court had faded by the mid-twelfth century, in the wake of the Crusades and the movement of the Germans, Rus and other Slavs to the East. The marauding raids of the Hungarians had ended more than a century before. But continual internal instability increased the danger of Pecheneg invasions, and the Hungarians had changed from thieves into gendarmes. Géza I (1074-77) finally reconciled the parties by accepting the Pechenegs into the country, boosting his military power against the ousted but still unsubdued former King Solomon.
The use of written documents spread in governance and administration as slowly as in ordinary legal affairs. Verbal agreements witnessed and administered by the bailiff in common lawsuits or contracts, and political decisions sanctioned by the memory of courtly memory alone, rather than by officially sealed documents, survived well into the twelfth century. A few official documents were irregularly issued by the priests of the court chapel until, in 1181, King Béla III emphasised the indispensable use of writing, leading to the rise of the chancellery. Following this example, from about 1200 private individuals soon began to have their transactions, agreements recorded at the ‘place of authentication’ – hiteleshely – an office with notarial functions, usually at chapter houses or abbeys.
This change in the political and legal culture would have been inconceivable without increasing familiarity with Western learning through diplomatic and commercial ties, in addition to academic links. Luke, Archbishop of Esztergom after 1158, attended the studium generále in Paris as early as 1150. The rediscovery of Roman law in the twelfth century in Europe not only supplied a framework in which the complex realities of vassalage, the manorial system or urban liberties could be lucidly expressed, but also facilitated the modernisation of primitive early medieval monarchies by re-introducing abstract notions of state and subject, and of mutual rights and obligations between them.
Many of these notions appeared in some shape or form in contemporary Hungary, but there were fundamental differences in how they arose in Western Europe and Hungary. In the West, from Germany to Britain, these resulted from successive stages in a more or less organic development that lasted several centuries. In Hungary, these structures resulted to a large degree from an organised response to historical challenges; initially from legislative and political action which, due to the powerful monarchs of the House of Árpád, especially István, Ladislas I and Coloman, compelled a semi-nomadic society to observe property relations and Christian values.
In the late eleventh and twelfth centuries, the fundamental class distinction in Hungarian society was still not that between the titled nobleman and the peasant serf, but between the freeman (‘liber’) and the ‘servant’ (‘szervus’). Neither of these had a legally defined, hereditary status. The ruling class was undoubtedly the aristocracy of ‘the great’ (maiores), the king’s retinue who comprised his council or ‘senate’ and were of very varied origins.Descendants of Stephen’s conforming chieftains, as well as those of foreign courtiers arriving with the rulers’ consorts – Bavarians under István, Kyívans under András, Poles under Béla, Swabians under Ladislas, Sicilian Normans under Coloman – all belonged to this most prestigious, but still non-hereditary caste. Beneath them were the jobbágy warriors of the king’s court and castles, his retinue of ecclesiastical and secular lords, and the civil ministers. However, while these strata were liber in an economic sense, their freedom of movement was restricted; the requirement of loyalty bound them to the estate of their overlord. The peasant cultivators were relegated to a servile status, though their obligations varied greatly between locations and estates of differing types (ecclesiastical, secular and royal).
In 1083, Ladislas began a campaign of canonisation, having several Polish and Hungarian divines elevated to sainthood, including Bishop Gerald (Gellért), who was martyred during the pagan uprising of 1046, and King István (Stephen) I. In this way, he also certified Hungary’s integral presence as a European Christian nation, issuing a warning to the remaining followers of pagan rites. He later gained for himself the glory he obtained for others, though he did little deserving of it. His daughter, Piroska (Irene), also became a saint of the Eastern Church. But the tenacity of pagan traditions remained firm throughout the Middle Ages and even into modern times. Making room for several waves of Pechenegs and Cumans meant that, although the pagan population underwent baptism, it did not become truly Christian for many generations.Ladislas I’s successor was his nephew, Coloman Beauclerc, whose first wife was a Sicilian Norman princess. In the first year of his reign, 1096, the challenges of the Crusaders’ armies reached Hungary one after the other, and were either defeated or sent on their way. The ten-year reign of Béla II (1131-1141) was threatened from Poland by a pretender to the Hungarian throne, Boris, who was thought to be the illegitimate son of Coloman’s second wife, Euphemia, from the new Rus principality of Suzdal.
Germany, 1179 – Emerging Dynasties.
The eighteen-year reign of Ladislas I began in 1077 after Solomon fled to a group who had taken the place of the Pechenegs, the Cumans, and perished in one of their incursory campaigns. For Ladislas, the Germans formed a more immediate threat than Rome; for this reason, he sided with the pope, although he did not submit to the feudal authority of the papacy in place of that of the Emperor, Henry IV, the brother-in-law of Solomon. The laws of Ladislas attest to both the continuity and change in Hungarian society. The legal system that evolved was very different from that of the Conquest period, based on entirely different views of private property and the value of life.The Conquerors were probably more steadfast in their morality in the ninth and tenth centuries than their eleventh-century descendants, based on the completely different values and customs they had brought with them from the steppes. The relationship between slaves and freemen in the early Middle Ages in Hungary was different among the semi-nomadic peoples of the steppes from that in post-imperial Rome. Similarly, when the feudal system appeared and gathered strength in Hungary, through the laws of Ladislas and his successors, the kind of feudalism that came into being was not the same as that established in Western Europe, nor was it like that which became institutionalised in the east.
1180: Crusader Europe – Central and Eastern Europe.
Throughout the period as a whole, German peasant settlement expanded eastward, especially in Saxony and Brandenburg, putting pressure on the Slavic peoples. The centre of Rus activity continued to move towards the forest belt. A new principality, Suzdal, developed in this area, while further east, in 1126, Novgorod became a republic and soon extended its territory to the White Sea. In 1169, Kyív was sacked by Suzdal and the title of Grand Prince was transferred to its ruler, the Grand Prince of Vladimir, Suzdal’s capital.
Across Europe and the Near East, the Crusades demonstrated that Christendom could take the initiative: they were as important for relations with Eastern Europe, especially Byzantium, as for those with the Islamic world. Crusading activity played a crucial role at the margins of Europe, and activity against pagan peoples in the Baltic was seen in the context of Crusading. In 1147, the Wends, a Slavic people in north-west Germany, were attacked by the Danes, Saxons and Poles. But these campaigns were as much spurred on by demographic pressures as by religious zeal.In 1144, most of the County of Edessa, captured by the crusaders in 1098, was lost to the Turks. This inspired the Second Crusade, but that led only to an unsuccessful attack on Damascus in 1148. Then, in 1187, Jerusalem and most of the Crusading states were lost by the Christians after Saladin’s crushing victory at Hattin. The Crusades also inspired a novel form of monastic organisation that had political overtones: the Military Orders. The Templars and Hospitallers had troops and castles and were entrusted with defending large tracts of territory across Palestine.
The Gesta Hungarorum (c.1210) was a chivalric romance of the Magyar conquest of the Carpathian Basin in which the adoption of Christianity was an undercurrent comparable to the knightly exploits of the chiefs from whom the contemporary noble houses were supposed to have descended. Of the orders of knighthood, the Hospitallers and the Knights Templar appeared in Hungary before the mid-twelfth century, while the Teutonic Order was invited by Andrew II in 1211 for purposes of defence and to convert the pagan Cumans.Despite the chivalric awakening, the outlook of literature and culture in general was predominantly ecclesiastic. Codices recording legends of saints, rites and monastery annuals of Benedictine abbeys constitute the bulk of this heritage. Besides the Benedictines, the representatives of the reform movement within traditional monasticism, the Cistercians and the Premonstratensians, first arrived in Hungary in the 1140s. Education was a monopoly of the Church. There were no seats of higher learning in the country, and even secondary education was only available in schools maintained by the more important chapter houses and monasteries. It was only at the most prestigious school in Veszprém that law was taught beside the liberal arts.
King Coloman’s son, the restless István II (1116-1131), fought a war in almost every year of his fifteen-year reign. During that time, Dalmatia was lost to Venice, then recovered and lost again; unsuccessful wars against neighbours, including Bohemia, Russia and Byzantium made a group of barons attempt to depose him, which he survived, but leaving no heir, he was succeeded by the blinded son of Prince Álmos, Béla II (1131-1141). The chief events of this reign were the ruthless showdown with those held responsible for his and his father’s suffering, and the defeat of the pretender Boris, who was the son of Coloman’s Russian wife expelled because of adultery, and invited to the country by the remnants of the opposition to Béla’s rule.Géza II (1141-62) was certainly powerful enough to afford, in the early 1150s, the pursuit of an aggressive foreign policy and waging a two-front war against Byzantium and Russia, while also being on hostile terms with the Holy Roman Empire. The reign of Géza’s son, Stephen III (1162-72) was a decade of conflict over the succession between him and his uncles, also crowned as Ladislas II (1162-63) and Stephen IV (1163-65) and, after both of them died, against Manuel, who had supported them. In 1169, however, Manuel’s son was born, and he supported the Hungarian prince in obtaining the throne of the country when it became vacant in 1172.
King Béla III (1172-96) overcame the resistance of the Church, whose head, Archbishop Luke, a Hungarian counterpart of Thomas Becket, took a strongly papalist stance in the renewed debate between secular and spiritual power. The Archbishop was also afraid of an Orthodox influence upon the accession of a prince brought up in Byzantium. Béla ruled over the Kingdom of Hungary at the height of its power during the Árpád period. Nevertheless, the Church jealously preserved a considerable degree of autonomy, to the extent that it became one of the chief vehicles of the development towards a system of estates.
But chroniclers were not only concerned with great powers and principalities, but also with the life history of peoples. It was hardly coincidental, though, that the youngest nation in Europe came into being and survived under Árpád’s descendants. A sweeping economic and social transformation took place in Hungary, resulting in part from the conscious intervention of the rulers and their councillors, and partly from the automatism of accommodation within Europe.With the new circumstances of ownership, rank and social strata following the disintegration of the system based on joint families and clans, the new leading classes, the ispáns and other officials, were soon dissatisfied with the privileges. Instead, because the separate and private possession of land was so important to royal supremacy, they also aimed at acquiring landed estates that would be under their permanent control. At the same time, the Hungarian serfs were still a privileged group compared to the servant class; they inherited much from the position they enjoyed as auxiliary troops in the age of the Conquest. During domestic conflicts, they supported an independent kingship, opposing foreign feudal dependency and the foreign knights on whom the claimants to the throne relied.
For a long time, the larger animals – horses and cattle – served as the most valuable resource and even as a standard of wealth among Hungarians. The minting of the coinage, which began by István I’s reign, transformed the economy and gave new impetus to the extraction of precious metals, and the role of various monopolies became stronger; commerce in salt and horses, mining, the ownership of customs stations, and income from fish ponds.The two major cities, Esztergom and Székesfehérvár, developed significantly, though the royal court itself continued to travel not just between the two capitals, but also from place to place to consume produce gathered in at some of the larger market towns. The export of horses was the sole state monopoly as regards agricultural products. The horse was also an important weapon of war at this time, and the subject of cattle export can also be found in the laws.
By the mid-twelfth century, the development of one basis for the envied wealth of medieval Hungary had begun in Transylvania and Upper Hungary: the extensive and highly profitable panning and mining of gold, silver and copper was continually re-regulated as to ownership and economic rights. At times, the nearly monopolistic position in the production and export of copper brought about enormous economic advantages for the nation, the king and the producers themselves, who were in a privileged position.It was not only the domestic growth that increased the size of the population, but also the settlers of varying ranks and orders streaming into Hungary from every direction to take advantage of its relative safety and even-handed treatment. For example, there was a large Ishmaelite Muslim population, who were able to practice their religion in comparative freedom and were obligated to serve the king only in case of war and only then against a non-Mohammedan enemy. Though often at war over Dalmatia, Venice and Hungary concluded an agreement allowing the free movement of merchants between them, and within Hungary, only the king dared collect taxes, arousing admiration from other European rulers.
The growth of urban communities with self-government in Hungary was largely a matter of the second half of the second half of the thirteenth century. Before 1150, it was only a few French and Walloon communities, and after that date, Flemish and Saxon settlers or hospites (guests) who moved into the cities of Székesfehérvár and Esztergom, or established their own towns that were endowed with privileges, thus becoming liberae villae, constituting the first type of western-style urban development. The Romanians were employed as frontier guards by the Hungarian kings and contributed to the increasingly multi-cultural nature of the kingdom.
Hungarian society at this time, amorphous and ethnically mixed as it was, seems to have lived in relatively prosperous conditions, according to the contemporaneous accounts of foreign authors. Otto, Bishop of Freising, and Abu-Hamid, a Muslim traveller from Grenada, visited the country around 1150, and in roughly the same period, the court geographer of King Roger II of Sicily also reported on it in his well-known description of the world, drawing on the first-hand reports of Italian merchants. Whether sympathetic or hostile towards the land and its people, it is described by all of them as one of plenty and prosperity with cheap corn, rich gold mines, busy fairs and affluent inhabitants.
While it was an exaggerated and stereotypical image, it may not have been entirely separated from reality. Then, as later, the country suffered relatively little from famine, which regularly afflicted the populations of Western Europe. Besides having a comparatively sparse population and abundant natural resources, the Hungarians’ far greater reliance on stockbreeding and fishing meant that they were also far less dependent on the vicissitudes of the weather and the cultivation of crops.In the eleventh and early twelfth centuries, the traditional distinction between freedom and serfdom depended on birth, but by the mid-century, status in the emerging manorial system became the decisive criterion, without the relations that arose within this new framework being consolidated into hereditary terms. In both temporal and spatial contexts, this was a transitory stage, to which the ambivalent nature of political institutions corresponded.
In the six decades following the reign of Béla the Blind, certain motifs returned: disputes around the throne, military campaigns with mixed success, and crusaders marching across the land. But on balance, there was much to be positive about in the reign of Béla III. His first wife was Anne de Chátillon (of Antioch), who, though of French descent, actually arrived at court via Byzantium. His second was Margaret Capet of the Capetian monarchy in France. These two women introduced the French style at the court, where Frederick Barbarossa was received in a manner worthy of his rank. With the king as their example, the barons increasingly followed the fashion trends of Western Europe, which to no small extent contributed to Hungary’s participation in world commerce.
The tomb of Béla III and his wife, Anne Chátillon (of Antioch), in the Matthias Church in Buda. Although of French descent, Béla brought Anne with him from Byzantium. They shared a tomb in Székesfehérvár, but the royal tombs there were ransacked, and most were destroyed beyond recognition. However, the well-preserved remains of Béla and Anne were moved to Buda in 1848.
The majority of landed property in the Kingdom of Hungary throughout the twelfth century remained in the possession of the king, whose authority was still preponderant. According to the testimony of a Paris manuscript of around 1185, the king’s revenues from the monopolies on precious metals, on the minting of coinage and salt, from customs on fairs and river tolls, and taxes from the counties, equalled and perhaps surpassed those in France and England. The patrimonial basis of the Western countries’ economic power was far from that of the King of Hungary. When considered in isolation, the Paris document indicates the efficient functioning of the system of royal counties, the chief units of administration of levying taxes and of raising troops in the country. The military force from the countries alone might have amounted to thirty thousand.
Major decisions were made by the king upon consultation with the royal council, consisting of prelates, court office holders and the ispans of the counties, a body of considerable and indefinite size, which, however, hardly ever convened in full number because of the constant movement of the royal household from manor to manor. Increasing familiarity with Western learning through diplomatic, commercial, and academic ties gradually spread to governance, legal affairs, and administration. Luke, Archbishop of Esztergom after 1158, attended the stadium generale in Paris as early as 1150. In 1177, the Abbot of St Genevieve there reported to Béla III the death of a Hungarian student called Bethlehem, who studied at the university there in the company of three of his countrymen. We also know of a Nicholas of Hungary, a student at Oxford in the early 1190s; together with many other clerics who studied in Paris, Padova and Bologna, which were also popular among Hungarian students into the early modern period.These clerics, as well as the knights arriving in the retinues of queens from western dynasties, were also instrumental in introducing courtly and chivalric culture in Hungary.
The Provencále troubadour Peire Vidal and the German Tannhauser were welcomed at the court of King Imre. The virtues of the knights of the Holy Grail, the valour of the Nibelungs, the blending of gallantry and devotion displayed by troubadours thus became models for young Hungarian nobles, and some of them adopted celebrated the names of Frankish heroes such as Roland and Oliver as well as Alexander or Philip of Macedon who also became idolised in the chivalric ethos.
Against this background of the social and cultural conditions of Hungary in the twelfth century, the political situation in the country began to change dramatically by the end of the century. The system created by István I was gradually replaced by an era in which periods of powerful central government alternated with those of unstable royal authority, caused either by continuing dynastic conflict over succession or by internecine aristocratic strife. In the early decades of the twelfth century, the country faced Byzantine or German interference in its affairs because of conflict within the House of Árpád, which supplied the pretext and opportunity for two great emperors, Manuel Komnenos and Frederick Barbarossa, to attempt to bring the nascent country within their spheres of influence.
THE HOLY ROMAN EMPIRE IN THE TWELFTH CENTURY
The growth in the power of Hungary was the most important development to the north of the Byzantine Empire in the twelfth century. After having fended off the attempts of Emperor Manuel I to conquer the Kingdom, Hungary counter-attacked following his death in 1180. The Hungarians gained not only southern Croatia and Bosnia but also seized a frontier zone in the vicinity of Belgrade.This consolidation during Béla’s reign was largely due to the increase of royal revenues and the growth of the chancellery. Also, the rise of the chivalric culture in this time in Hungary certainly owed a great deal to the way that the knightly code of honour was adopted from the West in the court of the innovative Manuel where Béla had been educated, and that his second wife was the French Princess Margaret, daughter of King Louis VII.
Béla’s Hungarian knights recovered Dalmatia and Syrmia from Byzantium and the fact that he assumed the role of mediator in the conflict between the German and Byzantine emperors occasioned by the march of the crusaders of Frederick Barbarossa across the East Roman Empire in 1190, together with the dynastic links established with Byzantium, France, Germany and Aragon during his reign, demonstrate the international importance of Hungary at the end of the twelfth century. The late twelfth century was also a period of fermentation in architectural styles, based on the late eleventh-century high Romanesque of Lombard extraction. The most splendid accomplishments of this in Hungary were the Cathedral of Pécs and the Basilica of Székesfehérvár. In 1190, French master builders arrived in Esztergom and launched the first Gothic workshop in Central Europe.
Conclusion: The Westernisation of Hungary
During the time of its earliest kings, the Europeanisation of the House of Árpád, Eastern in its origin, was, in addition to its adoption of occidental Roman Christianity, represented by the invitation extended to illustrious foreigners and their acceptance into the royal court. In the eleventh century, this was best exemplified by the presence of the exiled royal family of the ancient line of Cerdicingas from Wessex. In the twelfth century, the later members of the House of Árpád increasingly mingled their bloodline through inter-dynastic marriages, and also took over many customs and ways of thought prevailing at the courts of the ruling houses of Western Europe.
THE HOUSE OF ÁRPÁD AND DYNASTIC INTERMARRIAGE IN THE TWELFTH AND THIRTEENTH CENTURIES. The map above shows the places of origin of Hungarian queens in the period of the Árpád Dynasty. (After Alán Kralovánszky).
Thus, the concepts and material accessories of the Age of Chivalry appeared, mirroring Western Europe, at the Hungarian courts. Though posterity called (Saint) Ladislas the chivalric king, that process began earlier and lasted at least until the Angevin period of the fourteenth century. The advent of the House of Anjou to Hungary represented a further stage in the Hungarians’ incorporation into Europe. European influence grew so much stronger in Hungary that the spirit of the chivalric age flowed into it. In exchange, Hungarian influence extended to every point of the compass, including the furthest reaches of the West, in the successive centuries of the High Middle Ages.
Published Primary/ Main Secondary Sources:
Sándor Fest (Czigány & Korompay, eds., 2000), Skóciai Szent Margittól a Walesi Bárdokig: Anglo-Hungarian Historical and Literary Contacts. Budapest: Universitas Kiado.
Christian Raffensperger, Ties of Kinship: Genealogy and Dynastic Marriage in Kyivan Rus. (Harvard Series in Ukrainian Studies.) Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press for the Ukrainian Research Institute, 2016.
Christian Raffensperger, Conflict, Bargaining, and Kinship Networks in Medieval Eastern Europe. (Byzantium: A European Empire and Its Legacy 2.) New York and London: Lexington Books, 2018.
András Bereznay, et. al. (2003), The Times History of Europe: Three Thousand Years of History in Maps. London, Times Books: (Harper Collins).
Simon Keyes, Seán Duffy, and Andrew Jotischky (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British and Irish History. London, Penguin Books.
István Bart (1999), Hungary and the Hungarians: The Keywords. Budapest: Corvina Books.
David Smurthwaite (1984), The Ordnance Survey Complete Guide to the Battlefields of Britain. Exeter, Webb and Bower.
Peter Rex (2013), Hereward. Stroud, Glos; Amberley Books.
Charles Hopkinson, Martin Speight (2002, 2009), The Mortimers, Lords of the March. Herefordshire: Logaston Press.
István Lázár (1989), An Illustrated History of Hungary. Budapest, Corvina Books.
László Kontler (2009), A History of Hungary. Budapest, Atlantisz Publishing House.
Tom Holland (2009), Millennium: The End of the World and the Forging of Christendom. London: Abacus Books.
Simon Schama (2003), A History of Britain, Series One. London: BBC.
William Anderson (1983), Holy Places of the British Isles. A guide to the legendary and sacred sites. London: Ebury Press.
Episode Five – The King’s Peace and Justice; 1153-93:
When Henry Plantagenet returned to England again at the start of 1153, bringing only a small army of mercenaries financed with borrowed money, he relied on the forces of Hugh Bigod and Ranulf of Chester. The churchmen who met him on the Hampshire coast also emphasised that while they supported Stephen as king, they sought a negotiated peace.
Henry besieged Stephen’s castle at Malmesbury and successfully evaded his larger army along the River Avon, preventing him from forcing a decisive battle. In the face of the increasingly wintry weather, the two men agreed to a temporary truce, leaving Henry to travel north through the Midlands, where the Earl of Leicester announced his support for his cause. Stephen amassed troops over the following summer to renew the siege of Wallingford Castle, which controlled the important crossing over the upper Thames, in a final attempt to take the stronghold. The two armies confronted each other across the Thames in July. By this point, the barons on both sides were eager to avoid open battle, so members of the clergy brokered a peace, to the annoyance of both Stephen and Henry.
Now there was only Prince Eustace between Stephen and Henry in the succession to the throne. On 18th August 1153, Eustace died, and Stephen was persuaded to adopt Henry as his son and heir to the crown of England. On 7th November, the two leaders ratified the terms of a permanent peace and Stephen announced the Treaty of Winchester in the cathedral. Stephen recognised Henry as his adopted son and heir, in return for Henry paying homage to him; Stephen promised to listen to Henry’s advice but retained all his royal powers. Henry and Stephen sealed the treaty with a kiss of peace in the cathedral.
In 1154, Stephen became more proactive, attempting to exert his authority and starting to demolish unauthorised castles. The peace remained precarious, and Stephen’s son William remained a potential future rival to Henry. Rumours of a plot to kill Henry were circulating and, possibly as a consequence, Henry returned to Normandy for a period.ButStephen fell ill with a stomach disorder and died on 25th October 1154, allowing Henry to inherit the throne sooner than had been expected. He was buriedby the side ofhis wife and elder son at the monastery they had founded at Faversham. Stephen must take some responsibility for the troubles of his reign. He was a competent army commander and a brave knight, but perhaps too gallant for his own good. True, he was faced by a disputed succession, but so were all his predecessors going back to Edward the Confessor, if not to Eadmund Ironside; disputed successions in most of Europe were the norm. Stephen of Blois was, arguably, a more attractive character than any of the Norman kings, but he lacked the masterfulness of Henry I. Without it, he was unable to dominate either his court or his kingdom. Moreover, he spent very little time in Normandy; only one visit, in 1137, during his entire reign. This stands in marked contrast to the itineraries of his predecessors, especially William I, and given the cross-Channel structure of the Anglo-Norman aristocracy, it was certainly a mistake. In this sense, the ruler from the house of Blois can be said to have failed because he was too English a king to realise that the Kingdom was only a part of a greater whole. When Henry of Anjou was crowned Henry II on 19th December 1154, the Bishop of Winchester, Stephen’s brother, fled the country. The long nineteen years of anarchy and weary waiting were over.
Englishmen were now free to ponder afresh the question of national identity. But when they did so, some of them felt that a page had been turned. In 1161, Edward the Confessor was recognised as a saint and two years later, the king’s body was translated to a new tomb in Westminster Abbey.A new account of the Confessor’s life was commissioned from Aelred of Rievaulx, who elegantly reworked the earlier version from the 1130s, which had sought to legitimise the pre-Conquest Norman inheritance from Edward. Aelred concluded that when Henry had chosen Eadyth (Matilda) as his Queen, their daughter had produced a new king, Henry II, our Henry, as Aelred called him, joining both peoples. He went on:
Now, without doubt, England has a king of the race of the English.
Despite the fact that, in reality, Henry Plantagenet was only one-eighth English and that he was born and brought up in French-speaking Anjou, there seems little doubt that he was able to heal the breach of the Conquest. It was during this period that England’s ancient laws, distorted by the Norman preoccupation with land tenure, were finally codified and recorded, becoming The Common Law. At the same time, the power of the old English Shire courts was strengthened.
Scene Fifty – Westminster, 1154; ‘Our Henry’… an Arthurian Romance:
WhenHenry Plantagenet succeeded to the English throne in 1154, he could fairly claim to be the most powerful ruler in Western Europe. His lands stretched from the Pennines to the Pyrenees, their focal point being Anjou. We don’t know whether Henry ever met ‘his great relative’, King David of Scotland, who died in 1153, the year that the Plantagenet returned to England to prepare to become King, but Aelred of Rievaulx Abbey addressed a letter to him which he enclosed in his Genalogia Regum Anglorum, in which the abbot encouraged the young Henry (about fifteen at the time of his succession) to be worthy of King David, whose last hours and death he recounted.
Meanwhile, the real solution to the transnational problems of noble family fortunes lay in the reunification of England and Normandy. This was achieved in 1154 when Henry Plantagenet, who had become Duke of Normandy in 1150, was crowned King of England due to the agreement reached between them.
In England,Henry took over the throne without difficulty; it was the first undisputed succession for over a hundred years. His first task in the Kingdom was to make good the losses suffered during Stephen’s reign. By 1158 he had achieved this. In 1157 he used diplomatic pressure to force the young king of Scotland, Malcolm IV, to restore Cumberland, Westmorland, and Northumberland to the English Crown.
As lord of an empire stretching from the Scottish border to the Pyrenees, he was potentially the most powerful ruler in Europe, richer even than the German emperor and completely overshadowing the king of France, the nominal suzerain of his continental possessions. Although England provided him with great wealth as well as a royal title, the heart of the empire lay elsewhere, in Anjou, the land of his French ancestors. Socially and culturally, England was something of a backwater compared with the French parts of the Angevin dominion. The prosperous communities of the Seine and Loire and Garonne river systems and valleys were centres of learning, art, architecture, poetry and music. Aquitaine and Anjou produced two of the essential commodities of Medieval commerce: wine and salt. These could be exchanged for English cloth, and this trade must have brought great profit to the prince who ruled over both producers and consumers. Henry had also inherited the claims of his predecessors to lordship over neighbouring territories. These claims led to intervention in Nantes (1156), an expedition to Toulouse (1159) and finally, the occupation of Brittany after 1166 and the installation of his son Geoffrey as duke.
In England, Henry’s accession ended years of political anarchy and the breakdown of royal authority during which warlords had…
… filled the country full of castles. They oppressed the wretched people of the country severely with castle-building. When the castles were built, they filled them with devils and wicked men.
Henry was determined that royal castles, which in one way or another had fallen into the hands of various barons, were to be surrendered to the Crown, and unlicensed castles, the adulterine castles which had been built in such profusion, must be dismantled. His order was openly defied by several magnates, among them Hugh Mortimer, who refused to give up the former royal castle of Brug (Bridgnorth). It had been surrendered to Henry I by the earl of Shrewsbury during his rebellion of 1102. Following the confiscation of the third earl’s lands, Ralph Mortimer may have had some responsibility for the royal estates in Shropshire, renewed by Henry I or Stephen. Hugh Mortimer (II)’s stance over Brug was a direct challenge to the authority of the recently crowned Henry II. Accustomed to belligerent independence during many years of civil war, Hugh underestimated Henry’s determination.
William, count of Aumerle, was the first of the rebellious barons to submit to the king when he surrendered Scarborough Castle, and early in 1155 Roger, earl of Hereford, who had earlier declined to relinquish Gloucester and Hereford Castles, made his peace with the king. The King then advanced with an army into the borderlands to recover Brug and discipline Hugh Mortimer who was by then more or less isolated in his defiance. The king’s army wasted Hugh’s estates and besieged his castles at Wigmore, Cleobury and Brug, whilst Hugh’s forces in turn pillaged lands in the region. William of Newburgh described the outcome:
When this man was ordered to rest content with his own lands and to surrender those which he occupied belonging to the Crown, he obstinately refused to do so and prepared to resist with all its might. But subsequent events showed that this arrogance and indignation were greater than his courage … the king obtained Brug’s surrender and granted pardon to the earl … who now became a humble suppliant.
Fifty-one – Bridgnorth, 1154; Restoring the Crown’s authority in Wales and the Marches:
Hugh was forced to submit to the king before a gathering of magnates at Brug. He surrendered the castle, but retained Wigmore, Cleobury, and his other honours, and does not seem to have been otherwise penalised. With his eye on the restoration of the Crown’s authority in Wales, he needed baronial support, particularly from those lords with lands in Wales and the Marches. There was little to be gained in alienating a baron as important in the region as Hugh Mortimer as well as antagonising the baronage in general by over-zealous punishment of one of their number.
Pride, antipathy to the house of Anjou and a possible claim to Brug Castle all played their part in what appears to have been Hugh Mortimer’s reckless opposition to the king. That he participated in his defiance in virtual isolation was perhaps an example of folie de grandeur, stemming from the status that the Mortimers had attained by the middle of the twelfth century.
To William of Newburgh, Hugh was a man of powerful of noble birth; to Geraldus Cambriensis he was an excellent knight; to the chronicler of Wigmore Abbey he was …
… worthy, brave and bold … of fine bearing, courageous in arms, judicious in speech, wise of counsel … renowned and feared above all those who were living in England at that time … the most generous and liberal in his gifts of all those known anywhere in his lifetime.
This last description of this paragon of knightly virtue may safely be disregarded as a hagiography of the Abbey’s founder.Hugh lived on for a further quarter century after these events of 1155, during which his relationship with Henry II seems to have remained an uneasy one; in 1167 he repeated his defiance of twelve years earlier when he refused the king’s command to surrender cattle he had seized from one of the king’s knights. He was fined a hundred pounds, which he refused to pay, and in 1184, after he died, it was charged against his heir, though there is no record of it ever being paid.
Meanwhile, the Welsh exploded into self-expression and self-assertion. Adopting the methods of the intruder and adapting their own, they carved out a distinctive polity, entered European politics and at one stage began to create their own feudal state around Gwynedd.In Wales, Henry found in Owain Gwynedd and Rhys of Deheubarth two well-established princes whom it was impossible to browbeat. The Welsh princes turned their native oral culture, the Bardic tradition, into a brilliant literary one, retaining its Celtic core but glossing and enriching it from the new world which had been opened to them. Through the Norman March, they gave Europe the initial form of what became one of its more brilliant and abundant literary-historical traditions, that of Arthurian romance.They transmitted it through the March, the Cymro-Norman frontier between two different communities, developed into two divergent societies with distinct laws and loyalties, customs, memories and traditions. These societies were as much Welsh as they were Norman; families on both sides of the all but invisible frontier became inextricably intermeshed; the French language inserted itself between Welsh and Latin, making important sectors of society trilingual.
In 1157, and again in 1165, English armies marched into North Wales; and though Owain Gwynedd survived both invasions, he had to pay homage and put a check on his territorial ambitions. Welsh expansionism now had to deal with England’s strength as a limiting factor: the princes, the Lord Rhys of the south and then the two Llywelyns in Gwynedd, could no longer see themselves as autonomous, purely Welsh rulers, but rather feudal underlords of the English Crown. This was a discernible break with the past. Centralisation within Wales was the only way of securing relative independence for the Welsh princes from their sovereign liege, the English king. In 1163, during another major military expedition into south Wales, Henry II had asked an old Welshman of Pencader who had joined his retinue what chances he had of victory. The old man replied:
My Lord King, this nation may now be harassed, weakened and decimated by your soldiery, as it has so often been in former times, but it will never be destroyed by the wrath of man. … Whatever else may come to pass, I do not think that on the Day of Direct Judgement any race other than the Welsh, or any other language, will give answer to the Supreme Judge of all for this small corner of the earth.
It was Gerald the Welshman who reported the old man’s speech as the climax and conclusion to his celebrated Description of Wales (Descriptio Kambriae). He had accompanied the king on his expedition, perhaps translating for Henry, hence his verbatim record. Gerald was a distinguished and archetypal member of the new establishment, descended from a Norman lord and a Welsh princess. As a churchman, he had called for the independence of the Church of Dewi Sant (St David).
Any further ambitions Hugh Mortimer had in Wales were circumscribed by the ascendancy of the formidable prince, Rhys ap Gruffydd, and he appears to have played little part in the politics of either England or Normandy. In the 1160s, with Henry immersed in the Becket struggle and troubles on the continent, Rhys’s sorties from his base in Dinefwr in the south grew into a war when Owain Gwynedd joined in, moving to lead what had become a Welsh national coalition. They regained much territory from the Marcher lords. In response, Henry mobilised a massive expedition in 1165 to destroy all Welshmen, but it collapsed in the face of bad weather, torrential summer rain, and guerrilla resistance on the Berwyn Mountains. After 1165, Henry’s attitude to the Welsh princes was far more accommodating. As early as 1155, he had toyed with the idea of conquering Ireland. But the move into Ireland did not take place until 1169-70; at first by lords from the Welsh march and then (in 1171-2) by Henry himself. As the long delay made plain, in the king’s eyes, there were matters much more important than the conquest of Ireland.
Wales remained self-governing for over a century after 1165, but there was never any real security since English troops were liable to appear anywhere in the country, and, ultimately, there was nothing to stop them from attacking except for the politics of brinkmanship or the chance of seizing independence by force of arms. In addition, the law of gavelkind in Wales meant that when Madog ap Maredydd, lord of Powys, died in 1160, his lands were divided among his sons, and Powys was never again a united country. Ten years later, Owain Gwynedd himself died, and the same thing happened in Gwynedd. Hywel ab Owain, the poet, was killed by his half-brothers, who then split up the principality between them. Hywel, perhaps because of his high birth, has been seen as the poet of feudalism, close to ideals of the princes of Gwynedd. After that, the clouds seemed to gather for princes and poets alike.
However, in the early 1170s, with Owain dead and his sons slipping back into civil war, Rhys agreed to a quasi-feudal relationship with Henry II, who had finally given up hope of a conquest of the principality. Instead, an atmosphere of mutual trust developed between the king and the prince, the latter being seen as the head and the shield of all the South and all Wales and the defence of all of the race of the Britons. Henry, sensing the moment in 1170, went for settlement. Rhys was formally confirmed in his possessions and was made Justiciar of South Wales. At what looks like the first recorded eisteddfod, all the Welsh rulers from north and south took the oath of fealty and homage to the king and by the end of the century, the frontier which had emerged over two generations had been settled.
The old kingdom of Morgannwg-Gwent had vanished, and was replaced by Monmouth and Glamorgan, the strongest bastions of Norman power in Wales. The diminished lordship of Powys faced a struggle to survive, torn three ways between Gwynedd, the English Crown and the rump of the once great kingdom. In the end, this also split in two, the southern Powys Wentwynwyn remaining loyal to the Crown and the northern Powys Fadog to the royal Welsh territory of Aberffraw, eventually becoming part of Gwynedd, whose ‘prince’ controlled most of the north, as far east as Conwy. Under Owain and some of his successors, it grew into a major force, the strongest power in Pura Wallia (Welsh Wales).
A core of the old Deheubarth was re-established, ringed by Norman lordships with a strong base in Pembroke and a royal estate centred on Carmarthen. Everywhere in Wales, kings had disappeared to be replaced by lords owing allegiance to the English king and his Welsh overlord, Yr Arglwydd Rhys, of Dinefwr. To the east and the south, stretched the Marcher lordships in a great arc from the pivot of Chester; the powerful families of Montgomery, Mortimer, Bohun and Clare continued to stamp their imprint from Shrewsbury to Montgomery and from Hereford deep into mid-Wales at Brecon. Under the Clares, Glamorgan became immensely powerful, and, heading west along the fertile coast, the beautiful Princess Nest of Deheubarth could precipitate wars over her person like Helen of Troy.
There was a permanently disputed ‘shadow land’ and endless border raiding, but in this tension, there was also some equilibrium and stability, maintained by intermarriage and changing tactical alliances. In 1188,Archbishop Baldwin preached the Crusade and imposed the Papal authority on the new cathedral churches on his grand tour through both the March and Pura Wallia, a tour chronicled by Gerald the Welshman. He was the grandson of Nest and her Norman husband, Gerald of Windsor, son of Nest’s daughter, Angharad, and the Norman knight William de Barri. Gwyn A. Williams has written of the creative tension between Cymric and Norman cultures, which produced Gerald’s work:
… themost startling and… unexpected consequence of this confrontation was the entry into history of a brilliant new literary culture, simultaneously Welsh and European, and itself without doubt the product of of a new civilisation in Wales.
Gwyn A. Williams (1984), When Was Wales? Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
Once again, the Welsh had to define themselves in response to an outside challenge to produce this. The consequence was a literary renaissance in several languages. The new Latin monasteries, especially among the Welsh Cistercians, also helped to marry the traditions of European cloisters and old Welsh monastic traditions to producethe largest single body of medieval Welsh ecclesiastical manuscripts at Llantony Abbey. Along the communication networks of abbeys, Welsh friars filtered into the scholastic houses of western Europe, and European ideas filtered back into Wales. Adam of Wales and Philip Wallensis, who found their way to the University of Paris in the twelfth century, initiated a tradition. Young Welsh scholars made their way there and, in greater numbers, to its offshoot in Oxford, where they established a permanent and highly visible presence. Cambro-Normans like Gerald found a niche in the closely controlled episcopate; no fewer than three bishops were descendants of Nest of Deheubarth.
The native Welsh were admitted to much of the rapidly developing learning of Europe. Most particularly in its Welshness, the secular work of the poets enjoyed a revival, and the bardic order seems to have been reorganised. This was the age of the gogynfeirdd, the court poets, in which every court and many a sub-court had its official master-poet, and its bardd teulu, its household poet. The poets had official functions as ‘remembrancers’ to a dynasty and its people. They evolved a complex, difficult and powerful tradition which was, like the cathedrals, architectural in structure, leaving little room for individual creativity. Mostly it was a poetry of praise, morality, exhortation and legitimation, addressed to a strictly traditional concept of the prince and the lord, not much liked by the church. It is clearly derived from the pagan, druidic traditions of the old Welsh, adjusted to a world of lords and princes. What we hear is what they call the Old Song of Taliesin. It is a mutation of the British Arthurian tradition, the longest tradition in the writing of the Welsh.
It was at its strongest among the lower-order cyfarwyddion, the storytellers. It was with the arrival of the Normans that an unknown scribe wrote down his version ofthe Four Branches of the Mabinogi; the others followed directly into Europe via the remembrancers and the translators: Bretons, Normans, Flemings, English, and Welsh. The rough Arthur of the British moved in and out of the Celtic mythology into the realm of Arthur of Camelot and his Round Table Knights with their French accents. This renaissance was not stopped by any frontier: Norman lords soon succumbed to the charms of court poets, harpists and singers. With the Bretons strongly represented, the Cambro-Norman lords created whole schools of translators, particularly in Glamorgan and Monmouth. Flemings were among the earliest to transmit stories of Arthur and Myrddin (Merlin) into Europe through clerics. Out of this milieu came the remarkable History of the Kings of Britain written by a Breton based in Gwent, Geoffrey of Monmouth.
But the uneasy peace which then existed for the two decades from 1165 between the marcher lords and the Welsh princes came to an end with Henry’s death, since Rhys considered that his relationship with Henry had been a personal one and did not bind him to the king’s successor, Richard I, who showed none of the ‘subtelty’ of his father’s handling of Welsh affairs.
Fifty-Four; 1162-1170 – The Becket Controversy & The Murder in Canterbury Cathedral:
In 1169, the question of the coronation of the heir to the throne, Prince Henry, led to the interminable negotiations between the king, the Pope and the archbishop being treated as a matter of urgency, preoccupying the king’s attention. In 1170, Becket returned to England, determined to punish those who had taken part in the young king’s coronation. His enemies lost no time in telling Henry of the archbishop’s behaviour, to which Henry spoke the notorious words, Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest? These words were taken literally by four of his knights who, anxious to win the king’s favour, rushed off to Canterbury, where on 29th December, they murdered Becket in his own cathedral.
The deed shocked Christendom and secured Becket’s canonization in record time. In popular memory, the archbishop came to personify resistance to the oppressive authority of the State, but in reality, he was championing the privileges and indemnities of the clergy over all other considerations. At the time, everyone was better off with him out of the way. Once the storm of protest had died down, it became apparent that Henry’s hold on his vast empire had in no way been shaken by the Becket controversy. Whatever the legacy of the violent murder, in the early 1170s, Henry II stood at the height of his power.
By this time, the king had already decided that, after his death, his dominions should be partitioned between his three eldest sons. Young Henry was to have Anjou, Normandy and England; Richard was to have Aquitaine, and Geoffrey was to have Brittany. Later, in 1185, John was granted his father’s other major acquisition, Ireland. The death of young King Henry in 1183 and Geoffrey in 1186 should have eased Henry’s dynastic difficulties, but Richard was alarmed by his father’s obvious favouritism towards John. An alliance between Richard and King Philip II led to Henry’s defeat, and he died at Chinon in July 1189. Although his interest in rational reform has led to him being regarded as the founder of the English common law and a great, creative king, in his own eyes these were matters of secondary importance. To him, personally, what mattered most were dynastic politics, and he died believing that in this, he had failed despite the successes of the previous thirty years.
In 1169, the question of the coronation of the heir to the throne, Prince Henry, led to the interminable negotiations between the king, pope and archbishop being treated as a matter of urgency. In 1170, Becket returned to England, determined to punish those who had taken part in the young king’s coronation. His enemies lost no time in telling Henry of the archbishop’s behaviour, to which Henry spoke the notorious words, Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest? These words were taken literally by four of his knights who, anxious to win the king’s favour, rushed off to Canterbury, where on 29th December, they murdered Becket in his own cathedral.
The deed shocked Christendom and secured Becket’s canonisation in record time. In popular memory, the archbishop came to personify resistance to the oppressive authority of the State, but in reality, he was championing the privileges and indemnities of the clergy over all other considerations. At the time, everyone was better off with him out of the way. Once the storm of protest had died down, it became apparent that Henry’s hold on his vast empire had in no way been shaken by the Becket controversy. Whatever the legacy of the violent murder, in the early 1170s, Henry II stood at the height of his power.
Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Histories (Everyman’s edn.) are appended by a Translator’s Epilogue. He detailed the background to Geoffrey’s work and the transition from Stephen’s reign to that of Henry Plantagenet. Geoffrey and his world was growing old, and he was therefore offered the see of St Asaph. No alternative was available, and so he was consecrated to St Asaph in 1152, but there was no absolute obligation on him to retire immediately to the wilds of Wales.
Earl Robert had died, but his cause was rapidly rising into the ascendant. The Empress Matilda still lived, and her son Henry was growing up to manhood. His father, Geoffrey of Anjou, had died in 1151, and at his death, Henry became Earl of Anjou and Duke of Normandy. The same eventful year also saw the young Duke marry Eleanor of Aquitaine, the divorced wife of Louis VII of France. Stephen read the omens and proposed that his son, Eustace, should be crowned joint King of England with himself. But Archbishop Theobold and the rest of the prelates refused to crown him.
The seal of Henry of Anjou as Duke of Normandy and Count of Aquitaine. The Angevins ruled their French lands not as kings of England but as vassals of the King of France.
Writing in about 1200, after King Henry died in 1189, William of Newburgh noted of Henry II that he was unpopular with almost all men in his own days. Henry II’s apparent unpopularity with his subjects may have had something to do, for some, with his infamous early conflict with the Church, but it may also have been because, although he was king for thirty-four years he was also Duke of Normandy and Count of Anjou, he spent only thirteen of them in England. He held more lands in France than its king, while England’s wealth enabled him to outshine the German emperor. Through marriage, inheritance, diplomacy, and occasionally war, Henry II built up a huge domain, and he extended his sovereignty to Scotland and Ireland.However, he failed to give his empire any institutional unity. It therefore collapsed under his sons, Richard and John. By the time he died in 1216, John had lost all of the Angevin lands on the continent except Gascony, and England had once more been invaded by the French. Yet Newburgh also noted Henry’s other domestic achievements:
“In his laws, he displayed great care for orphans, widows and the poor; and in many places, he bestowed noble alms with an open hand… He never imposed any heavy tax on the realms of England, or on his possessions beyond the sea, … ”
But the desire of his sons for a taste of real power produced a family rebellion in 1173 in league with the Capetian king of France, Louis VII, and these events were exacerbated by an opportunistic invasion of England by the King of Scotland, William the Lion. Although Henry II eventually put down the rebellion, imposing humiliating terms on the captured Scots king, his plans continued to be frustrated by his rebellious sons, especially when Philip II Augustus ascended to the French throne in 1180 and started to exploit the differences in the Angevin family. Even after the death of the young Henry, who had been crowned king while his father was still alive, in 1183, problems remained, as Richard knew that ‘old’ Henry favoured John, so he allied with the French against his father. Henry II eventually died in 1189, a defeated man.
However, he left a great legacy in England. Having inherited a kingdom devastated by civil war, he quickly restored the stable government it had known under his grandfather, Henry I, while simultaneously ruling over two-thirds of France. He extended royal power in England by reforming both civil and criminal law. The Assizes of Clarendon (1166) and Northampton (1176) established the grand jury system, whereby royal justices and sheriffs tried those suspected of serious offences, while civil writs obtainable from the royal courts, secured the speedy restoration of those dispossessed without due process. Henry’s reign ranks as a milestone in the development of the English Common Law.
Yet ironically it is not for his successes that Henry is best remembered, but for his dubious role in the murder of Thomas Becket. In June 1162, Becket was consecrated Archbishop of Canterbury. In the eyes of respectable churchmen Becket, who had been chancellor since 1155, did not deserve the highest ecclesiastical post in the land. He set out to prove that he was the best of all possible archbishops. Right from the start, he went out of his way to oppose the king who, chiefly out of his friendship, had promoted him. But it was not long before the king began to react like a man betrayed. In the mid-twelfth century, Church-State relations were beset with problems which were normally solved or shelved by men of goodwill, but which could provide a field day for men who were determined to quarrel. Henry resented the way that clerics who committed felonies could escape capital punishment by claiming the right to be tried in an ecclesiastical court.
At a council held at Westminster in October 1163, Henry demanded that criminous clerks should be unfrocked by the Church and handed over to the lay courts for punishment. At a council held at Westminster in October 1163, Henry demanded that these clerics be defrocked by the Church and handed over to the lay courts for punishment. Becket and his bishops opposed this, but when Pope Alexander III asked him to adopt a more conciliatory line, Henry summoned a council to Clarendon in January 1164. He presented the bishops with the Constitutions of Clarendon, a clear statement of the king’s customary rights over the Church, and required them to observe these customs in good faith. Taken by surprise, Becket argued for two days before giving way. But no sooner had the rest of the bishops followed his example, than he repented of his weakness in giving way. Exasperated, Henry decided to destroy Becket, summoning him to appear before a royal court to answer trumped-up charges. Becket was found guilty and sentenced to forfeiture of his estates. Becket fled to the Continent and appealed to the pope, leaving behind an English Church in confusion due to his vacillation.
In 1169, the question of the coronation of the heir to the throne, Prince Henry, led to the interminable negotiations between the king, the pope and the archbishop being treated as a matter of urgency. In 1170, Becket returned to England, determined to punish those who had taken part in the young king’s coronation. His enemies lost no time in telling Henry of the archbishop’s behaviour, to which Henry spoke the notorious words, Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest? These words were taken literally by four of his knights who, anxious to win the king’s favour, rushed off to Canterbury, where on 29th December, they murdered Becket in his own cathedral.
The deed shocked Christendom and secured Becket’s canonization in record time. In popular memory, the archbishop came to personify resistance to the oppressive authority of the State, but in reality, he was championing the privileges and indemnities of the clergy over all other considerations. At the time, everyone was better off with him out of the way. Once the storm of protest had died down, it became apparent that Henry’s hold on his vast empire had in no way been shaken by the Becket controversy. Whatever the legacy of the violent murder, in the early 1170s, Henry II stood at the height of his power.
By this time, the king had already decided that, after his death, his dominions should be partitioned between his three eldest sons. Young Henry was to have Anjou, Normandy and England; Richard was to have Aquitaine, and Geoffrey was to have Brittany. Later, in 1185, John was granted his father’s other major acquisition, Ireland. The death of young king Henry in 1183 and Geoffrey in 1186 should have eased Henry’s dynastic difficulties, but Richard was alarmed by his father’s obvious favouritism towards John. An alliance between Richard and King Philip II led to Henry’s defeat, and he died at Chinon in July 1189. Only in the last weeks of his life had the task of ruling his immense territories been too much for Henry. He rode ceaselessly from one corner of his empire to another, almost giving an impression of being omnipresent, an impression that helped to keep his knights loyal. Although the central government offices, chamber, chancery, and military household, travelled around with him, the sheer size of the empire inevitably stimulated the further development of localised administrations which could deal with routine matters of justice and finance in his absence. Thus, in England, as on the Continent, government became increasingly complex and bureaucratic.
Although his interest in rational reform has led to him being regarded as the founder of the English common law and a great, creative king, in Henry’s own eyes these were matters of secondary importance. To him, personally, what mattered most were dynastic politics, and he died believing that in this, he had failed despite the successes of the previous thirty years.
Llandaff, 1152-4; The Welsh Chronicler and Kingship:
Historia Brittonum, or a History of the Britons, was purportedly written in the 8th-9th Century by a Welsh monk called Nennius. It is one of the earliest histories of the British Isles. Nennius’ work influenced later histories, such as that written by Geoffrey of Monmouth, and remained influential for centuries. Many myths and legends about the origins of Britain first appeared in Historia Brittonum. It contains ‘accounts’ of Arthur’s twelve battles, ending with the ‘Battle of Badon’ (c. 490-9), fought on a hillsite in southern England, possibly near Bath.
Geoffrey of Monmouth, the Welsh chronicler of the mid-twelfth century, was born in about 1100 and his life was therefore contemporaneous with the reign of Henry I, as he died in 1154. He studied at Oxford and became a Benedictine monk. He was Archdeacon of Llandaff, c. 1140 and was Bishop of St. Asaph from 1152 to 1154, though he remained at Llandaff and never visited his bishopric before he died. His most famous work was Histories of the Kings of Britain, written in Latin, Historia Regum Britanniae. He dedicated this to Robert, Earl of Gloucester.In her 1911 introduction to the work, for The Everyman’s Library edition (577) Lucy Allen Paton wrote (from Massachusetts) of Geoffrey that:
Geoffrey of Monmouth has been called again and again the father of Arthurian romance … before the beginning of the twelfth century to the name of the historic Arthur … there had already become attached much legendary and even mythological material, that his people … wistfully looked for his return to earth. Such was the general attitude of the Britons toward Arthur at the time when his story began to occupy the attention of Geoffrey of Monmouth.
About Geoffrey’s life, however, we have scant information. We know that he was a Welshman from Monmouth, giving himself the title Monumetensis, either because he was born there or because he was educated at the Benedictine monastery there. We also know that his father appears to have been named Arthur. He was probably appointed Archdeacon of Llandaff in 1140, when his uncle Uchtryd, who had been archdeacon, was made Bishop of Llandaff. The rest of his ecclesiastical career appears to have been unremarkable, even for himself, since postponed his own ordination to the priesthood until a few days before he was consecrated as Bishop of St Asaph, which was a small and impecunious see at that time.
He lived at a time when Britain was responding to the intellectual stimulus that had come to the country with the Norman Conquest. Its literary life, which had been lying dormant, began to enjoy a renaissance under the influence of scholars and chroniclers brought by the Normans. Henry I showed his appreciation for men of letters and surrounded himself with minstrels, balladeers and bards at court. After half a century of occupation, the Normans were beginning to take a keen interest in the past history of their newly-acquired domain and to turn to the traditions of early Britain. But, as Paton wrote, …
… the tastes of the Norman noble demanded something less mysterious, less fantastic, and less remote from his own world than Celtic myth afforded him, and also something more polished and entertaining than the bare chronicles at his disposal.
She claimed that it was practically certain that Geoffrey began to write his Historia Regum Britanniae as early as 1139. He dedicated the book to Robert, Earl of Gloucester, one of the most distinguished patrons of literature of the time, who rewarded him by advancing him to the archdeaconry at Llandaff. Geoffrey gathered his material from episodes in the chronicles of his contemporaries, especially William of Malmesbury and Henry of Huntingdon, in addition to the material from ancient Celtic records, myths and legends.
In their introduction to their 1948 translation of The Mabinogion, Gwyn Jones and Thomas Jones wrote that the eleven stories it contained were among the finest flowerings of the Celtic genius and, taken together, a masterpiece of our medieval European literature. The stories were preserved in two Welsh collections, the White Book of Rhydderch (Llyfr Gwyn Rhydderch), written down in about 1300-25, and the Red Book of Hergest (Llyfr Coch Hergest), of the period 1375-1425. But they must have been known long before the time of these earliest manuscripts, the likeliest date being early in the second half of the eleventh century. Much of the subject matter of these stories takes us back, in the oral tradition to early post-Roman, Brythonic times. These Four Branches of the Mabinogi – Pwyll, Branwen, Manawyden and Math – include the earliest Arthurian tale in Welsh, Culhwch and Olwen, and The Dream of Rhonabwy, a romantic and sometimes humorously appreciative recalling of the heroic age of Britain, as well as three later Arthurian romances, The Lady of the Fountain, Peredur, and Gereint Son of Erbin, revealing abundant Norman-French influences.
That Wales had its bards was well known across twelfth-century Europe. These bards were storytellers whose media were both prose and verse. The poetic chronicling of the eighth/ninth-century monk Nennius as well as that of Geoffrey of Monmouth, three centuries later, suggest that, by their times, these various bards had transmitted an amplitude of material in oral form, and that centuries passed before they were committed to writing in the White Book and the Red. When Culhwch first goes to Arthur’s court, the narrator supplies a list of people, which is an index to cycles of a lost story. Arthur’s warriors are a mytho-heroic assembly, set against a vast rolling panorama of lost Celtic mythology. They are the oddest retinue of any court in the world, but they form part of…
… a native saga hardly touched by alien influences, exciting and evocative, opening windows on great vistas of the oldest stuff of folklore and legend.
Without discussing the historical references to Arthur in Nennius’ Historia Brittonum, Gwyn Jones and Thomas Jones were at pains to stress that Culhwch and Olwen is a document of first importance for the study of the sources of the Arthurian legendarium. The Arthur it portrays is remarkably unlike the gracious, glorious emperor of later tradition, exemplified in the later tradition of French, German and English literatures, but when we recall that Arthur of these original legends was not of any of these nationalities, but a British king, it is not unreasonable to emphasise the significance of Cymric material material relating him. This original material was uncontaminated by the Cycles of Romance, though affected by a vast complex of Celtic myth and legend, consisting for the most part of Culhwch and Olwen itself, in addition to various poems.
One of these poems, the so-called Preideu Annwfyn from the thirteenth-century Book of Taliesin, tells of Arthur’s raids in his ship Prydwen upon eight caers (fortresses) of the Otherworld. This original Arthur is a folk hero, a beneficent giant, who rids the land of other giants; he undertakes journeys to rescue prisoners and carry off treasures; he is at once savage, heroic and protective. He is therefore at the heart of the British story, both for his fame as dux bellorum (warlord) and protector of Roman Britain against all invaders, and for his increasingly dominating role in Celtic folklore and legend. It is remarkable how much of this British Arthur had survived in the twelfth-century Historia of Geoffrey of Monmouth.
By the twelfth century, Celtic influences in literature were fashionable across Europe, especially those from the Arthurian legendarium. Arthur’s position in the British story; the twofold advantage to the Normans and Angevins of Arthur as a British, not Anglo-Saxon, hero; the skill of the Welsh and Bretons as storytellers, and the excellence of the stories they told: all these were key elements of the supremacy. Furthermore, the professional men of letters of the twelfth century knew their business well. They wrote of courtly love, religion, society and morality, mysticism and poetry. A place for all of these elements was found in the Matter of Britain.
The Arthurian legendarium also became a priceless European inheritance, but in this transmission, the three Welsh prose romances under discussion were a modest matter. Their interest lies in their evidence of Welsh tradition underlying the continental expansion, with Norman-French characteristics imposed on the visceral old Welsh tales, appealing to their more sophisticated audiences. But Geoffrey created the classical form of what was passed down the centuries as the British History, rooting the Britons in a history started by Brutus the Trojan, already outlined by Nennius in the early ninth century, giving them their great hero Arthur, who now bestrides Europe, broadcasting a wealth largely mythical but compulsive history and a prophecy of redemption when an Arthur would once again sit on the throne of Britain.
The Matter of Britain swept through French-speaking Europe and across the continent from Flanders to Scandinavia to the Bosphorus and the Levant. It became a European best-seller, even as other versions of the Arthurian traditions entered the discourse of Christendom to be transmuted at the hands of Chrétien de Troyes and others into something rich and very different. By 1180, Arthur was a hero in the Crusader states of Antioch and Palestine:
The Eastern peoples speak of him as do the Western, though separated by the breadth of the whole earth. Egypt speaks of him, nor is the Bosphorus silent…
Even as ‘history’, Geoffrey’s Arthur lived long, powering a new and highly effective British national mythology. This dramatic creation of a British-European culture mirrored the growth of a hybrid society along the Welsh Marches. In his writing, Geoffrey surrounded Arthur with a court that mirrors the British-Norman life in the early twelfth century. When he is established on the throne, Arthur distributes lands, repairs the damages of war and conducts himself in general after the fashion of a Norman king of England. Geoffrey’s description of Britain at the time of Arthur’s coronation, which he modelled on a Norman festival, is often cited as a striking example of his introduction of chivalric customs into the Arthurian legendarium:
For at that time was Britain exalted unto so high a pitch of dignity as that it did surpass all other kingdoms in plenty of riches, in luxury of adornment, and in the courteous wit of them that dwelt therein. Whatever knight in the land was of renown for his prowess did wear his clothes and his arms all one same colour. And the dames, no less witty, would apparel themselves in the same manner in a single colour, nor would they deign have the love of none save he had thrice approved him in the wars. Wherefore at that time did dames wax chaste and knights the nobler for their love.
Never before had the ideals of courtly life been connected with Arthur. They had blossomed in their richest form in Southern France and did not take firm root in England until the second half of the twelfth century when they were introduced by Eleanor of Aquitaine, queen of Henry II, and by Provencal poets who sojourned in England, but Geoffrey’s descriptions are evidence that they were present in England even before that, in his day.
Geoffrey’s Arthur embodies all the virtues of the chivalric hero: Courtesy, valour, youth, glad energy, and liberality; these were all the graces cultivated in twelfth-century France. After he had established peace in the realm, Arthur is said to have held…
… such courtly fashion in his household as begat rivalry amongst peoples at a distance.
Yet Arthur was not a chivalric hero par excellence. In the Middle Ages, highway robbery provided a means for a knight to enrich his followers if he had been too generous and had impoverished himself. Arthur is described as resorting to the sword to satisfy his thirst for riches:
Wherefore did Arthur, for that in him did keep with largesse, make resolve to harry the Saxons, to the end that with their treasure he might make rich the retainers that were of his own household. And herein was he nourished of his own lawful right, seeing that of right ought he to hold the sovereignty of the whole island in virtue of his claim hereditary.
Geoffrey’s Arthur knows nothing of the virtues of mésure (moderation) and of love, without which, according to the chivalric code, no knight could possibly be of gentle heart, possibly because these qualities are incompatible with some traces of barbarism that survive in him. He is tinged with the chivalric ideals of a Norman court, but he does not perfectly represent the laws of courtly behaviour which were illustrated in later French Arthurian romance.
The contemporary chroniclers, Geraldus Cambrensis (Gerallt Cymro/Gerald the Welshman) and William of Newburgh, were both contemptuous of Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Histories of the Kings of Britain. However, for Sebastian Evans, its translator, Geoffrey’s book is:
… not a history, nor even … a historical romance, but a romance of a distinct and peculiar stamp … a romance in the sense of a national epos.
A true national epos, I say, but of what nation? It is not English, not Norman, nor even Breton or Welsh. Yet all have their heroes allotted to them … In simple fact, we can never read Geoffrey aright until we realise what nation it was of which he aspired to be the national writer of the national epic. In a word, it was the national empire of his time …
Conclusion: Romancing Medieval Monarchy – An Empire from the Pennines to the Pyrenees:
In the end,Henry took over his kingdom without difficulty; it was the first undisputed succession to the English throne for over a hundred years. As lord of an empire stretching from the Scottish border to the Pyrenees he was potentially the most powerful ruler in Europe, richer even than the emperor and completely overshadowing the king of France. Out of the thirty-four years of his reign, Henry spent twenty-one on the Continent.
The Angevin Empire, c.1150-1200, showing the lands inherited by Henry II by 1154 (in yellow), those acquired through marriage to Eleanor of Aquitaine (in red), those acknowledging his overlordship or acquired by conquest/diplomacy (in pink/mauve), and those claimed by Henry II (in brown). The cross-hatches show French territory retained by John in 1214.
The actual empire of Henry I consisted mainly of England, Normandy, Wales and Brittany. At its height, the actual empire of Henry II extended, in a contemporary yet historic phrase, from the Orkneys to the Pyrenees. The dominant idea of the Plantagenet Henry II’s reign was to gradually extend the frontiers of the Anglo-Cymric-Norman-Breton empire until the descendants of the Conqueror of England would become the emperors of Christendom.
When Henry II came to the throne of England, adding the dominions held by Stephen, Normandy, Anjou and Aquitaine, it seemed that his dynastic dream could be accomplished within his reign. It was the lack of cohesion between the various constituent parts of the empire which was the greatest peril to that dream. As Paton wrote,
If only Norman and Englishman, Welshman and Breton, could be induced to work together in the common interest of the Empire there was no limit to the the potentialities of its future greatness. The restoration of an Empire mightier and broader than that of Charlemagne, nay, even that of Augustus, was no impossibility, but a practical aim, towards the attainment of which all the resources known to the statecraft of the time should be directed.
… Geoffrey… was inspired by Henry… Henry, indeed was no Augustus, and Geoffrey was far enough from being a Virgil, but in this respect the relations between the Roman emperor and the Mantuan poet were strictly analogous to those existing between the Norman king and the Welsh romancer.
Right to left: The tombs of Eleanor of Aquitaine (1122-1204), Henry II (1133-89) and Richard I (1157-99) in Fontevrault Abbey, Anjou. Their choice of burial site reflects the French identity of all three.
To Sebastian Evans, as a translator, Geoffrey’s book was an epic that failed, for it was to have been the national epic of an empire that failed. When, in the next generation, King John lost Normandy and most of France in the early years of the thirteenth century, the Angevin empire came to an abrupt end in Western Europe. Arthur, the romantic creation of Geoffrey, who was set to have been the traditional hero of the Anglo-Norman-British nucleus of that Western empire, became a detached national hero, a purely literary, mythological figure to the early modern British who had forgotten the short-lived empire that had created him.
For Lucy Allen-Paton, too, the Historia is not a chronicle or a history, but a romance based on early British histories, combining historical, legendary and mythological material with interest and ingenuity. Geoffrey raised a national hero, Arthur of the Britons, already the centre of myth and legend, to the rank of an imperial monarch, substituting for early British stories and customs those of Anglo-Norman England. In doing so, he provided a model of knightly and kingly custom and practice and a dignified place in literature and the popular national narrative, determining the form of the romantic chronicle for many centuries to come. By extension, the entire iconography of the House of Wessex, from the story of Offa’s bloodied sword to Agatha’s black cross and the Confessor’s Green Tree, is a forgotten thread, not just of a romantic royal chronicle, but of the British national narrative.
Main Secondary Sources:
András Bereznay, et. al. (2003), The Times History of Europe: Three Thousand Years of History in Maps. London, Times Books: (Harper Collins).
Simon Keyes, Seán Duffy, Andrew Jotischky (2001), The Penguin Atlas of British and Irish History. London, Penguin Books.
Marc Morris (2014), The Norman Conquest: The Battle of Hastings and the Fall of Anglo-Saxon England. London, Pegasus Books.
Marc Morris (2021), The Anglo-Saxons: The Making of England: 410-1066. London, Simon & Schuster.
David Smurthwaite (1984), The Ordnance Survey Complete Guide to the Battlefields of Britain. Exeter, Webb and Bower.
Peter Rex (2013), Hereward. Stroud, Glos; Amberley Books.
Kenneth O. Morgan (1984), The Oxford Illustrated History of Britain. London: Guild Publishing.
István Lázár (1989), An Illustrated History of Hungary. Budapest, Corvina Books.
László Kontler (2009), A History of Hungary. Budapest, Atlantisz Publishing House.
The Gizelakreuz – A Section of Gizela’s Black Holy Cross
Scene Thirty-Nine – Dunfermline and Edinburgh, 1093; The Deaths of Malcolm and Margaret:
In 1092, the peace agreement between Rufus and Malcolm signed five years earlier, broke down due to the building of another new castle by the Normans at Carlisle, even though the Scots claimed and controlled most of Cumbria. But the immediate cause of the outbreak of hostilities concerned Malcolm’s personal estates in England, granted to him by William in 1072 to enable him to visit his English relatives, including his sister-in-law Cristina and his daughter Eadyth. Both were interned at Wilton Abbey. After King William died in 1087, Eadgar continued to support his eldest son, Robert Curthose, who succeeded him as Duke of Normandy, against his second son, William Rufus, who received the English throne as William II. Eadgar was one of Robert’s three principal advisors at this time. The war waged by Robert and his allies to overthrow William ended in defeat in 1091. As part of the settlement, Eadgar was deprived of the lands in Normandy confiscated from William’s supporters and granted to him by Robert. They were restored to their previous owners by the terms of the peace treaty. The disgruntled Eadgar travelled once more to Scotland, where Malcolm was preparing for war with William Rufus.
When William Rufus had marched north to be confronted by Malcolm’s army, the two kings opted to talk rather than fight. The negotiations were conducted by Eadgar on Malcom’s behalf and by the newly-reconciled Robert Curthose on behalf of his brother. The resulting agreement resulted in a reconciliation between William and Eadgar. Still, within months Robert left England, unhappy with William’s failure to fulfil the the truce, and Eadgar went to Normandy with him.
A party among the Scots hated the rule of Malcolm, seeing him as a favourer of Sassenaghs and foreigners. They may have included, in their view, his Kyíván and Hungarian nobles. Soon after his death was announced, a party was already in arms preparing to besiege the Castle of Edinburgh. Having returned to England, Eadgar went to Scotland again in 1093, on his diplomatic mission for Willam Rufus.
William Rufus wanted the lands to be returned to the Crown, but the two men agreed to a meeting to discuss this. Malcolm travelled south to Gloucester, stopping at the Abbey to visit Cristina and Eadyth, but Rufus refused to negotiate, insisting that the dispute should instead be judged by the English barons. Malcolm was insulted by this and immediately returned to Dunfermline, where (according to the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle), …
… hegathered his army and came harrowing into England with more hostility than behoved him.
Queen Margaret had tried to moderate her husband’s fury. She is known to have interceded with him for the release of English prisoners from the border wars of the previous decades. Although a reforming Catholic from her time growing to womanhood at Andrew’s court in Hungary, she was also respectful of the Scottish Church’s Celtic roots, instigating the restoration of Columba’s Abbey on Iona. Besides the great Romanesque and Gothic abbeys of the eleventh century, there were also smaller monuments of the Reform movement in Scotland, like the tiny chapel she built, now standing on a rampart of Edinburgh Castle.
The stained glass window in St Margaret’s Chapel at Edinburgh Castle
But she had been ill for six months when Malcolm returned from his visit to Wilton Abbey and Gloucester, where he had an angry, confrontational meeting with William Rufus concerning his lands. Perhaps Queen Margaret, who was already too weak to ride out or rise from her bed, recognised the almost uncontrollable rage of her husband before he left with his army, and she had a premonition four days before she died. A priest who was with her during these last days reported that she told him,
“Perhaps on this very day, such a heavy calamity may befall this realm of Scotland as has not been for many ages past.”
The priest paid little attention to these words at the time, but a few days later a messenger arrived with the news that Malcolm had been slain on the very day that the Queen had spoken the ominous words. Before Malcolm left, she had been most urgent with him not to go with the army, but on that occasion, he had not followed her advice. Malcolm was accompanied by Edward, his eldest son by her and the heir-designate or Tánaiste, and by Edgar, her younger son.
Even by the standards of the time, the ravaging of Northumbria by the Scots was regarded as harsh. While besieging Alnwick Castle on 13th November, they were ambushed by Robert de Mowbray, Earl of Northumbria, whose lands Malcolm had devastated. In what became known as the Battle of the River Aln, Malcolm was killed by Arkil Morel, steward of Bamburgh Castle, and Edward was mortally wounded. Margaret was said to have died nine days later, having received the news of their deaths from Edgar. On the eve of the fourth day following his as yet unheralded death,
… her weakness having somewhat abated, Margaret went to her oratory to hear Mass, and… there she took care to provide herself beforehand for her departure, which was now so near, with the holy Viaticum of the Body and Blood of our Lord. After partaking of this health-giving food, she returned to her bed, her former pains having assailed her with redoubled severity. The disease gained ground, and death was imminent. … Her face was already covered with a deadly pallor when she directed that I, and the other ministers of the sacred Altar along with me, should stand near her and commend her soul to Christ by our psalms.
Moreover, she asked that a cross, called the Black Cross, which she always held in the greatest veneration, should be brought to her. There was some delay in opening the chest in which it was kept, during which the Queen, sighing deeply, exclaimed, ’O unhappy that we are! O guilty that we are! Shall we not be permitted once more to look upon the Holy Cross?!’ When at last it was got out of the chest and brought to her, she received it with reverance, and did her best to embrace it and kiss it, and several times she signed herself with it. Although every part of her body was now growing cold, still as long as the warmth of life throbbed at her heart she continued steadfast in prayer. She repeated the whole of the Fiftieth Psalm, and placing the cross before her eyes, she held it there with both her hands.
The Black Cross was first given by Gizela to Agatha in c.1045 when Gizela left Hungary to return to Bavaria (Niedenburg), where she lived out her life as a nun and died in c.1060. From Agatha, it passed to Margaret, presumably when Agatha returned to Bavaria in or after 1070. The cross isn’t described in detail, but it was gold set, encrusted with dark stones. It was at this point that her son, Edgar, returning from the army, entered the queen’s bedroom:
Conceive his distress at such a moment! Imagine to yourself how his heart was racked! He stood there in strait; everything was against him, and whither to turn himself he knew not. He had come to announce to his mother that his father and brother were both slain, and he found that mother, most dearly beloved by him, at the point of death. He knew not whom first to lament. Yet the loss of his dearest mother, when he saw her nearly dead before his eyes, stung him to his heart with the keenest pang. Besides all this, the condition of the realm occasioned him the deepest anxiety, for he was fully aware that the death of his father would be followed by an insurrection. Sadness and trouble beset him on every side. …
The queen, who seemed to the bystanders to be rapt in agony, suddenly rallied and spoke to her son. She asked him about his father and his brother. He was unwilling to tell the truth, and fearing that if she heard it she would immediately die, he replied that they were well. But with a deep sigh, she exclaimed,
“I know it, my son, I know it. By this holy cross, by the bond of our blood, I adjure you to tell me the truth.”
Thus pressed, he told her exactly all that had happened. … At that same moment, she had lost her husband and son, and disease was bringing her to a cruel death.
… Raising her eyes and hands towards heaven, she glorified God, saying…
“All praise to thee… who hast been pleased that I should endure such deep sorrow at my departing… and I trust that by means of this suffering… I should be cleansed from some of the stains of my sins. … Lord Jesus Christ, … deliver me.”
Her body was carried to the Church of the Holy Trinity at Edinburgh Castle, which she had built, and buried opposite the altar, and thus her body at length rests in that place in which, when alive, she used to humble herself with vigils, prayers and tears. Her place of death is not mentioned in Turgot’s Life of Margaret, but Fordun states that Margaret died in Edinburgh in Castro puellarum on 16 November1093, according to the Chronicle of Mailros. Wynton also related this in his verse form Orygynale Cronikil.
Malcolm’s body was taken to Tynemouth Priory for immediate burial but then was sent north-west for re-burial in the reign of his son, Alexander, at either Dunfermline Abbey or Iona (during the Scottish Reformation the bones of both Malcolm and Margaret were reinterred in Catholic Spain).
Forty; The Later Adventures of the Aetheling, Scotland and the Crusades, 1093-1126:
On his return from Flanders, Eadgar the Aetheling had been forced to pay homage to William, and a chronicler tells us that he dragged on a sluggish and contended life as the friend and pensioner of Norman patrons. Disappointed with the level of recompense and respect shown to him by William, however, in 1086 he renounced his allegiance to the Conqueror and moved with his retinue to Norman Apulia in Italy. The Domesday Book, compiled that year, records Eadgar’s possession of only two small estates in Hertfordshire. Clearly, he left for Italy not intending to return, but the venture in the Mediterranean was unsuccessful and within a year or so he had returned to England. But in 1093, following the death of his sister Margaret, Eadgar decided to go on his travels again, this time returning to his birthplace, Hungary, and from thence to the Eastern Mediterranean and Byzantium.
When the First Crusade was proclaimed in England in 1095, William Golafre (de Goulafriére), Suffolk sub-tenant, was one of the first Anglo-Norman knights to join the contingent of Robert of Normandy; in general, cross-channel family connections must have been how most crusaders from Britain were recruited.
The Norman army which had invaded England in 1066 was by no means exclusively Norman, nor were the new tenants-in-chief or barons of the thirty years following. They included men from many parts of France, who traced their ancestry to Flanders, Aquitaine, Anjou and Brittany, in addition to Normandy. The Golafre family were one noble family who really did come over with the Conqueror from St Evreux in Normandy where they were Lords of Mesnil Bernard. There is still a small town, or large village, called La Goulafriere.
Guillaume Goullafre can still be found in the archives of Bayeux Cathedral for the eleventh century (Chronology of the Ancient Nobility of the Duchy of Normandy, 1087-1096) where he appears on a list of lords who accompanied Robert Duke of Normandy on the first crusade in 1096. He is also listed as one of the Knights Templar. Leland also refers to a Guillaume Goulaffre (Dives Roll) and a Roger Gulafre, who claimed property from St. Evroult, where a great abbey still stands. He is referred to specifically as Lord of Mesnil Bernard. William Gulafre, as he later seems to have been known in England, held great estates in Suffolk at the time of Domesday (1086) and gave tithes to Eye Abbey.
William’s son, Roger Gulafre, was also of Suffolk, according to the Pipe Rolls of 1130, and Philip Gulafre held four fees in barony in the same county later in the twelfth century, as well as manors in Essex. They also seem to have inter-married with both French and Breton noble families who arrived in Suffolk during the Conquest. There was also increasing intermarriage between Normans and Saxons, but more often for land rather than love on the part of Norman nobles.
Malcolm’s successor, his brother Donald Bán, drove out the English and French soldiers who had risen high in Malcolm’s service and had aroused the jealousy of the existing Scottish aristocracy. This purge brought him into conflict with the Anglo-Norman monarchy, whose influence in Scotland had diminished following the Conqueror’s death. William helped Malcolm’s eldest son, Duncan, who had spent many years as a hostage at William I’s court and remained there when set free by William II, to overthrow his uncle, but Donald soon regained the throne and Duncan was killed.
In the forty years from 1093 to 1133, Jerusalem was taken for Christianity and north-western Europe’s population and settlements developed to a point not seen since the Celtic migrations of the fourth century BC.
The military and religious movement known as the Crusades began in 1095, with the call of Pope Urban II for a campaign to free the holy places of the Middle East from Muslim domination. Britain’s involvement with crusading was at first modest. A twelfth-century English chronicler wrote that of the events in Asia (’Minor’), only a faint murmur crossed the channel. When Pope Urban summoned the chivalry of Christendom to the Crusade, he also released in the masses across Europe hopes and hatreds which were to express themselves in ways quite alien to the aims of the papal policy.
The main object of Urban’s famous appeal was to provide Byzantium with the reinforcements it needed to drive the Seljuk Turks from Asia Minor; for he hoped that in return the Eastern (Orthodox) Church would acknowledge the supremacy of Rome so that the unity of Christendom would be restored.
In addition, he was concerned to indicate to the nobility an alternative outlet for martial energies which were still constantly bringing devastation to continental lands. The Church had, for half a century, been concerned with limiting feudal warfare by what it referred to as the Truce of God. Accordingly, in addition to the clerics, a large number of lesser nobles had come to Clermont to hear the Pope address the Council.
To those who would take part in the Crusade, Urban offered impressive rewards. A knight who took the Cross would earn a remission from temporal penalties for all his sins; if he died in battle, he would earn remission of sins. And there were to be material as well as spiritual rewards.
The great nobles of Western Europe set off in 1096 by different routes to Constantinople, crossing the Bosphorus and overrunning Asia Minor. However, Eadgar’s invasion of Scotland late in 1097 would have made it impossible for him to have been commander of the English fleet which arrived off the Syrian coast in March 1098, as claimed by Orderic. Another effort to restore the Anglo-Norman influence in Scotland through sponsorship of Malcolm’s sons was launched in 1097, and Eadgar made yet another journey north, this time in command of an invading army. Donald was ousted, and Eadgar installed his nephew and namesake, Malcolm and Margaret’s son Edgar, on the Scottish throne.
Moreover, Eadgar’s niece Eadyth, daughter of Malcolm and Margaret, married Henry I on 11th November 1100, becoming Queen Matilda, three months into Henry’s reign. While we have no record of the wedding guests, it is unlikely that Eadgar would have gone abroad before so auspicious a royal wedding. Finally, the English had an English Queen, a daughter of Wessex, of the true royal family of England, as the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle pointedly put it.
After the ceremony, Eadgar travelled overland to join the fleet in the Eastern Mediterranean. No doubt, he took the route along the Danube through the land of his birth, Hungary, opened up to pilgrims by King István. He would then have sailed from Byzantium through the Dardanelles to the Levant and Syria, though there is no record of his journey.
In dealing with the variety of crusader armies reaching the western borders of Hungary, King Koloman had forged good relations with the French-led forces, defeated those of the prophetae and did not permit both those of William the Carpenter, Viscount of Melun and those of Count Emich of Leiningen to cross the country. In addition, the marriage of King Ladislas’s fabulously beautiful daughter, Piroska, had earned Hungary the goodwill of Constantinople.
The reigns of both Ladislas and Koloman brought about a fundamental change in Hungary’s international standing. Whereas throughout the eleventh century, the nascent kingdom had to defend itself against German expansionism, in the next three centuries it was emboldened by the conquest of Dalmatia and Croatia, and it was able to pursue expansionist policies of its own. Koloman’s economic policies continued the work of Ladislas, imposing higher taxes on commerce, which was refreshed by the influx of Jews who had been expelled from Bohemia by the Crusaders.However, there is little evidence of a renewal of direct relations between the English and Hungarian monarchies until the end of the fifteenth century.
The crusaders entered Jerusalem in 1099 and the group led by Eadgar distinguished itself in the service of the Byzantine emperor on the Crusade of 1101-2. William of Malmesbury recorded that Eadgar made his pilgrimage to Jerusalem in 1102 so that Orderic’s report is probably the result of his conflation of the English fleet’s expedition with Eadgar’s later journey.
On his way back from Jerusalem, Eadgar was given rich gifts by both the Byzantine and German emperors, each of whom offered him an honoured place at court, but he insisted on returning home, whether that was to be England or Scotland. Some historians, however, have suggested that at some point in these years he served in the Varangian Guard of the Byzantine Empire, in a unit that was composed primarily of English exiles under the leadership of Siward Barn, released from captivity by William at the end of his reign, whom Eadgar had known from his time in exile at the court of King Malcolm. Siward was reported as being in the company of Eadgar at Wearmouth after the failure of the northern rising and the Harrying of the North, and to have accompanied him to Scotland. He was then arrested by William’s troops at the siege of Ely in 1072 and imprisoned until 1087. From there, he went to Byzantium where he became the Sigurd Jarl commanding the other Anglo-Danish exiles in the Emperor’s service.
Forty-one – 1100; Godfric and Godiva – the Anglophile Norman Monarch and his Wessex Wife:
A temporary truce between the royal brothers, William and Robert, had prevailed from 1096 when Robert left to fight in the First Crusade, but four years later Rufus was killed while hunting in the New Forest, leaving either Robert or the youngest son, Henry to be crowned as England’s new king. Robert hurriedly returned from the East, and the struggle for supremacy resumed.
Back in Europe, Eadgar again took the side of Robert Curthose in the internal struggles of the Norman dynasty, firstly against William Rufus and then against Henry Beauclerc. But when he was taken prisoner at the Battle of Tinchebrai in 1106 and sent back to England, he was pardoned and released by King Henry, who was by then his nephew through his marriage to Matilda (Eadyth). The dynastic struggle ended when Henry captured Robert, who spent the rest of his life in prison, dying in 1134, a year before Henry’s own death.
Henry’s victory at Tinchebrai over Duke Robert was the culminating point in the struggle for Normandy and after nineteen years, the King of England was once more Duke of Normandy; like Hastings, the battle was a touchstone of prestige among the Normans, a battle with which the aristocracy wished to be associated if they possibly could be.
Cristina of Wessex
Born in England, married in England to an Anglo-Scottish princess and buried in England, William’s youngest son, Henry, appears to have been the first royal Norman anglophile. His marriage was a major factor in this and came about because Margaret of Scotland’s sister Cristina (pictured above) became a nun in southern England and became acquainted with Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury (1033/4-1109). Margaret’s daughter, Eadyth, was placed in the care of Cristina, who took her first to Romsey Abbey and later to Wilton Abbey in Wiltshire, not far from Winchester. However, although Cristina made her niece wear a nun’s veil to protect her from the lust of the Normans, she never took holy orders and fought to maintain her status as a marriageable woman. Her father, Malcolm, is said to have torn her headdress from her when he first visited her at Wilton. The Abbey was a place of education for other royal children during the early medieval period.
While there, she met Henry at William Rufus’s Court following the death of her parents in 1093, and on the couple’s marriage, William of Malmesbury wrote that Henry had long been attached to her. Orderic Vitalis also wrote that Henry had long adored her character and capacity. He also wrote that she was not bad-looking, despite her excessive face painting which, he claimed, didn’t improve her appearance. She testified to Anselm at Lambeth Palace that she had not become a nun, and he held a council at which he ruled that she was eligible to marry the King and become his Queen Consort. At her coronation, she took the regnal name of her Great Aunt Matilda in order to appease the Norman noblemen at court, and became known to the people as Good Queen Maud.
He and his Eadyth christened their daughter Matilda, for the benefit of their Norman baronage, but privately called her by the Anglo-Saxon title ‘Aethelic,’ while their son William was given the title ‘Aetheling’, like his great uncle, Eadgar. During the English investiture crisis of 1103-1107, Queen Matilda acted as an intercessor between Henry and Anselm. England and Scotland also grew closer during Henry and Matilda’s reign, especially after Margaret’s youngest son David’s accession to the Scottish throne.
Henry ‘Beauclerc’ (1100-1135) helped Normans and Saxons to live side by side in peace and granted a charter upholding the best of the English laws. He set up a King’s Court (Curia Regis), where disputes and crimes were dealt with by trained lawyers. As a result, the chroniclers recorded, the people learned the value of the King’s Peace. Some of his plans to systematise this means of justice were carried out by Henry II.
Towards the end of his reign, in a sign of his commitment to compromise within the English Church, Henry appointed a Saxon priest, Aethelwolf to the newly created Bishopric of Carlisle. In addition to teaching her husband English, Matilda was responsible for encouraging William of Malmesbury to write his History of the English Kings. The chronicler had written of England after the Conquest as:
… the habitation of strangers and the dominion of foreigners. There is today no Englishman who is either earl, bishop or abbot. The newcomers devour the riches and entrails of England, and there is no hope of the misery coming to an end.
Clearly, Henry set out to effect a reconciliation between the Normans and the English. According to William of Malmesbury however, none of this went down well with the Normans at Henry’s court who openly mocked the king and queen, calling them Godric and Godgifu (Godiva), but it did play well with the majority of the king’s English subjects across the country as a whole. No doubt, this was Henry’s intention.
King Henry also reached out to the Scots by giving the hand of Matilda of Huntingdon, daughter of Waltheof, Earl of Northumbria, to David I of Scotland. The marriage brought with it The Honour of Huntingdon, a lordship scattered through the shires of Northampton, Huntingdon and Bedford. These new territories increased David’s status not just as the undisputed king north of the border, but as one of the most powerful magnates in the Kingdom of the English. In addition, he acquired the former lordship of Waltheof, covering the far north of England including Cumberland, Westmorland and Northumberland, as well as the overlordship of the bishopric of Durham. He was, effectively, ‘King in the North’. Despite his sister Eadyth’s death in 1118, David retained the favour of King Henry and was the first to take the oath to uphold the succession of his niece, Matilda, to the English throne.
Forty-two; 1113 – Scotland & the Borders to the reign of David:
The Normans faced an even less well-developed border with their northern neighbours than with the Welsh. There were no clear geographical boundaries capable of preventing political expansion, and ethnicity by itself could not serve as the basis for states. Nor could language, so that what eventually became Scotland, and, to a lesser extent, Cumberland and Northumberland, were ethnically, linguistically, culturally diverse territories which often ovelapped each other, including Scots, Picts, Gaels, Britons, Angles and Saxons.
Until the mid-twelfth century, it was unclear whether much of what eventually became lowland Scotland and northern England, in particular Cumbria and Northumbria, would be part of the Kingdom of England or the Kingdom of Scotland. The mixture of populations in Cumbria and Lothian ensured that there was no obvious border. William II’s conquest of Cumbria in 1092 played a major role in fixing the frontier with England, but many of the northern and western isles still remained in the possession of Norway, a continuing, complicating factor for the Plantagenet kings.
The Scottish King David I had been Prince of the Cumbrians (1113-24) before becoming King of Scotland. He spent most of his childhood in Scotland but was exiled to England in 1093, after being orphaned by the deaths of Malcolm and Margaret. As their second youngest son, he became a dependant of his aunt and uncle, Henry I and Queen Matilda. The three royal brothers, David, Alexander and Edgar, had been in their mother’s room when she died.
According to The Melrose Chronicle, the three brothers were then besieged in Edinburgh Castle by their paternal uncle, Donald III, who had made himself king and forced his three nephews into exile. John of Fordun later wrote that Eadgar Aetheling arranged an escort for them into England. From Westminster, King William II opposed Donald’s succession and sent the exiled boys’ half-brother, Duncan, into Scotland with an army, but he was killed within a year. When William was accidentally killed, his younger brother Henry became king and married David’s sister, Eadyth, making David his brother-in-law and an important figure at the English court. Despite his Gaelic upbringing, by the end of his time at court, David was a fully Anglo-Norman prince. When King Edgar died, he was succeeded by Alexander, and David became Prince of the Cumbrians in 1113. In the same year, Henry returned from Normandy and David founded Selkirk Abbey. This and King Henry’s backing seems to have been enough to force Alexander to recognise his younger brother’s claims to southern Scotland.
When his brother, Alexander I died in 1124, David took over the Kingdom of Alba but had to engage in dynastic warfare against his nephew, Máel Coluim mac Alexandair, a struggle that lasted a full decade. In 1134, Máel Coluim was captured and imprisoned in Roxburgh Castle. By the time King Henry died in December 1135, David had more of Scotland under his control than any Scottish king before, but his plans for the north began to encounter problems in the 1150s when the King of Norway gained fealty over Orkney.
Eadgar Aetheling travelled to Scotland once more late in life, around the year 1120 and was still alive in 1125, according to William of Malmesbury, growing old in the country in privacy and quiet. Having finally given up his claim to the English throne, the ‘Aetheling’ died in 1126, not long after his niece, Eadyth (Queen Matilda) in 1121. Before her death, Queen Matilda honoured her mother by founding the house of Holy Trinity in Aldgate, London.
The founding order, the Premonstratensians, had also been particularly important in Scotland, founding the house at Dryburgh on the border and reviving the holy site of St Ninian’s white church at Whithorn. But the most enduring of the new orders were the Cistercians. From their first foundation at Waverley in Surrey (1128) by William Giffard, Bishop of Winchester, the order quickly spread throughout Britain. They founded the abbeys of Rievaulx, Fountains and Byland in North Yorkshire, Tintern in Wales, Thame in Oxfordshire, and Coombe Abbey in Warwickshire.
The Cistercians exploited their far-flung estates through granges, model farms operated by lay brothers who supervised paid labourers. Most of these were established in the twelfth century, the great era of Cistercian expansion. By then, Yorkshire had forty-six granges. The size of a grange depended on the type of land, so that in North Wales, where it was mostly mountainous and barren, Aberconwy’s grange covered twelve thousand acres, whereas the average size of the granges in east Yorkshire was less than five hundred acres. In rural districts, where parishes might be far apart and ill-equipped, monasteries had always provided a pastoral ministry.
Scottish Cistercian monasteries such as Sweetheart and Glenluce operated a mission field covering much of southwest Scotland. The Augustinian canons, founded at the beginning of the twelfth century, supplemented the work of parish priests by combining extra-mural ministry with cloistered life. The main purpose of the monastery, however, remained the contemplation and worship of God within the abbey walls. Most monasteries, like Waverley, were slenderly endowed and remained poor throughout their first century. The building of the magnificent abbey church of Rievaulx, together with the equally impressive complex of cloisters, refectories, kitchens, infirmaries and dormitories, left the monastery deep in debt.
Forty-three; The White Ship Disaster and Succession Crisis, 1120-35:
The death of Henry I of England in 1135 left another disputed succession in England. Prince William, King Henry’s only legitimate son and heir, had perished in the wreck of the White Ship in 1120 and Henry’s second marriage, following the death of Matilda of Scotland, to Adeliza, the daughter of Geoffrey of Louvain, failed to produce a new male heir. In an attempt to secure the succession of his daughter, Empress Matilda (so-titled because she had inherited the German Empire from her first husband), Henry extracted an oath of allegiance to her from the Anglo-Norman barons in December 1126.
But Stephen, younger brother of Theobold II, Count of Blois, laid claim to the Crown on the pretext that Matilda’s mother had taken holy orders as a nun, and therefore that her marriage to Henry was null and void, meaning that Matilda was also illegitimate. This was despite Archbishop Anselm’s ruling before her marriage and coronation. Henry did little to ensure her succession apart from the oath, but her uncle, David I of Scotland, was among the first to take the oath.
Empress Matilda remained a popular choice in Wessex and West Mercia, acquiring the epithet, Lady of the English, an echo of the title given by the Mercians to Aethelflaeda two centuries previously. But her popularity did not extend to the Anglo-Norman barons and élite of London. Although the Saxons might support the concept of a female monarch, Stephen’s Norman supporters would not. Moreover, Matilda’s second marriage to Geoffrey Plantagenet, Count of Anjou, a traditional and much-hated enemy of the Norman aristocracy, provoked criticism from them, so that the question of the succession was, in reality, far from settled.There were alternative candidates but Stephen of Blois, Henry’s nephew, emerged as a favourite and seized the throne in the confusion that followed the king’s death.
One of the nobles who played a major role in this seizure of the English Crown was Hugh Bigod, who had succeeded to his brother’s estates in East Anglia after the latter had been drowned in the White Ship disaster of 1120. Bigod had plenty of scope for self-aggrandisement and coat-turning during the era of the Anarchy after 1135. Hurrying back from Rouen, where he had been attending the dying King, Hugh convinced the Archbishop of Canterbury that, on his deathbed, Henry had nominated Stephen as his heir. He did this not out of respect for Henry’s dying wishes, but because he saw Stephen as a weak man whom the barons could easily manipulate. As soon as these expectations proved unfounded, Bigod raised the standard of revolt at Norwich. There he was besieged by Stephen and forced to surrender. However, Stephen pardoned the troublesome baron with more charity than wisdom.
Stephen acted quickly, and took ship to London, where he was received by many as king, and hurried on to Winchester to secure the reins of government and the royal treasury. The result was a prolonged civil war in England, from 1139 to 1153, which extended into Scotland and Wales. Although many of the barons immediately declared for Stephen, there was opposition from the start in England, Wales and Scotland.
Forty-four – Durham, 1135-39; King in the North – The Anarchy.
At first, Stephen reigned securely throughout the entire Anglo-Norman realm, but then the Welsh, subdued under Henry I, revolted, while David seized Northumbria.
David had continued to support the claim of his niece to the English throne, bringing him into conflict with Stephen of Blois, and when Stephen was crowned on 22 December 1135, David declared war on him. Though some contemporary chroniclers claimed that he acted opportunistically, to protect his lands in northern England, dynastic hostility towards Stephen was also part of his effort to uphold the legacy of Henry I and the inheritance of House of Wessex. David carried out his wars in Matilda’s name, sometimes risking his own throne in the process.
Before December 1136 was over, David had marched into northern England, and by the end of January, he had occupied the castles of Carlisle, Wark, Alnwick, Northam and Newcastle. Stephen was forced to march north, arriving there with a large army at the beginning of February, which halted the Scottish advance. David was at Durham, where he was met by Stephen’s army. Rather than fight a pitched battle, a treaty was agreed by which David would retain Carlisle while his son, Henry, was re-granted half the lands of the earldom of Huntingdon, territory which had been confiscated.
Stephen would regain the other captured castles; and while David would do no homage for the re-granted lands, Stephen would receive his son, Henry’s homage both for Carlisle and the other English territories regained. These over-generous concessions in subsequent negotiations encouraged David to doubt the new English king’s resolution in pursuing affairs of state. The issue of Matilda’s succession was not mentioned; however, this first Durham treaty quickly broke down after David took insult at the treatment of Henry at Stephen’s court.
When the winter of 1136-37 was over, David prepared to invade England again. The King of the Scots massed an army on the Northumberland border, to which the English responded by gathering their forces at Newcastle. Once more, they avoided a pitched battle, and a truce was agreed upon until December when David demanded that Stephen hand over the whole of the old earldom of Northumbria. Stephen’s refusal led to a third Scottish invasion, this time in January 1138, when Stephen was forced to march north again.
Stephen’s army disintegrated through maladministration and betrayal in a brief campaign during which the Lowlands were due to be ravaged as an object lesson to the rest of Scotland. The ferocity with which the Scots army then invaded that January and February shocked the English ‘chroniclers’. Richard of Hexham called the Scottish force:
… an execrable army, savager than any race of heathen yielding honour to neither God nor man, (that)harried the whole province and slaughtered everywhere folk of either sex, of every age and condition, destroying, pillaging and burning the villes, churches and houses.
The same chroniclers (‘propagandists’ might be a more appropriate epithet) painted a lurid picture of routine enslavements, killings of churchmen, women and infants, and even cannibalism. In February, King Stephen marched north, but the two armies avoided each other and he was soon on the road south again. In the summer, David decided to split his army, sending a column into Lancashire, under his nephew William, while he harried Furness and Craven in advancing to Newcastle. On 10 June, William Fitz Duncan met a force of knights and men-at-arms near Clitheroe, and a pitched battle took place in which the English army was routed.
Later that summer, the influential English baron Eustace Fitz John went over to David, taking with him his castles at Alnwick and Malton. This encouraged the Scots to launch yet another and even greater offensive, with their army bolstered by reinforcements from the north and west. Stephen’s attention was fully occupied with rebellions in the south, and the defence of the north was left to Archbishop Thurstan of York. But in allowing his Galloway troops to plunder the countryside, David had overplayed his hand and the northern English barons united against him to put an end to the repeated Scottish forays.
Responding to Bishop Thurstan’s appeal for a crusade against the Scots to gather at Thirsk, the armed strength of the North mustered at York, preceded by the banners of St Peter of York, St John of Beverley and St Wilfred of Ripon, flying from a mast mounted on a carriage. The English army then moved north on the road through Northallerton to Darlington.
By late July 1138, two Scottish armies had reunited in St Cuthbert’s land, in the lands controlled by the Bishop of Durham, on the north side of the River Tyne. Another English army had mustered to meet the Scots, led by William, Earl of Aumerle. The Scots refused an offer of negotiations and the northern English army advanced to intercept them at Northallerton. Inspired by his victory at Clitheroe, David decided to risk battle. David’s force, apparently 26,000 strong, was far larger than the English army when the two forces met on Cowdon Moor near Northallerton (North Yorks).
Despite their strength in numbers, The Battle of the Standard, as it came to be known, was a defeat for the Scots. Early in the morning of 22 August, the Anglo-Normans occupied the southernmost of the two hillocks standing six hundred yards (550 metres) apart, to the east of the Darlington road. The carriage supporting the sacred standards was positioned on the southern summit and the English troops deployed in their defence. They formed in three groups with a front rank comprising dismounted men-at-arms and archers, a solid body of knights around the standards, and shire levies deployed at the rear and on each flank. At some distance to the south of the hill, a small number of mounted troops stood guard over the army’s horses.
The Scots drew up on the northern hillock with men-at-arms and archers to the fore and the poorly-equipped Gallwegians and Highlanders in the rear. The men of Galloway were incensed by their deployment and demanded to be repositioned in their customary place at the front of the battle line. Unwisely, for once, David gave his assent to their demand and the unarmoured Gallwegians formed the highly vulnerable spearhead of the attack. The troops from Strathclyde and the eastern lowlands formed on the right under David’s son Prince Henry, who also commanded a body of mounted knights. The left was predominantly West Highlanders and to the rear stood a small reserve under the Scots’ King with men from Moray and the East Highlands.
The men of Galloway opened the attack, charging through a hail of defensive fire from the Norman archers with such impetuosity that they temporarily broke the Norman front rank. The depth of the Anglo-Norman formation, however, made further penetration impossible and the Gallwegians were gradually pushed back. Despite repeated assaults, they were unable to make a decisive lodgement in the English ranks and Prince Henry attempted to break the stalemate with a mounted charge. Despite heavy losses of knights, his thrust was so successful that his cavalry crashed straight through the English lines and carried their charge in the direction of the tethered horses and Northallerton.
Before the Scottish infantry could take advantage of the passage created by their cavalry, the English had closed ranks and the Scots met a solid shield war. Prince Henry was marooned to the rear of the English army and unable to break away to the north. The Scottish left and the King’s reserve were unwilling to renew the offensive and many of their infantry began to leave the field.
Admitting defeat, David and his bodyguard joined the retreat leaving only a small company of knights to cover his army’s retreat. The Anglo-Norman deployment did not lend itself to the rapid exploitation of the Scots’ retreat and there seems to have been no attempt to harry or pursue them.
David retired to Carlisle, with his surviving notables, and having retained the bulk of his army, and therefore the power to go on the offensive again. He marched north to join the Scottish troops who had been attempting to reduce the castle at Wark. The siege, which had begun in January, continued until it was captured in November, and David continued to occupy Cumberland as well as much of Northumberland.
Satisfied that the Scottish threat had been successfully parried, Stephen’s army had temporarily dispersed, leaving only a baronial contingent in the field to besiege Eustace Fitz John’s castle at Malton. The ease with which the Scots were able to roam the northern counties demonstrated that the border country needed further fortification. Therefore, despite the defeat at Northallerton, David I was able to hold the frontier of his domain at the rivers Tees and Eden.
On 26th September 1138, David called together his kingdom’s notables, bishops and abbots. Cardinal Alberic, Bishop of Ostia, was also there and played the role of peace broker, and David agreed to a six-week truce which excluded the siege of Wark. A settlement was agreed in April, in Durham. David’s son Henry was restored to all his northern English lands and the earldom of Huntingdon, while David kept Carlisle and Cumberland. Stephen was to keep control of the castles of Bamburgh and Newcastle. This effectively delivered all of David’s official war aims and he attained dominion over all of England’s north-west along the River Ribble and the Pennines, and the north-east as far as the Tyne.
Forty-five – May 1139; Westminster & Winchester – Matilda’s Return:
By 1139, Robert of Gloucester, Henry I’s illegitimate son, had joined his half-sister, providing Matilda with a base in the west of England to accompany the lands held on her behalf in the North, Midlands and Wales. He then stood by her when she landed in England in 1139. The arrival in England of Empress Matilda allowed David to renew the conflict with Stephen.In May or June, David travelled to the south of England and entered Matilda’s company, and he was present for her expected coronation at Westminster Abbey. However, this never took place due to the hostility of the Norman élite in the capital. David therefore remained at Winchester until September when the Empress found herself surrounded there.
Now there were two rival courts in England, and a stalemate ensued. However, David’s control of northern England was confirmed. The castles at Bamburgh and Newcastle were again brought under his control, while his son brought all the senior barons of Northumberland into his entourage. David took over and rebuilt the English fortress at Carlisle, which quickly replaced Roxburgh as his favourite residence. His acquisition of the mines at Alston on the south Tyne enabled him to begin minting the Kingdom of Scotland’s first silver coinage.
Stephen became the hated usurper, especially in the North of England, where the conflict reopened many of the unhealed sores of the Conquest and the hatred between Norman and Anglo-Danish noble families. Stephen spent the rest of his reign in England struggling with Matilda’s supporters. For the best part of two decades, most of England and parts of Wales were embroiled in a deeply divisive civil war, a period when, according to the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, Men said openly that Christ and his saints slept.There, and in other chronicles, the record told of war and waste, pestilence and famine, castle-building, oppression and torture. After the long peace of Henry I’s reign, the vocabulary of the Conquest had returned.
In 1140, Stephen granted Herefordshire and its earldom, to Robert de Beaumont, Earl of Leicester, but excluded the lands and obligations of Hugh Mortimer and two other barons from Robert’s jurisdiction. The Wigmore Chronicler tells of Hugh’s continual feuds with Miles, Matilda’s nominee as Earl of Hereford. Whether or not the account of a private war is accurate, it vividly portrays the anarchic state of the Marcher lordships during the 1140s.
In addition,the Marcher lords became disillusioned with Stephen’s weak policy towards Wales and his inability to sustain his barons there. Many of them went over to Matilda as prospective queen in the civil war, but Hugh Mortimer appears to have been an exception, since the problem for many Norman magnates was that Matilda had married Geoffrey Plantagenet, Count of Anjou. The counts had for generations been rivals of the dukes of Normandy and many Norman barons in England with lands in Normandy now feared that, as by Norman law Matilda’s rights and property would pass to her husband, the Duchy would fall under the control of Geoffrey of Anjou. They therefore supported Stephen’s claim to Normandy and by extension to the Kingdom of England.
Nonetheless, Hugh Mortimer seems to have played little or no part in supporting Stephen on the national stage; his priorities were rather his interests in the March and the Anglo-Welsh border counties where he succeeded in reconquering Maelienydd in 1144 and was able to rebuild his castle of Cymaron. The Welsh chroniclers relate that in 1145-8 he captured the Welsh prince Rhys ap Hywel and later had him blinded.
Forty-six; The Siege of Lincoln, February 1141:
Stephen’s treaty concessions to the Scots, particularly the ceding of Northumbria, drove Ranulf Earl of Chester to rebellion as he considered the lordship of Carlisle and Cumberland to be part of his inheritance. Ranulf seized the castle of Lincoln and the town’s citizens appealed to the King for aid. Stephen and his army arrived at Lincoln on 6 January 1141 and although the speed with which the King had acted took the defenders by surprise, he was not able to prevent the Earl slipping away to Cheshire to raise troops. Ranulf also appealed to his father-in-law, Robert Earl of Gloucester, and promised loyalty to the Empress. Eager to exploit both the opportunity and the resources of his new ally, Robert quickly mustered his forces for a march on Lincoln. Earl Ranulf, with an army of his Cheshire tenants and Welsh mercenaries, joined Robert in Leicestershire and despite the restrictions on mobility imposed by the winter season, they were before Lincoln by 1 February.
Their immediate problem, as ever, was the crossing of the waterways, the Fossdyke and the River Witham, which lay between the rebel army and the castle. It appears most likely that the rebels marched some way to the west of the city walls and stormed across a ford on the Fossdyke which was inadequately guarded by Stephen’s troops. Once over on the Lincoln side of the dyke, the Earl’s army deployed for battle.
The Council of War summoned by Stephen to discuss the rebel threat was divided, the older nobles advising the king to garrison the city and withdraw to raise a larger army, the younger barons urging immediate battle. Stephen chose the latter course and deployed his army from the West Gate on the slope down to the Fossdyke. He formed his army in three divisions, with cavalry on both flanks and infantry in the centre. On the right-hand side were the followers, among others, of William de Warenne and Hugh Bigod, Earl of Norfolk. On the left, Stephen’s mercenary captain, William of Ypres deployed a contingent of Flemish and Breton troops alongside the troops of William of Aumerle. In the centre were elements of the shire-levy of the citizens of Lincoln.
The rebel army also deployed in three divisions, with disinherited nobles on the left, infantry levies and dismounted knights in the centre under Earl Ranulf, and cavalry under Earl Robert on the right. The lightly-armed Welsh were deployed in front of Robert’s cavalry. The rebels were the first to advance, moving forward with swords drawn, intent on close-quarter combat. On Stephen’s right, the Earls’ men fled the field rather than face butchery or capture, while on his left, Ypres and Aumerle rode down the Welsh and crashed into Earl Robert’s cavalry. At this crucial moment, the infantry of the rebel centre was able to intervene and the remaining cavalry under Stephen recoiled in panic which gave way to rout.
Though surrounded, the King and his guard fought their way out of their isolation, with Stephen himself prominent in the savage hand-to-hand combat that followed. Wielding his sword, and then a battle-axe, Stephen became the focus of resistance until struck down by a stone and captured by William de Cahaignes. The latter’s cry of Here, everyone, here! I’ve got the King! brought the fighting to an end. It was a total defeat for Stephen followed by the burning and pillage of Lincoln, whose citizens were slaughtered indiscriminately by the victorious rebels.
Stephen was conveyed to Bristol as a prisoner but although Matilda’s coronation as Queen now appeared only a matter of time, her assumption of the prerogatives of state alienated the citizens of London, causing many of them to confirm their allegiance to Stephen by joining an army raised by Stephen’s queen which routed Matilda’s forces at Winchester. By November 1141, Stephen had been freed.
David’s many successes in battle were in many ways balanced by his failures off the battlefield. His greatest disappointment was his failure to gain control of the Bishopric of Durham and the Archbishopric of York. He had attempted to appoint his chancellor, William Comyn to Durham, which had been empty since the death of Geoffrey Rufus. However, he was unlikely to secure the support of the Papal legate, Henry of Blois, Bishop of Winchester and brother of King Stephen. Despite obtaining the support of Matilda, David was unsuccessful in securing Comyn’s election to the see.
David also failed in his attempt to secure the succession to the Archbishopric of York. William Fitzherbert, King Stephen’s nephew, found his position undermined by the collapsing political fortunes of Stephen in the north of England and was deposed by the Pope. David used his Cistercian connections to build a bond with Henry Murdac, the new archbishop. Despite the support of Pope Eugene III, advocates for King Stephen and Fitz Herbert prevented Murdac from taking up the post at York.
Forty-seven – 1143; The Advent of the Angevins:
By 1143, Geoffrey of Anjou had won control of Normandy south of the Seine and the next year he subdued the remainder of the Duchy. Geoffrey Plantagenet’s victory in Normandy and his assumption of the title of duke placed the Anglo-Norman barons in a dilemma. Lords with interests in both England and Normandy who continued to support Stephen could hardly expect to retain their honours in Normandy. Those lords whose interests in Normandy were more important than those in England, and whoever therefore did homage to Geoffrey and by inference to Matilda, jeopardised their English interests in the parts of the kingdom where Stephen’s writ ran. Some withdrew from the quandary by joining the Second Crusade, but others like Hugh Mortimer reconciled their divided loyalties and preserved their family’s status in both dominions.
Meanwhile, Matilda’s husband, Geoffrey of Anjou, having overrun Normandy, was proclaimed its duke in 1144, winning papal and French support for the Duchy to pass to their son Henry in 1151. It looked as if the Anglo-Norman realms would be split permanently between the two camps, even after Henry invaded England in 1152.
It took the death of Eustace, Stephen’s heir, to break the stalemate: by the Treaty of Winchester (December 1153), Stephen acknowledged Henry Plantagenet as his heir and died within a year, bringing the protracted civil war to an agreed end, and securing for Henry the first undisputed succession to the English throne for more than a century.
In 1149, Henry Murdac had again sought the support of David, who seized on the opportunity to bring the City and Archdiocese of York under his control, and duly marched on the city. However, Stephen’s supporters became aware of David’s intentions and informed Stephen, who himself marched to the city and installed a new garrison. David decided not to risk such an engagement and withdrew. If his intention, as some have suggested, was to bring the whole of ancient Northumbria into his dominions, this event turned the tide against him, and…
…the chance to radically redraw the political map of the British Isles was lost forever.
Nevertheless, David had expanded his control across Northern England, despite defeat at the Battle of the Standard in 1138. He was an independence-loving king trying to build a Scot-Northumbrian realm by seizing the most northerly parts of the English Kingdom. David’s support for Matilda can therefore be seen not so much as a pretext for land-grabbing but as the result of his own descent from the House of Wessex. His son’s descent from the Earls of Northumberland encouraged him in this project which came to an end when his successor was ordered by Henry II of England to hand back the most important of his northern English gains.
Forty-eight – Spring, 1153, Rievaulx & Carlisle; the Scottish Church, David’s Death and the Black Cross:
The Scottish church historians usually acknowledge David’s role as the defender of its independence from claims of overlordship by the Archbishops of York and Canterbury. Aelred of Rievaulx wrote in David’s eulogy that when he became king, …
… he found three or four bishoprics in the whole Scottish kingdom (north of the Firth of Forth), and the others wavering without a pastor due to the loss of both morals and property; when he died, he left nine, both of ancient bishoprics which he himself restored and new ones which he erected.
However, although he moved the bishopric of Mortlach east to Old Aberdeen and arranged for the creation of the Diocese of Caithness, no other bishopric can truly be called David’s creation. The bishopric of Glasgow was restored, with David appointing his reform-minded French chaplain to it, and assigning all the lands of his principality except those in the east already governed by the Bishop of St Andrews. David was also partly responsible for forcing semi-monastic bishoprics like Mortlach (Aberdeen), Brechin, Dunkeld and Dunblane to become fully episcopal and firmly integrated into a national diocesan system.
In addition, some of these changes to ancient monastic foundations were sometimes made at the expense of the original Celtic settlements. Bishop Robert of St Andrews, with the agreement of David, dispossessed the Celtic monks or Culdees in order to place the most sacred relics of Scotland in the care of Augustinian canons. Robert built a church dedicated to the Syrian monk St Regulus, who had reputedly brought the bones of St Andrew to the site in the fourth century. In northern England, the abbeys of Rievaulx, Fountains and Byland in North Yorkshire were all built at this time, and among the daughter houses of Rivaulx was Melrose, established by David I on the place where Aidan had founded his first monastery in Scotland, on the Tweed.
David was one of medieval Scotland’s greatest monastic patrons. He founded more than a dozen new monasteries during his reign as King of Scotland, patronising various new monastic orders. Not only were such monasteries an expression of David’s undoubted piety, they also helped to transform Scottish society. Monasteries became centres of foreign influence and provided sources of literate men, able to serve the crown’s growing administrative needs. The Cistercian monasteries in particular helped to introduce new agricultural practices. They transformed southern Scotland into one of northern Europe’s most important sources of sheep wool.
As for the development of the parochial system, Scotland already had an ancient system of parish churches dating from the early Middle Ages. The kind of system introduced by David’s Normanising reforms was concerned with making the Scottish church as a whole more like that of France and Norman England in a piecemeal fashion, rather than carrying out more radical restructuring.
From the beginning of his reign, David had to deal with the problem of the archepiscopal status of St Andrews, which since the eleventh century had acted as a de facto archbishopric, but never made de jure by the Pope. This opened the way for the aggressively assertive Archbishop of York, Thurstan, to claim overlordship over the entire Scottish church. Added to this, the bishopric of Glasgow was south of the river Firth and neither regarded as part of the Kingdom of Scotland nor in the jurisdiction of St Andrews.
In 1125, the Pope had written to the Bishop of Glasgow urging him to submit to York. David ordered Bishop John to travel to Rome to secure a pallium which would elevate St Andrews to an archbishopric with jurisdiction over Glasgow. In the end, David gained the support of Henry I, and York’s claim over the bishops north of the Firth was quietly dropped for the rest of David’s reign, although York maintained its claims over Glasgow.
The greatest blow to David’s ecclesiastical and secular plans came on 12 July 1152 when Henry, Earl of Northumberland, his heir, died, after suffering from a long-term illness. David must have known that he had not long to live, as he arranged for his grandson, Malcolm IV, to be made his successor, and for his younger grandson, William, to be made Earl of Northumberland.While the eleven-year-old Malcolm was taken on a tour of the kingdom by the senior magnate and future rector (regent) Donnchad I, David’s health deteriorated rapidly in the spring of 1153, and he died at Carlisle Castle on 24th May.
On his deathbed, David asked for his mother’s black cross, which had originally belonged to Gizela, István’s Queen in Hungary, showing once again the importance of the Árpád dynasty heritage. In his obituary, he is called Dabid mac Mail Colaim rí Alban, Saxan (David, son of Malcolm, King of Scotland and England). The title not only acknowledged his English lands, but also his ancient Wessex heritage. He is recognised as a saint by the Roman Catholic Church but was never formally canonised, unlike his mother, Saint Margaret of Scotland, who was canonised in 1249. Aelred of Rivaulx, his courtier, praised David for his justice and piety, urging Henry Plantagenet, his Anglo-Angevin nephew to follow his example in kingship.
Scene Thirty; 1070-71 – The Legendary Outlaws of the Fens:
Many of the stories of Hereward the Outlaw that follow these events were written down several generations after his own day, by which time they had already followed a legendary turn of phrase. But the twelfth-century Gesta Herewardi contains a kernel of factual detail, and, interestingly, Orderic Vitalis, without mentioning Hereward by name, provided additional material concerning the roles of Edwin and Morcar in the Fenland Rising following their submission to William in 1070.
Nevertheless, despite these disappointments, the rebels took refuge at Ely where they held out for several months against the newly appointed Norman lords, including William de Warenne in Castle Acre in Norfolk, William Malet of Eye, William de Goulafriére in Debenham and Richard Fitz Gilbert in Clare, all in Suffolk, aided by Abbot Turold. The outlaws continued to harry the Normans at every opportunity.
Like Hereward Asketil himself, many were of Danish descent, including Thorkell of Harringworth of Northants. The success of their widespread raiding and pillaging, and their more organised guerilla warfare, reassured many Englishmen that all was not yet lost. In retrospect, Hereward can perhaps best be seen, not as an isolated outlaw, but as a typical product of Cnut’s Anglo-Danish state, the remnants of which were now in open resistance to the new Norman state.
For a time, the King did little, leaving the task of containment to these barons, until the small bands were joined by Earl Morcar and his Northumbrian supporters. These included Bishop Aethelwine, the last Anglo-Saxon Bishop of Durham, appointed by Edward the Confessor and consecrated in 1056. In 1059, he had accompanied King Malcolm of Scotland to the court of King Edward, and he was initially loyal to William, submitting to him at York in 1068, following the submission of most of the northern thegns.
Aethelwine had also brought word to William from Malcolm that the Scottish king wished to live in peace with the new English king. William sent him back to Malcolm’s court with his terms, which were accepted. In 1069, when the new earl of Northumbria, Robert de Comyn, came north to begin governing, Aethelwine tried to warn the new earl about the new English army which was in the area, but the earl was burnt to death in the bishop’s house in Durham in January 1069. When William marched north in retaliation, Aethelwine fled and became an outlaw.
During the Harrying, Aethelwine had led the people of his bishopric to a temporary refuge on Lindisfarne, but by the Spring of 1070 he had returned to the mainland. He decided to resign his bishopric rather than wait to be expelled. He feared William’s wrath, but taking ship for exile, was frustrated by storms and ended up in Scotland, where he met Eadgar Aetheling, Maerlsweyn and their band of fellow exiles. News reached them of the stand being made at Ely, and joining thegn Siward Barn and several hundred other exiles, at some point in 1071 they sailed down the east coast, meeting Morcar and other refugees near Ely.
The Earls Morcar and Edwin feared that, as part of William’s revenge for the risings of 1069, they would be imprisoned, so they had escaped from their house arrest at court and, for six months, hiding out in the woods and fields, evading capture until, hoping to find a ship to carry them to Flanders, they arrived at Ely, where they met with a few other nobles and their housecarls. Among the nobles were two more of Edwin and Morcar’s relatives, Godric of Corby and Tostig of Daventry. These men had come south, seeking to flee to the continent, except for Prince Eadgar and Maerlsweyn, the English sheriff of Lincolnshire and their supporters, who had sought refuge in Scotland.
They had all met up near Wisbech in the Fens, and persuaded Hereward to allow them to spend the winter at Ely. Hereward himself had not been among those who had joined Eadgar Aetheling in the welcome extended to Earl Osbjern and the sons of Sweyn of Denmark, nor in their advance on York and cooperation with the Northumbrian rebels. But his presence in England is confirmed by the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle for 1070, dealing with the appointment of Turold of Malmesbury to Peterborough. The monks of Peterborough learnt that…
… because they had heard it said that the king had given the abbacy to a French abbot called Turold… their own men, namely Hereward and his band (genge), wished to plunder the monastery.
They were also aware that Turold had arrived at Stamford in Lincolnshire with a troop of Norman soldiers who were preparing to advance on Peterborough. Turold already had a reputation as someone who would view the abbey as a source of personal wealth both for himself and his associates. His enfoeffments accounted for nearly half of the abbey’s property. The monks therefore arranged for Hereward and his men to raid the monastery in order to stop Turold getting his hands on its treasured ornaments and vessels. By mid-1070, William had extended military service to bishops and abbots because he needed the church and its monasteries to pay for his army of occupation. Consequently, he appointed abbots who were prepared to raid the abbeys’ treasures for him.
So, late in the same year, the last notable remnants of English opposition to King William were now all gathered at one place, the almost impregnable fortress which was the Isle of Ely with its equally defensible fenland monastery. The rivers, meres and marshes surrounding the Isle made it a formidable obstacle, especially to an army whose strength lay in its use of cavalry. Any attempt to get onto the Isle, such as from Soham or Downham, were well known and could be easily defended. Hereward and his band had held out for some months against William’s local commanders.
Thirty-one; 1071-72, Ely – The Last Stand of the English Rebels:
In 1071, William’s presence was required in Normandy to ensure his control over the duchy. King Malcolm was also a constant threat from Scotland and although the Danes had returned home, the magnates knew they could easily return. On his return from Normandy, William realised that the presence of a larger fighting force, led by the remainder of the Anglo-Danish thanes, including Hereward, would continue to be a magnet for the disinherited and disaffected.
Added to this, the English exiles in Flanders could organise a return at any point, and Ely could be reinforced via the Wash by the Danes. There were over eight thousand exiles on the continent, and with Flemish support, they could recruit mercenaries to recoup their strength. But the absence of a major figure in exile to organise an invasion would eventually enable William to defeat the rebels and overcome Ely. He ordered out naval and land levies to prevent a further Danish threat, and built a two-mile-long causeway onto the Isle. The Peterborough Anglo-Saxon Chronicle recorded that:
… all the outlaws surrendered to him, namely Bishop Aethelwine and Earl Morcar and all their except Hereward alone and all who wished to follow him; and he courageously led their escape.
This mention of Earl Morcar is the first since his submission at Warwick early in 1068 before the northern rebellions of 1069-70 in which they took no part. At some point during the winter of 1070-71 they stole away in secret from the king’s household and set about trying to raise rebellion once again. It soon became apparent, however, just how far their fortunes had sunk when no-one rallied to their cause. Their failure reduced them to the status of fugitives. The outlawed Mercian thane, Hereward, was one of the few men on whom the earls could count. Their flight to Ely was probably one of the key factors that persuaded William to return to England in 1071.
Sometime in the autumn of 1071, King William gathered together an army supported by a fleet and prepared to blockade the Isle of Ely. He could not lay siege to the whole of the island as if it were simply another castle or town, but he set guards on all known exits and, as Gaimar wrote,
…all the passages through the woods were guarded and the marshes round about were vigilantly watched.
The besiegers came from across East Anglia and the East Midlands, including Lincolshire, Huntingdonshire, Cambridgeshire, Leicestershire, Warwicks and Northants. There were also soldiers from Flanders under the control of Ivor Taillebois. Norfolk and Suffolk were not involved directly, perhaps because William did not trust the Bretons who controlled large parts of these shires under Earl Ralph, son of Ralph the Staller. The contribution from these counties came again from William de Warenne of Castle Acre, Richard Fitz Gilbert of Clare and William Malet of Eye.
William’s second attempt to cross his hurriedly-constructed causeway to Aldreth met with disaster when they overloaded the structure and it collapsed, jettisoning the leaders and their followers into the swampy waters where they drowned. Only one knight, Deda, managed to scramble onto firmer ground, because he was the first to cross. He was taken as prisoner to the English leaders, including Earls Morcar and Edwin, Tostig of Daventry and the Anglo-Danish noblemen Thorkill and Ordgar, and was shown the the resources of the isle and the garrison. In his description to the king of the scene in the monastery’s refectory, Deda pictured the monks and knights dining together in pairs with their shields and lances behind them on the walls and other armour readily accessible nearby. Then he was released and sent back to William.
William, who was holding a Council of War when the news of the catastrophe was reported, complained that he could not leave the pocket of resistance at Ely although he needed to move against the Danish army and then go to Normandy. Therefore, he was minded to offer peace terms to King Malcolm of Scotland, who was still offering support and succour to the outlaws. However, his councillors stressed that leaving these men undefeated would severely blow Norman prestige and encourage the English to mock the king. They also complained that many of their estates had been invaded by these outlaws and they succeeded in persuading William to make another attack, Ivo Taillebois being particularly insistent.
The king gathered reinforcements, renewing the blockade on the Isle and building a bridge at the end of the old causeway. The Normans built four round wooden towers from which they could use catapults and ballistae to bombard the peat defences of their opponents. Meanwhile, Hereward led his men covertly into the area, then threw off his disguise and signalled his men to attack, throwing the Normans into confusion by setting fire to the piles of wood on which the towers stood and then the towers themselves. The whole structure rapidly went up in flames, which spread to the peaty swamp of reeds and grew fiercely over nearly a quarter of a mile, fanned by a strong wind.
The Norman soldiery, led by William Malet on horseback, rushed headlong along the pathways and tracks through the marshes. Malet, trapped between the roaring fire in front and Hereward’s men firing arrows and throwing javelins from behind him disappeared into burning swamps with his horse and was drowned, along with many of his men from the garrison at Eye castle.
Orderic Vitalis showed his bias on the situation at Ely by magnifying the reputation of Edwin and Morcar and showing how ill-used they were by the King. Orderic had excused their short-lived rebellion of 1068 as provoked by envious and greedy courtiers, and described the brothers as…
… zealous in the service of God… remarkably handsome, nobly connected… and well-loved by the people.
Orderic believed that Edwin was killed after rather than before or during the attack on Ely. He also alleged that King William, ill-advisedly relying on evil counsellors, damaged his own reputation by treacherously surrounding Earl Morcar at Ely. He claimed that William sent crafty messengers proposing treacherous terms to Morcar that if he were to surrender he would be received in peace as a loyal friend, which Morcar considered would be preferable to continuing to hold out, protected only by the inaccessibility of the place which also prevented him from slippng away by boat along the surrounding rivers to the sea.
William had already posted large numbers of butsecarles to prevent such a manouevre. His blockade certainly trapped Morcar and may also have prevented Edwin’s departure. While Morcar stayed at Ely, Edwin was to go north to Scotland to get help from Eadgar, the Northumbrian exiles and King Malcolm. However he was betrayed by three of his own men and then murdered by a group of Normans who trapped him beside the fast-flowing, incoming tide from the Wash. His attackers cut off his head and took it to the king, who summarily executed them for killing a nobleman without his consent.
Morcar continued in his role as political leader of the defenders at Ely, but then, finally and perhaps foolishly, accepted William’s assurances of safe conduct and reconciliation, and surrendered. Leading his men out peacefully to meet the King, the earl and his men agreed not to contest the king’s final, successful attack. William was assisted in coming onto the Isle while Hereward and his men were away foraging for supplies. The king then focused his efforts on the place where he knew most of the enemy were to be found. He brought up siege engines against Ely itself, and laboured daily to take it by storm.
The Norman force in the final attack consisted of a thousand French knights who now joined battle against three thousand pirates and greater numbers of the English militia from the Midlands as well as many of the common people of the Isle. William still had to take possession of Ely itself and deal with those he regarded as the ringleaders. His army entered the Isle but the march to Ely was not easy, requiring more riding and marching along the crooked fenpaths in order to ambush and enforce the surrender of the rest of the enemy.
Nonetheless, this was soon accomplished, especially as Morcar had already decided to trust the king and make his submission. However, some of the men surrendering were sentenced to imprisonment, and the others to loss of eyes, hands or feet, even if the mass of the common people were released unharmed. Hereward, with a few others, made his escape through the Fens, and, according to the Gesta Herewardi, went north towards the sea called Wide near Welle (the Wash) to the Isle of Stuntney (see the frontispiece picture above).
The outlaws were then pursued into Bruneswald, in the great woods of Northamptonshire, by the king’s men from nine Midland shires, who searched the woods near Bourne, led by Abbot Turold and Ivo Taillebois. Hereward laid an ambush for them, however, capturing both men, but Hereward decided to let them go in exchange for a modest ransom. The outlaws attacked Stamford, one of the five main towns of the Danelaw, but were repulsed by the citizens, who by then had turned against them due to their constant raiding. Hereward and his band then returned to Bruneswald and it was at this point that he became reconciled to the king.
Thurstan and his monks eventually did a deal with King William, suing for peace at Warwick, where the abbot received a charter guaranteeing that the abbey and its possessions would be restored freely and honourably after the struggle was over.
Thurstan drove a hard bargain, however, demanding that William could only be sure of obtaining entry onto the Isle if he first treated the monks well and guaranteed restoration of their lands and goods. The remaining local barons, William de Warenne and Richard Fitz Gilbert of Clare were the guarantors of the king’s promise. For his part, Thurstan agreed to ensure that the common folk, who depended on his guidance and support would cease their resistance. Orderic’s claim that the conflict between Ely and the King lasted for several years was supported by William’s decision to appropriate the Church lands at Ely that lay nearest to the Isle and divide them among his followers.
Morcar was arrested on the fall of Ely and thrown into gaol in the charge of Roger, the castellan of Beaufort in Normandy, where he was held for years until eventually released by William Rufus, only to be re-arrested on his return to England. So ended the House of Leofric, eventually brought down by those they had seemingly failed to protect, who could see no hope in continuing to resist the Norman takeover.
Thirty-two; 1075 – The Last Acts of English Resistance:
Earl Gospatrick also submitted, but the earl then sought the protection of King Malcolm, later becoming the Earl of Dunbar. Earl Waltheof submitted and was pardoned after the Great Rising of the North, made Earl of Northumbria and given Morcar’s lands in the north, but he then became involved in the Rising of the Earls in 1075 for which he was executed for treachery by beheading.
Given these events, there was little reason why any of the Anglo-Danish earls would have trusted William, except perhaps for Eadric the Wild who, submitting in 1070, was the most powerful thegn on the Welsh marches and proved his usefulness to the Conqueror in his campaign against the Scots. Neither is there any reason why William should have accepted such a man as the Lincolnshire outlaw, his apparent nemesis, into his service, and to give him back his lands would only have annoyed those Norman barons to whom they had been given.
By the time William I’s third son, Prince Henry, came to the English throne in 1100, the vast majority of the thegns who had survived the battles of 1066, had either submitted and kept some of their lands as collaborators, or had fled into exile in Scotland, Denmark or Flanders. The original intention of those who gathered at Welle and Ely with Morcar had been to spend the winter there and then go into exile, but William’s blockade prevented them from doing so. They had then decided on resistance, perhaps hoping that the Danes would indeed return, or the English exiles would return from Flanders with a force of eight thousand to drive the Normans out. Of those who went into exile after the fall of Ely, little or nothing was reported. Some, like Siward Barn, ended up serving in the Varangian Guard of the Byzantine Emperors after his release from gaol in the reign of William Rufus.
The general narratives of the Norman Conquest have tended to focus on the Battle of Hastings as the decisive event, but more recently, some historians have argued that contemporaries may not have seen it like that, and believe that it is wrong to dismiss the matter of Ely as it unfolded over the several years it took the Normans to gain control over England. Much of this has to do with the Hereward Myth and later legendary literature.There was a retrospective reference to Hereward the Exile from the reign of Henry II, but most of the material about him was recorded in later centuries.
Certainly, the early accounts reveal Hereward to be a military leader of remarkable ability, a guerilla fighter and a popular hero for many, like other outlaw figures in the following centuries. But he was not a major political figure, unlike Morcar or Edwin, or even Eadgar, who, we must remember, was still only in his early twenties when these events occured following the initial five years of the Conquest. Orderic Vitalis preserved much of the material about Ely and the Fenland outlaws at Crowland Abbey in around 1115, yet in his own records, he never mentioned Hereward by name. His narratives related mainly to events involving the Earls Edwin and Morcar. Orderic also rejected the idea that the original intention of those who gathered at Ely was to drive the Normans out of England. He wrote of it as an attempt to compel King William to offer acceptable terms to the outlaws, the monks and the people; an attempt that was ultimately a glorious failure, but one which would live long in the collective folk-memory of the English.
Thirty-three; 1072 – The English Exiles at the Court of House Dunkeld; East Anglia, and the Conquest of Northumbria:
It is thought that Edwin was on a personal mission to Scotland when he was overtaken on the way to gain passage in a ship from the Wash to Northumbria or Scotland. Certainly, the majority of the rebels at Ely had arrived from Scotland, though many of them would have been English exiles who had first fled from Northumbria to join Eadgar there. He was still a refugee at the court of King Malcolm, remaining there until 1072, when William crossed the border to force Malcolm’s submission. Like King Aethelstan of Wessex before him, William invaded using both naval and land levies, blockading the Scottish east coast with his ships and personally leading an army across the Firth of Forth.
William had previously decided against attempting a conquest of Scotland to deal with the Aetheling. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle commented that he found nothing there that they were any the better for. Malcolm came to Abernethy, near the Forth of Tay in Perthshire, swore to become William’s vassal and gave him hostages, including his eldest son, Duncan. Accepting the overlordship of the King of the English was no novelty, as Scottish kings over the previous two centuries had done the same without resulting friction. The terms of the agreement probably also included the exclusion of Eadgar, who took up residence in Flanders, with Count Robert.
In 1072, the devout Queen Margaret invited the Benedictines to establish a monastery at Dunfermline and established ferry crossings at Queensferry and North Berwick to help pilgrims journeying from south of the Firth of Forth to St Andrews. She also instigated the restoration of Iona Abbey, an acknowledgement of the ancient Celtic traditions of the Church in Scotland. For her own private use, a cave on the banks of Tower Burn in Dunfermline became a place of devotion and prayer.
The Scottish royal family, from the time of her arrival in Scotland some time in 1068, considered that Margaret was descended on her mother’s side from the Hungarian royal lines, and a more recent, American Mormon source states that Edward the Aetheling was married to Agatha, a kinswoman of Henry II, Holy Roman Emperor, who was related to King István. However, she was not István’s daughter, as some sources claimed. Her name, margarita in Latin, was derived from the Persian word for a pearl, and she was known as the precious pearl as a child in Hungary, becoming known as the pearl of Scotland as Malcolm’s queen. Her nickname was Meg in English.
Bishop Aethelwine of Durham and Siward Barn, the wealthy thegn, were among the Northumbrian rebels, initially based at Wearmouth, who had decided not to join Eadgar Aetheling and Sheriff Maerlsweyn in Scotland, but took refuge on the Isle of Ely in 1071 with Edwin and Morcar. They were accompanied by a fighting force of several hundred, raised in Scotland, who had landed on the Norfolk Coast, on the Wash. Siward Barn had been a king’s thegn, an Anglo-Danish noble, holding lands in Derbyshire, Nottinghamshire, Lincolnshire and four other shires that totalled over a hundred hides. But after the harrying of the North, he had lost all his lands (to Henry de Ferrers). Trapped by William’s men after the fall of Ely, he was imprisoned until 1087.
Malcolm’s act of homage to William at Abernethy on Tayside was soon followed by further raids by him into Northumbria. Meanwhile, William had learnt that he could no longer count on the support of the Anglo-Danish nobility of Mercia and Northumbria to secure the Conquest in the North. As he moved south from Scotland, he took steps to provide greater security in Northumberland, north of the Tees. He built a new castle in Durham, adjacent to the cathedral, for the greater protection of both the bishop and the earl. He deprived Gospatrick of his title, while allowing him to keep his lands. However, the earl joined the rebels and went into exile in Flanders, with Eadgar.
He was replaced by Waltheof, who subsequently married Judith, the king’s niece. With connections to both the Anglo-Danish House of Bamburgh and the new Norman dynasty, he must have seemed like the ideal candidate to serve as the Earl of Northumbria, an Anglo-Norman magnate in the truest sense. However, in 1075 he became involved in an aristocratic conspiracy against the Norman king which ended in his execution.
In 1066, King William had appointed Ralph de Guader, an East Anglian nobleman of Breton origins, as his chief noble in the region. He was the high-born son of an Earl, thought to be Ralph the Staller, a noble at the time of Edward the Confessor. Ralph had fought at Hastings and was known for his bravery and strength of character. Then, in 1069, he routed a force of Norsemen that had invaded Norfolk and occupied Norwich, a triumph for which he was later created Earl of Norfolk and Suffolk. In 1075, Ralph married Emma, only daughter of William fitz Osbern, uniting two extremely large estates and important noble lines going back to the Saxon kings and the early dukes of Normandy.
Wary of creating over-mighty Anglo-Norman nobles, William did not give his approval to the match, but the wedding went ahead without it, and at the feast, Ralph, together with his new brother-in-law, Earl Roger of Hereford and Earl Waltheof of Northumberland, planned a revolt against the king. But this Revolt of the Earls, the last serious act of resistance against William I, was easily defeated, and Ralph and Emma left the castle in Norwich for his estates in Brittany. Waltheof was beheaded at Winchester the following year, having betrayed the conspiracy. Earl Roger was also deprived of his lands and earldom, but unlike Ralph he was sentenced to perpetual imprisonment.
Thirty-Four; 1072-80 – The Rivalry of Normandy and Anjou:
Meanwhile, on the continent, Normandy was threatened by the reviving political fortunes of both Anjou and the Kingdom of France. The new French king, Philip I, had emerged under the tutelage of his mother, Anna of Kyív, who gave him his Greek name, which was unusual in France at the time. He consciously pursued the anti-Norman policy developed by his father and in 1072 married the half-sister of Robert of Flanders, who had given refuge to Eadgar Aetheling. So, on all sides, Normandy was menaced by enemies. Duke William was still the most feared warrior in Europe, but he had to spend most of his time re-fighting old battles from Normandy, against younger adversaries, so that the government of England had to be entrusted to others. Archbishop Lanfranc exercised vice-regal powers, but he was naturally more concerned with reforming the English Church.
In 1072, construction began began on a new cathedral at Lincoln, designed, like Durham, to be as defensible as the nearby castle. During the same decade, new cathedrals were also started at Salisbury, Chichester, Rochester, St Albans and Winchester, the latter replacing the ancient minster which was demolished. These were grand buildings, expensively fashioned in stone which had to be shipped from Caen and completed in astonishing time. They emphasised the predominance and permanence of Norman hegemony. Lanfranc’s new cathedral at Canterbury, replacing the one that had burnt down ten years earlier, was also advanced enough to be dedicated in 1077. As part of the rebuilding, local Saxon saints, including St Dunstan, were purged from the commemorative calendar. Eadmer of Canterbury, the English historian and chronicler, commented that:
Sometimes, the archbishop had altered English customs for no reason other than to assert his own authority.
By 1077, relations between Anglo-Saxons and Normans were much better than they had been a decade earlier, not just in the view of Norman chroniclers, but also English ones. Orderic Vitalis recorded that:
… within just a few years of the Conquest, English and Normans were living peacefully together in boroughs, towns and cities, and were inter-marrying with each other. You could see many villages or town markets filled with displays of French ware and merchandise and observe the English, who had previously seemed contemptible tot he French in their native dress completely transformed by French fashions.
It was at this time that Eadgar Aetheling decided that it was time for him to submit to William’s rule. In 1074, he had returned to Scotland, but shortly afterwards he accepted an offer from Philip I of France who was already at odds with William over Normandy and Maine. This consisted of a castle and lands ont he borders of the Dukedom from where Eadgar could launch raids on William’s homelands. With his retinue, he embarked for France, but a storm wrecked their ships on the English coast. Many of Eadgar’s men were hunted down by the Normans, but he managed to escape with the remainder of them back to Scotland by land. Following this latest disaster and narrow escape, Malcolm persuaded Eadgar to make peace with William and return to England as his vassal.
Also by this time, William Rufus and Robert Curthose had reached adulthood and were keen to accept responsibilities from their father. He asked his father to name him as his successor in Normandy and Maine, but William told him to wait for a more opportune moment. Frustrated by this, he became estranged from both his father and his brothers. While Odo was lording it over the English, in Normandy William struggled to bring his eldest son to heel. Soon after Christmas 1078, William moved against him and a bitter stand-off ensued, in which, after a three-week siege, both William and Rufus were injured. For most of 1079, the magnates of Normandy attempted to bring about a reconciliation, and in the early months of 1080, William yielded to this pressure, granting Robert the right of succession to Normandy. The end of this familial dispute meant that William could finally turn his attention back to his kingdom, and after four years away he finally returned to England in the second half of the year.
Thirty-Five; Durham, 1080 – Return of the King:
Meanwhile, on the other side of the Channel, there had been conflict and disagreement between landowners when the Norman baronry encountered the remaining tangled strands of Anglo-Danish lordship. The Normans, whether by commission or submission, misinterpreted the rights of their English predecessors to match their own feudalinterests. They also, in many cases, simply grabbed whatever they could. While much land was given out by the king or his regents, and entered into legally, a considerable amount was acquired by less legitimate methods; extortion, intimidation, and violence. In certain regions of the country, for example the East Midlands and East Anglia, the Domesday Book shows no clear pattern of land distribution, but rather that the Norman settlement in these areas was something of a free-for-all.
Domesday also preserves the testimony of local jurors that certain Norman barons had simply helped themselves. The monks of Ely’s support for the Hereward rebellion earned them lasting royal displeasure. Many local Normans seemed to have assumed thereafter that the abbey’s estates were open to unofficial appropriation. The sheriff of Lincoln was the worst offender; such was the scale of his appropriations that the monks of the twelfth century there remembered him as a roving lion, a hungry wolf, a crafty fox, a filthy pig, a shameless dog. Yet in 1077, King William had written to all his chief tenants in England ordering them to return any church lands obtained by violence or intimidation. But protection for lay tenants from avaricious lords by abbots and sheriffs only lasted as long as the protectors themselves. When they died, those who replaced them were at liberty to hand out entrusted estates to Norman friends and relations.
The darker side of the so-called settlement, not merely confused and chaotic, but rapacious, violent and unjust, applied at the highest levels of the feudal pyramid. Odo of Bayeux, acting as William’s regent during his four-year absence in Normandy in the 1070s, was a great believer in self-help. He helped himself to many of the land rights in Kent held by the Saxon Archbishop of Canterbury, by force of arms.
In the autumn of 1080, when a riot broke out in Durham, Odo was equally brutal in his punishment of the Northumbrians by leading an army into the region and laying it to waste. According to Simeon of Durham, Odo murdered, maimed and extorted money from the guilty and innocent alike, before helping himself to some of the cathedral’s treasures.
The question of where the Anglo-Scottish border should be fixed remained a matter of continual dispute, higlighted by the imposition of the non-native régime in the south. When Malcolm took advantage of William’s absence in Normandy, invading England in 1079, Robert Curthose was sent back to England and to the north with an army to build a New Castle upon the Tyne and to help secure the frontier. However, Malcolm again pursued peace and this time he kept it for more than a decade. William’s decision to delegate responsibility for northern English and Scottish affairs may indicate that the King did not actually return to his kingdom until late in the year of 1080.
Thirty-Six: Christmas, 1080 – Gloucester…
In fact, William did not appear in public in England until spending Christmas at Gloucester, when he went hunting in the Forest of Dean. William ceremoniously wore his crown in the cathedral, as he did the following Whitsun at Winchester. Orderic Vitalis provided the King’s court at this moment. The chronicler described how the abbot of St Evreux crossed to England and attended the king at Winchester, who received him together with his magnates, all of whom made gifts to the Norman abbey. Their names were recorded in a charter; besides the king and his sons, Roger of Montgomery, Hugh of Chester, and William of Brittany (son of William fitz Osbern) were all present. The writer of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle who described how the Conqueror keptgreat state in less benign terms:
… He wore his crown three times a year, as often as he was in England; at Easter, at Winchester; at Whitsun at Westminster; at Christmas at Gloucester. On these occasions, all the the great men of England were assembled about him – archbishops, bishops, abbots, earls, thegns, and knights… he was so stern and relentless a man that no one dared do ought against his will. Earls who resisted his will, he held in bondage, bishops he deprived of their sees and abbots of their abbacies, while rebellious thegns he cast into prison.
Finally, the chronicler reports that William did not spare his own brother, Odo, but put him in prison. The Chronicle for 1082 simply tells us that in this year, the King arrested Bihop Odo. It has a startling effect on its readers, but it was not until half a century later that others wrote that he was plotting to usurp the throne, and others still that he was planning to become Pope. But at his trial, Odo was denounced primarily for his oppression of the English in a long speech from William himself, reported by Orderic. The king had arrested his brother personally, stating that he was not arresting a bishop, but an earl. After the trial, Odo was transported back across the Channel and imprisoned in the ducal castle at Rouen.
The Conqueror was soon hit by two more blows in his familial life in 1082-84. His wife, Matilda, died, and his eldest son, Robert Curthose, became alienated from his father once more, and went into exile. The King and Duke, must have felt increasingly isolated, as these he had now lost all three of the figures he had relied upon as regents. But they did not trigger any further crises in his dominions.
In 1085, however, William did have to deal with a renewed threat of an invasion of England from Denmark, a threat which seemed far more serious than previous incursions from Scandinavia since the invasion, defeat and death of Harald Hardrada in 1066. A new King Cnut sat on the Danish throne, and his fleets posed a far greater danger to William’s security than those he had led for his father in 1069 and 1075. Learning from these previous failures, Cnut prepared a fleet of more than a thousand ships for the invasion. He also had a key ally in Robert, Count of Flanders, whose daughter Cnut had married. According to William of Malmesbury, the Count had assembled his own fleet of six hundred ships, which added tot he overall invasion force. Naturally, as Malmesbury recorded, the King was very scared.
Nevertheless, William reacted quickly in the autumn of 1085, assembling the largest force of cavalry and infantry to set foot in England since the invading forces of 1066. John of Worcester wrote of many thousands of paid troops, foot soldiers and archers. The King’s Council decided that this defensive force should be dispersed throughout the country, billeted with abbots and other magnates. The land along the coastline was wasted so that the invaders would have nothing to live off, and coastal castles and defences were strengthened.
Christmas 1085, which William and his magnates once more celebrated at Gloucester, must have been a nervous one, with all those attending awaiting news of the sighting of the Danish-Flemish fleet. William revealed his own anxiety by dismissing the abbots of Crowland and Thorney, neighbouring monasteries in the Fens, because the monks had shown sympathy and support towards previous Danish invasions. The king replaced the Anglo-Danish abbots with two monks from Normandy. The Christmas court at Gloucester lasted five days and the Church council that followed a further three.
Thirty-Seven; 1086 – April-May 1086 – Winchester and Westminster:
The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle for 1086 reported that:
The King had much thought and deep discussion with his council about the country, how it was occupied and with what sort of people… he sent his men all over England, into every shire, and had them find out how many hundred hides there were in the shire or what land and cattle the king himself had in the country, or what dues he ought to have in twelve months from the shire. Also, he had a record made of how much land his archbishops had, and his bishops and abbots, and his earls… and how much everybody had who was occupying land in England… and how much money it was worth… So very narrowly did he have it investigated that there was no single hide nor yard of land… no one ox, or one pig was there left out and not put down in his record…
A hide was defined as an area such as could be ploughed by a single plough and a team of oxen in one season. Its size varied in different parts of the country, but probably ran from about forty to a hundred acres. In northern England, land was also measured in carucates and a tax called a carucage was levied on every hide or carucate of land at a rate of between 3s and 5s.
Despite the brutal expropriation of land in the early years of the Conquest, it is apparent from the manorial records in Domesday that most of the Norman magnates did not depend on royal patronage for their continuing tenure. Rather, they secured their tenure by keeping the peace on their lands, chiefly by respecting the pre-Conquest rights of their tenants, and managing their manors and estates diplomatically, especially in their relations with neighbouring magnates. There were also many cases of sub-tenanting and other flexible arrangements where the management of freemen was concerned.
In the case of the Golafre family, who were given lands in Suffolk early in the Conquest, these arrangements were due to their desire to maintain their lands in Normandy under Duke Robert. They were also determined to participate in crusades; Guillaume de Goulafriére, thirty years after standing at William’s right hand at Hastings, went to fight in the First Crusade, which left Normandy in 1096. He ceded his estates in Suffolk and in southern England to his son, Roger. The main branches of the held lands in East Anglia, especially in Suffolk and Essex, between 1086 and 1273. There are also references to the family name, deriving from their lands in Normandy, or variants of it, in local court records throughout the twelfth and thirteenth centuries.
In Suffolk, in pre-Conquest times, a tradition of fierce independence had been established. By the time of the Survey, the population of Suffolk was 20,491, which made it the most densely populated county in England with the possible exception of Middlesex. It was a shire of free farmers and small-holders. According to Domesday, there were 7,460 freemen in Suffolk and only about nine hundred serfs. The proportion of independent smallholders to peasants was quite different in Norfolk and Suffolk from that of any other shire.
Although the average freemen could only claim a little land, usually much smaller than a caracute, he could call himself his own man, something which meant a great deal to East Anglians. The land holdings were concentrated into compact blocks edged by market sor sometimes hedges. They might also have grazing rights on nearby heath and woodland. Every autumn they slaughtered their beasts and preserved their meat with salt from the saltpans on the Wash or in the Stour estuary. Most of them achieved self-sufficiency and were left with a surplus for market.
After the Conquest, Robert Malet had two small manors in the village of Aspall. He was one of the king’s chief magnates, the son of William Malet, a chief tenant to King William, who had accompanied the Conqueror from Normandy and was named as being present at Hastings. He had been given land in England by Edward the Confessor, and had an English wife. On William’s command, William had taken care of Harold’s body after the battle. Robert had inherited his father’s large estates in Suffolk following William’s death at Ely in 1072.
The eclipse of the English aristocracy was almost total. The three Anglo-Danish earls who witnessed the coronation of William at Christmas 1066 were all long gone by 1086, some assassinated, like Edwin, executed, like Waltheof, or languishing in gaol, like Morcar. Also gone were the lesser English nobles who were present at the Queen’s coronation. Among the witnesses of Salisbury in 1086, there was not a single English or Danish name. This was also true of Domesday’s ten thousand tenants-in-chief, of which a mere thirteen were English and only four had lands worth more than a hundred pounds. The king’s thanes, the ninety or so lords who may have each owned more than forty hides of land, were also gone. Even at the manorial level, the Anglo-Danish names were very much in the minority. England’s middling thanes, numbering four to five thousand, had been swept clean away.
Domesday therefore revealed cataclysmic change to the country’s ruling class, with Normans replacing native lords in almost every village and hamlet. By 1086, half the land of England was held by just two hundred Norman barons, who were many times more wealthy than their English predecessors. A quarter of the land was held by just ten magnates, including Odo of Bayeux, Robert Curthose, Roger of Montgomery, Richard Fitz Gilbert and Hugh of Chester. Yet, obscenely rich as these men were, their wealth was insignificant in comparison with that of the three English earls of the Confessor’s reign. At the start of that reign, Godwin of Wessex, Leofric of Mercia and Siward of Northumbria, taken together, and together with their families, had been equal in riches to the King himself.
By 1086, there were only two earls left in England, Roger of Montgomery and Hugh of Chester, both Norman Marcher lords. Even their combined wealth and power did not nearly approximate to that of their Saxon predecessors. After the Conquest, no coalition of magnates, nomatter how broad, could match the resources of the King, who had twice as much demesne as the top ten magnates put together.
While the Commissioners had been assembling their Domesday data, King William had been travelling around the southern part of his kingdom, what was once Wessex. At Easter, 5th April in 1086, he wore his crown at Winchester. By Whitsun, 24th May, when he was at Westminster for the knighting of his youngest son, Henry, he ordered all his magnates, spiritual and secular, to meet him on 1st August at Salisbury.
Thirty-eight – 1st August, 1086; Salisbury (Old Sarum) – Presentation of The Domesday Survey:
At that time, the ancient cathedral was north of the present city and cathedral at Old Sarum. The new cathedral, with its impressive spire was built by the early thirteenth century near the confluence of three rivers, and a settlement grew up around it, which received a city charter in 1227 as New Sarum, an official name which it kept until 2009. Until the eleventh century it was known by its Welsh inhabitants as Caer Caradog and in Latin as Sorbiodunum. Following the Saxon incursions of the sixth century until the eleventh century, it was known by its Old English name as Searobyrig. Preferring settlements in the valley below, such as Wilton, the Saxons had largely ignored Old Sarum until the Viking raids led King Alfred to restore its fortifications in the late ninth century. The Normans constructed a motte-and-bailey castle there in 1070, which was directly held by William and his Norman successors, and its castellan was also the sheriff of Wiltshire. Herman, the Bishop of Salisbury, began the construction of the first ’new’ cathedral, but this was not completed until 1092, only to be wrecked in a storm only five days later. Herman’s successor, Osmund, who had served as William’s Lord Chancellor, was responsible for the compilation of the Domesday Book which was presented to William at Old Sarum on 1st August 1086. Given its symbolic, strategic and religious significance, it was obviously a deliberate choice for the location of the major event of that day.
This was to be an assembly for the whole kingdom, the culmination of the Domesday process. The book names around a thousand individuals who held their lands directly from the king, his tenants-in-chief. Most, if not all of them, would have attended. Domesday also records about another eight thousand landowners at the next stage down, the sub-tenants of the king. These would have added another number well into four figures, possibly even reaching five.
The royal assembly at Salisbury was set to make the king even more powerful. William had summoned England’s landowning élites to participate in the climactic moment of the Domesday process, intimately connected with the true purpose of the book. When the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle recorded that those present all became the King’s Men by swearing oaths; it described an act of homage, of personal submission to a lord in return for their individual rights to hold particular landssubject to the king, by his sole permission.
While much of the land of England had been given out by royal charter, much had also been obtained by intimidation, encroachment and violence. Few of the Normans could have produced title to all of the estates they possessed at the beginning of the Domesday inquiries. But once complete, the Survey provided precisely that written evidence. These documents were effectively royal charters, giving the confirmation and security of title the barons needed to guarantee their personal appropriations.
It was the nature of the Conquest itself that meant that William was able to create a new system from scratch, because at the outset all lands were forfeit to the Crown at the time of his accession. He was therefore able to establish a new aristocracy bound by new terms of service, rights and duties of inheritance and marriage. Shortly before the ceremony on 1st August, news must have reached him that Cnut IV was dead. He had died on 10th July, murdered in church by his own rebellious nobles. His sudden death meant that the threat of a Danish invasion was finally lifted. There was no longer any challenge to the Conqueror’s hegemony over England, either from within or without.
William was, by this stage in his late fifties, having launched the initial invasion at the age of thirty-eight. By contemporary standards he was now old, and had also grown obese. Back in his capital, Rouen, it soon became clear that he was dying. On his death bed, he attempted to appease God by releasing all the prisoners in his custody, a list which included Earl Morcar, Siward Barn and even Harold’s brother, Earl Wolfnoth, held hostage since 1051. Eventually, Odo was also set free. During his last days, William also let his final wishes about the succession be known. He confirmed his eldest son as his heir in Normandy, while entrusting England to God alone, though expressing his hope that William Rufus should become King of England, God willing. Shortly before his death, William sent Rufus to England, armed with a letter to Archbishop Lanfranc recommending that Rufus be crowned by him in succession.
Orderic Vitalis accepted the Norman argument that the invasion and conquest of England had been justified by Harold’s perjury, but as an Englishman he could not accept the way that the Conqueror had mercilessly crushed the opposition to his rule. He saw the Harrying of the North, in particular, as a terrible stain on William’s legacy. Orderic also drew a distinction between the behaviour of the Conqueror and that of his soldiers:
They arrogantly abused their authority and mercilessly slaughtered the noble people, … noble maidens were exposed to the insults of low-born soldiers and lamented their dishonouring by the scum of the earth. Ignorant parasites, made almost mad with pride, they were astonished that such a great had come to them, and imagined that they were a law unto themselves. Oh fools and sinners, why did they not ponder contritely in their hearts that they had not by their own strength, but by the will of almighty God, and had subdued a people that was greater and more wealthy than they were, with a longer history.
There were similar verdicts from elsewhere in Europe. In Bavaria, the apparent birthplace of Agatha, the wife of Edward the Exile, and mother of the returning Wessex exiles, a chronicler thought that William had miserably attacked and conquered England, sending its bishops into exile and its nobles to their deaths. By this time, Agatha herself had returned to the continent at some point after 1070 (the date of Simeon of Durham’s last reference to her), probably to Bavaria, where she died. Another German, writing in 1080, lambasted Pope Gregory VII over his relationships with certain rulers such as William, whom he described as tyrants.
The notion that nothing changed after 1066 owes much to the rewriting of history by Norman chroniclers. It was precisely what William wanted future generations to believe, such was his desire to be regarded as Edward the Confessor’s legitimate successor and England’s rightful king. Harold’s brief reign and Eadgar Aetheling’s even briefer one were omitted from the Norman chronicles. Domesday presented a picture of quiet continuity and concealed massive tenurial upheaval. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, summing up the Conqueror’s reign, came closest to recognising the great gulf between Norman propaganda and the actual events of the period 1066-1086. It complained that:
The louder the talk of law and justice, the greater the injustices they committed.
What Domesday demonstrated beyond any question was how totally the Conquest had replaced one ruling élite with another. By 1086, the English had been totally eradicated from the higher eschelons of society. The transformation had almost certainly been William’s original intention. His hope had been to rule a mixed Anglo-Norman kingdom, much as Cnut had ruled an Anglo-Danish one. The English knew they had been conquered in 1016, but in 1066 they refused to accept this as the logical or necessary outcome of the Battle of Hastings. In subsequent stages therefore, the Norman Conquest became far more radical than its Danish predecessor. Henry of Huntingdon commented that:
In King William’s twenty-first year, there was scarcely a noble of English descent, but all had been reduced to servitude and lamentation.
But the English and the Normans were two quite different peoples. William of Malmesbury, in a famous passage, described the Battle of Hastings as a fatal day for England, a disaster which had resulted in the country exchanging old masters for new. He then went ont o contrast the natures of the two peoples:
The English were abandoned to gluttony and lechery, lax in their Christianity and addicted to wassail. They lived out their lives in small, mean houses, prefering to load their tattoed skin with gold bracelets, eating until they were sick and drinking until they spewed.
The Normans were well-dressed to a fault, particular about their food and more obviously religious. A crafty, warlike people, they built great, proud buildings in which they lived a life of moderate expense, although narrow in its focus and infected with moral hindsight…
Some of the Normans went home after their initial Conquest, satisfied with the fruits of their pay and plunder, but many others, fixed on acquiring and holding land, stayed to create a new colonial society. They settled across England, from east to west, and from south to north, tearing up the old tenurial patterns in the process, reorganising their estates as manors, and erecting castles to serve as administrive centres.
The numbers of free men owning and working their own land fell throughout the kingdom. On the other hand, however, by the 1130s, slavery was gone from England, and some contemporaries attributed this to the Conquest. Along with their belief that slavery was wrong in Christian terms, the Normans introduced the notion that it was better to show mercy to their opponents after they had surrendered. The English had been practising political murder right up to the eve of the Conquest, as the strange case of the death of Edward the Exile demonstrated. Also, with the sole exception of Earl Waltheof, no Englishman was executed as a result of the conquest. Very quickly thereafter, the practice disappeared and did not reappear until the death of Becket in the time of Henry II. The last judicial execution, on royal orders, in Norman England, took place in 1095, and after that there followed two and a half centuries of chivalric restraint.
It is certainly true that the Normans brought with them their zealous commitment to the reform of the Church. The boom in the building of parish churches in England had begun long before the coming of the Normans, yet there is little doubt that they accelerated these developments. In addition, they built many new monasteries. In 1066, there were around sixty in England, but by 1135 that number had more than quadrupled to as many as three hundred. The number of monks and nuns increased by a similar amount. In the North, just a few years after the harrying, monasteries and their lands were restored and others refounded at Selby, Jarrow, Whitby, Monkwearmouth, Durham and York. But, as across the continent as a whole, most of these developments would have taken place without the Conquest, as they did in Scotland, under the patronage of the Queen, Margaret of Wessex and her son, King David I. Indeed, before the Conquest, a great wave of monastic reform had already spread throughout Europe from the abbey at Cluny.
The economies of these monasteries were mainly based on sheep farming, but they also farmed coastal marshlands and woodlands; the key was that they should be on land that was not wanted by secular tenants and therefore unlikely to form part of a network of feudal obligations. They did not, therefore, form part of the land-grab of the Norman barons, and most of them remained relatively poor throughout the twelfth century. In any case, the first generations of conquerors referred to spend their surplus wealth to patronise monastic houses at home in Normandy, where they intended to be interred.
For the ordinary English at the time, however, the Norman takeover seemed an unmitigated disaster, a melancholy havoc, as William of Malmesbury put it. They had seen their artistic treasures being looted and taken as spoils to Normandy and the bones and relics of their saints being hidden from view, tossed away, or burnt. They saw the demolition of churches and great cathedrals like Winchester, which had stood for centuries and, in some cases since the first arrival of Christianity in England. Nevertheless, when the giant new Norman cathedral at Winchester, begun in 1079, was completed in 1093, the bones of St Swithyn were reinstated with great honour, and when, during the same year, another new cathedral was begun at Durham, it was very different from anything that had gone before, its pillars decorated with the linear patterns that were so characteristic of old English art. This was the best example of Anglo-Norman artistic fusion.
However, the remaining English-speaking clerics also noticed the sudden disappearance of English as a written language. After it ceased to be used in royal offices after 1070, it was also soon abandoned in usage in monastic scriptora around the country, to be replaced by Latin or Norman French. Only the E version of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle survived into the twelfth century, ending in 1154. After the Conquest, there were no new vernacular prayer books, so that an ancient tradition that was intended to raise the standard of religious literacy and oracy among the laity was dying before their eyes, and a vital bridge between the clergy and the people was broken until the Reformation.
The coming of the conquerors had brought with it acts of vandalism that not even the Danes had visited on Anglo-Saxon culture. All this came on top of the slaughter and deliberate wholesale starvation of the native northern population. As the agents of this genocide, the Normans appeared to the native English to be anything but civilised. For the survivors, there could be only one explanation for their suffering; the English had sinned and were being severely chastised by their creator. Most of the chroniclers seemed to be agreed on this point. This self-flagellation was reminiscent of the Venerable Bede’s view of the Britons, whom he believed had been replaced by the Anglo-Saxons as God’s chosen people. Just as in Bede’s day the almighty had used the pagan Vikings as his instrument of punishment, now it was their Christian descendants, the Normans, who had been chosen for that role.
The Conqueror’s hopes for the English succession were fulfilled in 1087 when William Rufus ascended to the throne. But his fears about the threats posed by other members of his family also proved to be well-founded. Robert Curthose, already installed as Duke of Normandy on his father’s wishes, also plotted to replace Rufus on the English throne. The plot failed, but the struggle between the two elder sons of the Conqueror continued for many years. Their younger brother, Henry, soon added a third element to the sorry saga of betrayal and double-crossing, and in May 1087 their uncle, the King of Scots added a fourth dimension.
Malcolm Canmore marched south again to besiege the New Castle built by Robert Curthose. This was an attempt by the Scottish king to advance his frontier from the Tweed to the Tees. The perceived threat was enough to bring the new Norman king, William Rufus, back from his native estates in Normandy, where he had once again been fighting with his brother. In September, learning of Rufus’s approaching army, Malcolm beat a tactical retreat, though he was prepared to fight if necessary. In a peace brokered by Eadgar Aetheling and Curthose, Malcolm again acknowledged the overlordship of the English king.
Robert had struck up a remarkable friendship with Eadgar since his submission to William in 1075. Orderic wrote that they were virtually foster brothers, since they were almost the same age. But this closeness between the Duke of Normandy and the last old English claimant caused both Rufus and Henry, to regard the Aetheling with greater caution. Despite William’s pardoning of Eadgar and his readmission to the English court, when Rufus became King of England after his father’s death, he confiscated the Aetheling’s English lands, so that Eadgar was once more forced to take refuge with his brother-in-law in Scotland.
When Rufus arrived in England in 1087, accompanied by the newly released Morcar and Wolfnoth, his first act upon landing was to have both men reincarcerated, demonstrating that he was not looking for reconciliation with the remnant of the English nobility.
Episode Two: Conquest, Flight and Resistance, 1066-70
Margaret of Wessex and her mother, Agatha, arrive in Scotland (the Forth), after being shipwrecked off Orkney in circa 1068, following their ‘escape’ from William’s court.
Scene Twenty; 1066 – The Norman Invasion:
After Hardrada’s defeat at Stamford Bridge, Harold was holding a celebratory feast at York, when news arrived of the Norman landing on the beach at Pevensey, 270 miles away. Harold’s army made the journey in under a fortnight, while Harold, on horseback accompanied by his guard of mounted knights, galloped ahead and paused in London for six days. The infantry bypassed London and headed directly to Pevensey in advance of the cavalry.
The Norman invasion of England was essentially different from the incursions of the Danes, Angles and Saxons before them. It was more like the Roman invasions, especially that of Claudius in AD 43, in that the invaders established themselves through a careful strategy, a well-organised expedition and a decisive battle. Once William had taken London and claimed the Crown, William then had to fight hard to retain and subdue his new kingdom and its territories. By the time of his death in 1087, the English, both Dane and Saxon, had been subdued and under Norman rule. Perhaps it was because of dramatic developments that followed, that the slender nature of the victory on that day in October 1066 tends to be overlooked.
Harold’s force at Hastings was classically Anglo-Danish in composition, comprising housecarls, professional men-at-arms, a permanent royal bodyguard founded by Cnut, an élite among the soldiers of Europe and those of the Saxon fyrds who had been able to answer the king’s summons. The housecarls were a mobile force that usually rode to the field of battle before dismounting to fight on foot. Although essentially infantry, therefore, they were well-equipped to challenge the apparent superiority of the mounted knight. At Hastings, it took over eight hours for the Norman knights to overcome the English defence. The housecarls’ most distinctive weapon was the long-handled, double-bladed war axe which was capable of bringing down both horse and rider with a single blow. Others would have been armed with javelins and swords, and all were armoured with knee-length tunics of mail, the hauberk, a conical helmet with nasal bar and a circular or kite-shaped shield.
Beyond fifty yards, the Danish short bow, the chosen weapon of Norman knights, was virtually ineffective against these defences and provided the housecarls could maintain a solid formation they were a potent deterrent to cavalry. The mounted Bretons fled when faced by the housecarls at Hastings, and only the weight of numbers appears to have overcome the surviving housecarls as darkness fell. That the horsemen could compete at all with heavy infantry was due to the introduction of the stirrup to Europe in the eighth century. But to the Normans it was never axiomatic that heavy cavalry should always fight mounted. Therefore, Hastings cannot be taken as demonstrating the innate superiority of either cavalry over infantry or the pre-conquest Norman military system over the Anglo-Danish.
William’s European army of about seven thousand fighting men was comprised of Normans, Bretons, Frenchmen from other provinces, Flemings, Italians and Sicilians. The uncertainties of the coming campaign dictated the need for a safe, large anchorage such as that at Hastings. He therefore moved his ships and troops along the coast to the port, ordered the construction of new defences, and proceeded to lay waste tot he surrounding countryside. It was vital for William’s plans that Harold should attack at the earliest opportunity. His strategy was based on a single conclusive victory in battle, and therefore involved destructive provocation and pillaging from as soon as he had arrived on the south coast, making Harold come to him, so his offer to English king to let him keep the earldom of Wessex was a ploy, as it had been fifty years earlier when made by Cnut to Eadmund Ironside.
Twenty-one; Senlac Hill, October – November 1066:
Harold hastened to give battle, therefore, since he heard that his lands near the Norman camp were being laid waste. He also hoped to catch William unawares, but the night-time attack William had been expecting never came. Instead, Harold’s army gradually reformed at an ancient landmark called the Grey Apple Tree on a long ridge of open land named Senlac. It was there that the Norman army chose to attack in plain sight on the morning of 14th October. Harold was therefore forced to give battle before all his forces had been amassed and arrayed.
His army of approximately 7,500 men was composed of two thousand housecarls, deployed on foot to stiffen the fyrd, each one of them charged with holding their position. As long as they did so, they would be very difficult to dislodge. Having seized the hilltop, the English arrayed themselves in their favoured formation, dismounting and forming a shield wall. Harold took his place in the centre of the line, planting the white dragon standard of Wessex on the summit of the hill. It was ultimately the death of Harold, earl of Wessex, which brought about the fall of that standard and the defeat of the English army.
Harold may have been hit by an arrow, possibly in the eye as the Bayeux tapestry seems to show and every English schoolboy now seems to know, but the many contemporary written accounts which are used to support this conclusion were Norman in origin and tried to play down the brutality of the final assault on Harold’s guard. William Malet, a pre-Conquest Anglo-Norman, witnessed this and reported it to Edith (Swan-neck), Harold’s first wife, after the battle. She had to identify Harold’s body, since it had been so badly maimed and mutilated that only someone who knew it intimately could do so, by certain marks.
The portrayal of Harold being killed by an injury to his eye is both legendary and mythological, a deliberate reference to Harold’s treachery in the Norman narrative. As already referenced, the common punishment for traitors in early medieval Europe was blinding, so that this legendary element, added for the tapestry, was therefore heavily symbolic. For many Saxons, in addition his Norman detractors like William of Poitiers, Harold was an untrustworthy king. In reality, the final phase of the battle came late in the evening when the Norman knights, under high-angle cover of fire from their newly re-equipped archers, broke through, by sheer weight of numbers, the position which had been held for eight hours, now severely reduced. When William observed Harold and his brothers being cut down by the swords of his knights, he ordered his mounted guard to ride to Harold’s position to deliver the coup de gráce. Those who recorded his slaying also describe him fighting to the last, wielding his sword. No doubt he had sustained many wounds, but it is difficult to envisage that he could have continued this kind of hand-to-hand combat with an arrow in his eye!
The defenders on the ridge were overwhelmed and although a body of housecarls rallied to fight a rearguard action at a feature behind the ridge named Malfosse, the battle was lost and the fyrd left the field, having witnessed the slaying of their king, and were pursued until long after nightfall by the Normans.
On the eve of the battle, William of Poitiers had recorded his description of Harold as a man soiled with lasciviousness, a cruel murderer, and an enemy of God and the Just. These words may help to explain the brutal nature of Harold’s death. Copying from this account, the Anglo-Norman scribe, Orderic Vitalis, changed the description of the Saxon king to a brave and valiant man, strong and handsome, pleasant in speech and a good friend to his followers. However, Orderic does not pass judgement on whether Harold was willing to break his oaths and murder those, like Edward the Exile, who stood in his way.
After witnessing Harold’s killing, but before the bloody conclusion of the battle, Morcar and Edwin left the field for London, presumably to secure Harold’s successor, Eadgar Aetheling. Harold had kept Eadgar away from the field. On reaching Westminster, they immediately sent their sister, Harold’s Saxon wife Ealdgyth and now widowed queen, out of harm’s way to Chester. With Harold dead, the two earls now promised to fight for Eadgar, who was elected by the Witangamot and proclaimed King by Stigand, Archbishop of Canterbury, supported by Ealdred, Archbishop of York.
Meanwhile, on the battlefield, Harold’s mother, Gytha, appeared among the carnage to plead for the return of her son’s body, which had been taken to Waltham Abbey to be identified by Edith Swan-neck, his Danish first wife. But Gytha’s request was refused by an angry William, who argued that it would be inappropriate for Harold to be interred while so many others were left unburied, having lost their lives because of him. It seems likely that the body was removed to Waltham some days later when William had left Hastings.
William was waiting there to see if there would be a formal surrender. But by proclaiming Eadgar king, the English signalled that they may have lost a close-fought battle but they had not yet given up the war to maintain their independence. Edwin and Morcar still thought that they could rally their earldoms, Wessex and East Anglia, around the Aetheling, and continue the resistance to the attempted Conquest. When no surrender came after a fortnight, the Duke of Normandy proceeded to ravage the south-east, including Romney, Dover (for a week) and Canterbury, punishing the people for not accepting him as king by victory in battle. Then, when he heard of the election of Eadgar, he ordered a siege of the city of London.
The Normans torched all the houses on the south bank of the Thames. However, they failed to cross the river to capture the city and so William led his troops along the Thames westwards, eventually crossing the river at Wallingford. The English chroniclers tell us that, on the way, William harried that part of England through which he advanced. John of Worcester wrote that the Normans laid waste to Kent, Sussex, Hampshire, Middlesex and Hertfordshire.
Following Harold’s death at Hastings, Edwin and Morcar had concurred in the election of Eadgar but, disappointed of their hope of a second battle with William under his banner, soon left the city with their remaining forces and returned tot he north, believing that the Conqueror would not advance so far. They had proposed that the Witan should elect one of them king, but failed to take effective steps to stem the Norman invasion and therefore left themselves no alternative but to submit to Duke William.
Twenty-Two; Dec. 1066 – The Berkhamsted Submission:
Wallingford was the first crossing up river from London Bridge which could safely be used by an invading army still in the thousands. There, Stigand became the first Saxon magnate to submit to William and to renounce his earlier proclamation of Eadgar as successor to Harold. By then, Ealdred had, in any case, already emerged as the spiritual leader of the English resistance throughout the country. But as William continued to harry the home counties, and as winter set in, Eadgar showed no desire to continue to resist William at the expense of the English population. In order, no doubt, to end the retribution, Eadgar was eventually persuaded to submit and pay homage to William at Berkhamsted in early December 1066, and to give up his claim to the crown.
The settlement was recorded as Burbium in the Domesday Book, and was probably chosen by William as a meeting place because it was already a burgh before the Conquest, with a large fortified enclosure suitable for the defence of his army and their maintenance within a sizeable encampment. No doubt he added some wooden buildings for administration, but he would not have had time to build a large motte and bailey castle within it by the time of the submission. In return for his submission, William agreed to treat Eadgar with respect and to allow him to continue to live at court with his family.
The northern earls, Edwin and Morcar, were also present with him, and made their submissions, which William accepted, receiving gifts and hostages from them, leading to their reinstatement to their titles and earldoms. Edwin and Morcar were then given leave to return to their lands. Even so, they must have felt humiliated; William of Malmesbury described them, whether unfairly or astutely, as two brothers of great ambition. Greater humiliation was to follow however, as William made vague promises to Edwin of a new role in the new state and a marriage to one of his daughters. Neither of these promises ever materialised.
The leading clerics and officers of the City of London then stepped forward. William was handed the Crown by Archbishop Ealdred, who would also be present to crown him at Westminster Abbey that Christmas.
Twenty-three; The Coronation, Westminster, 25th Dec. 1066:
William was now de facto king, having defeated Harold in battle and received the homage of Eadgar, the northern earls and other leading magnates, both spiritual and temporal. He had also promised to rule as a gracious lord. Eadgar’s short reign, which had begun with his proclamation on 15th October, was now effectively over without a crowning. However, as England was an elective monarchy at this time, it was his election by the Witan which added to his birthright and made him king until he died or abdicated in favour of William, which he had done at Berkhamsted.
This principle was tested by the monks of Peterborough who, after the death of their Abbot at Hastings, had sent his nominated successor to Eadgar for confirmation, following the custom and practice of the English church. This further annoyed William, who saw it as confering legitimacy on Eadgar as rightful king, especially as he had gladly consented to the monks’ request. William misunderstood the roles of election, proclamation and coronation, however. For the English, coronation was simply confirmation. Of itself, it conferred God’s blessing, but it did not create a king, unlike in continental ceremonies of the time.
For the Normans, kingship was conferred by God in the act of coronation. For them, since Eadgar had not been consecrated and crowned, he could not be regarded as a king. This left William’s status in a state of constitutional hiatus, so both the capitulating English magnates and his accompanying Norman barons urged him to take the crown quickly, hence the proximity of Eadgar’s submission and William’s coronation. His barons were more concerned about having to wait to receive their lands and honours in return for their fealty. As a result, William was set to be crowned on Christmas Day.
Even then, the newly crowned king hesitated. At this point, only the southeastern part of the kingdom was truly subdued, despite the aristocratic submissions from Mercia and Northumberland. Also, his wife and future queen was still in Normandy, and he naturally wished for her to be crowned alongside him as Queen Consort. On the first point, however, he was eventually persuaded that once he had begun to rule with full legitimacy, any actual or potential rebels could be quickly made to submit. The Archbishops and Bishops were no doubt relieved, if saddened, by the deposition of Eadgar and his replacement by a foreign ruler. But Eadgar himself was present at the ceremony, as were Earls Morcar and Edwin. Even Archbishop Ealdred eventually gave up the cause of Royal Wessex and was among those who crowned William I at the Abbey.
The audience comprised both Normans and English, but the majority of London’s citizens must have remained at home. No doubt those who did attend were relieved to help put an end to the bloodshed, as even those who were not present at the battle had witnessed the steady stream of walking wounded who found refuge in the city in the days which followed it. Some mounted cavalry remained outside the abbey, as a precaution against ambush. The ceremony followed a conventional form, adhering to long-standing English traditions. The service was conducted by Ealdred, Archbishop of York, rather than Stigand. William swore to govern the people well and justly, and to establish and maintain the law, totally forbidding rapine and unjust judgements.
But the Normans had harried everywhere they went, and continued to do so, as if they were still at war. The coronation itself was almost a disaster as Norman soldiers outside the Abbey, hearing shouts of acclamation for the new king in both English and French, mistook them for the start of an uprising and responded by setting fire to the nearby houses, causing the church to fill with smoke and many of those attending to flee in panic. Contemporaries observed that this was not an auspicious beginning for the newly crowned king.
William responded by continuing to point out that he, as the lawful successor to the Confessor, would guarantee the rights of his new subjects. However, in the immediate years after 1066, there was a keen sweep of the upper echelons of Anglo-Danish society in England: the leading Anglo-Saxon thanes had either been killed at Hastings, had compromised with the conqueror, or were in exile in Flanders or further afield. Both the lay aristocracy and the upper levels of the Church saw a considerable change of personnel, beginning with the replacement of Stigand by Lanfranc as Archbishop of Canterbury.
Just before William left for Normandy, he decided to move his household to Berkhamsted as soon as the castle was completed. Edwin and Morcar visited him there on returning from their earldoms. They were keen to recover some of the lands they had had confiscated as a result of their initial support for Eadgar. William treated them with honour, but fined them heavily in exchange for returning their lands. He also commanded the monks of Bury St Edmunds to produce a ledger of the lands of all those among the fallen Saxons at Hastings so that he could confiscate their lands.
Soon after, he travelled to Pevensey where he had commanded a large number of high-ranking Englishmen to meet him, including Eadgar, Morcar and Edwin. They were charged to sail with him to Normandy as his hostages, though they were treated as members of his retinue while in Normandy. Before he set sail, William had committed the government of England to Odo and William fitz Osbern, based respectively at Dover and Winchester. When he returned, William kept Edwin and Morcar as hostages at his court at Westminster.
Twenty-Four; Exeter, 1067-68 – The Norman Yoke:
After the short period of peace which followed William’s coronation and his departure for St Valery, there was renewed Anglo-Danish resistance and brutal retaliation by Norman barons, now unrestrained by William in Normandy, including the seizure of Saxon estates, and it was not long before full-scale rebellions broke out. Although the Norman chroniclers asserted that the two men dealt justly with their fellow Christian subjects, Orderic Vitalis again replaced what he saw as their propagandised comments with a passage which made no bones as to what the Saxon subjects suffered at the hands of their new Norman masters:
Meanwhile, the English were groaning under the Norman Yoke and suffering oppressions from the proud lords who ignored the King’s injunctions; the petty lords who guarded the castles oppressed all native inhabitants of high and low degree and heaped shameful burdens on them. …
For Bishop Odo and William Fitz Osbern, the King’s Vice-Jurants were so swollen with pride that they would not deign to hear the reasonable plea of the English or give them impartial judgement. When their men-at-arms were guilty of plunder and rape, they protected them by force, and wreaked their wrath all the more violently on those who complained of the cruel wrongs they suffered.
Moreover, the Norman expropriation of Anglo-Danish estates, frequently violent, was considered by the thanes to be a breach of William’s solemn promise at Berkhamsted as well as those he had made at his coronation. William had received news of an insurrection while still in Normandy. This was centred on Exeter, but was part of a more general conspiracy which had, as its core, the remnant of the Godwin family, coordinated by Gytha, the mother of Harold Godwinson and his three brothers, all of whom had been killed either at Stamford Bridge or at Hastings. His sons by his first wife, Edith Swan-neck, who, together with Gytha, had fled to Exeter.
Soon after arriving back in London, William mustered his troops and marched west through Wessex, Godwin territory, to the city. He besieged it, but when the Godwin faction left, it was surrendered by its citizens. But the Conqueror did not keep to the terms they had agreed, and sacked the city. Raids by Harold’s sons from the north Wessex (Somerset) coast and into the Bristol Channel were defeated, and William led his army on into Cornwall, putting down every disturbance that came to his attention, and then putting command of the far west in the hands of a Breton follower. He then disbanded his Anglo-Norman army and returned to Winchester in time to celebrate Easter.
Twenty-Five: 1067-9, York, Durham – Northern Risings; The Flight to Scotland:
It was probably on their return to England from Normandy in 1067 that Eadgar broke from William and fled to Northumbria, probably by ship and with his family. With the remainder of the Godwin clan in exile, their lands were now forfeit, and the Conqueror had more lands with which to reward his loyal followers. One of these, a long-time friend, Roger de Montgomery, was a principal beneficiary. He had been co-regent with William’s wife Matilda in Normandy, and now returned to England with William, being first charged with the keep of the castles of Chichester and Arundel. He was then made Earl of Shrewsbury when Shropshire was carved out of Edwin’s Mercian lands to create one of the new marcher lordships.
Another of the new king’s friends, William de Warenne, became the castellan of Lewes, so that with all the quickest routes to Normandy guarded, his chief tenants on the south coast could also keep an eye out for any further trouble brewing in what had only recently been the Godwin heartland further west.
The Norman king then turned his attentions to the North, after receiving a visit from Gospatrick of Bamburgh, who came south in the hope of securing the Earldom of Northumbria he had held before the initial conquest of the south. Despite having murdered William’s preferred candidate, William agreed to sell him the earldom for what Simeon of Durham declared to be a great sum.
For Morcar, the grant of the northern half of his earldom to Gospatrick must have come as a severe blow to his prestige, but in Yorkshire too, he may have exercised little power. After their defeat at Fulford, Harold had handed control of the shire to Maerlsweyn, the sheriff of Lincolnshire, and he was still in charge there two years later, in 1068. The earldom as a title had always been an overlordship in Saxon times, divided into two regions under the control of two lesser lords.
In 1068, the harsh Norman régime had led to further spontaneous native uprisings in the North, especially among the supporters of Eadgar Aetheling, who was now in Scotland with his family at the court of King Malcolm. According to William of Poitiers, William still counted the Aetheling among his dearest friends, on account of his kinship to Edward the Confessor and had tried to compensate him for the loss of the crown with gifts of land. However, it seems probable that Eadgar had not appreciated William taking him as a hostage to Normandy and that his resolve to support those in rebellion was strengthened by his mother and sisters having been freed from the same danger of being held hostage while at court in London.
They had taken ship from the Thames, obstensibly intending to return to Hungary via Hamburg, but more likely to the Humber and then, separately from Eadgar, to Scotland, but on the second stage of their journey they were blown off course and shipwrecked on Orkney at what later became known as St Margaret’s Hope. They subsequently dropped anchor in the Firth of Forth. It was claimed that King Andrew’s illegitimate son, George, who had accompanied the Wessex exiles to England and protected them during the previous ten years, played a major role in saving the three women from the shipwreck, for which he was later rewarded with lands on which to settle.
There they met and sought sanctuary with the King of Scotland, Malcolm III, whom Margaret had met ten years previously at King Edward’s court and who now escorted them to his court at Dunfermline. Having arrived in Scotland, they could no longer be held, effectively, as hostages by William in the wake of Eadgar revoking his allegiance to him and going over to the rebels. By joining them, he gave them a legitimate cause and figurehead. Orderic reported that they prepared to defend themselves in woods, marshes and cities. Also, The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle recorded that the king was informed that in the North, the people had gathered together and intended to make a stance against him, if he came north. William’s response to the rebellion was resolute. He did go north, intending to recapture York and to subdue the rebels. Along the route through Mercia and south Yorkshire, he allowed his men to harry wherever they went as a warning of what York might expect. As soon as he had planted his first new castle at Warwick, Edwin and Morcar, effectively the leaders of the rebellion, surrendered. When Nottingham fell, and another new castle arose, the citizens of York dispatched hostages together with the keys to the city gates. William arrived there soon afterwards and planted a third new castle, known as Clifford’s Tower.
At this point, the remaining rebels in Northumbria also gave up the fight. Some, like the Bishop of Durham, approached the king and sought his pardon. Others, including Maerlsweyn, Gospatrick and Eadgar Aetheling, sought refuge in Scotland. King Malcolm had supported the rebels from the start, and was preparing to send forces to their aid, but when he saw how quickly the rising had collapsed and envoys from William arrived demanding his submission, he sent back representatives to swear fealty and obedience on his behalf. William then left York, and built further castles on his way back to London, at Lincoln, Huntingdon and Cambridge.
But William remained anxious about the security of northern England, and with good reason. Although King Malcolm had personally submitted to William’s overlordship, he had not yet surrendered any of the English rebels at his court. Maerlsweyn, Gospatrick and Eadgar remained at large.
At the beginning of the New Year of 1069, therefore, the Norman king decided to tighten his grip on the North by appointing another new earl, this time a complete outsider. Robert Cumyn was probably from the Flemish town of Comyn, and came to England with a band of Flemish mercenaries, numbering between five hundred and nine hundred men. His remit was to govern the region to the north of the Tyne.
He allowed his men to ravage the countryside by looting and killing, which they carried on when they entered the city of Durham. At first light, the Northumbrians rushed through all the gates, killing the earl’s companions. The Flemish put up some resistance at the bishop’s house where Cumyn was quartered, but the insurgents simply burnt down the building and continued cutting down the rest of his Flemings. The massacre at Durham on 31st January acted as a trigger for a new general rising. A short time later, the governor of the new castle at York was slaughtered with many of his men. The Northumbrians gained confidence in resisting the Normans, whom they saw as oppressors of their friends and allies.
The leaders of the resistance returned from their exile north of the Forth. They joined forces with the rebels and led them in an attack on York, where the Norman sheriff and his men were still holding out. He managed to get a message out to William, who had recently returned from a second visit to Normandy. The Conqueror arrived at the city with a swiftness which surprised the Northumbrians, and shocked them with an overwhelming display of arms. Orderic reported that:
Many were taken captive, and more were killed, and others were put to flight.
The whole city was ravaged and Yorkminster was made an object of scorn by the Norman soldiery. The leaders of the rebellion managed to escape from the city, but Eadgar returned to Scotland alone this time. William gave the custody of the city to William fitz Osbern before himself returning to Winchester for Easter on 13th April.
Feeling increasingly secure, William sent messages to his wife, inviting her to join him at court. She came immediately, with her full retinue and a few weeks later, at Whitsun, she was crowned at Westminster. The witness list included Ealdred and Stigand, Leofric of Exeter and Odo of Bayeux, Roger of Montgomery and William fitz Osbern, Edwin and Morcar. However, behind the scenes, there was mounting anger at the ongoing redistribution of land. Edwin and Morcar were especially upset about their lost lands and as well as their enforced visit to Normandy the previous year. They offended William by leaving court immediately following the ceremony and once more returning to their estates to lead the local resistance which formed around them. However, their opposition collapsed at the first sign of favour from the king, and they were welcomed back to court. But despite their repeated acts of submission, they remained shunned and disaffected throughout the entire course of the Conquest.
The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle (E version) summed up the experience of the six months of 1068 since William’s return and the resentment of the earls and thanes in a single sentence:
When he came back, he gave away every man’s land.
Orderic Vitalis also identified the loss of patrimonies of the main cause of discontent from 1068 onwards. Even those whom the King had tried to appease were losing patience with him. The brothers Edwin and Morcar may have harboured resentment over their compulsory tour of Normandy as the king’s honoured guests but what must have rankled more was not just the loss of lands and wealth, but the steady erosion of their authority in England that went with it. Much of Morcar’s earldom had been granted to Normans, leading to the Great Northern Rising of 1069 and the devastation of Yorkshire the following winter.
Edwin may have been even more disillusioned with William’s rule than his brother, given the gulf between what he had been promised in return for his submission in 1066 and what he had actually received by the end of 1068. Orderic, himself a Mercian, reported:
When William had made peace with Edwin, he had granted him authority over his brother and almost a third of England, and had promised to give him his daughter in marriage.
This may not have been a promise William intended to keep, but it was taken seriously by Edwin, and for him the proposed marriage was not simply a transactional matter. He had been courting the lady in question for the past two years, and Orderic commented that William now…
… withheld the maiden from the noble youth, who had greatly desired her and had long waited for her.
Apart from the apparent heartbreak this caused him, Edwin also had his authority undermined. Along the border between England and Wales, the Norman king established Marcher lordships to control the borderlands. These were to be independent fiefdoms in the charge of William’s most trusted chief tenants, based on the three towns of Chester, Shrewsbury and Hereford.
The earldom of Hereford included Worcester, which had been a major concern for Edwin as a cathedral city, a major centre of the English Church, previously held by Ealdred before he became Archbishop of York. As for Shrewsbury, the powerbase of the new north Mercian earldom, it had always, through Saxon times, been the county town of Shropshire, a constituent part of the Kingdom of Mercia until the conquest of Cnut fifty years earlier when Eadmund Ironside had received King Offa’s bloodied sword from his brother Aethelstan. Now Shropshire was suddenly taken away from Edwin and given by William to a newly arrived Frenchman, Roger de Montgomery. In doing this, the Conqueror had driven a symbolic wedge between himself and the greatest surviving English earl.
Later in 1068, the brothers withdrew from court once more, returned to their earldoms and rebelled against William, attempting this time to raise a major rebellion in Mercia. Orderic described the cataclysmic nature of their action:
Edwin and Morcar rose in rebellion, and many others with them.
One of these involved in the rising was not even a true subject of the new Norman king, but a king in his own right. King Bleddyn of Wales was among the first magnates to come out in support of Edwin, no doubt enraged by the land-grabbing Norman barons who had established themselves, with William’s approval, along his borders. They were supported by many thousands of both English and Welsh; the clergy, monks and the poor were strongly on their side, and messages were sent to every part of the kingdom to stir up resistance.
Morcar’s activity may be inferred from the prominent role in the rebellion by York. The most significant supporter of the two earls was Eadgar Aetheling, who was now completely alienated from William, having left his court together with his family to join the Northumbrian rebels at the court of King Malcolm. He was again the figurehead for a fresh rebellion, having released himself and his family from William’s vice-like grip, and was especially upheld by the Bernician district under the control of Gospatrick. In addition, despite their recent divisions over William’s slicing up of Northumbria, Morcar received the support of Gospatrick, Maerlsweyn, Archbishop Ealdred of York (who nevertheless tried to calm the citizens of York) and the Bishop of Durham.
But both Morcar and Edwin were not inclined to risk too much; they advanced to Warwick and there made another submission to William, were pardoned and kept at court with an appearance of favour. On their defection, the rebellion came to nothing. As far as we know, the two brothers had played no part in the risings of 1068-70, either in the Midlands or the North after the Warwick submission. However, the two brothers had received the King’s forgiveness in 1068 in outward appearance only, and, in reality, they were prisoners at court.
Twenty-Six – Wearmouth, 1069-70; The Danish Invasion and the Harrying of the North.
Having left her island hide-away in the Bristol Channel, Gytha, after a short stay in Flanders, had sailed to Denmark in the summer of 1069 in the hope of attracting Danish support for the Godwin cause. Almost from the day after William’s coronation, Anglo-Danish thanes had been sending messages across the North Sea to solicit aid from the Danish king, Sweyn Estrikssohn. Up until this point, Sweyn had shown little enthusiasm for adventures along the English East coast, but since the Norman victory at Hastings, he had begun to display a keener interest and wished, in particular, to avenge the deaths of the Danish troops he had sent to Harold Godwinson’s aid.
But by 1069, the factor influencing him was doubtless the obvious unpopularity of Norman rule, especially in the North and the Danelaw, where there were still many familial ties to Scandinavia. In addition, a major rebellion flared up in Northumbria led by Earl Waltheof and Prince Eadgar, who had returned to northern England and joined with the other rebel leaders in Northumbria.
The English envoys now had little difficulty in persuading Sweyn that, if he intervened or invaded, he would be met by a huge groundswell of Anglo-Danish support among the English population. So, in the summer of 1069, Sweyn began to assemble a huge invasion force. Orderic stated that…
…he strained all the resources of his kingdom, as well as amassing troops from neighbouring regions that were friendly towards him; Poland, Fresia and Saxony all helped.
It was late in the summer when the Danish fleet finally sailed. It arrived on the Northumbrian coast at some point between 15th August and 8th September. With the arrival of Sweyn’s army, King Malcolm decided to take his army into Cumbria and across the Pennines via Teesdale before occupying Wearmouth. There Malcolm met Eadgar, who was invited to return to Scotland with him, but initially he declined the offer, prefering to remain in Northumberland until later in the year, when he then rejoined his family at Malcolm’s court.
In the meantime, the Danes raided their way up the eastern coasts of England until they reached the Humber estuary, where they were met by Eadgar, Gospatrick and Maerlsweyn. How exactly the aspirations of the three English magnates were going to be reconciled with those of the Danish king is unclear in the chronicles, but Sweyn returned to Denmark and was not there in person to take part in what was supposed to be his own invasion, so there seemed no urgent need for a solution to this issue. The English rebel leaders were overjoyed; it seemed to them that the them that the days of Norman rule in England were numbered. Archbishop Ealdred, however, was so distressed to hear of another Danish invasion that he took to his bed and died on 11th September. He was said to have died of a broken heart due to what may have seemed to him to be the impending defeat of the English cause in the North.
Eadgar and the other Northumbrian rebels joined the Danish army from the fleet, and there was a wave of fresh uprisings in various parts of England. News of the arrival of the Danish fleet in the Humber stirred the rebels in Wessex and Mercia into action. William was hunting in the Forest of Dean when he heard the news of the arrival of the Danish fleet. He sent messages to York, warning his men to be prepared, but they answered that they could hold out for a year or more.
York’s Norman garrison seem to have become even more anxious, and on 19th September, in an act of desperation at the approach of the Danish force, they began setting fire to the houses adjacent to the castle, fearing that their timbers could be used to bridge the defensive ditch. Predictably, the blaze ran out of control and soon the whole city was engulfed in flames, including the Minster.
Two days later, with the fire still burning, the Anglo-Danish army arrived. The Norman garrison sallied out to engage them, but was quickly overwhelmed. John of Worcester reported that more than three thousand Normans were killed, and only a few, including the sheriff of York and his family, were spared. The Danes and Northumbrian rebel forces then went on to take control of the earldom as a whole.
When William received the news three days later, he mobilised an army and marched on York, only to find that the Danes had returned to their ships and crossed to the other side of the Humber, where they were camping on the Isle of Axeholm in Lincolnshire, among the marshes, with no intention of meeting the Conqueror in open battle.
The king set about flushing his enemies out from their hiding places, but news arrived of rebellions in other parts of the kingdom, including in Somerset and Exeter (again). Shrewsbury was subjected to a combined attack from the Welsh, the local population and the men of Chester. This was led by Eadric the Wild and other untamable Englishmen. All William’s enemies were seizing the chance to shake off his lordship, his yoke. William sent Fitz Osbern and others to suppress this revolt in West Mercia. But the rebels set fire to Shrewsbury and scattered, only to reassemble once the Normans had moved on to Exeter.
The Conqueror himself then went to deal with the Mercian rebels, eventually defeating a large force at Stafford. Moving across the Midlands to Lincolnshire, he then turned his attentions back to York, where, in mid-November, the Danes had returned.
But William found that the bridge across the River Aire at Pontefract had been broken by the Anglo-Danish insurgents, blocking the way to York and giving the town its name (meaning broken bridge in Latin). There he was confronted by a river he couldn’t cross, without bridges he could use and a current that was too fast to ford. He was delayed there for three weeks until his scouts discovered a ford further up-river which he was able to cross, using a ballista bombardment to cover his advance and causing the Danes to retreat.
Late in the year, William fought his way into Northumbria, but it was not until December that William’s army was able to reoccupy York, only to find that the Danes had, once again, returned to their fleet in the Humber, where William could not get at it. William offered the Danish commander a large sum of money, and gave permission for his men to forage along the coasts, on the condition that he would leave, without fighting, at the end of the winter. The Danish leader accepted, and having bought off his main opponent, William left York and divided his army into smaller contingents. Eadgar’s small seaborne raid into Lindsey (Lincolnshire) ended in disaster and he escaped with only a handful of supporters to rejoin the main Anglo-Danish forces.
William’s response was to turn to terror tactics once more. Orderic explained that the Norman contingents spread out over a hundred miles of moorland and forest territory, slaying many men and destroying the homes and hiding places of others. William also commanded that all crops, herds, chattels and food of every kind should be brought together and burned, so that no future Anglo-Danish army would be able to sustain itself by raiding across Northumbria. William’s scorched earth policy was brutally effective, as he spent the winter of 1069-70 laying waste all before him, until all resistance was ended.
The resulting famine was reported by Orderic to have caused the starvation of a hundred thousand Northumbrians. The Harrying of the North as it became known, put paid to the immediate threat of a popular and widespread Anglo-Danish uprising. Orderic, albeit born five years later, concluded:
My narrative has frequently had occasion to praise William, but for this act, which condemned the guilty and innocent alike to die by slow starvation, I cannot commend him. For when I think of helpless children, young men in the prime of life and hoary greybeards perishing alike of hunger, I am so moved to pity that I would rather lament the grief and sufferings of the wretched people than make a vain attempt to flatter the perpetrator of such infamy. Moreover, I declare that, assuredly, such brutal slaughter cannot remain unpunished.
As 1069 drew to a close, and with the countryside all around him still smouldering, William left his army in camp and went to York for Christmas. But York Minster, according to the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, was completely… burnt down.
Soon after Christmas, William learned of the location of some of the rebel leaders and set out to confront them. Eadgar and his small band of followers had taken refuge in a marshy area north of the Humber estuary, perhaps Holderness. William moved against them and put them to flight. He then pursued them across North Yorkshire and caught some of them at the Tees, where Gospatrick swore fealty. But Maerlsweyn and Eadgar fled through Northumbria, back into Scotland. The Norman army followed them, spreading all over the moorland and forested area between the Tees and the Tyne, but failed to find them.
Twenty-Seven: Queen Margaret at King Malcolm’s Court, 1070.
Eadgar’s family was now settled in Scotland and, after a period of courting, Margaret became Malcolm’s Queen Consort in 1070. According to the contemporary evidence of Simeon of Durham, she civilised her adoptive country as well as Malcolm himself. When Malcolm married Margaret, he agreed to support Eadgar in his attempt to regain the English throne for the House of Wessex. According to Simeon, Agatha (Margaret and Eadgar’s mother) left Scotland at some point soon after 1070, probably returning to Bavaria by ship via Hamburg or Bremen. Before leaving, she gave her Black Cross (a section is shown below) to her daughter Margaret as an inheritance.
The name Margaret, margarita in Latin, was derived from the Greek word for a pearl, which is why Margaret became known as the precious pearl in Hungary and later the pearl of Scotland. The ultimate origin is believed to be Persian for child of light, based upon a myth about how is pearls were formed by dewdrops and moonbeams. The name first appeared in Scotland in the late eleventh century, having penetrated into central-eastern Europe through the veneration of St Margaret of Antioch, a third-century martyr. The name also became popular in medieval England and was shortened to Madge and Meg, while in Scotland the pet forms Maisie and Maggie also became common and Greta became popular in German and Swedish.
Of the three children of Edward the Exile, Margaret is the best remembered in history and tradition. Her importance lies not only in the fact that it was she who began the religious and administrative reforms of Scotland during the reign of her husband, Malcolm III, but that through her gentle influence, she ennobled the still austere morals and customs of the kingdom. That is why contemporary chroniclers claimed that she civilised Scotland.
Turgot, Bishop of St Andrews, wrote an obituary of Margaret, Queen of Scotland, which he addressed to Matilda, Queen of the English, wife of Henry I and Margaret’s daughter, who was christened Eadyth but crowned as Matilda, who had commanded him to narrate… the particulars of the life of her mother so that she could have it continually before her eyes. When Margaret died, Eadyth was at Wilton Abbey, and though her father visited her there, Turgot’s record of her life suggests that she had not seen much of her mother during her years in England:
… although you were but little familiar with her face, you might at least have a perfect acquaintance with her virtues… But far be it from my grey hairs to mingle falsehood with the virtues of such a woman as she was, in unfolding which I profess… that I add nothing to the truth.
Having known the late Queen of Scotland since her arrival in Scotland as a young princess (aged twenty-one) following the Conquest of England and the deposition of her brother, Turgot added:
… whilst Margaret was yet in the first flower of youth, she began to lead a very strict life, to love God above all things, to employ herself in the study of Divine writings, and therein with joy to exercise her mind. Her understanding was keen to comprehend any matter, whatever it might be; to this was joined a great tenacity of memory, enabling her to store it up, along with a graceful flow of language to express it. …
… even amidst the distractions of lawsuits, amidst the countless cares of state,… she used to ask profound questions from the learned men who were sitting near her. But just as no one among them possessed a deeper intellect than herself, so none had the power of clearer expression. Thus it often happened that these doctors went from her much wiser men than when they came. …
Her support for her husband and influence on him, according to the bishop, was significant:
… This prudent queen directed all such things as it was fitting for her to regulate; the laws of the realm were administered by her counsel; by her care the influence of religion was extended, and the people rejoiced in the prosperity of their affairs. … nothing was more enduring than her patience, graver than her advice, or more pleasant than her conversation. …
… When she spoke, her conversation was seasoned with the salt of wisdom …
… in regard to King Malcolm, by the help of God she made him most attentive to the works of justice, mercy, almsgiving, and other virtues; … she instructed him by her exhortation and example how to pray… There was in him a sort of dread of offending one whose life was so vulnerable. … nay, more, he readily obeyed her wishes and prudent counsels in all things. … Hence it was that, although he could not read, he would turn over and examine books which she used either for her devotions or her study. … She also arranged that persons of a higher position should be appointed for the king’s service … to accompany him in state whenever he walked or rode abroad. … wherever they came, none of them was suffered to take anything from anyone, nor did they dare to oppress or injure country people or the poor.
At the same time, Margaret was aware that it was part of her duty as Queen to maintain a certain degree of kingly dignity and decorum at the royal palace, but without creating a show of worldly splendour:
Further, she introduced so much state into the royal palace, that not only was it brightened by the many colours of the apparel worn in it, but the whole dwelling blazed with gold and silver… in her exalted dignity she was always watchful to preserve humility. It was easy for her to repress all vain glory… since her soul never forgot how transitory is this frail life.
She was also very careful about the upbringing of her children:
… She took all heed that they should be well brought up, and especially that they should be trained in virtue. …
Turgot, Bishop of St Andrews, Obituary of Margaret, Queen of Scotland: Edited by William Forbes-Leith (3rd edn., 1896).
Twenty-Eight: Easter, Spring 1070 – Mercia and Wessex
Towards the end of January 1070, William decided to end the hunt for the Northern rebel leaders and returned to York. There he spent some time rebuilding the city before setting off to deal with the remaining rebels in Mercia. Their siege of Shrewsbury was raised, and more new castles were built at Chester and Stafford. By March, after more than two years of fighting, the general revolt had been defeated. But although a few rebels such as Gospatrick had submitted and had their estates restored, many more had been killed or were in exile, which had also produced a new round of confiscations. Those who lost their lands at this point probably included Eadgar and certainly his fellow exile, Maerlsweyn, whose estates were transferred directly to a Norman baron.
At Easter 1070, William had himself crowned for a second time, at Winchester, in a ceremony which was designed to provide an emphatic statement of the Conqueror’s legitimacy in the ancient capital of Wessex. A papal legation of two cardinals and a bishop solemnly recrowned William. They also renewed the penitential ordinances that had first been issued after the Battle of Hastings so that they could cover the spilling of blood that had followed during the previous three years of quelling rebellions.
More importantly, they visited the various diocese to correct and reform the lax state, as they found it from their Roman view, of the English Church. This began with the deposition of Stigand, who had already been excommunicated for simony, holding two posts at the same time, Winchester and Canterbury.
Even before the risings, William had given his brother, Odo of Bayeux, the earldom of Kent and a castle at Dover, from which to defend the Channel, while in the Anglo-Welsh marches he created the earldom of Hereford, giving its stewardship to William Fitz Osbern, who also held Norwich for him in case of another Danish attack. William also created new earldom of Chester and Shrewsbury to protect against further rebellions like that led by Eadric the Wild, supported by the Welsh between 1067 and 1070, and to secure the border with Gwynedd, through the building and garrisoning of a new castle at Rhuddlan.
William’s followers thought it necessary to impress the conquered natives with their military might. They therefore erected castles throughout England; these were simple constructions at first, and from their wooden towers they sallied out to subdue the peasantry, though in Suffolk, for example, the Normans had little trouble from them; the freemen and serfs alike resigned themselves without a struggle to the exchange of a Danish thane for a Norman baron. The English knew how strong the new fortresses were since they had been pressed into building them themselves, under the watchful eyes of Norman overseers.
The Conqueror gave Richard Fitz Gilbert control over 170 castles in Essex and Suffolk, and the tenant-in-chief built his own castle at Clare on the conjunction of the Stour and Chilton. He reused the massive hundred-foot-high Saxon earthwork, surmounting it with two baileys, each fenced and moated. Another moat and curtain wall encircled the base of the motte making it a supremely strong, defensive fortification.
Twenty-Nine; The Attack on Peterborough, Summer 1070:
At the end of May 1070, despite the deal struck between William and the leader of Sweyn’s invasion force, Osbjorn, the Danish fleet had not sailed home. Their plan all along had been to establish and maintain a permanent base in northeast England from which Sweyn could lead an outright conquest. Sweyn had finally arrived, joining his brother at the mouth of the Humber. His reception was rapturous, and although the English leaders had fled Northumbria at the beginning of 1070, the local people came out in support of the Danish king, assuming that he would now go on to defeat the Normans in battle. But Sweyn appears to have remained close to the Humber, while Osbjern and a force of Danish housecarls immediately moved south into East Anglia, attacking first Peterborough and then Ely. Here, too, there was, reportedly, a great surge of goodwill among the people of the Fenlands, and considerable optimism. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle (E) commented:
Englishmen from all over the Fenlands came to meet them, thinking that they were going to conquer the whole land.
Meanwhile, during and after the northern rebellions, the northern thanes (those from north of the Thames) continued to resist the Norman land-grab. They were led in the East by Hereward Asketilson, an Anglo-Danish thane once outlawed and exiled by King Edward, who now rose in open rebellion. Hereward was desribed as a man of gentle or noble birth who was one of the leading men of the Fen district and a vir strenuissmus, a most active and energetic man, an action man, one with a fearsome back-story. He had returned to England from Flanders in 1068 to find that his father, Asketil, and grandfather, Toki (a merchant of Lincoln), had died in fighting, in addition to his brother, Toli.
Those left in charge when William returned to Normandy in 1067 had done nothing to control their men. Hereward’s estates had been seized, so he decided to join those Englishmen whom the Normans called the wildmen of the woods, who were resisting the continuing conquest.
By the time Hereward returned to the Fens, the rebels had taken refuge in the woods, marshes and river valleys. He first visited his uncle, Brand the Monk, who had succeeded Leofric as Abbot of Peterborough. Brand had angered William in the autumn of 1066 by going to Eadgar for recognition as Abbot because William had not yet been crowned king. William had fined him forty gold marks, a considerable, debilitating sum. Hereward had held some of his lands as a steward of Peterborough, and now renewed his promise to protect the abbey, but he also found out that all of his lands, and the lands of his father and grandfather, in more than seven shires, had been appropriated by the Normans.
Hereward was alleged to have driven out the Norman occupants of one of his manors, slaying several of them. He may well have returned from the continent to his inheritance, his patrimony, and discovering that it had been confiscated, slew the occupants and moved quickly against the Norman king, to whom he had not yet sworn allegiance.
This probably took place in 1067, after William had returned to Normandy, leaving his brother, Odo of Bayeux and William FitzOsbern to govern the realm for most of that year and the next. Neither of them did much to restrain the barons and the Norman soldiery. At first, there was little resistance in the southern shires, which were still reeling from the trail of terror William had left from Hampshire to Hertfordshire. Orderic Vitalis reported that this was a period of constant plotting and of rumours of plots among native Anglo-Danish leaders.
Basing himself in the rebel hideout in the Fens and given help by the Abbot of Ely, Thurstan, Hereward began harassing the Normans, killing and robbing them. William himself was forced to offer him a truce after he almost caught and killed one of the leading barons, William de Warenne, who was later made Earl of Surrey. He had already been appointed Sheriff of Lincolnshire and was one of the Norman lords who had shared out Hereward’s lands. Hereward then returned to Flanders to collect his wife, Turfrida, the attractive Flemish daughter of the Castellan of St Omer, and to recruit some of the mercenaries soldiers who had fought with him in Scaldermariland.
While in Flanders, Abbot Thurstan sent Hereward a message telling him that his uncle, Brand, Abbot of Peterborough, was dead and that the sons of Sweyn Estridssohn, had arrived in the Fens with a raiding army and might be persuaded to support a rising against the Normans. He was also told that William had appointed a Norman, Turold of Malmesbury, previously of Fécamp in Normandy, as Abbot of Peterborough, and that he was on his way to the abbey with an army to defeat the rebels. Hereward pulled his army together hurriedly and returned to England. He held a meeting with the Danes and talked them into helping him upset William’s plan by seizing the wealth and treasures of the abbey to prevent them falling into Norman hands.
Gathering together his combined forces of English, Danish and Flemish mercenaries, he then advanced to Peterborough, crossing the fens in large, flat-bottomed boats. At first they were resisted by the townsfolk, but then they set fire to the South gate of the abbey. Once inside, they collected all the movable precious objects they could lay their hands on. But then the Danes hung on to the greater part of the plunder and refused to help in further resistance to the Normans.
At some point after the attack on Peterborough on 2nd June 1070, William offered terms, which the Danish king accepted. His fleet sailed around the east coast, probably to collect his housecarls from East Anglia. They then put into the Thames estuary for two nights before sailing back to Denmark. By mid-summer, Sweyn and his troops were gone, leaving the English resistance on its own again. The Danes at Peterborough were ordered by King Sweyn to return to Denmark. He had done a deal with William in return for a large bribe, so the English rebels were left to face William’s wrath alone.
Sweyn must have quickly realised that even the great fleet he had sent with its army on board were inadequate to mount a full-scale conquest of the whole kingdom of England. With the benefit of hindsight, his subsequent decision to send Osbjern into East Anglia looks less like the start of a major military campaign, and more like a conventional Viking incursion or raid intended to recoup the costs involved in building the fleet and assembling the invasion force. However, even this more modest objective was also lost, as on their journey home, the Danes ran into a storm and most of their ships were wrecked, together with many men and much treasure. This was a disastrous turn of events for the Anglo-Danish resistance to the Norman power-grab.
Above: Hungarians at Kyív – a painting by Pál Vágó (1853-1928). It is extremely difficult to maintain, based on archaeological relics that have been unearthed in territories now forming part of Ukraine, that these objects are unmistakably the relics of the ancient Hungarians, or Magyars. It is probable, though, that as a result of research on such finds, that many more artifacts lie hidden in the Etelköz, the region settled by the ancient Hungarians before the final stage of their migration to the Carpathian Basin in the ninth century. The early eleventh-century spires of Kyív can be seen in the background, and in the foreground to the right, a young woman appears to be being traded as a slave with Hungarian traders.
Introduction – The Turn of the First Millennium
Raiders and Traders; Feudal Lords and the Unfree:
For generations on end, large areas of northern and central Europe were devastated by marauding raiders, Northmen and Magyars, and for centuries much larger areas were repeatedly thrown into turmoil by the private wars of feudal barons. At the same time, the bulk of the peasantry lived in a state of irksome dependence on their lords, ecclesiastical or lay. Many of them were serfs, slaves bonded to their landed masters, who carried their bondage in their blood and transmitted it from generation to generation. They belonged at birth to the patrimony of a lord, a uniquely degrading condition. …
During the mid-ninth century, the Magyars began their westward migration alongside other groups. Among them were a few herdsmen, while the majority were nomadic warriors engaged in raiding and trading, often dealing in slaves, gold, and silver acquired through plunder. Through this movement, they came into contact with the Rus, the Vikings, and the Turkic-Bulgar tribes residing along the Lower Danube.
One of these ethnic groups was the On-Ogour, which translates as “Ten Arrows” or “Ten Tribes” from the Turkic. This name refers to the ten Magyar tribes that had settled in the former territory of the Bulgar-Turkic alliance since the seventh century. Most of the future conquerors of the Carpathian Basin originated from the lands between the Dniester and Dnieper rivers, known in Hungarian as Etelköz, situated in the eastern foothills of the Carpathian mountains. They were therefore well-acquainted with the shores of the Black Sea, extending down to Byzantium, the Balkan Peninsula, the Carpathian Basin, and all of Central Europe to the west of the Danube. For many of them, a passion for warfare and wandering became a significant part of their identity. They began to move west, together with other groups, from the mid-ninth century. A few of them were herdsmen and the rest were nomadic warriors, raiding and trading in slaves, gold and silver taken as plunder. This is how they came into contact with the Rus, the Vikings and the Turkic-Bulgar tribes on the Lower Danube.
But most of the future ‘conquerors’ of the Carpathian Basin were found in the lands between the Dniester and Dnieper rivers, known in Hungarian as the Etelköz, in the east-facing foreground of the Carpathian mountains. They were therefore familiar with the shores of the Black Sea down to Byzantium, the Balkan peninsula, the Carpathian Basin and all of Central Europe to the west of the Danube. For the freer among them, warring and wandering also became a passion.
In Eastern Europe, Hungarian trade connections with the Vikings began to develop along the Vistula River in the early tenth century, coinciding with the settlement of the Magyar tribes west of the Carpathians. However, by the end of the tenth century and the beginning of the new millennium, continuous raiding had made it nearly impossible for them to sustain their traditional way of life. This situation began to improve in the middle of the eleventh century, as regions gradually became more peaceful, allowing for population growth and the development of commerce. In Eastern Europe, Hungarian trading connections with Vikings also developed along the Vistula from the beginning of the tenth century, when the Magyar tribes were settling west of the Carpathians. But by the end of the tenth century and the beginning of the new millennium, the continual raiding was making their traditional way of life almost impossible to sustain. This state of affairs only began to change when, from the middle of the eleventh century onwards, first one region and then another became sufficiently peaceful for population to increase and commerce to develop.
Byzantium, Saxonia and the Kyívan Rus:
This was partly the result of the emergence of ruling dynasties in established territories like Byzantium, Saxonia and those of the Kyívan Rus. The reign of Kyívan Prince Askold, c. 860-882, was first mentioned in Byzantine sources at that time. Henry I, ‘The Fowler’, was the first of a Saxon dynasty, and his son, Otto I, grandson and great-grandson forged an empire that stretched from the Baltic to the Mediterranean. Otto I came to the throne in 936, made himself King of Italy in 951 and was crowned Holy Roman Emperor by Pope John XVI in 961.
Henry instituted strong systems of government and made clever use of ecclesiastical resources and built bishoprics and monasteries. The royal women, relatives of the reigning king, played a conspicuous role in politics during this period, sometimes acting as regents. Otto II married a Byzantine princess, Theophanu, and asserted his title of Emperor in competition to that of the Byzantines. Their son, Otto III, developed the imperial concept further before his premature death in 1002. It was left to his cousin, Henry II, to consolidate the practical governance of the kingdom, especially in Germany itself, and to forge a strong polity for his successors. Good relations were continued with the Western Frankish kingdom, as well as the newly independent Kingdom of Burgundy.
Dynastic Inter-marriage in the Xth-XIIth Centuries:
It is striking how marriage alliances in the tenth centuries created links of varying strength between the kingdoms of England, Burgundy, Germany, Bohemia, Russia, Bulgaria, and Byzantium. For example, eighteen queens, princesses and princes left Hungary to marry abroad during the reigns of the kings of the Árpád dynasty from the mid-tenth to the mid-twelfth century. A further twelve Hungarian queens were from places of origin outside Hungary, from as far west as Rheinfelden, south as Raska, east as Byzantium and north as Gniezno. This demonstrates how international many of the royal courts of Europe were in the early medieval period.
In addition, the tenth century was marked by the marauding peoples of the previous centuries, the Vikings in the north and the Magyars in the east, forming settled kingdoms themselves. In England, too, the Danelaw became almost a state within a state, as did Normandy, and in Poland the Piast rulers, especially Mieszko (963-992) extended their rule to the east, while in the south Krakow occupied a vital strategic position on the Vistula. By the second half of the tenth century, the significant expansion of the Kyívan Rus and their conversion to Christianity in 987 meant that their interests were increasingly pursued to the south and west. Later that same year, an expedition against the Bulgars on the lower Danube resulted in further, albeit temporary gains. After the Samanids succumbed to the Turks in 998, the Bulgar on the Volga also developed rapidly as trading partners, and the Volga Bulgars were supplied in turn by the Rus, who continued to trade actively with Constantinople and the Islamic regions.
Trade played a significant part in the growing importance of the Rus. The Samanid rulers of Transoxiana, the region and Persian civilization of lower central Asia, had become very rich as a result of the discovery of silver in Afghanistan. They minted vast quantities of coinage and their merchants traded across eastern Europe. There they came into contact with the Rus, who were also active traders along the Volga and as far as Constantinople.
The rapid expansion of the Kyívan Rus had much to do with trade and wealth, but cultural links also formed in the wake of these mercantile connections, which were crucially important in religious and political developments as Rus interests continued to expand westwards.
At the same time, the eastward expansion of the German empire continued apace into the eleventh century. The establishment of church centres at Magdeburg (968) and Bamberg (1007) was a fundamental component of governmental and administrative consolidation. Political relations between the princes of Poland, Bohemia, Moravia and Hungary were played out in the context of the conversion of the rulers and ruling dynasties. This was especially the case with the House of Árpád in Hungary.
The formal conversion of Volodymyr and the Rus to Greek Orthodoxy after 987, the baptism of his people in 988, and his marriage to the Byzantine princess Anna, provided the essential link for Kyív’s future development. This process came to a formal conclusion with the first legal code, Ruska Pravda, in 1015-16. But the Kyívan state was dissolved after the death of Volodymyr I as he was succeeded by sons who each ruled separate principalities based on Novgorod, Polotsk and Chernihiv, in addition to Kyív.
The Era of István and Yaroslav the Wise:
The main problem for both the Rus and the Magyars at this point was that posed by a Turkic people attacking from the east, the Pechenegs. From 1017-37, the construction of St Sophia Cathedral and the Golden Gate took place in Kyív, at its completion commemorating the victory of Yaroslav the Wise over the pagan, nomadic Pechenegs. Its golden dome could be seen from all the hills surrounding Kyív. A painting by Pál Vágó (1853-1928) depicted “Hungarians in front of Kyív” in the early eleventh century, trading with Kyívan merchants on one of these hills, under a watchtower (see frontispiece). There appears to be buying and selling of military dress and armour, church ornaments, and slaves.
There also appear to be dark-skinned Kabers among the Hungarians, originally from the Khazar Empire, serving in the army as subject auxiliaries. Among them were Muslims and Jews, as well as a small minority of Christians. A few of them were herdsmen, but the rest were unruly nomadic warriors, raiding and trading in slaves, gold and silver taken as plunder. This is probably how they came into contact with the Rus traders and also with small bands of Vikings. Warring and wandering became dual passions for them. They were fond of home in winter, of the splendidly decorated yurt and the women they were accustomed to, who raised their heirs faithfully, while enjoying the embraces of the new slave women they had gained in battle.
The Hungarian state was being formed between disintegrating eastern and reintegrating western empires. Byzantium was experiencing centuries-long decline while the western experience was one of technical developments, growth of feudal societies and new forms of weaponry and ways of waging war. But all these developments were being challenged by avaricious Arabs, both Saracens and Moors, from the south and east while Vikings continued to raid from the north. Europe reacted slowly, with minor successor states continuing to squabble over the collapsed parts of the Roman Empire.
The still half-nomadic Hungarians could no longer content themselves with rich meadows, well-stocked streams and fertile ploughlands. There had to be a clear division of labour if they were to survive in their new homelands. Their agriculturalists could not participate in raiding parties; most of these campaigns began in the spring, the time of greatest agricultural activity, and rarely ended before the harvest. The marauders therefore constituted only one fifth of the population. On both sides of the Carpathians, a leading class was emerging whose power was based on strong military retinues in addition to material wealth. These retinues never knew a time of peace.
The agriculture of hoeing and ploughing and horticulture, together with the still rather nomadic animal husbandry, were more than adequate to meet the needs of the entire population. But the leading classes’ aspirations for power and wealth required money and the large military retinues had to content themselves with their small portions from the surplus yields of their new homelands.
The Taming of the Marauders – Augsburg, 955:
From the middle of the tenth century onwards, the rulers and aspiring rulers of Europe realised that the dynamics of incursions could no longer be supported. In Central Europe, this meant a recognition that by the constant weakening of each other’s populations and economies through raiding, all the marauding Magyars were doing was ruining themselves. Militarily, they recognised that the warfare of the Hungarian light cavalrymen was easy to see through and vulnerable, that this voracious people wedged in Central Europe could be tamed by counter-attacking their dispersed forces separately, not in isolated settlements but with united forces.
Contrary to the contentions of western European chroniclers, it was not primarily the defeat inflicted by Otto I at Augsburg in 955 that staggered the Hungarians. The victors exaggerated this news because of their intoxication with the war fever at home. It was the Hungarians’ defeat at Riade in 933 that had led to Géza, István and Andrew I transforming Hungary into a civilised Western European Catholic country.
Even as the remnants of the army headed homeward from Augsburg, internal relations in the homelands were changing. The wiser leaders of the Hungarian tribal confederations had already woken up, like their adversaries, to the fact that the restless, full-bloodied Hungarians had to be settled among the peoples within the more secure borders of Christian Europe.
By the beginning of the new millennium, the Kyívan Rus had firmer frontiers, further west, with both Poland and Hungary. Also, to the west of Hungary at this time, the upper marshes along the Danube, under Hungarian control, stretched into the Vienna Basin, even beyond Vienna itself. But news about the Hungarians withdrawing to their new borders after Augsburg had filled the raid-affected regions with a strong feeling of relief, if not exactly exultation.
The Christianisation of Central Europe and Hungary:
The Baptism of the Kyívan Rus by Prince Volodomyr Sviatolslavych in 998
Across Europe, Christianisation, particularly in its western Catholic form, served to unify states. In the organisation of worldly dominion, the integrating role of ethnic groups grew. For the Hungarians, it was precisely because the House of Árpád, holding the greatest power, recognised and accepted the direction of these changes, that the country was able to put the age of raiding behind it and move into a more peaceful period in the eleventh century.
In Constantinople and Kyív, efforts were made to foster good relations with the Hungarians when Géza and István began laying the foundations of the Christian state. Géza became a Christian, but only half-heartedly, keeping many pagan customs. However, he chose Gisela, the sister of the Holy Roman Emperor and a princess of Bavaria, as a bride for his son, which was an obvious political choice, setting a Christian course for the country. She was born in Niedermunster near Regensburg and became Grand Princess of the Hungarians in 997 before being crowned as István’s Queen Consort in 1000, remaining so until he died in 1038. Throughout his reign, she was a strong supporter of his Christianisation of Hungary.
Yet the balance of power in Europe did not always benefit the pacified Hungarians as the century progressed. In the age of the marauding Magyars, those nobles who wanted to increase their power in the neighbouring regions called on the Hungarian auxilliary forces’ assistance; then a balance of power prevailed for a period in the ill-defined East European territories on the rim of the Carpathian Basin; in the middle of the eleventh century efforts to make vassals of the Christianised and settled Hungarians occurred ever more frequently.
Efforts were also made to open the western frontiers of the Hungarian territories. In 1012, St Colman took the Danube road on his pilgrimage to Palestine from Ireland and was killed by Austrian peasants mistaking him for a spy. But his decision to take the route along the Danube in itself testifies that, by the early years of the eleventh century, a new attitude was developing towards Hungary from the western Christian nations, with both pilgrims and traders being able to approach István’s crown lands without fear. Nevertheless, it was not until the time of the First Crusade in 1096 that pilgrims from the British Isles made their way across Hungary in significant numbers. By then, it was the sojourning hordes that posed the threat to regional security.
Despite the growing sense of a more settled life, many Hungarians continued to lead a semi-nomadic life. The leading classes among the Hungarians still kept their dual lodgings, changing dwelling places in winter and summer. In keeping with the custom of the people of the Steppes, they also maintained the marshlands of the Carpathian Basin as uninhabited zones of land. At the same time, the Rus created states in the core areas of the Vikings, including Aldeigjuberg (Staraya Ladoga) and Holmgard (Novgorod) in the north, in addition to Kyív.
Following the death of Volodomyr I in 1015, his sons ruled separate principalities based on Polotsk and Chernigov, including Kyív. The Kyívan principalities were reunited by Yaroslav the Wise (1019-54) who also ruled Chernihiv. According to Adam of Bremen, he had three daughters: Anna, who married Henry I of France; Anastasia (b. c. 1020), who married Andrew I of Hungary (c. 1038), and Agafija, who married the King of Norway.
Danes, Franks and Germans:
From the late ninth century, Francia was also attacked by Magyars from the east and Saracens from the south. In 987, the Capetians established a new dynasty of ‘West Francia’. At the same time, the German Empire began to emerge between the Rhine and the Danube. Emma of Normandy’s daughter by Cnut, Gunhilda, married into the German Emperor’s family.
Because of the way that the formation and survival of European states often depended on the personal authority of a single strong leader, large areas could be joined together in one lifetime. This was especially the case, in the West, with the rise of the Northern European empire of the Danes. In England, even after Alfred the Great’s settlement with the Danes in 878, the Christian faithful could not feel secure for many years, and the East Anglian diocese, for example, was not recreated until 956. Although the Anglo-Saxon and Danish populations slowly cohered into a predominantly Christian community, their troubles were far from over.
In 981, fresh Viking raids began, and a decade later, in 991, ninety-three boat-loads of Norsemen landed in Suffolk. They burned Ipswich to the ground and then marched to Maldon in Essex where they met the English in the most momentous battle of the Anglo-Saxon period, at least before 1016. Their victory at Maldon inspired the Danes to attempt the permanent occupation of England, and the Anglo-Saxons, disheartened by their defeat, made the first payments of tribute that became known as Danegeld.
The Danish king, Sweyn Forkbeard, made his initial raids in 1002-1007 and 1009-1012. Part of his motivation may at first have been revenge for the St. Brice’s Day Massacre of 1002, when the native Danish earls were massacred on the orders of King Aethelred, the ‘Unready’ or more accurately ‘ill-advised’. Another way was to get more Danegeld, since their raiding had become a royal enterprise, directed by Sweyn and his son Cnut.
Sweyn then personally led a major incursion into England in 1013. This time, it was the turn of Thetford to be ruthlessly destroyed. However, before they could ravage further, they were confronted by Earldorman Ulfcytel with the East Anglian fyrd. After a bloody battle, the Danes withdrew but returned later for a final encounter. Thorkell the Tall marched across Suffolk to meet Ulfcytel’s force near Thetford, where the English stood little chance against Thorkell’s disciplined army, though both sides suffered heavy losses in the battle. During the following months, the whole of East Anglia was devastated, so that even the invaders were unable to find food.
Demoralised and ill-led, the Anglo-Saxon armies rapidly succumbed to the invaders and Sweyn was therefore able to conquer southern England almost unopposed as the English royal family sought refuge in Normandy. Aethelred returned to England when Sweyn died at Gainsborough (Lincolnshire) in February 1014, but Sweyn’s son, Cnut was proclaimed king by the people of the Danelaw and he continued the struggle while divisions among the Anglo-Saxons handicapped their resistance. However, Aethelred succeeded in forcing Cnut out of England.
Scenes from the Chronicles – Part One: England and Hungary:
Scene One: 1014 – Offa’s Sword, Tamworth
Eadmund (Ironside) was in his twenty-first year when he met with his elder brother Aethelstan at Tamworth in June 1014. The fortified burgh was the capital of Mercia, founded by King Offa who built a royal palace, a timber and thatch construction, at the end of the eighth century. In 913, Aethelflaed, Lady of the Mercians, made Tamworth her capital and refortified the town against Viking attacks. Aethelfled led a successful military campaign against the Danes, driving them back to their stronghold at Derby, which she then captured before dying at Tamworth in June 918.
Following King Aethelstan’s death in 939, Tamworth was again plundered and devastated by Vikings. It was soon recovered and rebuilt by Aethelstan’s successors, but it never regained its pre-eminence as a Royal centre. In the early tenth century, the new shires of Warwickshire and Staffordshire were created and Tamworth was divided between them, the county boundary running down the town centre streets. In Eadmund’s day, there was a burgh, a Saxon fort there.
Eadmund was born in about 993, the youngest son of Aethelred the Unready and his first wife, Aelgifu of York. Aethelstan, his brother, was mortally wounded in battle against the Danes in June 1014, making Eadmund heir apparent. By 1016, he and his wife Ealdgyth had two children, Eadmund the Aetheling and Edward the Exile.
There were other key contributors to the chaos which had developed under Aethelred’s rule. Eadric Streona, ‘The Grabber’ was Aethelred’s chief ‘bad counsellor’ who had risen to a position of power by 1008 by having his rivals dispossessed, mutilated or murdered. As a result, the English aristocracy was riven by feuds, unable to act as a counter-balance to Eadric in advising the King, so that he remained ‘ill-advised’ and therefore ‘unready’ to resist a full-scale invasion from Denmark.
England was then conquered by Sweyn Forkbeard, the last pagan King of Denmark (986-1014) and King of Norway from 999. Sweyn briefly ruled England after Aethelred was driven into exile. He became King of the English in 1013, but died in February 1014 at his base in Gainsborough (Lincolnshire).
Cnut was then proclaimed King of England by people of the Danelaw, but Aethelred returned from exile. Eadmund, who remained at Tamworth, rebelled against his father, whom he felt was not willing to fight hard enough to drive out Sweyn’s son, Cnut. Eadmund succeeded in this, but Cnut returned to Denmark only to assemble another invasion force with which to reconquer England.
So, Eadmund was not expected to become King, but by June 1014 his two elder brothers had died, making him heir apparent. Aethelstan, Aethelred’s eldest son, and heir, was mortally wounded at Thetford, where the second son had fallen in the battle. Before he died at the beginning of June, Aethelstan gave his brother the ‘bloodied sword’ which had belonged to Offa, King of Mercia, and urged him to continue the struggle against the invading Danes.
Offa had famously fought his way to power in the eighth century with his ‘bloodied sword’. His brother’s implication was obvious: Edward must continue to resist Cnut’s attempted usurpation with every last drop of his blood. Aethelstan and Eadmund had a close relationship; they probably felt threatened by Emma’s ambitions for her two sons by Aethelred, Edward and Alfred, fearing that they might be passed over in their favour as his successors. But there was no immediate danger of this, since both boys were safe in Normandy, and were unlikely to be brought back to England by their parents until at least the fighting was finished.
Still grieving for Aethelstan, Eadmund divided his time between the court at Westminster, Tamworth and Worcester, where he paid clandestine visits to a lady of noble birth, Ealdgyth, who was, however, already married.
Scene Two: 1016, Worcester
Ealdred was Bishop of Worcester until 1060, when he became Archbishop of York. The Chronicles he wrote became the basis for the relation of events by the monk, Florence of Worcester, up to 1117.
Despite their eighteen-month campaign together against the Danes during which Eadmund had managed to keep his father away from London and the influence of Eadric Streona, the distrust between Eadmund and Aethelred grew when, early in 1016, the King failed to appear at the muster of the fyrds at Worcester. Eadmund suspected an act of treachery or, worse still, sabotage by Streona, but he could prove nothing. The army was again leaderless, and dispersed in anger and confusion. Eadmund returned to Tamworth to raise his own army, travelling with care via London to collect levies.
Earl Uhtred of Northumbria, meanwhile, took his independent action against Eadric of Mercia, ravaging his Mercian territories. Clearly, Eadmund thought, Uhtred had his own spies at court who were aware of Streona’s latest trickery. Eadmund was Eadric’s brother-in-law, and therefore had to act circumspectly where the Earl was concerned, but he did nothing to stop Uhtred. When Cnut occupied Northumbria, however, Uhtred submitted to him and Cnut, true to his reputation, promptly had the Earl dispatched by an axe.
The native Danes’ powerbase was among the nobles of the East Midlands, especially in the ‘Five Boroughs’ in the Danelaw. The nobles there were angered by the killing of Uhtred, whom they had viewed as one of their own, given his mixed Saxon and Danish heritage.
So Eadmund took advantage of both this mood among the thegns, and Cnut’s distraction in the North, by appealing to them for support against the invaders in the raising of an Anglo-Danish army which would muster at Tamworth, a short journey from the boroughs. The response was better than Eadmund had expected, with the people of the five boroughs submitting to him. With this change in fortunes and forces, some of Cnut’s Anglo-Danish supporters lost by Aethelred’s weak leadership, including Earl Eadric of Mercia, changed their allegiance to Eadmund.
With Eadric Streona now apparently on his side, people who had sided with the Danes were punished, and some were killed. Two brothers, Morcar and Sigeferth were among them, and Aethelred had Sigeferth’s widow, Ealdgyth, imprisoned at Malmesbury. She had already attracted the close attentions of Eadmund and without his father’s permission, in the late summer of 1015, he took Ealdgyth from the priory at Malmesbury and, with the aid of a local monk, married her: She was a member of one of the strongest families in the Midlands, so Aethelred was unlikely to object. Neither did he. In the early Spring of 1016 she gave birth to twins, Eadmund (the eldest) and Edward. Ironside was energised by these births, which eased his nervousness about the succession, while also adding to his sense of responsibility for his family and the country when his father died.
That event was not long in coming. On 23rd April, Aethelred collapsed suddenly while defending London with Eadmund, and died. He was buried hurriedly, but with the honour befitting a king of England, within the city walls at Old St Paul’s. Suddenly succeeding to the throne, Eadmund wasted no time in setting up his military base and family home nearby.
Eadmund’s first campaign as king was therefore directed at restoring the kingdom’s allegiance to its old Anglo-Saxon dynasty, the House of Wessex. After the failure of his siege of London, Cnut followed Eadmund westwards into Wessex, and indecisive battles were fought at Penselwood in Dorset and Sherston in Wiltshire. Turning to the offensive, Eadmund then relieved London, parried a Danish raid into Mercia and drove Cnut onto the Isle of Sheppey, winning three out of his first five battles, without losing one. These battles, or rather skirmishes, were why he became known by the epithet ‘Ironside’, though it may also have had something to do with the symbolism of Offa’s sword, which was used at his coronation at Westminster. Certainly, he was fighting with renewed self-confidence, inspired by the birth of his two sons.
Scene Three – October 1016, Ashingdon, Essex:
However, though he had won a series of battles, Eadmund ultimately lost the war between himself and Cnut, which ended in victory for Cnut at the Battle of Assandun (Ashingdon) on 18th October.
Embarking on another raid, Cnut sailed from Sheppey and anchored in the River Crouch near Burnham in Essex. Eadmund moved to raise levies who could prevent the Danes, now loaded down with booty, from returning to their ships. In the words of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle,
… hepursued them and overtook them from Essex at the hill which is called Ashingdown, and they stoutly joined battle there.
Eadmund had mustered a large army there with contingents from Wessex, East Anglia and Mercia, and although his ill-trained levies could not match the Danes man for man, his superiority in numbers offered the chance of a decisive victory.
As Eadmund’s army made camp at Ashingdon Hill on the evening of 17th October, the enemy was in full view just over a mile and a half away. Cnut had little choice but to fight. To avoid battle and escape by land he would have had to abandon both the spoils of his latest raid and his fleet. With an undefeated enemy so close at hand, it would have been foolhardy to have attempted embarkation when his army would be hard put to defend itself.
Instead, he assembled his force on a hill at Canewdon which stood between Eadmund and the Danish fleet, where a low ridge connected the hill from which the armies faced each other. At the Danish end of the ridge, a slight rise of about a thousand yards in front of Canewdon offered Cnut the opportunity to advance without losing the advantage of higher ground.
Eadmund deployed his army in three divisions: the Wessex contingent under his command, the Mercians under Eadric Streona, and the East Anglians led by Ulfcytel. Eadric, now in favour once again, was stationed on the right flank, with Eadmund in the centre and Ulfcytel on the left. Eadmund began the battle by charging up the hill at Ashingdon towards the Danes. The English left, due to the nature of the ground, advanced far more quickly than the right and a rapidly increasing gap opened between the flanks.
As Edmund and Ulfcytel clashed with the Danish line, at least a third of the English strength remained uncommitted, for Eadric had halted his division well to the rear, already planning another act of treachery. The Danish left, finding no troops to their front, turned inwards to envelop the unprotected English, who nevertheless continued the unequal struggle until late in the afternoon when Eadmund was eventually able to escape with the survivors of his army.
But the English were defeated and Ulfcytel, the majority of Eadmund’s troops and a large proportion of the English nobility were killed. Eadmund retreated to Deerhurst on the Severn where shortly after the battle he and Cnut met to agree on the partition of England along the old boundary of the Danelaw. Despite his victory in battle, Cnut recognised that Eadmund had already earned a reputation as a skilful and courageous military leader, worthy of continuing to rule the Kingdom of Wessex. There is an early thirteenth century depiction of the two men (shown below) in the manuscript Historia Major by Matthew Paris, fighting a duel on horseback at Deerhurst.
So, the kingdom was divided in two between the two men, but Eadmund died ‘of his wounds’ in November, though there were many suspicions and rumours about the ultimate cause of his death. Again, Eadric Streona’s whereabouts and motivations would bear investigation, were there enough surviving evidence. From there, Eadmund retired to Winchester, while Cnut occupied London.
Adam of Bremen, the trusted European chronicler, wrote, shortly after the Norman Conquest, that Eadmund had been poisoned, and some twelfth century folklore writers stated that he was stabbed or shot with a crossbow while sitting in his garderobe. Whether and how Eadric and/or his men gained access to Eadmund’s private quarters is a matter of speculation, but John of Worcester also recorded that Eadric later advised Cnut to send Eadmund’s sons out of the country, to Scandinavia, to be put out of the way, i.e. murdered, so he may well have harboured similar intentions towards Eadmund himself.
In any event, Cnut took over the Kingdom of Wessex, and with it control of the whole Kingdom of England, which he annexed to his Scandinavian empire, though he agreed to rule England as a Christian king.
Four – Winchester Minster, 1017:
Aethelred’s death had enabled his queen, Emma, to marry Cnut. However, he also kept his first wife, Aelgifu of Northampton, who was kept in the south with an estate in Exeter, in conflict with Church teaching. He was later (1031) depicted in Christian iconography with Aelgifu presenting a cross to the new Minster at Winchester (pictured above). Cnut became conciliatory towards his conquered subjects, publicly paying tribute to Eadmund Ironside during a visit to his tomb at Glastonbury. He was himself laid to rest at Winchester.
To begin with, Cnut rewarded his Scandinavian supporters with ‘earldoms’, a Danish term, but one which came increasingly to depend on the Saxon noblemen, or thegns, at court. The political inheritance for Cnut and his successors was a kingdom dominated by two earls, Godwin of Wessex and Leofric of Mercia.
Eadmund Ironside’s death had left behind his Queen, Ealdgyth and two sons. At first, Cnut had confirmed Eadric Streona as the entitled Earl of Mercia, and he urged Cnut to have the heirs of Wessex put out of the way. John of Worcester recorded that, more specifically, he told Cnut…
… to kill the little aethelings, Edward and Eadmund, sons of King Eadmund.
But Cnut had ‘no desire’ to sully his name with the blood of children. They were only a few months old. John of Worcester continued…
… but because it would seem as a great disgrace to him if they perished in England, when a short time had passed, he sent them to the King of Sweden to be killed.
So Cnut dispatched the boys to Sweden, to King Olaf Sköttkonung, apparently with a written instruction that the boys should meet their end there. Gaimar blamed Emma for the princes’ exile, claiming that she urged Cnut to send the infants away because they were the true heirs and their presence in England might therefore cause unrest. Emma claimed that they were a threat to Cnut, but in reality she was simply concerned to secure the succession of her children by Aethelred.
According to Gaimar, the two princes were immediately sent abroad on the advice of their widowed mother, Queen Ealdgyth. But this must have been done with the full knowledge of both Cnut and Eadric Streona, who continued in his role as chief counsellor to the king. On Ealdgyth’s instructions, they were taken, instead, to a powerful thane in Denmark called Walgar (Valgarus), a housecarl or warrior, who had known the King of Hungary for some time.
Five – 1017, Gamla Stan to Gardimbre; Escape to Denmark, Sweden and Kyív:
Walgar was charged with protecting the boys, so he escorted the infants to the court of the devout Christian king of Sweden, whose capital was at Gamla Stan (‘The Old Town’ in Swedish), newly founded by Olaf, which was both a secure citadel on an island, situated on an inlet of Lake Malaren, an important trading centre near the Baltic. According to Gaimar’s account, Olaf was revolted by Cnut’s intended infanticide. Besides, the royal grandfather of the boys, Aethelred, had been Olaf’s close friend and ally. John recorded:
He, although there was a treaty between them, would in no wise comply with these entreaties, but sent them to the king of Hungary …to be reared and kept alive.
Fearing that Cnut would send assassins to the Swedish court, especially since he was already seizing neighbouring parts of Sweden in 1017-18, Walgar followed the Swedish king’s advice, taking them to the border lands between the Rus, Poland and the Hungarian crown lands. They then travelled for five days until they reached the city of Gardimbre (Gardariki was the term used for the lands of the Kyívan Rus) where they were met by King István and Queen Gizela. Yaroslav the Wise (Iaroslav Mudri) was the Grand Prince of Kyív from 1016 to 1018 and then again from 1019 to his death in 1054. The two monarchs were obviously on good terms at this time.
A divided succession had, at first, characterised the Kyívan principalities and territories in the east. But, in 1019, they had been reunited under Yaroslav in a period of political expansion and influence for Kyív as well as one of intensive cultural interaction.
Six – 1018; Royal Refuge at Esztergom, Hungary:
István and Gizela took the princes on to their court at Esztergom, where they were raised in relative safety by the royal couple for the next ten years. We know that the Hungarian king and queen received them cordially and educated them with deep affection. Towards the end of this period, Eadmund died, but his brother survived and Gizela made him her protégé, preparing him for the time when he might return to England to claim its crown following Cnut’s death.
In England, meanwhile, Cnut had had Streona executed in his purge of 1017, and Leofric became Earl of Mercia, the second most powerful man in the Kingdom. He was succeeded by his son, Aelfgar, whose son, Eadwine, became the last Earl, after the Norman invasion. By the 1020s, the Godwins had gained almost total control over southern England, south of the Thames. Cnut therefore took over a well-formed and fully operational kingdom of England in 1017 and made it the centre of his North Sea empire by extending his rule first over Denmark itself (following the death of his elder brother in 1018), then over Norway, after the expulsion of Olaf Haraldsson in 1028.
Seven – Gardoriki (lands of the Kyívan Rus) – 1028:
King Olaf fled to Sweden and laterly, to Kyív, as Cnut also seized more parts of Sweden, perhaps partly in revenge for the Swedish King’s decision to send the princes to Hungary. It may be that the Wessex prince or princes (depending on when Eadmund died) were removed to Kyív following Olaf’s flight there in 1028, when the boys reached the age of twelve, an age when they could inherit and marry. István again sent the prince(s) to Gadoriki, the lands of the royal court of the Kyívan ‘Rus’, where they could be protected and continue their education with Yaroslav the Wise, while Cnut was now ruling most of Scandinavia. The Grand Duke’s wife, Ingegard, became their guardian in this period while they were living in Hungarian ‘crown lands’ on the Carpathian frontier, perhaps in Zemplén county.
At that time there was no clear border between the Kyívan Rus and Hungarian sub-Carpathia, and the region where the national territories touched was not so well-defined as to exclude the possibility of both contemporary and more recent chroniclers confusing their physical and political data. The daughter of Yaroslav, born in about 1020, later became Andrew’s wife after he fled to Kyiv in 1038 with his brother, Levente, having been sent there to escape from the reprisals against their father’s supporters. Eadmund had died by this point (we hear nothing of him except that he died young), but Edward married Agatha, a relative of the German Emperor and Gizela’s close companion and confidant.
Eight – c. 1030; Zemplén, Esztergom and Pilismárot:
The Magyars and other raiders were also in the slave trade, especially along the Danube and the Black Sea coast, and up the Dnieper to Kyiv and beyond. Alternatively, the route northwards through Zemplén County may have been the way followed by raiders and traders on horseback. The Principality of Hungary had metamorphosed into a Christian kingdom upon the coronation of the first king, István (Stephen) I at Esztergom around the turn of the millennium.
Zemplén county was founded as a county of the Kingdom of Hungary in the eleventh century. It shared borders with Poland (Krakow), Galicia, and the Hungarian counties; Sáros, Abaúj-Torna, Borsod, Szabolcs and Ung. The rivers Laborc and Bodrog flowed through the county, tributaries of the Tisza. This may well have been the area in which Edward the Aetheling was hidden away from Cnut’s spies and assassins, most likely at the Zemplín Castle (Zempléni vár), the county capital from the eleventh century.
Istvan’s wife, Gizela (b. c. 985, m. 996), a daughter of Henry Duke of Burgundy and a German imperial princess, was a pawn in a complex diplomatic game, but one which played an important role in stabilising Hungary’s position in Europe. István had fought against his pagan brother, Koppány, with Bavarian help in the form of German knights. In return, the Catholic Church received powerful support from Stephen through the creation of a strong Catholic kingdom in central Europe.
Esztergom was the royal capital of the Árpád dynasty, which served not only as the royal residence but also as the centre of the Hungarian state, religion and economy. István himself had been born at Esztergom, which enjoyed a privileged position among the royal residences, and played a central role in military and agricultural affairs, taxation and the minting of coins. The city had primacy among royal cities, with its central role in economic and military affairs. The various tithes and taxes gathered by the county governor had to be handed over there every year.
In the place of the Basilica stood the private chapel of Prince Géza, István’s father. Géza had married Sarolta there; she had already converted to Byzantine Christianity. Géza had also erected a protective castle on the hill. The city remained an important centre for the Árpád dynasty from the founding of the Hungarian state to the thirteenth century.
The Castle was joined to the royal residence at the top of the hill and the archbishop’s palace. The population of the settlement, called Viziváros, protected by its great walls, was ethnically mixed. There were Latin peoples from Italy, German and Jewish traders, craftsmen and minstrels, as well as male and female court servants. It may also have been at this point that Andrew’s pagan marriage to a woman from Pilismárot, a village along the Danube Bend from Esztergom, took place.
It may have been that she had been sold into chattel slavery when he first met her, from which she would have been released on marrying the prince. This form of slavery was still widespread throughout Europe in the early decades of the eleventh century, especially since the Vikings were the foremost slave-traders both in Cnut’s empire and along the Vistula to Krakow and the Kyívan lands. It was still prevalent in the crown lands of István in the early decades of the eleventh century, despite the Christianisation of Hungary. This may help to explain why Andrew was so determined to stamp out paganism during his reign.
Nine – 1032, St Edmundsbury (Bury St Edmund’s); Cnut’s Empire and Anglo–Danish Kingdom:
The years 1028-31 formed the high-tide mark of the Viking achievement and of Danish migrant integration into the British Isles and Scandinavia. Cnut always regarded England as the most important part of his empire. He maintained Anglo-Saxon laws and preserved the power of local Saxon thegns as well as giving it to Danish earls. Since it was necessary for him to leave England for long periods, he divided the kingdom into four ‘earldoms’ based on the old kingdoms of East Anglia, Wessex, Mercia and Northumbria.
Unfortunately, however, this revived the old jealousies and rivalries of the Anglo-Saxon age. Such divisions weakened the country and made it easy prey to enemies once Cnut’s strong arm was withdrawn. It was during the troubled times of the Danish occupation that feudal society developed in England, as it had done in Europe in the wake of the Norse attacks on the Carolingian empire in the previous century.
Towards the end of his reign, Cnut had gained a reputation as a wise king who knew that if he wished the English to settle in peace under his rule, he must respect their feelings. According to one recent historian,
… one of the ways in which he demonstrated a new, loving regard for his subjects was in the lavish generosity he bestowed upon the shrine of St Edmund…
The saint’s remains were restored to the town now known as St Edmund’s Burgh (St Edmundsbury), and the King now contributed liberally to the building of a new church. More than that, he founded a new community of Benedictine monks to guard the shrine. In 1032, the new church was consecrated and Cnut himself came and made demonstrative reparation for the sins of his father. He offered his crown on the altar and received it back in token that his rule had the blessing and support of the saint. He also bestowed money and lands on the abbey, making it the richest in England, and giving it jurisdiction over virtually the whole of western Suffolk. By the time of Domesday, the abbey owned extensive estates in six counties.
When Cnut died in 1035, Harthacnut inherited his kingdoms, but as he ruled from Denmark, his half-brother, Harold ‘Harefoot’ was nominated as Regent in England, despite opposition from both Emma and Godwin, Earl of Wessex. Emma was still exiled with her sons, when Harefoot became Regent. Godwin seized control of Alfred while he was en route to visit Emma at Winchester, then placing him at the mercy of Harold Harefoot in London: the Regent’s followers blinded Alfred with a savagery which caused his death. In the words of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle,
… no more horrible deed was done in this land since the Danes came.
Alfred was abandoned by the Regent’s men at Ely, where he was found by the monks wandering blind in the marshes. He was taken into the abbey where he died shortly afterwards. The betrayal of him by Godwin permanently embittered relations between the Godwinsons and Alfred’s brother, even after he became King Edward the Confessor.
When Harold Harefoot died in 1040 and was briefly succeeded by Harthacnut, Emma returned to England with Edward, and when Harthacnut died standing at his drink in 1042, the Witan invited Edward to become king. The powerful group of Anglo-Danish earls, led by Godwin and Leofric, saw to it that Edward was recalled to England in the closing months of Harthacnut’s reign. This was taken to indicate a desire to return to the Alfredian line of kings, since not only was Edward the son of Aethelred II, of the royal house of Cerdic, but (through his mother Emma) he was descended from Rollo, the founder of Normandy. That made him acceptable to the formidable Anglo-Danish warrior-statesmen at court.
For the quarter century before Edward becoming king, England was no longer at the edge of the world, but part of Cnut’s North Sea Empire. His English kingdom was dominated by the two rival earls, Godwin of Wessex, representing the new nobles of the Anglo-Danish régime, and Leofric of Mercia, representing the entrenched political interests north of the Thames. The Anglo-Saxons sat at the edge of a period of violent confrontation and forced engagement with the rest of Europe.
In the 1030s, Anglo-Danish society was also more divided between ‘freemen’ and bonded peasants or ‘serfs’ than English society had been before Cnut’s conquest. Freemen gave up their land to the powerful thegns, or earls (yarls) as they were now known, in return for protection. The earls restored the land but demanded labour services in exchange.
Ten – c. 1035-1038, Kyív – Exiles at Yaroslav’s Court:
Georgius (György), the ‘illegitimate’ son of Andrew, was probably born sometime in the mid-1030s, to the woman from Pilsmarót. By then, Georgius’s mother may have been a servant in the royal residence who married Andrew and went with him to Kyív, where she became a lady-in-waiting to Anastasia, Yaroslav’s daughter. The marriage was probably made under pagan rites and was subsequently ‘put aside’ when Andrew became a Christian and married Anastasia. Georgius later became a Kyívan Rus noble and protector to Edward and his family, fighting alongside him in Hungary and accompanying the Wessex family on their journeys to England and Scotland.
Andrew and his brothers were the sons of Vazúl, Stephen’s half-brother, whom the King had blinded for treachery, and his concubine from the Tátony clan. According to the historian Gyula Kristó, Andrew was the second among Vazul’s three sons. He also wrote that Andrew was born around 1015. Vazul was blinded during the reign of his cousin. The king ordered Vazul’s mutilation after the death, in 1031, of Emeric (Imre), his only son surviving infancy. The contemporary author of the Annals of Altaich wrote that the king himself ordered the mutilation in an attempt to ensure a peaceful succession to his own sister’s son, Peter Orseolo.
According to the Hungarian chronicles, King Stephen wanted to save the young princes’ lives from their enemies in the royal court and counselled them with all speed to depart from Hungary. After enduring many hardships, Andrew and Levente established themselves in the court of Yaroslav the Wise, Grand Prince of Kyív (1019–1054) in the late 1030s. This must also have been the about time when Eadmund and Edward arrived at court with Georgius and his mother, travelling from Pilismarót via Zemplén. The grand prince gave his daughter Anastasia in marriage to Andrew (probably in c. 1038). Kristó writes that Andrew, who had up to that time remained pagan, was also baptized on this occasion. It was at this time that Andrew, Georgius and Edward, all by this time in their mid-twenties, fought against the pagan Pechenegs with Yaroslav before returning to Hungary in 1046.
Harald Sigurdsson, (also born c. 1015), half-brother of King Olaf II of Norway, spent several years at the court of King Yaroslav, after fleeing from Norway while still in his teens in the 1030s. He would likely, therefore, have also been a fellow exile of Edward the Exile and Andrew of Hungary. He then travelled to Byzantium, rendering service to successive emperors from Constantinople to Sicily and Bulgaria, before returning to Norway in the mid-1040s, where he earned the epithet ‘Hardrada’ (hard ruler), by ruling with a rod of iron.
Eleven – 1038-46, Fehérvár/ Réka:
Andrew (András) had been born about the same year as Edward, 1015-16, and Edward may have fought with him against the Pechenegs. At some point in the 1030s, they were brought together in Kyív by Andrew and Levente’s exile, as sons of Vazúl. István died in 1038, and András and Levente returned to Hungary in 1046 at the invitation of the Hungarian nobles. Edward had probably returned to the royal court and married Agatha before István died in 1038, when the king was considering naming him as his heir, and, according to the Hungarian sources, he settled down with Agatha on the estates granted to them by István before his death, at Mecseknádásd in the southern county of Baranya.
This was in the Mecsek hills close to the cathedral city of Pécs, an area which became known as the terra Britannorum. It was probably considered remote enough within Hungary from Esztergom to provide a safe home for Edward and Agatha to raise a family, out of the reach of Cnut’s Danish successors before the Exile’s uncle, Edward the Confessor, returned the House of Wessex to the throne in 1042. Due to his kinship with the new English king, in 1043, Edward (the Exile) was elevated…
… to a position of sole responsibility where England’s crown or domestic alliances were concerned…
This shows that Edward was likely to have been in contact with the Confessor’s court long before Bishop Ealred’s visit some twelve years later. Margaret is said to have been born at Réka Castle, near the village of Mecseknádásd in 1045/6, and her sister Krisztina was probably also born there, but Eadgar may have been born (c 1051) at the Royal Court in Szekesfehérvár, to which the Royal couple returned in 1046, to aid Andrew I in gaining control of Hungary and in consolidating the Catholic Church. Edward is likely to have accompanied him on his journey from Kyív to Székesfehérvár, together with Georgius. He also fought with Andrew’s army against the pagan rebels.
Szekesfehérvár, or simply Fehérvár, was the white city in central Hungary, which Andrew and Anastasia made their home in 1046, so much so that one of Andrew’s epithets was fehér (‘the white’). It was founded by Grand Prince Géza in 972 as the original royal residence and capital of Hungary under the rule of the Árpád dynasty, and it still held a central role in the Middle Ages, with significant trade routes to the Balkans and Italy, as well as to Buda and Vienna. It was also connected by a military road to the east. In addition, it was an important place of sojourn for pilgrims en route to the Holy Land.
For many people across Central-Eastern Europe, the colour white had a mystical association with both power and purity. Linguists point out that many capital cities contain the word white, without any topographical or geological reason. For instance, the ancient name of Belgrade was Castro Blanca, or Nandorfehérvár in Hungarian. Ethnographers say that migrating peoples from the east identified the colour with cleanliness, holiness, luxury and power. The migrating Magyar tribes were said to have sacrificed a white horse on entering the Carpathian Basin. So the association of white with the Hungarian royal city is obvious in its name, Fehérvár; The White Burgh.
Its location in the Dunántul (west of the Danube), surrounded by marsh land with limestone ruins of Roman buildings, had been chosen as a location for the princely residence they decided to call the Feherű Vár. This name survives from Latin charters of the early eleventh century. It can also be found on the chasuble prepared for the Fehérvár basilica and on the coronation mantle. In addition, it is mentioned in the Deed of Foundation of Tihány Abbey of 1055, the earliest surviving relic in the Hungarian language.
The Latin name of the residence in Latin was Alba Regio, When King Orseolo of Venice put the coronation city at the disposal of the Holy Roman Emperor, Frederick II, in 1045, the German garrison named it Stulweissenburg. The royal palace was situated on dry land surrounded and protected by immense marshlands. Water from the Sárvíz and Gaja rivers created a system of lakes which guarded the four hilly islands.
The environment resembled the Etelköz, the legendary land between the Dniester and the Dnieper, inhabited by the Hungarians before they were forced to migrate further westward. The Royal Palace was also at a crossroads of trade and military routes. Prince Géza built a fortified dwelling place at this crossroads, and a quadripartite church. He protected the city with a ring of smaller settlements and settled the fearsome Pechenegs to help protect the territory on the sandier side of the Sárvíz river.
The castle was already standing by the time István and Gizela were crowned at the turn of the millennium. In the first half of the eleventh century, it was surrounded by a stone wall. During the period of the Árpád dynasty, there were five altars (side chapels) in the church. The classification of the dynastic family and state church differed from the other early episcopal churches in that the Bishop of Székesfehérvár was not subordinate to the authority of the Archbishop of Esztergom. Above all, he performed the state ceremonial duties and was the custodian of the crown, the orb, the double cross, István’s cross, the sword and the rest of the royal regalia.
The consecration of the royal basilica did not take place with the death of István, but seven years later at the funeral of his son and heir, Prince Imre. As its founder, István was buried in a stone coffin in the nave. The city’s outer settlements were strengthened in the twelfth century, when settlers from Northern France, perhaps Normans, settled in the virtually uninhabited area.
Twelve, 1045-6 – Gizela’s Black Cross and Abaújvár:
The German Emperor Henry II was King István’s brother-in-law, being brother to Gisela, Princess of Bavaria and István’s Queen Consort. Her retinue of knights and priests had helped István to establish Hungary as a strong, Catholic state and to defend it against his power-hungry pagan relatives, the Pechenegs, before he died in 1038. Gizela had a young Bavarian noblewoman as her trusted companion and confidante, Agatha, possibly her niece, the daughter of Bruno, Bishop of Augsburg. Edward met and married Agatha following his return from Kyív in 1038. After István’s funeral, the couple left the Hungarian Court for the lands in southern Hungary (Baranya) given to them on their marriage by the King. This formed the basis of the statement in English records that the exiled prince exercised power and patronage over his Hungarian tenants.
Gisela’s mother was the wife of Henry of Burgundy and sister of the Holy Roman Emperor, Henry II, who was also Agatha’s uncle. She died in 1007 and her daughter donated a black burial cross, called the Giselakreuz, which she had made for her mother’s grave. On the cross, at Jesus’ feet, are two kneeling figures. One is Gisela herself and the other is her mother, who was also named Gisela, dressed in a nun’s habit. The cross bears a strong resemblance to the description of the one that Queen Gizela gave to Agatha when she left Hungary for Passau in 1045. Gisela lived out the rest of her life in the nearby nunnery of Niedernburg, where she died in 1063, aged about seventy.
A section of Gisela’s cross showing her and her mother at Jesus’ feet, the inscription to ‘Gisila’ and the precious black stones below.
The crosses were made of gold, but set with dark stones. Such stones were rare in Europe at that time, and reminiscent of the imperial grandeur of the Carolingian Emperors, who popularised their use. So it is probable that Gisella’s cross had its origins in Bavaria. Agatha bore three children with Edward: Margaret (born c. 1045/6), Christina and Eadgar (b. 1051). Their first two children were born at Réka Castle, near Mecseknádásd, and spent their early childhood there before returning to court at Szekesfehérvár, sometime before the birth of her brother there.
Having become an Orthodox Christian in Kyív in c. 1038, to marry Anastasia, András returned from exile in Kyív to Szekesfehérvár and became a devout Catholic, giving him his other epithet, the Catholic. After István’s immediate successor, son of his sister and the Doge of Venice, Peter Orseolo (1038-41 and 1044-46), had traded Hungary’s independence for the German Emperor’s help in restoring him to the throne, the feudal lords of Hungary had turned to András and his brother Levente, in exile in Kyív, to re-establish order.
In 1046, the dukes agreed to send envoys to András and Levente in Kyív to persuade them to return to Hungary. Fearing some treacherous ambush, the two brothers only set out after their agents in Hungary, including Georgius and Edward, confirmed that the Hungarians were ripe for an uprising against Peter. In 1041, the opposition to him had ejected Peter and made Samuel Aba king. By the time the two brothers decided to return, after a further five years, a further revolt had broken out in Hungary, which Aba could only put down by mercilessly murdering fifty lords. Peter returned to reclaim the throne with the help of Henry III, the Holy Roman Emperor, ruling for a further two years. But the territories neighbouring Hungary were dominated by pagans who captured many clergymen and mercilessly slaughtered them. They wanted to make vassals of the Christianised and settled Hungarians.
Andrew met the pagans at Abaújvár, near the current Slovak border in Northeast Hungary. The castle there was the main place of residence for the Aba family, the second most important royal house of Hungary and one of the most important Hungarian families of the time. The first known written record on Abaújvár dates back to the events of 1046, but presumably an earth castle stood there much earlier; the new stone castle was built by Samuel Aba before he became, briefly, King of Hungary. An Illuminated Chronicle narrated, perhaps with some bias, how the pagans urged the dukes…
… to allow the whole people to live according to the rites of the pagans, to kill the bishops and the clergy, to destroy the churches, to throw off the Christian faith and to worship idols.
Samuel Aba fell in one of the battles for the throne, perhaps killed by a treacherous assassin, but András caught Peter attempting to flee the country, deposed him and had him blinded. Aided by Edward and others from his Kyívan retinue, András then put down the pagan rebellion and he and the descendants of Vazúl were restored to the throne, ruling Christian Hungary for a quarter of a millennium.
Thirteen; 1051-1054 – Westminster; the struggle to succeed King Edward:
Meanwhile, in England, the childless Edward the Confessor, educated in Normandy and a Francophone, revealed his wish to be succeeded by his mother’s great-nephew when the latter visited Edward’s court in 1051. Edward had spent most of his boyhood among priests while in exile in Normandy, and was more fitted to being a monk than a monarch.
Nevertheless, Edward did become king and began a largely peaceful reign which lasted for nearly twenty-five years, despite the continual threat of a Scandinavian invasion and the internecine power struggle between the earldoms of England, which had become the power bases of the rival dynasties of the Godwin of Wessex, Siward of Northumbria and Aelfgar of Mercia.
In 1053, Earl Godwin and his sons, Leofwine and Harold, launched an incursion into England, which King Edward was powerless to resist. As a result, royal authority was undermined, the Norman connection was temporarily severed and the House of Godwin was restored in an almost unassailable position. But the other Anglo-Danish earls, jealous of the power of the Godwin family, refused to make a united front with them against the Normans. Nevertheless, according to the pro-Godwin Life of King Edward, written in 1065-70, the Godwins’ return to London was greeted with deep joy both at court and within the whole country.
The Godwins then became so powerful that Edward began to look for alternative heirs as ‘compromise candidates’ to both Harold Godwinson, who was about thirty in 1053, and William of Normandy. In the same year, Earl Godwin died suddenly of a seizure at Court. He had emerged as the most powerful earl and his authority was such that even his exile in 1051-52, and the King’s hostility could do little to diminish it. As king, he paid little attention to affairs of state and devoted himself instead to prayer and worship and the concerns of the Church.
But Edward could not afford to ignore the matter of the succession, especially as he was childless. Educated in Normandy and a Francophile, he preferred to be succeeded by his mother’s great-nephew whom he had got to know well during his time in Normandy. But he also knew that William’s claim to be England’s king was dubious even in contemporary terms. Certainly, William’s great aunt Emma had been the wife of King Aethelred, and Edward himself had given William a more recent claim by naming him as his successor during William’s visit to the English Court in 1051, albeit privately. But, a direct claim through the male line was much stronger for his courtiers and his country.
However, as yet apparently unknown to (most of) the Court, there was a claimant with a direct male bloodline to the throne; Edward Aetheling, son of Ironside and grandson of Aethelred, who was in exile at the court of András I, the King of Hungary. By 1054, opposition to William’s succession was formidable, especially from the anti-Norman faction at court, led by the Earldom of Wessex, which Harold himself now led. At this point, too, rumours began to spread, from the continent, of the survival of the direct line of the Wessex royal family in Hungary. They soon reached Edward’s ears and those of that faction at the English court that wanted neither William nor Harold to succeed to the throne. These courtiers began to show an interest in the exiled Prince Edward of Wessex as an alternative heir to the English throne.
Fourteen; 1053-58 – Köln, Tihany and Tiszavárkony:
Ealdred, Bishop of Worcester was the leader of this faction, the partisans of Wessex, and he was now commissioned by the Confessor to locate the Exile and his family and to invite them to return to England to meet his uncle. Ealdred also had his mission, to become the first English churchman to travel on pilgrimage through Hungary to the Holy Land. He was to deliver a letter to the Hungarian court, requesting the return of the Wessex family, before progressing on his pilgrimage. In the event, four years after leaving England, he finally arrived in Jerusalem in 1058.
But the first part of his mission was to deliver a letter to the imperial court of Henry III at Cologne, requesting his help in locating the prince and requesting that he negotiate with the king of Hungary, András I, for his return. Meanwhile, the German emperor had delayed his response to Edward’s request and kept Ealdred waiting for more than a year. Dealing with widespread unrest in his German empire, Henry III then fell ill and died while suppressing a Slav uprising in northeast Germany in October 1056, aged just forty. He was succeeded by his son, Henry IV, who was only six when he came to the German throne. In these circumstances, it’s perhaps not surprising that the imperial officers could not help the English king in his search for the lost English prince.
At Székesfehérvár, meanwhile, Anastasia of Kyív had given birth to two sons, Salomon (‘Solomon’) (1053) and Dávid (c. 1055). Margaret, then aged ten or eleven, helped to care for the two young boys, especially Dávid, whom she grew so fond of that she later named her youngest son after him. But the Hungarian royal family suffered a disaster when András had a stroke, which paralyzed him; fearful for his mortality, András attempted to make Solomon’s succession more secure, even against the rights of his brother, Béla, who had his strong claim to the succession according to the traditional principle of agnatic seniority.
However, the brothers’ relationship did not deteriorate immediately after Solomon’s birth, partly because he had given Béla his dukedom covering a third of the kingdom. In the deed of the foundation of the Tihány Abbey, a Benedictine monastery established in 1055 by András, Duke Béla was listed among the lords witnessing the consecration. This charter, although primarily written in Latin, contains the earliest extant text written in Hungarian; Feheruaru rea meneh hodu utu rea (“on the military road which leads to Fehérvár”), also demonstrating the strategic importance of Szekesfehérvár as a royal city and citadel at that time.
In an attempt to strengthen his son’s claim to the throne, Andrew pressed on with his plan and had the four-year-old Solomon crowned in the one-year-long period beginning in the autumn of 1057. Certain English forms and ceremonies were observed at the coronation, suggesting that the Wessex family were witnesses, or at least guests of honour. It is also possible that Bishop Ealdred, on mission to find the Wessex family, had arrived at Szekesfehérvár and attended the coronation ceremony, perhaps participating in it before resuming his pilgrimage to the Holy Land.
For the same purpose, András also arranged the betrothal of his son to Judith, a daughter of the late Emperor Henry III, and sister of the new German monarch, Henry IV (r. 1056–1105), in September 1058. Thereafter, according to an episode narrated by most Hungarian chronicles, the king invited Duke Béla to a meeting at Tiszavárkony, a castle on the River Tisza. At their meeting, Andrew seemingly offered his brother to freely choose between a crown and a sword, which were the symbols of the kingdom and the dukedom, respectively.
At what became known, dramatically, as the Várkony Scene, Duke Béla chose the sword, since he had previously been reliably informed by his partisans at Andrew’s court that he would be murdered on the king’s order if he opted for the crown. Béla then rode quickly back into exile in Poland, where he raised an army and returned to Hungary at the head of it. He defeated his brother, who died of his battle wounds (said to be caused by being crushed under wagons) soon afterwards. Andrew was buried at the Abbey at Tihány, which he had recently founded. During the civil war that followed, Queen Anastasia took refuge with her two sons in Austria.
Fifteen; Spring, 1058; Flanders and Westminster – Return of the Exile:
Whether Edward the Exile was still in Hungary and present at the Várkony Scene is impossible to discover. But given the turmoil in Hungary, the Wessex family may not have regretted leaving the country when they did, in 1058, even though this meant ‘returning’ to a country none of them knew, except by report, and the reports were not entirely encouraging, since they too were of dynastic disputes.
Although King Edward the Confessor, then in his late fifties, had been on the throne since 1042, the power behind the English throne in 1058 was Earl Harold Godwinson, of whom the exiled family could have heard very little before they arrived in England. Like the Wessex family, King Edward had spent most of his childhood and early manhood in exile, in his case in Normandy, succeeding to the English crown in what was then considered to be middle age, at forty.
Everything known at the English court about the Wessex exiles in 1057-58 came from the pen of Ealdred, Bishop of Worcester, who had visited four or five years earlier the court of the German Emperor in Köln on King Edward’s ‘business’. By that time, civil war had broken out in Hungary, so the spring of 1058 would have been an opportune time for Edward and his family to leave Hungary for England.
No details of their cross-continental journey or their arrival in England are recorded in the Hungarian or English chronicles. However, from the Scottish annals, we know that the Wessex family were accompanied to London by a retinue of Hungarian nobles, led by Andrew I’s illegitimate son, Georgius, who, together with others among them, later settled in Scotland. They probably travelled overland via Austria and Bavaria to the imperial palace in Cologne, and thence via Aachen to Flanders. This royal Hungarian guard must have provided strong protection, not just from attacks on the journey, but from foul play at the English court.
It was not surprising that Edward the Confessor had sought solace and counsel among the men he had grown up among in Normandy, but he had no great plan to ‘Normanise’ England or prepare the way for an invasion or occupation under his nephew. He had, however, been educated in Normandy and admired the Normans as a people, famed for their religious zeal as well as for their skills in warfare. Their enthusiasm for the Church was shown by the number of churches they built in their homeland, and their military strength by the castles they erected. The Norman abbots and bishops were among the best educated in Europe. Edward therefore desired to keep a significant number of Frenchmen at his court while remaining committed to the Wessex succession.
After almost three years, the Emperor Henry had refused the Confessor’s request for his help in locating the Exile, and Ealdred had continued his quest unaided. This was a time of tension between the German Empire and the Hungarian monarchy, when the latter was seen as being in rebellion against imperial rule. Nevertheless, the Confessor’s letter recalling the Exile and his family to England was finally delivered by Ealdred in 1057, and the Wessex family arrived from Flanders in the Spring of 1058.
The family reached England independently, though there was a suggestion that Harold went to Flanders, ostensibly under King Edward’s orders to meet them and bring them safely to London. But Harold seems to have had other plans when he met them. Six days after arriving in London, on 19th April, Edward of Wessex died mysteriously before his audience with the Confessor could take place. The Worcester (D) version of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle reported that we do not know how he was prevented from seeing his uncle in those six days, but there were suspicions that he had been murdered (perhaps poisoned) on the orders of Harold.
Someone wished to prevent this meeting, and suspicion fell on Harold, either acting in his interest, or as an agent of William of Normandy. Before the family arrived in England, Harold had gone to the continent on a mysterious mission, prompting speculation about the purpose of his journey and whether it was somehow connected to the arrival of the Wessex family. After travelling half way across Europe, Edward was buried in Old St Paul’s churchyard.
Sixteen – Rhuddlan, 1063; Mercia and Wales:
The Danish Conquest had destroyed respect at court for the Wessex inheritance and had created new, powerful Ango-Danish aristocratic dynasties, like the House of Godwin. Harold was determined not to allow either William or the Exile to block his path to power. Aelfgar, Earl of Mercia, had been declared an outlaw in March 1054 and twice exiled in the 1050s, the second time in 1058. On both occasions, he sought and was given the support of Gruffudd ap Llewelyn, who had defeated the levies of Hereford in October 1055.
By then, the four Godwin brothers controlled every part of England. In Northumbria, when Siward died, his son Waltheof was passed over as his successor in favour of Tostig. This threatened the equilibrium of the country. Aelfgar died in 1062, but his sons did not immediately succeed him, thus weakening the resistance to the Godwinsons. Ealdred was appointed Archbishop of York in 1063, the only remaining powerful representative of the Mercian interest. The Godwinsons decided to deal with Gruffudd ap Llewelyn in 1063 in a combined operation by Harold and Tostig, involving an unannounced attack on Rhuddlan. Gruffudd was killed in the attack and Wales was subdued.
Also in 1063, Edward the Confessor recognised Eadgar, aged twelve, as his Aetheling. He was supported by many Saxon bishops and thanes, but opposed by the Godwinsons, who persuaded the Witangamot, the Council of elders, that Eadgar was not old enough and not educated enough to be considered as king as yet. By this time, the Godwinsons controlled three of the four earldoms of England, so they therefore controlled the temporal lords in the Witan.
Seventeen; 1064, Rouen – Harold The Oathbreaker:
In 1064, King Edward sent Harold to Normandy to persuade William to withdraw his claim to the English throne. But Harold and his retinue were shipwrecked off the coast and when he was rescued and brought to Rouen by William’s men, the Duke would not agree to the request. Harold may have replaced his father as the power behind Edward’s throne, but William had been holding one of Harold’s brothers, Wolfnoth, and another relative, Hakon, hostage since Edward had first promised the throne to him in 1051. To gain their release, Harold agreed to support William’s claim.
William went further, however, and made Harold swear an oath on sacred relics to uphold the Duke’s claim. However, this part of the story seems to have been a later embellishment by a pro-Godwin chronicler seeking to justify Harold’s behaviour at this point and then later, in breaking his oath. A better-placed contemporary chronicler, Eadmar of Canterbury, made no mention of Edward’s promise or of the idea that the hostages were kept to keep Edward and Harold to their promise to uphold William’s claim. Whatever the basis of the story of Harold the oath-breaker, at the time Harold must have realized that he was in a dangerous position, in which he had to agree to what William wanted, under duress and in direct contradiction to his interests.
Eighteen, 1054-65; Northern England, Wales and Scotland:
Just as in other parts of Europe, by the mid-eleventh century, the nations and regions (or earldoms) of Britain were becoming increasingly inter-related in a variety of ways, especially in dynastic terms. It’s possible that Malcolm Canmore was already acquainted with the Wessex royal family at the Court of Edward the Confessor, having escaped from his father Duncan’s usurper, Macbeth. It’s also possible that Malcolm was at the court of Thorfinn Sigurdsson, Earl of Orkney and Macbeth’s nemesis. The usurper had ruled Scotland for seventeen years, from 1040 to 1057, until the House of Dunkeld was restored under Malcolm in 1058.
In 1054 Earl Siward of Northumbria had invaded Scotland with Malcolm, who had been in exile at Edward’s court, deposing Macbeth and installing Malcolm in succession to his father, as rightful king in 1058. Siward died in 1055 and was succeeded as Earl of Northumbria by Gospatrick. In 1061, Malcolm reclaimed Cumbria from Northumberland, resulting in continuing conflict between the two kingdoms over who ruled in these border territories.
Orderic Vitalis, the chronicler, claimed that Malcolm had already become betrothed to Margaret when he visited Edward’s court in 1059, a year after his coronation and after her arrival there. He had previously been married to Ingibjorg, the widow of Thorfinn Sigurdsson, and had his first two sons with her. Ingibjorg died before Malcolm’s marriage to Margaret.
In 1063/4 Tostig had two of Gospatrick’s men murdered, and then the Earl himself. Tostig then became the new earl, but the Northumbrians viewed him as a southern imposter and his arrogant behaviour led to the successful rebellion led by Morcar, who was acclaimed as the new earl.
In 1065, Harold was hunting in South Wales when he was attacked by the Welsh, wanting revenge for the attack on Gruffudd by him and his brother Tostig of 1063. In addition, the displacement of Morcar as the Earl of Northumbria led to a rebellion by both him and his brother, Eadwine. The two brothers were Anglo-Danish thegns, sons of Aelfgar, Earl of Mercia and grandsons of Leofric. Edwin had succeeded his father in 1063 as Earl of Mercia. Morcar also held lands in East Mercia, most notably in Lincolnshire, where he is recorded in Domesday as holding the Manor of Bourne in King Edward’s time. The manor was forfeited by Hereward Askeltilson as part of his punishment for outlawry in the reign of Edward. It was close to Stamford, one of the five boroughs of the Danelaw. During Hereward’s exile in Flanders, Morcar seems to have acted as caretaker for Hereward’s manor.
Marching south with the rebels, Morcar gathered into his forces the men of the five boroughs, including those of Nottingham, Derby and Lincoln, members of the old confederacy of towns in the Danelaw, and met Eadwine heading up a considerable force at Northampton. There they massed a huge force of arms from Mercia, Wales and Northumbria. Harold met the rebels at Northampton, where the brothers considered proposals for peace offered by him, but he failed to get them to stand down and Tostig was sent into exile from the Humber. Negotiations continued at Oxford, where with the Northumbrian army insisting on Morcar’s recognition, Harold yielded on 28th September 1065, and Morcar’s election was legalised.
Nineteen – Westminster, 1065-66 – Death of the Confessor; Harold’s Conspiracy and Coronation:
The Confessor’s health declined rapidly in 1065, and he was bypassed by the Godwinsons, who again persuaded members of the Witan that Eadgar was too young and inexperienced in matters of state and not mature enough as a teenager (aged fifteen) to lead the country under threat of invasion.
Due to the Confessor’s decline, the rededication of Westminster Abbey was brought forward to 28th December, and a week later King Edward died. Edward died close to the most important men in his kingdom who had come to Westminster for the rededication of the Abbey, including the Earls Edwin and Morcar. They were not, however, direct witnesses to his last words, and neither, of course, was the Aetheling.
Eadgar had been confirmed as Aetheling, his successor, by the Confessor as his health declined rapidly in 1065. He was also supported by many Saxon bishops and thanes. Before January 1066, he had been the main obstacle to Harold’s ambitions to rise to the throne. His blood link through his grandfather to the Kings of Wessex and, latterly, England, combined with the considerable efforts that had been made to secure the return of the Exile’s family from Hungary, must have led many to assume that Eadgar would, in due course, succeed his great uncle.
His title, according to many contemporary sources, indicated that he was considered worthy of ascending to the throne. Harold had sworn, in Edward’s presence, to uphold Eadgar’s rights, and besides breaking his oath on this, he then had to obtain enough support from the English magnates for the Aetheling’s rights to be set aside. This was secured by the deal Harold struck with Edwin and Morcar in October 1065, which strengthened their position through the marriage of the two leading Saxon families.
King Edward was disappointed by his nobles who were unwilling to face down the rebels. As a result of the rising, both Morcar and Edwin had their earldoms restored and with them the equilibrium of the kingdom. As 1066 began, therefore, Eadgar began to hope that he might one day soon become king with the help of Mercia and Northumbria in securing the royal Wessex succession.
They were defeated by Hardrada at York in 1066 and had to surrender the city after the Battle of Fulford Gate and before the Battle of Stamford Bridge, in which, apparently, they were not involved. Morcar was the Earl of Northumbria from 1063 to 1066, and Edwin was Earl of Mercia from 1063 to his death near Ely in 1071.
But, in 1065, unknown to the Aetheling, Edwin and Morcar had struck a deal with Harold in which they agreed to support Harold’s succession in return for the security of their earldoms. This agreement also involved the marriage of the Earls’ sister, Ealdgyth, to Harold, even though he was already married, albeit in the Danish tradition, to Edith Swan-neck.
The Anglo-Danish connection was further strengthened when Stigand was made Archbishop of Canterbury in preference to an Anglo-Norman candidate. It was becoming increasingly clear to William that if he was to gain the throne of England, this could only be done through force of arms, and with the support of the Papacy, which had been increasingly taken over by the Reformers led by the Benedictines.
At this point, Harold was seemingly unconcerned that William could, or would, launch an invasion fleet. Unlike their Viking forebears of previous generations, the Normans were, by now, a settled francophile people, not feared, unlike the Danes and Norwegians, for their ship-building and seafaring skills.
The Life of King Edward named four people as being present at the King’s death – the Queen, Archbishop Stigand, Robert (the Steward of the Palace of Westminster) and Earl Harold. The Life recorded the last words of the King to Harold as…
I commend the life of this lady and all the kingdom to your protection.
The rest of his recorded words concerned the welfare of Queen Eadith, Harold’s sister. His words therefore fell a long way short of providing an unambiguous designation of his successor. If anything, they suggest Harold’s appointment as Regent. The C and D versions of the Chronicle both use the same word, entrusted, concerning the kingdom, suggesting that Harold was only empowered to take care of the kingdom temporarily. However, none of those present refuted the suggestion that Harold had been designated as Edward’s successor.
However, according to other sources, many people seemed to have harboured serious doubts as to the veracity of Harold’s version of events. The Norman chronicler, William of Poitiers, claimed that Harold had seized the throne with the connivance of a few wicked men, suggesting that his election was far from unanimous as suggested by some versions of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle.
On his deathbed, Edward accepted that Harold would be regent, but that Eadgar would succeed him as King when he reached his majority, at sixteen, the following year. We cannot know whether it was always Harold’s intention to usurp his brother-in-law, or whether it was simply his interpretation of Edward’s dying wishes. There were conventions concerning the succession, but no set of rules governing it. Cnut had upset the principle, claiming the right to rule by conquest. Harold seemed to be in great haste to be crowned since, as more recently, the usual practice was to observe a due period of mourning for the recently-deceased monarch, lasting at least six months, if not a full year.
A close blood link was not necessary to succeed, though highly desirable. It was also seen as beneficial for the successor to have been designated as such by his predecessor. Thirdly, there needed to have been an election, with the clear majority of the Witan approving of the candidate’s succession. Earl Harold was related to Edward only by his sister Eadyth’s marriage and therefore, like William, had no direct blood link through the male line to the English monarchy. His main claim rested on nomination by Edward and election by the magnates. The E version of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle confirmed both of these, and John of Worcester claimed that Harold had been elected by all the principal men of England. But both were written with a strong pro-Godwin bias.
Unusually, Edward was buried the next morning, at Epiphany, 6th January, in his renewed abbey. The same day, in the afternoon, Harold was crowned as his successor. No single fact points more to a conspiracy than the circumstances of Harold’s coronation. No previous King of England had demonstrated so desperate a hurry to have himself consecrated. Besides the lack of the traditional respectful gap between funeral and consecration, the coronation had never been regarded as a king-making process in England.
Harold seemed to have been concerned to justify his highly dubious claim as soon as possible with an instant consecration. He may also have felt this necessary because there was still trouble in the North, where people were no more willing to have Harold Godwinson as king than they had been to accept his brother as their earl the year before. Harold himself went north soon after the event to head off any sign of rebellion and possibly, also, to arrange and celebrate his wedding to Ealdgyth.
The Bayeux tapestry shows the new king crowned and enthroned. The inclusion of the excommunicate Archbishop Stigand is probably a later Norman fabrication, designed to discredit the acts of coronation, as John of Worcester makes clear that the consecration was performed by Ealdred, Archbishop of York (as he had become in 1060). On the death of Edward the Confessor, Morcar professedly supported Harold as his successor, but the people of his earldom were dissatisfied. Harold, we are told, visited York the following Spring of 1066, and overcame their disaffection by peaceful means.
There are few primary sources dealing with the Norman reaction to the news of Harold’s succession and coronation. The only chronicle recording the event was written a century later, and it claimed that William was hunting near Rouen when a messenger arrived, and William received his message in private. He then returned to his palace in anger, speaking to no-one. He sent messages to Harold, urging him to renounce the throne and to keep his pledges. Harold chose to ignore these admonitions, and William received his message, and William resolved, in the words of the Norman chronicler and the Duke’s chaplain, William of Poitiers, to claim his inheritance through force of arms. Poitiers helped to ensure the support of the Pope, Alexander II, who sanctioned William’s use of arms by sending him a papal banner to carry into battle.
Twenty; Spring 1066 – The Norwegian Invasion and Battle of Stamford Bridge:
By Easter 1066, at which point Harold returned south from his mysterious trip to York, fears of foreign invasion were already mounting. His return to Westminster coincided with the appearance of a comet (later identified by Haley), which only appeared every seventy-six years, well outside the average human life-span in the early medieval period, so it was regarded as a terrible omen.
Estranged from his brother, Tostig had returned from Flanders in the Spring, launching an attack on the Isle of Wight, then on Sandwich on the Kent coast and then raiding up the east coast to Lincolnshire. According to the Chronicle, Tostig had remained as Malcolm Canmore’s guest throughout the Summer of 1066, following his unsuccessful attempt to invade Wessex in the Spring and his ravaging of the Mercian east coast in the early summer, which Edwin and Morcar successfully repulsed. Tostig then visited Norway to persuade Harald to join him in invading England. Tostig was back in Scotland, or perhaps Orkney, by the end of August, where he met with Hardrada’s invasion fleet of some two hundred ships. They sailed on to the Humber estuary and up the Ouse, landing on its north bank at Riccor, ten miles south of York, their principal target.
England now faced invasion on two fronts – by the Norwegian king, Harald Hardrada, and by William, Duke of Normandy, both of whom laid claim to the English throne. Before 1066, Harald Sigurdsson had been mentioned only once in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, at the start of his reign in the mid-1040s. There’s little evidence that he intended to become King of England, though there are reports of an earlier deal with Harthacnut, that each should become the other’s heir. Otherwise, he had been preoccupied with his struggle with Sweyn Estridsson for control of Denmark. He only became interested in invading England in 1066 at Tostig’s suggestion. According to the Chronicle, the events in the North occurred during the first week of September, which suggests careful planning by Harald and Tostig.
On 8th September, Harold Godwinson dismissed the great fleet he had held in readiness for a cross-channel attack since the start of the summer. He must have done so at almost the same time as the northern invaders embarked to capture York, suggesting that the Norwegian invasion had been unexpected in England. Certainly, Earl Morcar was unprepared to meet Hardrada’s force; it was not until York was directly threatened that, having been joined by Edwin, he went out against them with a large army. By the third week in September, Edwin and Morcar had mobilised the English militia against Hardrada’s army, a defensive force they thought sufficient for them to resist an engagement on the eastern side of the city at Fulford. Still, they were roundly defeated there on the twentieth.
When Hardrada and Tostig entered the city, its citizens surrendered without a fight. Edwin and Morcar were nowhere to be found. Further hostages were to be exchanged at Stamford Bridge on the River Derwent, where Tostig and Hardrada also planned to meet to receive a final round of submissions before advancing to subdue the rest of the kingdom. Meanwhile, Harold Godwinson had led a forced march, and within two weeks had arrived at Tadcaster on 24th September. He had expected to find his adversaries fortified in York, but discovered on entering the city next morning that they had already left for Stamford Bridge, oblivious to his arrival in Yorkshire.
It was an opportunity he could not miss, so he marched his army straight through the city and out towards the Derwent, a distance of eighteen miles. According to the Norse historian, Snorri Sturluson (1179-1241), when the two leaders met, Harold told Harald (Hardrada), that he would grant him only seven feet of ground, enough for his burial. Another of Snorri’s stories, corroborated by a contemporary, told of how the Norwegians had gone to Stamford Bridge without their mail shirts due to the warm weather, not expecting to be involved in battle.
When they were surprised by Harold’s army, the fierce fighting continued until late in the day. The English were prevented from crossing the bridge by a lone warrior wearing mail, until an inspired Saxon crept under the bridge with his javelin and speared him in the one place where his chain mail offered no protection. The rest of Harold’s army then swarmed over the bridge and the rest of the Norwegian army was slaughtered, including both Hardrada and Tostig. The remaining Norwegians tried to run back to their ships at Riccall, but they were pursued by the English, with some drowning and others slain in various ways.