Jesus’s close friends and followers from Galilee had great difficulty in getting out of their heads the widespread Jewish conviction that God’s chosen leader when he came would establish some kind of national kingdom, with a king and government. They had grown up with this idea, as Jesus himself had done, and took it for granted. The Zealots thought of God’s chosen leader or ‘Messiah’ as a military ruler, establishing his power by military conquest. Many others who were not Zealots thought much like this, though some believed that God himself would defeat the Romans. But Jesus would have nothing to do with such ideas. He had not come to be that kind of leader or to establish that kind of rule. His friends must have thought Jesus’s talk about suffering utterly impossible to believe – how could God’s chosen leader suffer in any way or die…
Pesach, usually called ‘The Passover’ in English, is the greatest of the Jewish festivals, the holiday of the year and the oldest in the Jewish calendar. Like the Christian Easter, which partly originates from it, it varies in date from year to year, but occurs in spring and lasts for seven to eight days, about four of which are non-working days. Celebrated in the spring, at the full moon in the first month of the year, then Abib (April in modern calendars), the month of the green ears of corn, it contained the rite of the smearing of the blood of a lamb on the tent posts, probably designed to ward off demons of destruction or infertility. The festival probably dates back to the time when the Jews were wandering herders in the deserts of the Middle East, pitching their tents wherever they found grazing for their herds.
At the time when the young lambs were born, they observed a festival at which either a sheep or goat was sacrificed as a way of giving thanks; they gave up something which was valuable to them. The sacrifice was given at nightfall and the animal was roasted whole, in a nomadic fashion, and eaten hurriedly with desert food, unleavened bread seasoned with bitter herbs. No bones of the animal were broken, and no meat was left uneaten by daybreak. It was a family affair, not connected with the priests or a place of worship. The participants in the meal were ready to move at a moment’s notice to defend their flocks, belts fastened, sandals on their feet and staffs in hand. Passover was, initially at least, the festival of a pastoral community.
The Israelite Exile & Exodus Story:
The Journey to the promised land: After forty yearsin the Sinai desert the Israelites probably went south, but we do not know their exact route. They avoided the coastal region because of fear of attack from the Philistines.
As some groups of Hebrews became more settled and lived by farming the land, they developed their own traditions and festivals more closely related to growing crops. This took place before they harvested the barley and was called the ‘Feast of Unleavened Bread’ referring to bread that had no yeast or ‘leavening’. At the beginning of the festival, all ‘sour doughs’ (used like yeast to leaven the bread), had to be destroyed to safeguard the produce of the year to come. Then the first sheaf of the newly-cut barley, the ‘omer’ was presented to the priest as a sacrifice of thanksgiving. These people, of course, did not move from place to place like the shepherds, and therefore were able to build more permanent places of worship, often ‘high places’ on the hills. Even so, there were periods of poor harvests when the Hebrews found themselves dependent on the Egyptians for corn during the poorer years. All these characteristics of the two festivals, which eventually became one, are explicable without reference to the events of the exodus described in the Old Testament which gave Passover a new meaning.
In fact, the story of the Israelites’ exile in Egypt really begins with the story of Joseph (at the end of Genesis), the son of Jacob (Israel) who had been sold into slavery in Egypt and then rose to a position of high authority, describes how the Israelite family moved into Egypt to share the better harvests there. As they grew in numbers and social status, enjoying the privileges they had been granted, successive Pharaohs gradually became more resentful on behalf of their envious people, and the Hebrews found themselves reduced to abject slavery, longing to be free to reach the land flowing with milk and honey, promised to them by God. The Book of Exodus narrates how, under the leadership of Moses, the Hebrews achieved their freedom and escaped from Egypt, beginning with Yahweh’s terrible punishment of the Egyptians, and then set out to find their promised land.
The Passover Story:
The name of the festival, originally ‘Pesah’ (Hebrew: pasah) uses a word of very uncertain meaning but one which is linked to the earliest ‘J’ source, with Yahweh’s ‘passing over’ the blood-stained lintels of Hebrew homes while the destroying angel smote the firstborn children of Egypt (Ex. 12. 21-27). In the ‘P’ tradition of Ex. 12. 11, the fastened belt, sandalled feet and staff in hand are memorials of the haste with which the Hebrews left Egypt at God’s command. In Deut. 16. 3, the unleavened bread is called the ‘bread of affliction,’ again a memorial of the people’s flight in haste from Egyptian bondage. The date was also given a link to the exodus, for in the month of Abib, Yahweh your God brought you out of Egypt by night (Deut 16. 1; cf. Ex. 23. 14 ff.; 34.18).
Ever since that time, Jews have remembered and commemorated the night when they ate hurriedly, ready for the journey, and painted the doorposts of their houses with the blood of the lambs so that the plague of death would not touch the house. The two spring festivals became one historical festival symbolising and celebrating the struggle of the Jewish people toward national freedom. In the early days of Israel’s history, the festival was a festival of Pilgrimage when all who could, made their way to the Temple in Jerusalem. After the destruction of the Second Temple, Jews became more widely dispersed around the Mediterranean world, the festival was divided into two parts, the ceremony in the local temple, or synagogue, and the observance of the ‘Seder’ meal in each home. For this, the home is made spotlessly clean, and on the eve of Pesach (the Passover), all leavened bread is destroyed while the ‘matzoh’ or unleavened bread is prepared. Greetings are exchanged, the home is filled with light, and the table is set so that the whole family sits around it.
The various parts of the meal remind the Jews of the deliverance from the cruelty and enslavement in Egypt. At its commencement, the youngest son asks four traditional questions which his father answers fully. In this way, the younger generation is taught the Exodus stories. There are up to fourteen parts to the ceremonial of the Seder. It has given rise to inspired works of art in the making of the Seder dishes, Passover banners and matzoh covers. The meal also has special items. Four cups of wine are taken and there are cakes of bread, dishes of roasted egg, saltwater; perhaps symbolising the tears of the Hebrews in slavery, bitter herbs, and a sweet paste of almonds, apple and wine, said to represent the clay with which the Israelites were forced to make bricks when they were slaves. The last part of the Seder consists of prayers and songs, and a cup of wine is poured symbolically for Elijah when the door is opened so that he too may enter and drink.
The Last Supper and the Christian Festival of ‘Pasque’ (‘Easter’):
Jesus washed his disciples’ feet before the Passover meal.
It was probably at this meal, known to Christians as the Last Supper or the Lord’s Supper at which Jesus, as Paul describes, took the cup and the bread at one point and instituted for all his followers what became the central act of worship of their religion also called, variously, Holy Communion, the Eucharist or the Mass, depending on the different traditions to which they later came to belong. Maundy Thursday is named in the church’s calendar from the words of Jesus when at the Passover meal held with his disciples in the Upper Room of a house in Jerusalem, he said that he gave them a new commandment or mandate. He spoke the words as he proceeded to his act of humility and service, washing his disciples’ feet. The Latin words are, Mandatum novum da vobis; A new commandment I give you. From the word ‘mandatum’ came the word ‘maundy’ in Old English.
Jesus’ Passover meal with his disciples, his ‘Last Supper’.
Pesach has a long history and in many countries, Easter (a name referring to the pagan goddess of spring, Eostre) is called Pasque (France) or Pasg (Welsh), following the Judeo-Christian tradition. In some parts of Britain ‘Pacé Egg Plays’ were performed on the following day in the Passover festival and beginning of the Hebrew Sabbath, Good Friday in the church’s calendar. Pacé was again derived from ‘Pasche’ or ‘Paschal’. The plays were thought to be based on a sixteenth-century story, The History of Seven Champions of Christendom.
The Exodus and the Hebrew Year:
The exodus from Egypt is central to the faith of the Old Testament. If there is one description of God that, above all others, is characteristic of the God of the Old Testament, it is this: I am Yahweh your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt. The prophets are the heralds of this God:
I brought you up out of the land of Egypt.
(Amos 2. 10; cf. Jer. 2.6).
When Israel was a child, I loved him, and out of the land of Egypt I called my son.
When a son is asked by his father the meaning of the commandments binding on Israel, the father is instructed to reply:
We were Pharaoh’s slaves in Egypt, and Yahweh brought us out of Egypt with a mighty hand, and Yahweh showed signs and wonders, great and grievous, against Egypt and against Pharaoh and all his household before our eyes…
(Deut. 6. 21 f. ; cf. Ex. 20. 2; Deut. 5. 6).
The significance of the exodus for faith is unquestionable; what actually happened was probably sober enough. A group of Hebrew slaves under the leadership of Moses left Egypt. They safely negotiated a stretch of water called ‘the Sea of Reeds’ (not the Red Sea). The location of the Sea of Reeds is uncertain; the likelihood is that it lay in the general region of what is now the Suez canal or perhaps further east along the Mediterranean coast at Lake Sirbonis. The earliest narrative strand ‘J’ speaks of a strong east wind blowing all night to push the water back (Ex. 14. 21-28). The pursuing Egyptian chariots stuck in the soft sand and were drowned by the returning water. Naturally, Egyptian records have nothing to say about what was at most, from their point of view, a minor frontier incident. In the Old Testament, however, this is never an escape bid engineered by Moses, but always a mighty act of God through which he delivered his people out of slavery. In what is probably the earliest OT witness account of these events, the triumphant Song of Miriam expresses the essence of what happened:
Sing to Yahweh, for he has triumphed gloriously,
the horse and the rider he has thrown into the sea.
(Ex. 15. 21; cf. 15. 1)
A depiction of the legendary crossing of the ‘Red Sea’ from Exodus. However, the Hebrew text refers to the ‘Reed Sea’ which was likely to have been somewhere north of the Suez Gulf, or along the Mediterranean Coast.
This was Yahweh’s victory over his enemies, a victory on behalf of his oppressed people. That it was interpreted in this way from the beginning must be attributed to the prior revelation of God’s purposes given to Moses. The exodus is the heart of the Old Testament gospel, the good news of what God has done. Just as the memory of central events in the New Testament gospel was preserved in the worship of the early Christian communities, so the exodus was handed down in Israel in one great family religious festival, ‘Passover’. Alone among the festivals of the Hebrew religious year, Passover goes back beyond the time of the settlement in Canaan, in all probability before the exodus itself. But Passover is also an illustration of something that happened to most of the festivals of the Hebrew year. Besides the Festival of Unleavened Bread (Massoth) which became linked to Pesach, Qasir (Harvest) and Asiph (Ingathering) are native to the agricultural life of Canaan.
Whatever their origins, the Old Testament gives the festivals a historical and religious reference, and in most cases, that reference was to the exodus or to the events associated with it. Asiph, for example, is the great harvest thanksgiving festival. With the farmer’s work for the year successfully completed, the mood was one of unrestrained rejoicing. In Deut. 16. 13, however, this festival is called Sukkoth (Huts). The origin of these ‘huts’ or ‘tabernacles’ is disputed. Some find in it a reference to the sacred booth in which the marriage between the god and goddess of fertility was consummated. Others think that they are simply reminiscent of the temporary harvest tents which gave protection to farmworkers from the Palestinian sun. According to Leviticus these huts or booths, however, had a totally different significance:
You shall dwell in booths for seven days; all that are native in Israel shall dwell in booths that your generations may know that I made the people dwell in booths when I brought them out of the land of Egypt. I am Yahweh your God.
Lev. 23. 42 f.
Patriarchs and People:
But although we may still think that the patriarchal stories preserve some kind of folk memory of earlier times, we cannot tell exactly how old they really are. Certainly, their names are not of a kind found later in Israel, suggesting that they do indeed genuinely originate from a time before that of the kings. But, in several cases, they are also unmistakably Egyptian. ‘Moses’ occurs as an element in well-known Egyptian names such as ‘Tut-Moses’ and Aaron and Phinehas, other characters in the exodus story, also bear Egyptian names. The exodus tradition also bears some kind of folk memory that the Israelite ancestors spent some time in Egypt, but these were not necessarily descendants of the same patriarchal group that had originally come to Canaan from Mesopotamia. Therefore, we may be dealing with two parallel memories, and it is not clear which resulting story is older than the other. There is one reference to ‘Israel’ on a stele (victory inscription) found in Thebes in 1896, belonging to the pharaoh Merneptah and dated to about 1215 BCE, which indicates that a people by that name was already in Palestine in the thirteenth century BCE, at that time under Egyptian rule. But we can learn nothing else about them, and Israel is never mentioned again in any ancient Egyptian texts.
If Meneptah’s stele refers to a group that had settled under Moses’ successor Joshua, while the patriarchal stories concern people settling under the leaders called judges in the Bible, then the traditions in Exodus could actually be older than those in Genesis. The tribes ruled over by the judges bear the names of the twelve sons of Jacob, so the Genesis stories about these characters could easily reflect folk traditions from the period of the Judges following the settlement of the Israelites in Canaan. This is, however, speculative and it is possible that the narrative sequence the Bible offers is correct. Unless some Israelites did genuinely owe their ancestry to people outside the Land of Canaan, it is hard to see why such traditions should have developed, for it was hardly advantageous in most ancient societies to present oneself as the child of immigrants. But the archaeological evidence, together with the biblical narratives and what is known of how folk memories are created, suggests that most later ‘Israelites’ were, in fact, Canaanites, descendants of native inhabitants of the Land. The belief that all Israelites derived from those who had come out of Egypt with Moses was the belief of a few, but it was not internalised by the nation at large until later times. So all of Israel later celebrated the Passover Festival and rejoiced in the deliverance from Egypt that it commemorates, even though most were the offspring of people who had never been there. Nation-building, whether ancient or modern, often involves sharing with the multitudes folk memories that were experienced only by a few.
The Early Christian Writers & the Old Testament:
Some early Christian ‘churchmen’ saw no need for a New Testament so long as the Old can be read as describing the Christian faith so fully, and it is not surprising that the Gospels were not seen as Scriptures themselves. In the Easter Homily of Melito, the Bishop of Sardis (in what is now western Turkey), who died in 180 CE, states that the passage of Exodus that describes the Passover lamb is not meant to be read alongside the Gospel accounts of the Last Supper and the crucifixion, as prefiguring Christ. Properly understood, it is already an account of the reliability of the Gospel and Pauline accounts because, once read through properly enlightened (that is, Christian) eyes, it is virtually is a New Testament already. When it is read in a church, it is a symbolic description of the passion of Jesus. The author of Melitho will almost certainly have known one of the Gospels. That is to say that he did not need to cite such texts as if they were scriptural, since for him the existing Scriptures, the Old Testament as we call them, were already to be read as essentially Christian works.
Perhaps this helps to explain the strange phenomenon among some early Christian writers who accused the Jews of falsifying the Old Testament text by removing references to Christ, or the Messiah, and inserting misleading passages. They believed that Christians had the right, therefore, to correct the Old Testament in the light of the full revelation of God in Jesus Christ. In this way, the OT was seen as a complete and completely true revelation, not merely some preliminary disclosure, and a theory was developed that the ‘false passages’ that had been introduced into it needed to be removed or corrected. The Mekhilta of Rabbi Ishmael is a Jewish commentary on the second half of the book of Exodus, probably produced by synthesizing material from various dates, sometime in the second century CE. It is concerned primarily with how to observe the various pieces of legislation in Exodus, which from chapter twenty onwards consists of laws and precepts about life in society and the worship of the sanctuary. The Mekhilta is one of the oldest collections of rabbinic teaching in the form of scriptural commentary. A typical passage in it concerns the Jewish custom of the binding on the forehead and left arm a small scroll containing certain biblical texts, before beginning prayer. This is seen as enacting the instructions about keeping the Passover in Exodus 13: 6-9:
For seven days you shall eat unleavened bread… You shall tell your child on that day, “It is because of what the LORD did for me when I came out of Egypt.” It shall serve for you as a sign on your hand and as a reminder on your forehead so that the teaching of the LORD may be on your lips; for with a strong hand the LORD brought you out of Egypt.
The phrase a sign on your hand is understood as meant literally rather than metaphorically, and as referring to the left arm rather than the hand, for various reasons that the Mekhita spells out. To many modern readers, this interpretation seems extremely strange. In the first place, the text in Exodus 13: 9 is surely intended metaphorically; the remembrance of the exodus is to be as close to the Israelite as if it were written on his hand. Still, it is understandable that a symbolic, physical expression of the command came to be customary.
Passover in the present – ‘the Season of Release’:
For Jews today, Passover remains essentially a family festival when the whole family comes together to remember, rejoice, and especially to hear again the wonderful story of their deliverance, and to look forward to the time when all over the world they will enjoy freedom once more. In Jewish tradition, the season is therefore known as ‘The Season of Release’. Its central theme is ‘release’ and this can be interpreted on three levels. Historically, Passover celebrates the exodus of the Israelites from slavery in Egypt. On the annual seasonal level, it represents the release of the earth from the tight grip of winter, and on a personal and familial level, for each of those taking part, it symbolises his or her hope of release from the ‘bondage’ of wrongdoing.
Sources:
John Barton (2019), A History of The Bible; The Book and its Faiths. London: Allen Lane (Penguin, Random House).
Martin Manser (1999), Bible Stories. Bath: Parragon.
Robert C Walton (ed., 1982), A Source Book of the Bible for Teachers. London: SCM Press.
In 1999, during the first government of Viktor Orbán, when Hungary became a member of NATO, his foreign minister, János Martonyi wrote of the change in the country’s system of government that had begun with the mandate received from the first free elections, which had replaced the one-party-state system. The Prime Minister of the new Centre-Right coalition government of József Antall, on 23rd May, announced their intention to initiate its withdrawal from the Warsaw Pact. Reflecting on this from the end of the decade, Martonyi commented that the system change presented Hungary with…
… a unique and irreproducible opportunity to reintegrate once and for all into the community of developed and democratic states which are bound together by their commitment to the basic values typical of all of them: democracy, the rule of law – with its institutional frameworks and substance, respect for human rights including minority rights, and an economy based on private property and free initiative. Not to miss such a historic opportunity this time must be the task and guiding principle of action of all responsible politicians, political parties and the government.
János Martonyi & Zsolt Németh (1999), “Hungarian Foreigh Policy and Euro-Atlantic Integration”, in Hungary: A Member of NATO. Budapest: Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
This opportunity, the authors went on, had been well recognised by the Antall government of 1990-94. In his address delivered in the Hungarian Parliament on the government’s programme, József Antall had pointed out that:
“… the new government will be a European government, and not only in the geographical sense of the word. We stand for the tradition of democracy, pluralism and openness. We want to return to the European heritage but at the same time, also to those values that Europe has created in the course of the past forty years, in the wake of the terrible lessons and experience of World War II.
This formulation of these foreign policy priorities – Euro-Atlantic integration, good neighbourliness ensuring regional stability, and support for the Hungarian communities living abroad – did not apply to one parliamentary cycle only, and all the subsequent governments of the 1990s continued to see these goals as being of primary importance, through to the beginning of the first FIDESZ-led government in 1999. By then, the Hungarian national flag did already fly, together with the Czech and Polish flags, in front of the Headquarters of NATO besides the other sixteen, demonstrating that the community had been enriched by its new central-eastern European allies.
Revolution in Budapest & at the Border, Oct. 1988-Oct. 1989:
In order to understand developments in the attitudes of the Hungarian political parties and their voters towards the North Atlantic Alliance in the 1990s, we need first to look back into the period immediately preceding the change in the system in Hungary in 1988-89. The Communist government announced on 23rd October 1988, the 32nd anniversary of the 1956 Uprising, that they would start negotiations for a Soviet troop withdrawal. They also announced the setting up of a historical commission to establish a true and official characterisation of the Uprising. Changes began to happen fast from that point. On 11th January 1989, Hungary’s Parliament passed a law allowing citizens to form independent associations, including political parties, thus paving the way for an eventual end to one-party rule. The following month, the groundbreaking report prepared by the historical commission of the ruling MSZMP reported, rejecting the official interpretation of the 1956 Uprising as a “counter-revolution” rather describing it as a popular uprising against the existing state power and saying that, under Stalin, the ideal of international communism was turned into a merciless imperial programme. Imre Pozsgay, who had become a prominent figure in the Politburo, acting largely on his own initiative, publicly announced soon after that the events of 1956 had indeed been a popular uprising rather than an attempt at counter-revolution. Even the Party Central Committee could not be induced to go as far as Pozsgay. Although by that time János Kádár had gone, it was still by far the most delicate subject in Hungarian politics.
Hungarian-Soviet improved when the Soviet Union withdrew two thousand soldiers from Hungary at the end of April, and Gorbachev stated that the Soviet goal was to withdraw ten thousand soldiers and four hundred and fifty tanks by May 1990, which raised the US and Hungarian expectations even further. Nevertheless, Hungary enjoyed an increasing sense of security and, as a demonstration of its independence, it began dismantling its fences along the Austrian border in May 1989. For forty years before that, the question of belonging to an alliance system was considered to be one of the strictest taboos in a Communist-led country occupied by the Soviet Union. It was much riskier to take a stand against the presence of Soviet troops in Hungary or even to raise the issue than to call for human rights or pluralist democracy. Besides the fact that the deployment of Soviet troops in Hungary was the main guarantee for the survival of the communist system there, the experience of 1956 had shown that a violation of Soviet military interests implied the threat of even more brutal repression. Due to this fear of the military might of the Soviet Union, even those opposition groups which took shape in the 1980s considered this issue of the country’s independence taboo and did not insist on placing it on the agendas.
But in June 1989 permission was given for the bodies of Imre Nagy, the executed former Prime Minister, and the other leaders of the 1956 Uprising to be exhumed. Nagy’s body was found buried in the waste ground at the Újkozmeto cemetery, wrapped in tar paper. On 16 June his coffin lay in state in Heroes’ Square in central Budapest before being finally reburied. The public funeral was attended by an estimated a quarter of a million Hungarians and broadcast nationwide on radio and television. The ceremony also paid tribute to the thousands of others who died in the retribution meted out by the revolution. While it was organised privately, several Hungarian officials attended part of the ceremony. It was there that the consensus of silence on Soviet withdrawal was first broken on 16 June 1989, when at the ceremonial reburying of Imre Nagy and his fellow martyrs, Viktor Orbán, one of five speakers, declared that:
The Young ‘Liberal’ Democrat, Viktor Orbán, speaks at the re-interment of Imre Nagy in June 1989. These days, neither Liberal Democracy nor Nagy’s Social Democracy are any more fashionable for Orbán and his now ultra-conservative party and government.
“If we do not lose sight of the ideals of 1956, we will be able to choose a government which will instantly start talks on the immediate start of the withdrawal of Soviet troops.
Viktor Orbán’s speech at Heroes’ Square, 16 June 1989, at the funeral of Imre Nagy and fellow martyrs in András Bozóki (1992), Tista lappal. A Fidesz a magyar politikában 1988-1991 (‘With a cleansheet. Fidesz in Hungarian policy 1988-91): Budapest, p. 155.
Orbán’s speech was a clear challenge to the reform wing of the ruling Communist Party (the Hungarian Socialist Workers’ Party (MSZMP) to keep their word. From the point of view of the security policy, his reference to the ideals of 1956 equalled a claim for independence and, along with that, the neutrality of Hungary. These developments were accompanied by much public discussion of the events of 1956, as well as many other historical subjects. At last, Hungary had come to terms with its past. Its future was secured by a decision, taken by the Central Committee, to introduce a multi-party system. By then, Pozsgay’s own position seemed closer to that of the opposition Hungarian Democratic Forum (MDF) than to his own party. President Bush praised the Hungarian Government’s decision to begin discussions with the opposition parties.
The reburial of the 1956 martyrs, 16th June 1989: Although himself a former Communist exile in Moscow, the 1989 exhumation and reburial of Imre Nagy and those executed with him, was a turning point in the accelerating changes and national renewal during the decisive year of 1989-90. The honouring of Nagy and his colleagues in this way confirmed the revolutionary (as opposed to the counter-revolutionary) nature of the 1956 events better than any legal rehabilitation could have done.
As a sign of the new US-Hungarian relationship, President Bush became the first US President to visit Hungary on 11th-13th July, accompanied by Secretary of State James A. Baker. By the time President Bush visited Hungary in July 1990, Hungary had effectively ceased to be either a Communist country or a Soviet satellite. He met with Hungarian officials and delivered an address at Karl Marx University in which he praised Hungary’s opening up to the West and its transition to democracy and a market economy, noting that “voices long stilled are being heard again.” At the ‘G7’ Economic Summit meeting, held in Paris on 15th July, participants agreed to provide economic assistance to Poland and Hungary to support their political reform process. Later in the summer of 1989, the civic organisations, in comprehensive negotiations with the leaders of the MSZMP achieved their declared goal of holding free, multi-party elections in the Spring of 1990.
President H. W. Bush participates in a bilateral meeting with PM Miklós Nemeth in July 1989 in the Department Room of the Parliament in Budapest. Source. The George Bush Presidential Library.
When the BBC Journalist John Simpson visited Imre Pozsgay later that summer, he asked him whether he and his colleagues would be the beneficiaries of the changes they were introducing. His answer was:
“Who can say? Naturally I hope so. That’s why we’re doing these things. But to be honest with you, there’s nothing else we can do. Even if others win the elections, there’s no serious alternative to doing what we have done.”
John Simpson (1990), Dispatches from the Barricades.
Hungarian PM Miklós Nemeth told the DDR Government it was simply being repaired!
An East German mother comforts her bewildered child at the Hungarian-Austrian border ‘picnic’ at which thousands escaped to the West in Sept 1989.
Hungary took another major step towards reasserting its independence when on 11th September, again at the instigation of Imre Pozsgay, it lifted restrictions on visitors from East Germany. It opened its borders with Austria, allowing people from East Germany (the DDR) on holiday in Hungary, to flood through to the West in such numbers that the entire future of the DDR was called into question, by dealing a fatal blow to its iron-fisted security system. Allowing them to leave Hungary to the west across the Austrian border, breached a twenty-five-year-old agreement with the DDR. The move prompted an exodus of tens of thousands of East Germans to West Germany via Austria.
Above: (left) Demonstrators in Budapest keep up the momentum; (right and below) East Germans, holidaying in Hungary, cross the border and head West, to the fury of their government, and to their own freedom.
The second republic was ended by the second Orbán Government in 2010-11.
In October 1989, Hungary’s Parliament also adopted a new, democratic constitution, changed the country’s name from the “Hungarian People’s Republic” to the “Republic of Hungary,” authorised the formation of political parties, forbade such parties to operate in workplaces, scheduled national elections, disbanded the Workers’ Guard, and authorised reparation payments to persons arrested after the 1956 Uprising. On 23rd October, exactly one year after the changes had begun, Acting President Mátyás Szűrös proclaimed the new Republic on the thirty-third anniversary of the Uprising. The Revolution of 1988-89 had reached its successful conclusion and the country’s transition to multi-party democracy and a market economy had begun. Developments throughout central-eastern Europe as a whole continued at a rapid pace. Warsaw Pact Foreign Ministers, including Soviet Foreign Minister Eduard Shevardnadze, met in Warsaw on 27 October and renounced the 1968 Brezhnev Doctrine, under which the Soviet Union had reserved the right to intervene in other countries whenever it believed that the government of a USSR-allied state was threatened.
The crowds outside the Parliament welcome the proclamation of a liberal-democratic Constitution for the new ‘Republic of Hungary’, October 1989.
Another Country: The Transition to Democracy & Independence, October 1989-June 1991:
This was a major step in redefining the nature of relationships between the Warsaw Pact countries, and a decision of major importance given the 1956 and 1968 invasions of Hungary and Czechoslovakia. The second step came on 2nd November, at least as far as Hungary was concerned, came when Imre Pozsgay, as Hungarian Minister of State, met with President Bush in Washington to discuss Hungary’s transition to democracy. By November, the position in East Germany had become so bad that the government of East Berlin could think of nothing better than to allow its citizens to move freely to the West. Liberalisation in Hungary had led directly to the breaching of the Berlin Wall which came down on the night of 9 November. US officials watched closely events in central-eastern Europe as the crumbling concrete mirrored the fall of communism. On 28th November, President Bush signed into law the Support for East European Democracy (SEED) Act, authorising $938 million in aid to Hungary and Poland, now considered to be well in the lead in democratic reform. Between 1989 and 1993, the SEED Act provided more than $136 million for economic restructuring and private sector development.
Senior politicians in Hungary now talked seriously about joining the European Community, and even their jokes about joining NATO were not entirely fanciful. In the autumn of 1989, as the political parties began to lay out their programmes for the free electorate, they went beyond the ideals of “independence and neutrality” in their party platforms. The Hungarian Democratic Forum (MDF) considered…
… neutrality to beattainable as a future goal, as a consequence of which the Soviet Union could perceive a country in its immediate neighbourhood that would be politically balanced and would not threaten its security interests.
Programme declaration, 1989, of the Hungarian Democratic Forum in The Hungarian Political Yearbook, 1990 Budapest: Edited by Sándor Kurtán, et. al.
The Alliance of Free Democrats (SZDSZ) pointed out that:
We have to point out … the fact that the Warsaw Treaty is a political reality, with its complete dissolution to be comprehensive international settlement. However, we must wait until the mutual dissolution of military blocs to implement Hungary’s claim for independence. Our goal is for Hungary to quit the Warsaw Treaty. On the other hand, we wish to bring about such retirement not through a unilateral announcement but rather to obtain the consent of the parties concerned.
Programme declaration, 1989, of the Alliance of Free Democrats, in: Hungarian political yearbook, 1990. Ibid, pp 597-598.
As was expected, Viktor Orbán’s then-nascent liberal party, The Alliance of Young Democrats (FIDESZ), held the most radical view:
… we will have to review our relationship with the Soviet Union and the Warsaw Treaty. We will suggest to start immediate talks with the Soviet government on the earliest possible withdrawal of the latter’s troops from Hungary … Quitting the Warsaw Treaty and declaring the country’s independence could be imagined as maximum goals.
Programme declaration of 1989 of the Alliance of Young Democrats, in Hungarian political yearbook, 1990, p. 500
Viktor Orbán in the mid-1990s, looking to the Right.
The most cautious view was expressed by the Hungarian Socialist Party (MSZP), which had emerged as an independent party out of the former ‘Reform Wing’ of the ruling MSZMP:
Our goal is for NATO and the Warsaw Treaty to become superfluous and eligible for dissolution simultaneously and still in the course of this century. While still being a member of the Warsaw Treaty, our country wishes to promote consent among blocs in an independent manner and through its initiative, as well as the strengthening of confidence and the exemption of interstate relations from ideological divergences of view … We are concerned that belonging to an alliance system must not be a basis for interference in a country’s internal affairs.
Programme declaration, 1989, of The Hungarian Socialist Party, in: Hungarian political yearbook, 1990. p. 583.
None of these programmes involved a sudden withdrawal of Soviet forces, however, nor did they propose or envisage applying for NATO membership in the short to medium term. In the early months of 1990, there was no indication of the collapse of the Soviet Union and its empire which was soon to take place. Hungarian politicians, Orbán included, were careful not to be seen as threatening Soviet security interests. The foreign policy slogan of the change of system – “change of orientation” – however, turned more radically into reality than was previously expected. The negotiating team of the last government of the socialist system reached an agreement in Moscow on the withdrawal of troops from Hungary on 9 March 1990, a mere two weeks before the first free elections. According to the agreement, the last Soviet soldier would leave Hungary on or before 30 June 1991 (as it happened, this event took place a fortnight earlier, on 16 June 1991). Two-thirds were to be withdrawn by the end of 1990.
Above: The famous MDF (Hungarian Democratic Forum) poster from the 1990 Election Campaign: Comrades Go Home!
The Hungarian democratic transition gathered speed in the spring of 1990. When the final round of elections came, on the 8th of April 1990, the ‘Reform Communists’ or MSZP won only eight per cent of the seats (33), finishing fourth, and Pozsgay and his colleagues were out of office. A centre-right government came to power, led by the MDF, which won 164 out of 386 seats. In 1918, Hungary had emerged from an empire and found itself on its own; but now, at least, it had shown the way to the rest of Central and Eastern Europe. In May, Hungary’s National Assembly elected Árpád Göncz as its Speaker and Acting President. The candidate of the Free Democrats, Göncz had spent six years in prison for taking part in the 1956 Uprising. While still Acting President he made a private visit to Washington and met with President Bush to discuss private-sector development and democracy. He was confirmed as President in August. József Antall of the MDF became Premier. On 26 June 1990, the newly constituted multiparty parliament in Budapest requested the government to start the talks on Hungary’s withdrawal from the Warsaw Treaty.
Flushed with the refreshing feeling of sovereignty and drawing lessons from the wider international political process, in particular from the rapid change in Hungary’s security environment, the Hungarian political leaders gradually turned from the idea of neutrality to the concept of Euro-Atlantic integration. Foreign Minister Géza Jeszenszky had already become the first leading representative of a Warsaw Pact country to visit NATO Headquarters on 26-28 June. He had talks with Secretary-General Manfred Wörner, who expressed NATO’s desire to develop relations with Hungary and accepted an invitation to visit Hungary. Alongside the obvious need for a transition in international security arrangements, as democratic reform began to take hold in Hungary, the United States and other Western countries agreed to help with the tremendous financial burden of restructuring the economy and preparing the country’s markets for global integration. In October 1990, Prime Minister Antall made an official working visit to Washington. President Bush noted the resumption of American business in Hungary. He had asked Congress for $300 million in economic aid for central-eastern Europe.
From the Dissolution of the Warsaw Pact, July 1991 to NATO Accession, 1998:
At the beginning of 1991, the Warsaw Treaty itself received a mortal injury: in accordance with the agreement reached in Budapest on 25 February, the military organisation of that alliance was disbanded. Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Poland announced their withdrawal effective by the 1st of July 1991 and, in the event, the entire Warsaw Treaty expired on that date when at a final meeting in Prague, the Pact was formally disbanded. Thus, after nearly five decades of Soviet occupation, Hungarians witnessed what less than two years previously had been seemingly impossible: the dissolution of the Warsaw Pact and the removal of Soviet troops from Hungarian soil. The Hungarian National Assembly approved this fact by unanimous vote. Almost simultaneously with the Warsaw Pact, COMECON also ceased to exist. At the same time, the US Agency for International Development (USAID) opened an office in Budapest, and between 1991 and 1998 USAID provided more than $240 million in direct assistance to Hungary. Having begun the reform process among the central-eastern European states, it had regained its full national independence ahead of its own timetable as a result of the internal collapse of the Soviet Union.
With the dissolution of the Warsaw Pact and subsequently, of the Soviet Union, the bipolar world order ceased to exist, with NATO remaining the only security alliance able to effectively influence political processes. From the point of view of Hungary’s security, the Balkan conflict which broke out in 1991 and continued with varying intensity throughout the decade in the former Yugoslavia (predominantly along the Hungarian border), border incidents – albeit mostly minor – highlighted Hungary’s vulnerability in a blunt manner. The fact that in a matter of not more than two years the number of Hungary’s neighbours had increased from five to seven, out of which only two (Romania and Austria) did not undergo a radical change of state territory, proved the uncertainty of the region. There was agreement among the Hungarian political élite that the only way to break away from the disintegrating central-eastern European region was through accession to the integrating West. The reunification of Germany proved that the institutional anchoring of a former Eastern Bloc country was possible.
In October 1991, PM Antall made a private visit to Washington, where President Bush reiterated the US commitment to the economic and political transformation of Hungary, particularly in the context of the impending dissolution of the Soviet Union. Antall also expressed concern about the civil war in Yugoslavia. In October 1992, the United States announced that it would contribute an additional $900,000 to the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) to support refugees from the former Yugoslavia who had been granted asylum in Hungary.
In this rapidly changing political environment and after a certain initial uncertainty, the principle of “national consensus” in foreign-policy decision-making was accepted in Hungary by 1992. In essence, this rested on a gentlemen’s agreement by which the opposition would not overtly criticise the government in foreign and security policy and, in exchange, the government would consult with the opposition before taking important steps in foreign policy. This system of so-called six-party coordination was established in Parliament, as a consultative forum which, in contrast to the composition of the Foreign Affairs Committee of the National Assembly, was operating on the basis of parity. The basic principles of security policy were adopted unanimously by Parliament in 1993 and the basic principles of national defence based on the first document constituted the peak of that process. The elaboration of these two important parliamentary resolutions had already started back in 1990 but substantial work had not been possible due to the constant changes in the international environment and the initial distrust among the parties. The Government submitted and withdrew one draft after another until, at the beginning of 1993, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs invited one representative from all six parties represented in Parliament to elaborate on the text of the draft resolution in cooperation with the Foreign Ministry. Besides the fact that they described the security of the country in harmony with the requirements of our age, the basic principles of security policy adopted on 2nd March became the first official document targeting fully-fledged Hungarian membership of NATO:
… we are suggesting concrete co-operation in the field of foreign and security policy as well as military co-operation that would gradually lead to establish the conditions for fully-fledged membership in NATO and the Western European Union.
Resolution No. 11/1993. of the Hungarian National Assembly on the principles of the security policy of the Republic of Hungary.
The “principles of national defence” were adopted a month later (14th April) also by consensus, as well-used even more unambiguous terms:
The goal of the Republic of Hungary is to join the already existing international security organisations such as NATO and WEU as full members. Existing co-operation with NATO member countries in the fields of security policy consultations, defence management, officer training, defence industry and human conversion, science and environmental protection provide valuable support for the transformation of the Hungarian Defence Forces in accordance with our necessities and capacities and for establishing the practical requirements of accession to NATO.
Resolution No. 27/1993. of the Hungarian National Assembly on the principles of the national defence of the Republic of Hungary.
With the Cold War over and the iron curtain having been torn down, both the American and Hungarian politicians and diplomats actively engaged in redefining their relationships in this new era. In October 1993, Secretary of State Warren M. Christopher visited Hungary. He met with Foreign Minister Géza Jesszenszky and addressed the American Chamber of Commerce. During the address, he said that NATO would propose outreach to central-eastern European nations through a Partnership for Peace programme. In December 1993, Vice-President Albert Gore attended the funeral of József Antall, Hungary’s first post-Communist Premier. Participants at the NATO Summit meeting in January 1994 formally announced the Partnership for Peace programme, which provided for closer political and military cooperation with central-eastern European countries. President Clinton, accompanied by Secretary of State Christopher, then met with leaders of the Visegrád states (Hungary, Poland and Slovakia), including President Göncz and PM Péter Boross, in Prague. In early February, Hungary joined the Partnership for Peace programme.
During the NATO meeting, the Presidents of the United States, Russia, Kazakhstan, Belarus, and Ukraine signed the START1 nuclear arms reduction treaty. Hungary had signed all of the OSCE’s follow-on documents since 1989. In December 1994, President Clinton and Secretary Christopher attended a Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe summit meeting in Budapest. A decision was made to change the name of the CSCE to the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe, and to expand its responsibilities. In June 1995, Hungary signed a ‘status of forces’ agreement relating to the programme. These organisations provided a good school for Hungarian MPs in the search for consensus and foreign policy cooperation beyond party interests. Except for the delegation to the Council of Europe, the composition of the Hungarian parliamentary delegation was based on the principle of parity and the members belonging to different parties were almost always put aside their disputes were almost always able to put aside their disputes related to internal policy in the interest of a more effective representation of national interests.
The North Atlantic Assembly (NAA), a parallel forum for legislators from member countries, maintained a close working relationship with the Alliance and submitted reports and recommendations for the North Atlantic Council. It was the first Atlanticist institution to open its doors to the countries of central-eastern Europe. As early as November 1990, it had accorded the status of associate delegation to several former member states of the Warsaw Pact, including Hungary. The Hungarian National Assembly accepted the invitation in its resolution adopted on 29th January 1991 and from that time on, the six-member delegation participated fully in the NAA’s activities. In the same year, one member of the delegation was nominated as a ‘special rapporteur’, the first time a delegate from a non-member state had been given this role. By 1994, the Hungarian delegation was allowed fully-fledged participation in committee work as well, and in May 1995, the NAA held its spring meeting in Budapest, the first such meeting to take place outside NATO territory. The NAA provided an excellent means of exchanging information and know-how about NATO’s functions on the one hand, and the goals of Hungarian foreign policy on the other. It was also in 1990 that the Hungarian National Assembly could join the work of the WEU Assembly by sending two ‘special observers.’ The redefinition of the role of the WEU at that time nurtured Hungary’s hope of joining the European Community (later the EU) as well as NATO through the links with the WEU. But by the mid-nineties, Hungarian foreign policy had not reached a position where it could decide between the ‘Atlanticist’ model, seeing the WEA as NATO’s European pillar or one based on a concept of a European defence identity within the evolving European Union.
By the end of the first parliamentary cycle following the change of system in Hungary, the joint political thinking that had been crystallised with respect to Euro-Atlantic integration suffered a severe setback when the opposition Socialist Party (MSZP) expressed reservations over a selective enlargement of NATO, stressing that it could only imagine Hungary’s accession to NATO only after a referendum on the issue. This variance in approach led to the predictable reaction against ‘leftism’ in Hungarian politics in the run-up to the general election. However, following a certain amount of hesitation after the elections, the consensus was restored by the newly elected Government, led by the MSZP, which had dropped its resistance to Hungary becoming a NATO member independently of others in the region in exchange for a referendum to ratify eventual membership. In the meantime, Hungary took several practical steps to aid the mission of the Western Alliance.
At the end of November 1995, following the initialling of the Dayton Peace Accords, which ended the war in Bosnia, the Hungarian Government announced that Kaposvár in southern Hungary would become the principal supply base of the US components of the international peacekeeping force, the NATO-led Implementation Force. The Hungarian Parliament was almost unanimous in voting to allow NATO forces to use Hungarian bases, including the airfield at Taszár. From December onwards, the US First Armored Divisions passed regularly through the city of Pécs in southern Hungary en route to peacekeeping duties in Bosnia. President Clinton visited the US military personnel at the base in January 1996 and met with the Hungarian PM, Gyula Horn and the Minister of Defence.
The close working relationship between the Clinton administration and the Socialist-led Hungarian Government which developed through practical cooperation led to the transition to full membership of NATO. During the NATO Summit Meeting in Madrid in July 1997, Secretary-General Javier Salana invited Hungary, the Czech Republic and Poland to join NATO. A national referendum in Hungary approved membership on 16th November of the same year. Only 49.24% of eligible voters turned out, but of those 85.33% voted in favour of Hungary’s accession, leaving 14.67% against. It could therefore be concluded that only the staunchest opponents of the accession took part in the referendum, presumably including those opposed to accession for ideological, political and conscientious (pacifist) reasons, as well as those who were strongly attached to the notion of neutrality. Following the referendum, the acceptance of NATO accession gradually increased further to reach its peak of 63% by August 1998, while the level of opposition remained at just 16% (see the graph below).
Hungary signed the protocol for accession on 16th December 1997, and Parliament voted for membership in February 1998. In May of that year, the second round of parliamentary elections took place, bringing Viktor Orbán and his Alliance of Young Democrats (FIDESZ) – Hungarian Civic Party to power for the first time. To begin with, this did not herald a shift towards a more conservative foreign policy under Defence Minister, János Szabó, and, in any case, it was too late to reverse the decision to join NATO, even had the new government wished to do so. Furthermore, in a resolution passed on 15th October, the National Assembly agreed to consent to the use of Hungarian airspace by reconnaissance, combat and transport aircraft, in addition to helicopters taking part in NATO actions aimed at the enforcement of UN resolutions on the settlement of the crisis in Kosovo, without restrictions.
However, Hungarian public opinion was very quick in taking the country’s membership in NATO for granted. The issue rapidly disappeared from the forefront of popular attention and political discourse. Except for some unusual periods related to specific, topical and important events, such as the period immediately preceding the referendum, the issue of international security was not a significant one for the broader strata of Hungarian society. It might be argued that it has remained out of the limelight ever since, especially since the threat of the spread of war has receded, until very recently. On the list of public priorities, the matter of NATO enlargement was lower down not only than most economic, social and internal political issues but also matters related to EU integration.
The attention paid in Hungary to NATO-related subjects tends to cover, in addition to those which formerly dominated issues directly related to Hungary’s accession, more and more of the broader perspectives of the activities of the Alliance. For example, according to the last poll taken in August 1998, the Hungarian public had a positive view of NATO’s role in preventing and managing conflicts within the region. With respect to the situation in Kosovo, 55% of those asked were of the position that involvement with NATO would reduce the probability of a border conflict between Albania and Yugoslavia, and could prevent the outbreak of a civil war in Kosovo. The remaining 45% were equally divided between the disapproving and the undecided. By comparison, according to the USIA Survey, the number of those replying positively to the same question equated to 56% in Poland, 51% in the Czech Republic, 66% in Romania, 70% in Slovenia and 85% in Croatia. But support for Hungarian participation in such actions was substantially smaller, and while the overwhelming majority accepted that Hungarian airspace should be made available, only 46% were supportive, and an identical percentage opposed the participation of a Hungarian engineering contingent in the SFOR-mission in Bosnia. Even fewer, only 28%, agreed with Hungarian military participation in Kosovo, while 64% were opposed to such a deployment.
This data regarding public opinion on NATO provided an early warning to PM Orbán and other potential leaders about the political perils of ignoring the attitudes of voters towards the active military deployment of Hungarian forces. As far as NATO enlargement was concerned, however, public opinion was generally supportive of the potential membership of neighbouring countries and even the Baltic states. It was clearly seen as being in Hungary’s interests for these countries to comply as soon as possible with the expectations and accession criteria of both the Alliance and the EU.
The End of Foreign Policy Consensus: The Balkans, the European Union, Iraq & Afghanistan, 1999-2009:
In the decade following the end of the Cold War, the last of the twentieth century, the Hungarian people were finally able to redefine their country’s place in the global community, concluding with In the second decade, Hungary began the process of reintegrating itself into a new, unified Europe. The road back to Europe culminated on 1 May 2004, when Hungary joined the European as a full member.
The post-Cold War era brought new levels of cooperation between European nations, including those of central-eastern Europe, as they joined together to support democracy and the rule of law and, especially after the attacks on the USA on 11th September 2001, to work together to combat the threat of global terrorism. There were also threats from epidemics and international crime. Secretary of State Madelaine K. Albright, herself a refugee from central Europe during the Second World War, and a noted scholar, visited Hungary in December 2000 and met with PM Orbán. She was awarded an honorary degree by Szeged University.
In a sign of the close bilateral relationship with the US, and its multi-lateral relationships through NATO, in January 2003, Hungary was one of eight central-eastern European states whose leaders signed a letter endorsing US policy during the Iraq crisis. During the early stages of the war, Hungary invited the US Army to train Free Iraqi Forces as guides, translators and security personnel at the Taszár airbase. It also committed a transportation company of three hundred soldiers to a multinational division stationed in central Iraq. On 17th June 2004, Hungary sustained its first combat casualties when a roadside bomb (IED) killed one soldier and wounded another, south of Baghdad. Less than a week later, PM Péter Medgyessy made a working visit to Washington and assured President George W Bush that Hungary would keep its troops in Iraq. Secretary of State Powell visited Hungary in October to thank Hungary for its support of the coalition and to encourage its continued participation. The Hungarian Government also donated seventy-seven tanks to the Free Iraqi military. Although the mandate for the Hungarian forces in Iraq expired at the end of the year, Powell convinced the Hungarian Government to renew its soldiers’ mandate so that they would remain until after the pivotal Iraqi elections in December.
In early November, PM Ferenc Gyurcsány proposed to Parliament that Hungary would not withdraw its troops until the end of March 2005. The Fidesz-led opposition opposed the proposal, breaking the security consensus which had existed since 1990, but Parliament voted by 191 to 159 to support the extension. However, the vote fell short of the required two-thirds majority, the Government was forced to terminate the mission at the end of the year and on 20th December it withdrew its troops from Iraq. But the Gyurcsány Government continued to work with the Allies to provide alternative assistance to Iraq, including participation in the NATO Training Mission there, and also stepped up its participation in other military missions. In 2005, it augmented its contingent in the Balkan peacekeeping missions to a 450-strong force. In August 2005, it also sent a reconnaissance team of a hundred and twenty troops to Afghanistan, along with medical and administrative personnel. In 2006, Hungary assumed the leadership of a Provincial Reconstruction Team(PRT) in northern Afghanistan as part of the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) operations.
In June 2006, President G. W. Bush visited Hungary to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the 1956 Uprising and Hungary’s ongoing efforts to strengthen global democracy. During his visit, he made a speech on Gellért Hill in Buda in which he said:
The lesson of 1956 is clear: Liberty can be delayed but it cannot be denied. The desire for liberty is universal because it is written by our Creator into the hearts of every man, woman and child on this Earth. And as people across the world sep forward to claim their own freedom, they will take inspiration from Hungary’s example, and draw hope from your success.… Hungary represents the triumph of liberty over tyranny, and America is proud to call Hungary a friend.
As part of their commitment to NATO, the US and Hungary continued to stand ‘shoulder-to-shoulder’ in the global war on terror. In November 2007, Hungarian Defence Minister Imre Szekeres announced Hungary’s latest contribution to this mission. A sixteen-nation consortium of NATO allies, plus two non-NATO states, selected the airport at Papa to host their strategic airlift fleet of three C-17 transport aircraft beginning in late 2008. Papa’s airport was supposed to play an important role in transporting logistics materials and provisions in response to worldwide crisis situations. It was a further demonstration of the excellent security cooperation that existed between the US, NATO and Hungary before the ‘second coming’ of Viktor Orbán in 2006. On the ‘eve’ of his advent to power, Marc J Susser, the US Department of State’s official historian concluded his study of US-Hungarian relations with the following comment:
Today, the two countries share a commitment to democracy, economic progress, and educational and cultural development. Shaped by a common experience of breaking free from an empire, the two countries have developed strong political, economic and cultural ties, marked by mutual respect. … relations between the United States and Hungary continue to improve, as Hungary continues to move ahead with its national commitment to democracy, the rule of law and a market economy.
Mark J. Susser (2007), The United States & Hungary, Paths of Diplomacy, 1848-2006. Washington: Bureau of Public Affairs, United States Department of State, p. 96.
The Reversal of Euro-Atlantic Integration, 2009-2019:
Since 2006, and especially since the beginning of his third term in 2014 in his sixteen-year rule in Hungary, Viktor Orbán has gradually returned his country to the Russian ‘sphere of influence’ and away from its supposed allies in the Euro-Atlantic Alliance. Following the flood of Syrian refugees crossing Hungary to seek asylum in other EU member states, such as Germany, in the summer of 2015, he began to criticise the management of the crisis by the EU institutions and member states, especially Germany.
Putin and Orbán in 2017.
By his own admission, Orbán is only worried about the fight against the EU as an institution that seeks to replace the nation-state. He is driven not by the healthy resurgence of national identity and patriotism in Hungary but seeks to pervert it into an authoritarian ‘nation-statism’ that belongs to the Horthy Era (1 March 1920 – 15 October 1944, see insert below) in recent Hungarian history, if not to the late nineteenth century when the country was finally emerging from its first general crisis. Orbán’s basic concept and strategy for European unity start from his observation that the EU is wealthy but weak. This, he suggests, is the worst possible combination… one that is acutely vulnerable to the single greatest threat confronting Europe – and Hungary. It is a threat, he claims, which is undermining his country’s financial stability and its precarious achievement in modernising the economy.
If the EU is wealthy but weak, Hungary is both poor and weak, with its wealth increasingly concentrated in the hands of an ever-decreasing oligarchy. The hard-working middle classes are reminded that they have his government to thank for its nationalist foreign policy (influence over its neighbours in and surrounding the Carpathian basin with Hungarian minorities), its restoration of ‘law and order’, ‘public safety against terrorism’ and its national culture that has slowly begun to flourish again after the long years of Communist sterility. The threat to all this comes, not from within, which has seen Hungary under his watch being returned to being one of the most corrupt nations in Europe, but from outside, from mass migration and its ‘mismanagement’ by the institutions ofthe European Union. On the significance of the Brexit vote, he drew his conclusion that…
… there used to be little doubt that the European Union was a major actor in global politics, capable of influencing developments not only back home but in remote corners of the globe. The secession of the UK marks the end of that era. The EU’s influence is even weakening closer to home, as it is apparent in the conflict in Ukraine.
Viktor Orbán (2017), Hungary and the Crisis of Europe.
Yet, for all that we might worry about the effect of ‘Brexit’ on European integration, the early signs are that it will, paradoxically, strengthen the Atlantic Alliance which Hungary was so proud to become a member of earlier this century before it joined the EU.
In 2018, after securing a fourth consecutive term, Viktor Orbán turned his wrath on Ukraine, which had introduced a new law to ensure that the Ukrainian language was used as the main medium of instruction throughout the country. About a third of the people of Transcarpathia, over the Ukrainian border from Hungary, are Hungarian speakers. The new law did not exclude the use of other first languages like Russian and Hungarian in schools or elsewhere, but Orbán found common cause with President Putin in opposing the new law as a pretext for involvement in Ukraine’s internal affairs. This became related to Ukraine’s desire to join NATO in 2019 when Hungary declared its opposition to Ukraine’s membership of the Alliance and announced that it would seek to block it. Russia had already illegally occupied and annexed Crimea in 2014, and supported the Russian-speaking separatist forces in their paramilitary campaigns in the Donbas and other regions of eastern Ukraine, supporting them with arms and troops (allegedly providing trading) and enabling them to gain control of a large part of these regions. Until the beginning of the current Russian attacks on Ukraine and the NATO condemnation of them, Orbán did not criticise Russian actions and, even now, he is refusing to allow military equipment and supplies to transit Hungary and cross its border with Ukraine. He has also proved extremely reluctant to apply agreed EU sanctions and claims that Hungary can remain ‘neutral’ whilst also remaining a full member of NATO. According to the Treaty, of course, there is no such status.
For some time now, it has appeared to be Hungary and others among the Visegrád countries who have deliberately sought to undermine the efforts of NATO and the EU to deal with Russian aggression in Ukraine, and to prevent them from sending clear signals to Putin about the independence of the Baltic states within the NATO-EU ‘umbrella.’ As he rightly admits, Hungary has benefited under this umbrella in the not-too-distant past, especially during the wars in former Yugoslavia, but more recently – under his rule – it has contributed very little. The Hungarian government will have to make up its mind in the near future whether it wishes to continue its commitment to NATO, as well as to the EU. To many Western observers, it seems that it wants to keep the resources from the west and east alike, but does not want to keep up its commitments as a member of these ‘clubs’.
Sources:
Rudolf Joó (ed.) (1999), Hungary: A Member of NATO. Budapest: Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Hungary.
Viktor Orbán (2017), Hungary and the Crisis of Europe, in Gyula Kodalányi (ed.), Hungarian Review, Volume VIII, No.1, January 2017. Budapest: Danube Institute.
Mark J. Susser (2007), The United States & Hungary, Paths of Diplomacy, 1848-2006. Washington: Bureau of Public Affairs, United States Department of State.
In a letter of 10th March, H.H. Patriarch Kirill ‘of Moscow and all Russia’ replied to a letter sent on 2nd March by World Council of Churches (WCC) acting general secretary Rev. Prof. Dr Ioan Sauca asking the Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church to mediate so that the war can be stopped. His letter repeated the claims recently made in a newspaper article written by Russian President, Vladimir Putin, with whom the Patriarch is said to have a ‘close relationship’. In his letter, he did not undertake to mediate in order to stop the war but accused ‘Western leaders’ of bringing suffering not only to the Russian political or military leaders but specifically to the Russian people. He went on to assert that Russophobia is spreading across the Western world at an unprecedented pace. On the more recent causes of the conflict he wrote:
The origins of the confrontation lie in the relationships between the West and Russia. By the 1990s Russia had been promised that its security and dignity would be respected. However, as time went by, the forces overtly considering Russia to be their enemy came close to its borders. Year after year, month after month, the NATO member states have been building up their military presence, disregarding Russia’s concerns that these weapons may one day be used against it.
Moreover, the political forces which make it their aim to contain Russia were not going to fight against it themselves. They were planning to use other means, having tried to make the brotherly peoples – Russians and Ukrainians – enemies. They spared no effort, no funds to flood Ukraine with weapons and warfare instructors. Yet, the most terrible thing is not the weapons, but the attempt to “re-educate,” to mentally remake Ukrainians and Russians living in Ukraine into enemies of Russia.
Pursuing the same end was the church schism created by Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople in 2018. It has taken its toll on the Ukrainian Orthodox Church.
As far back as 2014, when blood was being shed in Kiev’s Maidan and there were first victims, the WCC expressed its concern. Dr Olav Fykse Tveit, the WCC General Secretary at the time, said on March 3, 2014, “The World Council of Churches is deeply concerned by the current dangerous developments in Ukraine. The situation puts many innocent lives in grave jeopardy. And like a bitter wind from the Cold War, it risks further undermining the international community’s capacity to act now or in the future on the many urgent issues that will require a collective and principled response.”
That was also when an armed conflict broke out in the Donbas region, whose population was defending their right to speak the Russian language, demanding respect for their historical and cultural tradition. However, their voices went unheard, just as thousands of victims among the Donbas population went unnoticed in the Western world.
This tragic conflict has become a part of the large-scale geopolitical strategy aimed, first and foremost, at weakening Russia.
/+KIRILL/ PATRIARCH OF MOSCOW AND ALL RUSSIA
Source: History Today. Catherine the Great, depicted above, was the founder of the Modern Russian Empire into which most of Ukraine was annexed in 1796.
In my first article on this subject matter, I wrote about the historical inaccuracies contained in Patriarch Kirill’s letter regarding the Medieval and Early Modern relations between the Kyivan Rus, ‘Ukraine’ and its neighbours, including the ‘Rus’, modern Russia and other ‘neighbours’ including Cossacks, Lithuanians and Poles. In this second article on the History of Ukraine, besides giving a factual account of relations between the country, Russia and ‘the West’ over the course of the previous two centuries, I also want to address the two further ‘justifications’ given by Patriarch Kirill, above, and President Putin that it is ‘the West’ in general and NATO, in particular, that has brought about Russia’s cataclysmic war with Ukraine through provocative military actions, and that those leading the Ukrainian resistance to Russians are the inheritors of a form of Nazism.
Napoleonic & Nation-State Europe in the Nineteenth Century:
To understand the contemporary history of Russian-Ukrainian relations, we need to look back to the time of the third partition of Poland in 1795, and to the effects of Emperor Napoleon’s conquests on central-eastern Europe before his defeat in Russia in 1812. At the time, Ukraine was an integral and significant part of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. Since 1789, Europe had undergone a generation-long convulsion that had left nothing untouched. Old states had been abolished and the world of the ancient régime was gone forever.
Napoleonic Europe in 1812.
While Napoleon concentrated his efforts on conquering both Western and Central Europe after 1799, the Tsar asserted Russian power in the Baltic and against Turkey. Alexander I, who became Tsar after the assassination of his father, Paul I in 1801, at first opposed France, but after the defeat of the Austro-Russian army at Austerlitz in 1805, and the Prussian-Russian force at Friedland in 1806, his mood changed. Following his treaty with Napoleon at Tilsit in 1807, the boundary between the French conquests and Russia, Europe was divided into spheres of influence. Napoleon gave the Tsar the district around Belostok and in return, the Tsar accepted the existence of the Grand Duchy of Warsaw, a potential threat to Russia’s Polish lands. After Napoleon’s crushing defeat of Prussia in the autumn of 1806 and his rapprochement with Alexander I at Tilsit in 1807, Poland’s chances of regaining its independence barely a decade after its extirpation by the Third Partition seemed strong. Napoleon’s establishment of the Grand Duchy composed of territories taken from Prussia’s share of the last partition was meant as punishment for his enemies, but he showed no inclination to permit a genuinely independent Poland. Thus, after Austria’s defeat by Napoleon in 1809, it lost West Galicia to the Grand Duchy.
In 1809, Sweden was forced to cede Finland to the Tsar, though Alexander and his successors ruled it as a separate Grand Duchy with its own laws. The Tsar’s forces then occupied largely Romanian-speaking Bessarabia and forced the Sultan to give it to Russia in 1812. Up to this point, Napoleon had been content to leave Russia to its own devices, and Russia was in any case distracted by its war with Turkey. But nothing could disguise Napoleon’s determination to draw Russia into his Continental System, designed to choke Britain’s trade with Europe. Finally, in 1812, Napoleon lost patience and made the ill-fated decision to invade Russia. Prussia and Austria bided their time and waited to see how the invasion would turn out.
From 1812, with Napoleon’s catastrophic defeat in Russia, in which his army of six hundred thousand vanished into the steppe and the snow, the defeat of Napoleonic France suddenly became a probability. Driven out of Spain and then defeated by a coalition army at Leipzig in 1813, in 1815 the Imperial French forces suffered their final defeat at Waterloo in Belgium. Yet, although the representatives of the victorious powers who had assembled in Vienna to determine the future of Europe were joined by a common desire to restore the world lost after 1789, they were forced to recognise that no such course was open to them in practice. Thus, the Holy Roman Empire and its constellation of feudal principalities and mini-states were summarily abolished by Napoleon in 1806 was not restored. Instead, they drafted the boundaries of a thirty-nine member German Confederation, paying lip service to the notion of a common German identity that had been so strongly displayed during the war of liberation against Bonaparte after 1812. Yet the ‘new order’ established at Vienna was also profoundly conservative and the victorious allies agreed to meet periodically to settle any disputes which might threaten the peace and their hegemony as a guarantor of this. This “Congress System” proved inadequate for dealing with the crises that arose after 1815. It soon became clear that it had only been the overwhelming threat of Napoleonic France that had kept the Allies united. The disappearance of that threat after Waterloo revealed the continuing rivalries and differing interests of the four Great Powers who had vanquished it. Nevertheless, the boundaries established between them in 1815 proved remarkably stable over the next century, especially when compared with the twenty years of turbulence that had preceded the Congress.
Napoleon’s eventual defeat in 1815 meant a restoration of tripartite control of Poland by Russia, Austria and Prussia. The new division of spoils gave west Poland and Gdansk to Prussia while Austria surrendered its claim to West Galicia, which in common with the remainder of the Grand Duchy came under Russian hegemony, in exchange for Tarnopol. Alexander ruled this so-called “Congress Kingdom” of Poland as just another part of his empire, despite its constitution which made it a personal union with Russia. But it was the decay of Ottoman power in Europe during the nineteenth century which was the key factor in destabilising post-Napoleonic Europe. Moldavia and Wallachia were the first to rebel against Turkish rule in 1821, with the encouragement of Alexander I’s Greek minister, Capodistria. Despite the failure of these uprisings, the Greeks then started a more effective rebellion, backed by idealists such as the English poet Lord Byron. The British, French and Russians sought to temper Turkish reprisals for these revolts, leading to the annihilation of the Ottoman fleet at the decisive battle of Navarino in 1827, which cleared the way for an independent Greece to finally re-emerge in 1830. By then, Moldavia and Wallachia had become autonomous in 1829, emerging as the United Provinces in 1859, having also gained a part of Bessarabia from Russia in 1856, giving them access to the Black Sea. The provinces became Romania in 1861.
The Eastern Balkans and the Black Sea, 1815-61.
The great Polish rebellion of 1831 was easily defeated by the Russian army and provided Alexander’s successor, Nicholas I, with an excuse to tighten his control. The ancient university city of Cracow survived 1815 as the Republic of Cracow, the last remnant of self-governed Polish territory until 1847, when Austria annexed it in agreement with Russia and Prussia, despite the protests of France and Britain. In 1848, a series of revolutions rapidly engulfed Austria and Hungary and spread throughout Central Europe. They had, however, retained sufficient power to hold the line in 1848-49, albeit at great cost and in part because of the divisions within liberal-nationalist ranks. But relations between Vienna and St Petersburg cooled rapidly, opening the way for Emperor Napoleon III’s campaigns against Russia. These, and the strains imposed on the Russians in fighting the Crimean War (1854-56, shown on the maps below) against a coalition of France, Britain and Turkey, showed that neither the Habsburgs nor the Russian Tsar remained strong enough to preserve the Vienna system by force.
‘The Charge of the Light Brigade’ at the Battle of Balaclava in a contemporary painting.
In addition to her gains in Poland, Catherine II (‘the Great’) had acquired Crimea (1783) and Odesa (1794). The primary aim of the Romanovs was to secure access to the seas through ports that were open to navigation all year round. Throughout the first half of the nineteenth-century Russian policy aimed at continuing the drive toward the Mediterranean and gaining control of the Straits at Constantinople. This desire resulted in the Crimean War and British intervention in the Russo-Turkish War of 1877. Russia also claimed to be the protector of Orthodox Christians in the Turkish Empire, a claim that was rejected by Turkey. The British Government was forced to act by public opinion at home when Russia destroyed the Turkish fleet at Sinope. The allies, principally France and Great Britain, determined to destroy the naval station at Sebastopol and all the fighting was concentrated around this port. The allied troops were landed at Eupatori, marched southwards and met the Russians at the River Alma. Though victorious, they neglected to make a further speedy attack on Sebastopol, which was strongly fortified. To prevent a naval attack on the harbour the Russians sank some ships at the entrance. The siege lasted a year, from September 1854 to September 1855, during which time the Russian armies made three attempts to relieve the port, attempts which were repelled by the British at Balaclava and Inkerman, and by the Sardinians and French at Tchernaya.
Serfdom had disappeared in Prussia after 1807 and was abolished in the Austro-Hungarian Empire in 1848. As the map above shows, The 1861 abolition of serfdom in the Russian Empire was supposed to ‘liberate’ more than forty million peasants, but the system of the ‘mir’ was retained (collective ownership of fields and responsibility for the individual in the community). At the same time, there was the promotion of secondary and primary public education and a university statute granting academic autonomy and also easing press censorship. Nevertheless, the hoped-for easing of social tensions did not come about. The peasantry, increasing in numbers, suffered because of a lack of landholdings and high levels of debt to the landlords; the peasantry was not trained in the independent administration of their holdings, which led to relatively low yields at a time of increasing tax burdens. The ultimate result was unrest and in 1863 there were serious political uprisings followed by an assassination attempt on the tsar in 1866 intensified the autocratic reaction as well as the revolutionary movement of the intelligentsia.
By the 1856 Peace of Paris, Russia lost control of the Danube delta and the neutrality of the Black Sea was guaranteed. This led to the transfer of Russian hegemony to France, but it also led to tensions between Austria and Russia in the Balkans. The Crimean War also exposed the backwardness of the administration, economy and army of the Russian Empire. In particular, serfdom obstructed any form of progress, whether in the moderate form of a head tax or the often arbitrary form of corvées. Alexander II decided on an autocratic revolution from above, to eliminate the powder keg within the state. After the Crimean War had checked Russian ambitions of reaching the Mediterranean, the Russians redirected the ambitions toward Persia and the Middle East, Afghanistan, Manchuria and the Far East. These expansionist moves led to further clashes with Britain until 1907, because they seemed to threaten British interests in India (the Afghan Wars) and China, leading to the Anglo-Japanese Alliance of 1902.
Florence Nightingale, the ‘founder’ of modern nursing and the Red Cross at work in the military hospital at Scutari.
The Rivalry & Clashes of Empires, 1871-1914:
The European Empires of 1871
The years 1871 to 1914 saw Imperial Europe at its zenith. Outside Europe, all the Great Powers bar Austria-Hungary but including Italy, established empires that extended across the globe; within Europe, they co-existed uneasily. Russia considered it essential that no other power achieved a position from which it could control the straits at Constantinople, through which passed most of the grain on which its economy, and hence her Great Power status, depended. Russia’s fundamental motive may thus have been defensive, but in practice, it varied between attempting to stabilise Ottoman rule and overthrowing it in the hope of replacing the empire with a string of submissive satellites. To Habsburg Austria-Hungary, Russia’s efforts seemed a dangerously threatening attempt to encircle the Habsburg monarchy with a crowd of irredentist Slav states under Russian protection. As revolts against Ottoman rule spread through the Balkans in the mid-1870s, Austria was reassured by St Petersburg’s acceptance that no new large Christian state should be created that might thwart Austria’s ambitions.
Map showing the formation of the two groups of European Powers, the Triple Alliance and the Triple Entente, before the Great War of 1914-18. These sketch maps were first published in 1936 (see below for details of sources)
But by 1877 Russian public opinion had pushed the Tsar into was in support of the Orthodox Christian Slav rebels. Under the Treaty of San Stefano in 1878 which concluded the war, the Russians chose to create a “Big Bulgaria” stretching across the southern Balkans. To Austria-Hungary and Britain, this seemed like the creation of a Russian puppet-state, which also left Constantinople vulnerable to attack. The Chancellor of the newly united Germany, Otto von Bismarck, stepped in to separate his two imperial allies before a further war broke out. The Treaty of Belin (1878) overturned much of the San Stefano agreements and preserved a pretence of Turkish suzerainty over a much-reduced Bulgarian principality. But however understandable the failure to grasp the Balkan nettle at the Berlin Conference, the problems of the region’s numerous ethnic, nationalist, imperialist and religious rivalries festered unchecked into the next century.
Imperial Eastern Europe and the Mediterranean
The boundaries between the Great Powers changed little in the century after the Congress of Vienna. Germany, although now united, Austria-Hungary and Russia still shared largely the same frontiers as those established at Vienna, and most observers could be forgiven for regarding them as permanent. But in practice, the emergence of small states on the periphery of the Powers, allied to tensions created by conflicting aspirations for autonomy and independence on the part of the many ethnic groups within the Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires, marked the beginnings of a process that threatened those empires’ territorial integrity. In tandem with the Great Power rivalry, it created the pre-conditions that were to lead to the cataclysms of the First World War. Whatever its problems with regional nationalism, Russia, for its part, at least had a majority ethnic group. Both Austria-Hungary and Russia sought to increase their influence in central and eastern Europe.
A ‘Serio-comic’ map of Europe, 1899, reproduced by courtesy of the Trustees of the British Museum.
By the end of the nineteenth century, when the comic map above was published, parts of Europe had been transformed by a different kind of revolution than those of the first half of the century, an industrial one, like the one that Britain had begun to experience in the second half of the previous century.
The Russian Empire was catching up with the other empires. Taking coal production as an example, although by 1900 it was still only half that of French production, the increase in Russia’s growth since 1860 had reached 170 per cent, while French growth had slowed to twenty-eight per cent and Britain’s growth was at twenty-four per cent. In the late nineteenth century, Europe’s influence on the world at large seemed greater than ever. But the large-scale development of industry, the growth in towns, as shown on the map below, and the building of the railways also brought serious problems across the continent, as they had in Britain earlier in the century. Nevertheless, they also brought increased wealth and power. In Ukraine, the Donbas coalfield and the Yuzovka iron and steelworks led the way in the Imperial Russian Empire (see appendix one below for a case study of this). This European industrial supremacy did not last for much longer. By 1914, the USA was producing more iron and steel than the whole of Europe put together.
With Britain’s abandonment of its role as protector of the Turkish Sultan, a policy intended chiefly to contain Russian ambitions, the way was left open for Serbia, Bulgaria and Greece to attack Turkey in 1912, but dividing the spoils of this first Balkan War proved harder and led to a second war the following year. But it was the involvement of all these Empires which turned a regional conflict into a pan-European war. Especially after Austria’s annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina in 1908, Russia was determined to resume its role as the protector of Orthodox Christians in the Balkans and central-eastern Europe, if necessary against the Catholic Habsburgs rather than Muslim Turkey. With Austria and Russia members of two rival alliance systems, the Triple Alliance and the Triple Entente, their rivalry in the Balkans threatened to suck all the Imperial Powers of Europe into military conflict. Although Italy was also, originally, part of the Triple Alliance, it also had claims on Habsburg territories up to the Alps and along the Dalmatian coast, and, as it turned out, was not a reliable ally. Romania was also allied to them but was obviously not a great power. Austria and Germany could not afford to abandon each other, therefore, even at the risk of a general European war.
Central-Eastern Europe on the Eve of the First World War.
The First World War & its Aftermath in Central/ Eastern Europe:
Austria’s declaration of war on Serbia in July 1914 following the Serbian-sponsored assassination of the Habsburg Archduke Ferdinand in Sarajevo the previous month was the spark that lit the global conflagration which was referred to at the time as ‘the Great War.’ Once the Tsar had ordered a general mobilisation, there was little chance of extinguishing it, especially after Germany’s determination to smash through the Triple Entente that encircled it. If war did come, the Kaiser’s generals wanted it sooner rather than later: they were increasingly confident that they could defeat both France and Russia. However, by choosing to attack France first, through neutral Belgium, the Kaiser and his generals miscalculated, especially since they did not expect Britain to enter the war. While the Germans advanced into Belgium, the Russians, as they had promised the French, invaded East Prussia. An army of ten divisions advanced into the province from the east: another of the same size attacked from the south. The first actions went in the Russians’ favour, and two generals, Hindenburg and Ludendorff were ordered to Prussia to halt their advance. At Tannenburg, Ludendorff achieved a classic envelopment and almost completely destroyed the southern Russian force. Then he redeployed against the eastern army and drove it out of Prussia with crippling loss. The Austrians, who also had two fronts, launched their main offensive in a move north from Galicia into Russian Poland, but were caught sideways by the Russian counter-attack, a straight drive into Galicia from the east; despite German support, the Austrians were unable to recover and by the end of 1914 the whole of Galicia was in Russian hands.
In May 1915, a German force sent by Falkenhayn smashed through the Russian line in western Galicia. It then became the southern arm of a vast pincer movement against Russian Poland, the northern arm being provided by Hindenburg and Ludendorff striking south from East Prussia. By early August the Germans were in Warsaw; by early September they were masters of the whole of Russian Poland. In 1916, the Germans could always break through the Russian line if they wanted to and the Russians could punch a hole in the Austro-Hungarian front. Brusilov, the Russian commander in the south, did just that and was rewarded with a progressive collapse of the Austro-Hungarian armies in this sector that produced one of the most spectacular victories of the war. Czech and Slovene units had always performed reluctantly on the Russian front; now they simply threw away their weapons and ran. The Russians took a quarter of a million of them prisoner in the course of an advance that carried across the eastern half of Galicia. Other events of significance in 1916 included a major Russian advance in Caucasia and Germany’s creation of a Polish kingdom out of the Russian-occupied territories conquered by them, though they didn’t give this kingdom any of German Poland. Neither did it have a king.
The Russian Empire’s war effort was in serious if not terminal decline by the early months of 1917 and it was clear that before long, Germany would be able to dictate terms to it. The Russian peasantry had realised that the paper money the government was printing to pay for the war was in fact worthless. When they refused to accept it any longer, the towns got no food. In March (February in the Russian calendar), there were riots in Petrograd (formerly St Petersburg); when troops were called in to put down the rioters, they joined them instead. Liberal politicians formed a parliamentary government and ‘soviets’ (trades’ councils) were set up among factory workers. Unlike after the 1905 revolution, however, the Tsar was forced to abdicate. Russia’s new leaders were quick to assure the British and French that they would honour the Entente, and that the war would go on, but the capacity to wage war was no longer there: the support systems had disintegrated and the troops wouldn’t fight any longer. The country drifted miserably along, its leaders helpless, their authority steadily waning. As the map below shows, the Germans were making additional progress on the eastern front, especially in Galicia and Livonia.
The Bolshevik Revolution, & the ‘Peace of Bread’, 1917-18:
Lenin was the first and founding head of government of Soviet Russia from 1917 to 1924 and of the Soviet Union from 1922 to 1924.
Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov, better known by his alias Lenin, was a ‘man with a plan’, or rather a definite programme. When he arrived in Petrograd in April, from a lengthy Swiss exile, to assume the leadership of the ‘Bolsheviks’, Lenin insisted that peace should be their top priority, and he meant peace at any price. His supporters heard his views with dismay, his enemies with scorn, while the Kerensky government branded him a traitor so that he had to go into hiding. Over the next six months, however, the Petrograd Soviet came to see that this was exactly what the country and the revolution needed. In November (October in Russia), detachments of armed workers swept the Liberal government aside and put Lenin and the Bolsheviks in power. True to his word, he immediately asked the Germans for an armistice.
Lev Davidovich Bronstein, better known as Leon Trotsky, was a Ukrainian-Russian Marxist revolutionary.
Even as the terms were being discussed, the Germans were advancing towards St Petersburg. From 22nd December onward, Leon Trotsky conducted the peace negotiations as the representative of Russia, declaring an end to the war without accepting the German conditions. On the 10th, he briefly broke off negotiations and resumed the war, with the ‘rail offensive’. The Peace terms that Germany subsequently offered Lenin in March were very harsh: Russia would have to give up all claims to Poland, Lithuania and Finland and agree to make Ukraine independent. Lenin had already recognised Finland’s independence and was prepared to see Poland and Lithuania go too. They weren’t ethnically Russian and he believed in the principle of self-determination.
But when it came to Ukraine, even he had difficulty in giving it up, believing, like all Russians, that it was an integral part of the ‘Motherland’. Still, if this was the added price of peace, he was prepared to pay that too, and the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk (in Western Ukraine, see below) was signed in March, finally ending Imperial Russia’s war.
By August 1918, the Germans upped the price of peace still further: they wanted the rest of the Baltic provinces to be made independent, together with Georgia. Lenin gave way again, and when the Treaty of Berlin was signed that month, the former Russian Empire had lost a third of its productive land and a third of its people. With the exception of Georgia and the bulk of Ukraine, all these territories remained independent until at least 1939. Lenin hoped that some, at least, of the territories he ceded would maintain formal links with Soviet Russia, an idea wasn’t in itself naive – Finland, for example, would probably have ended the war as a communist state had the Germans not sent troops there to help the ‘White’ reactionaries to defeat the Reds (Bolsheviks). What was naive was to believe that the Germans wouldn’t intervene in this way. German forces quickly occupied all the ceded areas and made them into dependencies. Estonia, Livonia and Kurland were all earmarked for eventual annexation: Finland, Lithuania, Poland, Ukraine and Georgia would retain a degree of autonomy. No final decision was taken about Crimea or Bessarabia, the latter having already been annexed by Romania in April 1918 in compensation for their losses elsewhere, most noticeably in Dobruja, which had been divided between Germany and Bulgaria at Brest-Litovsk. By the Treaty of Bucharest (May 1918), Romania ceded Dobruja to Bulgaria and allowed their oil reserves to be exploited by Germany. Finally, after the breakthrough in Macedonia by the Allies in September, the Bulgarian army collapsed and an armistice was concluded at the end of October. By the Treaty of Neuilly the next year, Bulgaria lost all the territories it had recently acquired but retained access to the Black Sea at Alexandroupolis.
The Germans actually occupied considerably more Russian territory than they were entitled to under the terms of Brest-Litovsk. They took Belorussia simply to shorten their lines, but in the Black Sea region, where they advanced to the lower Don River and crossed from the Crimea to the Taman Peninsula, clearly aiming at taking over permanently. In due course, they would doubtless have extracted the third round of concessions from the Bolshevik government. Soviet power in this south-eastern area was then at a very low ebb. The Don Cossacks were refusing to accept the authority of Moscow, which had become the Soviet seat of government in March when Lenin decided that the Germans were getting too close to Petrograd. The anti-Soviet or ‘White’ forces that were rallying to the flag of General Denikin were proving more than a match for local Bolsheviks and, in Caucasia, in the far south, the Turks had reoccupied the towns they had lost in 1878 by the terms of the Berlin Treaty, together with everything else that German forces hadn’t already ‘nailed down. The two treaties, deeply unfavourable to Russia, revealed the shape of Europe Berlin hoped would be the outcome of the war. Germany’s subsequent defeat was to mean that little could be done to exploit the territories lost by Russia. Nonetheless, the German desire to lay claim to the resources of this vast region foreshadowed Hitler’s obsession with it twenty years later. By November, General Denkin was in complete control of the Kuban area: his success marks the formal opening of the Civil War between ‘Whites’ and ‘Reds’.
In February 1918, ‘The Peace of Bread’ was concluded by Germany, Austria-Hungary and Turkey, with Ukraine. This involved the recognition of the Ukrainian state, Ukrainian autonomy in Eastern Galicia, in exchange for the delivery of grain supplies to the Central Powers. By November 1918, when the armistice in the West was signed, General Denkin was in complete control of the Kuban area (as shown on the map below): his success marks the formal opening of the Civil War between ‘Whites’ and ‘Reds’. During the Armistice negotiations the Allies had insisted on the Germans withdrawing from their conquests in the east; the unwelcome result of this was that the Soviet forces occupied the Baltic states and Ukraine. The Allied reaction was to beef up the White forces – General Yudenich’s army in Estonia as well as General Denikin’s in the south – and support them in counter-offensives that by October 1919 had taken Yudenich halfway to Petrograd and Denikin more than halfway to Moscow. At the same time, the Poles occupied as much of Western Russian territories as they could.
Civil War, the Creation of the USSR & Inter-War Poland:
In Russia, 1918 had seen the formation of socially and politically diverse anti-Bolshevik groups (the ‘Whites’). They fought against the Red Army, organised by Trotsky. They fought in Siberia and the Ural-Volga area in the south. To safeguard their interests, the Allies landed their troops in Vladivostock, Murmansk, Archangel and all the ports on the Black Sea. In 1919, the Whites rejected President Wilson’s proposal for a conference of all Russian parties. By 1920, in any case, the Allies had withdrawn their troops and the evacuation of the last ‘White’ troops from Crimea had taken place. The Bolsheviks had cleared the country of the armies of foreign states and Lenin had supreme power. His aim was to create a world revolution, but he had first to reshape ‘Greater Russia’ itself. Conditions in town and country alike were appalling. His chief difficulty was to satisfy the peasants, who resisted attempts to confiscate their harvests. Famines in 1920 and 1921 compelled him to make concessions in order to restore some measure of prosperity to the country. By his New Economic Policy, announced in 1921, a certain amount of private trading in both town and country. By the Rapallo Treaty of 1922, Britain, Italy and France recognised the Russian Soviet Republic which in December of the same year, at the Tenth All-Russian Congress of Soviets became the USSR (Union of Socialist Soviet Republics) consisting of the Russian, Transcaucasian, White Russian and Ukrainian republics.
On the death of Lenin in 1924, Joseph Stalin, son of a Caucasian (Georgian) cobbler was the secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU). Over the next five years, he gradually became the dominant influence in the party and eventually the de facto dictator of the USSR. His aim was to develop the resources of the country and make the Soviet Union a powerful state and improve the unfriendly relations that had continued with other nations in the wake of the civil war. He was prepared to delay the coming of the ‘World Revolution’ to secure these ends. This brought him into increasing conflict with Trotsky, who also objected to individuals having private rights or property in a Communist state. However, by 1927 Stalin was sufficiently strong to drive Trotsky and his followers into exile. He then introduced his Five-Year Plan, a grandiose scheme to speed up the development of the Union’s industries, education and agriculture. In agriculture, the number of state farms was increased; they were intended to be model institutions for the education of the peasantry into improving farming methods. The smallholders, the poorer peasants were encouraged to combine their tiny plots of land and farm the land collectively. The rich peasants, the kulaks, objected to the collective farms, and in 1929 Stalin determined to destroy them. They were deported to poorer districts or sent to labour camps. The resultant chaos and the continuing confiscation of harvests led to widespread famine, especially in Ukraine, where mass starvation led to the period 1932-33 becoming known as the Holodomor (see appendix two below).
Polish leaders realised that the war had given them an opportunity to finally gain their freedom, though at first, they did not anticipate complete independence and struggled only for self-government. Though the mass of Poles fought in the armies of Russia, an influential group supported Austria, led by Józef Pilsudski, who became the Polish Chief of State (1918–1922) and First Marshal of Poland (from 1920). In 1916, Russian Poland was overrun by the armies of the Central Powers; the Germans occupied Warsaw and granted a measure of independence that did not come up to the expectations of the Poles. In 1917 the Revolutionary Government in St Petersburg endeavoured to obtain Polish support against Germany by a more generous offer of self-government, but an independent state was proclaimed in Warsaw and Galicia soon after the collapse of the Central Powers on both fronts. The new state was represented at the Paris Peace Conference, where its independence was recognised internationally. The western frontier was agreed upon, with the provinces of Posen, West Prussia and Galicia included in the new Poland, as shown on the right-hand map below. The eastern frontier was settled provisionally.
In the aftermath of the First World War, Germans in Austria were forbidden to unite with Germany under article eighty of the Treaty of Versailles, despite being entirely German in language and culture. This was confirmed in the Treaty of St. Germain, by which Austrians in the Tyrol, Galicia and Bohemia were also left under alien rule. Control of Galicia, a wealthy area across the Carpathians, passed to Poland. The most dramatic effects of the Paris settlement were the resurrection of Poland as an independent state more than six score years after its partition. Its soil was fertile and productive, with coal, iron, zinc, salt and petroleum resources also contained beneath its earth. The western part of the region was inhabited by Poles, but in the eastern part, the people were Ruthenians, creating a difficult minorities problem. Attempts made by these people to unite with their fellows in sub-Carpathian Ukraine, newly independent of Russia, were frustrated by the Polish Government, and an insurrection in 1919 was ruthlessly crushed by Pilsudski. In April 1920, during the Polish-Russian War, he invaded and overran Ukraine, occupying Kyiv. When the Russians began a counter-offensive that brought the Soviet armies to the outskirts of Warsaw, the very existence of Poland was once again threatened. With the aid of the French, the Soviet army was driven back, and a further treaty was signed at Riga in October by which Poland secured more favourable eastern borders including lands in western Ukraine, ceded by the USSR. But the still indefinite eastern frontier with the USSR and the desire of the Ruthenian minorities in Eastern Galicia to join with Soviet Ukraine. The fear of Bolshevism and the general poverty and lack of infrastructure in the country proved too much for the inexperienced democratic Government. After 1926, the country was ruled by Pilsudski as a military dictator.
Central-Eastern Europe in 1925
Two new states had also been created at the Paris Conference: Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia. Of equal importance, the Paris Peace Settlement left every post-war state in central Europe with internal problems and potential border disputes. It proved easier to break up the multi-ethnic empires than to replace them with ethnically homogeneous states. Poland and Czechoslovakia both had large German minorities after 1919, as well as disgruntled Slav minorities. Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia also had substantial Hungarian minorities, as did Ukraine (in its western sub-Carpathian region) and Romania (in Transylvania). Hungarian resentment at the loss of over two-thirds of its pre-war land and at the fate of more than one-third of the Hungarian-speaking population was to simmer throughout the inter-war period.
Territorial changes affecting Hungary (the beneficiary), Yugoslavia, Slovakia, Romania and Ukraine (Soviet Russia), 1938-41. The towns that were taken over as a result of the liquidation of Chechoslovakia, now in Ukraine, are Uzhorod (Ungvár) and Mukacheve (Munkaos), in the dark grey at the top.
For the first five years of his rule, the Nazi dictator confined himself to chipping away at the restrictions imposed by the Treaty of Versailles. He refused, for example, to resume the reparations payments imposed at Versailles, while in 1933 he took Germany out of the League of Nations. More seriously, in March 1935 Hitler reintroduced conscription and an airforce, both forbidden in 1919. In March 1938, Hitler’s pan-German ambitions became more apparent when in direct contravention of the Versailles Treaty, he engineered the unification (Anschluss) of his native Austria with Germany. By the following March, with the tacit blessing of Britain and France, who were anxious at all costs to avoid war, Hitler had also occupied the rest of the Czech lands, using at first the excuse that the country’s three-and-a-half-million German speakers had been persecuted by the Czechoslovakian government.
The Nazi-Soviet Pact & Partition of Poland, 1939-41:
Meanwhile, the poverty of the Polish people under Pilsudski’s dictatorship had remained acute. Pre-war emigration to the USA had practically stopped and there was much unrest among the national minorities in the mid-thirties. More than eight per cent of the population was Jewish, living mainly in the towns and seen as ‘a race apart’ by many of their new compatriots. They lived under almost unbelievable conditions of squalor and poverty and, given subsequent events, it is easy to forget that anti-Semitic agitation, as in Germany, was growing, providing the Polish Government with one of its major problems. But Poland as a whole presented a major obstacle to Hitler’s policy of Lebensraum.
… Poland’s isolation On 23 August, the German-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact was signed. Its secret clauses divided Poland between the two states along an agreed frontier in central Poland. This diplomatic coup convinced Hitler that the west would not intervene and on 1 September Germany invaded. But Ribbentrop continued to be concerned about the threat posed to any ‘necessary’ German incursions into eastern Poland, the region that adjoined the Soviet Union and that it had just been agreed was within the Soviet sphere of influence. He cabled Schulenberg, the German ambassador in Moscow, on 3 September:
We should naturally, however, for military reasons, have to continue to take action against such Polish military forces as are at that time located in the Polish territory belonging to the Russian sphere of influence. Please discuss this at once with Molotov and see if the Soviet Union does not consider it desirable for Russian forces to move at the proper time against Polish forces in the Russian sphere of influence and, for their part, to occupy this territory. In our estimation this would not only be a relief for us, but also, in the sense of the Moscow agreements, be in the Soviet interest as well.
But the Western Allies had just declared war on Germany because they had agreed by treaty to protect Poland against aggression. If the Red Army moved into eastern Poland, would they now decide to fight the Soviet Union as well? The Soviet leaders were concerned that a pact that, from their point of view, was designed to keep them out of the European war might now drag them into it. But there remained strong arguments in favour of military action. The Soviets recognised the material benefits to be gained from annexing a large chunk of the neighbouring country with which they had historical scores to settle. Stalin was still bitter about the war the Bolsheviks had fought with the Poles after the Revolution and the Treaty of Versailles before the USSR had come into being. The Curzon Line, the proposed border at that time between Poland and its neighbours, was used to agree on the spheres of influence in the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact. Moreover, ethnic Poles were not in a majority in these eastern territories. Around forty per cent of the population were of Polish origin, thirty-four per cent were Ukrainian and nine per cent were Belorussian. This, the Soviet propagandists realised, allowed any incursion to be couched as an act of ‘liberation’, freeing the ‘local’ population from ethnic Polish domination. A combination of all these factors meant that on 9 September, Molotov finally replied to Ribbentrop’s cable of the 3rd, to say that the Red Army was about to move into the agreed Soviet ‘sphere’ in Poland. At a meeting in Moscow the following day with the German ambassador, Molotov told Schulenburg that the pretext for the invasion would be that the Soviet Union was helping Ukrainians and Belarussians. This argument, he said, …
… was to make the intervention of the Soviet Union plausible and at the same time avoid giving…it the appearance of an aggressor.
The Nazi invasion was augmented by the Soviet invasion of eastern Poland in mid-September. The Soviet Union had so far made no more to invade from the east. With only three Polish divisions covering the eight-hundred-mile-long eastern border, it came as a complete surprise when at dawn on 17 September they did so, in accordance with the secret clauses of the Nazi-Soviet Pact that had been agreed on 24 August. The Soviet leaders wanted revenge for their defeats at Poland’s hands in 1920, access to the Baltic States and a buffer zone against Germany, and they opportunistically grabbed all three, without meeting any significant resistance. Soviet forces crossed Poland’s eastern borders from Belorus and Ukraine, meeting only light resistance, led by Marshal Kovalov in the north on the Belarusian front and Marshal Timoshenko in the south on the Ukrainian front. In a radio broadcast the same day, Molotov justified the Soviet action by the ‘plausible’ argument he had outlined to Schulenberg. Caught between the two great powers, Polish fighting power evaporated. Warsaw surrendered on 27 September and by the 29th, Germany and the Soviet Union had partitioned Poland between them. The following day all Polish resistance ceased. The Red Army was initially welcomed in many places, especially those with non-Polish majority populations. There was confusion in these places as to whether this was an actual invasion at all. Perhaps, some thought, the Soviet troops had really come to ‘help’. Maybe they would just motor through the flat countryside of eastern Poland and confront the German Nazis, who had already captured most of the west of the country. The photograph below reveals that there was little panic on the streets.
The total losses of the Red Army in Poland amounted to 734 killed. Stalin continued to use Polish ‘colonialism’ in the Ukraine and Belorussia as his casus belli, arguing that the Red Army had invaded Poland in order to restore peace and order. The Poles were thus doubly martyred, smashed between the Nazi hammer and the Soviet anvil, and were not to regain their independence and self-government until November 1989, half a century later. By mid-September, the Germans had already moved into several areas behind Warsaw and had indeed taken Brest-Litovsk and Lviv, but some fighting had broken out between Cossacks and Germans, with two of the former killed in one incident and fifteen Germans in another. The campaign cost 8,082 German lives with 27,278 wounded and the loss of 285 aircraft, whereas seventy thousand Polish soldiers and twenty-five thousand civilians had been killed, with 130,000 soldiers wounded. The chief of staff of the XLVIII Panzer Corps on the Eastern Front, Friedrich von Mellenthin, who served at the Battle of Kursk, the Battle of Kyiv, and the spring 1944 retreat through western Ukraine, concluded that:
The operations were of considerable value in “blooding” our troops and teaching them the difference between real war with live ammunition and peacetime manoeuvres.
Friedrich von Mellenthin
In his memoirs, Panzer Battles, published in 1956, Mellenthin, the Wehrmacht’s adversaries on the Eastern Front are consistently depicted in derogatory and racial terms, including in a section dedicated to the “Psychology of the Russian Soldier”. According to Mellenthin, a “Russian soldier” was a “primitive being”, characterised by “mental sluggishness” and lacking a “religious or moral balance”. He described them as “primitive Asiatics”. We don’t know whether this was the view that he held of them before Operation Barbarossa, however, when they were his allies in Poland.
It was not long before the whole of western Poland came under German control. On 28 September, Soviet and German representatives met to draw up a demarcation line which gave Warsaw to the Germans and the Baltic states as a sphere of interest to the USSR. Almost at once, the German authorities began to break Poland up. Silesia and the Corridor became parts of the Reich, and a central Polish area called the General Government was placed under a Nazi administrator, Hans Frank. Thousands of Polish intellectuals were rounded up and murdered. Peasants were removed from their villages in parts of western Poland and replaced by German settlers. Hitler had been right to calculate that Britain and France would give Poland little help, but he was wrong about localising the conflict. Although Britain and France had declared war on 3 September, there were only isolated raids by Allied scouting parties and aircraft.
In eastern Poland, casual abuse of the class enemies of the Communist system turned into a widespread and systematic arrest. On 27 September, just ten days after Red Army troops had crossed into Poland – the Soviets came for Boguslava Gryniv’s father. He was a prominent lawyer and head of the regional branch of the Ukrainian National Democratic Party (UNDO), a legally constituted organisation. When there was a knock at their door the Gryniv family were surprised to see a member of the local Soviet authority, as it was a church holiday and they were about to celebrate with a family meal. But they took his father away anyway, leaving the family to pray for him not to be punished and to be returned to them. He was one of the first of many to suffer at the hands of the Soviets in eastern Poland. Altogether, between September 1939 and June 1941, around 110,000 people were arrested during the reign of terror facilitated by the occupation of eastern Poland. Aristocrats, intellectuals, trade unionists, churchmen, politicians, veterans of the 1920-21 Russo-Polish War, anyone who might form the nucleus of new national leadership, were arrested by the NKVD and sent to concentration camps from which virtually none emerged.
The Nazi Conquests in the East to 1940
As in the case of Boguslava Gryniv’s father, individual arrests of members of the intelligentsia and others thought of as a threat to the new régime began from the moment the Red Army arrived in mid-September. Gryniv was sent to the local jail immediately upon arrest, a small cell that usually held drunks and petty criminals. All the most important people who had remained in the town were in this prison. They thought it was simply a ‘misunderstanding’. However, about three weeks later he was taken to Chertkov, where he discovered that all he was accused of was membership of UNDA, a legal organisation before the invasion which was by no means anti-Bolshevik. However, in reality, he was seen as a dangerous member of the previous ‘ruling class’. He disappeared from the prison towards the end of 1939 and fifty years later his family finally learnt that he had been murdered by the NKVD in the spring of 1940. By July of that year, when Hitler held victory celebrations in Berlin, Germany and the ‘Axis’ powers were masters, directly or indirectly, of the whole of Western and Central Europe, as well as much of Eastern Europe. The Soviet Union had made use of Hitler’s western offensive in order to occupy Finland and the Baltic states. But the difficulties experienced by the Soviet armies in obtaining these objectives suggested that it posed no threat to Germany. Hitler’s rhetoric about Lebensraum for German colonisation seemed about to become reality.
Operation Barbarossa & ‘Operation Blue’, 1941-42:
In June 1941 Hitler launched his greatest military gamble, the invasion of the Soviet Union. German forces proved unstoppable until they reached Moscow in December. On 22 June 1941, German forces, together with the allied armies of Hungary, Romania and Finland, threw three million men, three thousand tanks and 2,700 aircraft across a two-thousand-mile frontier with the Soviet Union. Geographically and numerically it was the largest military operation ever launched. The decision to attack the USSR was finally made in December 1940 when ‘case Barbarossa’ was laid down in Führer Directive number twenty-one. But Hitler had seriously explored the idea since the summer. The alleged weakness of the Soviet force after the Stalinist purges presented a tempting opportunity; while Stalin’s own ambitions in eastern Europe looked increasingly threatening. Above all, conquest in the east promised a vast area for exploitation, as it had done, briefly, in 1917-18, the ‘living space’ (Lebensraum) that Hitler wrote about in Mein Kampf. The fact that the space was already occupied by ideological and ethnic enemies of the Reich gave the operation the air of a crusade. Hitler’s crusade against communism, temporarily shelved by the Nazi-Soviet Pact, made the invasion a probable outcome, or at least a realistic prospect, however daunting.
Stalin remained impervious to all suggestions that a German attack was imminent in the summer of 1941. Local commanders made some limited preparations, but when German forces attacked almost complete surprise was achieved. Although Soviet forces had vastly more tanks and aircraft and approximately the same number of divisions, the poor quality of much of the equipment, coupled with the disorganization of the Soviet response, created ideal opportunities for the German armies to exploit.
During 1942 the main weight of the German military effort was concentrated on the Eastern Front. The Axis-allied forces attacked on three broad fronts; North, Centre and South, where Hitler insisted on an advance on economic targets in industrialised southern Ukraine and, in particular, on the oilfields of the Caucasus. Later in June, German forces launched ‘Operation Blue’, clearing Crimea and the remaining areas of southern Ukraine, before dividing the forces for attacks against Stalingrad and against the Caucusus oilfields around Maikop, Grozny and Baku. At first, Axis forces made remarkable gains. By September, the Red Army had been driven back into Stalingrad, which was expected to fall within a matter of days. By October much of Ukraine was in German hands and between two and three million Soviet prisoners had been taken in three months. Later that month, Hitler announced that victory had been achieved but his claim proved premature. By the end of November, the Germans were once more at the gates of Leningrad and Moscow. Hitler’s Germany was at the peak of its power, certainly, but this was the limit of the German advance. As the winter set in, they were forced to ‘dig in’ while fierce Soviet resistance in Stalingrad, and the extended supply lines slowed the progress of General Paulus’s Sixth Army to a crawl. Overstretched forces in the Caucusus were halted and then slowly driven back by Soviet forces whose supply position picked up as Soviet factories made good the losses of 1941.
Map 1: The Turn of the Tide, 1942-43.
In November a powerful Soviet counter-offensive cut off Stalingrad and drove the German line back as German forces faced their first real defeats of the war. The Russian counter-attack continued into December, driving the Germans back more than a hundred miles and giving Stalin time to rebuild his shattered defences. During 1943, the Wehrmacht was forced to retreat on all fronts, though they still possessed formidable military strength. On 31 January Paulus surrendered. Since November, thirty-two Axis divisions had been destroyed. In the summer of 1943, Hitler ordered one last attempt to break through the Soviet front. ‘Operation Citadel’ drew almost one million men and 2,700 tanks to a narrow front around the city of Kursk, on the eastern edge of Ukraine. There the military leaders planned to encircle and annihilate a Soviet force of more than one million. Soviet preparations blunted the German attack between 5-13 July and there then followed a huge Soviet counter-thrust which broke the German line and in four months drove it back to Kyiv. Although the German army fought a fierce defence, each successive Soviet surge forced a further withdrawal. In the event, The Germans were defeated by the immensity of the task they had set themselves: the enormous distances involved, the severity of the Russian winter and the seemingly limitless manpower of the Russian army.
The extent of Hitler’s Europe (East) in 1942. The red line marks the maximum extent of Axis military control. The brown area shows the Axis administration territories.
Nevertheless, the almost total conquest of continental Europe by the Nazis by the summer of 1941 provided the circumstances for a sharp change in the direction of German race policy towards the active pursuit of genocide. Hitler and the racist radicals in the Nazi movement had no master plan for the annihilation of non-Germanic peoples in 1939, but their whole conception of the war was one of racial struggle in which the Jewish people above all were the enemy of German imperialism. When Germany found itself ruling very large Jewish populations after its conquest of the east, the régime began to explore more extreme solutions to the Jewish Question. The German ‘New Order’ was viewed from Berlin in terms of a hierarchy of races: at the apex were the Aryan (Germanic) peoples followed by the Latin and Slavic populations, and at the foot were ‘races’ – Jews, Sinti and Roma (‘gipsies’) – who were deemed to be Untermenschen (sub-human) and thereby unworthy of existence. The treatment of these ethnic groups began with a programme of ghetto-building or imprisonment, but the orders for Barbarossa deliberately encouraged the murder of Soviet Jews. In the Baltic states and Ukraine native anti-Semitism was whipped up by the Nazi occupiers and led to widespread racial violence and massacres.
There is strong evidence that in July 1941 Hitler ordered the physical extermination of the Jews (Adolf Eichmann), flushed with the prospect of victory in the USSR and the realisation that there were no longer any forces in Europe that could constrain a programme of annihilation. The systematic murder of the Jews began in late 1941 with the establishment of a series of ‘extermination’ camps in occupied Poland where victims were either gassed as soon as they arrived, or worked to death in the factories and quarries close to the camps. The occupation and exploitation of the western Soviet Union, especially Ukraine, had long been the goal of Hitler’s Lebensraum policy. Although German forces never reached their ultimate objective of a line from Archangel to Astrakhan set by their Führer as the eastern boundary of his future empire, the organisation and exploitation of the occupied territories was commenced. A fluid area behind the front line was under military administration, but two Reichskommisariats were established, Ostland administered the territories of the former Baltic states plus Belorussia, while Reichskommisariat Ukraine administered the bulk of Ukraine (The Crimea remained under military administration and Sub-Carpathia, including southern Galicia, remained part of Axis Hungary, as shown below).
Resistance to the Reich
Extermination was placed on a ‘proper’ organisational foundation with the establishment of under the RSHA (Reichsicherheitshauplant) of a series of camps established in occupied Poland where victims were either gassed as soon as they arrived, or worked to death in factories and quarries close to the camps. The systematic murder of Jews began in late 1941, first of all with mass shootings in the occupied territories, and extended to the Sinti and Roma in 1942. In 1943 and 1944 Germany put pressure on Italy and Hungary, its Axis allies, to release their Jewish populations to the Reich. When both states were occupied, any resistance to anti-Semitism was quashed, and hundreds of thousands of Jews were deported to the camps in Poland and Germany slaughtered in 1944 and 1945 in an effort to complete what Hitler saw as his chief legacy for Europe, a ‘Jew-free’ continent. Records remain inadequate, but approximately 5.3 million Jews and at least 250,000 Sinti and Roma were killed in the camps.
Jewish deaths in extermination camps 1942-45.
In practice, the wartime situation, partisan resistance and Soviet military recovery meant that the German plans to exploit the western ‘Russian’ regions, including Ukraine, were barely begun, however. Only the policy of “mass extermination” of Jews and other groups targetted as enemies of the Reich was continued on a huge scale, even as Germany was being pushed back on all military fronts from mid-1944 onwards. Apart from inflicting enormous loss of life and massive damage to property, the German occupation of Soviet Russia itself left no traces on the ground. After the expulsion of the Germans, the Soviet forces rapidly restored the former Soviet administration, albeit in areas racked by depopulation. The summer and early autumn of 1944 were a time of conflict between the Allies, not only over what seemed to be the eternal question of Poland but also over the post-war shape of Europe, and, most particularly, Soviet intentions towards the eastern European countries that they were shortly to occupy.
Towards the middle of August 1944, the Soviet general offensive began to slacken, Soviet armies outrunning their supplies since behind them lay an advance of some 350 miles. Soviet troops were on the East Prussian frontier and had bridgeheads on the Vistula and the Narew, while the Soviet command planned to wipe Army Group North off the map. The Finns had already abandoned the German-Finnish compact and late in August were suing for peace, harsh though the terms proved to be. In the event, the Romanians beat the Finns in the race to make peace. The Soviet hammer having battered three German Army Groups (North Centre and North Ukraine), it was now the turn of Army Group South Ukraine to fall under it. Even before a shot was fired, however, this Army Group faced disaster, hemmed in as it was between the Red Army was eager to fall on it and the Romanians, who were even more eager to betray it.
The Defeat of the Reich, 1944-45: Liberation, January 1944-March 1945.
On 20 August 1944, Malinovskii’s Second Ukrainian Front launched its attack, encircling five German corps in the Jassy-Kishinev operation, while Tolbukhin’s forces trapped the Romanian 3rd Army. But defeat in the field was outmatched and outpaced by political events when on 23rd August a coup in Bucharest knocked Romania out of the war with King Michael’s unconditional surrender to the Allies. Romania’s declaration of war on Germany followed in a trice and Romanian troops were ordered not to open fire on the Red Army. The Romanian defection had cataclysmic consequences for Germany with far more than the fate of an Army Group involved: the fortunes of war in the entire south-eastern theatre had changed virtually overnight. With a German army hopelessly trapped and what was left of two Romanian armies laying down their arms, the whole of southern Bessarabia, the Danube delta and the Carpathian passes lay open to the Red Army. Henceforth neither the Danube nor the Carpathians could bar the Soviet advance and ahead of the Soviet armies lay the route to the Hungarian plains, the gateway to Czechoslovakia and Austria, as well as a highway to Yugoslavia and Bulgaria.
The Era of the Cold War in Europe, 1949-1999:
The Allies had considered the question of the post-war order in Europe as early as 1943, in Tehran, in November of that year. British PM Churchill and US President Roosevelt had agreed with Stalin that, should Hitler be defeated, the Soviet Union would be allowed to treat Eastern European territories its army had conquered as belonging to a Soviet sphere of influence. But the erasure of the Nazi map of Europe involved vast movements of population. Poland became an overwhelmingly Polish society for the first time, with half a million ethnic Ukrainians being ‘returned’ to Soviet-controlled Ukraine in 1946-47, as had been agreed at Yalta, many to certain death, allegedly for ‘collaborating with the Nazis’ (for more details of deportations, refugees etc., see appendix three below).
Cold War Central-Eastern Europe in 1949.
Following the defeat of the Third Reich, the map of the European continent was radically transformed. The most striking transformation was the shrinking of Germany, with Poland the principal beneficiary, and the division of what remained of the two countries. But Poland lost vast territories on its eastern border to the Soviet Union. The Baltic states – Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania – together with Ukraine and Bessarabia, were all incorporated into the Soviet Union. Austria was detached from Germany and restored to independence, initially under a Soviet-sponsored government, reluctantly recognised by the western powers. It gradually moved away from Soviet influence over the following ten years, but Hungary, bordering Soviet Ukraine, was not allowed to follow suit in 1956 following Stalin’s death. The two zones of Germany followed wholly divergent paths: while denazification in the west followed the Austrian model, with the first free elections permitted to take place in January 1946, in the east the Soviets moved quickly to eradicate all pre-war political parties other than the communists, simultaneously stripping Ukraine, for example, of industrial plunder for war reparation. Much the same was true of the rest of central-eastern Europe. Indeed, by 1949 it was clear that Stalin had created what was, in effect, a massive extension to the Soviet Empire, as well as a substantial buffer zone between the Soviet Union and ‘the West’. Western-Soviet relations were plunged into a ‘deep freeze’ from which they would not emerge for decades. The ‘Cold War’ had begun and, in escaping from Nazi persecution, much of Europe had simply exchanged one form of tyranny for another.
Given all these massive challenges for the victorious powers, the post-war borders of Europe proved remarkably resilient. For forty years after 1949, there were no major changes to the European map. Yet it was mutual hostility that provided the essential stability of the period of the Cold War. Eastern Europe was dominated by the communist Soviet Union, which imposed on it a repressive and economically backward rule. Western Europe, by contrast, was broadly democratic and economically vigorous. These divisions were underlined by rival military and economic blocs: NATO, the EEC (now the EU) and EFTA in the West; the Warsaw Pact and COMECON in the East.
The Fall of the Wall & Falling Dominoes, 1989-91:
Following the fall of the ‘dominoes’ and the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, Gorbachev’s attempt to reform the Soviet system through glasnost and perestroika failed to stem the swelling tide of liberal-nationalist ‘people-power’. In the Spring of 1990, Soviet public opinion, as the street demonstrations showed, was not just impatient, but also divided; on the ‘right’, the conservative communists complained that he was going too fast, whereas on the ‘left’ reformers felt that he was not moving fast enough. The Supreme Soviet responded by voting him sweeping presidential powers. On 11th March, Lithuania formally declared its independence. Vytautas Landsbergis, a musicologist, pictured below, was elected president, the first president of a free Lithuania for fifty years. He was a straightforward enemy of the Soviet state as constituted since the forcible inclusion of the Baltic countries at the start of the Second World War. His political skills were negligible and he had little conception of the need to assuage the dignity and self-esteem of a great country facing humiliation. Most western governments believed that Lithuania could singlehandedly destroy perestroika unless it developed a clearer sense of the art of the politically possible. Landsbergis showed no sign of doing so. Gorbachev attacked the action of the Lithuanians as “illegitimate and invalid” but was reluctant to use force to reverse it. At Malta, he had agreed with Bush not to do so, and in return, the US President kept his public remarks low-key. The US administration wanted to see the Baltic republics gain their freedom, but relied for world stability on a lasting relationship with a strong USSR.
Vytautas Landsbergis, first elected President of Lithuania, 1990.
As the chaos broadened and the crisis deepened in March, Soviet paratroopers occupied party buildings in Vilnius. On 25th March, Estonian Communists voted for independence; Latvia would follow in May. Meanwhile, on 28th March, already independent Hungary held its first free elections since 1945, which passed off completely peacefully. Struggling to retain control, Gorbachev imposed economic sanctions on Lithuania. He cut off oil supplies and eighty-four per cent of the flow of natural gas by pipeline, letting through just enough to keep essential services such as hospitals, going. He also prohibited the supply of other goods. The US considered, but rejected, sanctions against Moscow, despite lobbying in Washington from US citizens originally from the Baltic States. Instead, the administration threatened to withhold the signing of a projected trade deal with the Soviets. In Moscow, government officials saw Lithuania as the place where they had to make a stand if they were not to lose bigger republics like Ukraine as well. That would be an economic and political catastrophe from which Gorbachev would not recover. In April support for the Ukrainian nationalist movement, ‘Rukh’, was strong, especially in Galicia, which had been Polish-Ukrainian in the recent past. The Foreign Editor of the BBC, John Simpson (pictured below), visiting Moscow and Kyiv in April, was told by a Ukrainian friend that…
“You don’t see a single red flag flying there now, only the blue and gold flag of our Ukraine, the blue of the sky and the gold of the corn.”
John Simpson, BBC journalist, at the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, 1990.
As it happened, he was Jewish, and Ukrainians, like Lithuanians, had a powerful yet wholly unjustified reputation for anti-Semitism during the Second World War. It was claimed that the SS had recruited many of them for concentration-camp work and found them hard-working, brutal and obedient. When Simpson asked him why he, a Jew, had become a Ukrainian nationalist, he replied that in Lviv, the capital of Western Ukraine, politics was different…
… ‘Rukh’ isn’t like these other groups, ‘Pamyat’ and so on. It’s got some brains. When they found out in the elections Jews had voted almost one hundred per cent for Rukh, it changed its whole approach to us. Some of my friends and I had a meeting with the Rukh leadership. They agreed to set up Hebrew lessons, they decided to start demanding the right of emigration for the Jews. And you know what? They asked us for help in distributing their literature in Yiddish. … Oh yes, and one other thing. They came round to see us later, and said they’d heard there was a secret ‘Pamyat’ cell operating in Lviv. They offered us protection if we wanted it.
John Simpson (1990), Despatches from the Barricades, p. 299.
Clearly, the Ukrainian nationalists of the 1990s, as elsewhere in Eastern Europe, had put clear blue and gold water between them and the war-time Nazi collaborators. They had already decontaminated themselves from the stain of anti-Semitism, if they had ever really needed to, more than thirty years ago. But Simpson did comment that the thought that Jews might vote for a Ukrainian nationalist movement and that the movement might protect them from violence as a result set his young friend laughing and shaking his head again. By contrast, in Russia itself, at that time, Simpson reported that anti-Semitism was growing fast. The Jewish demand for emigration enraged people who themselves would have liked to have left Russia but did not have the international support given to the Jewish refuseniks. One Jewish ‘witness’ and victim of the ‘resultant’ abuse told him:
People in shops and in the streets say to us, “When are you going to Israel?” or “What are you waiting for?” You find swastikas drawn on posters near where you live. They shout at us and our children. The mood is getting uglier: you can feel it.
So much for the bizarre claim that a country that in 2022 has a Jew as its President is somehow historically anti-Semitic and in need of denazification. Many of those transported and murdered at Auschwitz were sub-Carpathian Jews, some of them ethnic Hungarians, but others ethnic Ukrainians, as well as Poles. In the early 1990s, once the travel restrictions began to be lifted in Russia, hundreds of thousands of (mainly ‘Ashkenazy’) Russian Jews poured through central European airports en route to Israel. Few of them were firm Zionists and some were actually anti-Zionists. All of them were leaving behind a country, Russia (not Ukraine), in which anti-Semitism was on the rise again. They feared further ‘pogroms’, like those that Theodor Hertzl and his family had endured a century earlier, under the Tsarist régime, before escaping to Budapest.
West German Chancellor Helmut Kohl, second from right, with Mikhail Gorbachev in Moscow, summer 1990. Kohl pledged to curb German military strength and offered substantial financial aid. Eventually, Gorbachev agreed that Germany could be reunited, within NATO.
In the early summer of 1990, the conditions to be attached to German reunification were hammered out. The Soviet Union failed to secure a transitional period in which the military forces in East Germany (DDR) retained “associated membership” in the Warsaw Pact, obvious nonsense, or an agreement on a hard-line plan whereby for three to five years the other powers would oversee Germany’s conduct. In London in early July, a NATO summit made a declaration of non-aggression with the Warsaw Pact nations. That helped the cause of German reunification, and Germany, meanwhile, helped itself by finally confirming its borders with Poland, promising to limit the future size of a German army, agreeing not to station nuclear weapons in East Germany and offering to pay the costs of removing half a million Soviet troops from the former DDR and resettling them in Russia. Kohl and Genscher went to Moscow together, and at a press conference on 16 July, Gorbachev declared, …
“ … whether we like it or not, the time will come when a united Germany will be in NATO if that is its choice. Then, if that is its choice, to some degree and in some form, Germany can work together with the Soviet Union.”
Left: January 1990. Right: December 1991, out of a job, Mikhail Gorbachev was hailed worldwide for his role in ending the Cold War, was ultimately rejected by his native Russia. Former US State Department analyst gave his verdict on the man, saying that while Gorbachev may not have been the main factor: “… what happened would not have happened without him. That cannot be said of anyone else.”
Gorbachev’s extraordinary statement was, as Chancellor Kohl put it, a breakthrough, a fantastic result. A fortnight earlier, at the Twenty-eighth Party Congress, Gorbachev had been ferociously attacked by party hard-liners for letting the Baltics go, weakening the Warsaw Pact, and undermining the ideological foundations of the Soviet Union and its ruling Communist Party. He was, nevertheless, re-elected its general secretary, and continued to commit the Soviet Union to uproot the cornerstone of its security policy since the end of the Second World War. On 3 October, East and West Germany (FRG/FDR) were joined; Germany was reunited. The crowds and flags in the pictures on the right and below show that this was a popular political reunification, at first, within the European Union. The security and economic issues would be addressed later.
The Brandenburg Gate, 3rd October 1990.
Some historians say the Cold War ended when the Berlin Wall came down in October 1989: others say it was when the Soviet Union publicly reconciled itself to seeing a reunited Germany, whose invasion and defeat in 1941-45 had cost the Union more than twenty million dead, in a military alliance with the West. Since Germany had always been at the epicentre of the Cold War in Europe, Gorbachev’s statement in Moscow on 16 July has a strong claim to be considered the decisive moment of the Cold War’s ending. But if the contest was over, the contestants had not yet left the ring. There was still a great deal of unfinished business, both in Eastern Europe and the Middle East. Just as the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 had marked the beginning of what has become known by historians as the ‘Second Cold War’, so also the summer of 1990 marked the beginning of two conflicts that still remained unresolved more than a decade later, one in the Persian Gulf and the other in what, then, was still part of the USSR, in Ukraine. The Soviet Union was still in being, though beset with problems, two of which were desperately difficult for Gorbachev to deal with. He was trying, as fast as he could, to reform both an economy that was rapidly collapsing and a system of government in which corruption had become a way of life.
He was trying to hold the Soviet Union together when every single member state sought independence or would do so very soon. On the same day that Gorbachev made his momentous statement in Moscow, 16 July, Ukraine declared its sovereignty, followed by Armenia, Turkmenistan and Tadzhikistan in August, and Kazakhstan and Kirghizia in October. In the same month, both Russia and Ukraine declared their state laws to be superior to those of the Union. In November, however, the Supreme Soviet declared this position invalid. Gorbachev proposed the setting up of a new central government that would have representatives in it of each of the fifteen republics. Boris Yeltsin, as leader of the Russian Republic, made clear that he did not want to see power concentrated at the centre, in Gorbachev’s hands. By the end of November, Gorbachev had shifted his position again, proposing a ‘new Union Treaty: a Union of Sovereign Soviet Republics’ with loosened ties between each republic and the central Soviet government. Meanwhile, the Supreme Soviet had been making fundamental reforms: on 1 October it passed a law guaranteeing freedom of worship and on 9 October legislation to bring in a multiparty system. They demonstrated that such huge constitutional issues could be settled by voting and diplomacy. The Media too were freed from state control.
Above: Ukrainians protest at continued Soviet domination. Ukraine was the first of several Soviet republics to declare its independence from the USSR and its sovereignty on 16 July 1990.
But the economy was a far more challenging task for Gorbachev to face: Just the prospect of radical economic restructuring threatened social chaos and caused immediate fear and distrust. To go from a command economy, where everyone did as they were told by the centre, to one that operated without central planning and control, leaving prices to market forces, was to travel a pathless route into unknown territory. Not many wanted to go that way, and the few who did had no route map by which to arrive at a clear destination. On 20 July a “five hundred day” economic programme to move the USSR towards a market economy was published. It proposed the sale of large numbers of state enterprises, the dissolution of state collective farms, currency reform and a new banking system. But Gorbachev’s nerve failed him, and the reforms were not introduced. Uncertainty was only making matters worse, and the Bush administration steadfastly refused to provide aid to fund the programme upfront, saying that it would only give it as a reward for implementing reform, not as an inducement. Moreover, concerned that Gorbachev might be deposed, the US continued to maintain a state of full military preparedness.
Towards the end of November (19-21), NATO and Warsaw Pact leaders met in Paris to sign a historic treaty setting reduced levels of conventional forces in the whole of Europe (CFE) from the Atlantic to the Urals. Disarmament was no longer simply about the ‘superpowers’ controlling the numbers of nuclear warheads. Negotiations had become multi-lateral and multi-faceted. It was against this background that, in Paris, the sixteen member-states of NATO and the six member-states of the Warsaw Pact countries published a Joint Declaration of non-aggression in which they stated that they no longer considered themselves enemies. As the Cold War ended with the former ‘satellite’ states freely placing themselves under the NATO umbrella, the conflict in the Middle East was about to go up in flames, quite literally. Together with the break-up of the Russian sphere of influence and the Balkan wars, this was to dominate the next generation of international relations.
Gorbachev’s Georgian Foreign Minister and ultimate ‘scapegoat’.
As 1990 ended, Gorbachev, under persistent conservative criticism, made a ‘sharp right turn’. The USSR’s Supreme Soviet, unable to agree on an economic programme, had granted Gorbachev special powers to rule by decree during the transition to a market economy. Firing his moderate interior minister and replacing him with the hardline former KGB chief, Boris Pugo, Gorbachev sent a clear reactionary signal on 17 December, saying that The country needed a firm executive rule to overcome the threat posed by the dark forces of nationalism.
By the end of the year, Shevardnadze had personally paid the price for the USSR’s concessions in Eastern Europe and on Germany, and support for the United States in the Persian Gulf.
He had been offered up as a scapegoat by Gorbachev to the conservatives. Knowing that he was about to be kicked upstairs as vice president, he resigned his post of Foreign Minister, warning that a hardline dictatorship was at hand, and returned to his native Georgia. Shevardnadze had played a key role in advancing ‘perestroika’ and ‘glasnost’ alongside Gorbachev. On 26 December 1990, the Congress of People’s Deputies approved new executive powers for the president. In Moscow, the following February, Gorbachev fought on. He held a referendum and won approval for his new Union Treaty; the Soviet Union was to be preserved as a renewed federation of equal sovereign republics in which human rights and the freedoms of all nationalities would be guaranteed. Several republics boycotted the vote, and Yeltsin made it clear that he sided with the boycotters. In March, a coal miners’ strike began in the Donbas, in Ukraine, and mass demonstrations took place in Moscow, for Yeltsin and against Gorbachev, despite a ban and the presence of fifty thousand police and soldiers. The marches went off peacefully, but the ban and the massing of armed forces caused much offence. Gorbachev’s rightward turn had cost him respect among the reformers. The following month Georgia declared its independence from the USSR. Correcting his course, the Soviet president held talks with leaders of nine republics to formulate a political and economic reform package and a modified relationship between the capital and the republics. The leaders reached a new agreement on a treaty, called ‘Ninety-plus-One’. On 12th June, Boris Yeltsin was elected to the newly created post of president of Russia, in a landslide. Yeltsin received fifty-seven per cent of eighty million votes. He was the first democratically elected leader in Russian history.
Central-Eastern Europe, 1991-2001
The Failed Coup & the End of the Cold War:
At the end of July, at a summit in Moscow, Bush and Gorbachev signed START 1, beginning a new sequence of strategic arms reduction agreements. George Bush had undertaken to visit Ukraine, and went on to Kyiv after Moscow. The Ukrainians were hoping for US support in their move to independence from Moscow, but Bush perceived just how perilous Gorbachev’s position was and did not want to make it worse. Speaking publicly in Kyiv, he denounced the grim consequences of “suicidal nationalism.” Croatia, having left the Yugoslav Federation, and Slovenia, were already at war, so it’s unlikely that he was speaking about the Ukrainians, but they were disappointed by these remarks. The speech went down badly in the USA as well; where Bush’s critics dubbed it his “Chicken Kyiv” speech. In August, Gorbachev went on holiday to his villa at Foros on the Black Sea. Early in the morning of 19 August, as his holiday was coming to an end, radio and television started broadcasting an announcement in Moscow from the State Committee for the State of Emergency: President Gorbachev was ill and unable to perform his duties; Vice-President Yanayev had assumed the powers of the presidency; an emergency had been declared. It was, of course, as we now know, a coup but for the ordinary citizens of Moscow, Kyiv and Leningrad at the time, matters were very unclear. Where was Gorbachev? Perhaps he really was ill?
What had actually happened was that on Sunday 18 August, a delegation from Moscow hat arrived at the seaside villa to see Gorbachev. Before they entered, the president tried to telephone out, but the line had been cut. As Navy vessels manoeuvred near the shore, the five conspirators pushed their way in: They told Gorbachev that he should approve the declaration of a national state of emergency and sign it, or resign and hand over power to Yanayev. Gorbachev flatly refused. They left, putting Gorbachev under arrest, cut off from communication with the outside world.
The plotters in Moscow included several members of the government, among them Prime Minister Pavlov; KGB Chairman Vladimir Kryuchkov; Interior Minister Pugo; and Minister of Defence Marshal Dmitry Yazov (pictured above, right). Most of them had been urging Gorbachev for months to impose emergency rule and had now decided to do it themselves, hoping he would go along with it. He had underestimated their strength, but they had also underestimated his determination to resist. His refusal to give in was brave, but in Moscow, the real struggle was just beginning. In every Moscow ministry and in the republics, every civil servant had to make up their mind about what to do. Most watched to see how things would turn out, but enough of them, in government, the army and the KGB refused to obey orders from the ‘Emergency Committee’ to ensure that the coup went off half-cock. Gorbachev’s insistence on a transition to democracy was paying off. Resistance was led by the White House, the seat of the Russian Parliament, by Boris Yeltsin. He denounced the coup and those behind it, rallying support for the legitimate government and a liberal-democratic future rather than a return to totalitarian tyranny. He called for a general strike.
Above left: Tanks in the streets; attempted coup in Moscow. But the army was halfhearted in obeying the Emergency Committee’s orders. The plotters failed to seize power outright. Above right: Crowds surround the Russian Parliament building, some with Ukrainian flags, where Boris Yeltsin leads the resistance against the unconstitutional coup.
Those who agreed with Yeltsin, and had the courage to say so, went to the White House, ringed by troops and tanks, to declare their support. Shevardnadze was one of the first. At eight in the morning, eastern US time, President Bush met the press. He praised Gorbachev as “a historic figure,” hedged on Yanayev, but stopped short of outright denunciation when he called the seizure of power, “extra-constitutional.” He insisted that he would not seek to “overexcite the American people or the world. … We will conduct our diplomacy in a prudent fashion, not driven by excess.” This reaction was not much more than ‘wait and see.’
At Foros, meanwhile, the Gorbachevs, on a transistor radio their captors did not know they had, had learned what was happening in Moscow from the BBC World Service. Raisa Gorbachev, in her diary, expressed indignation at the news on state television. Gorbachev sent a message to Yaneyev: Cancel what you have done and convene either the Congress ofPeople’s Deputies or the USSR Supreme Soviet. The first blood was spilt on the night of 20 August, when three young men were killed by armoured personnel carriers moving towards the White House in support of the coup. Had the ‘Emergency Committee’ been more resolute, many more lives would certainly have been lost. But they were hesitant, unsure of themselves, and of their support. The coup had failed. A delegation of the plotters reached Foros at 5.00 p.m the next day and asked to see Gorbachev. It included Kryuchkov and Yazov, but Gorbachev refused to see them until communications had been restored. When they were, Gorbachev rang Yeltsin, and shortly afterwards a Russian delegation arrived to bring the Gorbachev family back to Moscow. The conspirators resigned or committed suicide.
22 and 23 August 1991: Exiting the plane that Yeltsin sent for him, Gorbachev returns to a changed Moscow. Yeltsin was now in charge, and the next day, in the Russian parliament, he forced Gorbachev to read out documents implicating his own Communist colleagues in the coup against him.
All that remained was to establish the precise relationship between the Soviet Union and the individual republics. On the 20th and 21st of August, Estonia and Latvia declared independence, and Lithuania reaffirmed its declaration of 1990. The republics of Ukraine, Belarus, Moldavia, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan, Kirghizia, Tadzhikistan and Armenia followed soon after. On 2 September, President Bush announced that the United States recognised the independence of the Baltic states. The Soviet State Council did so four days later and, on the same day, Georgia broke all ties with the Soviet Union. The republics voted to reject Gorbachev’s Union Treaty, favouring instead a confederation. On 30 November, Yeltsin’s Russia, as the leading power in the new association, took control of the Soviet Foreign Ministry and all its embassies abroad. On 8 December, in Minsk, Yeltsin for Russia, Leonid Kravchuk for Ukraine, and Stanislav Shushkevich for Belarus, the three Slav states, without bothering to take the other republics with them, signed a pact ending the USSR and creating the CIS, the Commonwealth of Independent States. They first informed George Bush and Mikhail Gorbachev what they had done, humiliating the Soviet president, who the next day denied their right to have done it; but the Russian Parliament ratified and therefore legitimised the pact, and within days all but one of the other remaining republics joined.
US Secretary of State under George Bush
With James Baker, Bush’s Secretary of State, in Moscow a week later, the four republics possessing nuclear weapons – Russia, Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan – announced that they would abide by and implement the cuts in arms agreed by Bush and Gorbachev, and the three other states agreed to transfer their nuclear weapons to Russia, signalling that they no longer posed a nuclear threat to either the West or Moscow. On 25th December 1991, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was brought to an official end when the red flag with hammer and sickle was lowered over the Kremlin for the last time. Mikhail Gorbachev ‘resigned’, commenting a few days later:
I do not regard the end of the Cold War as a victory for one side. … The end of the Cold War is our common victory.
But, for his part, in his ‘State of the Union’ address for 1992, an election year, President Bush chose to claim triumphantly that the United States had “won the Cold War”. Others have continued to claim the same for the past thirty years.
In the wake of the collapse of communist rule in the USSR and the sudden disintegration of the Soviet Union, no fewer than twenty-two new countries, among them the fifteen former republics of the USSR, came into being. Thus the three Baltic states, Ukraine Belarus, Moldova, Georgia, Azerbaijan and Armenia gained independence that none of them had known since before the Second World War. These new states were not destined to remain in peace. Break-away movements emerged, threatening to inflict on the region a fatal combination of old hatreds and new destructive power. Transnistria declared independence from Moldova, Chechnya declared independence from Russia and Crimea sought to break away from Ukraine. Added to these divisions, civil war followed in Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan went to war over Nagorno-Karabakh, and from 1991 Yugoslavia simply imploded under pressure from long-suppressed inter-ethnic rivalries. A series of wars continued for a decade, forcing NATO to intervene to prevent genocide against the majority Albanian population of Kosovo. More peacefully, the general election of June 1992 led to Czechoslovakia breaking into two, the Czech Republic and Slovakia. By 1993, the euphoria following the events of 1989 had evaporated. Large parts of Eastern Europe were beset by instability, poverty, ethnic tensions and even outright war. It was, therefore, no surprise that the central European states looked to the west and the European Union. By 2001, most of the new democracies had applied to join both NATO and the EU. The ebb and flow of people across borders, and the changing nature of those borders, a process that Europe thought it had left behind in 1945, was returning with a vengeance.
Appendices:
Modern British-Ukrainian Connections – Three Case Studies:
Appendix One:
Hughesovka – A Case Study of the ‘Welsh’ city in Eastern Ukraine:
Since April 2014 Donetsk and its surrounding areas have been one of the major sites of fighting in the ongoing Donbas War, as pro-Russian separatist forces battle against Ukrainian military forces for control of the city and surrounding areas. Throughout the war, the city of Donetsk has been administered by the separatist forces as the centre of the Donetsk People’s Republic (DPR), with outlying territories of the Donetsk region divided between the two sides. Donetsk International Airport became the epicentre of the war with almost a year-long battle leading to massive casualties among civilians and total ruination of the northwestern neighbourhoods of the city.
Donetsk, formerly known as Aleksandrovka, Yuzivka, Yuzovka (Hughesovka), Stalino is an industrial city in eastern Ukraine located on the Kalmius River in the disputed area of Donetsk Oblast. While internationally recognized as being in Ukraine, the city is under the de facto administration of the Donetsk People’s Republic, which claims it as its capital city. The population was estimated at 905,364 (2021 est.) in the city core, with over 2 million in the metropolitan area (2011). According to the 2001 Ukrainian Census, Donetsk was the fifth-largest city in Ukraine. Administratively, Donetsk has been the centre of Donetsk Oblast, while historically, it is the unofficial capital and largest city of the larger economic and cultural Donets Basin (Donbas) region. Donetsk is adjacent to another major city, Makiivka, and along with other surrounding cities forms a major urban sprawl and conurbation in the region. Donetsk has been a major economic, industrial and scientific centre of Ukraine with a high concentration of heavy industries and a skilled workforce. The density of heavy industries (predominantly steel production, chemical industry, and coal mining) determined the city’s challenging ecological situation.
John James Hughes Born 1814 Merthyr Tydfil, Glamorgan, Wales Died 17 June 1889 (aged 74–75) Saint Petersburg, Russian Empire Buried: West Norwood Cemetery, London Known as the Founder of the city of Donetsk Engineer, businessman
The original settlement in the south of the European part of the Russian Empire was first mentioned as Aleksandrovka in 1779, during the reign of Empress Catherine the Great. In 1869 the Welsh businessman John Hughes founded a steel plant and several coal mines in the region, and the town was named Hughesovka or Yuzovka (Юзовка) in recognition of his role (“Yuz” being a Russian-language approximation of Hughes). Hughes was born in Merthyr Tydfil, Wales, where his father was head engineer at the Cyfarthfa Ironworks. It was there that Hughes started his career, under his father’s supervision. He then moved to Ebbw Vale, before joining the Uskside Foundry in Newport, Monmouthshire, in the 1840s. It was here that Hughes made his reputation and fortune, patenting a number of inventions in armaments and armour plating.
In the mid-1850s, Hughes moved to London to become manager of C.J. Mare and Company’s forges and rolling mills, which was then taken over by the Millwall Iron Works & Shipbuilding Company, part of the Millwall Iron Works, Shipbuilding and Graving Docks Company. Hughes was a director of the company when it foundered, and resultantly became manager of the residual Millwall Iron Works Company. In 1868, that Company received an order from the Imperial Russian Government for the plating of a naval fortress being built at Kronstadt on the Baltic Sea.
Hughes was born in Merthyr Tydfil CREDIT: Getty
Hughes accepted a concession from the Imperial Russian Government to develop metal works in the region, and in 1869 acquired a piece of land to the north of the Azov Sea from Russian statesman Sergei Kochubey (son of Viktor Kochubey). The worker’s settlement at the plant merged with Aleksandrovka and the place was named Yuzovo, later Yuzovka (Russian: Юзово, Юзовка), after Hughes. In its early period, it received immigrants from Wales, especially from the town of Merthyr Tydfil. He formed the ‘New Russia Company Ltd.’ to raise capital, and in the summer of 1870, at the age of fifty-five, he moved to Russia. He sailed with eight ships, carrying not only all the equipment necessary to establish metal works but also much of the skilled labour; a group of about a hundred ironworkers and miners, mostly from South Wales.
Welsh workers in the ironworks at Hughesovka, John Hughes is second from the right in the front row.
By the end of the nineteenth century, the Yuzovka works were the largest in the Russian Empire, producing 74% of Russian iron in 1913. A period of relative decline in the early years of the twentieth century was followed by expansion during World War I. Many of the men who accompanied John Hughes settled in Hughesovka and brought their wives and families. Over the years, although a Russian workforce was trained by the company, skilled workers from the United Kingdom continued to be employed, and many technical, engineering and managerial positions were filled by British immigrants; who were overwhelmingly Welsh. A thriving expatriate community was established, living in good quality company housing, and provided with an English school and an Anglican church. Despite the cold winters, hot summers and occasional cholera epidemics, some families remained in Hughesovka for many years.
Henry Taylor of Blaenafon with workers at Hughesovka, the 1890s
At the beginning of the 20th century, Yuzovka had approximately 50,000 inhabitants and attained the status of a city in 1917. So, the modern Ukrainian city of Donetsk began as the ironworking town of Hughesovka, founded by John Hughes of Merthyr Tydfil. South Wales, especially the town of Merthyr, was at the forefront of the development of the iron industry in Britain and it is therefore not surprising to find Welsh people leading the industry across the world in the nineteenth century. Many Welsh workers were employed there from 1869 until they were expelled during the Russian Revolution of 1917.
Hughesovka became Stalino in 1924 CREDIT: Getty
The Bolshevik revolution of 1917 ended the Hughes family’s connection to the works. The Hughes brothers and almost all their foreign employees returned to Britain or other countries. The works were nationalised by the Bolsheviks in 1919. During Soviet times, the city’s steel industry expanded. In 1924 Yuzovka was renamed Stalin and then in 1929 Stalino, and in 1932 the city became the centre of the Donetsk region.
Ruins of the Holy Transfiguration Cathedral, Donetsk, after its destruction by Soviet authorities in 1931. Image: Wiki Commons/State Archives of Donetsk region.
In 1929, when Yuzovka became Stalino, the USSR was producing, as Russia had done in 1914, about half as much steel as the United Kingdom, which in turn was producing half as much as Germany. Yet by 1937, when Stalin’s second five-year plan was completed, the gap had been virtually closed: The USSR was turning out considerably more steel than Britain and nearly as much as Germany. This achievement is visible on the map below in terms of urban population growth.
Stalin’s new industrial centres, including Stalino as the biggest, were dotted across what had been the ’empty’ corner of the continent. Renamed Donetsk (Donetske, according to the Kharkiv orthography) in 1961, the city today remains a centre for coal mining and for the steel industry. The works survived and prospered despite régime and socio-economic change, and Donetsk remains a major metallurgical industries centre today.
The re-built Cathedral of the Transfiguration of Jesus
A 2012 article, “Wales and the forgotten famine” – The ‘Holodomor’ in Ukraine:
The cost of Stalin’s forced industrialisation in human terms was immense, and almost unimaginable to people in western Europe then, let alone today. The peasantry, who had to provide the initial resources, were plundered and left to starve. Much of the labour needed was obtained by arbitrary arrest and most of those arrested were callously worked to death. More than a million people were shot out of hand; ten times as many as those who later died in the war-time camps. To ‘save’ Russians and Ukrainians from the Nazis, Stalin murdered beat and brutalised them in a reign of terror that even Hitler had difficulty matching. Yet little was known about this outside of the Soviet Union, partly because western politicians and journalists of the time did not wish to admit to the terror. Only recently has the full scale of this become clear and widely known.
A Holodomor memorial at the Andrushivka village cemetery, Vinnytsia oblast. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
The following article by Mick Antoniw, Welsh Assembly Member for Pontypridd, appeared in the Western Mail in early November 2012:
This weekend in Ukraine and in Ukrainian communities and homes across the world people will be commemorating the 79th anniversary of the “Holodomor“, the artificial famine created by Stalin which led to the deaths over an eighteen- month period during 1932-1933 of over seven million Ukrainian men women and children. The precise figures will never be known but estimates suggest between six and ten million died.
It is only in recent years, since the collapse of the Soviet Union that people in the West have become aware of this concealed and forgotten act of genocide.
As a child, brought up in a Ukrainian émigré community I became aware of the stories of the Holodomor. I grew up with some children whose families had survived and lived through these terrible events. In a hotchpotch community of the post war flotsam and jetsam of Ukraine, former soldiers from the Polish, Red and German armies, in some cases soldiers who had served in all three, ex partisans, nationalists, socialists, betrayed communists, ex-Gulag and concentration camp prisoners, former slave labourers and mere, ordinary refugees from the bombings and killings; all had their horror stories but all knew of and in some cases had experienced the Holodomor, the “death by famine”.
You might think that famine was nothing new; after all there was famine in the immediate post revolution period in Ukraine. However, this was different, a man-made famine which had as its main objectives, the forced collectivisation of land and the peasantry, and the wiping out of millions of Ukrainians and replacing them with more loyal, Russian speaking cadre, to appease Stalin’s feeling of political insecurity arising in central and South East Ukraine, the bread basket of Europe.
The famine also exposed the worst and the best in British journalism. The worst, typified by some of the left leaning journalists who visited and reported on the Soviet Union in glowing terms, feted and well looked after by the Soviet authorities they saw no famine. In fact suggestions there might be a famine on any thing like the scale suggested was immediately put down and rubbished as anti soviet or right-wing propaganda. Journalists of international acclaim such as the 1932 Pulitzer Prize winner Walter Duranty were seduced by the Soviet propaganda machine into allowing their hearts to overrule their heads and their responsibilities as journalists.
British and indeed international investigative journalism failed spectacularly. On the other side, the best of British journalism was exemplified by journalists such as Malcolm Muggeridge and in particular Welsh journalist Gareth Jones.After graduating from Cambridge in 1930, Barry born Gareth made his first visit to ‘Hughesovka’ (Donetsk) where he saw the first signs of famine. In 1933 he visited Soviet Ukraine again and defied a ban on travelling to visit the famine affected regions.During his March 1933 “off limits” walking tour of Ukraine he witnessed the famine first hand and reported:
“I walked alone through villages and twelve collective farms. Everywhere was the cry, “there is no bread, we are dying.”… In one of the peasant’s cottages in which I stayed we slept nine in the room. It was pitiful to see that two out of the three children had swollen stomachs. All there was to eat in the hut was a very dirty watery soup, with a slice or two of potato. Fear of death loomed over the cottage, for they had not enough potatoes to last until the next crop. When I shared my white bread and butter and cheese one of the peasant women said, “Now I have eaten such wonderful things I can die happy.” I set forth again further towards the south and heard the villagers say, “We are waiting for death.”
During the famine around 20-25% of the population of Soviet Ukraine was exterminated including a third of Ukraine’s children. That the famine was a direct product of Stalin’s political leadership was illustrated by the gruesome statement of leading communist MM Khatayevich who summed up the official position:
“A ruthless struggle is going on between the peasantry and our regime.It’s a struggle to the death. This year was a test of our strength and their endurance. It took a famine to show them who is master here. It has cost millions of lives, but the collective farm system is here to stay. We’ve won the war”.
Gareth Jones was vilified and ostracised for reporting honestly what he saw. He was nevertheless one of the few who stood up and maintained the highest journalistic principles. He was banned by the Soviet authorities from re-entering the Soviet Union. Two years later he was murdered in suspicious circumstances in Manchuria.
In recognition of Gareth Jones’ exposure of the famine a memorial plaque in English, Welsh and Ukrainian was unveiled in Aberystwyth in May 2006. In November 2008 I attended a ceremony in London at which his nephew was awarded the Ukrainian Order of Freedom. Wales has an unusual historic connection with Ukraine mainly arising out of its common industrial heritage. In Gareth Jones, Wales can be proud of something else; at a time when many turned a blind eye to the terrible events in Ukraine, it was a Welshman who stood up and told the world the truth.
Mick Antoniw, First posted on November 17, 2012, by AngloMagyarMedia.
The memorial plaque to Gareth Jones was unveiled in Aberystwyth in 2006.
Appendix Three: The Refugees’ Hymn – When are we going home?
The hymn How Great Thou Art owes much of its popularity to its extensive use in the Billy Graham crusades of the 1950s. But it owes its origins to a trail leading from Sweden to Britain via central-eastern Europe.
The sleeve from Stuart K Hine’s 1958 album featured a collection of hymns and tunes from eastern Europe.
The words in English are a translation of a Swedish poem, O store Gud, by Carl Boberg (1859-1940), an evangelist, journalist and for fifteen years a member of Sweden’s parliament. He was born the son of a shipyard worker on the southeast coast of Sweden. He came to faith at the age of nineteen and went to Bible School Kristinehamn. He returned to his native town of Monsteras as a preacher and it was there in 1886 that he wrote his nine-verse poem, inspired to praise God’s greatness one summer evening while looking across the calm waters of the inlet. A rainbow had formed, following a storm in the afternoon, and a church bell was tolling in the distance. Translated literally into English, the first verse of his poem reads:
O Thou great God! When I the world consider
Which Thou hast made by Thine almighty Word;
And how the web of life Thy wisdom guideth,
And all creation feedeth at Thy board:
Then doth my soul burst forth in song of praise:
O Thou great God! O Thou great God!
Stuart K Hine’s postcard from western Ukraine in the 1930s.
Boberg’s verses were set to music in 1891 and appeared in several Swedish hymnbooks around the turn of the century. An English translation was published in 1925 under the title O Mighty God, but never really caught on. Earlier, in 1912, a Russian version by Ivan Prokhanoff had appeared. This was almost certainly made from a German translation of the original Swedish hymn. The English translation was the work of British missionary and evangelist, Stuart K Hine (1899-1989), who heard it being sung in Russian in western Ukraine, where he had gone in 1923. After singing the hymn in Russian for many years, Hine translated the first three verses while continuing his missionary work in the Carpathian mountains in the 1930s. The scenery there inspired his second verse which draws little from Boberg’s original poem while remaining true to its general spirit of wonder at God’s creation:
When through the woods and forest glades I wander
And hear the birds sing sweetly in the trees:
When I look down from lofty mountain grandeur,
And hear the brook, and feel the gentle breeze;
Then sings my soul, my saviour God, to Thee,
How great Thou art! How great Thou art!
Stuart Hine wrote the fourth verse of his hymn when he was back in Britain in 1948. In that year more than a hundred thousand refugees from Eastern Europe streamed into the United Kingdom. The question uppermost in their minds was When are we going home? In an essay on the history of the hymn, Hine wrote:
What better message for the homeless than that of the One who went to prepare a place for the ‘displaced’, of the God who invites into his own home those who will come to him through Christ.
Contrasting with a third verse which is about Christ’s ‘bearing’ of our individual burdens of sin on the cross, the final verse is about our places among the multitudes on the ‘last day’, just like the mass of homeless refugees finding a temporary home in Britain:
When Christ shall come with shout of acclamation
And take me home – what joy shall fill my heart!
Then shall I bow in humble adoration
And there proclaim, my God, how great Thou art!
Seventy years ago, Stuart Hine published both the Russian and the English versions of the hymn in his gospel magazine Grace and Peace in 1949. It is perhaps worth remembering that, by then, many refugees from the Soviet Union had been ‘homeless’ for almost the entire decade. It was in 1940-41, following his ‘Winter War’ against Finland, that Stalin ordered the evacuation of Karelia with those returning forced to leave permanently. That was followed by the resettlement of two million Poles, mostly Catholic, from eastern Ukraine to northern Russia and the deportation to Siberia of Germans and other ‘unreliable’ peoples – Estonians, Latvians, Lithuanians, Tartars, Kalmuks and Caucasians to Siberia. Hundreds of thousands of ‘ethnic Ukrainians’, especially Cossacks, were also transported there. To strengthen the ‘Soviet peoples’ (presumably the Russians, Georgians, Kazaks and Ukrainians), such deportations were continued after the war.
Refugees and displaced peoples after 1945. Thirty million million Europeans, 60% of them German, lost their homeland. Almost all ethnic and national borders coincide since that time, also in eastern-central Europe. To care for the ‘displaced persons’ (D.P.’s for labourers, refugees of international background and the deported, the UN took over the 1945 UNRRA and transformed it into the IRO in 1947, which was then attached to the UNHCR in 1951.
O Lord My God rapidly caught on in evangelical circles both in Britain and the UK, as well as in Eastern Europe, despite (or perhaps because of) the oppression of the churches by the Soviet-style communist régimes that were taking control of the states where the hymn was first heard.
Sources:
Laurence Rees (2008), World War Two: Behind Closed Doors – Stalin, The Nazis and the West. London: BBC Books.
András Bereznay, Mark Almond, et.al. (2001), The Times Atlas of European History. London: Harper Collins.
Jeremy Isaacs & Taylor Downing (1998), Cold War. London: Transworld Publishers.
John Simpson (1998), Strange Places, Questionable People. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
Richard Overy (1996), The Penguin Atlas of the Third Reich. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
John Simpson (1990), Despatches from the Barricades. London: Hutchinson.
Colin McEvedy (1982), The Penguin Atlas of Recent History. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
Hermann Kinder & Werner Hilgemann (1978), The Penguin Atlas of World History, volume two: from the French Revolution to the Present. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
Irene Richards, et.al. (1938), A Sketch-Map History of the Great War and After. London: Harrap.
George Taylor (1936), A Sketch-Map History of Europe, 1789-1914. London: Harrap.
“As you know, this conflict did not start today. It is my firm belief that its initiators are not the peoples of Russia and Ukraine, who came from one Kievan baptismal font, are united by common faith, common saints and prayers, and share common historical fate.“
In a 10 March letter, quoted above, H.H. Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and all Russia responded to a letter sent 2 March by World Council of Churches (WCC) acting general secretary Rev. Prof. Dr Ioan Sauca asking the Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church to mediate so that the war can be stopped. His letter repeated the claims recently made in a newspaper article written by Russian President, Vladimir Putin, with whom the Patriarch is said to have a close relationship. In his letter, he did not undertake to mediate in order to stop the war but accused ‘Western leaders’ of bringing sufferings not only to the Russian political or military leaders but specifically to the Russian people. He went on to assert that Russophobia is spreading across the Western world at an unprecedented pace. He concluded:
I pray unceasingly that by His power the Lord help establish the lasting and justice-based peace as soon as possible. I ask you and our brothers in Christ, united in the Council, to share this prayer with the Russian Orthodox Church.
Dear Father Ioan, I express my hope that even in these trying times, as has been the case throughout its history, the World Council of Churches will be able to remain a platform for unbiased dialogue, free from political preferences and one-sided approach.
May the Lord preserve and save the peoples of Russia and Ukraine!
With paternal love,
/+KIRILL/ PATRIARCH OF MOSCOW AND ALL RUSSIA
In this first of two articles, I attempt to address, as an economic, social and political historian as well as a church historian, what I believe are the mistaken interpretations of Ukrainian, Russian and wider central-eastern European history which have been used by President Putin and Patriarch Kirill in justification of the Russian state’s invasion of Ukraine and its continuing war against the Ukrainian people as a whole. In doing so, I have tried to limit myself to the use of factual accounts and sources, including historical maps, while also trying to explain how Soviet-era ‘historiography’ has been used to create a ‘fake history’ and ‘mythology’ of relations between the ancestors of both Ukrainians and Russians over the past twelve hundred and sixty years since the founding of Kyiv as a trading centre the Rus, and the other peoples of central-eastern Europe. The ‘mythology’ has been powerfully linked to the ‘sanctification’ of the invasion of Ukraine through the Ruski Mir, the Russian ‘World-view’ which holds that Russians, Belorussians and Ukrainians are the same people in ethnicity, religion and culture.
Vikings, Traders & Tribes:
‘Hungarians at Kyiv’ – a painting by Pál Vágó (1853-1928). Tough many attempts, based in part on archaeological finds and in part on old accounts, were made to depict Hungarian prehistory and the Conquest at the time of the Millennium and the turn of the twentieth century, much uncertainty still attends the pre-history of the Hungarians., the period before they arrived in the Carpathian Basin. It is difficult to maintain, on the basis of archaeological evidence from the territories known today as part of the Ukraine and Russia, that these relics are unmistakably Hungarian. It is probable, however, that as a result of the extensive and multibranched archaeological research, many such finds today lie hidden in the area of the former Soviet Union, mainly in smaller regional museums, which through further scientific investigation will identify as being of ancient Hungarian origin.
Towards the end of the eighth century, while Charlemagne still ruled over his Frankish Empire, bands of hardy ‘pirates’ or ‘Vikings’ from the northern lands of Scandinavia. Driven by landlessness, poverty, and discontent, these pagan warriors sailed forth in search of trade, plunder, and adventure. In their long narrowboats, they made daring raids all around the coasts of Europe and up and down the rivers of the east as far as Kyiv on the Dnieper. Swedish adventurers, under a leader called Rurik, established a trading centre there in 862, with another one at Novgorod in among the northern ‘Rus’. However, evidence of Scandinavian activity east of the Baltic in the ninth and tenth centuries is ambiguous. A large number of coins from ‘northern Russia’ found in Scandinavia may indicate trade, plunder, tribute, or the payment of mercenaries. Islamic texts also refer to the “Rus” as traders who were settled in Kyiv as early as the mid-ninth century. Besides Kyiv and Novgorod, they also held a base at Staraya Ladoga. From their merchant kingdom, they sailed down the Dnieper and around the western coast of the Black Sea to attack the wealthy city of Constantinople (Micklegarth), which was besieged in 907. Links with Byzantium, where Northmen became members of the Imperial bodyguard led to their eventual conversion to Christianity.
It is striking how marriage alliances throughout the tenth century created links of varying strength between England, France, Burgundy, Germany, Bohemia, Russia, Bulgaria, and Byzantium, and to how international many of royal courts of Western Europe were at this time, welcoming scholars and ambassadors from many countries. Tenth-century Europe was also marked by the emergence of political entities in the northern and eastern parts of the continent. The marauders of the previous century, the Vikings in the north, the Magyars in the east, formed settled kingdoms. In the east, the Piasts extended their rule to Cracow in the south, and east and west. Rapid expansion on the part of the Kyivan Rus, notably under Igor in the 940s, enlarged the territories over which they had control at the expense of their Polish and Khazar neighbours. Later expeditions by Sviatoslav against the Khazars in 965, Volga Bulgars in 966, and the Bulgars on the lower Danube in 967 resulted in many gains, albeit temporary. Trade, too, played an important role in the growing importance of the Rus. From the coin evidence, it is clear that the Samanid rulers of Transoxania had become very rich at the end of the ninth century as a result of the discovery of silver in Afghanistan. They minted vast quantities of coinage and their merchants began to trade with the Volga Bulgars, Rus, Ves, Lapps, and Finns.
Showing States created by conquests in the core areas of the Vikings in the ninth and tenth centuries.
Significant expansion by the Kyivan Rus had much to do with their wealth, but the cultural links formed in the wake of mercantile connections were also crucial for political developments as Rus interests increasingly focused to the west and south towards the end of the tenth century. The formal conversion of Olga, the regent as Igor’s widow, and the marriage of Vladimir to the Byzantine princess Anna provided an essential connection with Byzantium, which was of great importance for Russia’s future development. The formal conversion of Vladimir and the Rus to Greek Orthodox Christianity in 987 in the wake of the marriage meant that the Kyivan Rus interests were increasingly pursued in the west and south towards the end of the tenth century. The Semanids succumbed to the Turks in 998, after which Bulgar on the Volga developed rapidly as a trading centre and the Volga Bulgars were supplied in turn by the Rus, who continued to trade actively with Constantinople and the Islamic regions.
Central-Eastern Europe in the Tenth Century.
The Emergence of Feudal States & Alliances:
Feudalism was the dominant system of political control and social organisation over much of eleventh-century Europe. The ‘state’ in the modern sense – an agreed territory with sovereign powers and clear borders, and with a precise relationship with all its citizens, simply did not exist. Instead, there was a series of individual rulers each effectively sovereign within his own lands, though each in turn nominally owing allegiance to a king or other ruler. As a consequence, the map of feudal Europe is complex. Much of it was dominated by principalities, duchies, and counties, so that even countries such as France, while united in theory, were in practice far from being so. This fragmented authority nonetheless provided the political context for a marked rise in Europe’s population, prosperity, and culture. The Church, too, Catholic and Orthodox, had an important act on the map of Europe, as many abbots and bishops were landowners on a grand scale, often with correspondingly great political powers. Even outside the lands of the former Carolingian Empire, where feudalism was at its strongest, ‘states’ were dependent on successful military-political leadership. The death of a strong leader could easily lead to political collapse. This danger was amply demonstrated in the early decades of the century by the fortunes of the Kyivan Rus and the Umayyad Caliphate of Cordova. The Kyivan Rus dissolved after the death of Vladimir I of Rus (c.978-1015), who was succeeded by sons who ruled separate principalities based on Novgorod, Polotsk, and Chernihiv.
The First ‘Russian State’ was established by the Kyivan Rus, circa 987.
Because the existence of ‘states’ often depended on the personal authority of a strong leader, large areas could be joined in a single lifetime. Thus in 1013, King Swein of Denmark conquered England, while the English king, Aethelred fled to Normandy. He returned when Swein died in 1014, but Swein’s son Cnut continued the struggle, while divisions between Saxons and Anglo-Normans handicapped the resistance. After Aethelred’s death, England was divided between Eadmund ‘Ironside’, his son, and Cnut, by the Peace of Alney in 1016. Cnut received Mercia and Northumbria, while Edmund continued to rule Wessex, including Kent. However, Edmund died the same year and Cnut became King of All England (1016-35). On the death of his elder brother, Harold, King of Denmark (1019), England became part of a Scandinavian empire, which expanded further with the conquest of Norway in the 1020s. In 1031 Cnut advanced to the Tay and received the submission of Malcolm II of Scotland. The essentially personal nature of authority was demonstrated, however, by Cnut’s empire: he did not create any administrative system to weld it together. Cnut was the king of a number of kingdoms, not a monarch seeking to enlarge one of them. After his death in 1035, his empire dissolved, but not before it had provided an important connection with the Kyivan Rus.
Archaeological finds along the banks of the Oder and Vistula reveal that the Hungarian kingdom of the House of Árpád also had direct commercial relations with the Vikings in the tenth century. The road across Russia, and especially to Kyiv, seem to have played a prominent role in these relations. St István’s coins have also been found as far north as the Faroe Islands. According to a passage in a chronicle written in French verse by Gaimar, who lived in Northumbria, the first Christian king of Hungary, István (1000 or 1001–1038) was acquainted with the Dane Valgarus even before he brought the sons of Eadmund Ironside to the Hungarian Royal Court at some point soon after Canute’s seizure of the English crown in 1016. But this is the only written record linking the Vikings and the Magyars. It was not until 1012 that St Colman decided to take the Danube road on his pilgrimage to Palestine from Ireland. He never got as far as Hungary, however, as he was killed by Austrian peasants who mistook him for a spy. But the fact that he chose the route along the Danube testifies to the new attitude of western nations towards Hungary, with pilgrims and traders now being able to approach István’s crown lands without fear. Nevertheless, for some centuries, only a few pilgrims from the British Isles made their way across the country.
King Cnut and Queen Aelgifu (Emma) receiving symbols of their power from Christ, present an altar cross to the New Minster at Winchester, from a manuscript written and decorated at Winchester in 1031. The double portrait acknowledges their importance to each other.
The first mention of Hungary in Western European sources was recorded when St István received the two young sons of Eadmund Ironside at his Court, exiles from Canute’s Court following his takeover of their father’s kingdom in 1016. As already noted, Eadmund died on 30 November 1016, shortly after reaching his agreement with Cnut, King of Denmark, deciding the boundaries of his realm. He left behind his Queen, Ealdgyth, and two small sons, Eadmund and Edward. Cnut’s advisor, Eadric, tried to persuade his king to have the two little orphans put out of the way as they might cause trouble in the future. However, since Cnut had already gained control of the whole of the kingdom, he had no desire to sully his name and new kingdom with the blood of children. Instead, he dispatched the two boys to Sweden, with the command that the boys should meet their end there. The boys were both very young, and Edward (the youngest) could only have been a few months old. But Olaf Sköttkonung, the devout Christian King of Sweden, was revolted at the idea of murdering the ‘innocents’, especially since Canute himself was unable or unwilling to undertake the atrocity. Besides, the princes’ grandfather, Aethelred the Unready, had been an old ally of his. He decided that the boys be taken for sanctuary to Hungary, to István’s court.
The painting on the left is ‘The Baptism of Vajk’ by Gyula Benczúr. Vajk became King István (Stephen), the first Christian king of Hungary.
Presumably, they were taken through Kyivan Rus in 1017-18, but the Anglo-Saxon chronicles record nothing further of them for the next forty years. It may be that the boys were removed to Kyiv in 1028, following Cnut’s deposition of King Olav. They must therefore have arrived in Hungary with Valgarus long before King István’s death in 1038 since we know from the Hungarian sources researched by the inter-war historian, Sándor Fest, that István received them cordially and educated them with deep affection. Eadmund, the elder of the two died young, but in due course, again according to the Anglo-Hungarian sources, Edward (‘the Exile’) married a Hungarian noblewoman, Agatha (Ágota), apparently a relative of both the German Emperor and István himself. She bore him three children: Margaret, Christine, and Edgar. The three children were educated in Hungary until 1057 when, after four decades of exile, Edward was recalled to England with his family by the childless and ageing Anglo-Norman king, Edward the Confessor (1042-66), Aethelred’s remaining son, who was delighted to hear of his nephew’s survival and therefore that of the House of Wessex. However, Edward of Wessex was to die in mysterious circumstances soon after the family’s return to England, once again leaving his uncle without a natural heir, since Edgar was only a child, far too young to inherit the throne. This led to the dynastic conflict which ended with the Norman Conquest following the Confessor’s death. Harald Hardrada of Norway invaded England, unsuccessfully, in 1066, and there was a further Danish incursion in 1069-70. With the Normans’ completion of their conquest, the Viking era of English history, which had begun with the raids of 789, was at an end.
Meanwhile, a divided succession had characterised the Kyivan Rus territories in the east as it had with Cnut’s empire. The Kyivan principalities had been united under Jaroslav the Wise (1019-54) of Novgorod, who, after the death of his brother, the Prince of Chernihiv, ruled them all save Polotsk. It was a period of particular Kyivan political expansion, as shown on the map below, and one of extensive cultural influence. The map below right, at the top, shows The Development of the Kyivan Rus, 862-1031 with the area in brown showing the territory added by them by 1000. The single green line shows the approximate western frontier of the Khazar Empire in the early ninth century and the broken green line shows its frontier in 967.
The expansion of Poland under Boleslaw I Chobry, ‘the Brave’ (992-1025, shown on the map below) was an overlapping feature of the development of the Kyivan Rus territories at this time. Boleslaw built on the foundations of the Polish ‘state’ created by his father, Prince Mieszko I, who had converted to Christianity in 965. Boleslaw strengthened the centre by creating an administrative system based on counts and used this as a base to expand Polish territory to the east, south, and west, taking Cracow (formerly a Bohemian territory) in 999. Many of Boleslaw’s conquests were temporary and involved long, debilitating wars on all frontiers. The conquest of Little Poland, which included Cracow, was permanent, however, and Casimir I (1038-58) transferred his residence there. At first, it was a dependent territory of the Holy Roman Emperor Otto III, who crowned Boleslaw King of Poland in 1000, but Boleslaw broke with the Empire after Otto’s death in 1002. He seized the imperial lands of Moravia (1003), Lusatia (1018), and Bohemia, though he controlled the latter for only two years (1003-4). Boleslaw further increased Polish influence in the east when he placed his son-in-law, Svyatopolk, on the throne of Kyiv in 1018. Boleslaw was again crowned King of Poland in 1024, this time by an Archbishop with the assent of the Pope, symbolising his independence from imperial control.
Some Russian and Ukrainian historians have also claimed, some quite recently, that Edward the Exile’s wife Agatha was ‘Agafija’, daughter of the Grand Duke Jaroslav the Wise of Kyiv. They claim that she married Edward Aetheling after he and his brother arrived at Jaroslav’s court in 1028. However, even if he was in Kyiv, Edward would have been only twelve at this time, too young even for a betrothal. We know that Agafija’s ‘sister’, Anastasia, referred to below, became the wife of Andrew I, István’s eventual successor. Her mother, Jaroslav’s wife was Ingergerd, who herself was the daughter of King Olaf of Sweden, another reason for Edward and Eadmund’s original refuge at the court in Kyiv. Anastasia, who was born in about 1020, married Andrew in around 1038, after he had fled with his brother Levente from Hungary to Kyiv in 1030. It is possible that Edward went with him, and returned with him to Hungary in around 1046 when Andrew became king, having fought in Andrew’s army. The problem with the ‘Rus’ solution to the Agatha mystery, however, is that Adam of Bremen only mentions the marriages of three of Jaroslav’s daughters, including Anna, who married Henry I of France, together with the marriages to the kings of Norway and Hungary, but not that of Agatha, or Agafija.
Medieval Hungarian chronicles also state that King Andrew I had an illegitimate son named Georgius by a woman from the village of Pilismarót. It has been claimed that Georgius accompanied the Wessex exiles back to Britain in 1057, settling with other Magyar nobles in Scotland and that the Clan Drummond is descended from George and his son Maurice. His name became popular among Orthodox believers, and one historian has written that Georgius’ mother may have been a Rus lady-in-waiting to Andrew’s wife, Anastasia of Kyiv. This is perhaps the origin of the confusion between Agatha, the mother of the three Wessex children, and the Royal Court of Kyiv. As to Agatha’s own name, although Greek in origin (meaning ‘good woman’), the name of a third-century martyr and Orthodox saint, it was popular in the Middle Ages throughout Europe, not just in the eastern parts, including in the French ‘Agace’ and the Latin ‘Agacia’, though it fell out of use in the later Middle Ages. The Hungarian form, Ágota, is still quite common today, however. It cannot, therefore, be taken as an indication that the Exile’s wife was a woman of Orthodox origin, as has been suggested. There is also a fresco of Jaroslav, Ingergerd, and their daughters, of uncertain eleventh-century date, in the Saint Sophia Cathedral in Kyiv, built by Jaroslav, which shows only three daughters. Some have sought to identify a fourth in the fresco, arguing that this could be Agatha, but this has been largely disproved. David J Webber concludes that the scientific and artistic evidence of the fresco shows this figure to be a young son and besides, that there is no written evidence of a fourth daughter, so that the Agatha mystery, for him at least, remains unsolved. For this purpose, Hungarian links to western Catholic states were more significant in the period of the Árpád dynasty.
More importantly for current purposes, the ‘Rus’ theory is largely based on an attempt by some historians of medieval central-eastern Europe to emphasise the importance of Russian imperial and dynastic links rather than the much more complex reality of the time, which was the struggle to establish independent states. Christian Raffensperger has recently emphasised the significance of ties of kinship between the ‘Rus’ and other royal dynasties, but in his review for the Medieval Journal of America, Alexandr Musin argues that Soviet historiography has played a decisive role in the construction of a myth about Ágota’s Kyivan origins in Raffensperger’s two books:
… the main challenge of both publications resides in the contradiction between the potential creativity of innovative approaches and the tyranny of concepts, which in many cases determines the vision of the past. On the one hand, the concept of (the) Rus that the author develops seriously questions the traditional perception of medieval eastern Europe as ‘alter orbis’ in respect to Latin civilization. On the other hand, the author shares the idea of the Kingdom of Rus as a clearly identifiable entity with a unitary system of political power, law, taxation, and culture based at Kiev that spanned territory from the White Sea to the Black Sea.
Today it is not necessary to specify that this geopolitical monster was only the invention of Soviet historian Boris Grekov. His concept of ‘Kievan Rus’ created in the 1930s was a “Soviet Union” projected into the medieval past. In fact, medieval eastern Europe was more a federation of semi-independent local polities with special identities and serious cultural differences, ruled by different branches of familial dynasties and nominally consolidated by the unity of ecclesiastical power.
Aleksandr Musin, Institute for the History of Material Culture, Russian Academy of Sciences.
The Rus Principalities & The Mongol Invasions:
Developing feudal states of central-eastern Europe in the eleventh century.
In the east, when he died in 1054, Jaroslav the Wise left each of his sons an autonomous principality. The Great Principality of Kyiv took precedence but it exercised little control over the others. Raids by Polovtsy nomads, who sacked Kyiv in 1093, weakened the Great Principality, moving the centre of Rus activity farther north to the forest belt and away from the exposed steppes but, as the map below for 1095 shows, the Rus principalities continued to develop as distinct territories. In the twelfth century, the centre of Rus activity continued to move towards the forest belt.
Central-Eastern Europe in the Late Eleventh Century, showing the early formation of the Rus states.
A new principality, Suzdal, developed in this area, while in 1126 Novgorod became a republic; it soon extended its power to the White Sea. In 1169 Kyiv was again sacked, this time by Suzdal and the title of the Great Prince was transferred to the new principality, becoming known as the Great Prince of Vladimir, after its capital. Eastern Europe suffered great turmoil in the thirteenth century, undergoing significantly greater territorial changes than occurred in Western Europe in the period. The Mongol invasions devastated the region; the northern principalities of the Rus were overrun in 1233-9; Kyiv was stormed and razed in 1240; in 1240-4, the Mongols tore through Hungary, taking Pest, while smaller forces poured into Poland, took Cracow and defeated a German-Polish army at Walstatt in 1241 before the hordes were recalled on the death of the Great Khan Ogedai later that year.
Central-Eastern Europe in the Twelfth Century, the Time of the Crusades.
Above: Eastern Hungary and Galich (Galicia) before and during the Mongol Invasions, 1140-1240.
The Growth of Poland & Lithuania:
In 1310, John of Luxembourg was elected King of Bohemia and Moravia (1310-46). He held much of Poland too, particularly Mazovia (1329-51), including Warsaw, and most of Silesia. Despite their loss of territories, under Wladyslaw I (1305-33), Poland successfully resisted overall rule by the kings of Bohemia. To the east, Lithuania under Gediminas (1316-41) was emerging as an important power, expanding into the northern Rus principalities, which were greatly weakened by the Golden Horde, the Mongols who settled the steppes after the invasion of 1240. The damage done to the Rus principalities created an opportunity for Lithuania to thrive. Founded in the thirteenth century by Mindaugas (d. 1263), this pagan state could not expand towards the Baltic because of the activity of the Teutonic Knights. Instead, it expanded east, which saw the seizure of the northern Rus principality of Polotsk as well as Podlasia.
The Mongol Invasions of the Thirteenth Century and ‘The High Middle Ages.’
During the joint reign of Algirdas (1345-77) and Kestutis (1345-82), the southern lands of the Kyivan Rus were overrun. Lithuania, therefore, absorbed Kyiv – which fell in 1362-3 – and the remaining central Rus principalities; Novgorod-Severski also fell in 1363. The Lithuanians thus expanded up to the lands of the Golden Horde, who were then pushed back, so that by 1392 the Lithuanians had reached the Black Sea to the west of the Dnieper. Meanwhile, Moscow became the seat of a growing Russian principality, Muscovy. At the beginning of the fourteenth century, the power of the rulers of Hungary had been greatly limited by the growth of aristocratic power. The native Árpád dynasty died out in 1301 and the first of the Angevin rulers was elected king in 1308. From his capital at Visegrád, Charles I (1308-42) reduced the power of the magnates, greatly increased royal authority, and strengthened the economy. but it proved difficult to retain control of frontier areas. His successor, Louis the Great (1342-82) considerably extended Hungarian territorial power. To the east, Moldavia emerged under the suzerainty of Hungary from 1372, which then gradually expanded its power towards the Dniester and the Black Sea. To the north, Galich-Lodomeria (Galicia) was gained by Hungary in 1370, and in the same year, Louis succeeded the childless Casimir the Great as King of Poland. Under John of Luxembourg and his son, Charles IV, (1346-78), the power of the Luxembourg dynasty grew greatly, as Charles was also Holy Roman Emperor. This amalgamation did not, however, long survive the death of Louis in 1382, an indication of the transient nature of state-building, especially in central-eastern Europe. Often, there was no political, strategic, ethnic, economic, or geographical logic to these conglomerations and no real constituency of interest behind them.
The Recovery and Consolidation of the Central-Eastern European States in the Fourteenth Century.
After Louis’ death, without a male heir, his elder daughter married Sigismund, bringing the Hungarian Crown lands under the Habsburgs. Charles also made Moravia, Silesia and Lusatia indissoluble parts of the Bohemian crownlands. Sigismund (1387-1437) became King of Hungary in 1387, Emperor in 1410 and King of Bohemia in 1419, taking Luxembourg power to its greatest heights, but this did not serve as the basis of a long-lasting state. But Poland remained independent under Louis’ younger daughter, Hedvig. In 1385, by her marriage to the Grand Duke of Lithuania, Jagiello, he became King Wladyslaw II of Poland (1386-1434). In return, by the terms of The Treaty of Krevo, the Lithuanians converted to Catholicism, although the two states continued to operate as separate entities. In 1410, however, the Polish-Lithuanian forces advanced into Prussia where they crushed the Teutonic Knights at Tannenburg. The Knights were greatly weakened, their period of expansion being brought to a definitive end. Uniting Poland with Lithuania made it an important power in central-eastern Europe until the sixteenth century.
The Advance of the Ottoman Turks & the Wars of Religion:
The Ottoman Advance from the Late Fourteenth Century.
Meanwhile, in addition to the growing Ottoman threat to the south-east, the century was one of a crisis caused by the ‘Black Death’, the bubonic plague which devastated the whole of Europe from 1346 to 1353, killing at least twenty million out of a total population of about eighty million. Recovery was hindered by further outbreaks towards the end of the century. This also helped to provoke social and economic tensions: the refined feudal system of the “High Middle Ages” broke down, helping to cause a wave of rural and urban disorder. There were crises in the Catholic Church too, with the transfer of the Papacy to Avignon (1305-77) and the Great Schism (1378-1417) in western Christendom between the rival Popes in Avignon and Rome. The fifteenth century was in some senses the age of the “new monarchies”, consolidated states with more definite frontiers and greater bureaucracies, which sought to know exactly where they could impose their demands for resources and where they needed to create their first line of defence. Central and Eastern Europe experienced a time of particular turmoil, with the ever-present threat of the Ottoman forces diverting much-needed resources to the defence of Christendom. In 1453, Mehmet II finally captured Constantinople, causing great consternation throughout Europe. His army then laid siege to Belgrade in 1456, but the siege was raised by the brilliant Hungarian leader, János Hunyadi. However, by 1460, the final Byzantine strongholds had fallen and with the capture of Trebizond on the Black Sea in 1461, the last remaining embers of Byzantium were finally extinguished.
Bohemia, meanwhile, was rent by religious dissent, with the followers of Jan Hus, who had been burnt at the stake by the Council of Constance in 1415, seizing power in 1419. It was not until 1436 that Sigismund, the Hungarian King, was able to reassert his authority there. In 1457 the Bohemians elected the Hussite George of Podébrady as King of Bohemia. Pope Paul II preached a crusade against him, which led to an unsuccessful Hungarian invasion in 1468 which nevertheless led to the partition of the Bohemian kingdom. Hunyadi’s son, Matthias Corvinus, was King of Hungary from 1458 to 1490, gained control of Moravia, Silesia and Lusatia and took the title “King of Bohemia”, though he did not control the Bohemian territory itself. Corvinus was a renaissance ruler who promoted learning throughout the lands he ruled, developing the Hungarian state considerably, but he faced opposition from the nobles concerned about maintaining their privileges. The Polish-Lithuanian Jagiellonian dynasty had a long-standing connection with Hungary. Wladyslaw I had been King of Hungary from 1440 to 1444, and after the death of Matthias Corvinus in 1490, the Hungarians chose Ladislav II of Bohemia as their King. He rejoined to Bohemia those areas which had been conquered by Hungary under Corvinus. Although Hungary and Bohemia remained separate kingdoms, their joint rule by the Jagiellonian dynasty might have produced a closer union. The late fifteenth century saw a consolidation of many European states and their coalescence into the contours that were to shape Europe’s borders until the crisis of nationalism four centuries later. The expansion of Muscovy to 1466 was a slow process that owed much to the determination of its ruling house.
Though the rulers of the Rus had been under the shadow of Mongols, and their northern descendants, the Muscovites were able to use this to their advantage in the challenges they faced from other Rus rulers, such as the princes of Tver, who were not subdued until 1468, however. Other Rus states were unable to resist Muscovy’s expansion and by the end of the century, Muscovy had emerged as the predominant principality in what was now described as ‘Russia’. The capture of Novgorod in 1478 marked the emergence of a new power in the east, and one that, with the disappearance of the Byzantine Empire, could now also claim to be the champion of Orthodox Christianity. Ivan III, the “Great” (1462-1505), who conquered both Tver and Novgorod, refused to pay tribute to the Golden Horde and defied its attempt to intimidate him into doing so (1480). In 1493, significantly, he took the title Sovereign of all Russia. Certainly, by then, he was the ruler of the Great Principality of Moscow, but this did not include the southern Rus who were then under the control of Lithuania.
The Growth of Lithuania to 1526.
Lithuania also claimed to be the heir of the Kyivan Rus, and Ivan was in conflict with it for most of his reign. In the early stages, he stirred his allies in the Crimea to raid Lithuania and, spinning a network of negotiations as far afield as Turkey, Moldavia, Austria and Denmark, he contested Lithuania’s sovereignty over the principalities on the borders of Russia. At the end of this first bout of diplomacy in 1494, Alexander the Grand Prince of Lithuania, not only recognised Ivan’s conquests but also married his daughter Elena the following year. The second bout (1500-03) began with an important victory for Ivan on the Vedrosha River (July 1500) and by the six-year truce which followed 1503, he kept all the lands he had conquered. When he died in 1505, he left Russia in a strong position to take both Smolensk and Kyiv at some point in the future. The fall of Pskov in 1510 marked the completion of this process of integration. Throughout Europe in the late Middle Ages, national boundaries had been hardened and the concept of “statehood” was emergent, becoming politically more significant than the “nation”, in its original meaning of a people of common descent.
After Wladyslaw II died he was succeeded in both Hungary and Bohemia by Louis II (1515-26; known as Ludwig I in Bohemia), but his reign was cut short when he was killed at the Battle of Mohács in 1526 when Suleiman the Magnificent destroyed Hungary’s army and independence. Louis had no children, and his inheritance was to be contested by his brother-in-law, Archduke Ferdinand, the brother of the Habsburg Charles V, and the Turks were to take control of the land east of the Danube. Neighbouring Moldavia was already a fiefdom of Poland-Lithuania, previously of Hungary under Corvinus, part of which had fallen under Ottoman control from 1484. Having become Emperor in 1519, Charles V faced an immense task in keeping his domains united. The rise of Protestantism in the first half of the fifteenth century placed an additional strain on the Empire. In 1529, the Sultan’s army besieging Vienna failed to take it, but the Turks’ gains confined the Habsburgs to Slovakia, Croatia and a thin strip of land along the west bank of the Danube. Although the successors of Charles V had vast resources at their disposal, they had to fight on several fronts, against the infidel Muslim threat in the east and the heretical Protestant challenge in the west. In the centre, Hungary was effectively divided into three parts. In the west, Ferdinand of Austria continued to rule over less than a third of the old kingdom (so-called Royal Hungary). In the east, Transylvania, a new state of Hungarian character and leadership was created under the loose control of the Ottomans. The third part was ruled directly by the Sultan who gradually extended the area he fully controlled until 1568 when the new frontiers were settled by the Treaty of Adrianople.
1530: The Habsburg Ascendancy, Ottoman occupation and the triumph of the nation-state in central-eastern Europe.
Although Eastern Europe escaped the intense religious wars that plagued the west, stability eluded the rulers even there. The Teutonic Order of Knights had never entirely recovered from its defeat by Polish-Lithuanian forces at Tannenberg (Grünwald) in 1410. By 1513 it was left with just East Prussia, and in 1525 they converted to Protestantism and secularised the remaining Teutonic lands as the Duchy of Prussia, the largest Protestant fief in the kingdom of Poland. Further south, for nearly two centuries following the union of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania and the Kingdom of Poland in 1386, the relationship had been a personal one, formed and sustained through dynastic inter-marriage. However, by the 1560s it was obvious that Sigismund II Augustus would be the last of the Jagiellonian line. For the Lithuanians, the implications of the loss of the link with Poland was dire. Lithuania had been under threat from both the Ottomans, who had seized territory on the lower Dnieper and the Muscovites, who were pressing westwards under Ivan the Terrible (1533-1584). This left Poland and particularly Lithuania vulnerable to interference by Russia. In this, the spectre of religious division as a tool of dynastic politics also arose, as many of the inhabitants of Lithuania were Orthodox, and Muscovy saw them as potential subjects. Only Polish support could guarantee Lithuania, while the union between the two countries offered the Polish nobility the prospect of fresh lands for settlement. In 1569 at Lublin, a Lithuanian Parliament specially called into existence agreed with the traditional Polish ‘Sejm’ (the bicameral parliament) to form an “indissoluble” union or “commonwealth” and to elect a common monarch after the childless Sigismund II’s death. But Poland and Lithuania were to remain distinct states, each with its own army, administration, and laws.
Meanwhile, in Bohemia, a movement of religious and political dissent against the Habsburgs had developed during the seventeenth century. By 1618, the largely Protestant Bohemian aristocracy was in open revolt over the closure of the reformed churches by the Habsburg authorities and their seizure of church funds. They decided to choose the neighbouring Calvinist ruler of the Palatinate, Frederick V, as King of Bohemia. He also had estates bordering Bohemia to the east at Eger in northern Hungary, which meant that in the event of an election to the throne, he was a clear, local counter-candidate to the Habsburgs. This was seen as a direct challenge to Imperial authority and what the Habsburgs considered as their divine right to rule. Besides this, control over wealthy and strategically central Bohemia, with its vote in choosing the Emperor, was essential to the Austrian Habsburg dynasty. Ferdinand II, the new Emperor, undertook an ambitious war of reconquest to restore his authority not just over Bohemia, but also other German principalities lost to Protestantism since 1570. By 1620 he had conquered Bohemia and installed himself as King there, but this was just the beginning of what became known as The Thirty Years War which ravaged most of central Europe (see maps below). When it finally ended in 1648 after the most savage and destructive warfare yet seen in Europe, few changes were made to the political map of central Europe.
The First Struggle for an Independent Ukraine:
Large-scale wars in Eastern Europe, particularly involving Poland, did have a major effect on the continental balance of power, however. Soviet historians date modern Russian history from the reign of Tsar Aleksei Mikhailovich (1645-1676), principally because of the beginning of the formation of the all-Russian market by ‘commercial capitalists’. The territory in the south of ‘Ukraine’ was Zaporogia, an autonomous Cossack area (see the map below). The wandering peoples of the steppes on the southern fringes of Russia and on the lower reaches of the Volga, the Don, the Donetz and the Dnieper consisted mainly of fugitive peasants and outlaws from Russia, Poland, Lithuania and Turkey, as well as some Tatars. They lived by hunting and fishing, keeping cattle and bees, and by plundering their neighbours, whether Turks, Tatars, Russians or Poles. Conforming to none of the more usual social systems, they settled in fortified towns and organised themselves on semi-military lines, mainly to defend themselves against raiding Tatar bands and their Turkish overlords, but sometimes to mount rebellions against Russia or Poland, as during The Time of Troubles (1598-1613) and during their revolts against Poland under Sigismund III, Wladyslaw IV and Jan II Casimir in 1625, 1630, 1649-51, 1654-67. Within Cossack society, the ataman had executive powers, and in wartime was the supreme commander in the field. Legislative power was given to the Band Assembly (Rada). The senior officers were called starshyna. In the absence of written laws, the Cossacks were governed by the “Cossack Traditions” – the common, unwritten law.
However, Ukraine appeared set to become an integrated part of the Polish Commonwealth. Russia and Poland in their turn pushed south as they gradually colonised the steppes and brought many Cossacks under their control. Local Cossacks became known as ‘registered Cossacks’ who were, in theory, subordinated to the Polish authorities though their obedience was often bought by encouraging them to raid Tatar and Turkish enemies to the south. The Dnieper Cossacks of Ukraine became especially difficult for the Polish authorities to control as religious differences exacerbated their political and social antipathy to Poland since the Cossacks were Orthodox and the Poles were mainly Catholic. But there were also major divisions and dimensions among Orthodox believers as well, most notably between the original Greek branch and the Russian branch. Nikita Minin, ‘Nikon’, Patriarch of Russia from 1652-66, ruled for a time both Church and State and caused the Great Schism or (raskol) by reforming the Church, including an attempt to make the Church superior to the State. He had risen quickly in the Church to become head of a monastery in Novgorod (1643); then, by inspiring Tsar Alexis he became Abbot of the Romanov family monastery of Novospasski near Moscow (1646); Metropolitan of Novgorod (1648) and then Patriarch of Russia.
While the Tsar was away from Moscow in the Thirteen Years’ War (1654-67), Nikon was named ‘Great Sovereign’ (velikii gosudar) and given as much power as if he were tsar. Fierce, impatient and overbearing, he enforced reforms in the Church in a series of annual councils (1652-60) which precipitated the schism. Unlike the traditionalists who believed that Russia had been converted to Christianity by St Andrew independently of Greece, Nikon saw the Russian Church as a legitimate branch of Greek Orthodoxy and now found it full of what he believed to be incorrect practices and other deviations from the ‘parent body,’ which he was determined to put right. Sacred books, services and chants were all corrected with the help of Greek scholars from Kyiv and elsewhere. Innovations not only shocked the mass of old-fashioned believers and clergy, but they also alienated his old brethren in the Zealots ofPiety. In fact, they split the Church, and the Old Believers remained steadfast nonconformists down to the twentieth century, their religious resistance mixed up with various forms of political and social power, including hostility to westernisation. In the time of Nikon, their leader was Archpriest Avvakum who was first exiled to Siberia and eventually burnt at the stake in April 1682. Between 1675 and 1695, about twenty thousand Old Believers committed suicide, by setting fire to their wooden churches.
Eventually, Tsar Alexis screwed up enough courage to oppose Nikon and his pretensions that the Church should be above the State, exempt from secular courts, its property immune from taxation. A Church Council (1667-7) attended by the Patriarchs of Antioch and Alexandria stripped Nikon of his priestly functions and exiled him to Beoleroz in the far north (Dec 1666). The same Council confirmed Nikon’s Church reforms but handed over to the State the job of punishing deviations. Nikon died on his way back to Moscow where he had been recalled by Theodore III. He had left the Church in no position to resist subordination to the State over the centuries to follow, whereas the Kyivan Greek branch of Orthodoxy was able to maintain its independence. This was partly because Wladyslaw IV Vasa, King of Poland (1632-1648), threw his weight behind toleration in a country of many religious denominations that was otherwise in danger of falling prey to the regimentation of the Catholic Counter-Reformation. He ensured toleration both for the Protestants in Western Poland, where he sponsored a Protestant-Catholic colloquy at Torun (Thorn) in 1645 and for the Greek Orthodox in Lithuania and Ukraine, to whom he granted religious liberty and recognition of their underground hierarchy (1633), in the form of the Metropolitan of Kyiv and four bishoprics. Nevertheless, the Jesuits were taking a firm grip on education, thereby succeeding in cutting Poland off from the intellectual progress in the West. Moreover, the Crown was too weak to subordinate the Church to the State, so its hierarchy and the Papacy became increasingly influential in Poland’s policy-making, especially in foreign affairs.
Finally, Wladyslaw found the Ukrainian problem too difficult to solve. The Cossacks were growing desperate as the Polish magnates colonised the Dnieper area, turned them into serfs instead of ‘registered Cossacks’, brought them under the machinery of the Polish State, and persecuted their Orthodox forms of worship. The Ukrainian Cossacks had long been restive as the tide of Polish colonisation crept over their steppes, regimenting their freedom-loving brotherhood, enserfing the peasantry and persecuting the Orthodox. Most Ukrainian peasants now found themselves enserfed. In order to persuade the Poles to take on the burden of defending them in future, the Lithuanians had agreed to turn Podlasia, Volhynia and Ukraine over to the Polish administration. In the second third of the seventeenth century, Polish noblemen and commoners moved into these territories, settling and establishing new farms and great estates, endowing Catholic (Uniate) churches and thereby extending the influence of the Catholic Church. In turn, this helped to fuel conflicts with the Orthodox groups already living in those areas, especially the Cossacks of Ukraine, who had spread well to the east of the Dnieper as far as Poltava.
An explosive mixture of racial, social and religious hatred brought the Cossacks out in armed rebellions in 1625, 1630, 1637 and 1638. Between 1638 and 1648, however, Wladyslaw enforced a period of ‘golden peace’ from a new fortress on the lower Dnieper. At the same time, he hatched a grandiose scheme for neutralising the Cossack’s influence once and for all by eliminating the Tatar danger further south. The Tatars agitated the Cossacks, sometimes by raiding their lands, sometimes by joining them in anti-Polish alliances; but the only successful way of curbing them was to defeat their overlord, the Ottoman Sultan. In the late 1640s, Wladyslaw began negotiating a visionary anti-Turkish crusade in conjunction with Venice, the Papacy, France and others. He encouraged the Cossacks to prepare for battle with hints of further privileges but kept the scheme secret from the Seym until 1646 when they forbade it. The Cossack rebellions of 1648-57 were serious enough as a Polish affair, stirring up religious and national minorities into violence as well as ‘infecting’ Polish peasants and townsmen, but catastrophic as an international conflict. Disappointment with the policies of Wladyslaw IV proved the last straw for the Cossacks who broke out into violence on the eve of his death and brought out many others in open rebellion, which rocked Poland in the reign of his successor, Jan II Casimir.
In 1648, thousands of peasants rose in revolt against their masters, encouraged by a simultaneous dispute between the Polish authorities and the leaders of the “free” Cossacks, led by Bohdan Chmielnicki, a skilful soldier and diplomat. Nevertheless, in Chmielnicki, the Cossacks had chosen a ‘Hetman’ with burning grievances of his own against the agent of a Polish magnate who had confiscated both his property and his wife. Starting from his base on the lower Dnieper in April 1648, he invaded Poland, beating Jan Casimir’s troops at Zólty Wody, Korsun in May and Pilawce in September, raising mass revolts in his wake. Kyiv fell to the rebels and was declared Orthodox again, while the Catholic clergy were driven out. After winning these dramatic victories, the Cossack leaders settled with the new King of Poland, Jan Casimir, much to the disgust of the peasantry. Abandoned by the Tartars, he made The Treaty of Zborow with Jan Casimir who was ready to compromise, in August 1649. The Dnieper Cossacks now aimed to form an independent state, and for the rest of the seventeenth century, they played off Russia, Turkey and Poland – and even Sweden and Austria – against each other in a series of wars that accelerated the decline of Poland but resulted only in the eventual incorporation of the Cossacks in Russia and Poland, at least while the latter still existed. For the time being, fresh quarrels ensued as the Poles gradually whittled down the area of Cossack control as the Cossacks turned to Muscovy for support. But when the war restarted, Chmielnicki, with the fickle Tartars once more not pulling their weight, not wanting the Cossacks to be too successful, was defeated at Beresteczko in June 1651.
As a result, he formed an alliance with Tsar Aleksei with whom he had been negotiating since 1648 and on whom he now applied pressure by threatening to ally with Turkey instead. By then, Russia was becoming involved in the Thirteen Years’ War (1654-67) with Poland and Sweden. The first phase of this involved a further Russian push into the west, into Ukraine, and north-west into Lithuania towards the Baltic. By the Treaty of Perejaslaw of 1654, Tsar Aleksei formed an alliance with Chmielnitcki and the Dnieper Cossacks in what Soviet historians regarded as the Ukrainian War of Liberation against Jan Casimir, King of Poland. In October 1653 the zemskii sobor (the Russian assembly) had voted for Ukraine’s incorporation into Russia, and at Chmielnitcki’s request, a meeting took place with Aleksei’s representatives at which an agreement was made whereby Russia accepted the sovereignty of the Cossacks, allowing them to remain self-governing with their own laws and social system. This treaty resulted in a joint attack on Poland in which Russia took Smolensk in October 1654 and advanced deep into Poland and Lithuania until the outbreak of the Northern War in 1655. In this, Charles X of Sweden invaded and temporarily took control of much of Poland, saving Gdansk and Lwóv (Lviv), forcing Russia to change its policy. In Moscow, there was always disagreement between those who favoured attacking Ukraine and those who favoured concentrating on the Baltic, and this time the latter won. Russia made peace with Poland and helped it fight Sweden. By the Treaty of Vilno (Oct-Nov 1656), Russia gained much of White and Little Russia from Poland.
The Northern War (1655-60), known by the Poles as ‘the Deluge’, submerged Poland, much weakening its control over Ukraine, particularly in the south and east, so that it was never again as secure as it had been before 1648. The further wars between Poland and Russia (1658-67) saw the Cossacks side with the Tsar against the Poles. In an effort to create an autonomous state for themselves, they switched alliances between Russia, Poland, Sweden and Turkey. This exhausted the patience of both Russia and Poland. The war also devastated the Cossack lands – it is a period known in Ukrainian tradition as ‘the Ruin’, but it also marked the emergence of Russia as a stronger military power than Poland. A joint Cossack-Tartar-Turkish invasion in 1667 was stopped by Hetman Jan III Sobieski, future King of Poland, but the continued threat of attack prompted Russia and Poland to make peace. By the Truce of Andruszów (1667), Poland lost much of Ukraine to Russia. The Treaty split Ukraine along the Dnieper River and Ukrainian Cossacks were known as Left-bank and Right-bank Cossacks. Muscovy gained Smolensk and Ukraine up to the Dnieper, as well as ancient Kyiv on the west bank. An autonomous region, the Hetmanate, was created on part of the territory added to Russia. The Cossacks of Zaporogia had autonomy within this area, which continued to apply to their lands when they were not under Polish or Ottoman control. Henceforth, Poland and Russia were jointly concerned with defence against the Turks.
Turning Points & Retreats:
By the early seventeenth century, the Turkish hold on central Hungary was weakening. Transylvania emerged during this period as an important and prosperous European power, ruled by Prince Gábor Bethlen (1613-29). He doubled the territory’s revenues and acted as a staunch defender of Calvinism in central Europe. His influence and that of his successor György Ráckóczi meant that the Habsburgs could not enforce the Counter-Reformation as brutally in the parts of Hungary they controlled, ‘Royal Hungary,’ as they did elsewhere in their empire.
Transylvania’s brief flowering ended after 1657 when the army of György II Rákóczi, Prince of Transylvania, a Calvinist who expected the second coming hoping it would make him King of Poland, invaded the kingdom with Cossack help. Rákóczy had to turn back at Warsaw with his army in shreds, destroyed by Tatars. As a result, Charles X had to abandon his war of Protestant conquest of Poland. Mehmet Köprülü, the Turkish Grand Vizier, took this chance to invade Transylvania and seized important parts of the principality in the west, including Várad. The Treaty of Hadiach (1658) left Ukraine and Poland joined in a personal union, but renewed Russian-Polish fighting meant its terms were never effectively implemented. The Habsburgs intervened and won a surprise victory against the Turks, but the peace settlement of Vasvár (1664) ratified most of the Ottoman gains. The apparent increase in Turkish power had encouraged anti-Habsburg plotting in Royal Hungary in the 1670s, and the savage Habsburg reaction had the effect of driving the malcontents to more extreme measures. In 1678, Imre Thököly, a young Transylvanian, raised the standard of revolt and occupied a large part of central Hungary.
The Turks took this opportunity to intervene and sent a huge army into Hungary in 1683. This laid siege to Vienna, putting the whole European balance of power. Although Polish troops led by Jan Sobieski played a decisive part in raising the siege, it was not Poland but the Austrian Habsburgs who ultimately benefited most from the defeat of the Turks. The threat of rebellion in Habsburg-controlled Hungary was reduced as the border with the Turks was pushed back to the south and east. By September, however, the siege had been lifted, and by 1699 Imperial forces had swept the Turks out of most of Austria-Hungary.
Distressed by his failure and the death of his wife, Jan Casimir abdicated in September 1668. In retrospect, however, he had done well to hold his kingdom together, despite the attacks from all sides. In that year, Poland had a population of only four million, almost half of what it had been in 1618, while its economy had suffered devastating damage. Its increasing weakness opened up a tempting vacuum that drew in states like Sweden and Russia, as well as the German principalities, all eager for territorial acquisitions. To the north, another succession crisis loomed when Charles XI of Sweden died in 1697, leaving his fifteen-year-old son, Charles XII, as his successor. Sweden’s neighbours eyed her territory greedily, and none more so than Augustus the Strong of Saxony, who had additionally ruled Poland in personal union since 1697. By 1699, Augustus was preparing for a campaign to seize Sweden’s territories to the south of the Baltic, despite direct opposition from the Polish ‘Diet’ (parliament). Meanwhile, the young Tsar of Muscovy, Peter I, had captured Azov on the Black Sea from the Turks in 1696, giving his previously land-locked empire an outlet to the sea. Peter managed to retain Azov, despite the weakening of his strategic position when Austria and Venice, his Holy League allies, made peace with the Sultan by the Treaty of Carlowitz in 1699.
Central-eastern Europe at the time of the Treaty of Carlowitz in 1699
The Eighteenth Century: Russia, Prussia, Austria versus Poland:
The Cossacks proved almost as unruly under the Tsar as they had been under the Poles. Under Peter the Great (1682-1725), Mazappa, the ‘Hetman’ (commander) of the Tsar’s Cossacks, tried to create an independent Cossack state in Ukraine, in alliance with the Swedes and the Zaporogian Cossack ‘Host.’ Peter’s victory in 1709, however, marked the conquest of the Cossacks. Many survivors were deported to the distant parts of the Tsar’s empire. By then, Peter had decisively altered the estimation of the previously vast but ill-organised Tsarist empire.
Habsburg Europe, 1699-1789, showing lands acquired from Poland-Lithuania in 1772 and 1775.
In central Europe, meanwhile, Charles VI’s reign (1711-40) saw the Austrian Habsburgs reach unparalleled heights of power, but by the end of it, Austria’s position was actually much weakened. By the 1730s, it became clear that there had not been any long-term increase in the strength of the Habsburg army. By the Treaty of Belgrade (1739), Charles VI was forced to surrender the city itself and its nearby Serbian territories back to the Sultan but was able to preserve the Hungarian territories in the Banat of Temesvár (Timisoara). This treaty also ended the hostilities of the five-year Austro-Russian–Turkish War (1735–39), in which the Habsburgs joined Imperial Russia in its fight against the Ottomans. Russia expanded its territories around the Black Sea, gaining Azov and the lands of the Zaporogian Cossacks. Meanwhile, as for any contemporary dynastic state, the absence of a male heir to Charles VI opened the widespread Habsburg lands to the threat of aggression from its neighbours.
The Rise of Russia to the Treaty of Nystad (1721)
Despite a defeat by the Turks which led to the loss of Azov on the Black Sea in 1711, by combining western techniques and technologies with ruthless autocratic methods, Peter created a military system for Russia capable of wearing down his gifted Swedish rival. By 1721, Russia dominated the Baltic region, gaining greatly from the Treaty of Nystad of that year, taking Estonia, Livonia, Ingria, most of Karelia and part of Finland.
In 1740, European affairs were completely changed by the deaths of Frederick William I of Prussia (pictured above) and of Emperor Charles VI of Austria-Hungary. The ambitious and unscrupulous Frederick II (‘the Great’) ascended the throne of Prussia; Maria Theresa then succeeded to the Habsburg territories. As a woman was not eligible for election to the Empire, her husband, Francis of Lorraine, was expected to become Emperor. Nearly all the Powers had guaranteed the Pragmatic Sanction, a document drawn up by Charles VI to ensure his daughter’s peaceful succession. Maria Theresa managed, however, to preserve the bulk of her father’s legacy, despite a Prussian invasion at the start of her reign which led to the loss of Silesia, gained by Frederick II as a result of the Austrian War of Succession (see the map above). Frederick began hostilities by invading Silesia, which he secured by the Battle of Mollwitz. This German and only Protestant province of Austria formed the basis of the Upper Oder. It was more fertile than any of the Hohenzollern territories, containing a flourishing linen industry and undeveloped resources of iron. Its seizure by Prussia, unchivalrous and unprincipled, provoked both the War of Austrian Succession and the Seven Years’ War.
The War of the Austrian Succession in central Europe, 1739-48.
Maria Theresa yielded the territory by the Treaty of Breslau, and Frederick coolly deserted his allies. Freed from Frederick, Maria Theresa was successful; her armies overwhelmed Bavaria. In 1744, Frederick, alarmed by her success, re-entered the war and compelled her to confirm his retention of Silesia by the Treaty of Dresden. Again, he deserted his allies. During the two wars, 1740-48 and 1756-63, Frederick proved himself to be the best general in Europe. By feats of endurance and military genius, he emerged exhausted but triumphant from conflicts with Austria, France and Russia. He had made Prussia not only the second great power in Germany but also one of the leading powers in Europe. Frederick succeeded in absorbing his new provinces, which also included Friesland (1744) which fell to him peacefully by succession on the extinction of the ruling family. Their inhabitants, having no barriers of religion, economic interests or national feeling, readily accepted Frederick’s ‘enlightened’ rule or ‘benevolent despotism’. He was one of the most progressive rulers of his generation, introducing penal reform (including the abolition of torture), religious toleration and schools for the sons of workers. To restore prosperity, destroyed by decades of war, he pursued a vigorous mercantilist policy. He assisted agriculture by draining marshes, lending seed to farmers, and insisting on their use of new methods. He built canals and fostered the silk industry.
At the end of 1757, Frederick saved himself by two remarkable victories, one against the French and the second against the Austrians at Leuthen in Silesia. The war between Austria and Prussia ended with the restoration to Frederick of all his territories, and no further changes were made to the map of Europe. After 1763, it was clear to Maria Theresa that Austria could not hope to recover Silesia from Prussia, so Vienna turned instead to plans to acquire other territories to “compensate” for its loss. By this time, Augustus the Strong’s ambitions to create a great Saxon-Polish power under his dynasty had come to nothing. The elective nature of the Polish monarchy combined with the fractious behaviour of much of the Polish nobility meant that the vast and strategically valuable lands between Poznán and Kyiv were an attractive target for other states’ ambitions. The three states of Austria, Prussia and Russia surrounded Poland, and their covetous rulers cast envious eyes over the declining state. Its internal weaknesses, resulting in disorder, gave them an opportunity and excuse for intervention. These internal weaknesses were fourfold. Firstly, Poland was an elective monarchy – the Poles inherited an old constitution under which the king was elected. Every election was accompanied by great disorder, produced by rival factions, and foreign rulers gained influence by supporting these factions. Secondly, there was the Liberum Veto, the procedure by which a single noble in the ‘Diet’ (parliament) could veto the proceedings. Thirdly, the nobles enjoyed great feudal privileges over their serfs, and there was a continuous and bitter feud between the two classes. Fourthly, the ‘true Poles’ were only one section of the population, which included Kyivan Rus, Lithuanians, Cossacks and Germans, among other ethnicities.
The Seven Years’ War
In the reign of Catherine II, ‘The Great’ (1762-1796), a further Russo-Turkish war in 1768-74 brought Russia Kerch and Yenikale in the Crimea and Kherson. The Treaty of Kutchuk-Kainardji which ended the war also gave the Tsar a vague duty to protect the Sultan’s Christian subjects, the cause of much future Russo-Turkish friction. Although the Great Powers avoided another great land war after 1763 for more than twenty-five years, possibly also offering smaller states greater protection, the First Partition of Poland in 1772 between Prussia, Russia and Austria was a foretaste of how cynically they could treat their weaker neighbours, carving out about a third of a helpless Poland’s territory. Announcing that she was liberating Russian subjects and uniting them with the ‘fatherland’, Catherine participated in the three notorious partitions of Poland of 1772, 1793 and 1795. In the First Partition, as ‘the ringleader’, Catherine obtained a large tract of land around Vitebsk, and a part of Lithuania, where there were many people of non-Polish ethnicity. Thus, Russia and Austria, the erstwhile enemies of Prussia, succeeded in detaching significant territories from the Polish Commonwealth. Frederick II of Prussia and Maria Theresa of Austria combined to seize territories in the north. Prussia took West Prussia, a province that had separated Brandenburg from East Prussia since 1618, though without the valuable port of Gdansk, which it only formally acquired in 1793. In the south, in 1772, Maria Theresa gained Galicia, including Lemberg (Lviv) although, according to Frederick, she “wept as she took it”. Nevertheless, weeping or not, she obtained the valuable province with much fertile land and important salt mines (she also acquired Bukovina from the Ottomans in 1775).
For the next twenty years, Russia was busy extending its territories towards the Black Sea at the expense of the Turks. It was confirmed in its possession of Azov and gained the Black Sea littoral between the Bug and the Dnieper. The Crimean Tartars became independent of Turkey and ripe for subversion by Russia. Russian merchantmen could sail the Black Sea and pass through the Straits, but Turkey kept Moldavia, Wallachia and the Greek islands. After being subjected to several years of subversion, however, Crimea was finally annexed by Catherine in 1783. The Austrian army had hardly covered itself in glory in the war against Turkey after 1788, fought in alliance with Russia. For Russia, Austria’s growing preoccupation with the French threat was quite convenient. It meant that Russia was in a better position to dictate terms to Turkey after the joint campaign. But by The Treaty of Jassy (1791-92), she finally gave up her hope of taking Constantinople and had to rest content with the annexation of Ochakov and the Black Sea coast between the Bug and the Dniester, as well as Turkey’s recognition of Russia’s possession of the Crimea.
The Partitions of Poland, 1772-95: Eastern losses to Russia, 1795.
Poland could only survive so long as its independence did not threaten the gains of the three powers. The Poles were setting their internal, domestic affairs in order by changing their constitution. But when serious reforms, including Europe’s first written constitution (of May 1791), got underway, Prussia and Russia acted to forestall any chance of a revitalised Poland reasserting itself. In 1793 they seized further territories in Poland. Catherine invited Frederick to join her in a second partition, knowing that Austria, deeply engaged in a war with revolutionary France, was in no position to advance its further claims in Poland. By the terms of this partition, Russia gained a larger share of Eastern Poland (including the former Lithuanian Ukraine). Besides the strategic port of Gdansk (Danzig), the Prussians also gained the Province of Posen. Influenced by the French Revolutionaries and seeing that their country was perishing, the Poles rose up to expel the invaders under Kosciusko in 1794.
The Triumphant Triumvirate:
After a brief, heroic resistance, they were swiftly defeated by the combined forces of the three powers, who then proceeded to divide what was left of the country among themselves. Austria and Prussia shared out what remained of Poland with Russia in 1795 when even Warsaw passed into Prussian hands. Russia took full possession of Lithuania; Prussia gained the area around Warsaw, which later became known as the Grand Duchy, and Austria received a large share in the south, including Cracow. One of the largest states in Europe had gradually disappeared from the map of Europe.
The Growth of Russia from the Fourteenth to the Eighteenth Century.
It was Russia that acquired the largest part of the original pre-1772 state of Poland. When Catherine died of a stroke at St Petersburg the following year, she had extended the Russian Empire by about two hundred thousand square miles. Catherine’s armies also conquered Moldavia, Wallachia and Crimea. By the Peace Treaty signed at Kutchuk-Kainardzhi in Bulgaria (July 1774), Russia made further important gains. During this half-century, therefore, Russia’s agricultural output expanded dramatically, not because of improved farming methods, which in the more advanced areas had reached only the level of the three-field system, but because of the enlargement of the cultivated area, especially after the Russian colonisation of Ukraine and the steppe lands down to the Black Sea. All sectors of the economy were stimulated by the expanding machinery of the Russian government and by the rise in population, which from fourteen million at the death of Peter I had grown to thirty-six million at the death of Catherine, including seven million from the annexed territories.
British Prime Ministers of the mid-Victorian Age: Benjamin Disraeli (left) and William Gladstone (right). Disraeli converted from Judaism and Gladstone was a keen Churchman.
Victorian Britain – An Age of Conformity?
For many people in the early twenty-first century, the title ‘mid-Victorian Britain’ conjures up an image of church-going, sabbath seriousness, packed pews and the head of the household, invariably the father, questioning his progeny on the points of the morning sermon. The very word ‘Victorian’ has passed into the English language as the epitome of grim, humourless authoritarianism, heavy-handed religion and ugliness. But there is another side to the picture. While the solemn Mr Gladstone (pictured above right) was observed to hang on the words of the rawest curate in the pulpit, and volumes of sermons found ready purchasers among the faithful, there were others who were less reverent. The Victorian age was one of authority and conformity for many, but it was also one of dissent, doubt and seething discontent. The seeds of doubt that had been sown by the rationalists of the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries were nurtured by sceptics and deists and came to fruition in the early nineteenth century. The whole fabric of Christianity was called into question as science, philosophy and history were all called upon to show that the Christian faith no longer had one leg to stand on, let alone two. It found itself challenged from all three directions at the same time. From science, in the shape of the theory of evolution, from philosophy in the form of alternative world-views intended to make belief in God obsolete, and from history in the guise of biblical criticism. If the truth of the Bible could be shown to be doubtful, then there would be nothing left on which Christian faith could stand, according to some of these critics.
A Continent Come of Age – God and the European Philosophers:
It is often the case with philosophers that what they hand out as a solution is only the old problem in another form. By the beginning of the nineteenth century, Immanuel Kant had put his finger on many of the weaknesses in the traditional arguments for the existence of God and the old approach of philosophy to religion. But to reject the traditional proofs for God’s existence is simply to see the flaws in the logic of particular arguments. It still leaves unanswered the question of whether God can be known in some other way. To say that our minds work in terms of time and space is not the same as saying that we can have no insight into what lies behind our existence in that time and space. It is inevitable that our language uses a great deal of symbolism. Jesus himself used picture language to convey truths that could not be put in any other way but by symbols. We do not have direct access to God, not even through the Bible. We do not see God directly as he is in himself. Our knowledge of him is always mediated by events, experiences and words. Without the words of the Bible, there could be no revelation.
God as a ‘world-spirit’:
The attempt to ‘outflank’ Kant was a major pre-occupation of nineteenth-century thinkers. In theology, Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768-1834) looked for a new approach that accepted Kant’s criticisms of the proofs for the existence of God and his strictures on the limitations of human thought. His solution lay in basing theology on religious experience. The ‘Absolute Idealism’ of G. W. F. Hegel (1770-1831) was also partly an attempt to provide an alternative understanding of God to that of orthodox Christianity. Instead of starting with the capital ‘I’ of individual faith, the Idealists began with the absolute ‘I’ in which all reality is the manifestation of the Absolute Spirit. God does not exist over and above the world, as in Christian orthodoxy, but is the ‘world-spirit’ that is to be found in the depths of the world-processes. Thus, the world is a manifestation of God. The end-product of this new understanding of God was a dynamic pantheism and these different philosophical approaches left their mark on the way in which Jesus Christ was understood. In the writings of Kant and in liberal Protestant theology, Jesus appears as an enlightened teacher of moral religion. In Schleiermacher and Hegel, Jesus appears as the supreme manifestation of the divine Spirit among men, and as the agent of the divine being in achieving the oneness of God and man.
When Hegel died in the cholera epidemic of 1831, his followers split into two camps. The ‘right wing’ was concerned to preserve the teachings of their master more or less as he had left them. The ‘left wing’ were revisionists and malcontents who ended up by ‘standing Hegel’s philosophy on its head.’ Ludwig Feuerbach (1804-72) had studied under Hegel. But whereas Hegel had regarded all reality as the outworking of the Absolute Spirit, Feuerbach argued that this ‘Spirit’ was equivalent to the whole of the natural world. He agreed with Schleiermacher that the essence of all religion is a sense of absolute dependence, but also argued that what man depends on is the whole of nature. For him, God is a projection of man’s own nature that has been freed from all limitations. Theology was simply anthropology, and the knowledge of God is nothing else but the knowledge of man. Feuerbach protested that he was not so much an atheist as an ‘antitheist’. This thought was, however, too subtle for masses, and his writings were only read by intellectual cliques.
Karl Marx, photographed in 1861.
The same could not be said of that other one-time devotee of Hegel, Karl Marx (1818-83). Born in the Rhineland to Jewish parents who became Lutherans, Marx became a student of philosophy who eventually reached the limits of that discipline: Philosophers only interpret the world; the point is to change it. After leaving university he became a journalist, but soon fell foul of the authorities on account of his radical political views. He was expelled from Germany at the age of thirty, during the ‘year of revolutions’ of 1848. Finding a ‘safe haven’ as a refugee in London among the expatriate German community, he met Friedrich Engels, who became his patron. Together, they wrote The Communist Manifesto (1848) in which they called upon the downtrodden ‘proletariat’ of Europe to unite in revolution to overthrow the existing order and usher in the new society:
Marx & Engels in the middle of their work (sketch by N. Zhukov)
In London, Marx divided his time between stirring up agitation and gathering evidence in the British Museum for what he intended to be a comprehensive critique of the capitalist system, Das Kapital (1867). By this time Marx had rejected not only Hegel but also Feuerbach as well. Neither the Absolute Spirit nor nature was the basis of reality. The basis of reality was to be found in matter. The history of mankind, then, is the history of how are related to material things. According to Marx, history is moving relentlessly forwards in the direction of the communist society. Up to that point, all history was the history of class struggle, but when communist society is reached, private property will be a thing of the past, and the state itself will manage everything until people have gradually learnt to manage these economic relations for themselves. Then it would whither away. The twentieth-century philosopher, Bertrand Russell, remarked that, although Marx claimed to be an atheist, he had an optimistic ‘outlook’ on the world and the eventual outcome of history which could only be justified by a believer in God. Political economy had its limits too.
Religion and Materialist Philosophy:
Two tendencies, one intellectual and one social, made for the collision in the 1860s, between scientific thought and religion. Religion of a fundamentalist sort was losing its utility as a social discipline it had possessed in the first critical period of the industrial revolution. The early performance of the industrial economy seemed to indicate the claims of individualism to provide a viable framework for social behaviour. Leslie Stephen wrote that his generation reared on John Stuart Mill,
… claimed with complete confidence to be in possession of a definite and scientific system of economical, political and ethical truth. They were calmly convinced that all objectors, from Carlyle downwards, were opposed to him {Mill} as dreamers to logicians; and the recent triumph of free trade {1846} had given special plausibility to their claims.
‘Some Early Impressions’, 1903, pp. 74-5.
The implication of this definite and scientific system was that codes of social behaviour were not affected by whether or not God existed. W. K. Clifford (1845-79), who at the age of twenty-six became Professor of Mathematics at University College, London, after a brilliant Cambridge career. In his lecture, ‘Body and Mind’, delivered to the Sunday Lecture Society in November 1874. Clifford put his position on the matter of ‘conscience’, which followed Kant’s view of the freedom of the will, politely but clearly:
The distinction of right and wrong grows up in the broad light of day out of natural causes wherever men live together; and the only right motive to act is to be found in the social instincts which have been bred into mankind by hundreds of generations of social life. … Duty to one’s countrymen and fellow-citizens, which is the social instinct guided by reason … is in all healthy communities the one thing sacred and supreme. If the course of things is guided some unseen intelligent person (God), then this instinct is his highest and clearest voice, and because of it we may call him good. But if the course of things is not so guided, that voice loses nothing of its sacredness, nothing of its clearness, nothing of its obligation.
W. K. Clifford, ‘Body and Mind’, printed in Fortnightly Review, December 1874.
Clifford’s politeness masked a deep hostility to any notion of man’s ethical sense being derived from some innate, and presumably God-implanted, ‘conscience’. John Stuart Mill shared his position:
The notion that truths external to the mind may be known by intuition or consciousness, independently of observation and experience, is, I am persuaded, in these times the great intellectual support of false doctrines and bad institutions. By the aid of this theory, every inveterate belief and every intense feeling, of which the origin is not remembered, is enabled to dispense with the object of justifying itself by reason, and is erected into its own all-sufficient voucher and justification.
J S Mill, ‘Autobiography’, 1873, p. 191.
By appealing to ‘observation and experience’ the ‘materialist’ philosophers were able to marshal on their side the body of research in the sciences, which by the 1850s was undermining belief in the literal truth of the Scriptures and in any supernatural intervention in the physical world.
Was God Dead?
An atheist with a more individualist approach was Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900). Whereas Marx was the prophet of communism, Nietzsche was adopted as a prophet of their new order by the Nazis in the 1930s. Nietzsche regarded himself as a prophet of the death of God, and a spokesman for liberated man. Since God was dead, man must go it alone. He must make up his own rules and values as he went along. Virtues that were prized by Christianity had to be discarded, as they tended to preserve the weak and the ailing. What was needed is a reassessment of all values and a will to impose new values on others, whether they wanted them or not.
A thinker who saw clearly the dangerous way in which political and even church systems were developing was the Danish writer Soren Kierkegaard (1813-55). In his lifetime he was little known beyond the borders of his native Denmark. It was only in the twentieth century, as his writings began to be translated, that his real significance came to be appreciated. Kierkegaard had a horror of systems. He was also acutely aware of the danger of trying to manipulate God. We must never forget that God is other. He exists outside of our time and space and it is, therefore, folly to try to prove his existence through rational argument. To be known directly is the mark of an idol, not the living God. God is only known as he makes himself known, in the human person of Jesus Christ, but incognito. We can know him, but only through a faith that is willing to put all at risk for God and to lead a life of personal discipleship. This was Kierkegaard’s repost to the totalitarian schemes of idealist philosophy and of church politics, but one which has had to be re-learned in each subsequent century, if not every generation.
The Biblical Critics – Strauss, Vatke, Wellhausen & Baur:
David Friedrich Strauss (1808-74) argued that the effect of such historical criticism of the Bible was positive rather than negative. In 1835-6 Strauss, then a junior lecturer in the Protestant seminary at Tübingen published his Life of Jesus, Critically Examined. The book, which cost him his post, is 1,400 pages long and examines all the alleged incidents and sayings in the life of Jesus from the same perspective as Remarius, asking rational and historical questions which make the assumption that miracles do not happen. Strauss dismissed all the supernatural and messianic elements in the Gospels as myth. Similarly, he dismissed the miracle stories with naturalistic explanations. But, entirely unlike Reimarus, he argued that this was ultimately a vindication of Christianity since it cleared the ground of false assumptions about a miraculous faith and made possible an attachment instead to eternal truths. Jesus was not divine in any unique sense, yet his story, rightly understood, disclosed the divine in all humanity:
Let an audatious criticism attempt to what it will, all which the Scriptures declare, and the Church believes of Christ, will still subsist as eternal truth, nor needs one iota of it to be renounced. Thus at the conclusion of the criticism of the history of Jesus, there presents itself this problem: to re-establish itself dogmatically that which has been destroyed critically.
‘Dogmatically’ here means ‘theologically’, at the level of faith. Strauss argued that what seemed to most readers a devastating attack on the Christian faith was actually a defence of it, but no one believed him anyway. In 1839 he was offered a chair in Zurich, but there was a popular rebellion against the very idea, which brought down the government, and he was pensioned off. Strauss’s work, however, had lasting effects and may be said to have initiated the modern quest for the historical Jesus. Critically, he distinguished between questions of history and questions of faith, much as Spinoza had done. A belief in the divine nature of inspiration does not answer, he argued, the question of whether this or that event is recorded in the Gospels actually happened: the two issues simply occupy different spaces on the map. It can be argued that this is a mistake: that it was only because of miraculous events that the disciples were brought to believe in Jesus in the first place, or that the divinity of Jesus makes it possible to believe in him actions that we could not believe of any other human. In this way, historical enquiry and theology went hand in hand, but for Strauss that was wishful thinking.
The kind of critical enquiry represented by Strauss has influenced biblical study down to the present day, even though many contemporary biblical critics are much nearer to traditional Christian orthodoxy than he was. As the nineteenth century progressed, the Old Testament came under increasing fire. It was widely assumed that the patriarchs Abraham, Isaac and Jacob were mythical figures, or perhaps titles of tribes associated with particular names. Many questioned whether Moses ever lived. Rational enquiry into the Old Testament followed similar lines to those applied to the Gospels.
In the same year as the first volume of Strauss’s Life of Jesus was published (1835), William Vatke (1806-82) published his Biblical Theology: The Religion of the Old Testament. The inspiration for this was the philosophy of Hegel but on the historical level, it was highly innovative in arguing that the order of the books in the Hebrew Bible was not a correct guide to the development of the theological thinking of ancient Israel. The religion of the prophets, Vatke proposed, was older than that enshrined in the Pentateuch. It stood at the beginning of the development of a system of thought that had been read back into the Pentateuch from later times. In essence, this anticipated the arguments of Julius Wellhausen (1844-1910), who was the most influential critic of all. He held that Hebrew religion had undergone a development from the primitive stories of nomadic times to the elaborate, institutionalised ritualism of the period of the centuries before the birth of Jesus. He claimed to have found various behind the Torah, which he dated to different stages in the history of Israel. These arguments could all be dismissed as merely an application of Hegelian ideas of spiritual development to material, the Old Testament, that they did not fit. Vatke largely disappeared from view until Wellhausen revived his theory, shorn of its Hegelianism, in 1878.
Vatke’s and Wellhausen’s theory owed much to Spinoza’s theory that it is to Ezra, writing as late as the fifth century BCE, that we owe the ‘books of Moses’. Scholars of this outlook saw the Old Testament as a patchwork of pieces that owed their shape and texture to outside influences. They also applied this approach to the New Testament. In Catholic France, J. E. Renan’s Life of Jesus (1863), and in Protestant England, J. R. Seeley’s Ecce Homo (1865), both took a more positive view of the historical contexts of the Gospel stories. But both tried to eliminate the supernatural, and reduce Jesus merely to a magnetic teacher.
Perhaps the most ‘notorious’ of the nineteenth-century critics was Strauss’s former teacher, F. C. Baur (1792-1860). Baur, like Strauss, taught at Tübingen where he enjoyed, by contrast, a long and distinguished career. He laid the foundations of the study of Gnosticism, and his work on the New Testament was also innovative. He dated much of it to the second century CE – much later than the modern consensus – and argued that it could be seen as a struggle between two versions of Christianity, one indebted ultimately to Paul, and the other to Peter. Baur worked on the assumption that there had been a great conflict in the early church between Peter (who stood for a strictly Judaistic attitude to the law) and Paul (who held to a more liberal Greek approach, which set little store by the law and Jewish ritual). The Pauline mission was to the Gentiles, whereas Petrine Christianity was concerned with the Hebraic roots of the faith, rooted in the Jerusalem community led by James. This argument referred directly to Paul’s report in Galatians:
But when Cephas {Peter} came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face, because he stood self-condemned; for until certain peoplecame from James, he used to eat with the Gentiles. But after they came, he drew back and kept himself separate for fear of the circumcision faction.
Galations 2: 11-12
On this basis, Baur set about deciding which books of the New Testament were genuine. Those which did not seem to reflect this supposed division were dismissed as later productions. Thus, only four of Paul’s letters could be regarded as genuine: Romans, Galatians and Corinthians I and II. The rest, according to Baur, were all later. He saw Acts as completely ahistorical, an early second-century attempt to reconcile Pauline with Petrine Christianity.
Arguably even more radical was Baur’s insistence that each of the four Gospels had its own theme or ‘tendency’ (Tendenz). This is now a commonplace view in New Testament studies but at the time it caused alarm because it separated the Gospels from the accurate recording of history and saw them as deliberately composed to make a particular point – which called into question their historical veracity. It also meant that they did not conform to a uniform system of Christian doctrine, due to the diversity among them. This diversity can be seen as between John and the synoptic Gospels, operating at both the historical and theological levels. The Jesus of Mark, for example, does not seem much like the Jesus of John: the former is clearly a human figure who sharply distinguishes himself from God, while the latter is ‘one with the Father’ and is described as the ‘Word of God’ who came down from heaven. Once each Gospel is brought into focus in its own right, the difficulty of reconciling their different pictures of Jesus becomes apparent. At the historical level, the narrative frameworks of John and the Synoptics are not compatible: in the latter, Jesus makes only one trip to Jerusalem as an adult, whereas John implies that he was there on several occasions.
What all these critics made clear above all, was that the New Testament does not unequivocally support traditional Christian doctrines such as the doctrine of the Trinty or even the divinity of Christ, any more than the Old Testament, studied critically, supports a traditional picture of the Mosaic origins of Israel. If we apply their critical approach to this same issue of ‘Christology’ – the nature of Jesus Christ – then the New Testament as a whole presents a mixed message. No book in the New Testament explicitly states that Jesus is God, and some of his own words seem to deny it (recall his question, Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone, in Mark 10: 18). Even in John’s Gospel, with its ‘high Christology’, Jesus prays to God. In Paul’s letters, the risen Jesus clearly has an exalted status:
God … gave him the name that is above every name, so that at the name of Jesus every knee should bend.
Philippians 2: 9-10.
His status is even more exalted in Colossians, which may or may not be genuinely Pauline. But Paul also seems to see Jesus as lower in status than God himself:
When all things are subjected to him, then the Son of Man himself will also be subjected to the one who puts all things in subjection under him, so that God may be all in all.
I Corinthians 15: 28
Christ is the head of every man, and the husband is the head of his wife, and God is the head of Christ.
I Corinthians 11: 3
The New Testament, therefore, supports at best a subordinationist Christology, that is, one in which Jesus as the Son is of lower status than God the Father. This is at odds with the later doctrine of the Trinity, in which Father, Son and Holy Spirit are of equal status. Furthermore, the Trinity is referred to explicitly only once in the New Testament, at the end of Matthew’s Gospel:
Jesus said, “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptising them in the name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.”
Matthew 28: 19.
But this passage is widely suspected of being a later addition to the Gospel. All this has been well known to biblical scholars since at least the work of Strauss, Baur and other nineteenth-century writers, though it remains unfamiliar to most Christians. Though Parish clergy have continued to learn it in their training, they have usually chosen to ignore it when preaching and teaching in the church. It has remained possible to believe unchallenged in Christ’s divinity and in God as a Trinity. But in the wake of the nineteenth-century critics, it became impossible to say that the New Testament clearly teaches these doctrines in anything like their later, developed forms. If the Bible is read in its own terms, it presents a range of ideas about Jesus and about God that cannot be systematised. That plurality of ideas is the clear implication of nineteenth-century biblical criticism. Strauss and Baur were not interested in questions of Church order and the obviously untenable reading of Scripture and even ancient authors that, from the time of the Apostles, there have been successive orders of ministers in the Church in the form of Bishops, Priests and Deacons. But these questions do indicate the kind of implications that follow once the New Testament is approached in a historically critical spirit.
Not all nineteenth-century biblical scholarship was negative, either in its contemporary impact or its longer-term outcomes. Among the gains was the less spectacular work of reconstructing the text of the Bible from ancient manuscripts such as the Codex Sinaiticus, discovered in a monastery on Mount Sinai. The discovery of new texts and the development of the scientific study of manuscripts confirmed the essential accuracy of the texts on which the older translations of the Bible, such as the King James’ Version (1611) were based. Prominent in the New Testament research were the Cambridge scholars B. F. Westcott, F. J. A. Hort and J. B. Lightfoot. Westcott and Hort’s Greek text of the New Testament surpassed all earlier versions. In their minds, the historical study of the New Testament was not intended to have a negative effect. The exploration of the language and background history of the New Testament threw fresh light on what the Bible was actually saying. Lightfoot’s study of early Christian literature after the New Testament period disproved Baur’s late dating of the New Testament books, showing that all of them must have been written by the end of the first century.
Archaeology, too, has confirmed the accuracy of a great deal of the information contained in the Bible. This can readily be seen in the writings of the scholar William Ramsay. His study of the geography and archaeology of the Roman Empire supported the picture of general events and locations evident in Luke’s account of the Acts of the Apostles.
The conclusions of Strauss and Baur highlight the danger of building a lot on a little – especially when that little seems to be preconceived. But if Christianity is a historical religion based on actual events in history, these events must be open to investigation by historians and other academics. Of course, for Christians, these events contain more than history, and the enquirer must not lose sight of their significance to believers, but they are also significant because they have their own historical dimension or ‘mystery’ which is also worthy of investigation. The work of the historians and archaeologists mentioned has shown that Christianity has nothing to fear from balanced historical scrutiny.
In terms of theological understanding, we cannot use our shared beliefs, however well-established, to decide what the New Testament authors meant, because that would be to confuse questions of belief with those of meaning. The New Testament does not prescribe any predetermined system for ministry, for example, because it ‘speaks’ with the many different voices of so many different witnesses. That does not mean that we should abandon all church traditions in these respects, but we should adopt these on the basis of earthly pragmatism, not on the basis of them being God-given. These are the effects of biblical criticism. Since the nineteenth-century biblical critics and theologians have danced around each other, trying to establish how a critical spirit can be reconciled with a desire to develop doctrine in a way that is true to the Bible. There has been a tacit understanding that students of theology have to study Biblical criticism, but the two areas have never coalesced, nor is it clear how they could.
A Sophisticated Ape? Darwin’s Theory of Evolution & its ‘Reception’:
We must, however, take note of one of the issues encountered by students of the Bible since the nineteenth century: its apparent conflict with science. The debates on science and religion more broadly occupied the centre stage of mid-Victorian Britain while the philosophical debates on the existence of God were taking place in the continental universities. The idea of evolution was not exactly new, even if the Victorian ‘crisis of faith’ came to a head in 1859 with the publication of Charles Darwin’s The Origin of the Species. It had had its advocates from the Greek philosopher, Anaximander, right down to Darwin’s own grandfather, Erasmus Darwin. In the 1830s, Charles Lyell had published The Principles of Geology, in which he argued that the present state of the earth’s surface had been brought about by a long and gradual development. The chalk cliffs of Dover were known to contain remains of sea creatures that had been deposited over many centuries. It was also claimed that the fossils found at places such as Whitby and Lyme Regis dated back an almost incalculable length of time. In 1844, the idea of evolution was extended from geology to the whole of plant and animal life in Robert Chambers’ The Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation.
Charles Darwin was attacked and ridiculed for his theory of evolution. This cartoon pictured him as an ape himself.
Charles Darwin (1809-92) had studied medicine at Edinburgh and theology at Cambridge, but in 1830 he sailed as a naturalist on HMS Beagle on a survey expedition to South America. For years, he pondered his theories but was finally stung into publishing them when he received a manuscript from A. R. Wallace outlining ideas similar to his own. They published a joint paper that paved the way for Darwin’s masterpiece. The creation story in Genesis 1 tells how God created in six days and rested on the seventh. The evolutionists were now saying that the world had evolved over millions of years, possibly from a single prototype being. To explain how life had developed, Darwin set out the principle of natural selection or, more bluntly, the survival of the fittest. In order to survive, he wrote, plants and animals have to prey upon each other. To cope with their environment they have to develop new capacities and capabilities. Where these become a permanent feature, new species evolve. This particular, the idea that plants and animals do not belong to fixed and unchanging species – but develop by a process whereby the mutant best adapted to the environment survives and transmits those characteristics that make it the fittest to survive – conflicted with the idea that God created each species as it is ‘now’ and set apart one species, human beings, with the gift of an immortal soul.
It is an understatement to record that Darwin’s work met with a mixed reception. Was Man really no more than a sophisticated ape? That is what the theory of evolution seemed to be saying. But more important was the reason why it was said. For ‘respectable’ Victorian middle-class church- and chapel-goers, it was bad enough to imply that man was ‘descended from the monkeys’. What made matters worse was that the reasoning behind it suggested that the world was not the work of a wise, loving Creator who had planned everything. Instead, the scientific claims being made seemed to many to be that all plant and animal life had just evolved naturally and that only the fittest had survived. In the new way of thinking, it also seemed that God was an unnecessary hypothesis. From the contemporary philosophical perspective, the reverse was also true. If the Creator could not be proved to exist, then there was no material ‘Creation’, only nature, ‘red in tooth and claw’. Philosophy and Science entered an almost ‘symbiotic’ relationship themselves, or to many an ‘unholy alliance’ in their advancement of rationality. The writer Charles Kingsley described the impact of Darwin’s theory:
Men find that now they have got rid of God – a master-magician as I call it – then they have to choose between the absolute empire of accident, and a living, immanent, ever-working God.
If man evolved from the lower primates through such a process of natural selection, then the same physical laws that governed their behaviour also governed those of mankind. Darwin himself was not free from nagging doubts about his theory. At the meeting of the British Association in Oxford in 1860, the Bishop of Oxford, ‘Soapy Sam’ Wilberforce, treated his audience to a display of sarcastic wit, ridiculing the ‘new’ ideas. But the bishop found more than his match in Thomas Henry Huxley (1825-95), who took the stance of a humble scientist facing facts rather than indulging in fine-speaking and dogma, and he persuasively argued the case for evolution:
The consciousness of brutes would appear to be related to the mechanism of their body simply as a collateral product of its working, and to be as completely without any power of modifying that working … Their volition, if they have any, is an emotion indicative of physical changes, not a cause of such changes …
The theological, or rather anti-theological implication of this was that if consciousness were an effect produced by changes in the substance of the brain, and was only known in this context, then notions of intelligence or volition – the modes of consciousness – occurring apart from a physically existent brain were untenable. Arguments for the existence of God, therefore, were not susceptible to scientific proof. Against what they regarded as an ‘assault’, the defenders of the religious establishment could have adopted a logical argument for God’s existence but chose instead to use grounds of ‘social psychology’. Even before Darwin had published his theory, in his ‘Bampton lectures’ of 1858, Henry Longueville Mansel (1820-71) argued that:
… in the universal consciousness of innocence and guilt, of duty and disobedience, of an appeased and offended God, there is exhibited the instinctive confession of all mankind, that the moral nature of man, as subject to a law of obligation, reflects and represents, in some degree, the moral nature of a Deity by whom that obligation is imposed.
H. L. Mansel, Limits of Religious Thought: The Bampton Lecturesof 1858, pp. 108-13.
Mansel was a fellow of St John’s College, Oxford, and later Dean of St Paul’s. He was notable in his time as a philosopher and theologian, and as a deft satirist. The following year, in the controversial scientific and theological context of 1859, he argued that scientists should…
… accept the traditional doctrines of the Church, because they have in practice endured and revealed a human need for them and… not attempt to question them by using methods of science.
At this point, the Establishment’s argument lapsed from the intellectual to the social and political. Mansel was a last-ditch defender of the prerogatives of the Church of England in the universities and an astute and active High Church Tory organiser; Clifford, Stephen and Huxley were all political radicals and secularists, campaigners for the removal of education from clerical domination. For them, the disestablishment of religious institutions that depended for their survival on prejudice or tradition was anomalous with advancing the values of rational investigation and discussion among the general public. Sir Leslie Stephen (1832-1904), a critic, biographer and editor, became an Anglican clergyman after graduating from Cambridge. Subsequently, he lost his faith and became an advocate of free thought. He was the first editor of the ‘Dictionary of National Biographer’ and the father of the novelist Virginia Woolf. In 1873, he wrote an essay, Religion as a Fine Art, in which he argued:
If the Bible states that something is a fact which is not a fact, it makes no difference to call it a ‘scientific fact’. It can hardly be seriously urged, that an inspired book is at liberty to make erroneous statements on all matters which may become the subject of accurate investigation – the only sense which can be made of the words. A reconciliation is required, founded on some deeper principle. The sacred images must be once and for all carried fairly beyond the reach of the spreading conflagration, not moved back step by step, suffering fresh at every fresh operation. The radical remedy would be to convey them at once into the unassailable ground of the imagination.
Admit that the Bible has nothing to do with facts of any kind, that theology and science have no common basis, because one deals with poetry and the other with prose; the sceptic’s standing ground will be cut away from beneath his feet. … The prevalent conceptions of the day will somehow permeate its poetry – if it has any – in spite of all that can be done to keep the out.
L. Stephen, ‘Essays in Free Thinking and Plain Speaking’, 1873.
Ongoing Controversies & Consequences:
In the years following the initial fifteen-year ‘furoré’, it was Huxley, as much as anyone, who gave the evolutionary theory the stamp of scientific orthodoxy. He had begun his career as a naval surgeon, a post that enabled him to pursue his inclination towards biological studies. He had become Professor of Natural History at the Royal School of Mines in 1854, but his eminence really dates from the early 1860s, when he supported Darwin energetically and went on to become a leading consultant to the British Government on scientific research and education. Although he did not fail to draw conclusions from scientific advances that were hostile to accepted religious thought, he coined the terms ‘agnostic’ and ‘agnosticism’ to describe his own religious beliefs. There were many -isms that claimed definite knowledge of all kinds of things. Huxley wanted a word to express the state of not knowing. Rather than adopt the point-blank denial of God of the atheist, Huxley said that he just did not know, and was not in a position to know. Towards the end of his lecture on The Automatism of Animals, delivered to the British Association in Belfast in 1874, extending his argument made in London in 1860, Huxley said he felt he was running no risk of either Papal or Presbyterian condemnation for the scientific views he had put forward, but that there were…
… so very few interesting questions which one is, at present, allowed to think out scientifically – to go as far as reason leads, and stop where evidence comes to an end – without speedily being deafened by the tatoo of ‘the drum ecclesiastic’ – that I have luxuriated in my rare freedom, and would willingly bring this disquisition to an end if I could hope that other people would go no farther. Unfortunately, past experience debars me from entertaining any such hope… It will be said, that I mean that the conclusions deduced from the study of the brutes are applicable to man, and that the logical consequences of such an application are fatalism, materialism and atheism – whereupon the drums will beat up the ‘pas de charge’.
… I venture to offer a few remarks for the calm consideration of thoughtful persons, untrammelled by foregone conclusions, unpledged to shore-up tottering dogmas, and anxious only to know the true bearings of the case.
It is quite true that, to the best of my judgement, the argumentation that applies to brutes holds equally good of men; and, therefore, that all states of consciousness in us, as in them, are immediately caused by molecular changes of the brain substance. It seems to me that in men, as in brutes, there is no proof that any state of consciousness is the cause of change in the motion of the matter of the organism.
If these positions are well based, it follows that our mental conditions are simply the symbols in consciousness of the changes which take place automatically in the organism; and that, to take an extreme illustration, the feeling we call volition is not the cause of a voluntary act, but the symbol of that state of the brain which is the immediate cause of that act. We are conscious automata, endowed with free will in the only intelligible sense of that much-abused term – inasmuch as in many respects we are able to do as we like – but none the less parts of the great series of causes and effects which, in unbroken continuity, composes that which is, and has been, and shall be – the sum of existence.
As to the logical consequences of this conviction of mine … the only question which any wise man can ask himself is … whether a doctrine is true or false. …if the view I have taken did really and logically lead to fatalism, materialism, and atheism, I should profess myself a fatalist, materialist and atheist; and I should look upon those who … should raise a hue and cry against me, as people who … preferred lying to truth, and whose opinions … were unworthy of the smallest attention.
But as I have endeavoured to explain on other occasions, I really have no claim to rank myself among fatalistic, materialistic, or atheistic philosophers. Not among fatalists, for I take the conception of necessity to have a logical, and not a physical foundation; not among materialists, for I am utterly incapable of conceiving of the existence of matter if there is no mind in which to picture that existence; not among atheists, for the problem of the ultimate cause of existence is one which seems to me to be hopelessly out of reach of my poor powers. Of all the senseless babble I have ever had occasion to read, the demonstrations of these philosophers who undertake to tell us all about the nature of God would be the worst, if they were not surpassed by the still greater absurdities of the philosophers who try to prove that there is no God.
T. H. Huxley, On the Hypothesis that Animals are Automata, and its History. A lecture delivered to the British Association, Belfast, 1874.
W. K. Clifford, addressing the Sunday Lecture Society in the same year, addressed the right of scientists like Darwin and Huxley to speak freely on matters of social instinct and conscience:
… it may be said that Science ought not to deal with these questions at all; that while scientific men are concerned with physical facts, … in treating of such subjects as these they are going out of their domain, and must do harm. … What is the domain of Science? It is all possible human knowledge which can rightly be used to guide human conduct. … It is idle to set bounds to the purifying and organising work of Science.
W. K. Clifford, ‘Body and Mind’, in Fortnightly Review, 1874.
In The Origin of the Species, Darwin had left room for belief in the Creator, but in its 1871 ‘sequel’, The Descent of Man, he was more openly agnostic. But in spite of all the controversy he faced, both internally and externally, when he died, Darwin was buried in Westminster Abbey. Public reaction to the theory of evolution ranged from outright hostility to wild enthusiasm. Philosophers and political economists adopted and adapted Darwin’s theories to support their own wider social theories. Karl Marx declared that Darwin had provided the biological basis for communism. But, equally, capitalists such as Andrew Carnegie and J. D. Rockefeller appealed to ‘evolution’ to justify the growth of ‘big business.’ Among Christian leaders, C. H. Spurgeon pronounced the theory of evolution a monstrous error, which would be ridiculed before another twenty years. In his 1891 address to the Annual Conference of the Pastors’ College, the leading Baptist preacher used the military language of the first letter to Timothy, to defend the Biblical account of creation:
The sacred Word has endured more criticism than the best accepted form of philosophy or science, and it has survived every ordeal. As a living divine has said, “After the present assailants are all dead, their funeral sermons will be preached from this Book – not one verse omitted – from the first page of Genesis to the last page of Revelation.” …
… We, brethren, are willing to ascribe to the Word of God all the inspiration that can possibly be ascribed to it … We are willing to be tried and tested by it in every way, and we count those to be the noblest of our hearers who search the Scriptures daily to see whether these things be so; but to those who belittle inspiration we will give no place by subjection, no, not for an hour.
… Do I hear someone say, “But still you must submit to the conclusions of science”? No one is more willing than we are to accept the evident facts of science. But what do you mean by science? Is the thing called “science” infallible? Is it not science “falsely so-called”? The history of that human ignorance which calls itself “philosophy” is absolutely identical with the history of fools, except where it diverges into madness.
If another Erasmus were to arise and write the history of folly, he would have to give several chapters to philosophy and science … I should not myself dare to say that philosophers and scientists are generally fools; but … I would let the wise of each generation speak of the generation that went before it … for there is little of theory in science today that will survive in twenty years, and only a little more that will see the beginning of the twentieth century.
We travel now at so rapid a rate that we rush by sets of scientific hypotheses as quicly as we pass telegraph posts when riding an express train … I believe in science, but not what is called “science”. … The fanciful part of science, so dear to many, is what we do not accept. … that part which is a mere guess, for which the gassers fight tooth and nail.
The mythology of science is as false as the mythology of the heathen; but this is the thing that is made a god of. … as far as the facts are concerned, science is never in conflict with the the truths of Holy Scripture, but the hurried deductions drawn from those facts, and the inventions classed as facts, are opposed to Scripture…
C. H. Spurgeon (1891, edn. 1982, 1999), The Greatest Fight in the World: The Final Manifesto. Belfast: Ambassador Publications.
As a ‘free churchman’, Spurgeon was noticeably more nuanced in his approach to science than many of the original ‘Establishment’ critics of Darwin who feared the attack on their privileges and authority which his theory seemed to present. Spurgeon was primarily concerned with maintaining the authority of the Bible for believers. Neither did he argue that scientists should not encroach upon doctrinal matters. Instead, he went on to argue that there were two sorts of people who were disqualified from making judgements in matters of science and religion. The first was the ‘irreligious scientist’ because he knew nothing of religion and therefore could not answer the question, Does science agree with religion? Obviously, anyone who would try to answer this query, Spurgeon said, would need to know both sides of the question. The second was the ‘unscientific Christian’ who will try to reconcile the Bible with science, without the scientific ‘tools’ and knowledge to do the job. Spurgeon suggested that he had better leave it alone, and not begin his tinkering trade. The mistake made by both these men, he argued, was that in trying to solve the problem they had only succeeded in twisting the Bible or contorting science. The solution had then been quickly shown to be erroneous after one side or another had declared victory prematurely.
Other Christian leaders were cautiously in favour of accepting the new theories. Frederick Temple, who later became the Archbishop of Canterbury, was fairly typical of this attitude. He held that the concept of evolution left the argument for an intelligent Creator and Governor of the earth stronger than ever. The world was not simply a series of accidents and the old argument from design to belief in God could be restated in a different way. The Scottish free churchman, Henry Drummond, applied the concept of the survival of the fittest in a novel way. Even in the animal world, survival is not simply a matter of stealth and strength. Care and compassion play an important part; the gospel of Christ was, therefore, also crucial to human survival. This was a similar observation to that made later by the Russian scientist and political theorist, Peter Kropotkin, who advanced the complementary theory of ‘mutual aid’ in nature by observing cooperation between species of plants and animals.
At first sight, however, the idea of evolution seemed to flatly contradict the book of Genesis. For centuries Christians had read Genesis 1 as if it had been a newspaper account of ‘The creation’, step by step. On the surface of the texts, the Hebrew Bible implies that the world was created in the fifth millennium BC: Archbishop James Ussher (1581-1656) calculated, using the figures in various books of the Bible, that the creation occurred on 23 October 4004 BC. Many Bibles were printed with marginal notes stating that the world was created on this date. This is, in fact, still believed by so-called young-earth creationists, but in the nineteenth century, a scientific evaluation of the age of the universe became entirely obvious in the light of scientific discoveries. The same century saw the assertion that in Genesis 1 God is shown to have created each species of plant and animal separately challenged by evolutionary science, in particular through the work of Darwin. As the Church historian, Owen Chadwick put it:
The Christian church taught what was not true. It taught the world to be six thousand years old, a universal flood, and stories in the Old Testament like the speaking ass or the swallowing of Jonah by a whale which ordinary men (once they were asked to consider the question of truth or falsehood) instantly put into the category of legends.
Owen Chadwick (1972), The Victorian Church, Part Two: 1860-1901. London: SCM Press, p. 2.
More recently, Philip Kennedy has commented:
The consequences of Darwin’s work are very far from being appropriated by officially sanctioned Christian doctrines. For example, the current ‘Catechism of the Catholic Church’ solemnly teaches that the biblical story of Adam and Eve, or rather the third chapter of the Book of Genesis, ‘affirms a primaeval event, a deed that took place at the beginning of the history.’ This teaching is solemnly declared. It is also false. Chapter 3 of Genesis is a myth. It does not provide any reliable information about the historical genesis of a human species. What it does say about human origins is false. To regard it as factually true is to violate its literary form as a myth.
Philip Kennedy (2006), A Modern Introduction to Theology: New Questions for Old Beliefs. London & New York: I. B. Tauris, p. 235.
The last sentence in this quote points to the practical effect of scientific knowledge on Biblical Studies: it made scholars and readers alike see that the Bible contained myths and legends, which might be full of wisdom and insight of many kinds but which did not provide any scientific information or historical account of human origins. The effect was not limited to claims made in the Old Testament. When Paul affirms that death entered the world because of sin (the sin of Adam: Romans 5: 12), this too is rendered clearly untrue through the observation that human beings, and their hominid predecessors, have always been mortal, as are all other organisms. This is important because it challenges a major element in the Christian story of the fall of man and his redemption, which John Barton (2019) calls ‘God’s rescue mission’, in which Adam’s sin plays a central role. This too, and not just Genesis, has to be understood in a non-literal way or relinquished as a complete fabrication, or ‘fairy tale’. On the whole, by the end of the nineteenth century, biblical scholars had made this transition, with varying degrees of enthusiasm; but ecclesiastical authorities, and Christians of a conservative disposition, have in many cases still not made it today. Biblical literalists continue to defend the historicity of the Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve, Jonah’s big fish and Balaam’s talking donkey, to the delight of atheist critics of Christianity.
Map showing how ‘Mesopotamia’ and ‘Canaan’ came into being and helped to shape the history of Abraham and his descendants.
At the heart of the whole area sometimes called the ‘Near’ East, sometimes the ‘Middle East’ lies the plateau of Arabia. This was once part of a large block called ‘Gondwanaland’ by geologists. To the north and west of this lay the sea which they call ‘Tethys’ of which the present Mediterranean is a remnant. The coastline of this sea fluctuated, sometimes extending far into what is now the land east and south-east of the Dead Sea, and leaving behind on top of the sandstone layers a layer of limestone, which formed the hills around Jerusalem. Another layer of softer limestone was formed, which was worn away to leave some of the mountain passes of modern Israel. On top of this came a third, harder layer of limestone, now seen between Mount Carmel and Samaria, and in the mountains east of the Jordan. Further geological shifts led to Mesopotamia and Canaan being brought together as one geologically-related area. However, in the Tertiary period, the seabed of Tethys, based on less resistant rock than Gondwanaland, was forced up by pressure acting from the north and was pushed and folded into mountain chains against the unyielding edge of Gondwanaland. At the same time, the plateau shattered in several places, dividing roughly to create the ‘boundaries’ of Africa and Arabia, and producing the shape of ‘Canaan’. The Meditteranean coast of this area became famous as a bridge between Asia and Africa, and clearly helped the rise of its civilisations. As a result, ‘Mesopotamia’, the land between the two rivers of the Tigris and Euphrates, is composed of two geographical regions; the northern region is the ‘island’ between the two great rivers, and the Delta region of the south, comprising ancient Sumer and Akkad, Babylon, biblical Shinar with Elam away to the east.
Mesopotamia and Canaan in the time of Abraham
After Darwin, there were many who continued in their belief in the Bible, not just as the ‘inspired Word of God’, but as scientifically and historically accurate in every detail. A popular manual much used by potential clergy in mid-Victorian Britain, at a time when the Church had a virtual monopoly on education, gave a clear verdict that, in the Bible, every scientific statement is infallibly accurate, all its history and narrations of every kind are without any inaccuracy. Doubts might be stirring, particularly as science began to raise serious problems, but a similar view was held by the vast majority of Christians. For them, the Bible was nothing less than the inerrant word of God. To challenge this view publicly in Britain was to invite personal abuse, dismissal, even legal action. Essays and Reviews, a collection of essays by Oxford scholars, was condemned after a petition of eleven thousand clergymen and over 150,000 laypeople when its most provocative essay merely urged those that the Bible should be approached like any other book. But others did begin to ask whether their reading had been too rigidly literal. As they gained experience in dealing with such objections, scholars learnt to match their own questioning to the world they were investigating. They learnt that they had to do more than look at the Bible by itself; they had to recreate the world in which it was composed, whether that was Palestine in the tenth century BCE or Babylon in the sixth or Corinth in the first century CE (AD). Only when there was better knowledge of how people in these places and times lived and thought and spoke would the relevant parts of the Bible take their place in the new picture. A useful illustration of this development was given in the 1960s by Dr Leonard Hodgson:
… modern zoology began when, instead of relying on Aristotelian and heraldic representations of animals in traditional bestiaries, men based their research on the observation of the actual nature and behaviour of living creatures. … As a result of this last century’s biblical studies, we are at a similar turning point in the history of Christian theology. … A hundred years ago our forefathers looked to the Bible as in the same way that medieval zoologists looked to Aristotle… To their successors’ substituting of observation of actual animals corresponds our attention to the historical provenance of the biblical writings.
Quoted by John Bowden (1970), (see ref. below), The Biblical Scholar and his Tools, p. 6.
This meant cultivating a historical sense. That too was developed over the century since Darwin’s theory, so it affected almost any arts subject, from music to languages, and even some of the sciences. The way we begin to understand anything is by looking at its roots, its origins, and discovering how it came to be as we observe it now. Biblical criticism had been in progress for some time before this point became clear. When it began, it was in no position to reconstruct past ethnographies, geographies and ecologies because it did not have sufficient sources of evidence to do so. But this did not mean that useful and lasting research could not be done on more limited, though still valuable issues. Even before archaeology began to make its impressive contribution to our contemporary understanding of events, contexts and developments referred to in the ancient texts, a great deal had already been established about those texts of both the old and new Testament books from their literary characteristics.
The change to a more modest assessment of the Bible happened over the course of a little more than a century from the publication of Darwin’s theory, not a long time compared with the whole history of the Bible as a ‘library’ of various books. It came about because questions were asked quite unlike those of any other previous period. They were questions prompted by a scientific revolution that affected not only the Bible but the entire modern world. Most believers long ago accepted that Genesis 1, for example, is not true in the sense of being an accurate, scientific account of the creation of the world, so that scepticism about the details of the narrative books can also now coexist with continuing to respect the texts as religiously inspiring and informative. We can follow a critical path while at the same time retaining our connection with the traditional use of the Bible by understanding the value of its profound narratives. John Bowden, in his article for the (1970) publication A Source Book of the Bible for Teachers (see the reference above), concludes that the ‘tools’ required by the biblical scholar are the same as those employed by other studies, including history, philosophy, languages, even science, in which disagreements are not uncommon, together with an approach of genuine openness. So biblical scholarship does not stand entirely apart. Where it differs is in the importance attached to its conclusions.
Inspiration, Metaphorical Meanings and Rational Reality:
So much in the past had been based on the belief in the fundamental truth and infallibility of the Bible that changes in perceptions, understanding and interpretation were felt, and still are by many, to have very far-reaching significance. Neither the Old Testament nor the New Testament books themselves contain any claim by their authors to have been dictated or even directly inspired, by God. The chief passage relevant to the inspiration of texts (as opposed to people) is II Timothy 3: 16-17:
All scripture is inspired by God and is useful for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, so that everyone who belongs to God may be proficient, equipped for every good work.
In this passage, ‘Scripture’ must surely refer to the books of the Old Testament, though by the time II Timothy was written some of Paul’s letters seem already to have been regarded as such, as in II Peter 3: 16. However, both these letters were unlikely to have been written by Paul, and both seem to be among the last-written books of the Bible. It also seems unlikely, had Paul had a hand in these letters, that he would have claimed that ‘hand’ to have been directly ‘inspired’ or dictated to by God. ‘Inspired’ literally meant ‘God-breathed’ in the Greek of that time, which would imply that God was the author of the biblical books in a way not otherwise asserted within the books themselves. In Judaism, it has been customary to see the books of the Hebrew Bible as given by the spirit of God, though the exact mechanism is not much discussed. Despite the paucity of references within the Bible itself, Christians have often quoted II Timothy and described the Bible as the product of divine inspiration. Dictation theories are unusual today: even very conservative Christians allow that the biblical authors contributed much from their own minds. But accepting this makes it difficult to exclude the possibility of human error, inaccuracy or interpretation in the writing of the biblical texts, which conservatives are concerned at all costs to avoid admitting.
Some ‘conservative’ Christians do indeed continue to hold that since Genesis 1-2 says that the world was created in six days, it must have been so created – a literal interpretation. Others are more concerned with the Bible’s infallibility than with reading all of it literally, and will sometimes accept metaphorical readings if that will preserve the fundamental truth of the texts. Some will maintain that ‘day’ does not literally mean a period of twenty-four hours, but a vastly longer ‘period’. Since God inspired the writers, they cannot have been in error; and since we know that the world formed and life evolved over billions of years, that must be what Genesis really means. Some have also been heard to insist that there must have been six periods in the creation of the earth, and that even that this is supported by science, in an effort to avoid accepting that – in purely scientific and historical terms – Genesis is simply wrong. Darwin’s contemporaries also witnessed many similar attempts to reconcile biblical texts with scientific discoveries. In his ministerial Conference address of 1891, for instance, Spurgeon described a good brother who writes a tremendous book to prove that the six days of creation represent six great theological periods:
… he shows how the geological strata, and the organisms thereof, follow very much in the order of the Genesis story of creation. It may be so, or it may not be so; but if anybody should before long show that the strata do not lie in any such order, what would be my reply? I should say that the Bible never taught that they did. The Bible said, “In the beginning, God created the heaven and the earth.” …There is nothing said about long ages of time…
… I do not here lay down any theory, but simply say that if our friend’s great book is all fudge, the Bible is not responsible for it. It is true that his theory has an appearance of support from the parallelism which he makes out between the organic life of the ages and that of the seven days; but this may be accounted for from the fact God usually follows a certain order whether he works in long periods or short ones. I do not know, and I do not care much about the question …
… {but} if you smash up an explanation you must not imagine that you have damaged the Scriptural truth which seemed to require the explanation… Believe everything in science which is proved: it will not come to much. And then believe everything which is clearly in the Word of God…
C. H. Spurgeon, The Greatest Fight in the World, loc. cit. , pp. 41-42.
On the other hand, a purely historical-critical style of reading the Bible would see the stories as reports of alleged actual events, but then go on simply to deny that such events actually happened. After all, there were two creation narratives in Genesis, both giving very different slants. Could it be that we are not intended to take these stories as exact, literal and scientific descriptions of what happened? Do they not rather present profound insights into man’s relationship with the world and his God, in terms which could be understood by pre-scientific man? Could it not be that, in describing the origin of the world, Genesis had to use a certain amount of symbolism, just as the last book of the Bible uses symbolism to describe the cosmic events of the end of the world? It is commonplace in modern discussions of religion and science to argue that the story of creation in Genesis 1 was never meant to be taken literally, and this was picked up by the Catholic Pontifical Biblical Commission in their short book entitled The Inspiration and Truth of Sacred Scripture: The Word that Comes from God and Speaks of God for the Salvation of the World:
The first creation account (Gen. 1: 1 – 2: 4a), through its well-organised structure, describes not how the world came into being but why and for what purpose it is as it is. In poetic style, using the imagery of his era, the author of Gen. 1 … shows that God is the origin of the cosmos and of humankind.
Inspiration and Truth, p. 74.
It seems to John Barton highly likely, however, that the author of the first account was trying to describe how the world came into being, in other words, that the text is, or was, meant to be taken literally. The problem with this way of understanding it is that, unless you are a ‘fundamentalist’, you have to go on to admit that the author was mistaken, and this comes very hard to many conservative Christians, especially when they are dealing with what became ecclesiastical documents. The metaphorical reading of the creation story is a ‘forced’ or ‘strained’ reading, designed to ensure that the narrative can continue to be seen as true in some sense. And perhaps it is true in that sense – but it foists on the authors what some readers believe is the best way we have of extracting benefit from the passages. Such readings are not a modern undertaking, but reveal a dependence on the view that, because the text is ‘inspired’ it must be ‘true’ according to our understanding of how the world is and how it came to be. Nonetheless, there is an alternative, which is to read it at face value, and then recognise that it is not true. If we do that, then the idea that the text is inspired becomes harder to hold on to. Perhaps, as John Barton suggests, it is better not to make the high claim that it is inspired or, at least, to understand ‘inspiration’ differently. Perhaps, also, the use of the word ‘fundamentalist’ to describe ‘conservative Christians’ who read the Bible literally, is not an appropriate usage. A Christian must be able to hold to the ‘radical truth’ of the Creation myths and sagas without accepting them as historically or scientifically factual.
‘The Ancient of Days’ by William Blake (1757-1827), from Europe, a Prophecy, 1794.
At the time, since the habit of reading Genesis 1 literally (and often at the expense of Genesis 2 which tended to be ignored) was deeply ingrained it was consequential that the battle should rage over creation versus evolution. Another consequence was that many people exchanged an uncritical view of creation for an equally uncritical view of evolution. Today, we can take a more objective view. For most Christians, it is not so much a case of either/or, but of seeing God’s creative action in the processes of evolution. To do this requires an understanding of modern science, but not an extensive knowledge of it. It means relating Christian beliefs, not only to an evolutionary time-scale but also to relative values. In the past, people have thought of God as God-of-the-gaps. God and nature were quite separate. For most of the time nature functions quite adequately on its own. God comes into the picture only where there is a break in the processes of nature. The trouble with this view is that the more science is able to explain our life in terms of natural processes, the less room there is for God. In the end, God is squeezed out altogether. But God is not a term of scientific explanation. He is not one cause alongside other natural causes. Rather, he is there working in and through all that goes on in the world. The believer knows from the Bible and in his experience that this is so. It is the inherited task of twenty-first-century theology to show us more clearly how we can think of God against the background of a scientific view of the world.
‘Conclusions’ – Continuing Questions, Doubts and Assurances:
But if, as is so often the case, there is just not enough evidence to come to any definite conclusion, then living with questions and doubt would seem to be the only answer. As in other areas of life, perhaps we just have to get used to that as the modern condition of mankind. But then, the believer may ask, can we be sure of anything? It might be wrong, or misleading, to collect a set of ‘assured results’ and present them by saying of this much, at least, we may be certain. All results are only probable, though some may be more probable than others, and many assured results of the past have since been overturned. A good deal of the tension between doubt and assurance is evinced by the question of what can we be sure? This tension may slacken once the distinction between ‘proof’ and ‘understanding’ has been made. The Bible bears witness to God through the whole life of a particular people and the way in which it looked at the world. That life had many aspects, and when we acknowledge that, a great many of its patterns and processes will fall into place of their own accord. On the vexed question of Biblical authority, Robert C Walton has concluded:
The Bible is self-authenticating. Its authority cannot be imposed, its significance cannot be demonstrated by using time-honoured phrases like ‘Holy Scripture’ or ‘the word of God’. … Yet it has been the experience of millions in the past and today that the Bible has the power to transmit to men the mystery and majesty, the power and loving-kindness of God: and also the mystery, the majesty and loving-kindness of Jesus. It makes its own claims on upon men’s minds and imaginations and consciences, but this self-authentication… is often built up slowly; it may take years, decades, or perhaps a whole lifetime.
Robert C Walton, Has the Bible Authority? in his (1970) Source Book of the Bible for Teachers.
Philosophical approaches, biblical criticism and the theory of evolution threw the church onto the defensive in the late Victorian period. All three seemed to be saying that man was only a superior ape, that philosophy put things in a clear light and that there is nothing but the material on which to base belief. Included in these secular views was the ultimate critique of the Bible as ‘fancy’ or as ‘fairy tales.’ As so often in the past, however, the challenge of opposition brought out the best in the Church. What these intellectual movements did was pose problems and there were those within the Church who rose to the challenge and propose solutions. But each generation must provide fresh solutions, and the twentieth century was to present problems for the church of a different order entirely.
Sources:
John Barton (2019), A History of the Bible: The Book and Its Faiths. London: Allen Lane (Penguin Books).
Tim Dowley (ed.) (1977), A History of Christianity. Berkhamsted: Lion Publishing.
Robert C Walton (ed.) (1970, 1982), A Source Book of the Bible for Teachers. London: SCM Press Ltd.
C. Harvie, G. Martin & A. Scharf (eds.) (1975), Industrialisation and Culture, 1830-1914. Basingstoke: Macmillan (for The Open University).
C. H. Spurgeon (1891, 1999), The Greatest Fight in the World: Conference Address. Belfast: Ambassador Publications.
Includes a scene from Regent Street Baptist Church, Smethwick, Birmingham, from November 1897, ‘The Church in Meeting Assembled’ by Rev. A. J. Chandler, Minister of Bearwood Baptist Church, Birmingham, 1965-79.
Revival, ‘Respectability’ & Reform in Britain, 1814-1859:
In 1814, there was an evangelistic revival at Redruth in Cornwall which continued for nine days. An eye-witness described what happened:
Hundreds were crying for mercy at once. Some remained in great distress of soul for one hour, some for two, some six, some nine, twelve and fifteen hours before the Lord spoke peace in their souls – then they would rise, extend their arms and proclaim the wonderful works of God with such energy that bystanders would be struck in a moment and fall to the ground and roar for the disquieture of their souls.
By 1826, a complete change had come over the social habits of Britain, or so many contemporary witnesses have told us in their diaries, journals and letters. In that year, one writer wrote of the courtesy of the people of Petticoat Lane in London. He walked there with his wife without hearing or seeing anything objectionable. Fifteen years earlier he had been blackguarded from one end of the lane to the other. But not everything was not a marker of progress and moral improvement. The cult of respectability among the emerging business classes was not the same as real Christianity, and there was also a great deal of hypocrisy among evangelicals. Most of them observed Sunday strictly, but the Victorian evangelicals were strictest of all. The Lord Day’s Observance Society was founded in 1831. Numerous letters and articles in the evangelical magazine, The Record, protested against Sunday opening of parks, museums and zoological gardens. For six years, the evangelical minister at Cheltenham managed to prevent all passenger trains from stopping there on a Sunday.
Evangelical societies made it their business to supply Anglican evangelical ordinands and endow evangelical parishes where they might serve. The most important patronage trust was that begun by John Thornton and taken over by the Rev. Charles Simeon. When he died, the Simeon Trust had the right to nominate the clergy to twenty-one Anglican positions. These were mainly in large towns such as Bradford and Derby. By 1820, one in twenty of the Anglican clergy were evangelical; by 1830, it was one in eight. But Anglican evangelicals gained high office only slowly. Henry Ryder became Bishop of Gloucester in 1815 and Charles Richard Sumner became Bishop of Winchester in 1827, but the commanding heights of the Church were not ‘taken’ until John Bird Sumner became Archbishop of Canterbury in 1848. These three men presented a new kind of bishop. They were much simpler in their lifestyles than their predecessors. They visited all parts of their dioceses and took more care over confirmations and ordinations. Their example was followed in the fifties by the ‘Palmerston bishops’, who were mostly appointed on the advice of the evangelical, Lord Shaftesbury. The English evangelical social reformer, pictured below, supported numerous causes, including improved factory conditions for the working classes, the regulation of child and female labour and slum schools.
Lord Shaftesbury
1833 not only saw the Abolition of Slavery within the British Empire, but also the first effective Factory Act passed by Parliament. It had often been suggested that Wilberforce and his associates in the Clapham Sect were only concerned with liberating black slaves overseas and not with the ‘white slaves’ of industrial England. This claim, also made ever since by some historians, ignores the fact that Wilberforce had been one of the first few reformers to complain that the ineffective Factory Acts of 1802 and 1818 did not go far enough. The specialists in the industrial problem were, however, the Yorkshire evangelicals, such as Wilberforce’s friend Thomas Gisburne, Richard Oastler of Huddersfield, Michael Sadler MP, their parliamentary spokesman, and John Wood, a Bradford textile manufacturer. Wood put the issue of ‘white slavery’ to Oastler in 1830 in terms of the ongoing campaign against Afro-Caribbean slavery:
You are very enthusiastic against slavery in the West Indies: and I assure you there are cruelties practised in our mills on little children, which, if you knew, I am sure you would strive to prevent.
A few months later, Oastler wrote a famous letter to the Leeds Mercury entitled ‘Yorkshire Slavery’ in which he represented the disappointment of his fellow northern campaigners with the lack of support received from dissenters and the more pietistic of their fellow evangelical Anglicans, who appeared content to leave the plight of the distressed working classes to the operation of so-called ‘natural laws’. Shaftesbury was also often criticised by more heavenly-minded evangelicals for being too concerned with the earthly conditions of the Victorian working classes. He had his own answer for their criticisms which he presented to a Social Service Congress held at Liverpool in 1859:
When people say we should think more of the soul and less of the body, my answer is that the same God who made the soul made the body also … I maintain that God is worshipped not only by the spiritual but the material creation. Our bodies, the temples of the Holy Ghost, ought not to be corrupted by preventable disease, degraded by avoidable filth, and disabled for his service by unnecessary suffering.
Continental Revival and Reaction, 1815-65:
Meanwhile, following the fall of Napoleon and state-sponsored atheism, between 1815 and 1848 a series of popular religious awakenings arose throughout Protestant Europe. The awakening (Réveil) in French-speaking Europe had its origins in Geneva, in the ministry of the Scot, Robert Haldane (1764-1842), who led an early mission to French-speaking Europe in the 1820s and 30s. In 1802, Chateaubriand’s Génie du Christianisme (The Genius of Christianity) was published in France, an immensely popular and powerful argument for Christianity, based on its aesthetic values. In Denmark, Nicolai Grundvig (1783-1872) initiated a pietistic movement by openly opposing liberal theology. The revival in Sweden resulted from the ministry in Stockholm of an English preacher, George Scott. In Norway, the awakening was largely a lay movement, connected with Hans Nielsen Hauge (1771-1824). These revival movements were not closely related to each other and were largely the work of ‘ordinary’ Christians. In 1848, there were outbreaks of revolution in France, Italy, Austria-Hungary and Germany. By December, the five hundred representatives from the German kingdoms, Austria and Bohemia attending an assembly at Frankfurt to create a constitution for Germany, for the whole Empire, produced a Declaration of the Rights of the German People which included a guarantee of religious freedom for dissenters. The ‘Old Lutherans’ who had rejected the Prussian Union of 1817 with the Calvinists, were allowed freedom of conscience. Nonconformists who had appeared in Germany as a result of missionary activity from English-speaking nations also gained toleration. But these gains were, however, short-lived.
Democratic institutions made little further progress in Germany and by 1850 most republican reforms, including those of the Frankfurt Assembly, had lapsed into disuse. In 1862, political reaction and religious autocracy had returned across Europe with Pope Pius IX’s encyclical, Quanta Cura naming political liberalism as one of the chief ‘modern errors’. The Syllabus of Errors also condemned rationalism in all its forms, including liberal theology, freemasonry and religious toleration itself. Even the Bible Societies, which had entered the European continent from Britain after 1815, were ejected. In 1816, Pius VII had rebuked the Societies for distributing the Scriptures without the comments of the church ‘Fathers’. In the 1830s, Pope Gregory XVI further condemned them as daring heralds of infidelity and heresy. So the Syllabus simply consolidated earlier opposition. The pope also issued a strong attack on the separation of church and state, fearing the continued strength of republicanism in France. In response, the French state prohibited the publication of the Syllabus of Errors in 1865.
Evangelical ranks in Britain divided from the 1820s, partly in reaction to developments on the continent. Edward Irving convinced many evangelicals that they were far too optimistic about the conversion of the world; in fact, the day of judgement was at hand. Christ’s second coming would precede the millennium. He believed that the missionary societies were deceiving the elect by talking of the conversion of the world. At the same time the Calvinist, Robert Haldane, won his campaign against Simeon to prevent the Apocrypha from being included in Bibles published by the Bible Society. Haldane’s nephew, Alexander, shared his uncle’s views. When the younger Haldane became the chief owner of the twice-weekly Record in 1828, he propagated these strong ideas. Haldane gave strict Calvinism a foothold again in Anglican Evangelicalism. The Record also adopted Irving’s views on biblical philosophy and the millennium, its policy becoming ultra-conservative in both politics and theology. Its strongest condemnation was for Sabbath-breakers and Roman Catholics, but ‘the Recordites’ also became a strident minority within the Evangelical party. ‘The mainstream party’ continued the tradition of Simeon and the Clapham Sect. Among their leaders were Edward Bickersteth, Henry Venn and J. W. Cunningham. Their journal, which stressed loyalty to the church, was the monthly Christian Observer, which had begun in 1802. In spite of theological differences, however, there was no open rift with ‘the Recordites’.
Missionary Societies, Colonies and Imperial Trade:
William Carey (1761-1834) achieved much in various areas during his time in India, including Bible translation and production, evangelism, church planting, education and medical relief, as well as social reform and linguistic and horticultural research. More specifically, he initiated mission schools, conceived the idea of Serampore College, founded the Agricultural Society of India (1820) to promote agricultural improvements, studied botany (being awarded a fellowship of the Linnaean Society in 1823), and took a leading part in the campaign for the abolition of widow-burning (sati), which succeeded in 1829.
William Carey, the untiring English Baptist pioneer missionary.
Carey’s devotion to India, which he never left, and his practical wisdom in his encouraging Indians to spread the gospel themselves. In this respect, he defined his chief object as follows:
“… the forming of our native bethren to usefulness, fostering every kind of genius, and cherishing every gift and grace in them; in this respect we can scarcely be too lavish in our attention to their improvement. It is only by means of native preachers (that) we can hope for the universal spread of the Gospel through this immense continent.”
The Evangelical Revival had revolutionised preaching and its objectives. Churchmen regarded the parish priest’s task as nurturing all the baptised members of the parochial church and could not easily adjust to the thought of preaching in tribal and nomadic societies. At the same, Calvinists with a rigid doctrine of predestination and ‘the Elect’ saw no reason to concern themselves with the conversion of the heathens. When God wanted to convert them, Carey was told by a fellow Baptist, he would do it without your help or mine! But the evangelical felt a personal responsibility to do this and saw no difference between the ‘baptised heathen’ in Britain and non-Christians overseas. But it was only in the 1820s and 1830s that interest in overseas missions become a regular feature of British church life generally. This was due partly to the success of the Evangelicals in influencing British life. Many of the values of the evangelicals were adopted outside their own circles. In particular, the idea of Britain as a Christian nation with a global mission took root. Bishoprics were established in India, though none had ever been established in colonial America, and the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel enlarged its operations to those of a general missionary society. In Scotland, moderate presbyterian churchmen joined with evangelicals to promote missions, strongly educational in character, under the umbrella of The General Assembly of the Church of Scotland.
The birth of the missionary societies, however, had nothing to do with the protection of British trading interests abroad. The earliest missions were in fact intricately associated with evangelical Baptists and supported by people with known revolutionary instincts and sympathies, such as Robert Haldane, the Genevan-based Scot. It was also the evangelical groups who led the continuing campaign against slavery in the British Empire. This caused some in the Anglican establishment to fear that they were basically subversive. To this was added the fear that in India, missionary preaching would offend Hindus and Muslims, upsetting a volatile colonial relationship and harming British trade. The semi-official Honourable East India Company, through which British administration and trade were exercised, was not initially favourably disposed towards Carey and his colleagues, so much so that the missionaries had to sail in a Danish ship and work from Danish territory. The antithetical attitude of the East India Company changed when in 1813 the Company’s charter came up for renewal, and the Evangelicals of the Clapham Sect denounced some aspects of its policy. Not only did the Company hinder missionary work, they argued, it positively profited by means of a tax on native temples and similar institutions of idolatry. They won a qualified victory through the abandonment of the tax, the appointment of bishops, and the enlargement of the system of government chaplains. Missions were largely unhindered and often favoured, though nineteenth-century evangelicals soon stopped asking for ‘official’ backing for them.
When planning his first missionary enterprise, Carey had asked: what would a trading company do? From this, he proposed the formation of a company of serious laymen and ministers with a committee to collect and sift information, and to find funds and suitable men. The voluntary society, of which the missionary society was one early form, was to transform the nineteenth-century church. It was invented to meet needs rather than simply to propagate doctrines, but in doing so it undermined all the established forms of church government. In the first place, it made possible ecumenical activity. Churchmen and dissenters or seceders cut off from church business could work together for defined purposes. It also altered the power base in the church, by encouraging lay leadership among ordinary members who came to hold key positions in important societies, the best of which made it possible for many people to participate. The enthusiast who collected a penny a week from members of his local missionary society and distributed the missionary magazine was fully involved in the work of the society. It was through the work of such people that missionary candidates came forward. The American missionary, Rufus Anderson, put their achievements in dramatic context when he wrote in 1834:
It was not until the present century that that the evangelical churches of Christendom were ever really organised with a view to the conversion of the world.
Within Wesleyan Methodism, Thomas Coke was anxious to extend Methodist missions on a worldwide scale and tried several times to get the Methodist Conference to approve his plans for an extension. The objections were mainly financial, so Coke worked towards forming local auxiliaries and by 1814 these were recognised by the Conference. In 1818 it brought together the auxiliaries in a Methodist Missionary Society. Eventually, every member of the Methodist Church was automatically enrolled in the Society. In Scotland, the Kirk took direct responsibility for missions in 1824 and appointed its first missionary, Alexander Duff. By that time evangelicals and moderates agreed on the importance of this work, with its emphasis on education, which became the hallmark of successive Scottish missions. When the Kirk was split by the ‘Disruption’ in 1843, the missionaries all joined the Free Church and the Church of Scotland had to begin again recruiting missionaries. The founding fathers of the early British societies clearly did not expect many missionary recruits from among ministers – or the normal sources of supply of ministers. Carey, a self-educated cobbler turned minister, was an exception. Most of the early recruits were craftsmen or tradesmen, who would be unlikely to seek or obtain ordination for the home ministry.
The first few years’ experiences of the London Missionary Society (LMS) showed the importance of the careful preparation of missionaries. Though many of the candidates had little formal education, their training, superintended by David Bogue, was impressive. Much of the early LMS study material on languages and tribes is strikingly scholarly. There was little appetite in the first half of the nineteenth century for the acquisition of new territories and in the 1840s there were pressures and plans to abandon as many as possible of such expensive luxuries. The missionaries also played an important role in the eventual emancipation of the slaves within the British Empire, which did not come about until 1833, after a long campaign led by Fowell Buxton.
Buxton was aided by direct eye-witness accounts from the missionaries as to how slavery continued to dehumanise the lives of Africans, Afro-Caribbeans and Afro-Americans. Even after Abolition, the missionary societies also argued that Britain owed a debt to Africa for slavery and to India for the wealth derived from it. From 1841 to 1856, the Scottish doctor, independent missionary and explorer, David Livingstone, (1813-73) served with the LMS, exposing the horrid facts of the Arab slave trade in central Africa. His strategy was not to exploit but to liberate and in this he contrasted sharply with Cecil Rhodes. Though a missionary for only half of his thirty years in Africa, Livingstone saw all his work in the context of a providential plan in which gospel preaching, the increase of knowledge and the relief of suffering were all closely connected. The Anglican Universities Mission to Central Africa owed its inspiration to this Scots Independent and after his death, the Church of Scotland and the Free Church of Scotland came together to open Central African missions which reflected his ideals and breadth of vision.
The greatest difficulties in recruiting were met by the Church Missionary Society (CMS) since their principles required the use of ordained men and very few came forward. These were eased by transcontinental collaboration with seminaries in Germany elsewhere. Of the first twenty-four CMS missionaries, seventeen were German and only three were ordained Englishmen. This imbalance was eased when the bishops became more involved with the society’s activities, and also as it became more rooted in the parishes. Following the lead of Carey and the Baptists, Indian missions continued to stimulate the British missionary societies, but by the middle of the century, there was an increasing involvement in Africa.
By mid-century, the importance of training ‘native ministers’ was better and more widely recognised, and an increasing number were serving on the staffs of the societies. The CMS Niger Mission, begun in 1857, was staffed entirely by Africans. In the last third of the century, missionary recruitment expanded enormously. This was largely due to the effects of the 1859 Revival, the Baptist Keswick Convention and other movements. The ‘Cambridge Seven’, ex-Cambridge undergraduates who set out for China in 1885, were only the first of hundreds to follow. These decades – the period of high imperialism – not only produced many more missionaries but a different type of missionary. The same influences were at work in producing new forms of society. These maintained the voluntary society principle and were directed towards particular regions, for example, the China Inland Mission (1865) or the Qua Iboe Mission (1887).
Others met particular needs, like the Mission to Lepers (1874). The photograph below shows women suffering from leprosy in a ‘mission compound’ at Champa, India in 1903.
The nineteenth-century missionaries, and the societies which called and directed them, were a major factor in transforming Christianity into a truly global religion. The number of volunteers, together with the technological and political developments of the age, led to the prospect of the evangelisation of the world in this generation. Those hopes of further Christian advancement were dashed by the outbreak of the First World War in 1914 and its ongoing effect on faith. But by the time European manpower was reduced, the great African and Indian native mass movements had begun.
Religious Responses to Industrialisation & Urbanisation in Britain:
‘Work’, a painting by Ford Madox Brown, the original of which can be viewed in Birmingham City Art Gallery. The artist depicts many of the skills and occupations of the working-class Victorian world, attempting to show both the dignity and degradation of labour in capitalist society.
Industrialism and urbanisation strengthened the factory system which had already begun with the ‘mills’ of the north of England. It was not so much the long hours and low wages that workers objected to. They were used to these in the countryside and urban slums were not much worse than rural hovels, and agriculture depended as much on the work of women and children as the new industries. With the invention of the steam engine, the manufacturer, at last, had a source of power independent from climate and season. This was a change of universal significance and with the development of the canal systems and the railways, the limitations of location were removed from major industries. The real tyrant was the substitution of the rhythm of nature by that of the machine, for the hated threshing machines were only irregular ‘interruptions’ in rural labour. In the new urban areas, machines were a constant accompaniment to everyday life. The Church of England was particularly slow to respond to these developments, finding it difficult to do so. As the state church, it needed an act of Parliament for a new parish to be created, a process that was both time-consuming and costly.
As a consequence, the Church found itself unable, at least until the 1840s, to adapt to the new industrial England and Wales. The new urban masses consequently grew up very often beyond its care: there was often simply no physical room for them in church, and all too often no clergyman to care for their spiritual needs. The parish church, in both rural and urban areas, all too often represented the Tory Party at prayer. In the 1830s, for example, the ‘Chartists’ found little support in the established church. They frequently marched on the parish churches, requesting the vicar to preach on some congenial text, such as: Go to now, ye rich men, weep and howl for your miseries which are coming to you. The rebuff they got from all the churches led them to establish separate Chartist churches in certain areas, and there was even a Chartist hymn book. Many of the Chartist leaders of the thirties and forties were Christians and church members. There is little firm evidence of the extent and class nature of church attenders in Victorian times. England’s one and only census in which church attendance was recorded took place in 1851. The deduction was made that roughly thirty per cent of those who could have attended service on Sunday did not do so. Dissenting churches were found to be approximately as strong as the Anglican churches; in fact, stronger in urban England. Church absenteeism was highest in the new northern towns.
‘Under the Viaduct’ (1872) by Gustave Doré (1833-83). Over a hundred thousand people were displaced from their homes in London alone as a result of railway building, and many were crowded even closer in the centres of cities because they could not afford to travel to work on the railways that had effectively evicted them.
Methodism did not have the same difficulties. With its simple barn-like preaching places, its itinerant ministers, and its local preachers it was admirably designed to go where the established church was unable to go. Other Dissenters, too, expanded into the towns and cities of industrial England and engaged in missionary work there with some success. But there always remained many more people beyond, in the unchurched, unreached, jungle of ‘darkest England’ as General Booth described it. Part of the difficulty was that the churches were dominated by class divisions. Many congregations became middle-class preserves – the Wesleyans and Congregationalists tended to attract a middle-class attendance, while the Baptist ‘Tabernacle’ and the Primitive Methodist ‘Bethel’ were more likely to have a largely working-class congregation. The other small but influential nonconformist group was The Brethren, (or open Brethren). They had a strong emphasis on missionary work, at home and abroad, and their most distinctive characteristic is that the ministry and gifts of the church are distributed to all believers. They had few full-time pastors and their full-time evangelists travelled widely. Local churches governed themselves and were free to apply the teachings of scripture in the light of local and contemporary needs. Their founding fathers were mainly Anglican evangelicals who felt that the Evangelical Movement was not going far enough, but there were also many nonconformists among them who deplored certain features of their original churches. Their best-known social reformer was Thomas Barnado, pictured below helping to feed some of the hungry homeless boys of Victorian London. Barnado (1845-1905) set up a huge institution to care for the homeless children of England.
Figures of two children from George Müller’s orphanage in Bristol. Müller was one of the earliest Brethren, who never made a public appeal for the funds with which to run his orphanage, but his pottery figures, made in Stoke-on-Trent, heéped with this.
Joseph Arch
In the countryside, meanwhile, the Primitive Methodist lay-preacher Joseph Arch of Tysoe (depicted in a contemporary cartoon, right) established the Warwickshire Agricultural Labourers’ Union in the early 1870s. This was the first union of unskilled workers, and their local strike found support from the Nonconformist British Quarterly Review, which in 1872 expressed the view that…
… the movement which commenced a few months since in Warwickshire, and which is spreading gradually over the whole agricultural region of south and mid-England, is not unlike the first of those upheavals which occurred five centuries ago. Like that, it is an attempt to escape from… an intolerable and hopeless bondage, with the difference that… the present is an attempt to exact better terms for manual labour. Just as the poor priests of Wycliffe’s training were the agents… by whom communications were made between the various disaffected regions, so on the present occasion the ministers or preachers of those humbler sects, whose religious impulses are energetic, and perhaps sensational, have been found the national leaders of a struggle after social emancipation.
A religious revival has constantly been accompanied by an attempt to better the material conditions of those who are the objects of the impulse… A generation ago the agricultural labourer strove to arrest the operation of changes which oppressed him… by machine breaking and rick burning. Now the agricultural labourer has adopted the machinery of a trade union and a strike and has conducted his agitation in a strictly peaceful and law-abiding manner.
Above: A Family evicted for supporting the National Agricultural Labourers’ Union
As legal restraints were lifted in the 1870s, it became easier for trade unions to spread to ‘unskilled’ groups, such as the agricultural workers, led by Arch, whose Warwickshire union spread quickly and grew into the National Agricultural Labourers’ Union. The growth of waterfront and related unions in the great seaports helped to change the geography of the trade union movement, although their strength ebbed and flowed with the trade cycle. In 1891, on the crest of the cycle, officially recorded trade union membership had penetrated deepest in Northumberland, Durham, industrial Lancashire, Yorkshire and Derbyshire, and South Wales. It remained at a very low ebb across the Home Counties, southwest England, the rest of Wales and most of East Anglia, despite the rise in agricultural trade unions. The same geographical pattern applied to the development of consumer cooperatives. ‘Coops’ divided profits among their members and were based on the doctrines of the mill owner Robert Owen, whose great discovery that the key to a better society was unrestrained co-operation on the part of all members for every purpose of social life. They attempted to build virtuous alternative societies based on a fair distribution of the rewards of labour, whose superiority to corrupt competitive capitalism would gradually and ultimately prevail. To raise funds for these Owenite communities, shops were established, with the surpluses going towards the next stages of cooperative manufacturing and agriculture. Wherever traditions of self-help and trade union commitment coexisted with hard-working, thrifty Nonconformity, cooperation took root.
Distant Dissenters, Morality & Social Justice:
A Victorian family on their way to the chapel. In this period, it became ‘respectable’ for the middle classes to attend chapel.
How to evangelise among the working classes was an ongoing problem, partly because the children of working-class Christians tended to join the middle classes. There was something ‘bourgeois’ about revivalist ethics in practice; gone was the expenditure on drink; new priorities included the family, self-improvement and Sunday school attendance. So there came to be a distinction between ‘chapel working class’ and the ‘brute working class’ of the back alleys. From the 1840s onwards most city churches boasted a cluster of satellite missions in the poorer areas of the cities. These mission halls were often far more than preaching stations and provided their respective areas with a kind of all-purpose relief station, complete with clothing societies, penny banks, tontine clubs, soup kitchens and other agencies. They paralleled the many-sided activities of the institutional church of the suburbs which apparently provided a total ‘chapel culture’ for its adherents. The old Puritan concept of the covenant community gave way to a Christian presence, represented by a range of Christian societies engaged in various aspects of missionary work. In the late nineteenth century, people’s concerns broadened and many agencies of the church became more concerned to offer a social gospel than the old dogmatic one. The Christian minister was becoming a social organiser more than a pastor of the local body of Christ.
Against this ‘backdrop’, the attitudes towards the poor of the more distant and ‘conservative’ Nonconformist leaders, were well illustrated from the pens of those who patronised them, those who preached to them and from those amongst the poor who discovered in the Nonconformist pulpit a means for calling their colleagues to self-realisation. It was significant that Andrew Mearns, William Booth and Charles Booth were all Nonconformists, but Dissenters were also prone to facing accusations of espousing philanthropy divorced from a sense of social justice, and even of outright hypocrisy in their attitudes towards the poor. Sometimes large congregations gathered together in great solid temples of middle-class respectability, possessed neither the common life of the meeting-house nor the urgent need to rescue the lost. Instead, they seemed to perpetuate themselves by some self-justifying principle. Church-building programmes increased in every decade of the century, and many full churches, both in city centres and in the suburbs, were presided over by princes of the Victorian pulpit. They conveyed an impression of progress and advance was often conveyed. In fact, the churches were failing to keep pace with the expanding population.
A cartoon by George Cruikshank on Victorian middle-class morality.
By the end of the century, however, the factory system also demanded an emphasis on precision, scrupulous standards, the clock and the bell, and the avoidance of waste. For many of the leaders of nonconformity, especially the many employers among them, the greatest industrial sin was drunkenness, which challenged all the values of the new industrial capitalist system. A new morality was needed and this was provided by the fruits of the evangelical revival. All too easily, as Briggs and Sellers (1973) noted, the phrase ‘the Nonconformist conscience’,
… could lapse into an unlovely onslaughtfrom a determined, Puritanical middle-class sectarianism against the drink, gambling and thriftlessness of the classes below and above it to the ignoring of the deeper social problems which afflicted the nation.
That is not to say that Nonconformity’s sympathies rested upon calculation alone. The growing call for the preaching of a ‘social gospel’ was, at least, the ‘child’ of a more positive definition of individualism, standing as a proper, practical and involved corrective to the implicit pietism of the tradition of conscientious separation. Nonconformists also felt the tensions involved in the relationship between church and evangelism. Victorian nonconformity blended Puritan churchmanship and revival evangelism. The revivalist strand was reinforced by the experience of the 1859 Revival, and later by the visits of American revivalists such as Moody and Sankey, and Torrey and Alexander. In his address published in the Congregational Year Book in 1885, Dr Joseph Parker began by envisaging a speech by one of that suffering community of ignorance, misfortunate, misery and shame who had spent a year observing the Unions, Conferences, Assemblies and Convocations held among Nonconformist ‘leaders’:
“We have had a full year among, and we cannot very well make out what you are driving at. We do not know most of the long words you use … We do not know what you are, or what you want to be at. From what we can make out you seem to know that we poor devils are going straight down to a place you call hell. … We read the inky papers which you call your ‘resolutions’ but in them, there is no word for us that is likely to do us real good. They say nothing about our real misery; nothing about our long hours, our poor pay, our wretched lodgings.”
… our evangelism is in danger of devoting itself almost exclusively to what is known as ‘the masses’. I must protest against this contraction, on the ground that it is as unjust to Christianity, as it is blind to the evidence of facts. If the city missionary … is wanted anywhere, he is specially wanted where … conscience is lulled by charity which knows nothing of sacrifice, and where political economy is made the scapegoat for oppression and robbery. …
There is only one class worse than the class known as ‘outcast London’, and that class is composed of those who ‘have lived in pleasure on the earth and been wanton’. The cry is ‘bitterer’ in many tones at the West End than at the East; … the thousand social falsehoods that mimic the airs of Piety … these seem to be distresses without alleviation, and to constitute heathenism which Christ himself might view with despair.
The ‘Prince of Preachers’ and the Paupers:
Spurgeon’s sermons drew many thousands to his churches, first at New Park Street Chapel and then at the Metropolitan Tabernacle in London (shown below). When printed, the sermons were also sold in their millions to people in the streets, and have since been distributed in more than two hundred million copies worldwide, giving some indication as to the continuing appeal of his thoroughly Biblical expositions. At the heart of Spurgeon’s desire to preach was a strong desire to develop a pastoral ministry. He did not regard people simply as souls to be saved, but loved them and wanted the best for them. His concern for their welfare extended to those involved in Christian ministry in all its forms, not just to ordained pastors. His book, Lectures to my Students was produced for those training for full-time ministry, but Counsel for Christian Workers was published for other people involved in a variety of Christian work. It contains Spurgeon’s clear-sighted viewpoints, advice and wisdom on the practical issues facing such people in their ministry.
Spurgeon himself had been born into a very modest home at Kelvedon in Essex. As early as 1861, following the opening of the Metropolitan Tabernacle in London, the great Baptist preacher warned against the atmosphere of snobbery which he perceived was increasingly prevalent among his flock:
There is growing up even in our Dissenting churches, an evil which I greatly deplore, a despising of the poor. I frequently hear, in conversation, such remarks as this:
“It is of no use trying in such a place as this: you could never raise a self-supporting cause. There are none but poor living in this neighbourhood.”
… You know that in the city of London itself, there is now scarce a Dissenting place of worship. The reason for giving most of them up and moving them into the suburbs is that all the respectable people live out of town, and of course they are the people to look after. They will not stop in London. They will go out and take villas in the subsurbs where it may be maintained.
“No doubt,” it is said, “the poor ought to be looked after: butwe had better leave them to another order, an inferior order. The city missionaries will do for them; send them a few street preachers.”
In 1865, in a bid to increase the numbers giving ordained ministry to the poor in the developing towns and cities, Spurgeon inaugurated the Annual Conference of the Pastors’ College. The foundation stone for the College building was laid eight years later. During his lifetime he gave twenty-seven addresses as President at the Conference. Many hundreds of ministers and students would gather each year to hear the ‘Governor’ at his best. He also became directly involved in setting up institutions to combat pauperism. He founded Stockwell Orphanage for Boys in 1867, followed by a Girls’ Orphanage in 1879. In April 1891, he gave his address, The Greatest Fight in the World (taking as his text I Tim. vi: 12 – “Fight the Good Fight of Faith”). While preparing this, he wrote to friends at the Tabernacle, “My soul is on fire with a desire for a special blessing from the Lord…” Little did he know that this would be the last conference he would attend. His address was one of the most powerful he delivered and was rapturously received by the vast assembly. Following the Conference, the transcript was revised and promptly published, later translated into many languages, passing through several editions.
As if he knew that his influence would continue after he had departed, Spurgeon said:
“Those preachers whose voices were clear and mighty for truth during life continue to preach in their graves. Being dead they yet speak; and whether men put their ears to their tombs or not, they cannot but hear them…”
The most noted evangelist of the age, the great American preacher D. L. Moody (1837-99), was inspired by Spurgeon’s preaching. He first heard the Baptist pastor during a visit in 1867, but it was his own tour of Britain in 1873-75, sponsored and encouraged by Spurgeon, that launched his career as a renowned evangelist. It started unpromisingly but by the time he returned to America, he was a preacher of international fame. By then, he had already teamed up with Sankey, and Harry Moorehouse had taught him how to preach. When he left England it was to devote his life to conducting revivalist campaigns. Though never as polished a preacher as Spurgeon, the style and organisation of campaigns were to have an enduring influence on both sides of the Atlantic. In 1892, Moody spoke at Spurgeon’s Jubilee Services, following the great pastor’s death at the end of January in that year:
“Twenty-five years ago, after I was converted, I began to read of a young man preaching in London with great power, and a desire seized me to hear him.
“In 1867 I made my way across the sea. The first place I came to was the Metropolitan Tabernacle. I was told that I could not get in without a ticket, but I made up my mind to get in somehow and succeeded. As Pastor Spurgeon walked down to the platform, … my heart’s desire for years was at last accomplished.
“I have been at the Tabernacle many times since, and when I looked down at those Orphan boys, when I think of the six hundred servants of God who have gone out from the college, of the two thousand sermons from his pulpit that are in print, and of the multitude of books that have come from the Pastor’s pen I would fain enlarge on all these good works…
“I say, ‘Go on brother, and God bless you.’ You are never going to die. John Wesley lives more today than when he was on this earth… Bear in mind, friends, that our dear brother is to live forever. We may never meet again in the flesh, but by the blessing of God I will meet you up yonder.”
D. L. Moody at Spurgeon’s Jubilee Services.
Moody and Sankey conduct a mass rally in Brooklyn, New York. Ira D. Sankey, the hymn-writer and musician, is sitting at the harmonium on the right.
For the burial, Spurgeon’s body was returned to London from the south of France, where he had died. The greatest crowds ever seen in the Tabernacle were on 8 February 1892, when Spurgeon’s body lay ‘in state’. Over sixty thousand people passed before the coffin, and a similar crowd again the next day. On the 10th, the day of the funeral, the building was filled to overflowing. His body was interred at Norwood Cemetery the following day, with thousands lining the streets to pay their respects as the cortege passed by on its route, as pictured below (bottom right).
The Salvation Army and other Home Missions:
One organisation that attempted to keep in touch with the working classes was the Pleasant Sunday Afternoons (PSA) Movement, formed in the 1880s with the motto Brief, Bright and Brotherly. Its meetings were for men only and were held on Sunday afternoons so that men would not feel ashamed to come to the meeting in working clothes. The Sunday afternoon programme was part entertainment, part evangelistic and part political, with some of the early Christian Socialists as frequent guest speakers. The Salvation Army, too, came into being to serve the working classes through urban missions. Catherine Booth claimed We can’t get at the masses in the chapels, so in 1865 she set up a Christian Mission in a tent in Whitechapel, east London, with her husband, William Booth. He had already had a varied career, having preached for the Wesleyans, the Wesleyan Reformers and then the Methodist New Connexion, by whom he was ordained in 1858 after being disciplined in the previous year for his regular itinerant preaching. He stayed with the New Connexion for only three years before again becoming an irregular itinerant. The Salvation Army soon became known for its uniforms and music. The Salvation Army band shown below was from Penzance in Cornwall, photographed in the 1880s. General Booth can be seen in the back row, with his trademark top hat and a long beard.
The Whitechapel Mission grew into the Salvation Army, to the irritation of many churchmen. Even the evangelical reformer, Lord Shaftesbury, in extreme old age, concluded that the Salvation Army was a trick of the devil, who was trying to make Christianity look ridiculous. It also met with violent opposition from a ‘Skeleton Army’ which parodied Booth’s activities and was supported by brewers who were opposed to the Army’s teetotalism as a threat to their trade. Contrary to the popular image of the early Salvationists, they were more concerned about moral and spiritual matters than social conditions among the working classes. In fact, Booth spoke out against attempts to deal with the latter, arguing that they were simply due to a lack of bricks and mortar. The first thing to be done to improve the conditions of the wretched was to get at their hearts. The Salvation Army did not see itself as being engaged in a war against poverty and oppressive political philosophies. Moreover, Booth himself was authoritarian in his attempt to achieve results. He gained control of the Mission in 1877 by what was virtually a military coup. After that, the military emphasis was developed, with uniforms, corps and citadels, and the magazine, The War Cry. But this did not worry the ordinary Salvationist, for, as Booth remarked, the Salvation Army made every soldier in some degree an officer, charged with the responsibility of so many of his townsfolk. It offered them not only a force with which they could identify but also a task to which they were committed. The Salvation Army officers filed regular reports on ‘slum work’ in their towns and districts:
Mrs W. – of Haggerston slum. Heavy drinker, wrecked home, husband a drunkard, place … filthy, terribly poor. Saved now over two years. Home A1, plenty of employment at cane-chair bottoming; husband now saved also.
A. M. in the Dials. Was a great drunkard, did not go to the trouble of seeking work. Was in a slum meeting, heard the Captain speak on ‘Seek ye first the Kingdom of God!’ Called out and said “Do you mean that if I ask God for work, he will give it to me?” Of course she said “yes.” He was converted that night, found work and is now employed in the gas works, Old Kent Road.
Jimmy is a soldier in the Borough slum. Was starving when he got converted through being out of work. Through joining the Army he was turned out of his home. He found work, and now owns a coffee-stall in Billingsgate Market, and is doing well.
A Salvation Army ‘farthing breakfast’. The officers are at the back of the room.
The Army was perhaps the only Christian movement to reach the masses on their own terms in Victorian and Edwardian Britain. They understood the need to use modern means of mass communication and, in particular, the techniques of religious advertisement. To begin with, the Salvation Army continued in the tradition of revivalist evangelism, adding its own military dimension, which fed the appetites of an increasingly imperialist and jingoistic nation. But Booth’s friendships with Congregationalist theologian J. B. Paton, and W. T. Stead, editor of the Pall Mall Gazette, led him to engage with a wider range of social concerns and problems. When he published In Darkest England and the Way Out in 1890, The Methodist Times exclaimed, Here is General Booth turning Socialist. The book, widely believed to be mainly the work of Stead, was designed to show that the submerged tenth of the British people was as much in slavery as certain African tribes. This produced a rift in the ranks of the Army. On the one hand, Frank Smith wrote a column for The War Cry under the unfamiliar heading ‘sociology’, pressing for further social action. On the other hand, more conservative officers feared that the social scheme was a turning aside from the highest to secondary things.
A collage from the front cover of the 1973 book by John Briggs & Ian Sellers, Victorian Nonconformity, designed to illustrate different facets of the movement, part of the Pugh Collection of Staffordshire figures.
The Booths had found themselves unable to reach the masses from a position within mainstream Methodism. In the nineteenth century the Wesleyan Methodists, led by Jabez Bunting, became a staid, respectable denomination. It imposed upon itself in the nineteenth century a ‘no politics’ rule, and until the late 1880s, it was suspicious of open political discussion. But Methodism had within itself its own nonconformity where this restraint was missing. For example, the Staffordshire Primitive Methodists produced several Chartist leaders. Involvement in chapel affairs made them into natural community leaders. They learnt organisation based on local church government and public speaking skills based on preaching and participation in church meetings and congregational worship. The local lay-preacher, like Joseph Arch in Barford, Warwickshire, could step readily from the pulpit to the strike platform. As a result, the Primitive Methodists developed a close connection with the growth of the mass Trade Union movement, both in urban and agricultural areas. John Wilson, the leader of the Durham miners, described his conversion at the age of thirty-one at a Primitive Methodist Class Meeting:
I took my seat, and when the class leader came to where I was sitting and me to tell him how I was getting on (meaning in a spiritual sense), I was speechless. The others, in response to his query, had replied readily but my eloquence was in my tears which I am not ashamed to say flowed freely … All was joy, and not not the least joyous was myself, even while the tears were chasing down my cheeks. This change made, I began seriously to consider how I could be useful in life.
This conversion experience led to a search for education, enrolment as a local preacher, an office within the Miners’ Union, and election to Parliament in 1885, as one of the earliest Labour MPs. Many other ‘Lib-Lab’ and independent Labour leaders, especially in the northeast of England and South Wales, had similar stories to tell.
A Sunderland slum, circa 1889. Squalor was all too often the fate of the industrial working class in Victorian times. In the later decades of the nineteenth century, local by-laws were used to regulate new housing, but clearing slums like the one shown here took longer.
In November 1886, the Revd. Samuel Francis Collier was placed in charge of the new Methodist Central Hall, Manchester, built at the then prodigious cost of forty thousand pounds. Magnificent though the Hall was, the dynamic evangelist, with a social as well as a spiritual conscience, soon launched a programme of practical help for the poor, using the motto ‘Need not creed’ in his daring new ministry. Nobody in need was to be refused help, regardless of belief. In 1891, an old rag factory was established at Ancoats, salvaging the waste of the city, old bottles, jars, empty tins, cotton waste, pails and clothing all being sorted for re-use and sale, destitute men being given a good bed and three square meals a day for their labour. From that venture in social rehabilitation grew the most complete set of social service premises possessed by any church in Britain. By the early 1900s, a Men’s Home, Labour Yard, Women’s Refuge, a Maternity Hospital for unmarried mothers and a Labour Advice Bureau had all been developed together with educational clubs, prison visiting services and holiday funds. The picture below shows the boys in the Labour Yard of the Manchester and Salford Wesleyan Missions. Outcasts of industrial society, they were welcomed by Collier and provided with clothes, food, shelter and hope in exchange for ‘honest toil’.
Church v Chapel – Establishment Schools & Progress for the Poor:
In the early decades of the century, the Home Office had feared leaving education in industrial areas to Methodists, a set of men not only ignorant but of whom I think we have of late too much reason to imagine are inimical to our happy constitution. The 1820s saw the end of the easy eighteenth-century co-existence between church and chapel. The revival of hostility led to a fierce campaign for the repeal of the Test and Corporation Acts, which was successful in 1828. Even after repeal, however, many irritants remained for nonconformists: first, the need for them to secure validity for marriages and funeral rites, then the campaign to repeal church rates, which were finally abolished in 1868. The ancient universities were bastions of Anglican power, and a campaign to open them to nonconformists achieved most of its aims by 1871. Early Victorian nonconformist movements tended to concentrate on the negative campaign of disestablishment. But the free church movement of the 1890s was more missionary-minded. It also reflected certain solid achievements concerning unity among the free churches. In 1856 a number of Methodist groups came together to form the United Methodist Free Church; Presbyterian union was achieved in 1876 and in 1891 the New Connexion of General Baptists was finally united with the Particular Baptists. But at the end of the century, the rift between church and chapel in English and Welsh societies still ran very deep. It was not simply the chapels of the industrial revolution confronting the churches of the rural squirearchy; urban Anglicanism and rural Dissent were equally part of the conflict, and in no area of life more so than the schools.
Newlyn School, Cornwall, 1889: Even isolated fishing communities, such as Newlyn, saw growth in educational provision, for girls as well as boys.
The chief providers of elementary education for most of the nineteenth century had been the voluntary bodies, especially the churches, from the 1830s receiving Treasury grants. Some among the middle classes supported universal education for philanthropic reasons, to prevent crime and immorality, or as insurance against social unrest. Some Anglicans were alarmed at the growth of Catholicism and Nonconformity and saw an Anglican education system as a defence against this. There was opposition, however, from those, especially farmers, who feared that educating the working classes would lead to higher taxes and labour costs, if not the spread of radical political ideas. National differences in education and literacy were marked. Levels of literacy were comparatively low in many parts of rural Britain, where school attendance was also low, but especially high in Scotland and Ireland, where favourable attitudes to an educated population were supported by a network of parochial schools. They were also higher among girls than boys in some areas where they were educated at voluntary schools, for example in East Anglia. In 1844, William Locke reported on the English ‘Ragged Schools’:
In many cases, because the children are so destitute that they cannot be taught, we give food – generally soup, occassionally meat, and good wholsome bread, sometimes coffee or cocoa, and bread and cheese. In one school they feed about two hundred twice or thrice a week … The children who come to the schools pay nothing; all the Ragged Schools are quite free, being intended only for the destitute.
Kindness, Christian love to the children and teaching them their duty to their duty to their neighbours and to their God, and making the Bible the theme of all our instruction …
Some of the most compelling photographs of poverty to survive were taken for religious and charitable organisations concerned with saving and helping children. The photograph above is of a ‘Ragged School’ showing not only ragged clothes but thin rickety legs, bare feet and the hollow-eyed accusative stare of children robbed of childhood. Pictures from the Church of England’s Children’s Society, the Methodist Mission and the Salvation Army confirm that the appearance of the children matches the descriptions left us by various contemporary social commentators.
Thirteen years before the first Education Act, when countless children toiled ten or twelve hours a day in a mill or a colliery, Jeremiah James Colman opened Carrow School for the children of his employees at his Stoke and Carrow mustard works in Norwich. He was the grandnephew of the founder of the company, a strong Nonconformist, philanthropist and Member of Parliament. The weekly payment for attendance at the school was a penny for one child, three halfpence for two and twopence for a third from the same family. The first school was over a carpenter’s shop and crammed in fifty-three pupils. In an opening statement, Colman announced:
… the school helps you to educate your children and to train up a set of men who will go into the world qualified for any duties they may be called upon to discharge.
With a workforce of three and a half thousand, Colman’s was, in effect, the local community and it was likely that their duties would be discharged in manufacturing mustard. The school began each morning with a hymn, a prayer and a Bible reading, but while a Colman education included diligent and careful teaching of the scriptures, it also included art and craft subjects in addition to ‘the three r’s’. Not only was Colman far-sighted in his attitude to education, but he was also a firm believer in women being given every opportunity for learning, and from the outset drawing and needlework were included in the subjects taught. Caroline Colman, Jeremiah’s wife, was the force in the direction and development of the school. The Colmans were also committed to technical education, and in 1899 they claimed to be the first to introduce cookery, gardening, laundry work, beekeeping and ironwork into the curriculum. As the school grew, it moved and improved, adding a wide range of technical subjects, but never neglected art and culture.
At the time the photograph above was taken in the early 1900s, Caroline Colman was intensely concerned with the physical wellbeing of her pupils, urging mothers to ensure that their daughters wore warm dresses ‘as a caution against measles and other childish ailments’. Although the children have been carefully groomed and prepared for the class photograph, their general condition of wellbeing contrasts sharply with the ‘ragged’ appearance and thin faces of the children in the London photographs. The reminiscences of former pupils were warm and grateful, happy and nostalgic if at times a little pious.
But ‘Church’ meant not only cathedrals, bishops, parishes and the Book of Common Prayer. It also meant continuing control over elementary education, the only form to which working-class nonconformists had access, deference to ‘the Establishment’ in both church and state. ‘Chapel’ stood for two forms of Dissent: the older, more loosely organised, congregational variety, and the newer, more centrally organised evangelical denominationalism of the Wesleyan Methodists and Baptists. Chapel religion had made so much progress that nonconformists were determined to secure equal rights with Anglicans. The campaign for outright disestablishment of the Church of England ceased to concern late Victorian nonconformists, except in Wales, where it was brought about in 1920 (in Ireland in 1869). But the fight for control over primary and elementary schools continued until the outbreak of the First World War in 1914. This battle did little credit to either side but deprived two generations of English children of education. All the labours of the Sunday schools hardly compensated for that. In Wales, the Nonconformist churches, and in Ireland, Catholics opposed state funding of education, fearing Anglican propaganda. The Welsh Calvinistic Methodists and Independents also feared that the established Church sought to extinguish the Welsh language through the provision of monolingual English schooling. This strategy would undermine the Sunday schools provided by the Nonconformist chapels, in which Welsh was the medium of instruction.
The Churches and the Co-operatives – the views of Beatrice Webb:
With its satellite towns of Stockport, Salford and Oldham, Manchester was the most impressive example of urban expansion up to the mid-century, and its dependence on factory industry and persistent identification with the ‘gospel’ of the market economy. This also extended among the mill towns of Lancashire and Yorkshire, like Radcliffe (shown above).
Beatrice Potter (later Webb) in 1875.
Beatrice Webb, née Potter, (1858-1943) was born into a Lancashire family who became integrated into the traditional administrative and professional class, and Beatrice found herself related to a good proportion of the academics, senior civil servants and leading lawyers of the capital. On the other hand, she still kept in contact with her Lancashire forebears who had not made the transition. Stimulated by the great Charles Booth, she embarked in 1884 on her own programme of social research into Co-operation and Nonconformity in Bacup, a town in the South Pennines of Lancashire, close to the border with Yorkshire. In a letter to her father, She wrote of her enquiries into the operations of the co-operative societies in the town, entirely owned and managed by working men:
I have spent the day in the chapels and schools. After dinner, a dissenting minister dropped in and I had a long talk with him: he is coming for a cigarette this evening after chapel. He told me that in all the chapels there was a growing desire among the congregation to have political and social subjects treated in the pulpit and that it was very difficult for a minister, now, to please. He also remarked that in the districts where co-operation amongst the workmen (in industrial enterprise) existed, they were a much more independent and free-thinking set.
There is an immense amount of co-operation in the whole of this district; the stores seem to succeed well, both as regards supplying the people with cheap articles and as savings banks paying good interest. Of course, I am just in the centre of the dissenting organisation; and as our host is the chapel keeper and entertains all the ministers who come here, I hear all about the internal management … each chapel is a self-governing community, regulating not only chapel matters but overlooking the private life of its members.
The Rochdale Pioneers founded the first modern cooperative in Rochdale in 1844, with their first shop in Toad Lane. The Pioneers established the principles of consumer cooperation.
Forty years after the Rochdale Pioneers founded the first co-operative society, the young social researcher, not yet a socialist, was clear about the ties which existed between the Nonconformist chapels in Bacup and the local co-operatives. Beatrice wrote in her now well-known diary:
One cannot help feeling what an excellent thing these dissenting organisations have been for educating this class for self-government. I can’t help thinking, too, that one of the best preventives against the socialistic tendency of the coming democracy would lie in local government; which would force the respectable working man to consider political questions as they come up in local administration.
… they are keen enough on any local question which comes within their own experiences and would bring plenty of shrewd sound sense to bear on the actual management of things…
There is an immense amount of spare energy in this class, now that it is educated, which is by no means used up in their mechanical occupation. … It can be employed either in the practical solution of social and economic questions or in the purely intellectual exercise of political discussion about problems considered in the abstract. …
In living amongst mill-hands of East Lancashire … I was impressed with the depth and realism of their religious faith. … Even the social intercourse was based on religious sympathy and common religious sympathy and common religious effort. ..
From Individualism to Collectivism – Clifford and Christian Socialism:
As the Victorian period progressed, there emerged a proliferation of philanthropic activity. Alongside the itinerant societies and the great urban Sunday schools, there developed a nondenominational Christian press and a great battery of Bible, tract and missionary societies. These organisations formed a pattern of Christian progress all the way from ‘Basle to New York’, all seeking to capitalise on the evangelistic opportunities which seemed to be afforded by the turmoil in western societies. This movement, much like the societies which created it out of the social tensions of the first half of the nineteenth century, had seemed to be getting out of control by the middle decades of the century. In consequence, the ‘undenominational evangelism’ of the Evangelical Revival was gradually replaced by the assertion of ‘denominationalism’ by the end of these decades. The earlier decades of philanthropic activity had been based on perilously fragile ‘social theology’. Some Christians argued that the campaign for social righteousness was essential to a proper gospel ministry, whilst others still saw social action as little more than a device for securing a working-class audience for the gospel. In the earlier part of the century, the activities of those calling themselves ‘Christian Socialists’ did not add up to very much. The novelist Charles Kingsley had set out their possibilities in Alton Locke (1850). But the Christian Socialist co-operative workshops were poorly organised, unduly idealistic about the contribution of labour, and only lasted a short while. However, Christian Socialists did good work in securing a better legal framework within which workers’ organisations, including trade unions, could develop, and in fostering workers’ education.
Within the Nonconformist tradition, however, the individualistic emphasis upon personal conversion had always had to be held in tension with a corporate understanding of the church and its role in society: as the normative social philosophy of Victorian Britain changed from individualism to collectivism, this correspondingly this second emphasis, which for much of the century was neglected, came into new prominence. Social Science may well have been a middle-class preoccupation of the mid-century, but when linked with the Kingdom of God theology of the Christian Socialists it provided an important link between the Christian Chartism and ‘Political Dissent’ of the 1830s and ’40s with the ‘Nonconformist Conscience’ or ‘Social Gospel’ of the ’80s and ’90s. The Baptist pastor, John Clifford, was actively involved in campaigning against the ‘living in’ system, as the photograph below shows. Dressed like dukes, treated like slaves, as the slogan went, since shop assistants were expected to dress like aristocrats and to spend their lives in total subjection to their employers. Almost half a million were of them were compelled to ‘live in’ their employers’ premises in conditions that were appalling and institutional. The shopowners created a tyranny as harsh as the yearly bond system of the mine owners or the feudal power of the squirearchy. Stores were open from morning to night for six days a week and working hours of eighty to ninety hours per week were common.
The ‘living in’ system bound the shopworker to the shopowner as tightly as the tied cottage bound the labourer to the farm owner. Much of the accommodation was barrack-like with beds alive with fleas and walls crawling with bugs. Baths were rarely provided and hot water was almost as scarce. The rules of one Knightsbridge store forbade lights after 11 p.m., breaching of which resulted in instant dismissal. Sleeping out required permission and failure to comply with this also resulted in dismissal on the second offence. Assistants were also forbidden to marry without permission and communal living denied them the vote. On their one free day, they were expected to attend church, not chapel. The photograph, taken in May 1901, shows thirteen shop assistants advertising a meeting against the system, with Dr Clifford as the chief speaker. The sandwich boards were hired from the Church Army; third in line is P. C. Hoffman, a pioneer of the Shop Assistants’ Union and a trade union official for forty years. In his Fabian Tract of 1897, Socialism and the Teachings of Christ, Clifford encapsulated the transition from individualist to collectivist thinking among many Nonconformists and Church organisations:
Collectivism, although it does not change human nature, yet takes away the occasion for many of the evils which now afflict society. It reduces the temptations of life in number and in strength. It means work for everyone and the elimination of the idle, and if the work should not be so exacting, responsible, and therefore not so educative for a few individuals, yet it will go far to answer Browning’s prayer:
“O God, make no more giants,
Elevate the race.”
… Individualism adds to the number of the indolent year by year; collectivism sets everybody alike to his share of work, and gives to him his share of the reward. … Collectivism affords a better environment for the teachings of Jesus concerning wealth and the ideals of labour and brotherhood. If a man is … only ‘the expression of his environment’ … then it is an unspeakable gain to bring that environment into line with the teaching of Jesus Christ.
In the Gospels, accumulated wealth appears as a grave peril to the spiritual life, a menace to the spiritual life, a menace to the purest aims and noblest ideals. Christ is entirely undazzled by its fascinations and sees in it a threat against the integrity and progress of his kingdom. ‘Lay not up for yourselves treasures on earth’. …
Now, though Collectivism does not profess to extinguish vice and manufacture saints, it will abolish poverty, reduce the hungry to an imperceptible quantity, and systematically care for the aged poor and for the sick. It will carry forward much of the charitable work left to individual initiative … is not all that in harmony with the spirit and teaching of Him who bids us see Himself in the hungry and sick, the poor and the criminal?
… Collectivismfosters a more Christian conception of industry; one in which every man is a worker, and each worker does not toil for himself exclusively, but for the necessities, comforts and privileges he shares equally with all members of the community. … It is a new ideal of life and labour that is most urgently needed. England’s present ideal is a creation of hard individualism; and therefore is partial, hollow, unreal and disastrous. …
Individualism fosters the caste feelings and caste divisions of society, creates the serfdom of one class and the indolence of another; makes a large body of submissive, silent, unmanly slaves undergoing grinding toil and continuous anxiety, and a smaller company suffering from debasing indolence and continual weariness. … No! the ideal we need and must have is in the unity of English life, in the recognition that man is complete in the State, at once a member of society and of the Government…
Dr John Clifford (1836-1923) was a prominent Baptist minister and President of the Christian Socialist League. This was the successor organisation to the Christian Socialist Society which took over the management of the Christian Socialist magazine from the Chartist Land Reform Union. Clifford was also an early member of the Fabian Society. As a liberal evangelical minister in Paddington from 1858, Clifford set this new ideal of life and labour against what he called the hard individualism of late Victorian society. It was this individualism that he saw as partial, hollow, unreal and disastrous, fostering the serfdom of one class and the indolence of another. It had created, on the one hand, a large class of submissive, silent… slaves undergoing grinding toil and continuous anxiety, and on the other a smaller class suffering debasing indolence. It spawned hatred and ill-will on the one hand and scorn and contempt on the other. This was at odds with the common ideal in both the soul of Collectivism and the revelation of the brotherhood of man in Christ Jesus.
The ideas of F. D. Maurice, a principal Christian Socialist thinker, were also to have a tremendous impact on Anglican thought about the secular world in the following century and to bring the movement to its climax in the work of William Temple, Archbishop of Canterbury (1942-44). This was partly due to the work of the Christian Social Union, founded in 1889 with Brooke Fosse Weston, the Cambridge New Testament scholar and later Bishop of Durham, as its first president. Evidence for the early role of Christian Socialists in the move towards independent politics can be found in that, as early as March 1895, a ‘Christian Socialist’ candidate fighting alone against the Liberal candidate for East Bristol lost the parliamentary election by only 183 votes in a total poll of over seven thousand. The Welsh Religious Revival of 1904-5 also helped promote the rise of working-class collectivist politics, first in the Liberal Party, but then in the development of a separate Labour Party.
Joseph Chamberlain, Birmingham Nonconformity & Social Reform:
In the Industrial Revolution, Birmingham had played a major role in the technological breakthroughs of the early part of the century with the improved form of the steam engine produced at the Boulton and Watt factory in the city. Birmingham had become known as the ‘city of many trades’ and maintained its position as a centre for smaller manufacturers alongside the expanding larger-scale factory industry. Indeed, its diverse industrial base made it a serious rival to Manchester as Britain’s second city in the second half of the nineteenth century. From the Nonconformist point of view, R. W. Dale (1829-95) delivered a Lecture to the New Electors, addressing the citizens of Birmingham who had acquired the vote as a result of the 1867 Reform Act. This had enfranchised the majority of working-class men, but not the ‘slum-dwellers’ whom Dale saw as a threat to social order in the urban areas:
Youhave a great practical concern in whatever measures are likely to make the criminal classes disappear, and I trust that such measures will have your hearty support. … There is another class from which we have almost as much to fear … one million persons receiving relief.
… And in this million you have first the permanent paupers, and then a vast mass of people who are on the parish on and off again every few months, but who when they go off are sure to leave successors … We have hereditarypaupers, as well as hereditary criminals, and I maintain that this is intolerable.
… You will feel very distinctly the sharp pressure that comes upon the community for the support of the ‘armies of the homeless and unfed’, and will be the more eager to discover how the pauperism of the country can be effectively diminished.
In Birmingham, as Dale knew well, the city’s municipal administration was notably lax with regards to public works, and many urban dwellers lived in conditions of great poverty. As a Congregational minister, Dale chastised his fellow nonconformists over their lack of action:
We are living in a new world and evangelicals do not seem to have discovered it. The immense development of the manufacturing industries, the wider separation of classes in great towns … the new relations that have grown up between the employers and the employed, the spread of popular education, the growth of a vast popular literature, the increased political power of the masses of the people, the gradual decay of the old aristocratic organisation of society, and the advance in many forms of the spirit of democracy, have urgently demanded fresh applications of the eternal ideas of the Christian faith to conduct.
The Unitarian Joseph Chamberlain made his career in Birmingham, first as a manufacturer of screws and then as a notable mayor of the city. He became involved in Liberal politics, influenced by the strong radical and liberal traditions among Birmingham shoemakers and the long tradition of social action in Chamberlain’s Unitarian church. Chamberlain was a radical Liberal Party member and a fierce opponent of subsidising Church of England and Roman Catholic schools with local ratepayers’ money. As a self-made businessman, he had never attended university and had contempt for the aristocratic leadership of the Tory Party, both locally and nationally. In November 1873, the Liberal Party swept the municipal elections and Chamberlain was elected Mayor of Birmingham. The Conservatives had denounced his Radicalism and called him a “monopoliser and a dictator” whilst the Liberals had campaigned against their High Church Tory opponents with the slogan “The People above the Priests”. As Mayor, Chamberlain promoted many civic improvements, promising the city would be “parked, paved, assized, marketed, gas & watered and ‘improved'”. In February 1874, he wrote to Henry Allen, Editor of the Nonconformist Review, reflecting on the election results and the need for a campaign to further a closer union between nonconformists as such and the working classes.
The only chance of the Government lay in a declaration of policy calculated to arouse the hearty enthusiasm of the non-conformists and the working classes. Instead of this Gladstone issued the meanest manifesto that ever proceeded from a great Minister. … At the same time, the returns show that the present political position of the Dissenters is not satisfactory. They are very hazy as to the principles of the Education question, and have, in many cases, been carried over to the enemy by the ‘Bible’ cry.
In the latter assertion, it can be assumed that Chamberlain is referring to the provision of the 1870 act in respect of Religious Education, which placed Biblical knowledge at the centre of the curriculum, alongside numeracy and literacy. By ‘the enemy’, Chamberlain was referring to ‘the Anglican Establishment’, as he went on to explain:
Worse still, they have ceased to combine cordially with the working classes, without whose active assistance further advances in the direction of Religious Equality are impossible. But both in the case of the agricultural labourers, and in reference to the demands of the Trades Unions for the repeal of what I do not hesitate to stigmatize as class legislation of the worst kind, the Dissenters have largely held aloof, and their organs in the Press … have been unsympathetic and even hostile.
In his references to the agricultural workers and the trades unions, Chamberlain was no doubt referring to the National Agricultural Labourers’ Union, which grew out of the local union founded in Warwickshire in the early 1870s, referred to above. Led by the Wesleyan lay-preacher Joseph Arch and supported by thousands of Nonconformist workers, many Baptists and Methodists among them, it had fought wage cuts and evictions imposed by local squires simply for their tenants joining the union. Their children had been excluded from parish schools in some areas. Arch later supported Chamberlain’s ‘Liberal Imperialism’ as a means of aiding and ‘protecting’ Britain’s home industries against the ravages of ‘free trade’ in the 1880s and 90s. He organised emigration schemes for impoverished agricultural workers and their families to the ‘Dominions’, especially New Zealand. The failure of some nonconformist church leaders to support their poorer members led Chamberlain to argue that:
Unless this is altered in the future such questions as Disestablishment and Disendowment will be indefinitely postponed, as the Artisan voter can see little difference between Caesar and Pompey, and looking like the whole affair is a mere squabble between Church and Chapel, will take no interest in the matter.
Chamberlain pointed out that the only districts in which Liberalism had come out of the recent elections were the Midland Counties, where they gained one seat and the Northern Counties, where the balance was still in favour of the Liberals. There, he wrote, the local parties appealed directly to the mass of the working-class population, with the Dissenters aiding very largely with their purses and influence, and cordially recognising the justice of the labourers’ claims. Chamberlain contrasted the enduring support of the local Liberal Press in Birmingham and Newcastle, in particular, with …
… this narrowness on the part of many of the rank and file of Dissent, will be fatal to the success of our special aims unless we can induce and make a more generous recognition of the claims of the masses.
Together with the west Midland industrial towns, which also became strongholds of radical religious Dissent, Birmingham was becoming overtly political with the rise to municipal power of Chamberlain’s Liberal reformers. They set about their reforming projects and programmes with a zeal reminiscent of the evangelical campaigns of the earlier part of the century. The city rapidly gained a reputation for municipal enterprise for its public works, including one of the country’s most extensive urban tramway systems (see the map above). Cheap and efficient public transport systems, based on horse-drawn omnibuses and trams, proved to be an effective way of dispersing the industrial working class from overcrowded and disease-ridden city-centre slums. The now radicalised diarist, Beatrice Webb, commented on her conversations with him on these social themes in her diary, in entries made during their four-year relationship which had begun in 1882 when he had become a minister in Gladstone’s second government:
The same quality of one-idea-ness is present in the Birmingham Radical set, earnestness and simplicity of motive being strikingly present. Political conviction takes the place here of religious faith. … Heine said some fifty years ago, “Talk to an Englishman on religion and he is fanatic; talk to him on politics and he is a man of the world.”
It would seem to me from my slight experience of Bacup and Birmingham, that that part of the Englishman’s nature which has found gratification in religion is now drifting into political life. When I suggested this to Mr Chamberlain he answered. “I quite agree with you, and I rejoice in it. I have always had a grudge against religion for absorbing the passion in man’s nature.”
It is only natural then that, this being his view, he should find in the uncomprising belief of his own set a more sympathetic atmosphere wherein to recruit his forces to battle with powers of evil, than in the somewhat cynical… political opinions of London Society.
(MS diary, 16 March 1884).
In March 1886, Chamberlain launched a ferocious campaign against Gladstone’s Irish proposals. His motivations combined imperial, domestic, and personal themes. Imperial, because they threatened to weaken Parliament’s control over the United kingdom. Chamberlain’s immediate chances of attaining the leadership of the Liberal Party had declined dramatically and in early May, the National Liberal Federation declared its loyalty to Gladstone. On 9 April, Chamberlain spoke against the Irish Home Rule Bill in its first reading before attending a meeting of Liberal Unionists on 14 May. From this meeting arose the Liberal Unionist Association, originally an ad hoc alliance to demonstrate the unity of anti-Home Rulers. During the second reading on 8 June, the Home Rule Bill was defeated by thirty votes, by the combined opposition of Conservatives, Chamberlainite radicals and Whigs. In all ninety-three Liberals, including Chamberlain, voted against Gladstone. Parliament was dissolved, and in the ensuing 1886 general election, the Conservatives and Liberal Unionists agreed to an alliance. With the general election dominated by Home Rule, Chamberlain’s campaign was both Radical and intensely patriotic. The Conservatives and Liberal Unionists took 393 seats in the House of Commons and a comfortable majority. Chamberlain did not enter the Unionist government, aware that the hostility to him in the Conservative ranks meant that an agreement with them could extend merely to Ireland and not wishing to alienate his Radical support base. The Liberal mainstream cast Chamberlain as a villain, shouting “Judas!” and “Traitor!” as he entered the House of Commons chamber.
The Liberal Association in Birmingham could no longer be relied upon to provide loyal support, so Chamberlain created the Liberal Unionist Association in 1888, associated with the National Radical Union, having extracted his supporters from the old Liberal organisation. In the 1892 general election, the Liberal Unionists did well in Birmingham and made gains in neighbouring towns in the Black Country. By now, Chamberlain’s son, Austen, had also entered the House of Commons unopposed for East Worcestershire. However, the national returns showed the limits of the Liberal Unionist Party’s strategy. In an age of increasingly well-organised, mass politics it was reduced to only forty-seven seats. Chamberlain’s standing was accordingly weakened. Gladstone returned to power and did not want Chamberlain back. The Liberal Unionists realized that they needed a closer relationship with the Conservatives. Chamberlain worried about the threat of socialism, even though the new Independent Labour Party (formed in 1893) had only one MP, elected in 1892 for West Ham. Keir Hardie (photo below), was himself a dissenter, a former miner and a preacher in the Evangelical Union Church in Hamilton, Scotland, the same church that nurtured the young David Livingstone. Chamberlain warned of the dangers of socialism in his unpublished 1895 play The Game of Politics, characterising its proponents as the instigators of class conflict. The Liberal Unionists were concerned that in the near future the ILP would take away the new working-class voters they depended on. In response to the socialist challenge, he sought to divert the energy of collectivism for the good of Unionism and continued to propose reforms to the Conservatives. In his ‘Memorandum of a Programme for Social Reform’ sent to Salisbury in 1893, Chamberlain made a number of suggestions, including old-age pensions, the provision of loans to the working class for the purchase of houses, an amendment to the Artisans’ Dwellings Act to encourage street improvements, compensation for industrial accidents, cheaper train fares for workers, tighter border controls and shorter working hours.
Having agreed to this set of policies, the Conservatives and Liberal Unionists formed a government on 24 June 1895. Salisbury offered four Cabinet posts to Liberal Unionists. Chamberlain had adjusted his political strategy after losing a dispute over a seat at Leamington Spa, agreeing to enter the cabinet in a subordinate role and putting his programme of social reform on the back burner. Unexpectedly, he used the Colonial Office to become one of the dominant figures in politics. Chamberlain had once been an outspoken anti-imperialist but by now he had reversed course. In 1887 he declared that “I should think our patriotism was warped and stunted indeed if it did not embrace the Greater Britain beyond the seas”. Much had been proposed with regard to an imperial federation, a more coherent system of imperial defence and preferential tariffs, yet by 1895 when Chamberlain arrived at the Colonial Office, little had been achieved. Chamberlain had not abandoned his dedication to social reforms designed to help the working man. He was instrumental in adapting Bismarck’s German model to set up a system of compensation for injuries on the job. His Workmen’s Compensation Act 1897 was a key domestic achievement of the Unionists at the end of the century. It cost the Treasury nothing since compensation was paid for by insurance that employers were required to take out, a system that operated from 1897 to 1946. Chamberlain also tried to design an old-age pension programme, but it was too expensive to meet with Conservative approval. He came to realize that a new source of revenue, such as tariffs on imports, would be required. Further opposition came from friendly societies, which were funded by their own pension program for their members.
Tariff Reform League poster
The end of the Boer War allowed Salisbury, in declining health, to finally retire. The Prime Minister was keen that Balfour, his nephew should succeed him, but he also realised that Chamberlain’s followers felt that the Colonial Secretary had a legitimate claim to the premiership. Chamberlain was the most popular figure in the government, but despite this and his organisational skills, many Conservatives still mistrusted his Radicalism, and Chamberlain was aware of the difficulties that would be presented by being part of a Liberal Unionist minority leading a Conservative majority. Both Balfour and Chamberlain were aware that the Unionist government’s survival depended on their cooperation. Balfour’s 1902 Education Bill was intended to promote National Efficiency, a cause which Chamberlain thought worthy. However, the Education Bill abolished the 2,568 school boards established under W. E. Forster’s 1870 Act, bodies that were popular with Nonconformists and Radicals, replacing them with local education authorities that would administer a state-centred system of primary, secondary and technical schools.
The Bill would also give ratepayer’s money to voluntary, Church of England and Roman Catholic schools. Chamberlain was aware that Bill’s proposals would estrange Nonconformists, Radicals and many Liberal Unionists from the government, but could not oppose it as he owed his position as Colonial Secretary to Conservative support. In response to Chamberlain’s warning about a feared exodus of Nonconformist voters and his suggestion that voluntary schools receive funds from central rather than local government, he secured a major concession – local authorities would be given the discretion over the issue of rate aid to voluntary schools. Yet even this was renounced before the guillotining of the Bill and its passage through Parliament in December 1902. Thus, Chamberlain had to make the best of a hopeless situation, writing fatalistically that ‘I consider the Unionist cause is hopeless at the next election, and we shall certainly lose the majority of the Liberal Unionists once and for all.’ Chamberlain already regarded tariff reform as an issue that could revitalise support for Unionism. The National Union of Conservative and Unionist Associations also declared majority support for tariff reform, which meant an end to free trade. With firm support from provincial Unionism and most of the press, Chamberlain addressed vast crowds and extolled the virtues of Empire and Imperial Preference, campaigning with the slogan “Tariff Reform Means Work for All.” Chamberlain explained at Greenock how Free Trade threatened British industry, declaring that…
… “sugar is gone; silk has gone; iron is threatened; wool is threatened; cotton will go! How long are you going to stand it? At the present moment these industries…are like sheep in a field.”
Intending to enlist the support of the working class, Chamberlain assured his audience that tariff reform ensured low unemployment. When the Liberal-supporting Daily News used official import prices to demonstrate that a loaf of bread under tariff reform would be smaller than a free trade loaf of bread, Chamberlain arranged for two loaves to be baked based upon free trade and tariff reform prices. On 4 November 1903, Chamberlain spoke at Bingley Hall, Birmingham and put the loaves on display, raising them aloft. “Is it not a sporting question … as to which is the larger?” he asked the rapturous audience. Now approaching seventy years of age, Chamberlain continued to campaign for tariff reform with zeal and energy. Reconciliation appeared imminent when Balfour agreed to a general election after the 1906 Colonial Conference, in which tariff reform would be discussed. However, threatened by backbench opposition, Balfour rescinded the agreement and demanded party unity. Chamberlain ignored this and intensified his campaign in November 1905, resulting directly in Balfour’s resignation on 4th December. With the Unionists divided and out of favour with many of their former supporters, the Liberal Party won the 1906 general election by a landslide, with the Unionists reduced to just 157 seats in the House of Commons. Although Balfour lost his seat in East Manchester, Chamberlain and his followers increased their majorities in the West Midlands. Chamberlain even became acting Leader of the Opposition in the absence of Balfour.
On 8th July 1906, Chamberlain celebrated his seventieth birthday and Birmingham was enlivened for a number of days by official luncheons, public addresses, parades, bands and an influx of thousands of congratulatory telegrams. Tens of thousands of people crowded into the city when Chamberlain made a passionate speech on 10th July, promoting the virtues of Radicalism and imperialism. But then Chamberlain suddenly collapsed with a stroke on 13th July while dressing for dinner in the bathroom of his house at Prince’s Gardens. Though he had lost all hope of recovering his health and returning to active politics, Chamberlain followed his son Austen’s career with interest and encouraged the tariff reform movement. He opposed Liberal proposals to remove the House of Lords’ veto and gave his blessing to the Unionists to fight to oppose Home Rule for Ireland. In the two general elections of 1910, he was allowed to return unopposed in his West Birmingham constituency. In January 1914, Chamberlain decided to not seek re-election. On 2nd July, six days before his 78th birthday, he suffered a heart attack and, surrounded by his family, he died in his wife’s arms. The family refused an offer of an official burial at Westminster Abbey and a Unitarian ceremony was held in Birmingham. He was laid to rest at Key Hill Cemetery, Hockley, in the same grave as his first two wives, and close to that of his parents. On 31 March 1916, the Chamberlain Memorial, a bust created by sculptor Mark Tweed, was unveiled at Westminster Abbey. Among the dignitaries present were former Prime Minister Arthur Balfour, Bonar Law, Chamberlain’s sons Austen and Neville (by then Lord Mayor of Birmingham), and other members of the Chamberlain, Hutton and Martineau families.
An ageing Chamberlain caricatured by “WHO” for Vanity Fair, 1908. Although his family attempted to conceal his disability, Chamberlain was barely capable of standing unaided by this time and was no longer an active member of the House of Commons. By “WHO” (unidentified Vanity Fair artist) – Published in Vanity Fair, 29 January 1908, as “Men of the Day” Number 1103.Downloaded from vanityfairprints.com, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=12524042
For the two decades before the Boer War, Chamberlain was never a blind supporter of free trade as a goal in itself. Instead, his goal was to both tighten the bonds of the Empire and, simultaneously, solve Britain’s domestic economic and political problems. He therefore merged political and economic nationalism in coming up with a formula for imperial preference in trade and tariffs. Historian Dennis Judd has said of him:
There is something so elemental and, in a way, timeless about the meteoric rise of Chamberlain: from his modest London Unitarian background, via his brilliant industrial and commercial career in Birmingham, to a position of almost supreme political power, where he could (and did) make and break the two major parties of late-Victorian and Edwardian England, destroy the immediate prospect of Irish Home Rule, reshape the British Empire, press for a restructuring of British economic policies and bestride the international stage as significantly as Rhodes or Bismarck.
Another view of him is that he was always a radical in home affairs. For instance, after leaving the Liberals, he remained a proponent of workmen’s compensation and old-age pensions. Though he became a ‘constructive’ imperialist in foreign affairs, these dual stances, apparently contradictory to many historians, were not, in reality, in great conflict with each other – with both, like many fellow radical dissenters, he rejected “laissez-faire capitalism”.
A Further Scene from Baptist History, from an unpublished play-script written by Revd. Arthur J Chandler, Minister of Bearwood Baptist Church, Birmingham, 1965-1979:
Regent Street Baptist Chapel, Smethwick, nr. Birmingham. There has been a Baptist Congregation worshipping in Regent Street, Smethwick since 1877. The current building has stood in Regent Street since 1893 and from its outward appearance is a typical Victorian chapel.
Setting: Regent Street… the Church in Meeting assembled with the pastor, Revd. Hugh Singleton, in the chair. Time: November 1897.
Hugh Singleton: The motion has now been proposed, seconded. All those in favour… Ah, carried unanimously! …
And now, brethren and sisters, may I share with you a project near to my heart, a matter which has been uppermost in my mind for some time.
When I came from Workington and settled here in August 1894, we had well-equipped chapel premises. We were then, I suppose, small in number and there was a crippling debt of four hundred pounds. Under God’s blessing, our numbers have grown and our debts paid.
For some time the need for School buildings has been urgent and I am still overwhelmed by the generous promises you made at our last Church Meeting – of gifts totalling four hundred pounds.
But Dr Shakespeare, our Baptist Union Secretary, will expect Regent Street to respond equally generously to the Twentieth Century Fund for Baptist Extension in the British Isles, and Bearwood, now, as many of you living there well know, is a growing district, for which I feel we are particularly responsible. It needs a Baptist Church.
For these reasons, my friends, I am going to be very bold and recommend to you the suspension of our scheme for new ancillary buildings – desperate though we are for additional accommodation for our School. We have premises in which to gather our children: Bearwood has none. I ask you to give me every assistance you can in my resolve to establish a Baptist witness there. We will resume our effort for a new Schoolroom when the proposed work at Bearwood is put on a sound footing. Are you with us?
William (a member): May I say something here, Mr Singleton?
Singleton: Certainly, William. You would not ask permission to address the Church unless you were under the Spirit’s constraint. Speak, brother.
William: I just wanted to say that I share to the full your pastoral concern for Bearwood and I promise here and now to give my fullest support to any enterprise the Baptists of Smethwick and neighbouring churches may feel led to initiate there. But some of us – indeed I am sure that I speak for most of us – are anxious about you and feel that we must do something practical to safeguard your physical well-being.
You came to us after twelve and a half very exacting years at Workington. You went there straight from Rawdon College in response to a call from the Lancashire and Cheshire Association – of which at the time your own pastor at Cannon Street, Accrington, the great Charles Williams was Secretary – for there was as yet no Church at in Workington to invite you, and you spent your first three weeks seeking out what few Baptists there were in that Cumberland town of twenty thousand inhabitants. …
… You found the place and the prejudice against the Baptists to be great handicaps. And when you left – I mention this for the benefit of our younger members – you left behind you a flourishing, self-supporting Church, with Chapel and School all free from debt. Many churches – some large and influential – sought your oversight without success. You came to us, believing it was God’s call.
Several: Bless the Lord. Amen. The Lord’s Name be praised.
William: You have given yourself without stint to the work here and we are grateful. In addition, you have been elected to the School Board, you have taken an interest in all the institutions of the Borough, not to mention the Nursing Institution, the Cripple’s Union and the Aid Society.
Sir, when we called you we solemnly undertook to take care of you. And take care of you we will. Too many of the Lord’s servants these days are being lowered into an early grave, much to the delight of our great Adversary, the Devil.
Sir, we beg of you, consider it possible that it may be unwise to make further demands upon your energies. Bearwood is a needy area. But Regent Street – your own church and people – need you, too.
There! I have said what it was in my heart and on my mind to say. And I think that others will feel as I do.
Deacon:(rising) I can assure brother William that the Deacons share his affectionate concern and our Pastor knows full well what is our view. Again and again, in the Deacons’ Court, we are constantly requesting Mr Singleton to ease up and to conserve his energies. Please God, he has a long and fruitful ministry to sustain among us. Couldn’t one of the other Ministers be asked to take the lead?
A sister, Emily: (rising) Mr Singleton, in some churches women have to remain silent. But churches of our faith and order have always ‘suffered’ a woman to speak! And sometimes, in consequence, they really have suffered! Or so the men will say. Seriously, though, we wives spend our lives looking after our men – nudging them when they are too slow, checking them when they are too hasty. I understand the point brother William has so effectively made. I share his view.
But I warn you – put shackles on this man (she points to Mr S), this prophet of God and true Seer, this evangelist, this soul-winner, if ever a man was … muzzle if you must the mouth of a man who cannot but speak the things he has seen and heard… and you will spend eternity regretting it.
This is the way God made Hugh Singleton. He cannot hug this wonderful salvation to himself, safeguard it as his own private possession, he believes that Christ Jesus tasted death for every man, and every man must know; he cannot be held within the narrow limits of one local Church; like John Wesley, having a whole Christ for his salvation, a whole Bible for his staff, a whole church for his fellowship, he must have a whole world for his parish. Out-reach is the breath of his nostrils; Evangelism is his life-blood. Take this opportunity from him, tie him up in some straight-jacket, keep him occupied making the machinery of Regent Street tick over – and this man, a giant among us, will become just an ‘ordinary’ minister – a tragedy fit to make the angels weep! If Bearwood has made a Macedonian call, and Hugh Singleton has heard it, then loose him and let him go! And let us also go with him.
Singleton: (emotionally) Sister Emily, I thank you. As you were speaking a text from the Psalms came to my mind: The Lord gave the Word; great was the company of women that published it abroad. You have been God’s messenger to us all. If this is, as with all my heart I believe it to be, a Heavenly Vision, then we must not be disobedient. Are you with me, brothers and sisters? Need I put it to the vote?
Member: No Sir, we will be upstanding as a sign that we are with you. God bless Bearwood. Our scheme shall stand suspended for the present.
Hugh Singleton: I thank you, my friends. (Boyishly) Now I may tell you that so sure was I of the leading of God’s Spirit that in anticipation of your approval I have already booked a classroom in the Bearwood Road School for a series of meetings, and I propose to conduct the first Service there in the New Year, 1898, on 30th January to be precise, and then I shall preach on every evening of the following week. May the Lord bless his work with signs following. Amen.
And now may I close in prayer:
O Lord, who didst command us all to go into all the world and preach the Gospel to every creature, in nearby Judea and Samaria as well as the uttermost parts of the earth, in all our rightful concern for the heathen abroad, may we ever be mindful of the needs of those who are our neighbours. Grant us thy blessing as we go forth bearing precious seed, so that we – or those who will come after and reap where we have sown – may, at last, come with rejoicing, bringing our sheaves with us. Amen.
(He concludes with the Benediction)
Background notes:
Bearwood was until the end of the 19th century simply a crossroads, Bearwood Road leading from Smethwick to Harborne, crossed the main Hagley Road and also the road from Birmingham to Rowley (the present Sandon Road). Inns stood at each of these crossroads and a few cottages around the junctions. In the 1890’s the rapid expansion of both Smethwick and Birmingham arrived in Bearwood and within a period of about 15 years the area was fully developed with good quality houses in relatively wide streets, it became a popular place with people working in both Birmingham and Smethwick. Regent Street Baptist church in Smethwick felt led to establish their work in the area and in 1898 began holding services in the newly built Bearwood Road school. The church rapidly established itself and within a short time, a site was bought on the corner of Bearwood Road and Rawlings Road. A church and schoolroom were planned and the Schoolroom was built and opened in 1903. Services and other activities were held there until a new church could be added. In 1915 Bearwood Baptist Church became independent of Regent Street, having been successfully nurtured by the Smethwick Baptists.
Socialism as a Matter of ‘Faith’ – Methodist or Marxist?:
By the end of the nineteenth century, ‘Secular’ British Socialists possessed a ‘faith’ in the righteousness and ultimate victory of their cause which acted as a powerful driving force. This faith owed as much to Methodism as to Marxism, being based both on Christian principles and the ‘scientific’ analysis of contemporary society first presented by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. Much of this analysis was modified, however, by Henry Hyndman and the Fabians, by William Morris and Robert Blatchford, though it still had a comprehensive reality for those who accepted it. To its working-class adherents, it gave a sense of purpose and pride in class consciousness; to middle-class philanthropists, it afforded the consolation that they were working in solidarity with a range of tendencies of social change and progress. It was this intellectual, religious and political milieu that poverty began to attract more attention once again primarily due to men and women of public conscience, notably the nonconformist shipowner Charles Booth and a member of the Quaker chocolate manufacturing family, Seebohm Rowntree, who began to investigate it, to quantify it and to reveal its extent in irrefutable detail for the first time. Thirty per cent of London’s population at the beginning of the 1890s fell on or below Charles Booth’s poverty line and in certain parts of London the percentages were far higher, sixty-eight per cent in Southwark, for instance, and sixty-five in Greenwich. Rowntree’s figure for York in 1899 was hardly any lower so that cases of real want could no longer be characterised as unrepresentative.
As Pelling concluded in his seminal work, The Origins of the Labour Party, the history of the world had often shown the dynamic qualities of a faith devoutly held, like that of the early Christians, the Calvinist reformers and the millenarian sects of the seventeenth century. Faith may feed on illusions, but it is capable of conquering reality. In a tract published by the Fabians, Socialism and the Teaching of Christ (1897), Clifford wrote of the Collectivist Gospel as having at least four distinguishing merits, in that…
while it does not change human nature, It destroys many of the evils of modern society because it sets everybody alike to his share of the work, and gives to him his share of reward;
it ennobles the struggle of life, leaving man free for the finer toils of intellect and heart: free ’to seek first the kingdom of God and his justice’, since that kingdom is made real ’not for the sake of life, but of a good life’… in keeping with ’the mind of Christ’;
it offers a better environment for the development of the teaching of Jesus concerning wealth and the ideals of labour and brotherhood,..
it fosters a higher ideal of human and social worth and well-being through a more Christian conception of industry; one in which every man is a worker, and each worker does not toil for himself exclusively, but for all the necessities, comforts and privileges he shares with all members of the community.
But despite the revelations of Booth and Rowntree that poverty was still alive and ‘well’ in the richest country in the world, there was an overall rise in living standards for the majority of British people over the Victorian and Edwardian periods. The growing urbanisation of the country which many people thought aggravated the problems of the poor also made it easier to deal with the worst social injustices. Towns provided an increasing range of free services, as local government expenditure almost doubled between 1900 and 1913. It was in towns that free school meals and school medical inspection began. Better medical attention was becoming available, too, in hospitals, which catered mainly for working-class patients. Paradoxically, the changing composition of the ruling classes gave the emergent working classes the opportunity to fight for a share in the spoils of progress and power. Initially, working-class activity had taken the form of semi-legal organisations and actions, mainly aimed at restricting production and/or trade. But once the working classes had established more ‘mature’ craft-based trade unions, and economic and political organisations, the manufacturing and professional middle classes were not slow to entangle them in their political intrigues and religious conflicts.
On the other hand, by 1913, the revolutionary syndicalist ideas which had preoccupied many industrial workers in the previous decades throughout Europe, including the British Isles, and across America, were in decline. It had become obvious that the respectable ‘Edwardian’ working classes as a whole had no use for the concept of violent revolution. Any leader who failed to recognise this could not expect to win widespread support. Economic grievances could temporarily arouse bitter discontent as they had done in the early years of the industrial revolution. But dislocations of this type were for the most part transitory: a permanent political organisation of the working class needed to disavow the use of violence. Only those who recognised this could effectively set in motion the movement to form a Labour Party. At the time Keir Hardie retired from the chairmanship of the ILP in 1900, it had captured trade-union support, with the ultimate objective of tapping trade union funds for the attainment of political power. But before the war, it was the Liberal Party, with the support of Labour after 1910, that offered the best prospect of a national programme of social reform.
For Calvinists at the time, as for many other conservative theologians since Spinoza, his role has been seen as purely destructive, as that of one who undermined the authority and inspiration of the biblical text and laid the foundation for Enlightenment scepticism about the Bible – the scepticism of the French philosophers, Voltaire (1694-1778) Rousseau (1712-1778) and Diderot (1713-84) as well as that of British ‘Deist’, David Hulme (1711-1776). It is even possible to view his endorsement of the central teaching of Scripture as no more than a cynical way of trying to avoid censure for his views – an aim, which if it was indeed his aim, he certainly failed. But John Barton (2019) concludes that Spinoza’s motivation in questioning the authorship of biblical books was ultimately political. He quotes Nadler’s view in A Book Forged in Hell: Spinoza’s Scandalous Treatise and the Birth of the Secular Age:
By showing that the Bible is not, in fact, the work of a supernatural God, “a message for mankind sent down by God from heaven”, as Spinoza mockingly puts it, but a perfectly natural human document; … naturalising the Torah and the other books of the Bible and reducing them to ordinary (though morally valuable) works of literature, Spinoza hopes to undercut ecclesiastic influence in politics … and weaken the sectarian dangers facing his beloved Republic.
At the same time, as John Barton also argues, it is possible to see him as both a pioneer of biblical criticism and as one who kept a firm hold on the essentials of biblical faith, while stripping away the whole scaffolding of interpretative subtlety that had tried to bring every last word of the Bible into an orthodox structure and, in the process, had lost the heart of the matter. In the eighteenth century, it was the negative side of Spinoza’s work seemed to come to the fore. Especially in Great Britain, rationalism generally prevailed, and the biblical text was much depreciated as crude and bloody, with the nobler sentiments of some of the New Testament seen as overlaid with inconsistency and falsehood: these denunciations reached a peak in Thomas Paine’s The Age of Reason (1794), but they can also be found in the works of many writers of the earlier part of the century such as David Hume and Edward Gibbon (1737-94).
An extreme example was Thomas Woolston’s six Discourses on the Miracles of our Saviour (between 1727 and 1729), in which he argued that we need to allegorise the miracle stories in the Gospels since, taken as literal history, they are so incredible that no sane reader would believe them. Yet he made such outrageous claims about the stories, including those of the resurrection appearances, that even by today’s liberal ‘standards’ that it is hard to accept his overall claim to be an orthodox Christian. Few rationalist writers went as far as Woolston, but his extreme case does still highlight a certain prevalent school of thought. He became something of a martyr for his beliefs. He was tried for blasphemy, sentenced to a year’s imprisonment and a fine of a hundred pounds. Unable to pay, he spent the rest of his days in prison. But there were less savage ways of replying to Deism. Thomas Sherlock, a bishop and best-selling Christian author, took his cue from Woolston’s trial and wrote a book called The Trial and Witnesses of the Resurrection in 1729 in which he put the resurrection witnesses into the dock. It went on to be reprinted into the nineteenth century. Another opponent of Deism was Bishop Joseph Butler whose Analogy of Religion (1736) argued that the evidence of nature and the testimony of Christian faith both pointed in the direction of supernatural religion. Among the rationalists, however, there were many staunch defenders of biblical orthodoxies, such as William Whiston and Anthony Collins. But the deist Matthew Tindal (1657-1733) saw the essential circularity of many defences of the authority of Scripture, as we still do today when he wrote:
It’s an odd jumble, to prove the Truth of a Book by the Truth of the Doctrines it contains, and at the same Time conclude those Doctrines to be true because contained in that Book.
In 1678, Richard Simon, a French Oratorian priest (1638-1712) published his Critical History History of the Old Testament, followed in the next few years by works on the text of the New Testament. By showing, like Spinoza had done eight years previously, that the biblical books had not been written by their supposed authors, Simon argued that Protestants were in error in thinking that they could rely on the Bible alone as the foundation of the Christian faith. The Bible was unreliable, and so the Church’s traditional and magisterial authority were needed if faith was to be securely grounded. Cardinal Richelieu, however, saw that this dangerously demoted the Bible below what was tolerable, resulting in Simon being suspended from his Oratory. Nevertheless, Simon’s arguments were, in themselves, sound enough, and his position alongside Spinoza as one of the founders of modern biblical criticism is a reminder that this was not, in origin, a purely Protestant movement, even though it would be Protestants, especially in Germany, who subsequently developed the rational study of the Bible to become a major industry.
The methods employed in such studies were, however, essentially the same as those used in secular criticism, which led many to believe that they were part of an anti-religious agenda. Major eighteenth-century contributions to textual criticism were made by J. A. Bengel (1687-1752), who published a critical edition of the New Testament in 1734, and J. J. Wettstein (1693-1754), whose two-volume edition of the New Testament appeared in Amsterdam in 1751-52. One of the first writers to try to rebut the accusation of blasphemy against those who claimed that Moses did not write the Pentateuch was Salamo Semler (1725-91), whose Free Research on the Canon, published in four volumes (between 1771 and ’76) sought to distinguish the essential supernatural message of the Bible from the detail of biblical exegesis, which belonged to the sphere of normal secular literary enquiry and on which no issue of faith turned. Semler argued that this distinction could be traced back to Luther. What was essential to faith, as Luther had asserted, was the assurance to believers that God accepted them by his free grace; who wrote this or that book was a matter of, at best, secondary importance, on which faith had nothing to say. This was challenging for many orthodox Christians, but it laid the basis of biblical enquiry in Germany for the next two centuries.
Yet Semler’s position about separating faith from criticism is arguably overly optimistic, and for many ‘fundamentalists’, then as now, the suggestion of even the smallest discrepancy in the Bible was and is, the ‘thin end of a wedge,’ because the very possibility of it calls into question the foundation of their faith. This may be an exaggeration, but there is an underlying point to it. It is doubtful whether Semler’s approach is compatible with the Reformed tradition after Luther, and it clearly clashes with the modern conservative evangelical stance on the centrality of Biblical authority to faith. Despite Luther’s relatively ‘relaxed’ attitude to biblical criticism, most ordinary Protestants reacted as though these issues were being brought forward for the first time. H. S. Reimarus (1694-1768) is remembered as the father of the ‘quest of the historical Jesus’ and was the first to show that Jesus’ message was thoroughly eschatological, inaugurating the ‘last days.’ But he also went beyond this to claim, like Spinoza and Thomas Woolston, in claiming that the biblical narratives were susceptible of a naturalistic explanation. Reimarus was a deist, and could not believe that God had intervened in the world following its creation. In the case of the resurrection, he argued that the disciples had stolen Jesus’ body to make it appear that he had risen. Then the later evangelists invented his predictions of the resurrection:
Having stolen the body they then proclaimed that this had indeed happened, as he had foretold. They reinforced their claims by twisting some Old Testament texts into supporting the case, giving it bite by adding that the world would shortly end and that anyone who had not accepted their message would burn in hell.
Robert Morgan with John Barton (1988), Biblical Interpretation. The Oxford Bible Series (OUP), p 55.
Rationalism and empiricism were not the only intellectual movements of the period. In its own day, Deism was proked a great deal of discussion. Like both of the former movements, Deism became increasingly hostile to the Christian faith in the eighteenth century. But the original Deism of the previous century in England was an attempt to demonstrate the rationality of belief in a divine creator without appealing to the special revelation of God in Christ. Matthew Tindal’s (1730) work Christianity as Old as the Creation argued that Christianity was really the religion of nature. Of course, the Christian faith holds certain central beliefs that go far beyond natural religion, such as the incarnation, but these were explained away as the work of superstitious priestcraft. The deists also attacked the arguments based on fulfilled prophecy and miracles. Like Reimarus, Anthony Collins claimed that the Old Testament prophecies did not really fit Jesus, and Thomas Woolston attacked the resurrection stories as, at best, myth and at worst as a fraud perpetrated by the disciples who had in fact stolen the body of Jesus.
But the natural theologians neglected the teaching of the Bible so much that in time some came to argue that its distinctive doctrines were either superfluous or false. They claimed that the parts of the Bible that agree with natural theology are simply unnecessary; the parts that contradict natural theology – the myths, miracles and priestly prattling – are simply untrue. The Christian religion consists solely of what nature and reason teach unaided: the belief in and worship of God, the repentance of sin, the practice of virtue, and the expectation of punishment and rewards after death. The number of deists greatly increased both in England and continental Europe during the first half of the eighteenth century, and the two branches of the movement had some common roots. For example, John Toland, the author of Christianity Not Mysterious (1696), was patronised by the German nobility. The work of the English deists was also known and discussed in Germany, where the effect was a demand for an enlightened re-evaluation of the church and its teaching, and of culture and philosophy. One of the leading ‘enlightened’ thinkers was the dramatist and amateur theologian, G. E. Lessing (1729-81). In his plays, Lessing shifted from the themes of classical tragedy and tales of kings and nobles to the dilemmas of middle-class life. Parts of Reimarus’ writing on Jesus were published posthumously by Lessing, thus lengthening and broadening their impact. He took up the deists’ view of Jesus, claiming that the resurrection was a fraud invented by the disciples, who merely wanted to continue their ‘easy’ way of life.
Orthodox Christians responded to the deists in various ways. Many continued with ever more detailed elaborations of natural theology, particularly in using the argument concerning ‘design’. In England, John Ray’s (1691) publication, Wisdom of God Manifested in the Works of Creation passed through numerous editions. Other Christians chose to defend the Bible by showing that its authors were reliable and honest. They then used the evidence of miracles and prophecies to show that orthodox beliefs were reasonable. The classic literature on ‘Christian evidence’ grew and remained popular until the mid-nineteenth century The deists were best combated by writers who questioned and reinterpreted the role of ‘Reason’. In The Case of Reason (1731), William Law showed that it was false to suppose that God always behaves according to strictly human rationality. George Berkeley, in Alciphron (1732), argued that God’s ideas are what really exists, not matter. Therefore, all beliefs that separate the human reality from the divine are faulty. In fact, the sceptical philosopher David Hume had a limited effect on his own century, His Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion appeared only posthumously, in 1777, influencing more the following century. Writers of natural theology continued to follow the laws laid down in the deistic controversy. Their work culminated in the most popular apologetic texts ever written: William Paley’s (1794) View of the Evidences of Christianity and Natural Theology (1802).
Sources:
John Barton (2019), A History of the Bible: The Book and its Faiths. London: Allen Lane (Penguin Books).
Tim Dowley (ed.), et. al. (1977), The History of Christianity. Berkhamsted: Lion Publishing
An ejected minister meets with his family under cover of darkness.
It was not until 1687 that the dissenting or ‘nonconformist’ churches felt able to look back upon ye Times of our late Troubles since the Act of Uniformity in 1662 had taken away the relative toleration they had experienced in the Interregnum. The Presbyterian minister Richard Baxter (1615-91) had taken very little notice of the Conventicle Act of 1663 but was preaching in his own house to his family and ‘friends’, first in London and then at Acton. Before long, many people from his own former parish and neighbouring ones were coming to hear him. He was careful not to preach to them during times of worship in church, and since his house was close by, he would often preach before the service and then take his congregation over to hear the new Vicar, who was – at first – pleased to have such large congregations. But he soon became jealous because he knew that the people had come, first and foremost, to hear Baxter, so he told the King that the latter was breaking the Act and two magistrates were sent to threaten the minister with prison if he did not stop preaching. He refused to do so and was sent to Clerkenwell gaol where he was allowed to have a room of his own where his wife could join him. The prisons became full once more crowded with Quakers, Dissenters and Presbyterian ministers ejected from parish churches. Baxter himself soon needed the comfort that his faith always brought him, as the poem he wrote shows:
Must I be driven from my book,
From house and goods and dearest friends?
My Lord hath taught me how to want
A place wherein to put my head.
No walls or bars can keep Thee out
None can confine a holy soul,
The Streets of Heaven it walks about
None can its liberty control.
In the winter, these prisons were bitterly cold and damp, and in summer they smelt atrocious and were full of flies and rats, spreading disease so that many people died in them. Baxter himself became ill, even in Clerkenwell, and might have died had not his friends managed to get him set free before his sentence was over. When he came out, he could not return to Acton due to the Five Mile Act of 1665, which prevented ministers from coming within five miles of any important town or of any place at all where they had once been ministers. In practical terms, this meant that not only had they no means of livelihood but also that they could get no bread from their home parish. Some went abroad and others hid near their old homes, visiting their wives and children secretly, at night. Many others, like Baxter, thought that it was better to go on preaching and teaching openly, even if they were sent to prison than to starve, or worse still, see their children starve. Baxter had to spend the winter in very cold and uncomfortable lodgings in Totteridge near Barnet, still unable to preach, but at least able to continue to write. He stayed there but was very busy in his one poor, smoky room as all sorts of sad people, rich and poor, learnéd and simple, wrote to him or came to see him, asking him for help. Some of them were ministers who, like himself, were excluded from their homes and livings due to the Restoration laws. One wrote that his wife and six children had lived ever since his ejection on black rye-bread and water, and another that he had to spin all day and half the night to make a living. Baxter and his wife Margaret did their best to help them all.
King Charles certainly wanted to protect Catholics from persecution, and would probably – if left to his own devices – have allowed freedom of worship to both Catholics and Nonconformists. Many moderate magistrates understood that he did not want severe punishments for those who refused to conform and therefore allowed services and preaching to continue to be held in private houses. In 1672, the King went further in issuing a Declaration of Indulgence which did away with some of the fierce laws against nonconformists and said that licences for preaching would be granted to certain ministers, including Baxter. He returned to London and settled in Bloomsbury, recommending his preaching in a big room over the market-house at St James which almost collapsed with the weight of the congregation he attracted. Margaret Baxter prevented this by quick thinking, and then bought some land nearby and built a chapel on it. But the King was forced by Parliament to put an end to his ‘Indulgence’ and Baxter was threatened with being imprisoned once more if he used the chapel.
William Penn
Baxter was then invited to Rickmansworth in Hertfordshire, where he met the famous Quaker, William Penn (1644-1718), who later founded Pennsylvania as a colony that attracted many Protestant nonconformists who had been persecuted in Europe, as a state where they were able to worship and serve freely. He and Baxter held a meeting, a disputation, in which they argued before an audience over seven hours, without even breaking for lunch. Both Baxter and Penn respected one another, though their viewpoints were at opposite ends of the nonconformist spectrum, so they did not agree on many points. But the fact that they were both in constant danger of persecution and prison yet went on preaching and discussing shows the constant courage of leaders across the range of dissenting movements.
Jordans, Buckinghamshire, The Quaker meetinghouse, 1688. is associated with William Penn, founder of Pennsylvania, buried in the graveyard outside.
A Scene from the Trial of Richard Baxter before Judge Jeffreys,1685:
The site of Baxter’s trial in front of Judge Jeffreys.
Richard Baxter was eventually brought to trial in 1685 in front of Lord Chief Justice of England, Judge Jeffreys who, at the Bloody Assizes later that same year, sent many West Country nonconformists to the gallows following the Monmouth Rebellion. James II had become King in February 1685 and he especially hated nonconformists because so many of them had opposed him. He thought that the best way of punishing them was to bring him to a public trial, but it was unclear what the charge could be since he had recently retired from preaching due to ill-health. But he was still writing books and had recently finished a Commentary on the New Testament. Jeffreys claimed that this contained thinly-veiled attacks on both the King, the bishops and the 1662 Prayer Book. Baxter was brought to trial at the Guildhall in the City of London on 30 May 1685. Fortunately, we have a full, if anonymous, account of the court proceedings, signed only with the initials I.C. by which the author identified himself to an ‘old friend’ who was also a friend of Baxter. It was not sent until five years later after James II had fled from England. But I.C. wrote his account immediately after getting home from the Guildhall. It reveals the vitriol with which Jeffreys tried Baxter on behalf of the Crown and the Anglo-Catholic ‘establishment’:
“This is an old rogue and hath poisoned the world with his Kidderminster ‘doctrine’ … an old ‘schismatical’ knave, a hypocritical villain: but what ailed the ailed the stock owl that he could not conform – was he better or wiser than any other man? He hath been ever since the spring of the faction. I am sure that he hath poisoned the world with his… doctrine … he was a conceited, stubborn, fanatical dog, that did not conform when he might have been made a bishop; hang him! … This one man hath cast more reproach on the Constitution of our Church than will be wiped out this hundred years; but I will handle him for it, for by God! – he deserves to be whipped through the city! …
Baxter’s lawyer replied to his ‘charge’ that it was not his business to explain why Baxter’s conscience would not let him become a bishop but to answer the charge against his commentary. At this, Jeffreys, in a rage, called upon Baxter to answer the charge directly himself. Baxter did so, calmly:
“One day, all these things will surely be understood and it will be seen what a sad and foolish thing it is that one set of Protestant Christians are made to persecute another set. I am not concerned to answer such stuff (as I am accused of) but am ready to produce my writings, and my life and conversation is known to many in this nation.”
When Baxter tried to speak again, the Judge stopped him and continued himself, apparently more softly, and more sinisterly:
“Richard, Richard, … dost thou think we’ll hear thee poison the Court? Richard, thou art an old fellow, an old knave; thou hast written books enough to load a cart, every one full of sedition, I might say treason, as an egg is full of meat, Hadst thou been whipped out of thy writing trade forty years ago, it had been happy. Thou pretended to be a preacher of a Gospel of Peace, and thou hast one foot in the grave … but I leave thee to thyself and I see thou wilt go on as thou has begun; but by the Grace of God, I’ll look after thee.”
I.C. ended his story bitterly and sarcastically:
Mr Baxter is now in prison at Southwark, where he lies for the fine of five hundred marks. We have fine judges and juries in England you see! This viper, I am told, proposed a whipping through the city, but I hear that some of his brethren abhorred the notion and stamped on it. So amonst them out of their great clemency, they have set the above fine.
If Jeffreys had had his way and Richard Baxter had been whipped through the streets of London, he would certainly have died, but even Jeffreys could not enforce this punishment against the other judges. Baxter refused to pay the fine which had been wrongfully imposed on him, so he remained in prison for a year and a half. As for Jeffreys, when, during the Glorious Revolution of 1688, he tried to escape from London, disguised as a sailor, he was recognised by some of his victims just as he was going down the steps at Wapping to board a ship. He was nearly torn to pieces by the crowd but was rescued and sent to the Tower, where he soon died from his injuries.
Scenes from the failed Monmouth Rebellion, supported by the nonconformists of Dorset, Devon and Somerset and commemorated on playing cards.
The accession of William and Mary brought a return of only limited toleration, but all active persecution of the nonconformists finally stopped. The oppressive laws remained, though Protestant dissenters of Trinitarian beliefs who subscribed to the main points of the Thirty-Nine Articles were exempted from penalty. Baxter persuaded many of his friends and followers to agree to the less severe tests, writing a book to help them see the wisdom of doing this, and that they would not be acting against their consciences. Having made this last attempt at moderation and peacemaking, Baxter died in 1691, with England finally at peace. With the Toleration Act of 1689, new chapels sprang up all over the country.
Nowhere was the Nonconformist movement stronger than in East Anglia. The simple but elegant places of worship they built are continuing proof of their devotion, vigour and wealth. Bury, Ipswich and Framlingham all have fine Unitarian, originally Presbyterian, chapels, and there are old Congregational chapels at Needham Market and Walpole. When Daniel Defoe visited Southwold, he attend divine service at the parish church with twenty-seven others. When he walked past the dissenting chapel afterwards, he found it full to the doors. But also with toleration came a wider range of theological views, and there were still many divisions and doctrinal quarrels. Dissenters and Anglicans both suffered a decline in religious vitality as a result. On the one hand, the General Baptists, like the Presbyterians, fell prey to the spread of ‘Arianism’, which denied the divinity of Christ. The Particular Baptists, on the other hand, over-reacted against theological liberalism. They tended to stress the sovereignty of God to such an extent that both individual moral action and evangelism were inhibited by what became known as ‘hyper-Calvinism’.
In response to the Liberal and Rationalist attacks, a ‘natural theology’ was developed to defend the Christian faith in the course of the eighteenth century. At no time previously had it seemed more important to use ‘apologetics’ to make Christianity appear ‘reasonable’. On the continent, first Descartes and then Rousseau, Voltaire and Leibniz had exalted reason and doubt in building their influential philosophies. Spinoza and historians such as Simon and Bayle had had also stimulated scepticism by criticising the Bible. But in England, Isaac Newton in his (1687) Principia Mathematica had set out laws for which for the first time revealed that the universe was divinely ordered. This encouraged the belief that human enquiries into nature unaided by Scripture could demonstrate the power of the Creator. But above all, the century of appalling religious conflicts – the Thirty Years’ War in Germany, the persecution of Jansenists and Huguenots in France, the Puritan Revolution, the British Civil Wars, the Monmouth Rebellion and the ‘Glorious’ Revolution of 1688 had all combined to create a thirst for tolerance and a desire to find doctrines on which most Christians, at least, could agree.
Philosophical Scepticism in Britain:
The Reasonableness of Christianity, the title of John Locke’s revolutionary book, published in 1695, became the main theme of theology for more than a century. The fundamental truths of the Christian religion were claimed to be few and simple, intelligible to the plainest of people. The immense size of the universe, the stability of its bodies and the simplicity of its laws; the position of the earth, the usefulness of its resources and the variety of its inhabitants; and the detail, order and symmetry of every form of life, all witnessed clearly to God’s existence, his wisdom and goodness, his purposes, providence and power. They witnessed, in other words, to a God of whom it was probable that a special revelation had been given. That revelation, given in the Bible, confirmed that Christianity was basically reasonable. In 1691, Robert Boyle, a chemist and natural theologian, founded a lectureship for proving the Christian Religion, against notorious infidels, viz. Atheists, Theists, Pagans, Jews and Mahometans, not descending lower to any Controversies, that are among Christians themselves. The Boyle Lectures continued for many years.
A more general philosophical scepticism began in Britain with David Hume. In his lifetime he was perhaps best known for his History of England, but today he is most remembered for the scepticism which Bertrand Russell claimed showed the bankruptcy of the eighteenth-century reasonableness. Hume’s sceptical thought was embodied in such works as Treatise of Human Nature (1739-40), Philosophical Essays Human Understanding (1748) and Dialogue Concerning Natural Religion (1752). Hume’s scepticism extended to the whole range of human knowledge. He claimed that it was impossible to demonstrate the existence of the soul or self, for whenever we look into ourselves we see only some feeling of pleasure or pain, but never the soul as such. Hume questioned the logic of speaking about cause and effect. He insisted that all we can see is one event following another. We do not see the cause as such, but only the sequence of events. In religion, therefore, he cast doubt on the old proofs for the existence of God, pronouncing the idea of a first cause to be useless. Miracles violate the laws of nature and are therefore improbable. For, since a firm and unalterable experience has established the laws of nature, the proof against miracles is as complete as any proof can be. Hume influenced many thinkers, from Kant in the eighteenth century to the logical positivists in the twentieth. But it is worthwhile pausing to ask how valid Hume’s arguments really were.
There is a sense in which what Hume says about the self is true. It cannot be seen directly, like an arm or a leg, or even a brain. But this is not the same as getting rid of the self altogether, for when we try to look into ourselves the self is active as the organising subject of the action. In other words, in order to refute the self as an object, Hume has to make use of the self as a subject. What the argument shows is something of the peculiar nature of the self. Similarly, Hume did not dispose of the idea of causation. The whole of our everyday experience of things and the whole fabric of modern science rest upon the principle that, when certain things always follow other things under given conditions, then it is proper to say that one causes the other. The idea of a law of science depends upon the fact that things do not just happen at random, but that some things are causes and other things are effects. This was the very same law that Hume depended on for his rejection of miracles.
Some of Hume’s criticisms of the arguments for the existence of God were entirely justified. A cause cannot be wholly known from its effect, and the original cause is hidden from us by myriads of other causes. Moreover, if we have an argument for God’s existence from causation and another from design, we need another argument to show that God in each case is one and the same. And we need a further argument to show that this God is the same as the God of the Christian faith. But to say all this is simply to spotlight certain ways in which the existence of God has been argued. It does not settle once and for all the question as to whether God exists, still less does it settle the question of who God is. Hume’s critique of miracles made some telling points, but when he writes about a firm and unalterable experience, he did not ask or answer the question, whose experience? If we take a sample of experience only from those who have no experience of miracles, then we are bound to conclude, as he did, that miracles have not been experienced. But if we include cases of experiences to the contrary, we cannot say that miracles are automatically ruled out, and have never happened. They may be unusual and contrary to common experience, but we cannot rule them out on the basis that they are at variance with all human experience.
The Unitarian Movement in Europe & Britain:
The Unitarian movement also emerged in England in the turbulence of the Civil War period, but it first began on the continent in the early sixteenth century when Renaissance ideas combined with some of the teachings of the ‘Radical Reformation’ to produce Unitarian ideas in the minds of many individuals. As the name suggests, Unitarianism rejects the idea of the Trinity, questioning the belief in the divinity of Christ and in the Holy Spirit in favour of the oneness of God. It was a ‘heresy’ that had been present in the early church, and notable early adherents included Martin Cellarius, Michael Servetus and Bernard Occhino. The ‘new’ teaching alarmed both Catholics and Protestants. Servetus was put to death by Calvin in 1553. Two prominent centres of early Unitarianism were Poland, where the ‘Polish Brethren’ as they were known, were formally organised in 1565, and Hungary. After 1574, when Faustus Socinus became their leader, the movement spread rapidly in Poland, but in the reign of the Catholic King Sigismund III (1587-1632) a reaction set in and the Unitarian community at Rackow was suppressed in 1638.
In 1658, the Polish Unitarians were given the chance of conforming or going into exile. Many chose exile and emigrated to Holland, Hungary and England. Giorgio Blandrata had also been active in Poland between 1558 and 1563, then moving to Hungary to become the court physician, where he had a strong influence on Ferenc Dávid (1510-79) who, in 1564, became the bishop of the Reformed Church in Transylvania, the eastern part of the old kingdom. In the same year, he also became court chaplain to the king, Jan Sigismund (1540-71). At the Diet of Torda (1568), the king ordered Unitarianism to be tolerated. In 1571, it was recognised as a ‘recognised religion’ along with Catholicism, Lutheranism and Calvinism. But when Jan Sigismund died in the same year, persecution began and by the later eighteenth century Unitarianism in Hungary had been almost completely suppressed. It only revived in the early nineteenth century when contacts were resumed with English and American Unitarians. Unitarian theology in Hungary was always compromising and conservative. It did not want to invite persecution by appearing aggressively heretical.
John Biddle (1615-62) is regarded as the founder of English Unitarianism, which remained individualistic at first, but in the rationalistic atmosphere of the eighteenth century, very many English Presbyterian and General Baptist churches began to be affected. They adopted first Arian and then Sabellian, Socinian or full-blown Unitarian ideas. Both became largely Unitarian denominations by the second half of the eighteenth century. The liberal Anglican Theophilus Lindsey left the Church of England in 1773 and opened the first self-styled Unitarian church, Essex Chapel, in London.
Meanwhile, there were theological changes in Unitarianism. Joseph Priestley (above) and his successor, Thomas Belsham, found their source of authority in Scripture. They interpreted the Bible in a rationalistic and optimistic way, to get around those verses which Christians had previously used to support the doctrine of the Trinity and the belief that man has a fallen nature. In Ireland, Thomas Emlyn was prosecuted at Dublin in 1703 for denying the deity of Christ. A Unitarian ‘Non-Subscribing Presbytery of Antrim’ arose out of a group of liberal Presbyterian congregations in 1726. After the American Revolution, Unitarianism spread rapidly, encouraged by Priestley, who fled there from England in 1794.
All ages are ages of transition, and most of them contain extremes. The period between 1650 and 1789 was no exception. It opened with the end of the Civil Wars in Britain and ended with the beginning of the French Revolution. Protestantism was already well established when the period began, but there was a further philosophical quest for truth and rationality. In religion, there were also quests for greater doctrinal clarity and deeper personal knowledge of God.
The Great Awakening in America & Britain:
By the second half of the eighteenth century, in the English-speaking churches, the age of reason became the age of renewal. The tide of rationalism was stemmed and deadening formality was replaced by enthusiasm, a fresh wind of the Spirit. This rebirth took place in the 1730s and ’40s. Its roots lay partly in the Pietist movement on the European continent partly in the revival of Puritanism in Britain and colonial America. The movement was known as the Evangelical Revival or the Great Awakening, which was also its name on the American continent. It began there in Northampton, Massachusetts, under Jonathan Edwards (pictured above), in 1734. This preceded the conversions of both George Whitfield and brothers John and Charles Wesley, and can therefore be regarded as feeding into the Evangelical Revival in Britain. The movement came to fruition in colonial New England between 1740 and 1743, the time of George Whitfield’s whirlwind visit.
George Whitefield
In 1690 the total population of the colonies of about a quarter of a million was almost exclusively British or Irish. European Protestants had begun to arrive; mainly Huguenots, Mennonites and Dutch Calvinists. The American Baptists trace their ancestry to a congregation at Providence, Rhode Island, where they were first gathered by Roger Williams, a separatist from London who had been ejected from the Puritan colony of Massachusetts. Most of those making up the first congregations were English or Welsh Baptists who already shared Williams’ beliefs and grew slowly until The Great Awakening. In the meantime, there had also been large-scale immigration of German Protestants belonging chiefly to the Lutheran Church, fleeing religious persecution in the Palatinate. When William Penn invited them to his colony, Pennsylvania, they crossed the Atlantic in their thousands and by the mid-eighteenth century, there were seventy thousand Germans in that one colony alone and almost three times that number in North America as a whole. Among them were also Moravians, Dunkers and Schwenkfelders. These German settlers introduced a different element into American society, which had previously been dominated by the Calvinist tradition. The German groups had already been touched by the Pietist movement which also lit the fires of Methodist Revival in England and Wales.
George Whitefield was the son of a Gloucester innkeeper, born in 1714. He had once wanted to become an actor but instead used his oratorical skills to become an outstanding preacher during the Revival. He was educated at Pembroke College, Oxford, and there became associated with the Wesleys and others in the ‘Holy Club’. Converted in 1735, he was ordained deacon in the Church of England in 1736 and set sail for Georgia the following year. In America, he engaged in a variety of charitable and church work. He returned to England briefly between 1738 and 1739 in order to be ordained as a priest and to collect money for his new orphanages and schools. It was during this year back home that he first discovered his talent for open-air evangelism. He returned to Georgia in 1740, for a second visit to America, setting off on a six-week tour of New England which resulted in the most general awakening that the American colonies had yet experienced.
In Boston, the crowds were so huge that they could not be accommodated in any of the churches, and Whitefield took to the open air, as he had previously done in England. He preached his farewell sermon to a congregation estimated at twenty thousand. Before leaving he invited Gilbert Tennent to Boston in order to blow up the divine fire lately kindled there. The revival continued in Boston with equal success for a period of eighteen months. Thirty religious societies were formed and churches were packed. Services were regularly held in homes. It was said that even the very face of Boston seemed to be strangely altered. A similar tale was told as Whitefield continued his triumphal journey. In the next three years, more than one hundred and fifty churches were affected by the Awakening, not only in New England but also in New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Virginia. In the latter colony, this paved the way for the outstanding preaching of Samuel Davies and the building up of the Presbyterian church there. The Baptists also began to expand, through evangelists like Daniel Marshall and Shubal Stearns. They soon began rejuvenating the revival itself. Devereux Jarrett attempted to revive the established Anglican church, but it proved largely unresponsive. One effect of Whitefield’s visit was to rouse the established ministers, for – as he explained:
“The reason why congregations have been so dead is becausedead men preach to them.”
During the Awakening, ‘dead men’ came alive and were themselves used to revive and add to their own congregations. Spiritual liberation paved the way for political liberation and contributed indirectly to the American revolution. Christianity acquired such a firm hold that it expanded with the western frontier and ensured that the independent nation would rest on a firm foundation.
Calvinistic Methodism in Wales, England & Scotland:
Returning to England once more in 1741, Whitefield embarked on a round of missionary tours which took him what were then enormous distances and were to continue almost to the end of his life. He made early contact with Hywel (Howell) Harris and the Welsh revival. Harris, pictured below, was Whitefield’s exact contemporary. While it is usual to regard the Revival as running from 1738 to 1742 (as it did in England), the first signs of it in Britain had, in fact, appeared earlier, and almost simultaneously, at Talgarth (near Brecon) and Llangeitho (near Tregaron, Ceredigion) in Wales in the summer of 1735. Griffith Jones had been preaching the evangelical message in Llandowror for the past twenty years, so he well deserves his title morning star of the Methodist Revival. Harris, a schoolmaster at Talgarth, was converted at a communion service on Whit Sunday in 1735 after reading books published by the Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge, with which Griffith Jones was closely associated. Harris said that his heart was filled with the fire of the love of God. He witnessed to his newfound experience and soon gathered a little society of fellow believers. They were the beginnings of the Welsh Calvinistic Methodist Church. Although unordained, Harris began to preach in private houses. People were transformed, as was the district, and further societies were started. The Welsh Revival had begun, three years before The Awakening began in England and a year before Whitefield’s first visit to America.
Daniel Rowland of Llangeitho had been spiritually awakened through a sermon by Griffith Jones and his preaching in turn brought about an awakening in his own parish. Harris and Rowland met and from that point worked together for the spiritual welfare of Wales. But Harris could be awkward and dictatorial and though he was an impressive figure with a powerful voice and magnetic personality, he was no theologian. Nevertheless, his enthusiasm won many to Christ, and there were signs of the blessings of the Holy Spirit wherever he preached. George Whitefield became closely associated with the Welsh Calvinistic Methodists and toured south Wales several times with Hywel Harris, preaching in English followed by Harris preaching in Welsh. Whitefield preached in many chapels owned by Selina, Countess of Huntingdon, who was the patroness of the Revival. Horace Walpole nicknamed her ‘St Teresa of the Methodists’. When evangelical preachers were banned from Anglican pulpits she found them a place in her domestic chapels and drawing-rooms. She made possible the proclamation of the Gospel to the aristocracy. In 1768 she founded the preachers’ (theological) college at Trevecca (Trefeca) near Talgarth, run by Harris. In 1779, the Countess was compelled by law to register her chapels as ‘nonconformist meeting houses’; they became known as ‘the Countess of Huntingdon’s Connexion’.
Besides his tours of Wales, Whitefield paid fourteen visits to Scotland, where, on the second, he helped during the famous Cambuslang revival, which began the Scottish awakening. Its impact on the national church there was even more marked than in England and Wales. It is no exaggeration to say that the history of Scottish Presbyterianism was radically altered. The eighteenth century was once described as the dark age of the Scottish Church. A debate about patrons had drained its energies and left it incapable of facing the more damaging challenge of theological scepticism. John Simson, Professor of Divinity at Glasgow University, was accused of teaching heretical views about the person of Christ, similar to those voiced in England by the deists. One of his students, Francis Hutchinson, set out to put a new face upon theology in Scotland. In his ideas, known as ‘Moderatism’, the gospel was reduced to a system of morality that offered only a flimsy hope to those who wanted assurance about eternity. Ministers were more concerned about culture than conversions and dismissed their heritage, which included persecuted Covenanters, with derision. A group of objectors set up an independent presbytery and were forced to leave the national ‘kirk’ in 1740. They themselves insisted that they were only withdrawing from the ‘prevailing party”, not from the Kirk. The ‘Seceders’ gained some support, and their breakaway might have spread, but revival broke out in the parish of Cambuslang in 1742.
There had already been stirrings of revival in Easter Ross and Sutherland in the north of Scotland. John Balfour emerged as the leader of the moment in the northern Highlands which reached its peak in 1739. All this happened even before Whitefield set foot across the border, though he is often referred to as the bringer of revival to Scotland. As in America, he sowed the seed on well-prepared soil. He was first invited to Scotland in 1741 by the Seceders, but when he refused to confine his activities to their churches, they disowned him. Immediately, however, he found an opportunity to work within the Church of Scotland. In 1742 William McCulloch was ‘used’ to spread the revival known as the ‘Cambuslang Wark’ which was well underway when Whitefield visited the parish of Cambuslang during his second Scottish tour. He shared in two memorable, open-air communion services. Commenting on the second of these, McCulloch described…
“… the spiritual glory of this solemnity … the gracious and sensible presence of God“.
Revival quickly spread to the surrounding area, with another ‘outbreak’ occurring at Kilsyth. James Robe had preached there for over thirty years without obvious effect. In 1740 he began a series of sermons on the new birth and two years later was able to report that:
“… while pressing all the unregenerate to seek to have Christ formed within them, an extraordinary power of the divine Spirit accompanied the word preached.”
Similar scenes were repeated for eighteen months or more. Cambuslang and Kilsyth were the highlights of the Scottish Revival. The excitement subsided but the benefits remained. The Evangelical party, mocked as ‘Zealots’ or ‘High-flyers’ by their opponents, took over from the moderates and shaped the outlook of the church. Whitefield was certainly the pioneer of Calvinistic Methodism in England. His converts in London and Bristol were the first of The Great Awakening in the country. He was the first to start field preaching, to recruit lay preachers and to travel to and fro as one of God’s runabouts, as he described himself. He was also the first to make contact with the American awakening, visiting America seven times in all and dying there in 1770.
This building was erected at Moorfields, just outside the City of London, to accommodate Whitefield’s congregation.
Whitefield’s legacy is generally thought to be that of a fervent persuaded, who helped and then left others to build churches out of his converts. Certainly, his letters to Wesley and his entrusting the care of the English societies to Harris in 1749, underline his lack of interest in the administrative task of raising and caring for infant churches. But he founded the English Calvinistic Methodist Connexion, whose first conference met in 1743. This boasted important London chapels, such as Moorfields (above) and the Tabernacle, Tottenham Court Road. These churches, also part of the Countess of Huntingdon’s Connexion, which was strong in the south and west of England. These kept up a distinct existence until they were absorbed into Congregationalism in the nineteenth century. Whitefield’s theology was centred on the old Puritan themes of original sin, justification by faith and regeneration. Sometimes he was militantly Calvinist, but he preached with a rare passion for winning souls for Christ. After 1740, his Calvinistic form of Methodism came into sharp conflict with the Wesleys’ Arminianism, thus opening up a breach that was never healed. His preaching style was dynamic and compelling; he spoke with fervour, yet in a style that was plain, unadorned and often colloquial. His physical bearing commanded attention and the range of his voice was astonishing. Anglican pulpits were often barred to him, his open-air services were often interrupted, and he was a favourite target for anti-Methodist disrupters and propagandists. In many ways, his work complements that of Wesleyan Methodism. In some respects, he was the forerunner of the Wesleys: for example, in his choice of Bristol as a base for evangelism, in daring to preach the open-air, publishing a magazine, founding a school and summoning a conference of preachers.
Pietism, the Moravians and the Wesleys:
The Great Awakening in England was focused largely on the established church and the groups which eventually broke away from it. On the continent of Europe its source in the Pietist movement, which had been cradled in the Dutch Reformed Church in the early seventeenth century. The Pietist revival across the continent re-emphasised the importance of regeneration, personal faith and the warmth of Christian fellowship as a spur to effective missions. Pietism revived the vitality of the Lutheran Church in Germany. One of the more obvious links between German Pietism and the Evangelical Revival lies in the fact that many of the new hymns inspired by the Pietists were translated by the Wesleys and became widely used in England and Wales. Pietism also stimulated missionary concern, which became a prominent feature of the revival in both Britain and America. Through Count von Zinzendorf, Pietism made its impact on the ‘Moravian’ community, who were the spiritual descendants of Jan Hus. Driven from their homeland during the Thirty Years’ War, they were scattered throughout Europe, losing many members. In 1722 a small company of them settled on von Zinzendorf’s estate at Herrnhut in Saxony, which then became a haven for radical Protestant refugees from all parts of Germany as well as from Moravia and Bohemia. Besides the United Brethren, Lutherans, Separatists, Anabaptists and Schwekfelders were also represented. In May 1727, this assortment of traditions came together to accept an apostolic rule of forty-two statutes, so raising again … out of its ashes that ancient Unity of the Moravian Brethren who thereby became the vital leaven of European Protestantism.
Count von Zinzendorf, the founder of the Moravian Church. He laid great stress on the importance of emotions in religious expression and wrote many hymns.
There are clear links between the renewed Moravian community and the Evangelical Revival in England. Most famously, it was a Moravian leader who steered John Wesley towards his dynamic conversion in 1738. The Wesley brothers first met a group of Moravian missionaries on a voyage to Georgia a year earlier, in 1737, on a mission for the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel. They were greatly impressed by the spirituality of the Moravian Brethren. Charles acted as secretary to the governor of the colony, but they were both dissatisfied with the result of their mission and returned to England in 1738. It was another Moravian, Peter Böhler, who was eventually responsible for counselling John Wesley in London as he searched for the assurance of saving faith in Christ. Within three days of each other, each of the brothers had a vital Christian experience, Charles on Whitsunday, and John on 24 May, when his heart was strangely warmed during a meeting at Aldersgate Street when a passage from Luther’s Preface to the Romans was being read. It was an event that has been characterised as the turning point of the Evangelical Revival if not in contemporary English History: What happened in that little room was of more importance to England than all the victories of Pitt by land or sea. And when John wanted to consider the implications of his revolutionary experience, it was to Herrnhut that he went. Many of the features of the Moravian community were taken up by the Wesleyan Methodist societies – for example, the love feast, the watch night and the class meeting. Wesley and Whitefield were both mightily used in the Revival, but much of its inspiration can be traced to the Moravian missionaries. John Wesley was soon to part company with the London Moravians and take a line of his own, but he owed them an incalculable debt. He said of Böhler:
“Oh what a work hath God begun since his coming to England! Such an one as shall never come to an end, till heaven and earth shall pass away!”
A caricature of the state of the eighteenth-century Church of England. William Hogarth illustrates the lifelessness of a sermon. …
Anglicanism & Wesleyan Methodism:
The Anglican church of the eighteenth century, though not as lifeless as William Hogarth’s contemporary pen and ink drawings reveal it to be, certainly stood in urgent need of revitalisation. The seeds of decline had been sown in the previous century which had left those in the established church with an understandable fear of extremes, whether Roman Catholic or Puritan. This resulted in a form of moderation that frowned on passionate convictions of any variety. Most sermons tended to be no more than moral essays at best, or crass homilies at worst. Added to this, the collapse of personal faith led to a slide in moral standards: Permissiveness was the order of the day. The orthodox theologians eventually emerged victorious in their long battle with Deism, but it was sadly ironical that though they had effectively defended the central doctrines of the Christian faith, the new life in Christ these were intended to encourage was nowhere in evidence. A new dynamic was needed, and it was this that theEvangelical Revival supplied, reminding the Church of its own spiritual resources. John Wesley himself spoke candidly about the irreligion of his time: What is the present characteristic of the English nation? he inquired rhetorically, answering, it is ungodliness … our universal, our constant, our peculiar character. The hymn-writer, Isaac Watts, regretted what he called… the decay of vital religion in the hearts and lives of man.
… and its impact on attending parishioners.
John and Charles were born at the rectory at Epworth in Lincolnshire, in 1703 and 1707 respectively. Charles was the eighteenth child in the family. Their father, Samuel Wesley, was a staunch high churchman but their grandparents were nonconformists. Susanna Wesley, their mother, was a remarkable woman whose influence on her sons was exceptionally strong. After attending different schools, Charles at Westminster School, each went up to Oxford, Charles entering Christ Church in 1726, just after John had completed his course there and had been elected a fellow at Lincoln College. It was Charles who started the Holy Club while his elder brother was away from Oxford, serving as his father’s curate. On his return, John took over as leader, though it was Charles who guided the devotional reading of George Whitefield before his conversion. Charles became a tutor at Christ Church in 1729, the same year that what Charles described as the harmless nickname of Methodist was originally applied to the Holy Club. This was because the group aimed to provide a disciplined method of spiritual improvement. Members pledged themselves to have regular private devotions and to meet each evening to read the Bible and pray together. Several labels were invented for them by jeering undergraduates – Enthusiasts, Bible Moths, Sacramentarians – but ‘Methodist’ was the one that stuck.
John Wesley later traced ‘the first rise’ of Methodism to these years. Charles was ordained in 1735 and joined his brother who was evangelising in the colony of Georgia. The second stage, John explained, began in 1736 when ‘the rudiments of a Methodist society’ emerged in Georgia, but by then Charles had returned to England, where he came under the influence of the Moravian missionary, Peter Böhler, and underwent a conversion to the ‘vital religion’ of evangelicalism. He then became an itinerant preacher for most of the rest of his life. Meanwhile, John Wesley helped to reframe the rules for an Anglican society that met in Fetter Lane, London. This came before his revolutionising conversion, just three days after that of his brother. The culmination of these preparative stages, the strange ‘warming’ of John Wesley’s heart on 24 May 1738, undoubtedly provided the most vital stimulus to the movement in England. The Oxford scholar was transformed by the grace of God into ‘the apostle of England’. The Revival had found its true genius. On 1 January 1739, a remarkable ‘Love Feast’ was held at Fetter Lane in London. There the leaders of the Revival were welded into a fellowship of the Spirit in a way similar to what had happened at Herrnhut in 1727. The Wesleys were present, along with Whitefield and Benjamin Ingham, who was to become an outstanding evangelist among the Moravians. John Wesley recorded in his Journal:
About three in the morning, as we were continuing instant in prayer, the power of God came mightily upon us insomuch that many cried out for exceeding joy and many fell to the ground. As soon as we were recovered a little from that awe and amazement at the presence of His majesty, we broke out with one voice, “We praise Thee, O God, we acknowledge Thee to be the Lord.” ‘
This Pentecost on New Year’s Day confirmed that the Awakening had come and launched the campaign of extensive evangelisation which sprang from it. Wesley explained what happened next by stating that it was…
… just at this time … that two or three clergymen of the Church of England began vehemently to “call sinners to repentance”. In two or three years they had sounded the alarm to the utmost borders of the land. Many thousands gathered to hear them, and in every place they came, many began to show such a concern for religion as they had never done before.
It is important to understand that the eighteenth-century revival in England was a work of the Holy Spirit that developed through various channels. There were the Moravian, Calvinistic and Wesleyan missions, which produced the societies which were eventually to evolve into the Methodist Church. In addition to these three strands, there was also a movement within the Church of England which became known as Anglican Evangelicalism. At first, all who were caught up in the spiritual renewal were called either ‘Methodists’ or ‘Evangelicals’, irrespective of which denomination they belonged to. But gradually the Evangelicals became recognised as a formal grouping within the Church of England who were seeking to achieve their aims within its existing framework. Cornwall was the cradle of Anglican Evangelicalism, where Samuel Walker of Truro emerged as the leader of the movement until his death in 1763, but it quickly spread to the rest of the West, to the Midlands, the North, London and East Anglia. The Anglican Evangelicals witnessed particularly effectively at the universities of Oxford and Cambridge.
John Newton (1725-1807), the one-time slave trader turned preacher and hymn-writer was curate of Olney in Buckinghamshire. He was one of the most remarkable figures of the Evangelical Revival, perhaps even its unsung hero. Sent to sea at the age of eleven, after just two years of schooling, at the age of twenty-two he began the captain of a slave ship trading between Britain, the West African coast and the West Indies. Three years later he underwent a dramatic conversion on a voyage across the Atlantic. A violent storm blew up, and Newton spent nine hours manning the pumps and a further seventeen hours at the ship’s wheels as the waves crashed around him. Several times he found himself crying aloud to God for salvation. The storm eventually abated, and Newton later traced the first stirrings of the ‘great change’ that was to turn him towards evangelical religion to his sense of deliverance after his terrible experience. Forsaking the slave trade and his seafaring life, he became friendly with John Wesley and George Whitefield and spent nine years training for the Anglican ministry. In 1764 he was ordained and became curate at Olney, where he remained for sixteen years, then going to London as rector of St Mary Woolnoth, where he remained until his death. ‘Amazing Grace’ first appeared in Olney Hymns in 1779. It reflects Newton’s own intense conversion experience and his profound sense that it was only the overwhelming grace of God that had saved one as wretched as himself from eternal damnation.
An artist’s impression of the ironworks at Colebrookdale in Shropshire, England.
The Wesleys were convinced that at all costs all the people of Britain must hear the good news of salvation. While other clergy confined themselves to their parishes, the brothers believed that their call was to travel from place to place. They preached in churches whenever pulpits were made available to them, but more often, as opposition grew, the only possibility they had was to go out into the marketplace or onto the common, so that the crowds might hear. The result was that the working classes were drawn to Christianity as the Industrial Revolution got underway. It was in the Midlands that the Industrial Revolution made its first impact. Quakers like the ironmaster Abraham Darby at Ironbridge in Coalbrookdale and the potter Josiah Wedgewood sought a lifestyle for their workers which had much in common with the seriousness of life often attributed to Evangelicalism. In fact, it was more a product of the revival of older forms of Puritanism, though it had much in common with the social witness praised by the Evangelical Revival. John Wesley, in particular, began a revolution in morals and behaviour among the working classes which spread to other classes by the beginning of the nineteenth century. The Evangelical Revival witnessed not just a revival of evangelistic activity but also a renewal of concern for Christian morality. The nineteenth-century historian, W. E. H. Lecky credited it with bringing about…
… a great moral revolution in England: it planted a fervid and enduring religious sentiment in the midst of the of the most neglected portions of the population, and whatever may have been its vices or its defects it undoubtedly emancipated great numbers from the fear of death and imparted a warmer tone to the devotion, and a greater energy to the philanthropy of every denomination both in England and the colonies.
Lecky went on to suggest that a major reason why Britain was saved from the ravages of a revolution similar to that in France was this new religious commitment. This idea was taken up by the French historian Elie Halévy who explained the extraordinary stability which English society was destined to enjoy throughout a period of revolutions and crises by reference to the Evangelical Revival. He described this as what we may truly term the miracle of England, … practical and businesslike, but religious, and even pietist. What Halévy saw as providential, Marxist historians have tended to label as a conservative sop for the economically oppressive urban society which emerged early in south Wales, the English midlands and the north of England. But it took the best part of a century for towns like Charles Dickens’ fictional ‘Coketown’ to emerge alongside William Blake’s dark Satanic mills and other historians have suggested that evangelical strength in England was too small at the turn of the eighteenth century either to prevent revolution or to act as a widespread ‘opiate’. Some have also argued that the evangelical emphasis on the ‘evils’ of capitalism can be traced back to John Wesley’s morality:
I fear, wherever riches have increased, the essence of religion has decreased in the same proportion. Therefore I do not see how it is possible, in the nature of things, for any renewal of true religion to continue long. For religion must necessarily produce both industry and frugality, and these cannot but produce riches. But as riches increase, so will pride, anger and the love of the world in all its branches.
Hymns & Spiritual Songs:
In the seventeenth century, hymns were taken or adapted from the work of poets, such as George Herbert and John Milton, and writers such as Richard Baxter and John Bunyan. Late in the century, hymns began to be freely written. Dissenters began to use them in congregational worship, the Baptists being the pioneers. Isaac Watts gave a great boost to the movement for using ‘man-made’ hymns, as distinct from the ‘inspired’ psalms in Scripture. His best-selling Hymns and Spiritual Songs was published in 1707. He followed this in 1715 with Divine Songs for children and in 1719 with The Psalms of David. In this book, he made ‘David speak like a Christian.’ For example, he transformed Psalm 72 into the missionary fervour of ‘Jesus shall reign where’er the sun.’ In over six hundred hymns, many still sung, Watts expressed wonder, praise and adoration covering the range of Christian experience. Another dissenter, Philip Doddridge, composed about 370 hymns, including ‘Hark the glad sound, the Saviour comes.’ The staunch Calvinist, Augustus Toplady, wrote ‘Rock of Ages,’ based on his experience sheltering from a storm in Somerset, lines that have been sung by Christians of all persuasions. This hymn first appeared in a magazine article calculating the ‘National Debt’ in terms of sin. Overshadowing all other eighteenth-century hymn-writers were the Wesley brothers. The Collection of Psalms and Hymns (1737), compiled by John Wesley, was the first successful hymn book compiled for use in the Church of England. John later edited collections for the Methodists, most notably for the definitive Collection (1780). This book contained many of his brother’s compositions and his own paraphrases from German writers such as Zinzendorf. Methodism, like Lutheranism, was ‘born in song.’
This famous hymn first appeared in 1747 but was altered by John for inclusion in his Methodist Hymn Book of 1780
In 1749 Charles Wesley married Sarah (Sally) Gwynne, the daughter of a Welsh magistrate, and made his home in Bristol. For twenty years he supervised the Methodist society which met at the New Room there. He moved to London in 1771 and shared the preaching at City Road Chapel. He has been described as the most gifted and untiring hymn writer that England has ever known. He crafted over six thousand hymns and sacred songs out of a total of nine thousand poems, so it is remarkable that so many reached such a high standard. All of them were written after his conversion to vital religion in 1738. His first hymn was And Can It Be That I Should Gain, composed just hours after he had made ‘the great change’. It was first published in his brother’s Psalms and Hymns of the same year and there is a strong probability that John sang the hymn on the evening of his own conversion, three days after his brother’s. Charles Wesley’s ‘Love Divine (right), All Loves Excelling’ expresses his doctrine of perfectionism. It suggests that Christ can transform us into children of God and that in this life it is possible to be cleansed completely from sin and made pure. Many Christians, including his brother John, have baulked at this idea and toned down the words to suggest a slightly less sweeping doctrine of sanctification.
In his hymnbook, John Wesley altered the third line of the fourth verse to ‘Pure and spotless let us be’ to avoid suggesting that Christians could achieve sinless perfection in this world. He also omitted the second verse of the hymn. All subsequent hymnbooks have followed these changes and some have also altered the second line of the third verse to ‘Let us all thy grace receive’. Hymn singing made an enormous contribution to the Evangelical Revival. The songs had at least as great an effect as the sermons. They not only expressed the joys of the Christian experience but also taught the truths of Scripture. Charles Wesley has been rightly described as the prince of English hymn-writers. His hymns are marked by a constant note of praise, for example, O for a thousand tongue to sing and Rejoice, the Lord is King. He praised God because he was amazed at his love, as in Jesu, Lover of my soul. Watts and Doddridge freely paraphrased Scripture. In addition, Charles Wesley paraphrased the Prayer Book and verified Christian doctrine and experience. In 1779, the fiery, converted slave-trader John Newton and the gentle, retiring melancholic poet, William Cowper, produced the Olney Hymns. Newton wrote Glorious things of thee are spoken and Amazing Grace! How sweet the sound. John Wesley called the Methodist Hymn Book of 1780 a little body of experimental and practical divinity.
However, in the Church of England hymn-singing was long considered to be incompatible with Prayer Book worship which, in conjunction with choral music (shown below), continued to be the dominant form for another forty years. As late as 1819, Thomas Cotterill, a Sheffield vicar, was charged by a church court for using a hymn-book in services. The test case which followed led to hymn-singing being more or less legally accepted in the Church of England.
Above and Below: The Village Choir by Thomas Webster (1800-1886). The Art Archive/ Victoria & Albert Musem/ Sally Chappell.
The Apostle to the Nation:
When, as a result of his conversion, John Wesley became an apostle to the nation, he was soon faced with the problem of caring for the converts. To meet their needs, a Methodist organisation was called into being. John Wesley found societies already operating in Bristol, but in London, he was pressed to devise one of his own for those who had listened to his outdoor preaching at Moorfields. When numbers increased to about a hundred, Wesley noted their names and addresses, intending to visit each of them in their homes. He wrote in his ‘Journal’:
Thus, without any previous plan or design, began the Methodist society in England – a company of people associating together to help each other work out their own salvation.
The early successes of the Methodist preachers are often explained both by the carelessness of the many Anglican churchmen and the fact that the Church of England had very little strength in the newly urbanised parts of the country. Methodism began, not as a church or a sect, but as societies. It was born and was expected to remain, within the Church of England. From the start, John Wesley assumed that the Methodists would attend Anglican services and sacraments. He himself had no desire to break away from the established church and consistently urged his followers to stand by it, despite the opposition he met from within the societies, especially in the early years of his ministry. The title ‘United Society’ was probably borrowed from the Moravians. It indicated that even though societies multiplied throughout the country, they were regarded as parts of one national association. By 1743 Wesley was referring to the ‘United Societies’ in the plural; they were soon organised into a ‘Connexion’. Only after his death did the Methodist ‘Church’ emerge.
The parent Methodist society in London was gathered late in 1739 and met in a disused cannon-foundry. This was the headquarters of Methodism until the opening of City Road Chapel in 1778. The society included ‘voluntary bands’, select groups of up to ten Methodists supervised by a leader. In one aspect, the foundry society was unique. The sole condition for prospective members was a desire to flee from the wrath to come, to be saved from their sins. The existing religious societies were restricted to those already attached to the Anglican church, or in full communion with it, such as the Moravians. Wesley refused to impose any such ecclesiastical test and opened his new society to nonconformists too. This openness was a mark of Methodism from its origins. In 1742 the ‘class meeting’ system was introduced, which turned out to be of unspeakable usefulness, as Wesley recognised. The name was simply from the Latin word classis, meaning ‘division’ (in a specific sense), and had no connotations either of school or, at that time, social divisions. The classes were rather larger than the bands and involved every member of the society. Their original purpose was to encourage Christian stewardship since each member gave a penny a week to the funds. Then Wesley realised that the leaders were the persons who may not only receive the contributions but also watch over the souls of their brethren. The class system thus played an important role in securing discipline as well as providing fellowship and pastoral care.
In the following year, 1743, Wesley took another step by drawing a common set of rules for all his societies, for Methodism was by then a nationwide organisation in Britain as a whole. In 1744, the first Conference was held to consider the best method of carrying on the work of God throughout the lands. The Connexion was organised in a series of circuits, or peachers’ rounds. The earliest printed list of circuits, published in 1746, included seven: London, Bristol, Cornwall, Evesham, Yorkshire (covering seven counties), Newcastle and Wales. The circuits were placed under the control of ‘Assistants’ to Wesley, who were recruited from the more experienced itinerant preachers. They were responsible in the absence of the parish ‘Minister’ to feed and guide, to teach and govern the flock, and to lead the team of preachers in each circuit. From the beginning, the oversight of Methodism was entrusted to these Assistants, later called Superintendents, although their authority was always subject to that of Wesley and the Conference. The Assistants were sometimes backed up by a limited number of Anglican clergymen who were prepared to devote some part of their time to itinerate preaching for the Methodists.
In addition to the travelling preachers, both clergy and lay, others who were ‘on the spot’ shared in proclaiming the Word as local lay preachers, including some women. Of these the most notable was Mary Bosanquet Fletcher (1739 – 1815), one of the first female Methodist preachers, credited with persuading John Wesley, to allow women to preach in public. She was born into an affluent family, but after converting to Methodism, rejected its luxurious life. She was involved in charity work throughout her life, operating a school and orphanage until her marriage. She and a friend, Sarah Crosby, began preaching and leading meetings at her orphanage and they became the most popular female preachers of their time. Bosanquet was known as a “Mother in Israel”, a Methodist term of honour, for her work in spreading the denomination across England. Her husband was John William Fletcher (1729-85), a fellow Methodist who was Vicar of Madeley, in Shropshire. The couple had a joint ministry in the parish in the eighteenth century.
Preachers and members alike were committed to what John Wesley referred to as ‘our doctrines’. The basic theological conviction of the Methodists was that justification by faith is the doctrine of the church as well as the Bible. To this was added a specific emphasis that salvation is for all, and stress on the assurance of the Holy Spirit and scriptural holiness. Whitefield disagreed with Wesley’s belief in universal grace, founding the Calvinistic Methodist Connexion, as detailed above. But the two men kept in communication and helped each other from time to time. Methodism continued to spread rapidly throughout England over the next decade and Ireland, first visited by Wesley in 1747, also became a stronghold of Wesleyan Methodism. In Wales, Calvinistic Methodism prevailed, especially in the Welsh-speaking areas. Only in Scotland did Methodism fail to make much ground, though there the Evangelical Revival made its mark on the Presbyterian Church of Scotland.
The major figure in the founding of American Methodism was Francis Asbury, who came from Handsworth near Birmingham and had been apprenticed to an iron smelter before joining the ranks of Wesley’s itinerant preachers. In 1771 he responded to the call to assist in America, and he urged his colleagues there to press to the frontiers in their evangelism. Many of Wesley’s transatlantic preachers returned to England during the War of Independence, but Asbury remained and, in 1784, became one of Wesley’s superintendents there. When the Methodists adopted the title, Methodist Episcopal Church, Asbury became a bishop. This amounted to a declaration of independence. Meanwhile, in England and Wales, 1784, Methodist preaching places became licensed under the Toleration Act of 1787 and following John Wesley’s death in 1791, in 1795 the Methodist Conference took the decision to secede from the Church of England. By the end of the century, the Methodist Church was in a position to spread across the world.
Three groups emerged from the Evangelical Revival in the eighteenth century: the Methodists, separated from the Church of England after John Wesley’s death; the Calvinists, successors to George Whitefield and the Countess of Huntingdon; and the Evangelical Anglicans, of whom the key figures were Samuel Walker of Truro, Henry Venn of Huddersfield and John Newton of Olney. The Methodists believed that Christ died for all men, some of whom might attain Christian perfection in this life. The Calvinists, led by Thomas Haweis, believed that Christ died only for the Elect, and stressed that human nature was fallen in every aspect, ‘total depravity.’ The Anglican Evangelicals believed that Christ died for the whole world; they also believed in ‘total depravity,’ and shared with both the other groups the assurance that their sins were forgiven. They also held that, through Christian missions, the whole of humanity would eventually come to faith in Christ. At that time Christ would return and the millennium would begin. These were the beliefs of the group of influential evangelicals who became known as the Clapham Sect, who also became founder members of the Church Missionary Society, the British and Foreign Bible Society and The Religious Tract Society. They drew away from the Calvinists and nearer to the Methodists, as they emphasised universal grace. On the other hand, they rejected the Wesleys’ doctrine of Christian perfection. They also supported the parish system and objected to the tendency of the Methodists to establish their own churches in evangelical parishes.
The Evangelical Passion for Social Justice:
The overall effects of the eighteenth-century ‘Awakening’ are difficult to quantify or evaluate. Nominal members of the church who ‘had the form of godliness without the power’ were turned into evangelical Christians. Many thousands who before had made no claim to be Christians were swept into the kingdom of heaven throughevangelism which sprang from the Revival. The clergy were reformed and re-energised and set a new, high standard of pastoral care. The ‘Awakening’ also led to the creation of agencies aimed at promoting Christian work; these are detailed below. Perhaps most importantly, in a period of rapid changes in economic and social conditions, the Revival encouraged a passion for social justice. Wesley advocated prison reform and encouraged John Howard in his crusade for this. He had a practical concern for the poor and contributed personally to their relief as well as raising funds. He saw to it that through his societies clothing was distributed and food provided for the needy. Dispensaries were set up to treat the sick. In London, one Methodist meeting room was turned into a workshop for carding and spinning cotton. Other jobs were created for the unemployed. A lending bank was opened by Christians in 1746 and legal advice and aid were also made available. Widows and orphans were housed. The Christian concern for the underprivileged led to the birth of the Benevolent or Strangers’ Friend Societies in 1787. They quickly established themselves as agencies of poor relief and bridged the gap until finally, the state took over. The Evangelical Revival made England aware of its social obligations.
The campaign to banish slavery from British colonies was led by men of evangelical convictions. In 1767, Grenville Sharp fought a case in the law courts to ensure that a slave should be freed whenever he set foot on English territory. William Wilberforce was educated at St John’s College, Cambridge and became MP for his home town of Hull in 1780 and then MP for Yorkshire in 1784, a seat which held until 1812. During a continental tour in 1784-85, he underwent a spiritual crisis which he emerged from as a believer in ‘real Christianity’ centred on Christ’s redeeming work. His conversion, while on the tour with Isaac Milner, ‘the Evangelical Dr Johnson,’ who became President of Queens College, Cambridge, gave Wilberforce the dynamism to lead the campaign against the slave trade, for which he is best known. He had abominated this since the age of fourteen but was encouraged by John Wesley, among other evangelicals, to make its abolition his mission. Wesley had expressed his humanitarian motives in his Thoughts upon Slavery (1775) in which he wrote that…
Liberty is the right of every human creature, as soon as he breathes vital air and no human law can deprive him of that right, which he derives from the law of nature.
By this time, people had also begun to question the assumption that the plantation colonies were essential to Britain’s prosperity. Here, for example, the British economist Adam Smith points out how expensive it was for Britain to defend these colonies:
The expense of the ordinary peace establishment of the colonies amounted … to the pay of twenty regiments of foot, … to the expense of a very considerable naval force which was constantly kept up, in order to guard, from the smuggling vessels of other nations, the immense coast of North America, and that of our West Indian islands. The whole expense of this peace establishment was a charge upon the revenue of Great Britain, and was, at the same time, the smallest part of what the colonies has cost the mother country. …
The Wealth of Nations (1776)
However, for many of the individual plantation owners, their profits were worth protecting, so the overall economic cost of the colonies was a price worth paying. Therefore, despite the claims of recent historians, macro-economic motives were not enough to end the Slave Trade. Religious and humanitarian motives played a significant role in ending it in a campaign lasting more than two decades and in sustaining the subsequent campaign for the Abolition of Slavery in the British Empire which occurred a quarter of a century later, in 1833, in the teeth of the fierce resistance of the sugar planters and merchants.
Thomas Clarkson had submitted a prize-winning essay on slavery in 1785, while still at St John’s College, Cambridge, Wilberforce’s alma mater, where Clarkson himself had been influenced by evangelicals. It was he who first persuaded Wilberforce to take up the issue of slavery in Parliament. From 1789 on, Wilberforce frequently moved parliamentary resolutions against the British slave trade. Only four days before his death in 1791, John Wesley penned a now-famous letter to Wilberforce, urging him to…
“… go on, in the name of God, and in the power of his might, till even American slavery (the vilest that ever saw the sun) shall vanish away before it.”
A mark of Wilberforce’s personal commitment and determination is that even after the eventual formal abolition of the British slave trade in 1807, Wilberforce continued to press for the enforcement of the ban and for European agreement to prohibit the trade.
A Revolution in Morals:
In Britain, the Wesleyans helped to bring brought about a revolution in morals and behaviour among the labouring classes. This revolution spread to other classes at the beginning of the nineteenth century through the writings of William Wilberforce (1759-1833) and his friend, Hannah More. She wrote simple moral tales, in colloquial English, and her tracts were delivered door-to-door by salesmen, very cheaply. They circulated in huge numbers and many were read at court and by the upper classes. For England’s privileged classes, meanwhile, William Wilberforce wrote his (1797) book, A Practical View of the Prevailing Religious System of Professed Christians in the Higher and Middle Classes in this Country contrasted with Real Christianity. In it, he commented on the increase in prosperity and luxury of the age, the growth of new cities, and the decline of religion, manners and morals. He reminded the rich of their duties to the poor and claimed that the only remedy for their greed and selfishness was to turn from their nominal Christianity to the real Christianity to be found in personal commitment. Several thousand copies were sold in the first six months following publication, and few books of its kind have been more influential. The new wealthy classes became more conscious of their responsibilities and some of the coarseness and cruelty which had marred social life in the eighteenth century disappeared in favour of a cult of ‘respectability’. ‘Victorian values’ arrived among the English middle classes twenty years before Victoria came to the throne. Of course, this was not the same as Wilberforce’s ‘real Christianity’ and hypocrisy soon replaced corruption as the typical sin of the age.
William Hogarth’s sketch of a woman at worship in the Anglican Church.
Early evangelicals believed neither in democracy nor trade unions, however. The French Revolution had frightened them away from such radical ideas. They were determined to do what they could for the poor, but in a paternalistic manner that would not allow the working classes to claim liberty for themselves. ‘The mainstream party’ continued the tradition of the Clapham Sect. Henry Venn was among their leaders, and their journal, which stressed loyalty to the established church, was the monthly Christian Observer, started in 1802. But in spite of theological differences in such a broad movement, there was no open rift but a continuing commitment to accommodate every kind of evangelical society and every kind of evangelical. As the leader of the Clapham Sect in Parliament, Wilberforce also helped to open India to missionaries and to protect popular travelling evangelists in Britain from government interference. He had supported repressive statutes between 1795 and 1812 in his concern to preserve constitutional order, but he was in favour of moderate parliamentary reform and relief for boy chimney-sweeps. Like Wesley, Wilberforce also advocated prison reform. Wilberforce influenced prominent politicians quietly but persuasively, particularly his friend William Pitt, who became Prime Minister, using charm, tact and eloquence in a political life to which he was sure he had been called by God.
The Impact of the Evangelical Revival on the Baptists:
The English Baptists were in no position to benefit immediately from the new lease of life represented by the Great Awakening. But several distinct movements did redirect its impact onto the Baptists. First, a group of working people in Leicestershire who had been evangelised by one of the Countess of Huntingdon’s servants came, independently, to Baptist convictions in 1755. Dan Taylor, a Yorkshire miner, converted among the Methodists, similarly came to Baptist convictions by his own study of the subject of believer’s baptism. He sought out the General Baptists of Lincolnshire to be baptised. Eventually, the Leicestershire group and Dan Taylor’s church joined together with a few General Baptist churches that remained orthodox formed the New Connexion of General Baptists in 1770. These churches prospered in the emerging industrial communities of central England, the textile communities of Lancashire and Yorkshire, and the hosiery and lace-making areas of the East Midlands. New life came to the Particular Baptists when, in 1785, Andrew Fuller of Kettering published The Gospel Worthy of all Acceptation. He proved that Calvinism itself, as distinct from the “false Calvinism” that was common in the eighteenth century, was essentially a missionary theology. This expressed systematically the doubts that a number of ministers had about the prevailing hyper-Calvinism. The Baptists, as a whole, went through their own form of rebirth in the eighteenth century. Their life from that time represents a debate between Puritanism and Evangelicalism. The General Baptists who opposed Dan Taylor’s ‘enthusiasm’ lapsed into Unitarianism; the Particular Baptists who rejected the correcting force of the Evangelical Revival and allowed only their own members to the communion table became the ‘Strict Baptists’.
William Carey’s Call to Mission:
By the 1780s, many Christians in all Protestant denominations were feeling that the signs of revival in Protestant countries foreshadowed an extension of gospel preaching to the whole world. It was the Baptists from the English Midlands who first formed an effective organization, as The Particular Baptist Society for the Propagation of the Gospel, which later became The Baptist Missionary Society. Fuller completed his book in 1781 but hesitated four years before publishing it. In 1784 he was able to apply the thought of the American theologian, Jonathan Edwards, to the English religious scene. The message of The Gospel Worthy of All Acceptation not only revived the churches at home but also gave British evangelicals a worldwide vision. Others too were influenced by the Awakening. Fuller’s colleague, John Sutcliff, issued a Call to Prayer to the Northamptonshire Baptists:
“Let the whole interest of the Redeemer be affectionately remembered and the spread of the Gospel to the most distant parts of the habitable globe be the object of your most fervent requests.”
William Carey (1761-1834) was the archetypal untiring pioneer missionary whose many-sided work in India included Bible translation and production, evangelism, church planting, education, and medical relief, as well as social reform, and linguistic and horticultural research. By the 1790s, Baptists, Arminian Methodists, impeccable Anglican churchmen, and ardent dissenters and seceders in England and Scotland were seeking to use means for the conversion of heathens as Carey himself put it. But with the rarest exceptions, such interests reached only those Protestant denominations touched by the Evangelical Revival. For the first two or three decades of the missionary movement, interest in missions was restricted to the Evangelicals. The Revival revolutionized preaching and its objectives. The clergyman’s task was viewed in traditional terms as that of nurturing the seed of faith planted at baptism in virtually all members of his parish. This concept could not easily transfer and adjust to preaching the gospel in a tribal society. Added to this, people who inherited a rigid hyper-Calvinist doctrine of predestination in which God made up his elect, saw no reason to concern themselves with why there seemed to be no elect in India or China. But the evangelicals saw preaching as calling sinners to God through faith and felt a personal responsibility to do this. They saw no difference in principle between ‘baptized heathen’ in Britain and in non-Christian peoples overseas.
As a direct consequence of this message, and out of the general renewal of Baptist life came the founding of the Baptist Missionary Society in October 1792. It was the first foreign missionary society created by the Evangelical Revival. William Carey and John Thomas became the Society’s first representatives abroad, while Andrew Fuller, with John Ryland of Bristol, John Sutcliff of Olney, and Samuel Pearce of Birmingham, supported them at home. Carey was born at Paulerspury in Northamptonshire, the son of a parish clerk and schoolmaster. In 1779 he was converted through a fellow apprentice shoemaker, becoming a dissenter, and was baptized as a believer in 1783. After some local preaching, Carey became pastor of Moulton Baptist Chapel in 1786, supporting himself through teaching and shoemaking. In 1789 he became pastor at the important but divided Baptist church at Harvey Lane, Leicester. In 1792, Carey published An Enquiry into the Obligation of Christians to use Means for the Conversion of the Heathen. In it, he argued that Christ’s great commission was to preach the gospel to every creature still applied to all Christians. In the same year, in a sermon in Nottingham, he preached the importance of mission with the stirring words:
“Expect great things from God: attempt great things for God.”
Foremost among the first fruits of the Evangelical Revival were the missionary organisations which multiplied at the end of the century. The Baptist Missionary Society was just the first of these, in 1792. Carey and his family sailed to India in the following year, 1793, devoting the rest of his life to taking the gospel to the country. He became foreman of an Indigo factory in Bengal (1794-99), a post that occupied him only three months of the year, leaving him free to study oriental languages intensively for the rest of the year. In 1799 he was joined by two fellow Baptists, Joshua Marsham and William Ward. For the next quarter-century, the three men worked together to form a growing network of mission stations in and beyond Bengal. Carey translated the New Testament into Bengali and was given a tutorship in languages at Fort William College in 1801. In the years up to his death in 1824, Carey supervised six complete and twenty-four partial translations of the Bible as well as publishing several grammars, dictionaries, and translations of eastern books. Although some of his early translations were hurried and stilted, his work was an immense achievement for a largely self-educated pioneer.
William Carey, untiring English Baptist pioneer missionary. Baptist Missionary Society.
Two scenes from an unpublished typescript by Rev. Arthur J. Chandler (Birmingham, c. 1965).
Scene One: – The Founding of the BMS (Baptist Missionary Society).
The parlour of Widow Wallis’s Home, Kettering, October 2nd, 1792:
John Timms: Do come through, Mr Fuller and brethren. Mrs Wallis has asked me to do the honours tonight. She is far from well. I am afraid the loss of her husband is still keenly felt. She bids me make you welcome and to say how pleased she is to put her home at your disposal for your Minister’s Meeting tonight.
Fuller: For twenty years now, brethren, this house has afforded gracious hospitality to the Lord’s servants. Little wonder it should have come to be known among us as ‘Gospel Inn’.
Carey: What a lovely and heart-warming welcome – and on such a night! The wind is in the east and there is a nip in the air. It’s been a sombre day, a bad day, with the sky all sables. But our meetings today have set our spirits aglow. Thank you, brother Timms.
(Timms leaves)
Fuller: A good brother. Already he is proving a fine substitute on our Diaconate for our brother, Beeby Wallis. A younger man, but quite promising. …
(They finally seat themselves)
… Brother Ryland, if I may make so bold, may I say how grateful your brethren are for your sermon this morning. You had a grand text: “I will work and who shall hinder it?” (Isaiah. 43: 15). It seems to me, and to many of us, that you have run your flag to the masthead. May I and Carey take it that you have committed yourself to the contemplated venture?
Ryland: I gladly confess, my dear Andrew, that since brother Carey’s magnificent utterance in Friar Lane, Nottingham, this May – together with your logical reasoning since I find myself with no other attitude. “Get up,” he said. “Find larger canvas, stouter and taller poles, stronger tent pegs. Dare bolder programmes. Dwell in an ampler world. Thy Maker is thy Husband. He is Lord of the whole earth”. Brethren, my rigid theory of Predestination has further been thawed by the fire of love which Samuel Pearce has this day cast in all our hearts. Bristol trained you well, Samuel.
Sutcliff: Two things impress me as I look around our group. As a Bristol man, I rejoice in the presence with us of other sons of the College: Samuel Pearce, of Cannon Street, Birmingham; Thomas Blundel, of Arnsby; and young Staughton there is just finishing his course at Bristol. And you, Doctor John, just about to consent to be its Principal. Bristol is in good evidence this night.
Ryland: And the second thing, brother Sutcliff?
Sutcliff: That is that it is young men, as Joel said it would be, who have caught the vision. I am forty; Ryland thirty-nine, Fuller thirty-eight; Carey, thirty-one; Pearce, twenty-six. The young men are not ‘sitting down.’
Fuller: And, as the world judges, there is little or no respectability amongst us … not so much as a squire to take the chair! But I move that we ask John Ryland to keep us in order!
All: Agreed!
Ryland: Thank you, brethren. But first, prayer:
‘O God, who hast promised to give Thy Son the heathen for His inheritance, and the uttermost parts of the earth for His possession, guide our thoughts and strengthen our wills to do Thine own.
Behold at Thy Commanding Word,
We stretch the curtain and the cord!
Amen.
I take it, Andrew, that our chief business now is to consider the shaping of The Plan, according to the Nottingham instruction? As I look around this circle it occurs to me that not half of you were present at Nottingham. You did not hear Carey’s sermon, or our brother Fuller’s ‘twelfth hour’ prevailing appeal. So I will ask Fuller to read the Nottingham ‘Instruction’, which he then proposed and which we passed before we dispersed that Thursday noon.
Fuller:(unfolds and reads). ‘Resolved that a plan be prepared against the next Minsters’ Meeting at Kettering, for forming a Baptist Society for propagating the Gospel among the Heathens’.
Ryland: How far has the Plan been shared? And can we here bring the project to life?
Pearce: We must, Dr Ryland, we must. One of my deacons, Thomas Potts, a wealthy manufacturer of Livery Street, Birmingham, has just returned from a visit to America, that country of unimaginable vastness to which he exports goods. (You will remember Potts as the man who financed the publishing of Carey’s ‘Enquiry’). Thomas has given us moving accounts of the need for the Red Indians and Negroes there. These are our brethren, for whom Christ died – whatever the colour of their skin. They must know the love of God in Jesus Christ our Lord. And Carey is more expert than any of us on the appalling degradation of the vast continent of India. I am sure the necessary financial support would be forthcoming. Potts will be generous.
Joshua Burton: I wish I could pledge some financial support from Foxton. But neither there nor at Roads, where brother Heighton ministers, do our members number twenty-five. And at Thrapston – as Reynold Hogg will tell you – we are too few for a far formation of a Church. Ours are little flocks. Are we not too inland and isolated to direct such an overseas effort? Ought not the greater centres and churches to take the initiative and shoulder the burden?
Reynold Hogg: Little flocks we may be. Indeed, the one flock is a little flock, but we have not forgotten the words of the Great Shepherd: ‘Fear not, little flock, it is your Father’s good pleasure to give you the Kingdom.’ Brethren, cannot the Lord save by the few as well as by the many? Since when was the battle to the strong? It is the lame who take the prey. God still chooses the weak things and the things that are not to pull down the strongholds of Satan. We are looking at God through our difficulties, whereas we should be looking at our difficulties through God. Humble pastors! Gathered in a lean-to parlour we may be, but may not our line go out through all the earth, and our influence to the end of the world?
Fuller: Thank you, Reynold. Brethren – Must Carey tug at my sleeve again this night and ask: ‘Is nothing again to be done, sir?’ God forbid!
Ryland: Brother Carey, Nottingham transformed your spirit of heaviness into a robe of praise. I hope you still wear it?
Carey: I believe that God ordains the end, but I also believe, with equal intensity that He ordains the means for achieving that end. I am certain that he has chosen this group to bring into existence a Baptist Society for the propagation of the Gospel among the Heathen. Ere tomorrow dawns, our fears will disperse like morning due before the rising sun. I know Whom I have believed. The good work He has begun in all our hearts will not be left unfinished. Courage, timid souls!
(He holds out his copy of the latest issue of the Periodical Accounts).
See what the Moravians are daring, and some of them, British like ourselves, and many only artisans and poor. Cannot we Baptists at least ATTEMPT something in fealty to the same Lord?
(A deadly hush, broken only at long last by the voice of Ryland).
Ryland: Brother Andrew, you have prepared a resolution. I believe that under the urge of Carey’s challenge we have all of us hushed our fears. If I discern aright, we are all constrained to commit ourselves. Will you read the resolution?
Fuller: ‘Humbly desirous of making an effort for the propagation of the Gospel among the heathen, according to the recommendations of Carey’s ‘Enquiry’ we unanimously resolve to act in Society together for this purpose; and, as in the divided state of Christendom each domination, by exerting itself separately, seems likeliest to accomplish the great end, we name this The Particular Baptist Society for the Propagation of the Gospel among the heathen.
Ryland: Do you so unanimously resolve?
All: We do so unanimously resolve. Aye. We will, God helping us, … (etc.)
Ryland: ‘And the Lord hearkened and heard, and a Book of Remembrance was written before him.’
Our next step is to choose an executive. Will you give me some names?
All: Andrew Fuller … John Ryland … William Carey … John Sutcliff … Reynold Hogg.
Ryland: I am sure that each of us is willing to serve?
(They all nod in assent)
Ryland: Can you elect these men?
(All show hands)
Ryland: And now, a Secretary and a Treasurer.
Pearce: I am just the visiting preacher for the day, but I know I voice the desire of all in nominating our brother Andrew Fuller as Secretary.
All: Agreed.
John Ayres: And I echo what is in all our hearts in proposing that we ask Reynold Hogg to be the Treasurer – in recognition of his whole-souled missionary zeal.
All: Agreed.
Abraham Greenwood: None of us is rich. I am in grave anxiety at Oakham. But I move that we take up from among ourselves an Offering. If we do not have not the cash in our pockets then we will write out our promises on paper.
Ryland: Timms! Can you come, please?
Timms: Sir, you called?
Ryland: Will you provide us with a receptacle for the first gifts to Modern Missions.
Timms: I will go and get something, Master Ryland if you will excuse me a moment.
Fuller: Stay, John! We will use my snuff box. A queer offering plate you may think, yet it has a fitness and odour of sanctity of its own. Impressed upon its lid is a representation of St Paul’s conversion – a miniature replica of the very scene in the pediment of St Paul’s Cathedral. We will pass it around quietly thanking God for the Great Apostle to the Gentiles, the man who brought the Gospel to Europe.
(Round it goes)
Ryland: It is good you remained, John. A deacon shall count the offering and tell us the amount given or promised.
(All remain silent and still as John quickly tots up. His face aglow, his voice trembling with emotion. John Timms speaks…)
Timms: Thirteen pounds, two shillings, and sixpence.
Ryland: Kettering has immortalised itself this night!
…
Scene Two: The Founding of the Baptist Union, 25th June 1812.
07:45 a.m. Outside Carter Lane Chapel, London.
Tom: Quarter to eight in the morning … I wonder what that group of men is doing outside Dr Rippon’s Church. … Black your shoes, your honour? They don’t want their shoes blacking. Look how worn and patched they are. How carefully they are avoiding the big muddy puddle! Bad for trade – very bad …
Hello! this is a very fine carriage drawing up at the door. Somebody’s getting out. I know him – cleaned his boots many a time. He always says “Thank you” and in such a kind way, too, as if he’s been done an honour! And he really believes the labourer is worthy of his hire!
He is greeting the other men. From what I can hear they have come from all parts of the country. Now they are moving into the chapel. … more of them are coming along the street. Ah! Here comes Dr Rippon’s coachman.
Coachman: ‘Op off! It’s no good you hanging about. Their boots won’t be any dirtier when they come out.
Tom: What are they all doing in there? Singing hymns?
Coachman: No. There won’t be any hymns this morning – they might finish up with one – but it will be mostly speeches. Funny, coming from all over England to listen to speeches. They go on for hours!
Tom: Seems a dull affair to me. Who are they? What are they talking about?
Coachman: They’re all Baptist ministers, and they’ve come to London for a special meeting. You saw some of them waiting here … you should have seen them arrive. They’ve been travelling all night on the tops of stagecoaches. … Looked like proper country bumpkins, I can tell you, but they couldn’t afford to travel any better.
Tom: But are all Baptist ministers poor? Dr Rippon isn’t. He’s got plenty of money, hasn’t he?
Coachman: O, he’s the richest baptist minister in London, but he’s earned it writing books. Gives heaps away. He’s paying for breakfast for the whole sixty of them this morning.
Tom: Makes me feel hungry. Any idea what they will have?
Coachman: Oh, Pidgeon pie, mutton chops, pig’s trotters for the Northerners, and all the trimmings. … he’s taken over this meeting. My wife’s his cook, and she says there’s been such comings and goings … he’s written hundreds of letters here; they are everywhere, arranging for them to come, finding places for them to stay. He says he’s going to do it every year. He must be keen about his ‘idea’.
Tom: What idea?
Coachman: You’ll grow into the shape of a question mark if you ask any more questions. Leave a fellow alone for a bit, can’t yer?
Tom: (Aside) No good asking him anymore … I’ll climb up to that window and see what’s going on.
(Tom does so)
Lights on Assembly inside the Chapel.
Button: The wave of sympathy which has spread throughout the country, since we had news of the fire at Serampore, shows no sign of diminishing. I hear that large sums are still arriving and that some have come from members of other communions.
First Minister: The rebuilding of the Press won’t give back the Manuscripts which Carey has lost. The work of years destroyed in a few hours.
Second Minister: Here he is!
Iviney: Who?
Second Minister: Dr Rippon.
Iviney: Here comes brother Rippon. Let us compose ourselves for the Meeting.
Ryland: Brethren, Dr Rippon has asked me to offer a prayer:
(All rise and stand with bowed heads)
“Almighty God, who didst brood over the separate and conflicting atoms of creation and hush them into silence, bring order out of chaos and for wild confusion give peace, who didst in fellowship so much as to create Man in thine own image; who didst give him a help-meet, since it is not good for man to dwell alone; we pray Thee to brood by Thy Spirit over the churches of our faith and order in this beloved land and welt them ever closer together in love and purpose. Grant us Thy blessing in our deliberations and if it pleases Thee, may the outcome of today’s assembly means that we shall henceforth no longer be isolated units, but a communion of saints, dwelling in brotherly concord. Then Thou wilt accord the blessing. May it be so. For thy glory.”
All: Amen.
(Ministers resume seats)
Iviney:Brethren, I understand that by common consent you desire to call Dr Rippon to the chair.
All: Aye, we do.
Rippon: Thank you, brethren. Our duty at this hour is to look forward, but I take one glimpse back and begin by thanking our brothers Fuller and Ryland for the eloquent missionary sermons of yesterday. I rejoice with you all that at that meeting three hundred and twenty pounds was subscribed.
Several: A goodly sum.
Rippon: Now to the business in hand. I need hardly remind you that we are living in a period of Societies, formed for a definite purpose. Partnerships in commerce have grown into common-law Companies with hundreds of members. In France, the non-privileged classes have developed political clubs to aim at reform.
Austin: Hear, hear! May the Lord prosper their efforts!
Rippon: While not desirous of damping our brother’s enthusiasm, I think I should point out that James Butterworth of Bromsgrove and others of our men have rendered themselves obnoxious to the ‘Church and King Party’ by uttering honest convictions about the French Revolution. I am merely reciting facts and using illustrations – I have no desire to arouse your passions!
(Thus having delivered this mild rebuke, he goes on…)
I sometimes feel… As it is, we cannot speak with a united voice to other religious Societies…
Minister: Are you suggesting, Dr Rippon, that we should become one only in order that we may, later on, become part of some super Church?
Rippon: No. Not that. Not that at all. That is not my understanding of our Lord’s words, That they may be one, but I would not try to limit the truth of God to my poor Baptist reach of mind!
Member: We quite understand your own position, Dr Rippon, and some of us stand with you, but unless we make ourselves crystal clear we run the risk of being misunderstood by our people. And you know how suspicious of London the rest of the country is – especially our members in Lancashire and Yorkshire, who would not easily give up the Independence of the local congregation.
Rippon: Let me be specific … Let me enumerate the advantages of a Union:
“The production of reports from the Churches; Support for the academies and the students; Support for our ministers and a proper scheme for their settlement; Education for the children of deceased ministers; Village preaching; The maintenance of Sunday Schools; Literature; New Church Buildings… “
These are but a few of the objects which should press themselves on our consideration, brethren.
Minister: Mr Chairman, I have here, on the fly-leaf of my Bible – so highly do I prize it – a cutting from an 1811 Baptist magazine. The writer puts my desires so well, that I have pasted it here. May I read it, sir?
Rippon: I think I know the article to which you refer. If I guess accurately, the author of it – present with us now – will, I know, not object to your giving his wise words wider publicity.
Minister: “We are anxious to see such a Union prevail in our denomination as well most effectually combine all our efforts in the Cause of Truth and Righteousnessat home, and give ten-fold vigour to our exertions on behalf of our efforts abroad.”
All:Amen.
Rippon: I would say ‘Amen’ a thousand times if that would do it. I say ‘So be it’ indeed, But it will take more than pious ejaculations to bring it about – valuable as these are. But it can be done if you sixty are ready to join with me in turning this dream into fact.
Thomas Thomas:Mr Chairman: Our brother has quoted from the Baptist Magazine. May I (he takes out a cutting) read from a newspaper I have received? It certainly contains a full account of the Meeting of our North Welsh Association which advocated such a Union to be desired, they thought, and to which the Association pledged its support. I wish to call your attention to the following:
“That a closer Union and connexion among Baptists throughout England and Wales, Ireland and America, would be a glorious thing.”
Brethren, I emphasise the word ‘AMERICA’. Can it be that a Union here would presage a Union yet to be when Baptists of other lands shall be united with us?
Rippon: In my more optimistic moods I have myself spoken of some kind of world association of Baptists, including those of America – and the Mennonites of Holland – but before that dream can be realised we have far to go. For today, let us confine ourselves to a possible Union of the home churches. That done, who knows how soon we may expect a wider Union?
Minister: Dr Rippon, will you now accept a Proposition? For I feel the time has come for us to act!
Rippon: I will. Brother Iveny, will you prepare yourself to make a careful note of this Proposition?
Iviney: I am ready, sir.
Rippon: Put your Proposition, brother.
Minister: More accurately, sir, it is a series of Propositions: Perhaps you would prefer to take them singly?
Rippon: Then put the first.
Minister:“That this Meeting of Sixty Ministers, held this day, 25th June 1812, in Carter Lane Chapel, London, solemnly resolves that a Union of Baptist Churches in the United Kingdom is very desirable and is hereby formed… We further resolve…”
JOHN RIPPON was an extraordinary faith-filled young man. In 1771, when he was just twenty, Carter Lane Baptist Church, Tooley Street, London, invited him to try out for their pulpit. Rippon had been a Christian just four years. He trembled at the offer because famed theologian John Gill had been the church’s pastor. It would be hard for one so young to follow so eminent a preacher. Nonetheless, he accepted the challenge and the majority of the congregation voted to call him. Forty members withdrew, however, saying he was too young to be their pastor.
The young Baptist proved to be an extraordinary leader, filled with grace.
The Carter Lane Baptist Church represented much wealth and Rippon encouraged its members to support Baptist world missions. After several years in which illness robbed him of usefulness, he died on 17 December 1836, having preached at Carter Lane (and its successor location at New Park Street) for over sixty years and edited the Baptist Annual for twelve. His pulpit would later be occupied by another famous Baptist—the youthful Charles Spurgeon (whose church would become Metropolitan Tabernacle).
Conclusion – Missions at home and abroad:
Among British Baptists in 1812, therefore, it had been agreed that a more general union of Particular Baptists was desirable, particularly, though not exclusively, to support the work of ‘the Baptist Mission’. The Union was formally founded the next year, in 1813, by the sixty Particular Baptist churches. In 1832, it was restructured to allow for membership of General Baptist churches. The other nonconformist denominations soon followed the example set by the Baptists. In 1786, the Wesleyan Conference, though not yet independent from the Church of England, had already approved the plan of Thomas Coke to take the gospel to India, thereby taking on the task of overseas expansion. The London Missionary Society, an interdenominational venture was formed in 1795 and the Church Missionary Society in 1799. But it was not only the overseas missionary societies that owed their inspiration to the Revival. Both the Religious Tract Society (1799) and The British and Foreign Bible Society (1804) also sprang from the Revival. Christian education gained a new dimension with the introduction of Sunday schools. They were started in 1769 by a Methodist, Hannah Ball, and then developed and popularised by Robert Raikes, an Anglican layman. The Church of England Sunday School was founded in 1786 by William Richardson, an evangelical vicar in York, and the Sunday School Union was founded in 1803. The Sunday school movement in Britain marked an important step towards free education for all. In this way, the Evangelical Revival gave birth to missions, at home and abroad, and missions led to denominational reorganisation.
Sources:
Tim Dowley (ed.), et. al., (1977) The History of Christianity. Berkhamsted: Lion Publishing.
John Barton (2019), A History of the Bible. London: Allen House (Penguin Random House).
Two more scenes from Rev. Arthur J Chandler’s unpublished plays on Baptist History, featuring Thomas Helwys and Col. John Hutchinson, plus a scene from David Starsmeare’s play, ‘Diggers: The Story of a Commune’, featuring Gerrard Winstanley.
Background – The First English Puritans & Exile in the Netherlands:
The Elizabethan puritans wanted to reform the church from within, to make it more like Jean Calvin‘s church in Geneva, as part of a ‘Corpus Christianum’, a Christian state. They simply wanted to purify the national church from all the ceremonial remnants, vestiges and vestments of Roman Catholicism. They also questioned whether there was any biblical basis for the authority of bishops over the Church. Some wanted to replace them with a system of elders and synods, with stricter discipline. This became known as Presbyterianism. Elizabeth I resisted these changes and James I hated Puritans, threatening to ‘harry them out of the land’ if they would not ‘conform’. While many compromised uneasily within the state Church, they were marginalised and very much on the defensive. Others eventually left of their own accord and small groups of ‘separatists’ grew up alongside the main Puritan group. They had formed their own independent congregation at Norwich in 1581, withdrawing completely from the Anglican Church, which they believed to be so polluted it could not be cleansed from within. They were led by Robert Browne (1550-1633), who became their pastor, so they became known as ‘Brownists’. Robert Harrison (d. 1585) was the ‘teacher’ within the church. The government of their chapel was based on a ‘covenant’, marking the beginning of the English Independent or ‘Congregationalist’ movement.
The ‘Pilgrims’ setting sail from Dartmouth: one group set out from Leiden in the Netherlands on the ‘Speedwell’.
They were persecuted by the authorities, the English government and the bishops, and driven abroad to the Netherlands. The Dutch were tolerant of religious nonconformity and allowed refugee status and freedom of worship to the English independents. In this way, the Netherlands played an important part in the life of English dissenters, who were often forced to find refuge abroad. Browne and Harrison took their small church to Middelburg, in Zeeland, where it survived for a few years. It survived for a few years but Brown later returned to England, where he eventually renounced his separation and resumed a ministry in the Church of England. Other leaders took over in the separatist movement, including John Robinson (c. 1576-1625) who, after living in Leiden, eventually emigrated to New England among the ‘Pilgrim Fathers’ via Plymouth, in 1621.
Scene One – Thomas Helwys in Amsterdam, 1612:
Another group, in Amsterdam, was led by John Smyth, who had been a fellow of Christ’s College, Cambridge. In 1608, he became convinced that no surviving church possessed the true ordinances, and baptised first himself and then the rest of his congregation. As a separatist group, they then fled from the harsh rule of James I and went into exile in Amsterdam rather than face the harsh penalties that threatened them at home in England. After his death in 1612, one of his associates, Thomas Helwys, led back to England a group that had split from Smyth’s former congregation.
Scene from an untitled typescript play by Rev. Arthur J Chandler (c. 1965), pastor of Bearwood Baptist Church, Smethwick, West Birmingham:
“Mr and Mrs Thomas Helwys’ Living Room in Amsterdam, 1612. Doors right and left to the rear of the stage. Chairs have been arranged in rows facing left to accommodate nine or ten people. Mrs Helwys, duster in hand, is putting finishing touches to the room. There is a small table to the left, with a chair behind it. Enter, right, a man arriving early.
First Man: Good evening, Mistress Helwys.
Mrs Helwys: Good even’ to you.
First man: I see we make you busy with our meeting here tonight.
Mrs Helwys (Pleasantly): That’s nothing. I was but setting the chairs.
(Enter, right, Helwys. He passes through the room with MS in hand, obviously preoccupied. Mrs H. watches him, puzzled and affectionately concerned. He exits left. The man also watches, and then lays his coat and hat down.)
First Man (Chattily): I hear there is important business to discuss tonight. ‘Twas only by the providence of God I was able to be back in Amsterdam.
Mrs H: Yes, I shall be glad when he has got it off his mind (still with her eyes on the door through which Helwys has passed).
First Man: Who? Master Helwys?
Mrs H: He has been restless for days, sleeping little and eating scarcely at all. All day long he works in his study and sometimes far into the night.
First Man: It will be his writing that he works at so feverishly. He was ever so when inspiration was upon him.
Mrs H (doubtfully): Maybe. But there is something more…
First Man: Is there something troubling him, think you?
Mrs Helwys: Most assuredly there is.
First Man: Then tonight he means to share it with us, and that will lessen his burden.
Mrs Helwys (deliberately): No, I think he has made up his mind: I don’t know what about. Today he has been calmer. Only… he walks around with his mind far away. save sometimes when he has looked at me… as though he would tell me something but cannot.
First Man: That is strange, for with you he has shared all his thoughts. What can it be?
Mrs Helwys: I know not. I only fear. (Enter JOHN MURTON, right)
Murton: Good evening, Mrs Helwys. I hoped to come earlier but was detained. May I go to Master Helwys?
Mrs Helwys: Yes, go in. He will be glad to see you.
(Voices outside, right, as of others arriving. Mrs Helwys, after a hurried survey of the room, goes out, to return later with wearing a bonnet and mittens for the meeting. She sits at the rear, facing the audience. Church members arrive in twos and threes and greet one another. There are several women among them. Men remove hats and coats. Women sit demurely. After a few moments, Murton and Helwys enter together. Murton is tense and solemn. They appear to discuss how they shall proceed. Helwys takes the floor. There is silence. Several members bow slightly forward, expecting prayer. Mrs Helwys is tense, nerving herself for what is coming.)
Thomas Helwys: Before we pray, I want you to know all that is in my mind, that we may pray for in fuller fellowship. Some of you know that for a long time I have been concerned about our witness here. I have wondered if it had not been better for us to have remained in England, for when has God decreed that men should fly from persecutions? I, at any rate, must go back, my friends.
All: Go back?!
Helwys: Aye – go back. Our time in this land has not been wasted, for we have here come to a fuller understanding of our Master’s will. And we have been richly blessed in the water of Believer’s Baptism. But the word has now come for us to return. There is much need for faithful witnesses in our own land. To us have been revealed new truths about our Christian faith and worship, and we cannot – dare not – keep them to ourselves. We must witness to them before our own people. If need be, we must suffer for them too. Murton is of like mind and will come with me.
First Man: But you are a marked man. They will throw you into prison.
Helwys: What if they do and it is God’s will? (turning to his wife) There, too, I may witness to my faith. My wife has done so before me, and I pray that I may not be afraid if my time should come. (At the mention of his wife several heads nod gravely and there are murmurs of admiration.)
Second Man (in dismayed tones):But your writings! What of those? Given though we have been few in number here, your writings have reached many in England.
Helwys (He shows MS): What good are my writings if I am not faithful I’m my living? That which I have recently written – it is finished – I must take it myself and present it to King James.
All: To the King?!
Helwys: Yes, it is a plea for religious liberty for all peaceable citizens among his subjects – whether they be Papists or Separatists, or of whatever connection. (They bow their heads, Mrs Helwys bows her head in prayer, her face grimly set to keep back her tears.)
In TEMPORAL matters the King’s power is supreme. We acknowledge it and confess ourselves his faithful subjects. (murmurs of assent). But in SPIRITUAL matters no man is our master save God alone. (louder murmurs of assent). Oh, that I could move the King! Let us pray…
CURTAIN”.
Spitalfields, London:
NARRATIVE:
“They came back, greatly daring, into certain trouble and persecution. They settled as the First Baptist Church in Spitalfields, London, Thomas Helwys’s latest treatise having set forth their Declaration of Faith to the world. Helwys was soon thrown into prison and there he died some years later. John Murton carried on the gallant fight. He addressed to Parliament a passionate plan for religious toleration for all. He was in Newgate Prison at the time, yet he contrived to write it, and to smuggle it out of prison.”
The First English Baptists:
Helwys’ group founded the first openly ‘Baptist’ church in England, the General or Arminian Baptist Congregation at Spitalfields in London, in 1612. Arminianism was a rejection of Calvinist ideas of predestination and ‘God’s Elect’, and an affirmation of the belief that God’s grace is available to all. Henry Bullinger, a mid-sixteenth-century divine popular with puritans wrote that:
The simpler sort are greatly tempted and exceedingly troubled with the question of election. For the devil goeth about to throw into their minds the hate of God, as though he envied us our salvation, and had appointed and ordained us to death.
H. Bullinger, (in Parker Soc., 1849-52), Decades, p. 187.
Thomas Helwys himself had agreed in 1611 that the doctrine of predestination…
… makes some despair, as thinking there is no grace for them and that God hath decreed their destruction. And it makes others deeply careless, holding that if God have decreed they shall be saved then they shall be saved, and if God hath decreed they shall be damned they shall be damned.
Quoted by A. C. Underwood (1947), A History of the English Baptists, p. 144.
In the background, there is a depiction of his execution.
Baptists practised believers’ baptism as a sign of their belief in universal grace and the exercise of free will. From their earliest days, they viewed ‘dipping’ (total immersion) as an outward symbol of an inward grace. By rejecting infant baptism, they directly challenged the right of the Church of England to control the lives of all their parishioners from the cradle to the grave. Until the 1630s, when Charles I and Archbishop Laud formed their fateful partnership, however, mainstream puritans felt no need to consider leaving England, for they felt tolerably at home in its established church. By 1638, there were also Calvinists in London who practised believers’ baptism, and these became known as ‘Particular Baptists‘. They had grown out of the first independent congregations in the capital, and their understanding of the church as a gathered community led to their profession that only the baptism of believers fitted such a view. It is not known exactly when they adopted full Baptist views. What we do know is that they were among the first of the ‘sects’ to oppose tithes and ‘Hireling preachers’. The extent to which the early Baptists were influenced by the European ideas and the theology of the Radical Reformation and the beliefs of the Anabaptists is still hotly contested. Helwys’ group had been much influenced by the Dutch Mennonites, but both the General and Particular Baptist churches developed out of a conscientious search for the true pattern of the apostolic church of the New Testament and the first century, forming the only pattern of church organisation for all successive generations. Unlike the Anabaptists and Mennonites, however, and like the Quakers at the time of the Civil Wars, the English and Welsh Baptists were not pacifists in the sense of rejecting participation in all warfare.
These youthful Baptist churches were hurled into the debate, current in the seventeenth century, on the relationship between church and state. They championed their own particular answers to that controversy at great personal cost. They also soon became involved, to varying degrees, in the millenarian speculations of the mid-seventeenth century. Like many others, the Baptists eagerly thumbed through the eschatological passages of the books of Daniel and Revelation, seeking the signs of the times and looking for guidance about proper Christian obedience. In his seminal (1972) work, The World Turned Upside Down, Christopher Hill gives a ‘worm’s eye view’ of the English Civil War, in which he ‘visited’ the various religious sects of the time, of which the Baptists and Quakers, as we know, with the benefit of hindsight, would survive and become dissenting denominations. As a consequence, we tend to impose outlines that are far too well defined on the early history of English sects and to read back later beliefs into the 1640s and ’50s. Hill is, perhaps, somewhat guilty of this himself.
The conflict between Parliament and the King was complemented by a conflict between ‘Presbyterians’ and ‘Independents’ on the side of Parliament. Political ‘Independents’ were those who thought, like Oliver Cromwell, that there was no point in fighting unless you were determined to win. The ‘Presbyterian’ grandees, however, who were strong in the House of Lords and among the gentry and ruling oligarchies in London and other trading towns, were anxious to reach a compromise with the King, if he would only accept their terms. But Charles’s obduracy gradually strengthened the hand of the win-the-war party whose support came from ‘the middling sort’, the lesser gentry, yeomen and artisans. Cromwell’s policy of promoting by merit among the troops under his command those who, though not gentlemen, had ‘the root of the matter in them’, and were therefore motivated by their faith eventually led to the creation of the New Model Army, officered by men who were competent military leaders with a determination to win. Religious toleration was the natural accompaniment of this approach to men outside the ruling landowning hierarchies.
Before 1640 nearly all Englishmen and Welshmen other than ‘recusant’ Catholics were, at least on the surface, members of the Church of England, having been baptised as infants. They were liable to be punished in its ‘spiritual’ courts for a wide variety of ‘sins’, including working on one of the innumerable saints’ days that divided up the agricultural calendar. They had to pay tithes, ten per cent of their income, to maintain the parson of their parish, in whose selection they had no say, and were punished (before 1650) for not attending Sunday services in their local parish church. The clergy were expected to read government circulars from the pulpit and were told which subjects not to preach on. For King Charles, control over the Church was therefore as important as control over the armed forces. Many men and women bitterly resented this apparatus and atmosphere of coercion in matters of conscience, but if they stayed away from the church and met in their own houses for worship and discussion, this was also punishable in the church courts. Apart from the many thousands who emigrated to the Netherlands and New England, many others, especially poorer dissenters, met in underground separatist congregations, which, as the political crisis deepened, became revolutionary cells. Religion and politics thus became inextricably intertwined.
Then, in 1640, the church hierarchy effectively collapsed during the meeting of the Long Parliament. Separatist congregations came up from underground and met openly, electing or ‘calling’ their own ministers, rejecting the state church and its parochial clergy. Toleration, therefore, became a social and political issue as well as a religious one. If men and women of the ‘meaner sort’ were to meet together in their own congregations, unsupervised by university-educated clergymen, for religious discourse, this would inevitably lead to the discussion of political subjects as well. Moreover, if lay people were to be permitted to preach, it was unlikely that their audiences would want to go on paying tithes to maintain parish ministers they did not want to hear. Eventually, there would be no state church to tell people what to think, and no livings for its clergy. So, for the Anglican establishment, behind ‘Toleration’ lurked the abolition of the traditional means of social control and an attack on property. Yet Oliver Cromwell and the ‘Independents’ supported it, many at least on genuinely conscientious grounds. Their need for a wide mass basis of support in order to defeat the King enabled their views to triumph.
Oliver Cromwell, Lord Protector, from a miniature.
In the decade from 1643 to 1653, Hill suggested, there was a great overturning, questioning, revaluing, of everything in England, in which old institutions, old beliefs, old values came into question. The following scene demonstrates how this radical mood affected every level of society, from the gentry downwards.
Scene Two: Colonel John & Lucy Hutchinson in Nottingham, 1643.
Col. John Hutchinson
In a scene from Rev. Arthur J. Chandler’s play, Vignettes of Colonel Hutchinson, John and Lucy Hutchinson (see my separate, previous article on them) are reading books and pamphlets confiscated from a Baptist group that has been meeting at the Cannoniers’ room at Nottingham Castle, where Colonel Hutchinson was Governor in 1643.
They are waiting to discuss the baptism of their fourth child with a Presbyterian Minister:
“Lucy: I don’t know whether Mr Foxcraft will have anything more to say, but I really feel that these Baptists are right on the question of Baptism.
John Hutchinson: I agree. Having read these books and papers I found in the cannoniers room, I find it most difficult to controvert the arguments they have brought forward. I am especially impressed by this book by Tombes, one of their divines. If they’re right and we accept their views, one thing is clear.
Lucy: You mean about the baby?
JH: Yes. If we are convinced that the baptism of infants is not in accordance with the teaching of Christ and His apostles, we should not have him baptised.
Lucy: That is true.
(Foxcraft, a Presbyterian Minister is shown in by Thomas)
Oh, come in Mr Foxcraft, we have been expecting you.
Fox.: Thank you, Mrs Hutchinson, thank you, Colonel. Do you wish to discuss the matter of baptism with me a little further?
JH: We do, Mr Foxcraft. You know what we have begun to feel in the matter.
Fox.: Yes, Colonel Hutchinson. You seem convinced that this writer, John Tombes is right, though as a Minister of the Presbyterian order, I find it difficult to agree.
JH: The arguments seem very sound to me, Mr Foxcraft. As I told you I found this book and other literature being used by the soldiers who met in the cannonier’s room. We have studied it carefully and are aware of the opinion that Tombes is right.
Lucy: I’ve spent hours comparing these writings with the Scriptures and feel sure the author is right. We should not baptise an infant child.
Fox.: And pray when should a child be baptised then, Mistress Hutchinson?
Lucy: When he has freely made his decision to follow our Lord, Mr Foxcraft, then, contends Tombes, the sacrament becomes effective. If this teaching is true we should not have our newborn infant baptised. Yet, on the other hand, it is right that we should hear what learnéd and godly Ministers who think otherwise have to say.
JH: I am said to have a little more learning than is becoming a gentleman. Peterhouse taught me a great deal. I attended their Chapel constantly, though their stretching of superstition to idolatry did not escape my notice. Lincoln’s Inn further trained my mind to think logically. I have brought what ability I have to my study the subject since these books came into my possession. We have discussed this subject with other clergymen, Mr Foxcraft. Now, pray, what is your opinion? Should this youngest of our children be baptised as the rest of our children were?
Fox.: Most certainly, he should, Colonel Hutchinson. A gentleman in your position should set a public example in these matters.
JH: And how would you defend this practice, Mr Foxcraft, in view of what we have read in the Scriptures?
Fox.: It has been the practice of the Church to baptise infants from the earliest days, Colonel Hutchinson. As early as the second century, Iranaeus, among the Church fathers, refers to it. It is the Church’s buckler of federal holiness. You should in no wise let it go.
Lucy: But, reverend sir, is it not true that even in the fourth century, infant baptism was the exception rather than the rule? And, may we not also go back earlier even than the second century and examine the practices of the Church in the first century recorded in the writings of the Apostles? It is not at all clear to me that an infant should be baptised. Indeed, it is obscure and mysterious.
Fox.: Mistress Hutchinson, however dark and mysterious it may seem to you, I counsel you to conform to the general practice of other Christians and let the baptism take place.
JH: Would you counsel a man to perform an act against what he believes in his heart to be right? (Foxcraft is silent for a time)
Lucy: Before you answer, Mr Foxcraft, may I add another word? You were present a few days ago when all the Ministers from the town dined with us and we discussed this matter with them. The Colonel explained his doubts and you heard their answers.
JH: They also said that the baptism of infants had been the practice of the Church since primitive times and that I should hesitate before setting aside that position with respect to the children of believing parents to which, it may be, the Holy Spirit has led the Church, and that I should conform to it. Now if I consider that this argument is overthrown, what do you advise me to do?
(Foxcraft is silent again, then turns around again.)
Fox.: Colonel Hutchinson, Mistress Hutchinson, I can say only this. If you are not convinced of the warrant of the practice of infant baptism from the Word, you are committing a sin if you proceed with it. You, as I, must do what you believe to be right.
JH: Then this child shall not be baptised until he seeks this sacrament of his own accord. But hear me further, Mr Foxcraft, we shall not retract one iota of our public benevolence and civilities among those who do not hold these views, nor shall we stay away from public worship within the Castle and City.
Fox.: May He who is our Guide lead you into all righteousness and truth.
… (Exit Lucy)...
Baptists, Independents & Levellers in the New Model Army and the Commonwealth:
Streeter’s plan of the Battle of Naseby, 1645. Col. Pickering’s Regiment was at the front and centre of the Parliamentarian Infantry lines (bottom).
The victorious New Model Army of Fairfax and Cromwell, formed by parliamentary order in 1645, held religious opinions which largely differed from those of the Presbyterian-dominated Parliament. Independents, including Congregationalists and Baptists, were dominant both in the leadership of the army and especially among the rank and file. For example, Daniel Axtell had been a Lieutenant in Essex’s army and joined Col. John Pickering’s Regiment as the first captain in March 1644. He was one of a number of Baptists, including, including John Lilburne and Richard Overton, the Leveller leaders, of humble and obscure origins who rose to positions of influence in and through the New Model Army. By the end of the first civil war in 1646, toleration existed in fact, if not in theory, guaranteed by the Army, which was in no mood to stand any ‘nonsense’ from the ‘Presbyterian’ majority in the House of Commons. Puritan preachers had called on soldiers to fight against the Antichrist, a vague symbol of all that was oppressive and tyrannical in the old order. Millennarian hopes for a reconstruction of society to benefit the poor and lowly were in the air. As early as 1644, rank-and-file Parliamentarian soldiers had asked a horrified royalist divine about ‘the Whore of Babylon’:
What do you know but that this is the time of her ruin, and that we are the men that must help to pull her down?
E. Symmons (1644), Scripture Vindicated.
By the Antichrist or ‘the Whore of Babylon’ the Puritan preachers were referring to the Pope or bishops: others were subsequently to apply the terms to the royalists more generally, then to the Presbyterians and finally to Oliver Cromwell himself; it was a widely extendable phrase. In 1647, Parliament ordered the Army to disband, without even providing for full payment of arrears of wages due and without producing any of the social and political reforms which the troops had expected. The rank-and-file revolted and, after a period of hesitation, most of their officers supported them. An Army Council was set up in which officers and elected representatives of the ordinary soldiery – ‘Agitators’ – sat side-by-side. It was ‘Major’ Axtell and two other ‘agitators’ who prepared a statement of the grievances of what by then had become Hewson’s regiment. The Lieutenant-Colonel, John Jubbes, another religious radical, represented the regiment at what became known as ‘the Putney Debates’ in the late autumn of 1647. Twenty officers and ordinary soldiers from the regiment also signed a letter setting out the political agenda of the Levellers. Colonel John Hewson was himself of humble origins, a sometime honest shoemaker in Westminster, who had joined the Earl of Essex’s regiment as a Captain at the start of the Civil War. He was known as an arch-radical and religious zealot but held a very different view of the Levellers than many of his officers and men. In February 1648, following a soldier petition to Fairfax, Hewson expressed a typically disciplinarian view when he commented:
“We have had trial enough of Civil courts, we can hang twenty before they will hang one.”
D Wolfe (1944), Leveller Manifestoes of the Puritan Revolution.
In his view, Hewson was very close to Cromwell’s justifications of his forceful putting down of the Leveller Rising at Burford a year later. Perhaps dismayed by his Colonel’s remarks, John Jubbes left the regiment shortly afterwards to join a group of radical pacifists in London. He was replaced as Lieutenant Colonel by Daniel Axtell, who then commanded the guard at King Charles I’s execution. Although as an MP, John Hewson signed the King’s death warrant, as a member of the Council of State, he later opposed Cromwell’s usurpation, continuing to do so from within the Protectorate after others had resigned. He also remained tolerant of religious radicals like the ex-Quartermaster and Quaker, James Nayler, when he appeared before parliament on a charge of blasphemy in 1656.
As an unrepentant regicide and republican, Daniel Axtell subsequently threw in his lot with General Lambert, in one last desperate attempt to reimpose the rule of the Major Generals, but in April 1660, Lambert’s forces were routed by Axtell’s former regiment at Daventry in Northants. Axtell himself escaped the battlefield, but was later captured and eventually executed as a regicide. Other Baptists had long since left the Army to plant churches in different parts of England and Wales. Thomas Collier, a former army chaplain, established a Baptist congregation in the Taunton area. Thomas Edwards, the presbyterian author and publisher, commented that:
“Truly ’tis a sad thing that that in all the towns and cities (for the most part) taken by the parliament’s forces, this should be the fruit of it, that errors and heresies should abound there, and that sectaries of all sorts get places of profit and power.”
Edwards, Gangrena, (1646).
In this struggle for positions of influence, the New Model Army, as a professional standing army that was difficult to disband, had been ‘on the spot’: Parliament and the Presbyterian clergy were far away. It was in vain that Herbert Palmer in 1646 urged the House of Commons to fill the deserted pulpits in the North, saying that Churches… will be your strongest castles if you furnish them with ministers. He also pointed out that larger maintenance payments were necessary to persuade such ‘spiritual commanders’ to fight the Lord’s battle in the North. One of Mercurius Politicus‘s correspondents was still saying in November 1650 that, in the North, a mission of presbyterian ministers would do as much good service to the state as a regiment of soldiers in a shire.
Under the Commonwealth and Protectorate, an established church was permitted to continue, but allowed Presbyterians, Independents and Baptists to act as ministers in it, according to the choices of the individual parishes. When a parish living became vacant, an eclectic body of ‘triers’ was formed in order to appoint a new minister, comprising laymen as well as clergy and Presbyterians, Independents and Baptists fairly equally represented. The triers were not empowered to impose any doctrinal test, but to satisfy themselves of three things: that the ‘presentee’ was well-grounded in the essentials of the Christian faith, that he was competent to preach and that his moral life was above reproach. Those dissenters who wanted to continue to worship apart from the national church were permitted to do so, as long as they didn’t disturb the peace. Some Baptists accepted office in the state church, but the majority chose to continue independently.
Samuel Fisher & Baptists Beliefs:
If ministers were dependent on the voluntary contributions of their congregations, as was made explicit by the church covenant in Independent churches, they would also have to reflect the theological and political outlook of these congregations, and so the church as an instrument for imposing and maintaining a consistent outlook would cease to exist. In the even more democratic churches of Baptists and other sectaries, the distinction between clergy and laity ceased to exist. The fundamental Baptist principle of believer’s baptism meant that each individual must choose or be chosen by a congregation after he had reached ‘the years of discretion’: it too disrupted the idea of a national church. As Samuel Fisher wrote in his Baptist days:
“Once give over Christening the whole parish infancy, and then farewell that parish posture which the Pope set up in all Christendom some six hundred years ago, yea then down falls the parochial-church-steeple-house, priesthood, pay and all. Amen, so be it.”
S. Fisher, Christianismus Redivivus, Christendom Both unchrist’ned and new-christ’ned (1655), p. 201.
Samuel Fisher was the son of a hatter from Northampton, educated at Trinity College and the puritan New Inn Hall, Oxford. Although a lecturer in Kent in the 1630s, where he underwent Presbyterian ordination in 1643, he resigned his living when he became a Baptist. A pastor to the congregation in Ashford, he maintained himself by farming, before becoming a Quaker in 1654. He died of the plague in 1665. In his Baptist period, Fisher published a lengthy defence of ‘dipping’ as against ‘sprinkling’ in which he wrote in a distinct style, using alliterative abbreviations, e.g. PPP for Pope, Prelates, Presbyters (or sometimes Priests) and called on the latter to depart from that papistical posture of parish churches and pastoral relation to such as are not sheep.
Apart from his advocacy of believer’s baptism, what is most interesting about Fisher’s doctrines is his application of them to Biblical criticism. Protestants, both in Britain and on the Continent, thought that all would be unity itself among them once they turned from the traditions of the Church to the text of the Bible: but among the reformed clergy, the Bible increased rather than diminished conflict. Fisher claimed that dark minds diving into the scriptures, divine lies enough out of it to set whole countries on fire. … till men turn to the light and Word within, there would be no peace. This thinking was very similar to that developed by Baruch (later Benedict de) Spinoza, who was born in what is now the Netherlands, in 1632, of Portuguese Jewish (Sephardic) descent. He lived much of his life in Amsterdam, where he was eventually expelled from the synagogue for his unorthodox beliefs. Notoriously, he suggested that the Pentateuch was written not by Moses but by Ezra. He is generally thought of as one of the first rationalists of the period, and thus a founding father of the European Enlightenment. Where the study of the Bible was concerned, he was a crucial figure in casting doubt on the biblical miracles, which he thought were either fictitious or descriptions of natural processes. He argued that nothing could ever happen contrary to the laws of nature, which were mechanistic in nature, and that God does not intervene in natural events. In this, he was an antecedent of the British deists of the later seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, ‘Deism’ being the belief that, though there is a God, his activity is confined to the creation of the universe, after which he took no part in its running. People had doubted the truth of the biblical miracles before, but Spinoza combined a belief in God’s existence with a conviction that he did not do anything to change the natural order of events. He also thought that biblical stories of miraculous events might simply be records of visions and dreams.
Cromwell’s Bible(which he took on campaigns).
Among many possible approaches to the Bible, two stand out among the slightly earlier and roughly contemporary English radicals. One was to use its stories as myths, to which each could give his own sense, a sense that need not consider the original meaning of the text. Thomas Edwards’ twenty-ninth Error was:
“We did look for great matters from one crucified at Jerusalem sixteen hundred years ago, but that does us no good; it must be a Christ formed in us. ”
Edwards (1646), op.cit.
The distinction between ‘the history’ and ‘the mystery’ was also made by the radical Welsh Baptist ‘Arise’ (Rhys) Evans, who held a dialogue with Oliver Cromwell as Protector. Another approach denied the infallibility of the Bible or subjected it to intense textual criticism. But in general, there remained a consensus among reformed theologians that the books of both testaments were by the people they had been traditionally attributed to, and no one approached the questions of authorship and authenticity as completely open ones, as Spinoza did with the Hebrew texts. Although he paid no attention to the Greek texts of the New Testament, the Roman Catholic Church still placed his works in its Index of Prohibited Books. At a less scholarly level, we see the process of textual criticism at work in the Records of the Churches of Christ gathered at Fenstanton, Warboys and Hexham. There we hear men and women rejecting the Bible, or parts of it they did not like, in the name of a spirit within them. They were applying John Milton’s theory that the Bible must be subordinated to ‘human convenience’. He was glad to find that the ideas he arrived at by searching in his own conscience could be found in the Bible, but they had greater authority for him because they were already in his conscience than because they were in the Bible. But in applying Milton’s test of the convenience of men in society, ordinary members of the congregation could always be out-quoted, if not convinced, by the Baptist organisers and ordained ministers.
The scholarly underpinning of this position on the primacy of the human conscience was done more effectively by Samuel Fisher. Holding that the spirit is far more important than the letter of the Bible, Fisher asks how reliable the text really is. It was silly, he suggested, to call it ‘the Word of God’, claiming that there is no evidence of divine authority for the present canon of the New Testament. He makes an interesting comparison with attitudes towards the Qu’ran:
“Nor will it do to say that the universal reception of the present canon guarantees divine inspiration: what about the Koran, ‘the public possession of many generations and in actual authority among men as a standard throughout the whole word of Mahometanism’?”
John Bunyan had similar doubts. A translation of the Qu’ran had been published in 1649, which explains the sudden awareness of its importance. For Fisher, the Christian Bible was…
“… a bulk of heterogeneous writings, compiled by men taking what they could find of the several sorts of writings that are therein, and … crowding them into a canon, or standard for the trial of all spirits, doctrines, truths; and by them alone”.
Fisher’s writings are a remarkable work of popular Biblical criticism, based on real scholarship. Its effect is to demote the Bible from its central position in the protestant scheme of things, to make it a book like any other. After a century of sacrifice to bring the Scriptures to the ordinary laymen, Fisher says that there are enough Bibles for anyone who can read them and has money to buy them. For him, the Bible is read too much and heard too often. The martyrs of the previous century would have been shocked to see that Protestantism had come to that. Fisher’s book brought to an end the epoch of protestant bibliolatry. The diversity of sects, each with its own interpretation of the Bible, had dissolved protestant unity. It was the end of the authority of the Book: but by no means a return to the authority of tradition. It was the beginning of the authority of conscience, both individual and congregational, the doctrine of the ‘inner light’ which could replace the absolute centrality of the Bible of the Puritan divines without shattering the foundations of the Protestant faith. In this way, Fisher deserves greater recognition as a precursor of the English enlightenment than he has received since his own day. His personal transition from Presbyterian to Baptist to Quaker was guided by his developing doctrine of scripture.
The ‘questioning’ of established political institutions became more intense from the Sping of 1649, when radical Independents and sectaries, understandably, began to see a better future for themselves under the Commonwealth, for all its imperfections, than under the Presbyterian-dominated Long Parliament. But there were limits to their intervention: on 2 April, William Kiffin headed a deputation of Baptist ministers which presented a petition to the Rump, dissociating themselves from William Walwyn’s Leveller ‘manifesto’, The Second Part of England’s New Chains and disavowing any intent to intermeddle with the ordering or altering civil government. The Leveller organisation had been so strongly linked to the General Baptists that the latter’s withdrawal of support seriously weakened the movement. Kiffin later joined other Independent ministers, including the pastor of the congregation which included John Lilburne (the Leveller leader) in putting his name to a pamphlet attacking Walwyn’sWiles, which unjustly accused him of immorality, irreligion and seeking to make all things common. This latter accusation may, in part, be a reference to the group of True Levellers, or ‘Diggers’ who emerged out of the general movement on 1 April 1649 to establish an early ‘commune’ on St George’s Hill, near Kingston in Surrey. Their leader was a Baptist from Wigan in Lancashire, Gerrard Winstanley, who may have known of various earlier anabaptist experiments of an economic nature on the Continent.
Winstanley had supported Parliament in the first civil war, but in 1648 he rejected both the ‘Presbyterians’ and ‘Independents’ no less than he had the royalists. God’s sincere-hearted ones, scattered abroad in the kingdom, he believed, shall stand and look on whilst the Royalists, Presbyterians and Independents sheathe their swords in one another’s bowels’. Nevertheless, this wrath, bitterness and discontent that appears generally in men’s spirits in England, seemed to Winstanley to suggest that liberty is not far off and that the British Isles might be the tenth part of the city of Babylon that shall fall off first. Winstanley hoped to help God in this great work. He tells us that he was, for a long time a good Puritan church-goer, believing as the learnéd clergy believed. But he came to see that such a life was one of confusion, ignorance and bondage. He went through the ordinance of dipping, but he did not long remain a conventional Baptist. In the early months of 1648, he published three theological tracts which wrestle with the subjects of poverty, evil and selfishness, foreseeing a glorious future in which God will reveal himself to the despised, the unlearned, the poor, the nothings of this world. Already Winstanley had broken with the traditional theological framework which most of his contemporaries accepted: he suggested that, in the end, everyone will be saved. One of his main concerns was already to insist on freedom for the poor. It was wrong that:
… sharp punishing laws were made to prevent fishermen, shepherds, husbandmen and tradesmen from ever preaching of God any more.
For Winstanley, God was to be found within every human being:
He that looks for a God without himself and worships God at a distance, he worships he knows not what, but is led away and deceived by the imaginations of his own heart. … he that looks for a God within himself … is made subject to and hath community with the spirit that made all flesh, that dwells in all flesh and in every creature within the globe.
This God is Reason – a social Reason which says:
Do as thou wouldst be done unto … For Reason tells him, Is thy neighbour hungry and naked today, do thou feed him and clothe him, it may be thy case tomorrow, and then he will be ready to help thee.
Winstanley had got thus far in his thought by July 1648, trying to understand the poverty and humiliation which had overtaken him and so many others caught up in the national situation. Dozens of other mechanic preachers were using the newly-won liberty of the press to grapple with the problems of the revolutionary epoch: most of them hoped that the national crisis marked the beginning of God’s Kingdom on earth. We have some clues to Winstanley’s use of the Biblical idiom which he shared with almost all his contemporaries, for example, his use of God to mean Reason, and of Babylon to stand for the old order which has to be overthrown. The clergy, Winstanley declares, have no special claims to respect as interpreters of the Scriptures, for the very text of the Bible depends on tradition. The clergy themselves are time-servers in a privileged state church that must be abolished, and all men and women must be given liberty to worship as they please. The months between October 1648 and January 1649 were crucial to the English Revolution. In them, the army seized power, purged Parliament, negotiated with the Levellers a modified Agreement of the People, and brought the King to trial. It was a time when ideas developed rapidly. When Winstanley asked himself why…
… most people are so ignorant of their freedom, and so few fit to be chosen commonwealth’s officers, …
… his answer was that…
… the old kingly clergy … are continually distilling their blind principles into the people, and do thereby nurse up ignorance in them.
The economic and political situation in the early months of 1649 was particularly explosive. Many in London were starving. Levellers and Army radicals felt that they had been deceived in the negotiations which led to the trial and execution of the King: the republic that Independent Grandees had set up fell far short of the reformed democratic society they had hoped to see. They demanded the reappointment of the Agitators and recall of the General Council of the Army. In April mutinies broke out when soldiers who refused to serve in Ireland were demobilised without payment of arrears. On 27 April Trooper Robert Lockyer was shot; his funeral two days later was a vast demonstration of support for the Leveller movement in London. Many more serious revolts broke out among the troops and on 14 May, Cromwell and Fairfax cornered and broke up the mutinous regiments at Burford in the Cotswolds. The ‘Digger’ movement appeared at the height of the unrest when on 1st April a group of poor men collected on St George’s Hill in the parish of Walton-on-Thames and began to dig the wasteland there, then sowing it with corn, parsnips, carrots and beans. Their numbers soon rose to twenty or thirty: an observer noted:
“They invite all to come in and help them and promise them meat, drink and clothes … They give out, they will be four or five thousand within ten days … It is feared they have some design in hand.”
In the following scene from David Starsmeare’s educational play, we imagine a church service from the previous week. The dialogue reveals the intertwining of religious, economic and social motivations of the Diggers and Gerrard Winstanley.
Scene Three – Demonstration in Walton Church, 1649:
From a play by David Starsmeare (1978), Diggers: The Story of a Commune. London: Blackie.
“(The parish church of Walton-on-Thames in Surrey. Among the congregation are FRANCIS DRAKE (the Magistrate), and his wife, ELIZABETH, Mistress Martha and Miss Henrietta, their daughters, forming one group, on the right. On the left are SUSAN, GERRARD, TOM STARR & NED BICKERSTAFFE. They all sit as the hymn comes to an end. The MINISTER enters the pulpit and begins to preach.)
MINISTER: In the twenty-eighth chapter of Ezekiel is it is written: “Though hast been in Eden, the garden of God… Thine heart was lifted up because of thy beauty. Thou hast corrupted thy wisdom because of thy brightness. I will cast thee to the ground and I will destroy thee.”
Dear brothers and sisters in Jesus Christ, Ezekiel spoke of the Prince of Tyrus, but there are Herods and Caesars in each generation. We told Charles Stuart we would have no bishops, he forced us to have bishops. We told him we would not pay his taxes, he forced us to pay taxes. We told him we would be ruled by Parliament, he dissolved Parliament for eleven years. For this did we slay him at Whitehall but a few weeks ago.
Oh my dear brothers and sisters, let us render thanks to the Lord that this war is over. Let us shout Alleluia!
ALL: Alleluia!
MINISTER: Let us pray now that the soldier will return to the plough, that trade may flourish and the wheels of industry may turn. Let each man pay a tax to a just government and his tithe to a just church.
(WILL, ROB & MEG lead a group of protesters before the pulpit. The MINISTER is at first unaware of their presence.)
WILL: Tithes? That’s ten per cent of all we earn.
ROB: Two shillings in every twenty, brothers, one pound in every ten.
MINISTER: O Lord… look down we pray upon the Councillors of State who rule this land. May they build for us a new Jerusalem. …
WILL: It sounds like the old Jerusalem if we must pay tithes. …
ROB: Come down from the pulpit, Vicar, quickly now.
MINISTER: Do not call me Vicar.
WILL: Come down! Or would you have us pull you down?
(The MINISTER leaves the pulpit.)
ELIZABETH: You are a magistrate, Thomas, stop this nonsense.
ROB: Stay in your place, Mr Drake, we mean business here.
MINISTER: Who are you people? What do you mean by invading my church?
WILL: Brothers and sisters, do you see this Bible? It was given to the people by old King James. Have you read it? Have you considered it deeply? Fairy stories! Nothing but tales to keep children in order!
ROB: When the world was empty and we waited for Jesus, the Bible gave us consolation. But now Jesus has come. He is born in our hearts.
WILL: Down with the Bible. It has served its turn.
(WILL throws the Bible to the floor. The MINISTER retrieves it on his knees.)
MINISTER: You will burn in hell for this!
MEG: My people, do not be alarmed. We bring peace such as you have never dreamed of.
ROB: The peace that dwells in the hearts of the saints.
WILL: Jesus has come again.
MINISTER: Do you call yourself Messiah?
ROB: When the axe removed King Charles’ head, each man took charge of his own destiny.
MEG: I proclaim the sovereignty of the people!
WILL: When the axe removed the Archbishop’s head each man became the priest of his own salvation.
MEG: I proclaim the sovereignty of the people.
WILL: Alleluia!
MEG: People of this parish, depose your minister and pay not one penny of his tithe.
WILL: What have tithes to do with the coming of the Kingdom?
ROB: People of Walton, depose your magistrates, those fat-bellied landowners who bleed the poor.
MEG: Christ is the magistrate in your heart. You need no other. He has come in glory. He has set up His Kingdom and we are in paradise.
WILL: Who now needs the kings and magistrates, ministers or Sabbath days? Every man is a walking Jesus. Every day is holy.
MINISTER: You speak profane nonsense.
ROB: You give thanks for the death of a king and accuse us of being profane? It is you who are profane for you rule this parish more harshly than Charles ever ruled England.
WILL: Yes, more wickedly than Israel was ruled by Babylon. Ezekial said unto Israel: I will be glorified in the midst of thee and there shall be no more pricking briar or a grieving thorn.
ROB: Bring the thorns, brothers.
(Two men come forward with a bundle of gorse and briar)
WILL: We place these thorns on your pulpit, Vicar. May you never preach there again.
(The pulpit is filled with thorns.)
MEG: Dear children of God, take this word and preach it through Walton. The sabbath is ended.
ROB: Tithes are ended.
WILL: Kings, magistrates and ministers, all are ended.
MEG: We proclaim that Christ has come again. His spirit walks with the saints.
WILL: The day of glory is at hand.
ROB: No more shall there be pauper or beggar.
MINSTER: Now I know you are mad. Who will feed the pauper? Who will give alms to the beggar?
WILL: In the fullness of time shall all be provided.
MINISTER: Depose me and many shall starve. I feed many mouths with the bread of charity. And where do I find this charity? Among the poor? NO, it comes from the rich, from the landowners and magistrates of this county.
ROB: You give bread and demand obedience.
MINISTER: Can you feed the poor? Can the invisible Christ feed them without help from the wealthy? Who but the minister and the magistrate can cure the miseries of the time?
WINSTANLEY steps forward.
GERRARD: I can, minister, I can do it very easily. … I can feed the poor of the parish.
MINISTER: Gerrard Winstanley, sit down, please. Their madness has touched your wits. …
GERRARD: I will say what I must, and then I’ll be gone. I can feed all the common people of England!
MINISTER: Oh, you are rich, are you?
GERRARD: No, I am a poor man.
MINISTER: Then where is your fortune to begin this work?
GERRARD: I have a very great fortune, sir, which has been held from me and my kind for six hundred years. I mean the common land, the hills, the royal parks and forests. Why two-thirds of England has never felt spade or plough. Folk like Ned and Tom here shouldn’t need charity. They are farmers.
WILL: We shall level all fences. Down with enclosure. The people are sovereign, let them possess all.
GERRARD: No, Esau, for that would be a new tyranny. Let the rich stay within their enclosures.
ELIZABETH: We thank you for that.
GERRARD: But let the poor dig up the common land.
ELIZABETH: But it is we who control the commons, Mr Winstanley.
GERRARD: Ay, but by what right?… Do you know, Mr Drake? Elizabeth? (pauses) Then, I will tell you. You hold these rights from the Crown. But how did the Crown possess these rights? Common land should be for all common folk. … The Crown possessed these rights by the conquest of the people. … I don’t mean King Charles, I mean the Conqueror. Before the Normans came, each man could use the commons as he wished – to graze his cattle, to raise his crops. The forest gave timber for his dwelling, fuel for his fire. But the Norman king set landlords over us and Englishmen became slaves to property. (1.)
WILL: As Babylon ruled Israel so did the Normans rule England.
ROB & MEG: Alleluia! Alleluia!
GERRARD: And then did the Norman power exact its due in rent and tithe. The common lands were fenced with laws and no man could dwell upon them.
MINISTER: The commons are protected by ancient law.
GERRARD: Norman law.
MINISTER: You may walk upon them, you may pick up sticks for your fire, you may even graze cattle upon them. But you may not raise a dwelling or dig the earth.
GERRARD: You speak like a conqueror. You begged us to give thanks that the King was dead but you have given no thought to what must follow. His sovereign power has passed to us.
WILL: The sovereignty of the people!
GERRARD: You keep shouting that, but have you considered what it means? It means the common land is ours again.
WILL: No more shall there be pauper or beggar.
ROB: Come with us, Jacob; you shall be our leader.
MINISTER: Go with these blasphemers and I shall ban you forever from my church.
GERRARD: I shan’t mind that. I shall build a new temple for the Lord. I have been chosen. I see now that I have reached my hour. Let all who wish to know more of me gather next Sunday upon George’s Hill. … But if you come, come not in your best attire. Our prayers will be the spade in the turf, and our psalms the ringing of axes. (2.)
(He walks out of the Church with SUSAN… the protesters leave the church, chanting):
WILL, ROB & MEG: The priesthood of all believers! The Sovereignty of the people! The Sabbath is ended. Tithes are ended. Kings, magistrates and ministers, all are ended. We proclaim that Christ has come again. His spirit walks with the saints. No more shall there be pauper or beggar.
(TOM and NED leave their places and follow the procession out. Unable to enter his pulpit, the MINISTER speaks from its steps. As the chanting fades, he regains his composure.)
MINISTER: I do not believe in tyranny. For that crime did we kill the King. But there must be order. There must be magistrates, there must be ministers. The Sabbath must be kept holy, the Bible is the word of God, and you must pay me your tithe. All these things are enshrined by law. I trust, that as Magistrate, you will make a full report of these events…
(MARTHA leaves as the lights fade.) …
FURTHER NOTES ON THE TEXT:
(1.) The notion that England was ‘a paradise’ before the Norman Conquest was known as ‘the Norman Yoke’ and was shared by many religious radicals and ‘levellers’. Although it is largely a ‘myth’, powerful at that time, which does not square with the facts (especially Domesday), historians do believe that some aspects of rural discontent were due to vestiges of feudalism, some of which were revived under Stuart rule.
(2.) Winstanley follows the Puritan practice of dropping the title ‘Saint’ from people ‘canonised’ by the Roman Catholic Church. Puritans used the term ‘saint’ to mean anyone who had found faith in God through Jesus Christ and had made a public profession of it their faith.
FURTHER NARRATIVE:
Sir Thomas Fairfax, Lord General of the Army in 1649.
Local property-owners called on the Council of State to intervene with military assistance. Thinking that great confluxof people may be beginning whence things of greater and more dangerous consequence may grow, the Council of State alerted the Surrey JPs and General Fairfax. The latter sent a couple of troopers down to see what was happening. From the report of Captain Gladman to Fairfax, it is clear that he thought the Council was being unduly alarmist. On 20th April, two of the Digger leaders, Everard and Winstanley, were brought before the Commander-in-Chief. They kept their hats on in Fairfax’s presence, the traditional symbolic rejection of social and political authority by dissenters. Their intention, they told the general, was to cultivate the wastelands as a communal group. They hoped that, before long, the poor everywhere would follow their example, and that property-owners would voluntarily surrender their estates and join in with the communal production. On the same day, they published a manifesto, The True Levellers’ Standard Advanced was sent to the printer. It appeared on 26th April. Fairfax refused to take the incident seriously but visited the colony himself at the end of May and had an amicable exchange with Winstanley, who repeated his assurance that the Diggers would not use force. However, the colony was raided more than once, crops and huts were destroyed, individuals were beaten up and horses killed. An action for trespass was brought against the Diggers in court at Kingston which resulted in heavy fines and distraint of property.
Places referred to in the play and supporting texts.
Some time in or before August 1649 the colony abandoned ‘George’s Hill’ and transferred to Cobham Heath, a mile or two away. But they were not left in peace there either. After a meeting at the Red Lion Inn in Cobham, a boycott of the Diggers was organised. Then Francis Drake, lord of the manor of St George’s Hill, together with Parson Platt, the lord of the manor at Cobham, had Winstanley arrested and fined again for trespass. In November, the troops were called in again, and although they themselves showed some sympathy towards the True Levellers, their presence emboldened the local yeomen and freeholders. The soldiers stood by while houses were pulled down, tools and implements destroyed, the corn trampled and men beaten and arrested. Winstanley was convinced that the poorer tenants were forced to participate under the threat of eviction, though ‘in their hearts they are Diggers’. But the Diggers continued to be treated with brutality and by the winter of 1649-50 the colony was in dire financial straits. It lasted almost exactly a year, through to the following spring. At their peak, they were cultivating almost eleven acres. But although their economic and social experience was an obvious failure, Winstanley’s writings have provided them with a lasting legacy that has given them a significance far beyond their numbers and agricultural production.
Winstanley’s Writings on Religion & The Church:
Winstanley was aware of the enormous influence of the Church on the illiterate mass of the population and regarded the clergy as propagandists in the service of the existing property system. He saw the danger of appealing to an uneducated democracy, and could not find in contemporary conditions of society the social force which could put through the changes necessary to make the common people aware of what might be done. Initially, God seemed the only answer:
‘The whole world we see is corrupt, and it cannot be purged by the hand of creatures, for all creatures lie under the curse and groan to be delivered, and the more they strive the more they entangle themselves in the mud, because it must be the hand of the Lord alone that must do it. … I do not speak that any particular man shall go and take their neighbour’s goods by violence or robbery (I abhor it) as the condition of the men of the nations are ready to do in this fleshly-settled government of the world. But everyone is to wait till the Lord Christ do spread himself in multiplicities of bodies.”
Winstanley, like almost all of his fellow Baptists, was not an absolute pacifist. Although he abjured violence for the Diggers, he had supported Parliament in the civil war; in 1648 he had looked to the civil power for defence against what he regarded as the tyranny of the greatest enemy, ecclesiastical tyranny. In 1650 he urged men to take the Engagement to support the Commonwealth. He believed that Biblical threatenings against the rich shall be materially fulfilled, for they shall be turned out of all. He advocated extreme forms of non-violent resistance. In January 1649, he called upon those that labour the earth and work for others that live at ease … the hand of the Lord shall break out upon every such hireling labourer and you shall perish with the covetous rich men. One of his most powerful passions is his hatred of parsons and the state church, a virulent anti-clericalism which he shared with John Milton. Their reasons were similar: parsons were paid to do a job that no one should be paid for; they used their privileged positions to impose standards of conduct on others.
Anti-clericalism had a long tradition in the English radical movement. Wycliffe’s Lollards of the late fourteenth century had rejected a separate clerical caste, William Tyndale attacked priests who acted not for the love of your souls (which they care for as the fox doeth for the geese). In the 1640s, the Leveller William Walwyn was one of the most forceful exponents of anti-clericalism. The clergy, he wrote, pray, preach and do all for money. Ministers should have no power of jurisdiction but should be limited to preaching, and no one should be compelled to come and hear them. Heresy-hunting was due to the clergy’s fear for their power and emoluments. The anonymous author of Tyranipocrit Discovered (1649) denounced scholarly parsons who have no experience in that honest simple life of tilling the land, nor keeping of sheep. Such critics wanted to get rid of a trained university clergy, appointed from above and paid by tithes, and to leave the field open to mechanick preachers, craftsmen who would maintain themselves by labouring six days a week and so would not need tithes to support them.
Ploughing with Oxen.
For Winstanley, the English state church was anti-Christian, a cheat by means of which vested interests and the covetous sought to defend themselves against the searching light of truth. Against it, he appealed with confidence to the poor and the humble, to the oppressed, and to the power of human reason, to education and science. As far as he was concerned, kingly power, clergy, lawyers, buying and selling, were all intricately linked. The myth of the ‘Norman Yoke’ included the idea that the role of lawyers was to protect property and that of the clergy was primarily to keep people quiet by telling them of a heaven and hell, after death, which neither they nor we know what will be. In return, they got tithes for their pains. They were also there to maintain the institution of marriage as, essentially, one of protecting property relations: A man must not take a wife but the priest must give her him, and the same was true of christenings, burials, education. And what is the end of all this but to get money? If a man labours the earth to get his bread, the priests must have the tenths of his increase, or else some oppressing impropriator. Tithes were crucial to the existence of the state church and linked the clergy to the propertied orders of society. The sheep of Christ, as he put it, shall never fare well so long as the wolf or the red dragon pays the shepherd their wages. He saw the professional clergy as at best superfluous, at worst the paid propagandists of a wicked social order. Ploughmen, he thought, may do better than they that take tithes to tell a story. As far as the priesthood was concerned, he condemned it in the strongest terms:
Priestslay claim to heaven after they are dead, and yet they require their heaven in this world too, and grumble mightily against the people that will not give them a large temporal maintenance. And yet they tell the poor people that they must be content with their poverty, and they shall have our heaven here (that is, a comfortable livelihood in the earth) and heaven hereafter too, as well as you?
Winstanley’s moral indignation flashes out against the whole profession in words similar to those of Voltaire’s criticism of the Roman Catholic Church in the following century. His concept of ‘Reason’ has been taken to be an anticipation of another French philosopher, Rousseau’s General Will, though it is not confined to one community. The ‘light of Reason’, according to Winstanley, is in all mankind but does not completely dominate the thinking of any single individual all the time: some may calculate that it is to their advantage to compete with and destroy one another. But this would change as Reason itself knits every creature together into a oneness, making every creature to be an upholder of his fellow and so everyone is an assistant to preserve the whole. Winstanley saw an intimate connection between the divided society of his day and the Eternal Decrees which condemned the mass of humanity to an eternity of suffering. For both Calvinist and Anglican theologians, the Fall of Man led to covetousness, private property and the divisions of society, and to the state which protects property. Laws are necessary safeguards against the sinfulness of fallen nature. The Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England rely heavily on the doctrine of ‘original sin’ to justify property and the authority of magistrates, against ‘Anabaptist’ heresies. The rebel Puritan MP John Pym agreed in 1641 thatlaws were necessary to put ‘a difference betwixt good and evil’. Winstanley reversed the order: covetousness and private property are the causes, not the consequences, of the Fall:
When self-love began to arise in the earth, then man began to fall. … When mankind began to began to quarrel about the earth, and some would have shut out others, forcing them to be servants: this was man’s fall.
Exploitation, not labour, is the curse. Buying and selling, the laws regulating the market and property itself were all part of the Fall. So for Winstanley and other Diggers, like the poet Robert Coster, it originated in murder, theft and covetousness (‘individualism’), necessitating the state. That is why and how Winstanley could fuse the myths of the Fall and the Norman Yoke: he took neither of them too seriously as historical fact, nor the former as fundamental to his theology. His main quarrel with the clergy of the ‘traditional’ churches was not a theological one, but that they claimed a monopoly of interpreting the Bible, and suppressed the free spirit in the uneducated. The spirit in men in his day was above the Gospel, he asserted, and he argued that the Bible should be used to illustrate truths of which the individual is already convinced. As we have seen, he shared this view with Milton and other radical independents, both religious and political. Unlike some of them, including Cromwell, he advocated complete religious toleration for anyone to worship, read and teach as they saw fit, and not just the Christian God. This would include Papists, Jews and Muslims. In his ideal state, there would be no religious test for office-holders. Winstanley severely criticised those who based their belief merely on the letter of the Bible. ‘There are good rules in the Scripture,’ he wrote condescendingly, ‘if they were obeyed and practised.’ But he would not make the Bible his main source for a code of conduct.
Winstanley held what was then the highly unorthodox view, even among ‘General’ Baptists, that all mankind shall be saved at last, since it does not make sense to believe in an omnipotent and beneficent God who will torment his creatures to all eternity. He denied the existence of a three-decker universe, with heaven and hell, a personal devil or a bodily resurrection. Heaven, he equated with mankind, and God with ‘Reason’ within men and women, which would eventually redeem them from the only true hell, that which they have created for each other on earth. Winstanley left open the question of any other hell: he merely wrote that nobody knows or can know anything about it, least of all the preachers who emphasised it so much. Hell exists in men because of the evil organisation of society and the concept is then perpetuated into eternity by those who benefit from it. Winstanley, who among all the radicals, came nearest to building up materialism that which was neither totally static nor susceptible to of only cyclical transformation. For him, the abolition of private property would cause a fundamental revolution, and science and invention would continue to keep society in motion. It would have been more difficult for sin and hell to survive in Winstanley’s commonwealth. His concept of God and ‘Reason’ as being synonymous is of the ‘lifeforce’ that pervades the whole universe and dwells in every creature, but supremely in man. He wrote that:
If you subject your flesh to this mighty governor, the spirit of righteousness within yourselves, he will bring you into community with the whole globe. … O ye hearsay preachers, deceive not the people any longer by telling them that this glory shall not be known and seen till the body is laid in the dust. I tell you, this great mystery is begun to appear and it must be seen by the material eye of the flesh. And those five senses that is in man shall partake of his glory.
An engraving from a Levellers’ broadsheet of 1649, designed by Germano Facetti.
In certain parts of his thought, Winstanley’s scepticism was explicit, e.g. his reference to people like ‘wise-hearted Thomas’, who believe nothing but what they see the reasoning for. He rejected the God of the traditional churches, ‘the God of this world’ from whom landlords claim title to the land and priests a right to tithes. He seems to have believed in the Trinity as a metaphorical term since he referred to the spirit within mankind as both Jesus Christ and ‘the Holy Ghost’. Prayer, for him, is the sum of ‘the reasonings of the heart’, and Holy Communion is not a specific sacrament restricted to ‘church’ but ‘the breaking of bread’ (i.e. eating and drinking) in any believer’s house in love and communion with one another, as the Diggers celebrated it on George’s Hill. But despite his unorthodox, perhaps heretical views on such matters, in The Law of Freedom, Winstanley develops his advocacy of rational science while at the same time seeming to draw on the theology of Calvin and the ‘divine’ poetry of Milton. When we read passages such as to know the secrets of nature is to know the works of God, we could be forgiven for thinking that we are reading Calvin’s Commentary on Genesis. Yet we can believe him when he claimed to be self-educated and not to have got his main ideas from anybody else. Winstanley wanted universities to cease to turn out clergymen, their main function in seventeenth-century England. Why, he asked, do university scholars try to suppress free preaching by laymen? It is, he replied, because…
… the Light of Truth that springs up out of the earth, which the scholars tread under feet, will shine so clear, as it will put out the candle of those wicked, learnéd deceivers. … Those that are called preachers … seek for knowledge abroad in universities and buy it for money, and then deliver it out again for money, for a hundred or two hundred pounds a year. … The upshot of all your universities and public preachers … is only to hinder Christ from rising…
University ‘Divinity’ was ‘a cloak of policy’ to cheat the poor of ‘the freedom of the earth’. Before a true reformation would be possible, Winstanley argued, the clergy’s ‘mouths must be stopped,’ though not, he was careful to add, ‘by the hand of tyrannical human power’, as they themselves have stopped the mouths of others. So through his theology, Winstanley reached conclusions that scientists were arriving at by other means in the seventeenth century: that new ideas drawn from contemporary experience were better than traditional truths, untested in the milieu of the revolutionary middle decades of that century. Winstanley claimed that it was the work of the devil to tell a man that he must believe what others have writ or spoke, and must not trust his own experience.
The Rule of the Saints & The Protectorate:
The Rump had few mourners among the dissenting churches, but the ‘Saintly’ Barebones Parliament which replaced it in 1653 had even fewer, certainly not outside the ranks of the Fifth Monarchy men. The ‘question’ now was how many of the radical independents in the ‘gathered churches’ would align with the Fifth Monarchists in opposing the drift towards the authoritarian government of the ‘Protectorate’ and how, in particular, the large number of Baptist congregations would react. ‘Anabaptist’ was still used as a generic label for extremist sectaries in the religious and political vocabulary of the mid-1650s. But though some prominent Baptists such as Hanserd Knollys and Henry Jessey remained suspicious of the Protectorate, others of reputation, including Kiffin, John Spilsbury and Joseph Fansom published a circular letter to the Baptist churches in January 1654, urging them not to engage against it, because the Barebone’s Parliament had brought ‘magistracy’ into disrepute. Cromwell remained tolerant and indulgent towards the many Baptist officers in the army in Ireland who opposed the Proclamation of the Protectorate there, unwilling to make martyrs of old comrades and showing that he could tolerate a few dissidents unless or until they engaged in open disobedience. He also knew that the vast majority of the army was strongly supportive of the Protectoral régime.
As Hill pointed out, however, among the locally gathered dissenters, God had been democratised, especially by the Baptists and Quakers. He was no longer the greatest feudal overlord, a kind of ‘high king’. He was in all his saints, but he is almighty and gives them of his power. In the Baptist churches of the interregnum, forms of democratic discussion became institutionalised. Mrs Attaway used to call for objections after her sermons, for it was their custom to give liberty in that kind. The former army chaplain and Leveller Henry Denne had a similar practice. At the Bell Alley Baptist church, public debates were held at which all might voice their opinions. It was a rule among the General Baptists that it shall be lawful for any person to improve their gifts in the presence of the congregation. Away from Westminster and the London Independent churches, men moved easily from one critical group to another, and a Quaker in the 1650s had far more in common with a Baptist of his own day than with a modern member of TheSociety of Friends. in 1653, a Fenstanton farmer was afraid that his landlord would turn him out if he joined the Baptists. The Baptist preacher, Henry Denne, told him to trust God and he would be a better landlord than Mr Bendwich. The Quaker Margaret Fell urged her husband in the same year.
Be not afraid of man. Greater is he that is in you than he that is in the world.
Isobel Ross (1949), Margaret Fell, p. 119.
Women Sectaries and the Sexual Revolution:
Margaret Fell’s role in the birth and growth of the Quaker movement has been well-documented, as has the role of women in early worship among Friends, including in a number of contemporary depictions, like the one below. Women had played a prominent role in the heretical sects of the Middle Ages, and this tradition came to the surface again in revolutionary England and Wales. Sects allowed women to participate in church government, and sometimes to preach. The Particular Baptists extended the functions of the laity to include women among their preachers. Women had voted in Hugh Peter’s Congregational church in Rotterdam in the 1630s. Female preachers abound in the pages of Thomas Edwards’ Gangrena in which, horrified, he cried out:
“If a toleration were granted, they should never have peace in their families more, or ever after have command of their wives, children, servants.”
Women did far more than preach, bad as that was for Edwards, though other divines like Samuel Torshell, writing in 1645, asserted that there was no difference between men and women in the state of grace. For Edwards and others, women threatened to subvert the marriage bond. Unequal marriages were anti-Christian yokes, they claimed: a wife might forsake an anti-Christian husband, just as a husband might an anti-Christian wife. The preacher, Mrs Attaway did just that, in the company of William Jenny. In 1641, Mrs Chidley argued that a husband had no more right to control his wife’s conscience than the magistrate had to control his. Quakers, following the example of some Baptists, practised marriage by declaration before the congregation, with no other civil or religious ceremony.
In addition, the liberating effect of the breakdown of church courts and the sexual lives of ordinary people helped to bring about something of a sexual revolution in revolutionary England and Wales. Social historians have estimated that at least one in every three brides in seventeenth-century England was pregnant when she was married and that bastardy was commoner in the country than in France. It also seems that adultery and sex outside marriage was more prevalent than both before and after the period. John Bunyan tells us that he himself heard a man in Oliver’s days advise a girl whom he was seducing, or tempting to uncleanliness with him to say, when you come before the judge, that you are with child by the Holy Spirit. Hostile opponents of the sectaries naturally made more of such tales than perhaps they warranted. Gerrard Winstanley wrote a pamphlet, The Saints Paradise, to dissociate and warn the Diggers from the Ranters’ excessive community of women, but he was also careful to say that no one should suppress that ranting power by their punishing hand, for it is the work of the righteous and rational spirit within … that must suppress it. He added that if thou wilt needs be punishing, then see thou be without sin thyself. In his Baptist days, Lawrence Clarkson was accused by a county committee of ‘lying in the water with a sister, whom he was dipping at night’. Clarkson replied to the accusation with the statement that…
“… Surely your experience teaches you to the contrary, that nature hath small desire of copulation in water – at which they laughed.”
Winstanley seems to have had some trouble in the Digger colony with Ranters who joined the community and ’caused scandal’. They attached too much importance to ‘meat, drink, pleasure and women’. Sexual promiscuity broke the peace in families and led to idleness. It also led to venereal disease, the incidence of which in England had presumably increased in the wake of armies and their camp followers. It may have been his experience with Ranters that convinced Winstanley of the need to have laws and rules in his ideal community, and punishments to deal with the idle and ignorant, the unruly and the ‘self-ended spirits’. Although he was no ascetic, Winstanley made a valid point against the Ranters’ advocacy of ‘free love’:
The mother and child begotten in this manner is like to have the worst of it, for the man will be gone and leave them, and regard them no more than other women … after he hath had his pleasure. Therefore you women beware, for this ranting practice is not the restoring of but the destroying power of the creation. … By seeking their own freedom they embondage others.
Winstanley (1649/50), A Vindication of those … called Diggers.
A decade late, the Baptist turned Ranter leader, Lawrence Clarkson, accepted this point, having originally hoped that his ethic would free both men and women from tormenting themselves for imaginary sins. Sexual freedom, in fact, tended to be freedom for men only, so long as there was no effective birth control. This was the practical moral basis for the Puritan emphasis on monogamy. Sexual liberty was a ‘hit-and-run’ affair among the poor. Many putative fathers must have taken to the road, leaving the mother and the parish authorities to carry the baby. We can see here perhaps yet another attraction of the itinerant life for a Ranter like Clarkson. He gave a thin religious veneer to practices that had long been common among vagabonds, squatter-cottars and migrant craftsmen. It was said in 1654 that Vagabondsbe generally given to horrible uncleanliness, they have not particular wives, but consort together as beasts. Contemporaries explained the ‘whoredoms of the Welsh’ by the mountain air: the modern historian more wisely sees them as the product of a society that refused to accept English protestant marriage laws. Rejection of church marriage not just by Ranters, but also by Baptists and Quakers, was in one sense a traditional attitude of the lower orders of society, looking back to Lollard and Familist practice.
Winstanley’s pamphlet of 1650, calling on common people to support the Commonwealth in the hope of further advance in a radical direction, also attacked the Ranters, whose sexual libertinism was disrupting the Diggers’ attempts at disciplined communal cultivation of the wastes. Their sexual practices, he suggested, merely stood traditional values on their head; it was not the transvaluation of values which, in their different ways, both the protestant ethic and Digger ‘communism’ strived for. He was just as fiercely opposed to the Ranters to the ‘clergy power’ which restrains the liberty of the inward men, not suffering him to act in the liberty of himself. The economically significant consequence of Puritan emphasis on sin was the compulsion to labour, to save, to accumulate, which contributed so much to make possible the Industrial Revolution in Britain. Only Winstanley put forward an alternative. Exploitation, not labour, was the curse of fallen, covetous man: Abolish exploitation with the wage relationship and labour in itself, to contribute to the beauty of the commonwealth, would become a pleasure. Unfortunately, this was never to be more than a dream.
The ‘Shattering’ of the Baptists and Independents:
The Baptists achieved an early peak of numerical strength and national influence during the interregnum, but even before the Restoration their influence their position was seriously compromised by the loss of members to more radical sects such as the Quakers and the Fifth Monarchists in many places. Vavasour Powell, a committed Fifth Monarchist in Wales, saw two stark alternatives. He asked his congregation whether God would rather have Oliver Cromwell or Jesus Christ reign over us? A Bristol (Broadmead) Baptist in 1654, when he heard that two Frenchmen had been imprisoned for foretelling the end of the world in 1656, was worried because he was not prepared for that event.
When these Baptist congregations claimed the local independence they were seeking, however, they were not claiming total competence for the local congregation. The need for mutual assistance from congregation to congregation led very early to the setting up of a General Assembly amongst the General Baptists, and of regional ‘associations’ amongst the Particular Baptists. From the early 1650s, there was a rapid expansion of Particular Baptists in Wales, who initially filled the spiritual gap, though in some parts they were then superseded by Quakers. Hill suggested that the Fifth Monarchists and early Quakers must have had a great deal to do with the ‘shattering’ of Baptist and Independent churches from which ultimately the Quakers were to benefit. In 1650, it was, apparently, by listening to the errors of Diggers, Levellers and Ranters that Baptist churches in Huntingdonshire… were ‘shaken’ and ‘broken up’.
Nevertheless, both General and Particular Baptist structures survived to become important tools for expanding the work. They also became forums for discussing theological and disciplinary queries, and so for establishing a ‘Baptist viewpoint’. Particular Baptist association meetings discussed such issues as…
… “the gathering of churches, believer’s baptism, communion with the unbaptised, the ordination of ministers, the maintenance of the ministry, the place of the magistrate, missionary activity, liturgical usages – such as vocal ministry, breaking bread, psalm-singing, foot-washing, anointing the sick – ecclesiastical discipline, the grounds and manner of exclusion, domestic duties and relationships.”
Who, then, supported the Baptists’ itinerant preachers? They had to live, and there were so many of them, often operating in competition with each other, both among the Baptists and the other sects. Some level of rational organisation was essential. The organisers of the sects used the Bible against what they called the ‘fancies’ of those whom the spirit was still moving in ways that were becoming unpopular; the ‘rebels’ rejected the Bible’s authority over them, even though they could not produce scholarly reasons for doing so that could compete with the learning of Henry Denne. But the organisers of the sects faced a dual problem. In the Records of the Churches of Christ gathered at Fenstanton, Warboys and Hexham, the participants discussed the pressure of landlords, driving their tenants to attend the parish churches. We can see that the tenants knew that as long as they conformed outwardly to the state church they had a chance of being left to their own devices. But the Baptist organisers did not leave them alone, perhaps making too many demands on normal frail humanity.
Restoration, Repression and Respectability:
So long as the end of days seemed imminent, psychological tension could be maintained, and intense moral pressure was tolerable, but not for the everyday world. And when in the restoration period fierce persecution came, it drove all but the most dedicated believers back to the state church. This increasingly meant that the membership of the sects became restricted to a self-selected élite of financially ‘independent’ men and that it was not a realistic option for ordinary tenant farmers and labourers. All this suggests that the seventeenth-century sects, as they established themselves, lost a large section of their earlier memberships after the old church was restored. Nevertheless, it has been estimated that by 1660 there were roughly three hundred General and Particular Baptist churches. Many of these played an important role not just as places of worship, but as social services, giving their members some protection in the tough mercantilist world. The Fenstanton Baptists distributed poor relief, even if partly as an institute of social control. A woman who went back to her local parish church – forced to do so for the maintenance of herself and her children – got seven shillings to satisfy her necessities as soon as she had repented.
The Restoration brought a quarter of a century of intermittent persecution by the Stuart state. As the world ‘righted’ itself, it also closed in on the sects, and their organisation tightened in response. Local evidence, such as The Broadmead Records for Bristol, gives graphic details of the price of dissent in these years. When Charles II was restored, it was claimed, then Satan stirred up adversaries against us, and our Trouble or Persecution began. Already in 1655, however, the Fenstanton Church had resolved that no member of the congregation shall travel from place to place without the advice and consent of the congregation to whom he belongeth, such consent to be in writing. In other words, in the years before the Restoration, dissenting churches were already self-regulating as far as the poor, itinerant preachers among them were concerned. In the 1670s John Bunyan’s church in Bedford showed great severity against members who did not pay their debts, and Bunyan himself advised deacons to use poor relief to encourage industry and discourage idleness. This is another reason why in the latter part of the century the nonconformist churches ceased to proselytise among the urban poor: they had enough to do to avoid and survive persecution by the state and to look after their own villagers. It was yet another argument against doing anything that would cause more prosperous, ‘respectable’ members to leave.
The restoration enabled the universities to survive, almost untouched by the scientific ideas which had invaded them during the Revolution. But continuing unchanged throughout it meant that their social role was transformed. They retained an intimate association with the Anglican church even though the latter had now lost its monopoly position. So Oxford and Cambridge became isolated from the mainstream of national and international intellectual life, a backwater, just as nonconformists, excluded from the universities, evolved in dissenting academies a culture that was as one-sided on the other side – utilitarian, provincial, sectarian. The split which Winstanley had hoped to bridge, between useless specialised scholars and ill-educated practical men, remained.
The radicals no longer hoped to turn the world upside down: they continued to compete with each other, even more desperately, as they adapted themselves to it. Baptists excommunicated ‘Ranters’ and ‘Quakers’, Quakers attacked Baptists and Ranters as being anti-Christian. To judge by the surviving local chapel books, ex-communication was one of the main activities among the ‘old dissenters.’ The maintenance of internal purity disrupted unity: without internal purity, survival was impossible. After Cromwell’s death in 1658, a period of desperate confusion ensued, in which radical groupings and opinions revived. There was still a broad agreement between the sects on political aims – opposition to the state church and tithes – but on theological issues, they split. As late as 1659, a series of pamphlets by a self-declared ‘gentleman’, William Covell, proposed to settle all wastelands and commons on the poor forever, to establish cooperative communities with no buying and selling among their members, to tax the rich in order to pay for the aged and to abolish the state church. But also in the same year, the disunity on doctrinal matters prevented the concerted effort which alone might have saved the Good Old Cause; in 1660, the consequences of these divisions were revealed in all their political ugliness. All sects were anxious to disavow those they considered to be more radical than themselves, to show how moderate and reasonable they alone really were. The schisms were used to bring about the restoration of the monarchy. The crucial question was asked by another pamphleteer in 1660:
Can you at once suppress the sectaries and keep out the King?
Most moderate Puritans and supporters of Parliament had by that time decided that they could not. During the revolutionary decades of the 1640s and ’50s, ordinary people were freer from the authority of the state church than they had ever been before, and were not to be again for centuries afterwards. Due to this temporary freedom, in particular the lack of censorship, we have a pretty full record of what they discussed. They had speculated about the end of the world and the coming of the millennium; about the justice of God in condemning the mass of humanity to eternal torment for the original sin of Adam; some of them became sceptical of the existence of physical hell. They contemplated the possibility that God might intend to save everybody and that there might be something of God within each of us. They founded new sects to express these new ideas. They attacked the monopoly on ‘divinity’ held by the privileged profession of the Anglican clergy. They criticised the existing educational structure, especially the universities, and proposed a vast expansion of educational opportunities. They discussed relations of the sexes and questioned parts of the protestant work ethic. Above all, these fresh human experiences could be used against both the dead weight of tradition within the Church and to balance the authority of the bible. The radical Baptist army chaplain, Thomas Collier, preaching to the Army at Putney in 1647, offered to confirm one of his points from Scripture, although he added:
I trust I shall declare nothing unto you but experimental truth.
Quoted in Woodhouse (1938), Puritanism and Liberty, p. 390.
One consequence of the stress on continuous revelation and on experienced truths was that the idea of novelty, of originality, ceased to be shocking and even became widely desirable among dissenters. Winstanley emphasised that the Law of Righteousness, about which he wrote extensively, was New. He told the clergy that this question should not be answered by texts from Scripture but that the answer is to be given in the light of itself, which is the law of righteousness … which dwells in man’s heart. He agreed with other dissenting voices that it was the devil himself who persuaded men that novel ideas, drawn from experience, were a sign of error. For Winstanley, as we have seen, God and Reason were one and the same, so that the Christ within his heart preached secularism. This meant that in a time of defeat when the tide of revolution was ebbing, this inner voice became quietist, pacifist. All the pressures were in the direction of accepting modes of expression not too shocking for the society in which men had to live and earn their living.
The radicals were so effectively silenced that, apart from those well-known for other reasons, like John Milton, whose hatred of priests, an established church, forms, ceremonies and tithes was as fierce as that of any of the radicals, we know little of what happened to them. Milton continued to reject the distinction between clergy and laity and thought that the meanest artificer might exercise the gift of preaching. But for most, opponents and supporters alike, the time of experimentation was over. ‘Inspiration’ said Sir William Davenant, was a dangerous word which many have of late successfully used. The doctrine of ‘the inner light’, then, was no longer for the sectaries mere absolute individualism, if it ever had been. It was to be balanced by ‘the sense of the meeting’ and ‘common sense.’ But John Bunyan’s question remained to ‘haunt’ the former radicals:
“Were you doers or talkers only? What canst thou say?”
John Bunyan
If Milton had intellectual affinities with the radicals but was set apart from them by his patrician status and assumptions, Bunyan shared the social and political attitudes of the radicals, but not their theology. Bunyan enlisted in the Parliamentary army when an edict demanded 225 recruits from the town of Bedford. There are few details available about his military service, which took place during the first stage of the English Civil War. A muster roll for the garrison of Newport Pagnell shows him as private “John Bunnian”. In Grace Abounding, he recounted an incident from this time, as evidence of the grace of God:
“When I was a souldier, I, with others, were drawn out to go to such a place to besiege it; But when I was just ready to go, one of the company desired to go in my room, to which, when I had consented, he took my place; and coming to the siege, as he stood sentinel, he was shot into the head with a musket bullet and died.”
The birthplace: Steel engraved print with hand colour, published in The Youth’s Magazine, 1848. Harrowden, Bedfordshire
Bunyan’s army service provided him with a military vocabulary which he then used in his book The Holy War, and it also exposed him to the ideas of the various religious sects and radical groups he came across in Newport Pagnell. The garrison town also gave him opportunities to indulge in the sort of behaviour he would later confess to in Grace Abounding: So that until I came to the state of Marriage, I was the very ringleader of all the Youth that kept me company, in all manner of vice and ungodliness. Bunyan spent nearly three years in the army, leaving in 1647 to return to Elstow and his trade as a tinker. He was baptised as a believer into a local nonconformist fellowship in Bedford and began to make known to others the Saviour whom he had found, finding great success as a lay preacher for them from 1653. His first writings were against George Fox and the Quakers; his theology developed in controversy with them, as well as with the ‘Ranters’. Between the years 1655 and 1660 he often preached in the neighbourhood of Bedford, but in 1660 he was put into Bedford County Gaol for preaching without a license; ‘lay preaching’, by people other than ‘ordained’ clergymen was made illegal after the Restoration of Charles II in 1660. One object of that restoration had been to put tinkers back into their callings. Bunyan’s parents had been cottagers and his second wife described him in 1661 as a tinker and a poor man, therefore he is despised and cannot have justice. But Bunyan recalled a lot from the revolutionary decades when he came to write The Pilgrim’s Progress in gaol, commenting on the ease with which, after the restoration, puritans became propertied and respectable. In 1658 he had written that …
… more servants than masters, more tenants than landlords, will inherit the kingdom of heaven.
John Bunyan, from an eighteenth-century engraving. He is dreaming of the beginning of Pilgrim’s Progress, with Christian fleeing the City of Destruction.
‘God’s own,’ he wrote in the same year, are most commonly of the poorer sort. We call Bunyan a Calvinist, but if so, he was a Calvinist with a difference. His questions above show that he shared Winstanley’s activism and that he believed that heaven had to be striven for; it was not a reward of inheritance as many of the hyper-Calvinistic Baptists came to believe in the restoration and later Stuart period. Bunyan’s theology represented the outlook of mobile small craftsmen, itinerants like himself. The hero of The Pilgrim’s Progress is one of the people: the law and its courts, he knows, will not give him justice. Salvation must be the arbitrary gift of God’s grace from outside because the essence of the Fall had been a breach of God’s arbitrary, irrational prohibition. We can see Pilgrim’s Progress as the greatest literary product of the poorer sort, the epic of the itinerant: As I walked through the wilderness of this world, Bunyan laid himself down to sleep in a den which he lighted on: Pilgrim’s Progress was the dream he dreamed. The first of the two books was first published in 1678, following release from his imprisonment, during which he wrote the first draft. The later two-part volume became the most important and popular book after the Bible itself, and often the only volume accompanying it in the labourer’s cottage.
The cover of the 1916 edition, published by The Religious Tract Society (London): ‘Evangelist’ points the way to Christian.
At first, following the Restoration, it seemed that a national compromise in the state church could be achieved between Puritans and episcopalians. Richard Baxter, a former army chaplain (to Cromwell’s troopers and later to the Lord Protector himself) and a leading Puritan ‘divine’, became a chaplain to Charles II, though he refused an offer to become the Bishop of Hereford, preferring instead to return to his old church at Kidderminster. But when it became clear that he could not go back there, he settled down to preach once a week first at St Dunstan’s in the West end of Fleet Street and then at St Bride’s Church at the other end. He hoped to bring about a reconciliation between the restored bishops and the Puritans, but the bishops were bent on getting back all the churches and parishes from those they saw as ‘usurpers’. They also believed, in any case, that the people had been wrongly taught by preachers who often lacked their level of university education.
They persuaded the King to agree to ‘The Act of Uniformity,’ which tried to make everyone return to the state church to worship in a uniform way. It also dictated that all the Puritan ministers were to promise to use the new (1662) Prayer Book and to obey the bishops and that, if they did not do this by St Bartholemew’s Day, 24th August 1662, they were to be turned out of their churches. Baxter was one of the many ‘good and true’ ministers who felt they could not promise this. Though he was not opposed to the use of the Prayer Book, he did think it wrong to force people to do so if it was against their conscience. Being turned out of their churches also meant being turned out of their homes, so that, according to Baxter, hundreds of good ministers with their wives and children had neither home nor bread. Many of their parishioners tried to help them and followed them out of the churches, listening to their preaching and teaching in private houses. So a year later another law was passed, ‘The Conventicle Act’, to stop all such meetings and to send everyone caught attending them to prison. Baxter himself had to change his home nine times in three years because spies were regularly set on him. On one occasion, two magistrates tried to arrest him while he was visiting the sick and praying with them, which would have constituted a breach of the law. Another time, he was preaching in a private home when a bullet was fired through the window at him, narrowly missing him.
Those arrested included many who were already attending independent worship, among them many Quakers, Baptists and Independents, of whom John Bunyan was the best known outside the capital. All of these groups now went by the name ‘nonconformist’ since they all refused to conform to the litany of the new Prayer Book. The Baptists were effectively back in the same situation they had been fifty years earlier, without any freedom to worship in their own ways, according to their own ordinances and in their own chapels.